Revenue and Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (37)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1535
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1535 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND U…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB114
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB114 Hester TO AMEND THE NOTICE REQUIREMENTS RELATED TO PROPERTY…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1014
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1014 Leding TO CREATE THE TEACHER'S CLASSROOM INVESTMENT DEDUCTI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1028
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1031
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1037
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1037 Wardlaw TO REGULATE THE SALE OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY; AN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1153
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS"…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1221
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1225
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSUR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1227
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES;…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1252
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1253
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1263
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1395
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EM…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1396
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1396 Leding TO EXEMPT FROM THE INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX EDUCATION S…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1397
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMB…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1399
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1409
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVIC…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1412
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1412 Ballinger TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION F…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1449
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1512
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDU…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1531
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1531 G. Hodges TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EDUCATIONAL LO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1559
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1559 Jett TO AMEND THE CORPORATE INCOME TAX WITHHOLDING REQUIREM…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1565
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1565 Jett TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE AND EXPIRATIO…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1582
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1582 Dotson TO EXEMPT CERTAIN ELECTION EQUIPMENT FROM SALES AND…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1647
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1647 C. Douglas TO EXCLUDE MANUFACTURER REBATES ON MOTOR VEHICLE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1649
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1649 C. Douglas TO AMEND THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR NEW…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1680
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1680 Jett TO CLARIFY THE ABILITY OF THE DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTME…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1681
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1681 Jett TO AMEND THE DEFINITIONS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TAX PROCED…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1682
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1682 Jett TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS TAX PROCEDURE ACT CONCERNING BUS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1683
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1683 Jett TO ESTABLISH A MILEAGE AUDIT APPEAL PROCEDURE FOR REGI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1684
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1684 Jett TO EXTEND THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR DETERMINING T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1693
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1693 Rye TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1772
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1772 Jett TO IMPROVE THE FAIRNESS OF PROPERTY TAX ADMINISTRATION…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB120
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX,…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB140
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB140 Files TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB362
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB362 L. Eads TO SUNSET CERTAIN TAX INCENTIVES; TO AMEND THE LAW…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
Representative Hendricks agreed to do this for Representative Hammer to get him out. I think he's running another bill. We're going to start off with Senate Bill 114. And we're going to call this meeting to order. And we're going to start off with Senate Bill 114. Representative Hammer, if you don't care, sir, recognize yourself. When you get
ready, feel free to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chamber. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, and with the chair's permission for the sake of expediency of time, Could I have some folks that are going to present with me come to the table?
Yes, sir. Just when I get down to the end of the table, just recognize yourselves. Does
Josh want to, you want to testify, Josh? It'll
be Cindy Walker, Josh Curtis, and Andrea Lee. Cool. Just when you need them, just recognize yourself, please. And then Representative Hammer, feel free to proceed, sir.
Thank you. I'll let them introduce and then go forward, sir.
you, Mr. Chairman. Members of the committee and Mr. Chairman, Mr. Chairman, what you have before you today is a bill that would be referred to as a good efficiency government bill in that it brings to current times best methodologies in order to keep the public well-informed with regards to information that is pertinent and needs
to be available to the community, but at the same time respects the fact that as times go on that county governments need the opportunity to manage their budgets a little bit better. And so that's basically what this bill is about. I know this has probably had a lot of PR, a lot of attention and everything. So what I would like to do for the sake of time, Mr. Chair, is give each one of the presenters that's sitting with me an opportunity to just share from their perspective how this bill is valuable and beneficial with the Chair's permission. You bet. That sounds good. Yes, sir.
Speaker 18
2:06
I kind of run down the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee, for allowing us to present this bill today. First off, what we've, these county collectors brought this bill to our attention last year and we noticed kind of some problems with the publication of delinquent minerals. Right now, the way this works is if somebody is delinquent on paying their mineral parcels taxes, they are put in the newspaper and you've got to pay $1.50 to put that in the newspaper.
And then if they're not paid in a year, you've got to pay $1.50 again and put it in the newspaper. If it's not paid by then, it goes to the land commissioner's office and certified there. Right now in the land commissioner's office, there's over 55,000, roughly 55,000 delinquent mineral parcels in the land commissioner's office. Last year, there was seven parcels that were redeemed. And the way you can redeem these parcels is you'd have to be the surface rights owner
or the actual owner of the minerals. So it's easier for somebody to take your house because the land commissioner's office puts these houses in real estate up for public auction, but that's not how it works with minerals. So what we're asking in this bill is to allow the county collectors to publish these delinquent mineral publications on a county website and a statewide website as well. It would save counties lots of money.
And for instance, I'll let Cindy go into kind of the numbers, what she has in her office and what it saved her county and how we'll be able to reach more people by publishing this on a website rather than in a newspaper that maybe only have a circulation
Speaker 7
4:04
of 10% of the population in that county. Thank you. Columbia County has been collecting royalty tax since the 1930s.
Recently, we've had a boom down there with our producing minerals. And in 2014 is when, well, in 13 is when we had our second big boom and a lot of wells were drilled and are producing. In 2014 tax year, I had 10,655 delinquent mineral parcels to be published.
that cost the county $15,982 to advertise. A lot of times, the minimum value on hours is $1.50. So it's exactly doubled by the time you put that publication cost on them, plus your penalty in interest.
And I get so much feedback from people from California, Arizona, Oklahoma, I don't read your local paper. I even send out a postcard after the deadline, October the 15th. I mail out these trying to get my publication list down. It's hard to budget what you have that's going to go delinquent this year,
and I've made my budget last year to know. I've had to go before quorum court and ask for money so I could put it in the newspaper by the December 1st deadline because you cannot know who will pay and will not pay to kind of estimate your publication cost. We have collectors in the Fayetteville Shell area that their producing mineral amount is less than the postage
that they are required to send it. And so when we look to our tax base and the people think we are crazy because it's bad government for us to spend that kind of money and charge them that much to get it. And so it's just a good cleanup bill, stop wasting taxpayer dollars,
and let's get it out there in a more efficient way on the web where people in California and Arizona can have access to it. Thank you. Mr. Chair, if I may,
can I have Andrea Lee present at this time? You can. Thank you.
