Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Aging, Children and Youth Committee

March 15, 2017 ·Committee Room 130 ·50:46
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

HB1849 0:05

The committee considered HB1849, introduced by Rep. Baltz with support from the Department of Human Services to improve stability for youth in care. [0:09] [0:34]

Director Misha Martin explained that the bill creates an “exempt-by-law” contracting authority that would bypass the normal six-to-nine-month RFP process for licensed family-style residential providers. [1:05] [1:36] [2:07]

He clarified that the exemption does not affect existing emergency shelters, does not alter the Child Welfare Licensing Act, and applies only to providers meeting specific licensing criteria. [2:32] [2:42] [2:47] [3:17] [3:48] [4:07] [4:10] [4:22]

With no public testimony, the committee moved to vote and unanimously passed HB1849. [4:54] [5:03] [5:10]

HB 5:52

The amendment to the monument bill requires any relocation of statues, plaques, flags, or similar monuments to obtain a written waiver from the State Historical Commission. [5:58]

Lawmakers debated whether the waiver would strip local governments of authority, with Rep. LeAnne Burch expressing concern but the sponsor emphasizing the goal is to prevent removal or concealment of historic markers. [7:01] [7:21] [7:30] [7:32] [7:38] [8:03] [9:05] [9:41]

Clarifications were provided that the definition includes temporary exhibits and does not extend to town names or street renamings. [10:12] [10:30] [10:33] [10:42] [10:51] [10:55] [10:58]

After discussion, the committee voted to approve the amendment as presented. [12:17] [12:48]

HB2089 13:11

Rep. Mickey Gates introduced HB2089, proposing to delete head-lice and truancy from the list of conditions that trigger a child-maltreatment hotline call, arguing the hotline is overloaded with non-serious reports. [13:21] [13:54] [14:32] [15:04] [15:35] [16:07] [16:42] [17:15] [17:48]

Committee members questioned the bill’s impact on truancy reporting and on schools’ ability to flag genuine abuse, while Director Misha Martin presented DHS data showing educational-neglect calls rose from 228 in FY2015 to 597 in FY2016 after the 2015 law change. [18:21] [18:34] [18:52] [34:13] [34:50] [35:21]

Witness Jerry Cox testified that the legislation would restore the pre-2015 framework, limiting inappropriate hotline use while preserving true emergency reporting, and several juvenile judges testified they strongly oppose the bill, fearing it would hamper protection of vulnerable children. [22:30] [22:40] [23:17] [23:51] [24:25] [24:59] [25:30] [42:40] [43:15] [43:46] [44:17] [44:48] [45:26] [46:01] [46:37] [47:08] [47:39] [48:12]

The committee considered a motion to reject the bill; the motion was adopted, effectively defeating HB2089. [49:02] [49:21] [49:35] [49:54]

