Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Insurance and Commerce Committee

February 15, 2017 ·Committee Room 149 ·1:07:00
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (15)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB247 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “I believe first on deck is going to be Senate Bill 247, and I'm going to have Representative Lowry chair the meeti…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1527 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1527 Rushing CONCERNING CONTINUING EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR RE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1145 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1166 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1166 Rushing TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1271 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1271 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1377 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1377 Lemons CONCERNING THE AVAILABLE WARRANTY FOR THE INSTALLATI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1448 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1448 M. Gray TO INCLUDE FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS INSURED BY THE NA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1455 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1455 Payton TO AMEND THE LICENSING AND CONTINUING EDUCATION REQU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1476 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1476 Collins TO REVISE CERTAIN PROVISIONS RELATED TO FORMATION A…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB133 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB133 Rapert TO AMEND THE PROPERTY AND CASUALTY LAW; TO CLARIFY T…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB209 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB209 Maloch CONCERNING THE AUTHORITY OF AN OFFICER OF A STATE BA…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB210 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB210 Maloch CONCERNING A CHANGE IN CONTROL AT A STATE BANK.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB259 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB259 D. Wallace TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE PROFESSION OF…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB260 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB260 D. Wallace TO REQUIRE A PEER REVIEW PROGRAM FOR PUBLIC ACCO…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB272 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB272 Bledsoe TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PUBLIC UTILITY".”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
I believe first on deck is going to be Senate Bill 247, and I'm going to have Representative Lowry chair the meeting while I run down and run Charlie's bill. This is where we are, Senate Bill 247.
▶ Play
Well, good morning, everyone. We are going to have a prompt and effective meeting today. Representative Lindstrom, you are welcome to present your bill and to have your witnesses introduce themselves.
▶ Play
Yes. Today I'm running Senate Bill 247, which is the omnibus insurance bill. I'm sure you've all looked over it, and I have two folks here that can help explain it in
▶ Play
more detail. If you would introduce yourselves. Thank you, Representative. I am Alan Kerr, the Insurance Commissioner for the state of Arkansas. With me I have Amanda Rose. She is one of our lead attorneys on this bill. So the omnibus bill is just a culmination of technical issues that we have to address each session. Some of this pertains to model language from the NEIC in order for us to keep our accreditation with them. Things change in the insurance industry so much that about every session we've got some adjustments that we have to make in certain parts of the code that are usually just minor adjustments. As far as controversy goes, we have a piece in here that pertains to cyber liability and the notification of a cyber breach to the insurance department. Currently, the Attorney General enforces sanctions under PIPA for all businesses in Arkansas. The insurance department will reserve the ability to sanction the entities that we regulate by the state that fail to notify effective policyholders. In other words, just pertaining to those people that we regulate, not all of business. However, we will not subject business to a type of double enforcement of civil penalties, injunctions, or restitution should the attorney general apply them. So in other words, we're not going to double hit them. If the Attorney General sees fit to sanction them, we're fine with that. The Insurance Department will still exercise its authority over licensees or insurers' authority to do business in the state relative to the Section 4. We will use the rulemaking authority in this section to engage with members of the industry and the public to construct a rule if needed. that is fair to the entities and we regulate by statute and most importantly does right by Arkansas policyholders. So again, in a nutshell, that section just pertains to notification of the insurance department. If there's a breach by an insurance company, what's the first thing you think of? Well, the insurance department should know about this and we should so that we can help the public and make sure that their information is made whole again, we want that notification. Other than that, there was absolutely no other questions in the omnibus bill, and I ask for a good vote. Unless you have any other questions. Thank you, Commissioner.
▶ Play
Members, do you have any questions? No questions. Representative Lundstrom, would you like to close for your bill? I would ask for a good vote. All right. We have a, and that is a motion, do pass motion. Do pass motion. We do have a do pass motion. Is there anyone here to speak for or against the bill? Right. We have a representative of, I believe, Nafa, Arkansas to speak on the bill. And before you begin, identify yourself and let us know whether you're
▶ Play
speaking for or against the bill. My name is Dolores Chitwood. I'm the legislative advocate chair for NAFA Arkansas, which is the Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors. I speak for the bill, and I particularly point out that we had made some suggestions about some specific language to be put in the bill about the nature of the reporting of cyber breaches. The commissioner has assured us, and the bill includes language that indicates that both NAFA and other stakeholders will be engaged in the development of the rules and regs on this. And so we thank the commissioner for that and point out to you that in the past several years, the insurance department has been very open to comment from NAFA as it relates to issues of our concerns for our clients and consumers and our agents as they work in the industry. And the commissioner has assured us that we'll be a part of developing rules and regs. And as he pointed out the other day when we spoke, he has depended on the fact that if rules and regs were unreasonable, he would depend on our speaking out. So thank you very much. We speak on behalf of the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 23 6:11
Thank you very much. I know if the commissioner assured
▶ Play
you, then he will follow through. Members, any further testimony for or against the bill? We have a do pass motion before the body. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say no. Your bill
▶ Play
Speaker 15 6:32
passes. Thank you. Congratulations. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Thank you. Let's see. I believe we're going to pass over Representative Gray and Representative Collins' second bill. Representative Bledsoe, or Senator Bledsoe. Okay, we'll pass over that one. Representative Lund, excuse me, Rushing, I believe you're up. Representative Rushing will be presenting House Bill 1527. Thank you,
▶ Play
