Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Girls State 2017

June 1, 2017 ·House ·3:56:29
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

The House debated House Bill 1005, a user-tax highway funding proposal shifting automobile-related taxes to the highway system, with supporters citing user-pay principles and rural road repair and opponents warning it would divert general-revenue funds from education and health care. [1:24:57] [1:25:20] [1:25:37] [1:25:43] [1:25:53] [1:26:02] [1:26:14] [1:26:27] [1:26:30] [1:26:57] [1:27:30] [1:27:39] [1:28:43] [1:29:32] [1:30:05]

The bill was defeated on the floor, receiving 40 yeas, 46 nays and 10 present, falling short of the required 51-vote majority. [2:14:49] [2:15:19]

Members clarified that Arkansas requires a majority of the full House (51 votes) regardless of attendance, explaining why the bill lost despite more affirmative votes than negatives. [2:34:02] [2:34:33] [2:34:45]

A motion to reconsider Bill 1005 was raised; after heated debate over the tax’s adequacy and impact on existing road funding, the motion was rejected by a vote of 17 yeas to 79 nays. [2:32:52] [2:33:01] [2:33:10] [2:33:23] [2:34:00] [2:34:02] [2:34:33] [2:34:45] [2:35:06] [2:35:22] [2:35:30] [2:35:38] [2:36:14] [2:36:26] [2:36:40] [2:36:44] [2:36:55] [2:37:17] [2:37:32] [2:37:58] [2:38:25] [2:38:58] [2:39:06] [2:41:02] [2:41:05] [2:41:43] [2:41:59] [2:42:16] [2:43:47] [2:43:57] [2:44:17] [2:44:22]

The chamber then considered House Bill 1006, which would require CPR certification for holders of Class A commercial driver’s licenses, with proponents highlighting public-safety benefits and opponents noting its narrow scope excluding school-bus drivers and questioning fairness. [2:15:49] [2:16:10] [2:16:19] [2:16:50] [2:17:24] [2:17:29] [2:17:32] [2:18:08] [2:18:18] [2:20:19] [2:20:25] [2:20:48] [2:29:41] [2:30:01] [2:30:21]

Bill 1006 also failed, tallying 49 yeas, 41 nays and 5 present, short of the required majority. [2:32:07]

After a brief recess, the House moved to Senate Bill 1, a proposal to require gender-neutral restrooms in public schools; supporters argued it would promote inclusivity and safety for transgender students, while opponents raised concerns about bullying, funding diversion, existing facilities, and impacts on disabled-access provisions. [2:48:20] [2:48:41] [2:48:57] [2:49:30] [2:50:10] [2:50:36] [2:50:48] [2:51:18] [2:51:51] [2:52:07] [2:52:21] [2:52:53] [2:53:25] [2:54:58] [2:55:25] [2:55:48] [2:57:54] [2:58:17] [2:58:25]

The motion for immediate consideration of Senate Bill 1 was defeated (36 yeas, 58 nays), and a subsequent motion to limit debate to five minutes was adopted (80 yeas, 17 nays). [2:59:58] [3:00:37] [3:00:58] [3:01:58] [3:02:28]

The session began with a motion for immediate consideration of Senate Bill No. 1, which was defeated 28-66. [3:14:43] [3:15:16]

The House then considered Senate Bill 2, proposing revised sex-education curricula for grades 7-8; supporters argued early instruction could prevent teen pregnancies and address social-media pressures. [3:16:31] [3:17:02] [3:17:33] [3:18:07]

Opponents countered that the bill would not save lives, might encourage earlier sexual activity, and suggested limiting the program to grade 9 instead of grades 7-8. [3:18:46] [3:19:17] [3:19:51] [3:20:19] [3:20:24] [3:20:28] [3:20:54] [3:20:59]

Testimonies from Representatives Fred Allen and Marcus E. Richmond cited personal experiences of early pregnancy and emphasized the need for comprehensive education at a young age. [3:21:35] [3:22:05] [3:22:29] [3:22:38] [3:23:06] [3:23:11] [3:23:41] [3:24:09]

After debate, the motion for immediate consideration passed overwhelmingly, and the bill was approved by 94 yeas to 4 nays. [3:24:15] [3:24:55]

The legislature then considered House Bill 1007, which would create school-wide investigation teams, enforce zero-tolerance policies for drugs and weapons, and establish graduated penalties, prompting questions about implementation, metal detectors, and funding. [3:26:17] [3:26:26] [3:26:35] [3:26:42] [3:27:16] [3:27:22] [3:27:25] [3:27:30] [3:27:48] [3:27:59] [3:28:04] [3:28:18] [3:28:37] [3:28:44] [3:28:49] [3:29:03] [3:29:23] [3:29:30] [3:29:35] [3:29:44] [3:29:53] [3:30:19] [3:30:24] [3:30:49] [3:30:55] [3:31:12]

Critics raised concerns about the cost of student searches and practicality of enforcement, while supporters argued faculty could conduct searches without additional expense. [3:31:50] [3:32:04] [3:32:21] [3:32:38] [3:32:44] [3:33:09]

The bill was adopted with 91 yeas and 5 nays. [3:35:24] [3:35:59]

Procedural remarks followed, with Representatives Ferguson and Vaught explaining legislative rules, dress codes, and the legislative calendar. [3:36:26] [3:36:30] [3:37:02] [3:37:33] [3:38:07] [3:38:37] [3:39:08] [3:39:40] [3:40:11] [3:40:41] [3:41:15] [3:41:48] [3:42:05] [3:42:21] [3:42:48] [3:42:52] [3:42:56] [3:43:22] [3:43:55] [3:44:10] [3:44:12] [3:44:18] [3:44:26] [3:44:30] [3:44:57] [3:45:21] [3:45:24] [3:45:28] [3:45:32] [3:45:39]

Finally, House Bill 1008, offering tax incentives to employers hiring individuals with intellectual disabilities, was explained, debated over job suitability and safety, and passed 89-4. [3:46:44] [3:46:54] [3:47:14] [3:47:49] [3:48:20] [3:48:53] [3:49:29] [3:50:03] [3:50:30] [3:50:35] [3:50:39] [3:50:47] [3:51:01] [3:51:07] [3:51:34] [3:51:38] [3:51:55] [3:52:03] [3:52:09] [3:52:27] [3:52:32] [3:52:45] [3:53:04] [3:53:19] [3:53:43] [3:53:50] [3:54:28]

The session concluded with a motion to adjourn sine die, which carried unanimously, and closing comments from Rep. Ferguson. [3:54:58] [3:55:05] [3:55:30]

