Insurance and Commerce Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (13)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1476
· 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1476 Collins TO REVISE CERTAIN PROVISIONS RELATED TO FORMATION A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB133
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…passed the bill. Thank you. The next bill on our agenda is Senate Bill 133. Representative Henderson, you're recognized to present Sen…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB272
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “All right, the next bill on our agenda is SB 272. Is anybody here to carry Senator Bledsoe's bill? Represent…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1377
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1377 Lemons WARRANTY EXPRESS DEFECTIVE AGAINST MANUFACTURER'S A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1145
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1145 C.Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A J…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1166
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1166 Rushing TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1271
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1271 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1448
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1448 M. Gray TO INCLUDE FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS INSURED BY THE NA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1455
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1455 Payton TO AMEND THE LICENSING AND CONTINUING EDUCATION REQU…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1026
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1026 Rushing TO SUPPORT THE CREATION OF THE BEVERLY CARTER FOUND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB258
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB258 Elliott CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS FAIR HOUSING COMMISSION.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB279
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB279 D. Sanders CONCERNING THE TYPE OF SERVICE CONTRACTS THAT AR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB290
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB290 Rapert TO CLARIFY THE TYPE OF ANNUITY CONTRACTS SUBJECT TO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
We've got a handful of bills on our calendar today. I know people are running bills in some other places as well. So we're going to go through this the same way we typically do. We'll run through the bills in order. And then if the member that is here to present that bill isn't here at the time, we'll go through them one more time before we adjourn the meeting so that people get a chance to run their bills if they'd like. The first bill on our agenda is HB 1377. Is Representative Lemons here? I don't see Representative Lemon, so we'll pass over that at this time.
And the next bill on the agenda is House Bill 1476. That's mine, and so I'm going to turn the chair over to Chairman Lundstrom. Representative
Collins, you're recognized to present your bill, HB 1476. Thank you very much.
And I have Mr. Smith with me, and if we get questions, he'll sign in as well. But what I want to do to share with folks what HB 1476 is about is give you a moment of background. There's something which is known as a captive insurance company. What that means is a company that is usually in some other line of business, let's say you're a retailer or you're something else, but you're big enough to where you don't want to have to buy your health insurance or some other type of insurance from another carrier.
And so what you want to do is to be able to form your own company where you are the only client of the company, hence the concept captive. So what this allows and what captive insurance allows is for that to be its own entity. Last time, we passed some laws that changed the tax rates on captive insurance companies, et cetera, because those types of companies tend to go where the regulations and the tax rates are favorable.
The laws we passed last time have had a very positive effect. We're starting to get a lot more of that business than we had before. Obviously, that generates revenue to the state via the insurance department. And this bill is going to reduce regulations further, which enables these companies to want to come to Arkansas. So my understanding is there are some companies that are actually looking here. The biggest change in this bill, I know there's a lot of pages in here, but the biggest change in this bill, and it's a little complicated, so let me walk through it, does this.
Let's say Representative Richmond has a company, and he wants a captive insurance company, and Representative Maddox has a company, and he wants a captive insurance company, and let's say some of the others of us do as well. There are two elements to managing the insurance process. One element is the risk of the claims. That's the biggest element. That's the most expensive element, et cetera. The other element is the administration of executing the process of insurance, collecting the bills, mailing out forms, following up, calling people, doing all the administrative functions.
What this bill allows is Representative Richman's company, Representative Maddox's company, Representative Sevilla's company to form an arrangement where each of the cells of individual liability and risk funding for each individual company remain its own entity and are incorporated as its own entity. but the administrative functions can be separated out to get the economies of scale associated with it.
So it's a little bit of a complicated animal, but rather than just being able to create the entity of your captive insurance company, this allows you to separate out the administrative function and pool that for efficiencies. That change will allow us to be more of a magnet for these types of organizations.
And with that, I'll take questions. Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Collins, I like everything I'm hearing so far, but is this pertaining to reinsurance, like service contracts and things like that?
What I'm going to do is I'm going to have Derek Smith sign in here in a minute. I think the answer to your
make sure that it gets answered properly. And the other half of my question, if I may. Yes. Is, as you have these cells, and they're very similar in their coverage, but they're separate entities on one side, can they be compiled and underwritten as a group on the other side?
Hello. My name is Derek Smith. I practice insurance regulatory law with the Mitchell-Williams Law Firm here in Little Rock. Representative Payton, I think on your first question on reinsurance and service contracts, the relationship with reinsurance is only that captive insurers can directly access a reinsurance market, but it's not to provide a reinsurance product in and of itself. The second question on combining the risk of the protected sales,
Each cell is completely independent, and the statutes are written in a way such that the owner of the cell is only concerned with the risk that's in that cell and not with the risk in other companies. And the revisions in this bill further fortify that separation so you don't have risk bleeding over from one owner to another. Thank
you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Ferguson? I guess I just need some education. John Hutchison would be so proud of you, Charlie.
