G. Arkansas Broadband Manager’s Report [EXHIBIT G] - Yessica Jones, Director, Department of Information Systems 34:20
The DIS Director Jessica Jones and Division Director Don McDaniel presented the semi-annual broadband report, noting an average fiber-installation cost of $18 per foot, modest gains in broadband access and speed, increased electric-cooperative participation, and upcoming K-12 network data from Education Superhighway.
[35:23][35:34][35:44][35:49][35:53][35:58][36:08][36:42][37:12][37:42][38:16]
Senator Mark Johnson queried whether the Connect America Fund applies a means-test that excludes wealthier households, and members discussed the complexities of eligibility and funding mechanisms without reaching a resolution.
[41:29][41:35][42:03][42:35][43:08][43:33][43:44]
I. Information Network of Arkansas, Legislative Reports on Fee Changes [EXHIBIT I] - Bob Sanders, General Manager, Information Network of Arkansas 52:43
Bob Sanders (General Manager) and Christy Williams (Director of Operations) introduced the Information Network of Arkansas, explained its public-private partnership model funded through user fees approved quarterly by a governor-appointed board, and presented service-authorization reports from three board meetings covering 2019 rates, which included 37 new services at a standard 3 % + $1 fee and eight fee-free services.
[52:55][53:12][53:17][53:22][53:26][53:32][54:05][54:35][55:10]
Representative Jim Sorvillo suggested adding a highway-debris reporting feature to iDriveArkansas.com; INA staff indicated the concept is technically feasible and would require coordination with the Department of Transportation or state police, but no decision was made at the hearing.
[56:32][56:51][57:48][57:58][58:05][58:10][58:19]
The committee clarified INA’s contracting arrangement (managed by the Arkansas Information Consortium) and then adopted the report as reviewed by unanimous aye vote.
[52:55][53:12]
I'd like to ask everyone for us to stop and have a moment of silence this morning. I think most everyone has heard the news that we lost a friend and a colleague last night. And as the first legislative committee meeting, since that news became available, I would like to ask in her memory that we pause for a moment of silence and thanksgiving for her life and for her service to the state of Arkansas. So if you would, please join me in that moment of silence for a few moments. All right, thank you. Also another bit of news before we get down to the business at hand today. Ever since I've been the chair of this committee, sitting to my right has been Ms. Smith. She has been an incredible analyst for the committee, always there, and unfortunately this is going to be her last meeting with us as the analyst. She's going to be retiring at the end of the month, and I just wanted to pause and say how much we appreciate her and the work and dedication that she's shown over the years to not only this committee, but to the citizens of Arkansas, so we just want to say thank you. She said she was fully prepared to give a long speech, but we're going to pass this morning. But again, thank you for your service. So first thing we need to do is to do a motion to authorize the chairs to approve any special expenses that come up in the committee. And so we've got a motion. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right, so that motion is adopted. The next little bit of business, we need to adopt the minutes from the December 11th meeting. Your motion on that? Motion. All right. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Okay, so we'll consider that adopted. The item E on the agenda, the ISP by Representative Whitaker, he's not here this morning. asked that we skip it over so he could present that to the committee at a future time. So we're going to go ahead and dig into the meat of the meeting this morning. We have a couple of annual reports that the committee
has to look at. Mr. Chairman, excuse me, before we get to, I saw on the agenda we're having several speakers, but are we going to ever have the high-cost fund, the chair of the high-cost fund, the director of the high-cost fund in front of
could have him at our next meeting, I think that would be essential because we have a couple of pieces of legislation that will probably be affecting the high-cost fund coming
up. Sure. Yeah, that sounds good to me. Anything else before we jump into this? Okay. Seeing none, let's go ahead and I'm going to ask Mr. Smith, if you would please introduce yourself and tell us about the broadband plan. Make sure your microphone is on, please, sir. Does that work? Okay.