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1001 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “Representative Montgomery, you are recognized to explain House Bill 1001.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1002 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “1002 House Bill 1002 by Representative Childers for an act to amend the Arkansas…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Montgomery, you are recognized to explain House Bill 1001.
▶ Play
Speaker 8 24:00
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Okay, an act
▶ Play
Speaker 13 24:18
to require the use of air conditioning in certain vehicles would require that school bus rides over two hours would have air conditioning during when weather was at a certain point when it was too high because I know that in a situation last summer when my volleyball team went to a summer camp in Missouri, we had several girls actually pass out from heat exhaustion, and it's become a present issue for many of our teams during summer. Are there
▶ Play
any questions? Representative Mayberry, for what purpose? Question.
▶ Play
Let's hear your question. How expensive is that going to be to get air conditioners either put into these buses or
▶ Play
Speaker 13 25:15
get new buses? Air conditioning units cost anywhere from about $130 to $1,000. And you would only need it in about one bus depending on the size of your school. larger schools might need two or three and you most modern buses already have air-conditioning in them so as schools replace their buses they would already
▶ Play
have a bus with air-conditioning representative Nix for what purpose question you're recognized where would
▶ Play
Speaker 13 25:46
you get the funding from um well most schools already have funding for whenever they need new buses so that would cover it in that purpose and if a school is in need of a hundred and thirty to a thousand dollars they could take it from the actual athletic funds because it would benefit athletes more so
▶ Play
representative rushing for what purpose a question you're recognized you mentioned a temperature limit but it doesn't stay in
▶ Play
Speaker 13 26:18
the bill do you know what that is. Um, I guess I can't really answer that right now. It would be normal summer temperatures anywhere from 80
▶ Play
and above. Representing lemons, you are recognized. Okay, so where
▶ Play
Speaker 119 26:41
would you, you would take it from the athletic fund right but what would you do like so many school sports are already underfunded what would you do for that purpose and that would be
▶ Play
Speaker 13 26:55
something that we would work out if we had more time to discuss the
▶ Play
bill representative Montgomery has explained the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill. Representative Allen, you're recognized. You need to come to the
▶ Play
well. Okay, I speak against the bill because I think there should be air conditioning in every vehicle, not just certain vehicles, because it only takes for a few minutes for someone to pass out and die of just being in a hot vehicle for a long time. So air conditioning should be in every vehicle, not just certain ones where you pick every school bus, every car. You don't wanna take a life just because of a few minutes because of being cheap for
▶ Play
air conditioning. Thank you. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? representative Collins you're
▶ Play
Speaker 47 28:17
recognized okay you guys I am speaking for the bill because in the bill itself it says that it will be provided in any vehicle used for transportation for educational events or like extracurricular events so provided in every vehicle not just the school buses thank you representative Montgomery would you like
▶ Play
to close for the bill thank you madam
▶ Play
Speaker 13 28:46
speaker and I would like to say that this is not just for athletes it does affect field trips and any extracurricular activities and we air conditioning units if you put them in every bus, it would become rather expensive, and you can't, no schools have the funding to replace all of their buses, and as they do get more modern buses, you will get more air conditioning units, but in regards to athletes, do we really want them to have to get on a bus after they've played in tournaments and games, after they've already gotten hot and exhausted, and have to go through that? I would appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote. Representative Montgomery has closed the bill. The question before the house is a passage of House Bill 1001. Prepare the machine, Madam Clerk. everybody voted cast up the ballot madam clerk by a vote of 67 yay 24 nays and zero present the bill has passed madam clerk please read house bill
▶ Play
Speaker 55 30:29
1002 House Bill 1002 by Representative Childers for an act to amend the Arkansas Code concerning gifted and talented programs in public schools.
▶ Play
Speaker 59 30:45
Representative Childers, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Speaker. Okay, the act that I am sponsoring is to make sure that gifted and talented programs are set in place in every school. As we have gotten older through public schools, I know at my school we had a gifted and talented program in the middle school. But after there were no funds for these things because the Department of Education deemed this unnecessary, there were no programs in our high schools. The point of the gifted and talented program is to present a platform for people who are academically strong or strong in other areas that would give them opportunities to excel in things other than athletics. There are several things in this bill if you will look through your packet. There are certain eligibility things that will make you eligible to be part of the program. The The way that we set this bill up is that if you do not have a GPA over a 3.5 or you do not have the teacher recommendations, you could meet three of the others or vice versa depending on which eligibility platforms that you meet in order to be able to be a part of this program. Are there any questions? Representative Armstrong for
▶ Play
what purpose? Question. you're recognized where are
▶ Play
Speaker 119 32:19
we going to get the funding for this new thing because a lot of schools already are having trouble are having trouble getting the funding for other programs
▶ Play
Speaker 59 32:28
where would they get it for this one the funding would come from the department of education and it would be up to the department of education to reallocate their funds that they are putting into other programs in order to make sure that there is funding
▶ Play
Speaker 66 32:51
for this program in all schools representative birch for what purpose question you're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 68 32:54
how would you fight the stigma between children who are placed into a gifted and talented
▶ Play
Speaker 59 32:59
program and other children okay not not to sound insensitive but as you get into the real world there are different programs that you are not eligible for and so it would just be another one of those things just like sports teams and tryouts and different things like that, you have to meet some criteria to be in it. And so before you did that, there would, the students would make sure and the schools would make sure that there were assemblies informing these students about the program so that they would tell the kids that what the program was for and that it was for different academic and leadership positions so that other people realized that it is a thing for certain students. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative McNair, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized. Would the kids in advanced
▶ Play
Speaker 55 33:49
placement be anything in AP classes be above kids in regular classes, even if they have the same GPA? Okay,
▶ Play
Speaker 59 33:58
the GPA would be on an unweighted scale. So the kids in AP classes, they would not get that extra five point above kids who were in regular classes.
▶ Play
Everything would be on the four point scale. Representative Ritchie, for what
▶ Play
Speaker 76 34:21
purpose? Question. You're recognized. When are you wanting to start this program? Is it going to start in elementary schools and go all the way through the senior year of high school or just be in a specific
▶ Play
Speaker 59 34:30
time? That is the hope, to be in elementary, middle, and high schools. Representative Lemons, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 119 34:41
You're recognized. Okay, so I see that you have to take a semester of an art class. Are you not eligible for this program until you take an art class? Because I know that some people can't fit it into their schedules until later
▶ Play
Speaker 59 34:59
on in high school. okay so what it says is that it will be a fine arts class whether that's drama depending on the school the school would regulate that so as long as you put it in place with your school so the school would be responsible for deciding whether or not that class could be taken in the future and you could qualify or if it was required to begin
▶ Play
representative jet for what purpose? Question. You're recognized. With their already being accelerated program for academically excelled students, what exactly would be the point of this? Okay, well the
▶ Play
Speaker 59 35:34
gifted and talented program would be responsible for leading four events a year, one per nine weeks, and it would give those students an opportunity to inform students about bullying or other things that the gifted and talented program decides to cover. Therefore, it's giving kids the ability to have an opportunity to lead different things throughout their school so that even if there's academic programs that might deal with one facet of education, these kids would be able to inform the student body about anything that they decided. So,
▶ Play
yes. Representative Petty, for what purpose? Question.
▶ Play
Speaker 87 36:18
you're recognized does the bus that the students are being transported on have to
▶ Play
Speaker 59 36:27
be air conditioned oh i guess with the passing of this bill yes
▶ Play
the previous bill representative boyd for what purpose representative watson for what purpose
▶ Play
Speaker 89 36:48
Oh, praise God. You're recognized. Okay, thank you. Like, for certain
▶ Play
schools that have different periods or blocks, how would that fit in with the other schools that don't do eight or seven periods? Like, what about four block periods? How would they fit that into their schedule? Because, like, I know in middle school, in my hometown, we're just now going to start moving into seven periods. We have blocks, and it's kind of hard being there when you're in sports, and you can't fit everything in when you have to get the certain criteria for the other classes to graduate, how
▶ Play
Speaker 59 37:24
would that work? This is another decision that would come down to the schools. So in some schools, there are enrichment periods or opportunities to join different clubs. So it would be the school's decision to make it run as if it was a club or to decide whether or not it was a class period. So if the bill was passed, you could take this up with the school board. If you have issues like that and you can make sure that it fits in order to your request.
▶ Play
Speaker 79 37:50
Okay, can I step out of the
▶ Play
Speaker 286 37:56
well? Oh, I'm stepping out of the well. Okay, when you're presenting a bill, you don't have to even stay in
▶ Play
the well and answer questions. A lot of times, you know, if you think the bill is going to pass and you might complicate things by taking a bunch of questions, then you'll just present the bill and walk out of the well and allow people to speak for and against. The other thing I wanted to point out, if you'll look at this bill, the Bureau of Legislative Research, BLR, is a pool of attorneys that write all of the bills for us. So if you'll look at this bill, you'll see it references Arkansas Code 642-106. So they take the area of code that the bill would apply to, and then the part where they line out, that means that we're taking that part out of the code and then the part that's underlined, in bold underlined, that's the part of the code that we're adding. So it's important that everything that's referenced in the bill applies to a certain area of code in law. Okay, so you don't have to stay in the will. You can answer a few questions and leave. You can answer no questions. And then after she leaves the well, you have for and against responses from the well. And I encourage all of you to take an opportunity and come speak from the well. Don't be embarrassed. You know, the first time you do it, everybody's kind of nervous and messes up. It's okay. And then after the for and against, she'll come back and close for her bill, and then you vote. And you can vote present. You can vote yes or no. If you don't really know where you're standing on it, a lot of times I'll just vote President because I'm confused about how I feel about it. Okay, now, sorry, for and against. She is
▶ Play
speaking for the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Minx, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam.
▶ Play
Speaker 106 40:23
I don't believe this bill should be passed because later on in the bill, if you read through it, there was a wording of a test, a gifted and talented test. And I don't believe you can test people for their gifted and talentedness. What would you test them for? You can't test them academically, I mean I guess you could, but it doesn't really make sense to me how you could test somebody for them to be gifted and talented.
▶ Play
Speaker 107 40:55
I don't believe this bill should be passed, please take my vote.
▶ Play
Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Hindren, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 59 41:15
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I would like to speak for this bill because I think that it provides an opportunity for students who are not involved in athletics or other activities that they might not have the ability to perform in or if they are not interested in enjoying the clubs that the school offers. But I think it gives another program that can allow intelligent students who enjoy reading or writing or things of that aspect to get involved in their school and to have more opportunities to put things on their resume that can help them in college acceptance. And so I would encourage a good vote for this bill. Thank you. Would anyone like
▶ Play
to speak for the bill, against the bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 113 42:05
Representative Brown, you're recognized. Hello, I'm speaking against the bill because I believe, I don't know about other people's schools, but my school has
▶ Play
Speaker 114 42:31
a lot of separation already. feel real discouraged by the AP kids, the advanced placement kids already. I feel like the gifted talent program will waste money and it already discouraged kids that already are in the regular classes. They're not in the AP classes. We all, at my school, we have a program called AVID, which everybody can join. It's not, you don't have to take a test to get anything. Most kids can't even test good. And if you have to take an art class, everybody is not good at art. I know personally I'm not, I'm not gifted in like any fine arts and I think that this bill would be a waste of money. Please vote against this bill. Thank you. Would anyone like to speak for the bill?
▶ Play
Representative Tucker, you're recognized. Hi. I
▶ Play
Speaker 119 43:30
would like to start off by saying, if you actually go through and read this bill, it states that you have to qualify at three out of five to begin in the program. To take the test, you don't have to pass it to actually get into the program you just have to qualify three out of five of the standards to actually join it I would also like to say that this program would give some kids who are very gifted and are very talented but maybe don't have as much leadership skills as some other students do. I know for me personally, I'm in several clubs, one of them being student council, but also know that there are students out there that at my school who are so talented and so gifted and are really smart, but just don't have that voice, don't have that push to do something different. And I think that giving them a different program like this one would give them the ability to do something that they couldn't do originally, that they don't have to be the loudest one out there or necessarily the best one out there. They still have a chance to do something amazing. And like in the bill, it says that they have to host four events a year. That teaches them to get a little bit more out of their comfort zone, a little bit more out there, to talk to more people, to do something. It gives them a chance to learn how to develop other skills that they wouldn't have learned otherwise. I also think that this program, that even though you may not be in it in the beginning, I think if a person really wanted to be in this program, they could work hard enough to join the program. It is not necessarily something that is completely closed off to just a select few. Yes, you have to meet requirements, but I think that if a student was really concerned about being in this program, they would take the effort to do what it has to do to be in it. I think this program would be absolutely phenomenal for those students who need something like this. So I think you should vote for it. Thank you. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Sabin, you are recognized. As a member or a former member of Gifted and Talented, I know how important it is to have a program that gifted students can go to. However, such a new program like this wouldn't offer a lot of benefits for people who are wanting something higher on their resume. A program that has weight on resume or college application has to have to be years in the making such as our current Gifted and Talented program or other organizations that are already present in your schools, such as FBLA, the National Honor Society, stuff like that, such a new concept like this wouldn't be accepted for many years. Not to say that it wouldn't be beneficial to students who can apply for this, but also, I hate to discriminate, but since this is such an easy way to get in, there's another example how much it wouldn't have a lot of weight on such a such a college education or or any job resume because of its easy entrance so I vote that you vote against the bill and that maybe we can come up with one that has more presence in the modern day thank you representative Richmond for what purpose motion let's hear your motion limit the debate to five more
▶ Play
minutes that's a proper motion it is not
▶ Play
debatable the question before the house is to limit debate to five minutes on the side all in favor say aye opposed nay the ayes have it debate is limited Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Wang, you're recognized.
▶ Play
I might say, you know, if you kind of feel like everybody's just repeating the same information, a lot of times people will call for limiting the debate or immediate consideration. So, you know, you try when you, I mean, I'm glad y'all are coming to the well. I mean, this is really more about the process, so, but, you know, you try to kind of not repeat information that's already been presented then that's why you would do that. Of course some people just want to limit the debate if they feel like their bill is going off the rails so you don't have to vote to limit the debate if you want to continue to hear the debate on the issue. Thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 136 48:57
madam. I would just like to say that I understand that kids would feel left out and not important, and I know that some kids' self-confidence is down, but I understand what the gift and talent is trying to do, and it's trying to take kids that aren't in athletics and aren't higher in the school, but have gifts and talents, and I feel like they should be recognized, and I feel like nothing in this world is given to us, and it's something that we have to work for, and the gifted and talented program is something that you have to work for. You have to get your GPA up, you have to do certain requirements just like the real world, and when you do certain requirements like that, doors open for you. So when you meet the requirements for this, and you do what you are asked of, and it's only three out of five, and the entrance is not as easy as it may seem. 3.5 and 4.0 is not easy for everybody, and I think that kids who work for this and kids who achieve this goal should be recognized for the Gifted and Talented program. Thank
▶ Play
you. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative
▶ Play
Mayberry, you are recognized. Hi, thank you. I'd like to speak against this bill because in my experience at my school, every single student that has qualified for gifted and talented in the past, is either involved in band, choir, athletics, or AP classes, or some other club at the school. So this is not necessarily bringing in new people that aren't already involved. And then I'd also like to point out that with the AP classes, that at most schools that's an inflated GPA, and so lots of students accept to be in that class, but this bill provides for it to be on an uninflated scale and so many students who would qualify by normal standards and who are high achieving students don't meet the 3.5 requirement and so I'd appreciate a no vote. Thank you. Would anyone like to
