May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
HB1865 Ladyman TO AMEND THE STATEWIDE FLUORIDATION PROGRAM; AND TO PROVIDE LOCAL CONTROL OVER FLUORIDE LEVELS. 31:42
Representative Jack Ladyman introduced HB1865, explaining that it would grant local decision-making to 14 public water authorities serving between 5,000 and 22,000 water meters-a subset representing about 1.3 % of Arkansas’s 1,065 water systems-and noted that a similar bill had previously passed the House but died in the Senate.
[31:53][32:02][32:05][32:27][33:02][33:36][34:07][34:42]
Committee members raised several technical questions, including whether the bill’s references to “persons” versus “users” both meant meters, and whether the language might unintentionally allow all systems to opt out; Ladyman clarified that the terms are synonymous and that only PWAs under the 22,000-meter threshold are affected, and he also addressed cost concerns, noting that Delta Dental would provide equipment at no charge but that ongoing maintenance, chemicals and training would still impose operational expenses.
[37:44][38:19][38:57][39:04][39:06][39:28][39:34][39:37][40:02][40:08][40:37][40:40][40:48][40:52][43:30][44:02][44:34]
After debate, Representative Ladyman moved to pass the bill, the motion was seconded, and the committee recorded an affirmative roll-call vote (aye) with no opposition, thereby approving HB1865.
[1:13:24][1:13:40][1:14:03][1:14:34]
SB339 J. Hutchinson TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM TO MANDATE PRESCRIBERS CHECK THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM WHEN PRESCRIBING CE… 1:15:05
After discussion of exemptions, reporting mechanisms, and penalties, the committee moved a motion to pass the bill, which carried unanimously.
[1:50:13][1:50:45][1:50:59]
SB206 Irvin TO AVOID UNNECESSARY EXPANSION IN MEDICAID COSTS AND SERVICES RELATED TO REHABILITATIVE SERVICES FOR PERSONS WITH MENTAL ILLNESS; AND TO CODIFY THE… 1:52:18
Senator Missy Irvin presented an amendment to SB 206 that adds an emergency clause at the request of DHS, and the committee approved the amendment by voice vote.
[1:52:36][1:52:51][1:53:03]
SB420 Irvin TO ALLOW INSURANCE CARRIERS TO OBTAIN PRACTITIONER AND DISPENSER INFORMATION MAINTAINED BY THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM; AND TO ALLOW P… 1:53:05
Senator Missy Irvin introduced SB 420, permitting insurance carriers to obtain practitioner and dispenser information from the PDMP and allowing prescriber data to be used for research; the committee subsequently moved and carried motions to pass both SB 206 (as amended) and SB 420 unanimously.
[1:53:09][1:53:24][1:53:44][1:53:58][1:54:15][1:54:45][1:55:01]
HB2150 Penzo TO CREATE AN INCENTIVE PROGRAM FOR THE SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM 1:55:45
Representative Clint Penzo presented HB 2150, creating a SNAP incentive program that encourages purchase of healthier foods using a $10,000 grant from the Arkansas Hunger Relief Alliance and stating no additional state funds would be required.
[1:56:31][1:56:55][1:57:01][1:57:06][1:57:16][1:57:20]
SB227 Rapert AN ACT TO CREATE THE PATRICIA HEATH ACT; TO INCLUDE ALL SERVICE DOGS AUTHORIZED FOR ACCOMPANIMENT UNDER THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITY ACT IN THE R… 1:59:01
SB 227, the Patricia Heath Act extending service-dog protections under the ADA, was considered; the committee moved and carried a motion to pass the bill unanimously.
[1:59:15][1:59:42]
SB351 B. Sample TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING COSMETOLOGY INSTRUCTOR TRAINING. 2:00:16
A motion to reject the bill was offered and adopted, resulting in the measure failing to pass.
[2:02:26][2:02:55]
HB2174 Bentley TO ADDRESS DUPLICATIVE TRAINING OF CERTIFIED NURSE ASSISTANTS IN LONG- TERM CARE FACILITIES; AND TO PROVIDE AN EXEMPTION FOR LICENSURE AS A PRIV… 2:03:47
Rep. Fredrick J. Love and Rep. Robin Lundstrum questioned whether the measure would block local jurisdictions from raising wages above the state floor, and Bentley clarified that the bill only prevents localities from lowering the wage.
[2:04:36][2:05:09][2:05:13][2:05:20][2:05:28][2:05:38][2:05:42]
Following brief discussion, the committee moved to a motion and adopted SB 668 unanimously by voice vote.
[2:06:49][2:07:03]
Bentley then announced she would present Senate Bill 361 concerning peritoneal dialysis regulations, which would be considered later.
[2:07:20]
SB361 Flippo TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF PHARMACY FOR DIALYSATE OR DEVICES NECESSARY FOR HOME PERITONEAL KIDNEY DIALYSIS IN … 2:07:41
Representative Mary Bentley described SB 361, which would amend the Pharmacy Practice Act to eliminate the requirement for a second pharmacist to affix a duplicate label on home peritoneal dialysis shipments, arguing it reduces redundancy and cost.
[2:07:52][2:08:23]
She noted the bill had been developed with the Arkansas Pharmacists Association and the State Board of Pharmacy and faced no opposition.
[2:08:23][2:08:54][2:09:14]
After a brief clarification that the medication is not a controlled substance, the chair called for any comments, received none, and the committee approved the bill by voice vote.
[2:09:25][2:09:32][2:09:49]
HB1894 Gates TO REQUIRE THAT BIRTH CERTIFICATES LIST THE BIOLOGICAL SEX OF AN INDIVIDUAL AS DETERMINED AT BIRTH; AND TO PROHIBIT AMENDMENT OF A BIRTH CERTIFICA… 2:10:21
Representative Mickey Gates introduced HB 1894, stating it would require birth certificates to reflect the biological sex assigned at birth and limit amendments except for certain genetic disorders.
[2:10:29][2:11:03][2:11:38][2:12:11][2:12:26][2:12:33][2:12:46]
Supporters such as Rep. Paul Calvert argued the measure preserves a basic biological identifier and that provisions exist for correcting genuine errors.
[2:31:06][2:31:39][2:32:13]
HB2230 Hammer TO REQUIRE CIRCULATING NURSES IN OPERATING ROOMS OF HOSPITALS AND AMBULATORY SURGERY CENTERS. 2:41:20
Rep. Kim Hammer introduced HB 2230 and yielded the floor to Danielle Glover of the Association of Perioperative Registered Nurses, who testified that circulating RN nurses improve patient safety, are supported by the hospital association, and that similar statutes exist in over 30 states.
[2:41:27][2:41:49][2:41:52][2:41:58][2:42:34][2:43:05][2:43:36][2:44:08]
Surgeon Speaker 254 questioned the necessity of the bill because hospitals already employ circulating RNs, and Rep. Kenneth B. Ferguson and Ms. Glover responded that the legislation addresses situations where nurses are asked to leave the OR and ensures consistent coverage throughout the procedure.
[2:44:52][2:45:09][2:45:36][2:45:40][2:45:42][2:46:10][2:46:41]
Chair Jeff Wardlaw raised concerns about over-regulation, prompting Rep. Hammer to argue the bill fills a liability gap and protects nurses in compromising situations, with Glover citing specific Arkansas incidents where nurses were forced to leave the room.
[2:48:32][2:48:46][2:49:20][2:49:53][2:50:29][2:50:45][2:51:05]
After Rep. Hammer moved to pass the bill, the committee voted with seven ayes and no nays, but the chair declared the measure failed.
[2:55:52][2:56:01]
HB2160 Gonzales TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING TRAINING FOR VOLUNTEER FIREFIGHTERS. 2:59:05
The committee considered HB 2160, which would permit volunteer firefighters to count continuing-education hours earned by EMTs, nurses or other medical personnel toward the required 16-hour annual fire-training requirement.
[3:00:32][3:00:48][3:01:22]
Representative Roger Smith, speaking for the State Firefighters Association, argued the bill would let departments skip essential fire-safety training, while Rep. Kenneth B. Ferguson noted fire chiefs oppose because it could jeopardize Act 833 funding tied to meeting the training mandate.
[3:01:47][3:02:04][3:02:36][3:03:08][3:03:31][3:03:34][3:03:43][3:03:56][3:04:15][3:04:38]
Committee members questioned the lack of a clear standard for applying medical-training hours, and the chair indicated the bill’s language was ambiguous and might need revision by the Fire Services Protection Board.
[3:04:46][3:05:17][3:05:31][3:05:47][3:06:22][3:06:30][3:06:44][3:06:54]
HB2220 Davis TO AMEND THE PROCESS FOR PERMITTING NONMUNICIPAL DOMESTIC SEWAGE TREATMENT WORKS. 3:08:32
Representative Warwick Sabin introduced HB 2220, proposing the creation of a task force to study non-municipal domestic sewage treatment works without requiring new expenditures.
[3:09:02][3:09:33]
While Rep. Fredrick J. Love argued the state already has too many ineffective task forces and voted against the measure, Rep. Kenneth B. Ferguson expressed support for a functional task force and indicated he would vote in favor.
[3:09:52][3:10:06][3:10:13][3:10:36][3:10:43]
After a brief vote in which ayes were recorded, the chair ruled that the required two-hand count was not met and declared the bill failed.
[3:10:53]
Members, we'll grab your seat. We'll go ahead and get started. Representative Collins, are you ready to present House Bill 1953? Committee, I think the amendment is on the tablets. 1953 on the tablets. Representative Collins, you're recognized to introduce your guest and present your amendment. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. What I'm going to do is I'm going to talk about the amendment as and then I'll let my help person here. We talked about this bill this week and I thank the committee for passing it on to the House. During the discussion there was concern in particular about one area, the area of changing the major cause approach from workers comp litigation. So even though I think the bill was better before personally, the way this business works is a personal preference is not enough to make a law. So what I want to do is concede this what I'm going to call very major point in order to reduce the overall impact of this law but allow us to make progress in this area. Obviously the benefit of doing that is by going a little bit more slowly, by going a little bit more sure-footedly, we can comfortably move in the right direction versus trying to take big leaps and bounds as perhaps I might prefer, but I'd defer to the body to do that, so I'd appreciate it if we could adopt this amendment that removes major cause from House Bill 1953 as a change. It's a pleasure to
committee on the motion. I got a motion due pass on the amendment. Any discussion on that motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. All those opposed? It would be nice if you guys kind of wake up this morning. We're all here
now. You recognize the presenter bill as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So now the bill is the same as it was we talked before. It improves from a business perspective some of the things that have been happening in the workers' comp law, but it doesn't go as far as it did before. It removes the change to major cause, and so I think it makes it more acceptable to everybody. It's a more sure-footed approach. It's a less aggressive approach than we had before, and it's still a good bill that's going to help the people of Arkansas and appreciate a do-pass-as-amended motion on House Bill 1953. Pleasure. Anybody in the audience
speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, what's the pleasure of committee? Got a motion to do pass. Representative Coleman. All those, any discussion on this motion? All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Congratulations, your bill is passed. Representative Collins, you've got a second bill
you want to present? Yes, sir. House Bill 1954. You're recognized. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair and committee. And I know this committee last week passed a bill 1706, which is going to create the provider-led care model in Arkansas. That's an innovative, unique model that hasn't been tried anywhere in the country. So it's exciting that Arkansas is going to be innovating in its health care system from that perspective. The health care task force over the past 18 months did a lot of work with DHS and outside experts and of course the governor's office and this model emerged as a synthesis of the different ways of moving us from our current fee-for-service Medicaid system into a more contemporary approach of managing costs. One of the key objectives of that is achieving the savings goal, $835 million over five years at the minimum, and this model we're anticipating is going to be able to achieve that. So what does House Bill 1954 do? It really lays out the legislature's expectation to DHS that they're going to be tracking that and reporting back to us on the progress of those savings. And it's telling DHS that if the model is not actually delivering the committed to savings, that they are authorized and expected to take additional reforms and additional actions and additional adjustments to ensure that we get that. So the bottom line is our current system is in a fast-paced growth mode in terms of Medicaid spending. It's growing at an unsustainable rate, basically two times the rate of growth of the economy. We don't want to put ourselves in a position where we're forced to raise taxes and tax rates to cover that. So the model you passed last week is designed to bend that cost curve, call it about $835 million. costs will go up just not as much House Bill 1954 is a tool in the toolbox of DHS to help make sure those savings are delivered and I'd appreciate a good vote representative meek's recognized for a
question thank you mr. chair and representative Collins I appreciate I think this is gonna be a good bill my concern is is at the very end it's as if legislative action is required to implement the additional reforms the department may take the acts of legislative council or executive subcommittee legislative council for immediate action how does that go as far as statutes are concerned because there are some things that may take statute changes is that going to override that no it
is not in fact representative meeks this language is not going to be codified so it would not supersede any of the existing code thank you for addressing that
Payton you recognize thank you mr. chair representative Collins I just want to make sure I understand what you mean by not codified what does this actually do if it does not become part of Arkansas
law this is not a permanent change to the law this is a temporal instruction and direction for DHS because what we're talking about is a specific program during its implementation phase. So if you think about it and you say to yourself, why do we always have so many more laws on the books that last forever and ever and ever? Isn't there anything those guys try to do that's ever going to end ever? The answer is you can say yes, you voted for one with 1954. Okay, if I could follow up, Mr. Chair.
they expected to deliver the savings. So for the next five years, they would have a very broad authority to develop additional reforms to achieve the savings goals, and there would be no legislative action required other than going through Legislative Council?
This doesn't give them new legislative authority to develop reforms. It would just be reporting back to us and letting us know what of their existing authority and reforms are they moving forward with. So, for example, things like managed care. The executive branch has the authority today to move forward with managed care. This does not give them any authority to do that. It doesn't remove any authority to do that. this really is more about clarifying between the legislature and DHS our expectation that they're going to deliver those savings and that they're going to let us know and update this report back to us quarterly and also some of the areas in that scorecard that we want to focus on. So it doesn't give them more authority per se than they already have, but it does let them know that we have an expectation that they deliver on those savings. And the reason for it, Representative Payton, is, as you probably know, there's a lot of discussion about how we go about achieving the savings, and this hybrid approach that we're taking is an unproven model. And what we are saying with this is that we don't want, in the shuffle, to lose sight of the fact that we're going to have and
Please. Representative Love, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Collins, thank you for bringing this. I do believe that I guess we should be monitoring the progress of this new piece of legislation. But I do have a question because you continue to say about the savings. And from my understanding from the department, and we may just need to get clarification, they stated that there was going to be very little savings. So what is it that we're trying to monitor here besides the savings? Because I guess they expressed to me that this was not really a savings measure, but more of an efficiency measure. So can you speak to me on that?
Yes. So if you look at the current trend of Medicaid costs, presuming we do nothing, we continue to use our fee-for-service model as it's implemented today. The projections are that our expenses are going to grow at 5% to 6% annually. So, the model that we're adding is not going to reduce from last year's spending. So in the context of $100 last year, will it go down to $95 this year, there are no savings. In terms of the word efficiency, that's another way of saying rather than growing from $100 to $106, it's only going to grow from $100 to $102 or $103. So moving forward, we're going to be more efficient. That's savings against a trend line, but it is not literal reductions. So you can talk about it as being more efficient moving forward, or you can talk about it as savings versus a trend line, but to your point, it is not an absolute reduction in spending
Representative Payton, I'm back to you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Collins, C1 specifically compels the department by saying it shall develop additional reforms. C2 says if legislative action is required to implement the additional reforms, the department may take the action to the legislative council or the Executive Subcommittee of the Legislative Council. We would be giving them very broad authority to take legislative action without coming back through the House and the Senate in session.
Oh, I apologize, Representative Payton. I didn't understand the distinction you were making between during the interim period with Legislative Council versus the session. There's no question that the amendment, the constitutional amendment that was passed, I believe it was in 2014, ensures that DHS goes through legislative council during the interim period. So this doesn't really change that and is consistent with that. It sounds like you've got some concerns that are probably above my pay grade. I don't know. Do we have anybody from DHS here? Is Kelly Link here? Mr. Link, if
questions. Kelly Link, Legislative Intergovernmental Affairs. So could you describe what we're talking about when we say legislative action is required, what authority we're given DHS?
