Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Revenue and Taxation Committee

March 7, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·1:07:25
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (51)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1562 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…. Members, we have a concurrence with Senate Amendment 1 on House Bill 1562. Representative Jett, you are recognized to present your am…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1772 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…l right. Representative Jett, you are recognized to present HB 1772. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1014 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1014 Leding TO CREATE THE TEACHER'S CLASSROOM INVESTMENT DEDUCTI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1028 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1031 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1037 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1037 Wardlaw TO REGULATE THE SALE OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY; AN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1153 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS"…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1221 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1225 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSUR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1227 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES;…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1252 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1253 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1263 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1395 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EM…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1396 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1396 Leding TO EXEMPT FROM THE INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX EDUCATION S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1397 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMB…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1399 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1409 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVIC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1412 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1412 Ballinger TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION F…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1449 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1512 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1531 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1531 G. Hodges TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EDUCATIONAL LO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1535 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1535 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND U…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1559 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1559 Jett TO AMEND THE CORPORATE INCOME TAX WITHHOLDING REQUIREM…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1565 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1565 Jett TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE AND EXPIRATIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1582 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1582 Dotson TO EXEMPT CERTAIN ELECTION EQUIPMENT FROM SALES AND…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1647 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1647 C. Douglas TO EXCLUDE MANUFACTURER REBATES ON MOTOR VEHICLE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1649 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1649 Douglas TO AMEND THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR NEW MO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1680 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1680 Jett TO CLARIFY THE ABILITY OF THE DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTME…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1681 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1681 Jett TO AMEND THE DEFINITIONS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TAX PROCED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1682 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1682 Jett TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS TAX PROCEDURE ACT CONCERNING BUS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1683 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1683 Jett TO ESTABLISH A MILEAGE AUDIT APPEAL PROCEDURE FOR REGI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1684 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1684 Jett TO EXTEND THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR DETERMINING T…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1693 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1693 Rye TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1788 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1788 Dotson TO PHASE IN AN EXTENSION OF THE NET OPERATING LOSS C…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1789 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1789 Dotson TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING THE CORPORATE FRANCHISE TAX…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1790 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1790 Dotson TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE AP…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1795 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1795 Gates TO EXEMPT CERTAIN DONATED ITEMS FROM SALES AND USE TA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1796 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1796 Gates TO AMEND THE TIME LIMITATIONS FOR TAX ASSESSMENTS, CO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1824 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1824 J. Williams TO ALLOW A PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1844 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1844 Beck TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION OF REVENUES DERIVED FROM THE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1845 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1845 Richey TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR TEACHERS EMPLO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1850 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1850 Leding TO CREATE THE STRONG FAMILIES ACT; AND TO CREATE AN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1940 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1940 Dalby TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE RECORDATION OF DEEDS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1965 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1965 Jett TO REPEAL PROVISIONS REGARDING THE USE OF SALES AND US…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1987 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1987 Fite TO AMEND THE EFFECTIVE DATE PROVISION OF ACTS 2017, NO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2009 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2009 Sturch CONCERNING THE REMITTANCE OF INSURANCE PREMIUM TAXES…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2066 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2066 Hammer TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL REBATE OF DISTILLATE SPECIA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2068 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2068 Hammer TO RETURN EXCESS FEDERAL GRANT FUNDS TO THE UNITED S…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB120 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX,…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB140 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB140 Files TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RA…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
Chair sees a quorum. Members, we have a concurrence with Senate Amendment 1 on House Bill 1562. Representative Jett, you are recognized to present your amendment. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. Bill is 1692. 1562. Members, what we have today in front of us is an amendment, a concurrent amendment from the Senate on House Bill 1562. And to my right is Mr. Paul Gehring from DFA. He's
▶ Play
Speaker 12 0:43
going to explain the amendment to the committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Vice Chair, Paul Gehring, Department of Finance and Administration, Assistant Revenue Commissioner. House Bill 1562, which previously passed out of this committee, the original bill provided a statutory mechanism for multi-state partnerships to apportion their income tax and to provide the same methodology that is utilized for corporate income tax. After the bill passed out of this committee, over in the Senate, we were approached by members of the legal community and the accounting taxpayer community to also put on an amendment to the bill to provide an alternate income apportionment method that is identical to what is used for corporations. So that amendment was put on in Senate Revenue and Tax, and that's the purpose of the amendment, to make the taxation of partnerships for apportionment purposes to be identical to how taxes are, income is apportioned for corporate income tax taxpayers. Are there any questions on the committee? All
▶ Play
right. Representative Johnson. And when you're referring to partnerships,
▶ Play
you're also referring to LLCs that are taxed on the 1065? That's correct, sir.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any other questions? Is there anybody audits once we pour against the bill or amendment? We have a motion to do pass, or concur the amendment. Representative Johnson, are you closed for the bill? I am, sir. Okay. All in favor of the motion, say aye. Aye. Against? No? You have to concur your amendment, I guess? Thank you, sir. All right. All right. Representative Jett, you are recognized to present HB 1772. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, with your permission, I'm going to ask Mr. Mike Parker, Ms. Lindsay Bailey, Mr. Andrew Parker. Okay, Mr. Parker, if
▶ Play
you'll take a seat at the end of the table and recognize
▶ Play
Speaker 25 3:00
yourself. And Mr. Bear Chaney. Sorry?
▶ Play