▶ Play
speak for the bill representative Boyd you're recognized like to make a motion let's hear your motion motion for immediate consideration that's a proper motion and it is not debatable the question before the house is immediate consideration of House Bill 1002. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. The ayes have it. The question before the house is passage of House Bill 1002. Prepare the machine, Madam Clerk. Has everybody voted? Cast up the ballot, Madam Clerk. A vote of 37 yeas and 55 nays and three present, the bill failed. madam
▶ Play
clerk please let me i forgot to mention to y'all regular bills just require 51 a majority vote but we do have bills that require two-thirds vote or three-fourths vote like appropriation bills which are appropriating money they require 75 votes so there there are bills that require more than the majority. Just all of these regular bills require
▶ Play
majority vote. Madam Clerk, please read House
▶ Play
Speaker 55 53:04
Bill 1003. House Bill 1003 by Representative Johnston to provide employment opportunities for the homeless to require a municipality to establish a Department of Homeless Services and to create a work training program.
▶ Play
Representative Johnston, you are recognized to explain the bill. Thank you, Madam Speaker.
▶ Play
Speaker 446 53:31
Have you ever seen someone homeless sitting on the side of the road? Have you ever wondered how you could help? Sure, money could do the trick, but that money won't last forever. They need enough resources to survive and get back on their feet. So what can help beyond that? How about providing them with jobs? Through this program, transportation will be offered to pick up visibly homeless individuals to go to do day labor work, workers would get paid minimum wage, there would be many other services offered and referred that homeless or poor people can take advantage of, meaning that these job opportunities and this program as a whole is a support system to help get folks back on their feet. In reality, there are thousands of people in each city who could benefit from the same kind of assistance. scale definitely isn't such a bad way to start. Questions?
▶ Play
Representative Rushing, for what purpose? Question, you're recognized. In your explanation, you mentioned
▶ Play
that the service would benefit homeless or poor people. How do you specify poor people? Like, do you have specific requirements? Like, is there an income cap or what? Yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 446 54:41
there would be an income cap, but as I said before, Once the bill would be passed, we would improve the bill more and more. Representative
▶ Play
Petty, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized. What kind of jobs
▶ Play
Speaker 148 54:56
do you think that these people are going to get? Because we're already low on jobs. So
▶ Play
Speaker 446 55:02
like picking up trash, cutting down trees, I mean, anything that can help the environment. Representative
▶ Play
Gray, you're for what purpose? You're recognized. Would all
▶ Play
Speaker 119 55:24
of the jobs be government-sponsored, or would you reach out to private corporations
▶ Play
Speaker 446 55:30
to have them help create jobs? Either way, I mean, I'm sure government-funded would also help, but I think once the bill gets passed, I mean, it'll be more improvements and more improvements, and we'll figure out that later in the bill. Representative, she
▶ Play
spoke for the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Deffenbaugh, you are recognized. While this may seem like a
▶ Play
Speaker 158 56:20
good bill, all the jobs she just mentioned sounded like manual labor to me. And that seems weird that these people, while they may be homeless and poor, that they might not have the strength and stamina to do these manual labor jobs. Why don't we put them in classes like GED programs to help them get those, or some kind certification class to help them not get these public service manual labor jobs that are, I don't know how to describe it, I don't want to sound rude, but it's kind of undermining to these homeless people. So don't vote for this bill. Would
▶ Play
anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Hendren, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 59 57:07
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Yes, I would like to encourage a good vote towards this bill because I think it is an opportunity to help people who themselves can't provide their own help. And also, I think it would, at the same time, it's an opportunity to help our environment and improve our cities and the, how they look and their presentation at the same time. So I think it would benefit more than just the homeless people, but it would also benefit our communities that we live in. So I would encourage a good vote
▶ Play
towards this bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Watson, you're recognized. Thanks.
▶ Play
I would like to say that being with this bill, if it gets passed, it will kind of stop already like, how would you say, community service, because that's what community service people do. They go pick up the trash and stuff like that. So wouldn't that take the place of the people that does that and what they have to do to get out whatever they're in, that like takes away. If we're giving a job to them, the people who have to do community service, what would they do? That's all.
▶ Play
Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Armstrong, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 58:57
I'd like to start this off by answering her question. What you could do for your community service is actually help these people be able to work for their money because a lot of homeless people are in this situation because they couldn't find a job and they were not able to be able to work. And I think it's a fair point to have them working where they can make money so they can feed themselves and get off the streets. So vote yes, please. Would anyone like to speak
▶ Play
against the bill? Representative Maggie, you're recognized. I stand before you
▶ Play
Speaker 59 59:40
today to ask that you vote against this bill. It says that it is a bill to offer jobs for homeless people and poor people. what if I am a highly qualified person what if I graduated high school what if I graduated college but a job just won't hire me that discriminates against me I'm qualified for the job but I can't be hired when you look at the homeless rate most of the homeless people are homeless not to sound rude but by choice they either dropped out of high school or got into illegal narcotics that left them on this on the streets on the side of the road so I ask that you vote against this bill just because some people who are actually qualified can't be hired but we're gonna hire people who don't have the correct qualifications
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:00:14
Thank you. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Sorvello, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 1:00:40
Thank you madam. I would just like you guys to consider not necessarily all the work programs that it provides but also the education that it's offering. It says in there about how they will recommend them if they're on the homeless streets because they're addicted to something. They have alcohol anonymous in programs that they will be referenced to. I also ask that you look at how the programs it's offering to provide the education, getting them back in school so they can get those qualifications to get jobs. Thank you. Madam Speaker, if
▶ Play
Speaker 168 1:01:16
I could interrupt for just one second. I wanted to let you guys know that you guys can actually ask questions of those who are speaking for and against as well. So there's another little trick and a complication in this. So if somebody's up speaking against and you think they've misinterpreted or misunderstand or whatever you want to catch them on something and help the sponsor or vice versa, you can pop up and ask questions of them if the sponsor has stepped out of the well. That's another method that we use to try and get our questions answered. So I just want to throw
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:45
that in. Thank you. Representative Bragg, for what purpose? Motion. Let's hear your motion. Immediate consideration. That's a proper motion, and it's not debatable. The question before the House is immediate consideration of House Bill 1003. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. The ayes have it. The question before the House is passage of House Bill 1003. Prepare the machine, Madam Clerk. Has everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Madam Clerk. By a vote of 55 yeas and 35 nays and 8 present, the bill is passed. Madam Clerk, please read House Bill 1004. I might mention
▶ Play
this to you. A lot of times there are people that are absent, like what, there are three or four seats not here today. and a lot of times when people are absent if if they didn't ask if they're not here they ask for leave and then that means they they Clark goes and takes their key where that machine can't be voted but I noticed Representative Gonzalez Mark De La Rosa here even though she's really not here so if someone voted that machine for her then you knew there were like that vote was 55 if you have five hands that you don't want it to pass, you have five hands, it's called sounding the ballot. You can sound the ballot and then you go around and everyone who voted yes has to be in their seat. So if there are a lot of people absent and you sound the ballot, the vote can be overturned. So, I mean, that happens on a very controversial or close vote a lot of times that people really don't want it to pass. They'll get, and then people go around the room
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:20
and make sure that people are in their
▶ Play
Speaker 55 1:04:22
seats. Madam Clerk, please read House Bill 1004. House Bill 1004 by Representative Rather to designate sales tax revenues collected from online sales to be used to reduce the individual income tax.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:04:36
Representative Rather, you are recognized to explain the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 180 1:04:44
Thank you Madam Speaker. This bill, if passed, would limit the current income tax rate for the top bracket, which is currently at 6.9 percent, to a lower rate, and in order to do this, we would use the funds from sales tax from online sellers such as Amazon, and I did not know this before we met, but Amazon already requires 45 out of 50 of the states in the United States to pay sales tax, but we don't know that. So we would use those funds to cover that. And currently the top tax bracket is 6.9% for people who make over $35,099. And when you hear, you know, lower taxes for the top bracket, you think, oh, these are wealthy millionaires, you know, they have the money to pay for these taxes. Well, actually the top bracket is not that high. These are average American citizens and they can't always pay the high rate. This would provide incentives for business owners to move to Arkansas. There are five states who don't have an income tax. These are Alaska, Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming. So this would provide incentive for people to move to Arkansas and open new businesses. This would also relieve the strain on small businesses. For instance, if you have two identical products, one is from a small business and one is from online. Since you don't have to pay sales tax for the one online, and you would for a local business, consumers are more likely to buy from the online seller, which helps consumers because they don't have to pay as much, but it hurts your small businesses. So by doing this, it would help your brick-and-mortar businesses, and it would level the playing field between online sellers and local sellers. So I urge you to vote yes for this bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:06:41
Representative Gray, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Speaker. are a little tricky,
▶ Play
Speaker 119 1:07:08
I know, but it's my understanding of the explanation, and I've read the bill, that you would be simply taxing online, or taking away, adding the online tax to reduce the income tax. So she's saying it makes a difference for the average American citizen, but really you're just simply reallocating the funds. You're still paying, just not up front, so I don't understand why adding another loophole is necessary when you're still going have to pay on income tax rather than simply online taxes. And it does make it easier for some consumers because I know ordering online is very important for some people who might not be able to make it out of the house or just simply busy Americans who that's necessary for. So I'm not sure why we would add online tax when you'd still pay it. And I personally would rather pay all of my money at one time than having extra costs every time I go to order online. Thank you, I would appreciate a no vote. Representative Rushing,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:08:12
for what purpose? For the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 189 1:08:16
I was gonna ask a question, but...
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:08:21
Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Rushing,
▶ Play
you're recognized. I want to address the last comments that were made. With the online income tax, it's actually required currently, but you have to turn them in yourself. You have to file them with your tax returns, I think, something like that. Right, it's called self-report. and almost no one does that now because most people don't know that it exists and there's no way for it to be tracked so no one has to pay it unless they're audited by the state so it's actually not increasing your taxes currently it's just collecting on this audits and so it's reallocating that money in a place where it can help us would anyone like to speak against the bill
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:09:24
Representative Speaks, you are recognized. I am speaking
▶ Play
against this bill because I believe if we are going to take tax from people who have more money, we should also tax, or we should reduce taxes in lower income tax brackets as well. So instead of just affecting the top income tax bracket, which I know is considered an an average salary, according to the person that read the bill, of $35,000, something along those lines. And I think that we should also spread that out to lower income tax brackets as well so we don't just affect the top bracket, but people who really need that money, whether it's $200 every six months or whatever it may be. I think people that live dollar to dollar would really appreciate us spreading it across multiple tax brackets instead of just the top one. I urge you to vote no for this bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:28
Representative Sabin, for what purpose? Let's hear your motion. Motion for
▶ Play
Speaker 119 1:10:34
immediate consideration. That's a proper motion
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:37
and it is not debatable. The question before the House is immediate consideration of House Bill 1004. All in favor say aye all opposed say no the nays have it would anyone like to speak for the bill. Representative Dalby, you're recognized. This
▶ Play
bill, oh, wait, sorry. This bill would
▶ Play
Speaker 203 1:11:31
help stores that are closing, like there's a bunch of like big stores. I know for sure in North Little Rock, Gainer Mountain's closing because there's like a bunch of stores that are going online and they're doing online only and that's losing jobs, especially for Arkansas. I know JCPenney's losing some too. And so when you have these like no sales tax on online, you lose these brick and mortar stores that lose jobs for people and our unemployment rates are at like an all-time low right now. So we should keep it that way. and so I'd appreciate a good vote on this bill.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:12:07
Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Collins, for what purpose? Question. Let's hear your question.
▶ Play
Speaker 47 1:12:18
Okay, so like she said before, this bill is already required, like the tax for online is already required, but you have to do it yourself. Would this change it to where the company has to put the taxes together? Would anyone like to speak
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:12:40
for or against to answer the question?
▶ Play
Speaker 208 1:12:53
The sponsor's not in the well, so you can't really ask that sponsor that question.
▶ Play
Speaker 211 1:12:57
She's not in the well. But you can come to the well and ask your question directly to her. She can, in closing, then address your question.
▶ Play
Speaker 87 1:13:05
Does that make sense? Okay. I don't
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:13:09
know if I'm fine. Can I explain that? Okay. Which side
▶ Play
of it? Okay. Okay. I think my voice carries pretty well in here. So she can say she's for the bill, even though she's really just wanting to ask a question. The sponsor is not in the well. She can't look at the sponsor and ask a question from there. The sponsor has to be in the well, okay? So she could come ask her question here in the well, all right? And she can look at her and say, hey, I don't really have a problem with this bill, but I need this question answered. And ask the question and walk out. Does that make sense what I'm saying? So you don't have to speak for or against necessarily.
▶ Play
Speaker 218 1:13:58
You can come ask your question right
▶ Play
Speaker 221 1:14:11
here. So she can ask the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:14:14
question after she is recognized to speak for the bill. So you are recognized if you
▶ Play
Speaker 224 1:14:21
would like to say your question. Okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 47 1:14:24
Thank you, Madam Speaker. My question, again, was someone mentioned that we already have to fill out tax forms and pay sales taxes for online purchases, but my question is would that change it from us doing it to the companies doing it and make it easier on the consumers?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:14:51
Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Wing, you're recognized. For what purpose? Motion. Motion. Let's hear your motion. Immediate consideration. That's a proper motion and it is not debatable. The question before the House is immediate consideration of House Bill 1004. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. The eyes have it prepared.
▶ Play
Do I see five hands? prepare the machine madam clerk the question before
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:15:42
the house is immediate
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:15:46
consideration of house bill 1004 you're recognized pretty please thank you madam
▶ Play
speaker so she asked a really good question so if you vote no, because this is on immediate consideration, if you vote no, then it fails and she gets to come answer her question. If you vote yes, you immediately turn around and vote on the bill again. So you're going to vote for immediate consideration and then vote on the bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Prepare the machine, Madam Clerk.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:16:44
As everybody voted, pass up the
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:17:03
ballot, Madam Clerk, by a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:17:06
vote of 52 yeas and 44 nays and three present. That's not proper in this particular vote. Would anyone like to speak for or against the bill? Against the bill. It's two thirds of a quorum,
▶ Play
Speaker 240 1:17:43
of a quorum. For immediate consideration, it's two
▶ Play
thirds of a quorum. It's two thirds of a quorum. Oh, yeah, for immediate, I'm saying some votes take 51, immediate, to sound the ballot,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:18:05
it takes two thirds vote. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Lady Mann, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Motion. Let's hear your motion. Limit debate to two minutes
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:18:32
aside. That's a proper motion, and it is not debatable. the question before the house is immediate is to limit debate of house bill 1004 all in favor say aye all opposed say no the eyes have it will limit debate to two minutes. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative
▶ Play
