Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Legislative Joint Auditing-State Agencies

October 10, 2019 ·1:30 PM ·Room 130 ·48:54
Video Transcript 1 document

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 8, 2026

ADOPTION OF MINUTES 1:56

The committee heard the Arkansas Department of Corrections’ audit presentation on internal-audit breakdowns and missing testing documentation, with staff outlining corrective actions such as co-locating audit and fiscal personnel, and a motion to accept those findings passed unanimously. [2:14] [2:23] [2:30] [2:37] [2:46] [2:59] [3:04] [3:25] [3:35] [3:51] [3:58] [4:10] [4:30] [5:01]

The Administrative Office of the Courts’ mileage-reimbursement finding of $14,386 was explained by Judge H.G. Foster, who testified that the court reporter’s official station was the courthouse, the agency had halted reimbursements, instituted additional training and spot-check policies, and the committee moved to accept the finding after agreeing on future guidance, the motion carrying. [5:35] [6:06] [6:41] [7:13] [7:18] [7:36] [7:40] [7:45] [8:05] [8:07] [8:15] [8:20] [8:48] [8:57] [9:33] [10:04] [10:37] [11:07] [11:39] [12:00] [12:04] [12:10] [12:40] [13:11] [13:19] [13:38] [13:41] [13:49] [14:07] [14:18] [14:27] [14:34]

The Department of Education presented three audit issues-an improper $6,300 payment to a corporation owned by an employee, deficiencies in monitoring Arkansas Better Chance child-care providers, and unauthorized personal use of state-owned vehicles-and department officials described remedial steps; the committee then voted to file findings two and three, which was approved. [14:56] [15:26] [15:57] [16:28] [16:45] [17:04] [17:06] [17:13] [17:20] [17:38] [18:15] [18:45] [19:17] [19:25] [19:30] [19:40] [19:51] [19:56] [20:00] [20:05] [20:11] [20:22] [20:24] [20:36] [20:45] [20:52] [20:59] [21:19] [21:30] [21:35] [21:42] [21:48] [21:52] [21:58] [22:02] [22:15] [22:39] [22:44] [22:55]

The Department of Finance and Administration reported two cash-shortage incidents involving missing checks and employee misconduct, while the Department of Higher Education reported student-loan ledger mismatches and related vehicle-use issues; officials from both agencies described new dual-person controls and corrective actions, and the committee approved motions to file both reports. [23:11] [23:42] [24:09] [24:34] [25:03] [25:12] [25:37] [25:44] [25:52] [25:58] [26:14] [26:29] [26:35] [26:47] [26:52] [27:11] [27:17] [27:26] [27:32] [27:42] [27:46] [27:52] [27:55] [28:23] [28:32] [28:41] [28:54] [29:25] [29:58] [30:29] [30:47] [30:51] [30:57] [31:00] [31:07] [31:24] [31:32] [32:06] [32:36] [32:44] [32:59] [33:05] [33:08] [33:19] [33:39] [34:03] [34:10]

REVIEW OF REPORTS 34:46

Representative Fredrick J. Love presented the DHS audit findings, outlining eight issues such as duplicate check recordings that understated the agency’s balance by $61,000, improper monitoring of Medicaid drug rebate transfers, unallowable purchase of foster-care amusement-park season passes, questionable fuel-card charges, patient-fund overpayments, and a $2 million “general account” holding balance spanning 2012-2018. [35:11] [35:47] [36:17] [36:51] [37:23] [37:54] [38:25]

Agency officials-including Chief of Security Brett Hayes, Legislative Affairs Chief Mark White, and DCFS Director Martin-responded that corrective action plans were underway for the first and last findings and that internal controls had been created to address the remaining six findings. [39:43] [40:02] [40:19] [40:32] [40:55] [41:03] [41:35]

Committee members questioned the accounting of the season-ticket purchases and the unresolved large balance in the general account, prompting explanations of new approval and chain-of-custody procedures for tickets and a discussion that unidentified funds would eventually be transferred to the operating account. [40:19] [40:32] [40:55] [41:03] [41:35] [42:07] [42:38] [43:09] [43:23] [43:39] [43:56] [44:11] [44:17] [44:45] [45:08] [45:14] [45:17] [45:37] [45:44] [45:49] [45:53] [45:56] [46:10] [46:16] [46:24] [46:29] [46:35] [46:54] [46:56] [47:00]

The committee moved to file all eight findings into the legislative audit report; the motion was seconded, passed unanimously, and the next meeting was scheduled for November 7, 2019. [48:21] [48:35]