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1849 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1849”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2089 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…, committee. Representative Gates, are you ready to present House Bill 2089? No. No. This is 2089.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1297 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “Representative Farrar, did you wish to present House Bill 1297?”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
present House Bill 1849. Thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 1 0:09
Madam Chair and committee. We bring a bill to you today that would keep a whole lot of stability and in some really bad situations for for some young people and I'll let Mishka kind of elaborate on it because DHS worked feverishly with me to make this a lot better bill than what I had done.
▶ Play
Speaker 5 0:34
So I'll give you a little bit. Oh, I'm Mr. Martin, Director of Division of Children and Family Services, and I do want to thank Representative Baltz for being so willing to work with us. He came to us with an idea, and we were really able to work together and come to a solution that I'm very excited about. So just to give you, if you don't mind, I'll give you a little bit of a back story. We at the Department of Human Services are required to follow strict contracting law, and that includes working with providers. So I cannot contract with a provider unless we go through the typical RFP process and the entire process, which can be six to nine months. But as many of you probably know, there are providers in your community who want to provide family-like settings, which we very much support, and we need the ability to work quickly with them so that they can provide appropriate settings for our juveniles so what this bill will do if you look at section two of this bill it allows an exempt by law contract so we're still going to put a contract in place we will still that contract will still have to come before the legislature but it can happen very quickly because we won't have to do the typical RFP process. It is very limited in scope. So our foster parents currently have that exemption and then this will allow if you have a community provider that's either licensed as a family style residential or provides a family home setting. So because it is a core value of the department which you see in section one to ensure that our children are placed in a family we want to encourage our providers to provide that family setting with house parents and this will allow us to contract and not have to wait for seven years or go through a full six
▶ Play
to nine month RFP process. Representative
▶ Play
Kavanaugh. Thank you Madam Chair. Just to clarify we currently have shelters that are licensed by the state that are family style. they provide a temporary emergency shelter already that's
▶ Play
Speaker 5 2:47
correct how will this affect them it will not so they will so what yes so currently um there the emergency shelter contract is ending and so in the next hopefully on friday actually we will be putting out a new rfp for emergency shelters they can choose to go through that process now this exemption is only for a standard board payment so there we actually have providers who want to contract with us to either get you know a standard board rate or an elevated board rate and so an elevated board rate is much less than actually getting responding to that RFP and getting a contract with us but we have several non-profit providers who are able to raise money and and come to us for a contract and provide so You could either choose to answer my RFP, or we could do an exempt by law contract in that interim period if you meet this very specific criteria. Follow-up?
▶ Play
Yes, you're recognized for your follow-up. Okay, so if they're currently existing in their contract laps, in the meantime they could go under this until they got their new contract if they chose to go and get that elevated rate. That's correct. But this will allow those
▶ Play
Speaker 16 4:07
who don't have that license or not a
▶ Play
contract. The one, I guess, my follow-up question is those that are getting this contract, they do still have some type of license and guarantee that the children are being taken care of properly.
▶ Play
Speaker 5 4:22
Oh, that's correct. This does not affect the Child Welfare Licensing Act. So the Child Welfare Licensing Act still requires that child welfare place in a licensed, approved placement, whether that be a foster home, emergency shelter. So this does not affect the requirement of who we can place with as far as licensing goes. All right. Any other questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Do we have – let's see. We do not have anyone from the audience signed up to speak for or against this bill. Would you like to close for your bill, Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 1 5:03
Balz? Yes, I would just like to say thank you to DHS and thank you to the committee and I appreciate a good vote
▶ Play
to pass. What are the wishes of the committee? Okay, any discussion on the motion? All in favor say aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations, the bill has passed. Thank you, Madam Chair and committee. Representative Farrar, did you wish to present House Bill 1297?
▶ Play
Speaker 28 5:34
Okay, and this will be, this has been amended? Yes, this is the amendment we're going to run
▶ Play
through. All right. Okay, so when we vote later, that will be on the bill as amended. As amended, yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 31 5:50
ma'am. Okay. What the amendment is, it kind of makes hopefully everybody happy on this. What it does for a person or entity to move the monument, it has to have a waiver from the Historical Commission, and the cities have to apply for it, and they have to okay the movement of it. That's basically what the amendment does. Just a moment. We have
▶ Play
a question. Some of you said you're not seeing the amendment. Okay, just a moment, please.
▶ Play
Speaker 37 6:31
Okay, one agenda is from this morning and
▶ Play
one is from now. All right. Okay, everybody ready now? All right, Representative Farrar. We have previously heard this bill just to remind everyone, and so this is just the amendment that we're looking at right now and the amended bill. Right. The same bill
▶ Play
Speaker 31 6:50
ran. I'd ask for a good vote on the amendment. All
▶ Play
right. We have a question. Representative Birch.
▶ Play
Representative, and I really appreciate it. I know that Dell worked with the amendment. My concern is still that I have a monument in Drew County, and Drew County folks want to move it, change it, and it falls directly within us. I have to come to a commission in Little Rock to tell us what we can do with our You have to, well you have to, the bill or
▶ Play
Speaker 31 7:21
the amendment says you have to get it in writing and send it to them and have them vote on it see if it's something that allow
▶ Play
you to vote. Which doesn't that take away complete control locally and put it in the hands of a commission that I don't have any impact over? What I