Watson you're recognized. I really think that y'all should vote for this as a yes because it's already a law. This is just going to get the money that we are already required to give in taxes already because it is already a law if y'all didn't know. So this is not changing anything. There's nothing being changed. Like, regardless, if you, like, okay, let me take that back. Well, that is what I'm saying y'all should do. But, like, if you're helping your local cities, because we're already enough going out of businesses, and then making an evil level ground will help our small local cities. It will keep small business from going out, and it will also help our towns from running out of businesses, all of that. This will help, and I really think I should vote for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:20:26
it. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Childers, wait, no, Representative Rather, would you like to close for the
▶ Play
Speaker 180 1:20:42
bill? Yes. I would like to address this question. Yes, it would give the companies permission to collect directly from them. So the answer to your question is yes. And another aspect of the bill, there is approximately $100 million that is currently not being collected. So just to give you guys a number of how much we could be limiting these taxes by, $100 million. And when you divide that out by everyone, I mean, that makes a lot. So I urge you to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:21:11
vote yes and pass this bill. Representative Rattler has closed for the bill. The question before the House is passage of House Bill 1004.
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:21:20
Prepare the machine, Madam Clerk. everybody
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:21:42
voted. Cast up the ballot, Madam Clerk. By a vote of 66 yeas and 21 nays and 12 present, the bill is passed. Madam Clerk, please read House Bill 1005. House
▶ Play
Speaker 55 1:22:07
Bill 1005 by Representative Derrick to dedicate the sales and use tax revenue generated from the sale of certain auto-related goods and services to the Arkansas State.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:22:25
Representative Dirac, you are recognized to explain the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you Madam Speaker. The State of Arkansas needs more funding for the Highway and Transportation Department. The passing of this bill would direct all taxes including sales, maintenance, and repair taxes to the tax and use tax, to the highway and transportation department. Currently, the taxes collected from auto sales, services, and maintenance go towards other departments, such as health or education. And so the highways need funding somehow, and it is logical that the people who would use automobiles and roads should have their taxes go towards something that would benefit them, such as the highway system. This would be considered a user tax, which means that, like I said, the taxes from repairs, the maintenance, the sales, taxes from automobiles would go towards the highway system. Are there any questions? Representative
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:23:42
Gray, for what purpose? Question? Let's hear
▶ Play
Speaker 32 1:23:47
your question. So I'm from Northwest Arkansas, and just about anywhere you go, there's highway construction. On both sides, everywhere, all the time. So in what ways do you think highway and transportation are underfunded? I
▶ Play
think that the funding is not in the proper place. I think that the funding that's going towards the highway system could go towards, you know, the user tax and the other areas. and the user taxes for automobiles, you know, the services and repairs on them would go towards the highway funding system. So it's more of where the funding is going to. Representative Meeks, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 106 1:24:40
Question. Let's hear your question. You said that you would take taxes that educational services use. What would they do if you're taking the taxes that they're using for your purposes?
▶ Play
What are they supposed to do? Well, they would get funding from taxes in other areas, like medical department or education departments. But since automobile taxes, you know, from the sale of your automobile, taxes on, like, tire changes, oil changes, all that stuff would go towards the funding for the highway system. And so that would, you know, because the taxes from these things are going towards those other departments, and this bill would make it more of the user tax for that
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:25:37
specific area. representative fielding for what purpose question let's hear
▶ Play
Speaker 272 1:25:43
your question so i come from a really small town and you can like basically get anywhere in under five minutes so where would like would the buses have to drop them off of their house or would they have to be
▶ Play
at a designated area is this regarding like the transportation system yes this bill wouldn't really consider like take that into consideration and like are you talking about buses like
▶ Play
Speaker 272 1:26:14
where they would pick up kids no i'm seeing that um like for the people who live in towns i'm seeing would they be dropped off near their homes or would they be dropped off at other places and and we'll have to take another bus just to get home.
▶ Play
Speaker 271 1:26:30
We would look at that more if this bill was passed. Yeah, so we figured out that
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:26:42
later. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Douglas, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Hi, as much as I don't like driving on bumpy roads, I don't think that we should be taking highway funding, because highway funding is already separately funded. In this bill, we would be taking revenue out from general revenue, which goes towards education, health care, all those things. So we'd be taking out that, and then we would be putting it towards the highway, which is already funded. And so how are we going to replace that gap that would be put into the income, which would be, which is in the general, like, how are we, how would we replace that deficit that we would be creating
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:27:39
by passing this? Thank you. Representative McGill, for what purpose? Let's hear your motion. Motion to recess for lunch. We're
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:28:09
not going to take that motion at this time.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:28:13
We're going to finish the bill and then break for lunch. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Gates, you are recognized. I have a few points that I would like to address. First of all, like Representative Dirac said, this is a user bill. So we have a few low-income families who don't use vehicles for transportation. In my city, we have people who live in the city limits and walk to school every day. They walk to work. This is things that they don't need to be funding with their tax money, with the money that they earn that doesn't apply to them. Okay, so the money that the automobile users are using, the repairs, the maintenance, like tires, transmission repairs, a cracked windshield, windshield wiper blades, this money is going towards repairing the roads that these users are tearing up. Okay, I also would like to focus on the fact that we had somebody speak up from northwest Arkansas. Well, I'm from a very rural town, and we have a lot of really, really messed up roads, and all this money is going towards working on the interstates and the highways in these more densely populated areas. Well, this bill would help us to get our roads fixed in our more rural areas, which is what most of Arkansas consists of. Thank you. We're going to recess for lunch. We need to be back at 11.30. The House
▶ Play
stands rec... Meet behind the Capitol and grab your lunch. go out go down the stairs to the main floor and go out the back door and yes put your visors back on and be sure and be back in here at 1130 we'll continue with this bill and with the Senate bills
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:31:06
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:32:06
Thank you. You're recognized?
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:33:06
Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:33:36
Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:34:06
Thank you. I really need to, I guess I've got to do that deal right now, and I'm just going to change the whole thing. Here we are. Where do you want me? I don't know. Where do you want me? Where do you want me? Where do you want me? Where do you want me? We can ask him. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:36:02
Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:36:32
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:45:02
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:47:32
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:48:32
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:52:02
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:53:32
Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:54:02
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:55:02
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:57:02
Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:57:32
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 286 1:59:32
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 2:00:32
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Okay, I'm very impressed that y'all ate that quickly. We'll take a few minutes. Someone asked me about the ladies, the women's restroom. It's out this door over here, and sort of an interesting fact is that there was no women's restroom in the house until I was elected four years ago. We only had a men's restroom, so they built us a very nice restroom, thankfully, so now we have equal restroom accommodations. But if any of you need to go to the restroom, it's out this side door. If you want to get your picture made at the well, let's quickly do that while everybody's getting back, and then we'll proceed with the bill that we left with. I know it was a really short lunch.
▶ Play
Speaker 286 2:03:24
No, I don't think so.
▶ Play
Speaker 308 2:03:32
You're going to just like... Thank you. I'm sorry. Okay, I'm going to be in the background of all of these, so...
▶ Play
Speaker 286 2:03:48
Huh? Oh, yikes. Does it need it?
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 2:03:54
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Okay, everybody's back and settled and had a quick lunch. I see Representative Jeff Wardlaw has come in, and someone yesterday, who told me yesterday that he was their representative? Someone. Oh, right. She actually said nice things about you. No, Jeff's great. Jeff is chair of public health, so he does a great job. All right, everybody's settled, and I think y'all understand the process now. We're going to finish the bill that we started before the recess, and then we'll also hopefully have an opportunity to run a few Senate bills. We need to be finished between 1.30 and 1.45, so we'll kind of see where we are in that bill process. Okay, who had the last bill before recess? Were we running the highway bill? Yes, about diverting the sales tax from certain revenues to the highway department. Okay, do you want to, is it appropriate that she does a little review of what the bill is, or we just have to proceed with for and against? Okay, all right, so where were we? I guess I'll let them bring us back into session, and then we'll proceed. The
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:12:12
House has come to order. Before we went to recess, we were working on House Bill 1005. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Object. For what purpose? And speak against the bill. You are recognized. Thank you, Madam Speaker. Many of you may not know, but the hallway department is independent from revenue, so there will be no way of knowing if the money that will be given to them, if this bill will be passed, will be used for the right purposes. So for that reason, you should say no to this bill. She spoke against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Mayberry for what purpose motion let's hear your motion I move for immediate consideration that's a proper motion and it is not debatable the question before the house is immediate consideration of House Bill 1005 all in favor say yay all not in all that
▶ Play
Speaker 329 2:14:13
opposed say no and the ayes
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:14:41
have it The question before the House is passage of House Bill 1005. Prepare the machine, Madam Clerk. Has everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Madam Clerk. We have 40 yeas and 46 nays, 10 present, and so the House Bill 1005 has failed. Madam Clerk, please read House Bill 1006.
▶ Play
Speaker 55 2:15:49
House Bill 1006 by Representative Jackson to require cardiopulmonary resuscitation certification for the issuance of a Class A commercial driver's license. Representative Bounds, you
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:16:10
are recognized to explain the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:16:19
Hello everyone. So it's common knowledge that lifeguards and other professionals who work with people have a CPR certification. It should be the same for school bus drivers who drive kids. They need a CPR certification. Just a little talk, it's only $5 to take your CPR class. Most of it you can learn online. Very simple, very easy, and it's once every two years. So it'd be really simple for somebody to pay and get this, and it could be an important way to save lives out on the road in school buses or in truck drivers. And more people who know CPR,
▶ Play
Speaker 341 2:17:24
the better. Armstrong for what purpose question
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:17:29
you are recognized for school buses are school bus drivers will the school be required to pay for their classes or will they have to pay for it lifeguards like I said pay for their own so if it was any more expensive I'd say that we would come up with a method but since it's only five dollars once every two years I think it's pretty simple for the person to pay it themselves or have you know somebody can give five dollars
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:18:08
Representative Jett, for what purpose? Jett. You are recognized. Since it's more directed towards students in school, why not have teachers do it as well? This bill is
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:18:23
not for teachers, this is for CDL licensed professionals. That would be a separate bill. Oh, can I have a follow-up?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:18:39
Yes. You are recognized. Okay, so why is it directed only towards
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:18:47
school bus drivers? This is, CDL license is pretty easy to distinguish compared to like a typical teacher's license. Now in the future, if you want to come up with a bill for a teacher's license, that would be a great addition or
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:19:08
another bill. Representative Mayberry, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 349 2:19:11
Question. You are recognized. I know that
▶ Play
many schools struggle already with getting bus drivers to drive their buses, so how would this affect schools in
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:19:23
attaining new bus drivers? I think it would actually benefit because there's a certain sort of dignity that it comes along with being known that you're CPR certified. And since people know these professionals are certified, they get, I would think, more respect
▶ Play
Speaker 350 2:19:42
because it's a better way to do school bus
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:19:53
driving. Representative Bounds has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Bragg, you are recognized. thank you madam
▶ Play
speaker uh i feel like this bill should not be passed because yes there is a certain dignity of knowing that you have a cpr license even as a bus driver but there are also teachers that have don't have CPR license and so like if the students in the classroom and they pass out this is just specifically for CDL drivers so what are we supposed to do about students that don't use the bus for transportation or are just like in the classrooms
▶ Play
Speaker 355 2:20:48
stuck representative lemons for what purpose
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:21:02
would anyone like to speak for the bill next representative nix for what purpose a motion to amend the bill we cannot accept that motion at this time Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 139 2:22:01
Boyd for what purpose? Before the bill. Right, you are recognized. To address the previous comment made that teachers should also have their license, I think that would be a completely separate bill. This bill only focuses on drivers for a reason because drivers need to have the capabilities in case there is an emergency on their vehicle so there could definitely be another bill that requires the teachers and I mean everyone should probably be licensed but the teachers is a separate issue this bill is focusing on a certain issue that needs to be solved
▶ Play
Okay. Evidently, you all are wanting to see how an amendment is done. Buddy Johnson's a parliamentarian. He's going to explain, you can do that on the floor, but it's unusual. Usually, amendments would be added in committee, and they typically are added by the person who's sponsoring the bill. To add an amendment, if you are not the sponsor of the bill, would be considered a hostile amendment, which would not be welcome, and it's kind of rude and not very often done. But you can add a hostile amendment. But I'm going to let Mr. Johnson explain how that would be done from the House floor. I've only seen it done once or twice since I've been elected, but it's done in committee a lot. People, they realize their bill's having problems. You go to them and say, I can vote for this. If you amend it, then they have BLR write up an amendment,
▶ Play
Speaker 368 2:23:40
and actually the sponsor amends the bill. Thank you. Thank you, Representative Ferguson. Thank you, Madam Speaker. The process of amending bills is a pretty common process in the Arkansas General Assembly. Once a member files a bill, it becomes the property of the House of Representatives. The only way that bill can be changed from that point on is for the House of Representatives to change it, and that's done through an amendment. Usually, as Representative Ferguson said, an amendment is done by the sponsor of the bill. In other words, they have a bill, they think it needs to be changed in a certain way, and then they're afforded the opportunity to do it. on occasion the bill is amended on the floor but to do that it it's either it's done in one or two ways it can be put on the amend on the on the amendment calendar where it comes up just like you've been doing the bills would be on on a calendar everything you do on just about everything you do on the house floor is on the calendar so everybody knows what's coming up there aren't We don't like a lot of surprises up here. So that's one you can do amended on the calendar, and it's up to the House to adopt that amendment. Another way to do it is if a bill is on the calendar for final passage, which is what we're doing with the bills here today, when it comes up, someone can make a motion to put the bill on second reading for amendment. And that's a debatable motion, and it takes the majority of a quorum to pass. So in other words, if 90 members voted on it, it would take 46 votes to put it on second reading. Once you put it on second reading, the amendment is presented and debated and then voted on. And it takes 51 votes in the House of Representatives to adopt an amendment. Back to the original point, when the request was made to amend one of the bills here today, We didn't accept that because there are several issues involved. One, the rules, as all the bills you're looking at are on paper in a very specific format, all amendments have to be on paper so everybody knows exactly what they're voting on. We don't allow voice or oral amendments to the bill. So you couldn't just stand up and say, I move we amend the bill to add a certain word here and there. We don't do that. That's against the rules. So that's why we don't generally do amendments during boy state and girl state. Where might I find the calendar? Where might I find the calendar? When the real House of Representatives is meeting, the calendar is placed on your desk, is placed on the desk of every member the day before the session. So that calendar would have been put on the desk the day before. It's also online on the General Assembly website. All the calendars are online. That's real important because a premium is placed on the public knowing what's going on up here. And that's why the calendar has to be published the day before action is taken on it, so everybody will know what's coming up. So the public will know, and if the public wants to be involved, it will have
▶ Play
