Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Education Committee

March 7, 2017 ·Committee Room 130 ·1:31:48
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (8)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1612 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1612”
Pre-2017 bill
SB423 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB423”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1517 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1517”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1567 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1567”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1804 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1804”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1806 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1806”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1945 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1945”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1957 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “Hb1957”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
Representative Douglas, would you take the end of the table, please? I can call this meeting to order. It's 3 o'clock.
▶ Play
Speaker 3 0:20
Do I have a motion? This is Senate Bill 423.
▶ Play
I have a motion. Do pass. Any objections? I don't see two hands. All those in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. It's too late on that
▶ Play
Speaker 6 0:49
one. I have two hands open. You could take a lesson from him. What did you just let
▶ Play
Speaker 11 0:58
out? Representative Rush, would you take the other table, please?
▶ Play
Speaker 13 1:01
Senator Lindsey's bill on career and tech education. It was just a cleanup bill. A cleanup bill. I don't
▶ Play
do that at all, but those cleanup bills are pretty simple. This
▶ Play
could be a cleanup, too. We could just call
▶ Play
it that. Is this a cleanup bill? No, not really, but it'll be a fast one.
▶ Play
Representative Rushing, you are recognized to present House Bill 1612. Go. Thank you, Representative Cozart. This is a bill that was brought to me by our circuit judge, Chris Williams. I have two of our superintendents here in attendance today that are also for this bill, and if need be, they can speak for it if you have any questions. Basically, it is a families in need of the notification, the FINS process is basically what it is. And it says after a student exceeds at least 50%, not just the total, that the parents will be notified. So this gives a little bit more notification that their student is in trouble and that there needs to be some action taken. and therefore I will let these two fine superintendents speak if you would like to hear them, if not. If they
▶ Play
would just state their name and who they're with, they're recognized to
▶ Play
Speaker 28 2:18
speak for the bill. Nick Sopes, assistant principal,
▶ Play
Speaker 34 2:22
Sheridan High School. My name is Ryan Sori. I'm the mental health coordinator
▶ Play
for Sheridan School District. You're welcome to make a
▶ Play
Speaker 28 2:29
statement if you'd like to. Ms. Sori and I work together with truancy and absentee issues on quite a regular basis. It's one of my roles and responsibilities at Sheridan High School to supervise attendance for approximately 900 students, and any time there is a concern about a student's attendance, it results in a report of truancy that runs through Ms. Sorey's office. Truancy is something, chronic absenteeism, it's something that is kind of near and dear to our hearts because of the negative impact that it has on children. Students who are routinely absent from school have decreased levels of achievement, they're much more likely to read below grade level and if you go back and look at some research reading below grade level at the end of third grade increases the likelihood of a student dropping out from high school for dropping out of school fourfold four times over somebody who is reading at grade level at the end of third grade students that are chronically absent score measurably lower on standardized tests and their peers and will end up having average gpas almost a full point lower than students who maintain acceptable attendance at school as I've said there's already an increased likelihood of dropping out some studies have shown as much as seven times greater occurrence of high school dropout for students that are chronically absent as opposed to students who do maintain acceptable attendance at school we have a handout that's coming out
▶ Play
for that too so go ahead continue on thank
▶ Play
Speaker 28 3:57
you thank you sir loss of credit and Retention, which loss of credit is what happens when a student misses too much school. Those are associated with higher rates of dropping out of school as well. And in addition, chronic absenteeism reduces the likelihood that a student will participate in post-secondary education. This doesn't just affect people that are going to a two- or four-year college. Post-secondary includes people who are going to learn a trade where they can earn a living. It reduces future earning potential for students. Just to give you an idea, from the Bureau of Labor Statistics in Washington, D.C., the average salary of a person that's dropped out of high school is about $25,000 a year. For someone with an associate's degree, that number is $40,000, and for somebody with a bachelor's degree, that's $58,000. So someone with a college degree over a dropout will earn approximately a million dollars more over the life of his working life than someone who has dropped out of school that's you know that's money that goes into the economy that's money that helps improve quality of life and so when we start talking about truancy and absenteeism we're not just talking about trying to keep kids in school we're trying to talk about improving a quality of life helping them have the future that we as educators would like to see them have moving forward just a little bit students that drop out of school have a disproportionately higher rate of participation in social service programs and we found one study that said they account for nearly half of the heads of household that receive social welfare benefits. There are higher rates of juvenile delinquency, higher rates of increased illegal drug use, students that are true and are four times as likely to use marijuana than students that regularly attend school. So we see a lot of negative effects associated with students who are attending school regularly and students that drop out are more likely to be incarcerated than students that finish high school and receive a diploma when you start looking at future quality of life students that drop out will earn about 65 percent of what somebody with a high school diploma will work so about two about two-thirds and when you start thinking about that the difference between dropping out and receiving a high school diploma is about four hundred thousand dollars over a person's working life and between that and a between dropping out and a bachelor's degree we're looking at almost a million dollars there's quality of life issues there's opportunities that students will have when they receive their high school diplomas that may never be open to them once they have decided to drop out of school and so we have come today to support this bill because we are here for kids we want to see good outcomes for the students that come through the high school and the public schools in Sheridan, in Little Rock, in Poe, and all across the state of Arkansas. And we are asking for your help in trying to put a piece of legislation in place that will allow us to respond to students that are missing school earlier than when they have already lost credit. Right now, we can't file for truancy until a student has already lost credit. And so essentially what we've done is we've watched a kid pick up a fork, walk over to the electrical outlet and stick it in the outlet and we don't respond until after the kid's already stuck the fork in the outlet we're trying to keep that problem from ever happening by stopping the kid from ever getting to that place where the damage is really done. I just want to echo what
▶ Play
Speaker 34 7:31
Mr. Soaps has already said he's kind of our data guy he's going to give you all the stats I work with at-risk youth in a lot of capacities as mental health coordinator as truancy coordinator juvenile court representative um and so what this bill does um to address all of those things that mr soaps has already sort of explained is i look at it as an early intervention bill it gives us the opportunity as a school district to to go ahead and provide those supports to go ahead and and make those referrals before we lose credit before our students lose credit and get behind because that just increases the probability of dropout and all of those negative consequences that Mr. Soaps has already put forth. And I think that we are willing to answer any questions that you guys might
▶ Play
have. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The questions I have are basically related. Under the language within the bill, if a student exceeds or uses 50% of the unexcused absences then it says then at that point we may do the prosecuting attorney so the questions I have related to that is number one can you give us an idea of how long a typical school would how many excused absences the student would have typically and then number two since we're changing the language to may notify the prosecuting attorney a student that uses all of those excused absences under the old system we would have to notify now we're saying that we don't and that may be okay i was just wondering if you could speak to those
▶ Play
Speaker 28 9:17
two for you this bill speaks to a student's unexcused absences so that that includes uh absences that are not covered by physician's note or a letter from a court official for maybe going to pay a speeding ticket or going to family court or something like that the way the current law works schools are able to write their own policies and determine at what point students would lose credit at sheridan high school we allow eight days per semester we spoke with the superintendent from poe and earlier he said they allow 10 so there's some variability from district to district when we start looking at this right now if in Sheridan if a student hits nine days that student is not eligible to receive credit and could be reported for truancy what this bill would allow us to do is to stop that student from ever losing credit by making that report earlier and engaging the supports of the court to keep that student in school just to give you an idea just because a student you know hits or exceeds 50 percent in Sheridan four days unexcused that doesn't automatically trigger a report of truancy now if we're in the first month of school and we've got a kid who's missed four days unexcused we might make that report but if we're in December and we've got five days left in the semester and a kid hits four days there's there's not going to be a report made so what this does it allows us to intervene earlier if we see warning signs related to attendance but it doesn't require us to act in such a broad way that everybody who exceeds that 50 percent mark would be reported for truancy. We want to take a little bit of common sense and blend it with the law and use it to create an early intervention system for our students that helps keep them from losing credit.
▶ Play
Thank you. You're welcome. Any other questions? Representative Walker,
▶ Play
