Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Education Committee

March 7, 2017 ·Committee Room 138 ·1:54:27
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (51)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB178 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1017 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1020 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLAR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1027 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1029 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1044 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1222 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1408 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1456 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDU…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1457 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1457 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT AND AN OPEN-EN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1458 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL AR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1459 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1510 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE AC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1516 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1516 A. Mayberry -CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING; TO ESTABLISH SCHOOL…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1517 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQ…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1567 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1567 Hammer TO MAKE FOSTER CHILDREN ELIGIBLE FOR A SCHOLARSHIP I…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1574 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1574 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1575 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1575 Lowery TO LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF FUND BALANCES A SCHOOL DISTRI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1576 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1576 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1579 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1579 Vaught TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1583 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DIS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1607 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1607 Della Rosa TO LIMIT THE USE OF AN ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNER'…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1608 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1608 Della Rosa CONCERNING THE ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM DEVELOPED B…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1610 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED W…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1612 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1621 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1621 Lowery TO CHANGE THE DATE OF THE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTION.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1646 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1646 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CON…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1648 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1648 C.Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1666 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1666 Sabin TO REQUIRE INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO PROVID…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1671 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSIO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1672 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1672 STucker CONCERNING ADMISSIONS POLICIES OF CHARTER SCHOOLS;…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1673 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1673 Tucker CONCERNING APPLICATIONS FOR OR AMENDMENTS OF PUBLIC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1689 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1689 Cozart TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING SCHOOL PUBLIC AND FUN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1701 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1701 Love TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1710 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1710 S. Meeks TO REVISE THE CIVICS AND WORLD HISTORY REQUIREMENT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1729 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1729 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CON…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1738 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIREC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1740 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1740 Lowery CONCERNING THE ENROLLMENT OR RE-ENROLLMENT OF HOME-S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1791 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1791 Tucker TO ESTABLISH A FOOD PANTRY MATCHING GRANT PROGRAM TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1802 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1802 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY AN ARKANSAS TAXPAYER TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1805 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1805 Sturch TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING POSTSECONDARY…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1806 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1806 Sturch TO REPEAL A SECTION IN THE ARKANSAS CODE THAT GRANTS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1820 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1820 Dotson CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE THE S…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1831 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1834 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1834 K. Hendren TO PROHIBIT A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT OR OPEN-ENR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1856 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1856 F. Allen TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS EARLY LITERACY ASSESSMEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB26 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS;…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB27 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB27 A. Clark TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF TEACHERS IN A CRITICAL T…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB329 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF C…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB423 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB423 U. Lindsey TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERN…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB427 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB427 Hickey TO AMEND THE POWERS AND AUTHORITY OF THE SECTION 529…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
We do have backups for you today. You do not get to be nurse of the day today. Call this meeting to order. Chair sees a quorum. Good morning, everyone. Again, we'll thank you that stayed late last night with us. We were here at about 630, and I do appreciate every one of y'all doing that. We won't really name who the culprit was that held you here that late, but he is amongst us. All right, this morning we have Senator Files sitting on the end. We are going to hear Senate Bill 178. Senator Files, you are recognized to present 178. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of
▶ Play
Speaker 8 0:46
the committee. I appreciate the opportunity to sit in front of you all and look forward to some good debate here. Senate Bill 178. Is that better? That's better. All right. I won't repeat all that, but thanks for your time and consideration of this bill. This is a very important issue that I think affects all of our kids in all the schools. As you know, we have the testing that goes on through the ACT Aspire in the third through the 10th grade. Took the place of the benchmark, we changed to park, and now we're on the ACT Aspire. And this is not anything disparaging about the ACT Aspire. all this does is delay the accountability portion for the writing that that's all this does for two years this year and then and the next school year and what we found in the testing was that the writing did not correspond to the language or the reading scores hardly at all and if you go back through the data and I've got I've got the data of the top 50 schools in in different grades and there's no correlation to if a school did very very few correlations if a school did well in reading and in language that did not translate to where they did well in writing and so what I'd like to do and I've heard from a lot of superintendents I've heard from a lot of a lot of teachers and and educators on this as well in that you know one one superintendent said hey you know we're taking third and fourth graders and giving them these tests on the computer and they had no keyboarding skills so even if they were great writers they weren't prepared and so this this pause would give them a chance to teach keyboarding skills in those in those grades and then there's just other things some of the arguments against it have been that it will throw us out of federal compliance which I disagree with that argument there's other states that that test along these lines and they don't include writing at all so again this just takes the the writing accountability and delays it for two years it still tests the writing it still scores the writing it still gives the schools the opportunity to correct and make adjustments on any deficiencies but it just doesn't hold them accountable and I don't think it's fair that we that we hold the kids accountable and the teachers even accountable when when we don't have we and the state department don't have a good grasp of of how they're testing for the writing and at the time they took the tests we couldn't they didn't even know how they were being scored if they were hand scored or computer scored so uh that'll i don't want to just go on and on it's not a very long bill and i'll be
▶ Play
glad to answer any questions representative sullivan you're recognized for a question yeah thank you mr chair i've been to a couple of my rural schools who have really struggled with this and then and i appreciate what you're doing i don't know well in two years because it's been pretty much what you talked about they're doing it on tablets and some on computers and just training and experience but i don't know that two years will actually get them the equipment and the training they need to go out there because they don't see any relief in sight have you studied
▶ Play
Speaker 8 3:57
that at all or heard that yes sir yes sir and i think that's a valid point the reason that we did i originally had three years in i met with uh commissioner key and some of his staff and they They said that they do things, and he's here. He can speak for himself, and I'm sure he will. But they do things in three-year cycles, and so this just tries to keep with that three-year cycle. It also gives us a reprieve to where we could come back in two years and then see how it looks. But really, I think, you know, in my district in Fort Smith and from what I've heard in other districts across the state, there's been very little outreach from the state to say, hey, here's why their scores were bad. Here's how we can improve them. here's what we need to do differently so I just think it gives them time to to adapt that way but that is a fair concern but I don't think we could just say I mean unless we just want to repeal the writing altogether and I don't know that that's anybody's goal here in Little Rock is to try not to have better writers but but just in terms of holding the kids in the schools accountable for those scores I don't think it was fair thank you mr. chair represent Walker
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Senator Fowles, does the Department of Education support this bill? No, they do not. Could you address, well let me let me back up. You are seeking, you recall that we had great debate over replacing several tests. Yes, sir. And with the ACT Aspire. Yes, sir. And one reason we did not want to go along with the test that was in use at that time was that it was probably two challenges and that there was a better way to address the students. And for that reason, we approved ACT Aspire, I may say, over my objection. Now, has ACT Aspire had enough time to be objectively evaluated, in your opinion? Well, first of all, I take it you're an educator first, right? No, sir, I'm not. Okay. So I take it you're dealing with this simply as a legislative and popular opinion, as a legislator rather than as an educator? Well, yes. I've
▶ Play
Speaker 8 6:31
spent, and I don't want to divert your question, but I've spent seven years in education in my background. My mom's a teacher. My sister is a principal. And here's where I got involved in this thing is I started looking at the scores of my kids' schools in Fort Smith, and and they were very consistent along what you thought they would be and then we get to the writing portion and they were very very inconsistent and it was an anomaly on every line so I started looking at all of them I started calling the the principals and saying hey tell me tell me why this is why what it is and he said we can't get any good answers we can't get anything back from anybody telling us why this is is how it is so I started diving in as a parent first of I've got an eighth grader, a fifth grader, and a second grader. And just trying to find answers as a parent, and that led me
▶ Play
to where we are today. Here's one of my concerns. There was a great rush, haste, to put some schools in academic distress. I understand. You were one of the supporters of that. I don't know that I was. Well, you voted for it. Okay. And the arguments were the same as you're making now to a great extent about there not being connectivity between what was being tested. I mean, there are all kinds of arguments against doing that. And the outcomes were predictable because we knew that there was a correlation between poverty and race and lower test scores. And now what we have is a test, ACT, Aspire, which goes along with the other one. which says that the majority of the students in this state, 70% of them, mostly white, cannot pass that test. So what you want to do is conceal the reality by saying that this is not the fact, and we want more time to address it, and then we'll look at it two years from now. Is
▶ Play
Speaker 8 8:33
