Judiciary Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (35)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1668
· 6 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ill 1663, I anticipate that we'll run that on Thursday. and house bill 1668 let's check we'll check with representative lemons and see…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1433
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…248 to deferred. And without objection, we're going to move house bill 1433 to deferred.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1542
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1542 Shepherd ADDRESSING THE SEALING OF A PERSON'S FELONY RECORD…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1665
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1665 Vaught TO CREATE A CAUSE OF ACTION FOR UNAUTHORIZED ACCESS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1055
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “House Bill 1055, I anticipate Representative Hammer would like to bring tha…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1198
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…embers, we're going to go back up to the top of the agenda, House Bill 1198.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1236
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1236 Gazaway TO PROTECT THE PRIVACY OF SURVIVING FAMILY MEMBERS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1248
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1248 J. Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INF…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1251
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…enda. House Bill 1382, Representative Gassaway is not here. House Bill 1251, Representative Walker. I will go ahead and run House Bill…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1382
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1382 Gazaway TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE COLLECTION OF A SMA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1577
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1577 Hammer CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF ARSON; AND CONCERNING THE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1578
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…is way over here to run that in a few minutes. Likewise for House Bill 1578. Representative Tucker has House Bill 1629, 1630, 1631, 117…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1629
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…es. Likewise for House Bill 1578. Representative Tucker has House Bill 1629, 1630, 1631, 1173, and 1175. And we're going to, at his req…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1657
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…tative Hammer would like to bring that back up on Thursday. House Bill 1657, Representative Gasway, he's not here. House Bill 1659, ano…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1658
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “All right, without objection, we're going to move to House Bill 1658, Representative Tucker. 1658, it's on page two.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1659
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1659 Tucker CONCERNING INSTALLMENT PAYMENTS BY A PERSON WHO OWES…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1663
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1663 Boyd TO BE KNOWN AS THE MENTAL HEALTH SPECIALTY COURT ACT O…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB102
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1095
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1095 Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1152
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEME…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1173
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1175
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1175 Tucker TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1265
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1265 Richey CONCERNING THE POSSESSION AND CARRYING OF A CONCEALE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1268
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1417
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1417 Sturch CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF SEXUAL SOLICITATION; PROVI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1444
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1444 Ballinger TO REVISE CERTAIN EMINENT DOMAIN LAWS THAT ARISE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1483
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1483 Shepherd IN TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO AND REPEAL O…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1630
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1630 Tucker TO PROTECT CHILDREN FROM UNATTENDED LOADED FIREARMS;…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1631
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1631 Tucker CONCERNING A WARRANTLESS ARREST FOR DOMESTIC ABUSE.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1685
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1685 Tucker TO CLARIFY THE CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS REQUIRED F…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1686
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1686 Tucker CONCERNING THE TRACKING OF AND ACCUMULATION OF DATA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1687
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1687 Tucker CONCERNING A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER ON THE CAMPUS O…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1713
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1713 Lowery TO ESTABLISH MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE AS A SEVENT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB113
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB113 J. Hutchinson TO REMOVE A DRIVER'S LICENSE SUSPENSION OR RE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB136
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB136 J. Hutchinson TO CREATE THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE EFFICIENCY AND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
committee will come to order chairman sees a quorum we members we're going to try and work through our regular agenda again today let's see is representative vault here
We're going to, a couple, a couple items of housekeeping, um, based on the sponsor's request without objection, we're going to move house bill 1248 to deferred. And without objection, we're going to move house bill 1433 to deferred.
All right, without objection, we're going to move to House Bill 1658, Representative Tucker. 1658, it's on page two.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm going to invite Ms. Laurie Compuris with the Prosecuting Attorney's Association to join me at the end of the table. Apologies to the members for y'all having to look through several bills with the name Tucker next to them to find this one. This is a bill that the Prosecuting Attorney's Association brought to me.
And I'll just give a quick explanation and let Laurie fill in the blanks for where I'll leave it off. Essentially, there was a court ruling that said that a consensual sexual relationship between two adults cannot be criminal. What currently this is, is that it creates a criminal violation for Someone who's employed with ADC, community correction, DHS, or a city or county jail. If they have a sexual relationship with someone in their custody, then it's sexual assault in the third degree.
And so there was a court case that essentially said consensual sexual relationship between two adults cannot be criminal. And so in order to essentially preserve this crime, you have to add in some language. And so the point there is that if the actor, that is the employee of ADC Community Correction, DHS, or a city or county jail is in a position of trust or authority over the victim. And they use that position in order to compel the sexual relationship, then it's a crime. And so that'll basically preserve the ability to prosecute this crime,
which is obviously a behavior that we do not want to condone in Arkansas. So that's the gist of it, and I'll let Ms. Kempuris chime in.
Speaker 23
3:17
Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, I'm Lori Compiris, the Deputy Prosecutor Coordinator, and that explanation of the bill is a really good one. The only thing I would add is that the court case that came down was dealing with a situation with a teacher and a student, and it said, you know, if the student's over 18 could not
be criminal without a particular language, so what we've done here is add in the language. They have the person employed by the Department of Corrections or other facility has to be in a position of trust or authority, and they use that position of trust or authority. And that just kind of monitors the language that was done in the teacher-student context. I'd be happy to answer any questions. Any questions from the committee? All right, seeing none,
Representative Tucker, are you closed for the bill? I move to pass. I appreciate a good vote. All right, we have a motion to do pass. Is there any further discussion? All in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Tucker, while you're there, do you want to go ahead and run the Senate concurrent memorial resolution number
two? Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for the opportunity. This is a concurrent resolution, so it's going to go through both chambers.
We've already done it in the Senate where Justice Corbin's family was able to join us. But this is a resolution to honor former Arkansas Supreme Court Justice Donald Corbin. He served in the Arkansas House during the 1970s for 10 years, and then he served for 24 years on the Arkansas Supreme Court, authored over 1,000 opinions, and is a longtime colorful political personality in Arkansas who made real contributions to our state, and this is just a resolution to honor his service.
Any questions? All right, no one signed up to speak on the resolution, close for the resolution. Yes, sir, I move to
we have a motion do pass, is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Members, we're going to go back up to the top of the agenda, House Bill 1198.
This is to concur in a Senate amendment. Representative House,
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, this is Representative Robin Lundstrom's bill, and she's asked both Bob Ballinger and I to get it through here for her.
As you can see, the Senate adds some clarifying language, made it a little bit more broad. We're talking about hot pursuit cases across state line, and it clarifies that we will honor those chases. and the Senate amendment so we concur in the amendment first and then I guess concur in the amendment. The
Speaker 41
6:40
bill has amended. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. All right. Are there any questions?
Move to pass. No one has signed up to speak for or against the amendment.
We have a motion to concur in the Senate amendment. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Thank you, Representative House. Do I need to move the bill as amended? My understanding is
Speaker 132
7:08
if we just adopt the concurrence in the amendment, that's sufficient. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you.
All right, members. Moving on down the agenda. House Bill 1382, Representative Gassaway is not here. House Bill 1251, Representative Walker. I will go ahead and run House Bill 1542.
on the House bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'd like to ask Brad Cazort with ACIC to join me at the end of the table for the presentation of House Bill 1542. This is a piece of legislation that was brought to me by ACIC. It brings some consistency to the law related to sealing of certain criminal records.
Many will recall that I believe, it was either four or six years ago, there was an effort to try and bring some consistency to the sealing or expungement statutes because there's several different sections. And that was something that the legislature had worked on. The ACIC brought this to me and asked that we pass this bill to bring some consistency and clarity to the provisions related to sex offenders and their inability to have their records sealed.
It's really just, and this is something that I've gone over a number of times here. You can see on page two of the bill that certain sexual offenses were not eligible for sealing under the old law. This basically brings consistency and doesn't really substantively change anything, except we're making reference to 12.12.901 for the definition of what a sex offense or a sex offender is.
