Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee

February 23, 2017 ·Committee Room 130 ·2:36:01
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (43)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1021 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1040 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1160 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN E…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1181 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1182 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1186 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APP…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1204 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBST…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1205 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1215 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE TH…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1228 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1237 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1250 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO CREAT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1254 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1255 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1255 D. Ferguson TO CREATE A TEMPORARY CHARITABLE DENTAL LICENSE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1257 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1300 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1300 Miller THE TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1439 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1439 M. Gray TO AMEND THE HEALTHCARE QUALITY AND PAYMENT POLICY…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1465 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1465 Miller TO CREATE THE MEDICAID EXPANSION ENROLLMENT FREEZE A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB15 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…se i want everybody's voice heard um and we're going to run house bill 15 51 first so if you're not here for 1551 it would help the p…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1501 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1501 McCollum TO MODIFY AND REPEAL LANGUAGE REFERENCING THE SUPE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1502 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1502 S. Meeks TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION TO THE DEFINITION OF RESIDE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1504 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1504 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1513 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1513 Holcomb TO AMEND THE ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ASBES…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1515 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1515 Ladyman TO PROVIDE LOCAL CONTROL OVER FLUORIDE LEVELS IN WA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1525 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1525 Magie AN ACT TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD AN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1526 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1526 M. Gray TO MODIFY ACT 143 OF 2017 TO SPECIFY THAT A CRIMINA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1545 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1545 Sullivan TO ALLOW THE DIVISION OF CHILD CARE AND EARLY CHIL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1550 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1550 Davis TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING NONMUNICIPAL DOMESTIC SEW…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1551 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1551 Womack TO STIMULATE JOB CREATION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT W…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1566 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1566 Hammer TO AMEND THE PROVISIONS OF LAW CONCERNING THE DISPOS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1609 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1609 Tucker TO INCREASE FLEXIBILITY IN THE LAW REGARDING FREQUEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1613 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1613 Barker TO EXEMPT A LONG-TERM CARE OMBUDSMAN FROM REPORTING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1624 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1624 Leding TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO WAGES EARNED ACT.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1625 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1625 Leding TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO KNOW YOUR PAY ACT.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1626 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1626 Pilkington TO AMEND THE PROHIBITION OF PHOTOGRAPHY IN LONG-…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1628 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1628 B. Smith TO CREATE THE HEALTHCARE FREEDOM OF CONSCIENCE ACT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1635 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1635 Eaves TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING UNDERGROUND STORAGE TANKS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1651 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1651 Boyd CONCERNING SOLICITATIONS AFTER MOTOR VEHICLE ACCIDENTS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1653 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1653 Miller TO CREATE THE DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES WAIVER DEAT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1030 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1030 Hammer PROMOTING THE AWARENESS OF PEDIATRIC ACUTE-ONSET NEU…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB148 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB148 G. Stubblefield TO CREATE BORN-ALIVE INFANT PROTECTION.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB167 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB167 D. Sanders TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS AC…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB301 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB301 J. Cooper TO ALLOW THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH TO SHARE IMMUNI…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
If members would, grab your seat. Yes. For the audience in the room, I'll make an announcement, and I've already made this clear with the police officers. We've got a lot of bills on the agenda. We've got some bills that require a lot of attention on the agenda today. For that reason, if you're in the room now and you have no concern with the bill that is running, there's probably 50 people outside that do so if you don't mind we can swap those places so that the right people are in the right in the room at the right time because i want everybody's voice heard um and we're going to run house bill 15 51 first so if you're not here for 1551 it would help the people that are here for 1551 to be able to be in the room so it's just kind of a courtesy thing it's not against anybody i love actually having a room full to the chairs that's why you're in here but i want to have the right people in the room at the right time so that their discussion gets heard so if you could help us out with that it's nothing against anybody it just makes it a lot easier
▶ Play
Speaker 3 1:28
for the people that
▶ Play
Speaker 6 1:35
want to hear the bills uh so without further ado no because i told him first representative hammer are you in here still would you lead us in prayer real quick before we get started today Thank you. Just respect each other's right to express opinions, present facts, and just do the best job we can. Lord, we present the issues that we've all got. When this life is over, we all stand before you. Give accountability for our actions here and ourself. Help us to look at the name of the Father. Just pray that I will be done. We pray that we will be done. We pray that we will be done. We ask all the saints in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen. Amen. Thank you. All these people speaking against it.
▶ Play
Speaker 10 2:31
Yeah. Are they in here? Yeah. Representative Walmatt, give us
▶ Play
one second. We've got a few things. We're trying to get housekeeping done first. Craig. Craig,
▶ Play
Speaker 17 2:50
can you all move that way for a
▶ Play
second? Committee, today we've got some special guests with us from University of Arkansas, Monticello, and they come to watch us do our work today. I've got Ms. Diana Williams, who is Assistant Professor of Social Work, and a few of her students. They're going to be up here behind me, and if you guys would, help me give them a welcome. We've got Emily White, Jasmine Sazmore, Ephraim Garcia, and Jessica Justice. Thank you, guys. All right, Representative Womack,
▶ Play
Speaker 24 3:32
you're ready to go. Thank you, Mr. Chair and Committee. I have an amendment that needs dealt with first, I believe. Okay. Is it on the tablet? It is. I don't think so. It's not
▶ Play
on the tablet. I think Mr. Price has a copy. If you would, go ahead and start presenting it. We'll get it passed
▶ Play
Speaker 24 3:52
out to the members. Okay, it's super simple. It's a one-word amendment that falls under the list on page 3, and the word is optometrist. That is the entirety of the amendment.
▶ Play
Uh, what's the pleasure of the committee on this amendment? I got due pass on amendment. Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? amendment pass please present your bill as amended representative walmart thank you mr chair and
▶ Play
Speaker 24 4:52
committee uh this may be the most boring presentation of a bill uh i've ever done or you've had to sit through i'm gonna just probably deal with the text of the bill because there's a a whole lot of misinformation that's out there that that i you know we can't really talk to so let me tell you uh i just want to read starting on page one that says this bill does not repeal any portion of current law concerning the regulation of occupations and professions, and it does not sanction the illegal practice of a licensed occupation.
▶ Play
Can you get closer to the mic,
▶ Play
Speaker 24 5:28
Representative, please, sir? And then I'd like to draw your attention to page 3, starting on line 21. The right to engage in a lawful occupation. A private individual has the right to engage in a lawful occupation without being required to comply with an occupational regulation that imposes a substantial burden on private individual in terms of time financial obligation or the expenditure of other resources is not substantially related to the state's important interest in protecting against present and recognizable harm to the public health or safety and is either unreasonable or more restrictive than is necessary to further the state's important interest in protecting against present and recognizable harm to the public health or safety I'd like to go a little further over to page four starting on line 11 and it says the right to engage in a lawful occupation under this section does not if the person is not certified registered or licensed as required by law allow the person to use the title certified registered or licensed or hold himself or herself out as being certified registered or licensed so I wanted to draw your attention to the text because I've received a world of emails from people that stated the exact opposite and I think it's important to to deal with the bill we have in front of us not the fears that are floating around out there so what this bill does is it provides a person the opportunity to defend against the regulations he or she believes are a substantial burden on their ability to make a living and with that I would be happy to answer any questions. Representative Payton you're recognized for a question. Thank you Mr. Chair. Representative Romack I appreciate you filing a bill that that brings up so much you know that needs to be vetted you know sometimes it seems like with all the boards and commissions and agencies that we have that regulations can become over burdensome to people trying to engage in making a living for the family. Do you see this bill as an unlicensing bill, or do you see it as a check and balance to give somebody a course of action that when an agency goes beyond what is reasonable, they would have a course of action to challenge that agency on their regulations? That is exactly why I filed this bill, and that's why I referred to the text to start off. This is not an unlicensing bill. This just provides an individual, an avenue to challenge the reasonableness of a regulation outside the board that established that regulation so they can get to an unbiased opinion.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Any further questions? Representative Coleman, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Representative Womack. On page 4 down in line 34, you say the state has the burden of proving by the evidence that the occupational regulation is at issue and is substantially related to the state's interest in protecting against present and recognizable harm to the public health and safety. isn't establishing those parameters what we come down here as legislatures to do and if we're wrong on that shouldn't the person that's wanting to do that occupation be the one to approach it from that standpoint. Representative Coleman, could you get closer
▶ Play
to the mic if you have anything else? We can't hear you. Good. Thank you. I would answer that's
▶ Play
Speaker 24 9:00
exactly what this bill does is give that person that avenue to challenge that. Follow.
▶ Play
Speaker 55 9:12
Follow. You recognize. Is the mic, can you hear me
▶ Play
now? You're perfect. All right, thank you. Well, the bill says that the state has the burden of proving this
▶ Play
Speaker 24 9:35
rather than the individual. Proving. that this occupational issue, that's correct. Public health and safety should be the bar for any regulation. So if that is challenged, then that's the level it needs to rise to in order to be regulated as a matter
▶ Play
of public health and safety. Do you have another question? I'll come right back to you. representative hammer you recognize
▶ Play
for a question like Michelle maybe maybe I didn't hear if this was asked right I didn't hear to understand so what is it that is currently obstructing those that are in a licensed area from being able to get what this bill is supposed to offer that's not
▶ Play
Speaker 24 10:24
already there there was The precedent set in a 1954, I believe, Supreme Court case that basically said if the court can imagine a reason that the regulation is reasonable, then that's the way the court finds. And this establishes in law that the individual has the right to work in a lawful occupation. Follow up, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
You recognize. Is that? right to work this is established in law that right to work still require a license issued by the appropriate board over that particular discipline it doesn't remove that barrier doesn't remove that accountability factor so if I'm understanding your question
▶ Play
Speaker 24 11:12
you're asking if this bill were to pass in its current form and be signed into law do the rules regulations law statutes that are currently in place in licensed occupations they still stand is that your question mr
▶ Play
chair can i finish this up yes sir thank you yes and what i'm trying to get to is if if they are if they're going to be required to have a license continue to be required to have a license as issued by let's say i'm going to pick the electrical board then this bill going into law is going to create what avenues that are currently not afforded them now if they're still going to have to have a license by
▶ Play
Speaker 24 12:00
the electrical board they have they have established in law right to work free from unreasonable regulation so now they have an avenue to challenge the reasonableness of that regulation outside the electrical board that decided it was a good
▶ Play
idea. To the bottom of the list, Mr. Chair. Absolutely. Representative Miller, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Womack, just to simplify for simple people like myself, does this mean that I, an uneducated redneck, can go out here and hang up a shingle as an electrician and start doing commercial electrical work without ever getting a license? No, sir. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Coleman, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Okay. My question goes back to aren't we as legislators, It's our job to come down here and to set the evidence as to whether or not these positions need a license and the oversight and the codes and the rules that they have to work under to do that. We do
▶ Play
Speaker 24 13:18
that on all new regulation moving forward, but everything that's in place now, we did not have that purview. You're recognized for follow-up.
▶ Play
Yeah, the past legislatures passed those rules and stuff, and most of those rules were put into place because someone that was doing a job didn't do it right or they misrepresented, and they didn't do a good job of doing it. And I know in my business, all of the regulations that we asked for was because you had someone that was unscrupulous out there was performing some of these things, which were a health hazard or a safety hazard or an economic problem, and so you go for the protection just to outlaw doing these things that create problems, and the legislature passes these laws and makes the rules. I'm not, is there a question? Well, didn't the legislature in the past approve these rules? or the boards that regulate them no sir we did not have to approve those rules in the past or the boards
▶ Play
Speaker 24 14:33
that regulated the boards did representative Coleman I
▶ Play
can address some of that for you I think four years ago we passed issue one which gave us the right to approve actual rules and regs from all the boards and commissions of state but within that we represented brands come make us speak to this better than I can being chair of council he passed acting a legislation last session that set forth the rules for which we can deny or disapprove a rule reg from a board or commission and the only reasons we can do that is if that rule reg doesn't follow the actual law that was passed that gave them the right to write that rule reg or if it's totally misaligned with the guidance of that board or commission. Representative Branscombe, did I do that right? Yeah, that's exactly right. So in the past, what Representative Womack is telling you is we only had review authority not approved, but now we do have approved authority as long as it's within the law set forth from the legislature. All right, Representative Hammer, are you recognized for a question?
▶ Play
I'm an electrician. I'm out working on a job, and I think I've got a better way to do it than what the current license and code allows me to do. So I go ahead and I do that the way that I think as an electrician on the job for 20 years thinks that it's best to do, even though it's going to go against the code. So is this bill, and so I go to the electrical board and I say, hey, I think there's a better way to do this an electric board says no we're going to do it this way because this way we want to do it does this bill allow me as an electrician in that scenario to have an appeals process that would take me around the board in order to get what I think is a better way heard I'm not sure how
▶ Play
Speaker 24 16:40
to answer that because I don't know exactly what you're getting at. Are you asking, does this bill allow you to do something that's not up to code? Fire up, Mr. Chair. I'm sorry. You're recognized to clarify your
▶ Play
question. Thank you. Because something that you said a while ago gave me that impression, and that's what I'm trying to clear up is that this bill wouldn't allow an electrician or plumber to go out there and do something on their own that is outside of what's allowed in
▶ Play
Speaker 24 17:17
the code book correct this bill will not do that this this bill keeps everything that's in place in place upon passage of this bill so if it's illegal for him to do that today it will be after passage of
▶ Play
this bill that's going to change anything from the way it currently is and I'm trying to get clear in my head this this is this bill by
▶ Play
Speaker 24 17:50