Madam Chair. Colleagues, ironically, I sit in front of you today, and as a freshman legislator, this was the first committee I spoke at, and this bill that I'm presenting to you today was the first bill that I actually spoke on. So ironically, we've made two-year circle, and I'm back up here talking about the same bill. But the reason that I am is because I feel like that in this bill, I made a mistake. I feel like that I was maybe just a little bit misled on the intentions of the bill. And so I'm here today to try to correct some of those mistakes that I made. And I'm willing to admit, as a freshman legislator, sometimes you're influenced a little bit, maybe by some lobbyists. Maybe you're influenced a little bit by some friends and colleagues that you've known. And I'm sitting up here today talking against my own industry. And therefore, it makes it even harder because, as all of you know, as a realtor, I've been one of the biggest cheerleaders up here for realtor issues and for homeownership. And so I hate that I'm going back today and saying that I need to fix something that I feel like we messed up on. But we had a continuing education bill that took us from six hours to nine hours with one hour dedicated to safety. When this bill was presented to me and I was asked to run the bill, I was told that we would not go to nine hours straight out of the chute, that we would just gradually take it there as our education system got better. The Realtors Association, over the last four years, has lost two of our most qualified educators. And we are in the process, I feel like, of kind of retraining some of our educators and trying to get on a path where we can actually have some good education. Now, when I, my first indication that they were going to go strictly to nine hours, over the seven hours that they had told me that they would stay at for at least a few years was in about February of 2016 when I got a phone call from a company wanting to know why we were going to nine hours. Now, and I told them, I said, no, that was not the intent of the bill. The intent of the bill was to go to seven hours with an hour focused on safety. I did make some phone calls. I did go meet with the Real Estate Commission and the Director of the Real Estate Commission, Gary Isom, and we had a hearing. I listened to the commissioners. They listened to me. When we left there, I felt like we were on pretty good terms that we were going to stay with seven hours and with one dedicated to safety. I did have one commissioner at that time actually look at me and tell me that they have nine hours to use now and we shouldn't care what the legislators say or do because it's in their hands and they should be able to use it. But I feel like that that promise of seven hours, you know, a word to word from when I was running the bill, I feel like that that was kind of a gentleman's agreement that we wouldn't go directly to nine hours. when I did find out that they were planning to go to nine hours again was in June of 2016 like I said I left that meeting feeling like that we were just going to seven hours in June of 2016 as I said in a legislative committee meeting at the ARA it was announced that we were going to nine hour modules and at that time that was the first that I had heard of that I thought I had been in really good contact with the real estate commission and the director and we've had we've had a good relationship and I have a lot of respect for Gary Isom. I did talk to him after the meeting and he apologized that he did not reach out to me. He did say that he felt like he just didn't want to intrude. That was around the time of the death of my daughter and he just felt like he didn't want to intrude on that and so I took that apology. He worked on it and I say that he worked very hard on it and we are back at seven hours and so for this year for 2017 they did go back to seven hours with the one hour dedicated to safety my theory is is that having the additional two hours and having the fact that the commissioners change every year is that we won't hold true to what was presented to me that we will stay at seven hours for a few years till we correct our education system. I did meet with the director yesterday of the Real Estate Commission, Gary Isom, and I believe he's here, and I think that you will probably hear some testimony against this bill. And I did tell him that I appreciate his work that he's done on it to keep it at seven hours, but he even made the statement to me that he can try to influence the commissioners, but there is no guarantee that he cannot guarantee me that it'll stay at seven hours for the next couple years till we get our education system fixed. This bill, and I did tell them that I will be glad if I'm reelected in 2019 to come back up here and add their two hours if they can prove to me that they have a good vetted education system. I'm one of those agents that sit through the education, so I know what it's like and I know what we've been having. Also, I have 60 agents, and I'll just give you one example of why I think some of our education system is messed up. I have 60 agents in my office, and in my office last year, we went to the Real Estate Commission website, and we pulled off, off of their website, we pulled a name to come teach our continuing education. There were 60 of us that sat in the class, and the instructor did a very good job. after several months of not noticing on the website that continuing education had not been recorded, we started making some phone calls and some inquiries as to why education had not been recorded. And we were told that they were waiting on some paperwork from the instructor that she had not completed some paperwork. So this goes on for most of the year, most of last year. And And by the end of the year, I was told by the director of the Real Estate Commission, Gary Isom, that there may be a possibility that all 60 of my agents would have to sit through another continuing education because this lady did not turn in her paperwork and she was not qualified, yet her name was on the Real Estate Commission's website. Of course, I talked to them and we got it all worked out And my agents, thankfully, did not have to sit through another six hours of education at that time because they would have probably chopped my head off. But that's just some of the issues that I think that we have with our education system. I'm a firm believer in education for the realtors, and I'm a firm believer that we need more education. But I'm a firm believer also that it's not about the hours. It's about the quality of the education. And right now, we do not have the quality. and as soon as we can get the quality, I have no problem with going to nine hours.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Rushing. Do we have any questions from the committee? I have a first up, Representative Ferguson. Well,
▶ Play
and I respect, you know, that you're a realtor and I'll vote for the bill, but I guess my question is I don't know of any other board who does it this way. Why would it be in statute and not in rules and regs of the real estate board? I mean, it's just this exact problem. When you put something so definitive in statute, then you have to wait two years to change it. I mean, why would you just not say the continuing ed will be dictated by the real estate board?
▶ Play
That's a good question. I don't have a good answer. But it's always been in statute. And I think that one of the reasons for putting it in statute is they wanted to make sure that we always had at least six hours of continuing ed. And so this, and then when they, that was the original bill that I changed was from six hours to nine hours, and to include one hour of safety.
▶ Play
Representative Lowry. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Rushing, if I remember correctly, I was not in insurance commerce at that time, but I do remember the bill, that the legislation was, the legislative intent was to address, it was a response to the issue of the kidnapping and the death of Beverly Carter, who was a real estate agent. The legislative intent was to add a safety course, a one-hour safety course, correct? That is correct. Okay. So the legislative intent of the bill is fulfilled if we just add the one hour.
▶ Play
Correct. The legislative intent of the original bill is fulfilled if we take the language that we have now that I'm presenting to you today. Okay.
▶ Play
But at some point there was language amended in that could say at least seven, no more than nine. The language says
▶ Play
not less than six and no more than nine. And so what we're striking is not less than six and no more than nine. And then to have seven, actually they should have said, yeah, they should have left that in there. But seven hours, seven classroom hours of continuing education required with the commission, which at least one classroom hour focusing on personal safety precautions for real estate agents. So we are keeping the
▶ Play