It would be legislative approval of rules. So let me kind of back up to Representative Love's question, then move forward to yours, and I think it would be a better understanding. So some of the savings we're talking about, and Representative Collins is exactly right, the provider-led entity bill that passed is not designed so much to cut and save as it is to keep from growth. However, if you remember in the last fall, we put forward a lot of rules having to do with the developmentally disabled. We put a soft cap on some of that. We changed, we reformed how behavioral health will be delivered and paid for in the state. This also monitors those savings to make sure that we're meeting those goals, because those goals were very specific of $835 million dollar savings over five years so this puts forward the Stevens group when they gave the report to the task force put forward kind of a dashboard of savings if you will representative and what this does it ensures that we're meeting that dashboard because some some legislators have concerned that the provider led would not save enough money which it may not but these other reforms should if we're not meeting them let's say that we need to hopefully not but if we're needed to move that soft cap down another $100 or whatever it is to make sure that we're meeting those goals that the Stevens Group and Task Force put forward, we would have to come before you, before the body, the legislative body through council to approve a rule change. And what it's doing is mandating that we move quickly. Because a rule change can take a long time to go out for public call, and the governor's office has a number of days to review it and all that. What it's saying is we would have to move quickly. We would have to bring it to you within 60 days to show the legislature we recognize the savings aren't happening as quickly as we hoped. Here's our plan for making them for catching up,
and we'd have to do that in 60 days. Well, if I could follow up. Yes, you may. I mean, I supported Representative Pilkington's bill and the idea, and I really like the idea of tracking to make sure the performance is there. But are you saying that when this refers to legislative action, you're only talking about the general rulemaking that has gone on in the past? Absolutely, yes, sir. Okay, thank you,
Mr. Chair. Thank you. Seeing no further questions, does anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? Representative Collins, you close for your bill? What's the pleasure, committee? Got a motion to do pass. Representative Coleman, Any discussion on the motion? I will say to this committee in discussion, I met with Representative Collins and DHS numerous times over this bill, and Representative Link did an awesome job while ago explaining, and that was exactly the way I understood this to work. And that last paragraph has to be there for them to have the ability to make a change that fast to make a difference in that savings. So I would say I totally agree with that being in the bill. So all those in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed. Thank you. Your bill has passed. Thank you very
I didn't mean it that way, Representative Collins. Representative Balz, are you in the room? What's your bill number, Representative Balz? 2015. House Bill
2015. you recognize to present. Thank you Mr. Chair and committee. Committee what we have here today is a emergency medical service personnel licensure interstate compact. This is not another license for anybody to have to get. What this simply does it doesn't allow anybody to cross state lines or you know come in and steal patients but in the event of an emergency This will allow personnel to be able to cross and service folks that are in need of it. The national compact that Arkansas will be joining has no fiscal impact to the state. Our surrounding states are doing this as well, and if we get in there early enough, we can have a seat on the governing board of this compact. There's nine other states that have done it, and George is actually voting on it this morning. It's a good piece of legislation, and I'll entertain any questions at this time. Any questions from the committee? Representative Ladyman,
adjoining states are in an agreement like this? Do you know? Every one of them. All of them? Yes. All right, thank you. Representative Meeks, you're recognized
Yes. All of them around us have. So Texas, Mississippi, all of them? Yes. All right, thank you, Mr. Chair. If we could, committee, can we limit our questions to not the same exact question, please? We have a lot of bills to run today. Seeing no further questions, anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? Are you closed for your bill, Representative? I am so closed. I got a motion due passed. Representative Love, any discussion on that motion? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Aye. Thank you. Your bill has passed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. I'm just messing with you. Representative Bentley is not in the room. Representative Wing, let's see how we do as
a transportation committee. You know, it involves the public financial health and the public transportation health, and that's why this bill is here. Happy to be here. This is House Bill 2273. What we're trying to do with this bill is give our Arkansas Highway Transportation Department an opportunity to utilize a different method for procurement that we believe will save the taxpayers money and also be able to get our projects done a little quicker. We all loved how the Broadway Bridge came across a little bit ahead of schedule. This is something that's similar to this. They just need statutory authority. I have a little show and tell here for you just to kind of demonstrate. On the top line is how we currently do it. You've got different projects starting with the programming and the preliminary drawings, the final drawings, and the bid process. Right here is a little black line. On the other side of the black line is the actual construction. What happens under the current method is those involved with the construction had no input on any of the previous processes. What can happen there is a lot of miscommunication, a lot of having to redo, and then you have overages. Those overages are passed on to the Highway and Transportation Department. We have to pay for that, or we have to decide to scrap the whole project and start all over again. The green is what we call the construction manager method. What that involves is someone from start to finish that handles the project. A lot more communication, a lot more transparency, a lot more speed, and then the benefit to the taxpayer is anything that happens underneath the guaranteed maximum price gets passed back to the state instead of being carried over as additional profit for the construction managers. And so that's kind of in a nutshell what happens there, and I've got one more for you because I was really active on the computer it shows what you see here is the blue line that goes down the further you go down in the project the less opportunity you have to be able to influence the final cost and then the red line shows you greater if you if you address it sooner you're able to influence cost a lot sooner and that saves the taxpayers money so with that I'm happy to take any questions I think you
your you know Well, it makes me feel familiar here. It does. It's transparency, collaboration, and a cost savings as well. Representative Lundstrom, you're recognized
concept, but that's what the engineers are for, is to make sure that's what engineers, the role that they have, civil engineers, that's the role they have played in the past. How is this different? Yeah, well, the engineers will still
play a role, but you'll have a construction manager that is coordinating all of this at the same time so that the people who are going to be working on the end will have input and knowledge of what's taking place at the beginning of the project. So the same engineers will still be involved, but what this does is allows more collaboration, which shortens the length of the project but also eliminates a lot of the questions that take place. Representative Payton. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So are we adding a layer management or are we substituting the layer management? Substituting. So what management's going out that this is replacing? Basically what you've got is you have manager here, passes off to manager here, passes off to manager here, and then at the end the construction manager has to do what all of these previous people have done. Now what you have is you've eliminated all of that, and you have one person who's coordinating everything. And if I could follow up? Yes, sir. Do we have an opinion from the highway department? They are all in favor of this. Yes, in fact, this is their bill. Are they going to be here to testify? He's in transportation right now. I just texted him. We're up. If you've got any specific questions, he'll be here. But, yeah, this is their bill. They're excited about this.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Love. I got a question. How does the bid process work on a project like this? Because in the past form, they have the project engineer, plans are drawn, Actually, I'm familiar with this. And then you look at those plans, the yield quantities, you know, on your yards, the dirt being moved and your asphalt and all that quantities. But if you start this at the beginning, none of that's there. So how do you, as a contractor, how would I know how to bid on a project like this?
Or how would that take place? Yeah, you've got a coordinator that's working through all of the process who understands what's going on. Any overages is going to be on him instead of the state. But you've got somebody who is coordinating everything from the very beginning of the design and layout is able to pick out flaws and some potential hurdles that somebody else might not have caught with the other method.
Yeah, I mean, he's going to be the one who coordinates just about everything through there. But you've got a much more seamless transition through all of this. And as we saw in that first one, there's a lot of overlap through there as well that helps them to be able to kind of manage the process a lot more
Thank you. And if this question's already been asked, you can just go ahead and cut me off. I'm trying to read and listen at the same time. But my question is on page four. It talks about the sum of the construction cost estimates shall not exceed $200 million. And then B, the construction cost of the first shall not exceed $70 million. Is there a reason for that particular cap that you've got in place? It's, and by the way, that's not any new money. That's just existing, you know, with existing projects. The cap is just because these projects are typically large projects. And they wanted to, this is a trial. We want to see if this can truly do what other states have done and saves taxpayers money. So we're capping it at a certain amount so that we don't just go crazy with large, much, much larger projects.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lunsford, are you recognized? You stated on page two that this was a pilot program. What's the time frame? I get the size of the
Yeah. Which is kind of a time frame in and of itself. So it shall terminate no later than June 30, 2020. Can you follow up, Mr. Chairman? You recognize? I'm still a little confused. A civil engineer is the one that normally manages these projects and puts out all the stuff that this is the list of things that we need. It seems like we're duplicating.
engineers are still involved with the process, but what you have now is somebody who's coordinating all of it rather than separate entities just doing their parts and then handing it off
question. Yes, Representative Wing, on page 5, it mentions that these reports shall send written notice identifying to the chair of the House Committee on Public Transportation and the Senate Committee on Transportation. Since this bill ran in public health, are you going to amend it so that Representative Wardlaw will get these written notices instead? Whatever Chairman Wardlaw wants, we'll do. I just
Chair. I just want to stay what I think this is, and then you tell me if I'm right. Okay. What I understand, and your charts kind of clarified this, but the way that process works now, the engineer would basically design this. The highway department would say, hey, we need to fix this road or go through this mountain or whatever. and the engineer would design that and go through a couple steps and then the contractor would bid on that but he'd look at it and say there is no way and that we can build this thing right yeah so with this new process the contractor is is there when the engineer and and i don't quite understand the bidding process but uh he's involved during the engineering process so if the engineer says you know make this thing 100 miles long and the contractor says there's no way in the blank that we can do this so that saves money yeah am I correct in my analysis it saves money and also
or anyone in the audience speak for against the bill represent wing you close for your close for the bill kind of motion do pass Representative Ladyman, any discussion
on the motion? Representative Payton, you're recognized for discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I wish you'd have given us a chance to co-sponsor this bill, but after a brief introduction here to this bill, I'm loving it, and I want to tell you why. Because back in the 60s, the Corps of Engineers decided to build several lakes on the White River watershed, and a man named Carl Garner that retired and died a couple years ago in Heber Springs, best I can figure by a quick overview of this bill, he basically was the type of manager that you're identifying here. He oversaw the projects for Will Shoals and Norfolk and Grisfree Lake from the real estate acquisition to the completion of the dams and saved the Corps of Engineers hundreds of millions of dollars in the 60s. I think this does have great potential for savings. And, again, I just wish I'd have been a co-sponsor.
I may need to explain. and this is the bill that I presented a couple of weeks ago, and I pulled it down and didn't have you vote on it because several people wanted other groups added besides physicians. This amendment, I got approval from the dentists, the nurses, and the chiropractors last week, so I did a member's own amendment, and then the optometrist came to me yesterday and said they would like to be included, so the amendment adds optometry.
Thank you. Seeing no questions on amendment, what's the pleasure, committee? Got a motion to do pass. Representative Branscombe. Any discussion on motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Opposed, say no. Ayes have it. Your bill has been amended, and you're welcome
to present your bill as amended. Thank you. And I won't go into a lot of depth with this because you've heard it all before. or I had originally written the bill for physicians, and it just says that if a physician, or now it says any provider, a physician, a dentist, a nurse, a chiropractor, or an optometrist, if they leave a practice, that the practice has to, if a patient calls in, they have to inform them where the provider has gone, where they are now, and give them that information. And when they get ready to leave the practice, they have to either send a notice to all of the patients that they're a provider for, or they have to give them a thumb drive or something with the names and addresses of all of their patients that they're a provider for to inform them. So I think y'all heard it all before, so.
for or against? seeing none uh you close for your bill representative ferguson i am i got motion do pass from representative gonzalez as amended hey thank you uh any discussion on this motion i would say that uh this is how the committee's supposed to work bill came to the committee she took it out amended it to the committee's uh pleasure and i appreciate that all those in favor say aye I suppose say no I have it your bill has passed thank you committee representative lady men are you ready to run your special order 1865
fluoridation program I ran a similar bill to this last session the bill that I ran called for a decision by the local water board or municipality on whether they wanted to participate in the fluoridation program or not that bill passed on the House floor with 70 votes they went to the Senate Public Health Committee where it died this bill is not the same bill it's different it's much more targeted it applies to a much smaller group of water systems the reason for that most of the larger water systems in the state have already implemented this program some systems however have not and they are indecisive on the implementation and that is causing some issues for these limited this limited group of water systems so So to help these few systems that are having difficulties implementing this program, this bill would allow these system boards to decide locally if they want to implement the program. Now in the state of Arkansas, there are three categories of water systems. They are, number one, public water authorities, number two, water districts, number three, municipal water systems. Arkansas there are 1065 water systems in these three groups this bill would apply to 14 water systems out of 1065 water systems would allow those 14 systems to make a local decision because of the situation that they are in the bill only covers the category of public water authorities that's one of the three categories that I mentioned and it only covers PWAs that serve between five thousand and twenty two thousand people and when I say people what does that mean that means water meters so these systems would have between five thousand and 22,000 meters on their system. There are 54 PWAs in Arkansas. That's the one category, one of the three that I talked about. There are 54 total PWAs in the state. So what this bill does is it gives 26% of the public water authorities local choice, 26% of that group, it gives 1.3% of all water systems in Arkansas the local choice option. That's 1.3% of the 1,065 systems in the state of Arkansas. and I have a list of the systems I won't read those but some of these 14 systems that would be affected by this bill have already implemented the system the authority the reason for the 5,000 22,000 the systems that are in trouble are in that 22,000 or less group the people that are serving 5,000 meters or less are already exempt from the fluoridation program so simply put this gives a few systems in Arkansas who are struggling with implementing this program it's not all cost Delta Dental has agreed to buy the equipment so it's not just that but they're struggling to get this put in and to implement it and I really believe I personally believe that we should give those boards at the local level the opportunity to vote on this and I'll just talk about a couple of things that I presented last session just so you know where I'm coming from on this I have a lot of experience in water treatment I ran two of the biggest industrial water treatment systems in the state one for general electric company one for Campbell soup company so I'm aware of what it takes I was also a mayor and I ran a water system than a wastewater system so it takes a lot of technical ability to run a treatment system to maintain chemicals at the level that you need to keep them at a lot of these rural water systems do not have that technical ability they do not have that training so they struggle with this sort of thing and for that reason I'd like to give them the opportunity to have a local vote so I'd be glad to take any questions representative Meeks you recognize for a question thank you mr. chair
representative lady man I'm not a legal expert by any means so I'm just hoping that um you can clarify but in under a it says 5 000 persons or more and then in b it says 22 000 users and so i want to make sure that they either both mean the same thing in the legal eyes or i mean this is so basically we know persons you know you could have five persons in a home Whereas users, could that mean that, you know, one meter covers a whole home? And so I want to make sure there's not a gap as far as, yeah.
According to BLR, I asked that question because it came up. And according to them, both of those terms mean meters. So if you're running a water system, you're not concerned about people. You don't even know how many people are in a house in many cases. So all you see are meters. so in both cases that's the only you can really count it is meters versus serving systems there are large like beaver water or one of the biggest systems in the state they serve 300,000 meters I believe it is but they also serve Fayetteville some cities so representative Ferguson you're recognize
know I'm a dentist so I think you all stand on this but my concern is I understood you know that you're trying to just involve those systems but the way I read the bill with the language that has been struck that it would allow all water systems not to fluoridate I I don't think it would just be limited to $22,000
certain line that you're seeing there? Well, just, yeah, just if you look at the, on page 1, lines 27 through 28, and then the language that's struck on the line on 11 through 13 in the back on the second page. I mean, the way I'm reading it, I
don't think it just limits it to 22. Well, the language that struck there on 27 through 28 would have opened this up to all systems, but that's been struck that was in the old bill and then what's added it says a public water authority that serves fewer than 22,000 users shall determine whether a public water authority will adjust so all others will not be able to determine if they adjust I mean
you're recognized for a question. I guess. Oh, I'm sorry. Go ahead. Thank you. So by striking company municipality, are they considered public water authorities, meaning would that would that catch them a part would you repeat that please fall as a follow-up to representative Ferguson's question when you strike out company corporation municipality are you gathering that definition up when you say public water authority meaning is a public water authority is it a company corporation municipality no let me use a visual aid here just to kind of give you an idea what I'm talking about here public water authority is a specific
that defined group that's that is this group here okay there's two there's two pages right that's public water authorities I didn't bring I've got a I have a second and a third spreadsheet there in my folder which I didn't bring down here with me that that has the other groups so all of these categories that are struck fall within these other two groups that I mentioned okay thank you this is okay this is the water districts this is about six pages okay it's a different category treatment plant systems this this is municipalities Now, private companies, well, they could fall in any of these categories. It doesn't determine, it does not designate who owns or operates those. There are POAs on these different lists. All right. Then a follow-up, Mr. Chair. Let me
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Ladyman, you alluded to that Delta Dental did provide funding for the systems, and so the implementation of this, and the reason why it's not being implemented in these, I guess, these multiple water systems. Can you tell me or associate some costs in regards to what are the additional costs that prevent them from implementing fully the water treatment?