establishing a person's right to work free from unreasonable regulation law this provides an avenue for people to challenge the reasonableness of a rule and regulation outside the board that made the rule. So what I envision is, and part of the reason this bill is written so broadly to apply everywhere is nobody knows all the ins and outs and tiny little rules and crazy things that happen in every industry. Now, you probably know one or two that are in your industry that are crazy, you know, by your judgment would be unreasonable. But this bill, the intent is to provide somebody an avenue to challenge the reasonableness of that. But I think it's important to keep in mind that somebody has to be so upset about the situation that they're working under that they're willing to, at their own time and expense, take this suit and then prove to a panel of their peers that it truly is unreasonable. So should they win that suit, all they get to do is work free from that regulation. So there's no other avenue for damages. This is a, I see this as an avenue to start slowly and methodically peeling back unreasonable regulation without upsetting business. Representative Boyd, can you come here for a second?
▶ Play
Representative Payton, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
Speaker 24 19:14
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, Representative Wilmack, if somebody was to, upon passage of this bill, engage in an occupation that we currently require to be licensed, that board or commission would be able to shut them down, get a court order that they stop, and they would have to win a lawsuit proving that the regulation was unreasonable before they could practice. Yes, sir. That's correct. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Branscombe, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Womack, kind of going back on Representative Hammer, just to pretend it's just me and you talking, nobody in this room. Okay. And you're trying to say, all right, Branscombe, here is why I'm doing this bill, because, and the because is, give me an example that you've witnessed or been told about back home of what you're trying, why you're trying to do this bill because of why give me an example i'll give you an example of something a guy told me just in the hall the other day here at the capitol uh he he had hired somebody to put in some tile in his bathroom like a little bitty five by five bathroom or something the uh the floor installer came in and put the uh put the ceramic tile down and then this guy had to hire a licensed plumber to come in and reset his toilet because of a regulation now I would think that somewhere out there there's a floor installer that that has to remove toilets all day long every day he could in my view just you know set the toilet he's not posed a major public health and safety safety standard in in my view but this allows him an avenue to challenge that regulation because there's no reason for the family to in my view for the family to be out while they're waiting on a plumber and then pay who knows how much to come and set a toilet that most anybody can do but the rules and regulations that are in place so that's just one little example that came up just a day or two ago but but my point is there's things in every industry that that are probably a little egregious and therefore for reasons other than public health and safety and and this provides an avenue for people to start picking those rules and regulations off one by one slowly and methodically and I think you'll start with the most egregious and and never never upset business there won't be this this does not drastic the passage of this bill will not drastically alter the way anybody does anything but it hopefully provides an avenue to start
▶ Play
peeling back on egregious regulation follow-up yeah before you do that I want to let the committee know a few things there's 11 people signed to speak on this bill now it's 1030 you guys know we have two hours I don't have lunch planned I could probably get that worked out so we got a whole line of members that's got questions here and you got all these people that drove in here from all over state and I feel like they ought to have their time to speak so just be conscious of that as we go forward representative love I got you
▶ Play
Speaker 24 22:36
for a question I guess I have a few questions but my first one is what are the insurance companies saying about this bill I have not heard from an insurance company okay the reason why I asked you that question is because usually if you are just a contractor you have to carry certain insurance for you know the work that you do so in case you know you're liable for any accident so I'm just kind of worried about about that piece in your bill I guess mr. chair if there's anybody from the insurance industry in the in the next you know next round we can ask them about that question thank you mr. woman thank you mr. chair I'm sure the insurance
▶ Play
companies are happy to offer a policy for anything they can But, I
▶ Play
Speaker 24 23:18
mean, that's the way it works today, and I'm sure that would continue to work that way in the future. Okay. All
▶ Play
right, Representative Ladyman, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Well, I just, I'm a little bit confused, and I just want clarification. Hopefully I can make this a good, clear question for you. I'll try my best to. But since I am an engineer and my profession is mentioned in your bill here, I wanted to ask this question. And this may not pertain to a PE certification. It's more, I think, to plumbers and those kind of people is what you're targeting here. But my question is, so we pass a bill here. Then the governor signs that. That becomes an act. And then that goes out to the agencies, and it's written in a regulation, and it's promulgated. So it's put out there as a regulation that people have to follow. And those regulations specify license requirements and all that. So if I have my PE and there's some regulation that is written based on a bill, it doesn't really match that bill, and I want to push back on that, I think that's unreasonable in my profession as an engineer, I can push back on that. Now, I think this bill would give me that opportunity to question that regulation that was promulgated from a bill and an act, but it doesn't match that. So my question is, does this give me the right as a professional engineer to question that regulation just like Representative Branscombe's bill gave us, the legislative, the opportunity to push back? Is that a
▶ Play
Speaker 24 25:00
true statement? In your instance, whatever the process is today will be the process because engineers are listed in that list of commonly recognized fiduciaries. So whatever is in place today will be in place after this bill. please sir
▶ Play
you're recognized thank you okay let me change to a plumber or someone else that but but my point is this gives the professional the opportunity to push back on a regulation that is probably promulgated that is unreasonable yes sir that's
▶ Play
absolutely thank you representative Peyton you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question thank you mr. chair I've
▶ Play
Speaker 24 25:37
got a lot of questions but real short uh so the example you gave of the tile installer and setting the toilet upon passage and and signing this bill into law are they going to be allowed to do that or are they just going to have to use their own money file suit and prove that it's an unreasonable regular regulation before they can do that yes sir not only unreasonable but but also not meeting the the bar of public health and safety standards so the passage of your bill doesn't change the fact until somebody goes to court and proves it's unreasonable that's exactly right thank you thank you mr.
▶ Play
chair seeing no further questions we'll move to the audience we have Tom Hunt to speak against the bill one thing I'd like to remind the audience when you're speaking please try not to repeat anything the speaker in front of you has spoken we we do have a lot of people signed up on this one let's keep our points direct and try not
▶ Play
Speaker 24 26:45
to repeat anything thank you mr. chair what I'd like to do is abbreviate my comments because there are so many people and in lieu of that I'd like to give a copy of the text of my comments to the members of the committee was that possible I'll review it thank you very much my name is Tom Hunt I'm with the Arkansas HVAC our Association and I appreciate the fact that there are folks in our state who want to do away with egregious and unnecessary yes ma'am I'm sorry regulation because nobody wants something like that to happen the example that was just given I'm not a plumber so I don't really understand why they wouldn't be able to do that? I'm in the heating and air conditioning industry and I know there is little or nothing that's in our law that prevents somebody from being able to do work that they should be able to do if they do not have training and experience. One of the things that I believe that this bill does is creates two classes of people in the heating and air conditioning business. As Mr. Wommack said, the law of licensing continues. But if you read on page four, I believe it's on line 10 and runs through about line 20, it says that this law says that if you are not licensed or you are not certified, you are not registered, you may not say that you are. But it also says that you may do that work. So we will have people who, because they're good professionals, want to be licensed, and then you'll have people who will say, I can fix a furnace, never done it before, but I'm not a heating and air conditioning person, so it's legal. I can design an air conditioning unit, I've never done it before, but since I'm not saying I'm an air conditioning installer or professional, I can do that too. The reason that's serious is because equipment has become very complex. Houses, as you have probably heard many times are becoming very, very tight. Therefore, the fact that we do not have the unintended infiltration like we used to have, installations of furnaces that we used to get by with before that were creating carbon monoxide that were automatically vented without anybody even knowing it, are not automatically vented today. The same thing is true on the air conditioning side. If you don't design an air conditioning system correctly, It will cycle too much, it will not take the humidity out of the air. The humidity in the house will seem clammy even though the temperature on the thermostat reads set point. Now all of a sudden you've got an excess of 60% humidity and you've got the conditions for mold and mildew in the house. These are not things that are intuitive. These are not things that a painter or a sheetrock person can say to their homeowner that they're working with, oh, I've never done it before, but I can do it, we should not allow folks who do not have minimal training and minimal experience. Our law is very simple and very easy to get into. If you want to be a heat and air conditioning person, the only thing you've got to do is get a job, which is very easy to do. In fact, it's estimated that there are 155,000 job shortages that will occur in the next 10 years. In Arkansas, you can't find help. So there's not a lack of jobs. But if you go get a job and you're there for two years, which is a minimal amount of time, and you can pass an open book test, you suddenly are a heating and air conditioning person. But at least you've had two years of being mentored and trained, and therefore it's much less likely that you will install a furnace that would create carbon monoxide poisoning or an air conditioning unit that would create conditions conducive to mold and mildew. We ask you to understand that our industry is just as involved in health and safety as those careers and occupations that were excluded. And I certainly understand why they were excluded. We have a fiduciary role with our consumers. Almost always we take a down payment. The smaller the company, the larger the down payment, sometimes as large as 50%. That's a big fiduciary responsibility. The concept of trust needs to be there. So the things that got these other folks excluded, we do all the time and should be listed. But even if Representative Walnark were kind enough to include the heat and air conditioning industry like he did the optometrist today, it wouldn't solve the problem. The problem would still exist in all the construction trades. I ask you, please, to reconsider your position on this bill until you have a chance to maybe find specific occupations that need to be reined in. Our law was established in 1991 after two legislative sessions of us working really, really hard because we believed we need to protect the health and safety of our customers and our friends and our neighbors. and I'm asking you to continue to allow us through our licensing law to do good work and to protect the health and safety of consumers. And I thank you for your time, and I appreciate the fact that you're working at trying to do away with egregious regulation. But our law is not one of those laws that needs to be pulled in. Thank you for your time. Would you
▶ Play
take questions, sir? Yes, sir. Representative Miller, you're recognized for a question. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Sir, I don't disagree with anything you just said, except for I'm not understanding how, and maybe you can clear this up for me, how the folks in the industry feel as though if this is passed, that all of a sudden I, Josh Miller, from Heber Springs, who has zero experience the heat and air industry, but decide tomorrow that I want to do that work, are you going to hire me to come to your house and fix your air conditioner? Well, sir, I believe
▶ Play
Speaker 24 33:21
that what frequently happens is that people will have a handy person, handyman, doing work at their house, and they'll say something like, doggone, my furnace is is on the blink and i need somebody to fix it and could you do that and the way this law says the way i read it it would say as long as you don't say you're heating and air conditioning a furnace person or a professional in that career field you could say well i could do that and if you can do that that's that class of people people are always looking for a way to do things for less and that person would be able to work for less but what will happen is that because they don't know what they're doing they'll have to come back multiple times and what I've seen watching the licensing board for these 20 years that I've been watching it is that attention to people sir they really do right they want to make a living for their family and they then they they they give their word on something that they really can't do but they figure it'll work out somehow and so they come back the second time the third time and then all of a sudden they got to pay the rent, so they go on and they do the same thing at somebody else's house. And then, all of a sudden, they have a problem there. The next thing you know is that the first house, the people they are, this would-be contractor forgets about them because he can't afford to come back. We've got to have people who can fix it right the first time, and if not the first time, at least the second time. That requires training.
▶ Play
Follow-up. You recognize. sir I understand that exactly and I don't I wouldn't want to hire myself for sure but is is what you just described not already going on and do we as people not have the right to hire who we want to fix stuff at our own house sir I believe that that is already going
▶ Play
Speaker 24 35:10
on we see it all the time I'm not saying that but but I think that this bill will encourage it to happen even more. It will legalize it. You will not have people who are trying to duck the inspector because they can say to the inspector, I didn't tell him I was a heat and air guy. I just told him I thought I could fix it. It will make the situation absolutely worse. And that's what scares us is that untrained, unexperienced people will be out there doing work. That can create a health and safety issue. That's what we want to protect against. You want to be in the heat and air business? It's so easy. Two years of experience. Pass an open book test. Yesterday you couldn't spell HVAC or today you are one. But you've got two years of experience under your belt. And somebody told you, oh, make sure this is vented like this because it's not intuitive. I was at one of our chapter meetings in Harrison recently and I said, we've still got But people who are members of our association as well as other licensed contractors who are trying to put an 80% furnace in an encapsulated attic, everybody there smiled. And I said, why did you smile? And they said, I don't know. I said, but it's because you know, you've had the training, you know not to do that. You know the dangers, but the people who just say, yesterday I was a sheet rock man, today I'm a heat and air man, do not know that. they are going to
▶ Play
create a problem thank you sir representative ladyman you recognize for a
▶ Play
question thank you mr. chair mr. hand I agree with what you're saying I've been involved in heating there and I understand exactly what you're saying about the integrity of a system and how it's designed and if you open up a duck work you might let something in there I agree with that I'm not sure that's what this bill is really trying to address let me give you ask you a question yes sir you know your HVAC guy and you know what's required if we passed a regulation in the legislature and it went out and got promulgated to say that every single piece of that system yes sir has to be painted red and and that got through the House and the Senate and got passed and they promulgated that so every time you worked on a unit you had to paint the system red would you not want an opportunity to push back on that
▶ Play
Speaker 24 37:39
yes sir and if I were in your district or I were in mr. Womack's district I would go to him and I would say this is ridiculous this needs to be taken up in your committee the next time the legislature meets and then I would do everything I could to get all the heat and air folks together to tell you that red might be fashionable but it's not necessary and then you sir as I elected representative would be able to make that call now though based on the the regulation that you were talking about earlier that kind of a crazy regulation has to go before your committee and I apologize for not knowing the name of it and y'all have a chance to say up or down on it and I think that's a very good thing as opposed to just looking at it now you can say no and I think you already have in place the mechanism to stop that kind of a ridiculous rule from taking place Representative Payton,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 38:37
Mr. Hunt, you've done a fabulous job explaining why licensing, training, regulation is very important. And I don't think you'd have any trouble getting a reasonable person to agree with you in those aspects of what you explained. However, the portion of the bill that you referred to on page 4, line 9 and 10, I think it was, does not do what you claim it does. Okay, sir. It says, however, the right to engage in a lawful occupation under this section. Okay, under this section means that after you've went to the court of law and you've gotten reasonable people to agree with you that this is an egregious regulation over burdensome regulation once you've won your case in the court of law and you operate without the license that you cannot you still have to identify yourself as unlicensed you can't go around and identify yourself as a licensed person once you've won the case it doesn't say you can go out and practice that occupation before you win the case and just like the arguments you made here you can convince reasonable people that these regulations are reasonable and just so is it your fear that the court of law would would make crazy decisions and allow people to operate and not not hear those reasonable arguments no sir one of the things in the bill and I'm sorry I I can't remember the section to refer to that concerns me, is it says that the judgment of that particular court is applicable only to that one person. It does not become a standard for the rest of the state. And another thing it talks about in there that the way I interpret it is that those standards may vary from person to person because for one person what may be a financial burden might not be for another. Time to get to someplace to take that test might be a burden for one person but not for another. And if, while we're being honest, sir, if I live in a particular county and I'm well-known and I tell them, well, I don't have enough money to go do that, and my brother-in-law happens to be the person that's helping to make that decision, he doesn't want me and his sister moving in. So he may tell me, I think you ought to be able to do that. In another portion of the state, if there's no relationship, that might not happen. And I know that's offensive for me to suggest that to some folks. But y'all know and I know that in the real world, relationships and who you know matters. I don't see this bill as being able to give equal protection and equal opportunity. And the way I read the portion that you're talking about there, The only thing I've got to do is say, I'm not licensed, and therefore I'm legal. That's only after you've won the court case. Is that your follow-up, Representative Payton? Yes, thank you. Appreciate it. You're welcome. And, sir, I defer to you because you do this stuff a lot more than I do. I just don't understand it that way. Representative Love,