Mr. Bear Chaney as well. Bear Chaney. Y'all have a seat down there. This is my legal team of Parker, Parker, Bailey, Chaney. It's an impressive team. It's pretty good. I bring backup. All right, y'all are recognized. Thank you. Members, over the last past year or so, they've been talking between assessors and the Association of Counties and the business community and the Public Service Commission about coming together and making a property fairness bill, if you will, on equalization and for what the taxpayers' fairness issue. And basically, I think what I'd like to do, Mr. Chairman, with your permission, I think what I'd like to do is go through section by section of the bill and then turn around and come back, and then we'll just entertain any questions that you guys might have. Okay. You're recognized, too? Thank you. Members, on Section 2 makes three minor changes to procedure for appealing assessments by the Tax Division of Arkansas Public Service Commission. Basically, this extends the deadline from protests to 10 to 30 days, clarifies that taxpayers can file their own protests instead of having an attorney file the protest for them, and provides more time for the scheduling of hearings. Section 3 clarifies the role of the Equalization Board to ensure that valuations meet the standards provided by law. When you see in Section 3, you'll look at Code 2626-1202, which is fair market value, and Code 2626-407 is based on residential value. Then it removes the language added in 2009 that appeared to limit the Equalization Board authority. Section 4 sets out the procedure for parties and Equalization Board to follow an Equalization Board hearings. Basically, this standardizes and defines how all Equalization Board are to be conducted, also prohibits ex parte communications with EQ Board members outside of hearings and lets a company appealing an EQ Board decision know about a court rule that requires a licensed attorney to sign and file an appeal. Section 5 makes the burden of proof for all appeals of EQ Board decisions to county and circuit courts, the same as the burden proof for state tax appeals. Basically, Mr. Chairman, this says preponderance of the evidence. Section 6 provides better support for EQ board members in several ways, provides more comprehensive training on the direction of the assessment and coordination department in a uniform manner, directs all materials used in training and education to be available online, makes ACD staff available to respond to questions from EQ board members, directs the director of the ACD to issue uniform hearing procedures in phases in training. Section 7 and 8 clarifies that errors in the property tax books should be corrected regardless of whose fault the error might be, the assessor, the taxpayer, or some third party. Error meaning anything other than valuation. This also relates to refunds and additional assessments under the Property Taxpayer Bill of Rights. And Section 9 finally provides that if an error was made for the two or more tax years, any fund can be split over two tax years. With that, Mr. Chairman, we will entertain any questions.
▶ Play
Thank you. Committee, we have any questions. Representative Flowers, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Yes, thank you. I almost signed on to the bill, and it seems to be something that would be fair. provide a level of fairness to taxpayers. My only question and issue is something that my assessor spoke to, and that was the course that is going to be sort of incrementally applied. And it only makes an exception for someone on the board who's an attorney or, what's the other one? Is it an appraiser? Appraiser, ma'am. Yeah. And apparently it excludes a realtor who also, according to my assessor, is aware of valuation. And so I'm wondering if there's a reason why that exception would not be applied to realtors. And I will just add that her concern was that it's really difficult to get people to serve who are active and know what they're doing. And the requirement of this course, especially with it not being defined, what kind of course it will be, how long it will take, and that kind of thing would kind of prohibit them from really getting good people to serve on that board. Yes, ma'am. First of all,
▶ Play
I guess the first part of your question, Representative Flowers, would be Bearer, the director of the coordination, assessment coordination department. Can issue waivers under my understanding? And I'm looking through. It's just for appraisers and attorneys. It's just for appraisers
▶ Play
Speaker 39 8:09
and attorneys. Okay. Do you want to add to that
▶ Play
question? Ms. Flowers, my name is Michael Parker. I'm an attorney in Little Rock in private practice, and I also am volunteer tax counsel for the Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce and Associated Industries of Arkansas. And I had a pretty strong hand in writing this bill. This is all about improving the professionalism of equalization boards. And, you know, I understand that concern. I've practiced tax law for 40 years. And nevertheless, when the Supreme Court came in and imposed the continuing legal education requirements, I mean, I satisfied my requirements by teaching the courses. And there was a lot of pushback among lawyers, anybody, the time you bring in a continuing education provision. We do think that the only folks that were sort of had a lock on waivers, and even this was permissive, that we identified in our discussion process, was appraisers and attorneys, because, you know, real estate agents, appraisers have probably been through the equalization board appeal type process. I understand what all the standards are. I'm not sure that a typical real estate agent has, because they deal with, yes, there may be experts on what property is worth, but there's a whole set of procedures and set of rules and the like that goes to the Equalization Board activity. So we did not include an automatic waiver or permissive waiver for that. I mean, we can consider that later on. We just did everything that we could to make it as painless as possible to phase this in, but still at the end of the day, improve professionalism, have some standardized training, try to get everybody to a similar level of understanding of what the whole process was.
▶ Play
Yes, and I'll add Representative Flowers also. So, I mean, the intent of this is to make, say, like Washington County Equalization Board operate the same as Clay County and Jefferson County. And if you don't have proper training, I mean, you have different boards operating in different manners. And basically we're trying to bring everybody under a uniform code. And it's got to be done through training. And, I mean, you know, I understand your concerns. But without the training, you know, I don't know how you're going to get everybody operating under a uniform, uh, be like, uh, DFA. If you had an, if you had an appeal process and you had like different DFA offices throughout the state of Arkansas and you go to a DFA office, they might have a different type of appeal process and, and going from one county to the next. And, you know, this all comes back to being fair to the
▶ Play
taxpayers. Follow up. And that, that makes total sense to me. And I would agree the only, I guess, question I would have is if that's what we're trying to do, then why would there even be an exemption for anybody if we're trying to standardize it so that everybody is accessing the same curriculum? Why allow some to be exempted and not others? I understand. I would just say that we're trying to
▶ Play
make this as painless as possible. and I don't know if that satisfies your answer to your question or not, but, you know, when you start looking at the attorneys and stuff, people that's actually professionals in that field, you know, we're trying to give enough latitude to where this is a painless process.
▶ Play
Representative Armstrong, you're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Jett, was there any cost associated, I think, in the bill? So you mentioned the transfer of information through online services or bringing us, I guess, into the 21st century through technology. Is there any cost associated with that for putting
▶ Play
that in place? We had that discussion with Mr. Barachaney, and he assured us that everything could be absorbed through his agency, and no additional money is going to be appropriated for this.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Donald Trump. Representative Hendren, you have a
▶ Play
question? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. A couple of questions that have been brought to me by constituents, and one of them, I guess, I guess Bear Chaney is still down there because this is from his and my county, Benton County. I've had constituents call me and say they've had a reappraisal. This is primarily in a downtown section of a town, and their appraisals went up two or three times, and they didn't like that, so they called the appraiser's office in Bentonville, and whoever they talked to said, well, what do you think it ought to be? and they reduced it, sometimes by 50% to 75%. So my question is, does this fix that? First of all, is that right? Can they do that? But they are doing it. It's not a matter of can they. They are doing it. Does this repair that, and does it fix it? The second question that I'd have with regard to this, I understand that when a bank repossesses property, most assessors, and I think that's what we've talked about here in a long time, most assessors appraisers will not consider that repossessed bank property as a comparable and the problem I have with that and my constituents have with that is this if a bank repossesses a house or a farm or whatever and they don't get the best they can for that property to satisfy whatever's left of the debt that's owed by their by their borrower to me it seems like to me that somebody's gotten a shaft in that deal and it's probably usually the borrower so Those two questions, can they do that? Should they be doing it with a call? They are doing it, but should they be doing it with a call from a constituent to reduce it just on a telephone call? And second of all, why should a financial institution not be – why should we not assume that they get market value when they repossess and put a piece of property up for auction? I think this is on,
▶ Play
Speaker 61 14:14
Mr. Chairman. Bear Chaney, Director of the Assessment Coordination Division. And to answer your first question, Representative Hendren, is we are auditing that, and they should not be just changing values over the telephone without looking at it. And one of the things that the Equalization Board is to do if it's brought before them, as you well know, is they're to look at all similar properties. And that's some of the things that we're looking at trying to audit them on. Now to your second question about the repossessed homes and stuff, is in any appraisal practice, you have to look at the market. If the repo homes is the market for that neighborhood or area, then it is okay to use those. But if you just have one or two repossessed homes in a neighborhood, that's not the market. So it just depends on the
▶ Play
Speaker 60 15:00
situation of whether they should look at those or not.
▶ Play
One more question. He just raised another answer in what he just said, but if it's—you say it's not the market. Who determines what the market is? The buyers and sellers determine
▶ Play
Speaker 61 15:27
the market. That's what I've always thought. It is, and like I said, though, if it's just one or two homes out of 200 homes, that's not the market. If you have a neighborhood or a market area of 100 homes and 100 of them are repossessed and reposed, then yes, that would influence your market, and that would be
▶ Play
the market. Representative, are you done? Are you
▶ Play
Speaker 39 15:52
there? No, I wasn't, but you said
▶ Play
one more question. Okay. Well, let's see if there's anybody else has another question. Okay. Representative Johnson,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We'll try to go a different direction here for a minute. If I'm understanding this correctly, you're saying the board equals that. You're not saying who can serve and who cannot serve. You want them to have the same sort of training statewide so that when you go to a board of equalization in one county or another county, they behave the same way in theory. And so that's what you're saying. You don't have to have a certain degree or a certain thing to be on the board. We don't have to go run everybody off that's on the board. We just want to give them some training to make sure everybody's doing the same thing. That's absolutely correct. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is there any other questions, committee? Representative Henry, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you for letting me have just another bite that let me remember what I just wanted to ask anyway. I visited the Equalization Board in Benton County on more than one occasion, and it's happened to me and another member of
▶ Play
Speaker 49 16:56
my family. Mr. Chairman, would you get attention here? They're not paying attention to what I'm saying. Committee, just keep the conversations to
▶ Play