well thank you for that question and that's a very good question and I don't want to get in the weeds too much here but I did mention that technical expertise is a big factor okay training you know these systems don't have engineers on site so that's a big factor that's not a cost related factor that's an operational factor as far as talking about cost it's my understanding and I could be mistaken on this but Delta Dental will provide all of the equipment at at no cost to the system if the system operator cannot afford to buy any of the equipment but there are maintenance costs there are chemical cost and i don't know delta might provide some of that chemical cost uh relief i'm not sure about that uh but there are ongoing operational costs plus there would be cost involved in training and retraining of operators so there are costs involved
there follow up Now, are operators also trained to perform additives in water in any other existence? As far as when you, it's my understanding that you treat water, so you're adding fluoride. Do we have any other additives to water that make sure that it's clean, it's palatable, it's potable, as they say, but also that require updated training? Yeah, and
again, that's a very good question. In Arkansas, there are two licenses. There's one for wastewater. There's one for potable water, as you just mentioned. It's different training, and you're required to recertify it. I hold both of those licenses. You're required to recertify every three years. One of mine's expired, but I'm not doing that anymore anyway. But anyway, it's a good question because you do have to recertify. The classes are different. In the water, potable water, the number of chemicals that you add, especially chemicals that could be poisonous or carcinogens, which fluoride could be poisonous at higher levels. When you add those kind of chemicals, it's critical. Now, at the wastewater treatment plants, you're adding a lot of those type of chemicals. but people are not drinking that water you know you that's not water that people are going to be drinking you're putting that into a creek or a river or a POTW depending on where you're discharging your treated water to but there are more there are harsher chemicals used in the wastewater treatment process more more more dangerous chemicals than in the potable water treatment system so it's not as the concentration of these chemicals chemicals is is not as critical in wastewater as it is in drinking water okay all right
I know you have a lot of experience and a lot of knowledge on this subject so I just like to ask you a couple of questions we live way out in the country and very rural and they tried to put a water system our farm was the last house on the system so when you get out in those very rural areas and there's a quarter of a mile or more between users and that water does not move very regularly is it possible for the fluoride to become concentrated in high spots or low spots in the line beyond what is healthy yes and
first off let me put a disclaimer I am NOT a doctor so I'm not in the medical field so this is not related to health but I am an engineer and I do know chemical treatment chemicals when you when you dispense when you put chemicals into a treatment system you You put them in through a metering pump at the point it leaves the source. And you're controlled. The concentration has to be, you're given a number and then a plus or minus, 5% or whatever that is, and you inject it at that point. So you're monitoring right there, and it's perfect. As that flows, the concentration changes. That's the way rivers clean up our drinking water. water flows through the river and it naturally cleans the water because these chemicals they need to drop out they known as deposits they come out a solution so the concentration changes so if you check at the treatment plant the concentration of phosphorus say and then you go a half mile down the pipe and you check that it's going to be a little bit different and in each chemical solid drops out of solution differently so the concentrations degrade at different rates if you follow what I'm saying so the flow will maintain that concentration if you have a constant flow if the flow there's parameters that change that would change the concentrations flow rate is one of those temperatures another one so those things affect that but you're absolutely right if you get into a pipe where it's the end of the line and there is no flow then And that chemical that remains could concentrate at that point. I'm not saying it does, but it could. The only way you know that for sure is
to analyze it. Well, and I appreciate your analysis there. So your bill specifically targets those small systems that would be more rural, like we're talking about, where the usage downstream is less likely to maintain the flow that would keep the chemicals stirred. And I'd just like to state for the committee, we had a horse poisoned by fluoridation, and we unhooked and got back in well water. Thank you. Well, your comment about them
systems seeing no further questions we have quite a few signed up to speak we'll get Dr. Nate Smith up first from the health department Dr. Smith if you would introduce yourself and your other guests and then you're recognized to speak against the bill Dr.
Thank you, sir. Dr. Nate Smith, State Health Officer and Director of the Arkansas Department of Health. I have with me Mr. Jeff Stone, our Chief Engineer at the Arkansas Department of Health, and Dr. Lindy Boland, who is our state public health dentist. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. I would like to speak against this bill, but first First I'd like to clarify that the systems that are covered or required to fluoridate have been provided all the resources and offered the technical assistance that they need to implement and the vast majority of them have implemented. The two that have not, it's been very clear in our communications with them, they've not implemented because they don't want to fluoridate. The idea of local choice, I understand that, and I wholeheartedly support that. This is a situation, though, where local choices have statewide consequences. Let me explain what I mean. Fluoridation is a very proven public health strategy for improving oral health, and at The recommended level of 0.7 parts per million of fluoride communities that have that level have half as many cavities in their children as those that don't. We've seen that here in Arkansas, comparing a community that fluoridated with a comparable community that didn't. That's been noted and published throughout the country. What that comes down to, though, is pain and suffering for children in communities that don't fluoridate, particularly low-income children who don't have as ready access to dental services. In a study in Louisiana, comparing fluoridated communities and non-fluoridated communities, found that low-income children were three times as likely to require dental care that required hospital operating rooms, so the most severe types of dental problems. And the overall costs for those low-income children were twice those in communities that fluoridated. In Arkansas, when those low-income children do have access to dental services, it's generally going to be covered by Medicaid. So a community choice has statewide consequences in terms of costs. It's estimated for every $1 invested in community fluoridation, it saves $38 in unnecessary dental costs. So what may save a local water operator a buck, you know, costs the state taxpayers $38. So this is a case where we have local choices have statewide consequences and I think that needs to be considered in evaluating this bill and whether this is one good for the public health of Arkansas and also whether it's good for the fiscal health of the state. Now in terms of some of the issues with the technical assistance of implementing this. Mr. Stone is our chief engineer and he can get down in the weeds as far as you would like. If there's questions about the merits of community fluoridation, Dr. Boland is able to talk down in the weeds on that as well. One thing I would like to mention is that once the fluoride is in solution, there have been some claims that there's differences between natural fluoride, which fluoride occurs naturally in all bodies of water. It's just a matter of concentration. The concentration is too high or the concentration is too low, it can have adverse health effects. If it's at the right concentration, then it's advantageous for overall health as well as oral health. There have been claims that there's natural fluoride and unnatural fluoride. Once fluoride dissolves in water and dissociates, it's the same fluoride ion. There's no difference between, there's no such thing as natural fluoride versus unnatural fluoride. It is the same element. The second is some of these chemicals that are used to fluoridate water Leather have been characterized as industrial waste. That's like characterizing leather as industrial waste from the beef industry. It's a product that is the result of a process. It has commercial value and it's required to meet certain standards. We have standards in place for those chemicals that ensure their safety and their composition. I'd open it up to questions. Attorney Michael. Representative Ferguson is recognized
for a question. I know before when we talked about this, we had talked about the fiscal impact to DHS, and you had some numbers at that time. Can you speak to the fiscal impact with the
Medicaid dollars and children in Florida area areas? There's a number of ways of defining those costs. One is in terms of prevention. It costs about a dollar a year to provide an individual with fluoridated water. So in their lifetime, maybe $70. To provide the same level of protection through, for example, fluoride varnish, you might have to do that, you know, every three months at a cost of, what, $19, $20? So huge difference in terms of what it takes to protect those children. Now when you're talking about treating kids, you know, with dental problems, you know, the cost of filling one cavity, treating one dental carry is more than the lifetime costs of providing fluoridated water to that individual. Representative Bentley, you're recognized for a
question. Dr. Smith, thank you for being here today. Just a quick question. Is there any known adverse effects to fluoride? I think purple have said it aggravates Crohn's and different things. So do we know of any validated issues that this high levels of fluoride can cause to adults or to other folks? If you could address that, I'd really appreciate it. Sure. The
short answer to that is no. Now, there's a lot of stuff out there on the Internet. There's false claims. There's fake science. But we have had over 70 years of experience with community water fluoridation. It's been implemented in over 40 countries. Currently, there are over 200 million Americans and over 2 million Arkansans that have been receiving fluoridated water. There are no medical conditions that I'm aware of as a physician, that have a recommendation not to drink fluoridated water at the recommended levels. Now, with any compound, if you exceed those levels, and there are some natural water sources that have much higher levels of fluoride than the .7 parts per million that's recommended, and those aren't used generally for drinking water sources in the United States, you know, Those high concentrations can have adverse health effects. They're noted first in the teeth and in the bones, but at the levels that we're talking about we've not noted any adverse health effects at the recommended 0.7 parts per million.
Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Smith, you cited some studies from, you know, I'm sure it takes many years to determine whether or not it's beneficial. And so the studies of people that grew up in the 60s, 70s, and 80s drinking fluoridated water, I assume, are the numbers that went into those studies that confirmed the positive effects of fluoridation. In the modern era, it seems that more and more people are drinking bottled water. And my understanding is taking a bath in fluoridated water doesn't help at all. So do you have any plans in the future going forward? I can't remember the last time I drew a glass of water out of the sink, and I think many people are buying filters to filter it, drinking bottled water. We don't have fluoride in our soda pops for sure. So do you have any plans going forward on how we would adjust? because it takes so many years before you're going to see a downturn in the positive results because people no longer get a glass of water out
of the sink. Actually, you're right. For the lifetime impact of community water fluoridation, it takes a lifetime. But the most profound effects are among young children. And we can measure cavity rates or dental carry rates and get results in much shorter periods of time. And our observations here in Arkansas are much more recent than what you're talking about. It's getting harder to do those studies because community water fluoridation is much more widely practiced than it was, you know, 50 years ago. But the findings have been consistent through the years, even up until relatively recently. And we can see those differences within just a few years in a community when we look at particularly the young children. And they're the ones who end up bearing the consequences most heavily for the decisions that are made by the water operators.
bottled water and filtered water and other sources? Now, I do have concerns about bottled water. One is that our standards for public water are actually higher than those for bottled water so the chemical and biological analysis of our public water systems which Mr. Stone oversees and can tell you about are actually higher than the FDA standards for bottled water so actually what we get out of our taps here in Arkansas is of higher quality than what you buy in the bottles, and my second concern is that by ounce bottled water actually ends up costing more than gasoline, and you have all these bottles that have to be dealt with somehow in a landfill or whatever, but although it's true that more people are drinking bottled water these days than they used to. Most of our low-income children are probably drinking most of their water from the tap, and when you cook, you know, when you prepare food, you know, we make Kool-Aid, you know, that's oftentimes usually out of tap water.
So you're not concerned with a trend away from it or making any preparations to provide fluoridation if society moves away from the tap water is that your follow-up representative
though honey right actually we are for children especially those who are on you know well water or our systems that don't fluoridate. We do have other ways that we can help with fluoride toothpaste. We have fluoride varnish that we're now able to offer in our local health units. The problem is that the cost is much, much higher than provided fluoridated water. As I mentioned, it's $19 per application for the fluoride varnish. It probably needs to be done about four times a year, that's a lot more than the buck a year for fluoridated water per person. Last time I checked, we are not a state with excess wealth to squander. Thank you, Mr. Dr.
Nate Smith, and thank you for your testimony. Thank you. Add chocolate. Chote. If you would, Mr. Chair, you're recognized. They're introduced to the committee and testify against
the bill. Thank you very much. My name is Ed Chote. I'm president and CEO of Delta Dental of Arkansas. I realize this is a local control issue, but I feel like this also puts our public health at risk. So my comments today will be speaking in favor of me. You get a little closer to that, Mike. Sorry, I apologize. Thank you. I'll be speaking today in favor of mandated fluoridation and in opposition to this bill. Community water fluoridation is one of the easiest, safest, and most reliable ways of improving the oral health of almost all Arkansans. As Dr. Smith indicated earlier, 75% of the population of the United States has access to optimally fluoridated water. The key term there is optimally. As was previously referenced, and I promise I'm not trying to repeat, I just want to emphasize fluoride is a naturally occurring mineral. Community water fluoridation process simply adds to a little bit additional fluoride to reach a safe and effective measure to help strengthen the enamel and protect a child or an adult against tooth decay. And as was previously stated, the optimal level is 0.7 parts per million. This is very, very diluted. Delta Dental supports community water fluoridation because it's central to our mission, which is to improve the oral health of all Arkansans. Community water fluoridation does improve oral health for everyone in our state, regardless of your income, your age, or your geographic location. And this is the most important part. It helps families that do not have easy access to preventive dentistry. That can come because of lack of money. It can come from lack of benefits. It can come from lack of transportation needs, education, understanding. You'd be surprised at the number of people who think baby teeth are disposable. These people need our help because, as was mentioned already, if these issues are not addressed, they end up in dental offices with a child in pain, and it costs everybody, especially the Medicaid program. We understand this is a controversial issue, but we're also willing to take a very strong stand when the public health and safety of our citizens is at risk, especially the children who need us most. Back in 2011, when this body was considering Act 197, thank you for passing that, you all were wanting to know what the cost would be, and if we were willing, Delta Dental was willing, to cover the reasonable cost for fluoride equipment in 34 water systems who would be affected by the bill. I asked at that time what that estimated cost would be, and I got a very thorough engineering-centered answer, which was our best guess is it's $500,000. I went to our board of directors. They approved it immediately. I said, in this room, in this chair, speaking to this body, and was asked by one of your colleagues in 2011, Mr. Cho, what if it costs more than a half million dollars? My answer was, we will pay whatever it costs. It's that important. Let's fast forward to 2017, just six years later. I'm very proud to tell you Delta Dental of Arkansas has spent just under $7 million on the reasonable cost for fluoride equipment and 30 water systems. Today, more than 600,000 Arkansans have got access to fluoridated water that didn't have it six years ago. Another statistic, I shared with you 75% of Americans have access to fluoridated water, 75%. In 2011, Arkansas was at 65%. Today, we're at 89%. Now, the key thing here is too often when it comes to health metrics, Arkansas finds itself below the average. Thanks to you, your courage, and your dedication to the health of Arkansans, we are now one of the top in the country. We are the envy of so many states in America. I know because my colleagues come to me and envy that the legislature that we have in Arkansas and wish it was in their state because you have the courage to do the right thing. So we believe fluoridation is important for all Arkansans, especially our children. Please vote no on this bill for the sake of our public health. With that, I'll be glad to answer any questions you might have. Seeing no
questions, thank you for your testimony. Thank you, sir. Excuse me. That's it. Seeing no further testimony anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill. Seeing none. Representative Ladyman, are you closed for your bill?
I'd like to close, yeah. Just like to make a few comments. to address the discussion here, and, again, I appreciate the discussion. I appreciate what Delta Dental has done, the commitment that they have made. That's a big commitment, and they should be commended for that. And I also commend our public health officials for wanting to do the best that they can for health. You know, I do not want to make this emotional. I want to keep it on the science and operations. That's what this discussion is about. You know, they made some statements from the viewpoint of their profession, which I'm sure are correct. But I have debated this chemical concentration issue many, many times with many other engineers and water plant operators, health people. It's a debatable issue, and there's not an exact answer on that. But I do believe that, let me just say this, you know, smoking, we all know that smoking is unhealthy and it's not good for you, but we don't ban it. You know, we don't tell people you cannot smoke. We try to convince them of that. So freedom is important. Freedom to make a choice of what you want to put in your body. That's what this is about. These people in these systems, they need to debate this at their level and decide what they want to do I appreciate the people that talked trying to educate that's great the statistics are good but those are general statistics we're talking local concentrated areas here just let me see if there's a couple of things let me talk a couple more things fluoride is naturally occurring so are most other chemicals strontium is a naturally occurring metal that you can find a lot of water that's used to make nuclear weapons all of these things are naturally occurring and they are the same chemical whether we're using it for treatment or whether we're getting out of water they're the same chemical so they're all naturally occurring but to say that fluoride has no adverse health effects is just an untrue statement because if you look at the SDS the safety sheet for fluoride there's any chemical has a safety data sheet which talks about the characteristics of that chemical if you will look at section 13 of the SDS for fluoride it will tell you how much fluoride it took to kill the lab animal that this chemical was tested on any test that's run has to be on that SDS probably any doctor would know that that's in there because he might need to refer to that if someone accidentally swallows a lot of fluoride so it is poison but again the people that spoke before were correct it's a matter of concentration and that's my point we cannot guarantee in some cases that the concentration is correct so again that's why you know I would ask you without being emotional you know I don't let me just say I want to protect our kids too I've got kids and I've got two young grandsons one's only three months old and I want to protect them too so I'm not opposed to that but i am for people having a say in what they put into their body and i that that's what this is all about that's what i'm here for and i would like to give those folks the opportunity to vote on this so i appreciate a good vote and can i make a motion do pass you sure you sure can thank you mr chair
i take a motion do pass representative ladyman any discussion on the Motion. Seeing none, all those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. I'm glad the rule of the ayes have it. I got two hands for a roll call. Mr. Price, if you would, call the roll.
and 3 noes your bill has failed. We're going to run the second special order was a companion bill and the Senate bill is here so there's no reason to run that House bill. I'm going to go to the end table and run that bill. Representative Hammer, are you going to join me?
Yes, ma'am. Okay, present the amendment, please. Madam Chair and the committee, the amendment addresses a typo. I believe it's on page two or three. I can't remember. It's at the beginning of
It's a one-word change. It's just one word. They changed dispensed to prescribed and dispensed. And what page is that on? Page, well, it's several places. Page 4, page 6, page 7. It just changes. Everywhere it says dispensed, they delete that and substitute prescribed and dispensed. That's all it does. The other amendments that you're probably familiar with were added in the Senate. It's just a word change. Okay. Representative Bentley? Okay. I have a motion to do pass on the amendment. Any discussion on the amendment? All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? Okay. Your amendment is passed. Please introduce the bill.