that basically what you're saying? No, sir, I disagree with that completely. um what i'm saying if if that was the case i would say let's do away with this or the test in general and i'm not saying that i'm saying let's continue to test as we're testing and let's address the deficiencies as they come up but in a time where we can't from from this body or from the department perspective we can't tell them why they're doing what they're doing and when you talk about correlations that that's exactly where i'm talking about the correlations are all all consistent except in the writing portion then there is no consistency and there's no correlation I'm saying let's take that section and just put a pause on the accountability I'm not saying quit testing and I understand I've talked to some senators who have your exact concerns and I've we've had some great conversations as to as to testing in general and this is not a conceal or a let's try to to make things look better than they are this is a let's give the schools and the students and the educators an opportunity to address areas where they're not they they don't have the tools to address those things right now and then let's move forward and and score it when we have a good sense about it well tell me let me let me
▶ Play
no let me move on you've already had two let me go i'll go back to you that's fine representative all
▶ Play
you're recognized uh thank you mr chair uh senator files up i had to talk to my superintendent and uh And he's of the opinion that, you know, they want to take what they've done and learn from that, not start all over, just, you know, just keep going and keep testing like that, but learning according to what they've done this past year. So what do you think about that? Or what's the difference between that and what you're wanting to do? Yeah, and I don't disagree with him, and that's
▶ Play
Speaker 8 10:27
why I'm not saying let's just do away with it. I'm saying let's continue to take the test as it is. Let's score it as we score it if we're going to hold them accountable, but let's not grade the school on the writing portion when it's showing no correlation, and I don't know if that's because of the testing module or something else, but it's showing no correlation to the reading or the language sections. If they were showing correlations and everybody was doing poorly, I wouldn't be sitting down here. I'd say we need to address the issues that we need to address. That's not the case. And when I met with the department folks the first time, they go through a bunch of reasoning, and I said, you can still do all of those things with this bill. We're just not holding the school or the student accountable. We're still testing, and we're still evaluating, we're scoring, and we're going to come up with recommendations to improve. we're just not going to hold the school or the students responsible for that grade because we can't get our arms around it. And one of the principals I talked to said, you know, in some sort of mind, and I don't understand all the way they evaluate teachers, but if they have a teacher that students do poorly, they may grade them well, but if the students are deficient, then they're forced to give the teacher a not, I don't know what the official remarks are, but they're forced to give them a needs improvement, if you will. And he said the hard thing about that is we're taking a test that we can't get our arms around, and we're grading a teacher based on that test because of how our students do, but we don't do that to the football coach if they have a bad year. We don't do it to the art teacher if he or she has a bunch of students that can't draw anything. But in this example, it negatively affects that teacher. And we can't give the – we don't have – at this point, we've not given the schools the tools to make the kids produce better writing scores. So it still tests, and I wouldn't – I'm not trying to step away from that side of it. I'm just saying let's give a pause in how the accountability is before we just continue to pile on. All right. Thank you. Representative Lowry, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Senator Files, you mentioned the keyboarding skills issue, and I know that that was a major argument that I used in criticism of the park test, that other states that had been implementing park long before Arkansas started to had found that it expanded the poverty gap. Their students did not have access to a computer at home. They did not have the necessary keyboarding skills to be able to do well in the test. But my question for you is, is the writing section the only section where keyboarding skills come into play with the ACT or the ACT Aspire? I
▶ Play
Speaker 8 13:30
think it's the most glaring. I mean, there's a lot of other opportunities just to ABCD or do things like that. The writing, they actually have to take their thoughts and put them down in a paragraph form. and in talking to one of the superintendents in northeast Arkansas he said you know my seventh through ninth graders did fairly well comparatively on the riding and I don't have a problem with testing at all but he said I had third and fourth graders that had never touched a keyboard before and we throw them into this into this arena where they have to he said even the ones who I thought were good riders either didn't finish or didn't have didn't have the skills necessary to do what they needed to do specifically in the writing he said this pause would give me chance to go back and and dial down and teach them keyboarding skills at the same time we're helping them with the writing so that we accomplish both goals but i think the writing is the the place where it shows
▶ Play
up the most follow-up mr chair
▶ Play
recognized thank you we've we uh had a preview uh representative from ACT was here for our education caucus and asked some questions about how the transition to ACT is going. And one of the things that I like specifically about the ACT as opposed to the park test that we had is that there are the interim tests that school districts can do during the year, that there's not just the summative year-end test, that there also are the tests during the year that allow the students, allow the teachers to be able to develop education plan, improvement plans for them. It seems to me that your bill, because it is specifying that, let me see if I can call it up, it actually says that the student, the accountability or the determination of an individual student's academic progress or proficiency level that you're wanting to put a pause on that so that seems to be counter to your argument that you want to continue assessments you just don't want there to be accountability so how would they not be would that not prevent them from being able to develop these individual and educational plans to help the students improve in writing the
▶ Play
Speaker 8 15:55
accountability section as it was written was just in the scoring mechanism that determined a grade level, if you will. It did not deal with anything at the student level or at the score level in terms of them taking the test, scoring the test, and continuing to assess the follow-up.
▶ Play
Speaker 58 16:14
I have a follow-up to that, but
▶ Play
I can wait. I'll wait. Representative Walker, you recognize again? I guess Representative Lowry now, the only ones who are speaking. Everything, oh, I'm sorry, Mr. Deffenbaugh had already spoken at you, okay. His was a legitimate question. We'd love to hear all legitimate questions. it's interesting that you want this pause and you use everything that we said with respect to Little Rock, Helena, Mariana, Mineral Springs, and other districts which were majority African American, and no pause was given and no consideration was given for the fact that the students didn't have the tools to address the subject matter, nor did they have the resources, nor the facilities. Were you aware that those schools didn't have the facilities or the resources and the tools to address their deficiencies at the time that you insisted upon, along with the majority, upon them being placed in academic distress?
▶ Play
Speaker 8 17:38
I didn't know I wasn't, number one, and I didn't insist that anybody be put in academic distress. I don't know if you've got me confused with somebody else. Well, it's the majority. It
▶ Play
was like, Representative Walker, does that really pertain to this bill? Well,
▶ Play
it is because we have here an equal protection concept, and then we have a logical concept. I mean, you treat everybody equally or fairly, and then that's the equal protection. And then the logic, if it was not good then, then it ought not to be good now I mean that's the only person position that I take if it wasn't good then then it shouldn't be good now you would agree
▶ Play
Speaker 33 18:16
with that wouldn't you Senator Files that's logical as you say thank you no more questions Representative Lauer you're recognized
▶ Play
for another question yes thank you Mr. Chair the follow-up on on the questioning about being able to develop the improvement plans if you do not allow a score for the students on writing how would the counselors or the teachers be able to develop the improvement plan i mean you're just going to give them
▶ Play
Speaker 8 18:42
a thumbs up or a thumbs down it is scored i think you're missing the concept that that the test is taken scored and assessed the actual accountability part where the score goes to the school itself and is punitive or rewarding, that's the part, that's the accountability part I'm talking about.
▶ Play
Follow-up. I'm looking at lines 28 and 29 where it specifically references the individual student's academic progress or proficiency level. So if we're trying to use the ACT Aspire assessment to help the student improve, there has to be some kind of a score or a thumbs up or a thumbs down or an arrow up or an arrow you know sideways something to let the instructors know that this student needs help whether it's help generally in writing or help in understanding keyboarding so you back up represent
▶ Play
Speaker 8 19:44
Lowry to 26 the Department of Education shall not include a student score on the writing portion in the determination of It doesn't say they shall not test, they shall not assess. In every conversation I've ever had is not ever, including with the bill drafters, is not ever dealt with removing any testing, removing any scoring at all, just in the accountability portion that goes back. Okay. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Meeks, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Thank you, Senator. The question that I have is I know as we've switched from these tests back and forth, we've seen that as schools adapt the first couple years, the test scores always seem to drop. And then as the school becomes better prepared, those tests can kind of come back in line with what our expectations are. So I kind of understand why you're going this route. The question that I have is what are the detrimental effects to the school by not allowing this exemption? So I understand you're wanting to do the exemption to allow the schools to be able to get up to speed on getting the kids prepared to be able to properly take the test. If we don't do this, what is the bad or what is the ramifications that the school would be facing for us not allowing this two-year reprieve or this two-year waiting period?
▶ Play
Speaker 8 21:08
Sure. That's up to this body, I think, in how we determine it. What I've looked at in terms of statistically is that the writing portion does not seem to mesh with any of the rest of it. And I understand that I'm not looking to switch tests or continue to put the schools on a merry-go-round as we have the last three years. But when you look at things statistically, the writing portion doesn't add up to the rest of it. And that's what I'm looking at just as a let's get these things in order and try to figure out what it is. is it going to do the school's harm I doubt it it's not it's not something that I'm looking to try to save any school because of the writing portion I just don't think it's fair to them to teach something that that doesn't line up if all the other disciplines line up and are going on the same track the writing sections right way over here and you can see it you know I've got I got graphs where you don't even have to be a statistician to see that that's a fair graph and then when you turn it around you get the writing portion that looks like you know a five year old just started putting dots on a page it does not make any sense to court to correlate the two together and that's the that's what i think we should try to get our arms around before we just charge off down the
▶ Play
down the path senator you do realize that we are on a one-year pause at this time with all of this there is no accountable you know there's nothing being graded against the schools right now one year yes sir so you're you're really looking at kind of continuing that on the writing portion is that what you're looking for for another three years no just for next year for next year for one more year yes sir okay uh representative start should recognize for question
▶ Play
Speaker 85 22:46
thank you mr chair thank you sir i've had these same conversations with my schools back home and what was kind of relayed to me and i'll just be honest i'm young enough i took the act test and so i know kind of what it was based on and then kind of what they've told me about park and then now ACT Aspire. But back then, the writing was based on kind of a prompt question. And so a student would write an intro, have three points, and then a conclusion. And for years and years and years, that's the way we taught writing. And then all of a sudden with PARC, we changed it to where it was just kind of an open response prompt. And a student themselves had to be, you know, I guess organized enough to put their thoughts together and so forth. And then now we've changed it back to ACT Aspire, which is basically, you know, a prompt response, intro three points and a conclusion so my question is did ADE not change the standards back to where we're teaching that style instead of the other or have they had those conversations with you about the curriculum itself no I
▶ Play
haven't had any conversations about the curriculum itself follow-up Mr. Chair you're recognized my question would be then
▶ Play
Speaker 85 23:53
why aren't we then attacking it from that perspective as far as changing the curriculum to where we know that the curriculum now is going to align with the tests that we're making. So where I think that was part of the no correlation part is because students were being tested on something they were never really taught and they were changed like that and that we need to make sure that the curriculum is matching the test before we just, you know. Yeah, that's fair. And
▶ Play
Speaker 8 24:19
I think you could do that with a two-year pause. You could incorporate that. Representative De La
▶ Play
Speaker 93 24:31