Speaker 30
7:19
How are you doing, Andrea? I'm excellent, Mr. Chairman. Thank you very much for having me here today. I was asked to come and present just facts of what happened after this body chose two years ago
to free up my having to file all of our unclaimed property across the state. Previously, we were required by law to advertise one day a year in all 75 counties in the newspaper of record. And that was costing us approximately $200,000 each time. This body two years ago changed that for us. and instead the law states now we just have to put a small ad in and then advertise on our website
and use other methods. You also asked us to put it in the law to make sure it was in each county courthouse. The Association of Arkansas Counties also puts all our information on their website as well. The results, I'm just here to share facts, the results were we instead have spent $30,000 instead of $200. And last year was a record year. We turned back 5,000 more properties, not at doing the names listed out in the newspaper. I think Representative Hammer said
it best. It's a best methodologies. When I came into office, I had an exit interview with the chief of staff for the auditor's office. And I asked them if there's one thing you could change. Um, if you, you know, if you were staying, if there's one thing you could change, what would it be? And their answer was specifically the law that you all changed for me two years ago because their hands were tied in where they could spend their advertising dollars. Thank you for joining us, Representative Armstrong, Representative Murdoch. Good to see you. Good to see you. Um,
basically it expanded our options that allowed us to utilize more effective and cost efficient, means that kind of matched the 21st century. So we still advertise a small advertisement in papers, but we don't list all the names any longer. And I think our numbers just simply prove that that move was a good one. So I want to thank you for what you did two years ago. And like I said, they just asked me to share the facts today. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am.
Speaker 18
9:40
Mr. Nehammer, are you ready for questions, sir? And I will say to follow up on Auditor Lee, we took a lot of the language that was in her bill and included in this bill, posting in the county courthouse and on the county website
as well as on our website. Okay. I'm ready for questions, Mr. Chair, or if I can have the right to defer to
one of the experts if that's allowed, please. You can, sir. I feel your pain, I understand. So, Representative Johnson, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. These, of course, local newspapers wouldn't be happy if we passed this, but that's neither here nor there. So, the mineral, the taxes that you're trying to collect or that are liquid are only on active producing wells, correct? Yes, sir, that's correct. Okay. Is there any way, because, you know, when I'm doing somebody's taxes, I get their 1099 that says they had $600 in money, and they had this in severance tax and this in this tax.
Could we get those companies that are operating those welts to pay that tax for them?
Speaker 7
10:49
We tried that several years ago and got shot down big time. Okay. We would love it. Okay, thank you.
Speaker 41
11:03
Thank you, Mr. Chair. President Gray, you recognize her? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have a couple of questions. one to the expert at the end of the table from the auditor's office.
You said you'd spent $200,000 in print advertising, and now you're spending only $30,000 in print advertising, or your entire ad budget is $30,000 now, or ad spends $30,000 compared to $200,000. That's
Speaker 30
11:27
a good clarification. Thank you, Representative Gray. Really intelligent question, and I really appreciate it. You're a really good guy. He needs all the encouragement he can get these days. Mr. Jeremy, can I go get my boots, please? No. Actually, that's totally legitimate. We spent $80,000, just using last year's numbers,
we spent $80,000 in total advertising. Of that, $30,000 was print, and that's in comparison to the $200,000. So less than half was spent overall with, I felt, much better results as far as how much we turned back to how many Arkansans
Speaker 41
12:09
got their money back. Thank you, ma'am. Mr. Chair, we'll follow up another question. And I guess, and I apologize, as you may have, I was in and out when you first started your testimony. But the final cost of advertising this also gets passed on to the taxpayer.
This is just a burden of trying
Speaker 7
12:30
to get it collected. Is that the? Yes, sir. The county pays for the publication upfront, and then as the individuals pay their delinquent tax, that money goes back, that $1.50 goes back to county. So the county does- If
Speaker 41
12:51
they pay. If they pay, absolutely. Yeah. And so, and finally, Mr. Chair, thank you. There was a very similar bill in the last General Assembly to remove all notices from
local print and to go to internet. And one of the major questions, nonpartisan or bipartisan questions was the internet accessibility and ease and also the usage of the Arkansas County's website versus what counties that are maintaining their own website. So you had the question of access, you had the question of ease of usage and user-friendliness, and then just the visibility once it was on the Internet.
And all of those were issues that ultimately defeated that measure. Can you answer those a little more specifically to
Speaker 18
13:45
this bill? Yes, sir. Thank you, Representative. And you said you came in a little late, but one thing that I did state at the beginning is you ask about the reimbursement back to the county if they do pay for it. In 2016, I believe there's over 50,000, approximately 55,000 mineral parcels in the land commissioner's office. Seven of those were redeemed. So all that cost was not reimbursed back to the county.
And as it regards to your next question, I know in Saline County, we have a population of about 100,000. The circulation of that newspaper is less than 10,000. So the access to the newspaper, I would make the policy statement as there's more access at being on a website. And you could also say that the mail, the notifications that we're sending out, certified mail and send out to these people are staying the same. We're putting it on, we are putting it on the county's
website, so it'll be on the individual county's website as well as our website, the Association of Arkansas County's website for the statewide viewpoint. But yeah, it will be posted at the courthouse, as I referred to earlier. But yeah, that's the only thing that's changing is not required to be in a
newspaper. Representative Hendren, you recognize her? Thinking
about Representative Gray's question here, I was just thinking about that, and
have you considered this possibility of wanting people to know about it? And based on information I've received in the last couple of months, if you put this on cell phones, every kid in the state of Arkansas has a cell phone. them a bonus if they tell their parents and I will guarantee you that's the cheapest fastest way you can do it. Have you considered doing that? You always provide
good wisdom, sir. Thank you. I'm going to tell you, I know for a fact that's good. Mr. Chairman, I'd like to point out one thing and my experts can put me back between
the ditches, but there is a requirement, I believe, that there has to be a notification placed in the paper that instructs people how to find the information. So it's not like we're just trying to, you know, put it under the rug. But there is that connection of the dots for those that want to be informed. They will be informed just by looking at that and then finding their way to the website, if nothing else, at their local library that we give so much money to because we want people to
have access to the Internet. Josh, if you don't care, walk us through the logistics.
So what I'm understanding is it's going to be a notification in the newspapers to go, and there's going to be a website link, go to that website, and you're going to talk, actually specify the manual rights portion of this?
Speaker 18
16:34
Yes, I'm sorry. I should have left that piece out, but Representative Hammer brought that up. We are, this bill still requires us to post in the newspaper where to go to get this information. You can either go to the county courthouse and get it. You can call your collector, which you can do now, or you can go to the website, either the county website or the statewide association of counties website.
Thank you. Any other questions, members? Representative Bragg, you're
recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. How does that posting differ from the posting that you would normally do that
you're trying to eliminate? Can we illustrate
Speaker 7
17:16
that, Mr. Chair? Yes, sir. This is my publication. This is, I would like, I'd have a couple of sheets for everyone here if they wanted to
look at it, but you can see, maybe not from there, but most of this is all producing minerals, $1.50. And I'm required to put that in the newspaper. This is a one time, one day they put this out. This is one day. If we have it on the website, it's 24-7 a year. It's there.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You're welcome, sir. Members, any other questions? Do we have Mr. Tom? I'm sorry, I'm going to butcher. His name is Latimer, Associated Press. I want to speak against Arkansas Press Association. Speak
against the bill. Please recognize yourself, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members of the committee, I'm Tom Larimer. I'm the executive director of the Arkansas Press Association. I represent the 120 newspapers in Arkansas who, as you can imagine, would find themselves in opposition to this bill.