Committee, I'll start off with introducing this bill. This is Representative Hammers, the House sponsor. He and I started working on this bill about three weeks ago, maybe four weeks ago. There's been numerous hours put into this bill, numerous associations and people involved in compromise on this bill. We put all those amendments and all that compromise in the Senate bill, and that's why we decided to run it instead of that House bill this morning. This bill is pretty much, I could call it an agreed-upon bill now through numerous meetings in the governor's office and all the things we've had to do. But what it basically does, it requires physicians to check the prescription drug monitoring program under certain conditions, and you can look through the bill. There's a lot of exceptions in there. We also allowed, there's two exceptions that are very important. One, we allowed the Health Department Board to address other exceptions as this bill life goes on in case there's a bundlesome worry upon a provider. That exception has to have a three-quarter majority of counsel to be approved. The reason that bar is set so high is because we want to make sure that that exception meets what it is, and that is a bundlesome to the provider. The second one I want to draw your attention to is the one about electrical failure and technological failure. The reason that one is important is, Representative Ladyman, you're looking at me and you live in northeast Arkansas and ice storms happen, and we don't want to hold your physicians up being able to see patients. If they don't have electricity or if a line's cut on the highway where they don't have Internet, I want to make sure that the patients be able to be seen at any time possible. With that, I'll yield to Representative Hammer's comments, and then we'll take questions. Thank you. Madam
Chair, okay? Yes, sure. Go ahead. Thank you. One thing also to point out as far as getting the exception to the rule, it's not only three-fourths of the members present, but it's also stipulated in the law when a quorum is present. That would help for many manipulation from occurring whenever a change occurs, so I think that's an important feature to note, and that's on page six, line eight. And then the only other thing I would say is I'd like to compliment Representative Warlaw. This has been a three- or four-week battle, and everybody, for the best interest of the citizens of the state of Arkansas, have come together to make sure that this is a bill that I think is going to be beneficial for everybody. The other thing I believe that happens also is produces the report card, produces a report card that the Department of Health is going to be entrusted with the responsibility, And what that report card will do is, I think after 6 or 12 months, Representative Ward-Law could correct me, it will produce a report card as far as the physicians or prescribers, and that's a key word, prescribers, as far as the number of Schedule II drugs and above that they're prescribing. What that will do is force the bad actors to the top and kind of float them to the top where it's easy to identify and perhaps Representative Ward-Law can take it deeper on that. I would be careful with the
word bad actor because we have a lot of doctors out there that prescribe what they think their patients need, but they have no idea what their peers are doing. And what this report card would do, and I hate to use the word report card because we're not grading doctors. We're helping doctors. What this piece of paper will do is show them it will take the top 100 prescribers every quarter, and it's going to send them a sheet, and it's going to have their peers on it. And when I say their peers for the committee's concern, If they're an oncologist, they're going to see other oncologists on their form. If they're a family practice, they're going to see family practitioners on their form. If they're a nurse practitioner, they're going to see what other nurse practitioners in the same field of study is seeing. And because of that, it gives them a baseline to see what other practitioners are doing at the same patients. They should be seeing the same type patients. So if you've got a doctor that's prescribing a lot of hydrocodone versus another one in his field, he's going to see that and you'll find that in states where they've done this they've seen a huge decrease because that peer interaction and what's going to happen is every quarter that's going to go out with a letter from the health department it's going to give them a warning hey you're reaching a high limit at the end of a year if that practitioner or health care provider however you want to word it because it could be a numerous it could be a dentist it could be a veterinarian it could be anybody um what's going to happen is if they haven't a heed to that warning they're going to be sent to the medical board to the to the veterinarian board to the dental board for uh for action for investigation and uh at that point they'll their file will be open and they'll be looked at the reason we waited for a year i didn't know this i learned this through this through this four-week deal um every time they open that file at the board perspective board it puts a black mark on that health care provider and we didn't want to do that because a lot of these people are not intentionally over prescribing and uh so that's why we left it at the health department for that first year is to give them a chance to correct that behavior so that before that investigation starts they've had a fair shot at looking at it and and getting it corrected and i'll be happy to answer any questions. Madam Chair?
before we vote, Scott has taken away from his profession to be here. If we could allow him a few minutes at appropriate time, I think it'll be something that'll kind of emphasize the importance and Chief Lane might have a comment to share if we could
you, Madam Chair. My name is Scott Durhoff, and I live in Maumelle, Arkansas. I had a 20-year-old son named William Christian Durhoff. William went to Catholic High School here in Little Rock. He had a 3.7 GPA, scored at 27 on his ACT and he was president of this community service club. Will spent his weekends volunteering to help out, set up church services and whatever role he needed to play in society to help those in need. That's what William did. We lost our son October 15th of 2016 of a heroin overdose my son's narcotic use was less than four months my son formed an addiction at the University of Arkansas after pledging a fraternity where there was permissive illicit prescription narcotics abuse the boys were getting their narcotics that were legally prescribed to patients but not being used for the intended purpose of the prescription they were being sold to make money my son was probably the most beautiful person that you would ever meet he was always getting the most unselfish person you would ever meet and because what I believe is that his life was taken for a purpose to make our a world better, we formed the William Christian Durock Memorial Foundation, and now we go on college campuses. We've been to Arkansas State University and the University of Arkansas, and we empower students to speak up and speak out, which is our awareness campaign, so that other students know that it's okay. we formed the foundation and we started willswork.org and speak up speak out because that's the only thing that I could do as a father that lost a son and my wife and William's brother but I'm a health care professional also I have almost 30 years of clinical practice I see patients every day I'm in physical therapy and we see patients with pain every single day we know in health care in 2017 that information is power and I would challenge that any legitimate provider that doesn't look at the record of treatment is not doing what they were trained to do so that's the reason why I'm in so much favor of this bill because I can assure you that it will stop the supply to be so readily available that kids' lives will be saved. And, you know, it may be someone in
you. Introduce yourself. Thank you, Madam Chair and members of the committee. Thank you very much for allowing us to speak today. On a national perspective, in 2015, for a one-year total in 2015, 52,560 people died of overdose, 65% of them, over 33,000 people, died of opiate prescription or heroin overdose. Every 25 minutes, every 25 minutes in our nation, a child is born because a birth or a child is born to a birth mother who is under the abuse of opiates, prescription, and that child is born within withdrawal and their survivability rate is low. So how it equates to Arkansas in that same period of time, it's approximately 13.6 persons per every 100,000 persons in Arkansas have died in 2015 in that time period. The state crime lab tells us that one out of four autopsies, no matter what the death, the manner of death is, have prescription drugs on board. And in 2015, 225 bodies that were examined under autopsy under the suspicion of overdose, every one of them had prescription drugs on board. This bill mandates prescribers to check the PDMP, the Prescription Drug Monitoring Program, which is a database that was established and went operational in the state of Arkansas in 2013. I have the privilege of serving on that advisory board. In the 18 states that mandate in those conditions, they see a reduction in their death rates to prescription overdose 25%, and emergency room visitations for overdoses 26%. You can just think of the impact of what that would be if we just did it. Currently, the prescription drug monitoring program under the current law is voluntary to prescribers to use it and have anywhere from a 40% to 50% usage rate in using that PDMP. The PDMP in this bill is not meant to demonize prescribers, not in any account. It's just to give them good information for making a good prescribing decision. And when we find that when that happens, we see those death rates reduce and those hospitalization rates reduced to this effect. Currently the cost of the PDMP to the state of Arkansas with a line item budget and grants total $360,000. So over the period of time over a million dollars have been spent establishing this database for this purpose. Last legislative session afforded delegate authority to give the prescribers the ability to ease their strain in seeking this information to make good prescribing decisions. With that, respectively, I not only speak for the Arkansas Chiefs of Police, but I also speak for the Sheriff's Association, the Arkansas State Police, and the State Crime Lab in this effort to bring this forward and hopefully for your endorsement on this. Thank you. Representative Payton, you have a question?
Thank you, Madam Chair. We know we've got a problem, and I do believe this bill has at least a partial solution and is a great idea. My concerns are with the logistics of it. I have a business in Clinton, Arkansas, right on Highway 65, a quarter of a mile from the hospital on the opposite side of the road. I assure you they write more prescriptions than I sell automobiles. but I've had to turn customers away and tell them come back in a couple of hours or the next day to sign them out because our internet was down. I subscribe to internet over the phone system and internet over the cable system so that I can alternate back and forth to try to cover the dead periods. And still we have multiple dead periods a week that last for 15 minutes to two or three hours. So how will the logistics work on this when a doctor is without live Internet? Representative Payton, that's an awesome question,
and I felt the same way when I started working on this. And that's the reason we went with the health department on the report at the end, because no matter if they – and that's the reason that other exemptions in there that I explained in my first part where I told you there was two that were very important. and one is if the Internet's down. We don't want to hinder doctors being able to see their patients and prescribe to their patients. So we put the report in there from the health department so that when they don't report and they don't check, we're going to catch over prescribing on the backside. So it doesn't matter whether they have Internet at the time. If they're not able to check the PMP and they're prescribing to somebody that's doctor shopping, we should be able to find that in that report from the health department on the backside every quarter. And every pharmacist puts that data in when that person fills that prescription. So that's how you catch that
to check? No, sir. Okay, thank you. Representative Blav, you have a question? Thank you, Madam Chair. I think some of what I was wondering was answered with Representative Payton's question. Now, let me get a better understanding now. All doctors, they subscribe to the PCMP. Is that? Yes, it would affect all prescribers. But do all prescribers, I guess I'm trying to understand, if they're putting in information, all prescribers and doctors? No, sir, that's what I was saying in
Representative Payton's question and my answer. The pharmacist actually entered all the data in when the prescription is filled. Okay. Representative Boyd, do you want to help on that?
So right now, currently, at least once a week, pharmacies have to upload this data to the prescription drug monitoring program or veterinarians because veterinarians dispense also. There is a paper process. Obviously, that's cumbersome and slower if you submit it by paper, but right now there is a mandate on pharmacies and a mandate on veterinarians to upload the data. Does that help you there? I did. Thank you.
So in my follow-up then, how easy is it for a prescriber or for a doctor to check the system? Representative Love, it's interesting you said that. When
this all came about, I had no idea about this bill, and I was kind of told from some people I knew to go look at it and get a hint on it. And I went and sat down and looked up four patients in the PMP. It takes about seven and a half minutes to check a patient, which was a concern. And that's the reason you'll find that Chief Lane and his group have been agreeable to some exceptions that are listed within the bill. There's hospice is totally exempted. Nursing facilities are exempted. different emergency situations are exempted because of that time and but when that patient leaves the nurse the hospital when that patient leaves the nursing home if they take a prescription they're going to be checked so there's a reason those exemptions are there and it's because of what you just outlined all right thank you thank you representative makes you recognized Thank you, Madam Chair.
My concern is not in the short term, because I think this helps to solve some problems in the short term, but my question is in the long term, when you're talking about three or four years down the road, because these physicians will be getting these quarterly reports, and hopefully through those quarterly reports, they'll be more efficient in the way that they're prescribing, they'll maybe try other methods or whatever the case may be. But after three or four years, what you're hoping to see is that physicians are getting to the point of where they're making better decisions as far as prescribing and whatever the case may be, at that point, you should hopefully be where physicians need to be, but you're still going to produce this list of the top ten or whatever prescribers. At that point, are we going to be putting pressure on physicians to not prescribe these medications where they should be prescribing because they don't want to be at the top of this list maybe they're in an area that just naturally you know where people come in with more pain or more uh diagnosis so if you could please alleviate the concern that's taken
into effect and that's that's why when i explained that a while ago i told you that we used the fields of study like a a cancer doctor and a pain doctor are are going to prescribe more than your family practitioners so when you look at that when you when we say the top 100 it's not just pulling the top 100 off of a deck it's looked at across their field of study so and that's kind of how that's addressed representative meeks
you have a follow-up go ahead yeah i mean it still goes on i understand that point but even among cancer doctors or family doctors or whatever they may look at it they may be hey you know what i've taken all the advice i think that i'm doing what i'm supposed to be doing you know my patients the area i'm in or whatever um you know whether it's northwest southwest arkansas or whatever they're still in the top 10 among family doctors they're still in the top 10 among cancer patient or cancer doctors and they don't think you know there might be a couple of things but they're still in the top 10 are we going to be penalizing them for doing what they think is
is right no sir right now the pmp the medical board i know i know about the medical board I don't know about any of the rest of them but the medical board requests the top five every two months from the PMP advisory committee right now which is the health department I'll fill all the way out and they look at those top five that doesn't mean that they actually investigate those top five every time but they look at those numbers and that's all that's going to happen after that one year after you get down the road they're going to look at those and if they can determine that there's nothing going on and there's nothing illegal or crazy they're not going to go and open a file on them so they're they have that's why the medical board nurse practitioner board those people are made up of respectable people in those fields of study because they look at that really close before they open an investigation they take that very serious you have
to say thank you guys so much for bringing this bill forward it's very very important thank you um did we not last session our representative warlaw passed legislation that would allow a nurse to go into the pm the prescriptive dogmary program look at it before the physician sees so really could cut down on time so if the nurse could go in her pre you know when she's checking the patient in and getting over she'd go look that report up for the physician so that time could be spent by her and not the physician in the room is that not correct it's
even worded as a designee so it can even be a receptionist in the doctor's office as long as that doctor requires them to be a designee. Yes ma'am that is true. Representative Love you had another question. Thank
you Madam Chair. Quick question because I was just thinking about this. Now this report that you're going to publish on these doctors is that report info liable? No sir. Okay all right
thank you. Fixed that for you. Representative Meeks you have a follow-up. Yeah, and this is basically page six, page seven, where it talks about the board, and, of course, it's talking about each individual board, so pomegranate rules, limiting the amount of Schedule 2 in our context that may be dispensed by licensees of the board. Can you go into further detail on that as far as what you plan on limiting or how, I mean, is it going to be, you know,
if they're seeing there's a problem? It's not. The bill doesn't limit any prescribing. It just helps eliminate overprescribing by the way of showing peers, physicians as their peers, how they're proceeding through their practice and having them check to make sure these patients aren't doctor shopping or pharmacy shopping. That's all the bill does. Okay, thank you. If someone comes in and says my back's hurting or comes in with a stab wound, let's use something more acute. somebody comes in with a stab wound in the arm and they need pain meds you can check the pmp and you can see that they've had pain meds somewhere in the past but you're going to go ahead and give them pain meds for that acute injury because i mean that's the right thing to do for that patient at that time someone walks into the dentist office with a decaying tooth you're not going to penalize them because they got something a month ahead they're still going to get that pain medicine so I would tell you that acute injuries are still going to be taken care of on a day-to-day basis across the state regardless of when they check they're just going
to have to check to see that if I may add to that too there was some question when we sat down with the medical board and the different boards that were involved of their understanding of their authority on what they could and couldn't do so they wanted to make it in this bill to give them understanding of the ability of what they could do so they could move forward in regulating themselves in their respective to their professions on what those prescribing guidelines could be. Thank you.
I'm representing Representative Hamer since he's not asking too many questions today. You're doing a good job of it, thank you. Because everything that we do in this bill is good, but at the same point we've also got to be cognizant of the fact that if you're limiting the amount of prescription drugs here, you potentially are going to force people or have people that will now go to other illegal drugs in order to, you know, for their pain. So what steps, because again, when we pass this bill, it's going to be great, but then you're going to have people that are going to want to go to other drugs, maybe even marijuana or LSD or whatever, for their drug issues. So are you all going to take that into account? Are there plans to take a look at those types of things as well? I know that may be kind of out of scope of this bill, but I just wanted to see if you all have been thinking about that particular process in forming this bill.