minimum. But when I've appeared before that board before, on at least two occasions with me and then with a member of my family, one of the board members, one of the equalization board members, say, aren't you old Kim Hendren from over there at Gravett? Now, the immediate, and as a citizen as well, which we all are, I assume, in here, my question to him is what, I want to put an expletive in there, but I'm not supposed to say it, what does that have to do with who I am? And not only did it happen to me, it happened to others, members of my family. And does this bill educate these people? Because it doesn't make any difference. If your name is Asa Hutchinson, when you go before an equalization board, you ought to be treated the same. Does this bill fix that? Yes, sir, it should. I mean, it
▶ Play
goes back to the proper training and the proper procedures, the proper questions to ask, and the proper way to work through the problems. Yes, sir, it
▶ Play
should. Does a citizen have any recourse if that happens? I'll shut up now, Mr. Chairman. Yes,
▶ Play
sir. Ms. Lindsey Boett is going to answer his also, but yes, sir. If you don't get satisfaction out of the Equalization Board, then you take it to your counties, your county judge and county court.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you, Representative Henry. Any other questions, Committee? Representative Hodges, you're recognized. Just a motion at the proper time. Thank you. Thank you. We'll accept that. All right. Any other questions? Okay. Anybody in the audience want to speak for or against the bill? We have David, I believe, Hogue to speak against the bill. Okay. Have a seat on the end. And you have a handout that you want to hand out to the members? I gave it to the staff. Okay. We'll hand that out. I'll get a little chance to get this out. Mr. Hogue, if you want to go ahead and recognize yourself.
▶ Play
Thank you. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, good morning. Thank you for your service. I am David Hogue. I'm the county... Can you press the button? There we go. Good morning. I am David Hogue. I'm the county civil attorney for Faulkner County. I'm here representing the county assessor and the county judge. The bill that you're looking at, we are not coming in opposition to the bill in general. We are coming to suggest some modifications and some caution at the most. I want to tell you the context in which Faulkner County comes. Faulkner County has been in litigation on many of the issues involved in this bill since 2012. We've been in litigation with subsidiaries of Southwestern Energy, and many of the points that are covered in this bill are the very things that we have fought over and grappled with for the last several years. The story behind that litigation is in 2012, Southwestern Energy basically gave Faulkner County a rendering of their holdings, you might say. That rendering was incorrect in 2012. Now, my tax assessor, my client, assessed that, assessed it, I think, correctly, and then it went to the Equalization Board, and then it went to the County Court, and then it went to the Circuit Court, and now that is up on appeal before the Supreme Court of Arkansas. Some of the things that you're looking at in this bill, such as who can sign a petition for appeal and so forth, are the very exact issues that are up for appeal before the Supreme Court. This bill very much, or parts of this bill, not all of it, but this bill very much looks to me, at least in part, as a response to some of the very litigation that we've had. And some of the things I want to point out is, like I said, when DeSoto Gathering, which is a subsidiary of Southwestern Energy, filed their assessment, they told us that they had certain property that was in Faulkner County, and then we go through, we appeal that, we argue that for extended litigation, and just recently, they've come back right at the cusp of the three-year mark and said, oh, gosh, we made a mistake. One of the properties that we said was in Faulkner County is not actually in Faulkner County. We want our money back. Okay, that causes a pause for our assessor because in our case, the company, which is which is obviously big business, knew back in 2013 that the property they were assessing in Faulkner County did not belong in Faulkner County. That was their mistake, and that was their error. But under this bill, as drafted and as presented, they would be able to come back three years after the fact and not only get an easy shot at a refund, but I need you to know that that refund would come out of the pockets of the school district, because that money, obviously, it doesn't just sit in the coffers of the county and so forth. It's passed out to the taxing entities, and in our area, one of those taxing entities is the Guy School District, who is a school district that's in distress. Why is it in distress? Because of the tax appeals that have been going on for quite this long between big business and the tax assessor. They finally petitioned a refund, and that's been dismissed. All of their cases have been dismissed on procedural issues. I tell you this story because I think that you may have an illusion here of people that are supporting this bill other than the people who are most affected by it. The people who are supporting this bill, I believe, are either assessors who don't have a whole lot of experience with refunds and and the appeal process or it's big business who has a very large interest in in making the appeal process and refund process a lot easier on them at the expense of and to the detriment of your constituents your voters and the small schools that are there in your areas and I want to disabuse you of any illusion you may have on that point as I said earlier to someone else it's it's easier it's easy to not object to the potholes in a road if you never travel that road what I'm doing here before you today is on behalf of Angela Hill and Jim Baker in Faulkner County I'm telling you about the potholes and I want to just briefly walk you through those as we as we go first of all, in section four, this bill clearly keeps the burden of proof on the taxpayers. If David Hogue has a problem with a tax assessment, then David Hogue has the burden of proof to prove by preponderance of the evidence that this assessment is incorrect or erroneous. In just about every judicial setting that you could find in the state of Arkansas or the United States, if I have the burden of proof, I am to present my case first, and I have a second bite at presenting my case after the fact. If your effort in this bill is to keep this fair for the taxpayers who are appealing, that burden of proof makes sense that the person bearing the burden of proof has two shots at the apple, and the assessor has one shot to explain why it shouldn't be changed. What this bill does is reverses that scenario so that where the burden of proof only has one shot. If you want to make it fair for the taxpayer, they need the two shots at the apple, not the one shot in the middle. That's just one issue. I would take you to section five. In the past and up till today, presently, in order to make a change in a tax assessment, you had to hire, you had to have corroborative evidence. You can't just come in and say, this is my opinion and this should be convincing. You have to bring in someone else besides your own opinion to persuade. What you're doing, and that's an objective standard, what you're doing in this is removing that objective standard, which by definition makes the bill more subjective, which makes the hearing more subjective, and then And you leave it more up to the people who are just making the decision without any extra proof coming in. Someone asked the question, does this make it easier or harder for someone to have a phone call and get something done? I say it makes it easier for someone without a whole lot of evidence to get an adjustment on their assessment because you're taking out the objective standards from the law that exists there to make it an easier decision for the Equalization Board. Another way that this takes out the objective standards is if you look into Section 5, that's where they take out the no reduction shall be allowed except on evidence corroborative. As we speak right now, there's two, Section 2 says that you have to, in the past, you have to show that the assessment is clearly erroneous, manifestly excessive, or confiscatory. With the new bill, you don't have to show that. You specifically remove the objective standards. What this bill that's before you is doing is saying let's remove the objective standards that would be easy for an equalization board to follow and make a decision based on, let's remove those objective standards, give them a lot of training, and then make it entirely subjective what the decision is going to be. It puts all the weight on the equalization board and then requires the very training that Representative Flowers was asking about. I agree with the idea that if this training is to happen, it should be given to everybody because I submit to you that just because someone is an attorney doesn't mean in some rural county in Arkansas doesn't mean that they are going to be a tax attorney, doesn't mean that they know this code, doesn't mean that they're going to be educated as much as they should such that they should be exempt from this training. This bill is going from objective to subjective. Finally, in Section 6, the Equalization Board says must adopt rules of procedure as established by the director. I would question the reasoning behind that on the point that if the director is going to establish the rules of procedure, why shouldn't the state law just say that the Equalization Board must follow those rules rather than putting a second notch in there where they have to adopt it and then follow the rules. All you're doing is creating an appeal process for people in case the Equalization Board forgets to adopt the rules, then you have a legal problem of what happens then. You should remove the spot where they have to adopt the rules and just say that they have to follow the rules that are made by the director. Finally, and this is actually the biggest point for Angie Hill, my assessor, as well as my county judge. This is a big effort, and I applaud the effort to be fair to taxpayers. But as much as we're making things easier for the taxpayers to get the refund and give them time and the ability to get the refunds or do the appeals, if you come back to my case with DeSoto Gathering or Southwestern Energy, the assessor did not make the mistake in our case. The taxpayer made the mistake, knew that they made the mistake, refused to correct the mistake by filing their proper renderings in the correct county. And what happens as a result of that is that if that were to go through and that refund were to be granted, a guy school district who is already in fiscal distress would have to pay back roughly $100,000. This is not fairness for the taxpayers. This is fairness for the big corporations that are taxpayers. The taxpayers are the people who will be hurt when that school has to pay back $100,000 and their kids have computers that they can't afford to upgrade. When that school can't afford because they don't have a good budget anymore because they've had to pay it back to the county or the state when they can't afford to run their schools correctly. Finally, that's all my specific points. I want you to understand and I applaud you for the work already done there's many good points in this and I'm not going through the whole bill obviously because I don't want to waste your time with saying how great the other points are these refunds and appeals are not tools used by the common Joe they are tools used by big corporations that have lots of money and lots of assets and lots of time to litigate that that is who this bill will help not the common taxpayer so I would urge the members of this committee to evaluate who are you trying to help, the common Joe, the kids in the schools, or the big businesses who already have plenty of benefits with all their assets and their ability to argue through litigation for years at a time. I am simply asking you to modify this bill, give it the time it requires to get it right for your voters, for your constituents, and finally, again, I thank you for your time and welcome any questions you may have.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Strogue. We have a couple of questions. Certainly. Representative Collins? You recognize your