The example you've seen here is a pretty extreme example. Most of our counties and most of our papers and other counties in the state don't have this, certainly not to this volume of publication. And the cost is minimal in most instances at that. And the argument regarding putting these on the website, you may not know that all public notices that are published in Arkansas newspapers are already on a website at the Arkansas Press Association website.
At ArkansasPress.org, you're welcome to go and have a look at that. it's searchable. I'd suggest that anybody that's going to look at the Association of Arkansas County's website to find this is probably going to find it a little easier and quicker on the Arkansas Press Association website because it already exists and people are already accustomed to using that. And those people who are using that are primarily people in California, absentee owners who check on occasion to read that. So the argument that putting it on the website is going to be a good idea and everybody's going to see
it really isn't a good argument because they're already there, basically. So if we're doing this just to put them online, as I can say, they're already there. I've also already suggested that the newspapers just want to preserve this revenue. Again, this is an extreme example of revenue, and this is a significant amount of money. But for our other newspapers, this really doesn't amount to a whole lot of anything, but it's still in the newspaper. It's required by law to be in there, and it's not only in the
newspaper. It's, as I said already, it's online. So public notices in general, this one included, are about keeping the public informed about what their government is doing and what their responsibilities are under the government, and certainly in this case, their responsibility is their delinquent on their taxes. When they settle up those taxes, and I understand they don't do it, maybe a better approach was find a better process for going after these people
who owe this money rather than trying to remedy it like this, is that they have to pay for those publication costs when they settle that tax bill. Whether or not they pay that, that's really up to whoever is responsible for collecting it, I would say. The other concern about even putting them online is the connectivity in Arkansas is very suspect. A large percentage, almost half of the households in Arkansas don't have connectivity, and I haven't seen the latest Census Bureau numbers on it, so I don't have that data available
for you. But the last time I looked, which was a couple of years ago, 25 percent of the households in Arkansas doesn't even have Internet connectivity at their local library. So you're basically disenfranchising a whole lot of people by just solely putting this on the Internet, and I appreciate the gesture of putting an ad in the paper to call attention to it, but I'm going to suggest this is just not something that's going to drive people to a website in droves to find out if they actually have a bill pending there.
So of course, the public notices cost. There's a small cost to it. I can tell you that on most of these things, that the newspapers publish because of their local government or whatever government entity is required to publish them, they're publishing these at a loss. They don't make money on them. So don't get the idea that this is a huge profit center for newspapers. Our concern is getting the public notified of the things that they need to know about government and doing it in a cost-effective manner.
Putting it in the newspaper and it's already online is about as cost effective as you can get. So that would be our argument against this bill, Mr. Chairman, and I would certainly encourage you to give that some consideration and vote no on this bill. Tom,
will you entertain questions, sir? Certainly. Representative Gray? Thank you,
Speaker 41
22:37
Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman, I, like I would assume many of us in this room, I appreciate the point you're making, but I also appreciate the need to move with the
change of the times and technology, but I share the concerns about access to the Internet across the state. So my question to you is, I have an uncle who doesn't take the paper, I guess that, and I would say that friendly way to say his politics and mine don't always align, but he always finds a way to call me and let me know how he feels when I'm in the paper. So he is seeing what is in the newspaper.
So can you speak to the relative impact that while a subscription number may only be 10,000, the number of people that paper may actually touch, can you speak to that, please? Well, certainly.
The auditing bureaus that audit newspaper circulation allow that every newspaper is seen by two and a half to three people. So if you give them the lower number, if you're talking about a 10,000 circulation newspaper, then you're talking about 25,000 people. In a town that supports a 10,000 circulation newspaper, 25,000 is a pretty good chunk of, you know, the number is relative to the size of the community.
So, yeah, some of our papers are as small as 1,000, 2,000. But if you look at the communities they're serving, this is where local people go to get their information. They don't go to the website. They don't get it, frankly, in the rural areas. They don't get it out of the Democratic Gazette. If you want to know what time the Pie Supper starts at the Methodist Church, you've got to get that out of your local paper. And this is the local newspapers in Arkansas is what people look to for their local information. And that includes public notices. And if you don't think they read them, put one in a wrong sometime and find out what you hear about that.
And that does happen, but rarely, thank goodness. Thank you for
that question. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You're welcome. Any other questions, members? Mr. Chair? Yes,
sir. Asking for permission, can Cindy say something in response to something that was said or? Can we hold
that for closing, please? We can. Let's hold that for closing if you don't care. Representative Hammer, let me clean that up. Do you just want to make a response or are you going to ask a question? I think it's
a matter of making a response to something that was said
make sure that that full information is disclosed to the committee so they
make a good informed decision. Okay. Um, yes, just go ahead.
Speaker 7
25:16
Go ahead. It will be now. Yes, sir. Thank you. Thank you, sir. First of all, this affects maybe 25 counties that have producing minerals. It's not all 75 counties. It's a minority of us that collect it, but it's a big expense for
our counties. And I even had the collector from Cleburne County, where the Fayetteville Shell is doing so well, tell me her local newspaper did not want her list to publish. They asked her if they could publish in two separate printings and she said no by law it has to be a one-time print so it is a hardship on some of our small papers and I have
never known that my delinquent mineral list was published online for the Arkansas Democrat Gazette and that's that's all thank you You're welcome, ma'am. Tom, appreciate your testimony, sir. Yes,
sir. We're going to move to Ms. Sue Lyles, speak for the bill. Is Ms. Sue Lyles here? Please recognize yourself, ma'am, and when you get ready, feel free to proceed.
Speaker 74
26:40
Yes, sir. Sue Lyles from White County, Arkansas. We're one of the largest producers in the Fayetteville shell. My advertising cost in November was over $26,000. About $10,000 was personal and real estate. The remainder was the cost of producing mineral rights. We don't have a minimum, so I don't even have a dollar and a half. I'm publishing mineral rights that are 42 cents. So we would appreciate putting this online,
and it would give more people, I think, access to it. we have a lot of mineral owners that are out of state also. Thank you, ma'am. Anybody have questions? Thank
you, ma'am. Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill? Anybody left want to speak for the bill? Representative Hammer, you want to close for your
bill, sir? Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. Especially, I want to thank the member that allowed me to go first before them, and I appreciate that. Let me just bring out some points that were shared during the discussion.