I'm Nathan Smith. I'm the economic policy director at the Arkansas Development and Finance Authority, and we've been on operation for a couple of years to deal with a lot of different projects, usually stuff that kind of pinch hitting where something doesn't fall into any other obvious niche. This was kind of a difficult project that came along. It was specifically related to the USDA ReConnect plan. And so the USDA has a new program called ReConnect, or the Broadband E-Connectivity Pilot Project. I can't remember whether the longer version of it is, but it's $600 million of money that they're currently working on allocating nationally on a competitive basis to ISPs who apply for the funds. And I could talk a lot more about it. We've been working on this quite a bit, helping ISPs to get applications ready and sometimes advocating for alterations in the portal. We've gotten pretty far into the weeds on this. But one of the aspects of this was that ISPs got 10 points on their application if there was a state broadband plan in existence that had been published within the last five years. And so there were documents that possibly we could have argued meant this standard, but it seemed like somewhat questionable, and so it seemed worthwhile to really bring some minds together and put something in writing that would pass this test. And so that was the origin of this, and that's what drove some of the deadline settings. So the first deadline for USDA Reconnect was May 31st. We targeted May 1st as a date for disseminating this plan. It ended up being like May 15, but still pretty ample time for ISPs to be aware of it and use it in their applications. So we consulted with a lot of stakeholders in the course of compiling the plan. For one thing, we spoke to ISPs. We spoke to other state agencies that had a stake in this in one way or another. So Ag Extension, for example, helped us out a lot, and DIS especially with sort of kind of co-equal partners, I think, in the development of this, and also civil society groups. So we reached out to Farm Bureau, and I mean, we reached out to a lot of them who never got back to us, but these are some of the ones that were more engaged. So an ad fund DIS kind of led in coordinating that. So the general problem is that people need broadband connectivity for more and more purposes. It's extremely important. And it's to the point where government probably can't really be indifferent to whether people have it or not because even government itself needs people to have broadband or transact with them and like finding out where voting booths are and informing the police if there's a disaster. Lots and lots of different reasons. Students doing their homework and so forth. But a lot of Arkansans lack even access to broadband defined as low-latency, high-bandwidth internet service. Satellite is pretty much available everywhere, so at least there's that. But in many cases, you can't get wireline service. You can't get something that would be recognized as sort of quality modern internet. And so this is sometimes called the digital divide between places that have broadband access and places that don't. And so that's the problem that we're hoping to tackle. There are a lot of companies doing this. Broadband now estimates that there are 136 ISPs in Arkansas. But in spite of that, they estimate 251,000 people don't have any wired Internet providers where they are. 641,000 lack access to service at a speed of 25 megabits per second download speed, speed, which is beginning to be considered kind of the standard, although in some areas you 10 megabits per second download speed is available, and that is certainly sufficient for many purposes, but not really, it's being a little bit left behind by the way the internet evolves, so there's things you can't do. And many others have access to only one wired internet provider, and I'll show some maps that give a little bit more detail about the competitive landscape in the state. Overall, broadband now at this point considers Arkansas the 50th most connected state, and that's fluctuated up and down. Sometimes we've been 47th or something, but we're certainly near the bottom of those tables, so it would be nice to do something about that. It's kind of a regional problem. This is a little bit old data from 2015, but it does show it's not just Arkansas. Most of Arkansas's neighbors are also affected by this somewhat. So, Governor Hutchinson set a goal which was then promulgated in the plan and that is partly what it helps to be a plan. I mean, otherwise, there would be a risk if they're just an informational document. But I think there is some commitment to this goal, some idea that this is how it should be, that at least in population centers, maybe not deep in the rural areas, maybe not if you're high up on the mountainside, but at least if you're living in a town, then you You should have 25-3 broadband access available. And I think he figured by the end of his second term would be a reasonable date to set to try to achieve that goal. And this is a map we made estimating how close we are to achieving that goal. Now, the green, generally speaking, the green is where it's been met. The red is where it hasn't been met. Now I should add a caveat here. is data from the FCC Form 477, which tends to, in some ways, overstate Internet coverage because it asks for the maximize advertised speed in every census block, but it's also a little bit out of date because it takes a while for this data to go through the pipeline from when they collect it from the ISPs to when it gets published and turns into something that we can use to make our maps. So probably the situation's a little bit better than this, actually, but we had ISPs writing to us and be like, hey, wait, there is Internet service in that area. I'm like, sorry, you know, we've got slightly obsolete data, but, you know, we do our best. This is similar information. This is shown as a share of population. So the dark green is where it's almost all covered. In Little Rock, you see there are some areas that still don't have 25.3 Internet, but it's a very small percentage of the population. So Little Rock's reasonably well served. But there are a lot of other towns that have very little broadband access, and those communities certainly feel it. And, you know, as we've gone around the state, some will say, yeah, we're just desperate to get broadband down here. We didn't make any commitments to funding broadband deploying with general revenue in the plan. I'm not aware of the governor ever having made any commitment of that sort. The focus instead was on making optimal use of federal programs that promote rural broadband, which do have quite a bit of money, and it seems to be expanding somewhat. So I think that's probably where the biggest opportunity lies, is just in using those federal programs to achieve this goal. But, of course, you're the legislators, and you may have lots of other ideas, which we'd be very interested in hearing and thinking about. And I'll tread a step very lightly here, but we do have some stuff on it in the plan, which had the governor's endorsement. And so I'll mention we did nudge towards maybe consider exploring some options for adjusting the state policy environment so that it favors faster and more efficient deployment. Possibly this could have something to do with pull attachment policies. Possibly this could have something to do with the Arkansas High Cost Fund. There may be clever ways of leveraging state assets, but I wouldn't say we see any low-hanging fruit here and we didn't take any bold stands on what should be done. And I think in each of these cases, it's easy to propose sort of simplistic, naive solutions, but in fact, there are a lot of reasons why the status quo is the way it is. It's really, really complicated. I certainly wouldn't say that it's optimal, but there are reasons why it is the way it is. So, probably not a lot of low-hanging fruit, but I think it is worth something to keep thinking about. So federal programs, the biggest agencies involved in this are the FCC and the USDA. And the FCC has a lot of different programs. I couldn't go into all of them here, but