And so with that, I would defer
Speaker 50
9:45
to Mr. Cazork for further comment. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Brad Casort with the Arkansas Crime Information Center. When the Comprehensive Criminal Sealing Law was passed four years ago or six, I don't remember, it did not allow any sex offense, any felony sex offenses to be sealed. The First Offender Act was not really amended at that time, and under the First Offender Act, some sex offenses could be sealed and some sex offenses could not be sealed.
Essentially, if you're offended against a child, you could not seal it. If you offended against an adult, you could. So the purpose of this is to bring the First Offender Act into line with the comprehensive sealing law so that no sex offenses can be sealed.
Any questions from the committee? Seeing no questions, no one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Shepard, are you ready to close with your bill?
I'm closed, and I would move, do pass. Okay, we have a motion for do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. Congratulations, Chair. Thank you, members.
We're going to continue down our agenda. There's a couple members that are trying to make their way over to run bills in our committee. But in the meantime, we'll continue to go down through the agenda. House Bill 1577, Representative Hammer is supposed to make his way over here to run that in a few minutes. Likewise for House Bill 1578. Representative Tucker has House Bill 1629, 1630, 1631, 1173, and 1175. And we're going to, at his request, we're going to continue to hold those on the regular agenda.
House Bill 1236, Representative Gassaway, not
here. Can we have a Tucker special order one? House
1417, Representative Sturge, Senate Bill 102, Senator Rice, House Bill 1433, we've already moved that to deferred.
House Bill 1055, I anticipate Representative Hammer would like to bring that back up on Thursday. House Bill 1657, Representative Gasway, he's not here. House Bill 1659, another Representative Tucker's bill, we're going to hold that. Representative Vaught is supposed to be on her way over to run House Bill 1665. House Bill 1663, I anticipate that we'll run that on Thursday. and house bill 1668 let's check we'll check with representative lemons and see if he's able to come
over and run that the remainder of items on the agenda uh i believe just came over yesterday and so my preference is to to let those stay on the agenda for one more meeting so if the committee will sit tight hopefully we'll get some members in here to run some bills shortly Thank you.
All right, Representative Lemons is here. I believe he has House Bill 1668.
You're recognized, President, House Bill 1668. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. I would like Ms. Sarah Wells, who's here to give testimony, for her to please come forward. And I didn't know I could get from Carti to here in six minutes. That's pretty good. So if I'm breathing into the mic, I'm sorry. I'm just trying to catch my breath. Oh, I mean 16 minutes.
You recognize, present the bill. Thank you, sir. House Bill 1668, basically what we're trying to do here is to strengthen the penalties for repeat offenders on DWIs. It takes the public service out as an option for the punishment for your fourth DUI or DWI in four years or your sixth, all the way up to sixth DWI in 10 years. And what I'd like to do is, it's a common sense bill, but I want to turn it over to my expert witness here, Ms. Wells.
Speaker 75
16:01
Thank you guys for allowing me to speak. I have a little bit prepared, so I'm just going to read through it if that's okay. Again, my name is Sarah Wells. I live in Lone Oak County. I have four beautiful daughters, all of whom I would fight for to my last breath. Today, I fight on behalf of my oldest girl, who happens to be my child via marriage. She is 13. She's in the eighth grade dance team. She runs in track. She's smart, gorgeous, and she has a negligent mother who is an alcoholic.
I'm here today to encourage you to do all you can to get House Bill 1668 passed. Ladies and gentlemen, our current DWI laws are flawed and are in need of repair. There are gaping loopholes in our current laws that allow repeat offenders to avoid real-world consequences. And I have witnessed firsthand how the current DWI felony law has failed to protect the public and my children. Since my oldest child has entered my life six years ago,
I have witnessed a breathtaking amount of ways in which the DWI laws are failing to protect the public and to correct the offenders. On August 14th, 2015, my child's mother got her fourth DWI. And since then, she has not stopped driving, she has not stopped drinking. She has been sent to multiple outpatient rehab facilities. She has been ordered AA classes multiple times.
She has worn an ankle monitoring device. The vehicle that she drives is not in her name, so it has never had an interlock device installed in it. So she continues to drive, and oftentimes with children in tow, I try to inform any adults that I know to not allow their children to ride in her vehicle, and it has not stopped anything. I have called the authorities every time I have seen her come to my house or leave school functions, and it has not stopped. She continues to drink.
I believe that she's in the drug court program now, and I believe that it's actually enabling her to believe that she is above the law and that she can wiggle through the system. In January, she has received two violations, one of which has been formally reported. And she served two out of four of the non-consecutive jail time days that were sentenced to her. She is currently in 60 days of rehab as part of the first violation and not her second violation,
which was a public intoxication in Hot Springs on New Year's Eve. And so because of that violation, she also now has a standing warrant for her arrest because they will not arrest her while she's in a mental health facility. um i'm i'm just asking that we close the loopholes that the drug court system is not designed to help people um who who feel that they can work the system and public service shouldn't be allowed either in my opinion um my child personally has been put in harm's way multiple times
and there have been other children that have also. And now that she's in our careful time, my focus now has shifted to our community, the people that share the streets with her, because she doesn't stop drinking. She doesn't stop driving. All right. Representative Tucker, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you for being here
today. I just want to ask Representative Lemons. I just want to be sure, so the disqualification from the drug court is on the sixth offense, is that what you said?
Speaker 83
19:55
Is that right? It's for all colonies. Actually, I believe it kicks in at the fourth.
It does? Okay. Yeah, I believe it's the fourth on. Within five years? Yes, within a five year period, or if you're really
habitual, six within a ten year period. Thank
you. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lemons, I just want to make sure I understand about the passenger being under 16 years of age.
And I guess where I'm a little confused on that is the fact that is this on any offense, any one of the offenses leading up to what would be considered the fourth offense, which would constitute a felony, or how is that going to work? Does it have to be on each offense, or can it stand alone on any one offense to receive those additional sentence
and penalties? Actually, we did not change that part of the law. But it does say here, if I'm reading it correctly,
that with your fifth or subsequent offense occurring within a five year period of the first offense. And then it talks about that with the 16-year-old. That it becomes an unclassified felony in the event that you have a 16-year-old in the motor vehicle or the motorboat at the time of the offense. So it's already part of the law. Representative Petty, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you so much for being here. I was just wondering where the prosecutors and the judges stand on this.
Speaker 75
21:34
I mean, is there any- I've written both the prosecutor and the judge, the prosecutor more than once, and the judge once. I've gotten no response, but she's still in the drug court program. She used to report back to the program when
could you have addressed? I can say that this has been vetted with BLR and their legal staff.
And we have not taken it past there to go to the judges or the prosecuting attorneys. But to me, this is one of those common sense bills that, I mean, it's rare that someone gets multiple DWIs. We're talking about people that have had four or more DWIs. I mean, common sense tells me that you've got to be for something like this. Representative Ballinger,
you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Have you, and there's not a fiscal impact on this, but have you talked to anybody about the fiscal impact?
I mean, how many people are we talking about?
I have not. I have not. In fact, I tried to Google that today to see if there was any listing of people in Arkansas with four or more DWIs, and I can't find the database. So that tells me that it's a very small amount. We could request it on the Senate end if necessary. Well, my
recommendation, and I'm just one of the committee, but would be to have that information before we actually have it come out of committee. And to just know what it's going to cost before we do it.
But it really just depends, unless somebody in this room can answer, as to how many people are not being incarcerated after a fourth offense DUI within five years. That's really the question that we need. Representative Blake,
you're recognized for a question. Mr. Chair,
uh, representative lemons that the only new language that you're adding into this statue is online on page three line 16, right? And it's that it's charged with a felony violation of driving or voting while intoxicated, which would be what represent about just as four fences in five years.
