Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Legislative Joint Auditing-State Agencies

November 7, 2019 ·1:30 PM ·Room 130 ·28:16
Video Transcript 1 document

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 8, 2026

A. Call to order by Chairman. -249:03

The committee heard the Department of Education June 30 2018 audit, which found a $6,300 payment to a corporation owned by an agency employee who failed to file required disclosures, and Senators Irvin and Hickey questioned the agency about ethics oversight and the reasonableness of the sole-source procurement, after which Chairman Nelda moved to file the report and the motion carried. [0:42] [0:48] [1:12] [1:25] [2:07] [2:26] [2:39] [2:44] [2:58] [3:15] [3:32] [3:37] [4:02] [4:50] [5:08] [5:28] [5:41] [5:48]

The State Board of Podiatric Medicine two-year report was presented, highlighting improper cash-receipt segregation and a delayed $210,000 deposit, and Department of Health representative Matt Gilmore explained that the board’s financial controls have been transferred to the department and that the transformation act should prevent recurrence; the committee then filed the report. [6:11] [6:44] [7:26] [7:51] [7:58] [8:02] [8:07] [8:14] [8:24] [8:48]

The Office of the Prosecutor Coordinator’s June 2018 finding of two mis-recorded $10,000 employee-benefit transactions was explained by Fiscal Officer Terry Isaac as the result of an inadvertent GL-code entry, and he described a new coding procedure to avoid future errors before the committee filed the report. [9:03] [9:33] [9:55] [9:58] [10:06] [10:41] [10:58]

The Veterans Affairs audit uncovered five findings, including improper emergency procurements for nursing services, delayed deposits, and uncollected receivables; agency leaders testified that new procurement specialists and staffing changes have been implemented, and Senators Garner and Dismang probed the adequacy of those controls before the committee adopted a motion to file the report and set the next meeting for Dec 12. [11:16] [11:24] [11:49] [12:26] [12:58] [13:29] [14:01] [14:09] [14:18] [14:26] [14:32] [15:05] [15:37] [16:08] [16:31] [16:38] [17:00] [17:05] [17:09] [17:26] [17:39] [17:53] [18:11] [18:16] [18:23] [18:42] [18:50]

