Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Insurance and Commerce Committee

March 17, 2017 ·Committee Room 149 ·1:10:02
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

SB579 Standridge CONCERNING THE VALUED POLICY LAW. 2:27

The chair, Rep. Charlie Collins, explained that SB 579 corrects a technical error in prior legislation and clarifies the insurance department’s authority, noting it contains no operative provisions and benefits Mr. Kern’s organization. [2:30]

No member sought to speak for or against the measure, a motion to pass was made, and the bill was carried unanimously with all ayes and no opposition. [3:07] [3:11] [3:21] [3:29] [3:33]

HB2139 D. Whitaker CONCERNING FRAUDULENT TRANSFERS AND VOIDABLE TRANSACTIONS. 5:37

Elisa White, a uniform law commissioner, testified that HB 2139 updates the Uniform Fraudulent Transfers Act by renaming it “voidable transactions,” adding a choice-of-law provision, removing the general-partner net-worth test, and setting the preponderance-of-evidence standard. [5:40] [5:45] [5:50] [6:09] [6:24] [6:55] [7:29] [7:59]

Rep. John Payton asked how the amendment interacts with bankruptcy, and White confirmed it permits avoidance of transactions made shortly before filing and can be used in bankruptcy proceedings. [8:29] [8:52] [9:01] [9:31] [9:33]

After brief discussion, Rep. Whitaker moved to pass the bill, which was adopted without opposition by voice vote. [9:55] [10:09]

HB1742 Rushing CONCERNING A CIVIL ACTION INVOLVING A DECEPTIVE TRADE PRACTICE; AND TO DEFINE THE MEASURE OF DAMAGES IN A CASE INVOLVING A DECEPTIVE TRADE PRACT… 27:42

Committee members debated HB 1742, with Rep. Klein raising concerns about class-action deterrence and Rep. Gray defending the amendment that preserves consumer-protective class actions while limiting them to Arkansas Constitution Amendment 89 cases. [27:54] [27:59] [28:06] [28:31] [28:39] [28:41] [28:52] [29:08] [29:39]

Additional comments from Reps. Lowery, Murdock, and the chair highlighted the balance between preventing frivolous suits and maintaining a deterrent effect, but no further opposition was voiced. [29:57] [30:11] [30:41] [31:17] [31:49]

The motion to adopt the amended bill passed unanimously, with the chair recording the ayes and confirming passage of the measure. [31:49] [32:20] [32:54] [33:25]

HB1941 C. Douglas CONCERNING AN ENTREPRENEUR UNDER EIGHTEEN (18) YEARS OF AGE; AND TO CREATE THE COLIN READY YOUNG ENTREPRENEUR MENTOR PROGRAM. 35:24

Rep. Douglas presented HB 1941, proposing that individuals aged 16-18 may have a qualified adult act as incorporator or organizer, and that a mentor program be created to assist young entrepreneurs without altering existing filing procedures. [35:35] [36:09] [36:40] [37:10] [37:45]

No committee members requested to speak against the proposal, and a do-pass motion was moved and carried unanimously, enacting the bill. [38:22] [38:48]

HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A JOINT TENANCY WITH RIGHT OF SURVIVORSHIP IN REAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 39:24

Rep. Douglas explained HB 1145 would require a notification process for terminating a joint tenancy with right of survivorship but would not alter substantive rights, emphasizing protection for title companies and other stakeholders. [39:49] [40:19] [40:35] [40:38] [40:43] [40:54] [40:59]

After brief discussion and acknowledgment from Rep. Warren that the revised bill meets title-company concerns, a do-pass motion was made and approved unanimously, passing the legislation. [41:15] [41:20] [41:24] [41:33]

SB763 Hutchinson TO RESTORE CERTAIN RIGHTS TO A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION. 46:27

Senator Hutchinson presented Senate Bill 763, explaining that it would grant nonprofit associations-such as medical societies-standing to seek injunctive or declaratory relief on behalf of their members, while expressly prohibiting them from pursuing monetary damages. [48:09] [48:31] [49:03] [49:16] [49:35] [49:56] [50:10] [50:43] [50:51] [50:56] [51:17] [51:51] [52:11]

Representatives raised several concerns: Rep. Farrar asked how the bill would affect nonprofit insurance companies, and Rep. Mark Lowery questioned the consistency of allowing broad nonprofit standing given recent limits imposed by the Deceptive Trade Practices Act and the bill’s application to all nonprofits. [49:16] [49:35] [49:56] [50:10] [50:43] [50:51] [50:56] [51:17] [51:51] [52:11] [52:17] [52:21]

After limited debate, the chair moved a do-pass motion, which was adopted unanimously with no opposition, thereby passing SB 763. [54:52] [55:09]

HB2087 Sabin TO OPEN ADDITIONAL BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES TO COOPERATIVE CORPORATIONS AND ASSOCIATIONS; AND TO PROMOTE THE PURSUIT OF CAPITALISM IN STRUGGLING COM… 56:27

Rep. Warwick Sabin introduced House Bill 2087, describing it as a deregulation measure intended to expand the use of cooperative associations and corporations as investment vehicles to bring capital and economic development to rural Arkansas, including applications in warehousing, real-estate, and construction. [56:43] [56:55] [57:11] [57:16] [57:22] [57:26] [57:33] [57:47] [58:16]

Committee members queried the bill’s practical implementation and banking implications; Rep. Les Eaves requested a concrete example, and Rep. John Payton asked why banking language had been removed, to which Sabin explained the historical prohibition on cooperative banking and the bill’s alignment with current bank-department guidance. [57:26] [57:33] [57:47] [58:16] [58:18] [58:30] [58:34] [58:42] [58:52] [59:01] [59:12] [59:25]

The chair then called for a do-pass motion, which passed without opposition, and HB 2087 was adopted. [59:25] [59:55]

SB208 Maloch TO AUTHORIZE THE BANK COMMISSIONER TO CONDUCT EXAMINATIONS OF TECHNOLOGY SERVICE PROVIDERS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 1:00:27

Rep. Matthew J. Shepherd presented Senate Bill 208, stating that it would empower the state bank commissioner to examine third-party technology service providers that deliver functions to banks-services that would otherwise be subject to regulation if performed by the banks themselves-thereby bringing state authority into parity with federal oversight. [1:00:28] [1:01:03] [1:01:34] [1:02:06]

No committee members offered questions, and the chair moved a do-pass motion that carried unanimously, resulting in the passage of SB 208. [1:02:14]

Rep. John Payton introduced Senate Bill 642, aimed at allowing individuals with disabilities under age 65 to purchase Medigap (Medicare Supplement) coverage in Arkansas; Ryan James of the state insurance department testified that the insurance commissioner supports the legislation. [1:03:53] [1:04:20]

SB642 Rapert TO ALLOW MEDIGAP COVERAGE, ALSO KNOWN AS MEDICARE SUPPLEMENT INSURANCE, TO BE PURCHASED IN ARKANSAS FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DISABILITIES WHO ARE UNDE… 1:04:32

Jackie Martin, a disabled constituent, testified that she cannot currently obtain Medigap to cover the 20 % gap in Medicare benefits and urged the committee to pass the bill, after which the chair reported no further discussion and the motion to do-pass was approved unanimously. [1:06:25] [1:06:32] [1:07:04] [1:07:07]