Is it just a clarification? That's that's the only
new language. Actually, any mention, uh, it goes back to the first page. The last two lines are being stricken from the first page. Okay. Basically, anywhere that it said four or more offenses where public service was allowed were striking out at that point. So first, second, and third DWI, we're not messing with that. But people that have got four or more, the public service just obviously is not working. Thank you. Yes, sir.
I do have a question because I think that there may need to be a clarification here. It appears, and there's certainly plenty of other people on this committee that can correct me, that what this bill has basically four components to it. The first three are that public service is not available in lieu of jail time for a fourth, fifth, or sixth offense DWI within a five-year period. Then this language that is added to the drug court program,
based on my reading of it, it would make any DWI offender ineligible for drug court, irrespective of whether it's first, second, third, fourth, fifth, or sixth, because 565.103 is actually, that's the, I believe that's the prohibiting statute. That's the actual underlying DWI statute. So I think if the intent is to exclude drug court for the fourth, fifth, and sixth offenses, there may need to be some language added or clarifying.
And somebody can correct me if I'm wrong about that, But it just appears to me that we're actually would be excluding drug court for any DWI or any
voting while intoxicated offense. Representative Whitaker. Mr. Chair, if we're looking at line 1617, sub D, it does specify felony violation. Okay, so the felony, yeah, that's right, felony
clearance. All right, good. See, I knew there was somebody who could correct me on this.
Yeah, what he said. All right. Very good. All right.
the only one that signed up on the bill, so there's no one that signed up to speak on the bill. Representative Lemons, you're recognized
to close for the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. To kind of put this in simplest terms possible, a person convicted of one DWI, at a minimum, they've demonstrated poor choice.
A person that is convicted of multiple DWIs, and we're talking four, five, six, they're just a direct danger to society. And we need to get their attention and do what we can to protect Ms. Wells, her children, and everybody else that's out there trying to make a living and have a good life. And with that, I'd ask for
a good vote. Okay. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative House? Okay, we have a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion? All in, Representative Ballinger, you're recognized.
I think that what he's doing here may be good and beneficial. I mean, especially when you talk about the specific case with the facts that we have, it seems like it's a good idea. And oftentimes, any kind of change tends to get pushed back on. And I don't want to be the guy who's pushing back on change. But one of the things that we are doing here, and basically the only thing we're really doing here, is taking away discretion from the court, and yet we've not heard from the court or
heard from the prosecutor, and maybe that's my own fault. Maybe I should have looked at this bill, I'm assuming it hadn't been filed a real long time, and visited with them. But what I'd hate to have is to step forward and pull this discretion away without really thoroughly vetting it. And at this point, we don't even know what it's going to cost us. So I don't want to be one to kill a bill, especially something that's a good idea. However, what I would say is that it'd probably be better for us to not pass it.
In fact, at the appropriate time, I'd have a substitute motion. Representative Tucker, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman,
and I'll just repeat something I said in here a few weeks ago. I concur with Representative Ballinger's comments. I would be curious for the judge's feedback on this. And just looking at the first three parts that the chairman referenced about prison, I really don't have a problem with. When it comes to the drug court, if you just look at the language in section two,
And the only other three categories of people we exclude from drug court are violent felons and sex offenders. And so, if someone just has a drug charge, for example, even if it's a felony drug charge, we don't exclude them from drug court. And those programs have proven to be effective in Arkansas for people who have substance abuse problems. And so, I understand the punitive aspect of people needing to go to prison for, But I would hate to exclude someone from a substance abuse type program that might benefit them.
And so I just would be curious to hear kind of from the judges about that also, in terms of how the drug court programs work for the repeat DWI offenders in
their court. Any other discussion? Representative Ballinger, what's your motion? My motion would be
to table it unless the sponsor wants to pull the bill down. And then, I would withdraw my motion.
Mr. Chair, we are willing to pull the bill down until Thursday. We'd like to come back with the answers to
these questions. Okay, very good. With that, if Representative Ballinger's withdrawing his motion and if Representative House withdraws his, we'll let you take the bill down and look for you to come back on Thursday. We'll be here, thank you very much for your time. Thank you, Representative Lemons. All right, Representative Vaught,
You're recognized to present House Bill 1665. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'll
can. I've asked Mr. Robert Coon to come to the end of the table to help me with any questions, and if my voice totally gives out, I'll just let him take over.
House internal threats to employers have greatly increased within the wide availability of technology. House Bill 1665 is modeled after a new enacted law in North Carolina in 2016. This legislation strengthens employers' defense against common forms of corporate espionage by prohibiting any person from placing a camera or an electronic surveillance device on the employer's premises without permission.
The legislation also prohibits employees from capturing or removing the employer's data, paperwork or records from recording sounds or images. This legislation is not tailored to one specific industry. In fact, it offers a protection for employers of all sizes and all industries from having their financial employee, customer, and business practices information illegally disclosed. In an effort to protect this legislation from constitutional challenges, it prohibits for
stiff civil penalties to be enforced through a private right of action instead of a criminal penalty. Again, I apologize for my voice. And with that, I'm through. All right, any
questions of the committee? Representative Howes, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
Representative Vaught, and I appreciate y'all coming. As I was looking through the bill, something occurred to me.
A lot of times lawyers and equal opportunity people will advise a victim of sexual harassment, usually a female, but not always, to record the actions of an employer or supervisor or co-worker to document what's happening to that person, doesn't this bill tell them it's illegal to do that? Robert Kuma, the Impact Management Group, representing
Speaker 132
32:59
the Arkansas State Chamber. Let me pull up the legislation quickly to see if I can help answer your question.
you do have on line 27 on page two where it says this section does not diminish the protections provided to employees under state or federal law that may cover some of that um you know part of that would depend on uh also if you look up where it talks about uh records records images or sound on page it's also on page two lines six seven and eight records images or sound occurring within an employer's premises and uses it to breach the person's duty of loyalty to the employer? I don't
know that that specific case would breach their duty of loyalty to the employer if there's, you know, criminal activity that's occurring in
the workplace. Well, sexual harassment's not necessarily the criminal. Yes, it is. Thank you, Mr. Chair. It is
criminal. That is criminal. Representative Tosh, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate the use of your microphone. A couple of quick questions. Just for clarification, I need to make sure I understand this. Law enforcement, this does not prohibit them in any way from entering those premises or doing what they would need to do as far in regards to their jobs. Is this correct? Correct. Yes,
Speaker 132
34:46
sir. That's correct. They're specifically exempted on line 34 on page 2 under lawful investigation. That's correct. Okay, and
I apologize for not reading the entire bill, and I would have noted that.
But anyway, second question, and, you know, sometimes, and I think the Representative House alluded to this, that sometimes there are occasions when people are asked to do certain things in the performance of their duties, and a good example of this would be in the event that maybe a private investigator was hired to conduct some type of surveillance, and they were under contract to do so, their licensed investigator here in this state, what would be their authority in regards to this?
I know law enforcement is exempt, but in the performance of their job and trying to do their work, would they also be excluded, or can you make comments in regards to that? I would say that a private investigator, number
Speaker 132
35:41
one, if they were doing it on behalf of the employer, they would have the employer's permission to do so. If they were doing it on behalf of an employee, perhaps the employee could seek the employer's permission for them to do so. You know, there are private investigators required to follow the law
as it relates to burglary statutes and all those other things already today. So, you know, if there are specific situations in which there's a concern about that a private investigator, I think we'd be happy to entertain those. But I think as an overall rule, I don't know that whether or not you're a private investigator and you are seeking to surveil inside someone's private property. I don't know that necessarily that's something that we want to occur kind of as a blanket level.
Well, without permission. Well, most of the time when they do those surveillances, it's without permission. And the law doesn't keep them from being able to do that. But what I'm saying, when you use the word premises, I think that's pretty broad in the terms as what that could, for example, when you say premises, are you talking about just the places of employment? Are you talking about premises like where they live or their private property there? How far would this be extended, the language that's in this bill?