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 8, 2026
First, before we start on the agenda, if you notice that there's a leak at the ceiling at the end of the table, so as you come up to testify, please go to the right so you don't go through our obstacle course we have here and actually are able to testify. So I just wanted to make a note about that. First, I'll take an adoption, a motion for the adoption of a meeting of the September 12, 2019 meeting. Got a motion, got a second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The motion carried. With that, we'll go to Tom. Auditor reports with no finding. All right, today we've got six reports with findings.
▶ Play
We also have 20 reports that don't have any findings, and these are listed in the audit summary
▶ Play
beginning on page one. I will entertain a motion to accept the audit reports with no findings. We have a second. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? The motion carries. Next we'll move on to the first
▶ Play
audit report. Our first report is the Arkansas Department of Correction, June 30, 2018 report, and this report contains one finding. Our report from 2017 of this agency included a finding regarding discrepancies between inventory records of amounts issued to inmates and the requests made by the inmates on their order forms at the McPherson Unit Inmate Council. Agency management indicated in their prior year response that their internal audit staff test Inmate Council inventories and point-of-sale controls on a regular basis and that they report any discrepancies to the unit wardens and ADC management for action. We requested that the AC internal audit provide us with reports or other documentation of any testing procedures performed on Inmate Council inventories since our last report and none were provided to us. That concludes our finding. Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Do we have
▶ Play
any representatives from the Department of Correction to come up, please? Gentlemen, when you take your seats, please state your name and your title for the record,
▶ Play
please. Solomon Graves, Chief of Staff and Legislative Liaison, Arkansas Department of Corrections. Mark
▶ Play
Speaker 10 2:23
Cash, CFO, Department of Corrections. Jeff Jerry,
▶ Play
I'm the Assistant CFO. Thank you. Do I
▶ Play
have any statements for these findings? No, sir. Any questions from members? Representative Love, you're recognized. My first question is for staff. You requested reports.
▶ Play
Did you request reports? Yes, we had this finding last year, So when we went back for the current year audit, we were following up on our prior year finding,
▶ Play
Speaker 16 2:59
and we asked for anything that they had done to
▶ Play
show us that they corrected it, and they didn't provide us anything to show that. Well, Mr. Graves, you don't have a response for that? Representative Love, no, sir, we don't. As staff indicated, those documents were not available. We've since taken the necessary actions internally to ensure that testing, that training auditing being done by our internal audit staff is in fact being done and that those reports are being made available to division management as they are being generated moving forward. Mr. Chair, well, let me
▶ Play
Speaker 16 3:35
ask another question then. Did you all do the testing that you all referred to? Were you all doing the testing that you referred to? Because if so, you would have documents. We are
▶ Play
Speaker 10 3:51
now, sir. So you weren't doing the testing? No, sir. There was a breakdown between my area and the internal audit area. It just didn't get passed on. They needed to schedule those audits and do those audits. And since the auditors came by and brought that to our attention, we have corrected that. Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Representative Love, one of the things, and again, we're not attempting to just justify what should have been done that was not done. One of the things that we did do is, while our internal audit section reports through our chief legal counsel, we've co-located our internal audit in the same building with our fiscal staff to increase that level of proximity previously they worked on the other side of town from the money folks they're now in the same building with the money staff to ensure that those lines of communication are open it was it should not have happened it did but we've taken the necessary internal controls to ensure that we're not sitting at the end of the table this year addressing this for a subsequent audit. Can you, if you have more questions, Representative Love? I'm fine, thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, any more questions? Thank you, with that, our entertainer motion to accept these findings. Motion, do we have a second? Second. Second, all those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The findings have been accepted.
▶ Play
Thank you. Next finding, please. Our next report is the Administrative Officer of the Court's June 30-18 report, and this report also contains one finding. Tri-Court assistance and Tri-Court reporters follow the travel guidelines contained in the Arkansas State Tri-Court Employment Guide that's published by the agency. According to this guide, an employee's official station should be the location or address where an employee normally reports for duty and spends the majority of his or her productive time conducting official job duties. An employee may be reimbursed for transportation costs associated with attending court away from their official station based on the number of miles between the location from which the employee leaves their official station or residence and the work-related destination, whichever is less. A review of mileage reimbursements for 21 trial court employees revealed overpayments totaling over $14,000 due to the following. The official station was not properly determined for individual A, resulting in improper reimbursements of over $12,000 for miles between the individual's home and official station. Individuals B and C consistently utilized their official stations as a starting point for calculating miles for reimbursement, although for some destinations the distance would have been shorter had their residences been used. Additionally, there was no indication that these individuals traveled to their official station prior to making the trip to the other locations. As a result, individuals B and C received mileage overpayments of almost $1,400 and $165, respectively. A duplicate payment of $469 was noted for individual D. And also, there was no documentation to support a mileage reimbursement of $260, and due to inadequate information available for three other individuals, we could not determine if mileage reimbursements were correctly calculated. This finding was referred to the prosecuting attorney. That concludes our finding, Mr. Chair. Thank
▶ Play
you. Do we have anybody from the Administrative Office of the Courts come and testify? If you do, please come forward. If you can, please identify yourself for the record and your title. My
▶ Play
Speaker 30 7:36
name is H.G. Foster. I'm a circuit judge in the 20th Judicial District. I'm Sam
▶ Play
Speaker 32 7:40
Kaufman. I'm the Director of Human Resources for the Administrative Office of the Courts.
▶ Play
Speaker 30 7:45
Do you have a statement on this finding? I do, Mr. Chairman. I've asked to be passed out to exhibits, exhibit A and exhibit B. I'm here to offer testimony on behalf of the Administrative Office of the Courts. The audit finding with regard to the 20th Judicial District of my trial court reporter. Ma'am, can you bring them up there? Let
▶ Play
me see them first. Just see what they
▶ Play
Speaker 37 8:07
are. Oh, thank you very much. I'm sorry,
▶ Play
Speaker 38 8:15
Mr. Chairman. Okay, I'll prove them to be passed out, please.
▶ Play
Thank you very much, sir. You may continue on with your
▶ Play
Speaker 30 8:48