Rosa, you're recognized. I just want to clarify because I think there's some confusion I've got a bill that's similar to this in terms of excluding certain scores from being counted in the accountability the way this is written the way that I read this this only excludes the test scores from accountability I'm sorry I've got a cold and i'm i'm out of it today um just cut me some slack um it's only going to count or you're only going to not count it in their accountability scores this has nothing to do with their individual assessment um it has nothing to do with you know what the teachers are going to get from them it's you're only talking about it counting against the student in the accountability scores of the school or the school's accountability scores you know as a district and all that i just want to make sure i understand that that's absolutely correct okay cold and all thank you thanks
▶ Play
any other questions committee i have a question madam co-chair you're recognized thank you mr chair uh senator files uh we share some of some common districts and the the i'm trying to sort this all out myself in the transition from the common core to the act aspire one of the reasons we really, really liked the ACT Aspire was because it was considered more of a college preparatory this is what they're going to get when they go to college, this kind of writing. And it's my understanding was that you had three prompts on the park test and in an effort to possibly make the test, the ACT Aspire our more concise, shorter time frame, which is what we wanted for the students. We took those three prompts, which were totally different in what they were asking for the kids, and we put those in three different grade levels. And I may have to ask, you know, this may be a question for ADE, but could it be that the the prompt that we got in one grade was you know was maybe something they weren't as used to but would be a pretty easy fix you know now going forward to get them ready for that prompt that they have specifically in the seventh grade then they have a different one in the eighth grade And all three of those together are, you know, we need all three of them. But I wonder if we look at the scores for a school, if maybe that one grade prompt, that one prompt was the problem, that they were just illy prepared for that one, and maybe they did okay in the other grades.
▶ Play
Speaker 8 27:27
I would agree with you. If there were one grade line that were causing issues, it's all of them. Every score that I've ever seen in all of them, the writing is an anomaly to everything else that's produced, and it doesn't matter if it's the fourth grader,
▶ Play
Speaker 81 27:45
the seventh grader. I mean, that makes logical
▶ Play
sense. Right. But it's not. Well, I talked to Greenwood, and they said that they weren't having that anomaly. So I'm trying to figure out what the difference is between schools and maybe the curriculum or the teaching practices. So I'll continue to look into that. But I just thought that might be an answer. Thank you. Representative Kavanaugh, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Senator, we went to the
▶ Play
ACT Aspire to try to get some stability into the system because we kept hearing over and over again that there was no stability. There was always a bouncing from one to another in the assessment system. Does this bill not take away that stability and puts us back into where there's instability because we're not going to look at a certain section
▶ Play
Speaker 8 28:43
of it? I don't think at all, and I was cognizant of the stability factor, and I think it leaves everything to say. They still take the test. Everything is the same. It just doesn't factor into their final accountability measure as it relates to a score. But everything else is the same, and it continues that moving forward. So I did not take it at all as a move
▶ Play
Speaker 87 29:04
of instability. Any other questions of the committee?
▶ Play
If not, we're going to move to the audience. First up, we have Chris Katzer. Is that right? You're welcome to take the end of the table if you would like to, by the senator or wherever down there on the end you want to get. If you would state your name and who you're with, you'll recognize the speaker against
▶ Play
the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. For the record, my name is Chris Kratzer. I am Director of Government Affairs for ACT. I want to first start off with commending Senator Files, actually, for the attention that he's paying to this issue. I think it's important, and I think he's well-intentioned. I want to be very frank with the committee and ask your indulgence. As the provider of the assessments for the state, I want to steer clear of any potential policy crossfires that might be addressed and speak only to the aspects of ACT and the ACT Aspire and the system of assessments that's in place in Arkansas. Very simply put, I have one objection that causes our opposition to this bill, and that is very simply that in the emergency clause of the legislation, it states that it is found and determined by the General Assembly of the State of Arkansas that insufficient research research and data exist on the ability of the writing portion of the ACT Aspire assessment to accurately measure academic progress and performance of a student, public school, or public school district. I contend that there is, in fact, the existence of evidence to the contrary. This issue has been brought up. The questions that were caused by this issue and the anomalies, potentially, that Senator Files references have been asked and answered. And they've been asked and answered by experts in the field in cooperation with the Department of Education. So, very simply put, I believe that it is inaccurate to state and it would impugn the integrity of ACT as a company and ACT Aspire as a product to state that it is in some way, shape, or form invalid. So, very simply put, that is the opposition that ACT has. There are a number of subject matter experts available for the committee members if you'd like to get into the weeds with the validity, the test development, the scoring, pretty much any question that you would like to ask, you will again be answered much in the same way that the Department was back in August
▶ Play
of 2016. Are there any questions? Seeing none. you sir all right we're gonna go well I have nobody signed up to speak against before the bill so I will ask is there anyone in the audience like speak for the bill I'm not ready for that anybody against the bill I have Commissioner key coming represent Walker did you have a question or just
▶ Play
Speaker 121 32:36
a inquiry well I was inquiring whether Commissioner was going to speak he's coming yes yes sir okay station
▶ Play
Speaker 125 32:46
name and who you're with and you're recognized to speak against the bill Johnny Key Department of Education also have with me Stacy Smith assistant Commissioner for Learning Services, and Hope Allen, who is our Director of Assessment. So with the indulgence of the committee at an appropriate time, they have some feedback and description of some of the things that we have been doing with respect to the writing component of the ACT Aspire. But two things that I want to cover up front. One is any assertion from anyone that the department has not been supporting schools for writing I think have not been aware either have not been aware or not made themselves aware of the work that we have been doing since the results came back we have been diligently working to support schools and districts educators through a number of means and hope Alan can certainly speak to the work that was done with regards to that actually team a team from the department going and visiting a CT to work through some of the issues and ask some of the questions that came to us the second thing I want to address is and this gets into the question of tests but if principals assistant principals administrators are out there and they are under the impression that a less than positive score on ACT Aspire is a reason by itself to give a teacher a needs improvement based solely on that artifact we need to give them some coaching because that is not a fact and we are certainly have been doing that and we are we'll certainly make ourselves available to help anyone who has that misunderstanding but mr. chairman with your indulgence I would like Ms. Smith and Ms. Allen to address some of the technical points that have been raised in this bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 128 34:55
They are recognized to speak. Stacey Smith, Assistant Commissioner, Learning Services. Thank you. Several of the points that I want to point out is schools are given an ELA score, which is a combination of English, reading, and writing. And we've been doing that in Arkansas for a while, okay even all the way back to our Arkansas benchmark it was a combined score this assessment ACT Aspire it was the first time that schools were given their scores and they saw student they saw English reading and writing broken out separately and with the not ready close exceeding okay before with Arkansas benchmark and with park it was all combined and it wasn't broken out into three sections, even though we had English, reading, and writing on all three, and they were combined together. On this assessment, we have looked at lots of data, lots of schools. We have done concordance documents with Arkansas Benchmark to PARC to current ACT Aspire, looking for is there consistency. One thing we kept hearing was students who scored really, really, really well on the benchmark in park scored poorly on this assessment so we pulled students and looked back at their data we pulled the top performing writing scores in certain districts districts where we were told that wasn't the case that those students weren't scoring and what we saw was we saw a student who met or who was exceeding in writing or or ready also on park were meeting expectations also on the benchmark were advanced or proficient. We could see trends. Hope Allen can give you more information pertaining to we took the PARC assessment last year. We took the ACT Aspire to look, is there a correlation between the ELA scores on PARC and the ELA scores of ACT Aspire? They're within 0.5 of one another. So there is a pattern. There's been lots of inaccurate information put out about the assessment, about the inaccuracies there's been lots of discussion about technology as a previous elementary principal myself I too had concerns about keyboarding in the lower grades and those were hard questions that we were asking ACTS fire and when we sent a team we specifically wanted to look at those areas one thing that we found and one thing I want to point out too is we've had standards in elementary for typing since 2010. 2010. So if a superintendent said, I didn't know that we were supposed to be doing this, it's been there since 2010. When we sent a team to actually look at Arkansas papers, okay, we went to Iowa City, looked at Arkansas papers, looked at the rubrics and actually compared does the rubric match the scoring that was done on Arkansas student papers and overwhelmingly we found the answer to be yes it was consistent all the way through we sent five ELA specialists from the department and Hope Allen our director of assessment and went through numerous papers asked hard and tough questions we do have ACT here today who can go more into the scoring guides if you have specific questions about that but we found consistency over and over again. I do want to acknowledge that when you look just at the writing scores in the state they are lower. The English language portion of the three ELA sections were the highest. The reading were the middle. We believe that we get a better picture of the student by combining all three parts of the ELA assessment. We actually believe if you take out the writing that we're not going to get an as accurate picture the more information that you put in the more the better the the evidence is going to be about that student so I think actually removing the writing it does contrary to what we're hoping to do a second point I'd like to make is when we're talking about accountability I'm very proud to say that we've done numerous listening tours throughout the state talking about our new accountability and what that should look like and one of the things that we heard when we were out talking to schools was don't change our assessment again we've had too many changes a second point that schools made loud and clear was use multiple academic measures not just one test at one time and that is something that we are as we're going through our accountability system and rewriting that that is something that we're looking at and tying in and you'll see new legislation coming out about using multiple academic measures so earlier when you're talking about an individual student plan that plan is based not just on the one test at the end of the year but based on student work student grades teacher recommendation more than just one assessment but we do believe that the ela score on the act aspire is is valid and the evidence to say that it's not is just not there we do see that the writing parts are lower in the state we do have a technical advisory committee that's an independent group made up of six nationally recognized assessment experts that actually advise the state according to accountability and assessment their recommendation was to use the writing as part of our ELA score. They also gave the technical advice in accountability. If you see that there are still questions and concerns about the lower grades, you might consider weighting it differently in your accountability system. So we have room to do that. But that's something that we think that we should have, the input from our stakeholders, our teachers, our students, our schools, as we go through and write the accountability system. Hope Allen, Director
▶ Play
Speaker 132 41:18
of Assessment. So just to echo everything that Stacey and Commissioner Key have said. Oops,
▶ Play
not close enough, sorry. I just wanted to speak to going to Iowa City and looking at the papers. We went, the team and I did, and we looked at over 100 student papers from Arkansas. When we looked at those papers, we really did go with the mindset of we're going to debunk this. There's got to be a reason Arkansas students are scoring so low in writing, because we know that we teach and that we are writing in classrooms. When we went, we looked specifically at the rubrics. The rubrics were out prior to the test being given. The rubrics were published when ACT Aspire first published the assessment. So those have been out since we started giving the assessment. Those rubrics do line up with our standards. So the expectations of what's being asked in those rubrics is actually in line with the Arkansas state standards. and what we found was many times whenever we were scoring if I looked at a paper and started to score I actually would score lower than what the the scorer scored and that made me feel better about the scoring because it did make me feel that that was consistent and fair those rubrics the the scorers are very well trained on how to how to score within that rubric and we felt like after looking at those papers very strongly when I looked at a student that was at a three and I looked at a student that was at a four consistently our team said yep this is what we want this is the expectation we want for our state is this four the three is close and it's almost there but we really want to raise the level of writing to write here for our state and so we felt very strongly that the the scoring is valid it is reliable we saw we talked very extensively about the writing procedures and like we've said we have ACT here to talk more about that if you'd like but they have a very strong stringent process in place to make sure that the the scoring is fair and consistent across whomever is scoring that paper are you