First of all, I want you to keep in mind that we're dealing with a population that's not being responsible and that they didn't pay the taxes or the mental rights that we're due in the first place. And so let's isolate it to where the problem lies. First of all, that's with those that aren't being responsible. I like to think of myself as being responsible. Some may disagree with me on certain days down here. But the reality is I know what I owe, and I know when I owe it. And if I don't, then it's my responsibility to find out either by picking up the phone or calling or doing my due diligence.
So I want to establish, first of all, the population we're dealing with. And then second of all, this has been presented as we're limiting information when in reality we're not limiting, we're expanding the availability of information to a society that has shifted as to how they gain information. Does that mean they don't have a smartphone that they look at and they have their local newspaper? Yes, they do, because I'm evidence of that, because I support my local newspaper, not because they're printing mineral rights in there, but because I want to know where the pie supper is. That other stuff doesn't apply to me, because I don't want my name in the paper on a delinquent tax list.
So I'm being responsible with that. And then, as far as an obligation to the public, our obligation, I think, first and foremost, is to the public we serve, not to an independent industry that offers a product to the public that they have to purchase in order to get it. And then the next thing I would want to point out also is the question of what could your counties do with the money? What could those 25 counties do with the money to help with regard to other areas, expenses of the county, like roads, improvements, things that have a day-to-day impact?
And there is a shift that is occurring that if we don't fail, if we fail to apply common sense changes when the opportunity present themselves, just like is being presented in this bill, the only thing that's going to happen is there's going to be a growing resentment that we are forced to subsidize an industry that turns around and charges the public in order to access it as far as that local entity is concerned. And then the final thing I'd like to drive home is this, that the idea of going after the people that are creating this sounds good in a good way,
but the reality is when you're going to collect 43 cents on $1.50, I don't think that's really good business. I think this would be good business. I think it would be good for our counties, and I think it protects transparency because there would still be a small ad that would be required in the paper. and if people want to know, they generally have a way of finding out. We don't have to tell them. We just need to make sure the dots are connected with that. I would appreciate a good vote. Thank
you, Representative Hammer. Representative Gray, you have a motion?
Representative Gray just made the motion to do pass any debate members. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations. You passed your bill, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. You're welcome, sir. Representative Hendren, you want to go, sir? Members, this will be House Bill 1535. House Bill 1535.
Representative Hendren, sir, when you get ready, just go ahead and proceed. Recognize yourself. Proceed, sir. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. Representative Kim, I almost wish I hadn't agreed to that. Look all the crowd. I thought they were
here for my bill. You went down to the end of the
table, sir, and everybody left. I'll try to make this short and sweet because this is, in fact, I don't even have a copy of the bill before me because it basically just answers one question that a lot of us have convictions about, and I'll try to make some comments about that. It's House Bill 1535. And as you probably know, if you've been reading the paper, if we talked about today and if I were seeing it on your cell phone, a couple of days ago, Amazon started collecting sales and use tax in Arkansas.
And I guess that group's teed off and those bills have been passed, are going to be passed. And anyway, Amazon started doing it as well as others. The projections on that are an increase I've heard, again, in the newspaper, from $34 million increase a year to $150 million a year increase in revenue to the state of Arkansas. Now, there can be a lot of debate whether that's a tax increase or not, but I don't think there's much of a debate. It's an additional income into the state of Arkansas, into DFA, and you hear a lot down
here, people take pledges. I've never done that. I don't take pledges for Grover Norquist or anybody else. As a matter of fact, it got me in trouble a few years ago. A lady from Right to Life came to me and said, I want you to sign this pledge that you're pro-life. And I said, ma'am, I don't sign pledges. That's a religious conviction I have, among other things, plus to my constituents, because I don't think, myself, that this slot that I occupy temporarily belongs to me. But I said, I don't sign pledges. So she said, well, we'll put you on the website or maybe in the newspaper as being pro-choice.
I said, ma'am, you can do what you please, but when you do, that's going to be a lie. And so I haven't signed a pledge about anti-tax increase for Norquist or anybody else. But I have committed in my heart and with my conviction to the people that I represent over the years that I don't believe we ought to continue to grow government or increase taxes. And so that's the genesis of this bill. And you have on your computers there the analysis of this bill, the financial impact statement of it, which says a lot of what I don't need to say we can read.
It's three pages long and talks a lot about it. But the basic issue of House Bill 1535, and I would say there's no use to go through the details about this and say what it puts it here, it does not grow government. We've had other bills that maybe went to various agencies to do this and that. This does not do this. That's not the intent of this bill. This bill has only one intent, and that's to offset the increased revenue that comes into the state of Arkansas with a like amount, a balanced amount, to the taxpayers of this state.
And when I vote for a bill like that and support a bill like that, I think I'm being true to what I believe and what I've represented that I believe down through the years. We just recently, I'll show you in the paper today, we've had a bill introduced to raise, what, $200 million for the highway department. And one of the things that I thought about this today, you know, that might be a good way to finance that bill with this stuff that's coming in off this Internet sales tax if they're going to do that. But again, that's another issue for another time. If you'll look at that analysis there, you'll see the triggers that it has in this.
It basically says this. After things are done here, 85 million, for instance, taken out and so forth, 50 percent of this increase in revenue would go to reduce people's 4.5 percent sales tax. That's something a lot of people don't realize in this state. We talk about reducing the state sales tax. Yeah, we're doing that. We've been doing it for several years now. But the dirty little secret about that deal is we don't increase the city. We don't decrease the local city and county sales tax on groceries or food or anything else. It's still where it was, and we all know the political realities, why that's there and why it continues to be there.
So what this basically does, it takes 50 percent of this, whatever windfall or income or whatever you want tax increase, but certainly increased revenue from the state of Arkansas beginning to come in as of yesterday or day before yesterday on March the 2nd, 1st from Amazon. And it does, and all this bill does, all my attempt for this bill to do, and as I finish up here in a minute, I'll say this, is that I welcome any amendments to make it do basically what we're saying is whatever comes in from the additional steps this legislature's taken
and perhaps the federal government takes to tax internet sales that have not been taxed in the past, whatever additional income is turned back to the taxpayers of this state in an equal amount. That's what this bill attempts to do with the six or seven pages it does, and we don't usually understand that, but we can work it over. Let me see what else I've got down here. I think that's basically it. Just tit for tat, good for the goose, good for the gander, whatever. Whatever additional comes in, we just reduce people's taxes by
the same amount. All this other stuff we're doing ought to be another issue, at least in my mind it ought to be, but this is a specific issue with a specific bill. It does not start any new programs. It does not increase programs, but it does say whatever revenue comes in, we're going to cut your whatever tax we choose to cut on that amount.