the opportunity. and unfortunately you're not having the advantage of having met in committees here usually most of these issues would have been vetted in committee so it's kind of the committee's job to vet these bills and not send stuff to the full body that's going to have trouble passing I mean 90% of the bills we vote on there yes up and down and they're no problem probably 10% are controversial and if If a bill, if you realize you ran a bill and it failed because just it needed to be amended in some way, then the member can ask for it to be sent back to committee and reconsidered. So to amend something from the House would be unusual. Sorry, go ahead.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:28:26
McNair for what purpose? I'd like to speak for the bill. You are recognized. This
▶ Play
Speaker 106 2:28:43
bill says that they would like bus drivers to be CPR certified
▶ Play
Speaker 55 2:28:48
and at my school and at some other schools that I know some of the bus drivers are are teachers, and so some teachers actually would be CPR certified because of this bill, because the bus drivers would also be teachers. And if there was a bus crash for any purposes or a kid were to faint or anything like that on the bus, and they wouldn't have to wait for an ambulance or for the bus to keep going to get them to the hospital, the bus driver could do CPR right then. So it would be immediate and it would be better for the student that were out.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:29:30
Representative Balling, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 446 2:29:41
Thank you. Colleagues, I would just like to direct your attention to the fact that this is specifying for only Class A commercial driver's licenses. In reality, Class A commercial driver's licenses are only given to tractor trailer drivers, truck drivers, tanker vehicles, livestock carriers, and flatbeds. Class B commercial driver's licenses are the driver's license that school bus drivers, city bus drivers, tourist bus drivers, and dump trucks and delivery drivers carry. SO THIS ACTUAL BILL WOULD NOT BE IMPACTING SCHOOL BUS DRIVERS WHATSOEVER. THANK YOU.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:30:21
REPRESENTATIVE BURCH, FOR WHAT PURPOSE? WOULD ANYONE LIKE TO SPEAK FOR THE BILL? REPRESENTATIVE MCGILL, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED. Thank you, Madam Speaker.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:30:51
So as a co-sponsor of this bill, I would urge you to vote yay for this because there's many people who drive these Class A CDL vehicles, and many times they can come across, like, wrecked scenes where someone could need CPR and it could save their life. So this is not affecting only the driver, it's affecting the people that they come across in their daily routes and this could save so many lives and it's all about the public transportation system and that
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:31:24
affects every single one of us in this building. Thank you. Representative Watson for what purpose? You are recognized for immediate consideration. That's a proper motion and it is not debatable. The question before the house is immediate consideration of House Bill 1006. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. The ayes have it. The question before the house is passage of House Bill 1006. Prepare the machine Madam Clerk. Has everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Madam Clerk. We have 49 yays and 41 nays and 5 present, so House Bill 1006 has failed.
▶ Play
Speaker 379 2:32:52
Representative Richmond, for what purpose? Motion. Let's
▶ Play
hear your motion. to reconsider House Bill 1005. Representative Richmond, how did
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:33:10
you vote? Nay. That is a proper motion, and it is debatable. Representative Richmond, you are recognized
▶ Play
to explain your motion. Okay, I would like to reconsider House Bill 1005. Why? Because we did just come from a recess. We were just trying to get the bill, just give it an answer and get it out the way, so I would like to reconsider this bill. Okay, we just had
▶ Play
a very good question a moment ago. Someone had asked why did that bill fail because it had more votes for it than it had votes against it. There were 49 who had voted for it and 40-some-odd who voted against it. In order for the bill to pass, it requires a majority of the entire House of Representatives, whether someone is here or not or whether they're voting present or whatever. So you have to have 51 votes. So if 49 people are absent and you've only got 51 people present in the House of Representatives, you have to have all 51 of those votes for a bill to pass. So that's why it didn't pass even though more people had voted for it
▶ Play
than against it. Well, and they had a good point. A lot of times if you really are adamantly opposed to a bill and you don't want it to be brought back up and you don't want to hear it again, and it's a very close vote like that, if it failed with 49 votes, you can ask for the clincher. And that means if we vote to clinch the vote with the majority, then it can't be brought back up. And so if you're sick of hearing it and you're adamantly opposed, then you can clinch
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:35:22
the vote and not hear it again. Going back to our motion to reconsider, would anyone
▶ Play
Speaker 129 2:35:30
like to speak against the motion?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:35:38
Representative Brown, you are recognized. Representative Jett, you are recognized. Thank you, Madam Speaker. As one of my fellow representatives just said, this bill does not even qualify for school buses because they are not in the Class A category.
▶ Play
So this bill... This is reconsideration of the highway tax. Oh, never mind. Would
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:36:40
anyone like to speak for the motion? Representative Flowers, you are recognized. I really
▶ Play
appreciate this chance, and I encourage you guys to vote for the bill to be reconsidered because, once again, we did just get back from lunch. I feel like people forgot about what the bill was about. And I think that also this bill would regard the highway funding system to help fix roads that are already in place, like roads that are already built. Like it wouldn't be just building new roads and building new highways. Highways that are already built would be helping to reconstruct those and all of everything. So I highly encourage you to reconsider, to vote for this and to pass this bill. Thank
▶ Play
you. One thing I wanted to mention, when you're reconsidering a bill, if you want to speak against, you have to speak now because once you vote to reconsider it, you go immediately to the vote. So you won't have a chance to debate the bill again. So if you want to speak for or against reconsideration, you should do it at the time of the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:37:58
motion to reconsider. Would anyone like to speak against the motion? Representative Gray, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:38:25
Thank you, Madam Speaker. First off, this is more of a question to think about. I'm not completely against it because I do like the idea of a user tax. However, I just think the bill is underestimating how much of our tax revenue comes from automobiles and automobile services, so I just wonder where the excess would go, and if it would just go into buying and spending money on new roads that aren't truly necessary, or if there would be money left over for education, because I just think that if we overestimate the tax revenue, we end up putting the money in the wrong places. Thank
▶ Play
you. One other quick note, too, when there's a motion to reconsider and you're speaking for or against the motion, you have to keep...someone could potentially stand up and say that they're not speaking to the motion, but they're speaking to the bill itself. And you're not allowed to debate the bill down here at this point. You're just debating the motion on whether or not to reconsider it. So if someone, if you think that they've strayed off course on speaking to the motion, you could stand up and ask for a point of
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:39:38
order and clarify that all right at this time we will be moving to the senator calendar and we will be addressing would anyone like to speak for the motion all right representative Watson you
▶ Play
You are recognized. Thank you, Madam Speaker. I would just like to say again that I think y'all should consider voting a yes for this because it's not really here to like fix, make new roads. It's just to fix things that already need to be fixed. if you fix roads that need to be fixed you won't have to keep on fixing your cars you know like bad roads will keep your cars bad and you have to keep spending money to get the cars fixed
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:40:52
so vote yes Mayberry for what purpose motion
▶ Play
motion let's hear your motion I'd like to limit conversation to two more
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:41:02
minutes that's a proper motion that is not debatable and the question before the house is to limit the debate to two minutes all in favor say aye all opposed say no the eyes have it Would anyone like to speak against the motion? Would anyone like to speak for the motion? Nix, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:41:59
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I'd like to speak in affirmation for the motion because the bill has some useful techniques that would be beneficial to our society. And it would be useful because if you don't use the roads, then you don't have to pay for the roads. And if you use automotive mobiles, then you can have a tax on that, and it would go towards the roads. I think we're underestimating how much roads
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:42:35
actually cost in fixing potholes. So I can continue. Representative Jett, for what purpose? A point of order. She's speaking on the veal and not for the motion.
▶ Play
Speaker 224 2:42:47
now would anyone like to speak against the motion
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:43:17
again would anyone like to speak against the motion to reconsider House Bill 1005 The question before the House is to reconsider the
▶ Play
Speaker 286 2:43:57
passage of House Bill 1005. Prepared the machine, Madam Clerk. Has everyone voted?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:44:17
Cast up the ballot,
▶ Play
Madam Clerk. By a vote of 17 yeas and 79
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:44:29
nays and two present, the motion fails. Now, let's move to the Senate bills. If we have time at the end, we can move back to house bills.
▶ Play
Okay, girls, this is, these are, the Senate passed these bills, and then they send them to us. What typically would happen, they would ask someone in the House to be the House sponsor, and unfortunately, we don't have that, but this happens sometimes. They send bills to us with no sponsor, and then they'll ask, they'll just say, these are the bills, would someone take these bills? So that's what I'm, I'm going to read the name of the bills, and I'm going to need some very brave people who have not read the bills to agree to be the House sponsor and speak for them. The first Senate bill is an act concerning restroom accessibility in public schools. Who's willing to look on the strike? Yeah, okay. Uh-huh. Can you have an extra copy of this? Yep. She got that. Okay. Come take this. The next is an act to revise public school sex ed. Who's willing to do that? Here's one. Come here. Oh, well, she's already taught her. The next... Huh? I was trying to find the same. Oh, okay. An act to promote and... Yeah, if you've sponsored a house bill, don't take it. An act to promote and regulate the testing on vehicles with autonomous technology. In the red? Come here. An act to increase the state sales tax for construction and operation of youth centers. Okay, those are the first four Senate bills that they've transferred. Oh, we just got a fifth one. Well, come on. An act to create the mental health outreach program. Okay. So read them very quickly, and then you'll need to present them, and, you know, just like we did the House bills. Once the bill passes the House and the Senate, then it's transferred to the governor's office to sign. And he has five days. If it sits there five days, it goes on through without a signature. but he can sign it or he can veto it. And then if it gets vetoed, it comes back to the House and the Senate to override the veto with a majority vote. Oh, that's right, yeah. The Senate bill would have, we're bypassing the committee process. The Senate bill, this would typically have gone to the House committee, passed the House committee, and then come to the full floor. Same thing with House bills. They would go House, pass the House, then go to the Senate committee, then the full Senate. Okay, are you ready to present the first
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:48:16
one? Okay. Madam Clerk, please read Senate Bill No. 1.
▶ Play
Speaker 55 2:48:20
Senate Bill No. 1 by Senator Coucher concerning restroom accessibility in public schools. You are recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 446 2:48:41
to speak for the bill. Okay, I think that the gender-neutral restrooms is a good idea for public schools. because right now in America it's pretty common to see somebody walking down the street that was born a man that's dressed as a woman and I think a lot of people would vote to have a restroom specifically for like a family restroom rather than somebody that maybe wasn't born that gender to go in the bathroom so like maybe five-year-old girls wouldn't be going in the same restroom as like a 50-year-old man dressed as a woman. And in the thing it says only one restroom per 100 students that attend the school. So it's not like it would be like this, you know, 20 stalls every floor like every normal schools have. And then it also says that it gives them five years to build the restroom so they can raise enough money for that as well if they don't already have one. So I think you should vote for this bill.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:49:51
She has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Murdoch, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:50:10
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I don't necessarily think this is a bad idea. The only thing I would like you to consider is the bullying rates. What would other kids think when they see this? I want to ask you to think about all the kids that get bullied every day. And just because they're gender neutral doesn't mean we should judge, but think about kids who do. That's all I
▶ Play
Speaker 27 2:50:36
would like to say in consideration. Thank you. Would anyone like to speak for the bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 47 2:50:48
Representative Collins, you are recognized. Thank you, Madam Speaker. I would like to speak for this bill for many different reasons, one of them being if a a man dressed up as a woman walked into the ladies' restroom because he identified as a woman, I would personally, like, hit him with my purse or something. I would not be happy with that, and I'm pretty sure a lot of other American females feel the same way, and a lot of other American males feel the same way about a woman dressed up as a man going into their bathroom and seeing them. So I think that gender-neutral bathrooms would be a good idea, And I think that they should be, like, a really good idea for schools, especially because teens do not need to see the teen of the identified gender in the bathroom. And that would increase the violence rates, most likely, because I feel like it would be the same way for the males. So a gender-neutral bathroom would solve that problem and I feel like that it would give the transgender kids also a place in this society so that they could feel more accepted. Thank you. Representative Collins
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:52:07
has spoken for the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Nix, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:52:21
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I'd like to negate the bill because I don't think that it would be... I think in public schools, they have a responsibility to keep all kids safe. And when you put in the situation that there could be a restroom available to both males and females, whatever gender that they could identify with, they could really get around with rules that are in place and go in together. Or, you know, how are we supposed to regulate this bathroom when we're not allowed to have cameras in restrooms or in classrooms? And how are we supposed to keep it appropriate? And then when other students are seeing other children go into these bathrooms, what are they thinking? And what are going to be the consequences? And then there is no funding aside. So that will be taking funding from other education programs that could needed or like the backpack program so what are we taking away from to provide these neutral restrooms thank you representative boy for what purpose
▶ Play
Speaker 276 2:53:48
to address the comment man want to take a question if
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:54:03
you want to speak for the bill all right you are recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 139 2:54:16
um to address the comment oops previously made if we can't really control people are doing in in the regular restrooms because there aren't cameras in there, then why take away from people who identify as a different gender going into their own restroom? Like, your argument was that we can't control what they're doing and they might be abusing school rules, but people are most likely going to do that regardless in whatever bathroom they're in. So I think you should vote for the bill.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:54:52
Representative Smith, you are recognized. I would like to,
▶ Play
whoa. I would like to speak against the bill. You are recognized. Okay, so Representative Collins spoke of how a gender-neutral bathroom would promote inclusivity, but I don't understand how that would work if you're forcing a group that just wants to go to the bathroom to go to a completely separate bathroom because someone might feel uncomfortable with their presence. I don't understand how making them go to a separate bathroom would promote inclusivity at all. Representative Lemons, you are
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:55:48
recognized. Okay, I would just like to
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:56:03
start off by saying that a lot of transgender people do not feel safe in the bathroom of the gender that they identify with, because a lot of people don't want them there. They don't feel safe. Now, this gender-neutral restroom isn't necessarily forcing them to go to that gender-neutral restroom. It's just a place for them to go if they don't feel comfortable going to the restroom, which they identify with. Because a lot of time, they can face violence, and they're just not comfortable with it. Because transgender kids are often bullied in schools, so they don't feel safe in
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:56:51
their environment. Thank you. Yes? yes representative Sabin you are recognized do you think a exclusive gender-equal bathroom would be
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:57:01
safer or would promote less bullying because for somebody who wants to be seen as equal a separate treatment kind of seems hypocritic. Well they don't necessarily have to use this restroom it's just if they don't feel like comfortable being in the other one it's I mean it's their choice to go to this one they don't have to use it it's just a facility that can provide a safe
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:57:39
place for them. Representative Baltz, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 2:57:54
Thank you Madam Speaker. I just want to speak against this bill because in the state of Arkansas, it is required that counseling offices and nursing offices in public schools have single-stall restrooms. So I feel like if we pass this bill, it would be a waste of money to create those additional restrooms when we already have them in
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:58:17
the state. Representative Ritchie, for what purpose? Motion. Let's hear your motion. Immediate consideration. That's a proper motion, and it is not debatable. The question before the House is immediate consideration of Senate Bill No. 1. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. Let's try again without the screaming. All in favor, say aye. Aye! Do
▶ Play
Speaker 286 2:59:13
I see five hands? Yes. the question before the house is
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 2:59:20
immediate consideration of senate bill number one all in favor prepare the machine madam clerk has everyone voted cast up the ballot madam clerk the motion has failed with 36 yeas and 58 nays representative Saban for what purpose let's hear your motion the question before the house is immediate consideration to limit the debate to five minutes. So five minutes on side. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. The no's have it.