So, I mean, if it was interpreted by a court, would it be extended to that individual's private property? Or are we talking about just their place of employment? I probably shouldn't have
Speaker 132
37:13
used the word premise. The bill's specific to the non-public area of an employer. That's what it says in the bill, non-public. Okay, no
further questions. Representative Charlene Fite, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You had mentioned the chamber being in support of this bill. What other
Speaker 152
37:44
organizations have come out in support of this bill? Council of Agriculture Council, Farm
Yes, ma'am. Representative Blake, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just a clarification on Representative House's question.
I know we mentioned on page two, line six about number two, but number three basically say if you place on employer's premises and unattended camera or electronic surveillance device and be using the unattended camera or electronic surveillance device to record images or data. Can you explain how with Representative House's question, how this statute will?
Speaker 132
38:49
I think it's a good question, to be honest with you, Representative Blake, and the sexual harassment question had not come up prior to us visiting with any members, so I don't know exactly how to answer your question, but I do think it's a good question. Representative Tucker, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, I'm following up, I had a similar concern as Representative Tosh. Because I think you all mentioned that under subsection C, it's addressing employers, right? But under subsection B, if you read a person who knowingly gains access to a non-public area of another person's premises, that seems to me to apply to all private property in Arkansas. And so I think I could be reading that wrong, but- I think
if it's a farmer's land, it would apply to that, yes, because that's his premises, that's his industry, that's his work, that's his job.
So I think it would be. And so using that as an example, you know, if Game and Fish or some other wildlife tracking expert puts a camera to track animal, you know, activity or something like that, I think it probably should apply to people's homes. I mean, I know where y'all are going, and I think it should apply to people's homes. But I just worry about kind of the scope of that and just wondering if y'all had contemplated that when you were drafting it.
Speaker 132
40:27
Well, I think the intent was to make it the non-public area of the premises. And whether that's, you know, a home, you know, non-public area above it, you can see, you know, the definition. It's not accessible or intended to be accessed by the general public. And so, I mean, if it is a non-public area, you know, that means it is someone's private property. And therefore, someone who is not authorized to be on that private property shouldn't have access to surveilling their private property. Can I have a follow-up, Mr. Chairman?
So one other question I have is, you know, the term that you all mentioned earlier, duty of loyalty. I mean, there are some duties that exist in the common law. But that's not one, to my knowledge. And so I just don't know if that needs some fleshing out or some definition because that's not otherwise defined in the law to my knowledge. And like the chairman said earlier, if someone can correct me on that, I would be very open to that. But that seems to me to have a term that should have meaning that I don't think does have meaning otherwise in the law.
Speaker 132
41:32
I just wonder if you all had any thoughts on that. I think part of the reason for that language is if you don't have something there that puts some boundaries around recording images or sounds within an employer's premises, that obviously that can be entirely too broad in scope, where someone might be using a phone to do something completely innocent, and therefore you have to have something from an intent standpoint to say that they are trying to do something that violates their responsibilities or duty as an employee at the business.
So, you know, we could certainly, you know, the language might not be something that fits within an existing duty or scope. You could, you know, you could probably reword that to say is consistent with their employment responsibilities at the place of business or something like that. But that's what that language is ultimately trying to get at so that you don't have something that says you can't record anything ever for any reason, because obviously that's not the purpose. Thank
MR. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Draw your attention to the very last paragraph of the bill, subsection G, where it specifically exempts state agencies, state-funded institutions of higher education. My gut is that that was to basically leave some safe harbor for our whistleblower statute. Is that correct? Or can you give me the justification of why this is only applying to evidently private companies?
Right, that would be covered. Okay. This doesn't diminish the protections currently provided at any way provided to employees under state or federal laws. Doesn't diminish
any of those. Okay. Follow up? I'm a little concerned about the chilling effect it might have on private whistleblowers. You exempt all these state agencies, but I call to mind the fact that we finally brought the big tobacco to the table to get the settlement because their employees had brought forth documents, data, et cetera,
where they had fake studies, they had lied to Congress, et cetera. Would a cause of action stand against someone who worked for, say, a tobacco company who wanted to divulge the company's lies? I
Speaker 132
44:00
think if those protections were already in the statute under whistleblower statutes, then they would prevail because they're already in the statute.
I'm concerned about private industry, where we may not have the same controls that we certainly do in state agencies.
Speaker 132
44:16
I'm just wondering if you know. Right, and I wasn't referring to those exemptions in G. I was looking back up to F1, where it says this section does not diminish the protections provided to employees under state or federal law. I would assume that the whistleblower statutes would fall under that category, not under the specific agencies that would be exempted. Thank
you. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. And again, I just want to try to make sure I understand just how broad the scope of this bill is trying to go.
And here's my question. You made a statement a while ago, and you said that in an answer you were providing to someone, You made the statement that you said that if you don't have a legal right to be on that property, then you would not be allowed to do a surveillance of that property. Well, that's two different issues. One is, even if you don't have a legal right to be on the property, I can understand that. But still, a surveillance of that property, does this language go so far that it includes the scope of it to the point that if you're not on that property, you no longer can do a surveillance of it?
Can you help me understand that? Are you talking about police officers? No, no, I'm talking about anyone that would be, as may reference a while ago, to a private investigator, anyone that wanted to do a surveillance of that property. In other words, if you're watching it for whatever reason, you drive by and you take a video of it, would this law say that you just violated this statute? Did you get on the land? Even though you're not personally on that person's place of abode, would you have violated this statute if you were standing in the street and you did a surveillance of that property?
Speaker 132
46:01
I wouldn't think that that would be considered a non-public area. If you can see it with your eyes from the outside, I mean, that's a public space. Okay, and that's
why I just want to make sure we've not got this bill, the scope of it, so broad that we, you know, we go that far with it that we prohibit those type of activities because some people have jobs to do, such as private investigators or anyone else in the performance of those duties, and we've really restricted that in the event that that would occur.
That's a public, that would not be considered non-public.
Speaker 132
46:39
and and and if you take on down from non-public and you look at the you know this this the items under section c you're talking about capturing or removing data paper records which you wouldn't be doing from the street recording images occurring within an employer's premises placing on the employer's premises an unattended camera i think placing it on the premise is different than filming something from across the street.
Conspires in an organized theft of items. I mean, I think the language down below that kind of gives the scenarios that fall under what's actually in the premises inside the non-public area versus something that would occur outside with visual line of sight. Representative Tucker, you're recognized for
wondering, you know, what the hole in the law is that compels this.
You know, are there cases that, you know, examples where something has happened that can't be addressed either in civil or criminal court? Part of the
Speaker 132
47:51
reason, and Representative House and I talked about this briefly before committee, you know he kind of asked why doesn't theft of property cover some of this and I think to some degree that it does but I don't think theft of property covers all of what we're trying to get at I mean this is intended to address corporate espionage activist employment at an employer's
place of business and also anti-competitive you know you have one employer the employee that knows they're going to work for somebody else and they steal all the files or copies of all the files and all the sales records to take them to their next job. You know, sometimes you have intangible property within a place of business that if you discover that it's been stolen or taken or filmed or what have you, it's hard to put a value on that. So if you're going to try to go through the theft of property, take it to a prosecutor,
number one, they have to decide whether they want to pursue it. Number two, they have to figure out what the value is. In many cases, it's hard to determine the value, therefore it might not meet the standard that they want to have in order to file a case. So this mainly gives an employer the ability to have a civil cause of action to enjoin the activity and to provide damages that ultimately would discourage the type of behavior that we're trying to avoid. So some theft of property may cover small parts of what we're trying to do, but I don't think that the statute, especially being on the criminal side, covers everything that this bill would do.