Representative Meeks, that was one of my questions, so I might add to the question before he answers it. I know, like in Kentucky and other states where they have passed these mandates, Kentucky had a 30% increase in heroin. So are we just trading one problem for another more serious problem? And, I mean, I just read an article last week where Kentucky had 52 overdoses on heroin laced with fentanyl. So, you know, I do think we have to be careful about mandating something so strictly that we, you know, create a bigger
problem. Members of the committee, I'd like to address that if I would. You know, Arkansas already has a heroin problem. We've already seen significant increases in law enforcement in heroin in Arkansas. Nine out of ten heroin users are let into it because of their addiction to prescription drugs. So as long as we continue to build the base of people that we're addicting to opioids, the greater increase of heroin will come affect anyway, but like it is already because on the street, a milligram of a certain dose is worth a dollar. So if you have 30 milligrams of hydrocodone, it's $30. And those $30, some people are five, 10, 15 pill a day habit. So you can imagine where that monetary need, which leads to crime, theft, different things that are affecting our community is. And to be able to trade that off for a $10 bag of heroin is an easy tradeoff when you can't make those means to get those prescription drugs. So it's kind of sometimes the chicken or the egg. And yeah, we do have a big problem, but being able to deal from a law enforcement perspective with illicit drugs is a lot easier task for us than it is the prescription drugs because prescription drugs is already well accepted within our everyday life. And that's the reason we have that problem. Did you
just start with the first one, and then if you want me to, I'll go to the second one. First of all, Representative Wardlaw, Representative Hammer, thank you for bringing this up. I hope you understand prescription drug abuse is a concern. I'm a pharmacist. I think everybody knows that, and I think we have to work hard. First thing I did is presented a resolution on encouraging law enforcement and medical team to work together to address this issue so I appreciate the that you bring this forward so first question I have is will medical marijuana be reported in this I mean does this bill have anything to do with medical marijuana so medical marijuana is not not going to be reported in this it is not okay may I have a follow-up yes follow-up and I apologize that I was not here I was presenting bills and two other committees and that's why I was not here so you might have already addressed this but the one thing I did want to know is what are the penalties for not following this mandate so if I'm a physician or I'm a dentist I'm an optometrist I mean am I going to go to jail is this a felony for not checking it is this a misdemeanor is this does the board have pre-determined fines what and then how are we going to rectify that are you going to run a report between this doctor's patients and with the input from the pharmacy and start identifying prescribers that are not following the mandate
too. Thank you. The penalty in the bill is left up to the prospective board of practice. So it's left up to the pharmacy board, the dental board, the medical board, those boards to pursue disciplinary action as they see fit.
to the sponsors of the bill, I want to say thank you for bringing this forward because this is a really, really important issue. And I have a few questions, but what you have to understand about opioid abuse and about doctors prescribing is opioid abuse is amenable to things where we have precise policies, where we target patterns of abuse, where we look for perpetrators of abuse. And the best part about this bill, if there's any good part about it, is the part about the report card to the physician. Physicians will respond to peer pressure. They will do that, and they will change their patterns of behavior. But some of the problems I have with the bill, though, is I think it goes too far. I think there's a little bit of a shotgun approach, and there's going to be some unintended consequences to this bill and one we addressed earlier about people will switch to heroin. Narcotics abusers are going to switch to heroin. They're going to die of heroin overdose and fentanyl overdose on the street. They're going to do that. But the thing that really concerns me more is this is an unfunded mandate to physicians. Seven minutes, it takes time for somebody, and you've got to pay somebody to do that. In a practice, I have a surgical practice. I would like to see in this bill that if there were a minimal amount of pain medicine prescribed, that those people did not have to check it. In other words, one of the reasons we can send patients home from surgery, I understand that we have in here prescription during surgery and during recovery from surgery in the hospital, but one of the reasons they can go home is because we can give them pain medicine to go home with. Years ago, they had to stay in the hospital for three or four days to take IV pain medicine. So I wish there were more of that. I think this is going to impede the practice of medicine and impede. It's going to be difficult on family practice people to monitor some of this. Do you have any comments, or is there any way we could include that? I think that's a real problem with it.
Representative McGee, the reason we put the health department in there is because that concern came up from the medical society. that concern came up from other boards out there. And we put the health department in there to watch this real close and to send those exemptions through council for a vote that caused that burdensome on providers. And I think the health department, I trust them to do their job and figure out what those exemptions should be. And they're going to work with those boards. They're going to work with the medical side. They're going to work with the dentist. They're going to work with all those people to come to us with a package in council that will address any of those concerns from any of the physicians, whether it be the eye surgeons or whoever. So I feel more than confident that the health department will do their job and bring that forth to us, and they're very willing. They're not against us. They're willing to do that work and come to us with that. Mr. Brick was in every meeting I've been in. Thank
seeing no further questions from the committee I think there's someone signed up to speak for that's not at the end of the table I can't read the name Scott something you know oh that's you okay I don't have anyone signed up to speak for or against what's the desire of the committee I do pass from Representative Bentley. Any discussion on the motion? Okay, everyone for, say aye. Everyone opposed? I'll say the ayes have it. Okay, thank you, Representative Wardlow. Thank you, and I thank
you're recognized to present your bill as amended okay members this basically puts what was in rule on RSPMI moratorium it puts it in a statute, worked with DHS on the bill. They also requested the emergency clause. They're going through transformation right now, and so they're wanting this moratorium to be in place. And I've worked with the providing community. They're fine with it, too. Any questions from the committee? Representative Peel,
continue to recognize for a question. Motion at the proper time. Do noted, 206. Senate Bill 206. Anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? seeing none senator you close for your bill yes i would appreciate a good vote thank you i got a motion do pass represent pilkin any discussion on a motion seeing none all those in favor say aye all those opposed eyes have it congratulations your bill has passed you recognize what's the number of your second one 420 okay
you recognize present senate bill 420 yes so this is also with the prescription drug monitoring program and this is with the department of Health, and I have Ann Purvis here if you have questions, but what this does is it allows that the department may provide this information to public or private entities for statistical research or educational purposes, and they also may provide it to insurance carriers, which is on the second part of the bill. So worked with everybody involved, and simple bill. This allows the information that we were in the previous bill that you just presented on the evaluations that you spoke of, this is enabling legislation for that. That is right. Any questions from the committee?
Seeing none, anyone in the audience speak for or against the bill? What's the pleasure, committee? I've got a motion due pass. Representative Boyd, any discussion on the motion? All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Congratulations. And you just passed two
it. You're recognized to present 2150. Okay. And you got an amendment, correct? I do have an amendment. Present your amendment first, please. Amendment 1 to 2150. What it does is it adds some language. I think it's on the tablets. It's coming to the tablet. It's not quite
there yet. The Arkansas Hunger Relief Alliance is going to put up a $10,000 grant for educational classes, teach people about healthy eating and how to prepare healthy foods. Do you have any questions on the amendment?
now amended. Please present your bill as amended. Okay. House Bill 2150 kind of modifies the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program. What it's doing is it's going to create an incentive program to encourage benefit receivers to eat healthier foods such as fruits and vegetables instead of candy, Coke, soda pop, things of that nature. Any
question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The last couple of lines say that they shall seek a waiver from the United States Department of Agriculture to implement the section. What are
we doing that requires a waiver? Any time any modifications are made, we have to get a waiver, whether it's anything having to do with the federal program. I've got someone here from the Hunger Relief Alliance, if you'd like to bring them up. I don't think
further questions, anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? Seeing none, are you closed for your bill, Representative Penzo? I'm closed. What's the pleasure, committee? I got a motion to do pass. Representative Love, any discussion on the motion? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations, bill. It's passed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Committee? Representative Meeks, you got a Senate bill? Yes, sir.
You want one? You got one? I don't have my phone. It's Senate bill 227. you recognize thank you community this is just a simple bill that helps to bring Arkansas in line with the new federal requirements as far as the American Disabilities Act as it regards to service animals and dogs and so with that I'll be glad to take any questions seeing no questions is there
Anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? I got a motion due pass. Representative Pilkington, any discussion on that motion? All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? Aye's have it. Congratulations, your bill's passed. Representative Warren, let's go. Senate Bill 351. Representative
Bentley, you're next. This is in keeping with the last couple of bills. this bill specifically adds language to address cosmetology instructor training to be an instructor you must have at least 480 hours of training secondly a person employed in a school to instruct students in the school shall be licensed in you give us a number of that bill I'm sorry 351 351 SB 351 secondly a person employed in a school to instruct students and in the school shall be licensed in one of the specific areas and must have received not less than eight hours of additional training in an instructor's training seminar or continuing education course certified by the Department of Health. Those are the only two changes to be made. Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
say that I actually have no idea how it will protect. I am just presenting the bill for the hours that they requested, and this was what they wanted, felt
for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Basically, above when you're adding the eight hours, it says, has passed an instructor's examination given by the Department of Health. If they're able to pass a test, an instructor's test given by the Department of Health, then why would they need the extra eight hours of training?
no further questions, anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? Seeing none, you close for your bill? I would appreciate a good vote. I have a motion. I would rather not. But you can. I'd like to make a motion. Do not pass. As a proper motion, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? I always have it your bill is failed thank you representative Bentley you recognize that's bad representative you recognize
present your bill thank you chairman Wilkenhouse committee members at HB 2174 a very simple bill that will simplify things uh cut down time for uh nurses aides that are traveling actually this is a d uh excuse me it just allows the uh nursing homes that are training cna to group folks together so we can get uh aids out sooner and simpler um get training easier so it's just agreed upon bill no one opposition to
the committee Seeing no questions, anyone of y'all didn't speak for or against the bill? Got a motion from Representative Pilkington to do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations, the bill passed. You got a second bill,
in the room. You'll be next. SB 668. This is a good, it's a bill for small business owners and businesses across the state. What this does is it gets Arkansas in line with states all around us. Every state around us has this bill in effect except for us. It will not allow a county or a city to set a minimum wage different than the state. It keeps the minimum wage where it's already in law that the state should set it, just codifies it. So we're getting in line with the states around us and making sure that somebody doesn't think that they could set a minimum wage limit for a county or a city. I really wouldn't want to see Perry County decide that they could set the wage for my employees different other than the state has. So that's what the bill does. Any questions?
Representative Love, you recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Now, at first I wasn't going to question the bill, but then, so are you saying if the city of Little Rock decides to set a minimum wage higher than the state, you're trying to prevent that? Yes, sir. Is that what this bill would prevent? Yes, sir. Follow up, Mr. Chair. You recognize. Would that not be a form of local rule? If the city of Little Rock voted to set a minimum wage for itself higher than the state, then, I mean, aren't we invading the local rule? There are
Lundstuhl, you're recognized for a question. Just a point of clarification. Yes. We aren't extending or telling somebody in Springdale how to run their business and do a minimum wage. Absolutely not.
Okay. We're just saying the city of Springdale can't tell you what the minimum wage is at your company. I like that. Instead of the state level and the state minimum wage is what it will be across the state. Is
a city doing that before. No, at this point it has not, but sometimes it's good to prevent a problem. So every other state has done that. I figure we'd be smart, like all the states around us, and do the same.
Seeing no further questions, anyone of y'all didn't speak for or against? Mr. Paul Colbert, you're a recognized speaker. You didn't tell me which way. I'll speak for it. Okay. Thank you,
Ms. Bentley, for bringing this bill. I think it's a good idea. We have some other preemption statutes on the books as well. There's one for gun rights. And I think this is just a good bill to keep cities from getting too big for the britches. Thank you. All
right. Seeing no one else speak for or against the bill, what's the pleasure, committee? I've got a motion due passed by Representative McCullough. Any discussion on motion? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Ayes have it. Your bill has passed. You're recognized to present your last bill. Thank you, Chairman. I
appreciate your allowing me to do this last bill. Senate Bill 361. What's this number again? Senate Bill 361. 361. I bring to you a great bill that's going to cut down on regulations and costs for patients in Arkansas and for businesses as well. We have citizens in Arkansas that do home peritoneal dialysis. This bill would amend the Pharmacy Practice Act to remove the additional requirement of a second licensed pharmacist to review the order and to place the second label on each box prior to delivery. What happens is a physician here will write an order for the peritoneal dialysis. It's kind of this set parameters for, does everybody know what peritoneal dialysis is? We good with that? Our kidneys are going out, and some folks can do their own dialysis at home. Sorry. I forget everybody's not in the medical field. Apologize. Okay. So prescription rights, the order goes to the company to get filled. It gets filled in a pharmacy place in North Carolina. That specific prescription is filled exactly. It's labeled with that person's name and their address and where it's going to go to, and it gets shipped to Memphis, and right now we have to get a second pharmacist to place a second label with the same name and the same address and all that to verify that what's on that box is already sealed up. They don't even open it up, so it's already sealed and labeled with that person's name, and we're requiring a second pharmacist to look at the same thing that was already checked out by a previous pharmacist in North Carolina. We're trying to get away with the second redundant label and cut down on some time and cost for companies. there is no opposition to the bill they worked collaborative with the Arkansas Pharmacists Association Arkansas State Board of Pharmacy to this bill Representative Meech should recognize for a question
thank you Mr. Chair it talks about on line 15 I think on page 2 it says the board shall retain oversight of all other drugs for home peritoneal kidney dialysis how does that correspond with the bill that we just passed with the prescription drug monitoring program? Peritone and dialysis does
not come under anything. It's not opioid or Schedule 2 at all. It's just fluids to cleanse your system like your kidneys do when they're working. Thank you for the clarification.
Excuse me. Excuse me. I'm sorry. Has the amendment been caught in gross in the bill? Do we know, Phil, on this bill? I'm sorry before we don't we don't have an amendment okay so we're believing it's already in the bill it's already been in the bill sorry for the confusion just want to make sure
before we do the final vote motion do pass representative Meeks any discussion on motion seeing none all those in favor say aye aye all those opposed ayes have it your bill has passed thank you for your Representative Gates, let's go. We're all hungry, so let's go. You're recognized to present House Bill, I'm not sure of the number. 1894. 1894. I, too,
am hungry and have been waiting all morning, and I appreciate y'all's indulgence. there's a lot of confusion what this bill does this bill is about our records it's about our vital records vital records are are things that are passed down from generation to generation it's how we figure genealogy it's how we figure medical records it's how we determining kind of the roots of our society. What this bill does and what this bill doesn't do seems to have confusion. This bill does not go to try to redirect how people live their lifestyle and how they choose to identify. What this bill does say is that our state records on birth certificates are issued at birth and birth certificates, thus the title birth certificates have to do with your genetic code, how you're born. Our birth certificates will have either male or female, and that will be filled in at the time of birth. There are a few genetic disorders that at birth makes it very difficult to determine that. And there's one that's not included on there that I will be hoping to get amended if this goes through, on the Senate end, and that our Surgeon General contacted me today on. And that was one where it appears a child has a genetic disorder where they appear to be female, but during puberty that it's determined that they're male. So outside of that and outside of the few exclusions where there are genetic disorders,
long, and it says outside of a disorder that we're going to issue a birth certificate. it it's going to say male or female and if they have a genetic disorder then most parents are trying if they have a child with a disorder most of them are trying to decide how they're going to raise that child and most of the time they try to do that earlier rather than later so that child can start early in life identifying how they're going to be raised and this bill says by the fifth birthday that they are going parents will on those disorders will determine what that's going to be and then it says after that that we won't change birth certificates outside of those exclusions that we don't change birth certificates now let's discuss the practicalities here's the practicalities there's a fiery car wreck on i-40 the body is burned beyond recognition bad fire we send that bad that body to the crime lab the crime lab is going to determine is it a male or female why because there's a genetic code every one of us are born with the genetic code and what this bill does it says our birth certificates will reflect our genetic code a hundred years from now when they dig up my body they will be able to tell my genetic code. They cannot tell how I chose to identify myself. You know, if tomorrow I decide I want to get a loan and I can get a better loan if I'm a 67-year-old Hispanic female, do I then get to decide that I can change what my birth certificate says? So all this says is our birth certificate is going to reflect what our biological makeup is. And, you know, we have other we have other issues right now what happens in our prison system if a guy wakes up he's raped a lot of women he wakes up one day and says I've decided that I want my birth certificate to say that I'm female are we going to now house him at the female prison so we don't discriminate him yes we have to do we put him in a cell all by himself we can't do that that's discrimination how many babies will we birth out of our prisons there are some things that need to be set down in concrete and this is one of those things by which we as a society say this is a birth certificate. If we need other identifiers, if we need other certificates, let's do that. But people have, a society has a right to determine what we are going to recognize, and a birth certificate should be exactly that. It's an identifier of what someone is at birth, and that's what this bill does. I'll be happy to take any questions. Representative Ferguson is recognized for a question. Well, first
Just because something has been lawful doesn't mean it doesn't need to be changed. We had slavery for how long? Did it need to be changed? Yes. Should it have ever been allowed to happen? No. There is a time where we as a society say things need to change, and sometimes they come up. Sometimes we ponder things. We pass legislation every year, and two or four years or ten years later, we decide, you know what, that wasn't such a good idea. There are unintended consequences. I believe that we see identifiers right now. I have some Christian youth camps in my district, and when they're hiring a seventh-grade girls' cabin counselor, they have a right to know whether the person they're hiring is the person that they think they're hiring. They have that right. And so this allows us to go back to some authenticity as to the person is who they say they are.
And this is one of those identifiers. Well, I mean, I guess my question to you, most of these people that start physical transformation are adults. And don't you think it's more awkward that they have physically changed from male to look like female and all of a sudden it says they're male on their driver's license? I think that's even more confusing legally than the very few situations you said about if somebody dies. I mean, I think, I mean, yeah, I mean, don't you think that's legally more confusing to have their driver's license identify them differently than they look or that they physically transformed? Well, that's why I went
back when I originally said if we need another certificate, maybe we need an identity certificate that we issue, that somebody wants to change their identity, let them do that. And I'm not opposed to that. But, you know, and back to your first part of your question, is we actually do have minors that are having operations, and they're going through, they're starting that process as early as, according to our local newspaper, as a freshman in high school. You know, those parents are allowed to, in Arkansas, they're allowed to make those decisions, life-altering decisions for their children. This doesn't change that. This doesn't prevent any of that. That just says our vital records are, we don't just change our vital records simply because somebody chooses to change their vital records.
you, Mr. Chair. Lifelong vital records are the official records in legal proceedings. Is that correct? That is my understanding. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You recognize. All other records, including driver's licenses, can be changed at the discretion as far as whether they choose to have them or don't have them as it currently is, whereas the vital record is the official record recognized by the state of Arkansas. Is that correct? I can't speak to those, but I can speak to records.