▶ Play
question? Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. So, Mr. Hogue, the potential amendments that you have top-lined, have you discussed these with the bill sponsor? I mean, have we had a discussion about which of these things should be amended into
▶ Play
this bill? I personally have not. My client, again, is Angela Hill and Jim Baker, the county judge and the county assessor. The county assessor specifically has been in numerous meetings, some of which I understand she wasn't allowed to bring other people, some of which she did bring other people, none of which fit my schedule such that I could go. But she has expressed her opinions on this over and over and over, and that has been made aware. I understand that there was a vote among the assessor's organization, and my understanding of that vote is that the assessor's organization chose to remain neutral on this. I've heard just today that the assessor's organization may be in favor of it. That's not what my client tells me.
▶ Play
At some point, Mr. Chair, I'd appreciate it if Lindsey Bailey from the counties could come to the end of the table and just give a perspective on why we don't need these and why they're confident that they don't need any of these changes in order not to have have our property taxes fall off a cliff when the lawyers
▶ Play
start running the gun. All right, we'll ask her to come down after we get through here. Any other questions for Mr. Ho? Representative Hinder, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you. One thing that you, I think you make some good points in this section four and five and so forth. But one thing you've said a couple of times, and it bothers me. You said that this outfit put their property in the wrong county, the wrong school district. They paid, apparently, in what you said, $100,000 in taxes, and they knew they were doing it to start with. And now, three years later, they want their $100,000 back out of the place where they intentionally paid it wrong. Correct. That sounds like a stupid company, me. I agree. Well, tell me, is there any reason for doing stuff like that? we need to put another section in this bill to
▶ Play
get rid of some executives? I couldn't agree more. I don't know why they would do that. The history of this litigation has been gamesmanship, quite honestly. We've been through discovery for many years at a time and gotten to the point of motions to compel discovery. The company that I'm talking about refused to give and refused to give proper discovery at the proper time in a timely fashion. They've been ordered by other counties to provide listing of their assets, and it was when we, in the discovery process of litigation, demanded a more detailed list of their assets so that we could assess it more carefully than we could, given their initial rendering, that they say they discovered that they had done it incorrectly. I agree with the humor in that,
▶ Play
Mr. Representative. All right. Any more questions? I'm sorry. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
Mr. Hoke, you made mention about the Tax Assessors Association. Just a point of clarification, the Tax Assessors Association is not in support, nor are they against this bill? Is that what you said? That's my understanding from my client. So they took no position at all? Again, that's my understanding from my client.
▶ Play
I don't speak for the Tax Assessors Association, but my client has said that her understanding was they voted to remain neutral on this bill.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gray, you recognize it. Thank you, Mr. Chair. More of a question for you or the committee or the sponsor of the bill. But I think a lot of us were under the impression that this was an agreed upon bill. supported by the assessor. So some clarification on that would be extremely helpful.
▶ Play
MR. Okay. Well, after Mr. Hoek's through, we'll have the sponsor come back down and set and answer these questions and his legal team. Any other questions? Okay. Mr. Hoek, thank you. MR. Thank you for your time. MR. All right. If Lindsey Bailey's in the office, or in the office, in the committee room, Have her come
▶ Play
down there, sit down, and recognize yourself. I'm Lindsay Bailey with the Association of Counties, liaison to the Arkansas Assessors Association. Representative Jett and Mr. Parker, along with Bob Smith, brought this bill to me back maybe in the first week of January, if not sooner, with a draft of this bill that is very different than the draft you see before you today. After no less than eight meetings with Representative Jet, Mr. Parker, myself, in the last three or four bringing in the Assessors Association leadership, we came up with the bill that you see before you today. It is an agreed-upon bill by the assessors. We recognize that up until now, the EQ board appeals system especially has not always been fair to the taxpayer. There was some resistance at first in making some of these changes, such as getting rid of the standards that Mr. Hogue pointed out, the clearly erroneous, confiscatory, and manifestly unjust. but when it comes down to it it was pointed out to us and we conceded that it just doesn't make for a level playing field for a taxpayer we came in good faith and agreed to this bill because we think it's the right thing to do obviously not everything in this bill is something that we would have hand and cherry picked ourselves but this did come from weeks and several meetings worth of negotiations and this is the bill that was agreed to by the assessors Thank you, ma'am. Will you take some questions? Sure. Okay.
▶ Play
Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you for addressing that issue. So just for clarification, agreed upon with liaison from the counties and assessor leadership is what I'm hearing from you. But can you say to this committee that the collective of the assessors in the state of Arkansas have endorsed this bill? Because that's the answer we're getting. And second part to the sponsor, and my apologies for asking this question at this time, but it's just some confusion on the endorsement, would be, is there an opportunity for members to talk to their assessors? I haven't reached out to mine because I was under the understanding that the assessors had endorsed this bill. Thank
▶ Play
you, Representative Gray. First of all, I just want to say, for just a second, let me back up. You know, everybody's busy here. If you're asking me if I call 75 assessors, no, sir, I have not. Has the assessor board, the executive board come and said that they would agree upon this bill? Yes, I was told by Mr. Barrett-Tarney that the executive assessor board has agreed to this bill. I'm not sitting down. I'm not playing games, you know. We don't have games, you know. The gentleman just testified a while ago. saying that the gamesmanship's been made here. I can assure you nobody's in this table's got room for
▶ Play
games or time for games. Representative Gray. Representative Jed, I appreciate that point, and I definitely wasn't asking you to call. I don't have time to call half of them with you, so I absolutely didn't mean to suggest that. My question was more to Lindsay in the form of was this endorsed by the executive committee of the assessors with your cooperation, or was this something that all the assessors collectively endorsed? I can tell
▶ Play
you the exact process we did on this bill. After several meetings with myself and Bear Cheney, Representative Jett and Mike Parker, I got with the assessor's leadership and they got the bill to where they thought they could agree to it. It was then sent out over the assessor's list served to all 75 assessors, and all 75 assessors were given the opportunity to come to a meeting and give their input. That meeting did take place, and more amendments were made at that meeting, some of which were accepted and some were not, but all assessors did have the
▶ Play
opportunity to participate. Okay. Thank you. Representative Collins. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Ms. Bailey, I appreciate the tremendous work that you've done along with Representative jet here, and also how you've enrolled the assessors, and your main point, which I always love to hear, is we're trying to level the playing field. We're not just going to say me, me, me, me, me. It warms the cockles of my heart to hear somebody say that. But what I want to make sure you also know that you have is you have support in the legislature for making sure we don't give away the farm. And so if there were amendments or things that the assessors felt or feel are important here, I'd rather take sure-footed, slower steps to loosening the reins of tax receipts than leaps and bounds where wily people can blow holes in tax collection. So I just want to make sure that we haven't opened the window to create loopholes which can get blown into unintended and unbelievable big numbers. I've seen it happen again and again and again, and I'm fearful it could happen here. If you're telling me you're not worried about that, I'll go with your word. But if in the back of your mind you're saying there are three things we ought to be doing here, I'd rather get those done and then move forward.
▶ Play
Is that a question, Representative Collins? Yes, ma'am. Can you put it into a form of a
▶ Play
question for me? Are there three things that we ought to do to make
▶ Play
this bill better or not? I think the bill, as you see it today, is the best bill that we could come up with and
▶ Play
agree to. Let me restate my question. Do you personally think there are three things that we should do to make this bill better if it was just you and you didn't have to agree with anyone else?
▶ Play
Well, unfortunately, I don't speak in that capacity. I speak for the Assessors Association, and that's who I represent. When they voted, there was only one assessor on the executive board who voted against these changes, and it was Mr. Hogue's
▶ Play
client. Thank you. Representative Deeks, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you. I was trying to follow the example in Faulkner County, and I'm not really sure I understand how Faulkner County ended up taking $100,000 of money that it wasn't owed. So I'm confused in that part of it. But I just would like to ask either of the folks at the end of the table, does this bill offer
▶ Play
protections, enhanced protections for the taxpayer? Yes. I mean, this is the whole position of the bill, is to make it a taxpayer-friendly level of playing tax. It's basically when Representative Ken Bragg, I think, last session, ran a taxpayer fairness bill with DFA. And the bottom line is this kind of goes hand-in-hand with the bill that we passed last session to make the taxpayers be on equal footing, if you will. I'm not saying the assessor's doing anything wrong. I think a lot of them are doing a great job. This bill's not coming after the assessors, but this bill is trying to give the taxpayers, you know, when you talk about the burden of proof, the promise of proof, you know, we're talking about fair market value. Why would we not want to have our property assessed on fair market value or residential value? You know, that's the whole reason why we're bringing this bill forward. Representative Armstrong, you're recognized
▶ Play
for your question. MR. So I'm just
▶ Play