some big ones to note. So the Connect America Fund 2 has been financing a lot of the build-out for years. That's what's been, for the past few years, spending the most money and probably getting the most locations served. Connect America model has also helped some of the smaller telecoms build out as well. The CAF2 auction 903 took place last summer, and Arkansas got about $50 million in 10-year funding allocated mostly to the rural electric co-ops, but a few other companies as well to build out broadband in some rural parts of the state. That's important in itself because it's going to lead to a lot of locations being served, mostly with fiber, so cutting edge, the best internet you can get. But also, this is likely to be the model for what's called the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund going forward. This isn't set in stone, but based on some statements that Chairman Pai of the FCC has said, then the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund, which will probably have $20.4 billion in 10-year funding, so that's a lot of money, will probably be modeled not on the Connect America cost model that they've been doing, that CAF2's been allocating money through before, but instead on some kind of a reverse auction model on the CAF2 auction 903. So that's not for sure yet, but it's something to think about in terms of the strategy of how can ISPs get the money they need in order to build out broadband in places where the The business case isn't strong enough just based on what revenues you can get from customers. Another one to mention, Mobility Fund 2 auction is going to be allocating $4.53 billion to cell phone companies to improve cell phone coverage in rural areas. And so USDA is also interesting. So the ReConnect program, which is allocating $600 million in one-time funds right now, or trying to. We'll see how many applicants they get, how many people pass the test. Maybe some of it gets rolled over next year. But if all goes well, 600 million. And so it's about a third, like on an annualized basis, roughly, USDA is probably going to be handing out about a third as much. And they have some other programs, too, but ReConnect is by far the biggest one right now. And there's some other agencies that do it, too, Department of Commerce, HUD, there's some others, but FCC and USDA are by far the biggest. So in terms of what the current situation looks like, this is a map we put together They're based on FCC data, Form 477, the same data sources I showed progress towards the governor's goal. This is the whole state. And shows the maximum advertised speed. So the darker green, the better. And most of the time, it looks quite a bit slower in rural areas than it does in urban areas. That's a general pattern. But there's big exceptions, like ArcWest Communications out in River Valley. They have fiber to all their territory, so you have that big block of green there, some parts of southern Arkansas too. So it's not always exactly what you'd expect. I won't go into too much depth about this, but there's a lot of different ways that broadband can be delivered. DSL goes over the old twisted pair copper wires, the telephone network, and it's hard to get cutting edge speeds, but the telephone network has very broad reach, so sometimes that's most widely available. The whole modem goes over the coaxial copper wires that were installed to distribute cable TV, and that you can get pretty good speeds. It's mostly in somewhat more urban areas where there's a cable TV company. Fiber optic cable is considered the best, future-proof. The signal travels faster, it's at the speed of light, the capacity is enormous, and there's some other small advantages like security because you don't emit a signal and so forth. It's considered the cutting edge and probably never, you're never going to better it. But it does involve a lot of investment and a lot of times if you have coaxial wires in the ground already, it may not be worth it because coax may be able to meet people's needs. So fixed wireless I think is somewhat novel. This is based on the same wireless distribution principles as a cell phone, but they have directional broadcasting where if you have, instead of shooting the signal in all directions at the same time, if you know you have a particular receiver you're aiming at, a little bit like a satellite dish, but it's aimed at a tower instead of into outer space, then that improves performance in a lot of ways. And this arguably can really be pretty competitive with some of the wireline options with a lot less capital investment up front. And mobile data, probably all of you have smartphones with mobile data plans on them. In some ways, it's great. You carry it around with you wherever you go and if service improved enough people might switch to just using mobile data but of course it's affected by data caps speeds aren't usually quite as good and so on so um so but it's an option for people especially if you don't have super data intensive internet habits uh you can offer this and then satellite which is available everywhere but it's just built it has high latency that there's no way to get around that because it has to go you know 20,000 miles into outer space and come back down and then go back up to get a signal turned around. So those are some of the technologies that are used. I'll show maps of the availability based on technology. So DSL, first of all, pretty widespread, though certainly not everywhere. And the colors indicate particular companies, and I'm sure you won't have time to read the particular companies, but one thing that I wanted to draw attention to is that we have a black-gray color in the legend for places where there are more than one company providing, and that's more than one in a census block, so they may not be competing at the level of individual addresses, but the main thing to note is there's hardly any black and gray there. There's really no competition here, and most of the technologies this is true for. There's one local monopoly provider. This is one reason, I think, why this tends to be a heavily regulated space with statutes intervening a lot more. I mean, if you want fast food, you can go to Taco Bell, Burger King, McDonald's. You've got a whole selection, not infinite, but maybe in a small town, you might not have much, but generally there's competition and we rely on competition to make the service quality decent and so forth. But in broadband service, you tend not to have competition for a given technology. Sometimes there's competition among technologies. So you might, if you don't want to do DSL, you might have a cable modem provider available, but because they're offering it different by different technologies, there's just going to be an inherent differences in performance. And so that limits the competitiveness of the market. Here's cable availability. The colors tend to be a little darker. That's because the speeds tend to be faster. Performance tends to be a bit better here, but it's not available everywhere, and particularly it tends to be available in more built-up urban areas and not reaching out into rural areas. Here's fiber, somewhat counterintuitive. If anything, it sometimes looks more like in rural areas than it is in urban areas, and that's because the cable's already been built out. If the cable's there, you might not feel the need to upgrade to fiber. And so fiber sometimes gets installed more in rural areas where you're not having to justify. You're basically jumping up from DSL to fiber or jumping up from nothing to fiber. If you're building new now, you probably want to build with fiber. But if you already have coax on the ground, it may or may not be worth it. Fixed wireless availability, and the map has a bit of a different shape because if you have a tower, it can shoot in a lot of different directions. So it covers an area, and the map looks a little bit kind of blobby like that. Another thing to draw attention to is the gray areas. That's where you have competitors. Fixed wireless, because you have a tower that shoots in a lot of different directions, you don't have to be digging wires to every house, then competition is a little bit more