Aging, Children and Youth Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (35)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1568
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…you out of my life and so with that I think I will take up House Bill 1568 at this time because House Bill 1568 was actually the bill…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1037
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HR1037 Eubanks CONGRATULATING EMILY RICHEY AS A RECIPIENT OF A PRU…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1039
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…kay, and Representative Petty, you're recognized to present House Resolution 1039. Thank you,”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1047
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HR1047 Tosh SUPPORTING THE DESIGNATION OF THE BIBLE AS THE STATE B…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1297
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1297 Farrer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS MILITARY HERITAGE PROTECTION…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1381
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1381 Gazaway TO AMEND THE GROUNDS FOR DENYING PERMANENCY PLANS T…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1445
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1445 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD RELATIONSHIP PROTECTION A…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1475
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1475 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF G…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1654
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1654 Rushing CONCERNING THE RIGHTS OF GRANDPARENTS INVOLVED WITH…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1678
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1678 Beck CONCERNING VISITATION WITH AN INCAPACITATED PERSON OR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1773
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1773 Rushing TO AMEND GRANDPARENTS' RIGHTS IN CUSTODY AND VISITA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1783
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1783 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE VISITATION RIGHTS O…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1849
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1849 Baltz TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PLACEMENT OF A JUVENI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1906
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1906 C. Douglas TO SET A SPECIAL HUNTING AND FISHING LICENSE FEE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1912
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1912 Gates TO REQUIRE VIDEO AND AUDIO RECORDINGS OF IN-PERSON IN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1913
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1913 Gates TO REQUIRE CHILD MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATORS TO PROVID…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1914
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1914 Gates TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISCLOSURE OF INFORMA…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1915
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1915 Gates TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AND THE D…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1927
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1927 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE GROUNDS FOR THE TER…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1933
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1933 Fite TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE MEMBERSHIP AND POWERS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1972
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1972 D. Meeks TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CONFIDENTIALITY AN…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1973
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1973 D. Meeks TO PROVIDE FOR THE RESUMPTION OF SERVICES FOR PARE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1974
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1974 D. Meeks TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CHILDREN TAKEN INTO PR…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2006
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2006 Capp TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE INITIAL PERIOD FOR WHI…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2038
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2038 Fielding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CHILD SUPPORT ORDERED…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2039
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2039 Drown TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE REISSUANCE OF A PURPL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2089
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2089 Gates TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE TYPES OF REPORTS THAT…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2124
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2124 Leding TO ELIMINATE THE ASSET OR RESOURCE TEST FOR LONG-TER…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB2198
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2198 McGill TO CREATE A UNIFORM DATA COLLECTION SYSTEM TO LOCATE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1013
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1013 Sorvillo HONORING THE 308TH TITAN II STRATEGIC MISSILE WING…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1025
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1025 S. Meeks RECOGNIZING THE CHICKAMAUGA CHEROKEE PEOPLE'S UNIQ…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1038
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1038 Lowery RECOGNIZING AND HONORING THE EFFORTS OF LAURA RHEA W…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1046
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1046 Hammer RECOGNIZING THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF JUNIOR AUXIL…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB132
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB132 J. Hutchinson CREATING THE COMMISSION FOR PARENT COUNSEL; C…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB268
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB268 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING THE TERMINATION OF A GUARDIANSHIP.”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 13, 2026
Good morning. Chair sees a quorum, so we will go ahead and get started. We do have a special order of business today, which I expect will take most of the committee's time this morning. But before we get to our special order of business, we have three brief resolutions that we're going to run. Representative Eubanks, are you in the room? You're recognized to present House Resolution 1037. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you, Committee. I know you have the special order. I don't want to take a lot of your time. This is one of the more gratifying duties that we have at times when we're able to recognize young people in our district that have devoted themselves to their communities and to their peers. And a couple of weeks ago, I got a letter in my house mailbox upstairs, and it was from the Prudential Corporation. And I hadn't heard about this at home in my district, but they had awarded Emily Ritchie,
a student at the Parris High School, their Prudential Spirit of Community Award for the work that she's done in that community. She worked with FBLA and her group there. And they had fundraisers, and they developed a doll therapy for elderly that have dementia that's been shown to be very beneficial to them. And they were able to raise $13,000, and they made 150 special dolls that they gave out
to some of the elderly that have dementia. and she's been recognized in the community as the Youth of the Year at the annual chamber banquet but I wanted to take this time to recognize her with this resolution so I appreciate a good vote. Are there any
questions from committee members? Okay. What's the will of the committee? Representative Petty? Motion do pass. All in agreement say aye.
Aye. Opposed? no. Congratulations. The resolution passes. Representative Tosh, you are recognized to present House Resolution 1047. Thank you, Madam Chair. And committee members,
it's a great honor for me to be able to present this resolution. And I have to admit, I feel some in some way quite inadequate to present a resolution of this nature.
I know many of you at this table would probably be more worthy to sit here and predict this than I am, but this is simply a resolution that recognizes the Bible as being our state book, and we put this in the form of a resolution instead of trying to codify it at this time. But we touch on four points, and it's that the Bible is the book of truth, and I think many of us in here would agree with that. We know that we see attorneys in here and other people that sometimes when you take an oath, you see them place their hand on the Bible.
And I believe before any court proceedings, I think you hear time and time again that you solemnly swear that the testimony you're about to give is the truth and the whole truth and nothing but the truth, so help you God. So it is the book of truth. And even when we take elected officials, take their oath of office, They placed their hand on the Bible, and they take an oath to defend the Constitution. So we're recognizing the Bible as the book of truth. And also, I think all of us agree, we especially as a legislative body,
that we realize that the basis, the laws that we actually hear today and the laws that we pass and the laws that we live by are contained within the Bible forms. The Bible forms the basis upon which the modern civilization is structured, and I thought we would all be in agreement with that. We do have multiple designated state symbols in Arkansas, and when I checked on this, I realized that we didn't have a state book.
So I thought, what greater book would it be for us to recognize as a legislative body than the Bible? And also, as you know, the Bible is widely read throughout the state of Arkansas. It's probably the number one bestseller. It's probably had a greater influence on the lives of people of this state than any other book. And I would ask for a good vote on this
resolution. Are there any questions? Representative Walker?
Mr. Tysh, I must disagree with you.
Usually, resolutions are non-controversial, and they pass without discussion or debate. And while most people here will probably disagree with me for whatever reasons they may have, there has never been, I state these positions, there's never been such a thing as a state book. Whatever a state book is, no one knows.
The resolution, as you present it, is not without some great discussion. There are some of us who believe in the Bible, but who also believe that evolution, as it has been discussed and practiced, may be a way for explaining the origin of man. by adopting this as a state book we in effect we dispute science
and other person's opinions which are well substantiated and regarded too just as the Bible is Is there a question there Representative Walker? Well maybe this is appropriate for discussion Let's hold it for the discussion Let's have
questions right now Yes Representative Birch Thank
you, Madam Chair. Do you see this as laying groundwork for a political discussion then that would even
include the monuments being placed around the grounds, that that could create the basis for such a controversial argument by passing this, that we would be involved in something that would take away the value of the book to so many of us and place it in a concern that's political. Do you see that as a possibility if this is passed? I think I see that
as a possibility if we had put this in the form of a bill and tried to actually draft it into law,
but by doing it as a resolution, then it's not binding. It simply says that this is the book that
we recognize. You're recognized for follow-up. Thank
you, Madam Chair. even so i mean that to say that do you see that that almost takes away the value of our resolutions which i hold very um dear that when we do pass a resolution that it's a significant thing a statement to us do you see this as is creating a concern that if we voted against it
it would almost be saying that we don't believe in the Bible, that it places us potentially in a position where our faith is kind of in conflict with our concern that this could be used as a political tool. Do you see that possibility? I really don't. I think
what you see here is that each of us knows the role that the Bible has had in our own personal lives. I think we just have to recognize that this is a resolution that just signifies the importance that it's had for each and every one of us
and what it's had throughout the times handed down through our generations. And I've mentioned the four points that this resolution deals with, that it's the book of truth, it's the book that our laws are based on, it's the book that's widely read, and it's a symbol. And, you know, I think it's an individual decision that each one of us has to make, but to your argument there, I really don't see the merit there. Okay, seeing no
other questions, what is the will?
Would you like to close for your resolution, Representative Tosh? I'm closed, Madam Chair. All right, what is the will of the committee? I see motion due passed, Representative Wing. All in favor, say aye. Oh, I am sorry. Excuse me, let me back up one step. I did agree that we would have discussion on the motion. Excuse me for that oversight. Representative Walker, you're recognized for discussion.