He wore me out about captive insurance when he sat next to me. I think he wore you out. I guess all the captives I'm familiar with are offshore companies. Can you tell me what, explain that to me and the advantages of them being
offshore instead of in the United States? The captive industry was historically an offshore industry. In more recent years, a lot of domestic states have started allowing captives. Arkansas passed its initial captive law, I think, in the early 2000s.
You have states like Vermont, South Carolina, D.C. that are known to be very favorable captive jurisdictions for domestic companies where they can be closer to their regulator. A good example is Texas. Texas passed a captive law in the last four years, and a lot of the Texas industry has been developing captives, and I think in four or five years they've formed 30 captives. So I think companies are starting to recognize benefits of having their captives on shore
as opposed to offshore, and all the changes in this law are meant to mimic statutes in other jurisdictions that have been viewed favorably
by the captive industry. I had a question. Are these captive insurance companies that we're creating
covered by the state guarantee fund? No, they are not. The captive is designed solely to cover the risk of the owner. So a large retailer might only cover its risk.
It doesn't provide products to the general public. And for that, they're not covered by the guarantee fund. They're not assessed by the guarantee fund. They don't pay into it, and their risk aren't covered. What happens if they go belly up? Then the owner is ultimately responsible for the liability. And would it ever come back to the taxpayers? It should not.
Okay. Any other questions? Okay, committee, what is your pleasure?
I have a due pass from Representative Payton. Discussion? Do we have members of the audience that would like to speak against? Do we have anybody that would like to speak for? Representative Collins, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed, Madam Chair. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Collins, you've passed your bill. Thank you.
All right, the next bill on our agenda is SB 272. Is anybody here to carry Senator Bledsoe's bill? Representative Hodges, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 272.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I've got Mr. Paul Means with Entergy, if
that's okay. Yes, of course. If Paul, if you would just
say introduce yourself and who you're with for the record. Paul Means with Energy, Arkansas, Mr. Chairman. SB 272 would exempt electric car providers, I guess, from being regulated by the PSC.
At least that's my understanding. In 1935, the legislature defined selling electricity or natural gas to the public as a public utility and made those persons or corporations subject to rate regulation by the Arkansas Public Service Commission. And, of course, in 1935, not a lot of vehicles used natural gas, and we didn't have many electric vehicles back in 1935. So in 2015, the legislature exempted cars using natural gas from the definition of a public utility.
And so this bill would create the same exemption for electric cars or electric vehicle charging stations. This bill would remove a regulatory obstacle to businesses installing electric vehicle charging stations in their parking lot and selling a recharge to an electric vehicle owner. It's been reviewed by the Arkansas Public Service Commission, the Arkansas Energy Office, the Attorney General, and the Public Electric Utilities. They all found it to be a reasonable bill. And with that, I will take any questions.
Representative Armstrong, you're right, can ask
Speaker 43
11:05
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative, could you tell me, or I guess, Paul, could you tell me how much municipalities may be generating revenue from having these electric docking stations incorporated in their towns? Do you have any idea? I don't
know. These are typically owned by examples of, like, there's one at the Clinton Library, there's one at UAMS.
You could put one in your hotel parking lot for when somebody spends the night in a restaurant where someone might stay an hour or two. They're not like a parking meter on the street, so these would be owned by private businesses who can make a little extra money by selling recharges to people that pull up with their electric car. Are there any more questions from the
committee? Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill, for the bill?
Representative Hodges, would you like to close for your
a do-pass motion. All right. We have a do-pass motion on the table. Is there any discussion on the motion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Hodges. You passed the bill. Thank you. The next bill on our agenda is Senate Bill 133. Representative Henderson, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 133.
Representative Henderson, you're recognized, and if you've got someone with you, sir, if you would introduce yourself
and who you're with. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I got with me today Chief Deputy Russ Galberth, and he's with the Insurance Commission, and Mr. Brian Waller with Shelter Insurance. And what we got today is SB 133. And what we're trying to
do with this bill is to clarify the language in the Arkansas Code to match the practices with insurance companies around the state. As many of you may know, there's really two types of insurance policy. There's what's called replacement. The replacement policy, and that's probably what most of us have. If your roof gets blown away, the insurance company comes back and replaces it. There's another policy that is that this is what's in question today. It's called the
actual cash value policy, and we deal a little bit more with the depreciation on this policy. If you buy, if your roof gets blown off today, and it's a 20-year warranty on that roof, and I think I'm saying this right, in five years, you know, your roof has depreciated 25%, and the cash value, they actually, I think, go back and just write you a check for the difference.
So, and that's what we're trying to do, is just really clarify that language. It does put some burden back on the commission. The commission has to give written notice about how they're depreciating your policy and why you're getting the money that you do. So with that, I'll open that up to any questions. Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. My
question is along the lines of what risk we put on the lien holders. As you know, these policies probably exist because the lien holder requires the debtor to be insured. And so in the case of a major loss, if the insurance is not paying enough to put the roof back on the house, where does that leave the lien holder?
This is Brian Waller with Shelter Insurance. The lien holder will still be protected. This change in the statute will be returning Arkansas to the place they were before this rule changed. And Arkansas will now be in the same place as all their neighboring states and actually 48 other states. And it will make us with 49 other states. California is the only state that has an issue that we're fixing here. So I think the lien holders will continue to be protected. Follow
up. So can you explain to me how the lien holder is protected if we're not paying enough on the claim to replace the loss?