feasible here. It's more a future in which you have a highly competitive fixed wireless broadband industry is sort of plausible in a way that a highly competitive cable modem industry is not. This shows, over all technologies, the number of competitors offering 10-1 internet. And we have just white, nobody's offering it. Light green, one company's offering it. Or darker green, two or more companies are offering it. And substantial parts of the map where there's competition, but certainly not most of Arkansas having competition, even for 10-1 speed, which is now starting to be considered a little bit antiquated. This is for 25-3, zero versus one versus two or more providers. And so there you see considerably more larger coverage gap if you're measuring it by that standard. So some information on state broadband activity, Obviously, the state broadband plan recently published, and also legislative activity. And, I mean, you guys will know more about this than we do, I guess. But for Act 792 passed, state broadband manager will be named by the governor. And I don't know the latest on that process, so I won't answer questions about that. But, you know, the plan, there would be a state broadband office, that being more of a dedicated position, rather than just like an extra title to, you know, attached to leaving the Department of Information Services. Act 198 of 2019, this removes barriers for municipal broadband, municipalities deploying broadband themselves, which previously was disallowed, but now there's more scope for them being able to do that. I think based on having talked to stakeholders, there may be some confusion about exactly what that permits or not. So I think the broadband plan, I mean, we wanted to be tactful, but there was kind of a suggestion, and there may be room to clarify this, educate municipalities about what exactly rights they have under Act 198. Act 813 of 2017 allows for public-private partnerships, and this is, I don't think this has really been implemented yet. I mean, it's basically, somebody has to write the rules. It's very, very complicated, and other people can speak to that better than I can. I don't know how live of an option this is, but in principle, it's appealing to be able to set up public-private partnerships, do this in a new way, and probably most, maybe most important, Act 999 of 2019. Now, to be honest, this was passed on April 17th. By that time, the broadband plan had already been circulated to stakeholders and feedback had been received and been sent to the governors. It was a little bit too late at that point. We were planning to distribute in a couple of weeks. It was a little bit too late at that point for us to dig into this pretty complex piece of legislation and try to master what it did and explain that in the broadband plan. So there's just a paragraph in there, and it really deserves more. Um, but, um, but it establishes a detailed policy framework for deploying small cells and, um, and other people in the room could, could say more than I could, um, would understand that better, I'm sure than, than I would. But I think that is an important piece of legislation. I mean, I'd say what it does is really important. What it's trying to do is really important. Whether it does it well, I can't say because I haven't dug into it enough. Um, and, um, yeah, I guess, I guess that's all. and I'll be happy to answer questions as best I can.
All right. Thank you, Mr. Brown. The first question I had was a statement that you started off right from the beginning that you were working with ISPs. That's one of the concerns I always had is how the state was proactively reaching out to ISPs to help them. So can you kind of expand upon that? How are you guys talking to these local ISPs to let them know what resources are available, help them through the red tape of the
bureaucracy and so forth? So, yeah, that's a very good question. And we sent out to ISPs when we were asking for inputs on the state broadband plan. We also added that we could try to provide technical assistance to apply for USDA Reconnect. And so we've had two companies come to us, and, I mean, I could probably disclose that, but I want to be a little bit careful just because I don't know what they would think about that. Um, and, um, and myself and my senior economist, Nicholas Aguilakakis, um, especially, I'd say, have, uh, done some pretty, uh, complicated technical work, um, trying to come up with, um, service areas that will, uh, get good scores on, um, the, for the USDA ReConnect applications. Um, and we'll see whether our help actually turns out to, uh, be helpful. I am hoping that it will. This is one of these cases where, you know, if we're successful, we turn to our cans and taxpayers on the little bit of our salaries that is dedicated to this time compared to the amount of federal money that could come down is enormous. And I think it's very intimidating sometimes to deal with these federal programs. And so this seems like something that the state can do. And, you know, that's been
one of my concerns is because you're right, because it is can be intimidating and especially for some of the smaller ISPs and having someone to coach them through it, I think, is a huge. And I know you've sent out letters, but as and you may may not have, but as opportunity as allows, I would be I would like to see being even more proactive. And that may become after the governor appoints a broadband manager at some point in the future. Any other questions from the committee?
Representative Love? Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Dr. Smith, actually, I was not even aware that ADFA had a broadband department, I guess. So when did you all, when did ADFA establish this? I'm
just curious. Sure. So a little back story on us. So my division was the brainchild of Aaron Burks, who was formerly one of your colleagues, a legislator. And he's, I'd say, a very creative policy thinker, very energetic, very much of a connector, very conservative and free marketeer. And so he had a vision for a division that would bring kind of more expertise into state government, maybe so that we'd be able to do some of the stuff that otherwise would be outsourced to consultants and just participate in a wide variety of policymaking conversations. And since then, I'd say we've worked on a lot of different policy areas from inland waterways to school facilities to public health, tobacco policy to federal tax policy, state tax policy, providing macroeconomic intelligence for the governor's office most recently broadband workforce analysis um and uh we don't really have uh power but uh we have maybe we have influence we have we we just try to provide um i don't know i guess brain power on demand when somebody's wrestling with a problem that seems to be a little bit too challenging and i think this was one where we felt like okay this is a really complicated policy space let's pull these these guys in and see
two and a half years two and a half years okay all right i need some information on that on your division so i can better understand because i'm familiar with that i'm just not familiar with your division so that that's good um number two um mr chair i guess i'm trying to understand because i we've been grappling with this broadband issue for a while. So can you tell me or is there a figure that providers usually put on the table for how much it costs for fiber to be ran? So say, for instance, I'm just going to give you a concept. So when we're dealing with the R-DOT, we say a mile of road is x amount of dollars so could you actually give me a figure or is there usually a figure associated with providing like a mile of fiber or x amount of feet of fiber or different things like well
that because i mean i've usually heard the figures quoted um on a per household basis in some ways what you're talking about would be even more instructive but um
because i mean Because that way we can kind of wrap our head around the concept of when people say, oh, it's cost prohibitive to do X or it's not feasible to do Y, then if we were to have a figure, then we could say, okay, we can understand why we are not in this area or why we're number 50.