▶ Play
do you recognize for a question? Well, actually, I have a motion. I'll hear
▶ Play
that motion. Motion to limit debate to 10 minutes per side.
▶ Play
That's a proper motion, non-debated. Will all those in favor say aye? Aye. All those opposed? No. Ayes have it. Motion passes. Mr. Price will be keeping the clock. Is there any time you'd like to reserve, Representative Womack? I'd like to reserve three minutes for close, please. Three
▶ Play
Speaker 24 42:30
minutes. Mr. Chair, thank you all very much for listening to me. I'm sorry we stuttered and stammered so much. Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 131 42:43
Ben Fury I'm just an old dirt farmer I'm just
▶ Play
Speaker 132 42:48
a dumb redneck so be ready We're a lot alike
▶ Play
If you would introduce yourself for the committee and you're recognized to talk against the bill be sure and be mindful of the
▶ Play
Speaker 134 42:59
last conversation so you don't repeat anything Absolutely, this will be short and sweet One dumb redneck to another Ben Fury, owner, founder of Fury Electric employee mid-50, electricians in the state. A member of ABC, speaking on behalf of 250-plus members, strongly against this bill. We were taught growing up, electricity will kill you. So how now that it's not, and anyone can do it without a license, is beyond us. And as far as regulation goes, we're unaware of regulation keeping someone doing electrical work or why it's unsafe what you need to do that would keep you from doing that unsafely electricity is not a hobby I don't know anywhere you can buy books it tells you that it is excuse my bullet points two years the same with electrician residential electrician if you need to be electrician same way as like HVAC two years you can get a residential license another two you can be a master I see it I'm up for questions representative hammer
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question thank you mr. chair one thing
▶ Play
I'd like to be addressed by somebody sits at the table where the sponsor is I'd like to know if this bill goes through where does the liability rest that if I after this bill was to go through and I utilize some of these services under what this law is going to allow is that person to be required to carry liability insurance in case something happens to my house when they perform work. I'd like that question answered Mr. Chair from
▶ Play
somebody. Representative Hammer if you want I'll give you time at the closing to ask that question to a sponsor or otherwise address the witness at
▶ Play
the table please. Thank you Mr. Chair. One thing I'd like to ask you specifically I'm glad you came up as a member representing the electrical is we've ran several bills this session already that have relaxed the ability for electricians to work in fact there was one bill that we ran where we gave them an extension of 90 days or 120 days in order to be able to get their licenses because they had let it lapsed and what I'm trying to rationalize in my mind is why is it that we're making exceptions over here on this side and being asked to make exceptions over here on this side but now we're being asked to not let this go through so I was I'm wondering if you could speak to that to help me understand.
▶ Play
Speaker 134 45:26
As far as an extension to a license, I'm unaware of any opposing within a minimal distance. I mean, obviously nothing within three years, I believe, was a number that was heard. 60 to 90 days. I'm unaware of any opposing of that from any electrician. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Seeing no further
▶ Play
questions for this witness, thank you for testifying today. Thank you, guys. Is there anyone in the audience speak for the bill? Seeing none, we'll move on to Mr. Joe Carter.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 46:03
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Joe Carter. I'm with Snyder Environmental, also a board member of the Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce. We oppose this bill. We oppose this bill for a couple of reasons. First, the briefing that we've heard from our attorneys with respect to what this bill does versus what we heard today seem to be different universes, and at a minimum there appears to be some confusion about what the bill actually does. But my general position is that we should not do anything that's going to undermine the licensure laws with respect to public health and safety. And if we're going to require 16-year-old kids to have a driver's license, then we should, and we're going to enforce those laws, then we should at least have the same standard for the person who's running gas into a house or running electricity. And my fear is, different than what I'm hearing, and perhaps the committee could clarify this for me, but my fear is that this piece of legislation gives somebody the right to engage in that occupation before a court intervenes, and that it sets forth a new standard that the state must prove, and when the state does prove that standard, that particular instance is unique and specific to that one individual. And so the regulatory bodies with oversight over all of these professions could be overcome with a number of issues and challenges and enforcement actions because they're having to repeat enforcement each time with respect to whether or not that toilet has to be placed by a licensed plumber after the ceramic tile's been replaced. And so that is a concern that we have. We do appreciate your service and your hard work for our state, and I'll stand down for questions. Representative Hammer, are you recognized for a question? Thank you. With regards to the illustration of the toilet
▶ Play
getting set, I know a lot of people that are competent to set that toilet. Let me ask you how you would feel about something. If somebody wanted to come before us as the public health committee and say, you know, the requirement says you've got to bring in a plumber in order to be able to do that, but I don't think that's right, and they wanted to come before us as a committee, and we as legislators said, we're going to give that person the ability to be able to set that toilet and just go around the board that is making
▶ Play
Speaker 24 48:35
the rules and regs. What would you think about that, or what would be your response to that? I think my response is that happens pretty regularly. I believe my impression is that this body establishes the rules and promulgates those rules out to agencies, and agencies enforce them, and when we recognize that there's a mistake in those rules, we come back here and correct and refine those processes. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Really short
▶ Play
one. Then from this point on, if this bill doesn't go through and that becomes the avenue that people want to start exercising, we could expect full commitment and non-resistance from boards when we start bringing these things individually one by one up before us? You have my commitment to that effect, and as a matter of fact, I
▶ Play
Speaker 24 49:23
think if the Department of Environmental Quality is in the room, they could attest that our industry is already doing that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. They're in the
▶ Play
room, too, Representative Hammer, if you need them. See, no further questions, and he's gone. I'm sorry. We'll move on to Jimmy Coker. Mr. Chair, I'm still. No, that's good. Perfect. I like it. Mr. Coker in the room. There he is. trying to get here if you would introduce yourself in a record and you've got four minutes roughly
▶ Play
Speaker 24 49:58
all right my name is Jimmy Coker I'm electrical contractor from Pine Bluff I employ about 40 electricians I've been in business for 37 years and I've been an electrician for 47 years this This bill, let me check my notes here, my question about this is to whose benefit is this law written? It doesn't increase work, it doesn't provide more work, there's a need for electricians now so there's plenty of work and it's being done by licensed electricians. Our electricians are all licensed because of state law, which came into effect in 1979. Prior to that, there were city licenses that had to be obtained. This is not going to benefit the public. It's to the detriment of the public because now there's, I mean, when you wire something wrong, there's always that possibility that there's going to be a fire. And the problem is that people sleep at night in these homes, and if there's an electrical fire, which happens a lot, fires are caused by electrical problems a lot, then that's why these need to be done by qualified licensed electricians. The license ensures that they do know what they're doing. Our electricians serve five years of apprenticeship. They have 8,000 hours of school, and then they have to take a state license test, and then they're German electricians. And so I question this. What are the unintended consequences of this law? That's my statement. Seeing no questions from the committee, thank you for your testimony.
▶ Play
Is anyone in the audience now to speak for the bill? Next up is Mr. John Burton. You have roughly a minute and a half, Mr. Burton. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 24 52:27
Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. My name is John Burton. I'm here to represent the Arkansas Society of Professional Surveyors. I believe our president-elect sent a statement out as to our opposition to this bill and the reasons, therefore, to all the members of the committee. I appreciate it if you all have read that and if you will and consider it. Anyway, we're a board of over 150. We as professional surveyors are registered under the board of professional surveyors and engineers, and we have a minimum standard that we have to attain, which was established by legislation and is enforced under the directive of that board. So we, at this point in time, we think that the uninitiated people out there, and I've seen many instances where they really don't understand what they're getting when they get a survey, and I've actually had people come into my office with a survey that says more or less a half acre, and when you run it, it's less than a quarter of an acre. So there's a reason for us out there, and it was established in the Constitution, health, safety, and welfare, and that's what we intend to
▶ Play
Speaker 152 53:36
provide. Any questions? Thank you very much. Thank
▶ Play
you. Did I make my timeline? Yeah, you've got a few seconds left. I've got
▶ Play
Speaker 24 53:46
a Dr. White. That's me, Dr. Glenn White, representing the Arkansas Psychological Association. Don't have much time, so we're concerned about the bill. A lot of the language in there is kind of confusing to us non-loggers, but we've had lawyers look at it, and they are also a little bit confused about it. You had the fact that even though the language says licensure laws stay and you can't, you know, practice in someone else's profession unlicensed, as someone else said, it looks like people can go out there and do that same work without being under the purview of a board who knows what's involved in that discipline. And we are especially made nervous by the fact that in the one section, It seems to accept several people, several professions. We'd like ours added to that. Representative Womack,
▶ Play
you recognize close for your bill, and Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question at the beginning of that close. Mr. Chair. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Womack, what I'd like you to address is if I'm a guy out working on a job, I've got some electrical skills, but I'm there for another purpose, I do work on that house because I tell the owner I'm not licensed, but I can do it, and then something happens to that house. Am I liable for what happened because that house burned down even though I'm not licensed? Would you clear that up or address it, please? Thank you. Yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 24 55:19
sir. I am not an insurance agent or an attorney, but my understanding is you would be liable, just like you are today. So if you did not have an insurance policy to cover that. So the answer to your question is this bill does not address liability issues because it does not change the current standard. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Womack, you recognize closed for your bill. Okay, thank you. I see no further questions
▶ Play
Speaker 24 55:51
from the committee. This bill no doubt embraces free market and small government principles. The reason I started this presentation out so boring and reading the text of the bill was so that you guys could see exactly what the bill does, not what so many people have said at the end of the table and described. I did want to address one thing. He said to whose benefit is this? This is to the general public's benefit. When you allow people to embrace their liberty and do the most they can do with their day and be productive at every opportunity that does not harm the public health and safety, it's a no-brainer. Another big aspect that I've not really talked about, but I think because of that question is worth looking at, there was a study done by the Center for the Study of Economic Liberty at Arizona State University, And it dealt with specifically the differences in states that were overly burdensome as compared to states that had the least amount of regulation when it came to recidivism rates with new crime. So that dropped from the most burdensome states, the new crime recidivism in the first three years, by 13.6% on average. So that's who it benefits. It benefits those guys that did not have the starting life that I did. And there's hurdles out there. There's things in place that prevent people from having an opportunity, like maybe being a felon or whatever. So this has potential to benefit those guys, the ones that start out worse than us. And, like I said, it's just a good free market bill. So I would appreciate a good vote, and I'd ask that you, when you consider this, consider the text of the bill and not the testimony that we've heard that that does not line up with the text of the bill and with that
▶ Play
Speaker 52 57:43
I would appreciate a good vote and I have a
▶ Play
Speaker 24 57:52
motion at the proper time mr. chair okay thank you mr. chair representative Womack you know I love you to death and of all this testimony I have become probably a little more confused I still think I know how I'm to vote but if chair would take this I'd like to table this motion to so I can have get more feedback from my district because I really haven't gotten a lot and I really haven't talking to you on
▶ Play
it so with that I move to table it's a proper motion it's non-debatable it takes a majority of the quorum so with that all those in favor say aye all those opposed no I rule the nose have it motion is failed with that I'll take representative Womack's motion do pass do pass as amended do pass as amended thank you you you're running me we have any discussion on that motion representative Meeks you're
▶ Play
Speaker 24 58:45
recognized for discussion thank you mr. chair representative Womack I do appreciate you being bringing this bill forward as been mentioned you know what if I wanted to set my own toilet which I've actually done in the past I know it's probably not the smartest thing to do but it's still working correctly but then also too when I needed to redo my air conditioning I did get the right person that was certified they've done a great job at it I mean and that's really what this bill to me is all about it is about freedom it is it is about giving people the opportunity that if they have or see an unwanted regulation or an overburdensome regulation it just gives them an avenue it gives them an avenue to challenge it and I think that it's that's you know that's about as American as you can get to push back against a government regulation that you think is unreasonable it you know has been mentioned before you know if somebody's going to do something they're going to do it anyways regardless of this bill and some members, I would ask that you would vote on this bill and I appreciate a good vote on
▶ Play
it. Thank you. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 160 59:58
for discussion. I think I understand, because I've done a lot of construction, that if you're doing it for yourself, you don't have to have a certification or license. It's when you're doing it for sale or for other people. If there's someone in the audience to contradict that, let me know. But that's what I've been doing anyway, so I hope it's legal.
▶ Play
For the audience, it's probably a good thing the audience can't speak under discussion. Representative Bentley, you're recognized for discussion. Representative Walmer, thank you for
▶ Play
your courage for bringing this forward. And colleagues, I would encourage you to take a minute once again to read the bill and not listen to the folks that have misrepresented this bill that have been here today because this bill does not take away anybody's license, does not change any licensing boards or regulations. And I have spent last night with a number of my constituents on the phone, and when we sat there and went over the bill and explained the bill to them, they were actually in favor of the bill because they're free market folks that really think that we do have some unnecessary regulations that were passed before we had the preview that we have now. There's some regulations four years old that we didn't have a chance to look at. This gives an opportunity for folks to stand up, file a lawsuit, for heaven's sakes, and fight an unnecessary regulation. I can't believe that we would stop this bill, and I thank
▶ Play
you guys for a good vote. Thank you, Representative Bentley, Representative McCullough, you're recognized for discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I mean, Representative
▶ Play
Bentley just took the words right out of my mouth. What I wanted to state is I appreciate the Arkansans and the folks coming here and giving their opinions known, but I couldn't help but think the whole time that most of what I heard completely contradicted what the sponsor said that this bill is intended to do. I read it. I spoke with individuals as well, and we're just giving individuals the avenue to challenge this at the expense of themselves, their own time, only to say if it goes through that process, that they could indeed do the work that they see fit. So thank you so much, and I'd appreciate you guys giving this one a yay vote.
▶ Play
Representative Miller, you recognize for this. We're starting to get into that double speaking, I think. representative Peyton thank
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:02:13
you mr. chair members you know I guess I I believe that that checks and balances are what our governmental system is all about and I believe that this installs a check and a balance on boards or commissions that may go a little too far with regulation I do not see it as an unlicensing bill as it was presented by the opposition today but I've got to I've got to tell you in my short life, very short lifetime, I've found at least a half a dozen different occupations to engage in. And we've heard testimony about how sometimes, you know, there's bad actors that are not capable of doing the jobs that they take on. I've got to tell you, I've seen boards and commissions and licensing and regulation used to squash competition and giving our citizens the opportunity to challenge that in the court of law, I think is a very important move, and
▶ Play
I'd ask you to vote yes on this. Thank you, Representative Payton. Representative Ladyman, do you have anything
▶ Play