Are we assuming that the debtor has the money in their pocket to make up the difference or
what? Well, it'll be the actual cash value will still pay the actual cash value of the roof. So while it won't replace the roof, it'll pay the value of the roof. I think the assumption is that insureds that choose to take that policy do that
knowing what the value of their property is. Mr. Wall, let me make sure I understand what we're doing here. Historically, a person would buy an insurance policy, and they would pay an amount to either have the entire roof replaced,
or the insurance company would charge them a rate that would really only cover a reduced benefit, call it the depreciated value. And even though somebody was paying the lower rate, the courts have mandated that the insurance company always pay for full replacement. And what we're doing here is we're separating and clarifying that there are two kinds of policies. A consumer can choose full replacement value and pay the premium associated with that.
Or they can choose depreciated replacement value and pay the premium for that and have the choice. Is that correct? This statute,
yes, this statute will make that distinction more clear between the two policies, the two policy types, to give the consumer the choice between those two policies. And the insurance company, when they put that forward, will give someone
the choice. can buy the good one, or you can buy the cheaper one, but if you buy the cheaper one, you lose your roof. You're only going to get the depreciated value, and the consumer will have that explained to him or her and why the pricing is lower for that option. Yes, the explanation will
be carried in the policy, and that policy language will have to be approved by
the commissioner's office. Representative Farrar, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Who determines the length of depreciation on
the roof or anything else? So that determination will be made with the adjuster, and my experience has been that the adjuster, it's typically a negotiation. You look at the appearance, the obsolescence of that property, and you visit with the insured, and you come up on an agreement as to how much it's depreciated.
So, another question. So, it's going to be, you're going to have to bargain over the length of it? I think, I guess what I was, you know, the fear I would have with the insurance company said, We did a year of depreciation on your roof. That's my fear. That's the question I'm having. Who determines that length
of the depreciation? So the adjuster that comes out and looks at the property that's damaged will make that determination. But my experience has been that they do that in conjunction with the insurer
that they come to an agreement on that. Can I ask a question? So, like, if you buy a factory and then you put in a machinery in the factory, the federal government has a depreciation schedule, and then the accountants look at some factors all in the context of what is in the agreement and what's in the tax law. So what you're describing is not a process where an insurance adjuster comes out with no baseline, no rationale, and starts trying to get out of paying the policy,
but rather saying this roof has been on here for one year or it's been on here for 27 years. So if a roof's been on for 27 years, it's going to be far more depreciated than if it's a brand-new roof. Then there are other factors, et cetera. Is that how it's done, or does the guy just come out and say, hey,
look, I got you now. I'm going to pay you nothing? No. I mean, typically with your roofs, you have a lifespan, and you can determine that by the type of shingles, and that's where that conversation begins. If it's like the representative started off talking about a 20-year shingle, and if it's five years old, then we know that's appreciated about 25%.
Representative Murdoch, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. Questions keep coming. Every time you say something, really, I thought I understood this. Somebody approached me about this, and now I have lots of questions about it. um so and of course depreciation on a warranty you're talking about a 20-year warranty on on shingles so that would not necessarily apply to uh depreciation you wouldn't apply
that to depreciation uh so that's not applicable but i'm trying to go back to understand exactly the purpose of this if you may if you can't go backwards for me we have acv and we have replacement costs. That's already clear. I mean, in all of the properties, I mean, I have those options already. What are you doing with this? Make
me understand this again. This statute just clarifies in statute that the actual cash value policy
can depreciate, and by doing so, it has to say in the policy what it's depreciating. So with the statute, we're just making that clear, and we're also, by the statute, saying that when you do depreciate, you have to spell that out in your policy so the consumer
has notice. And I don't think that we're doing anything that's not being done already. We're just kind of making sure this is in code so everything lines back up. Thank you.
I may have another question later, but thank you. Representative Lowry, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm curious, are we to read anything into the fact that a representative from one company is presenting rather than someone from a property and casualty association that would be representing a number of companies? I mean, is this something specific to shelter?
Russ Galbraith, I'm the Chief Deputy Insurance Commissioner. No, sir, this is an industry-wide situation. It's not necessarily a one-company issue. Okay, follow-up, please. So there's not
some companies that have more policies that relate to depreciation than others? I guess I'm asking for a selfish reason because Shelter is my insurance company on my house. I don't
know the numbers of how it plays out between replacement costs and ACV,
but I do know that most major companies have both types of policies. It just depends on the company, I guess. Okay. Thank you. Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized for a question.
confusion. When you purchase an insurance policy for one year or 20 years, you think it's going to be replaced when that hailstorm comes through, and then to find out on the other end 20 years later, oh, it's depreciated. We're only going to give you half a roof. I don't know how you're going to clarify this with the customer so that they don't feel cheated.