Hopefully that was helpful. Thank you. Any other questions? All right. And no one has signed up to speak for or against the
bill. Representative Vaught, would you like to close for the bill? I'll say this. In just a few seconds, somebody can destroy any employer, any farmer, anybody with this device right here. And it's being used
daily to destroy people's lives. So I would ask for a good vote. All right. What's the
pleasure of the committee? Representative Brown? A motion do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Thank you. Thank you.
Okay, Representative Hammer is supposed to be coming over to run some bills. Senator Hutchinson's here. Okay, we're going to take up a motion from Representative Ballinger. Okay, Representative Ballinger, you recognize for your motion? Thank
you, Mr. Chair. This is more than anything, just an effort to create some clean up on a bill that we're going to be working on.
But on SB 102, there is an amendment of DTP 124. I just make a motion that we expunge the vote by which that amendment passed. All right, we have
a motion to expunge the vote on Senate Bill 102. Any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay, the motion passes.
While we're waiting on Representative Hammer, Senator Hutchinson, SB 136 came out of the Senate yesterday and it's on our agenda. We're not going to actually take a vote on the bill today, but I'm going to allow Senator Hutchinson and Representative Tucker to begin discussing the bill for the benefit of the committee. And Senator Hutchinson, you're recognized. Thank
Speaker 191
52:13
you, Mr. Chairman. And hopefully we can get any questions answered today and I won't bother you all again with my presence at least.
Senate Bill 136 is a result of several years, at least a year and a half, two years worth of work done a lot by the chairman of this committee. He and I chaired the task force, criminal justice task force. And it had stakeholders from all over the state, from judges to prosecutors, to public defenders, to everybody who's involved in the system. And through the course of that year and a half study,
this was a result of recommendations were issued and this bill reflects those recommendations. There's really two components of it. One has to do with the mental illness and how we treat and deal with those people who police encounter almost on a daily basis who are struggling with a mental illness. And I'll let Representative Tucker, who chaired that committee, discuss that. I'll talk about what we're doing with our parole and probation in this bill.
Currently, to understand what the bill does, you have to understand how we're currently operating. And I don't think once you understand how we're currently operating, you can defend it because it's, in my opinion, indefensible. But currently for technical violations, which can be anything from testing positive on a drug test to missing a meeting to not reporting that you've moved, or it can be all sorts of stuff. So for technical violations, our options right now are very limited.
We can revoke somebody for a technical violation or for a minor misdemeanor, which is a hot check or something that's nonviolent, nonsexual misdemeanor, we can revoke them. And we've done that 1,650 times. So our prison beds, we have 1,650 prison beds that are being occupied on an average of 12 and a half months per stay by technical violators who are really just knuckleheads.
They just are addicts. They've got life issues, but they, at least while on probation and parole, haven't done anything violent or may not even have committed a crime, and they're sitting in our second crime, at least. They're sitting in our prisons. Meantime, we are every 90 days releasing violent offenders, a lot of them, through the Emergency Powers Act. So you all may not realize this, or you may, but every 90 days, our parole board releases 150 to 200 inmates who are far more scary than the technical violators.
And they're doing that so they can create bed space for the incoming people who are awaiting county jails. So this bill says we're going to rearrange our priorities. We're going to reallocate our resources and use those 1,600 beds for criminals, for threats to society. So what do we do with the parolees and probationers who have violated the terms of their, done a technical violation or committed some minor misdemeanor.
Well, traditionally, right now, we threaten revocation, and we have done it 1,650 times. But there's probably 30,000 times that we just threaten, and it's a hollow threat. And probationers and proleys, most counties know, yeah, they're never going to revoke me for that kind of stuff. And so there's no teeth, and we're not able to impact behavior, because while we may threaten it, we're not going to revoke them. This bill will say we're going to, again, reallocate our resources.
Department of Community Corrections will be able to house for up to 45 or 90 days technical violators and people who commit a minor misdemeanor. So the way it would work is if they're committed a technical violation, community correction can immediately send them to a facility, community corrections facility, to be there for 45 to 90 days and get some treatment. We hope that after that commitment that they come back and walk the straight and
narrow, but if not, we can send them again a second time for 45 to 90 days. And after two of those commitments, revocation is an option. But for the technical violators and the minor misdemeanors, non-violent, non-sexual misdemeanors, we're first going to give them 45 and 90-day commitments at the Department of Community Correction. That, quite frankly, is far more severe on our probation and
parolees than currently where we just threaten them with revocation. but rarely do we ever follow through with it. So it's swift, it's immediate sanctioning, which is all the data suggests is how you change behavior. And threatening and never going through with it does not change behavior. So this has been done by a lot of other states in the South and across the country, and every single state that's done it has seen lower recidivism rates, lower crime rates, lower cost to the system as a whole,
and just better results all the way around. There's no opposition to it. The prosecutors were initially concerned, but after hours and hours and hours of meeting with them, and I commend them and appreciate their willingness to meet that long, we've amended the bill several times in the Senate end, and they are now neutral on the bill. Your sheriffs have endorsed it. County judges have endorsed it. The chiefs of police have endorsed it.
So with that, I'll let Representative Tucker talk about the mental illness side and then
take questions if there are any. Thank you, Senator, and thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Hutchinson referred to the Criminal Justice Oversight Task Force and Senator Scott Flippo and I also chaired a task force on access to behavioral health treatment for the criminal justice population. And that task force was obviously composed of the two of us, but So Dan Honey at the Insurance Department, Kevin Murphy at the Department of Community Corrections, David Sterling at DHS, and then some mental health and substance abuse providers out in Arkansas.
And the two recommendations in the legislation came unanimously out of that task force. And as the senator mentioned, these are strongly supported by the Association of Counties, the county sheriffs, and mental health providers in Arkansas. And as I mentioned, there are essentially two mental health pieces in this legislation. The first is that we're going to provide crisis intervention training for every law enforcement officer in Arkansas. For every new officer is going to get 16 hours of training, whether they're for a municipal agency, a sheriff's department, or the state police.
And what this has shown is that officers are much more equipped to be able to identify someone who's having a mental health crisis. and then give them the tools to deal with that person at the time the crisis is happening. So not only are we going to provide that basic level of training for every law enforcement, we're also going to provide advanced training for at least one officer in every department. And for the bigger departments, they'll obviously have more than that. But what they found in other states, and I'll just use Mississippi as an example,
is that when a CIT officer, a crisis intervention trained officer, goes to a scene where someone's having a mental health crisis, They're able to identify and de-escalate that situation 52% of the time on-site without having to take them anywhere. And that serves that person much better. It serves our county jail system much better because they don't have to take someone who's in the middle of a crisis to the county jail where further problems often present themselves. And so it's just better for the system and the taxpayer all in all.
And so it also goes without saying that if someone commits a serious crime or violent crime, they're going to be taken to jail. So this is truly for someone who's just having a mental health crisis. And at the task force, you know, we had testimony from several sheriffs, but one example that stuck with me was from Sheriff Bill Hollenbeck in Sebastian County where someone was loitering because they were having a mental health crisis. They had to take him to jail because they had nowhere else to take him, where he assaulted an intake officer because he wasn't in full control of his faculties at the time.
And so after that, he was sentenced to prison for several years, and his life has changed forever. The people of Arkansas had to pay to incarcerate him for a couple years, and that's just not the smartest use of our resources. And so the first part is to get the officers the training to be able to de-escalate those that can be de-escalated. So the second part is, for those that cannot be de-escalated, you have to have somewhere to take them other than a jail. Because the jails just aren't suitable places to take someone in who's in the middle of a crisis.
And so we're going to create what's called a crisis stabilization unit. And these are 16-bed facilities. They have eight in Mississippi, eight in Oklahoma, they have them in Memphis. So they have them all around us. And what they do is they're places where you can take someone who is having a mental health crisis. They are presenting a danger to themselves or others, so they can't stay at home or wherever they may be. And so they go to this CSU, this crisis stabilization unit, for one or two or three days or however much time it takes in order to be stabilized.