And I think that's the name of that tune. Thank you, sir. Is it a one-to-one match for every dollar it comes in? Is the dollar tax cut?
Mr. Chairman, as you probably know, we've taken the last session, I think we've committed $25 million or something to this, a bunch of stuff we've done recently. That's why, Mr. Chairman and members of this committee, this is going to have to be a work in progress. And if this committee sees fit to even pursue it, then we need to go through and do it. But the intent, at least of this member, is just to offset dollar for dollar what additional income that comes in because of the new application of sales tax to people that don't have an in-state present, which is beginning to happen right now.
So that would have to be done through an amendment as we work through it
and modify the whole bill. Representative Collins, you recognize her? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hendren, as you know, we currently have a tax reform task force that is going to be tasked to do all of the things that you described. This bill dictates how we will do that. and the methodology chosen would give a rich person who bought a house full of furniture and a fancy new automobile a significant sales tax reduction, but wouldn't do anything to
help the person you hire to put up all your fence posts. Do you think that we need to make that decision today with this bill, or can we wait until we get to the task reform tax force in order to figure that out more specifically so we don't just help the rich guy. Well, as you
can imagine, Representative Collins, my idea here is not to represent the rich guy. That way I wouldn't have voted the way I did yesterday on that bill. But what I would suggest today, and I've just already suggested it, I ask for you and any
other member of this body down here on either end to come with an amendment to make it do What I, at least I personally have pledged to the people of Arkansas that I'm not going to raise their taxes. If I do it on something like that, I'm going to offset it on others. And specifically the task force put me down just a little bit skeptical that I would prefer to see 100 members in the House and 35 in the Senate in open debate and open input from the public make these recommendations than on a particular task force.
Sometimes those have a way of maybe not coming out the way that we had thought they'd be. But Representative Collins, I'd be glad to entertain any motion or any amendment you might offer that would deal with the problem that you have on it, because that's
what I want to do. Well, as you know, sir, the task force will have no authority to make law. What will happen is the task force will do the work and build consensus against all the ideas and then produce outcomes which the 100 members and the 35 in the Senate and the governor will then debate and adjudicate into law. So that process would achieve all your
objectives, would it not, sir? No, I don't agree with that, Representative Collins, what I've seen down here. Just because something comes out of a task force, many times we members don't know what's in that task force. We don't know what's in the bill. We don't know what we voted for. And I believe that you get a whole lot better input when you have more cooks cooking the meal. And And so I believe that when 100 people of us go back to our districts and then file for re-election next March or whenever it is, our people will have a chance to tell us, what do you want to do?
Do you want to reduce that tax based on how much additional came in, or do you want to start another program? And I think when you get that kind of input, you're going to have 135 members down here that are going to be, I think, in this member's opinion, more responsive to the 3 million people in Arkansas than any task force. But that's just obvious that we, every one of us has a right to our opinion on that. Thank
you, sir. Representative Ferguson, did you raise your hand, sir? I see you raised your hand, sir. Representative Gray, you're recognized.
Speaker 41
41:02
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hendren, obviously there's been quite a lot of discussion over the last month on the collection of internet sales tax and different ideas surrounding that revenue. So, you've addressed a couple of the questions I had when you first started, but I guess I would just real quickly, sir, being open to amendments, being open to suggestions of
this. So, I guess from just a purely procedural question. So are you willing to pull it down and not have an up-and-down vote on it today so we can further discuss this with you? Absolutely, and thank you for that question, because let me give you another philosophy of
mine, that part of why I introduced bills. You members know I have never come to a member in this legislature, 135 of you. I have never come to you and asked you to vote for my bill. I'll tell you what my bill is. I'll explain it to you and say I think it's good for the people of the state of Arkansas.
If you think it's good, after you, on your own opinion, without any need to do that to me, if you agree to vote for it, then vote for it. If you can improve it, let's improve it. If it's a bad bill, throw it in the trash can. I believe that's the way good government is done. And, obviously, I can make a motion as a member of this committee to do it, but I'm not going to do that today because I think this is good for the people of Arkansas. So I'll gladly pull it down. If you've got amendments to offer, let's look at them. Let's do it. And if we can make it where it's workable and doable for the people of Arkansas, let's pass it.
If we don't, there are some trash cans. I just put my open bottle of Coke over and want to go very carefully, by the way, Mr. Chairman. So if you dump that, be careful you don't spill it. But if that's where this thing needs to go after we look at it, then that's where we'll put this bill. So I'm understanding, sir, that you're
willing to pull the bill down as of right now? Yes, sir. Thank you very much. Unless there's an objection to committee. Reverend Davis, you want to run your bill, sir?
We're having fun now. Members, you want to move on to Senate Bill 362. Reverend Davis, just when you recognize yourself, sir, and Mr. Zook, recognize yourself as well, And when you guys get ready, feel free to proceed. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Andy Davis.
Randy Zook, President of Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce and Associated Industries of
Arkansas. Mr. Chairman, I'm going to give a really brief explanation of a really good bill here. I think most of you may be familiar with this by now. but essentially what Senate Bill 362 does is it sunsets the Investart tax credit program, and it phases in the elimination of sales tax on manufacturers' repair and replacement parts. This is, in my opinion, one of the best tax reform ideas and policy changes that we've seen here for some time.
This was a recommendation proposed by the Tax Foundation in their report that they wrote on our state's tax code last year. And I'm going to let you make remarks or you just want to take questions? I'd
Speaker 92
44:39
be happy to take questions. We'll just take questions. Whatever is easier. Okay, you
just want to start with questions. Everybody's kind of understanding what we've got going on here, members. Randy, I guess my question is going to be a point-blank, come-at-you type question.
Eight months ago, you know, we fought like crazy to keep Investark, you know, and up to the point to where, you know, it got tied up with the highway bill and all that. I mean, you know, the camera's coming to me. I heard it out of your own mouth saying, you know, we've got to keep it. We've got to keep it. No way
we can lose it. And eight months later, I hear you walking away from it. I just want to know what's changed. Well, essentially what's changed is the agreement and the proposal or the proposed bill that would swap Investark for a complete phase out and ultimately an exemption of repair parts for machinery and equipment for manufacturing companies in terms of sales tax.
So it's a ramp one down as one ramps up, and this came out of discussions with DF&A. It's much better for all the manufacturing sector because under InvestArc, a company had to make a $5 million or greater investment in order to qualify for a tax credit. They were only able to use the tax credit against half of their sales tax liability. So, in many instances, it wasn't uncommon for a company to lose part of the value of that tax credit
because there was only a five-year period in which to apply it against half their sales tax liability. And sometimes the credit ran out, the time ran out on the credit before they could burn it all off against obligations for sales tax. The basic issue here is that we are the only state in the region that still applies a sales tax to repair parts for machinery and equipment for manufacturers. So this will be for dollar one for small manufacturers all across the state,
all sorts of sectors, instead of just the large companies making the big $5 million and up investments. But I would say that we were already
pushing the parts and repair down for the last two sessions. We've been working on that already. Is there something that, I mean, what, what, I mean, I heard your explanation. I'm not doubting what you said. But, but we were already on that path of driving parts and repair down anyway.