▶ Play
Speaker 475 3:00:58
All right. Do I see five
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:01:03
hands for a roll call? I heard a roll call. The question before the house is a five-minute debate on the side. Prepare the machine, Madam Clerk.
▶ Play
Speaker 286 3:01:20
Prepare the machine, Madam Clerk. to the present day of motion, okay.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:01:58
Cast up the ballot, Madam Clerk. All right, with 80 yays and 17 nays, the motion is passed. All right. All right, Armstrong, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 3:02:28
I would like to point out lines 35 through 2nd on the second page. This is not just for gender-neutral bathroom, but for people with disabilities, like wheelchair-accessible bathrooms, and all I've heard is all you guys talk about is gender, when you should be carrying on with not only that part of it, but some of these people have trouble.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:02:58
Representative Wing, for what purpose? Question. You are recognized. What would the disability
▶ Play
Speaker 136 3:03:10
people have to do with the transgender bathroom when they're already going to the regular bathrooms? What does that have to do with them? At the
▶ Play
Speaker 119 3:03:25
bottom of the first page, it tells you that it makes the bathrooms more accessible to them. It makes them made, they'll have bigger halls in them and bigger doors. That way they don't have to use only the one area on the last end like every other bathroom has. It gives them a fair way. That way
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:03:52
they don't have to wait in line. Representative Deffenbaugh, for what purpose? Oh,
▶ Play
Speaker 158 3:03:59
schools are already required to have a disabled bathroom, so what would be the For what purpose? Oh. Question. Question. You are recognized. Well, schools are already like have to have disabled bathrooms, so I feel
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:04:18
like that line is very unnecessary when? Oh,
▶ Play
Speaker 158 3:04:21
I'm so confused. Oh, so what is the point of having that line in here when schools already have handicap accessible
▶ Play
Speaker 119 3:04:28
bathrooms? They have one in each one of the restrooms, period, that are big enough for wheelchairs to be able to get in and for people with walkers and stuff like that. So it's unfair to them to have to wait in line while everybody else is going in and just getting
▶ Play
Speaker 490 3:04:56
out fast. Represent, yeah, can I
▶ Play
Speaker 286 3:05:03
do that? All right, Representative Branscom,
▶ Play
Speaker 409 3:05:08
you are recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you, I would like to speak against this bill. Ladies, I know the weight and the controversy of this bill, but I would like you to consider the structural components of building these bathrooms. Bathrooms require plumbing and electricity and so many other elements that are so expensive, And we already have so many underfunded schools in rural areas in Arkansas that these schools still need things like textbooks and more money for teachers. And to punish a school for not being able to enable these bathrooms in five years I feel is unjust. And I would also like you to look at line 25 per 100 students enrolled in public schools. This means that this would apply to elementary schools as well. Thank you. Would anyone like to speak for the bill?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:06:37
I'm representative Warren you are recognized for what purpose to speak for you are recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 119 3:07:04
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I would like to bring to your attention that transgender and gender neutral are two different things. I would also like to bring to your attention that just because building these bathrooms per hundred student, that would actually kind of work out, because think about our school sizes. Some of us range all the way from a hundred students, maybe less, to all the way up to 800, which, in all actuality, if you have one per hundred, most of our schools are either small due to how many populations of students we have, or it's large due to how many we have. So, building a bathroom might not be logically, as far as financially goes, but I would like to mentioned the gifted and talented program that was brought up earlier. Of course, funds do have to be put out somewhere, regardless if it's from academics or if it is from athletics. My point I would like to give to you is the basic fact that it is our responsibility as upcoming Arkansans that we make sure our students are comfortable, because when you're not comfortable, you cannot learn in a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:08:16
school zone. Thank you. All right. Would anyone like to speak against
▶ Play
the bill? Representative Miller, you are recognized. I would just like to say that as a disabled person that the restrooms being accessible in the transgender bathrooms, it wouldn't be faster because I, from personal experience, know that it's just as faster for everybody else in normal bathrooms and that making it accessible in transgender, like, it's not going to change anything. So that shouldn't even be a factor in here at
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:09:17
all. Would anyone like to speak for the bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 446 3:09:29
Representative Penzo, for what purpose? I would like to speak for the bill. You are recognized. I believe that this bill, overall, is an incredibly progressive bill. However, I do believe that this bill is a step in the right direction for equality for gender-neutral and transgender people. recently um earlier representative ferguson mentioned how they put women's restrooms within the house and how that was a large step when she got elected and i think that it is necessary for the public schools here to take that step and to represent that and to be a light for not like for the nation i think that we have to be the goals um secondly someone mentioned bullying earlier. And I think that before we address bullying, we have to address equality. And we have to address that we have to represent these people and that it is our job to speak for those who do not have a voice here in Arkansas currently. So that is what I
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:10:48
have to say. Any questions? Representative Jett, for what purpose? Question. You are recognized. Do you not feel that the Separation, like a new bathroom for them, would allow for more discrimination?
▶ Play
Speaker 446 3:11:01
Again, I think we have to address equality first. I think
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:11:11
you're out of time. Time has expired. All right, we still have time for the against. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? All right, Representative DeFal, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 158 3:11:45
In the bill where it says that we have to have one bathroom for every 100 kids, well, I go to a school with 120 kids, so that would mean I would have to have a bathroom. And I can tell you that we do, it's not, it's unneeded in my rural town. We don't have that there. And it's not, it's just not necessary and it's already underfunded, so why
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:12:08
spend our money there? Representative Bollinger, for what purpose? Point of
▶ Play
Speaker 446 3:12:13
order. You limited the debate to five minutes, not five per each side, and we have reached that five limit, time limit.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:12:21
Or five minutes, excuse me. it was five minutes on each side that's
▶ Play
Speaker 504 3:12:26
not what you said or that's not what we voted for though
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:12:31
chair rules that it was five minutes on each side and the against side still has about two minutes left all right representative rushing for what purpose you are recognized who do you think?
▶ Play
Okay, that sounds offensive. Who are you to say that that's unneeded in your town? Do you know the hearts of each person and do you know how they feel about their gender identity? Have you asked each one specifically in
▶ Play
Speaker 158 3:13:00
your school? I've gone to the same school with these kids since kindergarten. We can see who goes, I mean, we know who these kids are. I live in a town with 120 kids in my class. I mean. Would anyone like to speak against the bill
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:13:40
Representative Lynch for what purpose? You are recognized Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 119 3:14:02
Madam Chair. I just think all personal feelings aside that most schools will not have
▶ Play
Speaker 60 3:14:08
the money to pay for this.
▶ Play
Speaker 207 3:14:10
Thank you. Representative Smith, you are recognized.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:14:23
I would like to make a
▶ Play
motion. Can I agree? Let's hear your
▶ Play
Speaker 355 3:14:33
motion. Immediate consideration. All right. That is a
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:14:36
proper motion, and it is not debatable. The question before the House is immediate consideration of Senate Bill No. 1. All in favor, say aye. Aye. all opposed say no the eyes have it the question for the house is passage of Senate bill number one prepare the machine madam clerk has everyone voted cast up the ballot madam clerk with 28 yeas and 66 nays senate bill number one has failed
▶ Play
Speaker 428 3:15:46
Madam Clerk, please read
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:15:54
Senate Bill No. 2. Senate Bill No.
▶ Play
Speaker 55 3:16:03
2, Senator Young to revise public school sex education curriculum. the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:16:14
representative for Senate Bill No. 2 to please explain the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 3:16:31
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I would like to start off by saying last year, my school hosted a big, I don't know what you call it, a program, I guess, where we invited several of our city's finest ladies to come and talk to us about sex education, about staying abstinent, which was some of their methods, or just how to have safe sex. But at this point, I felt like it was too late. We already had about three or four girls that were pregnant in my class, as well as several in the other grades. It was a little too late by that point. So if you look at this bill in front of you, you will see that it is clearly stated that they would like grades 7th and 8th to have good sex education. I think that is absolutely phenomenal. Kids need to learn this at a young age, especially nowadays, because you've got young girls looking up, you know you've I'm sure you've seen the post on Instagram they're trying to be older they're trying to look older and do older things so they're getting ahead of themselves before they actually know the consequences of some of the things that they're doing so if we had a good well-developed sex education for everyone I think it could save a lot of students lives as well as preventing any, I don't want to say it's unfortunate, life is not unfortunate, but the timing, you know what I mean. So I think this would be a fantastic bill. Thank
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:18:14
you. All right. Representative Tucker has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Rye, you are recognized. Okay,
▶ Play
Speaker 446 3:18:38
so she said that it would be unfortunate and that we're trying to save the lives of the young women that became pregnant. No one's dying, so there's really nobody to save. When you become pregnant, your life does not end. There's still a lot of possibility. yes, it may become harder, but just because you become pregnant does not mean that your life is over. My mom was pregnant in high school, and here I am. She still became a nurse, and she still works at the hospital, and she still provides for her family. Just because a girl becomes pregnant does not mean her life is ending. Also, I think that in grades 7 and 8 is still probably too young for kids, because if you start educating them on sex, then they might become more introduced to than they would have before the talk, therefore making them more likely to have sex unless, because they know what they're doing, because I sure didn't know what I was doing in seventh grade. So, I think that it would be more, I think it would provide them with education, yes, but I think that it would also provide them with, make them more likely to have sex at a younger age.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:19:51
Representative Allen, for what purpose? Right Representative wart law for what purpose a Question you are
▶ Play
Speaker 13 3:20:19
recognized You say that she was speaking only to pregnancy in the matter of saving lives but what about sexually transmitted diseases okay yes I could
▶ Play
Speaker 446 3:20:28
see how that would be a good thing to talk about but like I said in the seventh and eighth grade who's getting pregnant who's getting STDs who is receiving that in seventh and eighth grade a lot I don't see that many pregnant girls that are in seventh and eighth grade and I ninth grade tenth grade yes I see it high school I can understand I am only saying that the bill I think is a seventh and eighth grade is too young I think it should
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:20:59
be in ninth grade and it should be provided
▶ Play
in health class representative Richmond for what
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:21:11
purpose well would anyone like to speak for the bill representative i still ask my
▶ Play
Speaker 173 3:21:26
since she left the well
▶ Play
representative allen you are recognized Okay, thank you, Madam Speaker. I'm for this bill because there are a lot of 7th and 8th graders out here that are wanting to experience these things, but they don't know what's the repercussions to it. Just because at your school they're not pregnant, they're pregnant everywhere else. You haven't been to every single school that kids are doing this. When I was in 6th grade, there was an 8th grader that was pregnant at my school. That means they're trying and stuff. There's a lot of diseases and stuff they need to know about. And a lot of people are just suffering from this, and they need to know at a young, early age that this goes on almost every other school, and you need to learn very, very soon before you get yourself into something
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:22:29
you do not want to be in. Would anyone like to speak... What is it for? Against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Richmond, you are recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Madam Speaker. Okay, I am absolutely for this bill. I'm not even gonna lie. I was pregnant in the eighth grade. I do have a child now. You see where I am now. I'm standing in front of you guys at Girls State. So I also do understand, you need to teach girls in seventh and eighth grade. At my school, we were in home ec. We learned about it. It wasn't a separate class, but we were taught about sex ed. We were talked about to stay protected when you have sex. I'm not saying that it was something that just was out there for me, but it happened. But I think that seventh and eighth-grader girls should be teaching at that young of an age. No matter what people think, you can get judged about it, you can say that they're not going to make it. It's not going to ruin nobody's life. It's all about what you make it and how you perceive it, how the help that you have from the fellow peers of your school and your family. So vote for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:24:09
this bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Well, Representative Gassaway, for what purpose? Let's hear your motion. Immediate consideration. All right. that's the proper motion and it is not debatable the question before the house is immediate consideration of Senate bill number two all in favor say aye Aye. All opposed say no. The ayes have it. The question before the house is passage of Senate bill number two and prepare the machine, Madam Clerk. Has everyone voted? All right. Cast up the ballot, Madam Clerk. All right. With 94 yeas and four nays, Senate Bill number two has passed.
▶ Play
Speaker 286 3:25:31
We're going to go back to the house, the house bills,
▶ Play
Speaker 519 3:25:52
and... At this time, we will be going back to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:25:58
the House Bills, and we will be starting with House Bill 1007. All right. Madam Clerk, please read House Bill 1007. House
▶ Play
Speaker 55 3:26:17
Bill 1007, Representative Farmer, to ensure safer environments for public schools by creating investigation teams. Representative Farmer, you
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:26:26
are recognized to explain the bill. Thank
▶ Play
you. This bill is to ensure safety environments for public schools by creating investigation teams. Each school district shall adopt at a minimum on policy to ensuring zero tolerance in public schools for possession of illegal drugs or weapons or both. And using this section, weapons includes limitation, a handgun, knife, taser, razor blades, and pepper spray. A violation of this policy shall be immediately investigated by an investigation team. And many ask that, what if someone slipped drugs in your bag and you didn't have anything to do with it? You're not going to be immediately suspended, but there will be an investigation for further things.
▶ Play
Speaker 521 3:27:16
Is there any questions? Representative Mayberry, for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:27:22
what purpose? Question. You are recognized. Are programs like this
▶ Play
Speaker 18 3:27:25
not already in place? In some schools, they are already in
▶ Play
place, but some schools don't take it further. Also, in this bill, we were doing random checks for officers for no less than three times each nine weeks or semester. But at some schools, they don't, like at my school, we don't even get drug tested or anything, probably like once a year, and we were trying to take this further and do pop-ups like every other semester or
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:27:59
nine weeks. Representative Hendren, for what purpose? Question. You
▶ Play
Speaker 59 3:28:04
are recognized. What would be the repercussions of people that did bring weapons to school? Like, I know today in place is, like, they go to programs and they come back later, but would that still, would that change? Or what would happen?
▶ Play
If this bill is passed, it would go to further, as in first offense, second offense, third offense. Like, if you're caught with drugs, first offense, you could possibly go to repel, but second offense, you're getting suspended, third offense, expelled. I guess we'll go through the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:28:37
repercussions of what happens, each offense. Representative Fielding, for what
▶ Play
Speaker 272 3:28:44
purpose? You are recognized. I know you're gonna have investigation teams, but what about metal detectors? Wouldn't they be a part of making sure that it doesn't even be on campus, make sure that just stop it in the first place? Why don't you have metal detectors or something like that, pat-downs? Okay,
▶ Play
well, at some schools, there's over like 1,000 kids, so how are you going to metal detect each kid that comes into school? And also, there are multiple interests in every school. And also, someone did ask this before, and the response was, this is not a prison, this is school.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:29:23
Representative Shepard, for what purpose? You are recognized. Thank you, Madam Speaker.
▶ Play
How would you remove bias from certain members of the school? Like, I know at certain schools,
▶ Play
Speaker 180 3:29:35
they prioritize athletes over other people, certain small schools. So how would you remove bias, like if the quarterback of the football team was caught with drugs in his
▶ Play
backpack? I think fair punishment. that's where fair punishment should come in that he she immediately be removed but this building passed we will look further into athletes and stuff like
▶ Play
Speaker 119 3:29:53
that representative de la rosa for what purpose question you are recognized um when you were addressing a question earlier you said that there would be repercussions for the offenses and you said a second offense would be suspension so do you think the punishment for bringing a weapon to to school two times should be suspension? Because I think it should
▶ Play
be jail. Well, maybe for the drug offense, I don't know if I restated in my question earlier that that was for a drug offense. But in most schools, if you bring a weapon, you're automatically expelled and arrested on campus. So if you bring a weapon to school, that should be automatic expulsion, but drug offenses, I mean, I guess we can go about rehab and then see what we can help you do, instead of just, because like I said again, that I've seen shows where people have set up other people. Like, I slip drugs in your bag and a drug test comes, but you don't do these things, so