Bills discussed (30)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1742 · 6 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1742 Rushing CONCERNING A CIVIL ACTION INVOLVING A DECEPTIVE TRA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2139 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2139 D. Whitaker CONCERNING FRAUDULENT TRANSFERS AND VOIDABLE TR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2193 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2193 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DRIVERS EXCLUDED FROM A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1840 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Chair. Thank you, committee. The next bill on our agenda is HB 1840. Representative Johnson, are you here? Representative Johns…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB579 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Senator Malik? Seeing none, the next bill on our agenda is Senate Bill 579.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB763 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…you very much, Madam Chair. The next bill on our agenda is Senate Bill 763.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1890 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1890 Tucker TO ESTABLISH AN ARKANSAS CROWDFUNDING OPTION; AND TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1900 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1900. Is Representative Bentley here? House Bill 1900, Represent…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1958 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1958 M. Gray CONCERNING THE CREDIT SERVICES ORGANIZATIONS ACT OF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2048 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2048 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CASUALTY INSURANCE COVE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2054 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB2054 Hammer TO REPEAL THE ARKANSAS HOUSING TRUST FUND ACT OF 200…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2102 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Bill 763? Seeing none. Then the next Bill on our agenda is HB 2102, Representative Lemons, are you here? Representative Lemons…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2212 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2212. Representative McGee, are you here? Representative McGee,…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB208 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB208 Maloch TO AUTHORIZE THE BANK COMMISSIONER TO CONDUCT EXAMIN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1145 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1271 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1271 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1751 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1751 Cozart TO CLARIFY THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF AN INSURER FOR AP…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1753 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1753 Collins TO CLARIFY THAT THE SUBROGATION AND REIMBURSEMENT R…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1838 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1838 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE HEALTH SAVINGS ACC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1941 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1941 C. Douglas CONCERNING AN ENTREPRENEUR UNDER EIGHTEEN (18) Y…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2061 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2061 Hammer TO MODERNIZE THE FIRE RATING SYSTEM IN ARKANSAS; AND…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2086 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2086 Sabin TO PROTECT THE PROPERTY RIGHTS OF CITIZENS; TO PREVEN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2087 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2087 Sabin TO OPEN ADDITIONAL BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES TO COOPERAT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2135 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2135 Sabin TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2209 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2209 M. Gray TO CLARIFY THE USE OF AN ALL-PRODUCTS CLAUSE IN A H…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2251 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2251 Gazaway CONCERNING THE PERSONAL INFORMATION PROTECTION ACT;…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB498 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB498 Irvin TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "HEALTHCARE PAY OR"; TO PR…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB546 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB546 Rapert TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "ELIGIBLE INVESTMENT SECU…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB642 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB642 Rapert TO ALLOW MEDIGAP COVERAGE, ALSO KNOWN AS MEDICARE SU…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB683 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB683 D. Sanders TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS HEALTHCARE TRANSPARENCY IN…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
If not, we can come back to that one later, given that it's a re-referral, but we'll go to the next bill on the agenda, which is HB 2048. Representative Rushing, are you here to present HB 2048? Seeing that she's not here, the next bill on our agenda is Senate Bill 208. Is someone here for Senator Malik? Seeing none, the next bill on our agenda is Senate Bill 579. What I'd like to do is ask Representative Ferguson if she would come to the chair so that I can – excuse me, hold on, Representative Ferguson. Representative Gray, are you here to present 1742? So without objection, we're going to go back to the top of the agenda for 1742. Representative Gray, you're recognized to present House Bill 1742. Do we have an amendment for that, Carol? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I do have an
▶ Play
amendment that was supposed to have been sent over this morning. If it's not here, I would please defer until it gets here.
▶ Play
Okay, so we don't have an amendment. It's not here yet. Representative Gray, so if you wait, and you may want to check with the BLR attorney, make sure that the person is sending it down here. Thank you. of Ferguson, could I ask you to come and sit in the chair so that I can present Senate Bill 579.
▶ Play
Representative Collins, you're afraid to present your bill and introduce your
▶ Play
guest. Thank you very much. So what I'm going to do is just present the bill and then let Mr. Zeno introduce himself for any of the questions. So this is a Senate bill from Senator Standridge, and it does two things. The first thing it does is it corrects an error in private from prior legislation. There was a technical error made in the legislation, so it's a technical correction. Then the other thing it does is it clarifies some authority that the insurance department has to fix it when bad guys do bad things. So this is a bill that doesn't have any operation. It's something that's going to help Mr. Kern, his organization. And with that, I appreciate a good vote, unless there are questions.
▶ Play
Any questions for the committee or, Mr. Zeno, do you have any comments? Let's see if there's any
▶ Play
questions, Madam Chair. No. Okay. Motion do pass. Have any discussion
▶ Play
on the motion? Excuse me, ma'am. There's no one to speak for and against. Did you want to speak for the bill? No, I just wanted to make
▶ Play
sure that we gave people an opportunity to speak against if there's anybody here to speak against, especially since I made the claim that there's no opposition. Yeah.
▶ Play
No one to speak against the bill. I have no one signed up to speak against. Okay. I have a motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? Your bill is passed. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you very much, Madam Chair. The next bill on our agenda is Senate Bill 763. Is Senator Hutchinson here or somebody here to present Senate Bill 763? Anybody here for Senate Bill 763? Seeing none. Then the next Bill on our agenda is HB 2102, Representative Lemons, are you here? Representative Lemons, are you here to present 2102 seeing as he's not here. The next Bill on our agenda is House Bill 2193. Representative Hammer, are you here? Representative Hammer, are you here to present House Bill 2193? The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2212. Representative McGee, are you here? Representative McGee, are you here for 2212? The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2139. Representative Whitaker, are you here? I am, Mr. Chair. Representative Whitaker, you're recognized. House Bill 2139.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Here today to present House Bill 2139, which is an update and revisions to the what's currently known as the Uniform Fraudulent Transfers Act. I have with me today Professor Lynn Foster, who is not only a professor. Actually, I'm sorry. I'm a substitute. Ma'am, why don't you go ahead and
▶ Play
introduce yourself and who you're with for the record, and then you'll be recognized to speak
▶ Play
as well. I'm sorry about that. I'm a last-minute substitution. My name's Elisa White. I'm also a uniform law commissioner for the state of
▶ Play
Arkansas. As I said, this is current law that is being updated and renamed in our commercial code. And if Ms. White, sorry about the late minute substitution, if Ms. White would like to briefly tell you what that means. I can briefly tell
▶ Play
you if it's all right with the committee. You are recognized. Thank you very much. I am here to provide you just, it's always, I'm always hesitant to say a long bill really does only a few things, but most of this is old law and it really does just update it. Fraudulent Transfer Act has always been misnamed because you never had to have actual fraud for it and you never had to actually transfer anything in order to have a problem. This is basically a creditor's remedy that's designed to address when debtors have maybe sold property in order to hide it from a creditor, or there's some other reason that this particular transaction might be voidable under the law. And so the update in name is really just to clarify that these are voidable transactions. You don't have to actually be guilty of fraud for a creditor to come in and say and argue to the court that the, uh, action should be voidable. Um, this has been on the books in Arkansas since the eighties. It's the law in 47 jurisdictions across the United States, which is the uniform law commission's job. Um, it integrates with the uniform commercial code, and this is an update to do three additional things. It provides a choice of law provision because there's, there are a lot of court cases arguing about which state's law should apply. and we wanted to eliminate that need for argument. It also eliminates the requirement that you consider a net worth of a general partner when you're looking at whether the partnership as a whole is insolvent, which is the main substantive thing. So you wouldn't be able to go to the general partner's net worth in order to look at that, which is very important for people who are forming partnerships. And that's clear law in court cases, but we thought it was helpful to put it in the statute. And finally, it clarifies that preponderance of the evidence is the standard in court cases because the court cases are very confusing in that area. Any questions from the
▶ Play
committee? Seeing none. Excuse me? Representative Payton? Yeah, I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 41 8:20
forming a question. Can I try? Of course.
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Since I haven't really fully formed it yet, can you tell me how this relates in a bankruptcy case to, in other words, if there was fraud by the debtor, they can ask that the transaction be kicked out, I think. Is that what this is pertaining to?
▶ Play
Yes, it does impact bankruptcies. I mean, it doesn't change the bankruptcy rule, but that is one way. If there is actual fraud, then it can be avoidable transaction. But another way it impacts bankruptcy is if certain transactions happen within a certain period of time before the bankruptcy, like 90 days, six months, a certain period of time, then the bankruptcy court can go back and say, hey, we're going to go back and void those transactions that happened and make the person, you know, give back the money so that it's part of the bankruptcy estate and can be paid to the creditors through the bankruptcy. So yes, it ties in with bankruptcy law.