you didn't hear the... You recognized. I'd like for Representative Rushing to explain to me Why the rush to put these children in the judicial system by referring them to the prosecuting attorney who can only either prosecute or not prosecute? I mean, you know, I think skipping school and those kinds of things are important, but those are not things to cause young kids 10, 12, 14, 15 years of age to come into contact with
▶ Play
the police authority. I think our superintendent here said it the best when he says that we want to do an early intervention with these children, and sometimes they do not have the family life in order to support of that, and that is the only action that we put them into the prosecutor's hands. But this at least gives some warning signs early on rather than taking the credit away. this is actually better for those types because the credit's not already gone before it's too late. Follow-up. It is traumatic
▶ Play
for children to be placed before a prosecuting attorney, for a child to be placed before a prosecuting attorney in threatened with prosecution, especially when it may not be the fault of the child. And when you're dealing with children who are not even teenagers, And that possibility exists. It seems like it would be more appropriate to leave that with the school authorities and to have them sensitively address the issue as long as they can. I'd say even through the 10th grade or so. Because those children are not free agents, and they don't make their own decisions. So instead of referring the children to the prosecuting attorney, you may want another alternative. I
▶ Play
believe if you read the bill, it says that it may notify the prosecuting attorney and the student's parents, guardian, or person and shall be subject to the civil penalty. Well, when you say end,
▶ Play
you're going to notify the prosecutor and their parents. That means that it's both, and it's more or less either the threat of prosecution on behalf of the child, not to the parent. I just think that that's not a good bill, Ms. Rushing, and it's mean. Thank you. I'm sorry that you... Any other questions? Do not. I'm sorry you think I'm in.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's already the law. Change the law. During the interim, we had an organization, I think, out of Tennessee. It may have been Georgia. I'm not really sure where. And one of the things that we were asking was about kids entering the judicial system, that if they were an adult, we would not prosecute. And one of them had to do with, for instance, if you had a 17-year-old that was refusing to go to school and are we going to, you know, turn him over to a prosecutor, incarcerate him, put him in a juvenile detention, where if he were an adult, we wouldn't prosecute him for not going to college. So if you would address that concern that this may push somebody, and I've had family members that didn't finish high school, they just didn't finish high school, and they chose to go into a career that afforded them that flexibility, how will this not push people into the juvenile system and into maybe potential incarceration if they were true nonstop, their parents couldn't control them, How would this not bring more people into that system?
▶ Play
Speaker 28 14:50
Right now in Arkansas, we have a mandatory public school attendance law that states that all children up until the age of 18 are required to attend school. Now, if a student attends a private school, that's fine. If a student goes to a charter school or a public school, that's also fine. Some students even attend a home school. And if a student leaves the public school system and goes to a home school, there's some paperwork to file, so we keep track of those things. but that's a requirement of the state of Arkansas. Truancy statutes help us to maintain compliance with that law. Public education is in the interest of everybody in this room. Those of you that were in here heard me read through a list of negative outcomes for people that don't finish school. Incarceration, higher levels of drug use, reliance on public assistance, lost earning potential throughout a lifetime this bill is not about funneling kids into the the school to jail pipeline that some people talk about that's not what this is at all we are trying to intervene in a situation with children before they have lost credit because i've seen a number of students in in court in grant county when they've been turned over for truancy have the attitude why should I continue to go I have already lost credit it does me no good to be there other than for for me to go so the judge doesn't get upset with me we're trying to intervene earlier so that rather than those students losing credit they are able to maintain their credit to earn those credits and to graduate so they have that high school diploma that is so necessary today for moving on to the next step whether it be college education vocational school or going straight into the workforce, every one of us in this room knows that a high school diploma is a valuable thing. We're not trying to incarcerate kids. We're not trying to put kids in jail. We're trying to keep kids in school and help them to receive the credit they should earn for doing the work at school.
▶ Play
Thank you. Follow-up? You're recognized. Thank you. With the assumption that nobody has filed a bill to change those current laws on the books, this bill's intent is to try to intervene only on those ones that are looks like this is not people who've they're sick this is not the ones who have medical conditions this is the ones that are heading toward truancy so until the state law changes on what truancy is on public education this is just an intervention tool to try to head them off early versus waiting till it's too late and they lose a whole calendar year. Is that assumed correct? That is
▶ Play
Speaker 66 17:36
correct. Thank you. Representative McElroy. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. I was a county judge for 20 years in Deshaies County, and my daughter decided her and her friend were going to skip out of class. They never left school. They just laid in the car for one period. Well, anyway, the next thing I know, they sent me, the county judge, over to my own courthouse on a Finn's case and I looked at it like they could have called me the principal could have called me and said hey you know they skipped school but rather than that I think they took a cop out and just put it into the court system and for 20 years over there I noticed that a lot of those kids I don't know if it's because they don't want to discipline kids because they're worried about lawsuits. But I agree with Representative Walker. It's traumatic for my daughter to have to go over there and sit in court. It's embarrassing for me and my family to sit there and hold a hand in front of the judge. It's embarrassing for the judge since I paid their salary. But anyway, I've got some concerns about this. And by the way, you know, you say, well, we're just trying to stop the people that are headed for the penitentiary. Well, my daughter is a radiation therapy in radiation therapy over at Christy St. Michael's Hospital making more money than I ever made. But I wonder, and I'm not saying that you would do it, but I'm wondering sometimes it's not easier to say, look, we don't want to deal with this. might be a lawsuit we'll just send them into the court system but after they get in that court system it kind of puts a bad light and I'm like Walker I know there's a question in here somewhere but do you think that sometimes it gets abused the fence system there are
▶ Play
Speaker 28 19:47
over 200 school districts in the state of Arkansas I can't speak for practices at those other than my own where I operate but what I can tell you in any of the parents that I have worked with in truancy cases can tell you is that my primary goal is always always to avoid a prosecution of truancy if it is at all possible my first goal whenever I call a parent about a student's attendance is to find a way to keep credit for that student to find a way to keep that student moving towards graduation so that if that student's scheduled to graduate in 2017 or 18 or 19, that's exactly what we have. I can't speak for the other districts. I can't speak for the other people. I can only speak for myself, but my goal, if I have an opportunity to do it, is to keep kids in school out of the courtroom. That is a last resort for me and not something where I just
▶ Play
try to pass the buck along to somebody else. You recognize. Thank you. So do you contact the parents first of all? That's my main concern, is that I think the parents ought to be, you know, we don't know. A lot of parents work every day, and, you know, our kids don't say what your kid won't do. I just showed that just because you're a county judge doesn't mean that yours won't mess up. But do
▶ Play
Speaker 28 21:10
you contact the parents first? Yes, I do. I run attendance reports in my building on an almost weekly basis. Each semester, I will have conferences with somewhere in the range of approximately 100 students. Sometimes I will see some of those students two or three or maybe even four times, and each time a student is in my office, it leads to apparent contact. It is a process where I tell parents each and every time, I am not out here to get your kid in trouble. I am not out here to prosecute your child. I want us to work together and be partners in helping your child to maintain credit. You know, I keep a spreadsheet of every contact that I make, and I contacted, I don't know, six or eight parents yesterday, and I think so far this semester we're just into the very beginning of March, and I believe I've already contacted the parents of approximately 60 different students in a school of 900. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 79 22:11
De La Rosa. i apologize if you guys have already covered this but i came in late and i want to make sure that what i'm i understand what i'm voting on here um so this is saying that if the student has exceeded just 50 percent of unexcused absences you may now turn them over to the prosecuting attorney before they have even broken the rule of unexcused absences so that's part one of the question and part two of the question is what what is the attendance policy what are the number of unexcused absences that we have as our
▶ Play
Speaker 28 22:41
limit right now the the number of absences can vary from district to district eight and ten are common numbers depending on where you go Sheridan is eight Poe is ten many districts fall within that range right now we can't make a report of truancy or expect a prosecuting attorney to offer us assistance in getting a child back in school until a student has surpassed his allowed number of unexcused absences, and Sheridan, that's nine. When a student hits nine, the student has lost credit. The student can also be reported for truancy. It's too late for us to save that student's credit. While this bill does reduce the number of days that it takes for us to make a report, it does say may. It allows us, so it's not a hard and fast rule, it does allow us to intervene before credit is lost. you know and you know moving a step further I said a little bit earlier we want to take this legislation which allows us to intervene and possibly get the help of the court system and maintaining student attendance a little bit earlier we're going to take the legislation we're going to temper it with some common sense you know if it's the first of September and we've got a kid who's already missed four inexcused absences we may be calling our juvenile services for some support if it's december and a kid hits four days and we're just a couple days shy of being finished with the semester we're not going to make that report it's something that that will take a thought you know we will take a thoughtful and measured approach in using this legislation to support kids follow up mr chair you're recognized so you mean to tell me they can turn