testimony if you wish. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. As I said, I'm here to offer testimony in support of the administrative office of the courts. My court reporter has been submitting TR1s for offices in her home. The audit finding indicated that, as you'll see in Exhibit A, indicated that the law said that her official station is basically the courthouse, other similar building, and where she performs the majority of her duties. You'll see the word and is circled on Exhibit A. Exhibit B is the relevant portions of the trial court employee guide, and you will note that it is tabbed, and the provision in the trial court employee guide provides that it is courthouse or other type building, or it has the conjunctive and the disjunctive as well, where she performs the majority of her duties. My court reporter performs the majority of her duties, which is typing transcripts, and I realize that's a fact question that we're not really here for today, but she does perform the majority of her duties in her office and therefore is in compliance with the law as it's contained within the trial court manual. Now, since we became aware that this was a legislative audit issue, she stopped submitting TR1s or requests for reimbursement, nor will she submit any further requests for reimbursement unless and until she just basically gets the word that, hey, we're interpreting and or to be and, and you can't do it the way you've been doing it for the last 25 years, in which case she will comply with that. But unless and until she gets that cleared up, the distinction or the difference between those two, she can't submit any requests, and that's fine. I've been paying her travel out of my own pocket. There'll never be any request for that. It's not a problem. She's 73 years old, and she's a year away from retirement, so it won't be an issue. The only thing I'm here for today is to point out that I don't think AOC did anything wrong. I think they did comply with the provisions of the trial court employee manual, and as soon as we all became aware that there was an audit issue with regard to that and that the and or should be interpreted as merely the conjunctive and not the disjunctive, we stopped submitting the request. But she could not sign the official designation station form because it contained the language and, which is different than the language in the trial court manual. So, once again, as far as I'm concerned, as far as she's concerned, it's not an issue. I just wanted to come forward and let you guys know why I didn't think AOC did anything wrong. And if anybody did anything wrong, it's not AOC. It's me, because I'm the one that signed off on all the forms. That's everything that I have to say. Thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 37 12:00
very much, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Judge. Sam, do you have anything to add to that?
▶ Play
Speaker 45 12:04
Yes, sir. Uh, uh, uh, Marty Sullivan, uh, sends his apologies for not being here today. He's our agency director. He's a judicial counsel in Springdale on avoidable conflict. Uh, our finance administration director, Keith Leathers, similarly unavoidable, unavoidable conflict, but a family medical issue. Uh, uh, but I am authorized to make this statement, uh, to the committee to provide some clarification, uh, echoing what the judge said. Uh, you know, we received an anonymous complaint in fall 2018 regarding a trial court employee's, uh, travel reimbursement request. we immediately conducted an investigation, ceased payment. We contacted the trial court employee committee for clarification on the rule the judge was discussing. They clarified that a home could not be an official workstation. We contacted the judge and the trial court employee involved. And also to prevent future incidents in addition to the training we already conduct, we conducted additional training and sent out memoranda to that effect. We also have instituted new policies to increase the frequency of spot checks of travel reimbursement requests. Thank you.
▶ Play
So let me start with this. It seems like we have two separate issues here. What happened in the past with this particular three people and what the prospectively the guidance will be from AOC to the courts. It seems to me and from both your statements that in the future, the home station will not be including a home address, per se. It will be the actual courthouse from here on out. Speaking for myself, absolutely. Yes, Mr. Chairman. And that's the guidance being given out by AOC, correct? That's correct, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 30 13:41
They've been consistent with that since we started having the
▶ Play
conversation. Okay. Any other questions from the committee members? Yeah, I appreciate your thorough explanation. We deal with these kind of things, and it sounds like this is one of those things that was done in good faith I think that with a specific policy and as long as it's corrected in the future, I think that
▶ Play
that's a good outcome to this. I will entertain them. Sir, do you have a question? I do. Is there a possibility that we would be able to recoup this $14,386? I know that you said you sent it to the prosecuting attorney. However, will we have restitution? Sir,
▶ Play
Speaker 45 14:27
I believe that's in the, uh, it has been referred to the prosecutor and that's where I understand it. It lies now. Yeah, I
▶ Play
believe that's the extent of our ability as a legislative authority. Uh, with that, I'll take a motion to accept. Do we have a second? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Thank you, sir. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 54 14:44
Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Thank you for the committee. All right, to the next finding.
▶ Play
Speaker 3 14:51
Our next report is the Department of Education June 2018 report, and
▶ Play
this report contains three findings. The first finding, the Department of Education and one school district paid professional fees totaling $6,300 to a corporation owned by an agency employee for services provided by the employee. The employee did not file the required income and financial interest disclosure statements with DFA and the Secretary of State. This finding was also referred to the prosecuting attorney. The second finding, in the prior year report, we noted noncompliance in monitoring child care providers for the Arkansas Better Chance Program. The agency responded that they were working with DHS to develop a risk-based monitoring protocol for the ABC program. The DHS Division of Child Care and Early Childhood Education administered the program under contract with the agency, and expense reports submitted by all child care providers should be subject to review. DHS focused their corrective action for the prior finding on child care providers serving 20 and fewer children. Their staff are still not performing a review of expense report documentation for the vast majority of providers, those serving more than 20 children. Monitoring of all providers is required by program rules. And the third finding, the Commissioner of Education and the Deputy Commissioner of Education commuted in state-owned vehicles between their homes and agency offices. Arkansas Code and DFA regulations require reimbursement to the state for all commuting and other personal use of state-owned vehicles. DFA regulations require usage logs for every mile driven in state-owned vehicles. And DFA and IRS regulations also require the value of commuting and other personal mileage be reported as taxable fringe of benefits to the employees using the vehicles. The Commissioner and the Deputy Commissioner did not maintain vehicle use logs as required or reimbursed the state for commuting and other personal mileage. The amounts reported as taxable fringe of benefits were not valued according to DFA and IRS regulations. This finding was also referred to the prosecuting attorney. That concludes our report.
▶ Play
