Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Meeting

March 14, 2018 ·House ·1:26:15
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

Subtitle Sponsor Number 13:51

Representative Jeremy Gillam recognized Representative-elect Donald Ragland as the successor to Rep. Branscombe and announced the presence of guests from Ridgeview Mennonite School and the Jonesboro delegation. [14:02] [14:36]

He then asked the clerk to read House Bill 1003, which Rep. Laurie Rushing identified as a measure to amend the law on defenses to prosecution for operating an all-terrain vehicle on public streets and to declare an emergency. [15:08] [15:28]

HB1003 Maddox TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DEFENSES TO PROSECUTION FOR A VIOLATION OF OPERATING AN ALL-TERRAIN VEHICLE UPON A PUBLIC STREET OR HIGHWAY; AND … 15:31

Rep. John Maddox presented HB 1003, explaining that it would reverse the 2017 restriction on ATV trailhead-to-trailhead exemptions that had harmed tourism in his district and noting that there was no known opposition. [15:39] [15:54] [16:13] [16:45] [17:16]

After closing the bill, the House voted 92 yeas, 0 nays and 1 present, thereby passing the bill and its emergency clause. [17:49] [18:22] [18:37]

HB1008 Gillam TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ACT. 18:44

Rep. Jeremy Gillam introduced HB 1008, outlining amendments to the Arkansas Tax-Deferred Tuition Savings Program to make the 529 plan compatible with the federal ABLE program and newly added K-12 provisions, and he provided cost estimates and answered questions from Reps. Blake and others. [18:53] [19:02] [19:26] [19:59] [20:33] [21:04] [21:35] [22:05] [22:39] [23:11] [23:44] [24:15] [24:46] [25:16] [25:48] [26:19] [26:51] [27:22] [27:57] [28:29] [29:00] [29:38] [30:09] [30:40] [31:12] [31:46] [32:12]

The House subsequently voted 62 yeas, 16 nays and 10 present, resulting in passage of the bill. [38:53]

HB1009 Lowery TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE LIMIT ON SCHOOL CHOICE TRANSFERS UNDER THE PUBLIC SCHOOL CHOICE ACT OF 2015. 39:49

Rep. Mark Lowery explained HB 1009 as a technical fix to the 3 % school-choice cap, clarifying that siblings would count as one applicant only when the cap is reached to prevent unintended exceedances of the limit. [39:55] [40:00] [40:32] [41:04] [41:38]

Following brief questions, the House voted 76 yeas, 4 nays and 8 present, and the bill was adopted. [43:33] [43:51]

HB1007 Wardlaw TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE MODIFICATION AND REVIEW OF PERMITS ISSUED BY THE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY. 44:57

Rep. Jeff Wardlaw presented HB 1007 to codify current Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality permit-modification practices, assuring that it does not alter public comment periods or create EPA compliance issues; Rep. Stephen Meeks and Rep. Kim Hendren raised procedural questions that were addressed. [45:07] [45:12] [45:33] [46:05] [46:36] [46:48] [47:08] [47:32] [47:38] [48:10] [48:42] [48:53] [49:13] [49:44] [49:46] [49:55] [50:17]

The House then voted 73 yeas, 6 nays and 13 present, passing the bill and its emergency clause. [51:27] [52:02] [52:35]

HB1005 Bentley TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENT FOR CERTAIN PROPERTY UNDER THE CONTROL AND MANAGEMENT OF THE STATE PARKS, RECREATION, AND TRAVEL COMMISSION; AND TO DEC… 52:48

Rep. Mary Bentley introduced HB 1005, arguing that removing the $25,000 expenditure reporting requirement would streamline trail development in state parks and that the change posed no conflict with the Department of Finance and Administration. [52:57] [53:05] [53:37] [54:07]

With the bill closed for discussion, the House voted unanimously-94 yeas, 0 nays, 0 present-to enact the measure. [54:39]

HB1001 Pitsch CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF AN OPEN CONTAINER OF ALCOHOL IN A MOTOR VEHICLE; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS NECESSARY TO AVOID FUTURE FEDERAL… 54:57

Rep. Mathew W. Pitsch presented HB 1001 to update the definition of an open container in vehicles to align with federal highway funding requirements and avoid penalties, noting the bill’s straightforward technical corrections. [55:09] [55:15] [55:42]

After closing the bill, the House adopted it unanimously with 94 yeas, 0 nays and 0 present. [56:14] [56:45]

HB1010 M. Gray TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS PHARMACY BENEFITS MANAGER LICENSURE ACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY 56:59

Representative Michelle Gray presented HB 1010, the Arkansas Pharmacy Benefits Manager Licensure Act, explaining that it creates a new licensure scheme for PBMs, establishes network-adequacy standards, sets compensation and prohibited-practice rules (including a gag-clause prohibition), adds a severability provision and an emergency clause to make the law take effect immediately. [57:01] [57:09] [57:16] [57:51] [58:24] [58:55] [59:25] [59:58] [1:00:32] [1:01:05] [1:01:40] [1:02:13] [1:02:43] [1:03:17] [1:03:48] [1:04:23] [1:04:55]

During the debate Rep. Jack Ladyman asked if the bill would eliminate PBM “spread” billing; Gray responded that the bill does not ban the practice but requires PBMs to submit annual data reports and gives the insurance commissioner authority to regulate harmful practices, while Rep. Kim Hendren’s concerns about small-town pharmacies were addressed by noting the network-adequacy provisions are intended to protect rural pharmacies and are not expected to raise drug prices. [1:05:44] [1:05:57] [1:06:02] [1:06:06] [1:06:39] [1:07:10] [1:07:35] [1:07:43] [1:08:19] [1:08:43] [1:08:52] [1:09:18] [1:09:25] [1:09:55] [1:10:25] [1:10:57] [1:11:29] [1:12:01] [1:12:04] [1:12:38] [1:13:11] [1:13:41] [1:14:14]

The House voted on HB 1010 and its emergency clause, approving the measure with 92 yeas, 2 nays and 2 present, thereby enacting the bill. [1:16:54]

Bills discussed (7)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1003 Act 48 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1003 Maddox TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DEFENSES TO PROSECUT…”
AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS BOARD OF PODIATRIC MEDICINE APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2018-2019 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Returned by the Committee Do Pass
HB1008 Act 132 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1008 Gillam TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS P…”
AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - OFFICE OF CHILD SUPPORT ENFORCEMENT … Joint Budget Committee Notification that HB1008 is now Act 132
HB1009 Act 240 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Mr. Clerk, read House Bill 1009. House Bill”
AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - MANAGEMENT SERVICES DIVISION APPROPRIATION FOR … Joint Budget Committee Notification that HB1009 is now Act 240
HB1001 Act 222 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1001 Pitsch CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF AN OPEN CONTAINER OF AL…”
AN ACT FOR THE ARKANSAS HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE NINETY-FIRST GENERAL ASSEMBLY APPROPRIATION FOR … House Management Notification that HB1001 is now Act 222
HB1005 Act 130 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1005 Bentley TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENT FOR CERTAIN PROPERTY UNDER…”
AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE CONTROL DIVISION APPROPRIATION … Joint Budget Committee Notification that HB1005 is now Act 130
HB1007 Act 216 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1007 Wardlaw TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE MODIFICATION A…”
AN ACT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION - REVENUE SERVICES DIVISION APPROPRIATION FOR … Joint Budget Committee Notification that HB1007 is now Act 216
HB1010 Act 49 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1010 M. Gray TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS PHARMACY BENEFITS MANAGER LI…”
AN ACT FOR THE VETERINARY MEDICAL EXAMINING BOARD APPROPRIATION FOR THE 2018-2019 FISCAL YEAR. Joint Budget Committee Notification that HB1010 is now Act 49