And what they find is a lot of times people even go voluntarily. They're not in custody when they go because they recognize they're having an issue. and they know there's a safe place that they can go to get the treatment they need to be stabilized and then go back into the community. So the way these crisis stabilization works in our neighboring states is that the people on the ground at the CSU, they have a great relationship with law enforcement, and they also have a great relationship with mental health providers in their community. And so when someone gets presented to them through the criminal justice system, they're able to connect them into the network that they need for the support that they need
in order to have a stable, fulfilling life where they can contribute to society. And so just as the senator mentioned on the other side, with this we really feel like we're taking better care of the people who need that care. We're actually going to reduce crime. If someone with a mental health crisis goes into a county jail, their recidivism rate is 80%. If they go into one of these crisis stabilization units, the recidivism rate is 20%. So we actually believe we're going to reduce crime and enhance public safety and then save taxpayer dollars all at the same time.
So that's pretty much it on the mental health side.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I really like a lot of things about this, especially the crisis stabilization unit. But I had a question I wanted to ask you, a scenario, and you tell me how it would be affected by this bill if it passes. Let's say that a young woman has a serious drug problem and she repeatedly fails to do community service. The judge wants to send her to a regional corrections unit for drug treatment.
Would this bill, if it passes, prohibit him from sending her there because she's nonviolent? Well, first, I'm
Speaker 191
1:04:11
assuming she's on probation. And her sentence wasn't just community service. She was put on probation for a term of years or something? Well, I hadn't really thought that far into
my scenario, but let's say yes. Okay. If someone's not on
Speaker 191
1:04:27
probation or parole. This bill has no impact on them, right? Yeah. So if the judge has sentenced them to community service and they refuse,
then the judge can do whatever he wants or she wants with the person. But if they are sentenced to probation, let's say, and then in addition to that sentence to some type of community service that they're refusing to do, I mean, they can first of all file contempt, and the judge can sentence them to the county jail or whatever they want to do for contempt, for failure to follow the judge's orders. But for probation, if probation wanted to deal with it, I mean, I don't know if that would be considered a technical violation
because that's a separate part of a sentence. I don't even think this would apply there because that would be another portion of the sentence that they're not complying with. Probation, the way probation works, they say you're going to be on probation, we're going to supervise you for X number of months or years or whatever. And then there's terms of probation that include drug tests, that include you're not associating with known felons,
You're not associating it going to bars or places that you meet once a month or however often with your probation officer. Those are the types of violations that we're referring to. If somebody fails a drug test, right now our only option, we can send them to the county jail for a few days, which is an important tool. But there's no treatment there. There's no, it usually doesn't work, quite frankly,
though it's an important tool and we don't want to get rid of it. What this would do is say for 45 days we're going to send you to a place that there's treatment, and it's 45 days. It's long enough to get clean, and you're going to be in some, it's not perfect treatment. You can't be perfect in 45 days. But it can also be up to 90 days or even up to 180 days for some instances. So what we do now is nothing, really. We threaten them, we threaten them, and we typically don't end up doing anything.
And they eventually just term out, and we've not improved their life at all or their behavior at all. This allows us an additional tool that, hey, we're serious, and we're so serious, you need to grab your toothbrush because you're going to be gone for 45 days. And when you come back, you better start listening to me. and abiding by the terms of probation. So I don't know if I answer your question, if that was a term of probation and
they violated it, this would give us an extra tool to punish them. Whereas right now, the tool that we have is revocation, which is rarely ever used, and it's a really ineffective tool. Does that make any sense? Can I just chime
in real quick? You know, community correction, for the people who are in their facilities, they do an effective job with their substance abuse programs. And so, you know, the programs by and large are now 270 days,
and so these are obviously going to be much shorter than that. But they are developing specific substance abuse programs for these populations. And so, you know, there is specific to your question. I think this was part of your question. Specifically, there will be. So it's not just a tool to punish, which it is to some extent, But it's also a tool to rehabilitate and get them back on a path where they're not dependent on that. And so those programs will be within the Department of Community Corrections. And the other thing that I'll say, the Senator may have mentioned this in his original point, but
if you did I apologize for repeating it, but I think it's worth mentioning that if at any point someone on probation or parole, if the Department of Community Corrections, so the probation or parole officer or prosecutor deems that a particular individual is a threat to the community, regardless of whether they have satisfied the terms of what's in the legislation, then they can be fully revoked at that time. Any other questions? All right, if not, we'll take
Speaker 191
1:08:56
So let me say right now, I'd appreciate a good vote when you all do vote. I mean, I hope I don't. If I need to come back, I will. Representative House, you're recognized. I don't want to keep reminding
you of that performance you had at the basketball game.
I have no doubt. With as many shots as you put up, you should be. Representative House, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I just want Senator and Representative, I want to thank you all very much for the two years of work on the task force I got to attend some, but certainly not all of your meetings and the work and all the behind the discussions that necessitate the work you did.
Thank you very much. This is much needed, and we see some really major improvements. Like any other major work, there's going to be something in here somebody don't like, and that's fine, but that's the nature of the beast. And thank you so much for working this bill up to both
Speaker 191
1:09:54
of you. It's important. Well, I appreciate that, Representative House, and I do appreciate your often attendance. And I will say, those of you all who may remember different attempts at criminal justice reform,
I mean, I was here back when Governor Huckabee was doing it, and those attempts were, Governor Huckabee's was to eliminate 70% offenses, where you don't have to serve 70% of your sentence. And it was done to ease prison overcrowding. And Governor Beebe at Act 570 was in it, and we had a lot of good stuff in 570, but there was some lowering of sentences and increasing burdens of proof and on drug offenses. But they were both just, they weren't well researched or studied just because they didn't have much time.
It was all just kind of responding to, this is the first time that I'm aware of in 20 years or so that it's really based on data. and it's two years of analysis and talking to every stakeholder. And so I think it's significant, not just because of the bill, but because of the process. And Representative House and the chairman were certainly part of that. So thank you for your comments, and thank you to everybody who assisted in it over two years.
All right. Thank you for presenting, and we'll take this bill up possibly Thursday, but certainly we'll take it up at a later meeting. Representative Hammer is here. I believe he has two bills to run, and I think that'll wrap up our business for today. Representative Hammer, you're recognized to present House Bill 1577. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
House Bill 1577 comes as a result of a situation that happened down in Saline County several years ago. There was a major forest fire that destroyed thousands of acres, tied up valuable resources with the Forestry Commission. And also many individual private property owners were adversely affected by this arson. What was interesting was that things kind of went quiet on the matter for many years then after the statute of limitations had run out of it. Some information became available where it became known as to who the individuals were that possibly set this fire.
The problem was that it had gone past the statute of limitations. And so I was asked by a constituent to look at extending the time of which the offense of arson could be considered for prosecution. And one of the things I'd like to give you for perspective on this, if a house is burned down, which all things are valuable and nobody should do arson, I'm not trying to make one better or lesser than the other. But if a person's house burns down, typically you can get that be rebuilt in a shorter fashion of time. But when you burn down somebody's potential retirement in the way of timber or
lumber, it is years before that can be rebuilt. And so for that purpose, I'm before you today to ask and I would simply state that we would extend the length of time of which prosecution could be taken on somebody who commits arson and it would be up to ten years. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'll be glad
to take any questions. Representative Blake, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative, I almost called you. Representative Hammerin, you know what I was calling. I know. What's the current statute of limitation?
I think it's six years, if I'm not mistaken, maybe seven, six or seven. Representative Tucker. Any other questions? Go ahead. I understand that this is taking it beyond what is consistent in other areas. But I would appeal back to the fact that we're talking about timber land. We're talking about a crime that's hard to solve and talking about a real life example that happened that proved if they'd had that little extra time,
they would have been able to help the people accountable.