This really just accelerates the process and makes it, puts it into law rather than having
to do it bit by bit, each session by each session. So it sets up a trajectory for both. It sunsets applications for new Investar credits this year. I think it's July 1. And from that point forward, companies would apply for rebates against the sales taxes they paid on their repair parts, all manufacturers, not just the large ones. And it basically is swapping, as the tax foundation put it, swapping good policy for bad policy.
The Investark tax credit had been put in place to mitigate the damage or the effect of bad tax policy, namely taxing these repair parts. It drives a process called tax pyramiding, where you're stacking up costs for manufacturers that translate into higher prices, make them less competitive, make it harder for our existing companies to expand as much as they want to. What I just heard you say, sir, is
you said Investark was a bad tax policy is what I just heard you say.
It was a Band-Aid, yes, sir, it was. It was a Band-Aid to mitigate the impact of the bad tax policy of having a sales tax in place
pushback from anybody on Investark? No, sir. I've had one or two companies, large companies, say, wait a minute, are we sure we want to go down this path? And after they've examined it, they've turned, yes, they've wanted to. They've realized, well, hey, this will be a much more practical and readily available for all manufacturers, not just the big guys, but good for everybody down the road.
Thank you, sir. Representative Letting, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I know we've seen an impact or what the impact would be to the state, but have we been able to see what the impact might
be to counties or cities? We've not done that analysis, no. I'm wondering if DF&A may have. I'm not sure.
Yes, Paul, if you don't care, go down to the end of the table for us and recognize yourself. And then when you get down there, Representative Letting, ask your question again, please. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Speaker 103
49:33
Paul Gehring, Assistant Commissioner for Policy and Legal Department of Finance and Administration.
The question again, I know we've seen what the impact would be to the state, but if we
Speaker 103
49:46
seen what the impact might be to counties or cities? Certainly. Representative Letting, I think the first important issue is that the exemption does not, for repair parts and services, does not go into effect until July 1, 2022. So the very earliest that there would be any impact to the cities and counties would be July 1 of 2022. Now, as to the impact after that full exemption goes into place,
DFA would not be able to prepare a fiscal impact because of a great deal of uncertainty. Local sales taxes are sourced to where the delivery location of the item is for the customer, or also it could be if the item was purchased at a store, the sale would be sourced to where the individual bought the item. So because local sales taxes have those specific sourcing, it would be difficult, if not impossible, DFA to come up with a fiscal impact once that exemption goes into full effect in 2022.
Another issue just to be aware of is that the local caps on sales taxes also would present an issue. So it would be entirely too speculative for DFA to do an impact for the local sales taxes.
Speaker 41
51:08
Thank you. Thank you. Representative Gray, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Gentlemen, just a couple of education questions for me. So, INVEST Arkansas tax credit was created, good or bad policy,
but was created to create a credit for major repairs or expansions. Is that a correct summation of mainly an elementary definition of what the tax structure is for? It was actually for maintenance. I mean, it's
basically big maintenance projects. But you could couch maintenance
Speaker 41
51:42
as revitalizing a part of a plan or adding to a line. There was an ability to take advantage of that under the guise of a maintenance project.
Renovating a plan, replacing an outdated assembly line,
Speaker 41
51:58
something like that. So, over the last eight weeks in this committee, we've heard that exemptions for certain groups or certain sectors of the population were not always good policy and that we have this tax reform task force coming up to address new ways to tax.
My question is, understanding that maybe this invest arc structure has not created the growth that maybe it intended for the manufacturing sector, it was more of a job creator intent to savings to the manufacturers. The opportunity to create more jobs in a community or sustain jobs in a community, how do you rationalize that against just a reduced cost in their current cost of doing business when
Speaker 41
53:04
little unclear about that. Yeah, I'm not sure if I'll . So I appreciate it and I'll try to clarify. The Investark was touted as a way to pass savings back to manufacturers so they could, for lack of a better term, increase capacity or retain or create new jobs, whereas a sales tax exemption would, two questions here, a sales tax exemption would look more to just,
while relevant and certainly important in a for-profit business, would just put more money back in the coffers. A second thing is the question that we've heard in this committee over the last two that exemptions are not necessarily the best tax policy and that with a committee that's been created to look at tax reform that was referenced, in fact, in discussion of the last bill, would that not be a better time to discuss creating more exemptions in our tax cut?
Representative Gray, I would respectfully say no. I think this is one that has been discussed. Like you've heard in here over the last several weeks, we've got a lot of exemptions and things that are cut out and carved out. And a lot of those things have not been discussed to the extent that Investark specifically has. Legislative audit looked at Investark in the last couple of years. We've got a report from them that says there's no direct correlation between job creation and Investark.
So I would say Investark is one of those credits that we've said, said, you know, this is not the best way to shape our tax policy in this state. At the same time, we know from experience with agriculture that not applying sales taxes to inputs is a good tax policy, and that's what we're doing here. We're shifting from an exemption that doesn't benefit all manufacturers because one of the parameters, you've got to spend $5 million in order to be eligible for the investor tax credit.
The manufacturer is not going to be able to take advantage of that. So if we shift away from that exemption in InvestARC to eliminating the sales tax on inputs, then all our manufacturers get the benefit from that and, you know, circle back around to your question. This has been discussed, in my opinion, at some length for some time. So I think we're going to go ahead and move ahead with this one. Thank you, Representative Davis.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Hendren, you're recognized, sir.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to see if maybe you all can help me answer a question to myself and then also to the people back home. This bill we just talked about earlier that we're going to continue to look at how to deal with that. This removes the sales tax on repair parts for machinery and equipment. Is that correct? Yes, sir. over a five-year period.
And let me tell you, let me tell you how I'm asking this, like the pig going to have breakfast. I mean, this affects me. We have a tool on dye shop, Amarck Engineering. We started in 1977 that we buy stuff, we buy equipment. This is going to be a tax cut for a company that I own. I have a D5 cat bulldozer, and if I put tracks on that bulldozer, which I have in the past, that's $25,000. Would that be a cut on the sales tax on those tracks? I
think it would, wouldn't it? If the equipment is owned by a manufacturing entity, yes.