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 2 1:00
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 2:00
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 2 6:30
Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 7:00
Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 10 8:00
Thank you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 8:30
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
The House will be called into order at this time. I invite all of our members, our staff and guests, press and the galleries to stand and to be led in prayer today by our friend and colleague, Representative Jack Fortner, and then to remain standing to be led in the Pledge of Allegiance by Representative Greg Letting. Good
▶ Play
morning. It is an honor to be in front of you this morning. When I look up there in front of me and I see that over our door, in God we trust, it strengthens me every day. Do you hear that? Strengtheneth me. that's like a preacher. I don't have any stories and I am not going to preach, but I love that. I love that because in God I do trust. Let's pray. Heavenly Father, I thank you for this day. I thank you for my friends. I ask that you'll be with us today. Give us all strength, give us patience, and give us wisdom. We thank you for our breath. We thank you for our health. We thank you for everything you have done for us. Amen.
▶ Play
Speaker 2 12:02
Amen. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which
▶ Play
it stands, one nation under God, indivisible,
▶ Play
Speaker 2 12:44
with liberty and justice for all. All right, members, you know what to do. Okay, prayer to the machine, Mr. Clerk. Thank you. Casted the ballots, Mr. Clerk. 97 present, Chair sees a quorum. There
▶ Play
any requests for leave? Representative Rushing, you're recognized. leave representative lemons is leave granted for representative lemons all right so noted or any other request for leave representative Beck leave for representative Farrar is leave granted for representative Farrar all right so noted all right representative Lane Jean moves at this time that we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal without objection so order in your reports from select committees any reports from standing committees any Unfinished Business and Executive Communications. Okay, members, we have just a few special guests with us today that I'd like to recognize. In the East Gallery, we have Representative-elect Donald Ragland and his wife, the lovely Miss Freda. Let's welcome him. Many of you might not know this based on his continued presence in and around our chamber, but Representative Branscombe left this body, and Representative-elect Raglan will be filling out the remainder of his term. Okay. We also have with us today, and I'm not sure what gallery that they are in, but in a little bit we're going to have a group the group from Ridgeview Mennonite School that's here as guest representative Rye and the Jonesboro delegation so we'll try to point them out when they make it if I remember to do that that's going to conclude the morning hour All right, Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1003. House Bill
▶ Play
1003 by Representative Maddox to amend the law concerning the defenses of prosecution for a violation of operating an all-terrain vehicle upon the public street or highway and to declare an emergency.
▶ Play
All right, Representative Maddox, you're recognized to come and present the bill.
▶ Play
Yes, I know. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, colleagues. So yesterday I ran this bill in the Transportation Committee, and it passed without a dissenting vote. So I felt really good about myself, and I thought I did an excellent job. However, as I walked over here to the chamber, I had two separate members tell me that I went for so long that I almost killed my own bill. So I'm going to give you the condensed version of what I did yesterday. As most of you know, we passed a bill in 2017 regarding the defenses available to prosecution for riding an ATV. One of the things this bill did was restrict the trailhead-to-trailhead exemption for riding ATVs. This restriction has had an unintended consequence and has been very detrimental economically to my district and other districts where ATV tourism is a significant industry. When I started hearing complaints from business owners about how much their businesses were suffering and how much they were down, I listened to them, had a lot of conversations with them, and the very first thing I did was I called Representative Tosh, and I spoke with Representative Tosh about this matter, and he said, he said, buddy, I'm going to help you fix this. I just want to thank him for his understanding and cooperation. I very much appreciate it. Since this issue has arisen, I've spoken with many legislators and ATV enthusiasts all over the state of Arkansas who want to greatly expand where ATVs can be ridden in Arkansas, but that is not what this bill is. I want to be clear, that's not this bill. If we're going to address that, I believe that should be done more comprehensively in the general session. This bill is merely removing the restrictions on ATV use that we placed in 2017 and basically return that law back to what it had always been. I kept all of law enforcement apprised of this bill, and there's no known opposition to it at this time. Seeing no questions, I'd appreciate a good vote.
▶ Play
OK, members, you've heard an explanation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? All right, Representative Maddox has signified he's closed for his bill. So the question before the House at this time will be the passage of House Bill 1003. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Voting on the bill and its emergency clause. Everyone voted? All right, let's cast up the ballots with 92 yeas, 0 nay, and 1 present. The bill and its Merging Clause have passed. Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill
▶ Play
1008. House Bill 1008 by Representative Gillum to amend the Arkansas Tax-Deferred Tuition Savings Program Act.
▶ Play
Representative Gilliam, you're recognized to present the bill. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Members, I bring before you today language that you have been looking at now for at least a couple of weeks, maybe if not a little longer. So you, by now this, you've had plenty of time to read it, so I'm not going to belabor the point by going line item by line item in the actual bill, I will point out a change that has been added before I discuss what the bill does and doesn't do. There was a definition change that allows compatibility with the ABLE program so that students with disabilities would be able to access that program. There was a little bit of inconsistency in the federal language and we need to change the definition. So, that makes that more compatible with that. So that's the difference as far as language that you saw last week and what you have this week, which in my mind actually makes it a much better bill. So as I told the Education Committee yesterday, the two things this bill does not do is solve all the world's problems, nor does it cause the world to come crashing down around you. So I wanted to get that out of the way in committee, and I want to get it out of the way right now. All right, what this bill does and what it's intent to do is to make compatible, as best as humanly possible, our existing 529 plans and the language that we have for that with what the federal government did. Now, I know that you've heard a lot of the speculation and conjecture about what this bill does and how horrible it is or maybe how great it is from some sectors. It's really kind of in between. It's not great. It's not horrible. It's good. It's necessary. What the federal government did was put us in a position, like they do a lot of times, where we have to react to something that they have passed, and that's what we're doing here. A lot of the kind of conjecture around this bill is really about what happened at the federal level and not what this bill does, and I think that's important to note, is that, you know, a lot of the problems that people have with this is what happened at the federal level. It's not what's in this language right here. So what you've got is an attempt to mirror what our 529 language was in a way that will include the new K-12 language that the federal government added in through Congress that the IRS is now issuing guidance on and working through that in a way that is compatible, that simplifies the process as much as humanly possible in a fair way for the citizens of Arkansas. So our 529 plans have always been what I'm going to refer to kind of here as a triple play. Now, your IRAs and your 401Ks have double benefits, but they're either on the back end or on the front end. They don't have the triple benefit. But our 529 plan has always had that. So there were a few people last week that made mention of the fact, well, they just really want our 529 language to mirror the federal government. That hasn't happened since 2005. Ours has not mirrored in that regard because we allow the deduction after tax but on the front end when you put the money into your 529 account. So what this does is drop down the same language as far as that deduction and the structure down in so that you have one homogenous 529 plan and that you don't have multiple variations and complexities that although if you're in the accounting business would benefit you greatly because now you get more billable hours to have to explain all those complexities. If you're just the average citizen, it makes it easier to understand what the plan does because that structure is the same at both levels. federal government what they have never had that deduction it's never existed in their language their benefit is a double benefit but it's in the middle and on the back end as opposed to having that front end so this does not mirror the new language does not mirror what the federal government has got in their language as far as k-12 i want to make that clear and it's not going to because ours hasn't since 2005. It's an investment plan that you can invest in for college. Federal government now said we're going to amend that definition to also include K-12 language. Now, there was some confusion last week to allowable expenses and things like that. I want to briefly touch on that because yesterday I referenced what the language or the kind of the indication that's coming out of the Trump administration and the IRS as to how they're going to handle some of that may be a little premature, okay? So DF&A and everybody's looking at this as a static thing as to what's in it right now, okay? So I mentioned yesterday in response to a question that tutoring and some of those expenses would be allowable expenses. They're not as of yet, so