Yeah, that's a good point. So a couple figures I've heard, I've heard figures quoted $6,000 to $7,000 times the number of households served. That I think I'm remembering rightly from the state broadband officer in Minnesota, who's been, Minnesota's been very proactive in providing grants to get broadband rolled out. And then I heard a figure $2,500 per household for the subsidy that would be needed to close the business case. This is complicated. It depends on a lot of things. Obviously, it depends on technology, but it also depends on which technology you're using. So, for example, fixed wireless would be cheaper than fiber. But it also depends on the terrain. So it's harder to, if it's rock, that's a lot harder than if it's, you know, farmland. It depends on other claims on the property. Sometimes it's a lot more expensive per 100 meters or something in cities where there are a lot of other claims on the land than it would be in rural areas where the land is easy to get. But on the other hand, you can serve a lot more households with 100 meters of fiber in the cities than you can in rural areas. So the population density is an important factor. There's the mileage on the roads, and then you want to know whether the backbone is there already because if the backbone comes close and you just need to build it out a little ways, then that's a lot cheaper than if you have to build a lot of middle-mile infrastructure before you can do the last mile. There's the cost of digging along the street, and then there's the cost of actually connecting the homes. So you could separate separate those. So I think it I think it's a complicated picture of costs. And those numbers of like maybe seven thousand ish, six thousand ish in total cost per household and twenty five hundred in the subsidy that would be needed are just very crude ballpark figures just to kind of orient you. So is there any way we could we could actually
come up with a figure like come up with a figure for the whole state? Well, I mean, I just want to know how much it would cost to run a mile of fiber. Or, I mean, I'm just trying to. Representative Love, I
may be able to help with that because that's some of the information the providers have given to us. If it's a, like, if you're over in the Delta and you're working through sand, it may be a couple thousand dollars. If you're up in the Ozarks and you're trying to dig through granite for that same mile, you could be looking at tens of thousands of dollars for that same mile of fiber. And then you get into, is it cheaper to string it across the poles? In which case, it doesn't cost a whole lot to string it across the poles, but then the expense becomes every month you're paying that pole attachment fee. So you're looking at a monthly fee versus a one-time large capital to dig through that rock, if that helps. But he's right. It varies all over the place depending on
what the situation is. And the subsidy is less than the total cost because the ISP, who ends up being in a position to provide Internet, Well, they can get something at least from customers in most cases, and so they don't need to have all their costs covered most of the time. And I think part of what these auction mechanisms that the FCC is setting up, is trying to do, is to, through competition, through making ISPs compete with each other, to reveal the costs in a way that's difficult to do if you're just going to talk to them directly. Because as soon as they think the government is going to finance it, of course, they have every reason to inflate what the costs are. And there could be very legitimate ways to do that if there's risks that they're not sure about or discretionary improvements of service security and so forth. But the auction mechanism is really designed to say, okay, well, let's make you compete with each other. Let's see how low you're really willing to go in order to
Thank you. Yeah, which I think the committee members, at least I got a email. So we may have already got that. But if you need help with that, if you'll get with Ms. Smith. Okay. Any other questions? All right. Saying none, thank you, sir, and we appreciate your report to us this morning. Thank you. Next, we're going to move to the director of DIS for the broadband's manager's report and the rate adjustment, and I guess, director, I'm assuming there's probably a lot of duplicative information based upon what we heard and based upon what you're going to tell us. So I would just ask to highlight the pertinent points that we haven't heard yet. Maybe that's the politically correct way to say that. And
DIS. And Mr. Chairman, you're absolutely correct. I think Mr. Smith did a great job presenting the overall what does their environment look like in Arkansas as far as broadband goes. So that's kind of what our report talks about as well. But I'm going to let Mr. McDaniel talk about some of the highlights on our report.