additional hour. Okay. I'm sorry, I've already asked several follow-up. Can I ask another? Um, and unlike some industries, uh, in the real estate industry, there's, there's not any agent that is grandfathered in. Is that correct? All have to have at least. That's correct. That's correct. Okay. So this, this serves as a revenue stream for the commission or for, uh, outside third party educators.
▶ Play
Um, by increasing the hours, it could, it could cause a increase in revenue stream for the educators. I know that even with the one hour additional safety that our cost to our office has gone up for the classroom hours to sit, so there is an additional revenue stream for the educators in this, yes. Okay, but
▶ Play
none of that reverts back to the
▶ Play
commission itself? None of it reverts back to the commission itself, other than that the commission is over the education, but they don't control the cost. It is done with the educators themselves. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 35 18:34
you. Are there other questions from the committee? Hearing none,
▶ Play
is there anybody in the audience that would like to speak for or against? I'll go with for first. Against. Please go down to the end.
▶ Play
please identify yourself for the record. My name is Doyle Yates. I am chair of the Arkansas Real Estate Commission, a 40-year practitioner, executive vice president for my company, Cole Banker Harris-McKaney Fawcett in Fayetteville. And as background oversight over about 220 agents in our company. So having never done this before, I'm just going to jump out and if I'm going in the wrong direction, you can herd me back in. So take off. You're fine. What I'd like to do is just make a little statement and a little background about education for licensees in the state of Arkansas. The real estate commission has not always had oversight of education. In fact, the requirement for continuing education did not come along until 1988, and from that period forward to legislation in 2013, that education oversight was provided by the State Board of Private Career Education, which, by by the way, also oversaw continuing education for cosmetologists and any number of unrelated industries. In 2013, legislation was passed to allow the Real Estate Commission to take over and oversee education for licensees. So we've only had this opportunity, if you will, since 2014. I understand what Representative Rushing is saying about quality, but I will give you my take on quality. We have great educators in the state of Arkansas, and the Real Estate Commission has put a great deal of time and effort in improving that education, having taken it over in 2014. We do educator retreats. We have done mandatory educator training that every educator has to attend. Uh, the incident that, uh, uh, Representative Rushing, uh, referred to on a educator who came to her office, uh, and there was a delay, uh, that particular educator was approved by the commission as an approved educator, but the course that she taught, uh, at Representative Rushing's office had not been approved by the Real Estate Commission. And so the time lag was her getting that course into the commission, getting it approved, and on the heels of that, having those continuing education certificates issued to Representative Rushing's office. I want to give you also a little insight as a commissioner. This is my third year on the commission. There are five commissioners. Three of them are industry members, two are members of the public. What I see on a monthly basis in those hearings are a continual flow of people in there and in disciplinary hearings that continue to say, I didn't know that. I didn't know I was required to do that. Our education requirements, even at seven hours, is the lowest. there are 32 states in the country that have higher education requirements than the state of Arkansas. And not that just additional hours equals more knowledge, but, you know, this is an industry where most of you have heard that licensees deal with people making the largest investment in their life. The truth is, for a lot of people, it's the only investment they make in their life. And so the need to have a better educated licensee exists, and it continues to grow. We asked for the one hour for safety. Actually, the nine hours was approved, a minimum of six, maximum of nine. Those two other hours just lay out there in the bank. There is no proposal at this point. We did do discussions about nine hours around the state. In fact, we did five different road shows around the state where we brought agents and brokers in, asked them what they wanted, what they saw in the future. Four out of those five road shows, the majority of the attendees expressed their desire to go to nine hours. Now, that may sound a little strange to you because if we went to nine hours, that would require all of them to be in CE for nine hours. But here's the other side of that. They interact with other agents and other brokerages that do not have that training. And so not only does it complicate a transaction, it can actually put my client in jeopardy when I have to deal with an agent who is not well educated and not well informed. So I think the final thing I would leave you with is that the safeguards already in place about going to either eight hours or nine hours. And that is that we would have to run this by the governor's office. There would have to be a public hearing and public comment. We would be required to come back before legislative review. And so it's not something that we unilaterally, arbitrarily could decide to increase ours. There are a number of safeguards in place all the way back up to being here, not for this committee necessarily, but a number of people would have to approve of this, the least of which we would seek the buy-in of the industry, the Arkansas Realtors Association. I appreciate
▶ Play
your time. Thank you, Mr. Yates. Members, do you have questions? for
▶ Play
our witness. Representative Henderson. Thank you, Madam Chair. I guess what I'm confused about is really the intent when the board came to Representative Rushing to start with and agreed to increase, I guess, from six hours to eight hours. Was that the original? Six to nine. Well, no, the original intent of somewhere in the future, I guess you, I'm going to say you because you're the board member that we're talking to today. Commission member, right. Commission member. So was the commissions, I guess when y'all came and brought the bill to Representative Rushing's were the intent, the original intent of that law. Well, I think that's what we're working on here. I mean, it's not whether somebody needs something or you need more education. I think it was the original intent of the law. And what we all as a legislative body here voted on was that original intent. You know, if you need something, you need to come back and say something or get that law changed or at least get it approved. But what we voted on, I think, as a legislative body was for you to go from 7 to 8 and somewhere in the future go to 9.
▶ Play
Actually, this came up in a legislative committee hearing with Arkansas Realtors Association. And the motion was made to request legislation that would allow the Real Estate Commission to go from 6 to 7 hours, one hour being for safety. That got voted down. And so a following motion was to just go to nine hours, ask for nine hours, and that passed, and that is the way that bill was run. A minimum of six, a maximum of nine. The idea being, just like some gentleman in here said, why are we doing this time after time, the theory being that let's ask for nine, we'll use one for safety now, and the other two are out there for things in the future if there is a need in the future. Before Beverly Carter's death, no one thought we needed an hour for safety, but we did. So this leaves us now coming back to the legislature every time the Real Estate Commission sees a need for additional continuing education. And I will tell you this, as far as also the subject of poor or inadequate education, that boils down to human nature. Far too many licensees wait until the 11th hour in December and run out and grab whatever course is available. We have over 20 courses that are approved, and yet very few of them get utilized because people are just checking a box with this. It's one of the reasons why our new software will be able to track, for example, if you've taken three agency courses three years in a row, that you're not branching out and trying to expand your knowledge to be able to come to you and say, hey, it's time that you moved on to something
▶ Play
