Chair Representative Matthew J. Shepherd moved to adopt an amendment to HB1873, which passed unanimously after Representative Dalby’s motion.
[1:35]
Representative Lanny Fite was recognized to present the bill, requested a witness, and the committee agreed to defer further consideration until Thursday to allow the witness to appear.
[2:10][2:30][2:43]
Representative Greg Leding provided background for HB2088, noting Arkansas’s high concentration of hate groups, a recent threat to a university student, and that the bill would permit prosecutors to seek enhanced penalties for hate-motivated crimes.
[3:55][4:28]
Representative Greg Leding explained that HB2121 would create a bifurcated trial for hate-motivated offenses, allowing a prosecutor to seek a 20 % sentencing enhancement if hate motivation is proven.
[5:02][5:33]
Committee members raised equal-protection concerns about the protected categories, which Leding addressed by emphasizing the bill’s purpose to deter bias-motivated crimes and protect whole communities.
[7:08][7:44][7:51][8:16][8:49][9:11]
After brief discussion, a motion to pass the bill (including consideration of adding law-enforcement officers) was made and approved unanimously.
[11:21][11:31][11:33][11:43][12:04]
Representative Jimmy Gazaway introduced HB1885, noting that the current statute treats fleeing by individuals under 21 as a Class C misdemeanor even when serious injury occurs, and the bill would eliminate that disparity so adults 18 and older face the same penalties.
[21:10][21:41][22:15][22:48]
With no members requesting debate, the committee moved a motion to pass, which was adopted unanimously.
[23:20]
Senate Bill 547 would change the 13th Judicial District prosecutor from an A to a Division B (part-time) position; after a brief explanation, the committee approved the bill by voice vote.
[25:52][26:06][26:25][27:00][27:32][27:45]
Chair Matthew Shepherd presented an amendment to the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act to allow courts to determine fair market value without a formal hearing when a co-tenant does not respond; the amendment was adopted and the bill passed as amended unanimously.
[33:55][34:13][34:25][34:36]
Representative Bob Ballinger introduced HB2020 to re-word a code section and reduce its penalty to a Class C misdemeanor; after no opposition, the committee moved a motion to do-pass, which was approved.
[35:27][36:05][36:17][36:28][36:31][36:36]
Thank you for coming back downstairs so that we can hopefully take care of a few more items before the end of the day. Without objection, well, actually, I need to back up and make an announcement as to House Bill 1249, which was the Representative Collins bill that came back to concur in the amendment. We incorrectly referenced that there were seven amendments. There were only five amendments. Those amendments were amendments 1, 2, 4, 5, and 7. 3 and 6 were not adopted by the Senate. Therefore, we could not concur in those. So it was just an oversight. The amendments that we did consider were engrossed in the bill, so what we considered was all correct. But after conferring with when staff called that to my attention and after conferring with Buddy, I wanted to make an announcement for the benefit of the committee so everybody would understand that we concurred in five of the seven amendments. I'm assuming
No, the bill is moved out because we did concur in the five amendments. I'm just checking, Mr. Chairman. I would expect that our legal team here on the committee would keep us honest here, right? But anyway, I did want to make that announcement so everybody would understand exactly what the issue was there. Without objection, we're going to go to House Bill 1873. representative Lanny fight and there is an amendment okay it should be loading on the tablet and for the sake of some efficiency in dealing with the bill I would entertain a motion to adopt the amendment? Okay. Representative Dalby moves adoption of the amendment. All in favor indicate by saying aye. Aye. Any opposed? The amendment's adopted. Representative Fite, you're recognized to present the bill
as amended. Mr. Chairman, I guess a little miscommunication between you. I have a witness in which I need to have here someone to give testimony when I give this bill? Yes, I do. This is a constituent bill. Okay. So can I get my amendment
in today? The amendment, since we've adopted the amendment, it'll go to the member zone in the morning, and then we could take up the bill as amended on Thursday, correct? but i think he i think he's wanting to wait until his witness is here right correct okay that's our understanding we should be able to take it up on thursday all right
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. I'll try to be brief. In the summer of 2015, right after Dylan Roof shot 12 people, killing nine at the Emanuel AME Church in Charleston, South Carolina, I was contacted by a reporter back home. She was doing a story on Mr. Roof. And the story had to do with the fact that despite that Mr. Roof confessed that his killing was racially motivated and that, in fact, he had hoped to start a race war, he would not be able to be charged with a hate crime under South Carolina law because South Carolina was one of just five states without hate crime law on the books, the other four being Michigan, Georgia, Wyoming, and Arkansas. And she wanted to know why Arkansas was not on that or was on that short list. I told her I didn't know, but I would look into it. A few months later, doing some research on the issue, I learned that in 2015, Arkansas was home to more active hate groups per capita than any other state in the country. We had 22 active groups that year. That number did fall to 16 in 2016, but we still rank among the states with the most active hate groups. Then