And the question a while ago for Dr. Smith on the cost of fiber, when we were looking, and this is not current, when we were looking at the K-12. Mr. McDaniel, I'm sorry, can you
clear. Thank you, sir. I can do that. When we were looking at the K-12 network, whether the state would want to do that themselves, provide the fiber, provide the network, or outsource it to vendors, we end up going with vendors, the cost per foot of fiber, just placement, and granted, you've got the rock in northwest Arkansas, You've got the Delta. So just as an average, $18 a foot was a broad gauge price for placing fiber, and that would be in the ground. So I just want to mention that. We do this report or produce this report every six months. This is from December, so it's maybe a little dated information. There should be another one coming out this month. On page one, the key findings, the percentage of our Kansas with access to defined broadband is up a little bit from the last six-month report. The average speed is up a little bit. Electric cooperatives are getting more and more into the business of providing broadband. They own the poles, so it's lower cost for them. They don't have to pay pole attachments. They're poles. So that's increasing. and then as dr. Smith mentioned the calf fund awarded and we have a little the broadband now information we were looking at at the time said we had moved from 48 to 45th so we're going in the right direction still still at the bottom whether we're 50th or 48th or 45th we're still we need to go up I guess The other thing that I want to mention that's in here on page 5 is what Education Superhighway had produced related to our K-12 network, so it's all good. Education Superhighway has given notice that they're getting out of the business. So I guess a lot of that is because a lot of headway, not just Arkansas, but across the nation has been made in providing bandwidth to schools. And the rest of this is just information that backs up the key points. Some of our maps look at things a little differently. We're looking at more of a state view, and some of the data, as Dr. Smith mentioned, is dated coming from the FCC, and it's by census block, which is generally overstates what is out there. So are there any questions? I mean, that's really, unless you want something specifically covered, that's.
Senator Hammer? Thank you. When it comes to using polls as far as the means of distributing it out there, the company that owns the poll has negotiated the terms of the right-of-way for those polls to sit on.
Is that correct? Well, historically, that's been the case, of course, with the legislation that you all produced that is not, doesn't say 5G in it, but it is really for small sales. There's some, some, what word am I looking for? So a framework of how that should be done as far as pole attachments, because some, some owners of poles are, I'm hearing, tend to inflate the cost. they want maybe the pole replaced to even allow you to attach. So it supposedly should improve that whole process on pole attachments. And do
like to find that out, if you don't mind. Because if we've got polls sitting on state right-of-way property that was purchased by the state or by the county or municipality or whatever, I'm just curious how that traces back when it comes to the request to raise the cost on those polls if their origination is sitting on property that's owned by the state or municipality or county. That's a very good question. Good point. If you could find that out, or Dr. Smith or somebody in the room find that out, I'd like to know how many polls are sitting out there on state-owned property that we're paying on.
We'll work on getting you that answer. And, Senator, there are several providers in the room. To the providers in the room, can any of you answer that question? Do you have polls that sit on state? Do you pay anything to the state for that? Is there anybody that can help with that question? But that's probably something that our PSC, probably, they would be the ones that would be the agency over that. But that's a good question. If we could get that
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I guess Mr. McDaniels should take this question. It talks about the Connect America Fund. I've had a situation in my district where I have an area that is just literally has no broadband at all, except for the satellite, of course. And my constituent contacted me. I talked to folks at AT&T and asked them about Connect America and all that. And they mentioned that, in essence, this is done by census block. And that, I mean, I'm going to paraphrase. I see someone nodding over here. Basically what they said, and I'm paraphrasing what they said, is too many people live in that area are too rich, and so they can't access this fund. And so it's the old and this is an area where you might have, you know, a million dollar, you know, 40 acre estate and then, you know, across the road is a trailer and that's fine. We like the neighborhood. But the point is that they seem to be having a means test on everything they do. Is that the case of that fund or other funds where if there's too many rich people in the area, that it basically keeps everybody there from getting the broadband assistance? The whole thing, because every time you look at your phone bill, whether it's home phone or cell phone, you see how much they're taking out for universal service. And I know I'm generally talking about telephone there, but these technologies are all merging. I mean, we get our broadband off the same thing we talk on now. And with 5G being implemented, it's hopefully closing both those gaps. But is there some means test thing that is turning out to be an impediment to actually getting this implemented for everyone, regardless of their income level? I don't have the answer to that. That's a very
you. Oh, I'm sorry. Senator? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And you may not be able to answer this, but I think a lot of the power companies in the state now are starting to look at running their own fiber on their own poles. I know Clarksville Light and Water, they've changed their name to something. But I know that they're interested in putting fiber in their serving area. And maybe Arkansas Valley Electric, one of the co-ops, they're here that they're interested in running fiber in a lot of their area also. How many, have you heard about that? Is this something that is of interest to the power companies? and actually how do they do that? Do they have to have a certain, do they have to have a tariff or something changing to allow the power companies to provide this service? Well,
the power companies, I think more of the rural electric cooperatives, I think. Maybe the power companies, maybe like Energy, the larger ones, and municipally owned power like Clarksville. And I talked to those folks, or they called, and we talked. because they'd like to connect the state network and provide connectivity to state agencies, boards and commissions that are in Clarksville, that they see it as a good business. Like I was mentioning a while ago, they own the pole. So in that respect, there's not an extra cost to attach. And they're using passive optical technology, which is fine for that kind of distribution. I don't know. I don't think they have. They're not. They're a competitor to, like, any ISP. So I don't see them having to file anything with the Public Service Commissioner. Really, Internet is federal, so it's FCC. I don't know of anything that they have to do to get into that business. Okay. I
didn't know if maybe the PSC had some qualifications that they had to meet in order to be a provider of Internet service broadband or whatever, but I think that that's a great idea if the power companies can do that because they have power lines that run all over the country, through the mountains and everywhere else. And I don't know whether they would be their own provider of that or whether they would go to a local telco to get that service? Well, their connection
to the greater Internet, if you will, they're buying that from somebody, but they're buying in bulk. They're buying a large amount, so the cost per unit is less than it would be if an individual wanted a smaller amount of bandwidth. So they buy it and then distribute it. And I think a number of co-ops are in this business, and it really helps their members because they can provide very cost-effective, high-bandwidth service to their members. Okay. Thank you.