to add that's not double-speaking maybe? Well, I don't think it's double-speak. I'll try to make it short, but it's going to be difficult for me. But I do appreciate the electricians, the HVAC, and I've worked with people over the years in those professions, and they are professionals, and I understand their reaction to this bill and protecting their license. But I think the misunderstanding, you know, I think what this does is stops regulations squishing competition, as you said, Representative. Thank you. Thank you. Seeing no further discussion, all those in favor
▶ Play
say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Ayes have it. Your bill is passed. Roll call. I got two hands for a roll call, so we'll call the roll. Mr. Price, if you would, start calling the roll.
▶ Play
Speaker 172 1:04:10
Representative Love. No. Representative Hammer. No. Representative Branscombe. No. Representative Meeks. Yes. Representative Ritchie. Representative Ritchie. Representative McGee, Representative Miller, Representative Womack, Representative Payton, Representative Leidyman, Representative Lundstrom, Representative Bentley, Representative Gonzales, Representative Boyd, Representative Boyd, Representative Henderson, Representative Henderson, Representative McCollum, Representative Coleman. Representative Pilkington. Yes. Vice Chair Ferguson. Yes. Chair Ward-Long. Yes.
▶ Play
Representative Womack, with a vote of 10 yeses and 6 noes, your bill has failed. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. all right house bill 1250 uh michelle gray i mean representative gray
▶ Play
Speaker 182 1:05:57
mccullough and then sanders yeah you run that one today
▶ Play
If we want to keep the volume level low in respect to the next members. Representative Gray, you're recognized to run your bill, 1250.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. I come before you today with House Bill 1250. This bill we ran during the interim as an ISP, and it changes the Dental Practices Act, so it was a scope bill. And I appreciate the chair and the committee letting us bring this bill today instead of last week during the normal scope bills. We were still working on an amendment, and we do have that amendment engrossed, so when you pull the bill up, you will see the bill with the amendment engrossed. So what we've done, we have, I decided that I would run the ISP and the dental bill, and I ran it for DSOs or dental support organizations as they were trying to clarify the law and then also make some other changes to the Dental Practices Act. With that said, when I agreed to run the bill, I was very forthcoming and I didn't agree with all parts of the bill. There was definitely some work that needed to be done on this bill before it was in a form that I felt was right that I could run. So with the DSOs and the Dental Association, they put a lot of work, a lot of hours into trying to get this right, make some changes to the Dental Practices Act that were needed. And so at this point in time, this amendment has been agreed to. Mr. Chair, could I please ask that the door be closed? Yes, please. Thank you. We've got to get that door closed. So both the DSOs who brought the bill, we've worked with the Dental Association and come to an agreed-upon amendment, which is the amendment that's currently engrossed. So I'll go over. essentially kind of gutted the original bill and reworded it with the amendment. It has three main sections to it. So the first section, we're clarifying present law, permitting dentists to choose to hire DSOs. One thing that we made sure that this bill does, and we don't necessarily have this in the field of medicine, which I wish we did, but the one thing this does is it makes sure that DSOs are in no way so the people that they can come in they can own the buildings they can own the equipment so they can kind of manage the practice only administratively they are not allowed to manage the practice with the the patients they're not allowed to have any input into patient treatment and that was a big deal in this bill in allowing them to only serve administratively now they currently already do that in the state of Arkansas but it wasn't clarified in statute or in board policy. So the DSOs, based on the business model that they've already been using, just wanted it clarified in statute. So we worked with the Dental Association to get language that both were agreeable to. Section three, what we do with that, it allows out-of-state licensed dentists in good standing to apply for dentist positions and provide charitable care here in Arkansas for a limited four-day basis. When they do that, they still have to provide their license and all applicable information to the State Board of Dentistry just to make sure that, you know, for public safety reasons, but this does allow a four-day window for out-of-state dentists who are licensed to come into Arkansas and practice, do interviews for jobs, hopefully to increase the number of dentists that we have in Arkansas, as Arkansas is one of the lowest states in dentists per capita. So we're working to increase that, and that was agreeable with the Dental Association as well. And the third thing that we're doing is we're allowing specialist dentists to provide general dentistry services, and they can still essentially advertise and claim their specialty practice area as long as no more than 50% of their practice is done in general dentistry. And that was agreeable to both sides as well. So what we're doing, we're updating the Dental Practices Act with no known opposition at this time. And I'd be glad to take any questions. We worked a long time to get this to where it is, and I appreciate you giving us an extra week to get the amendment right. any questions
▶ Play
from the committee seeing none or anybody in the audience speak for or against the bill seeing none what's a pleasure to committee i got a motion do pass from representative coleman any discussion on that motion seeing none all those in favor say aye all those opposed ayes have it congratulations representative gray your bill has passed thank you mr chair committee thank you we got representative love to run house bill 1215 and then we're going to pull House Bill 1513 out of order after that. Can I do 1513 first? Yeah, you can. If you could, keep that door closed for us. Representative Love, you're recognized to run House Bill
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:12:09
1315 first. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm here to run House Bill 1513. it's for representative now basically this is just a clean up bill and I have ADQ here if
▶ Play
Speaker 196 1:12:20
the committee has any questions seeing
▶ Play
no questions or anyone to speak for or against this bill in the audience seeing none I have a do pass motion for representative Branscombe any discussion on that motion all those in favor say aye Hi, all those opposed Congratulations representative love you can tell representative Holcomb. You've got him. Thank you. Mr. Chair. Thank you You're now recognized to present House bill 1250 members. There is an amendment on this bill It's a paper amendment. We'll be passing it out if you would present
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:12:58
amendment first I will mr. Chairman. I'm gonna have Don Ike from the
▶ Play
massage therapy board come and sit with me before she speaks Just have a reckon introduce herself for the
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:13:09
committee. Okay Hi, I'm Don Ike. I am an 11-year massage therapist. I am a muster massage therapist, nationally certified, and also a neuromuscular massage therapist. You're recognized. All
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:13:23
right. The amendment for House Bill 1215 is just an agreed-upon language between the medical society and the acupuncturists. I'll take any questions. Thank you.
▶ Play
It's a pleasure. Committee on the amendment. Got a representative McCollum, is that a motion do pass on the amendment? Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:14:08
I was just looking at the amendment real quick, and it sure seems to have narrowed a class of people here. Can you explain it any further? Basically, Representative Payton, this is an amendment that actually the medical society and the acupuncturists want to put on the bill. I don't think it minimizes the scope or kind of weeds out anybody. but that was just agreed upon language if I could follow up mr. chair you recognize okay so not being able to engross it in my mind here with the rest of the bill I don't know exactly what sub chapter or whatever this may be affecting but when we narrow it from health care for professionals down to physicians and chiropractic licensed chiropractors I mean that leaves out all nurses and a lot of a lot of uh health care professionals i would think we narrowed it drastically well i'll tell you what since this is not my amendment i will have the medical society come and speak to it i mean okay but this is just something that they asked me to put in okay so if there's anybody from the medical society i'll be more than happy to allow them to elaborate on it other than that
▶ Play
i can just present my bill as is Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question while we're waiting on the Medical Society Well,
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:15:36
I guess if the Medical Society is here I read it a different way than Representative Payton did I'll let you address that Okay I don't The way that I read it that it's not preventing them from doing what it is as far as practicing acupuncture and related. Because the way that I read it is it says this chapter does not limit, interfere with, or prevent physicians licensed by the Arkansas State Medical Board from practicing acupuncture. So I think it's just kind of an open-ended deal from what it sounds like to me. So I'm reading it kind of maybe the exact opposite way.
▶ Play
I actually read it the same way you did, Representative Meeks. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:16:26
Payton, does that help you at any at all? Yes, I mean, I'm looking at it now, and we're talking about a class of people who are exempt, I guess, from needing to be licensed. Is that what it is? Yes. Okay. Previously, any health care professional was exempt. With this amendment, only physicians and chiropractors are exempt. Well, no, if you look at it within the code, that's not what we're trying to do, but Representative Payton, I'll tell you what, if we pass out this amendment, if there's any questions after that, what we'll do is we'll go back and we'll readjust it, and you have my word on that. Okay. Well, I just know that we've had a lot of turf war between physicians and nurses and other health care professionals in this committee lately and I would inadvertently do anything there trust me I was on the other end of the medical society on some bills and and so I wasn't trying I'm not trying to uh limit the scope of who can practice and so like I said once we pass out the bill if there's anything that we need to change I'm more than open to change it thank you thank you Mr. Chair representative Hammer has the medical society made it in the room yet Not yet. We're trying to get them here. We'll have
▶ Play
them here before we're done. What's the pleasure committee on the amendment?
▶ Play
Speaker 217 1:17:58
I don't know what all motions are appropriate this time, but I'd like to vote on the bill without
▶ Play
the amendment. Okay. I've got Scott Smith just come in the room. Representative Payton, you want to ask your question again to Scott Smith? If you would, Mr. Smith, introduce yourself for the committee, and you're recognized to answer your question, Representative Payton. what have I done to find
▶ Play
Speaker 79 1:18:27
out yes we support this amendment thank you mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:18:30
chair okay so my question is the amendment seems to be narrowing the class of health care professionals that are exempt on page 2 line 16 17 in that in that paragraph right before the amendment any licensed health care professional would have been exempt after the amendment only physicians and chiropractors are exempt right is that correct yes sir so how many so who all does that cut out as being exempt well I'm not really sure but we propose this language in response to some other language that we had seen earlier and and we just wanted to make sure that physicians who have this training didn't have to have an extra course. So what about advanced practice nurses? I don't even know if they're currently listed in the – I don't know. I don't know if they do these kind of procedures. Well, could somebody who knows speak to who exactly were limiting them?
▶ Play
Representative Love, did anybody from the APN – Association or the nursing board contact you for an amendment not not at all mr. chair and here's in committee I tell
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:19:47
you what if we have angst about the amendment we can scratch the amendment and just go to the bill I'm fine with that representative ladyman you have a question motion I make
▶ Play
a motion do not pass for the amendment all right all
▶ Play
those in favor do not pass for the emotion say aye all those opposed you recognize a bit present your bill as a
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:20:10
Okay, I'm going to present a bill of House Bill 1215. Colleagues, this is just a bill that will allow massage therapy to practice cupping, and it's a specific type of cupping. I'll take any questions. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
I just want to, to the chair, please, point of order, if I may. We just voted do not pass, which means that this amendment would not be able to be brought back up in this committee
▶ Play
once it receives a do not pass. Is that
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:20:42
correct? Not without a motion of expungement. Thank you. Okay. Thank you Mr. Chair. On line C it says that a massage therapist may practice cupping therapy as part of massage therapy after completing an educational program in cupping therapy. Could you be more specific about that educational program, what it might cost, how many hours it might be? Well, that's why I have Don Ike here, but as of right now, massage therapists already receive educational credit or educational programming for cupping, and so it's already included in their massage therapy license. But I'll let Ms. Ike also speak to that. Okay. Thank you. I wanted to add just
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:21:18
a little bit extra, as I'm sure you might have some other questions. Cupping as a modality has a lot of confusion about it. It's gained in popular mainstream media, so I wanted to talk just a bit on that. Cupping is a massage modality used to release rigid soft tissues throughout the application of a dome-shaped device, often called cups. Suction is created by using a hand pump to control the pump. Tissues are lifted away from the body with a controlled vacuum. This approach can be used effectively to give relief of discomfort from conditions such such as scar tissue, pullings, restrictions for muscles and fascia, that's the connective tissue that surrounds muscles and tendons. Various forms of cupping have been offered throughout history by a variety of practitioners. Therefore, understanding the specifics and objectives of cupping for massage therapy is very important. Here in Arkansas, massage therapy law first began in 1951. Until recently, massage for cupping was covered by massage law under the agreed term mechanical device as we use a hand pump to affect soft tissue and connective tissue. Today, Arkansas has more than 2,000 licensed massage therapists. We've never had a single complaint or case filed against one of our therapists regarding the misconduct or injury with the use of cups. In fact, our researchers have yet to find any case against massage therapists regarding cupping nationwide, despite decades of use by massage therapists. In regards to cupping for massage therapy on a national level, you will find major medical insurance providers are specifically listing cupping for massage under their coverage. Also, the NCBTMB, which is our national massage therapy board, list cupping for massage as a modality. To answer your question specifically, continuing education courses focusing specifically on cupping for massage has been in existence for years on both a national and a state level. Most of the major massage schools in Arkansas have, although not required, have decided to include additional introduction to training and cupping for massage purposes. They include this to their students as part of their core curriculum. Our industry has already taken great strides to ensure massage therapists are receiving full training and education regarding cupping for massage. Recently, cupping has gained popular attention from sports and entertainment industries with notable celebrities such as Michael Phelps, considered the most successful Olympic athlete of all time. Jennifer Aniston and Gwyneth Paltrow are also known celebrity wellness advocates. They can be seen regularly bearing the marks of cupping. I would like to reiterate that this bill we're just asking to be granted this, we're not asking for a new modality, we're just asking to be allowed to continue helping provide these services as we've been doing. I'm with the Coalition for Massage Therapists. I'm the President. We sat down with the acupuncturist and we discussed our specifics on education. We're going to recommend a minimum of 18 hours additional continuing education credits as approved by the M-TAC and the Department of Health. Thank you. Representative McCullough, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. I'd like to make a motion at the proper time. Not noted. Seeing no further questions from committee is anyone in the room speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, motion do pass by Representative McCullough. Any discussion on that motion? All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Love. Your bill is passed. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative McCullough, are you ready to run House Bill 1501?
▶ Play
Thank you Mr. Chair, Bill 1501 is more or less a lot of it has to do with cleaning up some language, it's a DHS bill and with that I'd like to introduce a guest, Craig Cloud. If you could introduce yourself, maybe tell the committee a little bit about what you you do, why this is a necessary bill, why we decided to strike the language from elder choices and replace it with what we did. Mr.
▶ Play
Cloud, if you would introduce yourself for the committee and you're
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:26:11
recognized to proceed. All righty. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Craig Cloud, Director of the Division of Aging and Adult Services, Department of Human Services. I appreciate the opportunity to bring this bill to the committee today. I appreciate Representative McCollum sponsoring this bill for us. Basically, as he stated, it's a cleanup bill. most of you remember last year we combined our two waivers our elders choices waiver and our alternatives for adults with physical disabilities waiver into one waiver called AR choices we're basically just changing the statute that allows us to reflect the new name and reflect the home home and community based services name of the program striking elders choices also there's some other cleanup in the bills that relates to private care agency license as issued by the Arkansas Department of Labor and at the Arkansas Department of Labor's request and I've spoken with Director Jones they support this we're striking this basically this is language that's been in the bill for quite some time our waiver providers have to pay $250 a year for private care agency employment license and as most of you know these agencies and these providers of services are not employment agencies so striking this language actually it's easier for the provider but it allows for the certification of the provider to rest within the Department of Human Services and allows us to ensure that they still meet the minimum certification requirements thank you Mr. Chair. Any questions from the
▶ Play
committee? Seeing none, does anyone in the audience speak for or against? Seeing none, it was a pleasure, committee. I got a motion to do pass from Representative Branscombe. Any discussion on the motion? All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed. Congratulations, Representative McCullough. Your bill has passed. Representative Tucker, I see you sitting over on the side over there. I recognize you'd run House Bill 1609. Is that correct? Yes,