trying to get ‑‑ thanks, Mr. Chairman, Representative Jettin. Thanks. I'm glad I'm on this bill, and I agree we're trying to do the right thing, but the Executive Committee, the Executive Assessors Board Committee was the final vote, correct? MS. That's correct. MR. And Mr. Hogue's client is the only one you said that voted against it, correct? MS. That is correct. and the assessors presented this to the entire association across the state?
▶ Play
I, along with their president, presented it to them over their listserv that all 75 members are a part of.
▶ Play
Okay, so, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. So the process in which if you presented it to them all over their listserv, they had a time to review, a time to comment, and a time to give that feedback to the executive board. That feedback was taken in. the executive board voted, were the assessors then notified that Stone is the way of the walk and this is the direction we're going or that this bill get created and then you say this is where we're going? I'm trying to figure out if they have been given the full level of transparency in the process, juxtaposed to the CEO telling the rest of the company we all got to wear khakis on Friday now? Yes, and
▶ Play
that's a fair question. I'm confident that they have all been thoroughly vetted and all through the process, as well as the conclusion of what the final bill would be. And I'd
▶ Play
also like to point out, we've been working on this bill for about a year now, probably a little bit over a year. Today, about five minutes before this meeting started is the very first time I've ever heard about this issue. I would think that Faulkner County would have had a major issue with this of this magnitude. They would reach out to the bill sponsored. And this is the very first time within five minutes walking to my office before we ran this bill. It's the very first time I've
▶ Play
heard about this issue. A follow-up, Mr. Chairman. Well, in consideration of that, is there any room, Representative Jed, if there are any modifications to Representative Collins' point, on its way to the other end? Are we willing to modify and adjust this as we go so that the sausage can
▶ Play
be? Absolutely. This is, I mean, I don't know if we ever pass a bill out of this building that's perfect, you know, we hardly ever see a bill that's perfect. I know maybe Representative Ease might have a perfect bill every so often, but absolutely, you know, this is, you know, we want to get this thing right, you know, as Representative Collins mentioned, you know, that we don't want to wake up and tear stuff up, you know. But on the other side, you know, we start talking about mistakes. First of all, there's a three-year cap looked back by the Taxpayers' Bill of Rights from 1999. I mean, so nobody can go past three years to look back. Second of all, we talk about schools and valuations of schools and schools getting the money. If a mistake had not been made, they wouldn't have got the money to begin with. So, I mean, it would be like you're going to use an analogy from Representative Collins. It would be like you're going to a store and giving the clerk a $100 bill for $50 worth of merchandise, and the clerk gives you $500 back. Are you obligated to give that money back? I would say yes. You know, I think you're morally bound to do that. You know, and for somebody to argue otherwise, I think that we're just going to have to disagree on that. But I can assure you, you know, if a mistake, the school would never have
▶ Play
had the money had a mistake not been made. Representative Brack, you have a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. This concern section five may be a question for Mr. Parker. Just clarification, or Mr. Hogue. We talked about reduction should not be allowed except on evidence corroborative of that property. The concern about removing that, but that doesn't imply that that evidence can't be brought up during the appeal process, does it? Absolutely not, Representative Bragg.
▶ Play
I mean, this is an attempt to go with these issues a different way. how is a taxpayer going to carry the burden of proof unless they have evidence of that nature? There may be other, just this is intended to not limit what they come forward with to one particular issue. It's to let them present all of the evidence that they might have. So that's the whole purpose of this, and providing the tools to equalization boards to understand how this works. And the
▶ Play
other statement in there, and item two about presumption of correctness or weight of authority. In other words, is that saying that just because the county has an assessment, that doesn't mean it necessarily carries more weight or it's not right and that the taxpayer is trying to – they come in on equal footing as far as evidence is concerned?
▶ Play
That's right. They come in on equal footing. The assessor goes first. They explain to the board why the assessment is the way it is because the taxpayer is objected to it. They come in and explain the assessment. The taxpayer explains what their problem is with it, presents the evidence that they have. If they have more evidence that it needs adjusted, then it's correct. The Equalization Board is supposed to adjust it. That's the whole purpose of the equalization process. And, you know, what this language that you just pointed out goes to is the fact that the assessment process is not complete until both the assessor and the Equalization Board have had their say. That's what the system is all
▶ Play
Speaker 120 49:04
about. Okay, thank you. Representative Gray,
▶ Play
correctness. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Jett, I want to say, and we all get frustrated a lot of times when people just talk to be talking, I absolutely appreciate why this bill is coming forth and will admit that I am asking some questions, but I'm supportive of this bill. My frustration is not with you, sir, with you telling us that this issue, which is obviously a big issue to Faulkner County, just got brought to you five minutes before we run the bill. My frustration, honestly, and I want to take the opportunity to say this, is the representation by the Association of Counties that this was an endorsement by the assessors. I have no problem with saying it was an endorsement by the Executive Board. I think that's fair. I would question if the Associate of Counties knew issues that assessors had with it and bit and bring it to you sooner, I would have an issue there. So my question is, or my ask is, frankly, if it's endorsed by the Executive Committee, there's a structure in place, that's why you have an Executive Committee, I absolutely get that. I just would appreciate some clarification going forward, because we have seen times where it's endorsed by the county judges because they've gotten all the judges in a room and they've taken a vote on it, and that's kind of the representation we got on the assessors on this one. So Representative Jed, I appreciate your frustration in these questions, I appreciate the point you make supportive of the bill, appreciate the bill, but I would just ask the association of counties going forward to provide us some clarification on things like
▶ Play
that. Sure, I'd be happy to. What you pointed out with the county judges, you're correct, that does happen often, and it really with them has to do with the timing of their meetings and that they all happen to be in a meeting here in Little Rock and in the same room, and you do have the opportunity to have a full discussion with everyone in the room and for everyone to take a vote. Unfortunately, at the time this took place, getting all of the assessors, all 75 assessors in a room to discuss this was not an option. Like I said, we did put it out on the list served to them, and we did have a meeting and requested all who were interested to come and speak to it. I do want to put on the record, in fairness to Mr. Hogue and to his client, and in fairness to Representative Jett, that I had heard all of these concerns from Faulkner County and from her deputy assessor before. That did come to me. I was aware of those concerns. All the other assessors who were in the room heard those concerns, and they just weren't concerns of the other assessors. I relayed to Representative Jett what the final decisions were. I gave some other suggestions that were negotiated down and some were accepted, some were not. I then took those back to the assessors and the ones who were participating at that time said that they were okay with it and they would go ahead to an agreed to bill. I don't want to make it look like Faulkner County hadn't fully vetted their concerns to me and to the other assessors before this time they had. That just never made its way back to Representative Jett. Thank you
▶ Play
very much for that explanation and I I appreciate you taking the time to explain it like that.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Hendren, you have a question? Yes, sir. I just settled down for a nap here on Representative Eve's turnaround to me and raised that $100,000 deal again. Sorry about that. Sorry, he even woke me up at all, right? There used to be a newscaster that said, let's just shuck right down to the cob. So let me ask you a specific question. Whatever happens to this bill, is that going to have anything at all to do with who gets that $100,000? If we pass the bill, does that company get the $100,000 back? If we don't pass the bill, does the school district keep it? Maybe I can understand that answer. Nobody
▶ Play
knows. I would not feel comfortable speaking to that case that's in current litigation. I imagine that would be up to the judge at the court that it's in at this time. I would
▶ Play
just point out this bill does not have an emergency clause. I have no idea where that litigation stands, what the courts might consider or where it is in the briefing or anything of that nature. But if you're trying to make a bill have an impact on continuing existing litigation, there's some language you can put in a bill that effectively says that, says it's supposed to deal with existing litigation. This bill doesn't have any language to that effect because this is the first I've heard about the litigation and wouldn't have put it in there anyway. It's certainly not intended, and I don't believe it's going to have an impact on pending litigation. Representative Lee said he and I would
▶ Play
split it if you can't find what to do with it.
▶ Play
All right, committee. All right, thank you. I see no more questions from the committee. Anyone who's speaking for the bill? Seeing none, would you like to close the bill? Mr. Chairman, I think we
▶ Play
beat this horse enough. I think I'm
▶ Play
just going to go ahead and close. All right. Representative Honridge, you're recognized for your motion. Yes, motion do pass. All right. We have a motion do pass. Any debate on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor of the motion, say aye. Aye. All against? No? Your bill has
▶ Play
passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Community, I appreciate your patience on
▶ Play
that bill. That was a lot of fun, wasn't it? All right. Next on the list, Representative Hendren, would you like to run your bill or are you passing over? I don't think this would be the best day to do that, no. All right. Members, let's go to House Bill 1662, Representative Jett, you're at the end of that one, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, members. I hope the next two bills, members, go just a little bit easier. Basically, members, what we have is a couple of DFA housekeeping bills. And to my right, I have a very smart cat, Mr. Paul Gearing. I'm going to start us off, and he'll answer any questions that you guys might have. But House Bill 1682 would amend the current law to say noncompliant taxpayers have collected state and local taxes from the customers who have withheld income taxes from their employees and have not paid the taxes collected to, that's owed to the DFA, then upon three failures to pay the tax, authority is granted to DFA to issue a business closure order to the non-compliant taxpayer who then must cease business operations until delinquent taxes are paid. A business closure order is subject to an appeal through an appeal process with DFA. If the appeal process is sustained, the owner has to close in 20 days, and the owner still has additional recourse to take it to circuit court. With that, Mr. Chairman, I'll entertain any questions. Okay. Representative Johnson, you