I was addressing the almost knee-jerk response to politicizing the issue that the Bible has to be made a state ornament in order for it to be regarded by us as legislators than by the state. And when the premises are set forth, I don't want to disagree with Mr. Tosh, Representative Tosh,
but I think that the Bible is often used for whatever political point of view we have. It was used to justify slavery. It is still used by some of us here to justify oppression. It is, and we wear it on our shoulders, and we talk about the humanity we have toward each other and the consideration that we have for each other, and then we go and enact legislation that is absolutely contrary to it.
It says that we are our brother's keeper in the Beatitudes, and then we proceed not to be our brother's keepers we are hypocrites and this is a hypocritical resolution the point is that if we have our beliefs then we do and I certainly don't defer to you Mr. Tosh in terms of my religion but I don't have to go around and announce it I happen to be a Methodist been one since I was four years old but I grew up in the white Methodist church not knowing that it was a segregated church it's now called the United Methodist Church and you
We had the CME and the AME, and all of that was justified on the basis of the Bible. That is not something that I want to have embraced. I did not know at that time the differences. And as I learned, I found that it is usually those people who oppress, who want to really reinforce the Bible as a standard for our conduct and our behavior. And I do not believe, and I'll probably be the only one who will state this position publicly,
I do not want to have the Bible as our official book. And when it comes down, I'll talk on the floor, I'll talk against it too, and I'll have a much more passionate and logical presentation for this. But this, I mean, when you make us stand up every day and say we adhere to Jesus and to the Bible, And then we, a few minutes later, go and say that people are not entitled to health care, they are not entitled to jobs, and that capitalism has to be the preeminent Bible of our legislature.
That is just totally contrary to what you are presenting here. Those are my views, Madam Chair. Was there
any other discussion? Yes, Representative Wing. I think as
we recognize the importance of this as a resolution and not as a bill, but if we were to look at every home in the state of Arkansas, we would find more copies of the Bible than any other book. And that's all we're doing is recognizing its importance. It is true. We are all sinners. We all have made mistakes. We should not be condemned for that, but we should be praised for seeking something higher.
And what this Bible does, it gives us hope that we can become a better people. and we can become more like God and attribute those qualities that Representative Walker has sought for all of
us as well. Thank you. Any additional discussion? All right, Representative Wing, you had a motion? Do pass. All in favor, aye. Aye. Opposed, no. The resolution passes.
Okay, and Representative Petty, you're recognized to present House Resolution 1039. Thank you,
Madam Chair. Wow. I'm coming down here today to do something a little bit different here. This is to honor a great man named James Donald Neal Burnett.
He was born August 31, 1925, and he grew up living in Oklahoma, and he worked for the general store that was owned by his parents. So honoring him is a great honor for me. After high school, he continued working in his family store until he took an interest in serving in the United States Navy while visiting with his classmates who had joined. Mr. Burnett
was assigned to the USS Oak Hill LSD as a repair and cargo delivery ship that operated in the Pacific Theater. The ship featured a floodable stern that allowed landing craft and other vessels to be dry docked inside the ship and maintained and repaired. He served on the Oak Hill as a motor machinist mate, third class, through the American campaign, the Asiatic Pacific campaign, the Philippine liberation campaign, and during the height of his service, Mr. Burnett often witnessed dozens of kamikaze fighters
attacked against Allied forces during a typical day. And when I was visiting with him, I had asked him about the kamikaze fighters. And, you know, I've never been in war, and I don't know how it is to be in war. And I asked him, did you see one or two a day? And he told me, no, about 25 to 30. So they were bombing around that ship a lot. So, again, it's just a great honor to be here and putting forth a resolution for him.
So he continued to serve on the Oak Hill during post-war, drawn-down efforts until he received an honorable discharge in 1946. After the war, he married his hometown sweetheart, and something else he commented to me is in that period, she was 18 years old and she was allowed to marry, but he was 21, and he was not allowed to marry due to state law, So his mother had to oblige him to get married at the age of 21.
They are great, wonderful people. He was very humble when I told him that I wanted to put forth this resolution and honor him. He's an amazing, amazing man. They had two sons together. They live in the Alma, Arkansas area, and he happens to be my husband's grandfather, and so I visited with him just all the time, and he's the most prayerful, humble person ever.
And additionally, I would like to add they had two sons, Jim and Bob, and Jim in 2000 lost his life as a hero to our nation while fighting a wildfire in Cates Basin in Wyoming. And I'd also like to end that by saying that the heartbreak that that family suffered after him going to war and then losing his son, it's a great honor for them that his name is out here on the Arkansas Fallen Firefighters Memorial
behind the state capitol building. And also he is also on the National Fallen Firefighters Memorial in Emmitsburg, Maryland. So Mr. Burnett is 91 years old, wonderful person, very kind and loving, and I would ask for a due pass on this resolution to honor him. Sounds like an amazing
person, and thank you for doing this. Does anybody on the committee have any questions?
Seeing none, what is the will of the committee? Motion due pass. Any discussion on the motion? I'm sorry Ms. Petty did you want to Representative Petty did you want to close for your resolution first No I'm closed Alright we're going to go ahead and take a vote Since I don't see anybody that wants to Add to the discussion All those in favor say aye Any opposed Congratulations you've passed your resolution Thank you so much Chair Did you want to go ahead and dive into your bills Oh I'm sorry that's Representative Rushing that has bills
Alright we're going to go ahead now and proceed, and Representative Rushing, you're recognized to go ahead and present your special order of business. Just let us know what bill you want to present first. Okay, thank you. I think that
we can take them just in the order that they're presented. That's kind of the way I had them set up to start with anyway. Okay, you're recognized to present House
Bill 1568 then. Okay, sorry, first you've got to look at my grandchildren.
Just as a reminder of why we're here. And as everyone knows, there are certain days in our lives that are defining for each one of us, and today as I present these four bills, I hope that each of you can relate that there are times that define our lives. And I hope that the chair will grant me just a little leniency where I can open for all four of these bills at the same times, and then we'll take each bill of their own merits.
But instead of having to listen to my story four different times, I think it will just be easier to present the story at first. So if that would be okay with the chair, if I would do that. Yes, that is okay. Okay, thank you. May 17, 2016, 9 a.m. My life was normal, normal as anyone in this room. What I would call a perfect family. I have a son, a daughter, a son-in-law who is an officer in the Marine Corps, three beautiful grandchildren, and a family that was very supportive of one another.
We spent the holidays together, vacationed together, and spent many, many times for the birth of children, aunts, uncles, cousins, and we all spent a lot of time together. 3 o'clock p.m. that same day, my life would never be the same. I received a phone call from my son-in-law that my daughter had been found dead on her couch at their home in North Carolina while she was home taking care of my grandchildren. We had just started a special session down here.
I think it was on transportation. I really honestly don't remember. That was the least of my concerns. So I was here at the Capitol. I immediately jumped on an airplane and flew out to North Carolina, and we arrived at 3 a.m. the next morning. We arrived to sleeping babies, and our lives turned upside down. May 28th, that was another defining moment in my life. That was the last day I was able to see my grandbabies.
We had, in the process of flying to North Carolina and preparing for my daughter's body to be brought back to Arkansas for burial, and burying her on May the 24th, on May the 28th, my son-in-law left with my three grandchildren and we all left on good terms. He stayed at our house the whole entire time. We had no bad words. There was no ill feelings. There was nothing that ever made us think that I'd be sitting at the end of this table
advocating that I had not seen my grandchildren or would not be allowed to see my grandchildren. I was at the birth of every one of my grandchildren. When my son-in-law was deployed in the Marine Corps, my daughter and her children lived with me, sometimes as much as up to six months. We gave them financial support. We spent holidays together. We laughed, we played, we cried. We went through weddings, we went through funerals, we went through the loss of my father.
All of it we did together as a family. The following Monday after my son-in-law left my house from the funeral of my daughter, he met someone. And at
he was engaged, we did spend a few times talking and we had some conversation, we had some FaceTime texting
and talking with the children. Then on July the 17th, just out of the blue, I received an email that reads, Cliff and Laurie Rushing, until further notice, you are not welcome at my residence at 311 Drake Landing, New Bern, North Carolina. If you do enter my premises, it will be considered a matter of trespassing. For all inquiries on this matter, please contact the Craven County Sheriff's Department, Thomas J. Watts, 1st Lieutenant, United States Marine Corps, 311 Drake Landing, New Bern, North Carolina.
