Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Judiciary Committee

April 2, 2019 ·Committee Room 130 ·1:32:00
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 9, 2026

SB451 J. Cooper TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR PROFESSIONS AND OCCUPATIONS TO OBTAIN CONSISTENCY REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHEC… 0:26

The bill was introduced by Representative Carol Dalby with assistance from the Attorney General’s Office; Brad Nye explained that SB 451 would streamline criminal-background-check requirements for Title 17 occupations, create a uniform list of disqualifying offenses, a waiver process and a pre-license check. [1:32] [2:03] [2:12] [2:15] [2:36] [3:10] [3:46]

Representative Spencer Hawks asked whether the bill applied retroactively and Representative Andrew Collins inquired about possible conflicts with other background-check legislation; Nye responded that the bill is limited to Title 17 occupations and no conflicts have been identified. [4:19] [4:28] [4:54] [4:59]

Chair Dalby moved to pass the bill as amended, the committee voted aye and SB 451 was adopted. [5:59] [6:03]

HB1844 Gates CONCERNING WHAT CONSTITUTES CRIMINALLY INJURIOUS CONDUCT UNDER THE ARKANSAS CRIME VICTIMS REPARATIONS ACT. 7:09

Representative Mickey Gates presented HB 1844, recounting a fatal crash involving a stolen vehicle and arguing that victims whose perpetrators did not steal the vehicle to kill should be eligible for crime-victims reparations, seeking to strike limiting language from the existing statute. [7:38] [8:10] [8:41] [9:15] [9:47] [10:22]

Representative Sarah Capp questioned the fiscal impact and potential loss of federal funding; Gates said he was unaware of any federal funding issues and noted the bill does not require additional appropriations. [12:08] [12:23] [12:28] [12:58] [13:28] [13:32] [13:36]

No committee members offered a motion to approve the bill, so the chair declared the measure failed for lack of a motion. [14:17] [14:37] [15:07] [15:37]

SB544 Irvin TO ESTABLISH PREJUDGMENT AND POST-JUDGMENT INTEREST RATES. 16:10

Representative Douglas House introduced SB 544, proposing a floating pre- and post-judgment interest rate tied to the reserve primary credit rate (currently 3 % + 2 %) to replace the static 6 %/10 % rates and ensure fairness for debtors and creditors. [17:26] [17:54] [18:27] [19:01] [19:34] [20:08] [20:39] [21:10]

Representative Sarah Capp asked how the rate would be enforced; House answered that attorneys would present the rate and courts could readily verify and incorporate it into judgments. [21:26] [21:41] [21:48] [22:16] [22:21]

John Duncan of the Arkansas Collectors Association testified that the bill could create paperwork errors and uncertainty for judges and consumers, and Representative Cindy Crawford voiced concerns that small collection agencies might be harmed by the change. [22:54] [23:27] [23:58] [24:28] [27:10] [27:43] [28:17] [28:51]

The chair moved to pass the bill, the ayes carried, and SB 544 was approved by the committee. [30:18] [30:27]

SB579 A. Clark TO REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF ALL EVIDENCE IN THE POSSESSION OF THE STATE TO A CRIMINAL DEFENDANT, WHETHER THE EVIDENCE IS INCULPATORY, EXCULPATO… 30:56

[92-94] [32:59] [33:04] [33:25]

[95-118] [33:28] [33:36] [34:09] [34:22] [34:33] [34:41] [34:43] [34:55] [35:00] [35:05] [35:09] [35:14] [35:40] [35:51] [36:14] [36:24] [36:47] [36:55] [37:31] [38:02] [38:33] [39:04] [39:43] [40:17]

[112-119, 121-128] [36:55] [37:31] [38:02] [38:33] [39:04] [39:43] [40:17] [40:32] [41:22] [41:32] [41:47] [41:50] [41:53] [42:04] [42:24] [42:42]

[179-185] [58:02] [58:17] [58:33] [59:04] [59:07] [59:36]

SB9 T. Garner GRANTING A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER EMPLOYED WITH THE SOCIAL SECURITY ADMINISTRATION OR THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF STATE THE AUTHORITY TO ARR… 1:00:04

[185-187] [1:00:07] [1:00:11] [1:00:45]

[188-196] [1:00:59] [1:01:04] [1:01:16] [1:01:21] [1:01:48] [1:01:59] [1:02:04] [1:02:10] [1:02:14]

[199-202] [1:02:39] [1:02:52] [1:03:06] [1:03:23]

SB541 T. Garner RELATING TO THE PRIVILEGE FROM DISCLOSURE TO AUTHORITIES FOR EVIDENCE CONCERNING A SERMON, RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION, OR RELIGIOUS TEACHING DELIVER… 1:04:44

[203-206] [1:05:11] [1:05:35]

[209-214, 219-225] [1:05:55] [1:06:01] [1:06:12] [1:06:27] [1:06:44] [1:07:11] [1:08:08] [1:08:10] [1:08:18] [1:08:26] [1:08:40] [1:08:52] [1:09:27]

[226-227] [1:09:42] [1:09:58]

SB569 T. Garner CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF BATTERY IN THE THIRD DEGREE; AND CONCERNING BATTERY AGAINST A PREGNANT WOMAN. 1:10:35

[231-233] [1:10:37] [1:11:04] [1:11:35]

[236-239] [1:12:48] [1:12:53] [1:13:20] [1:14:00]

[240-244] [1:14:36] [1:15:07] [1:15:21] [1:15:37] [1:16:19]

SB543 Irvin TO CLARIFY THE UNIFORM CONTRIBUTION AMONG TORT FEASORS ACT. 1:17:09

Attorney Justin Allen testified for the Arkansas State Chamber and the Arkansas Association of Defense Counsel, explaining that SB 543 would clarify that juries may apportion fault to immune non-parties such as employers or state entities, preserving the several-liability rule established by the 2003 Civil Justice Reform Act. [1:17:23] [1:17:26] [1:17:36] [1:17:56] [1:18:28] [1:19:00] [1:19:37] [1:20:08] [1:20:40] [1:21:12]

Representative Douglas House raised a hypothetical case involving multiple manufacturers and a retailer to question whether the bill would allow richer parties to shift blame onto a judgment-proof defendant, but Allen responded that the bill only applies when an immune party is involved and would not affect that scenario. [1:21:51] [1:22:16] [1:22:46] [1:23:00] [1:23:07] [1:23:16]

Representative Andrew Collins asked how trial courts have handled such cases; Allen said courts have generally barred juries from assigning fault to immune parties, and argued that allowing it would not reduce verdict amounts because plaintiff damages remain the same, though recovery might come from workers’ compensation or state claims. [1:23:27] [1:23:34] [1:23:48] [1:24:05] [1:24:23] [1:24:27] [1:24:54] [1:25:27]

After brief discussion, Representative Michelle Gray moved to close the bill, a motion that was seconded and voted on; the committee voted no, causing SB 543 to fail. [1:26:43] [1:26:57] [1:26:59] [1:27:34] [1:28:00] [1:28:04]

SB552 Teague CONCERNING THE REORGANIZATION OF LOCAL DISTRICT COURTS INTO STATE DISTRICT COURTS. 1:28:41

Representative John Maddox, on behalf of Senator Teague, presented SB 552, noting that it would add Pike County to the 36th Judicial District, creating an additional judgeship based on D-CRAB’s caseload analysis and with unanimous support from the board and the Arkansas Legal Counsel (ALC). [1:28:52] [1:29:06] [1:29:32]

Representative Douglas House sought clarification on the district reassignment, asking from which district Pike County would move, which Maddox confirmed would be from the 40th to the 36th Judicial District. [1:29:35] [1:29:42] [1:29:49]

The committee moved to close the bill, a motion to pass was made and unanimously carried, resulting in SB 552 being adopted by the committee. [1:30:05] [1:30:18]

The chair then adjourned the meeting, praising the committee’s work and noting possible future legislation. [1:30:54] [1:31:25] [1:31:56]