▶ Play
Speaker 79 24:13
a parent or kid over to the prosecuting attorney for missing four days of school with with
▶ Play
Speaker 28 24:20
this legislation if if uh we were in a situation where um a student missed a large number of absences in a short period of time that's a possibility uh this is just four though i mean if
▶ Play
Speaker 79 24:31
the rule is eight to ten that's four right four they could be turned over to a prosecuting attorney for missing four days of
▶ Play
Speaker 28 24:39
school that's a potential but it's not always going to happen that way if we have a situation where we're very concerned then we can enlist the support of juvenile services to help maintain student attendance but without this early intervention approach we can't get that assistance until a student has already lost credit now i'm calling parents and trying to maintain student attendance before it gets to that point that's part of my responsibilities on a day-to-day basis but right now i can't get support from from any type of legal remedy until a student has already lost credit thank you mr chair Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Help me out with this. Unexcused absence. I guess the question I'm going to ask is this. Could a child basically be getting unexcused absences that's related to something that's out of control of the child? And therefore, what is that? What's an unexcused absence?
▶ Play
Speaker 28 25:44
An unexcused absence is an absence that would not be accompanied by some type of official documentation, dentist, eye doctor, physician, visit to court, and sometimes parents will see us before missing for various purposes. You know, it could be possibly a trip to DHS where the child has to attend for some type of meeting. We will work out things where absences can be excused. But if a child just, you know, doesn't come to school for whatever reason and has not had some type of visit to, you know, an official visit of some kind, then that absence would be
▶ Play
classified as unexcused. Follow-up? So my concern is this, is that a child that's trying to come to school, you know, the home situation or something, how would you step in there and make sure that? I would like to see you address that that problem earlier so that they stop missing school but but how's how does that work I mean how does you know the home life situation I can't come to school for whatever reason now I'm unexcused because I don't have a piece of paper so how would you intervene with that beforehand because I could see with this law that that would that would put
▶ Play
Speaker 28 27:01
me in trouble when speaking about the truancy process there are a number of conversations that will take place, at least in the process that we run. We make sure that there's contacts with families. We try to get an idea of why the student is missing. And depending on what comes about as a result of those conversations, sometimes in a truancy proceeding, the onus will be on the parents, and sometimes it will be on the child. We have parents in Sheridan who work in Little Rock and have to be to work at 7 o'clock. So they get up, make sure their kids eat breakfast, and they go to work and depend on the kids to get themselves to school, whether it be on the bus or driving themselves. The parent has done everything he could within his power to get the child there but had to go to work so that the child is cared for. Some children in those situations simply choose not to come to school. When we get wind of that, we visit with parents. We try to get parent support before we ever make a report of truancy. Now, the bill allows us to act as soon as a student has exceeded 50%. It would probably be highly unlikely for us to file truancy on a kid at four or five days of unexcused absences unless there were some pretty serious circumstances. What we would do at that point is, you know, try to work with the parents first, just like we do now. But right now, we don't have a legal remedy to keep kids in school until they've already lost credit. I know we're talking about prosecution. I know that that is a traumatic thing for kids. Sometimes it's the kid making a choice not to come to school. Sometimes it's the parent not doing the job of the parent. Sometimes it could be something else entirely. But we don't have a remedy for kids to be ordered to be in school outside of the truancy process at this time. Kids can miss as much as they want up to a point, and then the courts step in to help enforce the law that says any child under the age of 18 has to attend school we're asking for support in in that process to try and intervene with kids earlier if if truancy can come earlier it doesn't mean that it will come earlier but knowing that that is a possibility earlier in the process may be enough in and of itself to persuade people to be more diligent about having their children
▶ Play
Speaker 95 29:28
at school i have a question or an observation as a school teacher for 25 years it is a huge problem in the classroom with kids missing school and what i found is that they play the system if they know they can go to eight days and then the consequences then they go to eight days and some schools even have a policy that you cannot make up the work if it's an unexcused absence we're not talking about medical excuses we're not talking about school business we're not talking about things that we know they legitimately should you lose for uh leave for but we're talking about they just stayed home probably or you know they made that choice so having that early intervention you know you've got to think is this more important to maybe put them through the stress of turning them in or would we rather these kids lose credit drop out of school you know become disengaged they can't make up their work it's a it's so So, you know, weighing the consequences of the pain of them going to court or the fear of them going to court, you know, to me, to save them could be the best alternative. So the other observation is that DHS has become the school's fallback a lot of times. They're called DHS when they miss these days of school, and they get taken from their parents. And to me, that's more traumatic as an alternative because they say that that's endangerment of the child when they miss that much school. So those consequences weighed against them knowing that they would have to go before a judge and getting a little scolding to possibly save them. I can see some great merit in an early intervention program. Wouldn't you agree? And my question is, you know, possibly could you have the early intervention like almost on site at school, a little less imposing than going to a courtroom? I don't know, but I was just thinking of some kind of an appeals court that you could do on site that would be in be worth you know maybe pursuing so thank you represent kevin off your
▶ Play
neck thank you mr chair uh the question i have is how did you come up with the 50 percent because if you're dealing with just four days that's not a lot of days that someone's missed and then you're going to start this process how come you came up with 50 and maybe say not 75 which
▶ Play
gets it closer but time enough for you to intervene i think that i can probably answer that for you um that came on the recommendation of of chris williams the circuit judge in my area who helped develop this legislation and that was that was the recommendation of him and some of the other judges that had met uh knowing that each school district was different on on the amount i know that i've i worked in the education system and in the school district that i was in their their amount of days was 12 days i think also some of them in hot springs are 12 days per semester so you're talking about missing almost a half a month at that point and so i think that that's where they came up with that because of the some of the school districts that are higher in number where they've already missed so many you're recognized thank you mr
▶ Play
chair but for the school districts that only have eight you've got it at four and i i like the idea and i think we need early intervention because whatever we can do to keep a child in schools better but in reality four unexcused absences is small before you start this process that's all i'm saying i understand that they got 12 but the problem is we're saying 50 percent of what theirs are and if you've got it what if You've got one that's got six. Then you've
▶ Play
got three. Correct, and that's why we have the may in there. They may contact, and that goes back to your superintendent, and that goes back to your school district, knowing the children, knowing the family, knowing the situation, and also back to the classroom teachers being able to tell, too, what is going on inside the classroom
▶ Play
Speaker 97 34:19
and what may or may not be going on with
▶ Play
that child in their home life. Rep. Walker, I recognize for your question. Thank you. Some districts cause children who have repeated TARDIS to have an absence for several TARDIS. I wonder, but that's just a comment. The economic consequences of involving the prosecution are pretty great, because a parent will have to come from work, hire a lawyer, and if they're in Grant County-type ordinary circumstances, it's going to be economically disastrous. So what you're doing is not simply trying to keep the kid in school and cause that kid to learn in a particular course or maybe more, but you're upsetting a family. and the cause of it may be even more disruptive because when the lights go off or when a person loses his or her job, then you have an even more dire circumstance. I do not, while I understand you want to keep kids in school, I do not understand, and I apologize for calling it inhumane, but I don't understand the necessity for treating children so mean. And bear in mind, this applies to children who are grade 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7. I mean, they may be, we're not talking about kids who have credit they can't recover. I mean, and basically the other thing, don't you understand, do you not understand that not any of us have been in a situation where a particular course made us, missing a particular course, made us or broke us, or a particular day in school. So I'm trying to understand what necessitates this other than that it's a bill that maybe somebody ought to bring. What necessitates it? There's no body of evidence that I see in these districts that warrants this as I see it. So if you could explain that to me, I'd
▶ Play
be most grateful. Well, I think that maybe we are, maybe there's a misunderstanding on the truancy laws and what we're trying to do. What we're trying to do is say that at 50% we're going to notify. The truancy laws, we're not trying to alter those others than saying that we're going to give some notification at 50% of those truancy days. If there needs to be something, I feel like the economic impact to a community and to our state is for these children to be missing school and getting behind a reading level, getting behind a grade level, and having to repeat the grade for whatever purposes or losing their credit. So we're not talking about the whole entire truancy laws. Maybe that is something that needs to be addressed in a whole and that each school district is on the same page and that they're on the same amount of absences, what defines truancy and what does not. But at this point, we're talking about let's give notification so these children can have an adequate education, which I think that we all want. Even if our kids are in first grade, second grade, third grade or they're a senior in high school getting ready to graduate I think we can all say that we want them to be able to have the best and most adequate education that they possibly can and if that means that they have to go to school which is what the law says then that means that's