▶ Play
Speaker 31 7:38
would say to that is we're trying to protect these monuments from being moved out of places. And you can have a city that move it and put it in the back of the building and hidden. That's what this is to protect. The Historical Commission is not going to let that happen. Now, they can allow you to move it somewhere else where it's visible, but if you don't want to destroy that monument and move it somewhere else, I hope that's not what they want
▶ Play
you to do or allow you to
▶ Play
do. Representative Birch, you're recognized for a follow-up. Thank you, Madam Chair. So my great-grandfather donated a monument in Drew County that, frankly, I find a little bit offensive personally now, even after all my military service. And we want to move it, and the family supports moving it. We have to get, and Drew County supports moving it. We have to get permission in writing from a commission in Little Rock to move it. Is it a military monument? Under this definition,
▶ Play
Speaker 31 8:47
it could be. That's a hypothetical, by the way. I want to ask you again, is it a military monument from somebody
▶ Play
from the war? This is totally hypothetical because there's not one, but... Okay. It would be in Arkansas County if my family was doing it. Hypothetically, yes.
▶ Play
Speaker 31 9:05
Right, but But the object of it is the historical commission to protect historical markers to the best of their ability. Now, if Drew County wants to come in and say, we want to move this monument, and we want to move it to a more visible spot, they write a waiver, look, here's what we're doing. Now, they're going to say, okay. Now, if you write, well, we're going to destroy this monument, and we're going to tear it to the ground, well, I imagine, don't know, that you're going to have to go to the historical Commission and explain why you want to do that thank you we're protecting we're actually we're protecting the military monuments and so well if you're protecting your monument then you don't want to destroy it it's gonna be you're gonna be okay look well here's what we're gonna move it now there's maybe there's a another county out there that wants to destroy that monument hypothetically and they're gonna in and the people that tell in the people the town don't want it, but the mayor and the city wants it done. Who's going to protect that monument then? Well, the historical commission.
▶ Play
Speaker 61 10:12
Representative Hodges? Oh, okay. Representative Petty? Does it exempt temporary exhibits?
▶ Play
From being moved? Yes. We have no,
▶ Play
oh, Representative Walker. Thank you, Madam Chair. Does the concept of monument extend itself to names of towns? No, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 31 10:42
It has on here, a monument means a statue, memorial, gravestone, plate, nameplate, plaque, historical flag, display, street, bridge, or building. Preserve. So there's no way I can take
▶ Play
Speaker 67 10:51
action to have the name Forest
▶ Play
Speaker 66 10:55
City changed? You could. But this doesn't prevent
▶ Play
you from doing that. Representative Birch. Thank you,
▶ Play
Madam Chair. I'm thinking back to the email that I got that had great consternation with regard to the Arts Center and whether they could even build on a bathroom without getting permission from the commission based on the way it was originally written. Has this amendment changed that some way?
▶ Play
Speaker 31 11:23
They wrote this amendment, yes, ma'am. This fixes their
▶ Play
problem. But it doesn't fix the problem. You're recognized for a
▶ Play
follow-up. I'm so sorry. It doesn't address anything particularly except the Art Center. I mean, that was the reason for this amendment. Right, the Art
▶ Play
Speaker 31 11:40
Center did that. You're not going to change the name if you had a bathroom.
▶ Play
You're not going to change the name. It wasn't the change. It was the... You're
▶ Play
recognized for a final follow-up. Thank you, Madam Chair. It was that they couldn't build on anything to
▶ Play
that based on the previous definition. Yes, it does.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 12:10
Yes, you can. Thank you. Okay. Representative Kavanaugh.
▶ Play
Representative Birch. Seriously, did you have another question? All right. Okay. Seeing no more questions, would you like to close for your bill? All right. What is the will of the committee? All right. Okay. Excuse me. This is regarding the amendment. No. The motion is due pass as amended, and that's what you were saying with your head nod. All right, thank you. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Congratulations, the bill has passed. I appreciate you. Thank you, committee. Representative Gates, are you ready to present House Bill 2089? No. No. This is 2089.
▶ Play
Are we ready? We are ready. You're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. as y'all know we deal with with so many calls to our hotline on child maltreatment 30 years ago well 20 something years ago when we were homeschooling our children we live way out in the country I traveled a lot and we chose to homeschool so that my family could travel with me and us not be separated the danger when we came back home is my wife could not leave our house during school hours because people would accost her and saying, why aren't your kids in school? That was 25 years ago. These days, because we have so many different ways of educating and schooling that it's become very commonplace. Now we're at the place where kids are homeschooled and then they go to their local public school for a class or two, or they go to a private school, or they go from one school campus to another school campus, or they go from a school to a college campus or to a votech our hotline is being one of the one of the criteria for calling the hotline has to do with head lice has to do with kids not being in school we have tendency laws on the books right now what this bill would do it would remove a few things from that one thing is head lice just because a kid has head lice doesn't mean that we need to call the hotline and have somebody investigate them. Now, y'all are laughing. Some of those are serious cases simply because parents are neglecting those kids to the point where they have sores and they have, you know, can carry diseases. So those are serious things. But just because a kid has head lice doesn't mean a call to the hotline needs to be called. Also, with kids, don't need to be called in if they are not truant. And I think that we've already got trancey laws on the books. So this changes that in this day because education is changing, how we educate received and perceived practices of education has opened up because we have private schools, home school, charter school, traditional schools, online education. Kids are just being taught differently today. DHS and the State Police Division Against Crimes Against Children are overloaded with phone calls. This is not one of those things that we need to be burdening their hotlines with doing. And it doesn't prevent our mandated reporters from doing. One of the things during the interim, we were looking at the incarceration of our juveniles. and