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 8, 2026
and the adoption of the minutes do I hear a motion to adopt the minutes second thank you and so we'll review
▶ Play
Speaker 6 0:16
the reports okay today we're presenting one deferred report and three current reports that have findings we also have six reports without findings and these
▶ Play
Speaker 9 0:31
are listed in the audit summary beginning
▶ Play
on page one okay okay the ones without findings do we have a motion to file these okay second okay well we'll
▶ Play
Speaker 6 0:42
file these our first report is the Department of Education June 30 2018 report in last month's meeting the committee voted to defer this finding until today so that the committee could get additional information from the agency. So all of you should have received some documents through email that we sent out, and I believe the Department of Education sent them out as well that were provided to y'all by the agency. The finding was that the Department of Education and one school district paid professional fees totaling $6,300 to a corporation that was owned by an agency employee for services that were provided by the employee. The employee did not file the required income and financial interest disclosure statements with DFA and the Secretary of State. And we did go back and look, and this finding was certainly referred to the prosecuting attorney. That concludes the finding. I believe there are some representatives from Department of Education here, if y'all would like to ask some questions. Would y'all like to come forward?
▶ Play
If you'll introduce yourself, please. Tracy
▶ Play
Speaker 19 1:52
Boyd, Division of Elementary and Secondary Education, Internal Audit. Greg
▶ Play
Speaker 23 1:59
Rogers, Assistant Commissioner for Physical and
▶ Play
Admin. Do we have any questions? So on this, do you have within, you have internal audit, Do you have an ethics person within your agency that somebody can go to if there's an ethics issue like this? I mean, this is beyond an ethics issue. I mean, I think it was referred to the prosecuting attorney's office. So what type of things are in place to make sure that this doesn't happen again? So
▶ Play
Speaker 23 2:39
as far as the ethics, since he does have a teacher's license, It has been referred over to the Professional Licensed Standards Board who does look at the ethics And they will have a hearing and decide if they want to move forward with that Information they found it or not As far as to try to ensure it and happen again, and we have Included more information in our onboarding process for new employees that we have as well as we're developing Through the onboarding process a professional development thing that we do once a quarter with our employees so we can refresh them on required information, how they're supposed to go
▶ Play
about it if they do have self-military income. Okay. And do we know that if this Department of Education employee contact the school district to get them to employ him or her?
▶ Play
Speaker 23 3:32
No, but there was the school district, It was actually at the charter school as well as the school district. Our charter school unit was trying to set up professional development for the school districts and the charters there, and they were reaching out to companies looking for professional development, and this company was referred to them from the co-op. And so that's how they came in without knowing that the employee was actually the owner of the business until after the fact.
▶ Play
Okay, and final question. Do you take an account of how many of your employees at the Department of Education have their own companies that would put these people in that type of a situation or other people in that type of situation? Are there multiple employees at the Department of Education that own their own companies as this type of instance? Not that we know of.
▶ Play
Speaker 23 4:27
And like I said, during our onboarding process, as we do have tightened it up for what we train them on to if you do have outside business or it can't be along the line of educational purposes as long as you're an employee of ADE. So we have improved what we tell them when they first start. Okay, thank
▶ Play
Speaker 32 4:45
you. Any other question? Senator Hickey. Right, and you all answered
▶ Play
some questions for me over since the last meeting, and I appreciate that. One thing I did think about later, of course, I had asked a question, and y'all rightfully so said it was under the amount so that they didn't have to get additional bids. So it was more of a sole source is what I'm going to call it. Did you all look at the amount and what they actually had done? Because I'd seen where it said, you know, kind of give a listing of what type of services they were going to provide. Did that seem like that was in line with what y'all normally see for something of that nature? Did you look into that any, just to see if the... It
▶ Play
Speaker 23 5:28
wasn't unusual for when we have professional development people come in and train. It's not if out of line was usually charged for that amount. Okay, so you didn't see anything that would raise an eyebrow as far as that part,
▶ Play
based on the amount of services they were providing and the dollars? No, sir, not at that time.
▶ Play
All right, thank you. Any other questions? Thank you for coming. so we'll file this take a motion to file it okay a second okay thank y'all our next report is the
▶ Play
Speaker 6 6:09
state board of podiatric medicine june 30 18 report this is a two-year report and it contains one repeat finding dfa financial management guide requires that collecting, recording, depositing, and reconciling of cash receipts be segregated among different individuals. However, the board's secretary treasurer had sole responsibility for performing these duties, and as a result, we noted two issues. The first was that the board did not keep a complete list of receipts for license renewals and application fees collected and did not reconcile revenues recorded on its books to ACES. Also, the board did not make a timely deposit. They had a bank account that was closed, and funds totaling over $210,000 were withdrawn on August 31, 2018. However, these funds were not deposited into the state treasury until October 1, 2018. That concludes our finding for this board. Do
▶ Play
we have someone from the department that would like to make a statement? No. Okay. would you please introduce yourself
▶ Play
Speaker 46 7:15
matt gilmore department of health joe thompson chief
▶ Play
financial officer department of health so the board of podiatric medicine is now under the department of health and this happened back in 2018 since transformation we're responsible for their operations their financial procedures We've implemented some things. We met with them last month. So transformation should solve this issue. We have access to their budget reports and all their financial transactions. So this shouldn't come up again. And like I said, transformation, the act, will take care of this as we absorb their
▶ Play
responsibilities and their operations. So you feel you have put things in order
▶ Play
to take care of that? I think the Department of Health will be able to
▶ Play
Speaker 47 8:07
handle it, and they'll have to abide
▶ Play
by our processes and our standards. Okay. Okay, Representative Sorella. Thank you, Madam Chair. Was there an explanation on where the money was between August 31st and October 1st?
▶ Play
So the treasurer, the position of treasurer switched during that time. There was one board member that gave that up and gave it to another position. so they were holding the check and they just didn't get it deposited into the treasury on time but it was it was a check
▶ Play
so anyone else thank y'all for coming thank you do i have a motion to we'll file this okay a second okay and so we'll file it thank y'all thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 6 9:03
Our next report is the Office of the Prosecutor Coordinator, June 30, 2018 report, and this report contains one finding as well. Arkansas Code requires the agency to ensure that no obligations are incurred that cannot be lawfully discharged for funds appropriated. A review of expenditures revealed that there were two transactions totaling just over $10,000 that were not properly recorded as employee benefits for the year into June 30, 2018. Had the expenditures been properly recorded against the appropriate budget item, the agency expenditures would have exceeded the remaining budget item. the remaining budget for that item that concludes our finding
▶ Play
do we have someone from the office for the prosecutor would you please introduce
▶ Play
Speaker 51 9:49
yourself yes ma'am thank you madam chairman Bob McMahon
▶ Play
Speaker 53 9:55
I'm the prosecutor coordinator Terry Isaac I'm the fiscal officer
▶ Play
Speaker 52 9:58