Bills discussed (51)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB451 Act 990 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ing Senate Bill 9? I don't see anybody. Next one up will be Senate Bill 451, and I'll ask Vice Chair Petty to take over. So please turn…”
TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR PROFESSIONS AND OCCUPATIONS TO OBTAIN CONSISTENCY … J. Cooper Notification that SB451 is now Act 990
SB579 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…id I see you? Back behind there. Members, if you'll turn to Senate Bill 579. Senate Bill 579.”
TO REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF ALL EVIDENCE IN THE POSSESSION OF THE STATE TO A … A. Clark Recommended for study in the Interim Committee on …
HB1844 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1844 Gates CONCERNING WHAT CONSTITUTES CRIMINALLY INJURIOUS COND…”
CONCERNING WHAT CONSTITUTES CRIMINALLY INJURIOUS CONDUCT UNDER THE ARKANSAS CRIME VICTIMS REPARATIONS ACT. Gates Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
SB544 Act 995 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB544 Irvin TO ESTABLISH PREJUDGMENT AND POST-JUDGMENT INTEREST R…”
TO ESTABLISH PREJUDGMENT AND POST-JUDGMENT INTEREST RATES. Irvin Notification that SB544 is now Act 995
SB9 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB9 T. Garner GRANTING A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER EMPLOYED WITH…”
GRANTING A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER EMPLOYED WITH THE SOCIAL SECURITY ADMINISTRATION OR THE UNITED STATES … T. Garner Recommended for study in the Interim Committee on …
HB1009 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1009 Dotson PROHIBITING CERTAIN SEX OFFENDERS FROM ENTERING UPON…”
PROHIBITING CERTAIN SEX OFFENDERS FROM ENTERING UPON A SCHOOL CAMPUS. Dotson WITHDRAWN BY AUTHOR
HB1029 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1029 Rye AN ACT TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HERITAGE PROTECTION ACT.”
AN ACT TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HERITAGE PROTECTION ACT. Rye Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1040 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1040 Rushing TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS HOT CHECK LAW.”
TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS HOT CHECK LAW. Rushing Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1059 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1059 Pilkington CONCERNING THE USE OF PHYSICAL FORCE IN SELF-DEF…”
CONCERNING THE USE OF PHYSICAL FORCE IN SELF-DEFENSE OR IN THE DEFENSE OF OTHERS. Pilkington Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1279 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1279 Gazaway TO AMEND THE OFFENSE OF SEXUALLY GROOMING A CHILD.”
TO AMEND THE OFFENSE OF SEXUALLY GROOMING A CHILD. Gazaway Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1294 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1294 Della Rosa RESTORING PROSECUTORIAL DISCRETION IN THE RESOLU…”
RESTORING PROSECUTORIAL DISCRETION IN THE RESOLUTION OF DRIVING OR BOATING WHILE INTOXICATED CASES. Della Rosa Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1307 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1307 Dotson PERMITTING A BANK OR BANKING INSTITUTION TO UTILIZE…”
PERMITTING A BANK OR BANKING INSTITUTION TO UTILIZE THE SMALL CLAIMS DIVISION OF A DISTRICT … Dotson Recommended for study in the Interim by Joint …
HB1325 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1325 Lowery TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CUSTODY OF A CHILD.”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CUSTODY OF A CHILD. Lowery Recommended for study in the Interim by Joint …
HB1450 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1450 Wooten CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY TO CARRY A CONCEALED HAND…”
CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN BY A RETIRED CERTIFIED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER. Wooten Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1486 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1486 Gazaway TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CUSTODY OF A CHILD BORN…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CUSTODY OF A CHILD BORN OUTSIDE OF MARRIAGE. Gazaway Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1494 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1494 V. Flowers CONCERNING THE IMPOSITION OF THE DEATH PENALTY O…”
CONCERNING THE IMPOSITION OF THE DEATH PENALTY ON A DEFENDANT WITH A SERIOUS MENTAL ILLNESS. V. Flowers Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1520 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1520 Petty CONCERNING THE LAST MEAL OF AN INMATE SENTENCED TO DE…”
CONCERNING THE LAST MEAL OF AN INMATE SENTENCED TO DEATH. Petty Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1613 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1613 L. Johnson CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF BATTERY IN THE SECOND…”
CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF BATTERY IN THE SECOND DEGREE. L. Johnson Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1635 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1635 Petty CONCERNING AN INCREASE IN THE SENTENCING RANGE FOR RE…”
CONCERNING AN INCREASE IN THE SENTENCING RANGE FOR REPEAT FELONY SEX OFFENDERS; CONCERNING SEX OFFENDER … Petty Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1662 Act 786 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1662 Dalby REGARDING THE SALARIES OF PERSONNEL AND OTHER REQUIRE…”
REGARDING THE SALARIES OF PERSONNEL AND OTHER REQUIREMENTS OF VARIOUS DISTRICT COURTS. Dalby Notification that HB1662 is now Act 786
HB1680 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1680 Gazaway CONCERNING THE DEFINITION OF "TARGET GROUP" AS IT A…”
CONCERNING THE DEFINITION OF "TARGET GROUP" AS IT APPLIES TO COMMUNITY CORRECTION. Gazaway Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1694 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1694 Womack TO ELIMINATE GUN-FREE ZONES; AND TO REPEAL LAWS IN C…”
TO ELIMINATE GUN-FREE ZONES; AND TO REPEAL LAWS IN CONFLICT. Womack Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1705 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1705 Gazaway TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC CONFIDENCE IN THE INTEGRITY O…”
TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC CONFIDENCE IN THE INTEGRITY OF JUDICIAL ELECTIONS; AND TO REQUIRE ADDITIONAL … Gazaway Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1756 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1756 Clowney CONCERNING THE WAIVER OF COUNSEL BY MINORS IN CRIMI…”
CONCERNING THE WAIVER OF COUNSEL BY MINORS IN CRIMINAL COURT. Clowney Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1788 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1788 A. Collins THE BAIL DATA AND TRANSPARENCY ACT.”
THE BAIL DATA AND TRANSPARENCY ACT. A. Collins Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1828 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1828 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD INTRASTATE RELOCATION ACT…”
TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD INTRASTATE RELOCATION ACT; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING WHETHER OR … Lowery Recommended for study in the Interim by Joint …
HB1834 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1834 Sullivan TO PROHIBIT DISCRIMINATION OR PREFERENTIAL TREATME…”
TO PROHIBIT DISCRIMINATION OR PREFERENTIAL TREATMENT BY STATE AND OTHER PUBLIC ENTITIES. Sullivan Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1843 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1843 Gates CONCERNING A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND THE S…”
CONCERNING A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND THE SCOPE OF WHERE A MEMBER OF … Gates Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1891 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1891 Scott TO ALLOW THE DIVERSION OF CERTAIN JUVENILE OFFENSES.”
TO ALLOW THE DIVERSION OF CERTAIN JUVENILE OFFENSES. Scott Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1898 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1898 L. Johnson CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF DISORDERLY CONDUCT; TO…”
CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF DISORDERLY CONDUCT; TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF AGGRAVATED DISORDERLY CONDUCT; AND … L. Johnson Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1919 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1919 Scott CONCERNING THE USE OF INSTRUMENTS OF RESTRAINT ON IND…”
CONCERNING THE USE OF INSTRUMENTS OF RESTRAINT ON INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE UNDER EIGHTEEN (18) YEARS … Scott Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1938 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1938 D. Garner GRANTING A PUBLIC COLLEGE OR UNIVERSITY THE ABILI…”
GRANTING A PUBLIC COLLEGE OR UNIVERSITY THE ABILITY TO DETERMINE IF POSSESSION OF A CONCEALED … D. Garner Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1939 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1939 D. Garner TO ESTABLISH UNIVERSAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR THE…”
TO ESTABLISH UNIVERSAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR THE PURPOSES OF PURCHASING, RECEIVING, OR TRANSFERRING A FIREARM. D. Garner Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1940 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1940 D. Garner REQUIRING THE USE OF A RESTRAINT HOLSTER FOR A PE…”
REQUIRING THE USE OF A RESTRAINT HOLSTER FOR A PERSON WHO CARRIES A HANDGUN. D. Garner Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1962 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1962 M. Hodges TO REDUCE THE SENTENCE CLASSIFICATIONS FOR CERTAI…”
TO REDUCE THE SENTENCE CLASSIFICATIONS FOR CERTAIN OFFENSES FROM A FELONY TO A MISDEMEANOR. M. Hodges Recommended for study in the Interim by Joint …
HB1971 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1971 Beck CONCERNING DISTRICT COURTS; AND CONCERNING THE DISTRIC…”
CONCERNING DISTRICT COURTS; AND CONCERNING THE DISTRICT COURTS OF THE THIRTY-FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT. Beck Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1972 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1972 Blake CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF MARIJUANA.”
CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF MARIJUANA. Blake Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
SB14 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB14 L.”
CONCERNING THE FEE TO ATTEND A VICTIM IMPACT PANEL THAT IS REQUIRED BY LAW OF … L. Chesterfield Sine Die adjournment
SB183 Act 987 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB183 A. Clark TO PROHIBIT CERTAIN REGISTERED SEX OFFENDERS FROM…”
TO PROHIBIT CERTAIN REGISTERED SEX OFFENDERS FROM HOLDING A POSITION OF PUBLIC TRUST. A. Clark Notification that SB183 is now Act 987
SB206 Act 800 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB206 Irvin CONCERNING THE TERMINATION OF A PERSON'S OBLIGATION T…”
CONCERNING THE TERMINATION OF A PERSON'S OBLIGATION TO REGISTER AS A SEX OFFENDER; AND CONCERNING … Irvin Notification that SB206 is now Act 800
SB267 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB267 G.”
TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PERSON WITH A LICENSE TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN … G. Stubblefield Sine Die adjournment
SB311 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB311 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISQUALIFICATION O…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISQUALIFICATION OF JUDGES. A. Clark Recommended for study in the Interim Committee on …
SB464 Act 810 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB464 Hester TO ENSURE THE CONFIDENTIALITY OF CERTAIN PROCEDURES…”
TO ENSURE THE CONFIDENTIALITY OF CERTAIN PROCEDURES INVOLVED IN THE EXECUTION OF A PERSON FOR … Hester Notification that SB464 is now Act 810
SB511 Act 814 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB511 Hill CONCERNING THE THIRTIETH JUDICIAL DISTRICT; AND CONCER…”
CONCERNING THE THIRTIETH JUDICIAL DISTRICT; AND CONCERNING LONOKE COUNTY STATE DISTRICT COURT AS IT WILL … Hill Notification that SB511 is now Act 814
SB541 Act 816 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB541 T. Garner RELATING TO THE PRIVILEGE FROM DISCLOSURE TO AUTH…”
RELATING TO THE PRIVILEGE FROM DISCLOSURE TO AUTHORITIES FOR EVIDENCE CONCERNING A SERMON, RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION, … T. Garner Notification that SB541 is now Act 816
SB543 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB543 Irvin TO CLARIFY THE UNIFORM CONTRIBUTION AMONG TORT FEASOR…”
TO CLARIFY THE UNIFORM CONTRIBUTION AMONG TORTFEASORS ACT. Irvin Sine Die adjournment
SB547 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB547 B. Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DIVISION OF PROP…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE. B. Johnson Sine Die adjournment
SB552 Act 817 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB552 Teague CONCERNING THE REORGANIZATION OF LOCAL DISTRICT COUR…”
CONCERNING THE REORGANIZATION OF LOCAL DISTRICT COURTS INTO STATE DISTRICT COURTS. Teague Notification that SB552 is now Act 817
SB569 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB569 T. Garner CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF BATTERY IN THE THIRD DE…”
CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF BATTERY IN THE THIRD DEGREE; AND CONCERNING BATTERY AGAINST A PREGNANT … T. Garner Recommended for study in the Interim Committee on …
SB623 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB623 A. Clark TO REMOVE A DRIVER'S LICENSE SUSPENSION OR REVOCAT…”
TO REMOVE A DRIVER'S LICENSE SUSPENSION OR REVOCATION AS AN AVAILABLE PENALTY FOR AN OFFENSE … A. Clark Recommended for study in the Interim Committee on …
SB87 Act 927 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB87 A. Clark TO DEFINE "IMMINENT HARM" UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVEN…”
TO DEFINE "IMMINENT HARM" UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989 AND THE CHILD MALTREATMENT … A. Clark Notification that SB87 is now Act 927