else. Follow-up, Representative Henderson. I think you missed my point completely. Okay. I mean, we're talking about what we were told as a legislative body and why we passed your law to start with. We're not talking about, there may be need for 20 hours. I don't know. I'm not in the industry. We're talking about you came, or I'm going to put it back on you because you're here. You came and told us one thing and you did another. And I kind of think that's the heartburn on legislators that's here right now. I'm not clear about what you just said. Told you one thing that we didn't know. Yeah, you, as I said, it's not you, but I'm just going to say you. Right. The request was? To go from six hours to seven hours. You'd make it nine hours somewhere in the past, in the future. The bill actually
▶ Play
says to go from six minimum, nine maximum. We chose to use one hour of that for safety. We do know what the bill says.
▶ Play
What we know is what we were told in the way that it was presented in committee and on the House floor. And so I would say to you, that's
▶ Play
exactly what we've done. Not if you're going to nine hours. We're not going to nine hours. We never did. We can't unless we go through the process that I
▶ Play
described, and we haven't done that. Let's keep it to two questions per member. Representative
▶ Play
Maddox. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think you referred to something. I'm not in the industry either. You called it a road show. Approximately how many agents attended those road shows, would you say?
▶ Play
I think over 200, and they attended with no CE credit. I'm not sure. Gary, do you know the total on the road shows attendance? It was probably about 300. 300. We did additional training that we did in different parts of the state on agency and on contracts, and we had over 200 attend those with no CE credit. Do you need a follow-up? Yes, follow-up,
▶ Play
please. Again, I have no point of reference here. Approximately how many licensed real estate agents are there in the state of Arkansas, would
▶ Play
you say? Roughly 9,000 that are active. Thank you. Members, thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Yates. Are there any more questions for Mr. Yates? Thank you, sir. May I clarify
▶ Play
before I step down? Make it very brief. We have gone to seven hours. That's what we've done. I don't know where the notion is that we've gone to nine. Nine is out there by legislation. The two hours lay out there. But right now, and it was approved at the end of last year, that we would go to seven hours, and that's the current requirement for this year is seven hours. Thank you. You bet.
▶ Play
Is there anyone to speak for? Seeing no other members of the audience that wish to address us, let's go. I'm sorry. Can I speak again? Yes, would you step to the, and please state your name. Folks, in an effort to time, let's keep our discussion tight. Please identify yourself for the record.
▶ Play
Speaker 90 32:36
Yes, ma'am. My name is Karen Krausen. I am a past president of the Arkansas Realtors Association, also a past commissioner. Thank you for allowing me to speak again. I know you've already heard at length, but I wanted to take the standpoint since Mr. Yates is actually the chairman of the Real Estate Commission right now, but to speak on behalf of the Arkansas Realtors Association. Our legislative committee met on this in 2014, and I was legislative chair at that time. We felt like it was important to increase by statute that number of hours, even though we knew, and the Real Estate Commission had worked with us and told us that by regulation, they were only going to go to seven with this one-hour safety. And the reason we even went to one-hour safety was we were hearing from so many of you, our legislators, who said you're going to let Beverly Carter's death go unnoticed in our state and not do something. And so we felt the importance of doing that and adding that one hour of education. It is not changing by regulation. We are still going to be at seven hours. I also wore many hats because when I was a commissioner, I served as the president of Arello, which is the Association of Real Estate Licensed Law Officials, which is an international association. And I was appalled when I would go to these meetings and listen to regulators from other states say, you know, we can't believe you only have six hours of education in your area. It was very unheard of. many other jurisdictions and states around our country have many more hours. In fact, I think you heard that 32 states have more education hours than what is required in Arkansas. I want us to be the best of the best. As an industry member and somebody who represents the public, I want our industry to be recognized as having the best education possible. I agree with what Representative Rushing had to say about education, that we need better educators. But it wasn't until 2013 that the Real Estate Commission took on this role of making sure that we have good educators. So we're in the very early stages of beginning to see what's going to change over in our state. And with their promise and what we've been told right now that by regular, because they can't change the regulation until they come back through the channel. So it's going to remain at seven hours and I'm a proponent of making sure that those seven hours are some of the best education that we can get in our state.
▶ Play
Thank you. Members, do you have questions? I understand Representative Lowry
▶ Play
has one. Yes, thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you for your testimony and the question I'm going to ask really points fingers at all of us. All of us are prone to use statistics that seem to speak in our favor when they really don't tell the whole story. I mean, you talked about 32 states having more CE for real estate agents, but Arkansas is also ranked 32nd in population. So would you not agree that that's probably a direct correlation there from our population to having 32 states ahead of us in CE? Well, I don't think it should. I mean, We're
▶ Play
Speaker 90 35:59
still representing buyers and sellers in the marketplace, as Mr. Yates said, in the biggest investment of their lives. So why should our education be any less? Okay. Thank you. Members, any other questions?
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you. All right, members, we've heard the for and against. Let's discuss this amongst ourselves. What questions
▶ Play
do you have? any discussion representative ferguson i i mean i just still think it doesn't belong in statute i mean had you talked to them or considered maybe just saying that you'll give that authority to the real estate commission to to make the guidelines for continuing ed and then we're just going through rules and regs and we're not coming back here every two years rewriting it seven nine ten you know i don't know i mean i
▶ Play
have not talked to them about that but like i I mean, I think that's something that's good for discussion, and I think that probably the director of the commission would probably be open to that and to be able to go through rules and regs to do that.
▶ Play
I mean, I look at the medical board, the dental board, every other board I know, all this is done through rules and regs. But, I mean, I know it was Beverly, the lady that died, that probably brought it in front of the legislature, but I just think that's a wiser place
▶ Play
Speaker 92 37:29
for it. Any other member comments? representative armstone
▶ Play
Speaker 102 37:34
represent thank you madam chair representative rushing do you intend to have more conversation with the current um chairman of the commission and or the rules and
▶ Play
regs yes i have a very good relationship with both with both of them and so i mean our line of communication is always open so we can always continue to work and try to to change it to get over to rules and
▶ Play
Speaker 102 38:02
regs. A follow-up, Madam Chair? Yes. Thank you, Madam Chair. And so I guess to Representative Ferguson's point, two, six years from now, if you were blessed to go on to the Senate or become the governor of our great state and somebody comes along and changes the statute, I mean, we're kind of working in vain. Would you agree? If we pass this out today and it gets to the floor, we do the goodwill of what your intent is. This could all be changed at any time. Wouldn't you agree? I agree.
▶ Play