I want to clean that up. The indication that the administrators of the 529 plan have from the federal government is that that probably will be included, high likelihood, but not a certainty or guarantee. So I don't want to sell anybody a bill of goods on that. So what we're looking at before you today is a bill that will make compatible. I want to make sure that's perfectly clear. It's not a mirror, but it's going to make what we've got here compatible with what the federal government has already passed. Doing nothing, as Representative De La Rosa, I think eloquently pointed out last week, is really not an option for us, because we have citizens in this state that are already going out because they've been told, well, the federal government is going to allow you to do this, and they're going to go out, and they're going to get penalized for doing it, okay? Now, I also spoke in committee yesterday. There's been a lot of numbers thrown around about, well, how's this going to work, and what's the cost going to be? I've had multiple conversations with DF&A and have visited with them about where that cost is at, okay? It's a static assessment based on everybody who has children in private schools taking the full deduction humanly possible, and that's how they came up with their number. They use the effective tax rate. They use their average across the board at a 4.25 to come to that, but the real impact that you're going to have on the actual budget and the money that you would actually be able to put in your pocket is a maximum of $690 for a married couple. And that's if you put the full $10,000 in and handled that. A question that came up yesterday by Representative Walker that was a great question was, okay, how does this 529 plan really work? Can any citizen put money in? The answer is yes. But you have to name a beneficiary. This isn't some holding account that you just get to put money in and then come back along the way later on 10 years down the road and decide, hey, I'm just going to pick Johnny or Sally and then move the money over to them. You've got to name it right then. You've got to pick who that is. Now, it is transferable in the event that you have a son or a daughter that you set this account up for and tragedy strikes and they pass away early. You can transfer it over to a nephew. One of our former colleagues that I served with in this house had that situation happen, and he did that. So I want to make it clear it's not that it always has to stay with that beneficiary if something happens and they become deceased that is transferable. So I don't want to do like Representative Maddox was accused of doing and going on and on about my bill here, but I want to make sure I cover some of the highlights and try to clear up some of the confusion that's occurred over this, because there has been a lot of people who have done no research, no conversations, that just leapt to a tremendous amount of conclusions about what this does or doesn't do. Okay. So I want to point something out here. I want to make sure, I'm sorry, I've got too many papers here. And I realized also as I started to come down here, I got my NCAA brackets in this folder too. So that's filling up a lot of my paperwork here. All right. We have over 11,000 individuals that actually have, yeah, 11,818 Arkansans have 529 plans right now. Okay. So if you, and this is important for the math as you start to think about what the actual real effect of this is going to be, and I'm going to come back to the DF&A assessments here. Okay. Out of that right now, out of the people who have 529 plans, who have the ability to do the deduction on the front end, you know, your growth, and then the back end money at triple play that I was talking about there, that triple benefit, that already had that existing, okay? So this is important because this is kind of part of that scare tactic thing that kind of got out there a little bit was how it was going to break the budget. So I'm going to walk you through some numbers here, okay? $118,180,000 is what the potential deduction allowances would be on that level at the higher ed level right now, okay? In 2016, only 20 million were asked of DF&A. So think about that spread in what is possible right now versus what reality is right now. Now, out of that 20 million that was listed on the tax forms by Arkansas citizens, less than a million of it was actually real impact. About $850,000 is kind of the ballpark where they're at. It's not a hard number. I can't promise you that's what it will wind up being. So stop and think about that in your numbers whenever you hear that the potential impact of this bill that I'm asking for you to vote for is $5.2 million. Because those same kind of application spreads could be applied to this as well. So I do not feel like that you were going to have in 2018 a $5.2 million hit because I do not think that everybody who takes it, who has that potential of taking the deduction, will take it, and I'm basing that off of historical data that we have currently available to us. Statistically, the people who have these accounts are just average Arkansans. They're grandparents. They're, you know, mothers and fathers and aunts and uncles. And so this is not something that is going to just everybody's going to run in and take advantage of. But as the governor said yesterday, we can be supportive of this in concept and how we handle it, but then monitor it along the way. You have the ability in 2019, if things begin to kind of look a little different than what we feel like they're going to now, to make the changes, to monitor it over the next two or three years and come back in and make that adjustment. So what I'm asking of you today is to vote for this bill. We need to take action, okay? And this is the most simplistic and fair way to handle it so that we do not wind up in in a situation where we're penalizing Arkansans by overly complicating things and creating unforeseen circumstances. And if you read the paper today about the bill being run in committee yesterday, you'll notice that there was a superintendent from Pulaski County who'd said, I don't understand what the fuss is. The impact to public schools is gonna be minimal. And he said, this is not a voucher bill, okay? So when your superintendents and people back home are making those kind of comments, just be aware of the fact that there are a lot of people that are in K-12 that do not hold that opinion. And so I will try to take a breath here and answer questions if there are any, because there are some things that I might not have covered. Before I do that, though, I will say this. not all of the deductions that are available or excuse me not all of the qualified expenditures that exist at the higher ed level are being transferred down which is why earlier referenced that the guidance hasn't come out yet but there are things that are not going to transfer down that were at the higher ed level and so like you know the ability for internet and things like that that are at the higher ed level are not going to transfer down and there are only you have the ability to only take out two withdrawals on the K through 12 portion at the federal language on an annual basis. And so it's not something that you can keep pumping money in on a monthly basis at the front of the month, take the money out on the back end, and work it that way. They've got fairly tight controls in that regard
▶ Play
Speaker 50 32:12
as well. Representative Blake, for what purpose? Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Question? You're recognized for a question. Speaker Gilliam, just to clarify, so these tax-deferred savings can only go to private school students who are private school students? No. And the language at the federal
▶ Play
Speaker 54 32:31
level includes across the board. I
▶ Play
mean, religious, private, public is what their language is. What I'm saying is the guidance from the IRS has not actually reached yet because it was just passed, you know, how the federal government kind of lags behind. I know your seatmate wants to change that, and he'll have that ability to if he was successful in his endeavors. And so what I'm saying is that at the current moment, I cannot sit here and tell you that all of the things that the IRS is saying that they're going to do will come to pass. but they they are indicating that they are going to be able to kind of work with the states on allowing things that would be beneficial
▶ Play
to public school students. You're recognized for a follow-up. So currently these savings can only go to private school students. What you mentioned was you have to name a beneficiary. Does that have to be a parent or a family member of that student? Or can grandparents, aunts, uncles, neighbors, friends, parents also get the same tax deferred tuition for private school students? Yes, as said earlier, if anybody
▶ Play
can open up one of these accounts and name a beneficiary. So as I encourage Representative Walker to do in committee yesterday, he's not here today, but I've got the spelling and everything of my kids names so that he can open some up for my children as well. But, you know, you can do it for a nephew. You can do it for a niece and put that money in, name them as the beneficiary and help them out. Maybe instead of buying them toys when they're younger, you decide, hey, I want to help them plan for their college. And so you can do that. And so like right now, we have that ability at the language we already have in our statute right now. I mean, you don't necessarily have to go to a state funded higher ed institution, you know, with the 529 plans. You can go to private higher ed institutions as of right now at that category. And what the federal language did, which is forcing us to act, is they've said, okay, now we're going to include K-12 in there. And the language that they used was public, private, religious. I mean, they put it across the board at a K-12 level. And that's why we are forced to act, come back in, and make our language and statutes compatible with what the federal government has decreed from on high.
▶ Play
Representative De La Rosa, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for a question. Did
▶ Play
Speaker 62 35:05
anyone speak for or against this bill in committee yesterday? Did any public education group show up because this is so detrimental to them, show up and speak against it, or any school choice organization show up because it's so beneficial to them, show up and speak one way or the other on this bill? No, but I did read
▶ Play
a couple of very eloquent emails they sent out later on last night. But I say that, they might not have been eloquent. It might have been the concussion talking.
▶ Play
Speaker 50 35:34
Representative Blake, for what purpose?
▶ Play