do you have a statement yes ma'am I think you have a response. It's actually an accurate statement of what happened. This was basically the result of an inadvertent GL code entry so that when that incorrect entry was made, it made it look like instead of money coming out of our account, out of the match part of our budget, it came out of our operating expenses so that in the spring when I asked for additional money to make the pay plan request, I only asked for the money in a salary, not knowing that we were lacking in match as well. So had that inadvertent error not been made, we would have asked for the match money as well. And we have implemented a procedure that was pointed out to us as to how to hopefully not have that happen again. And I think that's supposed to, the new process, and Terry may correct me if I'm wrong, is supposed to allow you to not have to rekey certain codes on a regular basis. And that's, I guess, what we determined was why the error happened. So I'd be happy to try and answer any additional questions. I hope that
▶ Play
explained what had happened. Is there any questions? Okay, thank you for coming. Thank you. Thank you. Do I have a motion to file this? Okay, in a second? Okay, we'll file it then.
▶ Play
Speaker 6 11:16
Our last report is the Department of Veterans Affairs June 30-18 report. This report contained five findings. The first finding, procurement law allows for various methods of obtaining technical services, including emergency procurements with approval by the Office of State Procurement. The AC used two vendors to provide nursing and nursing assistant staffing with total expenses of $1.1 million without establishing contracts within the procurement requirements of Arkansas Code. A similar finding like this was issued in the prior report. The second finding, AC accounting staff processed disbursements for nursing and nursing assistant staffing before approval for services rendered was received from management of the North Little Rock Veterans Home and held the resulting warrants until the approval was received. The third finding, the Financial Management Guide requires daily deposits, but weekly deposits are allowable if an agency receives only minimal amounts of cash and or checks. Of 75 rent receipts that we tested for the North Little Rock Veterans Home, 35 receipts totaling about $70,000 were deposited more than seven days from the date of the receipt. The fourth finding, the North Little Rock Veterans Home received VA approval on October 12, 2017, allowing retroactive recognition to August 3, 2017. Management did not apply for a VA facility identification number upon receipt of the approval and could not provide documentation of timely application for the number. Therefore, the AC did not receive it until January 2018. Review of claims made for resident room and board reimbursements revealed that claims for August through November 2017 were submitted in January 2018 with December claims submitted in February of 2018. Claims not timely submitted to either the VA or Medicaid total almost $1.5 million. Late submission created some cash flow difficulties as well as requests for additional funding and potentially avoidable transfers between funds. The fifth finding, the financial management guide requires state agencies to promptly record receivables and related receipts and collect all receivables in a cost-effective manner. A sample of veterans home resident receivables at June 30, 2018 revealed that over $138,000 had not been collected as of April 30th, 2019. Additionally, six accounts totaling almost $48,000 were related to Fayetteville Veterans Home residents that were discharged or deceased more than one year ago. And that concludes our findings for the Veterans Affairs. Do we have someone
▶ Play
from the Veterans Affairs who'd like to come and make a statement?
▶ Play
Speaker 63 14:01
Hello, Nate Todd, Director, Secretary of the Arkansas Department of Veterans Affairs.
▶ Play
Speaker 60 14:09
I'm Stacey Crawford. I'm a Special Projects Manager at DF&A, serving right now as Acting CFO for Veterans Affairs. Hula Lee,
▶ Play
Speaker 20 14:18
Accounting Operations Manager. I share with the
▶ Play
Speaker 63 14:26
legislative body that many of these findings were associated with our North Little Rock Veterans Home, basically a start-up business, acknowledge the complexities of that and the challenges, and things could have been done better. I'll share with you we've had a lot of help from DF&A, and we've instituted our own staffing. It's fully CPA-trained, and we've strengthened our financial management processes and procedures. Did you want to say something? Yeah, I have a question whenever it's open.
▶ Play
Okay. Okay, we're ready for questions, so go ahead.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chairwoman. So on the first finding, I think the issue we understand is that the North Little Rock facility had a cash flow problem, and I understand what your point about it being kind of a startup business. We know some of the history of that. I think the issue with this finding isn't so much that the money was moved, as we see in our report, probably from other facilities kind of cover that cost. We understand that. I think the issue and the reason it's a concern to me is this repeat finding is that you didn't come through the emergency procedures and procurement part to get in front of us and through ALC to do that. I don't think us as a body mind the money being moved and used in that way. We understand the urgencies and the needs of it. I think the issue is this was done without our approval and kind of done because it was needed, even though there is a process in place to do that through us. Would you agree with that assessment and say in the future that you would take steps to make sure that the proper procedures follows so that we have some kind of legislative approval through ALC. Yes, Senator Gardner.
▶ Play
Speaker 63 16:08
And within that, we had some verbal agreements with DHS that we could use their contract for those nursing personnel. That was not within procurement law. So now we have a procurement specialist who is reviewing each of those, and we have the appropriate request for proposals out to get that contract bidded upon. So, yes, sir, going through the right procedures is important, and we will adhere to that. I think that's the thing I see.
▶ Play
If you have that new procedure in place and that new person to do it, we won't be coming back in a year and having another report of this money being moved without our approval. I don't really have a problem with the money being moved. It's more about us having that legislative authority and oversight to do that. Thank
▶ Play
you, Madam Chairwoman. Thank you. Is there any other
▶ Play
questions? And it's really probably just for staff. is working on that. So, I mean, if I'm kind of looking at, it looks like we probably had accounting chasing kind of behind, so we were missing out or they were missing out on some of the processes. Is that, and so my question is, do they have the procedures in place to not always be working from that position to being behind? I mean, if I'm looking at some of what is
▶ Play
Speaker 6 17:26
caught, that's the way I would My understanding is, since this was as of June 30, 2018 and Mr. Todd correct they were starting up so they had some lag time and requesting reimbursements they had some lag time and collecting the receivables but our understanding is as far as them borrowing money between those funds like they were between the other home and the cemeteries is that that's gotten some better and they were starting to kind of reimburse those other entities i mean yes you may do a better job of answering that than i
▶ Play
Speaker 63 17:53
can but i mean that's my understanding from our discussions with them well several things happen the government and legislators approved from the rainy day fund a cash flow allotment so we've been able to use that and we've improved our timing on our reimbursements from the VA those are due within five days of the end of the month working days and for the last six months we've been able to meet that objective we've had some part of what I was talking
▶ Play
about that type of process it seems like we were always kind of chasing ourselves accounting wise or at least that's the way
▶ Play
Speaker 63 18:23
it reads yes sir and we put staff in both the North Little Rock Home and the Fayetteville Home financial staff to improve the accuracy and the timeliness of those reports. Okay. Thank
▶ Play
you. Anyone else? Thank you all for coming.
▶ Play
Speaker 78 18:42
Thank you. We need a motion to file
▶ Play
this. okay second so we'll file it our next meeting will be December the 12th is there any other new business that needs to be brought before us then we are adjourned
▶ Play
Speaker 85 19:22
Yeah, thank you. Okay. No, it fails. Good, so. Good, and it gets better. It will.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 19:52
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