▶ Play
Speaker 28 37:46
what the law says. If I might add to that when we talk about chronic absenteeism and truancy there's there's more than just the child's education at stake truancy is correlated to higher rates of juvenile delinquency it's correlated to higher rates of of drug abuse by young people and as you stated earlier representative walker it costs 128 000 a year for a child to go to alexander i think the truancy process is probably much less costly than the $128,000 a year that it costs to house and educate a child at the Alexander unit. I have one
▶ Play
more. I'm going to allow one more for testimony here, and then we're going to move on because we're running out of time. Representative Kavanaugh, if
▶ Play
you're allowed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mine's just a real quick question. In here, it includes adult education. Why are we including adult education programs in this? we did not change that
▶ Play
language that was in the law that was already part of the law and so again that goes back to the truancy laws that are in place that maybe that's the part that needs to be addressed and not necessarily this 50 percent that we're trying to add to to fix this problem all
▶ Play
right no more questions committee is there anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill you are recognized for a short brief statement against the bill please that's your name and who you're with you're recognized mr. chairman tracy annulston with
▶ Play
the arkansas education association so i want to just tell you a brief story of a real person with a real child, who happens to be one of our employees. His child ran a fever, and the child could not go to school for four days. The doctor would not see the child until the days were expired. The number of absent days were expired. As a result, after the child went back to school, and by the way, this is a straight-A student, a young lady, she had to go to court with her parent who had to miss work, who had to get an attorney to show up for a straight A student who was sick and realize that in the first portion of the sickness the doctor would not give a note and would not allow would not see the child until after a certain amount of time had passed To criminalize children and families is already a problem within schools. I don't think we should exacerbate it. I think we need to find a different way to intervene other than a court system because it alienates families and vilifies students. Thank you. We have a question. Representative Meek. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The question I have is based upon that
▶ Play
story, it seems like you would support the bill because under current law, it says once you reach that point, you have to involve the court system. You have to involve the prosecutor. What this law does, it changes it to may, so that way in a situation like you're talking about, that it's a common sense that there's no truancy issue going on here, that they don't have to get the prosecutor involved in this. So help me rectify this. They already do get the
▶ Play
court involved in it, so this would exacerbate it in our interpretation of the bill. How? Because it says they may. Because it would have happened at four absences instead of
▶ Play
eight. No, it says it may happen, not that
▶ Play
it has to happen. Well, who decides may? The school officials. right so parents don't get to decide we have the intervention of everybody else
▶ Play
deciding for parents parents don't get to
▶ Play
decide now thank you mr. chairman all right any other questions committee thank you thank you miss nelson anyone would like to speak for the bill against the bill
▶ Play
would you like to close for your bill yes real fast i'll make i'll make it brief right now we really need your help to pass this legislation in order to ensure that children keep in school and they keep we are active in the process of making sure that they stay in attendance i know there's been lots of good discussion on truancy i do think that representative meeks made a good here at the end where this does allow for us for the school systems may turn them in but in as in the case that was just stated at that point that that was required that was a shall now we're to a may so this is a little bit working closer towards helping with our truancy system keeping our kids in school and in for us and instead of in front of a prosecutor so I would appreciate a good vote. What's the
▶ Play
will of the committee? I have a do pass motion. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, no. No. I'm sorry your bill has failed. Thank you. Mr. Sturge. My order of business is going to we're going to let Mr. Sturge we're going to hear his short bill that he's already presented once and he's just going to tell you what he's done to amend this bill for what you guys had asked for in the last time we ran it so we don't have to linger on any longer than we have to on some of these bills and then we're going to hear my co-chair has a bill then we're going to hear mr. Mayberry everybody okay with that and if we have time I think mr. hammers the room if we have time we'll hear him but I'm not sure how long we're gonna be able to hold the crowd so we'll try to go that's kind of the order of
▶ Play
Speaker 134 44:22
business today you are recognized thank you mr. chair I really don't have much more to say you pretty much go but last week when we ran this bill we had a couple of colleagues who had a couple of issues with a mentoring piece of the bill where it allowed college students to go into high schools or whatever, and we left it enough broad language to say that it would be about healthy choices and good relationships and so forth and so on, and we left that up to the coordinating board to decide the curriculum and things, but there was enough pushback on that that instead of running it on the Senate end, I just wanted to clean bill here, and so that's what the amendment does. It deletes that mentoring program altogether, along with what Representative Douglas had mentioned, that they were already getting some of that in high school programs now in February and October. So that's all the amendment does. It deletes that mentoring program and leaves the rest the same. I need
▶ Play
a motion to adopt that amendment. I have a motion to adopt that amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Motion carries on amendments adopted. You may present your bill as amended. Same way. Okay. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 134 45:21
you, Mr. Chair. I won't linger. Like I said, this was my efforts in order to develop an action plan that we currently don't have in the state for sexual sultan college campuses there are some things being done with the cleary act and title nine of the federal program but we don't get those reports basically it allows schools to put a reporting system in place it allows some resources to be done but we don't know all the education piece and i would argue yes i do want more teeth in the bill yes i'd like it to be a little further but until i have a landmark to go by i really don't know what schools are doing currently and that's what the higher ed coordinating board would be doing is gathering this information from all universities and colleges and letting us know that, yes, they are being proactive in educating our students. And with that, I'll let the audience close later.
▶ Play
Any questions? Seeing none, anyone in the audience want to speak for or against the bill? Okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 139 46:21
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Shane Broadway with the Arkansas State University System, and I want to thank Representative Sturge. After the initial filing of the bill, we visited with him about what we currently do and what we're currently required to do under federal law and I think he has really worked with us to make this a better bill this is a personal issue for me in a way when I was about to become the student body president at Arkansas State University very close friend of mine was assaulted on campus and I worked with our vice Chancellor or Vice President of Student Affairs at the time and now our Vice Chancellor to install the first of the emergency polls that are on our campus that was back in 1993 and so now we have over 40 of those positioned all the way across campus to try to allow our students that they're involved in some type of assault or crime that they can hit that button automatically calls our police department on campus they can get there they know exactly where they are so it's a personal issue for me in terms of the importance of educating our students and on campus and off about the importance and understanding that devastating impact of sexual assault and it's something that we take very seriously on our campus and I think this will give us an opportunity to work together with our other campuses across the state and never hurts to sit down at the table and share ideas and figure out maybe that somebody's doing a better training program than others we take it serious in terms of prior to school of educating faculty and staff and students but there may be things more that we can do collectively better together to try to prevent these types of instances on our campus so I want to thank Representative Stern for
▶ Play
his bill thank you we'll let you know our coffee money is getting made over here we've got $50 already out of Bill Abernathy for letting his phone go off twice. Representative Sullivan, you recognize. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
I know all the universities want to work well together, but does this bill allow you to do anything you can't
▶ Play
Speaker 139 48:38
already do? There are some parts in it that... I think I would say it this way, Representative Sullivan. I think it puts the backing of the legislature behind it that may give us some thrust to go back to campus and say this is an issue considered by the legislature to be important. I'm going to take that as a no. It
▶ Play
doesn't give you the authority to do anything you can't already do.
▶ Play
Speaker 139 49:01
I think there are some things we can already do without the bill, but I think what it would help us with back on campus and across the state is recognizing the importance because so much of this is federal law. And Representative Letting had a lot of hearings during the interim. I don't want to belabor your question, Representative Sullivan, but I think the important thing is a recognition by this body about the importance that we do all that we can at our levels to try to prevent this would certainly help us on campus to say to students, look, legislature sees this as an important issue. Having that back in I think would help us. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 148 49:40
you, Mr. Chair. Any more questions? No more
▶ Play