▶ Play
Can I follow up, Mr. Chair? So if I'm understanding right, if there's misinformation on the balance sheet of the borrower and they load it up 90 days before bankruptcy, then this is given a means for the creditor to avoid the transactions? That's correct. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any other
▶ Play
questions? Seeing none, is there anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Whitaker, are you closed for your bill? I am closed, sir. I move do pass on House Bill 2139. Is there any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Whitaker, you passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. The next bill on our agenda is HB 1840. Representative Johnson, are you here? Representative Johnson, are you here to present HB 1840? Seeing he's not here, Representative Hammer, I know you were gone. Without objection, I'll go back up to House Bill 2193 if you'd like to present House Bill 2193. Representative Hammer, you're recognized to present House Bill 2193. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I want to tell you about two quick examples for why this bill needs to be placed into law. One situation, a driver was at a convenience store, backed out. That driver was a legal driver, approximately 17 years old, backed out of the stall on private property, and another vehicle pulled out from the gas pump, hit that driver. The driver that pulled out from the gas pump and hit the other driver was, in reality, a 15-year-old girl who had purposely been excluded from the insurance policy by her mama. because her mama knew that her daughter would probably in all likelihood take the car when she wasn't looking to take it for a joyride. That driver that backed out was my son. The other person was the young 15-year-old girl. When the police showed up, they couldn't do anything because it was on private property, so they couldn't issue any tickets. My insurance company ended up paying for it, and I lost a premium of deductible. Another situation that happened up in Russellville is a situation where a vehicle stopped at the stoplight. The vehicle behind it was stopped at the stoplight. The third vehicle came in and rear-ended the second vehicle, which pushed it into the first vehicle, totaling one car, damaging the other one. The driver of the third vehicle was a college student who had taken the vehicle of the friend. And when the police came to investigate, the driver that had caused the accident was not a named driver on the policy. And therefore, the first vehicle and the second vehicle, they had insurance claims and lost. My same son was the driver in the first vehicle. So twice we've had two different scenarios. And then since then, I've had multiple people talk to me about this. So that's the reason for the bill. And I'll just go through it real quickly and explain what it does. And it is an amended bill that's been engrossed. Down under item C, what item C does is that if a named insurer rejects coverage under the subsection of this section, the excluded driver from the coverage may be personally liable for civil damages caused by the excluded driver if that person who excluded them enables the excluded driver to be able to take the motor vehicle. If that scenario happens, then here's what can take place. That person can be charged with a class A misdemeanor and then B or number two, be held personally liable for civil damages caused by the excluded driver. So the way that would work is if that mama who had excluded her daughter from the policy leaves the keys on the counter where that daughter has not had, you know, it made it easy for her to take the keys and she goes out and has the wreck, even though she would be an excluded driver, personally, there could be liability that you could go through civil court and be able to get her because she didn't do a good job of keeping control of her vehicle. The second thing is, when it gets down to the second example, if an unnamed person takes that vehicle and does, as in the second illustration I gave you, then if that person fails to file a police report that says that the vehicle was taken against their will or without their knowledge, then that person could be held liable. And that's basically what the bill does. So it doesn't hurt the insurance companies. If somebody still wants to do that, they can do that. But what it does do is create an avenue to where you can seek civil damages against that person and allows you to go after them and collect damages. And with that, I'll be glad
▶ Play
to answer any questions. So if you, Representative Payne, you're going to ask for a question. Well, I don't have
▶ Play
to go first. I appreciate it, Mr. Chair. So the first part of your bill, I think I'm pretty comfortable with. The second part, I don't understand how that can work because somebody may steal your vehicle and wreck it or run into somebody within five or ten minutes or less. I mean, you definitely are not going to have had time to have filed a police report or notified the authorities. If I steal your vehicle at 6 o'clock in the morning, you don't get up until 9. I mean, this second part seems to me like it's almost unenforceable. Well, and I'll give
▶ Play
you an illustration. When I shared this with somebody and they gave me an example, they said, well, what if I'm at the grocery store unloading my cart and I go to put my cart up and say I left my keys in my car, which is what a lot of people do, and somebody comes in and steals it and takes it and goes and robs a bank and does something like that, that's a very simple scenario. Then you just file it as a stolen vehicle report. The police will investigate it, determine that, yes, indeed, you are not at fault, that somebody stole the vehicle, and then you would be released from that or that would be your coverage.
▶ Play
Representative Ferrari, you're recognized for a question. I guess on those same lines, I've got the same problem. So going back to your story, if the girl's mother said, well,
▶ Play
she stole my car, does that put everybody out of the liability? What it would do is if the mother said, well, let me give you the other example. In the second example, the roommate takes the car, okay, and the roommate takes the car and goes for a joyride with it. If the roommate doesn't report because that person took that as an unnamed driver, if the roommate takes it, then what the person who owns the car would do, you would have to call and file that as a missing vehicle. And then that would relieve them from the personal responsibility. If they don't do that, they haven't maintained their car well enough, and they know that they had a person that was not named on the vehicle. So I want to get insurance policy, I'm going to name myself, my wife, and my son. Those are the only three people that should be driving that car. If somebody else takes that car, and I've named them, then that person should be held responsible, I think anyway, for not controlling that vehicle. And that would allow then for us to be able to get personal damages in court.
▶ Play
Representative Eves, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Hammer, on the first page, line 35 and 36, I kind of get where you're going with most of it, but I have a little bit of an issue where it says, if the named insured enabled an excluded driver. I mean, does that mean if you left your keys laying around or if you were asleep and your daughter took the car? I mean, I have a little bit of heartburn over how you're going to prove someone enabled someone to do this. Would you give me that page in line? Yes, sir. Page one, line 35 and 36. I'm just trying to, I don't really understand how you're going to prove that someone enabled someone to take their
▶ Play
car. I mean, in those cases that I mentioned. As far as enable, I would give you the illustration I gave earlier, and that is if a mother purposely, and I won't say a dad, put it on myself, if a dad purposely excludes his son from being a driver of that vehicle, they're doing it because they know at the time they do it that there's a chance that that child may take that vehicle. And therefore, once they assume that, I think, that once they assume that responsibility that they have intentionally excluded that driver from that vehicle and they do not responsibly maintain control of that vehicle, then what that says is if they go out and get in a wreck, I'm not going to be responsible for it, and this is my way of being able to do it. With the main insurance companies, it's not such a big issue. It's with other insurance companies that maybe operate out of state that allow that option.
▶ Play
Well, my point is, though, say if I had excluded my daughter from being on my insurance policy and I was asleep and left my keys on the nightstand and she took it, would I have enabled her to drive even though she was excluded? I think that if you knew
▶ Play
that you had excluded your daughter and you didn't do that, then that would be my opinion. All right. Mr. Chair? Yes, Representative Hammer. I want to respect the fact that there's a sense of time, and I can respect there's a lot of questions. What I'll do is let me pull this down, and I'll go polish it up and bring it back next week if that's all right with
▶ Play
the Chair. Yes, it is. Very good. I respect for the committee. I'll do that, and thank you. Thank you. You're welcome. Next on our list is House Bill. We'll go back and give Johnson another shot. HB 1840, Representative Johnson, are you here? Representative Johnson, seeing as he's not here, HB 1890. Representative Tucker, are you here? Representative Tucker for House Bill 1890. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1900. Is Representative Bentley here? House Bill 1900, Representative Bentley. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1958, Representative Gray. I think she's working on an amendment. The next bill on our list is House Bill 2054, Representative Hammer. Thank you. Chair, I'd like to pass over that one day. All right. You're welcome to pass over. Representative Gray, is your amendment ready for – okay, so without objection, we're going to go back up to the top to House Bill 1742, which has been re-referred to the committee for an amendment. The amendment is now available, and Carol is going to be preparing it. Is it loaded on the machines yet, Carol, or are people going to get a paper copy? We're going to pass out a paper copy of that amendment. Just to refresh everybody's memory, this is a bill that we voted on on the House floor a couple times, and yesterday we agreed to re-refer the bill back to committee for an amendment. So this is a bill that we should be relatively familiar with from the discussions on the House floor. And as this amendment goes around, I'm going to recognize Representative Gray to start talking about it. This is the Deceptive Trade Practices Bill, so hopefully everyone has some familiarity with it. So as Representative Gray gets into the amendment, we can see how it fits together. Representative Gray, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And
▶ Play
I'll try to make this quick as we've rehashed the bill several times by now already. What we did here is I listened to Representative Walker, and just nobody would tell him that I actually listened to something he had to say on this. But a lot of people thought that what we were doing in the original bill would allow payday lending and those businesses that don't follow Amendment 89 or the usury laws to not be sued under this. And we did not feel that was the case, but just to ensure that that was not the case, We've added Part B or Section B here that says a private class action under this subsection is prohibited unless the claim is being asserted for a violation of Arkansas Constitution Amendment 89. So I don't think we could have gotten that any more clear than we did to essentially say that that is still allowed under this statute. And then I also and Representative Tucker also had an issue with some of the language talking about individual versus representative capacity. So we cleaned that up in that first section as well. And I'd be definitely welcome to take any questions, either on the amendment or on the bill. Are there
▶ Play
any questions? Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Did you do anything with if a class of people are damaged at a certain level, $1,000, $1,500 or something, that we'd still have the ability to enter a class? Or is it, in other words, it doesn't matter how much they're damaged, they can't have a class action under deceptive trade practice without going to the attorney general? Yeah, we did not put
▶ Play