late this last fall, there was a university student who woke up one morning and found a note taped to his apartment door that specifically referenced his religion and made some explicit threats. that whoever left the note followed the student home from his place of worship the evening before and left the note on his door for him to find the next day. That's when a couple of us decided we wanted to take a hard look at running this legislation this session. The last time the legislature tried was 2001, so we basically just took that bill and cleaned it up a little bit. What it would do is it would allow a prosecuting attorney, if she decides that a case she's going to try was motivated by hate, she can provide written notice to the court and there would be a bifurcated trial. So there would be a trial to determine the guilt of the defendant without any kind of discussion as to what the motivation was. And if the defendant is found guilty, there's a second trial during the sentencing phase in which the prosecutor would try to make the case that the crime was motivated by hate. And if that was found to be true by the court, the penalty for the crime would be enhanced
the sheriffs but the last time I talked to the prosecutors they said they don't tend to take a position they wouldn't take a position on this particular legislation again it's entirely permissive it does not require them to do anything it would be up to the individual prosecuting attorney to decide whether or not this was something they wanted to pursue. Thank you. Representative Whitaker you recognize
for a question. Thank you thank you Mr. Chair so a follow-up to Mr. Maddox's question so what What you're saying is we'd be providing the prosecutors with one more tool in their toolbox that they could use if they chose to?
that the victims of crime who are injured, murdered, stolen from, and all that have, in essence, less or unequal protection of the law if you single out certain groups of people for worse punishment? For instance, I look here at the things that you talk about, and these are the things, race, color, religion, ethnicity, ancestry, national origin, sexual orientation, gender. Except for sexual orientation, I think all of those are the federal disability is not covered. Yeah, there it is, disability. I'm sorry I didn't look down far enough. But that means that folks that are not one of those things are not as protected by the law as are the others. There's an equal protection argument here. What's your thought about that, please?
Well, I would say, first of all, I think this bill would provide protection to everybody. If I understand your question, I think you're saying that, like, if I'm murdered just in a dispute, that would somehow be seen as less severe than if I were murdered because somebody, I'm Catholic and they're against Catholics. I don't see this as providing less protection. There's still protection under the law. The real purpose with the enhanced penalties isn't to necessarily say that that crime is worse. The real motivation behind these kinds of laws are that when a member of a community is specifically targeted, then the other people in that community begin to feel threatened as well, and it can lead to discord and division in the community and perhaps further crimes. So it's really more about deterring further action and protecting the community. You know, earlier this session, we all voted for a bill to provide enhanced penalties for anybody who attacked law enforcement, I think for similar reasons, when we see our law enforcement officers targeted by certain individuals that can lead to a lot of tension between the law enforcement community and the people that they're there to protect. And we want to do everything we can to minimize that kind of tension. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Representative Leading, that brings me to my question. You're right. We did run a bill earlier in the session to enhance the penalty. And one reason we did that is because, you know, we looked at a hate crime and we didn't have a hate crime. So I guess what I was curious about is when you drafted this bill, you know, we'd already been through this earlier in the session. I'm just curious why officers wasn't included as part of the hate crime. Actually, we
did look at including them because Louisiana took a similar approach when they passed a bill last year. They included law enforcement officers in their hate crime bill, but because you were the House sponsor of one of those measures, correct? Yeah. Yeah. We knew that there was already some legislation out there addressing that, so we didn't feel it was necessary to include them in this bill, but we did look at that because of
what Louisiana had done last year. Representative Tucker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm going to take a stab at clarifying, I think, what Representative House was asking about. And he's talking about in federal employment law, for example, you know, some folks are protected, but not all. And so, you know, just taking me for example, if someone terminated my employment because I'm white or male, then I would not have a cause of action or under the age of 40, right? But if you're, you know, if I was a female and I was fired for that reason, then I would have a claim. But the way I read this particular language is that you have protection no matter whether you're male, female, you know, white, black, whatever the case might be. And so if someone were to commit a crime against me, and the reason is because I'm a male or whatever, I would still have the same protection. It's different than the federal law in that sense. Correct. That's the way that I read it. So for whatever that's worth, Representative House, thank you for the clarification. Representative House.