Okay. Any other questions? Okay. Seeing none, and you should all have a copy of that report there in front of you. We'll go ahead and move on to the rate adjustment report and the – as soon as you get settled there, if you would
Officer, DIS. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. In front of you, you have our proposed rate adjustment for fiscal year 2020. These are the rates that are based on estimates and forecasts. We take, you know, some of the factors that we use to calculate these estimates and forecasts. We base them on customer increases or decreases and, of course, on vendor cost change. The good news, the overall rate recommendation results in reduced cost to customers of approximately $1.3 million annually. So what that means, we're reducing, we have cost savings for our customers, any public entity. One of the biggest reduction is in disk storage. Our rate for fiscal year 19 was of $0.29 per gigabyte, and for fiscal year 20, we're bringing that rate down to $0.15 per gigabyte. And
that's for hosting on the state cloud, server over West Little Rock, essentially? That's correct. talking about. And would I be correct in saying the more we get state agencies to do that, the more it's going to drive the cost down for state agencies? Is that correct? Absolutely. That's correct. We love to hear those efficiencies. Thank you. Anything else before we go to the committee? No. No, sir. Okay. Committee members, any questions? Senator? thank
you and and as briefly as you can just for those of us that are new to the committee um can you just give me a summary of of what you just said and how it relates to all the uh agencies that you provide service to could you just give me like a two minute summary of of what you do and and how all that you just said ties into the rate reductions please One-on-one class
in two minutes or less, please. Okay, that's good. Yes, sir. So, the EIS is a cost recovery agency, so we provide services for any public entity, all executive branch agencies, boards and commissions, cities, counties, K through 12. Whenever we provide a service, we are required to, I lost my train of thought, to recover our cost, I apologize, to recover our cost. And therefore, to your point, when we provide a service, think about DI as buying in bulk again. So instead of an agency buying for a server, right, now we have the power, we leverage economies of a scale so that if we buy in bulk, we are able to reduce their rates.
So you want to take it? So as Director Jones mentioned, we are a cost recovery agency, so we take the costs that vendors charge us, whether it's for internet connectivity, telephone services, or software server services, and collect that cost and distribute to our customers. So since we are required to recover our costs, the fewer customers we have, it tends to run the rate up. So in the situation with the disk storage, as that customer base builds, those fixed costs get allocated across more people, therefore reducing the rates.
proven, your agency has proven that you can do it cheaper than, say, a private provider that would come in and do it for the state, and you have that documentation to show the comparison between
vendor and which ones would be better for DIS to perform. And are you the only agency that charges a service to state agencies or recoups for providing a service to state agencies that you know?
I'll stop there. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And it may help, Senator Hammer. They don't get general revenue, so their funding is by charging their customers. So they have to charge the customers to fund their
budget. So essentially that's what they're doing. Question to the chair then. Yes, sir. They don't have a percentage of markup. You are true cost only, and that applies to your compensation for your salary package, to your employers. So, there's not a hidden cost driving up your costs that you're charging back to the agency. No, sir. No, there's
no profit component for that. All right. Thank you. Okay. Any other questions? Okay. This is an item that we do have to review. So, if I could entertain a motion, got a motion to consider this reviewed. Any discussion on the motion? Got a second. All right. Seeing no discussion, all in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay, we will consider that reviewed. Last item on the agenda for today is, if I can find what I do with my agenda. Thank you. Mr. Sanders from the Information Network of Arkansas. When you get settled in there, sir, if you would, just please introduce yourself to the committee, and then you're recognized. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Bob
So we're here today presenting the service authorizations and rates approved by the Information Network of Arkansas board going back to September 11, 2018. And I know there are several new committee members, so before we dig into these reports, I'd just briefly like to give you some context for who INA is and what these service authorizations are all about. So the Information Network of Arkansas is a public-private partnership that was formed by legislation in 1995 with the sole mission to expand access to government services and information in Arkansas. And since 1997, INA has developed and supports the ongoing operation of about 1,000 online services and websites for state and local government entities, about 300 of those. These are services that you're probably familiar with, idrivearkansas.com, arkansas.gov, the state's online vehicle, tag renewal service, services like that. Thousands of citizens use these services each year to process millions of secure online government transactions, and that's all at no cost to the government. That's possible because our operation is primarily funded through fees that are paid by the citizens and businesses who choose to use those services. INA is overseen by a 12-member, governor-appointed board that approves all the fees that are charged for these services. The board meets each quarter to approve the rates, and pursuant to Act 550 of 2015, we report to this committee all of the rates that the INA board has approved. It's been a few quarters since we've shared these reports with you in person, so today we're presenting the service rate authorization reports from INA board meetings held on September 11th, December 4th, and May 30th of this year, which encompasses rates for services launched in the first two quarters of 2019. I don't want to read these reports to you, so I'm just going to hit some of the highlights, and if you have any questions, we can dig into them. So since the third quarter of 2018, the INA board has approved rates for 37 new services with convenience or user fees attached. All of these fall into our standard rate structure, so there's really nothing new or different. there. Most of them are 3% plus a dollar for most transactions. These are online and over-the-counter payments for several agencies. For example, the pharmacy board, pharmacists can now go into the office and renew their professional license by swiping their credit card. We stood up an online crash report service for state police and dozens of court filing services for the state's court automation project. There were zero changes to existing fees. Eight new services launched with no fees. For example, we redesigned Governor Hutchinson's website, and we launched a really cool driver's practice exam for state police. It's available on mobile app and also on Alexa and Google Home. And there were zero compulsory or mandatory user fees. So those are the highlights, and if you
ahead. Okay, any questions? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I did some research in 2015 concerning debris on the highways and I had talked to the highway department at the time that I felt, and as you know, there's an app called Wave. Are you familiar with that? And what I would like to have seen is that we would be able to post on, especially the major interstates there, an app, whereas a person could actually report a big tire in the road, which, as a lot of people know, that those are dangerous and they cost citizens a lot of money when you run over them. Yeah. And so, yeah, well, yes. Anyway, I was just asking, is that a feasible, I mean, is there, could there be a connection to, I mean, I know there's some downsides, but I think with, what do we have, 10 districts out there that, where that marker was, 126, if you could, if you could, on your app, identify it. then we could, you know, readily get it off the road, and I think that would, you know, would help us with safety and damage. That's just a question. I'll see what you can share with me.