From what I've been able to look at, there are a lot of records that would go back in history when we're trying to determine genealogy, when we're trying to determine just historical facts. We go back to yearbooks. Oftentimes when we're trying to find somebody, we go back to yearbooks. Are we going to require that our schools go back and change all their records to meet the new birth certificate? How often do we change those certificates? Do we have a limit on those certificates? Do we have a limit if I decide I don't like being Caucasian? Maybe I want to be, can I change my race? if I go, you know, if I do something cosmetically, does that change my genetic makeup? And, you know, when they can do a genetic test to tell me exactly what percentage, and they can even tell me by my chromosomes what my eye color is. And geneticists all over the country, this is how we determine our forensics, is we go back to these basic things that no matter what I desire, there are facts, and my DNA is something that's saddened. I worked on this at
two minutes per speaker okay i'll do it two minutes per speaker that's a proper motion all those in favor say aye all those opposed ayes have it we do have quite a few signed up uh representative gates if you will i will uh start calling them up We have Lucas Siegel, not in the room anymore. Ray Nelson. Mr. Price will alert you on the time limits. You'll see him hold his fingers up, and if you would introduce yourself for the committee, and you're recognized to
speak against the bill. Okay. My name is Rae Nelson. I am 25 years old. I was born and raised in Palm Bluff, Arkansas. I am a U.S. Navy veteran. I am a registered nurse, and I am a transgender woman, which means that I was assigned male at birth, although I now identify as female. I must be honest and say that HB 1894 equates to being state-sanctioned discrimination against transgender people like me. We are being unfairly targeted for existing as who we are and not as who people think we should be. I must ask, do you know a transgender person? Have you had a conversation with someone, sat down and had a meal with one of us, truly tried to understand us and who we are instead of relying on antiquated assumptions and media portrayals? I have always known that I was a woman, but I have a tremendous amount of fear and anxiety surrounding a male having to remain on my birth certificate. I fear that like so many transgender women that have come before me, I will be referred to as a male in life and in death. Current statistics show a life expectancy of 35 for trans-generated women of color due to violence. If I die in the next 10 years, I want to be buried and remembered for the same woman I am today. Not being able to change our birth certificate harms us in a number of ways. It invalidates our identities and potentially denies access to housing, employment, health care, and other legal documents like passports. We already experience an extremely high amount of discrimination and harassment and have no protection, since Arkansas has no hate crime legislation protecting transgender people. Not having documents that match our gender identity puts us at risk for further discrimination and violence. I don't believe this bill is necessary. There is absolutely no reason that justifies further vilifying a group of people that are already vulnerable to violence and harassment that leads to the transgender population experiencing higher rates of assault, murder, and suicide than the rest of the general public. If this bill passes, we as transgender Arkansans are essentially being told that we are second-class citizens that don't... That's right. That's the end of your time. All right.
be brief y'all and everybody introduce yourself for the committee my name is Zachary Miller I am a transgender man which means that I was assigned female at birth and I now identify as a man I'm a little older than going to look I'm 33 I'm also a veteran I served in the US Army for seven years and I now serve on the board of our tech which is Arkansas transgender equality coalition currently at the moment I'm studying for my certification and personal training I hope to help people with chronic ill chronic pain through corrective exercise and also help the transgender community build the bodies that we desire. After I get this certification, I will be searching for a job. If this bill passes when a potential employer goes to do a background check on me, because I have not currently changed my birth certificate, they will see female on my birth certificate even though they know they see me as male. That will out me as being transgender. Currently, there's no legislation that protects me in employment as a transgender person so this this bill would would make me susceptible to just to discrimination I just want to thank the legislators who already see this bill as a problem and thank you for your support to the legislators currently considering this bill I kindly ask you to reconsider thank you we take a question representative
hammer you recognize for a question I would in under the federal laws of sex discrimination in the scenario that you presented would you not be covered under the law or why would you not be covered under the law if you were discriminated against because you applied for a job that
sorry my My name is Michael Lauro. Yes, sir. I work for the state. I have another job, though. I'm also a private attorney that represents transgender people. I'm not speaking on behalf of the state. I'm speaking personally from my experience as an attorney on behalf of my clients, my friends and colleagues who are transgender. I would like to just make a couple points that the sponsor made regarding genealogical research. I have in front of me the rules and regulations for the administration of vital records. This was promulgated by the Arkansas State Board of Health. There are provisions in here for how to amend a vital record such as the birth certificate. It lays out who can do it, how you do it, methods of amending, and it also allows for disclosure of records. One of the sections refers that family members doing genealogical research will be able to access the records. It also states that substituted certificates shall be issued and originals shall be moved to a special file. So my understanding is these regulations allow family members to do genealogical research and access those original files. It also provides for, I think Representative Hammer mentioned vital records of the official records of law. It also allows for authorized representatives including attorneys, physicians, funeral directors and other authorized agents of individuals who have had their certificates changed to access those records. So I think access to original records that have sort of the sex at birth, those records are still available. The person now has a document that is congruent with the rest of their identity documents. So I would also like to make a point that the current law, as Representative Ferguson pointed out, has been around for a long time. We haven't had any problems with it. I represent clients every month going through this process, and we haven't had any problems with this law. I would like to say that we're also in line with southern states, except for Tennessee. Tennessee has a law like this. We're in line with Louisiana, Texas, Missouri, Mississippi, Georgia, Alabama. All those states have very similar laws. Sorry, that's the end of your
name is Ken Clark. I am a straight Christian 20-year married male with two sons. I am the owner of Chenal Family Therapy. I am a transplant business owner from the West Coast. I chose this state over three others for what was a moderate environment politically as well as a great environment for business. My business will pay over a million dollars in wages this year to its employees as well as spend another million dollars in the local market. I believe this is severely bad for our ability as a state to attract business, for me as a business to conduct business. When you look at what happened in North Carolina with the passage of that bill and the economic backlash, a similar bill passed in Tennessee. The American Counseling Association pulled their annual convention from Tennessee and moved it to another state. Bills like this paint us as a discriminatory state in a state where we already have a hard time attracting both business dollars as well as trained professionals. This will set us back. This will make us not a place of choice. Even now, as I look to expand my business over the next five years into other states, one of the primary drivers of which southern states we choose to go to will be which states are most embracing of all people. We will stay away from Tennessee as a business that is growing at a 50% annual rate because of their discriminatory statutes. We will look to other states that have progressive people who embrace middle-of-the-road economic policy that embraces all people. Any questions?
Representative Pilkington. Yes, please. So if I understand this correctly, you are stating that if we require that the biological sex of someone to be remain on their birth certificate that that will somehow make you want to move your business out of arkansas no i'm saying it's going
to have a tough time attracting business i chose between three different states one of the things that i evaluated and where i moved my family was the political environment that we were moving into we moved here in 2007 2008 the environment was moderate it swung more toward these anti-discriminatory type discriminatory statutes as we look at other states to open new uh branches of our business that will be a determining factor on where we choose to go and where we place our investment dollars that's the end of your political environment in those states that concludes uh people on the sign up is
My name is Paul Calvert. I think the state should indeed recognize various different aspects of human reality. The state recognizes human realities that have been around for far longer than government, and I think it's a good thing, such as parent-child relationship and marriage. And I think the state really should recognize these real human relationships and human aspects. They're just part of biology, basically. Male and female determination is a pretty basic aspect of human reality. I understand that sometimes sex is mistaken at birth due to physical abnormalities, and I think Representative Gates has said that he wants to actually add that in so that at a later date if that's determined there was a mistake made, even when it comes out of puberty, that it could be fixed. I think that's a good idea. I think that's about all I have to say on that. I think it's a good idea for the state to go ahead and recognize proper sex and not cater to those who wish to change that artificially. I appreciate your time. Thank you.
This bill doesn't control people's lifestyles. It doesn't control their choices. What this bill says is that we, as the determiners of what our birth certificates are supposed to look like, and how we're going to deal with them. This isn't about a choice. This is about what are the biological facts. I'm asking that we set that our biological facts at birth remain that and we stay consistent with those things. And I think the threat of financial backlash, how we set our policies is a bad way to go down because then at the end of this table, all somebody has to do is come and say, I might move my business, Therefore, you need to vote my way. This is a policy that I think we need to establish, and I don't think we need to move just like a surveyor's mark. Just because I don't like the results of the survey, I don't have the right by law to go pick up that survey and go move it 10 foot over into my neighbor's yard. It is one of those solid things that we should be able to count on, as I think a birth certificate should be.
on that motion representative ferguson i'm gonna recognize you for discussion well i i i understand that it's difficult sometimes for us to understand things that are rare and that are different and they're you know the wanting to change your gender is not just a choice it is a a biological thing, and this law has been in place for a long time. It's never been a problem. There are other situations where the birth certificate has changed. I just went through the adoption bill with many of you, and they issued a new birth certificate when they're adopted, so it's not unusual. And for them to do that, it actually requires that they have been physically changed and that they get a court order to do it. So it's not a willy-nilly process that's necessarily easy. And I do think it sets them up for discrimination and certainly for awkward situations when you have to have a birth certificate to get these other legal documents. I just think this bill is intentionally
hurtful and mean. Representative Pilkington. I have some issues with this bill. I appreciate what you're doing Mickey with this I really do but he's used proper excuse me yes I'm sorry but on page two line to the biological sex I'm sorry page one I have a lot right here but it's at age five you can change change the the gender I think waiting till they're five I mean if puberty will show that there is a change in gender why are we making that five and not making it 13 or 14 or 15 or maybe even 16 and letting them make that determination you're not allowed in discussion emotion you're not I guess I'm just
I'll be glad to address that I think a representative gates it touched on it at least in the The very fact is that for the vast majority of people, you know what the genetic code says. You know whether they're male or female at birth. There are some, like he said, that it might be up to five years old where they may not know. And at that point, you know, because of testing or whatever the case would be, they know whether they're male or female. He said that there was another thing that he discovered that sometimes it's up to age 13. So in those circumstances, he's willing to amend the bill. and he said that he would amend it for the older age on the Senate side to take those into account, that there are some genetic defects, that there might be some other medical condition or whatever where they might not be able to make that determination until that certain age. So I'm thankful that Representative Gates was willing to amend it to take those other medical conditions into account. See no further discussion.
With nine yes votes and four no votes, your bill has failed, Representative Gates. Thank you. Representative Hammer, let's go on House Bill 22, I'm not sure of the number, 2230. Yes, Representative Bentley, I'm going to recognize you for
about it's a bill representative bit only run a few minutes ago that had an amendment but we had 30 something amendments up here and it wasn't found in time so we're going to expunge the vote apply the amendment and it's on the table try
your indulgence on this. The amendment was found for the peritoneal dialysis bill that amended it so the pharmacy board was totally on board, so I just need to file this bill as amended, and I appreciate a good vote. I got a motion to pass
as amended. Thank you for your indulgence. Okay, so we have the bill amended for the peritoneal dialysis, and I'd appreciate it. Do pass on this bill as amended.
Anybody in the audience speak for or against this bill as amended? Seeing none, I have a motion to do pass. Representative Love, all those in favor say aye. Aye. Those opposed. Your bill has passed as amended. Representative Hammer, you recognize it as presented as amended.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The bill before you, which is House Bill 2230, deals with circulating nurses in the operating room. And just to kind of keep it short and brief, this is the person that is the one consistent person that's in the room all the time that you're having surgery. If you would, they are the one that makes sure that everybody cooperating within the room knows what's going on. So in the event somebody had to leave, they could come back in. And, Mr. Chair, with latitude, Ms. Danielle Glover has flown all the way in from Colorado to speak to the essential nature of this bill. I'd like to yield the mic to her because I think she can do it pretty quick. If you would
Thank you. My name is Danielle Glover, and I am the State Government Affairs Manager for the Association of Perioperative Registered Nurses. Perioperative nurses are operating room nurses, and that includes those that are RN circulators. AORN represents the interests of perioperative nurses by providing evidence-based research, education, standards, and practice resources to enable optimal outcomes in the EOR. AORN strongly supports this bill because it addresses a gap that you currently have in your code, and it puts patient safety first. The American Nurses Association and AORN both agree that one perioperative registered nurse circulator should be dedicated to each patient undergoing a surgical procedure for the entire interoperative experience. We've worked with the hospital association, and they are in support of this, and the medical society is neutral on this. This legislation, by the way, is very, very similar to how over 30 other states address the importance of having the RN circulator in the OR for the duration of the procedure. I just want to make sure that you understand a little bit about what the RN circulator does because I think it'll help you realize why so many states have decided to include this and address it and why there's so many organizations that support it. RN circulators, they are the patient advocate when a patient is under anesthesia and they cannot speak for themselves so they're the ones that are vulnerable and it is the perioperative nurse that has done the pre-op interview getting information that maybe the surgeon didn't get the first time around or something that the that the patient shares with somebody right before they go into the surgery and then they set up the operating room to ensure that the proper equipment is there and the instruments are available this could change depending on what their conversation is with the RN and let me tell you that sometimes patients will disclose a little bit more right before they're ready to go under anesthesia than maybe they did before, and they might have some other questions. They position the patient to make sure there's no long-term damage done. And one of the key things that they do is they lead the surgical team in key safety protocols. One that they do is called a timeout. They work with the surgeons and the entire team to make sure that this is the right procedure, this is the right person, and this is the right site. Let's make sure this is John Doe, and that we're actually operating on his left arm, and that's what we're supposed to be doing. They confirm medications and blood products, and they ensure there's no breaches in sterility. And one of their other important roles is ensuring that you don't leave the operating room with any retained surgical items, sponges, instruments, et cetera. So they improve patient safety and outcomes and need to be there immediately available to intervene if something like this were to happen, whether it's a surgical site infection, medication error, wrong site, wrong patient, wrong procedure surgeries, or retained surgical items. This bill is about quality care and ensuring patients are safe during surgery and that they have somebody in the room with them at all times. If y'all have ever had surgery or if you have a loved one that has, you may not have realized who or what went into keeping that you or them safe. So I would kindly ask the committee to support this bill. Representative
Mr. Chair. So I am a surgeon and I operate and I don't know of any hospital in the state that doesn't have a circulating RN in the operating room. So why do we need the bill? I mean, their policies are already there. Every time I do a surgery in the operating room, they're circulating RN. And then to follow up with that, what's your comment to that? And second is, you said a minute ago, one person responsible for the entire experience. Would that mean that one person is responsible for the preoperative, perioperative experience and then take them to the operating room? I don't know how that'll work. I mean, right now, that's not practical. Not in the hospital that
are a lot of hospitals that are doing this and the hospital association has even said that they're doing this. What we are addressing is not the issue of, who can be the RN or who can be the circulating nurse, but the fact is there are reports that are out there where nurses are being asked to go between two different rooms. And this is about ensuring that nurses have something that they can reference because as you said, they should be doing this and there are facilities that are doing this most of the time. They shouldn't be put in a compromising position. It's a best practice in hospitals. Again, we've heard reports where maybe they aren't doing this and consistency is essential in the operating room. Anytime we can create consistency, whether it's an urban, rural area, it is gonna be better for the patient. As far as addressing the second part of your question, which was are they going to be there, this is ensuring that there is a circulating nurse that is in the room at all times. So part of it will be the pre-op, part of it is when they're in the operating room, so that there's not somebody that's leaving and they don't have somebody that's looking out for the patient. So you will have somebody that is there the entire time, it just has to be a circulating nurse. the person that will stay for the duration of the procedure but if they need to for example if it's a 10 hour procedure and they need to change out they can have another nurse come in and relieve them of that duty but it has to be another circulating nurse to make sure there's always somebody that's kept making sure the sponges are collected that's making sure that the instruments that are there and they're making sure that somebody's standing up for the patient and that they are aware of their needs
okay follow up real quick you recognize. So you got go back to the perioperative period. So in the hospital that I operate in, the patient comes in to have surgery and they have a perioperative nurse at RN that works that patient up. She has nothing to do with going back to the operating room. Nothing. So what you said a minute ago is that the circulating nurse would be responsible for all the perioperative treatment but also pre-operative treatment. And so the circulating nurse in our hospital, when the hospital circulating RA and his response for the patient, when they pick them up from pre-op until they take them back to post-op. So, I mean, I still don't, it kind of confuses me that what you said. Let me try to clarify that. I'm
sorry. So this would ensure that there is in the operating room that there is somebody there for the duration of the procedure. Your facility may differ in some of the other facilities as far as who does the pre-op and who does not. Some places they do both, but specifically to this legislation, it's not stating that they have to be there. It is stating just in the operating room that they would have to be there the whole time. Does
that help? I understand. I understand. Thank you. I myself have a little bit of a concern, and maybe Representative Hammer or yourself can alleviate my concern, but I'm one that's kind of against over-regulation, and it seems like we're putting a law out there, and Representative McGee just brought this to my attention when I was listening to his question. I mean, I hate to put a law out there that we're already taking care of through hospital regulations, so can you explain to me, and I hate to repeat that, Representative Meeks, I know you're going to call me out on this, but I'm very concerned that we're going to put a regulation out there on top of people that already have a regulation that they're abiding by. I'm going to take a run at it and then get Danielle to come in. And specifically kind of name me out a problem that's occurred in this state that's caused you to come here and want to do this.