▶ Play
Speaker 125 43:08
are y'all through if if i may just wrap this up from the from the department's standpoint we'll be happy to take questions four points that that i want to stress one is that the passage of this bill does have real potential consequences on the future approval of our state essa plan it does so in this way we are required to assess our standards. Writing is in our standards as you've heard testimony since 2010. Our assessment must be peer reviewed and that is a process that as it states other people are going to be looking at our assessment. The assessment is not just the test itself. The assessment is the system and that includes how you use the scores that come from that system from from that system and if we're prohibited through statute of using the writing scores for accountability it will have a significant impact on that possibility of passing peer review second point is that the bill does not offer a remedy other than just time for any deficiencies or shortcomings that folks may think there are in this it simply carves it out of the system for two years. We traveled the state on a 10-city tour, Ms. Smith referred to that, and we got a lot of feedback. One area we did not get feedback on in any of these tours was concerns over the riding portion of ACT Aspire. We went back and looked at the feedback that we received, and no one knew that or mentioned there was a problem. This happened in the fall. This tour happened through the fall and before Christmas and we felt like since we weren't getting feedback on the writing portion we felt like the work we had been doing last summer and early fall to go out and support districts support educators and you know learning what they needed to learn about writing and how that would instruct the practices in the classroom we felt like we were a good place so didn't know there were still any issues out there until the bill was filed and the final point is this and you've heard it mentioned before about the stability you know the transition to act aspire came as a result of the governor's review task force on common core standards and if you remember what came from that was a complete review of our math and ela standards And one of those recommendations was moving to the ACT Aspire. So the governor was fully supportive of that as he is today. With the ACT Aspire, using that as part of our system, carving out a portion of the system would truly introduce instability into that system. We've been working so hard to try to meet the needs of our students, meet the needs of our educators, in moving forward, moving away from the Common Core Park combination of standards and assessments. Mr. Chairman, we'd be glad to take questions. Ripson, Kavanaugh.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Commissioner Keene, the question is, this legislation, I want to get your belief on this, my understanding, is this legislation does not actually allow the state to use writing scores to determine an individual student's proficiency or progress. and that really is against our federal regulations that y'all have
▶ Play
Speaker 125 46:41
to go by. Well, we believe that the inclusion of the score itself is a key component, as with math, with the reading portion, anything else. And to have that removed would create problems for us with the federal plan. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Sullivan, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate the data and the comments. When we talk about doing studies and looking at the data, it seems like we look at the outliers, particularly on the technology side. So if a school is outside and they're not able to achieve because of technology, that seems to be at a different level than some of the other criteria that you may be able to manage or train or have other solutions to so yes I'm just interested where are what is your perception of how big a problem the technology side of this was in those low scores so when we first introduced online testing to this will be our third year of online testing we did allow for for schools that had hardships to apply for waivers to test on paper and so we have had the process of phasing in the technology for three years now. As Stacey mentioned the typings has been in our standard since 2010 so that has been the expectation that our students were on the computer and typing during their school day in class work and other things and that would also then prepare them for the assessment. As far as the technology when I spoke with ACT about what is done in the equating process to make sure that a paper score is equivalent to an online score there is some equating that's done there so what they do is do studies to say you know students score this way on paper and they score this way online and they make sure that through the equating that they're producing an equivalent score that's really not the question I'm asking I guess there are schools that are taking it online and they're just struggling as you said one of the superintendents didn't even know it was in the standard. So a superintendent doesn't know, but the child is penalized. And the school doesn't have the equipment to actually do that. So, again, the child is penalized in the school, and I think that's where Senator Faust is going with the bill. It seems like whatever all those reasons are, we can say they shouldn't be doing this or they should be doing that, but in fact they're not. And there are people that are struggling. And I just wondered, so are 90% of our schools, do they have the appropriate technology and they're doing the training, 50%, 70%? Do you have any idea? So Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 128 49:27
Sullivan, so when we first did online testing three years ago, Hope, do you remember what percentage of schools actually did paper? Most did online testing. We had about 12 districts
▶ Play
Speaker 154 49:37
that were on paper. So when districts were
▶ Play
Speaker 128 49:39
given the choice statewide, you can take a paper test or you can take it online we had 12 districts who chose to take it on
▶ Play
paper three years of those are actually teaching the keyboarding skills all to all schools teach keyboarding now yes it's in the standards and has been for a no but
▶ Play
Speaker 128 50:02
you just said they were in the standards and people weren't doing it I didn't say that earlier so they've been in the standard since 2010 and so there's they the the the idea that a student would be able to type a paragraph or a paper in elementary school was an expectation since then let
▶ Play
Speaker 125 50:20
me clarify representative Sullivan the I think she made a hypothetical statement if a superintendent didn't know it was in there then you know they should have known I don't think we have any reports of any specific districts that haven't been doing that I just want to make sure
▶ Play
Speaker 160 50:37
sure we're clear on that I think again
▶ Play
I'm just asking what percent of our schools are actually whether it's in the standard out of the standard you know hypothetical or real what percent of our schools really have the equipment and are actually training to prepare students well I would say
▶ Play
Speaker 128 51:00
that all schools have the equipment because all schools actually you tested online last year I would hope to say all schools are preparing because it's part of our standards that's the expectation there's
▶ Play
Speaker 125 51:14
there's a certain level of local small a accountability that that you know we we have the expectation that districts are doing what they're supposed to be doing we don't check them every year you know We don't go around the standards reviews take place on a rotation. And so we're not in there in those classes to see what the practices are. But what we do is take the data that we get from the assessments and we set up professional development to go out and to address the deficiencies that we see either from the data or that we get in feedback from our schools. So our role is to provide them with what they need, working through our co-ops, working through our specialists out there to help them get to where they need to be. I will say, too, to your technology question, the first time we did this, there were a number of issues because of broadband concerns. And I'm happy to say that through the work that DIS has been doing and we've been partnering with them in upgrading the broadband capacity around the state for our school districts, There should be no more issues with respect to that side of the technology. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 96 52:36
again. I thought you went to sleep on us
▶ Play
there for a minute. You'll never find me asleep. Unless you put a Mickey in my... I'm concerned, Mr. Files, not about your faith in the matter, but about the possibility, which I have concern about ADE, too, that whenever we don't like the result reflected by a test, we simply change it. And I've addressed my questions to Commissioner Key, and I'm somewhat aligned on this. How do you address that? Now, I do have some evidence that they changed the test in order to get the results. They won't, and that's disputed, of course. But how do you deal with that general concept? And how does it apply to disaggregated subgroups and groups, which are largely minority? I would disagree
▶ Play
Speaker 8 53:43
that we're changing the test, number one, because we're not changing the test. We're changing components in the scoring mechanism that may or may not adequately affect what's been going on. I feel like there's plenty of data to back that position up in contrast to Ms. Smith. What I do think that is a bigger issue here that I've waded off into, perhaps unknowingly, is all these other issues that deal with testing. And I saw it on the Senate in some, but I didn't grasp the levity of it in that everybody's got an opinion of how it affects one group or another and everybody thinks that there may be a way to do this better or that better. And I wasn't trying to address – I'm not trying to do all things – be all things to all people. I'm trying to address a situation that I think is deficient. And so I understand your concerns in sub-aggregate groups and particularly minorities, and I think that we need to work judiciously to try to deal with those. What I'm doing here I think benefits all of the students at every level regardless. It gives if, and I'm not speaking for the bill, I don't know if that question was to me or to somebody here at the end of the table who was speaking for, but you know what I would say is that if if they're doing what they say they're doing and I don't have any reason to doubt that they are in and that they have testing they have means out there to support improving scores and doing things then I truly believe that time is a remedy they've they've mentioned that the only remedy here is time and if they're if they're doing the things that they're they say they're doing which I believe they are I just haven't seen evidence of it in my district um then then time would be an adequate response so i know that doesn't answer your question wholly and i don't know that there is an answer to your question wholly uh short of well we should do it this way and we probably have 135 different opinions of that um what i am here to say is that that i'm not looking to try to separate out one group or the other whether it be by race or poverty level or anything else i'm trying to look at at a situation that i think is deficient a mechanism to score that that i think is inadequate and and try to
▶ Play
give us time to get our arms around that that specific thing follow up mr chair you recognize well i i am equally concerned i can't say equally i'm concerned as well but here's where i am you fort smith that general area which i guess includes greenwood That general area is higher income, and it is less diverse, less racially homogeneous than the Delta. And if you have the concern there about the poor scores, which is a genuine one, then it has to be even more dire with respect to the areas with declining enrollment and declining resources. And that should have been a basis for pause and takeover and things like that. So I want all these kids in this state to learn. And I know that our kids can't learn if your kids don't learn. And it's important that we figure out what the learning differences are so that we'll know what the standards are throughout. And I don't know how you got off. I mean, I'd like to understand how you overcame the objection of the Department of Education on this without any hard data, without any hard data, just some looking at some data, but any hard data to try to arrive at something so important. I've got data, Mr. Walker. Could
▶ Play
Speaker 179 57:45
you share it with us later? Sure. I'd be glad to. I'd be glad
▶ Play
to. Thank you. robson kavanaugh recognize thank you mr. chair um commissioner key we keep talking about the low scores that it showed a low score our children scored low but my question is we're all talking about the test and not counting it but the test is a true indicator of where our students are at so i guess the real question to us is are we forgetting about the real problem and that is what the proficiency of our children are and when we don't include this then we do them injustice
▶ Play
Speaker 125 58:22
because we're not able to improve them that's certainly a it could be a concern you know we the way we look at this we take this data and we use it to inform our support for schools we hope that the schools are looking at the data to inform their instructional practices in the classroom there is a real concern that if you remove a scoring component from accountability then that lessens the importance of that it shouldn't but it can i mean that's a real possibility especially when you're looking at a carve out of a singular component that as miss smith testified earlier this is the first time we saw the that as a standalone piece of the of the scoring report you recognize but just to
▶ Play
clarify the scores their self are a true indication of where our students are at on this writing they are and
▶ Play
Speaker 125 59:17
