The committee first entertained and approved a motion to file all audit reports that contained no findings, with Senator Garner moving, Senator Bledsoe seconding, and the motion carried unanimously, and then turned to the Secretary of State audit, which identified a single finding that the agency failed to follow Attorney General Opinion 98-087 on historic-site procurement; the agency’s chief deputy and director pledged to review and strengthen procurement procedures, and the report was filed after Senator Hickey seconded the motion.
[1:35][1:42][1:47][2:17][2:23][2:35][2:41][2:52][3:05][3:08][3:24][3:56][4:27][4:33][5:04][5:12][5:24][5:35][9:37][9:46][9:58]
The Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace audit revealed a single accounting finding related to unrecorded invoices and receivables; the Insurance Department explained the issue arose when the marketplace operated as a separate entity and noted ongoing resolution efforts, and the committee subsequently moved to file the report, seconded and approved, before proceeding to introduce the next report on the White River Planning and Development District.
[27:05][27:16][27:43][27:59][28:12][28:19][28:30][28:50][29:00][29:02][29:34][29:42][29:48][47:57][48:18][48:49][49:11]
The White River Planning and Development District, represented by Byron Sutherland and Executive Director Jan Smith, addressed four audit findings by confirming staff numbers, locating missing documents, correcting the improper application of indirect-cost and fringe-benefit rates to the Workforce Innovation Opportunities Program and building-related expenses, and revising policies to charge vehicle costs directly; Senator Trent Garner moved to file the agency’s report, which was seconded and adopted without opposition.
[49:19][49:30][49:35][49:50][50:21][50:52][51:22][51:54][52:22][52:27][52:40]
Finally, the Arkansas Board of Examiners and Counseling, represented by Executive Director Lenora Erickson and Board Chair Robbie Klein, reported that an online renewal system now deposits fees directly to the Treasury, remedying the prior finding of untimely check deposits, and Senator Garner again moved to file this report, a motion that was seconded and carried unanimously.
[52:59][53:19][53:25][53:31][53:35][53:41][53:49][54:04]
First, as chairman, we're having these agencies up and we're reviewing these reports. We're often doing an investigatory function where we'll ask some questions, have a back-and-forth dialogue to try to dive into the meat of these issues. As such, as chairman, I give a lot of latitude to answering, asking these questions, as long as you're on the subject and you keep it short. You don't have to ask me every single time if you want to follow up. If I feel like you step outside the bounds or you went too far, I'll step in. But feel free to ask questions and have that back-and-forth dialogue. Secondly, as this committee moves forward, we basically have two actions that we'll take on most of the reports. One, we can do a motion to file it, which is basically us giving our tassel approval to it. The second one, we can make a motion to defer, which will push it off so we can get questions answered and move it on. We have one of those days from the Secretary of State. So as we move forward, if you have those kind of two motions, don't hesitate to reach out. With that, I'll move to action B, adoption of the minutes of the December 13, 2018 minute. If there isn't any questions about it, I'll entertain a motion. Got a motion approved by Senator Eads. Do we have a second? Second by Senator Dismay. All those in favor say yes. All those opposed? Good. With that, we'll move to
Agenda Item C, Review of Reports. Tom, if you will. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Today we're presenting six reports that have findings, but we also have 15 reports on the agenda without findings, and these are listed in
those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed. Thank you. Tom? Okay, our first report with findings today is the Secretary of State June 30-17 report, which contains one finding. And as the Chairman mentioned, this report was deferred from our December 13, 2018 meeting so that the new administration of the Secretary of State could come today and discuss their plans to address the finding. The finding is the agency failed to follow Attorney General Opinion No. 98-087 and the Public Works Law about historic site renovations regarding three capital bidding projects with contract costs totaling $887,000.