Thanks, Madam Chair. Representative Ferguson. I get, you know, maybe if we pass this today and then whatever bill comes last, you know, is the effective bill. Correct. If we pass this out, because I understand your concerns, and you can come to terms with them, and maybe write a new bill that says that continue it will be mandated by the Real Estate Commission. I don't know. It's food for thought. Thank you. I appreciate that.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Ferguson. Anybody else? I have a question. I'm a little concerned we're bouncing this back and forth as well. I realize Representative Rushing has some issues. I feel like I'm getting in the middle of an industry food fight. So I'm not quite sure. I realize your concerns, and that's why you're bringing it back to us. I just see this going back and forth and back and forth again. Is there any way that we can put an end to that? Well, I think that probably what Representative Ferguson is talking about
▶ Play
is probably a good idea and a good start. I think you heard the testimony of both people that sat at the end of the table, And both of them said that right now that we're at seven hours with no intent to go back, to go up at any time soon. So my argument with that is that if there's no intent, then why do we need to have this nine hours in here? Let's leave it at the seven for now if there's no intent. And then we can maybe go back and fix it with rules and regs.
▶ Play
And so if I could have my own follow up, we actually gave them the latitude to go to nine. That's why we passed that law. So now we're the Lord giveth and the Lord taketh away. So
▶ Play
I'm a little confused. Well, the Lord giveth, but they gave them nine hours with the intent of being told as a freshman legislator, being told that the intent and the legislative intent of the bill was to add an hour of safety of seven and not having to go in front of the legislature every two years or three years to ask for an additional hour, which goes back to Representative Ferguson's point of if it was in a different place that they wouldn't have to do that and they could add those as they needed and they could just go in front of rules and regs. And so I understand your concern, and we did give them nine hours, but I also think that if we continue to listen to the agencies and let them tell us what their intent is and then the intent changes, I mean, it changed this year. And twice I had to go back and basically not really fight, not really argue, but remind them that the intent of the law was not to raise it to nine hours. And that was their intent this last year is to raise it directly to nine hours. All right. Any other
▶ Play
questions? What is the will of the committee? Motion to pass. We have a motion to pass. Members? All in favor? Aye. Those opposed? Okay. Congratulations, Representative Rushing. Thank you. Members, I believe we have Senate Bill 209 for Representative Malik, and I believe we have Representative Shepard that will be presenting it for us today. Representative Shepard, you're recognized to present your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. With the Chair's permission, I would like to ask Susanna Marshall from the State Bank Department to join me at the end of the table in case there's any questions that need to be answered, technical questions that need to be answered. Okay. If
▶ Play
you could ask your witness to come down. If you could state your
▶ Play
Speaker 116 42:35
name for the record. Thank you, Madam Chair. Susanna Marshall, Deputy Commissioner with the Arkansas State Bank Department. Thank you, Mrs. Marshall.
▶ Play
Representative Shepard. Thank you. Senate Bill 209 is another bill from the Bank Department, and it simply adds the reference to Chief Executive Officer. Previously, the statute's referred only to the President. The bank department has asked that we add or chief executive officer as some banks have split those duties. And so it's really, in my view, it's just kind of a cleanup to reflect some of the changes in the banking industry.
▶ Play
All right, members, any, I'm sorry, looked down at the wrong spot. Is there anybody in the audience that would like to speak for or against? Seeing none, any members? Any questions? All right. What is the will of the committee? We have a motion to pass from Representative Jett. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Shepard. That was quick. Thank you. All right. I understand you have another
▶ Play
one for us. That's correct. Senate Bill 210. Yes, Madam Chair. Senate Bill 210 is another bill from the Bank Department. This bill relates to situations where there is an applied-for change in control at a state bank, and this simply allows the commissioner to waive certain application requirements in the event that, as I understand it, many times they are having to apply both to federal regulators and to the state bank department. And this would allow the state bank department to waive the application to the state bank department because the commissioner could essentially review the application that was made at the federal level. And so this is really a bill that has been described to me as essentially a simplification. If anything, it's a deregulation, but you're not really relaxing the requirements because the bank departments will still be reviewing an application. It's just instead of applying twice to two different entities, they can submit the same application to both. the feds would be looking to the State Bank Department for the commissioner's input, regardless of whether there was two applications or just the one. Yes. Madam Chair, may I make a
▶ Play
Speaker 116 45:17
comment to the committee? Yes, please. A moment of clarification on this bill. So there will still be a filing that is required at the State Bank Department, but currently in this proposed transaction of this nature, there are two filings required with the State Bank Department, And they are essentially duplicative, and so we're eliminating the opportunity to eliminate one of the two. So there will still be a filing with the state and still with the federal. We just want to reduce some of the burden on our institutions since those applications are essentially duplicative. That warms the cockles
▶ Play
of my heart. Members, do you have any questions for the folks at the end of the table? Okay. What is the pleasure of the committee? We have a motion to pass from Representative McCollum. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Rep. Shepard. You're done. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Committee. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Committee. I understand we have Senate Bill 259. And Representative Warren, you'll be presenting that today.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Chairman, first item up is I need to present an amendment to the bill to add Representative Johnson as a co-sponsor. Members? Thank you, Representative Jett. We
▶ Play
have a motion to pass. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Thank you. Representative Warren? Yes, I've asked a
▶ Play
gentleman to join me here, and I would ask him to introduce himself, please. Good morning.
▶ Play
My name is Jimmy Corley, Executive Director
▶ Play
for the State Board of Accountancy. Thank you
▶ Play
for being here, Mr. Corley. Representative Warren? There are three parts to this bill. One's clarification. Two is updating. Three is modifying. First, CPAs seeking licensure in Arkansas are allowed in with whether practicing a CPA firm or just performing accounting duties as long as they have met the requirements along the way. They're granted CPA or reciprocal CPA license. Secondly, recently issued professional standards have created the need for two updates. First, a definition for preparation of financial statements, and two, modify the definition of compilation. And then lastly, there's a need to modify the definition of a test to prohibit non-CPAs from using AICPA reporting language when issuing non-financial reports. Non-CPAs can still issue these reports. They just wouldn't be allowed to reference the AICPA standards. They would need to develop their own language. So I don't know if you want to add to that, Jimmy. That explains it very well. I will
▶ Play
open it up to anybody from the audience that would like to speak for the bill. Would anybody like to speak against the bill? Members, discussion. Any members have questions?
▶ Play
Representative Payton. Thank you, Madam Chair. My question is, how many accountants in Arkansas does this affect? All of them or just a narrow portion? This is
▶ Play
basically going to affect all of them, isn't it? This is basically clean up, getting all the standards and definitions correct. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank
▶ Play
you. Representative Jett? Thank you, Madam Chair. Is there any pushback from any CPAs on this? Is anybody pushing back as far as you know?