questions, committee. Anybody want to speak against the bill? Mr. Chair, motion do pass. Motion do pass. Would you like to close for the bill? Are you closed? He's closed. Have a motion do pass as amended. All in favor say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, you have passed your bill. Representative Douglas, would you take the end of the table rule? quickly or as quickly as possible i believe you have some people you would like to have join you i think they know who they are they're welcome to come to the table 1945 house bill 1945 i'm sorry it's afternoon i'm running a little slow Representative McIlroy and I are already wanting our nap, and we
▶ Play
Speaker 95 50:50
haven't got there yet. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, this bill, what it's going to do is add consistency to the governor's agency selection process. What we have now is a situation where the Department of Higher Ed is the only cabinet-level agency that does not have the agency director appointed directly by the governor. It is the only one. The process has become a little bit cumbersome and confusing, both for Higher Ed Coordinating Board and for the governor's staff. this change has been embraced by all of the stakeholders including the governor's office of course would be on board the and also you need to know that the higher ed coordinating board members are all appointed by the governor and they are the ones that are in on the process as well so what we'd like to do is just clean up the process make all of the agency heads appointed by the governor, and this would add consistency to that process. We may want Shane Broadway to come to the table to explain why this was the only agency that was not selected by the governor. And there's a little history behind that that he understands that he's privy to. If he's willing to come. Yes.
▶ Play
Speaker 163 52:25
I don't know about Able. Willing, yes.
▶ Play
Speaker 139 52:29
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. Just a historical background as to why this is the way it is. I was here in 1997 as a first-term House member when I think this bill was, when the language was changed. It was a political situation, and I'll not use the names to, what do they say? Protect the innocent, yeah. Or the guilty. Or the guilty. But it was a political situation where you had a member of the General Assembly who was not happy with the Arkansas Department of Higher Education. I'm not even sure we called it that at that point in time. And was not happy with the director. I'm putting it mildly. There are a few people who probably were around here at that time. And so this language was inserted into a bill that totally changed, in a sense, gutted. the department uh most of its employees most of its power uh so it was a it was a political situation during a session where you had member disagreeing with a director and it just stayed there it just stuck i mean it's it's had never been changed uh ever since there were only a couple of times where we changed directors and then when i became uh director at higher ed it is a very cumbersome process and another reason it was put in was to try to prevent someone from being appointed to the position back at back at that time was putting in a series of steps that would try to prevent that a certain person from becoming director so it was more of a political situation we looked at it when I was director at 88 sheet I think it's the only state in the Union that has this requirement and so we I'd recommend in a list of things on my way out and I think that was one on the list was that this be looked at and considered to change because it should be I've always believed as a member of the Senate when I was doing confirmations believe that the governor should have the ability to appoint his or her cabinet members that are going to work directly for them, and that should be
▶ Play
Speaker 95 54:44
their authority. And I'd like for Dr. Markham to address this as well. You're
▶ Play
Speaker 170 54:51
recognized. Maria Markham, current director of the Department of Higher Education. And so this bill affects me not at all because I'm already in this position, but when I went through the process, it was very frustrating for me and for the coordinating board, those that were on the search committee, and for the governor's staff and for him as well. There were so many back and forth. Well, maybe they should interview you now, and maybe I should interview you. And so there were a lot of conversations back and forth. It was very confusing with our boards and commissions downstairs. They weren't sure what exactly they were supposed to do with me. So it was something that was pretty obvious to me, and I said, why is every appointment like this? And he said, no, this is the only one. I thought, well, why are we so special? We're a pretty small agency, and I work at his pleasure. He is really the only one who can hire or fire me. So it just made sense. And in speaking with the stakeholders in this, you know, I took it to both of the system, ASU and the U of A system offices. Does this sound like something that you could support? And they said, oh, absolutely. I mean, that's really the reality of the way the process works anyway, because at the end of the day, I do work for the governor. So I just hope that we can get this cleaned up so that the next person doesn't have to go through the little circus that we had when I moved into the office. Ready for questions?
▶ Play
Speaker 139 56:13
One thing I mentioned, too, it's still – they can still do a national search. They can still do all the things, Mr. Chairman, that are currently done. Nothing prohibits that. It's still – Governor, I'm sure, any governor is going to run it by the President's Council, which is the presidents and chancellors, and get there so they know ahead of time who the director is going to be. So I don't think anything is really going to change, although it will save some time and money because it was a process. You ready for questions now?
▶ Play
We're ready. Representative Walker, you're recognized. Thank you, Representative Douglas. My concern is that the current system allows for absolute subjectivity to govern the process, and it allows for persons who may have either no qualifications or only minimal qualifications to address the issues of the various agencies. And while we say that the governor should be able to have people around him, as a legislature, we have set forth in place all of these plans to enhance our educational system, our government and everything, and we set up qualifications for all the jobs. And it goes without saying, Shane, you and I have had this conversation. It goes without saying that the president of the University of Arkansas system should never have a bachelor's degree by himself. It doesn't matter who appoints him. And it goes without saying, I objected to Shane. He turned out to be pretty decent, but I don't know whether on an objective qualification basis, Shane, Markham, Key, or Rutherford over the Clinton School would meet objective criteria when we are talking about having standards that should be uniformly applied in the process. And then the other thing is this. Non-discrimination laws at least require an opportunity for all people to be given fair consideration for each position pursuant to predetermined written criteria. So if we're going to simply say that none of those things matter, then we ought to just simply say that none of those things matter for the director positions and they'll only apply to the persons who support the directors. If we're going to say that, then that's another issue. And perhaps I should just ask you, Representative Douglas, is that what you're saying?
▶ Play
Speaker 95 58:53
I would hate for you to put words in my mouth, but... But is that what you're saying? No, we're just addressing a cleanup and allowing the governor to appoint all the agencies in his cabinet at his discretion. We're not saying anything about lowering standards. We're not, you know, diminishing any of the, you know, the qualifications. This is just simply allowing him to be consistent in the way he appoints all the agency heads. I don't see that this will diminish the qualifications.
▶ Play
Can I address that as well, Representative? Follow up, Representative. I'm not trying to be personal, so I don't want you to follow up. But here's my concern. It would be possible for me to be appointed by the governor to head the medical school without an iota of training in medicine, unless we as a legislature gave guidance as to what we expected as we seek to improve and enhance education. The persons who may be in consideration for that position to be the qualifications they should have. Now, I'm not going to oppose it because the government is going to get it anyway. But my point is that if we're going to call ourselves a state trying to raise standards and to cause other people to follow rules, then we should practice what we preach. Go ahead.
▶ Play
Speaker 170 1:00:24
I would like to respond. The qualifications for the selection for the person that is in the director of higher ed have not changed, and those are in another section of the code. it is required that they have an earned doctorate and there are several in so much time at institutions of higher education so we're not striking that language this is only in reference to the process for the appointment I
▶ Play
Speaker 95 1:00:53
see no other questions I would ask for a favorable vote and I make a motion for a due
▶ Play
pass is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for or against seeing none she has a motion of due pass all in favor say aye any opposed no the ayes have it you have passed your bill at this time I believe represent Mayberry is up House Bill 1517
▶ Play
I'd like Shane Broadway to join us. I just thought that was. Don't give him that much credit. I thought that was part of the criteria for presenting a
▶ Play
bill here today. I'm just going to kind of speak to the audience and everyone today. We're going to run this bill, and we'll see how long this takes, and the committee can decide if they want to hear any more. We have plenty more to hear, but that will be a voice vote of the committee to say yes or no after this bill.
▶ Play
Thank you. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Our presentation on this is going to be short. This is a much smaller, less complex bill than what we talked about earlier today. It deals primarily with the evaluation of school nurses within the schools. Just kind of an update on where we are today. A school nurse performance evaluation is handled on a district-by-district level, as this would continue to be done under this bill, but does not necessarily include nursing performance criteria. And so what this would do is allow the Department of Education, working with the Department of Health, to develop a rubric to delineate consistent criteria that can be incorporated into each district's specific evaluation performance for the nurses. That's the gist of what this does. Now, it also establishes how that evaluation takes place. if there is a nursing supervisor, a school nurse supervisor in the district, that that nurse supervisor would handle that evaluation. It does not require that a district have that position. And if that's the case, and let's say that today a principal is handling that evaluation or a superintendent and there is not a school nurse supervisor, that would continue to be the case on a go-forward basis as well. If there is a, if the school decides to hire a school nurse supervisor, that person would be required to be an RN, similar to what we had spoken about earlier today. But, and then there are some additional things that you will see in the bill with regards to recommendations about what that position would entail or the criteria for that position.