▶ Play
sir, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, members of the committee. This is a very simple bill. The law requires employers to pay their employees semi-monthly, and so what that means is that if you pay your employees more than semi-monthly, then you're in technical violation of the law. So if you pay your employees every other week, then there are two months a year where you have three pay periods and that's technically in violation of law or if you pay your employees weekly then you're in technical violation of law now this is not strictly enforced but it could be enforced and so that was not the intent of the provision the intent of the provision was just to make sure employees pay at least twice a month and so what this bill does is it just clarifies that language that employer shall pay no less frequently than semi-monthly instead of exactly semi-monthly, essentially. And so that's what the bill does. It's very simple just to make sure the employers out there will still get paid at least twice a month, but the employers who pay more frequently than that are not in violation of the law. That's it. Representative Pilkington, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Is this an issue right now in Arkansas? I mean, why is this legislation coming up? Just to make sure. an attorney who's a friend of mine who represents employers on a regular basis brought this to my attention and the employers that she represents are just concerned that at any time they could be you know held in violation be fined or whatever the case might be just because they are paying their employees every other week and so they're two months a year where they have three pay periods and that's technically not in compliance with the law as it is now and so they're concerned about it and they told their lawyer about it, and she told me about it,
▶ Play
and that's it. Thank you. Any further questions? Representative Miller, you got a question? Okay. Seeing no further questions, or anyone in the audience speak for or against? Seeing none, what's a pleasure to committee? Got a motion due pass for Representative Ritchie. Any discussion on the motion? All those in favor? well that's weak it's not even 12 o'clock yet all those opposed I have a representative Tucker congratulates your bill passed thank you mr. chairman thank you members of the committee cinder Cooper are you ready for us you're gonna run Senate bill 301 correct all right you're recognized to run Senate bill 301 and mr. break if you would introduce yourself for
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:30:55
committee and y'all are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is a bill that was brought by the health department and it's a bill that enables them to share their immunization registry across jurisdictional lines. That's really about it. What we're trying to avoid are people that get shots in other jurisdictions, other states, and it even includes, you'll notice in the act, the Compact Free Association, that's for the Marshallese population mainly. But we'll be able to share that data across jurisdictional lines. People won't have to get duplicate shots because we'll be able to pick those shots up when we search, and it's a
▶ Play
good thing. Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:31:44
question. Would you be able to get that information without the people's permission? well every every childhood immunization is is it's mandated that be in the registry now adults can be in the registry if they choose to or if their doctor chooses to do that all this does and when you need when you when you're going to school if you're going to go to k-12 or even to college you can come to the health department print out your shot record to make sure you've got the required shots what happens is especially if you're in a border town or if you moved in from another state, we can't pick up all those shots that you've already had, but they're just not in the registry. And so by being able to share that, especially with border states, we'll be able to pull down the entire shot record, not just the things that were given in Arkansas by an Arkansas provider. So, I mean, people haven't consented to this, but they've got to have this information to go to school or even to daycare. So it would require – Is that your follow-up? Yeah, thank you, Mr. Chair. So it would require consent from the parent before – Well, it's typically the parent that wants the shot record so they can enroll their child into school or daycare. So I would assume – or if a provider – if you came in from another state and you go to a provider here in Arkansas, they'll be able to also look up that information to see if they're up-to-date on their shots or what shots they might need. We hope that this results in fewer duplicate shots. You'll be able to pick up that information. It's still protected health information. It won't be shared. It's not shared widely at all. Any further
▶ Play
questions from the committee? Seeing none, does anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? Seeing none, what's the pleasure of the committee? I got a motion due passed by Representative Henderson. Any discussion on that motion? all those in favor say aye all those opposed I just have it congratulate Senator Cooper your bill is passed thank you mr. chair thank you committee thank you representative hammer I
▶ Play
Speaker 182 1:34:02
think you've got a couple bills you want to run representative hammer there's a senate
▶ Play
bill and a house bill if you just enlighten us on which one you want to run first will much oblige mr. chair
▶ Play
i'd like to start off by running house bill 1566 okay you're recognized to run
▶ Play
house bill 1566 could I call someone with the family council forward
▶ Play
to sit beside me and also to be introduced for the record please mr. chair if that's what you wish sure esteemed with family council thank you mr. Reese thank mr. chair for the sake of time, I'll tell the members what this bill gets to and what is the essence of the bill. Number one, it aligns with the responsibilities of the Arkansas Final Disposition Act of 2009. It brings things in line that we've been working on for the last couple of years, but just cut through the chase and say exactly what it does. It prevents abortion clinics from being able to sell off baby parts in order to be able to be sold on the market, and that's the long and short of and I'll be glad to answer any questions any questions from the committee on the
▶ Play
Speaker 134 1:35:26
bill representative Gonzales you recognize for a question thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:35:36
mr. chair would this prevent any research from from involuntary abortions no Representative Lundstrow, do you
▶ Play
have a question? Okay, due noted. Is there anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? See it in LA, what's the pleasure of committee? We've got a due pass from Representative Lundstrow. Any discussion on motion? All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, ayes have it. Congratulations, Representative Henry. Your bill has passed. Do you want to present Senate Bill 167 now? Yes, I would. All right. You're recognized. The amendment's engrossed. May I invite a
▶ Play
guest to the table, Mr. Chair? Is there an amendment to this
▶ Play
Speaker 55 1:36:31
bill? I do not have an amendment for this bill.
▶ Play
Then your answer would be yes. Senate Bill 167. Moment, Mr. Chair. Yes. If you would have your guests introduce herself for the committee. Hi,
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:36:57
Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Amanda Story with Hargraves Consulting, and I represent the Association of Surgical Technologists. Representative Hammer, you're recognized to present your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I'll just go to what the thrust of the bill does. It creates a volunteer registry in order for surgical techs to be able to sign up and have their cells placed on a voluntary registry. This is a trend that's occurring in other states, and it is intended to improve the quality to make sure that those that are at the most important stage of a surgery, which would be those that keep the room sterile and clean, could have their names placed on a volunteer registry so that whenever it is that they are being viewed for employment, they would be able to be identified as being part of that volunteer network. And I'll be glad to answer any questions, or if I may, Madam Chair, let Amanda
▶ Play
Speaker 138 1:37:50
enlighten just a little bit beyond that. Sure.
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:37:55
Go ahead. Introduce yourself. Hi, again. It's Amanda Story with Hargraves Consulting, and I represent the Association of Surgical Technologists. And I would just reiterate what Representative Hammer said. This bill, in our eyes, is all about quality and positive patient outcomes. And secondly, it's about cost efficiencies. We know, studies have shown that annually, surgical site infections cost up to $10 billion. A single surgical site infection can cost over $35,000. And the surgical technologists are essentially the co-pilot in the operating room. They're the surgeon's kind of right hand, if you will. They're the folks that are responsible for maintaining that sterile field. and really the first line of defense against a surgical site infection. Other states have passed a registry law, and again, this is just a voluntary registry. We're putting it on ourselves just to be voluntary. It's not a licensure, not a certification requirement. It's a voluntary list just so we know who's doing this in the state because those folks really are the first line of defense in surgical site infections, and they're the ones who are going to be able to reduce it. Other states have passed, Virginia, for example, just passed this very piece of legislation a couple years ago, and they've reduced their surgical site infections by 11%. Medicaid no longer covers hospital-acquired infections and surgical site infections. A lot of times the costs aren't fully covered by insurance companies. So in our eyes, this is about patient outcomes first and cost savings second. I'm happy to answer any questions. Representative Meeks, I want to recognize
▶ Play
you before we lose any more attendance out of the room for your point of personal privilege. I didn't mean for you to interrupt
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:39:39
the bill that was being presented, but I do have a group here today, and actually me and Representative McGee, since we both represent Conway, from UCA are nursing students, and so we'd like to welcome you to public health, and hopefully you guys at least get a little bit of an education about how things are done down here. So thank you for coming here
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:40:05
and being here. Mr. Chair, could I have one more statement? I also wanted to reiterate, we've worked on this for about two years, and we worked with the Medical Society and the Hospital Association to ensure that their folks are on board as well, alleviating any concerns that they had. And so we did that and
▶ Play
feel confident that we've addressed those. I have a question, Representative Love. I
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:40:30
have a question. I'm just a little curious. At the end of the bill, page 3, it's the title protection is line 9 through 12. It says a person shall not use or assume the title registered surgical technologist unless the person is registered with the Arkansas State Board of... I guess my question is, can they use the title now?
▶ Play
Speaker 278 1:40:53
I mean you put this in for a reason so can they use a title
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:40:59
now? I guess feasibly they could and there are folks out there who have not undergone a certification and this doesn't change require any kind of certification but they cannot call themselves registered now because there's no registry so they can't use the term now this just ensures that when there is a registry that folks who aren't on it don't hold themselves out to be. And that's really the crux of why it's needed. There's no oversight whatsoever. There's not even a definite number of people in the profession in the state right now, and so that's just part of the list, just kind of keeping up with that and knowing
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:41:44
who is practicing the profession. I do have a follow-up. Do you recognize? Now, you said that you're representing the Surgical, the...
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:41:52
Association of Surgical Technologists. Okay, so the
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:41:55
association is for this. Is there any known opposition to this bill? I don't
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:41:59
have any opposition to this, to creating this registry. We've talked with the nurses about, you know, some issues they may have had of adding something that, you know, we think is better addressed in different legislation but as far as an opposition to creating a registry we know of none okay thank you thank you mr. chair before you open it up
▶ Play
to the public and after all the questions i'd like to make a statement please recognize for statement no other questions at this time from members i don't see any all right thank you you will find out in a minute that there will be some opposition to this bill for those that are going to come and sit the end of it everybody in this room knows how how much and maybe not may have worked it out here's the point here's one of one of the things I want to make a point to and that is that when it comes to the surgical procedures that are taking place nurses play extremely high role and in a moment or after a while I may bring a different bill that would make sure that they would have the fullest protection afforded them in that environment. But this bill, if we can stay focused on this bill, what it does is just creates a volunteer registry. So with that in mind, I'll be glad to answer any questions or at the chair's discretion. Representative Lundstrow, you're recognized for a question. Going back to
▶ Play
that volunteer registry, are we about to make one step towards licensing? And I have a follow-up question, too. You're recognized.
▶ Play
It is not the intent of this sponsor that we would move toward licensing as far as in the future. What this does is simply create an ability for those that are in that profession to voluntarily place their name on a list so that when they go for employment, the hospital or whoever it is that's going to hire them will see that they have self-identified themselves as professionals in this area. They already carried those credentials, but what this list will do is voluntarily give them the ability to identify themselves with a group that have come out publicly and said, yes, I have met these standards. May I have a follow-up? Why the Medical Society and not the
▶ Play
Nursing Board? And fill me in a little on that thought process. Be all right with you. To start off with, I'll let Amanda
▶ Play
handle that, and then I'll come back and finish up. Could you repeat your question?
▶ Play
Why under the medical board? Yes, and not the nursing and what's just a
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:44:40
little bit of background. Yeah, and if it's okay, I'm not trying to evade. A member of the National Association and a practicing surgical technologist here in Arkansas, Mercy Hospital in Fort Smith, is here to speak for the bill, and she'll be able to address that more specifically on why through the medical board because I believe it deals more with the scope of practice and oversight in the operating room.
▶ Play
If you don't mind, Representative Lundstra, we've got her signed up to speak for the bill. If you want to hold that question until that point, that would be better. What procedure? Representative Ferguson,
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:45:16
you're recognized for a question. I have a long question that's probably two questions. Is that okay? I like short ones. Because I've been involved with this process for a couple of years, And there is another path to be a surgical technologist that is not a registered technologist that takes the board.
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:45:36
Is that right? Absolutely. And there are folks who practice, and you can even be on the registry without being a certified technologist or having a certification. You could get grandfathered in and be on the registry. So this does not
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:45:51
preclude anyone from practicing. So those people that have trained in hospitals and hadn't gone through this program, they are not prohibited from working or anything they still and i guess in answer to representative lundstrom's question it was my understanding that they just needed a place to help the registry and there are a good number of organizations respiratory therapy and all those people that place their registry for administrative purposes under the medical board the medical board's actually doing you a favor to kind of take you is
▶ Play
that right yes thank you thank you Representative Love, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:46:29
question. Thank you. Now I really do have a question because Representative Ferguson just said that there's an alternative path to becoming a, what I asked you was about the registered surgical technologist. Right. There's an alternative path. But then in this bill that we're going to be passing, if there's an alternative path, I guess we take that path away if we say a person shall not use or assume the title registered surgical technologist unless the person is
▶ Play
Speaker 202 1:47:05
registered with the Arkansas State
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:47:08
Medical Board. Right. So you could practice and call yourself a surgical technologist without being on the registry. You just could not call yourself a registered surgical technologist. but you could still practice, and you could also not have a certification. Right now there are eight facilities in Arkansas that certify surgical technologists, and a lot of folks have that certification. A lot of people don't have the certification. You could not have the certification and still be on the registry. That language was just included in the bill to keep folks who don't take the step of just voluntarily signing up on the registry for holding themselves out as, quote, registered.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you. Seeing no further questions, we'll move to the audience. We have Ms. Rachel Ray to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:48:14