that's the annual assessment that's the point it reflects the the achievement of those and growth when you look from one year to the next and and there's a piece there to represent Cavanaugh that was talked about earlier about penalizing students and I want to make sure because it really fits into your question what we're talking about is using those scores not to penalize students but identify the interventions that they need to get better. So right now, these scores are used as one indicator to prepare the academic improvement plan for students, and that has become a compliance piece. So in a bill that we'll be bringing to you all soon, within the next couple of weeks, we move away from the compliance of an academic improvement plan to a student success plan where we will still be informed by things like assessment scores and other indicators of student success and student need to try to bring the interventions to bear on how to help them get better. Representative
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:25
Sturge, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Commissioner Key
▶ Play
Speaker 85 1:00:31
or whoever wants to answer this, can you just confirm for me in my mind that right now our standards per grade level match the assessments per grade level as far as whether they're going to be tested on narrative writing piece or persuasive writing piece or even you know I can't remember the third one right off the top of my head but there's another one that I want to make sure that right now as you said with the changes in the test that right now our standards and curriculum are starting to match up with what they're expected at each grade level yeah I'll let the experts okay thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 128 1:01:03
yes our standards do match to what they're being expected to do on the assessment. Now I will say we went from a very lengthy assessment last year with PARC where we had multiple writing prompts to a much shorter assessment with ACT Aspire where you had one writing prompt. So the standards will require for students in different grades to write on many different genres and types of writing but they may be assessed on just the one narrative or an expository piece but the standards do cover that and I do have the standards pulled up for you to look at at the end okay thank you thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 125 1:01:41
and if we could on that because of the time was an issue and would y'all talk about that the changes that we advocated for and we were granted based on what we encountered in the last administration and schools
▶ Play
Speaker 85 1:01:53
are still getting used to those changes yeah yeah so
▶ Play
we heard overwhelmingly from schools that 30 minutes was not a sufficient amount of time for students to formulate and construct their written response so we did go to act and relayed those concerns to them and through some back and forth with them we did come to the conclusion that there would be 15 minutes added to the writing prompt to the time so in the lower grades and 10 minutes added in grades six and above so that means that our students in grades three through and i'm looking at my people to make sure um three through five i'm sorry um in the lower grades they will have 45 minutes and then i believe it started in sixth grade through 10th grade they will have 40 minutes to write there to construct their response this year still just one prompt for each student yes represent
▶ Play
mcgill you're recognized thank you mr chair what time did we leave last night about 6 30 We left at 6.30 back at 10. It doesn't seem like I've ever left. From a layman's standpoint, when I talk to people in my district, what I'm hearing is that we're consistently scoring low in writing, and we're aware of that. My question is, and I understand that I'm hearing that The Department of Ed is informing those districts that are performing low in writing. The question is, what are we doing to improve those writing scores? What methods, what techniques, what is being employed to change this? So this year, early on, we've done writing webinars with
▶ Play
Speaker 128 1:03:39
school districts on how to understand the rubric that was being used to score the writing. We've provided professional development in writing throughout the state. We're working with our educational service cooperatives in bringing writing professional development to their cooperatives so that they can help their local schools on a local level. We've put together a writing live binder that's on the Arkansas Department of Education website where it has different writing lessons for teachers in the classroom. We've provided online webinars for teachers to log into. so there is an ongoing basis of providing professional development and support to teachers
▶ Play
Speaker 180 1:04:26
and schools. Thank you. Any other questions? I have one. Oh I'm sorry.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:33
Thank you Mr. Chair. So if I'm kind of summarizing the discussion just a little bit on the sixth grade hit the benchmarks and the nine and ten hit the benchmarks and they were all in good shape but it was just the sixth grade piece no it was the seventh grade that had the trouble with the expository prompt if we pull that piece out and understood and help me understand maybe why the narrative prompt was easier for the kids and they did better on that and all those in all the grades that used it but the expository was the seemed to be the problem am i summarizing that right or not yes and i'm trying to pull the numbers to actually confirm the the the grades um i think the seventh grade was 28.5 percent so with the different types of
▶ Play
writing some of those are more difficult for students so for example I have a fourth grade writing prompt pulled up and fourth grade was a grade that we did pretty well in and it says you're going to write an essay to explain the qualities of a good movie so for a student that's a pretty they can relate pretty well to what a good movie is they could probably pretty well to develop out that idea of what a what they like about a good movie but whenever you get into some of the other types of writing they are more difficult for students and so that's why in certain grade levels we did see drops in scores but we completely expected that on the front end and that was
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:13
not surprising. So tell me why a student needs that. We have that as one of the props. Why do they need that as a part of this testing going forward into college? How are their freshman college writing going to be based on expository or narrative both probably more expository the
▶ Play
Speaker 128 1:06:36
narrative writing when you're going into college but the standards cover all types of writing right and because we have one prompt per grade level on the assessment that we're using expository is the sample that was in the seventh grade right what What I would hope for our schools is to see where they scored low, go back and look at the standards, look at their curriculums, look at their instruction in their classrooms, and do a self-check and then go back out there and keep teaching. It's not about, I mean, it's easy to say it's not all about one test, okay? But then when our accountability is tied to it, the test matters. if we're assessing the standards and the standards are good and schools focus on teaching the standards we should be doing okay in our classrooms but we have got to make sure that we look at our data we look to see what it tells us to do and then we make changes so if a seventh grade group didn't do well on the expository writing I would hope that they would go back and
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:48
look at their instruction in expository writing and if that was a statewide problem then that prompts your
▶ Play
Speaker 128 1:07:55
department to provide assistance in expository writing through professional development which we have done so that that's
▶ Play
good thank you i have three hands up i'm not sure what i've got you want you want to speak oh yeah we have motions Mr. Lowry, I believe your hand was up first Let's hear your motion I have to have a motion on the floor for immediate consideration If I take a motion on the floor, I'm going to vote it I don't have any other Mr. Meek, you have a motion? Mr. Chairman, I will make a motion Obviously an important question,
▶ Play
but we've debated this bill for over an hour and 10 minutes now. So I'd like to make a motion that we limit debate to five minutes either side to give everyone a chance to make some closing remarks and then
▶ Play
Speaker 59 1:08:50
move to a vote. That's a proper motion. All
▶ Play
in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. All right, we have five minutes. I believe the against is finished on their end. And do I have anyone in the audience like to speak for the bill? Against
▶ Play
Speaker 8 1:09:14
the bill? Would you like to close for your bill? Yes, sir. I won't take the whole five minutes either. Representative Douglas, the fourth grade prompt produced 13.5% that met the readiness benchmark, just so you know. Like I said to Representative Walker, I've waded off into a topic that's far deeper than just should we pause the writing for another year. It deals with testing. It deals with who does the testing. You've got people that are very defensive of the things that they have picked. and some for good reason, some I think are a little bit fabricated, not in terms of a lie, but just in terms of producing a response. As I look at this and think of testing and it's showing an adequate representation of where we are, I look at an athletic example. If you run the 40 and you're on flat ground, everybody gets the same score. You know how fast you are based on just running from zero to 40. If you're running uphill, then you're not going to get an adequate measure. And that's what I think is coming up here, is that we're not getting adequate measures in what we're doing. And we can gloss over and say that we did this or we're doing that or it's adequately showing where we are, but it's not because there are too many anomalies in the scoring. And you look at the writing portions with the reading and the language, and they don't mesh. And this is not disparaging on the test at all. It is a fact, though, when you look at the data. So having said that about the various things, I would ask for your support. If we're going to fix these things, we've got to start one thing at a time, and so I would ask for a good vote on the bill. What's the will
▶ Play
of the committee? I have a due pass from Representative Meek. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. I'm sorry your bill has failed. I'm going to do a I have a concurrent on here real quick if you guys don't mind madam chair would you I'll just sit here instead of taking time to move to the other end you're recognized all right it's a house bill 1539 that I need to concur on a senate amendment and you know Sentimentum 1 and 2. If you have any questions, I'll be glad to try to answer them. This was a civics test. We did get amended on the other end. Got sanitized. Any questions from the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:11:45
committee? What is the will of the committee? Do pass. All those in favor? Opposed? You pass your amendment. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you, committee. All right. At this time, I was going to try to run Representative Douglas in on a really short one, but I don't see him out there unless he's in the crowd and I don't see him. But if not, Representative Mayberry, I believe you're going to be up. Committee, I will try not to hold you past 12 o'clock. We're going to run a couple of bills from them, from Representative Mayberry. and if we have any other committee members that have a bill on the table today that want to run we'll go to Mr. Sturge I believe has one so we'll try to be nicer to you today than we
▶ Play
Speaker 210 1:12:44
were yesterday we're going to do 1616
▶ Play
Speaker 215 1:12:50
is that correct right 1516 will be the
▶ Play
first bill we'll hear from them I believe this is a bill you brought back that's amended, and you ran that amendment's already on there, right? It's okay. It's already went through. Yes. Yes, Mr. Chair. You are recognized to present your bill. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. I've also got with me former Representative Mayberry as well. We're not going to rehash all of the presentation that we did just last week on this bill. We did make some amendments to try to the best that we can to address the various concerns that we heard on this committee. committee, I hear what you're saying. And so we've done our very best to bring some amendments to you that can address those concerns, but it's still, at the same time, still have a bill that is effective and moves us forward. So let me just kind of walk through what those are. The biggest one, most likely for many of you, is the fact that we are no longer going to have these standards placed in the standards of accreditation. So if a school district does not meet the requirements that we have here, they're not going to risk losing their accreditation due to that fact. Some of the others, we heard some concerns about some smaller districts, especially with regards to the nurse on each campus. So with regards to the campuses, and actually for all of the schools, with regards to the campuses, if the campuses are located within a mile of each other, than a single nurse, as long as they're meeting the ratio requirements, a single nurse could suffice for multiple campuses within that one mile area. For the school districts with an enrollment of 500 or fewer, they are excluded from that particular requirement as well from the one nurse per campus. Now having not put this in the standards of accreditation, that kind of takes the teeth out of what's there from an enforcement standpoint. So what we have put in, we have added some language that would say that if a school does not meet these requirements as they're written in Arkansas code that the Department of Education would provide notification not just to the superintendent but to the board members as well to make them aware that they were not in compliance. Now then it's going to be up to that school to determine how they will wish to move forward with regards to that information but they will be made aware of it. One other change that we made is one of the superintendents who was here to speak against the bill last week had concern because in his school district, their employees are hired on a contract basis. Those contracts are renewed yearly, and he had some concerns regarding that. We've changed that language to make it clear that they count, that that counts in terms of an ongoing employee with the rehire qualification there. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 218 1:15:44
Mayberry, do you have anything that you'd like to add?
▶ Play
Speaker 220 1:15:53