any kind of a floor or a ceiling on this as to whether or not they could. Right now, if they would have to go through the Attorney General's office, and I did verify that some of the questions were whether or not the Attorney General could seek restitution, and there are multiple cases in where our Attorney General has sought restitution, and we have funds available for that. So they cannot do it privately, but it can be done through the Attorney General's office. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
McCollum, I believe you had a question. Yes,
▶ Play
thank you. Can you elaborate a little more? Just help me out here. Representative versus individual capacity.
▶ Play
Yes. Right now, it's essentially called representative capacity under the current statute, and that essentially says representative as in representing an entire class of people. So our intent with the bill was to say that you could no longer do representative under deceptive trade, but you could bring a claim individually. And Representative Tucker and I, when we talked about individually, We were worried that it might be interpreted that a guardian or something like that might be excluded unintentionally. So we took out, we changed that wording a little bit just to kind of make it clear.
▶ Play
Are there any further questions? Is there anybody here to speak for the bill or the amendment? Against? All right. Committee, discussion.
▶ Play
So I'm going to make a motion we adopt the amendment to House Bill 1742. Is there any discussion on the motion? If not, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Gray, you passed your amendment. Now we are going to hear House Bill 1742 as amended. Representative Gray, you're recognized to present House Bill 1742 as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair. and I think we've heard it
▶ Play
quite a bit. Again, I'm open to any questions. If not, I'd appreciate a good vote. Is there any questions from the
▶ Play
committee? Seeing none, is there anyone here to speak against the bill? It looks like we've got Mr. Hank Klein has signed up to speak against the bill. Mr. Klein, are you here? You recognize you speak against the bill? I recognize that you spoke against this bill in a previous session, so hopefully if you focus on the new information you want to share
▶ Play
with us, that would be much appreciated. I'm happy to do that. My name is Hank Klein. I'm a resident of North Little Rock, Sherwood, Arkansas, and a volunteer with AARP. I appreciate Representative Gray looking specifically at Amendment 89 and payday lenders, but what I really question is the next payday lenders that are going to come along in five years or ten years. In other words, the business that does not do what they're supposed to do based on Arkansas law and the inability of consumers to go to an attorney, hire an attorney to solve that problem because it's such a small problem. It's a $0.35 problem on my bill from the phone company, but those $0.35 bills, when you add them up from all the bills the phone company has, turns out to be a very large problem for our Kansans. I realize, and she's mentioned before, that attorneys get millions of dollars in these class action lawsuits, and the people who are hurt get a small amount of money, $100, I have a check here for $1.35 on a class action that I was involved with, and that really isn't the point. To me, the point is that once that company, once Target has been sued because their system has been breached and my wife's card has been stopped because some fraud has happened on that card, once they've been caught doing that and they pay a fine, even if most of it goes to the attorney, the rest of us in Arkansas benefit because they take care of the problem and the problem doesn't happen again, hopefully, with that company. So I think class action lawsuits actually have a place in our society and actually help Arkansas consumers. Maybe not necessarily the ones who get a $1.35 check, but all of us, all of us. Thank
▶ Play
you. Is there any questions for Mr. Klein? Seeing none, does anyone speak for the bill, against the bill? Representative Gray, are you closed
▶ Play
for your bill? Real quick, I'd just like to kind of rebut what Mr. Klein said and just kind of clear this up. He mentioned fraud, and there's still the ability to sue under a class action for fraud. This does not touch fraud in any way, just deceptive trade practices. So I just wanted to clear that up and remind everyone that the AG, the Attorney General's office, is our biggest advocate for consumer protection, and they are the only ones that can actually stop bad business practices. These lawsuits are just monetary lawsuits. They would not stop any bad business practice. So with that, I thank you, the committee's time, for letting me come back a second
▶ Play
time. I appreciate a good vote. All right. I move that we pass House Bill 1742 as amended. Is there any discussion on the motion? Representative Lowry, you're
▶ Play
recognized for discussion on the motion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just want to, I think Mr. Klein's testimony, even though we resolved the payday lending issue, hopefully, I think his testimony was on point of talking about how many times these class action suits are not so much about recovery for individuals, but sending a message to any entity that is trying to get away. And in most cases, that's what they're trying to do. They're trying to get away with deceptive trade practice. And somebody has to step up and stop them, whether there is going to be substantial financial gain to individuals or not. The fact that the class action lawsuit process is still put in place can hopefully could serve as a deterrent or at least a backstop of making sure that those practices are called out and they're stopped. So I just I think that there is a purpose for the ability to bring these lawsuits and I think we would be undermining the process by excluding them. Thank you. Well and I think that's a fair point. I
▶ Play
just I just want to make sure I'm sharing the counter-balance point. When the crash happened, and I know this isn't necessarily exactly the same, but when the crash happened, somebody got the idea that we could sue every company under the sun because their stock price went down, and so I lost bazooka money, and I got like 100 lawsuit packets that each one of them cost probably $5, and the whole thing said if I filled out another stack of paperwork, I might qualify for $0.25, even though I lost bazooka times that amount of money. So there was nothing for me, but somebody was making a lot of money on it. So balance is always the challenge, and I don't pretend to be the expert, but it sort of looked like the balance was in the wrong direction to me. Are there any other discussion on the motion? Representative Murdock, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 91 30:41
Thank you, Chairman. I concur with Representative Lowry in the purpose and to kind of push back on what you're saying. There are frivolous lawsuits that are filed, whether through class action or individually all the time. So there's a system to eradicate that. But the purpose of this is to prevent, hopefully, by a financial possible loss to the entity that's doing this, that they would see that it would deter them from these type of actions. And, yeah, the $1.35 individually doesn't mean anything. But the big purpose here, and while we're even trying to mitigate that or eradicate that, it doesn't really make sense to me. You know, we should be protecting the ones that can't speak for themselves in these situations, and I just think that there's no reason for us to do this. Again, I concur with Representative Lowry, and hopefully we won't pass this bill. This is not a good one. Thank you. Is there any other discussion on the motion?
▶ Play
Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. Representative Michelle Gray, congrats. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I see a hand for a roll call. I see one hand. Lowry, your second hand. Carol, please call the roll. Representative Murdoch? Nay. Representative Lowry?
▶ Play
Speaker 93 32:20
No. Representative Ritchie? Representative Ritchie, Representative Armstrong, Representative Jett, Representative Farrar, Representative Ferguson, Representative Payton, Representative Eves, Representative Hodges, representative brushing, representative rushing, representative Henderson, representative Henderson, representative servilo, representative bought representative Richmond, representative Richmond, representative Representative McCollum? Yes. Representative Maddox? Yes. Representative Warren? Yes. Vice Chairman Lundstrom? Yes. Chairman Collins? Yes. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12.
▶ Play
1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12. 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12. With 12 votes, you have passed your bill. Congratulations, Representative Gray. Without objection, I'm going to move to House Bill 1941. Representative Douglas, you're recognized to present House Bill 1941. Actually, without objection, I told Representative Douglas, since her bills are kind of a package that we could present them back-to-back, so without objection, we'll plan to do that. Is House Bill 1941 the one you'd prefer to present first, Representative Douglas? You recognize to present House Bill 1941. Yes, whoever you'd like to have, just come to the end of the table, introduce
▶ Play
Introduce yourself and who you're with for the record. Ryan
▶ Play
Norris with Secretary of State's Office, Business and Commercial Services.
▶ Play
Speaker 107 34:44
Representative Douglas, you're recognized to present House Bill 1941. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. The back story on this bill is that there's a high school class at one of my high schools. We have a teacher there that started what he called the indifference project. Not make a difference, but the indifference project. And what he challenged the students to do is find something around them in their lives that they could no longer be indifferent to. He asked me to come speak to his classes and challenge them, and because I spoke to their classes and became accessible to them, I've gotten lots of suggestions about things that we should change and that they were indifferent to. This is one that I think merits a look by your committee. Recently young aspiring business persons have started creating LLCs and after filing their articles of organization, they're usually or have to be denied services for their businesses under the ACA 427201 cited as the reason for the denial because you have to be 21 to incorporate. And we understand that because you do not want a 16-year-old in charge of a business and then you cannot, you know, sue for liability. But with the rapid growth of technology and database businesses and the quick acquisition of skills in those areas and other areas by younger entrepreneurs who find it necessary to incorporate or organize their businesses formally, this bill would allow business-minded young people to acquire the services of an incorporator organizer who meet the age requirements of the law. This is not a drastic change and would have no impact on current filing process. They still have to file. The state of Arkansas actually does not ask for an age, but it would recognize and inspire young Arkansans to see their ideas through without implied barriers to business. So all this does, if you look at the bill, very, very short, it's just saying that persons who are between the ages of 16 and 18 shall have a person who is at least 21 to serve on his or her behalf as an incorporator or a corporation by executing and filing according to existing law. And as a part of this, I think we're going to do a look at starting a mentor program for these young entrepreneurs to guide them through, you know, the process. Many states, the states are all over the board on ages. Some have no age. Some have 16. Some have 18, 21. So I would just like for Arkansas to be kind of on the cutting edge moving forward and say we encourage these young entrepreneurs to incorporate under the guidance of the law. And I'd like for us to be able to send that message. And that's what this would do.
▶ Play
Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Douglas, are you closed for your bill? I am. Thank you, Mr. Chair. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Farrar, you're recognized for a motion? We have a do-pass motion on the table. Is there any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Douglas, you've passed your bill. If the committee will indulge me, again, without objection, I'd like to let Representative Douglas run her other bill, House Bill 1145. Then we'll get back to our order and resume with House Bill 2061 One is the next bill on our agenda, but Representative Douglas, you're recognized to present House Bill 1145, and I
▶ Play
Speaker 107 39:11