one of the number one things they said that I think it was Tennessee that came in some of y'all may have been there one of the things that they recommended was we quit incarcerating and putting kids in juvenile detention system that are that we would not incarcerate for once they became an adult so if you have a 17 year old that refuses to go to school you don't go get him and put him in the juvenile system forcing him to go to school because it's just at that point we're probably not going to get our desired results. Years ago, this was not calling in for transparency or a child educational neglect was not put in there. I think it was back to prior to, I think, 2013. And then when we put it on there, those number of calls have become, I understand the arguments. Some of them are valid arguments, but I think our DHS workers are overloaded enough, and, you know, we've had cases where people were found education in neglect for a simple thing. They failed to register their kids with a local school district, and we found them guilt. We've had true findings of educational neglect simply for failing to register their school district. I sit in a court in Garland County, and a judge said, I do not believe it was the intent of the legislature to classify somebody who fails to register their kids with a local school district in the same light as somebody who beats or burns or poisons their children. And by putting a parent on a maltreatment list because their 17-year-old refuses to go to school, to me, is just ridiculous. And I know that is a very difficult times we live in. So anyway, this bill does that. It takes those kids off of the hotline so that we're not using man hours investigating this, and we're using those man hours to actually take care of what they should be doing, and that's real maltreatment. With that, I'll open to any questions.
▶ Play
Representative Hodges. Thank you, Madam Chair. You said truancy. Where is truancy? Is truancy in this bill? I don't see truancy in this bill. No,
▶ Play
Trent C. isn't in the bill, but part of the, I guess, legitimacy of our call now is when they're trying to figure out when kids are starting to go off course, one of the ways they start going off course is they start missing school, and so that's one of the ways that they start an investigating process, and so people will start calling the hotline and saying, hey, so-and-so is missing school. and some of your mandated reporters. But it goes way beyond that as far as people reporting children that are being educated. They're just not being educated in a five days a week, eight to three o'clock. And so we're investigating people that are actually getting educated.
▶ Play
Yes, you're recognized for a follow-up.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Okay. What is this bill designed to do? I mean, who – the statutes that are already in place, who – I mean, were they written by, I'm sure, professionals that I guess soon felt that, you know, headlights, severe headlights were important enough to report based on their profession? You know, my wife was a school nurse for a year, and, you know, if a student had severe headlight, and she saw that consistently, she reported that because there was apparently neglect. Correct. So, I mean, I guess I have several questions in one. What's the purpose of this piece of legislation, this bill, and who, I mean, Did an agency or someone ask you to run this, you know, were there a problem which caused you to bring this bill forth?
▶ Play
Well, part of the problem and having homeschooled and sent my kids to private school, I remember on Election Day one time, I had a bunch of high schoolers during school hours were holding up signs for different political candidates. from the same school you had one holding up a Republican sign and one holding up a Democrat sign. They were holding up, they were exercising their free speech. I had somebody complain. They complained about one party and not the other and that they should be in school and that they should be reported for educational neglect. They were participating in government and their right to free speech, but in civics. you know it wasn't education on neglect go look at their test scores so the purpose is is is to take people out off of the radar of not the radar off out of the scope uh if you will that don't need to be targets and we don't need to be spending the resources that we're using right now to go after private and homeschoolers and non-traditional schools and kids that are going from one school district to the other school district. And so we've got, I know family council's in support of this. I don't know who else, and I would love for them to come because I know they have a lot of association with. Excuse me. Yes, ma'am. This way. Okay. So, you know, they probably answer more than me. I know I have a number of private schools in my district, and that's concerns that a lot of those parents express is that if they can't go out during normal hours because they get complaints that they're not educating their kids simply because they don't do it like everybody else. All right. Did
▶ Play
you wish to call a witness? I do, if I may. All right, you may call a witness and introduce your witness.
▶ Play
Speaker 85 22:19
Thank you. I'd like to call Jerry Cox. Please
▶ Play
identify yourself to the committee. Thank you, Madam Chair, members of the committee. I'm Jerry Cox. I'm the director of family council here in Little Rock, and what this bill does is it seeks to put the law back the way it used to be, and I'm sure that Representative Gates has gone into some of the background on this particular bill, but here's the point that I would like to make, or one of the points, and that is, if you're going to talk about education on neglect. It's really difficult to just, as a casual observer, and I say this from an educator's point of view, because I was a high school educator for about 11 years before I got involved in work here at the Capitol, and it's really difficult for a casual observer just to look and say, ah, I think that kid's education is being neglected. It takes a lot more than that. In fact, you'd almost have to get that kid down and test them and see how much they know and so forth and so on. And so we're not talking about anything regarding a hotline regarding a child being physically abused, being hurt, being put in imminent danger. That's what that hotline is supposed to be for it's like dialing 9-1-1 and so if if there's a true emergency then all that's still allowed and it doesn't affect that but this law used to be the way we're trying to put it back to right now and so what some people are concerned about is that this hotline would be used inappropriately it'd be almost like me dialing 9-1-1 because the trash man didn't pick up my trash at my house you know there's another number to dial there are other ways to deal with that and and I'm not trying to trivialize this at all or compare child abuse to trash pickup or anything like that but it's just not the proper way to use that particular hotline number and so there are a few people out here who whose children do not attend public school these are kids that go to a private school or there's these are kids that are homeschooled and they're out all kinds of times when during the day and so they live with some level of anxiety that somebody's going to say ah I saw those kids playing in the yard they must not be they must be educationally neglected when in reality they're just doing recess, you know. And so there is some level of concern with that. And so if somebody were to say, well, you know, what problem are we trying to fix? Well, two problems, really. One is the inappropriate use of the hotline. And number two, there are some people that are concerned that it might be used inappropriately to get them all tangled up in the child maltreatment world and when all they're doing is just exercising their rights to, you know, homeschool their kids and so forth. So with that, Madam Chair, I'll be glad to entertain questions.