Well, I can make it that right quick. You know how that thing works. And a backhoe and
You and your accountant. Well, you know how accountants are and lawyers. Let's put them in the same category. And your conscience. That's right. And I'm glad you said that because that's why I'm asking this question. How can I vote to cut the tax on Amarc and increase our bottom line or in my poultry operation or my bulldozer after my accountant does what you and I suggest or I suggest they do, I guess,
and not cut the sales tax to the people we've just put it on for the Internet sales? How do I walk through the farm when I go home tomorrow, I hope, and walk through my chicken house and walk out on the farm and tell those people out there, look, I cut the tax for my business down at AMARC, but I didn't cut yours. How do I give
that answer? It's a really good question, and I think it gets to the basic principles of tax policy. The sales tax is intended to be applied at the final point of consumption of a product.
And these tax pyramiding activities, like we eliminated ultimately the sales tax on utilities companies for manufacturers over about a five or six year period. This is another of those business input taxes that are applied along the way in the adding of value in a manufacturing company, which pyramids their costs. Wouldn't you agree,
though, that a sales tax is a regressive tax and that if I raise
the tax on, for instance, my company down there to cost me $1,000, well, so what? If I'm making a whole lot more than that, it doesn't make that much difference. But if I'm making $8 to $10 an hour picking up dead chickens in a chicken house, that tax increase,
that's where I think the regressive part comes into it. Wouldn't you agree? Well, I mean, I can't argue the point that sales taxes are regressive. I think that's a commonly accepted evaluation of sales taxes. But in cases of manufacturers, in this case, this tax, this sales tax, is only used for
equipment directly used in manufacturing, so your bulldozer would not apply unless you're making something. Well, that's what I use it for. I mean, I
just don't, you know, don't ride around on it. That's what I use it to develop property and housing additions and what have you and occasionally tear up something with it, you know. But that still wouldn't qualify
under the under the law. Well, then maybe I need to amend the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. President Flowers, you recognize.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I guess this would be a question for DF&A
because I believe I just heard that this wouldn't go into effect until 2022, but I'm looking at the fiscal impact statement, and it looks like the first year where there would be a net loss would be 2020.
Speaker 103
59:55
Okay. Okay. Got it. Thank you. Representative Flowers, I can try to explain the mechanism that is in place right now and then what the mechanism as this bill provides for. Currently, this bill really only impacts state revenues until the full exemption for repair and placement parts and services go into effect July 1, 2022. What you have in this bill up until July 1 of 2022 is that the amount of the state sales
tax that is subject to refund, it gets greater and greater until July 1, 2022. So the local sales taxes are not affected by this bill until July 1, 2022. Oh, okay. There's only
an impact. That was the answer to Representative Letting's question. Correct.
Speaker 103
1:00:49
The amount of the state tax that is subject to the refund under this bill gets greater over time until 2022 when there's just a full exemption on the repair, replacement parts
and services. Got it. Okay. Thank you. Welcome.
Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Mm-hmm. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Randy, in most of this manufacturing equipment, tax exempt when it's
purchased? Paul would have to answer that question, but I think yes, that's true. When you make the investment,
you... Right. I know farm equipment, if I buy a tractor to use
on the farm, it's tax exempt. I thought manufacturing a lot of the equipment was, but the parts are not. So you can, the equipment in lots of cases is tax exempt, but then when you break something on it and you go to buy a replacement part for it, currently it's not. So this would be falling along the same category that if the equipment is worthy of a tax exemption, the parts to repair it and keep it working would be worthy of the exemption too, wouldn't you say? I think
as a principle, you want to encourage manufacturers. Think about the Whirlpool plant in Fort Smith. You want to encourage companies to keep their equipment in as up-to-date and productive a condition as possible. So anything that mitigates their costs associated with that, especially if they're multi-state companies where they're competing for capital, you want them to be as competitive as possible for that capital. Thank you. You're welcome. Commissioner Bragg,
Thank you, Mr. Chair. References made to waiting on a task force, what would be more beneficial in a tracking industry, the potential outcome of a task force or a
guaranteed reduction in these taxes? I think this, well, let me just, to speak to that point, let me, there's a piece that the Tax Foundation put out regarding this bill. According to the State Business Tax Climate Index, Arkansas's rank on the corporate tax subcomponent would improve from 40th best overall to 34th best overall.
So we would be recognized, and the Tax Foundation says this is a very positive step forward if Arkansas takes it in terms of competitiveness and holding ourselves out as a place that you want to come and invest your capital and grow your business. Okay. Thank you. Welcome, sir.
Members, any other questions? If not, anybody in the audience wants to speak against the bill,
for the bill? Could I make one comment, Mr. Chairman, just to add on? I want to single out or point out the cooperation from DF&A on this bill with the chamber and
those of us interested in this issue, specifically the director, Larry Walther, Paul Gehring, You've heard from Tom Ashley, Walter Anger, and Joel DePippa. This was a terrific conversation. The governor's office was involved in the whole process, and this was a very constructive process that resulted in this bill, and we appreciate their help very much. Thank you, sir. Anybody in mind just want
to speak for the bill now? Josh?
Please recognize yourself, sir, and get to the
end of the table. My name is Josh Waters, I'm an attorney for Political Strategies. Conduit for Action is our client. And I don't have a whole lot to add, but I did want to take the opportunity to come before the committee to be speaking for a bill, and so this is on our scorecard. And so I wanted to be speaking for this bill and just reiterate, I think one of main points that was talked about is whether this is an exemption or not. And at least our position
is kind of alluded to. It's not really so much that it's an exemption because it's not on the final product. And so what you can see happen is what they talk about tax pyramiding, something is taxed multiple times in the process before the final product is finished. And so that can lead to double, triple taxation. And ultimately, as you know, taxes are passed on to the consumer. So this would provide an opportunity for whatever final product of this manufacturing could reduce those prices for consumers.
Another big part of this that we like is that it applies to all businesses evenly. And so I think everything else is pretty much covered, but I did want to talk about that. And then the point about bringing us more competitive, 40th to 34th, while that might not seem like a big jump. I think when businesses look to which states they want to go to and to expand in, that's a number that they look at repeatedly. And so I would encourage the committee to vote for this bill.
Thank you. Thank you, sir. Representative Davis, you want to close for your bill, sir? I'm closed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Representative Dawson, you have a motion? Representative Dawson has a
Speaker 41
1:06:23
motion for due pass. Any debate? Representative Gray? Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I'll be brief as I know what the cooperation that has gone on in this bill is on a fast track. I would just like to make the point that anytime we can help the employers of Arkansas, it's a good thing.
But one third of our state's economy is AG, who Representative Douglas referenced when he buys a piece of equipment. there's no sales tax and when the manufacturer buys a piece of equipment, their sales tax exempt, the difference will be after this bill that when that one third of our economy that farms has to repair or buy replacement parts on that machinery, he will pay sales tax. I would hope that Representative Collins would look at these kinds of exemptions for
the one third of our economy, which is the ag industry and the task force. And I appreciate that.