Good morning, Mr. Chair and committee. My name is Rachel Ray. I'm a certified surgical technologist and a certified surgical first assistant. I have been working in the operating room arena for 22 years. Nationwide, we have 39,694 surgical technologists that are certified, and we have statewide 437. In our state, we do not have any way to govern with the registry. we would be able to govern that. The fact of this is that these are the people that have come forward to announce our title, our education, and our competencies. The fact that we don't know how many are not being recognized is what we are trying to prevent and cause no more harm to patients. Surgical technologists are individuals' responsibility to getting the rooms ready for the operating suite, and we ensure that the instruments are safe and repaired and working order, functional, sterility. We are charged with the maintenance of the essential sterile field to remain that way throughout the surgery. We also help the surgeon, as they said, as the co-pilot. We are a second set of eyes, hands, and ears in the operating room. We are the ones who are managing specimens collected during surgical procedures. We are the ones to dress the incisions of the closed wounds. Our work is critical in preventing surgical site infections. You've heard prior to this about the research found on the average cost for a surgical site infection being $35,000 and also being $10 million annually in direct and indirect medical costs. Right now, as we know, there is no oversight in place to keep up with this growing profession. This bill does not, I repeat, does not propose a certification or a licensure. It will simply create the registry, which will be administered by the State Medical Board. Surgical technologies currently credentialed by the National Board of Surgical Technologists and Surgical Assistants will be registered. as those would have successfully completed a surgical tech training program. Also, these practices, before legislation is put into place, would be grandfathered in and given a year to get the credentialing and do so. Registration will help ensure the patients undergoing the surgery in Arkansas can expect the highest quality of medical care for all the members of the surgical team. Registration will identify those surgical technologists who meet the educational requirements and standards by nationally accredited education and certifying organizations. This will also allow the Medical Board to identify surgical technologists who may have a history of a drug use, an alcohol abuse, or a drug theft in the exercise its authority to revoke the registration if needed. Further, it will allow hospitals and other facilities to have a better idea of the credentials and the competencies of the individuals practicing surgical technology in the state of Arkansas. Data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows no correlation between higher wages for surgical technologists and states that have regulated the profession, so there will be no added cost to a hospital. Nationwide, as they were telling you, eight states require graduation from the National Credit Program and have passed the certifying exam. Four states have registration laws in place currently. Seven states, including our own, have legislation pending concerning the surgical technologists, which is a total of 19 states from our 50 that have acknowledged or are currently acknowledging these in the profession of surgical technology field. In conclusion, I do want to add, I am a national board member for the Association of Surgical Technologists. I sit on that board. And in conclusion, I would like to say that this surgical technology registry would support an optimal patient outcome based on required competencies. Arkansas currently has no regulations in place to oversee the practice of our profession. We are completely devoted to the success and public awareness and transparency of the profession of surgical technology.
▶ Play
Thank you so much. Thank you, Representative Meeks, you're recognized for
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:52:54
a question for the witness. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I'm just trying to wrap my head around the surgical technologist field, because from what it sounds like, unless you have a big hospital like a Baptist in Little Rock or whatever, who may be able to hire a surgical technologist full-time, am I understanding that you basically are out there, and then if the hospital needs a surgical technologist for a surgery they give you a call or all of them just employed full-time so I'm trying to understand why we need this particular registry if all of our surgical technologists may be employed by a hospital full-time yes sir they
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:53:31
are employed full-time slash part-time or as needed PRN is what they would be called on a daily basis in either a 10-hour day and 8-hour day or so on and so forth the fact of the matter is is that the the people that come into surgery have no idea that the all of the surgical technologists in the room that are given that title have not all passed a an exam or have not had to meet competencies because that's not been a requirement of us so therefore it creates a safety issue and we are trying to put patient first cut down costs on the infection rates or potential disasters because someone's not educated enough on a particular competency. Follow-up. Recognize. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:54:20
Why would it not be the hospital's responsibility to, I mean, I know that they might only do so much, but if that is, I mean, that's such a big deal about infections and everything, why would the hospital not do their due diligence before they hire this person part-time, full-time, or as needed to know their certifications, to know as much about them as possible? Yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:54:44
sir. I do believe that's a public awareness problem. People have no idea, and they want to pinpoint, oh, it's from surgery or an infection came from the surgical suite on this specific patient on the postoperative end of it. However, we are the front barrier is what we discussed earlier. We're the front barrier of surgical prevention with making sure everything stays sterile. If it doesn't, get rid of it, get something else, making sure everything is treated properly, make sure that everything you hand into that unknowing surgeon's hand, when he's looking into an incision, that he trusts the fact that this is sterile, this is what's, you know, that you are competent to know that he is keeping the patient safe as well as you.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, I'd like to also add on to that and respond maybe to Representative Meek's question. And that is part of the – I think that's part of what this bill is intended to do. It creates that volunteer registry that you take a small hospital, maybe not a network hospital, and if they wanted to find out if you were an individual that was voluntarily associating and placing yourself on this list, it would give that hospital a greater level of comfort that when they hire you that they would see that you have agreed to the things that you require or that you are subjecting yourself to in order to have your name placed on this volunteer list. So it protects the hospital, but it also protects the individual that they are self-aligning with others that have met the requirements of what's in the bill. I rarely do this, but I
▶ Play
do have a question. Yes, sir. We'll have to vote on this shortly, I guess. Are these people out there today practicing? Yes, they are. okay and this is my follow-up committee so you know I abide by the same rules what protections out there for the public today or is there any or is there a registry are they volunteering to take a board or kind of give me some insight of what's going on today
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:56:47
no it is personal integrity taken upon one person and I can't speak for anyone else but the people that have taken the same steps that I have taken to become educated and as I said earlier I've been doing this for 22 years back in the day you didn't do things like you do now there was an old way and a new way and technology has evolved therefore we have to evolve meaning we have to stay in touch in tune and competency wise be on the upper level of what is coming at us what do we do how do we fix it yes there are people that do not have this sense of integrity or they were just trained on the job and many years ago that wasn't an issue now it is a legality and those type of things you if you get um pulled in let me do you a
▶ Play
favor I want to restate that question for you this is a restatement i gave representative hammer one of these earlier because i don't think she answered what i was asking okay is there a stream of high level of infections that are taking place today that this is needed i mean i was asking you that question for basis of is there reasoning reasoning for this volunteerism for registering i mean are we having infections happening right now that hadn't happened in the past or what's what's
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:58:19
the reasoning yes there is the reasoning for that they did a control study and the hospitals that had the higher infections they had personnel that were not um keeping their self educated keeping their self you know together certified those type of things they weren't involved in a registry and they had an 11 percent higher surgical site infection percentage than those who did. I mean, it's out there, the data, but, yes, that's the
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:58:51
answer. Representative Walmack, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess I'm just not clear. I mean, you asked part of my question, so well enough to satisfy that, but I've got another one. Why do we need legislation? I mean, if this is a voluntary list that the hospitals can access, why aren't we writing a law? Why don't we just have a voluntary list on your website and
▶ Play
Speaker 273 1:59:14
problem solved without a new law? We have a voluntary National Board of Surgical Assistants and Surgical Technologists currently, and that is represented on a nationwide, but it is not represented on a state-by-state recognition. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? You're recognized. What prevents
▶ Play
Speaker 24 1:59:30
you from doing it on an Arkansas base currently without this legislation? i'm sorry what prevents you from from just making your list and putting it on your website i mean if this is a voluntary deal then everybody that wants to be part of it would have the opportunity to sign up i understand mr mr chair can i
▶ Play
get amanda to come back to the table because i think she can give some specific insight to that i'll
▶ Play
let you do that after we go through the witnesses Okay. Representative Payton, you have a question for this witness? I'm pretty sure my question is for Representative Hammer. If you want to hold that to the end, I'll give you time for that. Seeing no further questions, thank you for your testimony. Thank you, sir. We did have someone signed up to speak against, but I think that's not going to happen or is. You just have to call and find out, Mr. Chair. It's Kenneth Worley. You still want to speak against the bill, Mr.
▶ Play
Kenneth? Yes, sir. I'd like to say
▶ Play
a quick thing. You're recognized to introduce yourself for the committee, and you're
▶ Play
recognized to speak against the bill. Yes, sir. Thank you. My name is Kenneth Worley, and I am a registered nurse who is certified in the operating room. I represent myself in my central Arkansas chapter of the Association of Prairie Opera Room Nurses. Though originally we were opposed and against some of this bill, I have had assurances from Lucas Hargrave, Representative Hammer, and Senator Sanders that they are willing to work with us to address these concerns. So at this time, I would like to change my status to a neutral position, please. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Hammer, before I recognize you to close, I'm going to allow Representative Womack and Payton to ask you those questions again. Would the
▶ Play
chair allow me to have Amanda to come for expert witness? Yes, sir. or you said a man or Amanda Amanda
▶ Play
Speaker 237 2:01:32
I'm both thank you mr. chair could you ask
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:01:39
that question thank you mr. chair my question is basically why do we need legislation if this is just a voluntary registry for hospitals to access who's available right why can't we just have it on a website somewhere so here's a list without passing a law i
▶ Play
Speaker 273 2:01:56
understand that and and as rachel testified they've tried that um on different different states associations have tried that and there's a different i think you would you would agree there's a different level of um kind of commitment and when you're putting your name you're you're putting your name on a registry that is run that's an official registry run by the state board of medicine uh versus you're just kind of typing your name in on a website that may or may not be held out as official. I think in our mind, that's the difference. And again, as Rachel said, we hope folks would hold them to their professional integrity. These folks, if they're already practicing, they don't have to have a specific certification or licensure. If they're already practicing, they can still sign themselves up on the register and hold themselves
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:02:52
out as registered. Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hammer, I guess my mind's been running a few rabbit trails while we were on this subject, but I mean, I want to know your opinion, and you all have not explored this angle, but hospitals, one of their largest expenses is liability insurance, and I can see where a liability insurance carrier might prefer that those in the operating room they're doing these jobs be identified as having received this certification has there been any discussion on y'all's end about about the importance of doing this you know for for those reasons i can tell you one of
▶ Play
the reasons because on the surface it may appear like this is going to create another level of bureaucracy and create another entity which we've been discussing a lot about this morning so you know from that perspective I could I could see where somebody might have that view of this however what I would fall back on as far as why I'm carrying this bill aligning with some of those same arguments that we had earlier is this that in the states where this has been implemented and it's a state-to-state thing as was shared but in the states where this has been implemented they have seen a reduction in fact I think it was ten billion dollars was the number that was thrown out I'll substantiate that with hard documentation, but it has helped reduce in the infection-related issues in the operating room by this volunteer list, by the very thing that we're enacting into law, and I think that that speaks to the ability to level it, you know, raise it to
▶ Play
Speaker 273 2:04:30
a level of credibility that would give reason for this. And I'll just echo that, Representative Payton, yes, yes, that's a major reason, and as I said, we've worked with the Hospital Association to address their concerns, and And one thing that I think was brought up earlier is these site infections are very costly. That often is not covered. Medicaid does not cover the hospital-acquired surgical site infections any longer. And often the full cost is not covered by insurance companies. So it's definitely a
▶ Play
liability issue as well. Seeing no further questions. Representative Gonzalez, I'm sorry. I missed you. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 134 2:05:09
you, Mr. Chair. I like your waves, though. I don't want you to
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:05:16
miss me again. I got you. I guess I'm failing to see how this is different than creating a license. I mean, there's requirements for training to be on this list. Could you just tell me how this is different than creating a license? I mean, we're just calling it a registry is what it looks like, not a licensure. We're
▶ Play
Speaker 273 2:05:42
just not giving them a card. And I understand your concern, definitely. And like Representative Hammer said, the intent is not to create another level of bureaucracy or a licensure. The fact is somebody could operate, and we debated this issue in a different bill, But somebody could be practicing as just, you know, out of high school or whatever and had been hired by one of the hospitals who hired them and trained them. They don't have any specific education, any specific certification. They could still be on this registry without any education level, without any certification. If they had been hired by a hospital, they could be grandfathered in and sign up on the registry.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:06:29
Follow-up. So they could be grandfathered in, but it wouldn't allow that to happen for anyone else from this point
▶ Play
Speaker 273 2:06:39
forward. Correct. But you could still work as a surgical technologist. You just could not be on the list of registered surgical technologists. You could still work if the hospital hired you. You could still enter the profession. You just wouldn't be able to hold yourself out as a
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:06:58
registered surgical technologist. So it's creating a license for surgical technologists.
▶ Play
Speaker 273 2:07:03
I see your point, but there's no licensure requirement, and there's no. Okay. Yes, sir. Thank you. Add one
▶ Play
thing to that. I think a good perspective of what this would do is create a method that if you were a person that was in that particular situation just described, it would give you a credible means whereby you could have your name associated on a list that's recognized as viable and as legal so that you could go out and perhaps have even greater opportunity to get employment because you have submitted voluntarily to having your name placed on this list. That's the other way to look at it. You don't have to do that because, again, it's totally volunteer. If you want to go out there and try to do it on your own independently, you can. But if you're in that unique position, you just explain, this gives you the ability to have your name raised to a credible status by voluntarily having your name put on this list and what is expected when you do put your name on this list. So it actually helps that person. I think that's why they were grandfathered in. Moving forward, I understand you would not have to have your name on this list, but that's your choice if you do or you do not. It just takes in consideration those that are there right now up to this snapshot
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:08:20
of time. Representative Boyd, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
So, in general, does registration have the same legal expectations as licensure? I
▶ Play
Speaker 273 2:08:33
don't know the answer to that question as far as the definition. It's not defined in this legislation, and I would defer to the attorneys at the medical board or the other bodies of how they define registry versus licensure. It is the intent that it does not carry the same definition as license in this context, Simply, I mean, in our mind, for the intent of the legislation, it's a list. It's straightforward. Representative
▶ Play
Boyd, that was my understanding also that this is not licensure. This is volunteer placement on a list that has met the criterias. And the other reason as to why law versus just sign up on a website, when it's in law and somebody screws up later, you've got the law to go back to to hold them accountable to. An association can put whatever they want to put out there, and we as legislators don't necessarily have a lot of control over that. I think to the sake of public interest and why this is coming before this committee is that if we choose to do this, we are saying that there's a standard of expectation if you voluntarily place your name on this list and somebody looks at this list as a reference, they'll know that those expectations have been fulfilled, Whereas, if I'm an association website, I can put any name on there, but that doesn't necessarily, no disrespect, give that credibility that something like this is going to do. Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. And this will
▶ Play
be the last question, and we'll move on. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Actually, I
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:10:05
think Representative Hammer just cleared up what I wanted to know, so that'd be all. Thank you. represent hammer you close for your bill i would just say
▶ Play
and want to focus on the fact that a this is voluntary secondly in the other states where this has been put into practice hospitals have seen a decrease in events in the surgical waiting room in the reduction of infection and i think that that within itself gives evidence to the fact that this is is something that people can voluntarily do would not necessarily be mandated in closing also there because i don't want to leave too much confusion in the room with regards to those that were lined up to speak against it the issue that we are going to be working on together and i have the commitment from those that have brought this bill to me that we are going to work together is just to make sure there's a clear chain of protocol with regard to the nurses role in the er and make sure that there's no liability assumed to them as unintended consequences so that would be a different piece of legislation that as soon as we get out of this room and we get this thing out I'll go to work on but but that's just to clear up why somebody may have sat down to talk against the bill thank you mr. chair it would make appreciate a good vote and I'll
▶ Play
make a motion do pass on motion do pass you need discussion on the motion representative
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:11:36