I reached out to my son-in-law at that time asking him what the problem was. What had we done? Had we done something that made him upset? And please remember the day before we had just been on the phone. We had been laughing. We had been sending pictures back and forth on the 4th of July. I have video. I have Facebook messages I have FaceTime we had all been having a good time everybody was one big happy family the only answer I got from him is he said
because I can he said I don't want you to see my family because I can I'm starting a new life and I want you out of my life and so with that I think I will take up House Bill 1568 at this time because House Bill 1568 was actually the bill that I personally started working on after this situation. House Bill 1568, I think, I believe has an amendment on it. Is it engrossed, or is this the one that we need?
Yes, Representative Brushing, that's engrossed into the bill. Okay, I know there's a couple that hasn't been engrossed. Are
you not finding it? I've got my other copies, so I was just making sure. All right, thank you. 1568 Arkansas from what I can say has very very good grandparents rights I mean in comparison to what other states have when I sit here and testify today I just want you to remember that that I'm doing this for other people in the state of Arkansas for your constituents and my constituents because I'm not facing the courts here in Arkansas I'm facing the
courts in north carolina who has terrible grandparents laws but arkansas what i can say has a very good start and just needs a few little tweaks and i think that that's what we're getting out of this proposals that i'll give to you but 1568 removes um the section of death of a child and puts in it its own section and basically it may it says that a that a grandparent can file for grandparent's rights,
and it gives several different reasons, emotional abuse, emotional neglect, and because of there was a recent case in Virginia that came down that was filed on behalf of the children that actually the judge ruled in favor that it was an emotional neglect to the children, that their parents were having emotional neglect by not allowing them to see the grandparents to whom they'd had an established relationship.
We tried to take very good precautions in this bill. What we did do is, which is a little bit different than the rest of the bill and different than a bill that you'll see later on, is in this portion of the bill we make the responsibility on the grandparent. the grandparent is the petitioner and has to have they have to do the proof of burden that they are fit and that they did have an established relationship and that this is neglect to the child and that that you're not just petitioning because you want to be mean to someone or
something but because you do love the children and you can prove that you have provided them with love and support that they've had throughout the the course of their their lives And so, at
this time, I'll take any questions. Are there questions by the committee?
mic's off. I empathize with your circumstances and wish that you had not experienced those tragic events and the tragic unation from your grandchildren. But I'm concerned about us as a legislature and whether or not we can, for all of our slights or misadventures or adversities,
we can come up with legislation or should come up with legislation to address it. I start off with the premise, and maybe you can help me with this. Do you think that we could legislatively impose what are essentially parental obligations upon grandparents? I
think that we already have a Grandparents Rights Bill in Arkansas, and we have them across the United States. And I believe that if we're in protecting of children and we're protecting them from emotional neglect
and emotional abuse that is being done by their parents in regards to not allowing them to have someone in their life that has been in their life, that has been a substantial part of their life, that, yes, I believe that we can legislate this type of legislation. Now, we do have to be, I will agree with you that we do have to be very careful as to make sure that the parental rights are not destroyed and that everyone is in agreeance and that a judge can make reasonable visitation,
and I think we have defined reasonable visitation, which was very hard for me in this bill to make reasonable visitation because that was one thing that a court had said is what is reasonable. And so in this legislation we had to define reasonable, and we defined it as a period that is no less than one week during a year and no more than four weeks during a year. The reason that the time frame is so short on four weeks because I've been criticized because of that four-week period is because we have to take into consideration those parents that are divorced and that they only get to spend a week at a time or every other weekend, and we cannot take that right away from the parent as well.
We just need to have a good balance between the parents and the grandparents and being able to see the children that's healthy for the children and to make sure that they are in a stable environment and knowing that they are loved by all parties. Follow-up. Excuse
me, you're recognized for a brief follow-up. Madam
Chair, I don't think she answered my question, so I'd like for this to be my question just to restate it. And I wrote it so that it won't be rambling.
Can we legislatively impose parental obligations upon grandparents? Now, parental obligations are housing, medical care, food, just basic responsibility for the upbringing of the child. I do not think you're speaking to this particular bill. I think maybe
that there will be a bill later in the session. I'm not speaking to the bill.
I'm asking the question, and it goes to this. Obviously, it's a follow-up, which would be, can we require, is it a right of a child to be able to require that a grandparent participate in that child's life? We are not
requiring the grandparent has to petition the court to ask for
that right. But I can discuss it later, but here's my concern.
If we can force our way into the lives of a child without having any obligation for that child, then it would seem, don't you think, that the child would be able to impose upon us some liability for the child's upbringing and its financial responsibility and things like that? I think if you will proceed and read the bill,
that it does say in here, in this particular bill, that the grandparent would be responsible for the financial obligation of the child while they were under their care.
Well, my concern is that I have 17 grandchildren, eight great-grandchildren, and it's impossible for me to just be financially responsible, or even emotionally responsible for all of them. So the question is, what is it? Representative
Walker, we have others in the queue. I apologize, Madam Chair. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Madam Chair. I just want to make sure that we're clear on this. On page two, it says this section does not apply to dependency neglect proceedings. So I just wanted to be absolutely clear that this does not affect those kids who are adopted through the state. Is that correct?
Correct. This bill particularly here does not affect those children that have been adopted through the state. And I have had DHS look over it for me and to kind of help verify and vet these bills to make sure that they do not interfere with any
of their obligations as well. Second question.
Yes, you recognize for follow-up. And the second question that I have is that you have some instances where you have grandparents that, I'm trying to be nice how I say this, but you have grandparents that.
Mean ones. Okay, that's a good thing. You have mean grandparents, and so you may have a situation where one of the parents does not want to have any communication at all with grandparents. the spouse may say well they're my grandparents and I know that they're just you know mean and whatever the case may be and one you know the one that one spouse dies what do you do in a situation like that is that going to again be up to the court to do that because there was a
relationship but again that other spouse may say I don't like the way they're telling me to raise my kids I don't you know they're causing issues or whatever the case may be so how does the court or how does
this law affect that type of situation? And I think that's a very good question because that is exactly what this law would affect. And it would be the burden of proof goes back to the grandparent to prove that they had a relationship and a loving relationship and one that they are not forcing their will on.
That does not get the parent, the remaining parent of the deceased, still will be in court to testify on anything that they have going on. And if, and I did add this to this bill, if for any reason the court may require the petitioner to pay the attorney fees of the other party if the court determines that this case is without merit. And so I was hoping that that would help cover some of that situation where a grandparent just wouldn't come in and file a case.
Did that answer your question? Not really. Representative Kavanaugh. Thank
you, Madam Chair. Representative Rushing, you had spoken about that this bill addressed that financial support of the child. I can't find it in this bill. Where is it at? Let's see here if I can find it exactly.
Well, it's supposed to be in here, so it may be in one of the other ones that we have that's where the financial support may come into play, so I apologize for that
if I misspoke on that particular portion. Representative Birch. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Birch, there's not anybody in here that doesn't find this incredibly compelling story to be personal to us potentially, so we'll just start with that. i i'm glad that we had the the point where we can kind of look at consider these all together
but frankly i think they to me run together that they're i'm confused with different parts but i want to start with my question on page two because it's the the burden of proof that bothers me about this particular bill because it is so incredibly low it's so on on line 25 to prove it's the preponderance standards petitioner has the capacity to
give the child love affection emotional support and guidance but there's not much to that they just say I can do
that yes and previously in the current law that we have now it just says that the petitioner has the capacity to give love to the child we have added the additional proof and and again
just being all they do is put them on the witness stand they say I can
do this it actually it actually strengthens what we already have in place now it goes on the
the burden is to show likely it's going to be likely to harm or emotionally distress the child if this doesn't happen what would you this is a Several-part question. What do you see as the evidence with regard to that particular part of the proof? What do I see as the evidence on how it would harm a child? No, as to what somebody would put on as evidence to show one or the other. I just think this is a, I apologize, let me get back to, I think this is a very low standard of proof.
There's not a lot that a grandparent would have to do to come in and to show this, and a parent would be potentially frustrated because it's such a low standard of proof for a grandparent to come in. That doesn't mean I don't think grandparents should have the right. It's just this standard of proof is really, really low and could allow for abuse by a petitioner, in my opinion. As followed with the question,
have you talked to any attorney with regard to the possible problem
with regard to this burden of proof? All of these bills have been vetted through my circuit judge and attorney, and he was the one that even helped write some of the language and suggested. Also, I have spoken to House Attorney Counsel and also helped with some of the language. Representative Gates. Thank
you, Madam Chair. Many of us were going through with you at that time,
and I've knew your daughter for many years and we did how when you were going through this situation how did he treat the others his parents the other set of grandparents
the other set of grandparents have been he has removed them from their life his life as well all every all of the family all of the family in Arkansas and any any family other than his new wife and their family have been terminated at all he has denied rights to all of us so for clarity it wasn't just the
in-laws no it was his own parents it was his own parents correct okay um you're recognized for thank you sorry about that uh the burden of proof goes back to not just saying this is my kid there's the blood, but being able to say that the removal of this child out of the grandparents out of this child's life could be so emotional devastating to that child that it's not some
distant grandparent who had no emotional attachments but was deep-rooted in those children. Being able to prove that is still the burden of the grandparents. That is correct.