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 9, 2026
Members, let's start back at the top of our agenda, Senate Bill 9. Is there anybody on this committee or anybody in the audience that's running Senate Bill 9? I don't see anybody. Next one up will be Senate Bill 451, and I'll ask Vice Chair Petty to take over. So please turn to Senate Bill 451.
▶ Play
Thank you. You are recognized to present Senate Bill 451.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Permission, I'll have someone with the AG's office here by me to also present. I believe we have an amendment. Yes, ma'am, it's on the tablet. Members, if you will look at the amendment to Senate Bill 451, and I would move for adoption
▶ Play
of the amendment. All those in favor of the adoption of the amendment say aye. All opposed. Thank you. Please explain your amendment.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. If I may, I'll move into the bill as amended. And with that, this, as you can tell, is a 67-page bill, and it is coming from the AG's office. It's an effort to streamline laws regarding criminal background checks for our different professions and occupations and to give those licensing boards some parameters and some guidelines in regard to background checks. And if it's permissible with the chair, I'd ask the assistant attorney general to then explain the meats of the bill. Thank you. Just identify yourself for the
▶ Play
record, and you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair, members of
▶ Play
the committee. My name is Brad Nye. I'm with the Arkansas Attorney General's Office. To Representative Dalby's point, this is a somewhat meaty bill, but the beauty of it is the only real pertinent language to pay attention to is the first seven pages of the bill. The remainder of the bill is clean up from Title 17, and I'll get into that here momentarily. Basically, this is the work of the Red Tape Reduction Committee, who was tasked with identifying and lowering barriers to entry to professions here in the state of Arkansas. Out of that committee, they had five recommendations that went to the governor. One of those recommendations dealt with the criminal background check process. And so this bill, 451, is a start in that process towards cleanup of background checks. This bill in particular only applies to Title 17 occupations and professions. It makes background checks for those particular occupations and professions more uniform and centralized. it creates a list of offenses that disqualify you for a period of up to five years but also creates a waiver process for boards to consider whether you've been rehabilitated and should be able to get a license it creates a pre-license check which is extremely important for our applicants out in the community they are able to inquire from a licensing entity early on before they pay for schooling as to whether or not anything in their past would otherwise disqualify them. This grandfather's in existing licenses, again, I imagine in two years we will be back down here tweaking this bill, but the bill as is, is a good bill and I think it's a step in the right direction for the state. And with that, I'll
▶ Play
take any questions. Are there any questions? Representative Hawks, you
▶ Play
recognize. Thank you, Madam Chair. and I believe you just answered this so this grandfather's existing licenses so there is not retroactivity in this bill that's correct
▶ Play
representative thank you representative Collins you recognize it thank you madam chair has has an effort been made to go through all of the bills that we passed this session and make sure there are no conflicts specifically thinking about a couple background check bills that have come through this committee representative boyd had had one even ones that have not necessarily cleared both houses and been signed by the governor i know that there's that one i don't think is clear both houses and been signed there's one about uh about nursing licenses i'm not sure if any of these would conflict has any
▶ Play
effort been done on that no thank you for that question representative our office has been tracking legislation as it develops We've not identified any bills to date that would conflict with this, and this is limited only to Title 17 occupations and professions. Any changes to, like, nurses, nurse background checks that we've seen are not in conflict with this bill.
▶ Play
Is there any further questions by the committee? Would you like to close for your bill? Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. No one has signed up for or against this. So if you are. Just ask if there's anyone in the audience. Okay. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak for or against this bill? Okay.
▶ Play
If you're ready to close for you, Bill. Yes. Thank you. And I want to thank Mr. Nye from the AG's office. They've worked long and diligent hours to get this bill prepared. And with that, I would make a motion to do pass as amended. We have a
▶ Play
motion to do pass as amended. What is the will of the committee? All in favor, say aye. Those opposed? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. Thank you.
▶ Play
Members, I tell you what, let's go ahead and take Representative Gates to get him because I did promise him last week that we would hear his two bills, and those were the only two House bills we were going to take up, be House Bill 1844, House Bill 1844, Representative Gage, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Last week when I was
▶ Play
scheduled to be here, I was actually at the Crime Victims Reparations Board appealing for constituents of mine's family. My constituents were killed, and this bill came into view in light of the tragic circumstances that happened on September the 12th last year. Last year, about 1130 in the morning, and a 19-year-old young man stole a vehicle in Hot Springs, and a police officer, Hot Springs City Police Department, pulled him over, and in that process, he fled. A short pursuit happened, and then they called off because it's in a highly dense area of town, and so they called it off. And a few minutes later, they got a phone call of a wreck that happened. I had a husband and wife. George was 49, his wife. Kathleen was 51 years old. They'd been to the, not the hardware store, but the farm supply place at Atwoods, and they had just pulled out. They were stopped at the stop sign, and a 19-year-old in a stolen vehicle, felony fleeing from police, lost control of his car, went through a fire hydrant, hit their car sideways, it drove them 90 feet, actually their car went through a fire hydrant and went 90 feet and killed them on the spot. It turned his car upside down. The police was able to get there within one minute and they arrested him while he was still trying to get out of his car. Now, I've got constituents that are having to bury their family members, and in the appeals to the Crime Victims Reparations Board for help for burying family members, it comes to find out that unless that guy had stolen the car for the purpose of killing somebody or causing serious bodily harm that we won't consider them for reparations to be able to help those families. And I understand it. Money is limited, but they should be considered. The families are no less, the family members are no less injured or dead. And in this case, family members are lost because of a criminal act perpetrated. There's one thing in the law, the very last thing says, unless they were trying to flee. Well, this guy wasn't trying to flee because within one minute of wrecking his car, the police were there to arrest him. He was already felony fleeing. I think they should at least be considered. That's all this bill does. it just strikes out some of the language so that we can consider them. The families appealed to the appeals board and said, you know, why can't we consider this? This guy was fleeing. So I recognize that with this, there could be some more appeals. They're already getting appeals, and last week's visit there kind of proved the point that that's part of the process, and I think these victims and their families should at least have a right to be considered just because a car wasn't stolen for the purposes of running somebody down. In fact, the question is, when was the last time y'all heard of anybody still in the car to go kill somebody? I can't think of it ever happening. I think somewhere in Canada, I think somebody stole a U-Haul or something and mowed down a bunch of people and stole it for that purpose. Other than that, we just don't hear of that. And I think these victims and their families at least should be considered. If at some point in the future that more money is appropriated and we can help more money or help more families, then so be it. Right now, there's a set amount of money. They've got a tough job. But I think these families, our constituents, should at least be considered their victims. Just nonetheless, the fact that somebody didn't purposely steal a car for that reason, I don't think should disqualify them. And I sit in front of that board, and I know the couple that came before us, that there There was, you know, I think it was a murder victim and family of a murder victim. And, you know, I know they've got a tough job. We think we've got a tough job. They've got a really tough job. And, you know, I hope sometime in the future that we can talk about finding some more money to help these families because a lot of times these people are helping people that have no other means, and these are victims. I think that's another subject that we need to deal with, I think, as a legislature, but that starts by being able to at least consider them victims worthy of reparations.
▶ Play
With that, I'll entertain any questions. Members, are there any
▶ Play
questions? Representative Kapp, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Gates, I appreciate what you're trying to do here, but I know that there's some federal funding tied specifically to this. Have you looked into that, or have you asked for a fiscal impact? No, and
▶ Play
there would be an impact in the fact that any time you hear, you know, it's just like we as a legislature, any time we have more meetings, there's going to be a fiscal impact. And they would, you know, they could have more people appeal. Right now, what happened with the family that when they, you know, made their first appeal for reparations, they got a form letter. You don't qualify because you can't, you know, unless a car was stolen for the purpose of running somebody down. And they appealed in any way because part of that was appealable. So, granted, there would be some more appeals. I think our appeal probably lasted, I don't know, 20 minutes. It took longer to get in than it actually did to make our appeal. They're very kind and courteous and heartfelt, very genuine people. And I don't know about federal funding, but I know that if state money ever comes available for us to help those people, I would be the first one in line to say, let's find a way to put something up to help. You're recognized for a follow-up? So
▶ Play
you have not talked to anyone about the impact of your bill and how it would affect the state in regards to any funds that we receive
▶ Play
on a federal level? To my knowledge, I mean, nobody's come to me and said that it would disqualify us for any funds. You know, I know there are federal dollars, but I also know that if state dollars becomes available, if we're not even considering these victims, they already turned down people. Some years they may have more claims than other years. I doubt they ever have as much money, and it's very difficult when you're, especially at the first of the year, you've got a certain amount of budget that you've got to last you all year long. And I don't know how they do it. I don't think that I would want to be on that committee because I don't know that I could do that because I don't think
▶ Play
there's ever enough money for that. Representative House, you're recognized for a question. Any other questions? We have no one who has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Gates, you're recognized to close. Is there anyone in the audience? Representative Gates, you're recognized to close for your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you. This doesn't ask for any more money for reparations for victims, and I will say this. The parent of the man that was killed actually was able to take the cost of themselves for the husband but could not afford to take care of the wife. And so the niece that actually works for me had to go out and take out a loan, and her husband had just gotten laid off of his job and they had to go out and take out a loan. Thankfully, they did get some help from the funeral home, sold them a last year's edition coffin at a discount and helped, but they still had to take out loans to pay for those very meager services. I think this is a good step. I don't think that it, because it doesn't require any more funding, But at least these people should feel like that we're at least listening and caring.
▶ Play
And I would appreciate a good vote. Members, the representative is closed for his bill. What are the wishes of the committee? Seeing no motion, your bill has failed for lack of motion. Thank you. Next bill we're going to take is Senate Bill 544. I understand Representative House, are you going to be presenting Senate Bill 544? Members, if you'll turn to Senate Bill 544.
▶ Play
Madam Chair, a question first. Yes. Do you have anyone here to sign up for or against this bill?
▶ Play
Yes, we have Mr. Duncan. okay good I knew that someone
▶ Play
had made some representations to some people that it would be heard tomorrow I'm ready to present it today but I didn't want anybody shut out of the process I didn't make any such promises we do have Becky
▶ Play
Mickey McHughes, she had to leave, Ben Chesom, they all had to leave, I mean, we can, you're okay with that, all right, I thought there was a group, I believe
▶ Play
Speaker 72 17:08
those were the ones that we had
▶ Play
signed up, so I think we're fine, Representative House, if you'd like to, looks like these individuals have indicated that they're good with going, and I know they had set through all morning, so I appreciate your thinking of that.
▶ Play
Thank you. Well, I don't ever want to misrepresent anything we do to anybody, so if they're here, that's great. Thank you, Madam Chair. May I proceed then? Yes, you may. You're recognized. Colleagues, in the law, there are certain lawsuits, contract actions are one good example. you borrow money and then fail to pay it back or a person fails to pay it back. And a suit has to be brought during the time from the default of the debt, when you don't pay your debt until you get judgment. The loss of that money is a real loss to the person that either sold the goods or loaned the money or did something like that. and the law recognizes the loss of use of that money from the time of the transaction or the time of the default on the transaction, default meaning failure to pay, is compensable at law. And then after judgment, it takes some time to get your money back, maybe garnishments or executions or something along those lines, or just some time needs to go by until the person can pay those judgments. And at the same time, loss of that income is recognized as compensable. Back in the 1980s, I remember when 25% interest rates were very common. And there were people turning down, refusing to deposit their money, even though 17%, 18% interest would be paid on those deposits because they could go up to Montana or South Dakota and get 26%, 27% interest. And then there's been other times where 2% or 3% here in the last couple of years, you have almost negative interest rates from the use of money. But anyway, the interest rates that people are allowed to charge and the courts are allowed to award prior to judgment and after judgment have been in a state of flux for 30 years. 6% has been a sum when there is no specified interest rate out there. Like if you borrow money at 8%, then that'll be the interest rate you'll be able to recover before a judgment. After judgment, it has traditionally been 10%. Now, the law will allow a plaintiff, when they sue to recover money, to recover those interest rates. But they're not allowed to make a windfall profit. They can't get 25% or 30% when the going rate downtown is not near that much. So what this bill does, it uses a floating rate, and it's the reserve primary credit rate. You can Google it on the Internet. I did it earlier today, it's 3%, plus an additional 2%. So right now it would be 5%, which is a pretty fair return on money today. Now, two or three weeks from now, two or three months from now, it's probably going to be something different. But anyway, you do have a rate that is readily determinable and that can be applied by the court when those circumstances come up. That's what this bill does. It seeks to find a happy place where everybody's treated fair, the debtor's treated fair because you don't pay a windfall, and the creditor is treated fair. They don't lose more than they're able to gain what is fair for them. That's it in a nutshell. Thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chair. Members, are there any questions? I've seen Representative Kapp. You're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative House, from a practical standpoint, do you see any issues with trying to enforce this? I mean, are the courts going to be the one to enforce this to make sure that the rate is the correct rate? Or is that obligation on the attorneys who are the ones that prepare the orders and submit to the
▶ Play
court? What do you foresee? The answer to all those questions is yes. The attorneys will certainly present evidence. and since this is a readily determinable rate, the court can verify it, or I would think that under those circumstances there wouldn't be any much argument about what the reserve primary credit rate is, and then it would be incorporated into a judgment, so many certain percentage up until time of judgment, certain percentage after judgment. Yes, ma'am, the court would award that in a
▶ Play
judgment. Any other questions? We do have some individuals who have signed up to, or an individual who is here to sign up to speak against Mr. Duncan. If you'll come to the end of the table and you can state your name and you'll be recognized to proceed. thank
▶ Play
Speaker 87 22:49