▶ Play
Okay, I have a question. Yes, ma'am. Because this specifically says educational neglect from a school. It doesn't address from individuals, as you were talking about calling in and saying, I see these children playing outside and not attending
▶ Play
Speaker 89 26:05
school. But the way it is right now, for example, I've had school officials
▶ Play
tell me, you know, They drove by somebody's house, and they saw the kids out in the yard playing. Well, the kids were homeschooled, and they said, well, they must be neglected. Well, maybe they could be, but there needs to be a lot more than just a casual observation of something like that. And I think that's been one of the concerns that people would have, is that anyone with the ability to use the hotline might use it inappropriately. But again, the hotline is supposed to be for an emergency. It's like the child is in some kind of really imminent danger, and this kind of situation just doesn't rise to that level, is my point. We have several
▶ Play
questions. Representative Meeks. Thank you. And just
▶ Play
Speaker 106 26:56
for a little bit of background, committee, I was the one that actually passed the law in 2015 that changed it to the way that it actually was. And while I agree with you that we don't need this to be abused, this to be used against homeschoolers, I'm also afraid that we go back to the way that things were where a child falls through the cracks that is being abused or neglected and that we need to be calling on the hotline because the teacher knows that there is something wrong because they're missing classes and the hotline is not investigating they're not accepting the report and you know we are we are going six and seven and eight weeks the teacher knows that something is wrong but the hotline is not accepting the call because of the fact that we've now changed this law back to the way that it was and so I would like you as part of my question to address that particular concern, is that if we change this law, are we going to see more kids that need help that should be, the parents should be investigated, but are not because we've made this change back? And I think we need, thank
▶ Play
you Representative Meeks for the question. I think we need to distinguish between child abuse and educational neglect. I mean, those are really two different, yes, they're both bad, but I think most of us would agree that if a child is being put in physical danger or being physically harmed, then that rises to a whole different level than it would be if he wasn't going to class or something like that. And so what we're trying to do is really put the law back the way it was, and I'm not really sure what the impetus was for changing it to the way it is right now, but I think putting the law back the way it was, Representative Meeks, it still gives people the opportunity to call the hotline. It just says that the hotline doesn't have to, and I can't, forgive me for not recalling the operative word, but it's either take, receive, there's some operative word there where under the old law, they had discretion. The person taking the call had discretion to say, you know what, based on everything I'm hearing on this, I just don't think it rises to that level. And so the way it's written now is the people that receive the call are put into a box where they almost have to take some kind of action, no matter whether the call is is seems to be is serious or not serious and I know we would say well every call ought to be taken seriously and and I get that but on the other hand what if it is what if it is a fraudulent kind of deal or what if it is one that's that's not legitimate and then all of a sudden this innocent family is caught up in this swirl of the whole child abuse world, and they're on a registry, and pretty soon they feel like they're the criminal and they haven't done anything wrong. And so it would seem that putting the law back the way it was does strike the reasonable balance there between trying to take care of kids but not an overreach. That's what it would seem, because it did seem to work at least prior to when it was changed. So that would be my answer to that. Yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 106 30:42
a follow-up. Well, the impetus was that a child was missing every Monday, and there weren't any really noticeable bruises on that child, but the teacher knew that something was wrong, and she had called the hotline, I think it was six to ten times, and the hotline would not accept the report. There was no investigation done. And finally, somehow, they were able to find a way to get this thing investigated. And this was after 10 or 12 weeks, and they found out that the parent was pimping out their child on the weekends and was then missing school on Monday. But, again, it was weeks and weeks beyond what it was because that hotline was not accepting that phone call. And so that was the reason why we had changed it. And so those types of cases, you know, we definitely want a school to be able to report, and this law, it seems, would be taking away that ability. So would you please do a second? Yes,
▶ Play
I will. That would seem to most people, I think, to be a staffing problem with whoever was running, whoever was taking the calls. It would seem to most reasonable people that they simply were not doing their job because under the old law, they would be required to do their job, and if they're not, then that's a staffing issue rather than a legal issue with this particular law. We have several questions. Representative Birch,
▶ Play
you're next in the queue. I guess, Madam Chair, with
▶ Play
regard to that question, And I'd really like to hear from DHS because I think that's an accusation that certainly in my experience is not the case. So can we reserve the possibility of asking DCFS, Ms. Martin?
▶ Play
Ms. Martin, would you be willing to
▶ Play
Speaker 109 32:44
come to the table? And please introduce yourself to
▶ Play
the committee. Members, I apologize. I did not anticipate this session lasting this long. I'm Misha Martin, Director of
▶ Play
Speaker 5 32:58
Division of Children and Family Services. I'm sorry. Yes,
▶ Play
thank you. You're recognized. Am I answering a question?
▶ Play