In this bill, that is correct. that is still the burden of the grandparent, that they have to show that
they have an established relationship. Thank you. Representative Walker. Thank you. In terms of the burden of proof, how does this apply in a situation where DHS has custody of children
and DHS has decided not to allow any parent who may still be alive or grandparent to have any association with the foster parent. This bill does not address that situation.
There is another bill that addresses the situation that is in this package that addresses the foster care and the EHS's position on placing
and allowing grandparents to see the grandchildren that are in their care. This deals strictly with the child still being in care of the remaining parent. Thank you. Representative Kavanaugh. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative
Rushing, do you see that this could be a possible problem for the child to be placed in the middle between the parent and the grandparent when they're having to be used as the witness or help support the reason why that the grandparents
need to see the children? I do not feel like that the grandchildren, if are you trying to say if are we using them as pawns, I don't think that's the intent of any grandparent that would be sitting down at the end of this table that would be here to testify today or anyone that we do not none of us want to have to put our grandchildren through that situation we want to try I personally have tried on every merit to do a mediation through attorneys through judges and and at
well not through judges excuse me just through attorneys and to do a mediation and offer up some written contracts and still getting no response and so I do understand that it could be a burden on the children at some point in time where they may have to testify for it for a judge which we would hate to see that happen but we would also hope that between the judge and the parents that that could be kept out of it and maybe the judge would meet behind closed doors one-on-one is what
you see a lot of the times with the children
so represent your flowers I'd first like to say that how, I don't want to say moved, but, well, how moved I was at the service that we attended for your daughter. And while I never met her, I got an opportunity to see what she meant.
And since then, we've had conversations about these circumstances, and I say that to say that I think when applied to circumstances like these, this makes sense. My only concern is that how it would apply to circumstances not like these, where you would have a mean, and I don't even want to say mean, There are so many situations that all of us at this table hear from constituents where we can't even fathom.
I couldn't fathom this had you not told me and had I not attended your daughter's service, right? And so I'm thinking about sort of when the script is flipped, for lack of a better term, how we can make sure that if we promote something like this through legislation to provide protections for grandparents in these sorts of circumstances that we couldn't imagine, how do we make sure that this doesn't assist someone who is unlike you
but in a position to use this against parents who might want to protect their children from whatever? And that said, I'm wondering what the role was of DHS, because I heard you mention that they helped you with some language, as it relates to that burden of proof issue, if they had any feedback for that, or if someone's here to talk about what the perspective of DHS is
and how this would be implemented. Well, I think that on this particular bill, I think probably more the one that you would want to hear from, DHS, would be the one coming up. They had a lot more input on that one than this one. This one was sent to them to look at as well. They came back with no
corrections on that. And I'm sorry, for this one, you mentioned your judge. Yes, our circuit judge. Your circuit judge. And he is
the one that had – he's the one that actually put in there a reasonable amount of time.
He said we need to define reasonable because that's what's hard on judges to define what reasonable is. They hear these cases. Like I said, we do have these laws in place anyway that are – and this actually makes them a little bit tougher for grandparents, for lack of a better term, the mean grandparents that we're all talking about. So I think you'll find that most of the grandparents are not what you're going to find as mean. You'll find that a lot of the parents are, for whatever reason, wanting to distance theirself, in my case,
because of new family, separate, move on with my life, and get rid of everybody else that was part of my life. I think you'll find that that's a lot of the thing that has happened. You'll find that a lot of these grandparents have helped out financially. They've let the children live in their homes. They have been very, very supportive, and that these grandchildren still want to see these grandparents and still ask about these grandparents and are told they cannot. And there are some federal laws in place for parent rights,
which I think will be some good protection for parents as well to protect from the mean grandparents. and so hopefully just being able to get all of this in a state where we can agree and again like I said Arkansas is in my opinion one of the best of all of them that I've read what we have in place yet it still has its flaws and its loopholes to allow for those mean grandparents to come in as well and so I think by putting the burden of proof
of coming back and saying showing situations of like you said you attended my daughter's funeral and you saw the bond between me and the children and and and and the type of relationship that my entire family had with the children and um I think that this will strengthen those by putting the burden of proof back onto the grandparent to come back and say this is uh as a matter of fact BLR suggested that I that I they said why don't you want to make the burden of proof make a make the parent prove that
you're unfit and I said because I feel like that it's uh it's a burden of proof to feel that I that I am fit and that I am here for the right reasons and so that is hopefully that helps answer
your question and representative oh I'm sorry did you have a follow-up just yeah and and I do know that initially I asked about DHS on the other bill, but for this one I guess I was, in listening to the attorneys on this committee
and the concern about the burden of proof, I guess I would ask, I know you talked to a judge, had you talked to any attorneys, who really would be in the position of representing parents and grandparents in
this situation? Well, this judge that I talked to, that's what he does. I mean, he's a family judge, and so this is what he deals with every day. And he told me, he said, this is what we need. We need some definition to go by on how we need to rule and how we need more clarification than what we have.
And so this was run by him. And that's Surrogate Judge Chris Williams out of Hot Spring County. Representative Rushing, I
had a question. Sure. If I understood you correctly, this bill would not help you. You are doing this for other grandparents, is that correct?
That is correct. None of the bills that I'm running today would help me personally. All of my situation would go directly to North Carolina, who, by the way, has some of the worst grandparent bill rights. And so I would say that Arkansas is above the cutting edge,
and we should be applauded for that on its own. Thank you. Representative Kavanaugh.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Rushing, my concern is about the mean grandparents because as a family member has had to experience a mean grandparent after the death of their husband, and everything that that grandparent took them through was not a pretty thing. And so for me, although most of us sitting at the end of that table
would be the ones that want to see their grandchildren and do the right thing. There are more of those mean grandparents than you can, that you probably believe. And I think maybe one of the determinants in this particular case that may have kept them from wanting to go through the petition process was if they were required when the judge said, no, you can't see it, that you pay it. You have it listed as may be required. How come you didn't use shall be required? because that's going to make them have to cover the attorney fees that the parent had to put out to show that they were not fit.
I had BLR draft this up. I did not catch it. It said may instead of shall, so that was just an oversight. Representative Birch.
bit confused because I've got 9-13-103, which is the current law, in front of me. And there's a lot of the exact same language in it. Same burden. I'm like, exactly.
I'm looking at on page 1, line 27, you've struck out death, but death is already included. I'm collectively having a real hard time figuring it out. all the parts of the four collectively and what's already in law. I have struck
out death to put the burden of proof back onto the parent, the grandparent of the deceased.
The rest of the bill, if you'll read section 913-103, if you read that, the burden of proof to prove that they are unfit goes back to the parent of the child by removing death we have made it its own section and that burden of proof has been put onto the grandparent in order to make the grandparent the burden of proof fall on the grandparent that they can provide the the support and the emotional
okay committee I see we have several more questions I'm not sure what hand was up first you had a follow-up with Representative Birch and
I'm even more confused and I get easily confused and you've been looking at this a lot longer than I have, a lot longer but I'm looking in the law already it's already the burden on the petitioner and it's the exact same language to establish that visitation with the petitioner
is in the best interest of the child the petitioner must prove by preponderance of the evidence the following, the petitioner has the capacity to give the child love, affection and guidance Now, I mean, this is the exact same language that's already in it, and the petitioner has the burden, which I thought was what you just said. The loss of the relationship between the petitioner and the child is likely to harm the child. Now, there's a little bit additional language or that the loss of the relationship would result in emotional abuse or emotional neglect to the child is in your proposed bill. But then the last sentence, again, this is already in law,
the petitioner is willing to cooperate with the custodian if visitation with the child is allowed. but this is not being struck but this is the same language in the law I'm just again easily confused but as a lawyer the collective parts of this and seeing if we pass one out but not parts of the other and one thing death is struck and another proposed part it's not can we just get to specifically
what's not in the law already that you would like to change because you say that Arkansas
already has good grandparents' rights. Okay. Emotional abuse is not on emotional neglect, is not in reasonable visitation, is not in the current law. It is not I'm trying to, I wish I had the other
total the law as it was written in front of me right now, but I do know that the emotional abuse, the emotional neglect, and the reasonable visitation are, have not, are not part of our law right now and the one thing that really really is a stickler for most of the judges across the state is the
reasonable visitation so if there was you're recognized for your follow-up thank
you madam chair so if there was a the definitions and then we get the the alienation and the reasonable
visitation if those definitions were incorporated into the current law yes would that be substantially would that substantially tighten the law so that we could get rid of all the three different separate proposals and put that
into what's already law? Well, I think what you're going to see in one of the big bills is 1780, I think it's 1783, 1773 maybe is the, it has
most all of them in it so why don't we just go to it and look at passing it
and not the various parts that conflict and well you will see that all of those are incorporated into that most of them with it with the exception of I think 1780 1783 is not incorporated into 1773 and representative
Birch we need to consider each one on its own merits. All right, I have Representative Kavanaugh. She stepped out of the room. Were there any
other questions from the committee? We have two people signed up to speak for 1568. First, I will recognize Lorna Nobles. Please introduce yourself to the committee. And you are recognized.