Yes, I'll introduce myself, Julie Mayberry, parent of a child with a medical need in our school system. Also wanted to address, Representative Lowry had asked some questions of one of the school superintendents who spoke, and these were all very good questions, and I just wanted to address them so that you all can have a little bit more ease in this. First of all, one of the things that got brought up from some of our school superintendents is that they can't find RNs, that putting an RN requirement is just something that they just can't find RNs in their area. So I've asked the State Board of Nursing to give us some information on what is the status of our nurses in the state. And I will tell you, statewide, there are 39,648 RNs. In comparison, statewide, there are 15,557 LPNs. So therefore, statewide, you're looking at plenty of RNs. You actually would have a harder time finding LPNs than RNs. But you might say, well, maybe they're all in Little Rock. They're all in Fayetteville. Well, we specifically looked at the counties affected by the school superintendents who were here. So I looked at Grant County, where Poen School District is, and in that county, there's 128 LPNs to 295 RNs. In the county right next to it, Hot Spring County and Garland County, LPNs 251, RNs 409. Garland County, 541 LPNs, 1,511 RNs. So I think that you can feel rest assured that there are plenty of RNs out there looking to be hired. Many of them probably would prefer to not have to drive to Little Rock for a job and might want to stick closer to home and work in that school district. The other thing that was brought up was the cost of the RNs versus the LPNs and stating that there's just not money in the school district budget. And as I mentioned, Representative Lowry brought up an interesting point, so I thought I would look more into the actual dollar figures there. and in the you know we could do this district by district but in the particular district that was here the poen school district the fund balance is 1.8 million dollars nearly 1.9 million dollars last year and basically that same in 2014 1.6 in 2013 1.3 in 2012 1.2 and in 2011 2.1 million dollars left over at the end of the year i think there's money there if you have a fund balance of 1.8 million dollars i think you probably can find a little bit of money for the rn then looking specifically at poen school district there's two lpns as stated by the school superintendent that was here so once again looking at the charts of what's on their website As they are reporting, there are two RNs, I mean two LPNs. One LPN has a salary full-time of $12,240. The other LPN has a salary of $14,684. That's about the same pay as the custodians. Combined, it is. And combined, there's actually a custodian that makes more than that, a custodian that makes $28,000. By this, this school district wouldn't have to have two LPNs. They'd only have to have one RN. You combine those two salaries, you're looking at $26,000, $27,000 already in their budget. The average school nurse salary in the state is $35,000. That's not a whole lot of money we're asking them to come up with. And
▶ Play
I will say that that school district does an admirable job with pay for their teachers and their administrators. There are 45 teachers and administrators, according to the information from their website, and 40 of those make in excess of $40,000 per year. So they do a good job in making sure that their teachers are taken care of and many of their other staff members as well. We just feel like that the money is there that they could provide, I guess, more adequately trained nurses. And, again, we just speak to that one school district because they were the ones who were here that day. But, members, this is about the amendments that we made today, and we've made these amendments specifically to try to address the concerns that different ones of you brought to us last week. And with that, certainly open to
▶ Play
take any questions. Representative Walker, you are first on deck. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess I've had a transformation, metamorphosis, whatever you call that, And the reason for it is that I have learned, you all are here, in effect, begging for nurses based on a demonstrated need. And I hate that you all have to do that, but my transformation comes about because I learned, and maybe the other members here do not know, that the average cost for a child to be taken out of a public school and put into Alexander is $128,000 per year. So for 20 students at $2.5 million, many of whom should not necessarily be in Alexander, you'd be able to make all the funding changes that you wish. So my question is, and I guess it's to the committee here, How can we justify not having nurses or paying them more fairly or teachers more fairly when we pay to keep a child detained, $128,000 a year, and to provide educational services from the time that child may be 12 years old until he or she is 18? I don't understand that. For that reason, I'll
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:22:53
support you, Bill. Thank you, Representative Walker. Any other questions,
▶ Play
committee? Representative Lauer, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just wanted you just to take a few minutes to emphasize the expanded duties that a nurse on every campus could give in terms of health education. You know, we're addressing so many issues, not the least of which a lot of families are still, even if they have Arkansas works coverage or the previous private option, a lot of families are still going to emergency rooms for colds. so obviously there's a need for health education that you should get a primary care physician not to mention just education about obesity smoking drugs all that could you just you know briefly give us an overview of how that nurse on that campus or the expanded use of nurses could help address those needs.
▶ Play
Speaker 220 1:23:57
Absolutely, Representative Lowry. Sometimes this school nurse is the only health care professional that our children will ever see. And you talk about rural Arkansas, this is your doctor in that area. This is the one that's going to make that connection. This is the one that's going to detect if the child can't see well, if the child's not eating well, if the child is being abused in their home. And that school nurse is the one that's going to pull all this together. And I'm not that school nurse, and I would love if I could, I think maybe they were here to speak on behalf of the bill, if I could let our school nurses actually share more of that, because I think it would come better from them. Can I pull one up now or in a? I'm sorry, would you repeat that? Well, I have some school nurses here, and I feel like they would probably be better able to answer that. I think we have them for
▶ Play
and against, and if we could, let's just hold that question until then. Okay.
▶ Play
If I might just add one thing, Representative Lowry, in our own school district, I just was looking at some statistics from the annual school nurse survey, which they're now completing. Of the six campuses, they actually had information from five of them. They didn't have from the junior high school. But last year in the Sheridan School District, there were 23,000 visits, almost 23,000 visits to the school nurse. If you factor out, you do the math on that from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. on the five different campuses, you're talking about roughly one student every 15 minutes coming into the school nurse's office. On those five campuses, there were 54 children who were then sent to the emergency room. in a year's time 54 er visits uh subsequent to those nurses office visits so this is i mean this is very different than you know just um putting a a band-aid on a on a cut and studies have shown
▶ Play
Speaker 220 1:26:06
that for every dollar spent on a school nurse you actually have a state savings of two dollars and 20 cents based on the fact that you have um possibly a not having to go to the emergency room a parent not having to take off work because that's what happens when the child is being sent home sick the child has to leave work which then costs the employer money and cost everybody else money for lost productivity there it also takes out productivity in the school so the teacher no longer is you know if you have a child that suddenly is throwing up um that kind of interrupts the class and you have to clean it up you have to call the parent you have to clean that child up this is everyday occurrences so do we want our teacher to have to deal with that and stop all educational process that might be going on to deal with that or allow a school nurse to more properly deal with that and take care
▶ Play
of it rebs and gates you recognize Thank you, Mr. Chair. Probably nobody's worked harder on an issue than you all have on this one. I voted no last time. I guess my question is if I vote yes to get it out of committee to allow you to present this to the full body, which I know oftentimes we have something that we can't get out of committee but would like to be heard by the whole. uh those of us that would vote to let you present it to the full body uh my question is since there's supposed to be a question if we end up not voting for it on the floor uh the the fence won't be there but you'll i'll i'll still invite you over to dinner one okay so uh i guess that's my question i think that violates some kind of ethics something somewhere i know anybody else
▶ Play
I have no other questions unless somebody else has one. All right. All right, we have one to speak against the bill. Mike Mertens, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 243 1:28:31
you recognize thank you mr. chair and members of
▶ Play
Speaker 244 1:28:39
the committee I'm Mike Mertens I represent the AAEA as school administrators and I do want to thank both representatives Mayberry's for their hard work I've we've been working on this for several years and I appreciate the amendment that that he has made but we still have several concerns regarding this bill and I'd just like to go through them and some of the data I'm going to provide comes from a document that's called the resource allocation report that is developed by the Bureau of Legislative Research and was handed out to the adequacy committee back in May of 2016 so let's start with what's required now what's the requirements for school nurses right now it's one per district 235 districts so statewide that would be a requirement of 235 nurses of course so our district uh doing the minimum uh absolutely not according to the resource app the uh resource allocation uh report they are 846.63 nurses in the state Now, that is what's called full-time equivalent. There are more nurses. Some of them work part-time. If you equate that to full-time nurses, it's over 846 nurses. So the first requirement in the bill, it starts on page 2, line 19, that says we're going to require one nurse for every 750 students. so that's the new requirement above what is the the current requirement so uh so what does that equate statewide 751 uh students per nurse would equate to 637 nurses statewide again schools have 846 nurses, they're already providing 400, excuse me, 600 nurses more than what's required by state law, and they're also, they're providing 200 nurses more than what the 750 to 1 would be. Now, would the new 750 to 1 requirement cause some hardship, some, and it kind of goes back to what this committee talked about last night, which represented a search bill on waiving the 350 minutes during the day to give schools flexibility. So going to a 750-to-1 mandate is going the other way when it comes to providing health services. So we have 14 districts that have between 750 and 825 students. Some of them already have more than one nurse. Many of them, because they're on one campus, they may have one nurse, and they don't have any medically fragile students. They require additional nurses. So with that new mandate of the 750 to one you'll have some school that'll be looking for a tenth of a nurse now you can find part-time nurses but trying to find a nurse to come in and work one-tenth of a time just to meet this new mandate that we're all in the same box would be a hardship on some of those schools now we have another mandate which kind of conflicts in the bill and one part of the bill a sudden 750 to one and then we have another mandate that says if you have less than 500 students then you have to have one nurse and then starting in 2018 if that nurse leaves you have to replace them with an RN it has to be an RN so is that a hardship for those districts that or less than 500, that's a different mandate than the 750-to-1. It's a mandate for however many students they have, whether it's 350-to-1, 375-to-1, 425-to-1. That is an unfunded mandate, and it absolutely could be a hardship for small, especially for small districts. And we heard, again, we've heard testimony on both ways regarding the availability of RNs in some rural areas, and we won't go over that again. And then the other piece of the mandate is for if you have over 500, then you're back to one nurse per campus if they're more than one mile apart. Now, while the amendments will help some districts, we still have some districts out there that are less than 750. They have two campuses that are more than a mile apart. So this is also an unfunded mandate for those districts that have to meet that mandate. They could very well meet the 750 to 1 because we have 43 districts that are between 500 and 750. 750 they could meet one mandate that's in the bill of 750 to one But they don't meet the other mandate of having a nurse per campus if they're more than a mile apart so Our main issue is the unfunded mandate for especially some of our smaller districts and having to meet These mandates and the other thing is it's the bill conflicts itself. It has a mandate of 750 to one And it also had these other mandates, depending on whether you're below or above 500. So I guess I'll, I mean, we talked about this a long time, the first time we were here. So I'll stop my testimony in there. I'll be glad to answer any questions.
▶ Play
Representative Walker. Yeah. Well, I guess I'm on an equality mission today. I was looking at the Arkansas School for Math and Science. It doesn't have too many students. And they have, I mean, you understand that we talked about the $128,000 per student who goes to Alexander. It's over against now. On the other end, the math and science schools, we got the bad students over here and the so-called smart students over here. And according to Google, you have a full-time nurse available on campus at the math and science school. Plus they have other health resources available right away in the event that anything takes place. Now, I'm concerned. How can we treat in an educational environment the children who are supposedly our cream of the crop and the ones who are the worst of the crop more favorably than handicapped students or just ordinary students with respect to providing the possibility of health care on campus while they're there?
▶ Play
Speaker 244 1:36:13