Thank you, Tom. Do we have any representation from the Department of Education? Please say your name and your title for
▶ Play
Speaker 59 17:04
the record, please. Greg Rogers, CFO, Department of Education
▶ Play
Speaker 60 17:06
Tracy Boyd, Internal Auditor for the Department of Education Greg Beaumont,
▶ Play
Agency Controller for the Department of Education Thank you for coming. Do you all have a statement on any one of
▶ Play
Speaker 63 17:20
the findings? Yes, sir. First of all, Secretary Key wanted me to apologize for him not being able to be here today. uh state board is meeting today and he needed down there that going on today so he wanted me to on the first on the first finding that we had the employee had the consulting firm before he started working for the department and even though in our onboarding process and procedures that we have we prohibit this he was misunderstanding how it meant on the prohibiting because he already had it plus he wasn't doing the professional development as a part of his job with the Department of Education. But since this finding, we've counseled him, worked with him, explained to him, as well as updating our onboarding procedures and our rules for how employees are supposed to, that employees aren't supposed to be doing that. And if they do receive any income outside, they are required to file that. The second finding, um, with the ABC, as the report stated, it was a program that was split between DHS and Department of Education, where Department of Education actually had the funding and appropriation for the program. But DHS was in charge of actually running the program. Since transformation has come, the program is now going to be under one department with the Department of Education. So as of October the 14th, all the ABC personnel, finance and everything will be moved to our building, where we hope that we can work with them, update their risk assessments, update their procedures to finally get this audit taken care of. The last one, the car situation, the department had a waiver of the commuter rule with the DFA for some time back. We had been applying that waiver as it had been done until we were notified by audit that actually the rules and the procedures had been changed once we were, and we just missed that while we've never updated our procedures on it. Once audit caught it, we talked with the secretary and with the deputy commissioner. They gave up their vehicles immediately. All both those cars are now part of the normal fleet vehicle for all IED. Thank you.
▶ Play
Any questions from committee on any finding? Senator Hickey? Yes, sir. I heard you say
▶ Play
that the gentleman under finding one had the consulting company before he was an employee. Did he have the contract to do the work also? Is that what you're saying?
▶ Play
Speaker 63 19:40
I'm not sure if he had the contract, but he had done similar work like this before with other school districts through the co-ops. and so he was unclear that when he became an AD employee that he should have shut that off. He had it with a partner, and so he had some confusion on that. So was
▶ Play
this consulting work for an individual school district? Is that what you're saying?
▶ Play
Speaker 63 20:00
Yes, sir. They had asked his firm to come out and actually work with him on professional
▶ Play
development. Okay. And I heard the lady, I believe it was, she said you were with the audit department. Did we look into this and see if the bid for this consulting work was done correctly? I mean, it looks like to me that it was done after there was a contract for this consulting work after they became an employee. Was that correct?
▶ Play
Speaker 66 20:24
This was actually under the amount that there would have to be a contract for because it was for $5,300. So this was paid through a purchase, through an IOR. Did we check to see was this a sole
▶ Play
source even though it was under, or how was that done? Did we delve into that any? no sir we did not
▶ Play
Speaker 66 20:45
delve into whether it was a cell source or not this
▶ Play
has been referred to the prosecuting attorney yes not that particular finding
▶ Play
Speaker 63 20:59
senator hickey it's not no when we made aware of it we've done ours and we turned the information over to dfa as following on our procedures when that was done. So it has been referred to them as the next step of what we had
▶ Play
to do. Okay, I'd like some more information. I understand that it may have been under the amount, but I'd like, since everything that's transpired right here and with it being an employee, I would like for us to see if there was an actual bid process or if this person was just giving this and kind of get some more specifics. It
▶ Play
Speaker 63 21:35
went through the cooperative down there, But we have the letter where we did the background, and I'll get you a copy of it. Okay. And I'm not sure that
▶ Play
I want to vote on file emissions. That's what I was going to ask you, Senator Hickey.
▶ Play
Do you want to vote to file it and then to do it later, get the letter information later? Or would you like this fine and pulled from the motion, assuming we've moved forward with the other two?
▶ Play
If it will please the committee, I'd like it pulled because I'd like some more information on this employee and how all this transpired just to make sure that, you know, it was just a, and I'm not doubting you all, but I'd like to make sure it is just a mistake and there's nothing else in there involved with that. I think
▶ Play
that'd be appropriate. Assuming we get to the end of this, we'll do a motion on the second and third finding and have this for the next meeting where you can explain a little bit more detail for Senator Hickey. Any more questions on any of the other findings? Seeing none, I will entertain a motion to file finding number two and finding number three. Hold on one second. I want to make sure we have them correctly. Yes, two and three. Correct. We had to write. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Thank you. Moving on
▶ Play
to Department of Finance and Administration. Our next report is the Department of Finance Administration, June 2018 report, which also contains two findings. Both of these findings related to shortages at DFA revenue offices and were reported to us by DFA. The first one, in October 2018, DFA discovered three checks totaling over $1,900 missing from September deposits at the Hot Springs Downtown Revenue Office. After being questioned by police, a service representative admitted removing and destroying a $639 check for her personal title and registration and recording a non-existent customer check to conceal about $1,200 in misappropriated cash. A third check for $77 remains unaccounted for. The $639 was reimbursed and the employee was terminated. The second finding, a DFA employee from the Hot Springs Albert Pike Revenue Office informed management that her cash flow was short $1,000 in December 2018. Further investigation by DFA revealed that the employee did not follow protocol when accepting cash from a customer. After a failed attempt to have the customer pay the remaining balance, the employee reimbursed the agency and retired from her position. Both of these findings were referred to the prosecuting attorney. That concludes our report. Thank you, Tom. Do we
▶ Play
have anybody from DFNA to come up and speak on this matter?
▶ Play
Speaker 86 24:34
Paul Lothian, Deputy Director, DFA. Thank you, Paul. Do you have any statement on these findings? No, sir, other than the fact that you'll notice that both of them are no longer employees with us. We followed the protocol after the money became missing. We've changed two different policies here. We have two people going to the bank when possible, one with a key, one with a bag. In the other instance, we try to have two people there to take any cash that's provided by the taxpayer, have two people to cash or to count that at the time that the deposit's made. Thank you. We have any questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Senator Hickey? Just one, Paul.