appreciate the committee's indulgence. And I do as well, and I appreciate allowing me to get back to committee. This bill is the bill that I brought you about a month and a half ago on the joint tenancy with rights of survivorship. At your bequest, I began working with stakeholders and looking for suggestions on how to make this better. The frustrating part about that process was I have gotten not one suggestion on how to do this bill better. As you will look at the bill, very, very short, all it does is ask for a way to make a pathway for notification. It does not change any laws about being able to sever. It just says that the notification process needs to be there. Let me just read a couple of statements. There are mitigating circumstances whereby the law can and does cause harm to the innocent. And in these situations, the law must be reviewed, revised, and rewritten in order to provide protection. And I believe that's what— Excuse me, Representative Douglas, would you allow me to try and
▶ Play
help you? I would love that. All right. If
▶ Play
Speaker 107 40:38
it's real help. All right. So— By
▶ Play
my definition. So I just had a chance to talk to the Arkansas Insurance Commissioner, and they're fine with this bill, so if you're ready to conclude your presentation, we'll go to committee member
▶ Play
Speaker 84 40:54
questions. I would take your thoughts on that, sir. Are
▶ Play
there any questions from the committee? Is there anyone who would like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Payton, you're recognized for a motion. We have a do-pass motion on the table, is there any discussion on the motion? Representative
▶ Play
Warren, you're recognized for discussion. I was the one who brought up issues the last time as a title company. I will say that the bill has been modified, and it looks great from a title company perspective,
▶ Play
so thank you. Thank you very much, Representative Warren. Thank you. Is there any other discussion? All in favor? Aye. Any opposed?
▶ Play
Speaker 107 41:33
Congratulations, Representative Douglas. You passed your bill. I love
▶ Play
this committee. Thank you. Thank you. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2061. Representative Hammer, you're recognized to present House Bill 2061. Representative Hammer? Representative Hammer is not in the room at this time, so we'll move to the next bill on our agenda, House Bill 2087. Representative Sabin, you're recognized to present House Bill 2087. Representative Sabin, are you here? The next bill on our agenda, House Bill 2135, Representative Saban's not here. We'll come back up and get him and Hammer if they come back. The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2251, Representative Gassaway, are you here for 2251? House Bill 2251, Representative Gassaway, are you here? He's not here. over House Bill 1753. Representative Murdoch, would you come to the chair so that I can present Senate Bill 498, please? And again, without objection, I'd appreciate if the committee would let us hear Senate Bill 498, and then after that hear Senate Bill 546, and I'll just present those back to back, and then I won't need to leave the chair again for the rest of the meeting. Representative Murdoch, if you would take the chair and we'll do Senate Bill 498 and then we'll do Senate Bill 546. Yes, sir. Thank you very much. Okay, Chair
▶ Play
Speaker 91 43:34
McAuliffe, when you get to the end of the table, you're recognized to present
▶ Play
Senate Bill 498. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. So this is a bill that's coming from the Senate that amends the definition of healthcare payer and the waiver, and so the intricacies of this bill were just something that I really wasn't sure I understood, but I talked to the people at DHS. They are very good with this. This helps them, so on their good word, I'm asking you to support Senate Bill 498.
▶ Play
Speaker 91 44:07
Are there any questions? You have any questions? He can't help it, you guys. Any
▶ Play
Speaker 120 44:18
questions from the committee? Yeah, can you maybe give us a little more detail on
▶ Play
what we're doing here? Yeah, so the definition of health care payer currently says that a health care payer means an entity that reimburses a physician for the delivery of health care services that are covered by the health care payer, but now we're going to get more specific than that. We're going to change that definition to say a plan administered, issued, or delivered by the entity. That way it covers more, makes clear exactly what that covers. So that's the primary change. Were you good, Representative Veeze? Yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 91 45:01
sir. Thank you. Okay, Representative Ferguson, you're a recognizable question. I'm kind of like
▶ Play
everybody else. I'm just not familiar with the bill. I'm just trying to understand why we need this and why the reimbursement is just for physician services. All right, Representative Murdoch, I'm
▶ Play
going to pull the bill down. And I'm going to ask Senator Irvin to come over and present it next week. Without objection, we will pull down Senate Bill. I'll tell her the committee
▶ Play
Speaker 91 45:31
has questions that only she can answer. Senate Bill 498. With that being said, if we can go to Senate Bill 546, you'll recognize
▶ Play
you present Senate Bill 546. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. So what Senate Bill 546 does is expands the options of eligible investments for the treasurer. So today they have a pool of investments they can pick from. This will expand that pool to include one new thing, bonds issued by Israel. So they don't have to buy bonds issued by Israel. I just talked to the Arkansas Insurance Department. They've got no issues with this. It just gives the treasurer the option to purchase bonds that are issued by the state of Israel. Happy to take any questions. Any questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Speaker 91 46:19
Seeing no questions, anyone to speak for the bill? against the bill. Seeing none. Chairman, you're free
▶ Play
to close for your bill. I move do pass on Senate Bill 546. We have a do pass motion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Those Opposed? No. Congratulations.
▶ Play
Speaker 91 46:38
Your bill passes. Thank you very much.
▶ Play
Without objection, I'd like to go back up to the top of our list to do Senate Bill Bill 763, Senator Hutchinson here to present. Senate Bill 763, Senator Hutchinson, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 125 47:15
Mr. Chair, I'm going to find it here.
▶ Play
Speaker 126 47:24
So this bill would grant, would allow, I think it's already allowed in some cases, but it's rather mix whether an association can have standing I don't I don't know I know I don't have a tie it's Senate where you're lucky I'm even here today much
▶ Play
Speaker 127 47:46
less I know I agree with you all the harder workers in the Senate but are we greater overall than the Senate We're more efficient. We can get our work done in four days. Three and
▶ Play
Speaker 126 48:09
a half, maybe. All right. So this bill would be granting associations like the Medical Society the standing to file for an injunctive relief or some type of declaratory judgment on behalf of their members. Oftentimes, individual physicians may not want to challenge somebody because they're worried they get thrown out of network or they'd cause some problems, but the association could challenge a law or a contract on behalf of their members. It would not allow them to seek monetary damages on behalf of their members. If they were seeking monetary damages, the members would have to sign their name to the actual pleading, But the federal government allows this in most instances, and so we'd be asking for the same thing in state court.
▶ Play
Are there any questions for Senator Hutchinson? Can I ask a quick one? Representative Farrar, you're
▶ Play
Speaker 126 49:16
recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Insurance companies are non-profits. How would this affect those? Well, I mean, I guess if there's a insurance companies bring suit all the time on behalf of their own company, but if there was some type of insurance association that wanted to bring a suit on behalf of what they could. But typically, quite frankly, the reason this is needed is so that you can sue an insurance company without raising a red flag saying, look at me and punish me. But there's been no opposition to the
▶ Play
bill. Representative Lowry, you're recognized for a question? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I've been Executive Director of a nonprofit organization. I understand the need to be unshackled in representing your members. My concern is we've already heard a bill today where individuals are not going to be able to enter into class action lawsuits against deceptive trade practices, and yet here we're going to let a non-profit organization file suit on behalf of their members. It just seems inconsistent application of law. How so? Well, the other bill that we passed says that only an individual, and they have to prove their own individual loss. Here, you're talking about the nonprofit on behalf of one or more members, not having to prove that that one member had a substantial loss, but that it affects in an ethereal way the purpose
▶ Play
Speaker 135 50:51
of the organization. Well, the Deceptive Trade
▶ Play
Speaker 126 50:56
Practices Act that you all passed, I guess, that's news to me. But in that case, they're seeking actual monetary damages. And in this case, if a physician or whomever is seeking monetary damages, they have to put their name on the pleading and be a part of the case. This would be challenging on some constitutional basis or a form contract that you're required to sign if you're going to be in network or challenging. a, it's really injunctive relief asking for the court to declare this statute that impacts their members to be unconstitutional without having to have one member stand up and be the GOAT who, you know, the insurance company, whoever it may be, tries to target. So I guess I see some inconsistency, but I think the main difference is we still are requiring, if you're going to seek monetary damages, you have to be an individual who puts your name on the pleading, but for injunctive and that type of relief, and this association could do
▶ Play
it on behalf of their members. Representative Lowry, you're recognized for a follow-up. Thank you. And I understand
▶ Play
the specific, the anecdotal example that you're giving, but this bill goes beyond just the example that you gave. It covers all nonprofits. And I'm just uncomfortable with saying that we're going to treat members of a nonprofit like they're part of an LLC, that they don't have to be identified as an individual and making some type of a claim. And also the language on line 32, neither the claim is certain nor the relief request or requires participation of a member. However, how does claim exclude some type of monetary claim?
▶ Play
Speaker 126 52:58
Well, that line on 32 is what prohibits an association from collecting monetary damages because you cannot bring a case that does not require the participation of a member and ask for damages. I mean, the participation of the members required in order to prove a damage model. So the association would only be allowed to seek relief that is broad, affects all their members, and is injunctive or declaratory in nature, not seeking monetary damages. And you're right. I mean, it does extend beyond trade associations, but, you know, I don't necessarily have a problem if you're seeking injunctive relief. I don't care who the plaintiff is to challenge the constitutionality of an issue or something. That's really – there doesn't need to be a particular plaintiff, I don't think. I mean, certainly if you're seeking monetary damages, there does. But, I mean, think of right to life. I mean, they can challenge stuff in federal court. The NRA challenges stuff in federal court. Planned Parenthood challenges stuff in federal court. In Arkansas, it's mixed. Some people think you can't, but this would clarify that those types of associations, This is brought by the Medical Society, to be just transparent with you. And they're doing it because their doctor members are, in some cases, fearful of putting their name on something to challenge and be targeted for it. Okay. Thank you very much. All right, are there any
▶ Play