Meeks you're recognized for discussion when you say there's this other piece of legislation that y'all have agreed upon or that you're going to work on and to me passing this bill without knowing whether or not that other piece of legislation is going to make it through is very concerning for me so I don't I'd like to get more information about what you just said as far as legislation is concerned and make make sure that if there is some agreement that that other legislation is going to make it through before we can go forward with this one so at this point I'm gonna be a no on this pending whatever other agreement legislation policy rule or regulation that you just mentioned unless I'm confused about it but you're on the committee and you might be able to address what you just
▶ Play
said thank you mr. chair representative love I see you but I'm gonna let mr. representative hammer address that before I
▶ Play
recognize you thank you mr. chair and with regards to that particular issue it is actually outside the scope of what this bill is intended to do that's why I'm gonna bring it as a different issue as a as a different bill and the only reason at all that I I brought that up was because I wanted to try to clear up without making it more confusion the fact that somebody was going to sit down and speak against this bill and then they went neutral. I would only ask you this, that if that was the case that they went neutral when they sat down, that would imply that as far as that particular issue and the relevancy to this bill moving forward should be within itself evidence that that concern has been addressed. The issue that's going to be addressed in a separate piece of legislation, as I said, was just the accountability process in the actual operating room itself. It has nothing to do with the content of this bill. And I actually didn't add it as an amendment because I wanted this one to stand pure on its own with the commitment of working forward moving on. So I hope that that would help change your mind to what you just said. Thank you. Representative Bentley, you're
▶ Play
recognized for discussion. Representative Hammer, thank you. I think that there's some confusion on the committee, so I just wanted to give my thoughts out there. We have a group of people that are very important. Nothing's more important. These folks that are in the surgery, when they're handing that doctor an instrument, it needs to be sterile, it needs to be cleaned. They're stepping up and saying we want to voluntarily have this list so that we can be sure those folks that are operating in the operating room with a surgeon are handing them clean, sterile instruments, and it's a volunteer list for them to step up and I think improve the care and the surgeries that are going on in the state of Arkansas. I don't see it as something that's negative. I know I just spoke there in licensure, but to me this is a voluntary list of folks that to me are stepping up and saying we want Arkansas to a place that has clean, sterile instruments handed to a surgeon in the operating room. It's simply what it is. I think we're making more of it than it needs to be at this point, and I trust Representative Hammer, as most of you guys do, and with that I would just encourage
▶ Play
you guys to vote yes on this. Seeing no further discussion, all those in favor
▶ Play
say aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Representative Hammer, congratulations. Your bill is passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the
▶ Play
committee. Representative Charlene Fite, you're recognized to present your bill. Two more. This is a working committee, and we are working people. We have two more bills after Representative Fite, so if you guys can stay with me, we'll get
▶ Play
this worked out. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Can you hear me? Yes, ma'am. Okay. I bring you today's Senate Bill 148, the Born Alive Infant Protection Act. And may I bring my witness to the end of
▶ Play
the table, please? Yes, ma'am. If you would, have
▶ Play
Speaker 223 2:15:41
them introduce themselves for their record. hold
▶ Play
on one second representative fight you said senate bill 148 yes sir
▶ Play
Speaker 120 2:15:50
a little issue stubble
▶ Play
Speaker 182 2:15:59
field okay you recognize carry on All right. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Thank you,
▶ Play
committee. This is Senate Bill 148, the Born Alive Infant Protection Act. This bill spells out protections in Arkansas law for babies born alive during or following a failed abortion procedure. It ensures a baby born alive following an abortion will be provided appropriate medical care, including emergency care. Let me tell you a little bit more about this. On March 12th, 2002, the federal Born Alive Infant Protection Act passed the House of Representatives by a resounding voice vote. Later, on June 19th, 2002, this same act was approved by a 98-0 vote in the U.S. Senate. Senators Hillary Clinton, Ted Kennedy, Barbara Boxer, and John Kerry all voted in favor of this bill. On the Senate floor Senator Boxer voiced her strong support for this bill exclaiming who would be more vulnerable than a newborn baby. She continued stating that all of our people deserve protection from the very tiniest infant to the most elderly among us. You may wonder why we need this on the state level since we have it at a federal level? Well, this would be the state counterpart. The state Born Alive Infant Protection Act specifically declares that we do not implicate or infringe on the right to abortion, but we need this for several reasons. First, the federal act only applies in limited circumstances. For example, it only covers those hospitals and employees operated by the federal government or which receive federal funding. It would not prohibit private or state-operated clinics and hospitals from denying care or medical attention to born-alive infants. Twenty-six states, including every state that touches Arkansas, now have laws creating affirmative duty for physicians to provide medical care and treatment to born-alive infants at any stage of their development. We offer these protections to premature infants. I would like to have our state also protect these most vulnerable infants among us. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Pilkington, you have a question. Just a
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:18:36
real quick one. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. On page 1, line 25, it says, It is not infringement on a woman's right to terminate her pregnancy. By passing this, would it not mean that we are putting in law that a woman does have a right to terminate her pregnancy? This would not change any statute that
▶ Play
we already have. Follow-up? You recognize? But by putting this
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:19:02
language, by passing this language, I mean, we're essentially saying that there is a right that a woman has to terminate her pregnancy. I'll
▶ Play
Speaker 351 2:19:14
turn that to you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is, I'm sure he's dealing with Family Counsel. Give me a moment and let me pull that up. No
▶ Play
state or federal statute would be changed by this law, but we'll get you a more specific answer. I'm sorry, would you tell me what page you're on?
▶ Play
Speaker 261 2:19:36
Page 1, line 25. Okay. This language just refers to the Bovert versus Wade decision, and it just states that this does not infringe on a woman's ability to get an abortion. This has no impact on it. It actually has nothing to do with abortion. It actually has to do with the baby that's born alive resulting from an abortion.
▶ Play
Speaker 220 2:20:09
representative love do you have a question no no it's
▶ Play
for discussion we'll get around to that i got a feeling are any further questions for the sponsor see a nun or anyone in the audience speak for or against Representative Lundstall has a motion due pass Representative Love you're recognized for discussion It didn't take long It did Well actually
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:20:47
my discussion is towards Representative Pilkington's question and I'm for sure that family council is not going to put anything in any legislation that's going to allow anybody an abortion Thank you Mr. Chair Much appreciated Representative Pilkin, do you
▶ Play
have anything to add to that discussion? I agree with you.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:21:10
The language just made me squirm a little bit. Thank you. See
▶ Play
it. No further discussion. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Aye. As I have it, congratulations, Representative Fite. Your bill is passed. Representative Gray. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. you're recognized to run house bill 1526 if I'm right thank you Mr. Chair
▶ Play
I'm running it's house bill 1526 and I'll make this very quick I ran a bill earlier in the session the title of it was licensure by endorsement to practice optometry it's through it's now act 143 and it was brought to my attention through the Criminal Justice Information Law Unit, through the Office of General Counsel, through the FBI, that we added essentially saying that the license by endorsement would, they'd be able to do state and national background checks. However, we failed in the drafting of the bill to say that background checks had to be, we had to submit fingerprints in order to do the background checks. That's standard language that the FBI has to have in order to allow background checks. So all this is is cleaning up the original bill that we ran to add the fingerprint section that the FBI has to have or we cannot do background checks. So be glad to take any questions. Seeing
▶ Play
no questions, Representative Pilkin, do you have a question? I jumped the gun. I'm going to say motion at proper time. All right. Seeing no questions, or anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? Seeing none, I have a motion due pass. Representative Pilkington, any discussion on that motion? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say no. Ayes have it. Congratulation bill passed. Representative Sullivan. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee. Thank you. This will be our last bill for the day. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized to run House Bill 1545.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:23:16
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Folks, this bill essentially, as it says in the title, allows the Department of Early Childhood to promulgate regs. Currently, there is a commission, the Early Childhood Commission, that was established in 1998, and they have the approval over any rules or regs that go forward. So essentially, that commission has more power than you as a legislator or more power than the governor's office. Just to make it just a little bit clear, I've worked with the agency quite a bit. I am in that business as a matter of fact the Commission asked me to serve on their review board for any violations so and when they department came to me they said you're trusted by the Commission they think you are knowledgeable and asked me to serve and I served on that again all this does is make the department the sole the early childhood department the sole arbiter of any rules or regs that are made. I have some information with me. I don't think I'll go through it. I'll wait and see if we have any questions. But essentially, the rules of the manual that's made by a child care licensure goes to rules and regs. And when it goes to rules and regs, if the policies are made, unless they violate the law, we as a legislator can't do anything about that. I do have several examples, a whole list that BLR sent me of commissions, and this is the only commission that we have that I'm aware of, that BLR made me aware of, that has this authority. There are some boards that do have promulgation authority, but let me just read a couple of them. The State Employment Security Advisory Council, no authority. The correlation for juvenile justice board no authority long-term care advisory committee no authority home health no authority emergency medical facilities governor's Commission on people with disabilities all these commissions operate is an advisory capacity and that's essentially what this does it doesn't eliminate the board of a commission it only puts the Commission advisory capacity. Also the number of daycares is shrinking. In 2013, private daycares, we had 25, 255 went out of business, 108 started. In 2014, 267 went out of business, 136 started. And we're seeing that trend in private businesses close. More and more of our daycares are being funded through the public sector and your tax dollar. And this committee makes rules. I'll just read you a couple of rules that are in there. And by the way, the Attorney General said in an opinion that the department cannot waive or have an alternative compliance to a rule. So if the commission and the department make a rule, then the department can't go back and say we'll allow you to violate that rule based on some other circumstances. So just some examples. One of the rules says that a new daycare will have a reasonable proposal. I'm not aware of what a reasonable, who determines what reasonable is. It also says that if you have video in your daycare, that the investigators can have of a daycare, I'm sorry, the department can take that video at any time they want. There's no warrant, there's no reason, it doesn't have to be a part of an investigation, that they have access to your video any time it's requested. They've changed the number of students on the ratio. They've dropped it from 6 to 1 to 5 to 1, from 9 to 1 to 8 to 1. Folks, what that does, I talked to a daycare owner the other day that has 40 employees. She was hit this year with the minimum wage rate and changes in this ratio. It's going to cost that daycare over $100,000 this year because she has so many private patients or private care clients. If you're in a Head Start or an ABC program or other program publicly funded, those rates and that increase is funded by the taxpayer. If you're a private daycare and you can't do that, then you just absorb those rates. um they're phasing that in over two years but that was changed to four years do you know that as in your daycare now it's in the regs that they will encourage breastfeeding well that may be a good practice and they may want to do that that's a reg that you are mandated as a daycare to provide. I don't know if they're, how they regulate that or what steps they take to make sure that happens. I could go through several more. You know, infants and toddlers will be, the teachers will be their protector as well as their friend. I don't know what things like that mean. I don't know how one goes about having an audit for those things. I think there are some cases where the commission, instead of having things as best practice, puts them in rules and regs. I think we could get by with some of those things, but now that the commission has more authority than I as a legislator have or you as a legislator have, I think it's time to put that commission under the authority of the agency and make them advisory only. With that, Mr. Chair, I'll take any questions. A question for Representative Love. Mr. Chair, I'm going to pass right now. I represent him, Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So I'm trying to understand the whole path here because normally if a division or agency or whatever has a rule, they promulgate the rule, they have a comment period, and then, you know, once that is all done, and then they come before the legislator, it goes through the legislator before it finally does it. So can you give me the pathway of them promulgating so that I can kind of picture it in my mind when they want to put a new rule or regulation into place? Yeah, the division promulgates the rule, but before they can take it to comment, before they can take it to the legislature, the agency of the commission has to agree. Once the commission agrees, then it can go for comment and then it can go far before the legislature. But that commission can give thumbs up or thumbs down to anything that the division might put forth as a reg. Does that clarify it? It's very unique that I'm not aware of any other commissions that have that authority. there are boards that can promulgate it but this is the only commission I'm aware of that has that authority you recognize for a follow up so if the division wants to put in a new regulation or maybe take away an old regulation if that commission says no then it's done with they cannot bring it before the legislature they cannot go around or whatever bring it before the legislature to actually do it is that correct I won't go into the detail but there's an instance where the The agency agreed that a reg that was promulgated with poverty was not a good idea, and they can't comply. In fact, there are daycares out right now that are out of compliance, that the agency was giving alternative compliance to these daycares. Attorney General's opinion said you can't give an alternative compliance, so we have daycares now who are out of compliance, who can't get in compliance, and the commission refused to, and the agency said, I'd like for you to reconsider what you're doing, and let's modify what we're doing so people can comply, and the commission said no. So we're kind of
▶ Play
stuck there. Representative Fred Love, you recognize for a question. We've been here way too long. Thank you, Chairman Jeff Wardlaw.
▶ Play
Speaker 235 2:32:11
Representative Sullivan, what necessitates this change? Well,
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:32:16
right now we have, there are several things. One, I think previously when something went to rules and regs, whether it was out of respect or whether it was out of deference to, rules and regs could change what went forward. Rules and regs can say, we don't like this in the rule, go back and change it. Recently it's come to my attention that rules and regs, our rules legislators don't have that authority anymore. that whatever is promulgated, essentially whatever that commission agrees to, now the governor can't stop it, you can't stop it, I can't stop it, it goes through. If we would change this, it would make this commission advisory only so that you or any of us could go to the division and say there are things about the rules you're promulgating we'd like to have a discussion about, and we would like for you to change, and we have a little bit of leverage to do that. Currently, the way it stands now, we don't. So by making this change, it will give the legislature more authority and more leverage if we want to negotiate things with the division or with the commission. Thank you. Thank you. Seeing no
▶ Play
further questions or anyone in the audience, Representative Laidman, you got a question I didn't see? Got a couple of those. Anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? See a non-question? Is there anyone from DHS still here? Mr. Chairman,
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:34:08
I have DHS has no position. I recognize you to close for your bill. Okay, thank you. DHS, I spoke with them. They have no position on the bill. They are not for or against it. Folks, I think when you see the list of commissions, the governor has a task force, has some bills on commissions that are reducing the numbers. It's trying to bring the commissions more in line. With what legislative intent is, I think that's what this bill does, and I'd appreciate a good vote. I
▶ Play
had a motion due pass from Representative Ladyman. Is there any discussion on that motion? Representative Bill, continue to recognize.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 2:34:49
I know we're trying to get out of here, so I'll just be real brief. When I was in my administrative residency, one of the tasks I was giving was to look at the daycare at the hospital I was currently working at. We were losing $90,000. I went in to look at the regs. They were ridiculous. is this is a bad oftentimes employers like to offer daycares or part of daycares in order to attract new people to to an area and unfortunately our regs are making that harder and harder and harder so I would appreciate a yes vote on this thank you seeing no further discussion all those
▶ Play
in favor say aye and those opposed the ayes have a representative Sullivan congratulates your bill is prepared thank you we do have a few cleanup items committee stay seated please house bill 1439 by representative Michelle Gray will be moved to defer without objection agreement from the sponsor house bill 1502 from representative Stephen Meeks will be moved to deferred by agreement from the sponsor without objection there was no others moving to deferred today and that's all our business thank you
▶ Play