▶ Play
have a question? So if a business doesn't send the money on the taxes they withheld, you can close them down. If they work out an agreement where they're on a payment plan, you're going to
▶ Play
Speaker 12 56:20
still let them stay in business? Is that correct? Yes, sir, Representative John. I'm sorry, Paul Gehring with DFA. Yes, sir. Usually business closure is the procedure of last resort at DFA. We try to be as cooperative as possible with taxpayers that are having difficulties with the business and making sure that their obligations are taken care of. But certainly if a business does proceed to business closure, there's always the option that we can work out a payment plan with the taxpayer. But usually if the matter is proceeding to a business closure and a payment plan is no longer an option due to the circumstances, then we certainly are going to have to proceed only to a business closure and having a final order entered only when all of our options are just unavailable.
▶ Play
Okay. Because your little business closure letter does scare people pretty good. You know, they hadn't filed their zeros on their withholdings, but okay.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Johnson, I think it's directed to, say, if an employee is holding payroll Texas, for example, that money technically does not belong to them. It belongs to the employees. I mean, we're talking about egregious violations here is what we're really talking about. Yes,
▶ Play
sir. And those are trust fund. The IRS, they call it a trust fund. And, you know, they're held in escrow for the state, and I agree with you. I just didn't want it to be non-negotiable if the business owner wants to pay those taxes and wants to try to work out something. Yes, sir. I want to make sure we're not being non-negotiable.
▶ Play
I completely agree. and, you know, they have, you know, they're going to be afforded three failures before anything will take effect, and then they still have the pill process, and then they can always take it to
▶ Play
court on top of that. Thank you very much. You're welcome, sir. Representative Ferguson. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Quick question. After the third failure, is there a penalty if the business owner has not paid? There
▶ Play
Speaker 12 58:23
are certainly already penalties in existing law that certainly can apply to failure to file the returns, failure to pay the tax when owed. Just want to clarify that the business closure procedure, it's already been a part of Arkansas law for several years now. The main purpose of this bill is once the administrative procedures have concluded, if the taxpayer is going to want to continue to operate the business after they have filed an appeal to circuit court, they have to get permission from the court in order to continue to operate.
▶ Play
All right. Any other questions, Committee? Representative Armstrong? So
▶ Play
this is a very confusing question, and there's a representative that has an issue right now, and he's bringing a bill before us. hypothetically speaking, he manufactures, um, a product and he gave away a certain amount of those products as donations to churches. He had no idea, wasn't aware that he's actually supposed to pay a tax on any of those items that he's given away. So in the instance that a business owner, small business owner is under that, or say Joe gives me a tractor trailer, VCRs and DVDs come out the next day. Joe's still got to pay sales taxes on what he donated to me, but that's very unclear to the business owner until they come to DF&A. So if you're going to close their business down, I mean, how do they go through that whole appeals process in the event that something like that happens if there's a real gray
▶ Play
Speaker 12 59:57
area for the owner? Representative, currently what you're describing there would be an issue for an audit and an assessment. Typically, in purposes of an audit that results in an assessment of tax, there is the procedure under the Arkansas Tax Procedure Act to appeal the auditor's assessment and then have an administrative law judge make a determination on whether or not the tax is owed. And then if the taxpayer disagrees with the ALJ's final determination, they can appeal to circuit court, and there are certainly those procedures that are available. What we're talking about here for purposes of business closure, those are generally taxpayers that have stopped filing their returns, and if they have stopped filing their returns quite often, they're not even sending in the tax that's been collected to. So I think what you've described is an audit question that generally is not going to result in a business closure unless the taxpayer just is not, has discontinued filing their monthly returns and has discontinued paying their taxes when due on a monthly basis.
▶ Play
MR. I'm not expecting a confusing question from a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:14
confusing member. MR. All right.
▶ Play
Any more questions for the committee? Representative Hodges. MR. Thank you, Chair. I just have, I mean, this may be a juvenile question, but you struck some, it looks like some language is struck out on Section 2, on line A, when it says, if the decision of the hearing officer is under whatever, Section 2618102, is to affirm the closure of the business, the decision shall be submitted in writing and delivered by the United States Postal Service or by hand to the noncompliant taxpayer. Why was that struck out, and how will they be notified? I know that in banking, if I want to make sure that a customer is notified, I do a certified letter so I can get my receipt back to know that they were served with that letter. How will the customer be notified that they have to comply
▶ Play
Speaker 12 1:02:16
or their business is going to be closed. And that's certainly a good question, Representative Hodges, not juvenile at all. The reason for that language to be stricken is it's just merely duplicative of the notification requirements that are already existing in the Arkansas Tax Procedure Act. We are going to continue to notify the taxpayer consistent with the requirements of the TPA. That language in the business closure section was just unnecessary, and we just took it out in this bill because it was really obsolete. and not at all required to be in the statutory language because it exists elsewhere in the Tax Procedure Act. Okay, seeing no more questions.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:55
Is anyone in, and no one signed up to speak for or against the bill? Are you, Representative Jett, you closed for the bill? I am, sir. All right. I'll have them take a motion to do pass. I'll give the motion to do pass. I have a motion to do pass. Any debate on the motion? All in favor of the motion, say aye. Aye. Against, nay. Representative Jett, you passed your bill. Thank you, sir. All right. And members, House Bill 1683, the Representative Jett showed today. So we
▶ Play
were recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman, members House Bill 1683 is a DFA housekeeping bill. It has to do with trucks and over-the-road carriers, IRP, International Registration Plan. Basically, all this is doing is setting up an appeal process, a mechanism for an appeal process for anyone who challenges a DFA mileage audit report. IRP is a registration agreement among all states, the District of Columbia and Canada for apportional fees on the basis of total distance operated in all jurisdiction. I'm assuming this is IFCA. Is that right? This goes back to the people that have the trucks and stuff. It goes back to the IFCA stickers that trucks run in different states. It's broke out. The driver's got to keep up with what miles they run in what states. And the apportionment part of that way taxes are due, because, say, if you run more miles in Texas than you do Arkansas, more tax money goes to Texas and Arkansas or vice versa. So if there's an appeal, this actually sets in place an appeal process with the federal government and for the truckers that I'll be glad to answer any questions or attempt to. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:47
Hendren, do you have a question? I don't know whether this deals
▶ Play
with this or not, but it's something that I've been interested in for a long time. If you buy a new semi-trader tractor now, you're going to spend probably $120,000 or $130,000. dollars. And the practice that we've done from the past was basically that in Oklahoma. In fact, if you look at these trucks up and down the road, you'll see a tag maybe of not very many Arkansas, at least to be in Oklahoma, perhaps, and others. And the reason you do that is because the property tax on that tractor for $130,000 is much less maybe in another state than it is Arkansas. And for years, we've talked about how to get those people who actually have businesses in Arkansas. Now, people like Walmart and some of the J.B. Hunt and these Internet Tysons, these international or national and international companies, there's a little different question. But have we does this bill do anything? And have we done anything to encourage Arkansas operators to base tag, base plate these tractors that are proportional on their fuel charges with this bill to get them to base plate those trucks in Arkansas? So are that little school district that's going to lose that hundred thousand dollars, maybe that Lansing is going to get. Is there any way to see that we can get more of that in this bill? And have we done it? Maybe we've done something and fixed it, and I just
▶ Play
don't know about it. I'm sorry. Go ahead. Representative Andrews, I think somebody's actually running a bill to address that this session. As far as I know, this bill does not do that. This bill just basically picks up the portion of what trucks, how many miles, what trucks run in what state. But all this bill has to do with the appeal process. If somebody gets caught up in a DFA audit, all this does is set a mechanism to where that truck owner or owner-operator, if you will, has a proper appeal through that apportionment. But to your question, sir, I think, and I don't know who's doing it, but I
▶ Play
think somebody's actually running a bill to address your concerns. Could somebody help me with that and tell me? I'd appreciate
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:48
it. You're welcome, sir. I think that knows this. I've seen any other questions from the committee. Anybody in the audience signed up for or against the bill? Representative Jett, you want to close for your bill? Mercifully closed, Mr. Chairman. All right. Motion for the committee. Representative Ferguson? Do pass. We have a do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All against, no. All right, say it. Representative Jett, you're passing
▶ Play
the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. I appreciate your patience today. Thank you very
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:20
much. Committee, I know nothing else on the agenda. If that debate will be adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1562 Jett TO REQUIRE THAT\ PARTNERSHIP INCOME BE DETERMINED FOR STATE INCOME TAX PURPOSES BY USING AN APPORTIONMENT METHOD.