I'll take that one. So, you know, it's the responsibility of the agent to explain what type of policy they're selling, number one. Number two, there is going to be information given to the policyholder. That's part of this bill, I believe, in terms of disclosure. as to what is being sold. Number three, an ACV policy is usually sold at a much less premium than a replacement cost for obvious reasons because, you know, replacement cost is going
to be more expensive. So there are a number of things lined out when it comes to the point of purchase and then later on with the disclosures as to what the policyholder is getting. But Ultimately, it is, I would think, the responsibility of the agent to make sure that that is clarified. But if somebody is buying an ACV policy, they know that they're getting that policy for a cheaper rate than what they would with replacement cost and should be aware that when a claim comes, it's going to be a depreciated value.
Representative Maddox, you recognize for a question. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. I guess one thing for me is that these ACV policies have been around for a long time. I'm an attorney. I have numerous claims where ACV policy, and we've had a lot of issues trying to look at depreciation. So to me, there's some good language in here that basically says that the insurer shall provide a written explanation as to how depreciation was calculated. So to me, that will actually be a benefit for the insured. And that's new.
I know in my practice, we've argued about how you
came to that depreciation valuation. Would you agree with that? I do see that as a strong consumer protection to have that written explanation. I do.
I agree with you. So what I want to ask is, historically, there's been a lot of confusion about this, just as we've got lots of questions here. and historically the courts have decided and people thought they were purchasing one thing
and someone else thought they were selling something else. And what this really does is clarify you have two concrete choices. One has a higher benefit and costs you more money and you can look at them side by side and an agent can say you can purchase it this way, you can purchase it that way. And it clarifies how those things are going to be calculated So it provides consumer choice and clarity and pricing options. Is that what we're doing here? Yes, sir.
Representative Lundstrom, you recognize for a question?
Just a quick one. How does the bank know that holds the mortgage that the two different ones are being purchased? I just see a lot of confusion both on the consumer side
and banking. Could you clarify? Back to the lien holder question and the bank question. I think a lien holder can mandate what type of coverage the person gets. So if they are, you know, they can say, look, we want this to be replacement cost or, you know,
after underwriting or whatever, we understand that an actual cash value is better and you have the means to take care of this if the property is depreciated. But that's something that the lien holder and the consumer work out, I guess, through the contract and, you know, through
that type of thing. And I do know a little bit more about the banking business than, I guess, the insurance business. But when you're dealing with a bank, the bank can require you to choose whatever kind of policy,
in fact, that the bank probably would ask you or require you to use the replacement cost policy. And if it didn't and the insurance companies wrote that check, then that check would actually be sent to the bank. if that's correct. So the bank is always involved in anything that has to do with your mortgage. Representative Payton, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I appreciate your comments about the lien holder and the bank.
And I just, I guess if the banking association is represented here, they may come to the table and give us a level of comfort if they're okay with that. But I'm an auctioneer, and actual cash value is something that I deal with every day. And actual cash value is what a buyer and a seller can agree on at any given moment. And that seems to apply well to a total loss situation. But what bothers me is the partial loss where, you know, we're not talking about depreciated value of a home that's 40 years old.
We're talking about the roof blew off, and if it doesn't get replaced, it's going to destroy the rest of the house. Uh, so is there a difference in how this is handled when you have a total loss versus a partial
have the, uh, the valued policy law that, that, uh, covers the, I guess, policy limits when, when a, uh, uh, uh, when there's a total loss on a property.
I may be able to, I'm going to try to clarify a little bit because we've kind of been talking around. We've talked about warranties. We've talked about a couple of different things for a roof, because a lot of people focus on the roof part. You know, you've got a 20 year shingle, maybe you have a 30 year shingle, something like that. And so, you know, we can look at when the house was built, if the original owner is there and if they've been in the house for 10 years and there's hail damage or a roof blows off and they have actual cash value. We know that this is a 10-year-old roof. Therefore, the replacement would be, you know, the depreciation would be
somewhere around 50 percent, something like that. You know, if you have a piece of property like a TV, and it's an old box TV with a tube, and it's 20 years old, you're not going to get much. If it's an actual cash value policy, you're not going to get much for the replacement of that TV. The company is not going to replace it with a flat screen or the value of a flat screen. So, So, you know, the depreciation factor is based off of the age of the item that's being replaced. So I think, you know, when we're talking about what formula it is or whatever, you know, it's fairly consistent based on the age of the property that's being depreciated or the property that's being covered.
Can I ask this question? There are two choices in life. Either we can say everybody's going to buy a Tiffany Diamond, and we're going to price everybody that way and force them to either purchase the best option, the most expensive option for complete and unadulterated, every nickel in the box back, or we're going to give people a choice to purchase something else. And when you go to the toothpaste towel, for example, there's about 900 choices. Is that really what we're talking about here, or is this how do we screw the consumer?
this this is increased consumer choice this is this is this is uh more choices for the consumer uh to choose what coverage is best for them uh in in whatever situation it is that's that's what this is about representative warren you're
mr chairman I know in the title business when I do closings, we have several forms that we have people sign off
that they understand that when they sign off that this is exactly what it is so that later on if there's any questions, they're saying you didn't tell me this. My question for you is in the insurance industry, Is there something that the consumer signs that says, I understand I'm not getting replacement cost, I'm getting a depreciated value, I'm going to have to come up with something if my roof needs replacing at a later date?