▶ Play
But again, those are recommendations. y'all ready for questions any questions committee Wow that's good all right no questions committee anyone the audience like to speak against the bill
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:35
you know the drill thank you mr. chair richard abernath executive director of aaea and i believe mr merton mertens has been working with them and there's just one concern that we have with this particular piece of legislation and and that's we have some especially some of our larger school districts um already have a system of evaluating nurses that we're not so sure a statewide system would meet their particular needs. What we'd like to see is for a system to be developed with the people who they have recommended, but give that option to a district who may already have a very good system that's already working for them. And then, like I said, especially in northwest Arkansas, some in central Arkansas, we have school districts with 20-plus buildings out there, many nurses. If that system's working for them, why change it? And so that's the only concern that we have with this particular piece of legislation. Representative Walker
▶ Play
has a question. Thank you. This goes back to my concern about the last subject. If you're going to have nurses, they are presumably qualified. RN means they have already completed a course and been licensed and or certified, whichever is appropriate. And there are general standards that the profession has set. And one reason that apparently they are hired is because they're going to fulfill those standards. But we as a legislature have also already set standards that legislators, I mean, that nurses have to perform, have to fulfill with respect to their performance in schools. So why should we as legislators tamper with that anymore unless those standards are not working? that's a good question represent
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:28
walker so why is this bill necessary i will defer to the sponsor thank
▶ Play
you of the bill representative sullivan you're recognized kind of following that same line oh sorry yeah following that same line there's nothing in this bill that the schools can't already do
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:44
No, so this is trying to develop a statewide evaluation program.
▶ Play
But there's nothing they can't. If they wanted to implement this law now, the items in this, they could do that on their own. They had the authority within their school board to do this anyway. Yes. Thank you. Right. Any
▶ Play
Speaker 95 1:07:09
other questions from the committee? Anyone want to speak against? the bill? For the bill? Okay. If you will identify yourself, please. Turn your mic on. There we go. Deborah
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:07:35
Jones, Assistant Director, Arkansas State Board of Nursing. You're recognized thank you um and i again served on the advisory committee to the legislators regarding development of these criteria and not all nurses are evaluated exactly the same across and many times they're not evaluated on their nursing skills they're evaluated on whether or not the nurse the superintendents and the teachers like them or and feel like that they are doing their job, but they really don't know what nursing is. They don't know if the nurse is actually doing their job, and this would just give them a tool to help them with that evaluation and to help that nurse also to develop and grow. Yes, we set minimum standards, Representative Walker, for nurses who, as they graduate nursing programs, and they have to pass a minimum test to show they have minimum skills but school nursing is very specialized school nursing is not something that you are taught in nursing school it is recommended in our school nurse guidelines that nurses have five years of experience before they go into nursing because they need that nursing experience to carry over and to work without a lot of supervision. When you're in a hospital or a nursing home, you have other nurses around that you can confer with. You have doctors readily available that you can call and ask questions and get orders from. In a school system, You do not have that support group that you have in other settings. You are many times the only medical trained person in the school system, and nobody else knows what you should be doing or how to do it or if you are doing it right. They only know that something is wrong when there's a complaint. So this tool that would be developed along with the other agencies, the education department and with the health department, then it could be a useful tool for the superintendents, for the principals, for the teachers to know if their nurse is doing something correctly. It would also enhance, hopefully, the ability to have the right people in there doing the right job, both licensure and their scopes of practice, their continuing education, their development of their skills. Will you accept
▶ Play
Speaker 95 1:10:28
a question, please? Yes. Representative Walker, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Do you not have some consternation about having lay people evaluate the work performance of professional nurses? Yes. Or is it that you want to have criteria set out that would be applicable statewide subject to lay person implementation or
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:10:59
evaluation? Ideally, nurses evaluate other nurses in performing their nursing care because we're the ones that understand whether or not it's being done correctly or not. Ideally, you would have nurses, and this would allow the supervisor nurse to do all the evaluations on their nursing practice. It doesn't take away the superintendent or the principal's ability to supervise non-nursing functions within the school district it just says that nurses are going to evaluate nurses but those that don't have but one nurse would be have the tool that they that would assist them in doing that evaluation and having backup from the health department follow-up you
▶ Play
recognized isn't it true that the superintendents or other person designated for that purpose can perform the non-nursing evaluations already and you don't have to have a new level introduced. And that does not change one bit. My concern is that this seems to be a function for the Department of Education in terms of developing criteria and then having oversight since this is entwined with the educational process. Would you not agree to that i they
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:12:22
certainly are involved in it they are named as one of no no
▶ Play
no my question isn't that isn't that a more appropriate role for the department of education which can have which can assemble the professionals in order to deal with the health of our children in a professional way pursuant to objective criteria and i think that's what this bill does okay I'll take your word I don't see it but
▶ Play
Speaker 95 1:12:52
thank you any other questions committee all right thank you are you finished with your comments yes thank you ma'am anyone against would like to speak against the bill for the bill okay would you like to close representative Mayberry
▶ Play
yes thank you madam chair um to go to dr abernathy's um one issue that that he had with the bill um what this bill does is it develops a rubric of some criteria that would be incorporated into a specific district's performance evaluation it doesn't preclude the the district from having all their own criteria, their evaluation, just the way that it was. Let's say, for instance, if you had a specific district that, and I know that in some of these districts, the evaluation may be, do you show up on time? Do you wear appropriate attire? Are you courteous? Well, those are all good things, but don't necessarily address the nursing performance. In districts that do a good job of that. Let's say that in a district, I was told of one in northwest Arkansas, they've got a seven-page performance evaluation, and that the first page of it is that standard kind of information that I just spoke of, you know, the timeliness and things of that nature, and then the last six pages of it regards their nursing performance. If the rubric, once it's developed, and again, this is developed by Representative Walker, both the Department of Education and the Department of Health working together, so, and the Department of Health We'll be working, I'm sure, with the Board of Nursing and others to make sure that we've got the specific criteria and the right things to be judging upon. But let's say that rubric has 10 criteria, and in this specific school district, if their performance evaluation already has nine of those in there, then they're not going to have to adjust those nine. All that would be done would be adding one more element into that existing performance evaluation. And so that's what this is doing is it's just making sure and ensuring that our nurses across the state are not only being evaluated by whatever criteria that the local school board and the school district would want to do, but establishing also that they are meeting minimum nursing qualifications or criteria along the way. Yes, they've received the appropriate licensure, hopefully, but they're also, this is a yearly ongoing evaluation of how they're actually doing their job in providing the medical care for the children. With that, I would certainly appreciate a good vote. What's the
▶ Play
will of the committee? I have a motion to do pass. Representative Meeks. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No? No. I'm sorry. Your bill has failed. Thank you. Yes? Somebody asked something? I did say that we were going to try to get out of here. I had Representative Hammer that was supposed to have been here to run a real short one, and I don't see him. He gave her a short one. Yes, ma'am. Representative Speaks I would just
▶ Play
undo some of the small ones And get them on out of here So we don't Personally Representative Sturge, take the end of the table and run another one Tell me
▶ Play
which one you got I'd love to get as many out here as possible
▶ Play
Speaker 134 1:16:40
Are you hungry? McElroy, if you'll stay with me I promise I'll give you some
▶ Play
Speaker 225 1:16:50
chicken I have a motion House Bill 1804, sir 1804 Committee, this
▶ Play
Speaker 227 1:16:54
was brought to me by the Department
▶ Play
Speaker 134 1:17:01
of Higher Education It changes a date for a report on the financial assistance awarded by our institutions of higher ed As you well know, school usually doesn't begin until August the 18th but for some reason in the language we had them doing this report on August the 1st and so they're wanting to just push it to November the 1st when they report all the financial assistance they were given to us, and that's all the bill does. Do I have a
▶ Play
Speaker 117 1:17:28
motion? Do I have a motion? Y'all all want chicken, huh? All in favor,
▶ Play
say aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you passed your bill. You got another one like that? Pass bill 1806, sir. 1806?
▶ Play
Speaker 134 1:17:45
1806. And what does it entail? Mr. Chairman, this bill was also brought to me by a higher ed department. In code right now, we have a section that says we'll give free tuition to all World War I veterans. And if you know, we also have a bill that says anybody over 65 can go to school at a public institution for free. Considering that World War I veterans, the youngest is 118 years old, we thought we could repeal this section. Do I have a motion? I have a