One last question. Now, you recognize your question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Maybe the concussion from Mitch Peacher is talking. Mr. Speaker, you base your $5.2 million saying that only the parents of, that was gotten for only the parents of students who are in private school now. Now, if you can open a tax-deferred savings plan for any grandparent, nephew, niece, friend, how are we only basing that off of parents?
▶ Play
Great question. I didn't articulate that earlier, and I apologize, and I was trying to be as brief as I could in my presentation there. the $5.2 million is based on the way they had to look at that was all the students that were in private schools and if they had to use some multipliers and kind of come up with their formula there so yes I mean I could put one in I could create a 529 plan for Representative Tucker's children and you know try to help with their education and I'm going to get that deduction if I so choose to take it. What their assessment was is that the parents would be the one to take it. And they're basing that on, like I said earlier, the spread from the fact that you've got all of these accounts that exist now, but yet reality and who are actually applying and putting those deductions on their tax paperwork is so low compared to that spread. And so that's where they're coming around from that. So the $5.2 million that I said, that's judging that everybody takes that. But like I said, I might not have said this today and I apologize if I didn't, but your maximum for, if you don't file jointly, you're talking about a $5,000 deduction that would be for one person. So it's $345 at the maximum level. You're going to spend $100 with your accountant trying
▶ Play
Speaker 56 37:37
to get the $345. A follow-up? You
▶ Play
recognize for a follow-up? But wouldn't you agree that if parents and grandparents and nieces and uncles and aunties and neighbors and friends do take advantage of this tax-deferred savings, that number could be extraordinarily higher than $5.2 million? No. Well, I mean, it would be
▶ Play
an unprecedented shift in behavior, and from a social psychology standpoint would be highly unlikely. However, though, the number that probably would shoot through the roof that I think everybody needs to remember about this is that if that were to occur, I think our rankings and where we're at in education in this country are going to go through the roof too, because that means we're putting a heck of a lot of focus on making sure our kids are being better prepared for the world ahead of them. and I think that ought to do it folks I probably stood more than I'm supposed to based on the medical advice I received last night and this morning so I appreciate
▶ Play
it thank you for a good vote Speaker Gilliam has explained the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill Speaker Gilliam indicates he is closed for the bill The question before the House is the passage of House Bill 1008. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Has everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. With 62 yeas, 16 nays, and 10 present, the bill is passed. Mr. Clerk, read House Bill 1009. House Bill
▶ Play
1009 by Representative Lowry to amend Arkansas law concerning the limit on school choice transfers under the Public School Choice Act of 2015. Representative Lowry, you're recognized to explain
▶ Play
the bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I was
▶ Play
advised as I walked down here short and sweet, so I will try my best. This really is a technical fix. Many of you have heard the explanation of it. It relates to the 3% cap on school choice that was put in in the Public School Choice Act in 2015. A scenario was presented near the end of debate then that what if a 3% cap is 60 students and a school district has had 59 applications and a family of three children applied? Does that mean that only one student will be able to choice out and two have to stay? So language was put in that said in that intended, in that case, siblings would only count as one. Unfortunately, because it was so late in the session, the wording really was inaccurate. and it applied that said siblings would count as one throughout the entire 60. Now, it's taken us three years to get to a point where school districts are starting to feel the impact because right now there are only six districts in the state that have over the 3% cap. This is a fix. This is a good faith fix to make sure that we do what we said we were going to do, which is that this is a hard 3% cap. It does though, because of the wording, it does allow that if you get up to that cap and you have a group of siblings, that that would give you the flexibility to be able to go over the 3% just to the number of those siblings. So, you know, I think we have to be honest and we have to be fair with one another and not take advantage of miswording or misinterpretation. And that's what we're doing here. We're trying to correct this so that the 3% cap is a true 3% cap. So I would appreciate support and I will stand ready for a question. Representative Tucker, for what
▶ Play
purpose? Question. Are you recognized for a question? Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 81 41:56
you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Lowry, so I just want to understand in your hypothetical, under the current scenario, the siblings would count as one throughout the process and so are you saying then if this were to pass and they would count as one during the application process,
▶ Play
and then thereafter they would count as three? They would only count as three, excuse me, they would only count as one if you're bumping up against the cap so that you're not having to separate siblings. Okay,
▶ Play
Speaker 81 42:27
follow-up. You're recognized for a follow-up? So just to modify your example a little bit, if there were 50 kids with a 60-person cap and there were three siblings, then in that scenario, they would count as three if the bill were to pass yes that is correct currently they just count as
▶ Play
one the concern is that if you had if every application under the current wording every application included sibling groups of two or three that that three percent cap could conceivably end up being a six percent hit on the school district or if it's an average of three siblings nine percent that was not the intent so we're wanting to be good faith brokers in this and make sure that we're not getting something those of us who are for school choice to get something that was not intended so we're trying to correct it representative board law for what purpose
▶ Play
question you recognize for a question representative larry would you say this bill is more restrictive
▶ Play
on school choice or less restrictive it is a fair restriction it is the correct restriction but it is more restrictive yes thank you very much
▶ Play
i appreciate your support for this bill. Representative Lowry has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Lowry indicates he is closed for the bill. Question before the House is the passage of House Bill 1009. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Has everyone voted? Cast up the ballot, Mr. Clerk. With 76 yeas, 4 nays and 8 present, the bill is passed. representative rise guests are in the East gallery we have the group from Jonesboro the Jonesboro delegation in the Ridgeview Mennonite School and they are in the East gallery please join me in welcoming them Mr. Clerk, read House Bill 1007. House
▶ Play
Bill 1007 by Representative Wardlaw to amend the Arkansas law concerning the modification and review of permits issued by the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality. Representative Wardlaw,
▶ Play
you're recognized to present your bill. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Speaker. Everybody got jokes today. that's going to be good. Regardless of what you read in the newspaper, I've presented this bill twice already, and I can tell you this bill has nothing to do with the current hog farm issue that you're hearing about. This bill does not help C&H Hog Farm. This bill will not benefit C&H Hog Farm at all. It is sad to me that we can't write a bill to help C&H Hog Farm, but this bill does not do that. What we have is because of C&H Hog Farm, issues have arose that all the current permit holders in the state are now scared and nervous because people can come around and sue and try to take their permit away from them after they've proved everything that's needed to have that permit. So what this bill does is put the current practice that's being practiced today at AEDQ in law. The bill actually doesn't change anything in the current practice. It just puts it in law. And if you read the bill, it brings up one example of why you can't come back after the comment period, and that's over location. That's because that is the only example that's not already listed in the current process. So they went back and closed that loophole. So I'll be happy to take any questions, but I will tell you this bill absolutely has nothing
▶ Play
to do with C&H hog farm. Representative Stephen Meeks, for what purpose, I apologize? Question, please. You're recognized
▶ Play
for your question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. A question I have is I've heard there's some concern that this may somehow affect how our AEDQ interacts with the Federal Environmental Protection Agency dealing with the Clean Air Clean Water Act. Any truth to that or is there any concern that we may be out of, in violation of any of those acts with this change?
▶ Play
Thank you for that question Representative Meeks because that does probably have a lot of people's concern because there was a draft previous to this one that did have some concerns with the EPA but this is a totally different draft, wasn't even amended. This one has no concern with the EPA. Thank you. Seeing no further questions, thank you for a good vote. Good thing I didn't take that step. Representative Hendrick, for what purpose? I
▶ Play
have a question, Mr. Speaker. You're recognized for your question, sir. Thank you, Representative, for staying there and taking my question. I have a letter, an email. Many of our colleagues got this, and I want to read just a part of the question here that this person asked. And I might say this is a gentleman that most of us know, and about 15 or 20 years ago, if we'd listened to this lawyer a little bit more, things might have been different in a lot of cases. And this is a question, and I think you've addressed it, but I just want to get you and me both on tape as we do this. It says this, if in fact the legislation is not intended to affect the pending matters, then why not remove all doubt by amending this bill, they say Senate Bill 8, I guess that's the companion bill, House Bill 1007, to include a clause that specifically states that the legislation will have no effect on any permit that is presently the subject of an appeal from an ADEQ decision, or make the legislation prospective only by adding a phrase in section whatever that provides if an application for modification of an existing state permit for a Liquid Animal Waste Management System is filed with the department after July 1, 2018. I think what they're saying is, can we put it in stone, or do you think it need to