other questions? Is there anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill? Senator Hutchinson, are you close for your bill? I'm close. I move do pass on Senate Bill 763. Is there any discussion on the motion? Seeing none. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? No. Congratulations, Senator Hutchinson. You've passed your bill. What we're going to do next without objection is I've told Representative Saban, who we've been playing whack-a-mole, that he could present House Bill 2087 next, and then we're going to have Representative Shepard present Senate Bill 208 after that. So I know Representative Shepard's been waiting. So Representative Sabin, you're recognized to present 2087. And if you've got someone at the end of the table with you after he introduces himself and who he's with, he'll be recognized
▶ Play
to speak as well. Go ahead. I'm Adam Fogelman. I'm the county attorney for Pulaski County. And thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. This bill is really designed to improve the law when it comes to cooperative associations, mainly to improve their viability as an investment vehicle and to help infuse more capital into the rural areas of our state in particular. It's a deregulation bill, which I want to emphasize, and I'm going to let Mr. Fogelman kind of walk you through very quickly the details of what we're trying to do in this statute. And I will be very brief, and thank you, Chairman, and thank you, Committee, for having me today. The bill is, as the stated purpose, is what representatives said, as Saban said earlier. And really, this just takes the cooperative model and expands the opportunity so that it can be used for warehousing, real estate development, construction, and a couple other purposes. I think marketing is also included and clarifies that it's not just limited to mercantile and retail. Right. So it's basically, again, trying to create more opportunity to use cooperative associations and corporations to allow different kinds of investments. And like I said earlier, it helps, hopefully, to bring more capital into the rural parts of our state. Representative
▶ Play
Sabin, did you talk to the insurance commissioner and find out, like
▶ Play
I did, that they're fine with this? I'm glad to
▶ Play
know that they're fine with this. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any questions from
▶ Play
the committee? Representative Eves, you're recognized. Yeah, Representative Sabin, could you give us a real-world example of how this might be used
▶ Play
and effective? You can go ahead. I'll do my best. So this has been used, the same model, and in fact some of the same language has been used in other states in areas that have had issues with access to credit where communities have gathered together and taken on projects to redevelop like Main Street-type buildings where there may be a building that's worth saving and individuals who individually don't have the capacity or finances to take on the project themselves, but when they pull the resources through the cooperative model, they're able to accomplish that. And it's something that could be done. Drive any of the highways in Arkansas, and you'll see plenty of buildings that stand as an opportunity for investment. So it would be
▶ Play
Speaker 66 58:16
a really good economic development tool?
▶ Play
It would be a great tool for economic development. We've visited with Rural Services. We've visited with the Bank Department. Farm Bureau is supportive. Any other questions? Representative Payton, you
▶ Play
recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I was just trying to figure out why you crossed out banking or took banking out of the matrix. We
▶ Play
also visited with the Bank Department, and since the 1940s, cooperative banking has been outlawed in Arkansas, and in order to this really this law hasn't been touched in a long time and in order to bring it up to speed with the existing bank law they asked that be stricken and we worked with them to accomplish that. Can I follow
▶ Play
up? But as I read further down through the bill I mean it does seem to establish a type of banking where you're gathering capital and
▶ Play
loaning it to members. Well it's it's through the the investment structure of a cooperative so it's not not really a bank, per se, it's a business model that works to develop certain projects for certain
▶ Play
purposes. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone here to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Sabin, are you closed for your bill? I'm closed, and I appreciate a good vote, Mr. Chair. I move to do pass on House Bill 2087. Is there any discussion on the motion? Rep. Armstrong, you're recognized. Duly noted. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Saven, you passed your bill. Next, we're going to recognize Representative Shepard to present Senate Bill 208. That's back at the top of your agenda. Representative Shepard, you're recognized to present the bill and the young lady next you if she introduced herself and who she's with, she's recognized to speak as well. Thank you, Mr. Chairman,
▶ Play
Speaker 152 1:00:21
members of the committee. My name is Susanna Marshall, Deputy Commissioner with the Arkansas State Bank Department.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman, committee members, Senate Bill 208 is another piece of legislation that the State Bank Department has asked for. And previously, earlier in the session, I already received some questions about, was there a similar bill? Previously, there was a bill concerning new technology that passed through this committee and is now, I believe, on the Senate end. This bill, Senate Bill 208, as you can see, it provides to certain technology service providers to banking institutions, and it only applies in the limited circumstance where those service providers are providing services that if the bank itself was providing them, they would be subject to the regulation and investigation by the state bank department. And essentially, these third-party service providers are providing covered services that are specifically marketed to banking or depository institutions. Currently, the federal government is able to investigate and regulate, but the state has no authority. And so the federal government right now could not share any information with the state bank department. And so this is really just a matter of parity and bringing our laws up to current day where banks are more and more outsourcing to third-party providers some of the functions that normally and historically were handled within the bank. I believe that Ms. Marshall told me ahead of time that roughly 30 states have already passed legislation similar to this. And with that, I'd turn it over to Ms. Marshall if she
▶ Play
has further comment. Any questions from the committee? Seeing none, does anyone here speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Shepard, are you closed for the bill? I move to do pass on Senate Bill 208. Is there any discussion on the motion? All in favor. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Shepard. You passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you. So now we're going to go back to our order. I'm going to give Representative Hammer another shot on 2061 if Representative Hammer is here. Saying that he's not here, the next bill on our agenda is House Bill 2135. Representative Sabin, are you here to present House Bill 2135? I don't see Representative Sabin. The next bill on our agenda is 2251. Representative Gassaway, are you here for 2251? The next bill on our agenda is House Bill 1271. Representative Hammer, are you here? Representative Hammer, House Bill 1271. Seeing as he's not here, the next bill on our agenda is 2209. Representative Gray, Michelle Gray, are you here for 2209? The next bill on our agenda is Senate Bill 642. Representative Payton, are you here to present Senate Bill 642? This is a Senator Rapered bill, you're the co-sponsor. Representative Payton, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 642. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair and committee. This is a great bill. A constituent, no, seriously, a constituent contacted me, and she is not yet 65 years old. However, she has been declared disabled, and so the insurance options to somebody who is not yet 65 years old and have been determined to be disabled are very limited in Arkansas, And there are some types of Medigap insurance policies that we do not currently compel the insurance companies to offer in Arkansas. So this is a bill to try to correct that. And I'll let Kenneth Ryan James take over. Good afternoon or good morning. It's not afternoon
▶ Play
yet. My name is Ryan James. I'm the public information officer and legislative liaison with the state insurance department. And you can infer that the insurance commissioner does, in fact, approve this bill by my presence here.
▶ Play
Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing none, is there anyone to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Payton, I see a hand to speak for the bill, ma'am. Sir, Representative Payton, are you closed for the bill? Yes, sir. Thank you. All right. I move do pass on Senate Bill 642. Is there any discussion on the motion? No. Representative Lowry, you're recognized for discussion.
▶ Play
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. I know we're trying to be efficient here, but it looks like the lady has some notes, and she came up here
▶ Play
for specific purposes. Can a four-speaker be allowed? Of course she can. I asked her if she wanted to come
▶ Play
and speak for the ballot. Well, if she can. If I can, since we're in the discussion phase, I'd like to warn the
▶ Play
committee, this lady can speak for a long time. I know her well. I know Jackie well also. So Representative Lowry has brought it up, so what, but ma'am, ma'am, so what I'm doing is we're in the discussion phase on a motion to approve the bill, but since a member thought I went too fast in not giving you an opportunity to speak, I want to make sure I do that, and we need to be in session at 10 o'clock, and there are other people that have bills that they would like to pass as well, so it looks like you're in good shape to get what you want, and I sell for a living, and so we have an expression, don't buy it back. Yep, not going
▶ Play
to. Ma'am, you're recognized. My name is Jackie Martin. I thank the committee and the chairman for allowing me to speak briefly, and I'm glad I finally found a bill that Representative Collins and I could agree on. That's good for you. Yeah. Yeah. Actually, I talked to Representative Payton about this because I have been totally disabled since January 2015. January 2017, I'm eligible for Medicare, but in Arkansas, I cannot purchase Medigap insurance to pay for the 20% that Medicare does not cover. So I'd appreciate a due pass on this.
▶ Play
Thank you. Yes, ma'am. Is there any more discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Is there anyone opposed? Congratulations Representative Payton, you've passed Senate Bill 642. The next bill on our list is Senate Bill 683, it's Senator Sanders' bill, is there anybody here to present Senate Bill 683? Seeing that there's no one here for Senate Bill 683 and that we still have 20 minutes before the session starts, what I want to do is I'm going to go back up to the top of the agenda and give people that were not here when I went through it an opportunity if they're here now to present their bill. So I'm just going to run through these. I'm going to do it quickly. So if you're here, jump up and wave your hand or something so that we catch you. So House Bill 2048, Representative Rushing. Representative Rushing. House Bill 2102, Representative Representative Lemons, House Bill 2102, Representative Lemons. House Bill 2193, Representative Hammer, House Bill 2193, Representative Hammer. House Bill 2212, Representative McGee, House Bill 2212, Representative McGee. House Bill 1840, Representative Johnson. House Bill 1840, Representative Johnson. House Bill 1890, Representative Tucker. House Bill 1890, Representative Tucker. House Bill 1900, Representative Bentley. House Bill 1900, Representative Bentley. House Bill 1958, Representative Gray. House Bill 1958, Representative Michelle Gray. House Bill 2061, Representative Hammer. House Bill 2061, Representative Hammer. House Bill 2135, Representative Sabin. House Bill 2135, Representative Sabin. House Bill 2251, Representative Gassaway, House Bill 2251, Representative Gassaway, House Bill 2209, Representative Gray, House Bill 2209, Representative Michelle Gray, Senate Bill 683, Senator Sanders, Senate Bill 683, Senator Sanders, saying that none of those people are here, I'd like to let the committee know that we're going to meet on Monday at at 10 a.m. So our next meeting is going to be Monday at 10 a.m., and obviously we'll also meet next Wednesday at 10 a.m. So for planning purposes, those are key meetings for folks. And with that and without objection, we are adjourned.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:09:58
Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - Wednesday, March 22, 2017