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:30:49
we're going to investigate it. Yes. Representative Douglas, for what purpose? Question. You are recognized.
▶ Play
Speaker 529 3:30:55
On line 30, it mentions the different weapons. In the first one, it says his handgun. What about rifles? Can you repeat that, please? In line 30, it mentions the weapons. And the first one, it says his
▶ Play
handguns. but what about rifles? Handguns, well, I guess if this bill does pass, we can go further into rewriting this bill and add all kinds of, you know, weapons, which should be every weapon, handguns included, and rifles.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:31:33
Representative Farmer has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Sabin, you are recognized. Okay, maybe
▶ Play
Speaker 119 3:31:50
I misunderstood, but students can't search other students. So this would have to be like police or somebody of the nature. A question for closing, if we get to that point, where's the money going to come from? This is for paying police officers to search each individual student. That's going to take a lot of time and effort to go through, and that equals a lot of money. I vote for no on this bill unless that
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:32:21
can be answered. All right. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Farrer, you are recognized. I
▶ Play
would like to speak for the bill because at my school we had searches, actually things have happened on campus to where they've heard of someone bringing a weapon. And we didn't have to call in police officers, but it would be faculty members. So I don't think funding would be a problem. Our faculty members have simply like set up like a, they have tables when we enter the door or whatever, and they've taken each of us individually, they searched our backpacks so it's more of a time thing the time to put in I don't think funding would be a problem I think it could be done in like every school without a problem so I vote for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:33:09
this bill would anyone like to speak against the bill would anyone like to speak for the bill. Representative Payton, you are recognized. OK,
▶ Play
Speaker 113 3:33:43
thank you, madam. Something I would like to address in 2002, over 2,000 national teen deaths were from drugs. And now in 2015, where this was recorded, over 30,000 lives are lost, teen lives are lost from that. Also in 2013, there have been over 200 school shootings in America since 2013. That is nearly one a week. I feel like the least of our worries should be money. Our worries should be lives and teen lives, teen students who have bright futures. In my school, it's about 1,000 people that go to our school. We have mainly one resource officer, one, and then a second one that is there some of partially the time who goes to, like, the middle schools and the elementary schools more so. That is not enough. And this, and whoever, I can't remember who specifically it was, said that the investigation, I think that it was you, said that investigations can't be done by other students. If you also look on line, on the second page, on line three, it says that the investigation team itself includes a resource officer. So that would all be taken care of. I think that the most important thing here is we should be thinking about the bright futures of us. We should be thinking about people like us and people who aren't like us, because every teen deserves to live, and they deserve to feel safe in their learning environments. Yes, question. Representative Wayne, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:35:24
Motion. What is your motion? Immediate consideration. that's a proper motion and it is not debatable the question before the house is immediate consideration of house bill 1007 all in favor say aye aye all opposed say no the ayes have it the question before the house is passage of house bill 1007 prepare the machine madam clerk all right has everyone voted cast up the ballot madam clerk All right. With 91 yays, 5 nays, House Bill 1007 has passed. We're going to
▶ Play
continue to run bills, but just questions that all of us are getting, I thought we'd take a little break and kind of talk about process a little bit. You do get very vested in your opinion and in some of these bills when you're running them, and they become very emotional and you become very attached to them and you think you know exactly this is how it should be done, but you're also going to have a good number of members who think absolutely that is the wrong thing to do. The sex ed bill is a good example. You know, a couple of sessions ago I passed a bill that required sex education and contraceptives and abstinence and all of those things in community colleges. And the reason we addressed that first is because when we looked at the statistics, three-fourths of the unplanned teen pregnancies were in 18- and 19-year-olds, not high school students. Although I personally think sex education is very important for 7th and 8th grade. Obviously, you all feel a lot more comfortable with sex education than your legislators. They really had real qualms about sex ed being taught in schools and not by parents and were concerned about abstinence and all those things. So these bills do become very controversial and you have very different opinions. But I think the legislators who are mature and responsible, you can separate your disagreements over policy with your personal feelings about someone. I mean, there are a lot of people that I disagree with vehemently on policy, but I like them a lot as people. And I think just like I talked about the young lady with a disability or the young lady that had a child in eighth grade, everyone comes with their own personal perspective. And I think when you really get to know people and you understand why they feel the way they do and why that's their opinion on policy, then you can empathize with them and you sort of understand their position better, and you understand that they're representing a different constituency maybe than I am. I'm from the Delta. People from Northwest Arkansas represent a completely different constituency. So you do really have to be able to separate policy from your personal feelings about someone. I mean, I'm not going to say legislators always do that, but it's the appropriate thing to do. I wanted Deanne just to talk to you a little bit, because she's house management, about house rules, about dress code, and who can be on the floor and all of those things so you understand that.
▶ Play
So when you come to the well or when you're being recognized, a man has to wear the jacket and a tie. These are our own rules that we have created for ourselves, and it's kind of like a respect for the building, all right? We're here to do business for the people of Arkansas, and we should look like we're here to do business for the state of Arkansas. Women have to wear a suit jacket. If you come to the well and you don't have those appropriate things on, someone could yell point of order and you would have to leave even if you're presenting your own bill. So it's important that you have those. We don't clap on the floor. We clap for if there's somebody up here that's a guest, that's a special guest, we'll clap for them. House resolutions we clap for. but very seldom do we clap on the floor. Let's see. Oh, people on the floor. So the only people allowed on the floor is house members or previous members, and they have to wear a certain badge on, okay, for them to be on the floor. On swearing day, we can have one family member on the floor with us. Other than that, no one's allowed on the floor. That's just our rules. Again, this is our rules. The Senate really has that same exact rule. Now, the senators can come down here because most of them have been previous reps, but we can't go on their floor. They'll kick us off. What now? Unless we get permission from a certain senator. And then, even yet then, I about got kicked off the floor down there, even though I had Senator Teague's permission to be there. We do have a private room, a private area, and it's through these doors and right back over in here. And that's a place just for reps to go. Past members can go. Someone was saying, somebody was on the struggle bus earlier. She was having a hard time staying awake. You know, you get tired from sitting there. You're like, good golly, when's it going to quit? We debated a bill for over three hours this past session. And you'll see people get up and leave, go get a drink, get themselves woke back up and come sit back down. You don't want to be caught falling asleep in your chair because it's live stream. And there's always camera people up there taking pictures, so it's important that you don't fall asleep in your chair. And in three hours, I guarantee you somebody has to go to the bathroom, so you just get up and leave and come back to your chair. Oh, yeah. There is, back there in the back, we actually have a TV in our quiet room and speakers, and you can hear very well in there. Even if you go to the bathroom, you'd be able to hear there's speakers in there. There's speakers all throughout. so you wouldn't miss anything by getting up and going to the quiet room to get a drink and wake yourself back up.
▶ Play
Anything else? Thank you. Yeah and I know many of you have paged and it's a great program for younger people to come and see the Capitol. You have to be 12, usually 7th through 11th graders. So if you have people in your high school I would encourage you to have them contact the representative and ask to be a page because I think it's important and I don't know I might just take a moment do y'all have any burning questions now that you've kind of gone through the process does anybody want to ask anything of any representatives for a few minutes before we move on yeah oh did you have a question sure you can you can get up and leave your seat and go and come, whenever you want. Let
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:42:48
me get her first. Back here in the back. Like an actual bill to be passed. Well, each bill
▶ Play
is different. Like I said, 90% of the bills are pretty easy. They're, you know, everybody agrees. It's no problem. It goes to committee, and it has to come up on the committee calendar and get passed. It can fail twice in committee, and it can't be brought back up. But if it passes the first time, then it has to sit on the desk, what they call for two days then we vote on it in the house and then it goes to the senate and the senate has they don't have to hold it for two days but it goes to their committee and then passes and go to the governor's office so at the very most you're probably talking about a week yeah and you know when we're in we're only in session every other year like this year we're in session from january to usually the middle of April. Then in 2018, we'll have a fiscal session that's just 30 days to address any appropriations or money, you know, budgetary issues. But I would say our job was not just those days. Yeah, oh no, like legislative council works in the off session. We have committee meetings. I mean, I'm here a day or two a week even in
▶ Play
Speaker 534 3:44:10
the off session usually. Is there, like, for representatives, are there,
▶ Play
Speaker 542 3:44:12
like, a certain amount of absences or anything that you can use before, you
▶ Play
know, you can be in trouble? No. No, you wouldn't want to miss too many, though, or it might be a campaign issue when you have an opponent the next time.
▶ Play
Speaker 231 3:44:26
Can I address something with that? So we have what you call leave,
▶ Play
and you can have one of your fellow members ask for leave for you. And you can always pair your vote with somebody if you're going to be gone two days for, like, medical reason or something. You could pair your vote with a parliamentarian, get it paired correctly. And you could still vote, even though you're not in your seat, by leave and it being paired. Does that make sense? Yes.
▶ Play
It's seniority. We all come in here, all the chairs are cleared, and we start with the person who's been here the longest, who's representing Meeks' brother, Stephen Meeks. And you go in order of seniority from 1 to 100, and you choose your seat. You know, the seats in the back
▶ Play
Speaker 222 3:45:21
go first, usually. Or it's just less disruptive
▶ Play
to get up and go to the quiet room and leave if you're sitting in the back. Yes? In order
▶ Play
Speaker 270 3:45:32
to get to this point of being representative for the House, did you go through a lot of local government in
▶ Play
order to... I think everyone's done it differently. I never served in public office before. Like I said, I was a dentist for 25 years and then ran for state representative. I had been very involved in government. My husband was a representative. My father-in-law was a representative. My mother-in-law was a mayor. So I had been involved with other people's campaigns, but many people have been county judges and mayors. I mean, we all come from very different backgrounds. You know, we have two members this time that were 23 years old right out of college. So, and I think that diversity is the strength of the legislature. Like I said, everyone comes with their own unique perspective, and that contributes to the process. Anyone else? All right, let's go to
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:46:29
the next House bill then. Madam Clerk, please read House Bill 1008.
▶ Play
Speaker 55 3:46:44
House Bill 1008, Representative Furman, to create a tax incentive for programs that aid individuals with intellectual disabilities in finding employment. Fuhrman,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:46:54
you are recognized to explain the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 446 3:47:14
So I would like to start with a little bit of history of Arkansas first. In 1883, we established the Arkansas State Hospital. This was a place that served as an asylum for mentally disabled and mentally ill patients. It gave them a structured society and a structured lifestyle in which they could adapt to the changing environment around them because it was an era of reconstruction, and there was a lot that the nation had to do from the ground up. And while this plan worked for a very long time, in the 1970s, it began to falter. And with the rise of individualism and the want for community-based, like community-based volunteering to help these mentally ill patients, the Arkansas State Hospital ceased to exist. And some statistics I would like to throw out there before I really discuss the bill is that 57,000 people in this nation are imprisoned and they also have mental health conditions. I would also like to say that one in four Arkansans lack health insurance, and that's already on top of the fact that there is a lack in Arkansas of mental health insurance that's adequate. And then 26% of the homeless in the United States as well, they are also mentally disabled. So what this bill is going to do is they're going to go through a screening process. The mentally disabled that are willing to go into this process and find a job, they go into a screening or a job interview. And during that job interview, the interviewer attests their diagnosis, sees to the extent that their disability is, and will pair them with an employer. And I'm going to get to that in a minute, like how all that works. It pairs them with an employer that will provide them with a job best suited for them in a safe environment. So with the employer, the employer will apply for this. It's going to be a state program based off funding from state revenue. So they're going to go into a process, and by doing that and pairing with this and hiring those mentally disabled people, they're going to receive a tax cut annually, and it's going to be based off a six-month period. They're going to have to hire this mentally disabled person for a six-month period, and after that six-month period is completed, there's going to be an evaluation to make sure that everything is okay, everything is safe, and it's prepared to the best ability, and they're being efficient in their job. And after that, there's going to be a tax cut that they will receive to promote it and to give those employers some incentive to help with this process and bring those people up. So we're moving from that period of reconstruction and that period of rebuilding and doing things such as that with the Arkansas State Hospital, and we're taking what we've learned from that, and we're creating a period of renewal and really just creating a new program that could serve as an example for the nation.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:50:30
I'll take questions. Representative Sabin, purpose.
▶ Play
Speaker 10 3:50:35
For what purpose? How would you guarantee safe places for these workers? So that's
▶ Play
Speaker 446 3:50:39
going to be based off the interview process. Like, are you talking about discrimination and just? Ill
▶ Play
Speaker 119 3:50:47
people have, like, social problems. Really hard for them to work in, like, a social environment. I guess that would be part of the screening process, but how could you guarantee that they would get a job? How could you guarantee that they would get
▶ Play
Speaker 446 3:51:01
a job in that? That is what this program is. That is the entire, like, the entire basis and foundation of this program, is that these employers are pairing with the state and, like, volunteering themselves because of that incentive with the tax cut. They're going to pair themselves with this program, and after the interview process is over, we're going to assess, like, we're going to assess where that person will be best suited, like, among the employers that we
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:51:34
have, like, we have. Representative Gray, what is your purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 119 3:51:38
You are recognized. Thank you. I like the bill. I just would like some examples, because I'm trying to better understand it, of jobs that you think would benefit both employer and those with intellectual disabilities that they could do and
▶ Play
Speaker 554 3:51:55
would work in this program. Okay. So going along with that,
▶ Play
Speaker 446 3:52:03
for an example, a person with OCD wouldn't necessarily be able to work in a job that is chaotic and doesn't have organization. And so if they were able to get a job in, like, not waitressing or something among those lines, but something like being maybe a secretary or being someone that just organizes things, that would be the type of job with a
▶ Play
Speaker 445 3:52:27
private company that they could
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:52:32
aid in. Okay. Representative Furman has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Would anyone like to speak for the bill? All right. Representative Leidyman, you are
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you Madam Speaker. I would vote for this bill because there are people who do have these disabilities and the only way that they can take their mind off that disability is if they do something. If they're just sitting at home, then they're just overthinking things or they're not really doing anything. So I think this would be a good opportunity for for them to break out of their comfort zone, do things that they normally wouldn't do, so I vote
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:53:43
yes. Thank you. Representative Gray, what is your purpose? Motion. Let's hear your motion. Immediate consideration. That's a proper motion, and it is not debatable. The question before the House is immediate consideration of House Bill 1008. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. The ayes have it. The question before the House is passage of House Bill 1008. Prepare the machine, Madam Clerk. All right, has everyone voted? All right, cast up the ballot, Madam Clerk. All right, with 89 yays and 4 nays, the House Bill 1008 has passed. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for what purpose?
▶ Play
Madam Speaker, I move we adjourn sine die. That
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 3:55:05
is a proper motion and it is not debatable. The question before the House is to adjourn the girls' state legislature's sine die. Proper motion, not debatable. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. The ayes have it. The session is adjourned.
▶ Play
Turn my mic on. Great job, girls. I'm sorry we didn't get to everybody's bill, but I think you do understand the process a little better. It's been a pleasure having you, and I think you all are supposed to, you have a little time. They say between 1.30 and 1.45 to get to the bus, so you don't have to hurry. So if you still need to get your picture at the well or any of those things, you probably have five minutes to do that. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 3:56:27
You
▶ Play