▶ Play
be? You don't have to, Representative Hendren, and I've seen that and addressed it, because the current C&H Hog Farm does not hold a Reg 5 permit. C&H Hog Farm went through and obtained a general use permit, which was a Reg 6. There's been a moratorium put on those Reg 6 permits. That permit was only good for five years. That permit has expired. They did apply for a Reg 5, but the difference between a Reg 6 and a Reg 5 is a Reg 6 doesn't take into effect public comment. It doesn't take into effect geological issues. A Reg 5 does. Therefore, they were denied that Reg 5 permit, and they are currently in an appeal period. But like I told you, this doesn't apply to them because they do not hold this permit, so there's no reason for that clause. Thank you. Representative East, for what purpose? Question.
▶ Play
You're recognized for your question. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 103 49:46
Beesburg. Representative Wardlaw, does this in any way affect the public's ability to make comments during the public comment portion of the application process or when they do modifications? Absolutely
▶ Play
not. That was brought up in the newspaper this morning in that wonderful article where it's the hog bill. But it does not. It does not change the public comment period. It does not restrict the public comment period. It just says that after you've had that period that's currently in the reg. you can't come back with more and more reasons for the next 20 years trying to shut that permit down. And I can tell you, you can't do that today, but it's not in statute. So that's all this does is clarify that process that's already being practiced
▶ Play
today by ADQ. Representative Petty, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Question? You're recognized for your question, ma'am. Thank you, Representative Wardlaw. I've been getting the same emails, I think, as Representative Hendren, And I was just wondering, as addressed in the emails, why we are taking this up in a special session and not in the general when we come back.
▶ Play
Speaker 107 50:49
Good question. Because lenders that lend these people these millions
▶ Play
of dollars to build these facilities, dairies, I mean, we're leaving dairies out of this, but dairies require a Reg 5 permit as well, are very apprehensive now without this being in stone about lending money to new facilities and new facilities not being in the Buffalo River. watershed but we we have some folks looking at our state to move here not hog farms but require this permit and before they're going to be able to obtain that they need this clarified so that's why i'm standing before you today thank you i appreciate a good vote okay
▶ Play
members you've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like to speak against the bill for the bill representative award law signified it's closed for the bill so the question now before the house will be the passage of house bill 1007 prepare the machine mr. clerk All right, has everyone voted? Okay. Has everyone voted? All right, let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clark. With 73 yeas, 6 nays, and 13 present, the bill has passed. All right, members, and I apologize. This happened while Representative Wardlaw was presenting his bill, but I just at least want to acknowledge that they were with us for at least a few minutes. Senator Irvin had brought down a guest of Representatives, Michelle Gray and John Payton, the Stone County youth leadership, and they were in, and then they left. They were on a tight schedule, and we were presenting the bills, and so I at least want to acknowledge that they were with us before we move on. Okay, Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1005.
▶ Play
House Bill 1005 by Representative Bentley to amend the requirement for certain property under the control and management of the State Parks, Recreation, and Travel Commission and to declare an emergency.
▶ Play
Representative Bentley, you're recognized to present your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Speaker. Colleagues, I bring to you a very simple bill that we can all get on board with and be happy about today. As you have seen across the state, we've seen more and more hiking trails and biking trails in our state parks, and they're doing a phenomenal job, doing such a good job that the interests of many people in the private sector want to help and spur that on even more across our state so that all of us can benefit from some hiking and trails in our district. There's a statute in law that says they spend more than $25,000 of funds on a trail. They have to go to the Department of Finance's building authority. And in doing so, it just really has bogged down the process. State parks have done this for years. They've done a phenomenal job. The engineers they have are doing a great job. All this does is get rid of an unnecessary regulation to allow the state parks to do this in a quicker fashion and get things done in our state parks. Absolutely no discrepancy from DF&A. They're fine with it. They came on board to make sure we had the definition of what they needed to for a soft trail so it could exactly be what we're asking for. With that, I appreciate a good vote. Any questions? Thank you, colleagues. Okay, members.
▶ Play
You've heard a presentation of the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Bentley has signified that she is closed for the bill. So the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1005. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. You're voting on the bill and its emergency clause. All right, everyone voted. Let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 94 yeas, 0 nay, and 0 present, the bill and its emergency clause have passed. All right, Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill
▶ Play
1001. House Bill 1001 by Representative Pitch, concerning the possession of an open container of alcohol in a motor vehicle and to make technical corrections necessary to avoid future federal highway spending penalties.
▶ Play
Representative Pitch, you're recognized to present your
▶ Play
bill. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, today we bring before you House Bill 1001. If you will harken back to the last legislative session, Representative Carlton Wing carried an open container bill so that our state was one of the last ones to have one. It was voted unanimously when he did that. It wasn't until we were post-session we found out from the federal government we had some clauses that needed changed because there was a detriment and a penalty if we weren't word-for-word in alignment with the federal government. They're fairly simple things. We needed to define what an open container was in that part of the statute, and we also needed to define that we had one application of an open container that could be reached while sitting in the driver's seat, and we had to fix that. So with that, it's pretty simple, straightforward bill. I'd be open for any questions, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
All right. You've heard an explanation of the bill, members. Would anyone like to speak against the bill, for the bill? All right. Representative Pitch is signified that he is closed for the bill. So the question now before the House will be the passage of House Bill 1001. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, has everyone voted? Okay, let's cast it to ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 94 yeas, 0 nay and 0 present, the bill has passed. Okay, Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1010. House
▶ Play
Bill 1010 by Representative Michelle Gray. To create the Arkansas Pharmacy Benefits Manager Licensure Act and to declare an emergency. Representative Gray,
▶ Play
you're recognized to present your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, I want to start out with this bill kind of the same way I did in committee yesterday, and that's just to say thank you to almost every single person in the chamber. You've all been very helpful, very engaged on this issue. You've come to me or Senator Caldwell or others with suggestions or comments, and I just want to say I really appreciate it, and I know that your constituents do as well. And I want to give a couple of specific thank yous to Representatives Jeff Wardlaw. I cannot believe I just said that out loud. Jeff Wardlaw, to Reginald Murdoch, which he's not in the chamber at the moment, and to Jimmy Gassaway. I think Jimmy probably put the most amount of time in on this bill, helping us look at it from many different angles. So thank you to all of you specifically. And then also Senators Caldwell, Raybert, and Malik for helping us tackle such a big issue. But I will go through this bill just as quickly as I can. I know that most of you've had it for about a week and have asked any questions that you already had. It's a 12-page bill, and pages one through four are just the definition section of the bill. So what we're doing is setting up an entirely new section of statute in the insurance code, so we had to put all the definitions in there for the first time. Section 504 is where the bill starts, and that's license to do business. So for the first time, in Arkansas, and from what I understand in the nation, we will be regulating pharmacy benefits managers and essentially creating a license to do business in Arkansas. And that gives regulatory authority to the insurance commissioner, the insurance department here in Arkansas. To my knowledge, they're one of the only, when you look vertically through healthcare, all the different pieces are regulated in some form or fashion, whether it's the health insurer, the pharmacist, the physician, everybody has an accrediting board or they have some regulatory oversight. So this is a much needed, it's much needed. Section 505, it provides for PBM network adequacy. So originally we came to this place because pharmacies were getting paid way below cost on their medications, not to mention they weren't making anything, so they couldn't pay their invoices, and they weren't making anything to pay their overhead or their salaries or for their bottles. And a lot of people wanted, you know, they wanted a payment floor in place, or, you know, you have to pay so much plus an administrative fee. Most of the legislative body, we're not going to do that. We don't want to say this is, we don't want to start