Like we said before, there are disclosures attached to this bill. You know, when a consumer signs their contract, their insurance contract, that's one way to, I guess, show that they have taken a look and understand the contract. We all know that there are tons and tons and tons of paper that go with that, and the disclosures you may or may not see. Really, that goes back to the agent and the agent's responsibility.
And as the insurance department being first and foremost consumer protection, if we start to see that agents are not doing their due diligence and not giving those disclosures or explaining the policy the right way, then we have action that we can take. Thank you. Representative Ferguson, you're going to ask for a
just need maybe you to make me feel more comfortable with this.
I understand Representative Collins and that sort of hard line. Yeah, you know what you're signing. But I'm concerned about the senior citizen and the less sophisticated person, you know, who owns their home that costs $60,000. And, of course, they're going to take the least expensive option. But then their roof blows off or they have an insurance claim and they can't afford to make up the difference from what the claim cost is and what the cost of replacement, and they're out of their home.
I guess if you could make me feel comfortable with this
next scenario. Again, consumers have choices, and there is a certain responsibility when it comes to the consumer. There's also responsibilities when it comes to the agent and the point of sale and the discussion of the policy. um, as a consumer protection department, um, when we see that that is a, uh, uh, something
that is prevalent, then we, we, we take the appropriate action. So, um, you know, if it's, if it's, uh, uh, uh, you know, one bad, um, player who, who is not, uh, you know, is trying to sell the cheapest thing and then, and then doesn't, uh, um, uh, explain the situation, then we'll take action. But from what we have seen, you know, like somebody had mentioned before, actual cash value policies have been around, and this is not a prevalent thing that we are fighting on a consistent basis.
Excuse me. Could we solve that problem by putting on the form into the law, if you're over 60 years old, you must buy the most expensive policy? Could we solve the problem if we did that? Boo. I'm confused, seriously. Representative Murdoch, can I ask
for a question? Okay, so to the gentleman from the department, representing the Assurance Department, Consumer Protection, and that's, so the concern becomes that you're going to be,
well, so after the fact, many times they're injured in these type situations are the less sophisticated, as Representative Ferguson mentioned. So therefore, when they become injured, they may not even have the capacity to know to come to you and even know about the insurance department. So my concern becomes up front that with the concerns you're hearing from this committee, that it almost sounds like we're legitimizing a way almost,
and I don't mean offense by this, but I do mean defense by this, that we're legitimizing a way to get people. We're putting it, we're going to legitimize this is okay because this is written now, and it's already there. It's already there that they can make those choices. But from consumer protection standpoint, what is the department committing to to protect those that we are concerned about? You're hearing our fears, and you should see why
with the question, the lines of questions that you're
getting. I need to feel better about this. We have an extensive consumer services department that goes out outreach at different places all over the state. That's something that if you'd like us to, we can come to your district and have a seminar or be there to answer questions and that sort of thing. That's going on constantly. As to your first statement about maybe legitimizing a way to get something over people, I think
if the premium was the same as a replacement cost policy, then that would be the fact. But the fact is that this is a much lower premium. Most people who buy the actual cash value policy understand that for a lower premium, they're getting lower coverage. And I believe, again, in this bill, there are disclosures that specify that in terms of getting that information to that person. And I'll go back. I think I've said this three or four times.
It is the responsibility of the agent to make sure that a policy is explained to their customer. And that's something that we are very strongly for and like to promote. Representative Lundstrom, you're right, can I ask for a
going. Less cost, so there's less value to it. More cost, so there's total replacement.
Is there a way we could see the documentation that you're going to be showing the customer so it's not in the bottom line and fine print, it's up there? you're purchasing something that's not going to give you replacement value. It's only going to let you replace a few shingles after a hailstorm. Is there a way we could see
that documentation so we know the consumer is not going to be confused? That's going to be, I guess, from the companies. I will tell you that our responsibility is to view that and make sure that it is something that is not in, you know, eight-point print and that it is prevalent. And
if it's a situation where we feel like that this is being hidden, then we will, you know, we have the ability to make rules and bulletins to enhance that. So that's, again, part of our charge is consumer protection, and we would make sure that that's not an issue. I don't know specifically, you may have an answer to that, Brian, what the disclosure would look like. I think that's something that they have to submit to us. We have to approve anyway.
Rep. Henderson, I've got a question for you. Given all the questions that are still on
the list, would you like to consider pulling the bill down today and seeing if you can provide the committee members some additional information? Or if you'd prefer, we can continue to vet out questions. Obviously, that's your call. But we've got a long list, and it's not getting shorter. That would be
fine, Mr. Chair. The only thing that I would say amongst our conversation right now, looking on the banker's side of it, I mean, if a bank's going to require, if I have a mortgage on your house as a banker,
I'm probably going to have you get a replacement cost policy. And I wouldn't know any bank or mortgage company that would not do that, unless it's probably a fine one to ask that question, too. On the other side, Representative Murdoch, you were talking about the less sophisticated people that couldn't do it, and I understand that, and there may be some of those people out there, but you've got the less wealthy people out there, too, that needs this policy.