▶ Play
We've heard no comments against this bill. It's kind of standard across the country. I think 37 out of the 50 jurisdictions have adopted the new definition of a test, which is the more substantive of these changes. We've had no negative feedback at all that I know of. Pretty much
▶ Play
all the CPAs in the state are aware of this might be coming?
▶ Play
We put it in our newsletter as well as the Society of CPAs put it in their newsletter, so yes, sir. So
▶ Play
most of these CPAs do get that newsletter? Yes, sir. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you. Members, any other questions?
▶ Play
I have one. We had this bill come up two years ago. Is this a cleanup from that? Because we voted it down two years ago because we felt like it was too onerous. That's the next Bill 260. That's the next Bill 260. Okay. All right. Thank you for refreshing my memory. Any other questions from the committee? What is the pleasure of the committee? Representative Jett, moves do pass. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? Thank you. All right. Let's go to the next one. Representative Warren, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 260.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chairman. Had the same request to amend this bill, to add Representative Johnson as a co-sponsor to this bill. Thank you. Members, what is your
▶ Play
pleasure on the amendment? Okay, we have a do pass. All in favor? Aye. Okay, Representative Warren, you're recognized to present your bill
▶ Play
as amended. Thank you. First of all, I would like to introduce a guest here. We have a CPA from Hot Springs. I'll let him introduce himself.
▶ Play
My name is Gary Beckwith. I'm a practicing CPA, a sole owner of a small firm in Hutch Springs in
▶ Play
Garland County. Thank you, Mr. Beckwith. All right. This bill focuses on a relatively small percentage of CPAs, but it's hugely important. This bill would require CPAs and CPA firms who issue reviews and audits to go through a peer review once every three years. This does not have anything to do with compilations. Arkansas is the only state not using this program. Our current monitoring system is outdated and limited in scope. Two items in question right now because of the current situation. Number one, mobility of CPAs to go practice in other states is being questioned. It hasn't happened yet, but the absence of this review process is making a CPA license in Arkansas appear where an Arkansas CPA is lesser when they apply to go to other states. It's really bringing into question whether it's the same level of CPA licensure when they go to other states. second the department of labor has rated employee benefit plan audits from arkansas cpas as unacceptable at a higher rate than the rest of the country representatives from the department of labor have actually told people in arkansas that if we don't improve they may need to take over. Now there's also a cost factor to this and that's one of the negatives that you would see but I can tell you from talking to CPAs one of which is sitting right next to me that has an independent practice in Hot Springs and others that they want to pay this fee to have a peer review system set up because they want to protect the integrity of the system. They want this extra level of protection and assurance to the people in the state of Arkansas that they're doing things properly. So there is a cost factor. It escalates based on the number of audits that you're performing and the level of the audits. So in summary, many CPAs will not be impacted by this and not required to participate in peer review. Secondly, this measure will improve the viability success of retirement plans and give our lending institutions greater reliability on the financial data there to make lending decisions and ultimately the value of stocks many Arkansans own. The Department of Labor has repeatedly expressed concern, as have many of our state CPAs that are here today. The State Board of Accountancy is here in support of this. We need to make this right. Now, I know this came before the legislature last time, but I think everything anything that was in question last time has been made right. So at this point, first of all, I'll see if you would have anything you wanted to add, Gary, to what I've said, and then open for questions. I
▶ Play
would like to add just a few quick comments. First of all, I was one of the small firms that was selected just a few years ago by the Department of Labor. I had to box up the entirety of my audit work papers and send them to a lady in Washington works for Department of Labor. She had a couple of questions. We resolved them rather quickly, but as we were wrapping up, she told me that she was responsible for the state of Arkansas for small firms, small firms being firms that perform less than five of these audits on an annual basis. She told me of the 23 that she had looked at, that I was only the third that she thought ought to be in the practice of auditing period, much less in the area of the Department of Labor. The second point I want to make is remember the P in CPA stands for public and what we try to do when we follow standards is to protect the trust of the public and I have volunteered for the State Board in their quality review program. I am also a peer reviewer and the the two systems are very different and by the time on the quality review side that's run by the State Board, by the time that somebody gets to the point that they're making a trip to a person's office to look at their work papers to see if they even exist, their timing is such that they're 18 months to two years behind. Our peer review process moves through a little bit quicker than that. And the last point that I want to make is this. I have been a peer reviewer, and Marcia reminded me this morning, our state society executive director is here as well. She reminded me this morning, I've been on the peer review committee for the state society for 15 years. In those 15 years, we have not one time recommended as part of the peer review process for somebody's license to be revoked. What the process is about is getting people educated and getting them the tools that they need and making recommendations to them for them to get their work up in accordance with standards. And again, the PNCPA is for public and we're trying to protect the public trust and that's the reason that even as a small firm that I'm in
▶ Play
support of this bill. Thank you. I believe we do have some questions.
▶ Play
I'm sorry, Representative Johnson, did you want to add to that? I would. I was one of the ones that was against this bill the last term because it had a negative impact on I'm talking a lot smaller CFA firms than his firm that does. I do we do no audits. We do balance sheet reviews for the contractor's last year board for small contractors. We don't even do big contractors. So with the changes the contractor board are making, that if you don't do a job over $750,000, all you need is a compilation, I would rather not do a review. I would rather not do an audit. I'm not an auditor. I'm a tax guy and a bookkeeper, and I don't do that kind of work. Auditing's a special work. And so what we're saying is we've got to keep our auditing standards up with the rest of the nation, or the nation's going to come and govern us. And big brothers are going to come and tell us what we're going to do. And we've always been the society, the AICPA, we've always governed ourselves. Since Enron, everything else, we've always tightened the restrictions on ourselves. So we're, as CPAs, we're asking for this because it makes us better. And the little firms that don't want to do audits in a test function can stay out of that business and still make a good living. So it won't hurt the little bitty CPAs or the little bitty contractors. And so that's why I was opposed to
▶ Play
it last time. All right. Thank you, Representative Johnson. I believe we have some questions on deck. Representative Payton,
▶ Play
you were up first. Thank you, Madam Chair. And you all have just almost answered my questions in your discussion. This is the bill that covers a narrow section and not all accountants. Is that correct? That's
▶ Play
correct. Yes, sir. It would only cover those that do audits and reviews. And I think most people that do any kind of large audits already are in the peer review program, aren't they? I mean, if you do government audits, you've got to be in the peer review. So it's not like it's going to go get a whole bunch of people that aren't part of the program now. It's just going, if you do audits or reviews, then you