dictating price in legislation. So what we did, we looked at network adequacy. So right now, specifically CVS has been sending letters to pharmacies. So they've been paying them below cost now since at least January. We're going to pay you below cost, make it to where you can't pay your bills, you can't pay your salaries or yourself, and then we're going to send you a letter and say, would you like to sell your business to us? So we're going to try and force you out of business, and then we're going to try and take you over. So what we've done in network adequacy is a lot like, it's kind of a TRICARE standard that's already in place for Medicare Part D, and it says that the PBMs have to have an adequate network of pharmacies to serve the patients that they have in place, to serve the beneficiaries. And just like on the national level, we do not allow mail order to be counted in that calculation. They can still use mail order, but they can't include it in the calculation because you can't get medication same day through mail order. You might need an antibiotic or something, an inhaler that you need the same day. Section 506 is the compensation and prohibited practices. Originally in the bill, we had a whole list of practices that were what I call kind of egregious that were being done by the PBMs, and we softened that up a little bit. So instead of saying they're prohibited, what we've done is said they're prohibited unless they're approved by the insurance commissioner. So if you have someone who wants to contract and do X, Y, and Z that's in the prohibited practices, as long as they can show the commissioner that it's warranted and that it's agreeable, then it's fine. So we softened that up quite a bit. Section 507, and this is where I forgot to thank somebody very important, which is Mr. Speaker. He actually, so thank you, Mr. Speaker. He actually asked for something specific in the bill, so this was his, and it's gag clauses. We prohibited gag clauses, which is very important. Right now, the pharmacies, and it doesn't matter, it's independence chains. Everyone is gagged from telling the patients what the total cost of the medications are. They're gagged from talking with legislators or other businesses. they just can't discuss their contracts or their pricing at all. So what this gag clause prohibition does is it allows the pharmacist to talk to their patients about the cost of their medication, and if they can get it cheaper by paying cash than paying the copay, which happens quite a bit, they can now tell their patients that. And it also says, kind of in response to a memo that was sent out by CVS, Caremark, that they're not gagged from talking to government officials specifically the insurance department so anything that any complaints or anything that they need to talk about they have that right to go to the insurance commissioner and discuss it now we did put in here that any information that's given to the insurance commission or government officials is protected as proprietary information and that is to cover we won't we don't want information out that's proprietary, and it's also not available through FOIA because it is proprietary. So we added that to kind of keep that protection in place. I'm almost done. Section 508, 509, and 510 are enforcement rules and applicability, and those are fairly standard. What the insurance commissioner has agreed to is, or actually brought to the table, is to have all the rules and regulations promulgated by September 1st, and that's actually quite an undertaking because of the process that we have to go through, through ALC and everything. So I want to commend him and his staff for taking such a proactive approach on this. And one of the last things that we did on pages 10 and 11, currently PBMs are in the insurance code as third-party administrators. So that there's no confusion. We are striking that. We're striking all language relating to PBMs in the TPA language of the insurance code. Now they have their own section just for them. We added a severability clause to the bill, and I will, in good faith, I want to tell you that this bill is exactly the same bill that you received last week with the one exception, and that is the severability clause that we added. We didn't touch the current language. We just added a severability clause. Personally, I expect that CVS and or the National Association will challenge this bill, just like they did the one in 2015. And we do have a general severability clause in statute, but I just wanted to make sure that there were no questions, that if anything were to be stricken in this bill, the rest it still stands in its entirety. And then lastly, we've added an emergency clause just to make sure that this takes effect as soon as possible. So that's the crux of the bill and what it does, and I'd be glad to take
▶ Play
Speaker 126 1:05:39
any questions. Representative Bladyman, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for your question, sir. Representative Gray,
▶ Play
just a clarification, personal clarification, your bill, will it help or eliminate the problem with the span billing by the PBMs to different pharmacies? If you
▶ Play
could clarify your question again, you called it what kind of billing?
▶ Play
The spread in billing, the spread in billing to different
▶ Play
pharmacies. Okay, so currently what we're finding is that a pharmacy will send a claim, they'll try to adjudicate a claim, and they might be reimbursed $10. The medication costs them $20, so they're losing $10. But when the PBM then turns around and builds the insurance company, they'll bill them for $100, and they'll keep the $90 for themselves as essentially profit. it. So this bill does not specifically address that. It does not prohibit it or allow it. But what it does do is it requires the PBMs to submit yearly reports with all their data so that essentially they can look through the data, see what's being done. And the biggest reason that we want to do that, we have something called a medical loss ratio. And it gets very complicated, but it's something that does have to be monitored. So although this doesn't specifically prohibit or stop that, we will be able to to see it and monitor it. And the insurance commissioner throughout this can set up and promulgate rules and regs moving forward. So if they see a practice like this that's happening that's affecting the public health public health and safety of the residents of Arkansas, then they could promulgate rules and regs. Mr. Speaker, could I have a follow-up question, please? Yes, you can have your
▶ Play
follow-up, sir. Would it be a fair statement to say that in the long term it will help this problem because of the oversight?
▶ Play
Yes, I'm fairly certain that it will help. I can tell you that even when we ran the bill in 2015, I remember telling the Pharmacy Association and my pharmacist at that time, they'll find a way around this. They always do. They have for 13 years now. And so one of the big things to me was, I said, this time, I don't want to have to come back every two years. Plugging holes is not fair to our pharmacists. It's not fair to our constituents to have to keep attacking this from so many different levels. So what this does is it gives the insurance commissioner the authority to do something about it within months. instead of us having to do it every two years or wait for a special session we can address anything that happens on a much more timely in a much more timely manner all right see no more question you every time you do it every time it's your fault for not moving quicker I know all
▶ Play
right representative hindered for what purpose I'm sorry mr. speaker but I'm just a little slower than the rest of my colleagues in here are but at 80 years old I use a lot more of this product so I have a specific interest I know some of you think I'm not taking the right one but anyway I've had some questions from constituents and I just wanted a couple of questions number one is why do we need PBMs the second question is is I've I've been told, and we'll take them one at a time if we can. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Perry. Okay, that's the question of the day. PBM started, I don't even know, I'm going to say 20-something years ago, simply kind of like as a third-party administrator, but they just processed claims when electronic claims started, you know, computers, technology. We got to have the insurance company said this isn't our line of business. We need somebody that can do this for us. And so they just essentially took like an administrative fee off of every claim. seemed to work fine. And then their scope grew and grew and grew. And there was a point in time, I truly believe, where the PBMs were cost effective. They helped reduce the overall cost of medication. They started, you know, tiering medications and formularies. They worked in many different facets to help lower the cost. That time's come and gone. They're to the point now where, based on everything I can see, they're just in it to make as much money as they possibly can without regard to the beneficiary, to the patient, to the pharmacist, to anybody else in that chain. So I don't know that we necessarily need PBMs in the grand scheme of things now. And I know several of our colleagues actually talked about running a bill to just do away with them. I'll put it that way. And I can tell you that right now we have, make sure I get these right, CVS is trying to buy Aetna. So if that happens, then what you have is a complete vertical integration of the prescription medication market. You have the health insurer, you have the PBM, then you have, they have their own pharmacies, they have their own mail-in. They essentially will dictate the entire thing, the entire part of your pharmacy experience. And then we also have one that's the other way around where we have an insurer looking to buy a pbm so i think what everybody's figuring out is they don't need to be separate they could be together um so that was a very long answer so i apologize you recognize for your follow-up thank you mr
▶ Play
speaker another question that i that's been raised is that uh is this gonna tend to do away with small-town pharmacies because and so you have to drive 20 or 30 miles to get your medication and that's that's a problem for me again because i used to when i drive down the road people didn't work friendly but they honk at me all the time when i'm driving my car so is this going to tend to help small pharmacies this bill or is it going to be the opposite and when it does that is it going to raise our prices if we don't do that no that's perfect and
▶ Play