So, yes, from a technical standpoint, there's nothing that would prevent either the Department of Transportation or the state police from integrating that into iDriveArkansas.com. They do partner on that application, so there's an exchange of data there. They'd want to consider things like, you know, would they accept one report or would they want to see multiple reports before they would actually act on it? So there's some safety things that they'd want to take into consideration. We manage those applications on behalf of those agencies, so if that's something that they wanted to do, we would work with them on it. I'd be happy to bring
that up to them and see what they thought about it. Follow-up. You know, they post the phone number. I think where I saw the real challenge there is, while someone's driving, the fact that you have to call in, it has to be dispatched, and so forth. And so I think the ease of delivering that message would be a benefit in regards. So that's kind of my position there.
We will take that up with them. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So I was thinking about what you said, the structure was a public-private partnership. Now, so are you all
manages the contract on behalf of I&A. Okay. I&A is the board. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Any other questions from the committee? Okay. So this is strictly a report, and we appreciate your service to the state. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Real quickly, before we wrap up this morning, unless circumstances change, we probably will not meet in July and August just because of all the summer conferences and all that. So it'll probably be September before we come back. We'll see if we can't get a report from the Arkansas High Cost Fund. The other thing I'm going to try to do between now and then, as you all may have seen in new Starlink. SpaceX has launched the first couple satellites to that, and that promises to be another potential broadband solution. And so I'm going to see if I can get someone from SpaceX to talk to us about that system when they think it will come online, what the capabilities will be to help inform any decisions that we might make. So that should be interesting. And with that, if there's no further business to come before the committee, We are adjourned.
E. Consideration to Adopt Interim Study Proposal 2019-017: To Establish the Digital Fair Repair Act, Representative David Whitaker [EXHIBIT E]
F. Arkansas State Broadband Plan - Nathan Smith, Arkansas Development Finance Authority, Director of Economic Policy
G. Arkansas Broadband Manager’s Report [EXHIBIT G] - Yessica Jones, Director, Department of Information Systems
34:20 - 52:4374 segments14 speakers
The DIS Director Jessica Jones and Division Director Don McDaniel presented the semi-annual broadband report, noting an average fiber-installation cost of $18 per foot, modest gains in broadband access and speed, increased electric-cooperative participation, and upcoming K-12 network data from Education Superhighway.
[35:23][35:34][35:44][35:49][35:53][35:58][36:08][36:42][37:12][37:42][38:16]
Senator Mark Johnson queried whether the Connect America Fund applies a means-test that excludes wealthier households, and members discussed the complexities of eligibility and funding mechanisms without reaching a resolution.
[41:29][41:35][42:03][42:35][43:08][43:33][43:44]
H. Department of Information Systems, Proposed Rate Adjustments Report [EXHIBIT H] - Yessica Jones, Director, Department of Information Systems
I. Information Network of Arkansas, Legislative Reports on Fee Changes [EXHIBIT I] - Bob Sanders, General Manager, Information Network of Arkansas
52:43 - 1:00:3229 segments6 speakers
Bob Sanders (General Manager) and Christy Williams (Director of Operations) introduced the Information Network of Arkansas, explained its public-private partnership model funded through user fees approved quarterly by a governor-appointed board, and presented service-authorization reports from three board meetings covering 2019 rates, which included 37 new services at a standard 3 % + $1 fee and eight fee-free services.
[52:55][53:12][53:17][53:22][53:26][53:32][54:05][54:35][55:10]
Representative Jim Sorvillo suggested adding a highway-debris reporting feature to iDriveArkansas.com; INA staff indicated the concept is technically feasible and would require coordination with the Department of Transportation or state police, but no decision was made at the hearing.
[56:32][56:51][57:48][57:58][58:05][58:10][58:19]
The committee clarified INA’s contracting arrangement (managed by the Arkansas Information Consortium) and then adopted the report as reviewed by unanimous aye vote.
[52:55][53:12]