well my response to that is is districts are doing that if they weren't meeting the the health care needs of their students on campus they wouldn't have 600 more nurses than what the law requires for them to have well we're not we're
▶ Play
talking about with the pardon me I'm sorry mr. chair no different thank you but my concern here isn't whether or not they're meeting the standard but whether or not the service is being made accessible to them without cost necessarily being a factor. The per nurse cost at the math school is much greater than it is in a public school. And the per nurse cost at Alexander is far greater than it is in a public school. So we should not be in a position, should we, of having children to be deemed bad and then sent into a restraining facility or into a facility where they can get special care in order for them to have their health care needs met while wards of the state. Should we?
▶ Play
Speaker 250 1:37:23
No, sir, we should not. Thank you. Any other questions?
▶ Play
Thanks, sir. All right. This time, Deborah Jones. you recognize to speak for the bill i'm not trying to hurry testimony i'm just reminding everybody we got 20 minutes so we are going to we are going to adjourn our recess we'll actually recess to make sure we're not going to come back this afternoon or not but we probably will be back this afternoon you
▶ Play
Speaker 251 1:38:00
recognize what's your name and who you're with deborah jones assistant director arkansas state Board of Nursing, and I also served on the committee along with former Representative Julie Mayberry in developing these guidelines, and that was based upon the, was the basis for the legislation that has been introduced. I'll just point out that there is an educational difference between our LPNs and our RNs. The LPNs attend a 9- to 12-month course to qualify for taking the examination. And they were not intended to replace RNs. They were intended to fill a technical role for nursing needs. And they are to assist other health care providers in providing that care. Now, I've been an LPN. I've been a candy striper, a nurse's aide an LPN, RN and I now hold a master's degree so I have progressed up the line LPNs play a vital role in our health care I do not want to disqualify what role they do play and they are very vital to our health care that's provided but they do not have the educational level that the RNs do and that is the reason it is very vital that we get RNs into the school system. The Nurse Practice Act requires the LPN to work under the direction of an RN, an AP RN, a physician, or a dentist. And when LPNs are not practicing under that supervision, they are violating the Nurse Practice Act. We are not out there looking for LPNs who are violating the Nurse Practice Act. We have plenty of complaints for us to deal with. We are not out there looking for someone to discipline, but they are subject to discipline if a complaint is filed that they're practicing outside their scope of practice. In 1902, the first school nurse was hired in the city of New York, and their sole role was to increase student attendance. and that one nurse which was Lena Rogers did such a great job in increasing attendance that they went out and hired 12 new nurses the next year and school nurses have expanded across the nation since 1902. They do play a vital role in keeping students in school so that they can learn and they can also be have their health care needs met and hopefully Representative Walker to keep them out of the Alexander unit for disciplinary problems. So nurses do play a vital role. It is essential that they have the qualifications that are necessary to provide the best care. And that's the conclusion of my statement. Does anybody have questions regarding the Nurse Practice Act?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:41:12
I'm on. No questions? Okay. Thank you for your testimony. Anyone want to speak against the bill? Ms. Margo Bushmeyer would like to speak for the bill. State your name and who
▶ Play
Speaker 257 1:41:41
you're with. You're recognized. Margo Bushmeyer, Coordinator of Health Services, Little Rock School District. I've been in that position for 20 years. I also served on the National Board of School Nurses, so I know national standards as well. First, I want to speak to Representative Lowry, and thank you for your excellent question about what nurses can do to promote the health of students and families, teachers. That's actually one of my interview questions when I interview nurses. I only hire people that know the resources and are committed to helping our citizens of the state, and that is what school nurses do. We keep children out of the emergency room. We save state dollars. We promote quality of life for our children. Without school nurses, secretaries and teachers send kids home. They don't know what to do. They've got a child coughing, sneezing in class, respiratory distress, asthma attack. Call the parent and send them home. School nurses know how to manage those conditions and keep children in school. I'd like to speak to the issue about the requirements and why there is a need for a change. Prior to being a school nurse, I was a pediatric nurse, taught pediatric nursing. Children are changing. We have eradicated many diseases, that is wonderful, but now we have new health conditions. Our environment, our technology, there are many reasons why children have different kinds of illnesses. Allergies are increasing, asthma is increasing, diabetes. Children with complex medical needs are in schools because they're not in institutions like we did before 1975. they're at school and they need quality highly qualified nurses to take care of them this bill supports teachers i also heard a question last uh time this was presented about teachers and you know concern about teachers teachers ask for more school nurses so that they can take care of their students and teach them and they can send a student that's having symptoms to a safe place and then they can come back when they're healthy and free of symptoms this bill supports teachers you've heard testimony about how it supports families we have a parent that would also like to speak to that so i won't address that lastly i'd like to speak to just the issue miss jones spoke about the lpn issue and the scope of their practice i actually have one our LPN working with me she's great at checking immunizations that's another way we keep kids healthy if they're not immunized we work towards with the family on getting them immunized you know we've got a crisis about mumps in this state we've had whooping cough schools have had to close when you have school nurses in the building you don't have schools have to close for health reasons our lpns are great about helping with shot records and basic pass out daily medicines but not the complex medicines so there's definitely a place for the lpns that work in our schools and we value them thank you representative sutherland has
▶ Play
Speaker 146 1:45:01
a question thank you mr chair i think everybody
▶ Play
agrees we need nurses there's nobody here that disagrees with that that i'm aware of the example that you gave was a local district, although a large district, New York, taking the step to do that, not the state of New York. So why is it that we need to have the state take this rather than the local
▶ Play
Speaker 156 1:45:23
school district, which is the example you used? My
▶ Play
Speaker 257 1:45:27
understanding is you only have to do legislation when people don't do what's right.
▶ Play
Representative Beck, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. But didn't we hear someone say that we're already exceeding the numbers that are in this? Or did I misunderstand? Statewise, we already have more nurses in the school districts than this legislation would mandate. Overall, now they might
▶ Play
Speaker 257 1:45:56
not be distributed like we want. There are many districts that do have more nurses on campus than is required by law. Sadly, I do know of a district that added a nurse to every campus after a student died. I don't want that to happen. So some districts are doing great and others are not. That is my understanding of why we need this legislation.
▶ Play
A follow-up? You're recognized. Okay, and I'm going to ask this because you brought this up about the mumps epidemic in the state, and we certainly want to address that. But do you know the school districts that seem to have came up from northwest Arkansas, Were they inadequately, the number of nurses there,
▶ Play
Speaker 257 1:46:42
was it inadequate in those school districts? No, but having nurses there helped contain that.
▶ Play
All right, thank you. Representative McGill, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My understanding is that the funding was not included in the school funding analysis, I guess is my point. And that my question is, was this taken before the adequacy committee? I can't
▶ Play
Speaker 271 1:47:21
speak to that. I'd have to let the representative
▶ Play
speak to that. Either one. Was this taken before
▶ Play
the Adequacy Committee? If you want to know about a presentation, there was one made before the Adequacy Committee on
▶ Play
Nurses, yes. And I guess to follow up to that, if you don't mind, Mr. Chair, does this apply to charter schools as well?
▶ Play
Speaker 261 1:47:50
Public schools, yes, and they receive yes. All public schools. My question was, does it
▶ Play
apply to charter schools? Yes, sir. I think that's a
▶ Play
yes. Any other questions? Thank you, ma'am. Our last one, I don't think is anyone to speak against the bill? Okay, I have one. All right. You are recognized to introduce yourself and speak against the bill. I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 275 1:48:24
Jerry Newton, and since I've got roasted so
▶ Play
Speaker 276 1:48:26
much today, I thought I might want to come up and talk from Poland School District. I'm not against nurses of any kind. As they spoke, we have two LPNs. We have a part-time RN. My only problem is it's an unfunded mandate. We think we're doing a good job in our school district. We've not had any complaints with our parents, but it is an unfunded mandate, and that's the only thing that I have a problem with. If they would take the word RN out and leave nurses, then we'd be good to go.
▶ Play
And I'll try to answer any questions. Any questions? Seeing no questions. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Our last one, and I do mean last, Amber Johnson. You're up. State your name and who you're with, and you're recognized to speak
▶ Play
for the bill. Hi, my name is Amber Johnson, and I'm a parent. I have a daughter who goes to Pulaski County School District, and the school that she is zoned for, she does not have a nurse full-time. My daughter is epileptic. She has bleeding on the brain. She has Asperger's syndrome. And when there's not a nurse there, we don't have a way to keep her in school. The teachers are not equipped to take care of her. They don't know how to handle a seizure. and it's hard to have her in school so we have to move her now she is being transported to another school that has a full-time nurse um that makes it hard on me as a parent because it's harder for me to get her to school or get anybody to take care of her so it's real important that we have those nurses the nurse is that we have there is only there two days a week at the school she's at now which is down the road from where we live so I mean going through a daily life it means seizures they're not I can't schedule them they're not it can't be on just the days the nurses are at school it's daily sometimes sometimes we don't go and have one that week at all but um it's it's just very important it's vital to her and for us to know that she'll be taken care of and the with the nurse there with the teachers they just they're scared then they say that they don't know how to handle her and it makes it hard so it's real important you know for me as a parent to know that while she's at school and I'm not there to watch her, that there's going to be someone to take care of her. Are there any questions? Thank you, ma'am.
▶ Play
Thank you. Would you like to close for your bill, Representative Mayberry? Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I'll
▶ Play
make this brief. I just wanted to address a couple of things that were brought up. one regarding the comment about there being a conflict in the bill. I don't view that as a conflict at all. It was originally a 750 to 1 ratio for all school districts. The 500 to 1 came as an amendment to try to give more flexibility to smaller schools. I don't believe there's a conflict there. Are we exceeding the numbers, Representative Beck, statewide? We statewide have good numbers. Most of the school districts are doing what they're supposed to do, what they need to do, what they should be doing to provide for a healthy, safe, educational environment for their children. However, there are some school districts that are not doing what they should be doing for those children, and that's where this comes. In our last presentation last week, one of the individuals who spoke against the bill said that instead of doing something on a statewide level, we ought to go after the outliers. Well, essentially, that's what this is. It's, again, a smaller number of districts that really aren't doing what they need to be doing for those children, and that's what we're trying to address here. Again, going to Representative McGill's question about funding, school nurses is part of the matrix funding formula. It's not a mandated piece, but there are certain dollars that are allocated through that matrix funding formula of four school nurses, and we've had long conversations about how all of that plays out, so we won't go back into that again today. I don't know that I can add a whole lot more than what you've heard today, other than the fact that this is a step that we need to take and that we should be taking for the kids of the state of Arkansas. There are always going to be certain individuals who, they like the status quo, and we can make amendment after amendment after amendment, and until we amend away the entire bill, they're not going to be happy with it and i can't do anything about that uh i will say that um if if you guys on this committee are tired of hearing about this just vote yes and we'll go on to the house floor other otherwise uh for as long as uh either uh representative mayberry either one of us is elected i think we'll keep bringing this back up to you so i would appreciate a good vote
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:53:48
motion do pass have a motion do pass all those in favor say aye all
▶ Play
opposed no The ayes have it. That's your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, unless Rep. Sturge can run that bill in five minutes. We are going
▶ Play
Speaker 285 1:54:12
to come back this afternoon, Rep. Sturge, and
▶ Play
I do have you on the list if you want to wait. I think everybody's kind of ready to break in. Representative Mayberry, I don't think we have time to run your other bill in five minutes either.
▶ Play