I agree with that. Any other points, members? Does that have a motion for due pass from Representative Dodson? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. Ayes have it, congratulations. Thank you, committee. Members, that is it for today. Right now we're looking about coming back Tuesday, maybe, on Senate Bill 140. Yet to be determined, but maybe Tuesday. With that, we're adjourned.
Agenda
HB1647 C. Douglas TO EXCLUDE MANUFACTURER REBATES ON MOTOR VEHICLES FROM THE DEFINITIONS USED FOR PURPOSES OF DETERMINING SALES AND USE TAXES.
HB1649 C. Douglas TO AMEND THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR NEW MOTOR VEHICLES PURCHASED BY NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS OR WITH URBAN MASS TRANSIT ADMINISTRATION FUNDS.
HB1565 Jett TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE AND EXPIRATION OF GROSS RECEIPTS TAX PERMITS AND THE COLLECTION OF UNPAID TAXES UPON DISCONTINUATION OF BUSINESS.
HB1535 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES.
HB1559 Jett TO AMEND THE CORPORATE INCOME TAX WITHHOLDING REQUIREMENTS FOR MEMBERS OR OWNERS OF A PASS-THROUGH ENTITY.
SB140 Files TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RATHER THAN USE TAX ON SALES BY CERTAIN REMOTE SELLERS.
HB1680 Jett TO CLARIFY THE ABILITY OF THE DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION TO CANCEL OR REFUSE TO ISSUE, EXTEND, OR REINSTATE A LICENSE, PERMIT, OR REGISTRATION UNDER STATE TAX LAW.
HB1681 Jett TO AMEND THE DEFINITIONS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TAX PROCEDURE ACT; AND TO PROVIDE THAT ERRONEOUSLY PAID REFUNDS ARE CONSIDERED UNDERPAYMENTS OF TAX AND ARE SUBJECT TO ASSESSMENT.
HB1682 Jett TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS TAX PROCEDURE ACT CONCERNING BUSINESS CLOSURES; AND TO PROVIDE THAT A BUSINESS CLOSURE ORDER ACTS AS AN INJUNCTION PROHIBITING FURTHER BUSINESS OPERATION UNLESS OTHERWISE PROVIDED BY A COURT.
HB1683 Jett TO ESTABLISH A MILEAGE AUDIT APPEAL PROCEDURE FOR REGISTRANTS WHO HAVE RECEIVED APPORTIONED REGISTRATION UNDER THE INTERNATIONAL REGISTRATION PLAN.
HB1684 Jett TO EXTEND THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR DETERMINING THE CORRECT AMOUNT OF TAX DUE IN RELATION TO CERTAIN AMENDED RETURNS OR VERIFIED CLAIMS FOR CREDIT OR REFUND.
SB114 Hester TO AMEND THE NOTICE REQUIREMENTS RELATED TO PROPERTY TAXES; AND TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR PUBLISHING NOTICE OF DELINQUENT TAXES ON MINERAL INTERESTS.
HB1693 Rye TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES.
SB362 L. Eads TO SUNSET CERTAIN TAX INCENTIVES; TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX REFUND FOR THE REPAIR AND PARTIAL REPLACEMENT OF MANUFACTURING MACHINERY AND EQUIPMENT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1772 Jett TO IMPROVE THE FAIRNESS OF PROPERTY TAX ADMINISTRATION AND APPEALS.
DEFERRED BILLS
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VEHICLES FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.
HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RECEIVED UNDER THE COMMUNITY MATCH RURAL PHYSICIAN RECRUITMENT PROGRAM.
HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS" ON THE PART OF A COUNTY ASSESSOR IN THE ASSESSMENT OF REAL AND PERSONAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR SALES BY A CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION.
HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF CERTAIN ADVERTISING AND PROMOTION TAX RECORDS UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.
HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES; AND TO REMOVE THE THRESHOLD FOR CLAIMING AN INCOME TAX DEDUCTION FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES.
HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR AND REPAIR OF AGRICULTURAL EQUIPMENT AND MACHINERY.
HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES BASED ON THE GROWTH OF INCOME TAX COLLECTIONS.
HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.
HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVICE PAY AND ALLOWANCES OF FOREIGN SERVICE PERSONNEL.
SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX, SALES AND USE TAXES, AND THE SOFT DRINK TAX; AND TO SUPPLEMENT THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TRUST FUND TO OFFSET DECREASED DEPOSITS FROM TAX REVENUES.
HB1037 Wardlaw TO REGULATE THE SALE OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY; AND TO PROHIBIT OWNERS OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY FROM BIDDING ON OR PURCHASING TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY.
HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PREPAY SALES TAXES.
HB1412 Ballinger TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED VETERANS IN PROPORTION TO THE EXTENT OF THE DISABILITY OF THE VETERAN.
HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EMPLOY A RECENTLY RETURNED VETERAN.
HB1396 Leding TO EXEMPT FROM THE INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX EDUCATION SCHOLARSHIPS, AWARDS, AND GRANTS FROM NONPROFIT VOLUNTEER SERVICE ORGANIZATIONS.
HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES FOR CERTAIN CLUBS AND FACILITIES; AND TO LEVY A SALES TAX ON DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES TO CERTAIN FACILITIES AND CLUBS.
HB1014 Leding TO CREATE THE TEACHER'S CLASSROOM INVESTMENT DEDUCTION.
HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS THAT ARE IN THE PROCESS OF LIQUIDATION.
HB1531 G. Hodges TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EDUCATIONAL LOAN PAYMENTS FOR QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS AND EMPLOYERS OF QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS.
HB1582 Dotson TO EXEMPT CERTAIN ELECTION EQUIPMENT FROM SALES AND USE TAXES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDUALS, TRUSTS, AND ESTATES USING REVENUES DERIVED FROM SALES AND USE TAX FROM SELLERS THAT DO NOT HAVE A PHYSICAL PRESENCE IN THE STATE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Joe Jett Chair
Unverified
Representative Ken Bragg Chair
Unverified
Speaker 7
Speaker 18
Speaker 30
Representative Bob Johnson
Unverified
Speaker 41
Representative Kim Hendren
Unverified
Representative Lane Jean
Unverified
Speaker 74
Representative Charlie Collins Chair
Unverified
Representative Michelle Gray
Unverified
Representative Andy Davis
Unverified
Speaker 92
Representative Greg Leding
Unverified
Speaker 103
Speaker 110
Speaker 114
Representative Vivian Flowers
Unverified
Speaker 35
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Josh Waters
Unverified