Yes, yes. Sorry. And would you ask your question again? Yes, ma'am. Thank you. Representative Meek's question. I guess basically what's the issue with it right now? And I do have some experience. My experience has never even looked at this as a homeschool issue. My experience is that time after time, when the educational neglect comes in, it leads to other things, especially with young kids that are not coming to school, that teachers recognize exactly, as Representative Meek said, that there are issues. Was there something wrong with the law before that this needs to change, especially with regard to perhaps staffing? concerns so just to be clear this is
▶ Play
Speaker 5 33:56
not a bill that we ask representative gates to run but we are we are not opposed to this bill as um but as far as there were there were some comments made that um were concerning about staffing issues but the law prior to 2015 this is the law that's being the bill that's being proposed was the law prior to 2015. um we have and just to clarify a couple things when the hotline receives a call of educational neglect it does go to differential response which is a different way of responding than investigation so we go out and work with the family and try and address those issues now we have seen an increase in our cases since the law was changed in 2015 and I did bring those numbers so where I pulled the educational neglect calls not the calls, but the actual accepted for educational neglect and sent to differential response, where educational neglect was the only allegation. I do have the numbers for when there's multiple allegations, but when the only allegation on the family is educational neglect, we went from 228 in state fiscal year 2015 to then 597 differential response cases in 2016. I guess another issue that I probably want to address with you guys is that this is about limiting the school's ability to call the hotline unless they comply with those truancy laws so the law prior to 2015 it was put in place to try and get schools to really address truancy issues before calling us and involving us so I understand that the the bill in 2015 was addressed concerns that we needed to be in there working with the family to see if there were other issues but we also it's also important to hold schools accountable to address truancy issues before they just get the family involved with us representative Kavanaugh
▶ Play
thank you madam chair representative Gates my concern is we're going to limit some real people able to notify when there's real abuse that we're going to limit because we're going to say they're not going to be able to accept those calls and we're going to miss some very real abuse problems going on by limiting who can turn someone in.
▶ Play
Well I don't if there's real abuse and suspect of abuse we you know that of course that's a problem we all as legislators have we don't want to make a change for one that ends up coming and and crippling the hands over here and so that is not the intent the intent is to reserve our hotline and I think Jerry hit it very poignantly you reserve the hotline I mean we had people I was in county government you know how much time and energy we spent answering the phone that somebody didn't get the right hamburger at Wendy's and they you know wanted somebody to respond just the taking of those phone calls requires staff time and everything else and you know you know I look at educational neglect what is educational neglect you know is it is it if we have that child in the seat and they are not truant they go to school every day and we give them a gold star for for showing up and three months after graduation they get to college to get to find out that they're not ready for college they need remedial classes i would i would assert that's more closely to educational neglect than somebody who may not spend a whole lot of time in a classroom but passes test and can go get his ged in two weeks when challenged uh you know i don't want to tie the hands of those but we're spending resources if we look at how many calls we have in our hotline compared to our surrounding states. And this is, you know, I don't see that it rises up to that. We're not preventing anybody from calling the hotline out of those schools, but it does, they need to go through their proper channels before they just bring in the state to investigate and let them deal with their truancy first, and then if it fails, then they come.
▶ Play
Madam Chair, may I just add one thing to what Representative Gates said? Yes. May I do that? Thank you. And I promise to be brief. When this issue was debated or discussed in committee some years ago, as I recall, one of the reasons for limiting the hotline was that people were calling the hotline for things like children having head lice, and they were saying, well this is educational neglect because these parents are letting these kids come to school they got head lice and there were things being phoned in that just did not rise to the level of educational neglect and so that was the impetus behind making the law the way it used to be or one of the impetuses and and believe me i understand representative meek's point about the the the child that was truly in a bad way so you have those bookends on both ends of it it would seem where I think if you change it, if you open it up too much, then you're going to get those calls that don't rise to that level probably. And then people are going to have to deal with that. And you may say, well, what's wrong with that? Well, the parents are the ones then to get pulled in to that whole child neglect world. And I don't think, I think most of us, you know, would not ever want to be tangled up in that because it's a difficult thing to get out of once you're pulled into that. So thank you, Madam Chair.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Gates, I get calls from constituents complaining about their garbage not being picked up or needing a tour of the U.S. White House or something. So, you know, you're going to have leakage. You're going to have issues like that on a regular basis. But my question is, what type of empirical data, what kind of data do we have? You know, you mentioned the numbers from 228 to 597 as far as education neglect since 2015. But my question, out of those calls, how do we know which ones were credible or not? What kind of data do we have to get us to this point where we have to legislate changing the laws to fix
▶ Play
it? I don't know the numbers that was actually found substantiated or not. I'll let the director address that if I could.
▶ Play
Speaker 5 41:04
You're recognized. Oh, I'm sorry, Representative Fy. I apologize. Since we changed to using differential response, I believe it was in 2010, 2011, I don't have it in front of me, the mode of which using differential response, we do not make true findings for educational neglect unless there are some circumstances if there were multiple other allegations and there was an investigation. But if the call is accepted by the hotline, which means there's enough allegations that it meets the criteria of educational neglect, then we send it to differential response and we work with the family. We're not actually investigating to determine if it's true or not. So now I can tell you that we did have some true findings because there are some that go to investigation, but I cannot tell you out of the ones that went to differential response, did we get out there and assess the family and determine whether