Any other questions from the committee? All right. No one has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Letting, would you like to close for
appreciate a good vote. All right. Representative Tucker, you're recognized. Motion to pass. Okay, we have a motion to pass. Is there any discussion? Representative Tosh, you're
recognized for discussion. Representative Letting, if this bill passes out of here, would you consider adding law enforcement officers to this hate crime? Oh, absolutely. So you would do that? I mean,
my understanding is that they're already protected by the legislation that you passed earlier this session. Is that not? Well, not to this degree. To this degree? No. That is certainly something we would be willing to consider, especially if that ensured passage of the overall bill.
Any further discussion? All right, the motion before us is due pass. All in favor indicate by saying aye. Any opposed? No. When rule of no's have it. Thank you, committee. Members, without objection, we're going to move to House Bill 2121. representative wommack is rep is recognized present house bill 2121 thank you mr chair and
members uh this i think will be real quick and simple uh in 2015 we passed a photographer's rights bill and there was a an amendment that was kind of came in at the very last moment that weakened the intent just a little bit and so this is simply to correct that basically what it what the bill does is if government stops you from video on quorum court meeting traffic accident arrest something in a public setting then the government can be sued for damages and and the way that was weakened is basically if if you have a bad actor under current law it's not sufficient to make the government liable this bill corrects that error and encourages as government actors not to violate the rights of the citizens that they
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Walnick, I remember when this bill ran two years ago, and I had a little problem with it then, and you and I visited about it. But I've still got some concerns about it in regards to the fact that, you know, police officers in the course of their performance of their duty out there, sometimes they have to deal with minors, they have to deal with people in all kinds of situations and to allow someone to be able to video that and then be able to, the officer not being able to protect the identity of that minor or other individuals that, you know, they may have under arrest and when they're under arrest and they become their responsibility. And I think this law prohibits law enforcement from being able to protect those that's in their custody from having that type of exposure. Would you care to address that? The only way I can respond is if you remember, the
Yeah, to the best of my knowledge, there was no opposition at all to this bill. I mean, it was a work in progress for a while. That's kind of how that little slip-up happened there at
for a question. Maybe you could explain to me, or I'm not reading it exactly right, and I wasn't here the last term, but on line 24 through 26, we're changing that to where if an individual is sued, they're sued in their personal capacity, and then it becomes incumbent upon the state to bear the liability for someone who's acting in a personal manner and not in their official capacity, and why are we making
that change? I admit I am not an attorney, but the way I understand that is the intent was to encourage government to enact policy, to make a policy for the government actors to not prohibit somebody from video. Okay, thank you. Representative Gasway, you're recognized for a question. Well,
premise of this statute to begin with, but it doesn't look like that's not the issue here. It looks like what apparently this bill does is it just allows a person who is a public officer employee who, I guess, doesn't allow the video recording and is sued in their personal capacity, the state is going to defend them, and the state will have to pick up the tab in the event that they're found to be liable. Is that correct as far as what this bill does? Yes, sir. Okay. Well, okay, that's all.
Any other questions from the committee? No one has signed up to speak for against the bill. Representative Womack, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. What's the pleasure of the committee? All right. I see no motion. We'll leave it on the agenda. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. a few items of housekeeping without objection i'm going to move house bill 1713 to the deferred agenda. And I understand, just for future reference, I believe Representative Blake would like to run House Bill 1798. We're going to attempt to do that on Thursday. Is there anybody else on the, I think the others who have bills to run in our committee are tied up across the hall, or is there anybody else on the committee that has a bill for us to run at this time? Another bill, I believe Representative Flowers, there's been some question about a bill that She had filed, and I believe she intends to run that next Tuesday. We'll leave. The Clark Tucker agenda is dwindling, but we'll leave them on there. If I ran both of them and we didn't have any
Members, if you give me just a second, I'm going to see if there's anybody else that is on their way. We're going to check real quick. I've got an amendment to one of my bills. I'm going to see how long it takes for us to get it over here. If you'll indulge me for just a minute or two. Representative Gasway, do you have any bills to run? I think the strategy here is Representative Tucker, he front loads all his bills, and Representative Gassaway comes in at the end and brings him on. All right. You're recognized to present House Bill 1885.