Thank you. Any other questions? Okay. No one has signed up. Representative Hammer, are you closed for your bill? Yes, sir. I appreciate a good vote. Thank you, Mr. Chair. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Tosh moves do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Representative Hammer, you're recognized to present House Bill 1578.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Basically, what this bill does, if you're looking at it, if you get over to page two, that's where the meat of the bill begins to occur. What this bill does is expand that in times of protest or specifically if that protest moves from peaceful into a writing status, it gives our emergency medical service personnel a little bit more latitude as far as holding somebody accountable if they interfere with the operations of the emergency medical services personnel as they are defined on page 2.
It does identify on page 2, line 11, the distinction of knowingly, which is just a general awareness, and then you move down to line 18. It talks about a person who purposely, which is a conscientious objective, to engage in the activity itself. What this is intended to do is that if you are participating in a peaceful march, which we have a lot of those around the Capitol, that's well and good. One thing I want the members of the committee to know is that this does nothing as far as circumventing the ability to protest peacefully.
That's not what's intended to happen, nor does it by the way this bill is written. But in the event that something moves from a peaceful protest into a status of rioting, Or if that protest begins to interfere with the ability of emergency mental personnel to do their job, it does bring higher penalties to them as spelled out on page two. You get over into page three and four, some of this actually is just a little bit of clean up. The bill drafter caught a couple things that he put in there as far as cleaning up some specific things on page three.
But then the rest of the meat of the bill is over on page five. On page five, beginning down with line 25 and going to the end, one of the things that this bill does is it creates an avenue that if you're an individual that is adversely affected by somebody who is protesting but specifically moving toward the angle of rioting, it creates avenue where you could take civil action against that person. Or in the event somebody brings in a group of people to protest, it allows the opportunity for you to bring civil action against them in case you're adversely affected.
For example, your store gets burned down or you have a baby that's in the ambulance and that baby cannot be transported because you have purposely blocked the highway and that has adversely affected you. You may think I'm making that stuff up, but here's a copy of an article of last year, what happened over in Memphis on I-40. This isn't somewhere else. This happened here, and that's part of the reason why this bill is being presented to you today. So it does three things. It gives greater protection to those that are in the emergency mode,
holding accountable those that are interfering with those that are operating in emergency mode. It also brings a higher standard in the bill that you cannot block the interstate or municipal road or local road. It brings a higher level of accountability if you do that. And then if your action adversely affects somebody else, it creates that avenue where you can hold them accountable. The one thing I want you to remember as I begin to close is this. It doesn't interfere with anybody protesting peacefully. We have that happen around here all the time.
We have all segments of life that peacefully protest around this Capitol, and we want to preserve that right. But when the bad actors move in among those people and start doing things that adversely affect other people, What this bill does is raise the bar as far as holding them to a higher standard of accountability and allows you as a citizen to civilly seek damages against them if that has adversely affected you. And with that, I'll be glad to answer any questions, Mr. Chair. Representative
Blake, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. On line 25, number 10, a riot means violent conduct by three or more persons acting in concert it creates a substantive risk of causing public alarm or disrupting the performance of governmental function. Can you explain what causing public alarm is and what the definition of disrupting the performance of a governmental function? Yes, sir,
and actually that is current law as written now. The new segment that's added is D, which is the impending of travel or
public right of access to the road, highway, or thoroughfare designed for transit. So A through C is already in current language, it's just restated here. And I know it's underlined in reading bills, in my mind, I can get confused pretty easily. But what it does is take each one of those current three, adds the fourth one, D, and it sets it to the higher tone of violent conduct. So I don't know if that answers your question, but that's our current language, adding number four. And it defines, actually, I just remembered riot was not as defined before as it is being defined in this bill.
So when the word riot was used, it was pretty open and vague. This bill creates a definition of what we mean when we say riot. So some of that was already in there. We just put it together in the package.
Representative Tucker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Hammer, my question actually was about subpart D there. And my question is, I know sometimes when folks have a parade or a protest or whatever the case might be that's peaceful, they'll go through the proper channels and actually close the street.
And so, I think you're trying to get at the situations where they don't do that. But I guess I'm just wondering if the language as it is might subject someone, Because if you have properly closed a street and you're marching down that street or whatever, you are impeding travel or public access, right of access to a road.
do, and I think the answer might be this. It is contained in the Section 2, which identifies the word riot.
So it has moved from the situation that you've described, just like recently the one that Right to Life. You know, we used to be able to march out here and come up to the Capitol this way, but then the police department wanted to charge a $2,000, so they got permission, $2,000, so I heard. So they got permission, and now we come from the backside of the Capitol. You know, that's all done in a peaceful, organized manner, and in that scenario, nobody's going to be impacted because it's all done within what's allowed by the law.
D is put in there so that if it was to, say, either move from a peaceful to a riot status or it just full-blown started out as a riot status and they blocked the highway, then that's why that was put in there. So I really don't think that it's going to affect the example that you used. Thank you, Mr. Thank you. Representative Whitaker, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hammer, we're going to stay on D for a second.
I'm reading this, and I think I'm reassured, but I would like to hear it from you, too. I think my concern on D is that let's talk peaceful. What if in purely nonviolent direct action a group walks out, sits down, and blocks a street? They're not rioting, are they, under this
new language? I don't think they would fit the description of rioting as defined,
but I think that they are going to have problems in other areas where I think it's mentioned in section seven. Section seven, page four, drop down to line 33. Class A misdemeanor under subdivision of this section is a person obstructs vehicular traffic or federal interstate highway or state highway. Because they're not operating or conducting themselves in what is defined as riot status, they've just peacefully gone out there and done that, they're only going to be able to be arrested under that section that I just read.
Disorderly conduct. For disorderly conduct, which would carry the Class
A misdemeanor. But they wouldn't be charged under the riot. They wouldn't meet the definition of a riot because the opening phrase says violent conduct, correct?
was vague before. But we don't want those folks doing what you just illustrated. That doesn't really rise to the occasion of somebody that's inciting a riot. They need to be dealt with, so they would be dealt under the disorderly conduct.
and what is number down there on line 33 of Section 7. Thank you. Thank
you. Representative Blake, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. On Section 3, line 25 on page 3, there's new language added. Employees, contracts, or pays another person, group of persons, or entity representing or employing more than one person to engage in, instigate or participate in a riot. Why is that new language added?
Because it goes to the side that it goes to the civil damages. If you are an organization, a group that transport people in here purposely, knowingly to conduct in a riot status, let's say, or maybe it starts off peaceful and it goes to a riot status. Now, this is my personal opinion. That's why I'm running this bill. I think that if you bring people in and it turns into that, I think I have the right that if I've just had my 18-wheeler locked down on the interstate for four hours,
and I've lost a load of product because you've moved into this mode, then I think I have the right to go after you, and I think I have the right to go after the people that would have helped make that
happen by bringing people in to do that. Follow-up. So if family counsel brings in people for the Right to Life march, and something happens during that march, we have to, the law enforcement has to determine if their intent was to engage or instigate the participation.
I think that's all going to be settled between two lawyers and a judge in a courtroom, and this provides that opportunity to be determined. But if, you know, if family council brings in members and it is, I mean, it would all end up having to go to court, and that's part of what this piece of legislation is going to create the avenue to help happen. You know, if my 18-wheeler has been shut down because family council brought a bunch of people in and they said, you know, put your butts in the middle of the interstate and block the interstate, then I think I need to have the right to hold family council or anybody else, you know,
accountable in a court of law because I've just been adversely affected by them. Any other questions? No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Hammer, would you like to close for the bill? I did run this by law enforcement and those that would be impacted by it. There was no opposition ran by the Prosecutor Association. There was no opposition from any of those entities. All right. What's the pleasure of the committee?