So even though it may not be a perfect bill, it may not be a perfect law, it does go to help people. And I think what the Insurance Commission has done was really set up, trying to set up guidelines that's already practiced, that is already going on, and we're just trying to put that in code. I mean, I know there's a lot of questions. There's a lot of things I don't understand about insurance policies, and I wouldn't jump out there and say that I know everything.
But talking and going through this and studying and really trying to get a good grip on this, I really do think it goes back to a little consumer protection. You know, we want to make sure that insurance companies are giving this notification why it's getting depreciated like it's getting. And there are recourses. There's recourses out there. if you disagree, and I agree with you,
there's less sophisticated people out there, and I'm probably one of them, but that you could just take advantage of if you wanted to. And there's nothing we can do. There's nothing that we can put in statute. There's nothing that anybody can do. If somebody wants to cheat somebody, they can probably find somebody to cheat. so
representative henderson um do you want us to continue taking questions from the committee
uh or is that what you'd like us to do it's obviously it's your your call i'm just i'm looking at the clock we've got 16 minutes so what what i'm going to do is uh if you want to continue moving forward today then i
will of the committee i know it's my choice, but if there's questions out there that wants to be answered, then we might want to pull it down. If there's just a few out there and we can combine them and get a vote today.
Could I have a point of order? Yes.
You recognize Representative Payton. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just think it's very healthy to vet this in committee forum for the next five or ten, however many minutes we've got, rather than everybody trying to run around and catch each other. This is the most conducive way to vet it. If
we could just continue with some questions. Representative Lowry, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This
question from Mr. Galbraith. This disclosure is not currently required in statute. Is that correct?
Is that really what we're fixing is that we're requiring, because the language is not permissive, it's shall language, we're requiring a disclosure that clearly explains depreciation. That's correct. Okay. And that is a consumer protection? Absolutely. Can you assure us? I'm sorry. I've been asking this last one. Can you assure us that there is going to be a minimum requirement, and this is in rules promulgation, that this disclaimer is not going to be four-point tight?
It's going to be very clear in its explanation to the consumer and the protection of the consumer.
I can assure you that the disclosure will not be hidden. It will be in a way that will be prominent like other disclosures. Okay. Thank you very much. Representative Seville,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Senior Chair. I have a choice when I take an insurance policy out concerning a deductible,
and I realize what that means. I don't know if there's any association to this, but once again, if I take a higher deductible, my premium is lower and so forth. So I understand that, and I don't know if this is similar to a choice of that nature, but I guess my question would be back to the Insurance Commission. Have we had a series of claims that would make us cautious in regards to this particular legislation, in regards to people who are undershared?
Representative, not that I'm aware of. Like I said, our Consumer Services Division works complaints. That's our complaints department. And this has not been a prevalent issue. Representative Rushing, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My question is for us people that maybe, as in Representative Henderson's terms, I'm not smart about everything, and I may be one of those too.
Can you tell us what happens and what the repercussions are if this bill
was not to pass? there's going to be less consumer choice. You would look at the possibility of there being less, I guess, more expensive choices when it comes to policies out there. Replacement cost is going to be more expensive. So if your ACV policies, you may have companies that
start selling more replacement costs rather than ACV because of this situation. Follow-up? So you're basically saying that we'll be limiting consumer choice if
we don't pass this bill? That would be a... That could be a possible repercussion. Yes, ma'am. Thank you. Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question.
Just one. I don't know which one to ask. But anyway, currently, my understanding is we are selling ACV policies in the state of Arkansas, and it is currently cheaper. So we've talked about how on the ACV policy, there's a negotiation process over the loss in the claim. It seems to me that this bill is going to take away one of the very strong positions of the policyholder in that negotiating process.
So can you tell me how we are adding a third product? I mean, currently we have the full coverage. We have the ACV. Are you talking about we're adding a third product or we're modifying an existing product?
I'm not sure if I understand your question about what is being taken away from the consumer in terms of negotiating, but I'm going to let Mr. Waller cover that as well.
So what this statute is doing is just having the policy state that it's depreciating so it's clear what it depreciates. So in that way, we have that clear delineation between the two policies. So if I could follow up, we are strengthening the insurance company's position in the negotiating
process. I don't think it's going to change the negotiating
process at all. I don't think it changes how. I think it's just making it clear that you have an ACV policy and that it depreciates,
and it'll describe what and how it depreciates. So I see this as giving
more consumer protection. And this is just putting in the Arkansas code. This bill is just putting in the Arkansas code what is
already being done. I mean, if... Which strengthens the insurance company's negotiating stand in the process, in the
settlement. I don't really understand where that comes from.
You always have a right. But if you feel like somebody's done you wrong, you always have recourse on what you could go to the insurance commission. You can take them to court and sue them. I mean, you can, in which. Isn't that what's happened here? They've been taken to court and lost? I
mean, that's part of what I was told leading up to this meeting is that there had been class action lawsuits about the labor component in this and that the insurance companies had lost.