you very much madam chairman uh and thank you everybody of your allowance to be here my name is John Duncan I'm a board member of the Arkansas Collectors Association and again it's been a pleasure this is my first experience with this so it's been amazing watching you guys today so thank you madam chairman and committee thank you in advance for your time and considerations we are appealing to you for these reasons and concerns and which you've already kind of brought some of those up the Arkansas collectors Association promotes lawful consumer debt collection for creditors and government we serve members by providing education and training promoting ethical professional conduct and acting as a voice with lawmakers we are concerned that this legislation will cause much stress in the court paperwork that has to be submitted in perfect order if the interest rate for today is typed in the paperwork and is forwarded to the judge to sign but he does not get to it for a few weeks and the interest rate has changed then the paperwork will be incorrect and rejected possibly we feel like it will create uncertainty with our attorneys clerks and other creditors as well as our judges and one of our main concerns is a is for the least sophisticated consumer if the interest rate is just left blank on the paperwork it then puts the burden upon the county judge or traveling judge to write in the correct interest rate on the daily signs of paperwork if this bill is passed this will create yet another avenue potentially for attorneys to sue agencies who are struggling to comply if the interest rate is incorrect and again we are concerned about the false representation of the character amount character the amount or legal status of the debt I can just say that from our industry, from our agency, we're heavily regulated, and it's always about certainly trying to be fair to the consumer, but making sure, making clear that we have the correct amount owed, and that's, I think, our biggest concern, and the others had to leave earlier today, but our concern is making sure that we have the correct balance owed, And our concern is that, you know, will that consumer understand if it's floating? So really, that's kind of our question. But thank you again. Certainly appreciate your time. Are there any questions for this witness? Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Dunklin. Thank you, ma'am. And there were others who had signed up, and I believe, as he stated, they have gone. We don't have anyone who has signed up to speak for the bill. So Representative House, you're recognized to close for your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, colleagues, and I appreciate his comments. That's the whole point of this bill, try to reach a point. You have to understand that in a lawsuit to collect a debt, if there is a contractual rate, it might be 18, 20% if it's a credit card debt, then whatever contract rate you've got is what holds unless it exceeds the rate that's specified in Amendment 89. If there's no contract rate specified, then this comes in here, and that's what the courts have generally held. And that's the way I read this statute, and it's the way I read this bill, and it's the way I read the statute for a long time it's been 6% then 10% right now 10% is windfall 6% is probably a windfall but it's that's about what you can make on the stock market and it does represent a real loss of money so if there's no other questions and now I believe I'll close then thank you very much
▶ Play
representing Crawford you have a question okay I'll get to you Representative House is closed for the bill. Would you like to make a motion, Representative House? Representative House has made a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion of the motion? Representative Crawford, you're recognized for a discussion. Thank you, Madam Chair.
▶ Play
Somehow, as a freshman, my name got on this bill. Do not remember signing it, and I signed very few, so a little concerned about that. And the other is that I have been getting emails, phone calls, texts from my constituents who this will devastate their business as collection agencies. And part of what they say is that the Arkansas Collectors Association promotes lawful consumer debt collection for creditors and government. We serve members by providing education, training, promoting ethical professional conduct, and acting as a voice with their members and are the backbone of the credit-based economy recovering rightfully owed debts. Their industry is largely comprised of small businesses. 85% of agencies have 49 or fewer employees, while 44% have nine or less. They say that their work is important to helping businesses remain operational while reducing the cost of goods and services. The industry returns close to $67 billion annually to the national economy, including over $260 million in Arkansas. I would just like some discussion on this. I do not want to do something that is going to hurt people who are trying to get out of credit debt. And then we are adding legislation that could possibly bring lawsuits on these collection agencies. I'll allow
▶ Play
some latitude, Representative House. Representative
▶ Play
Crawford's concern is genuine. The law already provides for interest on judgments. It's 16-65-114. Right now, it's 10% per annum on judgments and 6% per annum up until judgment. Now, the plaintiffs, in this case collection agencies that you mentioned, are entitled to recover the loss of their money, the fair loss. They're not allowed to make a windfall on a collection action. And these rates have fluctuated over the years, and periodically they have to be adjusted in line with the times. The legislature only meets every two years, so this is an attempt to build in a way where you can look it up online, get the federal rate, add 2% to it, and that will always be. It's as determinable as going to the statute book and looking it up. It's fair to everybody. and it can go way up and it can go way
▶ Play
down. Any other discussion? Members, we have a motion on the floor. All in favor of the motion do pass, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. The ayes have it. Motion is carried. You have passed your bill. Senator Clark, did I see you? Back behind there. Members, if you'll turn to Senate Bill 579. Senate Bill 579. Representative House, could you maybe go to the end of the table and punch up the bill number so Senator Clark can find it? Oh, I see Allison's doing that. 579. Senator Clark, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 579.
▶ Play
Madam Chair, if we could run this Thursday, Mr. Rosen-Swag is not in the room and I think we're all going to be a lot better off if he is.
▶ Play
We really weren't planning on meeting Thursday. Okay. And I don't want to prejudice your bill in any way, but we were really making an effort to be done today. But what's the will of the committee? I'll let the committee look. You're not presenting anything, so give it up. I'd like to let's proceed
▶ Play
Senate bill 579 Thank you, Madam Chair. 579 requires the disclosure of all evidence in possession of the state to a criminal defendant where the evidence is inculpatory, exculpatory, or neither inculpatory nor exculpatory for other purposes. That's the title, and that pretty much explains what it does. I'll be happy to take questions to the best
▶ Play
of my ability. Representative Collins, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator, if Mr. Rosenzweig were here, what might he be saying?
▶ Play
What Mr. Rosenzweig would be saying, and the attorney who asked me to run this bill, is that until this is encoded in law, because what some testimony will be is that under Amendment 80, some of this is already in place, that we have some prosecutors in some areas who don't do this. And if it is indeed supposed to be the practice of the courts, there's no reason not to encode it in law. Follow-up? You're recognized
▶ Play
for a follow-up. And, you know, this is not an area where I practice, but is this generally supposed to be the practice of the courts? Is that your understanding, that this is more or less what we believe should be happening anyway? That's
▶ Play
what I heard in testimony on the Senate end. Any other questions?
▶ Play
Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chair. Senator, I just want to make sure I see the prosecutor's office in the room and also law enforcement in the room. I just need to make sure that everybody's on board with this. Do
▶ Play
y'all have any objections? They have signed up to speak against it. No one has signed up? No,
▶ Play
they have signed up to speak against it. They have? Yes. Oh, okay.
▶ Play
I'm sorry. I'll wait for the end. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Kapp, you're recognized for a question? I guess what I'm looking at, and thank you, Madam Chair, is understanding. I mean, now you file discovery in a case, and then the state is bound to answer that discovery. So specifically, and I apologize, I've not had time to really examine the bill, but, I mean, what is this bill seeking to obtain that's not otherwise obtainable through the normal discovery routes?
▶ Play
Representative Kapp, I don't know. the um again i apologize uh mr rosen swag said he would be more than able to explain it uh the attorney who gave it to me who became a defendant and never expected to be one uh said that after being on the other side of the law uh that it gave him a whole new view of things uh and that it was needed and that's about as deep as my understanding goes I understand thank you Members any
▶ Play
other questions We do have a couple of folks who have signed up to speak against Bob McMahon And Mr. Hunter I think y'all are tag teaming So I'll recognize both of you You're recognized, just state your name and
▶ Play
Speaker 126 36:47
you can proceed. Bob McMahon, prosecutor coordinator representing the Prosecuting Attorneys Association. Thank you, Madam Chairman and members of the committee. We are opposed to this bill. We do specifically have some concerns. First of all, it's our opinion that the court rules that are already in existence address what is in this bill. For example, and I know I don't read everything to you. If you have specific questions, I can certainly go a little more deeper into the rules. But generally speaking, Rule 17.1 of Discovery outlines the prosecuting attorney obligations. The rule then goes through all the different aspects of that rule and components. For example, 17.2 says that the prosecutor's performance, he shall give that information up as soon as possible. 17.3 talks about giving information that is held by other government agencies or law enforcement. So we have to give that up as well. 17.4 talks about discretionary disclosures. If there are certain situations that would prohibit something to be disclosed, then that is possible that would go before the court and a decision would be made. Under Rule 19.1, there is a continuing duty to give that information should it come into the prosecutor possession or other governmental personnel possession. So that's addressed by the bill as well. Rule 19.4 talks about protective orders, which is discussed a little bit in this bill as well. And then Rule 19.7 talks about failure to comply. So there are sanctions possibly out there if someone fails to comply. So in general, it's our opinion that this is already covered, and it's up to the court to set those rules. When we talked a little bit about possible unintended consequences of this bill, I was contacted this morning by one of our prosecutors who had a couple of examples of cases that he wanted me to share with the committee today, should you hear this bill. And this is, again, some unintended consequences that came recently in two specific cases that were prosecuted by a particular judicial district. I'm not trying to name those victims at this point. I don't want to do that. These are real cases. They have already been held. But, again, for privacy reasons, I don't want to name the victims. But I will tell you what happened in those cases. And it's our fear that should this bill pass, that information that I'm going to mention to you would then be disclosed to the defendant and would be out there in public and would basically re-victimize people. So, again, a couple of examples here. One was a rape case where the victim in the state was raped and later learned that the rape left her unable to have children. Another victim was raped and had an abortion when she learned after the rape that she was pregnant. Neither of these victims wanted this made public and certainly didn't want this information to get out. Even with the protective order, it's our opinion that that information would, in fact, get out. It's not right for the victim to have to give up their right to privacy in one of the most painful events that they've ever had to deal with in their lifetime. What this bill, in our opinion, would do then, by taking something farther than exculpatory or inculpatory evidence, it would give access to anything that was in the case file. So those are two specific examples of something that would be given to the defendant and given to the public that would not be exculpatory, would not be inculpatory, and wouldn't have any effect one way or another on the case to be tried. In other words, the defendant would still be tried. The defendant would still have a right to a fair trial, as they do. And, of course, anything exculpatory that would lead to possible showing that the defendant was, in fact, innocent would be given by the state, and anything inculpatory as well. So, again, those are two examples, in our opinion, where this bill would go further and would show an unintended consequence. So, in summary, we believe that this is already controlled by court rules, and this going a little farther would cause possible problems and privacy issues. and we'll be happy to answer any questions. I don't know if Mr. Hunter has anything
▶ Play
Speaker 127 40:32
to add at this point or not. Mr. Hunter? Thank you, Madam Chair and Committee. Kyle Hunter, prosecuting attorney in Jefferson, Lincoln County, president of the Arkansas Prosecuting Attorneys Association. I think just all that I would try to add at this point is that we do believe that the discovery rules take care of what's been presented in this bill. other than the unintended consequences that could happen, as Mr. McMahon has pointed out. Also, I want the committee to consider the fact that there is remedies for a defendant who thinks he is not getting what he thinks he should have, and that's a motion to compel the courts address when need be, when a defendant doesn't think that he's getting what he's supposed to have. So I think that this bill has some unintended consequences, And other than that, all those things are already covered by current rules.
▶ Play
Representative Petty, you recognize for a question? Mr. McMahon, would this sort of be getting rid of the rape shield in a way? I guess
▶ Play
Speaker 126 41:32
in a way it could be construed that way. When you recall, I would think it's possible. Yes, ma'am. Something that wouldn't normally come in would then come in. It wouldn't be coming into evidence, but it would come into the possession of individuals that wouldn't have access to that. That would be
▶ Play
my understanding. Representative Collins, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you. I think that's, I'm trying to get at something here. You know, and you said that you talked about some information that wouldn't have any effect one way or another in the case to be tried. That really wouldn't be evidence then, would it? No,
▶ Play
Speaker 126 42:04
Representative, I don't think that it would be evidence in the case, which is why it wouldn't, under normal discovery rules, have to be given. So I think, again, this is what I mean by that goes a step further. It wouldn't be something that was necessary in the trial one way or another, whether exculpatory or inculpatory. So the unintended consequences would be giving somebody information that would not have come out in the trial as evidence.
▶ Play
Follow-up? You're recognized for a follow-up. But the reason I ask that is that this does specifically limit it to evidence collected before, during, and after, whether it's exculpatory or inculpatory or neither. So, you know, that really wouldn't apply there. This is only evidence we're talking about in this. It depends
▶ Play
Speaker 126 42:42
on how that would be construed. I mean, again, I don't know. Again, this goes farther by saying neither specifically exculpatory or inculpatory. I don't know what a court would determine. I mean, it may be a factual situation where the other side is arguing that, in fact, it is evidence. I would argue in most situations that it's probably not. But, again, our concern is this goes farther and possibly re-victimizes people with information that would come out, again, in the course of the discovery process under this bill that they wouldn't normally get at this point. So I think we'd have to look at each individual, you know, case to determine each individual piece of information to determine whether that fit this or didn't fit this. It's kind
▶ Play
Speaker 132 43:15
of hard to answer that, you know, without knowing exactly what it is. Representative Clowney,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Mr. McMahon, for your testimony. I guess as I'm reading this bill, it looks like it's pretty carefully drafted to avoid the kind of situations, the kind of consequences that you're talking about. I'm looking specifically on page two, starting at line four, where it lists out all of the ways that a court could prevent immediate disclosure. And it strikes me that the rape shield would fall under that exception in lines 7 through 9. Can you just express why these exceptions, why these lines 4 through whatever it is, 17, aren't adequate in your mind?
▶ Play
Speaker 126 43:57
Representative, if I'm following that question correctly, it looks to me like the part of the bill you're referring to is where it says the court may issue a protective order against the immediate disclosure of this information. It looks to me like the stuff that I described wouldn't fit any of these, unless I'm reading this wrong. The first says evidence is favorable to defend it solely because the evidence would provide a basis to impeach the credibility of a potential witness. So that clearly is not that. Second, the state establishes a reasonable basis to believe that the identity of a potential witness is not already known. It would not encompass that situation. And third It says disclosure would present a threat to the safety of a potential witness. So it doesn't apply to any of those three things, I don't think. So that protective order, the way I read that, that the state would get to keep this information out, I don't think it applies to the situations that I was given
▶ Play
by that prosecuting attorney. I read that
▶ Play
differently. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Prosecutor, other than the examples that you've already provided to the committee in regards to the evidence as it related to a rape, it says here that all evidence, would that also affect minors involved in a criminal case?
▶ Play
Speaker 126 45:11
Representative, I don't think it differentiates between that. I just think, again, those are just a couple of examples. I'm sure that we could come up with others. But, again, anything that, in our opinion, that did not fit exculpatory or inculpatory would be extra than the current rules provide. So I think it's possible, and if I'm answering your question correctly, in a number of situations there could be evidence that don't fit those two specific examples, and therefore it would come in in a situation where it would not come in under current rules. Give me an answer.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Maddox, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. McMahon, so we currently have rules of evidence, we have rules of criminal procedure, we have years and years of precedent. If my understanding is if a criminal defendant's counsel is unhappy with what he's getting, he can file a motion to compel, that'll be litigated, and a circuit court will determine what should be turned over. My question, I guess, is that correct, and do you feel that our system is working just fine as
▶ Play
Speaker 139 46:09
it is? Yes, Representative, I believe that is
▶ Play
Speaker 126 46:13
correct, and I do believe it does work fine. And obviously, there are situations where defense attorneys disagree with prosecutors, and the situation you described is a perfect example. They can go before the court and file a motion to have something compelled. And there are sanctions that are in current law if the court finds that the prosecutor has not complied with court orders or court rules. I believe there are sanctions, and the rule that I mentioned, Rule 19.7, talks about failure to comply, and I can look that rule up real quick if you need specifics, but I would agree with you. I think that the current system does work fine. Obviously, there are differences from time to time, but the court can address those.
▶ Play