▶ Play
Finding two, that's a different employee, correct? Yes. Okay. And they just self-reported that $1,000 on their own? Is that the way that transpired on that
▶ Play
Speaker 86 25:52
particular one? Yes, sir. But at the end of the day, if they don't balance out, they have to call their boss. And we try to then send another person over to help them reconcile the situation. In this case, they thought they had it finalized and found, and they didn't. We tried to collect the money back from the taxpayer. That didn't work, and so she resigned her position and paid the money back. Okay. We just had to assume that that all worked out the way it should have. We didn't just lose a good employee because of a bad situation. Sure. Thank you, sir. Any more questions,
▶ Play
Speaker 91 26:29
committee? Senator? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm just trying to follow the
▶ Play
two folks going to the bank together. I mean, it seems to me, I mean, you have a deposit slip, and the next day you just make sure the deposit slip matches the deposit ticket to the bank. I mean, what is two people going to go to the bank? What does
▶ Play
Speaker 86 26:52
that fix? We have had situations in the past where we believe the employee took the money out of the bag they had the key in the bag they took the money out of the bag themselves between the office and the bank and this way they cannot they cannot open the bag during transport so there's
▶ Play
not a deposit slip that's created then prior to going to the bank yes there is
▶ Play
Speaker 86 27:17
but then you get down to someone saying well the deposit slip was incorrect okay when I got the cash okay Any more questions, Mr. Committee?
▶ Play
Yeah, with this first one, I think it's fairly important that we refer to the prosecuting attorney. It sounds like that was an intentional act. And even though it's not a large sum of money in the scheme of things, I think that's something I think we need to follow up on. Without any more questions, committee, I will take a
▶ Play
motion. Sir, you have a question? Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You said that you try to have two people go. What circumstances would you not have the two people
▶ Play
Speaker 86 27:55
go? Well, you have small revenue offices in small locations. Sometimes we have one person there by themselves during the day. Sometimes they have a person and a part-time person. So you don't always have two people at that location that can go to the bank. But where we can, we've put that in place. Same thing with counting the cash. If there's more than $500, if you have availability to do that, that's the proper control we have in place, and you have to follow that.
▶ Play
Any more questions? If not, I'll entertain a motion to file this report. I have a motion. We have a second. We have a second. All in favor say aye. Aye.
▶ Play
Any opposed? Thank you, sir. Next one. Our next report is the Arkansas Department of Higher Education June 3018 report. This report contains two findings. The first finding is a repeat finding from last year. The agency oversees several state-funded student loan programs. Students who receive the loans may be eligible to have the loans forgiven if they meet certain criteria. Students not meeting the criteria are placed in repayment status. The agency is required to maintain student loan subsidiary ledgers for each student to track changes to loan balances throughout the year. These individual subsidiary ledgers are then used to adjust loans receivable in ACES during the fiscal year and closing process. Our review of 40 active individual student loan files revealed three instances totaling almost $57,000 in which student loan balances did not match the subsidiary ledgers, resulting in an overstated receivables balance. And our review of 25 inactive student loan files revealed that four instances totaling almost $11,000 in which student loan balances did not match the subsidiary ledgers, resulting in an overstated receivables balance. And three instances totaling $12,000 in which student loan balances were written off without proper approval from the chief physical officer of the state the second finding is very similar to what we had on department of education the chief physical officer of the state under authority of arkansas code issues rules concerning state-owned vehicles and publishes the state of arkansas vehicle use and management handbook this sum but this handbook requires certain information that you can see in the bullets be maintained in a vehicle use log the handbook also requires employees to reimburse the cost of their personal use of state vehicles including commuting The AC director obtained commuter status in February 2018 and commuted in a state vehicle. However, there was no vehicle use log maintained, and as a result, we could not determine the extent the vehicle was used for commuting or an accurate amount of reimbursements owed. And this finding was referred to the prosecuting attorney as well.
▶ Play
That concludes our report. Thank you. Do we have any representatives from the Arkansas Department of Higher Education? Please say your name and your
▶ Play
Speaker 102 30:47
title for the record, please. Maria Markham, Director of the Arkansas Division of
▶ Play
Speaker 85 30:51
Higher Education. Nick Fuller, Deputy Director at the Division of Higher Education. Thank you both. Do you have a statement on either one
▶ Play
Speaker 102 30:57
of these findings? We concur with both of the audit findings. We have taken measures to remediate both of those. Thank you. I know that
▶ Play
since my time being on here, we've had this issue with an inactive student It seems to be a recurring thing. I know it's probably something that's very hard with so much going on. But it's just something I've noticed that we've had that pattern on. So, I mean, you talked about new controls and new staff to do it. Can you explain that in a little bit more
▶ Play
Speaker 102 31:24
detail, please? Yes, so it was a similar finding. It was about the same program, the student loan program. We actually did remedy the finding from last year, which was the balance between our agency ledgers and ACES. So that part of it was fixed. The issue that we had this year was between our third-party servicer and our agency ledgers. We have had some lag time between the reports that we received from our collectors from the third party and what we received at the agency. We have learned that we are going to have a new third-party collector, so we're hoping that we will see a shortened time between the time those accounts are updated and when we receive that information at the agency.
▶ Play
Thank you. Any questions for the committee? Senator Hickey? Yes, Ms. Markle, Mr. Fuller. Mine's going to be on these three instances totaling the $12,000. What steps have we went, since it wasn't sent to the Chief Physical Officer, what steps have we done to go back and look at those and make sure that that's just not a situation where we just give somebody their student loans? And also, I would assume that if we charge it off our books, Does the chief fiscal officer later have the – they could attach to any tax returns or things like
▶ Play
Speaker 102 32:44
that? Well, just to clarify, the three instances totaling $12,000 had not yet been written off. We were in the process of seeking approval to write those off, so we were not actively under collection. But we had not yet written those off. So you hadn't
▶ Play
Speaker 67 32:59
made the entry on your books yet? They were entered in the book, but we do have the
▶ Play
request to go to DF&A for approval. It's just not been done, but it's already been on our books to be written off. It was the error on our part, but it is being remedied, and there is a
▶ Play