My name is Lorna Nobles, and I am Laurie Roshan's mother and grandmother, Tara Roshan,
Speaker 140
55:26
and great-grandmother of these three children.
I prepared no speech today. I thought I could talk very easily about this. But after the
last 30 minutes listening to you as the legal part of this bill and the legal part of what we are going through, it makes me really sad that there could be so much legal stuff involved in such an emotional state for me and for my family. I think any bill or any grandparents' rights or any bill that actually has this much debate
and this much difference in opinions from just a small group of this, I don't think you're ever going to make anybody real happy with any bill or any part of this. I'm only looking at the emotional part for myself and my family and what has happened to us. I sort of had, like I said, I didn't have a speech written, but I did have some notes, and I'm just going to throw those away because I can see that the legal part of this, that y'all are going to have a real hard time getting this put together because there are so many different opinions.
And the emotional part that we're going through, we're not the mean grandparents. We're not the parents that actually are mean. We just want to see their children. And I thought I could come in here this morning without the legal system being so hard on what I thought was a simple grandparent's right, that at some point in time this was a baby step into maybe a larger step from here to North Carolina, that we could see these children before they're grown and before they're old enough to make their own decisions.
This is really hard for me to sit here and listen to the legal side of it because I'm only the emotional side of it. We've been denied. My granddaughter died under very suspicious circumstances, and all of a sudden he sends me an email and said, please don't contact me again. My children have a new mother. They have a new person they called Mommy. We don't need any Arkansas family. And so I'm only here on the emotional side. I can't give you any information on the legal stuff. And after listening to Lori and listening to each one of your concerns,
I understand even all the concerns that you have. But I think it's like any other law. You can almost pick it apart until it makes no sense for nobody. You know, I believe what I do know and what I've listened to in the last half an hour is that if you could get this in the systems and one-on-one us talk to judges or attorneys or whatever we had to do that maybe each individual case could be heard. But you're hearing, at this point in time, analyzing it to the legal part of it, and I don't understand the legal part of it.
So I'm going to throw this away and just say I really wish you would think of the emotional side of people like us, people like us that have had a family taken away and torn away from us, to the circumstances that we can't even control. and then now we have a legislative body that we have to go through not only in Arkansas but in North Carolina. I believe these children, these grandchildren, great-grandchildren of mine, will probably never see them until they get to be adults, until they can make their own decisions
because I think groups of legislators like you in North Carolina are going to pick these bills apart little by little for that it makes sense for nobody. So I appreciate you listening to me, And hopefully if you decide to work with this new bill or one of these three bills, that it will make it a little bit step easier for all of us to be able to see our children. I know that some of you have children and grandchildren. And if you just woke up tomorrow morning and you realized that you could never see your grandchildren again
and you knew you had a good, healthy, loving relationship with them and you had to go through the legal system in order to do it, you would probably be in the same point we are here like how has this happened to a normal a normal family a loving family that's grew up my granddaughter grew up in a loving wonderful relationship these grandchildren call their laurie their nana and their poppy and and now all of a sudden we have to go through a complete brand new legal step in order to even get any type of
visitations. So thank you for listening. Thank you
so much. Were there any questions for this citizen? All right, thank you. Oh, Representative Flowers.
I just want to commend you for coming here and speaking before us and just know that your testimony is not falling on deaf ears and that I speak for myself, but I'm sure my colleagues also are not trying to pick it apart, but to make sure that it's something that can be strong and work for
all the citizens we represent. So I just want to tell you that and thank you for coming. Thank
you. Appreciate it. Thank you. Representative Birch. Thank you, Madam
Chair. She has left the chair. We also have signed up to speak. Is there anyone in the audience who wishes to speak against the bill? We have signed up to speak for the bill. Bethel Sanders and please introduce yourself to the committee
Bethel Sanders and you're recognized I'm a little bit like Lorna I'm not a public speaker but I have a bit of a background for eight years I worked alongside my husband who's an attorney and did a lot of domestic law and it was really sad time after time when grandparents would come in and they had lost their child and the other parent decided because they could
that that parent the other grandparent was no longer valuable in their children's life and it's one thing I would like everyone in here to think about is that most of us grew up with grandparents in our life, even if it was just one set of grandparents, and we had the privilege of experiencing a really loving and nurturing relationship, which is really important for children to develop into healthy, successful adults, and the realization
that one parent, because they can, could cheat a child out of love and nurturing relationship from a grandparent, it seems should be addressed. And the fact that I've heard here people quote mean grandparents, just because a parent and an in-law have a mean relationship does not even mean that a mean grandparent can't be a wonderful asset
and nurturing and loving to a grandchild. That relationship is completely different than the relationship with in-laws. And I believe when two people get together and decide to marry, not marry, conceive a child together, they've accepted that family into their child's life. And just because the absence of one parent happens and the other one can, you know, eliminate another family, it seems very abusive to the child who really needs all the love.
It takes a village. A child needs all the love coming from everyone, and I don't think that the parent of the grandparents' relationship should be the exciting factor of whether the grandparents love and nurture the children or not. And like I said, I had notes just like Lorna, but in listening, I hear that it seems like to just a lay person like us that we're so worried about the clog up in the court system and the decision,
but I've heard judges rule over and over and over on confusing things that end up being in the court because people don't clearly understand that just because you can do something, that it's not good for every party involved. So I guess I would just like to see if it was written in the bill that the parents, I mean, the grandparents did have a right
to access the grandchildren because of the children's rights to love and to be loved and nurtured by people that love and nurture them that it would deter a lot of parents in the absence of the other parent from even going through the legal system. But when they read the law and they come to an attorney and the attorney says, yeah, you're right, there's nothing in there. There's nothing in there that protects those grandchildren. You can do whatever you want, cut them out. Because the law doesn't protect the children.
If the law was written appropriately, I don't see the court systems being clogged up with it because it's already been addressed so the lawyer would advise them don't bother that's what the law says you need to offer it and you know you know bypass a lot of the dispute anyway that's all I have to say thank you are there questions from the committee thank you
Representative Brushing, would you like to close for
your bill? Yes, thank you, Madam Chair. I would just hope that each of you would take this on its own merits. I know that there's been some great questions that have come out of the committee today, and I appreciate every one of your comments. I know that there's things, and there's still a lot of work to be done on this situation. There's a lot of work to be done on this situation across the whole United States, not just in Arkansas. And I hope that Arkansas can be a starting point that we can gain some latitude where grandparents, the good grandparents and keep the mean grandparents out.
I do want to respectfully disagree with the fact that we think that there's a lot of more mean grandparents out there than there are. I think that that comment was made that there's a lot more out there. I think there's probably a lot more of the good grandparents that are being denied the rights rather than the mean grandparents that are not, that are being denied the rights. And I think a judge can see that. And I think with this bill that we have that opportunity to, especially in this particular case,
in the death of a child, make this right in moving forward. And with that, I would appreciate
a good vote. Representative Gates, you're recognized for your motion. Motion do pass. Is there any discussion of the motion? All in favor say aye. Opposed, no. The ayes have it. The bill has passed. Thank you committee.
And members, with your indulgence, I'm not feeling well. I'm going to turn the chair over to representative mix the little dental surgery i had yesterday seems to be catching up with me thank
you madam chair and praying for you to get better so you can be with us either this afternoon or
signature. All right. Representative Rushing, you are
you're recognized to present House Bill 1654. Okay.