I'll address the issue if there's a specific problem. I'm going to let Danielle speak to that, or I don't know if I'm going to put her in an awkward spot that Jodi Ann might want to come and identify or speak to because this is not opposed by the Hospital Association. But what this does specifically is that in a situation where this would occur, and say in the event that you might have the luxury in working in a hospital that does have the benefit of all the resources, what about the hospitals or what about the nurse that's put in the awkward position of saying or being said to by somebody in authority in that surgery room, look, I need you to leave and go over here and do this. What is that nurse supposed to do? And what if that hospital board doesn't back that nurse up? Some of it boils down to the question of liability, and what this bill does is eliminate that gap that in the question there is a liability that it would not fall upon this person so it does bring the requirement the mandate if you want to use that word that somebody who's going to be 100 percent in charge of that patient care if a discipline leaves that room that this is one person that represents the interest of the patient some are doing it now but in some cases it may not occur may or may not be occurring this just adds that extra layer of protection to make sure that by law somebody is supposed to be there and it's not necessarily dictated to by an individual hospital's policy. And I'll let Danielle clean up whatever I messed up or add to it.
That is correct. And we have heard of cases. I want to be clear, this is not an everyday occurrence where people are being asked to go between two different rooms, but there have been cases here specifically in Arkansas that our nurses have expressed where they've been put into a compromising position when they've been asked to leave the room. So it is most of the time something that is happening but this is addressing the intent of what you guys currently have that does state that you have a circulating nurse who is an RN it's just adding a little bit of clarification around that they're there for the duration of the procedure and it therefore is addressing the concerns that have been addressed here or have been brought up here in Arkansas regarding the the going between two different rooms any questions from the committee
representative lunchroom I'm a little confused if this was something that needed to get done because hospitals are paying the insurance why they don't already do this and my understanding is a lot do because it saves them time and money I'm not sure we should be in the middle of this I mean this I get it we do a lot of nursing stuff in here I get all that but hospitals are already addressing this and if they aren't they're the ones paying the insurance and getting sued and all that good stuff
i would appeal back to the situation of yes if you want to look at it from that perspective that would be one but what about the patient and what about who represents the patient and make sure that the quality is care there for the patient from the beginning to the end i would i would take a guess that probably the vast majority of hospitals do this. I work for a hospital. I feel the vast majority of hospitals do this, but what about in the case of one that may not do this, or what about one where you have a nurse that's in a position of liability and responsibility for that patient, and they are directed and said, you know what, I need you to go here and do this. Now, I think there is an exemption put in the law that says that in case of emergency situations, that was one thing that was placed in there to make sure that in the case of a natural disaster where a facility is overwhelmed, reality happens. But in the day-to-day practices, the reason that this is there is to protect that nurse who is looked at and expected to be the person that's front-line representing them, but if they are put in a position that they are asked or told, you need to go to that room, I don't care what, that nurse needs some coverage. How much does it happen? I don't know that I could give you substantial evidence as to the percentage of time that it happens but the reality of it as happens as just given testimony I think does show that it's there we want to give coverage to everybody else why wouldn't we want to give coverage to the very the person who is most who is responsible for that care from from the beginning to the end I want to know when I'm put under the anesthesia I want to know when I wake up if something goes wrong I don't want to know who to blame or who to hold responsible I want to know somebody's watching over me all the way through and not leave it necessarily to an independent policy as much as I would that the law says this is what's supposed to be done. Gives that
nurse some protection. Thank you Representative Hammer. Thank you. That leads me to one more question and I'm being very politically correct here but where did this bill come from? Did somebody come to you and say they had this problem? I mean I'm having a hard time understanding where this bill So, I mean, where did you, I guess, dream this up at is what
I make a closing comment? Yes, ma'am. Thank you, Mr. Chair. members I know the perception may be over regulation and that that is the fear that we have it's only over regulation in the event that a hospital doesn't have this policy in place it would be perceived only perhaps as over regulation if you are the nurse that's put in that awkward position and you want to know you've got the state of Arkansas has your back it's only overregulation if you're the patient that when the last thing you hear is the anesthesiologist say look at the fish swim up in the ceiling tile that you know you can be put put that sounds terrible that you can be put under anesthesia and know that somebody is going to be the constant person in that room and if something goes wrong that there's somebody be held accountable the one thing I would like to point out is that in the states that have used this that there's been the decrease in infection, medication errors, wrong site, wrong patient, wrong procedure surgeries, that can't help but lead to lower insurance costs for the hospitals. Whether that gets translated back to your insurance policy or not, or less lawsuits or not, I can't say, but this is the one safeguard that we can put in place. It's only over-regulation in that it helps protect where people choose not to do the right thing. Thank you, and I appreciate a good vote. As a member, I would make a motion do pass. That's a proper motion.
I have a motion to do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. A rule to no is have it. Your bill has failed, Representative Hammer. Don't call that baby if you don't mind, please. I got two hands. Mr. Price, if you would call the roll. Yes, sir. no we are not it's a good thing we got the ball we won't be in this that's fine it don't matter Mr.
Chair Wardlawn? No. With seven yeses, your bill has failed. Representative Gonzalez, you got House Bill 2160, is that right? You recognize to present House Bill 2160. Thank you, Mr. Chair. There is an
It's on the tablet, yeah. Well, we'll run the amendment, and then we'll do the bill. We got a motion on amendment. I got a motion. Representative McCulloch on the amendment. All those in favor, say aye. All those opposed? We are still here, people, okay? I don't
Yeah, there was a different amendment. Hold on, we'll find that for you. All right, if you've only seen the stack of amendments over here. I just paper it. No, this is 1818, Phil. He needs an amendment for 2160. this is house bill 1818 he's presenting 2160 yeah it looks like it looks like it is already engrossed okay you can present the bill as amended okay thank you
um i tried not to bring y'all another nursing bill it's actually not it's i know it has a nurse in it but it's not a nursing bill it's more fire training yeah i know i'm sorry um what this is is your volunteer firemen are now required to have 16 hours of continuing education every year to keep up their certification to be volunteer firemen. What happens is a lot of those calls that are taken up by your volunteer fire departments are first responder calls. So we're adding in that any training for emergency medical workers or nurses that are ER trained, So those people do continuing ed as well, and it would allow those continuing ed hours to apply to the fire training hours. That's all it is. You got a question for Representative Payton? I do. He said he wasn't bringing a nurse's bill, but I see right in the bill that it says provided to nurses. I tried to get them taken out, but they said. Thank you. Any other questions? Seeing
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members. My name is Roger Smith. I represent the State Firefighters, the State Fire Chiefs Association. We have discussed this bill with the director of the Fire Academy. The 16 hours of training that is required by our volunteer departments, the primary purpose of that training is to make sure that the firefighters, it's a safety issue about their lives. It isn't so much about using equipment. If we allow this particular training to take the place of the required 16 hours of fire training these people would in essence be on a department where they don't do any training aren't required to do any of the necessary training that relates to safety and protection so if there were a need to recognize some time some of the continuing ed hours I don't think that would be objectionable but nobody has come to the fire services protection board that actually establish the required training hours so in the present form in this bill's present form we would have to speak against the bill we certainly value those first responders but the way the bill is written it basically undermines the required 16
a question yeah thank you you might answer this question because fire departments aren't my thing but I did get a text from my fire chief saying to please oppose this bill and uh 21-22 because it interferes with their act 833 monies is that correct yes ma'am interfere with them being able to distribute those monies the the distribution
of their act 833 money is contingent upon them meeting all of that training requirement every year. They must do that. Each department has got to make sure that their staff all complete the 16 hours. And I don't know how else to put this, but we care more about the firefighter than we do about the property. You know, you can always replace a chicken house that might burn down or even a home, but you can't replace a firefighter. So the required training is really about making sure we do everything we can to protect the lives of those and to undermine that is really
money is that correct that is possible yes thank you representative meeks thank you and again I don't understand all this either so I'm trying to get a little bit more information on it it seems to me that if you have nurses and emergency medical workers that are going out on these trucks and that is their primary job is to treat those folks who need medical attention you know I know in Conway most of their calls are actually going out for you know car wrecks or whatever it's not actually fires why wouldn't you allow them to use their hours to get the medical training or updates or whatever that they need instead of having to do something something else.
Representative Meeks, there really is no standard whatsoever for medical training that relates to the fire service training. There isn't anything there. The fact that they are nurses, ER techs, and so forth is very important. The fire departments welcome them there and would like to have them. They're a resource. They're an asset. But they still need to do the basic training because not every incident involves medical issues. Sometimes it's just pure fire and that type of thing. So maintaining that training standard is important. Could it be modified in the future to recognize some of that time? That's possible, but that needs to go back to the Fire Services Protection Board so they can look at who really is responsible for setting a standard of training for first responders. and right now I'm not sure there is any real standard of training for first responders. Okay, so as a follow-up
then, what you're saying is that based on this bill, if it passes, they could actually use, I guess, all 16 hours on medical and nothing on fire or it could be all 16 hours on fire-related things and nothing on medical? Is that the way that you understand it? Representative
Meeks, I'm going to be kind of blunt. I'm not sure that it's clear that it says that it all can be used or part of it can be used. It's kind of ambiguous, so that's an area that needs to be made clearer if this is going to be something you all consider. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Seeing no further questions, anyone else in the
audience speak for or against? Seeing none, are you closed for your bill, Representative Gonzalez? No, I'm not, actually. this bill has been out there for a while I
the amendment filled in and this is the first I have heard of any objection to it it would have been nice if they had come to me before now and said hey we could work on fixing this I guess I would like an opportunity to do that I want to get this right it was never my intention to undermine act 833 money or the fire training um you know if we need to amend this to apply just to the first responders i'm more than willing to do that so i'll uh i'll withdraw it and and work on it
thank you representative that's a proper motion we stand no further business we stand adjourned oh oh hold on committee let's pull back in i need to representative saving has sat here this whole time. It's got a little bitty non-controversial bill. It does not have any nurses in it. This bill is for Representative Davis and Representative Savion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And again, I hate to
present a bill when everybody was wanting to get out of here. I haven't eaten lunch either. This is a bill that I'm kind of doing with and really for Representative Davis. And of course, he's not here because of the service for his father. And it creates a task force, which I know everybody's tired of, but it's specifically to study non-municipal domestic sewage treatment works, and this stems from some issues that are going on where cities are trying to determine how to provide this kind of domestic sewage treatment to areas that are in expansion areas around cities, so we're all dealing with them kind of where this kind of real estate development and expansion is taking place. There's nothing in the bill that would require any expenditure of money. It's sort of an agreed-upon bill, again, because people are trying to sort through these issues. There are obviously a lot of interest on both sides of this issue from the cities and municipalities as well as from the real estate developers and others, and so we're just asking to create this task force to study it further. It has representation from industry as well as from the state, ADEQ and others, and again, I'd be glad to answer any questions, but it should be simple, straightforward, and as the chairman said, not controversial. Seeing
no questions, anyone in the audience speak for or against? I've got a motion to do pass by Representative Branscombe. Seeing no discussion on a motion, all those in favor?
Representative Pilkington. I hate to speak against Representative Saban and Representative Davis, but we keep on creating more and more task force, and I feel like the reason we have committees is to come and address these issues. So I will be voting against this bill.
recognized. And I understand Representative Helkington. I mean, when I first came, we had all these task force that really were nonfunctional and did nothing. And I do think we need to get rid of those that are doing nothing. But some of them, I think, have a real function that addresses a specific issue that probably is not easily addressed in subcommittee. So I have a little bit different feeling than some people. I know we have followed this sewage treatment plant problem for a long time, and I do
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - Wednesday, March 22, 2017
Number Sponsor Subtitle
HB1865 Ladyman TO AMEND THE STATEWIDE FLUORIDATION PROGRAM; AND TO PROVIDE LOCAL CONTROL OVER FLUORIDE LEVELS.
31:42 - 1:15:05114 segments11 speakers
Representative Jack Ladyman introduced HB1865, explaining that it would grant local decision-making to 14 public water authorities serving between 5,000 and 22,000 water meters-a subset representing about 1.3 % of Arkansas’s 1,065 water systems-and noted that a similar bill had previously passed the House but died in the Senate.
[31:53][32:02][32:05][32:27][33:02][33:36][34:07][34:42]
Committee members raised several technical questions, including whether the bill’s references to “persons” versus “users” both meant meters, and whether the language might unintentionally allow all systems to opt out; Ladyman clarified that the terms are synonymous and that only PWAs under the 22,000-meter threshold are affected, and he also addressed cost concerns, noting that Delta Dental would provide equipment at no charge but that ongoing maintenance, chemicals and training would still impose operational expenses.
[37:44][38:19][38:57][39:04][39:06][39:28][39:34][39:37][40:02][40:08][40:37][40:40][40:48][40:52][43:30][44:02][44:34]
After debate, Representative Ladyman moved to pass the bill, the motion was seconded, and the committee recorded an affirmative roll-call vote (aye) with no opposition, thereby approving HB1865.
[1:13:24][1:13:40][1:14:03][1:14:34]
SB339 J. Hutchinson TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM TO MANDATE PRESCRIBERS CHECK THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM WHEN PRESCRIBING CERTAIN MEDICATIONS.
After discussion of exemptions, reporting mechanisms, and penalties, the committee moved a motion to pass the bill, which carried unanimously.
[1:50:13][1:50:45][1:50:59]
HB1653 Miller TO CREATE THE DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES WAIVER DEATH NOTIFICATION ACT; AND TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PUBLISH CONCERNING THE WAITING LIST FOR THE ALTERNATIVE COMMUNITY SERVICES WAIVER PROGRAM.
HB1714 Petty ACT TO PERMIT THE OPERATION OF MOBILE SALONS; AND TO CREATE A LICENSING PROCEDURE CONCERNING MOBILE SALONS.
HB1718 D. Ferguson TO CREATE THE PATIENT RIGHT-TO-KNOW ACT; TO PROVIDE FOR ACCESS BY PATIENTS AND THEIR HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS TO CONTACT INFORMATION; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1731 Jett TO PROVIDE AMENDED UNEMPLOYMENT CALCULATIONS AND BENEFITS FOR CERTAIN AGRICULTURAL AND CONSTRUCTION EMPLOYEES.
HB1746 A. Mayberry TO CREATE THE DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES WAIVER LEGISLATIVE TASK FORCE.
SB206 Irvin TO AVOID UNNECESSARY EXPANSION IN MEDICAID COSTS AND SERVICES RELATED TO REHABILITATIVE SERVICES FOR PERSONS WITH MENTAL ILLNESS; AND TO CODIFY THE REHABILITATIVE SERVICES FOR PERSONS WITH MENTAL ILLNESS MORATORIUM.
1:52:18 - 2:00:1638 segments8 speakers
Senator Missy Irvin presented an amendment to SB 206 that adds an emergency clause at the request of DHS, and the committee approved the amendment by voice vote.
[1:52:36][1:52:51][1:53:03]
HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLOW AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO BE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.
HB1818 Gonzales TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING AND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
HB1835 Dotson TO PROMOTE, RECRUIT, AND RETAIN A HIGHLY SKILLED WORKFORCE IN THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; TO ESTABLISH A SYSTEM OF RECIPROCITY FOR LICENSING, REGISTRATION, AND CERTIFICATION FOR CERTAIN PROFESSIONS.
HB1846 Collins TO AMEND AND CLARIFY THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1857 Magie TO PROHIBIT DISCRIMINATION AGAINST A PHYSICIAN FOR A DECISION TO NOT PARTICIPATE IN ANY FORM OF MAINTENANCE OF CERTIFICATION.
SB335 Irvin TO PERMIT VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; TO CREATE A LICENSE EXEMPTION CONCERNING VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY..
HB1628 B. Smith TO CREATE THE HEALTHCARE FREEDOM OF CONSCIENCE ACT.
SB351 B. Sample TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING COSMETOLOGY INSTRUCTOR TRAINING.