i honk at you every time i pass you on the road driving 40 that's what it is but so first question is yes this should help the the small town the rural pharmacies because of the network adequacy piece so if I'll give you for instance in my county where I live in Isard County in Melbourne I have two pharmacies they're both struggling through what's been going on the last few months so let's say I lose both those pharmacies. I have no other pharmacy so my closest pharmacy would be to go to another town about 20 miles away. I have a one in Horseshoe Bend, another one about 20, a little over 20 miles is in Calico Rock and then outside of that I have to go to another county. So it's, then it would be 30 miles in any direction, north, south, east, or west to get to a pharmacy. So it's very, very important to me that we keep our local hometown pharmacies because I can tell you CVS doesn't want to come put a drugstore in my town and so when I've got patients who can't drive we deliver medications all across the county I need an antibiotic right away I need something we need them there and so because of that network adequacy piece there have to be pharmacies in Isard County and throughout the state they can service our the residents of the state sufficiently yes and then your second question was will it make the drug prices go up. That was the last kind of the last tactic that was thrown out there earlier in the week. I don't foresee drug prices going up because of this, so let me tell you what I think what should happen, okay? In that in that instance I said earlier where I said they paid the pharmacy $10, they billed $100, and I've got tons and tons of stuff here to show that. They keep $90. Well, you tell me where in that they couldn't have paid the pharmacy $30, let's say $30, $20 for the med, $10 to dispense it for their overhead. They could have kept $30 for themselves, and there would have been $40 left over that that insurance company wouldn't have had to pay. And guess what? That could be returned to us in lesser premiums. In my opinion, if oversight's done correctly and we will finally, finally get to see the data. I asked for the data. show me your spreads, show me what you billed versus what you reimburse. I did that in January. Not one time, I have not been given any information, neither has the pharmacy association, neither has the insurance. At this point in time, I'm not sure where the AG stands. They obviously would not discuss it if they were given that data. But once we see that data, I guarantee you, we get that transparency we want. There's no reason that our co-pays And our premiums should not go down. And I tell you, as a legislator, next year when I see the rate increase or the rate projections or requests from Arkansas Works, I don't want to see a 10% increase. I don't want to see a 15% increase. I'm going to tell you, it should be 5% or less is what I think it should be. And I said this yesterday in committee, and here I'm getting kind of worked up. But I said it in committee yesterday. I can tell you that pharmacies are not getting reimbursed any more money. okay? They're getting reimbursed on a large percentage below cost of their medication. I've got pharmacists who haven't paid themselves since December. Healthcare, your physician's office, their reimbursements haven't gone up in, I know Medicaid's like 14 years. Medicare has gone down every year steadily for the last 10 years. Hospitals are not getting paid anymore. Nowhere in that provider chain are they actually getting reimbursed any more money. So you say, well, why do my premiums keep going up? That's a really good question, and we've been trying to get the data, and they refuse to give it to us, and I'm pretty sure I know why. So I hope that answered your question. Thank you. Seeing no other questions, I would appreciate a good vote. Thank you. And I would also like to recognize I have a hometown girl up here and her dad, Cheyenne Bean, and her dad Skeeter she's a second year pharmacy
▶ Play
student so thank you okay members we've heard an explanation of the bill would anyone like speak against the bill for the bill representative gray would you like to close for your bill she signified that she has done so so the question now before the house will be the passage of House Bill 1010. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. Voting on the bill and its emergency clause. All right, everyone voted. Let's cast up the ballots. Mr. Clerk, with 92 yeas, two nays and two presents we the bill and its emergency clause have passed okay members we've got a couple of announcements here real quick before we move on with our day as representative guests of representatives Eubanks caps and senator Gary stubblefield former member of this chamber we have a group here in the East gallery that has arrived to watch our proceedings today from the county line school system. So let's welcome them. Okay. We're still working on some logistics with the Senate. They're going in today at 1 o'clock on their end. So the chairs will be paying attention to your emails and contact information because the committees will meet on the call of the chairs. The Judiciary Committee may have to meet before the Senate goes in today. I'm going to let them work that out. So just everybody pay attention to the schedules, and they're going to handle that. All right, it pains me to have to do it this way. I'd hoped that this would be in a more celebratory fashion, but I do feel like that this chamber needs at least some positive basketball news after our unfortunate loss last night. And so at the request of several members in the body, I'm going to at least read off the names and recognize those schools who were victorious in the state championship that was held in Hot Springs last weekend. Now, as you know, North Little Rock, who was here, was one of three cities that won both the boys' and the girls' tournaments. Earl was the same way, class 2A. Earl won both. In the 3A boys division, McGee won. Now I do have to ask a question before I go any further. Did you go and cheer them on when they were playing? Okay. That could be why we keep losing then. You keep cheering for us. And so just for next year, guys, just be mindful of that. But I think Representative Birch was there, though, if I understood her hand gestures correct. So all right, the 3A girls was Charleston. So good for them. 5A boys was Little Rock Parkview. 4A girls was CAC. The 6A girls and boys champions were both Jonesboro. The 1A girls was Wonderview. The 4A boys was Baptist Prep.
▶ Play
Speaker 142 1:20:36
The 5A girls was Hot Springs. And
▶ Play
the 1A boys was Guy Perkins. All right, I'm not aware of any other announcements. Like I said, the Senate's going in at 1 today. We're going to wait for the transmittal of bills from their chamber to ours. We'll read them across. So pay attention to the calendar and communication with your chairs because the times of the committee meetings this afternoon will be on their call. And so do I have any other announcements? Okay. Representative Vaught, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I do have several. So don't forget
▶ Play
to clean out your desks. I know y'all are tired of me asking for y'all to do that, but I really do need you to do it. Tomorrow we're going to do the Dupas Denim, and so Representative Birch told me what the call actually stands for. It's Children of Arkansas Loved for a Lifetime. So I think that's really cool. They will be here tomorrow. Lori Currier will be here tomorrow with them to receive the money, so please participate so we can give her some money for that call. And then if you're interested in boys' state, girls' state, make sure you see Ms. Kay today. The speaker will be nominating 10 fellows and 10 ladies to go help with girls' state and boys' state. And I think
▶ Play
Speaker 136 1:22:05
that's it. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. If you don't volunteer, I'm just
▶ Play
going to pick you, by the way, on the girls' state and boys' states. Yes, Representative Birch, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker. Just a reminder, the Hunger Caucus is still looking for lots of great names and volunteers to save the day for the Serving Up Solutions. This is the 10th annual Serving Up Solutions cards are on my desk. It's June 14th. I know a lot of you have already let Representative Douglas or me know, but please, please, please consider it and put it on your heart. And they do great things with regard to grants that you can then use in the food bank areas in your own community. So, please let me hear from you. Thank you. Okay. Representative Chris Ritchie. Sorry.
▶ Play
You recognize me. Question? Yes. Mr. Speaker, I didn't know if it would have been appropriate earlier when
▶ Play
Speaker 149 1:23:00
you were in the well, but I did want to ask, did you pick Arkansas to beat Butler in the first round on your bracket since you had it with you when you were filling it up there? I actually have
▶ Play
Speaker 151 1:23:11
Arkansas winning that game. Okay. All right. I just wanted
▶ Play
Speaker 149 1:23:13
to check on that. I did. I did.
▶ Play
It doesn't mean they will, but I also had us winning last night, too, and that didn't work out very well. Okay.
▶ Play
Representative Vaught caught us. All right, Mr. Speaker. So, because it's already been texted to me and asked, the $20 for the Dupas Denim, see Ms. Kay and give her
▶ Play
your $20. Thank you. Okay. All right. Remember, pay attention to your chairs and the calendar for the meeting times this afternoon. I don't know how long the debate in the Senate is going to last. I mean, so the committees could start meeting at 2, it could be 2.30, 3. It just depends on how long, when did they get. So, all right. Representative
▶ Play
Stephen Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. After the announcements, reading of the bills, transferring of the bills, placing the calendars on the desk, members amending their own bills with their own amendments, members withdrawing their own bills, finalizing resolutions reading communications and any remaining committee reports I move that we adjourn until 9 o'clock tomorrow morning it is
▶ Play
a proper motion non-debatable all those in favor say aye all those opposed say no aren't
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:24:22
the eyes have it the motion carries Thank you. Okay, read the committee reports, Mr. Clerk.
▶ Play
Mr. Speaker, we are Committee on House Management, to whom was referred House Resolution 1001 and 1002. Beg leave to report that we have had the same under consideration. Here are the term the same with the recommendation to do pass.
▶ Play
Respectfully submitted, Deanne Vaught, Chair. All right, the desk is going to remain open as needed for the reading of bills and upon completion of the items named in the adjourned resolution, the House will be adjourned until 9 a.m. tomorrow morning.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:26:09
Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