request to DF&A to have those written off. Respectfully, my thought process is if you make the entry on your book, you've written it off. That's the way I look at it from the accounting process. But is the chief fiscal officer, are they aware of this? Because I would, and I'm making an assumption here that may be right. I assume that they do put that on and possibly, and Paul or somebody, that in the future we could get some type of tax returns or things like that? Yes, sir. So have these been done on those particular ones, or do we know? They have not. Okay. Are we going to make sure that gets done so that everything lines up with what we normally would do? Yes, sir. All right, Mr. Fuller. Thank you, sir. Any more questions from committee? Seeing
▶ Play
none, I'll entertain a motion to file this report. Motion, do we have a second? Second. Second, all those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Thank you.
▶ Play
Moving on to the next finding. Our last report is the Department of Human Services June 3018 report, and this report contains eight findings. The first finding, according to the State Financial Management Guide, it is the responsibility of the executive head of each agency to keep and maintain a record of all property of the agency, and all items transferred, lost, stolen, destroyed, or sold must be promptly removed from the detail of capital assets. While we were performing an observation of 60 capital assets, we noted the following. Two equipment items could not be located for observation, five items had a different serial number than the serial number recorded in ACES, and three equipment items do not have a serial number recorded in ACES at all. The second finding is also related to capital assets, specifically low-value capital assets. During a review of checks written from the gifts and bequest account, we noted one check written for the purchase of a greenhouse totaling almost $3,400 that met the capital asset guidelines definition of low-value equipment but was not being reported, accounted for in ACES. The third finding, the State Financial Management Guide states that bank accounts must be reconciled to the bank account statement monthly. During our review of the Arkansas Medicaid refund account, we noted two instances where a check had been posted twice in ACES. Although the checks had actually cleared the bank during the fiscal year, due to the duplicate recordings, the agency continued to list them as outstanding checks on the bank reconciliation at year end, therefore resulting in an understatement of the agency's book balance of over $61,000. The fourth finding, during our review of the Medicaid drug rebates bank account, we found that the AC did not adequately monitor the accuracy of Medicaid drug rebate monies being transferred from the account to the State Treasury. We noted one instance in which the AC failed to transfer almost $128,000 in rebate monies received and three instances totaling over $3,000 in which the AC transferred more rebate monies than had been received. In addition, the AC incorrectly recorded $12.8 million in Medicaid drug rebate funds held for transfer at physical year end. The ACES journal entry reported this as revenue in a cash fund when it should have been reported as revenue in the treasury fund. The fifth finding, during our review of purchasing card transactions, we noted that the agency purchased 10 amusement park season passes, totaling over $1,200 for 10 foster children under the foster care program. According to the Regional Program Manager of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Administration for Children and Families, the cost of the amusement park season passes would be considered already covered under the child's maintenance cost or per diem rate provided to their caregiver. Therefore, the AC's purchase of the season passes under foster care is considered unallowable. Additionally, the AC did not maintain any documentation of the children for whom the passes were actually purchased for or of the applicable caregiver's receipt of the passes. The sixth finding, during our review of 105 fuel card transactions, we noted seven questionable charges totaling $773. Agency personnel said they were unaware of these charges until we inquired about them. Subsequently, the agency has disputed the charges and is seeking reimbursement from the credit card company. In addition, the agency was unable to provide supporting documentation and the applicable vehicle use logs for 37 field card purchases totaling about $2,500. This finding was referred to the prosecuting attorney. The seventh finding, during our review of the Arkansas State Hospital's patient's money fund, we noted the patient ledger contained 17 individual patient accounts with negative balances, totaling over $2,100. The majority of this total was due to one patient's negative account balance. According to the patient ledger, the patient had a balance of $70 in his account. However, when the patient was discharged, the AC issued a check of just over $1,400, resulting in an overpayment of around $1,300. We also noted an account labeled miscellaneous with a negative bounce of $444. The eighth and final finding is during our review of the general account cash fund, we noted that the agency maintained an account bounce in excess of $2 million for fiscal years 2012 through 2018. Agency personnel indicated that the purpose of the general account is to provide a temporary holding place for deposit transactions that need to be researched prior to transferring the monies into the appropriate fund. Such deposits include, but are not limited to, refunds from residential provider facilities, state tax intercepts, and refunds of recipient entitlement overpayments. We requested documentation from the agency as to what constituted the balance in the account. However, the agency was unable to provide what made up the account. Mr. Chairman, that concludes our findings for DHS. Thank
▶ Play
you, Tom. Cindy, I know you have a crew back there, so So either you can come up with yourself and a few select members or call them as of as needed, but just make sure we do it judicially. You can quarterback or it's good. Please say your name and title for the record, please. I'm Brett Hayes, Chief of Security and Compliance for DHS. I'm Mark White, Legislative Affairs Chief for DHS. Thank you. We can go through each finding if you want to say a statement
▶ Play
Speaker 115 39:43
for each or whatever is best for you. Yes, I would like to say that on the first and last findings that were noted in legislative audits report, the corrective action plan is still in progress for those findings. We have a plan in place and we have a monitoring plan that we will conduct after the finding is corrected, but those are still in progress. The other six findings that were noted in the report have all been corrected with internal controls created to prevent findings in the future. Anything to add to that,
▶ Play
Mark? No, sir. Okay. Let's go with the cars that were given to pay for the amusement park. The way I understand it is, is that it was under state law allowable for you to pay for those, but it might have been put under the wrong account. And that issue is more of an accounting issue. I think the issue is that once these were purchased, there was no tracking of who actually you received them or how that benefit was used. In theory, I could have went out there and bought this and used it for my home if I was an employee. Can you describe the corrective actions on that and how in the future you will track
▶ Play
Speaker 119 40:55