A. Call to order by Chairman.

-249:03 - 28:22 105 segments 22 speakers

The committee heard the Department of Education June 30 2018 audit, which found a $6,300 payment to a corporation owned by an agency employee who failed to file required disclosures, and Senators Irvin and Hickey questioned the agency about ethics oversight and the reasonableness of the sole-source procurement, after which Chairman Nelda moved to file the report and the motion carried. [0:42] [0:48] [1:12] [1:25] [2:07] [2:26] [2:39] [2:44] [2:58] [3:15] [3:32] [3:37] [4:02] [4:50] [5:08] [5:28] [5:41] [5:48]

The State Board of Podiatric Medicine two-year report was presented, highlighting improper cash-receipt segregation and a delayed $210,000 deposit, and Department of Health representative Matt Gilmore explained that the board’s financial controls have been transferred to the department and that the transformation act should prevent recurrence; the committee then filed the report. [6:11] [6:44] [7:26] [7:51] [7:58] [8:02] [8:07] [8:14] [8:24] [8:48]

The Office of the Prosecutor Coordinator’s June 2018 finding of two mis-recorded $10,000 employee-benefit transactions was explained by Fiscal Officer Terry Isaac as the result of an inadvertent GL-code entry, and he described a new coding procedure to avoid future errors before the committee filed the report. [9:03] [9:33] [9:55] [9:58] [10:06] [10:41] [10:58]

The Veterans Affairs audit uncovered five findings, including improper emergency procurements for nursing services, delayed deposits, and uncollected receivables; agency leaders testified that new procurement specialists and staffing changes have been implemented, and Senators Garner and Dismang probed the adequacy of those controls before the committee adopted a motion to file the report and set the next meeting for Dec 12. [11:16] [11:24] [11:49] [12:26] [12:58] [13:29] [14:01] [14:09] [14:18] [14:26] [14:32] [15:05] [15:37] [16:08] [16:31] [16:38] [17:00] [17:05] [17:09] [17:26] [17:39] [17:53] [18:11] [18:16] [18:23] [18:42] [18:50]

D. New Business. The next meeting will be held December 12, 2019

E. Adjournment.

Speakers

Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 6
20 segments
Speaker 9
1 segment
Speaker 19
1 segment
Speaker 23
10 segments
Senator Missy Irvin Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 32
1 segment
Senator Jimmy Hickey, Jr Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 46
1 segment
Matt Gilmore Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 47
1 segment
Representative Jim Sorvillo Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 51
1 segment
Speaker 53
1 segment
Speaker 52
3 segments
Speaker 63
8 segments
Speaker 60
1 segment
Speaker 20
1 segment
Senator Trent Garner Unverified
3 segments
Senator Jonathan Dismang Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 78
1 segment
Speaker 85
1 segment