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, House Bill 1885 is a bill that was brought to me by the Prosecuting Attorneys Association. In this regards the criminal offense of fleeing, specifically what the bill does is that there's a section of the fleeing statute that states, and this is subsection E, regardless of the circumstances in subdivisions C1 through 3 of this section, if the defendant is under the age of 21 years of age and has not been previously convicted of fleeing, the offense of fleeing is a Class C misdemeanor. And that's a rather unusual provision because the sections that it's referring to earlier in the statute are those if a person is fleeing, let's say, in a vehicle and they run somebody over and cause serious bodily injury to that person, the way the statute is currently written, if that person is under the age of 21, then the worst offense they could be found guilty of is a Class C misdemeanor. Well, a Class C misdemeanor carries a maximum of 30 days in the county jail as a penalty. And I think the rationale, there's a question about if a person is an adult and over the age of 18, and they cause seriously bodily injury in the course of fleeing, why should they only be subjected to a Class C misdemeanor with a maximum of 30 days in the county jail? And so what this bill would do is simply remove that and hold an adult if you're 18 years of age or older, and you seriously injure someone in the course of fleeing, that you're going to be held to the same standards as everyone else. no one is really sure why the provision was inserted into the statute that if you're under the age of 21 for some reason it's a class C misdemeanor but the prosecuting attorneys association has asked that it be taken out and so that's that's the gist of the bill and I'm
happy to answer any questions any questions from the committee all right no one signed up to speak on the bill represent gas where you close for the bill close for the bill make a motion do pass okay we have a motion do pass is there any discussion all in favor say aye any opposed motion passes all right members i have an amendment coming over on my bill if you'll just sit tight for a minute or two and hopefully uh that this may wrap it up i think the others who wanted to run bills are across the hall in their committee at this point My bill is House Bill 2156.
Bill 547. All right, members, Mr. Chairman and members, Senate Bill 547 is Senator Malik's bill, and this concerns the 13th Judicial District, which is my judicial district. It's Union, Columbia, Ouachita, Dallas, Calhoun, and Cleveland counties in South Arkansas. Previously, it along with another judicial district, I can't think of it right off the top of my head. I believe Representative Richmond carried the bill, converting the other district from an A to a B prosecutor. And similarly, in the 13th, Senator Malik is changing it from an A prosecutor to a Division B prosecutor, which is essentially a part-time prosecutor. The way these have historically been handled is from time to time, members have brought legislation to either change from an A to a B or vice versa. And so two years ago, we actually put a sunset clause on some of this with these two positions, and we did look at it during the interim. But I think kind of the consensus was that we were going to continue to kind of leave it as is. If the bar and the prosecutor and the constituents in those local areas wanted to make a change, they could contact their representative or senator. And so because of that, I'm here on behalf of Senator Malik and asking that the committee approve this bill to change our prosecutor back to a B division prosecutor. Any questions from the committee? Seeing none, no
one signed up, speak for or against the bill. Ready to close? I'm closed for the bill, and I would move, do pass. Committee, we have a do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no.