it better? Good afternoon. And I'm Mr. Martin. I'm the director of the Division of Children and Family Service. That particular audit funding was as to DCFS. And so just to add on to the funding, yes, it was about without tracking of chain of custody that we could confirm that the foster children actually got the tickets. And we did use federal funding, which was not allowable. We did also strengthen our controls about when we buy those season tickets because there are good incidences when we use state funds or a child's trust account to buy particular season tickets, whether it's to Magic Springs or Silver Dollar City. We do not pay for vacations for families, but we do, like, if the child is going to go to daycare and that is an expense that they're incurred. So we didn't want to just stop all purchases of season tickets. And so we have internal controls now, and this is new, but all season tickets have to come up for my approval if they're not through the child's trust account. So if we're using the child's trust account, which maybe they are getting money from SSI or other funds like child support and otherwise, then those can be purchased without coming to me. But if it's just using state general revenue, then all those have to come to me for my approval. And then we have a chain of custody tracking system, which I also brought the form if you'd like to see it. But that is a similar internal control to what we have with gift cards because we've had similar situations at Christmas where we literally have to track the gift card all the way down to the person who gets it and every person who touches it. So staff's already familiar with that process, but now we're using it for season tickets. And so everybody signs all the way down to that person, and then that form, that signature all the way down, then comes back to central office, and it'll be part of the documentation that we keep for that season ticket, and those documents will be kept as part of the financial record for the season ticket. We're also putting on the season ticket the name of the child who it's supposed to be used for. Good. Well, I appreciate those. I think that
▶ Play
it's a noble cause allowing those children to do that. This will make sure that nobody takes those monies, which is well intended and used in a bad way. Any questions from the committee on any other findings? Did you say any of the other? Any other findings, yes, sir.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. I want to hear about finding eight. I want to go into a little more detail with that because tell me why that's not a slush fund if we can't
▶ Play
Speaker 115 43:23
tell. if we're saying it's a temporary holding place? So we have a lot of payments that come into the agency. We receive a lot of checks. So those checks need to go into an account. We don't want them to not be deposited later than the day that they're received. So when those checks come in, it's not always apparent as to what account they need to go into. So they go into that holding account so that they can be researched and determine which account it's appropriate to be placed in.
▶ Play
According to our staff here, it says this goes back to 2012. So we have monies in there that's been sitting there since 2012. What's the process if we can never figure out where they go? I mean, we're just allowing it to sit there. I just need some more detail on what's happening with
▶ Play
Speaker 124 44:17
this. Sorry, I'm Jeremy Fields. I'm the Chief Deputy over General Operations, which, from the end of the stick, we're the ones who write the checks back out of those accounts to that. That's part of our corrective action plan, trying to figure out. We'll work with audit and DF&A is to figure out what the final resolution of that is. But we're still in the process. What we've learned a great deal as new folks come in and look at this is there has a true cycle to this as the tax intercepts come in in the early part of the spring, And we have high balances to that point, and then they work them out. We're about to get through September, and we'll have a real core balance, knowing what is over 45, 65 days, 60 days old at that point. And then we're going to have to just start slicing and dicing as we work out. But when we look at this, it goes back for years. There's balance. And the real question is, in our mind, how much of it is a row-in balance, and how much of it is truly unidentified in there? Okay. I
▶ Play
guess I'm struggling a little bit as far as the legislature is concerned. If you don't know where it goes, is that something that we should appropriate? So it's just something for us to consider right there, because if you don't know where it goes and can't prove where it goes, then it looks like to me there may be possibly another step that should be taken. So I just want us to consider that, and maybe I'm on the wrong track of
▶ Play
Speaker 124 45:37
that, but. I don't believe you are, so we're going to have to have very good documentation on what goes out and how we
▶ Play
identify it. Okay. Mr. Chair, is that something that, or with staff, are we going to continue to monitor this particular situation? Is that how we're lined up to do it or does that need to be a motion to do this committee? We look
▶ Play
at that general account every year, so it's something that we'll follow up on to see if they've got documentation of what's in there. I don't believe, correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe there's any appropriate expenditures out of the general account. It's just basically a place to hold stuff that they
▶ Play
Speaker 39 46:10
haven't identified yet. That's absolutely correct. Okay. May I have Mr. Chair to staff? Correct. Go ahead, Senator
▶ Play
Hickey. But if they can never find, if your finding right here says that they cannot even tell you where it's supposed to go. So if they don't know and they can't figure it out, what's the process for
▶ Play
that at that point? Well, I think at some point then that has to go in just to the general operating account. That's what I would say that they would have to do with it eventually. Now, what we were saying was not that they couldn't tell us where it could go. we know that they don't know where it's going to go. That's why it's in this account. What we're looking for is a list of what's there so that we can tell that they're following up with it to make sure that it's getting to where it's going to go, not just sitting there
▶ Play
forever. But we think that they'll have authority if they do not know where it goes to transfer it out into general operating and that's... I
▶ Play
would think that'd be the only thing that they could do at that point. Most of these are, if y'all correct me if I'm wrong from DHS, but But most of these are, like, refund checks coming in or overpayments that have been made. So if they can't identify them, then it makes sense that that's where they would go.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. Okay. At the very least, I would just like for leg audits, you know, if they get the report with DF&A or whatever and how they're going to do it, that we get that and just make sure that it's done the way we believe it's appropriate.
▶ Play
Speaker 130 47:30
Okay, yeah. Every year we do that, Senator Hickey, we'll look at that and follow up on that without
▶ Play
a problem. Thank you, sir. And thank you, sir. Any more questions, committee? Representative. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Being that it's a rolling balance, are we drawing any interest on this large sum of money? I do not
▶ Play
Speaker 124 47:51
believe we are, sir. Why wouldn't we? I don't know at this point, sir. I can get back with you on the explanation. Okay. I mean, I
▶ Play
think the report says there's, what, $2 million in there? Yes, sir. Okay. I'd like to know about that. Yeah, I actually
▶ Play
asked that same question to Tom when we were discussing earlier. I don't know if there's some reason why, and that's such a short-term turnaround, they wouldn't be able to actually make an interest bearing off of it. But that'd be something I'd follow up on for sure. Any more questions from the committee? Final shot to all eight of them. Seeing none, I will accept a motion to file all the eight findings under this report. We have a motion. We have a second, all those in favor say aye, any opposed, thank you. Thank you. All right, the next meeting will be held on November 7th, 2019. And with that, this meeting is adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