Any other questions? Representative Tosh, I saw you first, and then I'll get to Representative Glewett. Thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chair. As I read this bill, Mr. Prosecutor, maybe this answer's for you, but I just want to make sure, and I think maybe we've already touched on it to some degree, but the bill, the way it's written, would this expose a victim's history to the defendant almost to the point that it could become embarrassing for them to the point of not wanting to prosecute? Do you see that happening with this particular bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 126 47:26
Yes, Representative Tosh. I believe that is another excellent example. I believe this, we may disagree, Senator Clark and I, but I certainly believe the possibility that information about an individual's background could get out in a situation like this would possibly and definitely, I believe definitely, would impact some individuals for going forward with a particular case in the criminal justice system. They would be embarrassed to air, for lack of a better word, dirty laundry about their past or certain things in their family history or things like that. So I agree with you.
▶ Play
I think that's a great point. Representative
▶ Play
Glover, you're recognized for a question. Pull your microphone down. Thank you, Madam Chair. Essentially, I reviewed the law, the bill, and I think it's quite – the existing discovery law under the criminal rules of criminal procedures really includes the issues that are raised in this bill. And some of the issues that are raised, it's my opinion, they will not be allowed, but the court could allow the lawyers to, in camera, or, you know, to find out exactly what things they are wanting. I mean, the rape shill provision would still apply. I mean, in the prosecution of a defendant, he or evidence should not go against any other information about the victim other than what's critical to the prosecution of the crime. our history of the sexual activity of the victim other than what's before the court should not be allowed it would not be allowed so I I think the existing criminal Rosa procedures are adequate and as has and I guess my thing is a The question, my question is, why is this
▶ Play
Speaker 144 50:14
rule necessary or required?
▶ Play
Representative Glover, is your question directed at Senator Clark or one of the prosecutors? It
▶ Play
would be to Senator Clark. You asked why? The good question. I was born a skeptic, and the longer I'm here, the more skeptical I get. It is interesting to peel back the onion as the process goes. I had absolutely no attachment, emotional or otherwise, to this bill. But we heard testimony on the other end that we didn't need the bill because it didn't do anything that wasn't already done. And then I sat here, and first that's where we were headed. And then he said, no, actually it does do something else, but we don't want to do that. And, of course, as usual, the world may come to an end if we do it. The no amendment offered to protect victims that you wouldn't have to give that information. And just so the best answer, I think, to your question, Representative Glover, is I think that they do protest too much. And I think the law is working perfectly well for prosecutors. I think that would be my answer. Any other questions by the
▶ Play
committee? Representative House, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. I'll tell
▶ Play
you what, I had to reach way back here in the back for the criminal law experience, but Brady v. Maryland, the Supreme Court says that the state must disclose all evidence exculpatory or inculpatory, I can't even say the words, to the defendant. This bill has a protective order, evidence that is favorable to the defendant solely because it would provide a basis to impeach the credibility. Brady says if it's evidence that can impeach the credibility of a witness, it must be disclosed, yet this bill says don't disclose it to the judge candid. That's contrary to Supreme Court law on the other extreme. If we adopt this, we're in violation of the Brady rule, which means you've got
▶ Play
Speaker 147 52:50
to give everything to the defendant except for very limited circumstances if it's
▶ Play
Speaker 127 52:56
not evidence. essentially, am I correct? Brady, along with the cases that followed Brady, do require the prosecution to turn over all evidence that might be exculpatory, even evidence that might lead to exculpatory type situations, even if it involves just the impeachment of a witness. And so those are burdens that are upon the prosecution now that should be in our country to deliver all that type of information. And prosecutors go beyond, take that very seriously in disclosing to defendants what they need to disclose. And, in fact, many offices around this state just have an open file policy to let them have whatever's in there, except the things that Mr. McMahon was talking about that have nothing to do with the case itself, that you might learn about a particular victim or a witness during the preparation for a trial. So I don't think that everything goes the prosecution way. I disagree with the senator with all due respect. But I think that the rules that are there now allow for the defendant to have everything that he needs because the last thing that any prosecutor wants is for someone who's innocent to be convicted. That's not what we want in this state. And so a great effort is taken to comply with those discovery rules because there are repercussions and consequences if it's not. Representative House,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a follow-up. Thank
▶ Play
you. I was privileged to work with people that I trusted and had confidence in, and I would follow that open file policy until I learned that the police sometimes would not turn over evidence to the prosecutor because they knew the prosecutor would give you the whole case file to review anything and everything that he or she had. I don't see that this bill adds anything to that. Maybe it does. I'm looking for something that will expand what the defendant gets because too many times we have seen police withhold evidence from prosecutors. I mean, in all fairness, do you all see anything
▶ Play
Speaker 127 55:23
that will help a defendant? Representative House, now under the Brady cases and those that follow, the prosecutor is imputed with the knowledge of what's in the police file. And so an effort has to be made to get everything out of that police file to turn over anything that might be inculpatory or exculpatory. Even if we don't know about it, we have a duty to seek it
▶ Play
out under Brady. Representative Maddox, you're good. Any other questions? I believe that's all the questions from the committee. We have no one else who has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Senator Clark, you're
▶ Play
recognized to close for your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Uh, I always find it interesting, uh, that no one in government ever does anything wrong. Um, the, um, the, uh, I, when I first started one course of investigation four years ago, everything was perfect. Uh, there were no problems. Um, and I said here and I hear that all prosecutors do the right thing every time. That's not to say anything against the 95% that no doubt do, but there's a reason why we have laws. We have laws against murder, not for all of us who aren't going to kill anybody, but for the people who do. And I apologize for the fact that I'm not really the best one to be presenting this bill, But if there need to be protections, I think the rape shield law actually protects against anything that this bill does. And you have to question why things are brought out that really can't happen. And you come back to, is there a reason why the evidence should be turned over? Who decides whether the evidence might be exculpatory or not? You know, how often? And if it's not turned over, if it's up to one side to determine whether it's exculpatory, inculpatory or not, But who else is ever going to see it to find out whether it was actually done or not? And so I think it's a good bill, and I would appreciate a good vote, and I appreciate your time.
▶ Play
Members, Senator Clark has closed for his bill. What are the wishes of the committee? We have a motion to do pass on the table. Is there any discussion? Representative Maddox, did you have a discussion? You're recognized for discussion. Thank you, Madam Chair. I just want to say
▶ Play
what's concerning me. One, I brought it up, but I believe now we have the rules of evidence. We have the rules of criminal procedure. We have, in essence, a system that, in my opinion, in my experience, of 20-some-odd years worked and has been working. But the more I sit here and think, the one thing I'm really concerned about is we're not getting into rulemaking. So as a legislative body, we're going to start making rules of evidence, rules of criminal procedure and those things. That concerns me. And frankly, I don't know that we have that authority. I think some of that came out, and when we tried to do tort two years ago, taking rulemaking authority, obviously that didn't happen. I don't know that we can do this anyway, but I just have concerns about us getting into making rules for the court. So I cannot support this.
▶ Play
Representative Collins, you recognize for discussion? Thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chair. Just to that point, I think if we were actually going into rulemaking, we would have heard from the Judicial Council on this, and probably we'd have heard that from the prosecutors. So I go back to what Senator Clark said. If this doesn't do much, then it doesn't do much. And if it does something, it's probably going to be helpful in balancing what is a stacked deck, I think, a lot of times against criminal defendants. So I'll vote for it. Thanks. Any other discussion?
▶ Play
We have a motion on the floor. All in favor of the motion, please say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. No's have it. the bill has failed. Thank you, Senator Clark. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Committee. Members, if you'll go back to Senate Bill 9. Senator Garner is here. Senator Garner, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 9. Thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chair. This bill was brought to me by somebody who works for the Social security administration right now they do a lot of operational social security fraud and other things they work with local police departments but i don't have that authority to be a law enforcement agent under the arkansas code they asked us to bring this lead and everybody seemed to be fine with it jamie cook i talked to her about it she was in the meeting when this initially brought up as we move this bill forward the u.s state the u.s state department actually also asked to be reached out and be including this as well i can't get into details they shared some information but but they do a lot of extensive operations here in the state, dealing with very serious crimes from forgeries, things like that, that usually lead back to terrorist-related activities. And so I think giving them the power to do that is a very good thing. I'll take any questions from the committee. Members, are there
▶ Play
any questions of Senator Garner? Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chair.
▶ Play
I think you covered it, Senator, but I want to make sure. They're not going to be given any authority that would extend out past what the responsibility they have with the agency that they're employed by. Could you elaborate or make sure we expand on that just a little bit? I want to know how much
▶ Play
authority are we giving them? Yes, sir. They'll be included similar to like the FBI, drug enforcement. A lot of these places already have that kind of authority to actually do sort of the arresting powers and things like that. And they do these operations, but usually I think the way they have to do it now is with another branch. And I understand we're letting the federal government kind of get that power, but we already give that to many different agencies on the federal government. They would just like that because it becomes convoluted in how they're using that power when they actually go on these raids and things like that. So, like I said, I ran about Jamie Cook and Lita. She didn't have any problem with it. I talked to both sides. They're not going to step outside of what they're doing now. Just
▶ Play
in them rare cases, I'd like to have that authority. Members, any
▶ Play
other questions? Representative House, you're recognized. Senator, do you think any of these folks that are federal agents, do you think they require any state blessing at
▶ Play
all? Yes, sir, they do. They explicitly say without this, they are limited in the certain things they could do without, you know, under their current arrangements. And they said that from both sides, and I believe them. I mean, I don't do what they do every day. And they said if you give us this authority, we're not going to abuse it, which is always from federal government's interest in. But with it, they'll be able to do their jobs more effectively and protect the people of Arkansas. Okay, so they
▶ Play
can only enforce federal law but not state law if something came across there. Yes, sir. It has to do with
▶ Play
their ability, how they're going to do these operations in the state of Arkansas. It just gives them more. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Senator, you just answered the question. I just want to make sure Representative House asked the question that they would be enforcing federal laws, correct, but not state laws. but, however, they're gaining their authority from a state statute. Is that correct? Yes, sir. They'll be doing
▶ Play
federal law. Follow employed full-time law enforcement agencies without warrant of violation of U.S. code or authorized carry firearms and be considered agents. Like I said, the FBI is under this. Secret Service is under this. There's a lot of federal agencies. They just want to have that ability as well.
▶ Play
Members, any other questions? We have no one who has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Senator Garner, you're recognized to close for your bill. I'm closed, Madam Chair. Members, Senator Garner is closed for his bill. Do we have wishes for Senator House? You're recognized. We have a motion to do pass on the table. Is there any discussion of the motion? All in favor of the motion, please say aye. Any opposed? Motion carries. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Yes, ma'am. members if you'll turn to senate bill 541 senate bill 541 senator garner you're recognized to
▶ Play
present your bill thank you madam chair this came out of a situation that arose out of texas where the city in houston in an obvious attempt to chill speech and intimidate people of the faith subpoenaed a sermon of five pastors who opposed a local ordinance i believe it was terrible was a terrible display of bigotry against those pastors who were just simply professing their religious faith. Fortunately, the state of Texas didn't take too kind of those actions, and they passed a law very similar to one that we're trying to do now. In Arkansas, I've seen some other local ordinances that may be controversial, and we want to make sure in a civil court, these pastors aren't having their works, their sermon, and things dragged in there to be done intimidation. This is about protecting religious freedom of the clergy in the face of increased hostilities toward people of faith in all walks of life. This will prevent a religious leader or member of the clergy as defined in the bill, and it's pretty broad. I think you can run into issues if you try to narrowly tailor what a religious clergy is from having to produce their sermons and other religious works or testify on their sermons or other religious works. If the civil action is by the state or the city, this will not apply in a rare case where you have civil action dealing with terrorism related activities we didn't want to inhibit that key parts of that one has to be a civil action does not deal with any kind of criminal action secondly this has to be the city or state is not an individual so if you defame me in a public setting I'd still be able to sue you in a civil court and bring all your sermons and things to that but that I'll take any questions
▶ Play
members are there any questions representative house you're recognized for a question senator if you come across any other state that's adopted this. You mentioned Texas, but.
▶ Play
No, sir, that's what alerted me to that. It was a big story roughly about two or three years ago, and I thought that was a good bill that we could be preempt kind of any kind of thing like this
▶ Play
happening. Representative Maddox, you're recognized for a question. Thanks, Senator. Is
▶ Play
there any opposition at all to this? Have you heard, do you have any opposition to this, Senator Garner? I've heard from no formal opposition.
▶ Play
Obviously, some people voted against it in the Senate, but that always happens in my bills. Representative Clowney, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Garner, can you just talk a little bit about this H? So I'm on page, I guess I'm on page two maybe? Yes, ma'am. Line two, layperson who is engaged in the ministering and instruction of or teaching of a religion. That strikes me as really broad. Will you talk about who you have in mind with
▶ Play
that? Yeah, it's twofold. One, you know, I took a First Amendment class when I was in law school, and I know if you try to really define what a religious person is, you can run into some issues. So I'm really scared about doing it in such a way where you may have somebody who may not be an ordained minister but is preaching at a church. That church, to be considered a religious organization, would have to qualify under federal state code, tax code, for being a religious organization. That is a little bit of a backstop. Secondly, you know, if you have somebody who is, let's say, not necessarily a preacher, but they may be a music minister or they may be in some capacity like that, you know, that would be much more rare. they'd be subpoenaed, but in that case, you know, I didn't want it to be too inhibitive of what that
▶ Play
would be. Any other questions? Representative Glover, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Has the Attorney General or the Prosecuting Attorney's Office or any other agency put any input into this bill? I heard no formal opposition. I put the
▶ Play
bill out there a few weeks ago. I can't remember the exact time. I ran through committee, ran through the Senate, ran to here. I haven't heard any opposition from them. They didn't have any direct input in it either. No, sir.
▶ Play
Representative Collins, you're recognized for a question. Thank you.
▶ Play
And, Senator Garner, you may not know this. It's kind of putting you on the spot, so if you don't, that's fine. But do you know what the privileges are that we currently have out there? What would this be joining among the existing privileges? I know it's typically disfavored. We don't have that many of them, but what are they as far as
▶ Play
you know? I'm a little bit confused about the
▶ Play
question, sir. Can you clarify for me? Well, we're talking about privileging certain information from disclosure. What other types of information is similarly treated out of that?
▶ Play
I could not say off the top of
▶ Play
my head, sir. Any other questions? Representative Kapp. Thank you, Madam Chair. And you may have said this, and I apologize if you covered it, but can you clarify for me why you're running this and, I mean, what need there is currently or maybe go into
▶ Play