House Bill 1654 was actually brought to me when Representative Wardlaw realized that Senator Sobelfield and myself were working on some grandparents' rights bills and so Representative Ward Law wanted this to be included in the package and I told him that I would carry this for him. It does have to do with foster care and the adoption cases and so this is one that I really did send to DHS
to really study really hard to make sure that we're not in conflict with anything that they do. Basically it's saying that grandparents... Hold on, I'm sorry, I apologize. I
think this one has an amendment on it. Which one? 1654. I think we have to deal with the amendment first. I apologize. I didn't see it until just now. I
think it just adds Senator. Yes, this amendment just adds Senator Irving as the Senate sponsor. Okay. Did
anybody have any questions on the amendment? All right. Seeing none, motion do pass.
Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor of the amendment? Aye. Any opposed? Okay. Your amendment
is passed. Okay. I'm sorry. Go ahead. Basically, as I was saying, this just says that a child that will be put into foster care, grandparents and great-grandparents would have a preference over an additional foster home. This would help, along with our foster care system, with the shortage of foster care parents
that we have at the time. it also says that the grandparent would have to go through the same process as any other foster parent so it's not saying that we're going to give special privileges if that grandparent is unfit it's saying that if they're fit and they're found to go through the same process that they're going to be allowed to have first preferential treatment on that child
being placed with them Okay, Representative Birch, you recognize your question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Rushing, would you agree with me that this is already the law and this only brings 927.355 and 928.108 in line with what is the law, 99.102, that in fact DHS is already required to do exactly
this. We have added language to make this stronger, and that was part of DHS's services to me on this bill, and that was actually one of their comments to me that I really appreciated
that said that not only that we already did this, but it made it an even stronger bill to make it so the grandparents and that the relative would have the first
potential right. Okay, anybody else have any questions on this bill? Representative Blake,
you're recognized. Just for clarification, thank you, Mr. Chair, just for clarification, Representative Breshing. Yes. Is a grandparent not considered a relative
right now? A grandparent is considered a relative, I'm assuming.
I used to think that it was, but at this point I'm not sure that I really agree if it is or
not. Representative Gates did you okay anybody else have any questions okay seeing none it was there anybody to that wanted to speak either for or against this bill you don't see anybody there what is the pleasure of the committee most you can do it during discussion if you want to that's
Okay, I do see a motion of due pass. Any discussion on the motion? Representative Gates, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We found during the interim that while it is a state law, we've actually had judges threaten state employees that work for DHS that if they suggested that they place a child with a blood relative, which is state law, that they would hold our DHS workers in contempt.
So, you know, we as legislators, when we pass a law and then we see people thumb their nose at it, our own state employees, sometimes we need to state it again. Judges, this is what we've decided. And so I agree with you. We shouldn't have to do that, especially for our judges. But when we have state employees that are threatened, that if you don't break the law, that I'm going to hold you in contempt.
I mean, there comes a battle sometimes, and I think this is one of those times that we need to reinstate. We do recognize that most of these kids already have an established relationship. Let's recognize that, and let's keep these kids out of the system, and they can go to Grandma's house. So I would speak in favor
of this bill. Thank you, Representative Gates. Representative Walker, you're recognized. I wouldn't have spoken. Thank you. I
wouldn't have spoken, but for Mr. Gates' position.
And when you say that you've had judges threaten people with contempt, you know, I don't know if that's factual. Judges may threaten, and if a person is threatened with contempt and then is held in contempt, they have a remedy. And I don't think that we should legislatively try to overrule judges before they make judicial decisions. Now, I don't know if that's necessary for this bill to pass,
but I think we become on awkward ground when we take a loose representation of the judge threatening me with contempt if I did this or if I did that. That may be one person's pejorative way of saying that this is what I was faced with. But what happens in a courtroom is subject to having a record. And the person who was adversely affected by that record has an appeal right. And you have been careful to put in these bills appeal rights of the parent, of the grandparent.
So without that language of Representative Gates, which I don't think adds to the bill, I think that I would have
like to, Representative Gates, if I may respond to Representative Walker, it was under, during the interim, we had sworn testimony by the director of DHS that that was the case of some of her employees.
So that was sworn testimony. So according to them, they're workers. That's where that data came from. It wasn't just an employee. It was actually the former director. Response please. Thank you. You have a follow-up, Representative
Warmer. Yes. Sworn testimony about a conclusion is not testimony about a fact. All right. Any further discussion on
this bill? Seeing none, all those in favor, say aye. Aye.
All those opposed? All right, you have passed your bill as amended. Thank you. Okay, go ahead and proceed with House Bill 1773. If you don't mind, could we
skip to the House Bill 1783 and come back to 1773? I think it will go faster for the committee. Yes, we may, and we do have
an amendment, so let's go ahead and deal with that amendment first. All right. You
recognize to explain the amendment? The amendment is to add Senator Irving as the Senate
sponsor. Okay. All right. We have a motion due pass. Any discussion on the motion?
All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment has passed
it. Go ahead and proceed on House Bill 1783. House Bill 1783 simply adds a line 4 and 5 to the code of 913-103B, which is what we have been discussing, there is, and what it would do is say it adds a new spouse
or either parent of the child adopts a child or either parent of the child is incapacitated, incarcerated, or has his or her parental rights terminated. Basically, what this would do is it would allow, and I'll give you a real-life situation. My son-in-law is now married. He has a new wife that is adopting my three grandchildren. So at that point, if for some reason he goes back off to war and he's killed in the line of duty, I no longer, because of the adoption rights, I no longer have rights to see those children
because she is now the adoptive parent of those children. Even if I'd already been granted grandparents' rights, I would have no rights to them because of the adoption laws in this state. and so this is to help correct that we can continue on with those grandparent rights for this type of situation. Okay, members, all
right, Representative Kavanaugh, you are recognized for a question. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Rushing, I just want to verify something
because I'm a little confused. I want to make sure we're not going to do something that we don't intend to do. On Bill 1568, you took out death. Okay, in here it is left, and it's the same section of the law. So are we not creating a
conflict there? I think that when you see, that's why I wanted to go to 1773. 1773 is going to have most everything incorporated into it. This would probably be the only thing that it's not.
This was kind of a last-minute bill that we threw in here, and it will need some corrections at some point in time. We don't want to correct it before we try to pass it? we can we can table it if if i mean i'm only concerned that we're going to create a conflict and i don't want to do that and i did and i did look at that last night and was thinking the same thing that it could cause a conflict and that we may be better off to table this particular one and that's why i was saying it might be easier for us to address this one first before we go to the next bill
okay thank you yeah that was my concern is that we were taking it out we're leaving it in
We're going to have a conflict, and then that's where we'll
be with the conflict. Representative Birch, did you have a question? That was your question. Okay. Does anybody else have any other questions? Okay. While we're on this bill, does anybody want to speak either for or against this bill? Okay. And I understand that you're just going to... I would like to pull the bill down for now. All right. We'll go ahead and do that. Thank you. And then finally, House Bill 1773, you're recognized.
Okay, thank you, Mr. Chair. House Bill 1773 has been worked on, and I have to give a lot of credit to Senator Subblefield, who is over in the Senate side right now, or he'd be here with me to help present this bill. But he's worked a long time on this bill, and I think it's been in debate and interim studies and all kinds of stuff for the last several years to try to make some corrections. What you'll see in here is it is, we did add in the reasonable visitation of our periods
of one to four weeks, unreasonable alienation, meaning that a parent or parents of a child have refused or obstructed access or communication with a grandparent or great grandparent of the child without a justifiable purpose. um we've also added the marital relationship between the parents of the child is intact but there has been an unreasonable alienation of a grandparent or great-grandparent with respect to his or her grandchild and great great-grandchild and i think this is the section
where my other bill that i just pulled would we would have some issues with and so we need to kind of correct um upon finding an unreasonable alienation the court shall allow the grandparent grandparent to be heard so if the if there is an unreasonable alienation that can be proven then the court will be able to hear it before the presumption was that the and this is why i said earlier while we took it the death and changed it over to making it so the grandparents has a
burden of proof, here is where we are asking for it to be changed that in these situations that actually the custodian is the one that has, the custodian's decision denying or limiting visitation to the petitioner is in the best interest of the child so the custodian, actually the burden of proof will be on the custodian and i know there's lots of questions on this and i hope i can answer them so
because like i said most of mine have been on the other three and we have kind of tried to incorporate all of them into this one so i'm
uh representative kathwin are you recognized okay thank you mr chair uh representative rushing and you've said this several times that we've taken the death issue out and made it different than the rest of them. Why? I'm just curious why we just chose death to be the only reason that you changed the way that the law is versus all
the other ones. Well, the reason I
took out death is because death is something that, as we all know, we all have no control over. We don't have control of any of the others either, but there is a lot of conflict that goes on in the situations with divorce and parents getting involved and taking sides of this that and the other most likely in the case of death there's no side taking there's people that are just in grief and they're hurting and so to remove the death from that portion in order to kind of separate
it out and not get it mixed in with with the divorce situation or those other types of things where there's been hurtful things said amongst parents and grandparents, and so that's why the death has been put in a separate section. That was my reasoning. Can I have a follow-up? Yes, you may.