Agenda

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
196 segments
Speaker 8
1 segment
Speaker 13
10 segments
Representative Andy Mayberry Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 119
62 segments
Representative Fred Allen Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 47
7 segments
Speaker 55
13 segments
Speaker 59
22 segments
Speaker 66
1 segment
Speaker 68
1 segment
Speaker 76
1 segment
Speaker 87
2 segments
Speaker 89
1 segment
Representative Danny Watson Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 79
1 segment
Speaker 286
46 segments
Representative Deborah Ferguson Unverified
53 segments
Speaker 106
4 segments
Speaker 107
1 segment
Speaker 113
5 segments
Speaker 114
2 segments
Representative Marcus E. Richmond Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 136
4 segments
Speaker 446
31 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 148
2 segments
Speaker 158
7 segments
Speaker 168
2 segments
Speaker 180
7 segments
Speaker 189
1 segment
Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
2 segments
Representative Carol Dalby Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 203
2 segments
Speaker 208
1 segment
Speaker 211
1 segment
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 218
1 segment
Speaker 221
1 segment
Speaker 224
2 segments
Representative Carlton Wing Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 240
1 segment
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
3 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 32
1 segment
Speaker 272
6 segments
Speaker 271
1 segment
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 308
1 segment
Speaker 329
1 segment
Speaker 341
1 segment
Speaker 349
1 segment
Speaker 350
1 segment
Representative Ken Bragg Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 355
2 segments
Speaker 139
3 segments
Speaker 368
8 segments
Speaker 379
1 segment
Speaker 129
1 segment
Speaker 27
1 segment
Speaker 276
1 segment
Representative Brandt Smith Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 475
1 segment
Speaker 490
1 segment
Speaker 409
2 segments
Representative Josh Miller Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 504
1 segment
Speaker 60
1 segment
Speaker 207
1 segment
Speaker 428
1 segment
Speaker 173
1 segment
Speaker 519
1 segment
Speaker 521
1 segment
Speaker 18
1 segment
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 529
1 segment
Representative Joe Farrer Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 534
1 segment
Speaker 542
1 segment
Speaker 231
1 segment
Speaker 222
1 segment
Speaker 270
1 segment
Speaker 10
1 segment
Speaker 554
1 segment
Speaker 445
1 segment
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Unverified
1 segment