detail of who brought you this legislation? Yes, ma'am. Like I said, the reason I saw is because the city of Houston had passed a, I believe, a anti-discrimination local ordinance, and four or five pastors spoke out against that in their religious faith. At the time, the city actually used the power of the state to subpoena their sermons to drag them into court. It was, in my opinion, and this is my opinion, an obvious attempt to try to stifle their religious freedom, to try to chill their speech, and the state of Texas quickly remedied it at. My fear is that if we go in the future and we have controversial ordinances in many different cities on different things, that become a thing where the city could use the same kind of power for that civil action. So I'm really worried about it, and this isn't a left-right issue. I could see it going the other way as well, where a city passes, you know, a tax increase, and a local pastor speaks for it, against it, and then somehow they use this power to do this. So this is more of a preemptive measure to make sure we don't go down that road. I do not see a problem, and I had a specific example in Arkansas, but just in case that ever happens, we'd have this on the book to protect our clergy members. Members,
▶ Play
any other questions? We have no one who has signed up to speak for or against it. We have – I'll recognize Senator Garner to close for your bill. I'm closed, Madam Chair. Thank you. Representative Tosh, you're recognized. Motion, do pass. We have a motion to do pass on the table. Is there any discussion of the motion? All in favor of the motion, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say no. Motion carries. Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator Garner, you have one last bill on our agenda. Yes, ma'am. Thank you. Well, I don't know. Maybe I won't call it
▶ Play
Speaker 160 1:10:23
up. No. Well, considering this is the last meeting, I hope you do.
▶ Play
Senate Bill, let me call the number, please. Senate Bill 569. Members, if you'll turn to Senate Bill 569. Oh, really? And then you'll be recognized to present your bill,
▶ Play
Senator. Thank you, Madam Chair. I appreciate the indulgence. This was brought to me, actually, by a law student here in Little Rock, Mallory, who works for the prosecutors. And what she found is a quirk in the law that if you engage in third-degree battery against a domestic partner or somebody you have, it can be enhanced to a felony issue. But if you don't have that preexisting domestic relationship, it can't be enhanced to that Class D felony. So what this does, if the person should know or does know that the woman is pregnant and decides to do third-degree battery, it can be enhanced to a felony. They found, she found in her limited time there, and she spoke eloquently at the Senate meeting that there's many cases where this is brought up and pregnant women are being beat and they're getting a relatively small penalty for what the endangerment that could to that child in that situation. So in those rare, in those cases where that happens, this can be enhanced to that penalty. With that, I'll take any questions.
▶ Play
Members, are there any questions? Representative Kapp, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. I spent some time looking at the battery third statute, the battery second statute, and battery one, and what drew my attention to it was battery third, which is currently a misdemeanor. That's when someone is, the injury was caused because of their reckless conduct or their negligent conduct, And specifically, if an injury is caused to somebody and on accident, someone else could have been injured because it specifically states with the purpose of causing physical injury to another person, the person causes physical injury to any person. So as you know, I mean, the intent of the offender is very important in criminal law when we're talking about the disparity with what type of a criminal offense we're going to assign them. So specifically, why do you feel with the alleged offender's conduct being reckless or negligent, it would qualify for a battery with it being advanced to a felony? Yes, ma'am. I mean,
▶ Play
in the practical terms, I don't think you can be reckless or negligent and enter the mens rea to know or should have known the woman is pregnant. But for the first and fourth element, it's purposely causes or with the purpose of causing an injury. In that case, the person would know they are causing that injury. I think the second and third element, you're right. I don't see what the prosecution could actually bring that with the intent to do it. But on that first and fourth element, there is an intent to do that action, unless I'm reading that wrong.
▶ Play
You're recognized for a follow-up? But hypothetically speaking, if I intended to injure Representative Clowney, but in the process of it, you know, I throw my nameplate and it causes injury to Representative Crawford and she's pregnant and I should know she's pregnant because she's got a huge belly sticking out. I mean, under the way that you've written this, it would qualify as a class D felony with exposure of up to six years and a $10,000 fine versus a misdemeanor when somebody didn't purposely intend to hurt the victim.
▶ Play
Correct? Yes, ma'am. I think in that scenario, I mean, if you knew or should have known that the person was pregnant and you still did the action even though it wasn't intentionally toward them, then in that rare circumstances I do think it's fine to go up to a felony because if you're in that situation around a pregnant person and you're getting in a fight if you're trying to cause harm to another person, I think that's not an unreasonable thing to expect you to use extra caution and if you do go up to that felony action. And like I said, we already do this for domestic situations that happen as well.
▶ Play
Any other questions? We have no one who has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Senator Garner, do you want to close for your bill? Yes, ma'am, I'm closed. Senator Garner has closed for his bill. What are the wishes of the committee? Representative Tosh? We have a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion of the motion? All in favor of the motion, please say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. No's have it. Your bill has failed. I need another hand. I
▶ Play
Speaker 191 1:15:21
have two hands. Representative Shepard. Representative Shepard. Representative House. Yes. Representative Fight. Representative Fight. Representative Tosh. Yes. Representative Blake, Representative Blake, Representative Rushing, Representative Rushing, Representative Smith, Representative Maddox, Representative Cap, Representative Gassaway, Representative Gassaway, Representative Berry, Representative Crawford, Representative Davis, Representative Scott, Representative Glover, Representative Clowney, Representative Hawks, Representative Collins, Representative Petty. The bill has failed.
▶ Play
Members turn to Senate Bill 543. I think Representative Gray is here to present Senate Bill 543. thank you madam chair and if i
▶ Play
could invite someone up to help me with this bill if you'll identify yourself good
▶ Play
afternoon uh madam chair and committee my name is justin allen i'm an attorney here in little rock and i'm here today to speak on senate bill 543 on behalf for the Arkansas State Chamber and the Arkansas Association of Defense Counsel. Representative Gray, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam
▶ Play
Chair. And so what I'm going to do is a little bit unusual, but your committee scares me about half to death right now. And I used to sit on this committee, and I have much respect for it. So I'm going to, as this is probably above my head, trying to explain this to all the attorneys in the room, I would like to let Justin do it. Mr. Allen, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair.
▶ Play
Senate Bill 543 has to do with the Uniform Contribution Among Tort Feasors Act. And what we're talking about here is how courts and more likely, more often, juries apportion fault to people who are involved in an incident that gave rise to an injury. So perhaps the most common example is a two-vehicle automobile accident. The plaintiff sues the defendant. The plaintiff says the defendant caused my injuries. I need to recover damages. The defendant says, well, I was not at fault or at worst. I was only partially at fault, and the plaintiff was also at fault for causing this accident. And so what happens in those situations is the jury is instructed to decide what percentage of fault the two parties are. And the jury can come back and say the defendant was 60% at fault, the plaintiff was 40% at fault. And why do we do that? We do that because the law in Arkansas, as it existed since 2003, says that a defendant is not to pay, with some exceptions we may talk about, but a defendant is not to pay more than his or her percentage of the fault. So if that defendant in that scenario was 60% at fault, then that defendant would not be required to pay more than 60% of the plaintiff's damages. That was the shift that we made in 2003 with the Civil Justice Reform Act of going from joint and several liability to several liability. Again, the fundamental proposition, policy proposition being a defendant will not pay more than his or her percentage of the fall. Where this really comes into play is when there are multiple people or entities involved in the incident that gives rise to the injury. Sometimes all of those people that are involved are made parties to the lawsuit. Sometimes they're not a party to the lawsuit. Perhaps they've settled. Perhaps you can't find them. Perhaps they're immune, and that's going to be the fundamental part of this bill I'll come to. But what the 2003 Act said, when it said we're several liability only, you only pay your percentage of the fault, it said that defendants can also ask the judge when they go through the appropriate process, file the appropriate pleadings, make the right notifications, to instruct the jury that they can apportion fault to a non-party, again, somebody that's not there for some reason, and ask the jury to consider that non-party's fault. And that is something that has been going on, again, since 2003. Juries have been allowed to apportion fault to non-parties. The clarification, as Senate Bill 543 declares it to be, is that what happens if that non-party is immune from tort liability because it's an employer who, as you all know, is immune because of the exclusive remedy of workers' compensation. Or the example that came up in Senate Committee, which was a good one from Senator Flowers, is what if it's the state? What if it was a state employee who was involved in the event that gave rise to the injury and sovereign immunity comes into play there? And the courts have struggled, the trial courts have struggled with what was meant by the 2003 Act. And so this bill is designed to bring clarification that if I as a defendant believe that an employer on the work site or a co-employee of the plaintiffs was responsible for part of the incident, I will be able to ask the judge to have the jury apportioned fault to that immune non-party, which is consistent with the policy underlying several liabilities as opposed to joint and several liability, which is to ensure that the policy position of the state, being that a defendant not pay more than his or her percentage of the fault, does not pay more than his or her percentage of the fault. And with that, Madam Chair, I'd be happy to take questions.
▶ Play
Members, are there any questions? Representative House, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Real-life case. An inventor, an engineer, a manufacturer, a distributor, and a retail installer of a wooden stove that had a glass front. The customer bought the stove, put it in his house. The glass front blew open and burned a half a million dollar house down, plus about $750,000 worth of personal equipment. the inventor, the manufacturer, the distributor, and the engineer, I guess I skipped one, all got together and blamed the retailer, and the retailer said, yep, I'm 100% at fault. It's all my fault because he was poor, he was bankrupt, and the rest of the folks had money. Now, when you start apportioning liability, there is a tendency for the more powerful and richer people to cast all the blame on the judgment-proof defendant. Why is this bill not doing exactly that? Well, to your hope, I think there might
▶ Play
have been two questions there. Okay, to that factual scenario, I don't believe I heard, unless I missed it, there were any immune entities involved. So this bill would not affect that fact case whatsoever. Representative Collins, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you. Mr. Allen, so
▶ Play
you said the trial courts have struggled with this. What have they done when these cases have arisen? That's a good question. To my knowledge, I
▶ Play
think in all cases they have ruled that the jury cannot apportion fault to the immune party. and i can get a little bit more into the reasoning at least as it's been explained to me by the litigators who've been involved but the the current language speaks about apportioning fault to who may have joint liability or several liability in tort and the courts have thought well they don't have joint liability or several liability in tort because
▶ Play
they're immune follow-up you're recognized for a follow-up so and tell me if i'm mischaracterizing what you're saying but basically the idea behind this is that it will be more in keeping with what our approach toward it is as a state, but it will result in smaller verdicts because some of this will be attributed to an immune party and therefore it won't really ever be recovered. Is that
▶ Play
right? I wouldn't agree completely with that. The verdict will be the same. The plaintiff's damages are the plaintiff's damages, uh, regardless of how fault is apportioned and whether any of it's apportioned to the immune party. A couple of points on that. Uh, the two scenarios I brought up, uh, of likely where an immune party, uh, would be apportioned fault would be an employer. And in that case, the plaintiff's going to have recovered likely workers comp. Uh, so there's going to be some, be some recovery there or the state where the plaintiff could pursue, uh, a claims commission claim, which I've seen done in medical malpractice cases involving UAMS and children's hospital. Uh, also important to point out that there are some exceptions to our current law in terms of several liability. Uh, and this was part of the O3 act. There are circumstances where a plaintiff may petition the court to recover more than a defendant's assigned percentage of fault. If they can show that it's not collectible from another that was assigned fault. In particular, if you have a defendant who's been assigned anywhere between 10 to 50% of the fault, the judge can award an additional 10% to be collectible from that one. And if they're 50 to 100% at fault, they could recover another, an additional 20%. So if you've got a defendant at 60, 70, 80%, and the plaintiff can establish that the other defendant or those assigned fault can't pay, the judge can award that additional amount.
▶ Play
Representative Clowney, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Mr. Allen, and I apologize if you already addressed this and I missed it, but can you just let me know where the trial lawyers are on
▶ Play
this? They are neutral. Thank you. Members, any other questions? We have no one who has signed up to speak for or against the bill. Representative Rushing, you're recognized. Close for your bill. I mean, great. Well, I'm looking down, and I just saw the name.
▶ Play
I apologize, Representative Gray. Thank you. For the day I've had today, you can call me rushing. I'm good with that. No, I would appreciate a good vote on this. I think you did a great job explaining what the problem is and kind of where we need to go. So I appreciate a good
▶ Play
vote. Thank you. Members, Representative Gray is closed for the bill. What are the wishes of the committee? We have a motion to do pass on the table. Is there any discussion of the motion? representative house you're
▶ Play
recognized for discussion joint and several liability is a very complicated subject and subject to many many opinions and it's it's been a work in progress for decades what's right what's fair what's reasonable what can a jury really decide in real life according to the evidence. We've changed bills. We've changed directions. The courts have changed directions and changed rules and all of that. And for us to be making a snap decision on 15 minutes late at night when we're all tired and hungry and, what, we've got five lawyers in the room, I think six maybe, I think we're way out of our league on this one. And this is something that the Bar Association, a trial lawyer association, the judiciary ought to all be weighing in. And if there needs to be a change, then they need to do it rather than one organization sending their lawyer over here to do it. That's what I think. Any
▶ Play
other discussion? Members, we have a motion on the floor. All in favor, please say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. The no's have it. The bill has failed. Members, we have one last bill. We're going to take Representative Maddox on Senate Bill 552. I'm sorry, Senate Bill 552. It's actually Representative Teague's bill, but I mean Senator Teague's bill,
▶ Play
but Representative Maddox will be presenting it. Thank you, Madam Chair, and I'll be brief. So I'm proud I get to be the last bill of this session.
▶ Play
So I guess we'll see. We have great
▶ Play
hope, so go for it. Well, keep your expectations low. Senator Teague just handed me this a few minutes ago. So this is part of the D-CRAB, which I don't like that acronym, but actually Representative Kapp, Chairperson Dalby, and I are members of it. This is unanimously supported by D-CRAB. What it's going to do is it's going to add Pike County to the 36th Judicial District. It's going to add one judge, and this was unanimously approved, again, by this board, and it's based on their caseload. I don't believe there's any objection whatsoever. Obviously, ALC, everyone is in support of it, and I'll be glad to take any questions. Reverend Sandy Paus,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question? Um,
▶ Play
if we're taking, if we're taking, you said Pike County, uh, we're moving one county to another district. It's coming from which district to which district I'm 40th. Yes, I believe
▶ Play
that's correct. It's going to the 36th and to be frank representative house. Um, Oh, you don't know. I don't, I don't know. That's fair. I apologize. But it's a really good bill. any other questions we have no one who's signed up to speak
▶ Play
for against bill are you closed for your bill yes ma'am do you and I would make a motion to pass we have the representative Maddox is closed for the billion has made a motion to do pass is there any discussion on the bill all in favor of the bill please say aye all opposed say no motion is carried congratulations you have passed the bill members you before you bolt and run before you bolt and run and before we gavel out because I think it's important enough that we be on the film we may listen carefully we may have to meet Thursday for concurrences are possibly a Senate bill that may come our way but for all practical purposes we are we are through. You have done a yeoman's job in this committee this year. I cannot commend you enough for the attention to the detail, the attention to the seriousness of the matters that come before this committee, and I applaud you for your hard work, but we have two people that we really want to applaud tonight, and that's why I wanted to stay so that it will be memorialized, and on behalf of the House Judiciary Committee, Allison and Judy. We would like to, it's a token of our appreciation to say thank you very much for being here each and every time to hear all of our stimulating discussion that we can have on this committee. And members, if you would please join me in a round of applause for their hard work. With that, with that, members, we are adjourned.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:31:56
Listen for any announcements. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