HB2086 Sabin TO PROTECT THE PROPERTY RIGHTS OF CITIZENS; TO PREVENT THE ABUSE OF THE POWER OF EMINENT DOMAIN BY PRIVATE PIPELINE COMPANIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

RE-REFERRED TO COMMITTEE

HB1742 Rushing CONCERNING A CIVIL ACTION INVOLVING A DECEPTIVE TRADE PRACTICE; AND TO DEFINE THE MEASURE OF DAMAGES IN A CASE INVOLVING A DECEPTIVE TRADE PRACTICE.

27:42 - 1:00:27 113 segments 21 speakers

Committee members debated HB 1742, with Rep. Klein raising concerns about class-action deterrence and Rep. Gray defending the amendment that preserves consumer-protective class actions while limiting them to Arkansas Constitution Amendment 89 cases. [27:54] [27:59] [28:06] [28:31] [28:39] [28:41] [28:52] [29:08] [29:39]

Additional comments from Reps. Lowery, Murdock, and the chair highlighted the balance between preventing frivolous suits and maintaining a deterrent effect, but no further opposition was voiced. [29:57] [30:11] [30:41] [31:17] [31:49]

The motion to adopt the amended bill passed unanimously, with the chair recording the ayes and confirming passage of the measure. [31:49] [32:20] [32:54] [33:25]

HB2048 Rushing TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CASUALTY INSURANCE COVERAGE AND MORTGAGE LIEN PROTECTION.

SB208 Maloch TO AUTHORIZE THE BANK COMMISSIONER TO CONDUCT EXAMINATIONS OF TECHNOLOGY SERVICE PROVIDERS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

1:00:27 - 2:27

Rep. Matthew J. Shepherd presented Senate Bill 208, stating that it would empower the state bank commissioner to examine third-party technology service providers that deliver functions to banks-services that would otherwise be subject to regulation if performed by the banks themselves-thereby bringing state authority into parity with federal oversight. [1:00:28] [1:01:03] [1:01:34] [1:02:06]

No committee members offered questions, and the chair moved a do-pass motion that carried unanimously, resulting in the passage of SB 208. [1:02:14]

Rep. John Payton introduced Senate Bill 642, aimed at allowing individuals with disabilities under age 65 to purchase Medigap (Medicare Supplement) coverage in Arkansas; Ryan James of the state insurance department testified that the insurance commissioner supports the legislation. [1:03:53] [1:04:20]

SB579 Standridge CONCERNING THE VALUED POLICY LAW.

2:27 - 46:27 140 segments 22 speakers

The chair, Rep. Charlie Collins, explained that SB 579 corrects a technical error in prior legislation and clarifies the insurance department’s authority, noting it contains no operative provisions and benefits Mr. Kern’s organization. [2:30]

No member sought to speak for or against the measure, a motion to pass was made, and the bill was carried unanimously with all ayes and no opposition. [3:07] [3:11] [3:21] [3:29] [3:33]

SB763 Hutchinson TO RESTORE CERTAIN RIGHTS TO A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION.

46:27 - 5:37

Senator Hutchinson presented Senate Bill 763, explaining that it would grant nonprofit associations-such as medical societies-standing to seek injunctive or declaratory relief on behalf of their members, while expressly prohibiting them from pursuing monetary damages. [48:09] [48:31] [49:03] [49:16] [49:35] [49:56] [50:10] [50:43] [50:51] [50:56] [51:17] [51:51] [52:11]

Representatives raised several concerns: Rep. Farrar asked how the bill would affect nonprofit insurance companies, and Rep. Mark Lowery questioned the consistency of allowing broad nonprofit standing given recent limits imposed by the Deceptive Trade Practices Act and the bill’s application to all nonprofits. [49:16] [49:35] [49:56] [50:10] [50:43] [50:51] [50:56] [51:17] [51:51] [52:11] [52:17] [52:21]

After limited debate, the chair moved a do-pass motion, which was adopted unanimously with no opposition, thereby passing SB 763. [54:52] [55:09]

HB2102 Lemons CONCERNING THE RESULTING LIABILITY UNDER A WARRANTY DUE TO A BUSINESS NAME CHANGE.