Representative Smith moves, do pass. Okay, we have a motion, do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. And on the other matter, if I don't have that cleared up and ready to go by Thursday, I'll ask for the chair to move it to the deferred list. Thank you. Thank
you, Representative Hammer. Members, I believe that concludes our business for today. The remaining items on our regular agenda were just assigned to our committee yesterday, and I'm still trying to at least allow a day so
everybody can see it's on our agenda, and if there's no further business before the committee without objection, we're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1198 Lundstrum TO ALLOW AN OUT-OF-STATE LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO FOLLOW A VEHICLE INTO ARKANSAS TO INVESTIGATE A FELONY OR THE OPERATION OF A VEHICLE WHILE THE DRIVER IS INTOXICATED, IMPAIRED, OR UNDER THE INFLUENCE.
RE-REFERRED TO COMMITTEE
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1382 Gazaway TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE COLLECTION OF A SMALL ESTATE BY A DISTRIBUTEE; AND TO ESTABLISH PROCEDURES TO BE FOLLOWED AFTER A CLAIM IS FILED AGAINST A SMALL ESTATE.
REGULAR AGENDA
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1251 Walker TO CREATE THE "HELPING OUR PEOPLE EXCEL (H.O.P.E.) ACT OF 2017"; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.
HB1542 Shepherd ADDRESSING THE SEALING OF A PERSON'S FELONY RECORD WHEN THE PERSON IS A FIRST-TIME FELONY OFFENDER.
HB1577 Hammer CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF ARSON; AND CONCERNING THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR ARSON.
HB1578 Hammer CONCERNING OFFENSES INVOLVING RIOTS, INTERFERENCE WITH EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES PERSONNEL OR FIRST RESPONDERS, DISORDERLY CONDUCT, AND OBSTRUCTING A HIGHWAY OR OTHER PUBLIC PASSAGE; AND ESTABLISHING CIVIL LIABILITY.
HB1629 Tucker TO PROTECT VICTIMS OF DOMESTIC ABUSE AND STALKING; AND PROHIBITING A PERSON CONVICTED OF MISDEMEANOR DOMESTIC BATTERING OR STALKING FROM POSSESSING A FIREARM.
HB1630 Tucker TO PROTECT CHILDREN FROM UNATTENDED LOADED FIREARMS; AND TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF NEGLIGENTLY ALLOWING ACCESS TO A FIREARM BY A CHILD.
HB1631 Tucker CONCERNING A WARRANTLESS ARREST FOR DOMESTIC ABUSE.
HB1173 Tucker TO AMEND AND MAKE CONSISTENT THE OFFENSES OF SEXUAL INDECENCY WITH A CHILD AND SEXUAL ASSAULT IN THE FOURTH DEGREE; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "SEXUAL ABUSE" UNDER THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.
HB1175 Tucker TO REQUIRE LIFETIME REGISTRATION ON THE ARKANSAS SEX OFFENDER REGISTRY FOR A PERSON CONVICTED OF RAPE WHEN THE RAPE INVOLVED THE USE OF FORCE.
HB1236 Gazaway TO PROTECT THE PRIVACY OF SURVIVING FAMILY MEMBERS OF A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER WHO DIES IN THE LINE OF DUTY; AND TO EXEMPT CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT RECORDS FROM DISCLOSURE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1248 J. Williams TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967 CONCERNING CERTAIN LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIVE RECORDS.
HB1268 Murdock CONCERNING THE USE OF AN IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE.
HB1417 Sturch CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF SEXUAL SOLICITATION; PROVIDING FOR IMPOUNDMENT OF A MOTOR VEHICLE; AND PROVIDING FOR HUMAN TRAFFICKING AWARENESS EDUCATION FOR EDUCATORS.
SB102 Rice TO CLARIFY THE LAW CONCERNING THE FINES, FEES, AND COSTS THAT MAY BE ASSESSED FOR A VIOLATION OF THE MANDATORY SEAT BELT USE LAW.
HB1433 Baltz TO PROHIBIT A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER FROM LIVING NEAR A FACILITY WHERE PRSON WITH A MEDICALLY DIAGNOSED MENTAL DISABILITY OR PHYSICAL DISABILITY RESIDES.
HB1055 Hammer TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PURPOSES OF DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE.
HB1657 Gazaway TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS AND TO REPEAL OBSOLETE LAWS FOUND IN TITLE 27 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE.
HB1658 Tucker CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF SEXUAL ASSAULT IN THE THIRD DEGREE.
HB1659 Tucker CONCERNING INSTALLMENT PAYMENTS BY A PERSON WHO OWES COURT COSTS, FINES, OR RESTITUTION TO A CIRCUIT COURT.
HB1665 Vaught TO CREATE A CAUSE OF ACTION FOR UNAUTHORIZED ACCESS TO ANOTHER PERSON'S PROPERTY.
HB1663 Boyd TO BE KNOWN AS THE MENTAL HEALTH SPECIALTY COURT ACT OF 2017; AND CONCERNING MENTAL HEALTH SPECIALTY COURTS.
HB1668 Lemons CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF DRIVING OR BOATING WHILE INTOXICATED; AND CONCERNING THE DISPOSITION OF A DEFENDANT CONVICTED OF DRIVING OR BOATING WHILE INTOXICATED.
HB1685 Tucker TO CLARIFY THE CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS REQUIRED FOR AN APPLICANT OR EMPLOYEE OF A CHILD CARE FACILITY OR A CHURCH-EXEMPT CHILD CARE FACILITY.
HB1686 Tucker CONCERNING THE TRACKING OF AND ACCUMULATION OF DATA CONCERNING THE FAMILIAL OR RESIDENTIAL STATUS OF A VICTIM OF A SEX OFFENSE.
HB1687 Tucker CONCERNING A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER ON THE CAMPUS OF A PRIVATE SCHOOL.
SB113 J. Hutchinson TO REMOVE A DRIVER'S LICENSE SUSPENSION OR REVOCATION AS AN AVAILABLE PENALTY FOR OFFENSES NOT RELATED TO DRIVING A MOTOR VEHICLE.
SB136 J. Hutchinson TO CREATE THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE EFFICIENCY AND SAFETY ACT OF 2017.
SCMR2 Bond IN RESPECTFUL MEMORY OF JUSTICE DONALD CORBIN AND IN RECOGNITION OF HIS MANY CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.
HB1483 Shepherd IN TO MAKE LEGISLATIVE CORRECTIONS TO AND REPEAL OBSOLETE LAWS CONTAINED TITLE 27 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE.
HB1713 Lowery TO ESTABLISH MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE AS A SEVENTY-PERCENT CRIME.
DEFERRED BILLS
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1095 Johnson CONCERNING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE FOR A CURRENT OR FORMER MEMBER OF THE UNITED STATES ARMED FORCES.
HB1265 Richey CONCERNING THE POSSESSION AND CARRYING OF A CONCEALED OR UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; TO ESTABLISH A LICENSE TO CARRY AN UNCONCEALED HANDGUN; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS.
HB1152 Watson CONCERNING THE ABILITY OF AN AUXILIARY LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN AND TO BE EXEMPTED FROM THE LICENSING REQUIREMENTS TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN.
HB1444 Ballinger TO REVISE CERTAIN EMINENT DOMAIN LAWS THAT ARISE OUT OF PROPERTY RIGHTS SECURED UNDER THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION, ARTICLE 2, § 22.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Chair
Unverified
Representative Clarke Tucker
Unverified
Speaker 23
Speaker 25
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Speaker 41
Speaker 132
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Speaker 50
Speaker 54
Representative Tim Lemons
Unverified
Speaker 75
Speaker 83
Representative Rebecca Petty
Unverified
Speaker 91
Representative Bob Ballinger
Unverified
Representative Charles Blake
Unverified
Representative David Whitaker
Unverified
Speaker 26
Representative DeAnn Vaught
Unverified
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Speaker 152
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 191
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Speaker 211
Speaker 212