TO OFFER TESTIMONY ON A BILL, PLEASE SIGN IN TO BE RECOGNIZED BY THE CHAIR

CONCUR IN SENATE AMENDMENT

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1662 Dalby REGARDING THE SALARIES OF PERSONNEL AND OTHER REQUIREMENTS OF VARIOUS DISTRICT COURTS.

RE-REFERRED TO COMMITTEE

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1705 Gazaway TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC CONFIDENCE IN THE INTEGRITY OF JUDICIAL ELECTIONS; AND TO REQUIRE ADDITIONAL REPORTING AND TRANSPARENCY OF INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURES IN RELATED CAMPAIGNS.

HB1486 Gazaway TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CUSTODY OF A CHILD BORN OUTSIDE OF MARRIAGE.

REGULAR AGENDA

Number Sponsor Subtitle

SB183 A. Clark TO PROHIBIT CERTAIN REGISTERED SEX OFFENDERS FROM HOLDING A POSITION OF PUBLIC TRUST.

SB464 Hester TO ENSURE THE CONFIDENTIALITY OF CERTAIN PROCEDURES INVOLVED IN THE EXECUTION OF A PERSON FOR A CAPITAL OFFENSE.

SB9 T. Garner GRANTING A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER EMPLOYED WITH THE SOCIAL SECURITY ADMINISTRATION OR THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF STATE THE AUTHORITY TO ARREST.

1:00:04 - 0:26

SB206 Irvin CONCERNING THE TERMINATION OF A PERSON'S OBLIGATION TO REGISTER AS A SEX OFFENDER; AND CONCERNING LIFETIME REGISTRATION FOR CERTAIN REPEAT OFFENDERS.

SB311 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DISQUALIFICATION OF JUDGES.

SB451 J. Cooper TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR PROFESSIONS AND OCCUPATIONS TO OBTAIN CONSISTENCY REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS AND DISQUALIFYING OFFENSES FOR LICENSURE.

0:26 - 16:10 44 segments 7 speakers

The bill was introduced by Representative Carol Dalby with assistance from the Attorney General’s Office; Brad Nye explained that SB 451 would streamline criminal-background-check requirements for Title 17 occupations, create a uniform list of disqualifying offenses, a waiver process and a pre-license check. [1:32] [2:03] [2:12] [2:15] [2:36] [3:10] [3:46]

Representative Spencer Hawks asked whether the bill applied retroactively and Representative Andrew Collins inquired about possible conflicts with other background-check legislation; Nye responded that the bill is limited to Title 17 occupations and no conflicts have been identified. [4:19] [4:28] [4:54] [4:59]

Chair Dalby moved to pass the bill as amended, the committee voted aye and SB 451 was adopted. [5:59] [6:03]

SB544 Irvin TO ESTABLISH PREJUDGMENT AND POST-JUDGMENT INTEREST RATES.