A. Call to order by Chairman.

B. Adoption of minutes of the September 12, 2019 meeting.

ADOPTION OF MINUTES

1:56 - 34:46 138 segments 26 speakers

The committee heard the Arkansas Department of Corrections’ audit presentation on internal-audit breakdowns and missing testing documentation, with staff outlining corrective actions such as co-locating audit and fiscal personnel, and a motion to accept those findings passed unanimously. [2:14] [2:23] [2:30] [2:37] [2:46] [2:59] [3:04] [3:25] [3:35] [3:51] [3:58] [4:10] [4:30] [5:01]

The Administrative Office of the Courts’ mileage-reimbursement finding of $14,386 was explained by Judge H.G. Foster, who testified that the court reporter’s official station was the courthouse, the agency had halted reimbursements, instituted additional training and spot-check policies, and the committee moved to accept the finding after agreeing on future guidance, the motion carrying. [5:35] [6:06] [6:41] [7:13] [7:18] [7:36] [7:40] [7:45] [8:05] [8:07] [8:15] [8:20] [8:48] [8:57] [9:33] [10:04] [10:37] [11:07] [11:39] [12:00] [12:04] [12:10] [12:40] [13:11] [13:19] [13:38] [13:41] [13:49] [14:07] [14:18] [14:27] [14:34]

The Department of Education presented three audit issues-an improper $6,300 payment to a corporation owned by an employee, deficiencies in monitoring Arkansas Better Chance child-care providers, and unauthorized personal use of state-owned vehicles-and department officials described remedial steps; the committee then voted to file findings two and three, which was approved. [14:56] [15:26] [15:57] [16:28] [16:45] [17:04] [17:06] [17:13] [17:20] [17:38] [18:15] [18:45] [19:17] [19:25] [19:30] [19:40] [19:51] [19:56] [20:00] [20:05] [20:11] [20:22] [20:24] [20:36] [20:45] [20:52] [20:59] [21:19] [21:30] [21:35] [21:42] [21:48] [21:52] [21:58] [22:02] [22:15] [22:39] [22:44] [22:55]

The Department of Finance and Administration reported two cash-shortage incidents involving missing checks and employee misconduct, while the Department of Higher Education reported student-loan ledger mismatches and related vehicle-use issues; officials from both agencies described new dual-person controls and corrective actions, and the committee approved motions to file both reports. [23:11] [23:42] [24:09] [24:34] [25:03] [25:12] [25:37] [25:44] [25:52] [25:58] [26:14] [26:29] [26:35] [26:47] [26:52] [27:11] [27:17] [27:26] [27:32] [27:42] [27:46] [27:52] [27:55] [28:23] [28:32] [28:41] [28:54] [29:25] [29:58] [30:29] [30:47] [30:51] [30:57] [31:00] [31:07] [31:24] [31:32] [32:06] [32:36] [32:44] [32:59] [33:05] [33:08] [33:19] [33:39] [34:03] [34:10]

C. Review of reports. (Refer to the Summary)

REVIEW OF REPORTS

34:46 - 48:52 55 segments 9 speakers

Representative Fredrick J. Love presented the DHS audit findings, outlining eight issues such as duplicate check recordings that understated the agency’s balance by $61,000, improper monitoring of Medicaid drug rebate transfers, unallowable purchase of foster-care amusement-park season passes, questionable fuel-card charges, patient-fund overpayments, and a $2 million “general account” holding balance spanning 2012-2018. [35:11] [35:47] [36:17] [36:51] [37:23] [37:54] [38:25]

Agency officials-including Chief of Security Brett Hayes, Legislative Affairs Chief Mark White, and DCFS Director Martin-responded that corrective action plans were underway for the first and last findings and that internal controls had been created to address the remaining six findings. [39:43] [40:02] [40:19] [40:32] [40:55] [41:03] [41:35]

Committee members questioned the accounting of the season-ticket purchases and the unresolved large balance in the general account, prompting explanations of new approval and chain-of-custody procedures for tickets and a discussion that unidentified funds would eventually be transferred to the operating account. [40:19] [40:32] [40:55] [41:03] [41:35] [42:07] [42:38] [43:09] [43:23] [43:39] [43:56] [44:11] [44:17] [44:45] [45:08] [45:14] [45:17] [45:37] [45:44] [45:49] [45:53] [45:56] [46:10] [46:16] [46:24] [46:29] [46:35] [46:54] [46:56] [47:00]

The committee moved to file all eight findings into the legislative audit report; the motion was seconded, passed unanimously, and the next meeting was scheduled for November 7, 2019. [48:21] [48:35]

D. New Business. The next meeting will be held November 7, 2019

NEW BUSINESS

E. Adjournment.

MEETING ADJOURNED

Speakers

Senator Trent Garner Unverified
44 segments
Representative Fredrick J. Love Unverified
36 segments
Solomon Graves Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 10
3 segments
Chair Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 16
2 segments
Speaker 30
10 segments
Speaker 32
1 segment
Speaker 37
2 segments
Speaker 38
1 segment
Speaker 45
4 segments
Representative Jim Sorvillo Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 54
1 segment
Speaker 3
1 segment
Speaker 59
1 segment
Speaker 60
1 segment
Speaker 63
10 segments
Senator Jimmy Hickey, Jr Unverified
30 segments
Speaker 66
2 segments
Speaker 86
9 segments
Speaker 91
1 segment
Senator Jonathan Dismang Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 102
6 segments
Speaker 85
1 segment
Speaker 67
1 segment
Nick Fuller Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 115
4 segments
Speaker 119
5 segments
Speaker 124
5 segments
Speaker 39
1 segment
Speaker 130
1 segment