SB361 Flippo TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF PHARMACY FOR DIALYSATE OR DEVICES NECESSARY FOR HOME PERITONEAL KIDNEY DIALYSIS IN CERTAIN SITUATIONS.
2:07:41 - 2:10:219 segments4 speakers
Representative Mary Bentley described SB 361, which would amend the Pharmacy Practice Act to eliminate the requirement for a second pharmacist to affix a duplicate label on home peritoneal dialysis shipments, arguing it reduces redundancy and cost.
[2:07:52][2:08:23]
She noted the bill had been developed with the Arkansas Pharmacists Association and the State Board of Pharmacy and faced no opposition.
[2:08:23][2:08:54][2:09:14]
After a brief clarification that the medication is not a controlled substance, the chair called for any comments, received none, and the committee approved the bill by voice vote.
[2:09:25][2:09:32][2:09:49]
HB1894 Gates TO REQUIRE THAT BIRTH CERTIFICATES LIST THE BIOLOGICAL SEX OF AN INDIVIDUAL AS DETERMINED AT BIRTH; AND TO PROHIBIT AMENDMENT OF A BIRTH CERTIFICATE TO CHANGE THE BIOLOGICAL SEX LISTED ON A BIRTH CERTIFICATE.
2:10:21 - 3:44
Representative Mickey Gates introduced HB 1894, stating it would require birth certificates to reflect the biological sex assigned at birth and limit amendments except for certain genetic disorders.
[2:10:29][2:11:03][2:11:38][2:12:11][2:12:26][2:12:33][2:12:46]
Supporters such as Rep. Paul Calvert argued the measure preserves a basic biological identifier and that provisions exist for correcting genuine errors.
[2:31:06][2:31:39][2:32:13]
HB1916 Hammer TO REQUIRE ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES TO USE THEIR OWN MEDICAID PROVIDER NUMBER OR A MODIFIER TO A MEDICAL CODE WHEN BILLING THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERVICES.
HB1951 Collins TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW ENACTED BY INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948; AND TO REGULATE FINAL SETTLEMENTS OF CLAIMS INVOLVING JOINT PETITIONS.
HB1952 Collins TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE LIABILITY OF AN EMPLOYER FOR MEDICAL COSTS RELATED TO A COMPENSABLE INJURY; AND TO AMEND PORTIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED MEASURE 1948, NO. 4.
HB1954 Collins TO REQUIRE A PROGRAM SAVINGS PLAN FOR THE MEDICAID PROVIDER-LED ORGANIZED CARE SYSTEM.
HB2001 Baltz TO ALLOW THE CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD TO SUSPEND OR REVOKE THE CERTIFICATE OR LICENSE OF CERTAIN CONTRACTORS.
HB2004 G. Hodges TO REQUIRE COOPERATION BETWEEN THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AND THE OFFICE OF CHILD SUPPORT ENFORCEMENT REGARDING SNAP ELIGIBILITY.
HB2013 Lynch TO ESTABLISH AND REQUIRE CONTINUING EDUCATION FOR HEATING, VENTILATION, AIR CONDITIONING, AND REFRIGERATION LICENSEES.
HB2071 Pilkington TO PLACE LIMITATIONS AND SAFETY GUARDS ON THE MIFEPRISTONE PRESCRIPTION FOR ABORTIONS.
HB2000 Leding TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS OF EMPLOYEES AND APPLICANTS FOR EMPLOYMENT; REGARDING EMPLOYER USE OF CREDIT REPORTS AND BACKGROUND CHECKS OF EMPLOYEES AND APPLICANTS FOR EMPLOYMENT.
SB420 Irvin TO ALLOW INSURANCE CARRIERS TO OBTAIN PRACTITIONER AND DISPENSER INFORMATION MAINTAINED BY THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM; AND TO ALLOW PRESCRIBER DATA TO BE USED FOR RESEARCH PURPOSES.
1:53:05 - 1:55:4511 segments3 speakers
Senator Missy Irvin introduced SB 420, permitting insurance carriers to obtain practitioner and dispenser information from the PDMP and allowing prescriber data to be used for research; the committee subsequently moved and carried motions to pass both SB 206 (as amended) and SB 420 unanimously.
[1:53:09][1:53:24][1:53:44][1:53:58][1:54:15][1:54:45][1:55:01]
SB429 L. Eads TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR MASSAGE THERAPISTS.
HB1625 Leding TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO KNOW YOUR PAY ACT.
HB2023 Fielding TO REQUIRE A FIRE EXTINGUISHER IN ALL APARTMENTS IN ARKANSAS.
HB2140 Rye TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS REGARDING ACUPUNCTURE AND EXEMPTIONS TO THE LICENSURE OF ACUPUNCTURISTS.
HB2145 Penzo TO CREATE THE MEDICAID PROVIDER-LED ORGANIZED CARE ACT; TO IMPOSE AN INSURANCE PREMIUM TAX ON RISK-BASED PROVIDER ORGANIZATIONS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2148 Penzo TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (SNAP) BENEFITS FUNDS TO PURCHASE LUXURY FOOD ITEMS.
HB2149 Penzo TO REQUIRE A MERCHANT TO REQUEST A PHOTO IDENTIFICATION CARD BEFORE ACCEPTING AN ELECTRONIC BENEFITS TRANSFER CARD.
HB2150 Penzo TO CREATE AN INCENTIVE PROGRAM FOR THE SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
1:55:45 - 3:08:32249 segments28 speakers
Representative Clint Penzo presented HB 2150, creating a SNAP incentive program that encourages purchase of healthier foods using a $10,000 grant from the Arkansas Hunger Relief Alliance and stating no additional state funds would be required.
[1:56:31][1:56:55][1:57:01][1:57:06][1:57:16][1:57:20]
HB2176 McCollum TO ENCOURAGE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT BY FACILITATING EMPLOYMENT OF INDIVIDUALS; TO REGULATE OCCUPATIONAL BOARDS, COMMISSIONS, AND OTHER ENTITIES WHILE PRESERVING HEALTH AND SAFETY STANDARDS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2220 Davis TO AMEND THE PROCESS FOR PERMITTING NONMUNICIPAL DOMESTIC SEWAGE TREATMENT WORKS.
3:08:32 - 2:59:05
Representative Warwick Sabin introduced HB 2220, proposing the creation of a task force to study non-municipal domestic sewage treatment works without requiring new expenditures.
[3:09:02][3:09:33]
While Rep. Fredrick J. Love argued the state already has too many ineffective task forces and voted against the measure, Rep. Kenneth B. Ferguson expressed support for a functional task force and indicated he would vote in favor.
[3:09:52][3:10:06][3:10:13][3:10:36][3:10:43]
After a brief vote in which ayes were recorded, the chair ruled that the required two-hand count was not met and declared the bill failed.
[3:10:53]
HB2245 Gazaway TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING INFORMAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION HEARINGS PERTAINING TO DISPUTE RESOLUTIONS FOR LONG-TERM CARE FACILITIES.
HB2160 Gonzales TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING TRAINING FOR VOLUNTEER FIREFIGHTERS.
2:59:05 - 16:20
The committee considered HB 2160, which would permit volunteer firefighters to count continuing-education hours earned by EMTs, nurses or other medical personnel toward the required 16-hour annual fire-training requirement.
[3:00:32][3:00:48][3:01:22]
Representative Roger Smith, speaking for the State Firefighters Association, argued the bill would let departments skip essential fire-safety training, while Rep. Kenneth B. Ferguson noted fire chiefs oppose because it could jeopardize Act 833 funding tied to meeting the training mandate.
[3:01:47][3:02:04][3:02:36][3:03:08][3:03:31][3:03:34][3:03:43][3:03:56][3:04:15][3:04:38]
Committee members questioned the lack of a clear standard for applying medical-training hours, and the chair indicated the bill’s language was ambiguous and might need revision by the Fire Services Protection Board.
[3:04:46][3:05:17][3:05:31][3:05:47][3:06:22][3:06:30][3:06:44][3:06:54]
HB2019 Boyd CONCERNING INVOLUNTARY COMMITMENTS; AND CONCERNING WHO IS PERMITTED TO MAKE THE DECISION TO INVOLUNTARILY COMMIT ANOTHER PERSON.
HB2060 Hammer TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS PEER REVIEW FAIRNESS ACT TO ASSURE DUE PROCESS FOR PHYSICIANS AND TO PROTECT PATIENTS.
HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APPLICABLE TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES WHO MEET CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE.
HB1771 S. Meeks TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS NIGHTTIME ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION ACT.
SB514 Hester TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SUPERVISION OF APPRENTICE PLUMBERS IN THE FINAL YEAR OF AN APPRENTICESHIP.
SB747 Hester TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING WORKERS' COMPENSATION COVERAGE REQUIRED FOR A CONTRACTOR.
HB2015 Baltz TO RECOGNIZE THE EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES PERSONNEL LICENSURE INTERSTATE COMPACT.
HB2016 Brown TO EXEMPT WHEELCHAIR TRANSPORTATION FROM LICENSURE AS AN AMBULANCE; AND TO PRESERVE AND ENHANCE ACCESS TO TRANSPORTATION OPTIONS FOR THE STATE'S MEDICAL PATIENTS.
HB2024 Barker TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ABORTION; AND TO AMEND LAW REGARDING MAINTENANCE OF FORENSIC SAMPLES FROM ABORTIONS PERFORMED ON A CHILD.
HB2059 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM; AND TO CREATE THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG ABUSE REDUCTION ACT.
HB2159 Womack TO PROVIDE FOR OVERSIGHT OF STATE OCCUPATIONAL REGULATIONS; AND TO CREATE THE OCCUPATIONAL REGULATION OVERSIGHT SUBCOMMITTEE.
HB2174 Bentley TO ADDRESS DUPLICATIVE TRAINING OF CERTIFIED NURSE ASSISTANTS IN LONG- TERM CARE FACILITIES; AND TO PROVIDE AN EXEMPTION FOR LICENSURE AS A PRIVATE CAREER SCHOOL OFFERING RESIDENT OR CORRESPONDENCE PROGRAMS.
Rep. Fredrick J. Love and Rep. Robin Lundstrum questioned whether the measure would block local jurisdictions from raising wages above the state floor, and Bentley clarified that the bill only prevents localities from lowering the wage.
[2:04:36][2:05:09][2:05:13][2:05:20][2:05:28][2:05:38][2:05:42]
Following brief discussion, the committee moved to a motion and adopted SB 668 unanimously by voice vote.
[2:06:49][2:07:03]
Bentley then announced she would present Senate Bill 361 concerning peritoneal dialysis regulations, which would be considered later.
[2:07:20]
HB2178 McCollum TO ADOPT THE FEDERAL RESOURCE LIMITS FOR THE SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (SNAP).
HB2192 Sabin TO CREATE A TASK FORCE TO STUDY NONMUNICIPAL DOMESTIC SEWAGE TREATMENT WORKS; AND TO PREPARE A REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL.
HB2230 Hammer TO REQUIRE CIRCULATING NURSES IN OPERATING ROOMS OF HOSPITALS AND AMBULATORY SURGERY CENTERS.
2:41:20 - 18:43
Rep. Kim Hammer introduced HB 2230 and yielded the floor to Danielle Glover of the Association of Perioperative Registered Nurses, who testified that circulating RN nurses improve patient safety, are supported by the hospital association, and that similar statutes exist in over 30 states.
[2:41:27][2:41:49][2:41:52][2:41:58][2:42:34][2:43:05][2:43:36][2:44:08]
Surgeon Speaker 254 questioned the necessity of the bill because hospitals already employ circulating RNs, and Rep. Kenneth B. Ferguson and Ms. Glover responded that the legislation addresses situations where nurses are asked to leave the OR and ensures consistent coverage throughout the procedure.
[2:44:52][2:45:09][2:45:36][2:45:40][2:45:42][2:46:10][2:46:41]
Chair Jeff Wardlaw raised concerns about over-regulation, prompting Rep. Hammer to argue the bill fills a liability gap and protects nurses in compromising situations, with Glover citing specific Arkansas incidents where nurses were forced to leave the room.
[2:48:32][2:48:46][2:49:20][2:49:53][2:50:29][2:50:45][2:51:05]
After Rep. Hammer moved to pass the bill, the committee voted with seven ayes and no nays, but the chair declared the measure failed.
[2:55:52][2:56:01]
HB2274 Hammer TO AUTHORIZE REVOCATION OF THE ELIGIBILITY FOR UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS OF A RECIPIENT WHO REPEATEDLY MISSES REQUIRED JOB INTERVIEW APPOINTMENTS.
SB635 J. Hutchinson TO EXEMPT OWNER-OPERATORS AND CONTRACTED DRIVERS OF MOTOR VEHICLES FROM THE DEFINITION OF "EMPLOYMENT" FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES LAW.
HB2273 Wing TO DEVELOP A CONSTRUCTION MANAGER-GENERAL CONTRACTOR METHOD OF PROCUREMENT FOR TRANSPORTATION PROJECTS; AND TO CREATE A CONSTRUCTION MANAGER-GENERAL CONTRACTOR METHOD OF PROCUREMENT PILOT PROGRAM.
HB2267 Leding TO ESTABLISH THE USE OF GRANNY CAMS IN A LONG-TERM CARE FACILITY; AND TO ESTABLISH AUTHORIZATION FOR AND USE OF A MONITORING DEVICE IN A LONG-TERM CARE FACILITY.
SB354 D. Sanders TO AUTHORIZE ELEVATOR SAFETY TESTS TO BE WITNESSED BY PRIVATE SECTOR LICENSED INSPECTORS; TO ELIMINATE THE SEMI-ANNUAL INSPECTIONS; AND TO IMPROVE ENFORCEMENT OF ELEVATOR SAFETY LAWS.
SB339 J. Hutchinson TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM TO MANDATE PRESCRIBERS CHECK THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM WHEN PRESCRIBING CERTAIN MEDICATIONS.
SB227 Rapert AN ACT TO CREATE THE PATRICIA HEATH ACT; TO INCLUDE ALL SERVICE DOGS AUTHORIZED FOR ACCOMPANIMENT UNDER THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITY ACT IN THE RIGHT OF INDIVIDUALS WITH DISABILITIES TO BE ACCOMPANIED BY A SERVICE ANIMAL.
1:59:01 - 1:05
SB 227, the Patricia Heath Act extending service-dog protections under the ADA, was considered; the committee moved and carried a motion to pass the bill unanimously.
[1:59:15][1:59:42]
HB2265 Cozart TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CONTRACTORS; AND TO CREATE A TASK FORCE TO STUDY THE BEST PRACTICES AND EXAMINE THE CURRENT LAWS AND RULES PERTAINING TO THE LICENSING OF CONTRACTORS AND CONSTRUCTION PROFESSIONALS.
RE-REFERRED TO COMMITTEE
HB1953 Collins TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948.
HB1624 Leding TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO WAGES EARNED ACT.
DEFERRED
HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONCLINICAL SETTING.
HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIORITIZE SPENDING WITH THE DEPARTMENT AND THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO FULLY FUND HOME- AND COMMUNITY-BASED SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES.
HB1439 M. Gray TO AMEND THE HEALTHCARE QUALITY AND PAYMENT POLICY ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
HB1502 S. Meeks TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION TO THE DEFINITION OF RESIDENTIAL CARE FACILITY AND THE DEFINITION OF ASSISTED LIVING FACILITY.
HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; AND TO ESTABLISH THE REGISTRATION OF SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS.
HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES FROM THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD.
HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBSTITUTIONS.
HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT.
HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ACT; AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.
HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSE.
HB1551 Womack TO STIMULATE JOB CREATION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT WHILE PRESERVING HEALTH AND SAFETY STANDARDS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1525 Magie TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD AND THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO DEVELOP A JOINT APPLICATION FOR COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENTS BETWEEN COLLABORATING PHYSICIANS AND ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.
HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.
HB1664 Payton TO AMEND THE FEES FOR WASTE TIRES; TO REQUIRE PAYMENT OF WASTE TIRE FEES FOR NEW CAR TIRES; AND TO REQUIRE PAYMENT OF WASTE TIRE FEES BY DEALERS MOUNTING TIRES SOLD AT OTHER LOCATIONS AND FLEET OWNERS.
HB1809 Watson TO REFORM MEDICAID SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1810 Watson TO CLARIFY AND ESTABLISH AN APPROPRIATE MEDICAID REIMBURSEMENT METHODOLOGY FOR SMALL INTERMEDIATE CARE FACILITIES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1903 Bentley TO CREATE THE ENHANCED ELIGIBILITY AND AUTHENTICATION ACT.
HB2123 Branscum TO PROVIDE THAT SERVICES PERFORMED ON AN AS-NEEDED BASIS ARE NOT CONSIDERED EMPLOYMENT UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES LAW.