Go ahead. But we're changing the way that it's going to be approached. With the other ones, it's up to the parent to make that case.
Now you're changing it to be that the grandparents make the case. I'm just trying to reason why we're only in the
case of death because in the case of death I feel like that a grandparent can reasonably show that they have had that bond and that relationship and that there has not been hurtful situations that would be intended to hurt the child in any way shape or form just because of the death of a parent we're in a divorce there can be times
when the one parent will take a child and alienate it from the grandparents of the other with the intent not only to hurt the children but also to hurt the other grandparents and the other spouse. And so I think death is one that there is not any ill intent of anyone to hurt anyone other than the fact that everyone's just grieving at the time. And maybe hurtful things are said at the time, but everyone kind of moves past them.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Representative Birch, you may have just answered this, and again, I kind of stumbled a little bit. So on page two, you just discussed removing the death part. So it's removed on the section for 9.13.103, and then on page four, when we're talking about Section 9, 13, 111, death is put back in.
Is that on page four? Because I'm looking down on lines 34, 35, 36. It's creating the petitioner's rights when there's one parent that's deceased. Yes, this is,
this was 1568. This is adding a new section to that, to this, this is the combination of 1568 to add the
death in and it also adds is deceased, missing or in a permanent vegetative state. So if the other parent just shows up missing or is in a permanent vegetative state, like been in a terrible accident or something, that would also cause grief. You need a follow-up? Yes. Okay, you're recognized. Please,
I come down to it and I look just at this one, this one's probably okay. It's when I try to add all the other parts to the other three being considered that I get confused.
If we just had one thing clearly with the definitions, which are now in a couple of different things, I could understand a lot better. So is there any part of this bill, 1773, that you believe now conflicts with any of the prior two we've just passed out of committee? Well, actually I was hoping that you would
say that 1773 was going to be the best bill so I could pull the others down if we could get this one passed out.
The intent was that if I could have something better than nothing, and so 1773 is the better bill. It is the bill that needs to go through. It's the one that will take care of most situations other than the foster care, which is the one the Representative Wardlaw had asked me to run for him, and other than the one that I had pulled down, but I would make an amendment on the Senate side to correct this and come back and concur if that would be the will of the committee I
would be willing to do that if we can get 1773 passed through and that would save a lot of confusion I know and I'm
sorry I confused all of you okay representative gates you're recognized thank you mr. chair so let me get this straight if this was presented on the house floor and passed putting aside the one that Wardlaw brought would we need to go forward on the other two no thank
you okay any other questions from members of the committee okay seeing none was there anybody that wish to either speak for or against this bill okay seeing none there was the pleasure of the committee do pass as amended okay that motion that do pass as a minute is there any discussion on the motion seeing none all those in favor say aye any opposed your bill has passed thank y'all very much I appreciate it all right members I think we're done with the
special order of business I think we still have a little bit of time we're under a time crunch as you know because we're wanting to get out of session by the end of March we're as far as I know we're not planning on meeting on Friday and so our next opportunity next Wednesday so I would really want to try to get more bills through if we possibly can. So I see Representative Beck standing over there. So Representative Beck, I'm going to go ahead. Are you ready to present, I guess, an amendment to the bill that you had prior? Okay, so you're going to be recognized to do that at this point?
So this is going to be House Bill 1678, is that correct? Yes. Okay, you're recognized to present the amendment, and I think it's on the table, is that correct? Yes. It is on your table, it's JNL220.
You recognize, Representative Beck. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So do we want to just vote on the amendment, and then we'll talk about the amendment as the bill as amended?
Yes, we'll go ahead and present the amendment first, and then once you're done presenting the amendment, then if you need to say anything on your bill, then you can do that, and then we'll,
of course, take the whole package. Okay. All right. Well, first of all, speaking to the amendment itself, I want to thank the DHS for all their help and input as far as on the amendment. They've really stepped forward. We had a rather lengthy meeting, and I believe this bill is much better than it was.
Okay, hold on just a moment because the amendment is not pulling up on the table. I'm getting a blank thing, and I think others are too.
Is there paper copies that we can? It's not engrossed in
the bill, no. If you hold on just a moment here, we'll go ahead and get that amendment passed out so members can look at it. Okay. Good job.
the comments from the committee, it does remind you of that really bad essay
that you got back from your teachers. There seems to be more amendments than there are to the original bill. This morning when I got ready to put my paperwork together for this, I noticed that there's five pages of amendments to a bill that was originally six pages long. And one of those amendments is to delete the last page of the other bill. So it truly is a big change. So what I thought I would do is, first of all, I do want to thank the DHS, and I will say that the DHS is in total support of this bill as amended.
So what I thought I might do is, instead of talking to the individual changes, because there are many of those, what I will do is get some bullet points here that summarize what has been changed in the bill that we heard earlier. All right, so with that, the first point is that you'll notice that we've removed the definition of interested person. That is totally, the phrase is out of the bill, there is no more interested person,
so this only deals with relatives. The next point is on the first section of the bill, which deals with Arkansas Code 12-20-103, we have removed the definition of incapacitated individual. And what has replaced that throughout that section is the language that is already in that section in other places. So what this does is it's commonly used, matched language throughout the bill,
and they did a great job of doing that. The next bullet point is the burden of evidence has been changed from clear and convincing down to the preponderance of the evidence. Now, what that does is that's just the legal people know this, but that's just a slight shift downward in the burden of proof as it was. The next level, the next change that is brought about by all the amendments is the shifting of the burden of evidence if the word objects to the visitation.
What that means is this. If you're a word, which means you could be a word of the state, You could be a ward of a caregiver for whatever reason. If that person is asked, do you want to see your son or your daughter, and they say, no, I do not want to see them, then it shifts everything over to the person requesting visitation and says that you now have to prove, it shifts that burden over because the person has said that they do not want to visit with you. And then the last thing we did is we deleted the last page, which is Section 6.
So that's the cliff note version of the changes to this bill, or the amendments to the bill. Okay, do any
of the members have a question on this? Yes, Representative Brooks, you're recognized.
Representative Beck, are you happy with the amendments that this still meets the intent of you you and the persons that came to you to help with changing the law in the state of Arkansas?
I believe that. I honestly believe it does better. I really do. Okay, any other
questions from members of the committee? All right, seeing none, is there anybody that wishes to either speak for or against this bill? Or amendment, excuse me. All right, what is the pleasure of the committee on the amendment? Motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed say nay. The amendment has passed.
Representative Beck, you are now recognized to present your bill as
amended. Thank you. Last week we had a lot of testimony from individuals who obviously have an interest in this bill. So I'm not going to go back through all that testimony, and I thought what I would do is just give a quick review to remind people that this bill only deals with visitation. It doesn't deal with any other things related to being a ward or the guardianship.
It's just visitation. And it's just visitation between an individual that is a ward of the state or a caregiver and that ward's relatives. It does not include interested people, other interested people. So why isn't visitation important? As we learned from last week, that restricting visitation really provides the bad caregivers. And I want to say that the majority of these caregivers are doing exactly what they should be doing.
But there are some bad caregivers there. And one of the main tools that they use is the isolation of their wards. Once a ward is isolated, they have no connection to their relatives. and they may not even know that their daughter or their son or their brother or their sister is trying to contact them but is being denied access. This is critical because in most cases, this is a time when that individual needs to see their relatives.
And so we just want to make sure that that happens. There's some statistical stuff that was presented last week that actually shows that the mortality rate for individuals who are denied this visitation is higher. So it's very important that we do this. What are the reasons for isolation? You know, they vary from case to case. And to be honest with you, they're not important. It's not important to know why a bad caregiver would isolate. You know, it may be that they want to get a bigger piece of the wheel or something.
But that's not what this deals is. And it's really not important. What's important is that we pass this bill and begin a process that once this bill is complete, we'll put laws into place that will allow us to prevent unnecessarily the isolation of the people that are under award. This bill provides laws that will require that a third party review, in the case where a relative thinks that their visitation is being unnecessarily restricted,
a third party will come in and take a look. A third set of eyes will determine that. That third set of eyes will obviously validate the request or it could go the other way. It could be that the caregiver was right, that the visitation of this individual is a problem with the ward and so therefore it would be denied. Once that happens, the court will then have the ability to demand compensation from the bad actor,
whether it's the caregiver or the relative that wishes to do harm to the person that's under the care of the ward. So with that, that's a sum of what the bill does. And I'd entertain any questions. You've heard a presentation of the bill. Does anyone have any questions?