▶ Play
services were needed. members we still have three questions in the queue but we also have two judges who have signed up to speak against this they have traveled a long distance and the hour is late without objection I would like to go ahead and let both of them come forward and perhaps we could save our questions until afterwards representative excuse me judge Stacy Zimmerman signed up to speak against would you please come forward and introduce yourself to the
▶ Play
Speaker 125 42:36
group. Thank you, Madam Chair, for your hard work with children, and Representative Gates. I didn't know you were a West Texas guy. I Wikipedia'd him while I was waiting all day. Are you a West Texas guy? Okay, alrighty. I think we played you in football from Amarillo. But anyway, Anyway, so I'm here as a juvenile judge and also here for the Judicial Council, and we strongly oppose this bill. And the reason that we strongly oppose this bill is it's not good for our children. There's a big difference between educational neglect and truancy. Truancy is an act or omission by the juvenile, skipping out the back and not coming to school. That's truancy, where a child is incorrigible and they're not going to school. Educational neglect is an act or omission by the parent. The way the law is, thanks to Representative Meeks and people that took stand for these young children, the way the law is now, these children, these often young children who are in elementary school, and we're not talking homeschoolers, This does not, the way the law is now, does not in any way target homeschoolers, alternative learning environment children, charter schools. I have lots of homeschoolers that come to court to observe juvenile court. This bill, the way it's written now, would take away a teacher, an educator's right to hotline educational neglect where a child is not going to school, not because they're skipping in their truant, but because there is something going on in their home that is bad. Our teachers and our educators in public schools are on the front line. They're the ones that see a second grader who's not in school and wondering why that child's not in school. I've been in juvenile court for 27 years. I've been on the juvenile bench for now 19 years. I am in the trenches. I am not a casual observer. We're not talking about services to get your trash picked up or hamburgers being made. We're here about children that have fallen through the cracks. And the reason that the numbers of children in 2000, I think a director from DCFS DHS stated that in 2015, they had 208 calls, and in 2016, 597. So the reason there were low calls was because teachers weren't allowed to hotline a hotline on these little children that weren't in school because the hotline wouldn't take the call. And when they started taking the calls and the DHS went out to investigate, well, guess what? those children weren't in school because their parents were high on meth, they're strung out on meth. We had one case in which we had a second and third grader who hadn't been to school for a week. And when they went out to check, because the hotline now would take the call, they were without heat, had been out without a heat for a week, and mom was in the hospital. And I have the statistics in Washington and Madison counties from my jurisdiction that in 2014, January 1st, 2014 to December 31st, 2014, we received nearly 70 FINS reports because the teachers in the schools had the only option to file a court case because the hotline wouldn't take the call. It wasn't screened out. They wouldn't take the call. These are children 12 years or younger. We're not talking truancy. These are not kids that are skipping. We are not talking homeschoolers. These are children that are falling through the cracks because they are being neglected at home. When the first bill came through before it was passed the way it is now, it said that if DHS went out to investigate for educational neglect and that's all they found, they couldn't treat the underlying causes, the meth problems, the pimping out your child, the beating your child, not sending them to school because they have bruises on their body. And so now DHS, when they go out there, they don't just say, oh, is your kid in school next week? No, they have to treat the reason why the kids aren't in school. It's an onion. You get out there, there are lots of layers. And DCFS, of course, would rather not have these cases because it's a lot of little kids that need our help. And if the teachers can't call and hotline this, and we're not talking truancy, we're talking educational neglect for young children who are not in school 20, 30, 40 days in a year, then we failed our children. And it's with, I mean, I will sit here all day. I was here this morning waiting for Representative Gates to get here. I was all excited. I will come back on Friday. I will come back next week. And all of the juvenile judges in Arkansas oppose this bill. we do not need to go back to the way it was. This does not target special educational groups. This helps our children in crisis on the front line. It also gets these services to children so hopefully we can resolve it and I don't have to take a 72-hour hold to put these little kids in foster care so they're not in a meth house, they're not being pimped out, they're not getting beaten and not sent to school because those bruises might show. And so it's with strong, strong vigor that I oppose this, and so does the Judicial Council, and I appreciate your time and all the hard work you do for families in sitting on this committee and coming back at 5 o'clock after you had a hard day's work that shows your commitment to juveniles. And
▶ Play
I know that Representative Gates
▶ Play
is committed, although I disagree with him. Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. I move for immediate consideration. You have to have a motion. I move. That's the motion. I move for immediate consideration and that we reject the act. I do not pass. Yes. Motions do not pass. At 6 o'clock, the statement is compelling. Just
▶ Play
a moment, please. Okay, that motion is debatable as we check here. Any other comments on this motion? Okay, all in favor of immediate consideration, say aye. Aye. We have a motion on the table. Do not pass. All in favor of this do not pass motion, say aye. Aye. The motion has passed. The motion do not pass has passed. I didn't hear the other
▶ Play
Speaker 132 50:10
vote. Were there any votes for it? I didn't hear that vote. Were there any votes to
▶ Play
pass? Let me back up. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you for your testimony. and with that we will plan to meet Friday again I apologize I did not mean this to be quite as lengthy as it turned out to be but we got some good work done today and we will meet Friday and I'm hoping we will wrap up our work next week if you have members with bills that need to come forward please encourage them to do that as quickly as possible
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1849