I'm sure you're recognized on your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, I have an amendment here to House Bill 2156. This amendment is to the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act. This is a bill that actually, it's a uniform law, which we've seen. I think we have a couple of uniform laws that are presently filed. but a uniform law is something that there's uniform law commissioners from across the country they get together and they come up with recommended or uniform statutes that states can adopt and it tries to promote some consistency across the states and also it aids in not having to reinvent the wheel the uniform partition of heirs property act was a is a uniform law that Actually, I was asked to sponsor in the previous session, which the legislature did pass. And in the course of its application, I had a couple of individuals in my district who had asked about a possible change to it. And basically, what occurs, this applies to a partition action. So where you have co-owners of property, and one of those owners wants to partition the property. The Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act applies where 20% or more of the ownership is owned by or comes from basically a common family. And so this act was trying to discourage or take out the incentive for a co-tenant to basically use the sentimental value of property as leverage in a partition action. Well, one of the things that the act requires is, in the event you're having a partition, you have to have an appraisal brought in and the court determines the fair market value. Under the current act, then the court holds a hearing on that to determine the fair market value. Well, what has occurred is, in some instances, there have been cases, and it's not that uncommon, where there is actually no response filed. The parties are properly served. one files a response or an objection they may just essentially not just not take any action under the current act some judges believed and i believe correctly that you had to have a hearing and that would consider that was additional time money expense and effort what we're trying to do here uh is just simply provide that if if no defendant or co-tenant responds or objects then the court would still have to consider what and make a determination of fair market value, but there's no requirement that it actually has to be a formal hearing. So the judge could just simply review a proposed order in chambers and make a determination. And this is something that I actually went back to and worked with Arkansas's uniform law commissioners on. They actually, because when it comes to uniform law, there's always a concern that if you make certain changes, that you will become essentially non-uniform and lose that designation. They vetted this with other uniform law commissioners and experts in other areas of the country. And we understand we have an agreement as to these changes. So it's a very small change, but it's one that I think will promote efficiency in our judicial system. and in dealing with these, nobody's rights are being prejudiced. It's still going to be essentially the same process. And so with that, I would move adoption of
the amendment. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. Amendment's been adopted.
And then I've essentially explained the bill, but I would appreciate a good vote on adopt or a motion do pass as amended on this particular bill. Okay, we have a
motion do pass on the amendment, on the bill. Any discussion? Seeing none, I want to sign up, speak for or against the bill. We have a motion do pass. All in favor, say aye. All opposed, say no. Congratulations.
you're recognized thank you mr. chair this is a bill that's actually brought to my attention that the language the wording of this code section could actually be interpreted as as prohibiting what it actually intended and so it's just basically rewording the code section to make sure that judges and other individuals have the ability to carry in a courtroom. And it also actually reduces the fine to class C misdemeanor, which probably everything else will just clean up. That's the only thing that's a policy change at all. And I'd be happy to answer any questions. Any questions from the committee?
we have a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. committee is there anybody else that has a bill to to run okay all right if there's no further no further business before the committee without objection we're adjourned
Chair Representative Matthew J. Shepherd moved to adopt an amendment to HB1873, which passed unanimously after Representative Dalby’s motion.
[1:35]
Representative Lanny Fite was recognized to present the bill, requested a witness, and the committee agreed to defer further consideration until Thursday to allow the witness to appear.
[2:10][2:30][2:43]
Representative Greg Leding provided background for HB2088, noting Arkansas’s high concentration of hate groups, a recent threat to a university student, and that the bill would permit prosecutors to seek enhanced penalties for hate-motivated crimes.
[3:55][4:28]
Representative Greg Leding explained that HB2121 would create a bifurcated trial for hate-motivated offenses, allowing a prosecutor to seek a 20 % sentencing enhancement if hate motivation is proven.
[5:02][5:33]
Committee members raised equal-protection concerns about the protected categories, which Leding addressed by emphasizing the bill’s purpose to deter bias-motivated crimes and protect whole communities.
[7:08][7:44][7:51][8:16][8:49][9:11]
After brief discussion, a motion to pass the bill (including consideration of adding law-enforcement officers) was made and approved unanimously.
[11:21][11:31][11:33][11:43][12:04]
Representative Jimmy Gazaway introduced HB1885, noting that the current statute treats fleeing by individuals under 21 as a Class C misdemeanor even when serious injury occurs, and the bill would eliminate that disparity so adults 18 and older face the same penalties.
[21:10][21:41][22:15][22:48]
With no members requesting debate, the committee moved a motion to pass, which was adopted unanimously.
[23:20]
Senate Bill 547 would change the 13th Judicial District prosecutor from an A to a Division B (part-time) position; after a brief explanation, the committee approved the bill by voice vote.
[25:52][26:06][26:25][27:00][27:32][27:45]
Chair Matthew Shepherd presented an amendment to the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act to allow courts to determine fair market value without a formal hearing when a co-tenant does not respond; the amendment was adopted and the bill passed as amended unanimously.
[33:55][34:13][34:25][34:36]
Representative Bob Ballinger introduced HB2020 to re-word a code section and reduce its penalty to a Class C misdemeanor; after no opposition, the committee moved a motion to do-pass, which was approved.
[35:27][36:05][36:17][36:28][36:31][36:36]