16:10 - 1:04:44 159 segments 19 speakers

Representative Douglas House introduced SB 544, proposing a floating pre- and post-judgment interest rate tied to the reserve primary credit rate (currently 3 % + 2 %) to replace the static 6 %/10 % rates and ensure fairness for debtors and creditors. [17:26] [17:54] [18:27] [19:01] [19:34] [20:08] [20:39] [21:10]

Representative Sarah Capp asked how the rate would be enforced; House answered that attorneys would present the rate and courts could readily verify and incorporate it into judgments. [21:26] [21:41] [21:48] [22:16] [22:21]

John Duncan of the Arkansas Collectors Association testified that the bill could create paperwork errors and uncertainty for judges and consumers, and Representative Cindy Crawford voiced concerns that small collection agencies might be harmed by the change. [22:54] [23:27] [23:58] [24:28] [27:10] [27:43] [28:17] [28:51]

The chair moved to pass the bill, the ayes carried, and SB 544 was approved by the committee. [30:18] [30:27]

SB511 Hill CONCERNING THE THIRTIETH JUDICIAL DISTRICT; AND CONCERNING LONOKE COUNTY STATE DISTRICT COURT AS IT WILL BE CONSTITUTED IN 2021.

SB87 A. Clark TO DEFINE "IMMINENT HARM" UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989 AND THE CHILD MALTREATMENT ACT.

SB541 T. Garner RELATING TO THE PRIVILEGE FROM DISCLOSURE TO AUTHORITIES FOR EVIDENCE CONCERNING A SERMON, RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION, OR RELIGIOUS TEACHING DELIVERED BY A RELIGIOUS LEADER OR MEMBER OF THE CLERGY.

1:04:44 - 1:17:09 42 segments 11 speakers

SB543 Irvin TO CLARIFY THE UNIFORM CONTRIBUTION AMONG TORT FEASORS ACT.

1:17:09 - 1:28:41 36 segments 7 speakers

Attorney Justin Allen testified for the Arkansas State Chamber and the Arkansas Association of Defense Counsel, explaining that SB 543 would clarify that juries may apportion fault to immune non-parties such as employers or state entities, preserving the several-liability rule established by the 2003 Civil Justice Reform Act. [1:17:23] [1:17:26] [1:17:36] [1:17:56] [1:18:28] [1:19:00] [1:19:37] [1:20:08] [1:20:40] [1:21:12]

Representative Douglas House raised a hypothetical case involving multiple manufacturers and a retailer to question whether the bill would allow richer parties to shift blame onto a judgment-proof defendant, but Allen responded that the bill only applies when an immune party is involved and would not affect that scenario. [1:21:51] [1:22:16] [1:22:46] [1:23:00] [1:23:07] [1:23:16]

Representative Andrew Collins asked how trial courts have handled such cases; Allen said courts have generally barred juries from assigning fault to immune parties, and argued that allowing it would not reduce verdict amounts because plaintiff damages remain the same, though recovery might come from workers’ compensation or state claims. [1:23:27] [1:23:34] [1:23:48] [1:24:05] [1:24:23] [1:24:27] [1:24:54] [1:25:27]

After brief discussion, Representative Michelle Gray moved to close the bill, a motion that was seconded and voted on; the committee voted no, causing SB 543 to fail. [1:26:43] [1:26:57] [1:26:59] [1:27:34] [1:28:00] [1:28:04]

SB552 Teague CONCERNING THE REORGANIZATION OF LOCAL DISTRICT COURTS INTO STATE DISTRICT COURTS.

1:28:41 - 1:10:35

Representative John Maddox, on behalf of Senator Teague, presented SB 552, noting that it would add Pike County to the 36th Judicial District, creating an additional judgeship based on D-CRAB’s caseload analysis and with unanimous support from the board and the Arkansas Legal Counsel (ALC). [1:28:52] [1:29:06] [1:29:32]

Representative Douglas House sought clarification on the district reassignment, asking from which district Pike County would move, which Maddox confirmed would be from the 40th to the 36th Judicial District. [1:29:35] [1:29:42] [1:29:49]

The committee moved to close the bill, a motion to pass was made and unanimously carried, resulting in SB 552 being adopted by the committee. [1:30:05] [1:30:18]

The chair then adjourned the meeting, praising the committee’s work and noting possible future legislation. [1:30:54] [1:31:25] [1:31:56]

SB569 T. Garner CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF BATTERY IN THE THIRD DEGREE; AND CONCERNING BATTERY AGAINST A PREGNANT WOMAN.

1:10:35 - 30:56

SB547 B. Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE.

SB623 A. Clark TO REMOVE A DRIVER'S LICENSE SUSPENSION OR REVOCATION AS AN AVAILABLE PENALTY FOR AN OFFENSE NOT RELATED TO DRIVING A MOTOR VEHICLE.

SB579 A. Clark TO REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF ALL EVIDENCE IN THE POSSESSION OF THE STATE TO A CRIMINAL DEFENDANT, WHETHER THE EVIDENCE IS INCULPATORY, EXCULPATORY, OR NEITHER INCULPATORY NOR EXCULPATORY.

30:56 - 7:09

HB1756 Clowney CONCERNING THE WAIVER OF COUNSEL BY MINORS IN CRIMINAL COURT.

HB1788 A. Collins THE BAIL DATA AND TRANSPARENCY ACT.

HB1843 Gates CONCERNING A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND THE SCOPE OF WHERE A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY MAY CARRY AND POSSESS A HANDGUN.

HB1844 Gates CONCERNING WHAT CONSTITUTES CRIMINALLY INJURIOUS CONDUCT UNDER THE ARKANSAS CRIME VICTIMS REPARATIONS ACT.

7:09 - 1:31:58 270 segments 24 speakers

Representative Mickey Gates presented HB 1844, recounting a fatal crash involving a stolen vehicle and arguing that victims whose perpetrators did not steal the vehicle to kill should be eligible for crime-victims reparations, seeking to strike limiting language from the existing statute. [7:38] [8:10] [8:41] [9:15] [9:47] [10:22]

Representative Sarah Capp questioned the fiscal impact and potential loss of federal funding; Gates said he was unaware of any federal funding issues and noted the bill does not require additional appropriations. [12:08] [12:23] [12:28] [12:58] [13:28] [13:32] [13:36]

No committee members offered a motion to approve the bill, so the chair declared the measure failed for lack of a motion. [14:17] [14:37] [15:07] [15:37]

HB1828 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD INTRASTATE RELOCATION ACT; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING WHETHER OR NOT A CHANGE OF PRINCIPAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE OF A CHILD IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CHILD.

HB1898 L. Johnson CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF DISORDERLY CONDUCT; TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF AGGRAVATED DISORDERLY CONDUCT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR INJUNCTIVE RELIEF.

HB1938 D. Garner GRANTING A PUBLIC COLLEGE OR UNIVERSITY THE ABILITY TO DETERMINE IF POSSESSION OF A CONCEALED HANDGUN ON THE CAMPUS OF THE PUBLIC COLLEGE OR UNIVERSITY BY A PERSON IS PERMITTED; AND TO MAKE ORGANIZATIONAL AND TECHNICAL AMENDMENTS.

HB1939 D. Garner TO ESTABLISH UNIVERSAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR THE PURPOSES OF PURCHASING, RECEIVING, OR TRANSFERRING A FIREARM.

HB1940 D. Garner REQUIRING THE USE OF A RESTRAINT HOLSTER FOR A PERSON WHO CARRIES A HANDGUN.

HB1325 Lowery TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CUSTODY OF A CHILD.

HB1962 M. Hodges TO REDUCE THE SENTENCE CLASSIFICATIONS FOR CERTAIN OFFENSES FROM A FELONY TO A MISDEMEANOR.

HB1971 Beck CONCERNING DISTRICT COURTS; AND CONCERNING THE DISTRICT COURTS OF THE THIRTY-FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT.

HB1972 Blake CONCERNING THE POSSESSION OF MARIJUANA.

HB1059 Pilkington CONCERNING THE USE OF PHYSICAL FORCE IN SELF-DEFENSE OR IN THE DEFENSE OF OTHERS.

DEFERRED BILLS

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1009 Dotson PROHIBITING CERTAIN SEX OFFENDERS FROM ENTERING UPON A SCHOOL CAMPUS.

HB1307 Dotson PERMITTING A BANK OR BANKING INSTITUTION TO UTILIZE THE SMALL CLAIMS DIVISION OF A DISTRICT COURT.

HB1040 Rushing TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS HOT CHECK LAW.

HB1029 Rye AN ACT TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HERITAGE PROTECTION ACT.

HB1450 Wooten CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN BY A RETIRED CERTIFIED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.

HB1294 Della Rosa RESTORING PROSECUTORIAL DISCRETION IN THE RESOLUTION OF DRIVING OR BOATING WHILE INTOXICATED CASES.

SB267 G.

Stubblefield TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PERSON WITH A LICENSE TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN WHO FAILS TO FILE A RENEWAL APPLICATION BEFORE THE EXPIRATION DATE PAYS A LATE FEE.

HB1494 V. Flowers CONCERNING THE IMPOSITION OF THE DEATH PENALTY ON A DEFENDANT WITH A SERIOUS MENTAL ILLNESS.

HB1520 Petty CONCERNING THE LAST MEAL OF AN INMATE SENTENCED TO DEATH.

HB1613 L. Johnson CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF BATTERY IN THE SECOND DEGREE.

SB14 L.

Chesterfield CONCERNING THE FEE TO ATTEND A VICTIM IMPACT PANEL THAT IS REQUIRED BY LAW OF ANY PERSON CONVICTED OF DRIVING OR BOATING WHILE INTOXICATED, REFUSAL TO SUBMIT TO A CHEMICAL TEST, OR POSSESSION OF ALCOHOL BY A MINOR.

HB1834 Sullivan TO PROHIBIT DISCRIMINATION OR PREFERENTIAL TREATMENT BY STATE AND OTHER PUBLIC ENTITIES.

HB1694 Womack TO ELIMINATE GUN-FREE ZONES; AND TO REPEAL LAWS IN CONFLICT.

HB1279 Gazaway TO AMEND THE OFFENSE OF SEXUALLY GROOMING A CHILD.

HB1680 Gazaway CONCERNING THE DEFINITION OF "TARGET GROUP" AS IT APPLIES TO COMMUNITY CORRECTION.

HB1891 Scott TO ALLOW THE DIVERSION OF CERTAIN JUVENILE OFFENSES.

HB1635 Petty CONCERNING AN INCREASE IN THE SENTENCING RANGE FOR REPEAT FELONY SEX OFFENDERS; CONCERNING SEX OFFENDER REGISTRATION REQUIREMENTS; AND CONCERNING SEX OFFENSES AND SEX OFFENDERS.

HB1919 Scott CONCERNING THE USE OF INSTRUMENTS OF RESTRAINT ON INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE UNDER EIGHTEEN (18) YEARS OF AGE DURING A COURT APPEARANCE.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Carol Dalby Chair Unverified
72 segments
Chair Unverified
6 segments
Brad Nye Unverified
5 segments
Representative Spencer Hawks Unverified
2 segments
Representative Andrew Collins Unverified
13 segments
Representative Mickey Gates Unverified
16 segments
Representative Sarah Capp Unverified
12 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
37 segments
Speaker 72
1 segment
Speaker 87
6 segments
Representative Cindy Crawford Unverified
4 segments
Senator Alan Clark Unverified
15 segments
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 126
20 segments
Speaker 127
7 segments
Speaker 132
1 segment
Representative Nicole Clowney Unverified
4 segments
Representative John Maddox Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 139
1 segment
Representative Don Glover Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 144
1 segment
Speaker 147
1 segment
Senator Trent Garner Unverified
25 segments
Speaker 160
1 segment
Speaker 191
3 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
3 segments
Justin Allen Unverified
16 segments