0:05 - 5:52 22 segments 7 speakers

The committee considered HB1849, introduced by Rep. Baltz with support from the Department of Human Services to improve stability for youth in care. [0:09] [0:34]

Director Misha Martin explained that the bill creates an “exempt-by-law” contracting authority that would bypass the normal six-to-nine-month RFP process for licensed family-style residential providers. [1:05] [1:36] [2:07]

He clarified that the exemption does not affect existing emergency shelters, does not alter the Child Welfare Licensing Act, and applies only to providers meeting specific licensing criteria. [2:32] [2:42] [2:47] [3:17] [3:48] [4:07] [4:10] [4:22]

With no public testimony, the committee moved to vote and unanimously passed HB1849. [4:54] [5:03] [5:10]

HB

5:52 - 13:11 39 segments 9 speakers

The amendment to the monument bill requires any relocation of statues, plaques, flags, or similar monuments to obtain a written waiver from the State Historical Commission. [5:58]

Lawmakers debated whether the waiver would strip local governments of authority, with Rep. LeAnne Burch expressing concern but the sponsor emphasizing the goal is to prevent removal or concealment of historic markers. [7:01] [7:21] [7:30] [7:32] [7:38] [8:03] [9:05] [9:41]

Clarifications were provided that the definition includes temporary exhibits and does not extend to town names or street renamings. [10:12] [10:30] [10:33] [10:42] [10:51] [10:55] [10:58]

After discussion, the committee voted to approve the amendment as presented. [12:17] [12:48]

HB2089

13:11 - 50:45 100 segments 14 speakers

Rep. Mickey Gates introduced HB2089, proposing to delete head-lice and truancy from the list of conditions that trigger a child-maltreatment hotline call, arguing the hotline is overloaded with non-serious reports. [13:21] [13:54] [14:32] [15:04] [15:35] [16:07] [16:42] [17:15] [17:48]

Committee members questioned the bill’s impact on truancy reporting and on schools’ ability to flag genuine abuse, while Director Misha Martin presented DHS data showing educational-neglect calls rose from 228 in FY2015 to 597 in FY2016 after the 2015 law change. [18:21] [18:34] [18:52] [34:13] [34:50] [35:21]

Witness Jerry Cox testified that the legislation would restore the pre-2015 framework, limiting inappropriate hotline use while preserving true emergency reporting, and several juvenile judges testified they strongly oppose the bill, fearing it would hamper protection of vulnerable children. [22:30] [22:40] [23:17] [23:51] [24:25] [24:59] [25:30] [42:40] [43:15] [43:46] [44:17] [44:48] [45:26] [46:01] [46:37] [47:08] [47:39] [48:12]

The committee considered a motion to reject the bill; the motion was adopted, effectively defeating HB2089. [49:02] [49:21] [49:35] [49:54]

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
34 segments
Speaker 1
2 segments
Speaker 5
15 segments
Representative Frances Cavenaugh Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 16
1 segment
Speaker 28
1 segment
Speaker 31
12 segments
Speaker 37
1 segment
Representative LeAnne Burch Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 61
1 segment
Representative John W. Walker Chair Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 67
1 segment
Speaker 66
1 segment
Speaker 54
1 segment
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
21 segments
Representative Monte Hodges Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 85
1 segment
Jerry Cox Unverified
20 segments
Speaker 89
1 segment
Speaker 106
7 segments
Speaker 109
1 segment
Speaker 125
13 segments
Speaker 132
1 segment