▶ Play
motion. Representative Walker, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, you have passed your bill. I will defer now. I have Representative Hammer that's been waiting in the wings, so he is up next. House Bill 1567. Representative Gray, what bill do you have? 1957. We will hear you next, and then we're going to kill it. Oh, God. We have an amendment for Representative Hammer's bill, I believe. Is that correct? Yes, sir. Should have. All right. Do I have a motion? What is the amendment about? Give me a brief.
▶ Play
It gives you everything you asked for in committee the other day as far as removing Section 4, added Representative Douglas as the sponsor, and then it put a cap of 20 on the number of foster kids that could take advantage of this opportunity. Excuse me, I ran from the other end of the building. I saw it. Sucking air. And that's
▶ Play
a maximum of 20 scholarships? Yes, sir. That was kind of
▶ Play
a number that was just casually thrown out in the committee. All right.
▶ Play
Whenever somebody is ready to give me a motion, I have a motion from Ripson Meek to pass the amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. You may present your bill as amended. Could I get a
▶ Play
copy of the amendment, please? It's coming. You've got to
▶ Play
sign it, so it's coming. Thank you. I thought I'd sign it already. Sorry. this this bill you've already briefly explained the other day so basically everybody should know what it's about and you go ahead you're welcome to explain it again as short as possible
▶ Play
thank you mr. chair as i mentioned it removes the section four that gave i think some pause for individuals of the committee, and then it set a cap of 20 on the scholarships. And currently, my last check, there were 27 that had been used, so 20 could be a good number to get started with so that we can just kind of monitor this as it goes along and not let it turn into a runaway. But this would allow foster kids, and I did not put the IEP on it. it would allow foster kids that are in group homes the opportunity to attend a school that is accredited, that are covered under the rules and regs of the Succeed Scholarship. And that's pretty much it in a nutshell, Mr. Chair. Any questions, committee? Seeing have
▶ Play
one. Representative Lowry, you're recognized. Of course.
▶ Play
I'm sorry. Sorry, I just caught the tail end of your explanation of the amendment. I see there's a maximum of 20, but, Representative, did you also say that the foster children would have to
▶ Play
have an IEP? No, sir, they would not because they would not under this amendment. That's one reason I set the cap for 20. Okay. And if we needed to come back and revisit that next session. I could have brought in some really good testimonies, but for the sake of time, I felt that wasn't necessary at this point.
▶ Play
Okay, thank you. Thank you. Any other questions? Seeing none, anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill? I didn't see your hands. You're recognized. It's late in the day. We've got to make her work for it. I think she just wants to stay to five to her regular time to get off. Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee.
▶ Play
My name is Tracy Ann Nelson. I'm with the Arkansas Education Association. You've heard our concerns about this bill before. I'm not going to go through all of them again, but the whole foundation of the Succeed Scholarship Program was for students with IEPs. So to eliminate that now for anybody, any student who is in foster care without the IEP seems to me problematic and changes the whole foundation of the Succeed Scholarship Program. Proponents of the Succeed Scholarship Voucher Program say the parents will hold the schools accountable. However, children in foster care often do not have advocates, much less someone to enforce accountability. That's actually the job of our legislators and your role on this committee. It is the duty of lawmakers to act in the public interest to ensure that institutions accepting public funds are transparent and accountable. Unfortunately, expanding a program that is neither transparent nor accountable with public funds only further undermines the public's ability to know how their dollars are being spent and erodes the lawmaker's ability to ensure that a child is having his or her needs met. As a taxpayer and a child advocate, expanding a program that takes public funds, funnels them through a third-party organization backed by people acting on behalf of private entities that have no public face is the opposite of what we know to be good government. Shifting public resources to any entity without any oversight and allowing those organizations to spend them as they see fit is wrong. I would hope this committee would put a bigger lens on this program. Thank you. Any questions?
▶ Play
Seeing none, thank you. Anyone like to speak for the bill? Against
▶ Play
Speaker 241 1:24:29
the bill? I have another one to speak against. State your name and who you're with. Richard Hutchinson, Arkansas Public Policy Panel, Citizens First Congress. For the reasons that already have been enunciated, we believe that
▶ Play
Speaker 242 1:24:40
this bill would not be good public policy. Thank you.
▶ Play
Would you take a question? Sure. Representative Lauer, you are
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you very much. We have also seen efforts in vocational training and some higher ed bills to direct public funds to private colleges that are historically black colleges. Can we expect the same opposition from the Public Policy Foundation on those kinds of bills? No, I don't believe so. Okay. And why is that a different situation?
▶ Play
Speaker 241 1:25:18
Well, first of all, it deals with higher education and not with K-12 education. But I think that question would probably be better addressed to the organization itself, but I'm not aware that it would be testifying against that.
▶ Play
Okay. I'm just trying to understand the concern about public funds being directed to private entities. I'm wondering why that is not a universal position that your organization takes.
▶ Play
Speaker 241 1:25:49
I think we believe that there are important reasons that transferring public money to private schools is not good public policy. And by private schools, I'm talking about in the K-12 arena. I think that if you want to explore this a little further, there is quite a bit of research out there. In fact, there was some research just recently released by the Economic Policy Institute that shows that existing voucher, private school, K-12 voucher programs do not work and are not good public policy. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 117 1:26:39
you. Any other questions from the committee? to anybody all right
▶ Play
anybody like speak for the bill oh there's no more against right I'll have somebody against I'm sorry come on down
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:27:03
thank you mr. chair rich Debron at the executive director of AEA and with this amendment it does make it a problematic you know this this bill was passed a couple years ago a representative house to deal with specific needs of individuals with IEPs and this is certainly going to expand that to where an IEP is no longer required with this amendment and so we would we would be
▶ Play
opposed to this legislation any questions seeing none anybody like speak for the bill against the bill just
▶ Play
like close for you bill yes sir I'd like to remind the committee of a few key points if you would please the succeed scholarship was problematic from the beginning because those that are of the traditional mindset have opposed it all along the way so I'd like you to keep that in your mind when you make your decisions if you would number two we did set a cap of 20 on this you could consider a pilot program you could consider whatever you would like but if it aligns with what the definition of the program is which is succeed scholarship I guess I have to ask the question why wouldn't you want to give foster kids they're in group homes we're not talking about an expanded population we're talking about a very narrow population and granted they don't have IEPs not all of them do but that doesn't mean that their needs shouldn't be met in a way that is non-traditional to what the public school offers Now, I also want to remind the committee, if you would, please, that these children have to get the approval of DHS. So when you use the phrase lack of public faith, I think that's a pretty strong statement, considering all the safeguards that are in place, that these kids are going to have to receive the approval of DHS to be able to go and to take advantage of this type of situation. If there is a fear of a runaway situation, given the fact that only 27 of the 100 slots have been used, the balance can remain there or they could be put to good use in order to try something to see if perhaps for those kids that are in that adverse situation could have the opportunity to succeed and so with that i would just simply ask for a good vote thank you mr chair members of
▶ Play
the committee with that what's the will of the committee have a motion do pass for representative Sullivan as amended by Representative Sturge. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed no. No. Motion carries. Congratulations you passed your bill. Thank you Mr. Chairman. Ms. Gray would you like to take the end of the table for a very short bill. 1957 house bill and this is it. We are done.
▶ Play
you're recognized thank you mr. chair committee this bill um came to it came to be based on a constituent issue that i had so we have the academic challenge scholarship and what i what i encountered in my district was i had a a student who made it through three years of of college she got accepted into a professional into the pharmacy program so she did not actually graduate with her bachelor's, but based on the current language, she was not allowed to take that challenge scholarship with her for her fourth and final year. So essentially, we were punishing her for entering a professional program a year early. So I actually, I had this written up. It's fairly simple. I had it written up, and then I presented it to Senator Hickey, who does a lot with the challenge scholarships, and he liked the idea. And so what we did, we are allowing it to be carried through to that fourth year if you go to a professional program early and also what we what Senator Hickey wanted to add to the bill is we have some students who will in their fourth year in their final year of college they might just need six hours to graduate well currently you have to take the full 15 hours in order to be funded for your scholarship even if that's nine hours more than what you need to graduate. So what Senator Hickey wanted to do was add to this bill that you could take just the hours needed to graduate that final semester, and we would prorate the challenge scholarship. And so what we felt was that will offset some possible small additional cost for allowing the fourth year professional program. So that's essentially what the bill does. All right. Any questions on the
▶ Play
committee? Do I have a motion? I have motions from everybody. I have motions to do pass. There's nobody out there who wants to speak forward against this, I'm sure. Nope, no hands went up. All right. We have a do pass motion. All in favor say aye.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB423