HB2193 Hammer TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING DRIVERS EXCLUDED FROM A MOTOR VEHICLE INSURANCE POLICY; AND TO IMPOSE CRIMINAL LIABILITY ON THE INSURED DRIVER AND THE EXCLUDED DRIVER IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES.

HB2212 Magie TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF AN ALL-PRODUCTS CLAUSE IN A HEALTHCARE PROVIDER CONTRACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB2139 D. Whitaker CONCERNING FRAUDULENT TRANSFERS AND VOIDABLE TRANSACTIONS.

5:37 - 56:27 160 segments 26 speakers

Elisa White, a uniform law commissioner, testified that HB 2139 updates the Uniform Fraudulent Transfers Act by renaming it “voidable transactions,” adding a choice-of-law provision, removing the general-partner net-worth test, and setting the preponderance-of-evidence standard. [5:40] [5:45] [5:50] [6:09] [6:24] [6:55] [7:29] [7:59]

Rep. John Payton asked how the amendment interacts with bankruptcy, and White confirmed it permits avoidance of transactions made shortly before filing and can be used in bankruptcy proceedings. [8:29] [8:52] [9:01] [9:31] [9:33]

After brief discussion, Rep. Whitaker moved to pass the bill, which was adopted without opposition by voice vote. [9:55] [10:09]

HB1840 Johnson CONCERNING THE APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS RESULTING FROM FIRE DAMAGE TO PROPERTY COVERED BY PROPERTY INSURANCE.

HB1890 Tucker TO ESTABLISH AN ARKANSAS CROWDFUNDING OPTION; AND TO REGULATE EXEMPTIONS UNDER SECURITIES LAWS.

HB1900 Bentley TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE FOR MEDICALLY NECESSARY FOODS USED IN THE TREATMENT OF INBORN ERRORS OF METABOLISM.

HB1958 M. Gray CONCERNING THE CREDIT SERVICES ORGANIZATIONS ACT OF 1987.

HB2054 Hammer TO REPEAL THE ARKANSAS HOUSING TRUST FUND ACT OF 2009.

HB2061 Hammer TO MODERNIZE THE FIRE RATING SYSTEM IN ARKANSAS; AND TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS FIRE RATING BUREAU ACT.

HB2087 Sabin TO OPEN ADDITIONAL BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES TO COOPERATIVE CORPORATIONS AND ASSOCIATIONS; AND TO PROMOTE THE PURSUIT OF CAPITALISM IN STRUGGLING COMMUNITIES IN ARKANSAS.

56:27 - 35:24

Rep. Warwick Sabin introduced House Bill 2087, describing it as a deregulation measure intended to expand the use of cooperative associations and corporations as investment vehicles to bring capital and economic development to rural Arkansas, including applications in warehousing, real-estate, and construction. [56:43] [56:55] [57:11] [57:16] [57:22] [57:26] [57:33] [57:47] [58:16]

Committee members queried the bill’s practical implementation and banking implications; Rep. Les Eaves requested a concrete example, and Rep. John Payton asked why banking language had been removed, to which Sabin explained the historical prohibition on cooperative banking and the bill’s alignment with current bank-department guidance. [57:26] [57:33] [57:47] [58:16] [58:18] [58:30] [58:34] [58:42] [58:52] [59:01] [59:12] [59:25]

The chair then called for a do-pass motion, which passed without opposition, and HB 2087 was adopted. [59:25] [59:55]

HB2135 Sabin TO CLARIFY THE OBLIGATIONS OF RESIDENTIAL LANDLORDS AND RESIDENTIAL TENANTS; AND TO REQUIRE MINIMUM HABITABILITY STANDARDS FOR TENANTS OF RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPERTY.

HB2251 Gazaway CONCERNING THE PERSONAL INFORMATION PROTECTION ACT; AND TO DEFINE "ENCRYPTION" IN THE PERSONAL INFORMATION PROTECTION ACT.

HB1753 Collins TO CLARIFY THAT THE SUBROGATION AND REIMBURSEMENT RIGHTS OF PARTIES TO AN INSURANCE CONTRACT ARE TO BE DEFINED BY THE INSURANCE CONTRACT.

SB498 Irvin TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "HEALTHCARE PAY OR"; TO PROHIBIT WAIVER OF ALTERNATIVE PAYMENT SYSTEMS BY CONTRACT; TO PROVIDE A LEGAL ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM TO ENFORCE ALTERNATIVE PAYMENT SYSTEMS.

HB1271 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HEALTH INSURANCE INNOVATION ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1941 C. Douglas CONCERNING AN ENTREPRENEUR UNDER EIGHTEEN (18) YEARS OF AGE; AND TO CREATE THE COLIN READY YOUNG ENTREPRENEUR MENTOR PROGRAM.

35:24 - 1:04:32 101 segments 19 speakers

Rep. Douglas presented HB 1941, proposing that individuals aged 16-18 may have a qualified adult act as incorporator or organizer, and that a mentor program be created to assist young entrepreneurs without altering existing filing procedures. [35:35] [36:09] [36:40] [37:10] [37:45]

No committee members requested to speak against the proposal, and a do-pass motion was moved and carried unanimously, enacting the bill. [38:22] [38:48]

HB2209 M. Gray TO CLARIFY THE USE OF AN ALL-PRODUCTS CLAUSE IN A HEALTHCARE PROVIDER CONTRACT.

SB546 Rapert TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "ELIGIBLE INVESTMENT SECURITIES"; AND TO ALLOW CERTAIN PURCHASES BY THE TREASURER OF STATE.

SB642 Rapert TO ALLOW MEDIGAP COVERAGE, ALSO KNOWN AS MEDICARE SUPPLEMENT INSURANCE, TO BE PURCHASED IN ARKANSAS FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DISABILITIES WHO ARE UNDER SIXY-FIVE (65) YEARS OF AGE; AND TO REQUIRE AN AMENDMENT TO RULE 27.

1:04:32 - 39:24

Jackie Martin, a disabled constituent, testified that she cannot currently obtain Medigap to cover the 20 % gap in Medicare benefits and urged the committee to pass the bill, after which the chair reported no further discussion and the motion to do-pass was approved unanimously. [1:06:25] [1:06:32] [1:07:04] [1:07:07]

SB683 D. Sanders TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS HEALTHCARE TRANSPARENCY INITIATIVE ACT OF 2015.

HB1145 C. Douglas TO RESTRICT A JOINT TENANT'S ABILITY TO SEVER A JOINT TENANCY WITH RIGHT OF SURVIVORSHIP IN REAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

39:24 - 1:10:28 107 segments 21 speakers

Rep. Douglas explained HB 1145 would require a notification process for terminating a joint tenancy with right of survivorship but would not alter substantive rights, emphasizing protection for title companies and other stakeholders. [39:49] [40:19] [40:35] [40:38] [40:43] [40:54] [40:59]

After brief discussion and acknowledgment from Rep. Warren that the revised bill meets title-company concerns, a do-pass motion was made and approved unanimously, passing the legislation. [41:15] [41:20] [41:24] [41:33]

DEFERRED

HB1751 Cozart TO CLARIFY THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF AN INSURER FOR APPLICATION OF INSURANCE PROCEEDS FOR ROOF REPAIR; AND TO PROVIDE FOR PROPER ALLOWANCES ON A ROOF REPAIR; AND TO PROVIDE FOR PROPER ALLOWANCES ON A ROOF REPAIR INSURANCE CLAIM.

HB1838 S. Meeks TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE HEALTH SAVINGS ACCOUNTS OF CERTAIN STATE EMPLOYEES.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Charlie Collins Chair Unverified
75 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
11 segments
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Unverified
7 segments
Representative David Whitaker Chair Unverified
3 segments
Elisa White Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 41
1 segment
Representative John Payton Unverified
11 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
15 segments
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Representative Les Eaves Unverified
4 segments
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
2 segments
Representative Austin McCollum Unverified
1 segment
Hank Klein Unverified
5 segments
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 91
8 segments
Speaker 93
2 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 107
14 segments
Speaker 84
1 segment
Representative Les Warren Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 120
1 segment
Speaker 125
1 segment
Speaker 126
12 segments
Speaker 127
2 segments
Speaker 135
1 segment
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
13 segments
Speaker 66
1 segment
Speaker 152
1 segment
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Unverified
4 segments
Ryan James Unverified
1 segment
Jackie Martin Unverified
3 segments