There was a lawsuit about policies defining labor, and what we're looking to do is, with this statute, it'll just clearly say, if you depreciate labor, you can do that if you state it in your policy. So this is making it, I think, more clear for consumers, because if that company is depreciating labor or any of the other costs that go involved in that, they have to state it in their policy, and then that language has to be approved by the department. and the company has to explain that in writing when they're adjusting the laws.
Okay, thank you. Representative Richmond, you recognize
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Forgive me, but a few minutes ago you stated that we're already selling these type of policies in the state, and then later you stated that if we don't pass this, there's going to be less consumer choice. Could you explain to
me why that would happen? So, with the lawsuit that was mentioned, there was a concern about labor being depreciated.
And if labor is not depreciated, then that increases the cost, because that's part of the unit. With this law, it'll allow companies to again depreciate labor like they had been. But when they do that, they have to spell that out in their policy. So it is, we do have ACV policies in Arkansas, and we've had them for a long, long time. This is just making it clear that when they depreciate all the costs, they can do that, but they have to spell it out in their policy. And when they're allowed to do that, that's what gives you that differentiation between the two. Because being able to depreciate all the costs and not just some of it is what changes the cost of that product.
Representative Lundstrom, you're asking for a question. You're currently already selling this product, correct? There are ACV policies in Arkansas, yes. So why hasn't
this already been made clear? The lawsuits that were mentioned, I think, have muddied it a bit as to what can be depreciated. So, again, we're looking, this will make it clear because you'll have to spell out, if you're going to depreciate, you have to spell it out, and then it has to be approved by the department. So that's, those are the new components. Okay, but you, follow up?
Couldn't you have already made this clear to the consumer you're purchasing a less valuable product, and then are you're purchasing replacement product? I mean, that's something the industry could already have done to protect itself and the consumer. So I'm confused. Sure. I think that has
been done. I think the only question was about some of the language and some of the policies about what they were and weren't depreciating what the policies said. We had lawsuits about that. And so this is making it clear that you can depreciate those things, but you have to spell it out in your policy.
Representative Murdoch, you have a question. Thank you again. Okay, so the more we talk, the more I get confused again. So I'm going to join that group with those other two. But I don't think that's really the case. I think there's something else. So let's keep talking. So when the question was asked about what's going to be changed if this law does not pass, because currently ACV and replacement value policies are offered.
They are offered at a different cost. That's today, before this statute, before this bill. Now, then a lawsuit came into this conversation. So what I want to know clearly, what's the purpose of what we're doing? Because trust me, listen before you start answering. Because what you're doing is not making any clear so far to most of us. It's going back and forth. It's what we're doing, but it's not really what we're doing. And then what we're going to do now, I'm going to clear up something,
but it really don't sound clear. Okay. So please try to make it more clear and deal with how the lawsuit, this labor depreciation, now affects the situation because we do know, and I appreciate Representative Payton for reminding me as well, that there was a settlement recently, and now that that settlement is gone, now we're doing so. Sure. Put it
all on the table because it's going to come probably. Sure. So we've always had these ACV policies, and they've depreciated property.
The lawsuit was about whether or not when they depreciate all the costs, part of those costs is labor costs. And the lawsuit was about whether or not you could depreciate that labor cost. And so the issue is, so we had the lawsuit, and the court said you can't depreciate that labor cost. But when you're not allowed to depreciate that labor cost, that increases the cost of that ACV policy because a big part of the cost is labor. And so what we're saying now, you do have the ACV policy,
but that cost of it is creeping up being closer to an actual cash value policy because if you're not allowed to depreciate the labor, it's really kind of becoming a replacement cost policy. So you're not really having the two choices. Technically, there is an ACV policy, but it's being made to act more and more and more like a replacement cost policy. So we're looking to be able to go back to where we were before the lawsuit, where you could depreciate all the costs. And by having this statute, it'll allow us to then depreciate all the costs, including labor.
And by including labor, depreciating labor, and all the other costs that go into that unit, that will then make the distinction that we had before. So with the lawsuit and the judgment that said you can't depreciate labor because you can't depreciate it, it increased the cost of that ACV policy. So you do still have the two, but they look more alike and they act more alike and they're going to cost more alike because you're not allowed to depreciate that labor. So this is allowing us to, again, depreciate labor and to depreciate all the costs. And by doing that, it's going to, again, pay less like it did before, which means it'll cost less.
Speaker 74
55:11
Okay, so this allows you to be able to depreciate labor. Yes, sir. That's the big part of this. It technically allows us to depreciate all of those, but labor is the big part. Why wasn't that ever said? Why wasn't that ever made the focus of this?
Stay with me for a second. Why do it in the way that you did it? Because really the point now, you're getting to the whole point of this. And I'm okay with you getting to this
Speaker 74
55:36
point, but I wish you would get here much differently. Well, I apologize. I did not mean to be confusing at all.