▶ Play
have to be part of this program. Okay, and if I could follow up. So one of the major reasons we want to do this is
▶ Play
for reciprocity going out of state. Reciprocity is one of the two reasons. The second one is to protect the integrity of the retirement plans in the state of Arkansas.
▶ Play
So this question is basically, as we cast this net and cover these accountants with the new regulation, what percentage of them are concerned with that reciprocity? How many of them are going to be thrown under it that really doesn't care about the reciprocity? I'm not going to
▶ Play
disagree with your comment about reciprocity because to me the reciprocity piece means nothing. I'm not going to practice out of the state what small amount of work I do from surrounding states. I actually peer review firms in other states, and I'm not required to have a reciprocal license for the work that I do. And there are many that come in this state that don't have that as well. My concern is for the public. I have, as a peer reviewer and especially as a quality reviewer for the state of Arkansas, I have seen the work of some accountants who put an opinion on a piece of paper and in the essence of making a price so low that not only could they not follow the standards with their work papers, their work papers did not exist. That is a loss of trust to the public. And my concern is the public. Thank you. That's good information.
▶ Play
And I appreciate you, Representative Johnson, for coming back to give us some ease on this issue. Thank you, Madam Chair. You're welcome. Thank you. I believe next we have on
▶ Play
deck is Representative Ferguson. Well, I just have my same
▶ Play
question that I asked Representative Rushing. Why does this need to be in statute? Why can't it just be in the rules of the board? I'll let Jimmy answer that.
▶ Play
That's a fair question. Right now, our laws discuss a quality review program, and so this bill would replace that program with peer review for folks that do audits and reviews. so you're saying that the review is
▶ Play
in statute already well the the practice monitoring program is in statute it's the quality
▶ Play
review program nobody else in the country uses that we're trying to get rid of it replace with peer review and move to be in balance with everybody else so that's why is there a reason any
▶ Play
of that's in statute i guess is my question why wouldn't you
▶ Play
just give that authority to the board that's a good question um i think most states do have it their statute and so um the accounting industry has a document called the uniform accountancy act it's not anything that congress has done but it's something that's volunteer organizations put together and every board tries to model their statutes um with that document and so we're trying to do that that goes back to the idea of mobility and being able to uh practice across lines that's a bigger deal if you live in Fayetteville or Texarkana or Memphis versus Little Rocker Hot Springs uh but that's definitely important for those folks to live in the corners
▶ Play
of Arkansas. Thank you. Any other questions by the committee? Representative
▶ Play
McCollum? Part of this might be a little bit of a repeat from Representative Payton, but I'm just trying to understand. I heard you mention the mobility of CPAs being questioned out of state. Is that just that they're being questioned because we're not up to the same status, or is their status as a CPA not actually being upheld when they go to another state. I'll let Jim answer that.
▶ Play
I'll take that one. About 10 years ago, the accounting industry nationwide went to the idea of mobility, where, you know, just like a driver's license, you can take your license elsewhere for most services. And the basis of that concept was substantial equivalency, and that is the laws in California are similar or close to the same as what's in Arkansas. And so what we've got now with peer review is we fear some states are going to look around and say, well, Arkansas, you're the only state that doesn't require peer review. This is a pretty important thing for our profession. What's wrong with you? And we're not going to recognize your CPAs to come to
▶ Play
our state. So follow up. Yes, follow up. So just to understand, it's more of being proactive. And so I'm hearing it's a fear of, and we want to meet those standards. It's not something currently that the status of CPAs of Arkansans is not being upheld in
▶ Play
other states. Nothing's been questioned yet. However, I will say California undertook a study this summer evaluating every board's enforcement resources. So that's a separate issue. But we fear that once that's done, they're going to come right back and start looking at us because our
▶ Play
standards are so low on practice monitoring. What I would add, too, I think more importantly, it's not so much the reciprocity with CPA licensure as it is Department of Labor looking at us and saying your audits are not up to standard, and if you don't do something which this would address it, we're going to come in and take over, and you're the only state not doing it right.
▶ Play
Representative Payton, I believe you had a question. Yes, ma'am. Thank you, Madam Chair. I guess the next question would be, how much time and effort and money is it going to take for these
▶ Play
accountants to do what we're asking them to do? It's going to depend on whether they perform audits or not. If you are a firm, as Representative Johnson spoke of, that he only prepares reviews and compilations, the review would be subject to an engagement review. As a peer reviewer and engagement reviews, they send me work from one or two engagements depending on the size of their firm. If they don't perform audits, they just send me the work papers and the report from one or two engagements, and I report on those and send them by. That's relatively inexpensive. I have some of those that I perform on a three-year basis in the $6 to $850 range. The cost of a system review for a firm that performs audits, that steps it up to where the reviewer actually has to come on your premises, and they look at your system of quality review. They look at your education records. They look at your professional library. They look at your staffing requirements. So once you perform audits, and like Representative Johnson in the last couple of years, I have gotten completely rid of my audit practice because, from my standpoint, a small firm, it's very difficult to maintain an audit practice. And I can make a great living without it. And my point in that, to answer your question, is that there are some CPAs out there that are continuing to perform audits that shouldn't be. And by the time they get caught up to in this quality review system, it's three or four years down the road. And again, my biggest emphasis is a protection of the public. And that's, this, to me, this takes the, this takes the monitoring and the oversight out of the state's hands and puts it in the hands of the profession. And can
▶ Play
I address a little more to that is you have, I think, 18 months, is that right, Jimmy, to sign up to, uh, after this goes into effect, you have 18 months to sign up and with 18 months you, you have to have a peer review. So really you're looking at Almost a three-year transition. We're not going to go take your business away from you today. You can say, I want to keep doing this. I'm going to meet those standards, and then we're going to give you time to do it. Is that, am I correct? That's right. Okay.
▶ Play
All right, members. Thank you. We've had a good discussion. Representative Warren, would you like to close for your bill or any additional things you want
▶ Play
to add? I basically have said what I need to say. I think we need this in order to get Arkansas to a level playing field with the rest of the country.
▶ Play
I would appreciate a good vote. Members, what is the pleasure of the committee? All right, we have a do pass. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Okay. Congratulations, Representative Warren. Thank you. All right, members. Seeing no other issues that need to come in front of this committee, no other
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:06:57
members wishing to present their bills, we are adjourned. Thank you. I appreciate you. Absolutely.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1271 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1377 Lemons CONCERNING THE AVAILABLE WARRANTY FOR THE INSTALLATION OF A ROOF SYSTEM.