Agenda

SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - MARCH 7, 2017, 10:00 AM

Subtitle Number Sponsor

SB178 Files TO DELAY THE INCLUSION OF A SCORE ON THE WRITING PORTION OF THE ACT ASPIRE ASSESSMENT IN A DETERMINATION OF THE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE OF A STUDENT, PUBLIC SCHOOL, OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

Files

0:00 - 1:54:26 332 segments 50 speakers

SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - MARCH 9, 2017, 10:00 AM

Sponsor Subtitle Number

HB1222 Dotson THE ARKANSAS PARENTAL EMPOWERMENT FOR EDUCATION CHOICE ACT OF 2017.

REGULAR AGENDA Number Subtitle Sponsor

HB1517 A. Mayberry CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING AND TO MODIFY THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A SCHOOL NURSE.

HB1567 Hammer TO MAKE FOSTER CHILDREN ELIGIBLE FOR A SCHOLARSHIP IN THE SUCCEED SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1574 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING HOME SCHOOLS.

HB1575 Lowery TO LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF FUND BALANCES A SCHOOL DISTRICT MAY MAINTAIN.

HB1576 C. Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ACADEMIC FACILITIES PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CONCERNING APPROVED BUT UNFUNDED NEW CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS.

HB1579 Vaught TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATORS AND EMPLOYEES.

HB1583 Dotson TO CREATE RECALL ELECTIONS FOR MEMBERS OF SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARDS OF DIRECTORS.

HB1607 Della Rosa TO LIMIT THE USE OF AN ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNER'S SCORE ON A STATE- MANDATED ASSESSMENT FOR PUBLIC SCHOOL AND PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT ACCOUNTABILITY PURPOSES.

HB1608 Della Rosa CONCERNING THE ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM DEVELOPED BY THE STATE OF ARKANSAS UNDER THE EVERY STUDENT SUCCEEDS ACT.

HB1610 Tucker TO PROVIDE ARKANSAS BETTER CHANCE PROGRAMS LOCATED WITHIN A SCHOOL DISTRICT FUNDING EQUAL TO THE FOUNDATION FUNDING AMOUNT FOR EACH EARLY GRADUATE OF THE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1612 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REQUIRED NOTIFICATIONS TO A PROSECUTING AUTHORITY REGARDING A STUDENT'S UNEXCUSED ABSENCES.

HB1621 Lowery TO CHANGE THE DATE OF THE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTION.

HB1646 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC EDUCATION.

HB1648 C.Douglas TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL ACCOUNTABILITY.

HB1666 Sabin TO REQUIRE INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION TO PROVIDE INFORMATION ON MENTAL HEALTH AND SUICIDE PREVENTION SERVICES TO ENTERING STUDENTS.

HB1671 Tucker TO GIVE CHARTER SCHOOLS AUTHORITY TO WEIGHT ADMISSION LOTTERIES AT THEIR DISCRETION.

HB1672 STucker CONCERNING ADMISSIONS POLICIES OF CHARTER SCHOOLS; AND TO ALIGN CHARTER SCHOOL ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO HAS BEEN EXPELLED FROM ANOTHER SCHOOL DISTRICT WITH ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS FOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS.

HB1673 Tucker CONCERNING APPLICATIONS FOR OR AMENDMENTS OF PUBLIC CHARTERS UNDER THE ARKANSAS QUALITY CHARTER SCHOOLS ACT OF 2013.

HB1674Tucker TO CREATE A COMMUNITY PUBLIC EDUCATION BOARD.

HB1689 Cozart TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING SCHOOL PUBLIC AND FUNDING AND INDEBTEDNESS; TO AMEND FUNDING PROVISIONS CONCERNING PUBLIC EMPLOYEE HEALTH INSURANCE; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING EDUCATION SERVICE COOPERATIVE FINANCING.

HB1701 Love TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM TO MAKE GRANTS TO HISTORICALLY BLACK COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES TO PROVIDE EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS TO OFFENDERS WHO ARE RECENTLY RELEASED OR SOON-TO-BE RELEASED FROM INCARCERATION.

HB1710 S. Meeks TO REVISE THE CIVICS AND WORLD HISTORY REQUIREMENTS TO GRADUATE FROM HIGH SCHOOL.

SB26 A. Clark TO INCREASE TEACHERS IN HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS; AND TO PROVIDE ENHANCED ARKANSAS ACADEMIC CHALLENGE SCHOLARSHIPS FOR TEACHERS WHO AGREE TO TEACH IN THE HIGH NEEDS SUBJECT AREAS.

SB27 A. Clark TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF TEACHERS IN A CRITICAL TEACHER SHORTAGE AREA; AND TO ESTABLISH THE TEACHER CANDIDATE LOAN FORGIVENESS PROGRAM.

HB1729 Cozart TO AMEND VARIOUS PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING PUBLIC SCHOOL FUNDING AMOUNTS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1738 C. Douglas CONCERNING ETHICS OF MEMBERS OF A BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT; AND TO CREATE THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS ETHICS REVIEW BOARD.

HB1740 Lowery CONCERNING THE ENROLLMENT OR RE-ENROLLMENT OF HOME-SCHOOLED STUDENT IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT.

HB1791 Tucker TO ESTABLISH A FOOD PANTRY MATCHING GRANT PROGRAM TO BE ADMINISTERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION.

HB1802 Lundstrum TO ALLOW CONTRIBUTIONS BY AN ARKANSAS TAXPAYER TO A TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ESTABLISHED BY ANOTHER STATE TO BE DEDUCTED FROM A TAXPAYER'S INCOME TAX.

HB1805 Sturch TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING POSTSECONDARY COURSES IN UNITED STATES HISTORY, UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT, AND THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.

HB1806 Sturch TO REPEAL A SECTION IN THE ARKANSAS CODE THAT GRANTS FREE TUITION TO STATE-SUPPORTED INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION FOR WORLD WAR I VETERANS.

SB329 A. Clark TO RAISE THE PRICE THRESHOLD FOR THE PURCHASE OF COMMODITIES THAT SCHOOL DISTRICTS MUST PROCURE BY SOLICITING BIDS; AND TO PROVIDE FOR ANNUAL ADJUSTMENTS IN THE PURCHASE PRICE THRESHOLD BASED ON INFLATION.

SB423 U. Lindsey TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING CAREER AND TECHNICAL EDUCATION.

SB427 Hickey TO AMEND THE POWERS AND AUTHORITY OF THE SECTION 529 PLAN REVIEW COMMITTEE AND THE INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1408 C. Douglas CONCERNING WHO MAY SERVE AS A PROCTOR OF A TEST OR ASSESSMENT ADMINISTERED UNDER THE ARKANSAS COMPREHENSIVE TESTING, ASSESSMENT, AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM ACT.

HB1457 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT AND AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO DEVELOP A PLAN FOR THE USE OF AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD OF INSTRUCTION TO BE USED ON DAYS WHEN SCHOOL IS CANCELLED.

HB1459 C. Douglas TO PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY IN THE AWARDING OF COURSE CREDITS; AND TO ALLOW A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT TO DEVELOP AND IMPLEMENT A PLAN THAT ENABLES A STUDENT TO EARN COURSE CREDITS BY DEMONSTRATING SUBJECT STUDENT COMPETENCY.

HB1516 A. Mayberry -CONCERNING SCHOOL NURSING; TO ESTABLISH SCHOOL NURSE-TO-STUDENT RATIOS; AND TO REQUIRE AN ANNUAL SCHOOL NURSE SURVEY.

HB1820 Dotson CONCERNING SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVERS; TO REQUIRE THE STATE BOARD OFEDUCATION TO GRANT A SCHOOL DISTRICT WAIVER PETITION IF AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL DRAWING STUDENTS FROM THE SCHOOL DISTRICT WAS GRANTED A WAIVER.

HB1831 Leding TO ALLOW AN OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL TO USE A WEIGHTED LOTTERY IN ITS ADMISSIONS PROCESS BASED ON CERTAIN STUDENT CHARACTERISTICS.

HB1834 K. Hendren TO PROHIBIT A PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT OR OPEN-ENROLLMENT PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL FROM INCLUDING IN ITS CURRICULUM OR COURSE MATERIALS FOR A PROGRAM OF STUDY BOOKS OR ANY OTHER MATERIAL AUTHORED BY OR CONCERNING ZINN.

HB1856 F. Allen TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS EARLY LITERACY ASSESSMENT PROCUREMENT ACT.

HB1017 Cozart TO ALLOW THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983 TO BE WAIVED IF A PUBLIC SCHOOL OR PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT IS UNDER STATE AUTHORITY AFTER BEING CLASSIFIED AS BEING IN DISTRESS.

HB1020 Love TO CREATE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY PROMISE LOTTERY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM; TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO EVERY CHILD BORN IN ARKANSAS TO BE USED FOR COLLEGE TUITION.

HB1027 Eubanks TO PROHIBIT A SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM USING PUBLIC FUNDS TO PAY A TEACHER'S OR CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEE'S MEMBERSHIP DUES IN A PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATION.

HB1029 Lowery TO EXCLUDE PRINCIPALS, ASSISTANT PRINCIPALS, AND CENTRAL OFFICE EMPLOYEES WITH A MULTIYEAR EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF "TEACHER" UNDER THE TEACHER FAIR DISMISSAL ACT OF 1983.

HB1044 F. Allen TO ALLOW A STUDENT TO CHOOSE WHICH GRADE IN WHICH TO TAKE THE COLLEGE AND CAREER READINESS ASSESSMENT.

HB1456 C. Douglas TO ALLOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO WAIVE PHYSICAL EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR A STUDENT WHO PROVIDES PROOF OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY; AND TO EXEMPT A STUDENT WITH A PHYSICAL EDUCATION WAIVER FROM PHYSICAL EDUCATION GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS.

HB1458 C. Douglas TO REQUIRE A STUDENT TO PARTICIPATE IN VISUAL ARTS OR PERFORMING ARTS IN EITHER GRADE SEVEN OR GRADE EIGHT.

HB1510 Gonzales TO CREATE THE DEMOGRAPHIC PREFERENCE DISCLOSURE ACT.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
31 segments
Speaker 8
45 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Chair Unverified
21 segments
Representative John W. Walker Chair Unverified
28 segments
Representative Fred Allen Unverified
2 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
10 segments
Chair Unverified
19 segments
Speaker 58
1 segment
Speaker 33
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 85
6 segments
Speaker 93
2 segments
Speaker 81
1 segment
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 87
1 segment
Chris Kratzer Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 121
1 segment
Speaker 125
24 segments
Speaker 128
25 segments
Speaker 132
1 segment
Speaker 154
1 segment
Speaker 160
1 segment
Speaker 96
1 segment
Speaker 179
2 segments
Representative George B. McGill Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 180
1 segment
Speaker 59
1 segment
Speaker 210
1 segment
Speaker 215
1 segment
Representative Andy Mayberry Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 218
1 segment
Speaker 220
15 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 243
1 segment
Speaker 244
13 segments
Speaker 250
1 segment
Speaker 251
6 segments
Speaker 257
11 segments
Speaker 146
1 segment
Speaker 156
1 segment
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 271
1 segment
Speaker 261
1 segment
Speaker 275
1 segment
Speaker 276
1 segment
Amber Johnson Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 66
1 segment
Speaker 285
1 segment