I really didn't. Well, it's another word besides confusing probably, but it was sort of confusing the way it
was masked, framed. It was not my intention to mask it or confuse anyone. I apologize. I would have started by explaining it that way up front. All
right. Here's where we're at. We've got like two minutes before we need to go on session. We've got a resolution that a member would really, really love to get done. And so we've got two choices for the committee, and I'm going to ask for your feedback.
Either we're going to do 30 seconds of against for and close and take a vote, or we're going to pull this down until next week. So Representative Henderson, I'll ask you first, what would you prefer to do? I would rather go ahead
So we're going to, without objection, we're going to use 30 seconds for for and against and close altogether, and then we're going to take a vote. Is there anyone that wants to speak against the bill, for the bill?
Senator Henderson, you want to speak for the bill? Sir, you're recognized for 28 seconds. I'll make
Speaker 134
57:01
this very brief, Mr. Chairman. I'm Len Zeno, the director of the Independent Insurance Agents of Arkansas. We represent 400 agencies from every part of the state, from the big ones to the little ones. Almost everyone around this table has replacement cost coverage. But there are a lot of sections and a lot of areas in the state, and especially the rural areas,
Class 9, Class 10 properties, that we sort of have a homeowner's crisis in this state right now. Those agents can't find companies to write insurance for those Class 9, Class 10 properties. Many of those properties are only eligible for ACV policies. Sir,
I apologize, but the 28 seconds is up, so I appreciate that. Representative Henderson, the allocated time is gone, so we're now at the place where we're looking for a motion.
Do I have a motion? Representative Rushing, what's your motion? I make the motion do pass. All right, we have a motion on the table. Is there any discussion on the motion? No discussion, so all in favor? Aye. All opposed? No. Chair rules, the ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Henderson. You presented your vote. Don't leave everybody. We've got one more thing. Representative Rushing, you're recognized to present HR 1026. This is a resolution, so our goal is to do this.
think I can get it done in 30 seconds. You're recognized to present
the resolution. Thank you. This is just a resolution to support the creation of the Beverly Carter Foundation and its mission to create a safer real estate industry. Carters will be here on Tuesday, and we would like this to be presented when they are here. All right. Thank you very much. I'm assuming there are
no questions. Is there anyone to speak against the resolution for the resolution?
Representative Rushing is closed for a resolution. Representative Murdock, you're recognized for a motion. Motion to pass. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Rushing, you've passed your resolution.
Agenda
REGULAR AGENDA
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1377 Lemons WARRANTY EXPRESS DEFECTIVE AGAINST MANUFACTURER'S A CONCERNING ASPHALT ROOF SHINGLES.
HB1476 Collins TO REVISE CERTAIN PROVISIONS RELATED TO FORMATION AND OPERATION OF CAPTIVE INSURANCE COMPANIES.
SB272 Bledsoe TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PUBLIC UTILITY".
SB133 Rapert TO AMEND THE PROPERTY AND CASUALTY LAW; TO CLARIFY THE DEPRECIATION APPLICABLE WHEN DETERMINING THE VALUE OF DAMAGED PROPERTY.
HR1026 Rushing TO SUPPORT THE CREATION OF THE BEVERLY CARTER FOUNDATION AND ITS MISSION TO CREATE A SAFER REAL ESTATE INDUSTRY.
SB258 Elliott CONCERNING THE ARKANSAS FAIR HOUSING COMMISSION.
SB279 D. Sanders CONCERNING THE TYPE OF SERVICE CONTRACTS THAT ARE SUBJECT TO THE MOTOR VEHICLE SERVICE CONTRACT ACT; AND TO ADD THEFT PROTECTION PROGRAM WARRANTIES TO THE MOTOR VEHICLE SERVICE CONTRACT ACT.
SB290 Rapert TO CLARIFY THE TYPE OF ANNUITY CONTRACTS SUBJECT TO THE UNCLAIMED LIFE INSURANCE BENEFITS ACT.
DEFERRED
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1145 C.Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A JOINT TENANCY WITH RIGHT OF SURVIVORSHIP IN REAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1166 Rushing TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS AND RESIDENTIAL TENANTS; AND TO REQUIRE IMPLIED QUALITY STANDARDS FOR TENANTS OF RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPERTY.
HB1271 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1448 M. Gray TO INCLUDE FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS INSURED BY THE NATIONAL CREDIT UNION ADMINISTRATION AS INSTITUTIONS ALLOWED TO SERVE AS DEPOSITORIES OF PUBLIC FUNDS.
HB1455 Payton TO AMEND THE LICENSING AND CONTINUING EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR AUCTIONEERS; AND; TO PROVIDE FOR A FOUR-YEAR AUCTIONEER'S LICENSE.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlie Collins Chair
Unverified
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Representative John Payton
Unverified
Speaker 12
Derek Smith
Unverified
Representative Nelda Speaks
Unverified
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Speaker 43
Paul Means
Unverified
Speaker 42
Representative Ken Henderson
Unverified
Representative Joe Farrer
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Reginald Murdock
Unverified
Representative Mark Lowery
Unverified
Representative John Maddox
Unverified
Speaker 85
Representative Les Warren
Unverified
Speaker 108
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Representative Marcus E. Richmond
Unverified
Speaker 74
Speaker 134