0:20 - 1:14 5 segments 4 speakers

HB1612

1:14 - 50:30 150 segments 20 speakers

HB1945

50:30 - 1:03:25 34 segments 7 speakers

HB1517

1:03:25 - 1:16:48 42 segments 9 speakers

HB1804

1:16:48 - 1:17:33 5 segments 4 speakers

HB1806

1:17:33 - 1:18:18 4 segments 2 speakers

HB1567

1:18:18 - 1:29:49 36 segments 9 speakers

Hb1957

1:29:49 - 1:31:48 4 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bruce Cozart Chair Unverified
43 segments
Speaker 3
1 segment
Speaker 6
1 segment
Speaker 11
1 segment
Speaker 13
1 segment
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
19 segments
Chair Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 28
43 segments
Speaker 34
4 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Chair Unverified
7 segments
Representative John W. Walker Chair Unverified
24 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 66
1 segment
Representative Mark D. McElroy Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 79
4 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 95
17 segments
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 97
1 segment
Tracy Ann Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 134
8 segments
Speaker 139
13 segments
Representative Dan Sullivan Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 148
1 segment
Speaker 163
1 segment
Speaker 170
5 segments
Representative Andy Mayberry Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 205
10 segments
Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 225
1 segment
Speaker 227
1 segment
Speaker 117
2 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
9 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 241
4 segments
Speaker 242
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
4 segments