0:13 - 2:51 10 segments 4 speakers

REGULAR AGENDA

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1772 Jett TO IMPROVE THE FAIRNESS OF PROPERTY TAX ADMINISTRATION AND APPEALS.

2:51 - 55:01 162 segments 20 speakers

HB1647 C. Douglas TO EXCLUDE MANUFACTURER REBATES ON MOTOR VEHICLES FROM THE DEFINITIONS USED FOR PURPOSES OF DETERMINING SALES AND USE TAXES.

HB1649 Douglas TO AMEND THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR NEW MOTOR VEHICLES C. PURCHASED BY NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS OR WITH URBAN MASS TRANSIT ADMINISTRATION FUNDS.

HB1565 Jett TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE AND EXPIRATION OF GROSS RECEIPTS TAX PERMITS AND THE COLLECTION OF UNPAID TAXES UPON DISCONTINUATION OF BUSINESS

HB1535 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES.

HB1559 Jett TO AMEND THE CORPORATE INCOME TAX WITHHOLDING REQUIREMENTS FOR MEMBERS OR OWNERS OF A PASS-THROUGH ENTITY.

SB140 Files TO PROVIDE FOR THE COLLECTION OF SALES AND USE TAX RATHER THAN USE TAX ON SALES BY CERTAIN REMOTE SELLERS.

HB1680 Jett TO CLARIFY THE ABILITY OF THE DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION TO CANCEL OR REFUSE TO ISSUE, EXTEND, OR REINSTATE A LICENSE, PERMIT, OR REGISTRATION UNDER STATE TAX LAW.

HB1681 Jett TO AMEND THE DEFINITIONS UNDER THE ARKANSAS TAX PROCEDURE ACT; AND TO PROVIDE THAT ERRONEOUSLY PAID REFUNDS ARE CONSIDERED UNDERPAYMENTS OF TAX AND ARE SUBJECT TO ASSESSMENT.