SB247 Rapert TO ENACT THE STATE INSURANCE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OMNIBUS BILL.

Lundstrum

0:55 - 6:55 14 segments 6 speakers

HB1448 M. Gray TO INCLUDE FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS INSURED BY THE NATIONAL CREDIT UNION ADMINISTRATION AS INSTITUTIONS ALLOWED TO SERVE AS DEPOSITORIES OF PUBLIC FUNDS.

HB1476 Collins TO REVISE CERTAIN PROVISIONS RELATED TO FORMATION AND OPERATION OF CAPTIVE INSURANCE COMPANIES.

SB272 Bledsoe TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PUBLIC UTILITY".

SB133 Rapert TO AMEND THE PROPERTY AND CASUALTY LAW; TO CLARIFY THE DEPRECIATION APPLICABLE WHEN DETERMINING THE VALUE OF DAMAGED PROPERTY.

HB1527 Rushing CONCERNING CONTINUING EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR REAL ESTATE LICENSEES.

Rushing

6:55 - 0:00

SB209 Maloch CONCERNING THE AUTHORITY OF AN OFFICER OF A STATE BANK.

0:00 - 41:55 120 segments 15 speakers

Shepherd

41:55 - 1:34:38 88 segments 12 speakers

SB210 Maloch CONCERNING A CHANGE IN CONTROL AT A STATE BANK.

1:34:38 - 43:55

Shepherd

43:55 - 45:55 6 segments 3 speakers

SB259 D. Wallace TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE PROFESSION OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTANCY.

Warren

45:55 - 49:55 18 segments 5 speakers

SB260 D. Wallace TO REQUIRE A PEER REVIEW PROGRAM FOR PUBLIC ACCOUNTANCY LICENSEES; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE PROFESSION OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTANCY.

Warren

49:55 - 1:07:01 58 segments 9 speakers

DEFERRED Subtitle Sponsor Number

HB1166 Rushing TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS AND RESIDENTIAL TENANTS; AND TO REQUIRE IMPLIED QUALITY STANDARDS FOR TENANTS OF RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPERTY.

HB1455 Payton TO AMEND THE LICENSING AND CONTINUING EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR AUCTIONEERS; AND; TO PROVIDE FOR A FOUR-YEAR AUCTIONEER'S LICENSE.

HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A JOINT TENANCY WITH RIGHT OF SURVIVORSHIP IN REAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY

.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Robin Lundstrum Chair Unverified
34 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
12 segments
Alan Kerr Unverified
5 segments
Dolores Chitwood Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 23
1 segment
Speaker 15
1 segment
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
28 segments
Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 35
1 segment
Doyle Yates Unverified
22 segments
Representative Ken Henderson Unverified
8 segments
Representative John Maddox Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 90
7 segments
Speaker 92
1 segment
Speaker 102
3 segments
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 116
3 segments
Representative Les Warren Unverified
18 segments
Jimmy Corley Unverified
10 segments
Representative John Payton Unverified
6 segments
Representative Joe Jett Unverified
3 segments
Gary Beckwith Unverified
13 segments
Representative Bob Johnson Unverified
8 segments
Representative Austin McCollum Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 160
1 segment