Agenda

REGULAR AGENDA

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1551 Womack TO STIMULATE JOB CREATION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT WHILE PRESERVING HEALTH AND SAFETY STANDARDS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

3:53 - 1:06:03 193 segments 18 speakers

HB1439 M. Gray TO AMEND THE HEALTHCARE QUALITY AND PAYMENT POLICY ADVISORY COMMITTEE.

HB1504 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM TO MANDATE PRESCRIBERS CHECK THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM WHEN PRESCRIBING CERTAIN MEDICATIONS.

HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO CREATE ADDITIONAL EXEMPTIONS TO THE PRACTICE OF DENTISTRY AND DENTAL HYGIENE; AND TO MODIFY DENTISTRY SPECIALTY LICENSES.

1:06:03 - 1:13:31 22 segments 5 speakers

HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE THERAPY TO INCLUDE THE PRACTICE OF CUPPING.

1:13:31 - 2:24:08 248 segments 27 speakers

HB1545 Sullivan TO ALLOW THE DIVISION OF CHILD CARE AND EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION OF THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO INDEPENDENTLY PROMULGATE RULES CONCERNING CHILD CARE FACILITIES.

2:24:08 - 2:24:29 1 segment 1 speaker

Dan Sullivan

2:24:29 - 1:34:49

HB1566 Hammer TO AMEND THE PROVISIONS OF LAW CONCERNING THE DISPOSITION OF FETAL REMAINS.

1:34:49 - 1:25:13

HB1501 McCollum TO MODIFY AND REPEAL LANGUAGE REFERENCING THE SUPERSEDED ELDERCHOICES PROGRAM.

1:25:13 - 1:36:31 38 segments 8 speakers

SB167 D. Sanders TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; AND TO ESTABLISH THE REGISTRATION OF SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS.

1:36:31 - 1:12:23

HB1465 Miller TO CREATE THE MEDICAID EXPANSION ENROLLMENT FREEZE ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1502 S. Meeks TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION TO THE DEFINITION OF RESIDENTIAL CARE FACILITY AND THE DEFINITION OF ASSISTED LIVING FACILITY.

HB1513 Holcomb TO AMEND THE ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ASBESTOS ABATEMENT GRANT PROGRAM.

1:12:23 - 2:21:47 250 segments 27 speakers

HB1525 Magie AN ACT TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD AND THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO DEVELOP A JOINT APPLICATION FOR COLLABORATIVE AGREEMENTS BETWEEN COLLABORATING PHYSICIANS AND ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSES.

HB1526 M. Gray TO MODIFY ACT 143 OF 2017 TO SPECIFY THAT A CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECK SHALL INCLUDE THE TAKING OF FINGERPRINTS; TO AUTHORIZE LICENSURE BY ENDORSEMENT FOR OPTOMETRISTS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

2:21:47 - 2:16:07

HB1550 Davis TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING NONMUNICIPAL DOMESTIC SEWAGE TREATMENT WORKS AND THE NONMUNICIPAL DOMESTIC SEWAGE TREATMENT WORKS TRUST FUND.

HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.

HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APPLICABLE TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES; AND TO CLARIFY THE PROCESS NECESSARY FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO QUALIFY FOR PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY.

HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; AND TO ESTABLISH THE REGISTRATION OF SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS.

HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES FROM THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD.

HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBSTITUTIONS.

HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT.

HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ACT; AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.

HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLOW AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO BE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.

HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSE.

SB148 G. Stubblefield TO CREATE BORN-ALIVE INFANT PROTECTION.

2:16:07 - 1:30:52

SB301 J. Cooper TO ALLOW THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH TO SHARE IMMUNIZATION REGISTRY DATA WITH FEDERAL, STATE, AND LOCAL JURISDICTIONS.

1:30:52 - 1:28:23

HB1609 Tucker TO INCREASE FLEXIBILITY IN THE LAW REGARDING FREQUENCY OF PAYMENT OF WAGES.

1:28:23 - 2:36:01 229 segments 26 speakers

HB1613 Barker TO EXEMPT A LONG-TERM CARE OMBUDSMAN FROM REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR ADULT MALTREATMENT, LONG-TERM CARE FACILITY RESIDENT MALTREATMENT.

HB1624 Leding TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO WAGES EARNED ACT.

HB1625 Leding TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO KNOW YOUR PAY ACT.

HB1626 Pilkington TO AMEND THE PROHIBITION OF PHOTOGRAPHY IN LONG-TERM CARE FACILITIES.

HB1628 B. Smith TO CREATE THE HEALTHCARE FREEDOM OF CONSCIENCE ACT.

HB1635 Eaves TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING UNDERGROUND STORAGE TANKS AND SECONDARY CONTAINMENT.

HR1030 Hammer PROMOTING THE AWARENESS OF PEDIATRIC ACUTE-ONSET NEUROPSYCHIATRIC SYNDROME AND PEDIATRIC AUTOIMMUNE NEUROPSYCHIATRIC DISORDER ASSOCIATED WITH STREPTOCOCCAL INFECTIONS.

HB1651 Boyd CONCERNING SOLICITATIONS AFTER MOTOR VEHICLE ACCIDENTS.

HB1653 Miller TO CREATE THE DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES WAIVER DEATH NOTIFICATION ACT; AND TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PUBLISH CONCERNING THE WAITING LIST FOR THE ALTERNATIVE COMMUNITY SERVICES WAIVER PROGRAM.

DEFERRED

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS CONCERNING PROHIBITED CONDUCT AND REMEDIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS.

HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN ELECTRICIAN".

HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONCLINICAL SETTING.

HB1300 Miller THE TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIORITIZE SPENDING WITH DEPARTMENT AND THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO FULLY FUND HOME- AND COMMUNITY-BASED SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES.

Page 2 of 3

HB1515 Ladyman TO PROVIDE LOCAL CONTROL OVER FLUORIDE LEVELS IN WATER SYSTEMS THAT SERVE FIVE THOUSAND (5,000) USERS OR FEWER.

HB1255 D. Ferguson TO CREATE A TEMPORARY CHARITABLE DENTAL LICENSE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Jeff Wardlaw Chair Unverified
116 segments
Speaker 3
1 segment
Speaker 6
2 segments
Speaker 10
1 segment
Speaker 17
1 segment
Speaker 24
177 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
57 segments
Speaker 55
2 segments
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
5 segments
Representative Richard Womack Unverified
1 segment
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
13 segments
Representative John Payton Unverified
1 segment
Representative Fredrick J. Love Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 131
1 segment
Speaker 132
1 segment
Speaker 134
7 segments
Speaker 152
1 segment
Speaker 52
1 segment
Speaker 160
4 segments
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 172
3 segments
Speaker 182
3 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 196
1 segment
Speaker 273
54 segments
Speaker 217
1 segment
Speaker 79
1 segment
Representative Aaron Pilkington Chair Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 138
1 segment
Speaker 278
1 segment
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 202
1 segment
Speaker 237
1 segment
Representative Justin Boyd Unverified
1 segment
Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 223
1 segment
Speaker 120
1 segment
Speaker 351
1 segment
Speaker 261
1 segment
Speaker 220
1 segment
Speaker 235
1 segment