Okay, seeing none, Was there anybody that wishes to either speak for or against this bill? Okay, seeing none, what is the pleasure of the committee?
Do pass as amended? As amended, okay. Any discussion on this motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations. Representative Beck, you have passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you, committee. Okay. Representative, I think Bolts is going to wait until next week. Representative Lowry, Eubanks Representative Gates, were you going to present any of your bills today? Okay, I am also going to wait until next week
Representative Lighting, did you want to present your bill? Okay And I don't see anything else Anybody want to jump up and present any other bills while we're here? All right, saying none, we are adjourned.
Agenda
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - WEDNESDAY, MARCH 8, 2017 - 10:00 A.M.
HB1568 Rushing TO GRANT VISITATION RIGHTS TO GRANDPARENTS WHEN A PARENT OF A CHILD IS DECEASED, MISSING, OR IN A PERMANENT VEGETATIVE STATE.
HB1654 Rushing CONCERNING THE RIGHTS OF GRANDPARENTS INVOLVED WITH FOSTER CARE AND ADOPTION CASES.
HB1773 Rushing TO AMEND GRANDPARENTS' RIGHTS IN CUSTODY AND VISITATION MATTERS; AND TO GRANT VISITATION RIGHTS TO GRANDPARENTS WHEN A PARENT OF A CHILD IS DECEASED.
HB1783 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE VISITATION RIGHTS OF GRANDPARENTS AND GREAT-GRANDPARENTS. \
REGULAR AGENDA
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1297 Farrer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS MILITARY HERITAGE PROTECTION ACT.
HB1475 K. Hendren TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF GUARDIANS AND THE REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR GUARDIANS.
SB268 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING THE TERMINATION OF A GUARDIANSHIP.
HB1445 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD RELATIONSHIP PROTECTION ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FACTORS AND PROCEDURES FOR DETERMINING WHETHER OR NOT A CHANGE OF A CHILD'S PRINCIPAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CHILD.
HR1025 S. Meeks RECOGNIZING THE CHICKAMAUGA CHEROKEE PEOPLE'S UNIQUE HERITAGE AND IMPORTANT CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.
SB132 J. Hutchinson CREATING THE COMMISSION FOR PARENT COUNSEL; CONCERNING DEPENDENCY- NEGLECT REPRESENTATION FOR THE PARENT OF A MINOR CHILD; AND CONCERNING REPRESENTATION IN THE JUVENILE DIVISION OF CIRCUIT COURT.
SCMR1 K. Ingram IN RESPECTFUL MEMORY OF CORRECTIONAL CORPORAL BARBARA ESTER.
HB1678 Beck CONCERNING VISITATION WITH AN INCAPACITATED PERSON OR A WARD; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DECISIONS MADE BY APPOINTED GUARDIANS ON BEHALF OF WARDS.
HB1849 Baltz TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE PLACEMENT OF A JUVENILE REMOVED FROM HIS OR HER HOME.
HR1039 Petty HONORING ARKANSAS WORLD WAR II VETERAN JAMES DONALD NEAL BURNETT.
HR1038 Lowery RECOGNIZING AND HONORING THE EFFORTS OF LAURA RHEA WITH ARKANSAS RICE DEPOT.
HR1037 Eubanks CONGRATULATING EMILY RICHEY AS A RECIPIENT OF A PRUDENTIAL SPIRIT OF COMMUNITY AWARD.
HB1906 C. Douglas TO SET A SPECIAL HUNTING AND FISHING LICENSE FEE FOR ACTIVE MILITARY MEMBERS HOME ON LEAVE IN ARKANSAS.
HB1912 Gates TO REQUIRE VIDEO AND AUDIO RECORDINGS OF IN-PERSON INTERACTIONS AND VERBAL COMMUNICATIONS THAT OCCUR DURING INVESTIGATIONS PERFORMED UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989 AND THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.
HB1913 Gates TO REQUIRE CHILD MALTREATMENT INVESTIGATORS TO PROVIDE CERTAIN NOTICES TO ALLEGED OFFENDERS, PARENTS, AND GUARDIANS.
HB1914 Gates TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION RELATING TO A REPORT OF CHILD MALTREATMENT.
HB1915 Gates TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AND THE DEPARTMENT OF ARKANSAS STATE POLICE TO PROVIDE REPORTS CONCERNING THE NUMBER OF OVERTURNED TRUE FINDING DETERMINATIONS.
HB1927 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE GROUNDS FOR THE TERMINATION OF PARENTAL RIGHTS.
HB1933 Fite TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE MEMBERSHIP AND POWERS OF THE CHILD C. DEATH AND NEAR FATALITY MULTIDISCIPLINARY REVIEW COMMITTEE; AND TO AMEND THE EXPIRATION DATE OF ACTS 2015, NO. 1245.
HB1972 D. Meeks TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE CONFIDENTIALITY AND RELEASE OF FOSTER HOME AND ADOPTIVE HOME RECORDS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE RELEASE OF INFORMATION RELATED TO INVESTIGATIONS OF CHILD MALTREATMENT.
HB1973 D. Meeks TO PROVIDE FOR THE RESUMPTION OF SERVICES FOR PARENTS WHOSE PARENTAL RIGHTS ARE TERMINATED; AND TO PROVIDE FOR THE REINSTATEMENT OF PARENTAL RIGHTS.
HB1974 D. Meeks TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CHILDREN TAKEN INTO PROTECTIVE CUSTODY UNDER THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.
HB2006 Capp TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE INITIAL PERIOD FOR WHICH A TEMPORARY GUARDIAN IS APPOINTED FOR AN INCAPACITATED PERSON; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING FULL MERIT HEARINGS HELD AFTER THE ENTRY OF EMERGENCY TEMPORARY GUARDIANSHIP ORDERS.
HB2038 Fielding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CHILD SUPPORT ORDERED PURSUANT TO A DIVORCE DECREE; AND CONCERNING THE ESTABLISHMENT AND DISESTABLISHMENT OF PATERNITY BEFORE AND AFTER THE ENTRY OF A DIVORCE DECREE.
HB2039 Drown TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE REISSUANCE OF A PURPLE HEART RECIPIENT SPECIAL LICENSE PLATE TO A SURVIVING SPOUSE.
HB2089 Gates TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE TYPES OF REPORTS THAT ARE ACCEPTED UNDER THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.
HB2124 Leding TO ELIMINATE THE ASSET OR RESOURCE TEST FOR LONG-TERM CARE MEDICAID WITHIN THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM FOR VETERANS.
HB2198 McGill TO CREATE A UNIFORM DATA COLLECTION SYSTEM TO LOCATE VETERANS IN G. ARKANSAS TO ENSURE APPROPRIATE SERVICES ARE PROVIDED FOR VETERANS AND MILITARY FAMILIES.
HR1046 Hammer RECOGNIZING THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF JUNIOR AUXILIARIES, INC., AND PROCLAIMING "ARKANSAS JUNIOR AUXILIARY DAY".
HR1047 Tosh SUPPORTING THE DESIGNATION OF THE BIBLE AS THE STATE BOOK.
DEFERRED
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HR1013 Sorvillo HONORING THE 308TH TITAN II STRATEGIC MISSILE WING AND THE RESPONSE TO THE 1980 MISSILE EXPLOSION AT DAMASCUS, ARKANSAS.
HB1381 Gazaway TO AMEND THE GROUNDS FOR DENYING PERMANENCY PLANS THAT PLACE JUVENILES IN THE CUSTODY OF A PARENT, GUARDIAN, OR CUSTODIAN.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlene Fite Chair
Unverified
Representative Jon S. Eubanks
Unverified
Representative Dwight Tosh
Unverified
Representative John W. Walker
Unverified
Representative LeAnne Burch
Unverified
Representative Carlton Wing
Unverified
Representative Rebecca Petty
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Representative Laurie Rushing
Unverified
Speaker 67
Speaker 20
Representative Frances Cavenaugh
Unverified
Representative Mickey Gates Chair
Unverified
Representative Vivian Flowers
Unverified
Speaker 77
Lorna Nobles
Unverified
Speaker 140
Speaker 56
Representative Charles Blake
Unverified
Representative Rick Beck
Unverified
Speaker 179