HB1682 Jett TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS TAX PROCEDURE ACT CONCERNING BUSINESS CLOSURES; AND TO PROVIDE THAT A BUSINESS CLOSURE ORDER ACTS AN AN INJUNCTION PROHIBITING FURTHER BUSINESS OPERATION UNLESS OTHERWISE PROVIDED BY A COURT.

55:01 - 1:03:34 28 segments 7 speakers

HB1683 Jett TO ESTABLISH A MILEAGE AUDIT APPEAL PROCEDURE FOR REGISTRANTS WHO HAVE RECEIVED APPORTIONED REGISTRATION UNDER THE INTERNATIONAL REGISTRATION PLAN.

1:03:34 - 1:07:25 15 segments 3 speakers

HB1693 Rye TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES.

HB1788 Dotson TO PHASE IN AN EXTENSION OF THE NET OPERATING LOSS CARRY-FORWARD PERIOD FOR CALCULATING ARKANSAS INCOME TAX; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CHANGES.

HB1789 Dotson TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING THE CORPORATE FRANCHISE TAX; TO REPEAL THE ARKANSAS CORPORATE FRANCHISE TAX ACT OF 1979; TO MAKE CONFORMING CHANGES.

HB1790 Dotson TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE APPORTIONMENT OF BUSINESS INCOME; AND TO REPEAL THE THROWBACK RULE.

HB1795 Gates TO EXEMPT CERTAIN DONATED ITEMS FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.

HB1796 Gates TO AMEND THE TIME LIMITATIONS FOR TAX ASSESSMENTS, COLLECTIONS, REFUNDS, AND PROSECUTION; AND TO LIMIT THE TIME AVAILABLE FOR A TAX AUDIT.

HB1824 J. Williams TO ALLOW A PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED VETERANS WITH A ONE HUNDRED PERCENT (100%) TOTAL DISABILITY THAT MAY NOT BE PERMANENT; AND TO CLARIFY THE REQUIREMENTS FOR ESTABLISHING ELIGIBILITY FOR THE EXEMPTION.

HB1844 Beck TO AMEND THE DISTRIBUTION OF REVENUES DERIVED FROM THE SEVERANCE TAX.

HB1845 Richey TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR TEACHERS EMPLOYED IN CRITICAL TEACHER SHORTAGE AREAS.

HB1850 Leding TO CREATE THE STRONG FAMILIES ACT; AND TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EMPLOYERS THAT PROVIDE PAID FAMILY AND MEDICAL LEAVE FOR CERTAIN EMPLOYEES.

HB1940 Dalby TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE RECORDATION OF DEEDS FOR PURPOSES OF THE REAL PROPERTY TRANSFER TAX.

HB1965 Jett TO REPEAL PROVISIONS REGARDING THE USE OF SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES FROM REMOTE SELLERS; TO DEPOSIT SALES AND USE TAX REVENUES FROM REMOTE SELLERS INTO A FUND TO BE USED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1987 Fite TO AMEND THE EFFECTIVE DATE PROVISION OF ACTS 2017, NO. 141, FOR CERTAIN C. SECTIONS OF THE ACT.

HB2009 Sturch CONCERNING THE REMITTANCE OF INSURANCE PREMIUM TAXES.

HB2066 Hammer TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL REBATE OF DISTILLATE SPECIAL FUEL TAXES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO CREATE THE DISTILLATE SPECIAL FUEL TAX REFUND FUND.

HB2068 Hammer TO RETURN EXCESS FEDERAL GRANT FUNDS TO THE UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT; AND TO ENCOURAGE RELIEF OF THE NATIONAL DEBT OF THE UNITED STATES.

DEFERRED BILLS

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VEHICLES FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.

HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RECEIVED UNDER THE COMMUNITY MATCH RURAL PHYSICIAN RECRUITMENT PROGRAM.

HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS" ON THE PART OF A COUNTY ASSESSOR IN THE ASSESSMENT OF REAL AND PERSONAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR SALES BY A CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION.

HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF CERTAIN ADVERTISING AN D PROMOTION TAX RECORDS UNDER THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.

HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES; AND TO REMOVE THE THRESHOLD FOR CLAIMING AN INCOME TAX DEDUCTION FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES.

HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR AND REPAIR OF AGRICULTURAL EQUIPMENT AND MACHINERY.

HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES BASED ON THE GROWTH OF INCOME TAX COLLECTIONS.

HB1399 Ballinger HONOR ARKANSAS VETERANS ACT OF 2017.

HB1409 House TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE INCOME TAX FOR SERVICE PAY AND ALLOWANCES OF FOREIGN SERVICE PERSONNEL.

SB120 J. English TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX, SALES AND USE TAXES, AND THE SOFT DRINK TAX; AND TO SUPPLEMENT THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TRUST FUND TO OFFSET DECREASED DEPOSITS FROM TAX REVENUES.

HB1037 Wardlaw TO REGULATE THE SALE OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY; AND TO PROHIBIT OWNERS OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY FROM BIDDING ON OR PURCHASING TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY.

HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PREPAY SALES TAXES.

HB1412 Ballinger TO PROVIDE FOR A PARTIAL PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION FOR DISABLED VETERANS IN PROPORTION TO THE EXTENT OF THE DISABILITY OF THE VETERAN.

HB1395 Leding TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR TAXPAYERS THAT EMPLOY A RECENTLY RETURNED VETERAN.

HB1396 Leding TO EXEMPT FROM THE INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX EDUCATION SCHOLARSHIPS, AWARDS, AND GRANTS FROM NONPROFIT VOLUNTEER SERVICE ORGANIZATIONS.

HB1397 Leding TO EQUALIZE THE SALES TAX TREATMENT OF DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES FOR CERTAIN CLUBS AND FACILITIES; AND TO LEVY A SALES TAX ON DUES AND MEMBERSHIP FEES TO CERTAIN FACILITIES AND CLUBS.

HB1014 Leding TO CREATE THE TEACHER'S CLASSROOM INVESTMENT DEDUCTION.

HB1449 Dotson TO AMEND THE ANNUAL FRANCHISE TAX FOR CORPORATIONS THAT ARE IN THE PROCESS OF LIQUIDATION.

HB1531 G. Hodges TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR EDUCATIONAL LOAN PAYMENTS FOR QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS AND EMPLOYERS OF QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS.

HB1582 Dotson TO EXEMPT CERTAIN ELECTION EQUIPMENT FROM SALES AND USE TAXES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1512 Davis TO REDUCE THE INCOME TAX RATES APPLICABLE TO INDIVIDUALS, TRUSTS, AND ESTATES USING REVENUES DERIVED FROM SALES AND USE TAX FROM SELLERS THAT DO NOT HAVE A PHYSICAL PRESENCE IN THE STATE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1684 Jett TO EXTEND THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR DETERMINING THE CORRECT AMOUNT OF TAX DUE IN RELATION TO CERTAIN AMENDED RETURNS OR VERIFIED CLAIMS FOR CREDIT OR REFUND.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
32 segments
Representative Joe Jett Unverified
40 segments
Speaker 12
12 segments
Representative Bob Johnson Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 25
1 segment
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 39
2 segments
Michael Parker Unverified
10 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
9 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 61
4 segments
Speaker 60
1 segment
Speaker 49
1 segment
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
29 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
7 segments
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Unverified
3 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
11 segments
Lindsay Bailey Unverified
15 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
2 segments
Representative Ken Bragg Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 120
1 segment