Wednesday, March 14, 2018 10:00 AM

10:48 - 10:49

Call To Order

10:49 - 12:30 6 segments 3 speakers

Prayer & Pledge of Allegiance

12:30 - 12:31

Roll Call

12:31 - 13:48 4 segments 2 speakers

REGULAR BILLS

13:48 - 13:51

Subtitle Sponsor Number

13:51 - 15:31 4 segments 2 speakers

Representative Jeremy Gillam recognized Representative-elect Donald Ragland as the successor to Rep. Branscombe and announced the presence of guests from Ridgeview Mennonite School and the Jonesboro delegation. [14:02] [14:36]

He then asked the clerk to read House Bill 1003, which Rep. Laurie Rushing identified as a measure to amend the law on defenses to prosecution for operating an all-terrain vehicle on public streets and to declare an emergency. [15:08] [15:28]

HB1003 Maddox TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DEFENSES TO PROSECUTION FOR A VIOLATION OF OPERATING AN ALL-TERRAIN VEHICLE UPON A PUBLIC STREET OR HIGHWAY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

15:31 - 18:44 8 segments 3 speakers

Rep. John Maddox presented HB 1003, explaining that it would reverse the 2017 restriction on ATV trailhead-to-trailhead exemptions that had harmed tourism in his district and noting that there was no known opposition. [15:39] [15:54] [16:13] [16:45] [17:16]

After closing the bill, the House voted 92 yeas, 0 nays and 1 present, thereby passing the bill and its emergency clause. [17:49] [18:22] [18:37]

HB1008 Gillam TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS TAX-DEFERRED TUITION SAVINGS PROGRAM ACT.

18:44 - 39:49 54 segments 8 speakers

Rep. Jeremy Gillam introduced HB 1008, outlining amendments to the Arkansas Tax-Deferred Tuition Savings Program to make the 529 plan compatible with the federal ABLE program and newly added K-12 provisions, and he provided cost estimates and answered questions from Reps. Blake and others. [18:53] [19:02] [19:26] [19:59] [20:33] [21:04] [21:35] [22:05] [22:39] [23:11] [23:44] [24:15] [24:46] [25:16] [25:48] [26:19] [26:51] [27:22] [27:57] [28:29] [29:00] [29:38] [30:09] [30:40] [31:12] [31:46] [32:12]

The House subsequently voted 62 yeas, 16 nays and 10 present, resulting in passage of the bill. [38:53]

HB1009 Lowery TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE LIMIT ON SCHOOL CHOICE TRANSFERS UNDER THE PUBLIC SCHOOL CHOICE ACT OF 2015.

39:49 - 44:57 17 segments 5 speakers

Rep. Mark Lowery explained HB 1009 as a technical fix to the 3 % school-choice cap, clarifying that siblings would count as one applicant only when the cap is reached to prevent unintended exceedances of the limit. [39:55] [40:00] [40:32] [41:04] [41:38]

Following brief questions, the House voted 76 yeas, 4 nays and 8 present, and the bill was adopted. [43:33] [43:51]

HB1007 Wardlaw TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE MODIFICATION AND REVIEW OF PERMITS ISSUED BY THE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY.

44:57 - 52:48 26 segments 8 speakers

Rep. Jeff Wardlaw presented HB 1007 to codify current Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality permit-modification practices, assuring that it does not alter public comment periods or create EPA compliance issues; Rep. Stephen Meeks and Rep. Kim Hendren raised procedural questions that were addressed. [45:07] [45:12] [45:33] [46:05] [46:36] [46:48] [47:08] [47:32] [47:38] [48:10] [48:42] [48:53] [49:13] [49:44] [49:46] [49:55] [50:17]

The House then voted 73 yeas, 6 nays and 13 present, passing the bill and its emergency clause. [51:27] [52:02] [52:35]

HB1005 Bentley TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENT FOR CERTAIN PROPERTY UNDER THE CONTROL AND MANAGEMENT OF THE STATE PARKS, RECREATION, AND TRAVEL COMMISSION; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

52:48 - 54:57 6 segments 3 speakers

Rep. Mary Bentley introduced HB 1005, arguing that removing the $25,000 expenditure reporting requirement would streamline trail development in state parks and that the change posed no conflict with the Department of Finance and Administration. [52:57] [53:05] [53:37] [54:07]

With the bill closed for discussion, the House voted unanimously-94 yeas, 0 nays, 0 present-to enact the measure. [54:39]

HB1001 Pitsch CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF AN OPEN CONTAINER OF ALCOHOL IN A MOTOR VEHICLE; AND TO MAKE TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS NECESSARY TO AVOID FUTURE FEDERAL HIGHWAY SPENDING PENALTIES.

54:57 - 56:59 5 segments 2 speakers

Rep. Mathew W. Pitsch presented HB 1001 to update the definition of an open container in vehicles to align with federal highway funding requirements and avoid penalties, noting the bill’s straightforward technical corrections. [55:09] [55:15] [55:42]

After closing the bill, the House adopted it unanimously with 94 yeas, 0 nays and 0 present. [56:14] [56:45]

HB1010 M. Gray TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS PHARMACY BENEFITS MANAGER LICENSURE ACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY

56:59 - 1:24:03 73 segments 14 speakers

Representative Michelle Gray presented HB 1010, the Arkansas Pharmacy Benefits Manager Licensure Act, explaining that it creates a new licensure scheme for PBMs, establishes network-adequacy standards, sets compensation and prohibited-practice rules (including a gag-clause prohibition), adds a severability provision and an emergency clause to make the law take effect immediately. [57:01] [57:09] [57:16] [57:51] [58:24] [58:55] [59:25] [59:58] [1:00:32] [1:01:05] [1:01:40] [1:02:13] [1:02:43] [1:03:17] [1:03:48] [1:04:23] [1:04:55]

During the debate Rep. Jack Ladyman asked if the bill would eliminate PBM “spread” billing; Gray responded that the bill does not ban the practice but requires PBMs to submit annual data reports and gives the insurance commissioner authority to regulate harmful practices, while Rep. Kim Hendren’s concerns about small-town pharmacies were addressed by noting the network-adequacy provisions are intended to protect rural pharmacies and are not expected to raise drug prices. [1:05:44] [1:05:57] [1:06:02] [1:06:06] [1:06:39] [1:07:10] [1:07:35] [1:07:43] [1:08:19] [1:08:43] [1:08:52] [1:09:18] [1:09:25] [1:09:55] [1:10:25] [1:10:57] [1:11:29] [1:12:01] [1:12:04] [1:12:38] [1:13:11] [1:13:41] [1:14:14]

The House voted on HB 1010 and its emergency clause, approving the measure with 92 yeas, 2 nays and 2 present, thereby enacting the bill. [1:16:54]

Motion to Adjourn

1:24:03 - 1:22:50

Announcements

1:22:50 - 1:24:28 11 segments 5 speakers

Adjournment

1:24:28 - 1:26:38 4 segments 2 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Speaker 2
7 segments
Speaker 10
1 segment
Representative Jeremy Gillam Unverified
78 segments
Representative Jack Fortner Unverified
2 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
9 segments
Representative John Maddox Unverified
4 segments
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 50
2 segments
Representative Charles Blake Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 54
1 segment
Speaker 62
1 segment
Speaker 56
1 segment
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 81
2 segments
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
11 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
2 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 103
1 segment
Representative Rebecca Petty Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 107
1 segment
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
2 segments
Representative Mathew W. Pitsch Unverified
2 segments
Chair Unverified
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
36 segments
Speaker 126
1 segment
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 142
1 segment
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 136
1 segment
Representative LeAnne Burch Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 149
2 segments
Speaker 151
1 segment