And that's the finding, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Representative Love, I noticed you had a question. Yes, sir. I had a question before. The audit reports with no findings, are these verified by you all of these reports? Are these audit reports done by outside agencies? It could be both. Okay. Some of them are outside
Thank you. Since we've already discussed this prior meeting, we'll call representatives from the Secretary of State if they would like to come by and say a quick statement. Please say your name and the agency you're with
Secretary of State. Kurt Nauman, Director of Administration, Secretary of State. You may proceed with your statement. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. As previously stated at the December 13, 2018 meeting, The Secretary of State's audit was presented, and the finding was released with a specific recommendation in the finding. It was deferred until this meeting so that the new administration could look over the audit report and also look at the finding and recommendation. As stated, the finding was in regard to non-deference to the Attorney General's opinion 98087 in public work laws with historic site renovation. Our staff met on May the 2nd of 2019 with Mr. Bullington and Mr. John Moore to discuss the particular audit and the finding, and we concur with the recommendation that was made in the audit that we will review and we will strengthen our procedures regarding procurement in regard to the audit finding. We have just begun that review process. The auditors are in place now to do the fiscal 2019 audit, so we will do that review. We will interface with the audit, and we will address that concern as best we can moving forward. And we would be happy to answer any questions you may have. Thank you. Any questions from the committee?
but what was the procurement issue? The procurement issue was that the standards were not being followed by the Secretary of State's office in procuring contracts in regard to an attorney general's opinion that was issued in 1998 in historic preservation law in regard to contracts for the, uh, improvements, repair, replacement of certain historical structures be made in accordance with the law. It was, uh, ACA 22-9-2008 regarding procurement of services for, uh, improvements to the public areas of the building here in the Capitol. Gotcha. Okay. All right. Thank you. Representative, if you're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. When you just stated that you guys were going to be strengthening what that process is, give me an example of what that means in
terms of strengthening the process. Thank you for the question. What we're going to do is look at our existing procurement policies that we have in place now in regard to thresholds, criteria, qualifications, the whole process for which we undertake projects. We're going to review those procedures, review it back against the Attorney General's opinion and the law. Also, we're going to look at consistent practices that we've done historically regarding those processes. Then we're going to get back with the auditors and make sure that we put together a written procedure that incorporates that into our existing procedure to make sure that the auditors are happy with that, that we're consistent with the law and practices. Senator Hickey, you're recognized.
Yes, sir. Thank you. I want to make sure I understand, and I wasn't here also. The agency response that we have, that is from the previous administration. Is that correct? Yes, sir. That is correct. So you all do not agree with the previous agency response, is what I'm understanding. Is that correct? Do you agree with LEG Audit's findings? Yes. Okay. Did you all, or does LEG Audit, do we need an addendum to this report as your response from the new administration? And that may be something to ask staff. I think, Senator
Hickey, that was the idea of bringing it back here today, deferring it today so that you could hear what the new administration wanted to do. Our report's already been issued and been released, so it's out on the web the way it is already. So I don't know that we can go back and change that report, but it's just to give you as a body an opportunity to hear what the new administration's plans were for that process. Okay, and I guess that we'll
probably go into a little bit of detail in the minutes of this meeting so that that'll be included. And yes, sir, I would think we would do that, yes, sir.
All right, thank you, sir. And thank you all. Representative, you're recognized. Okay. Would we want to hold this findings until we get the report, or would you say this should be closed? Representative, I'll
say that I was here when this issue was brought up before, and it was an issue about separation of powers and if we had the authority to monitor this constitutional office. There was a contention between the old administration and that issue, whether the findings of self-procurement is important or not. I think what I'm hearing from the representatives from the Secretary of State's office is they will comply with the law and our ability to audit them. And in my opinion, obviously, as a chair, I think that's an important thing, and I think that we can move forward
without holding this up any further. Representative Love, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So give me some understanding. I guess you all are not subject to state procurement laws, or they are subject to state procurement laws. I'm just trying to figure out why there's kind of a
not subject to, but there are some that they are. This one about historic site renovations didn't give any exclusion to the Secretary of State. And from looking
that does any work for a historic site. Okay, so then I guess, why is the agency putting together, or does state procurement have regulations and policies in place that already outline this procedure? This law itself tells you exactly,
it starts out with an assessment of the project to see if this law is applicable, and if it is, it tells you exactly what to go through, what bid process you have to go through, the whole
contracts. Gotcha. And so this is what your agency is adopting. Your agency is adopting what state procurement has. Well, basically, technically it follows an assessment process to determine what applies. So the answer is yes, we're going to comply as they are requesting. But the previous
administration did not. They felt like this historic site renovations law did not apply to the Secretary of State because they were constitutional. I think that was really the
questions? With that, I'll entertain a motion to file this report. Motion by Senator Bledsoe. We have a second. Second by Senator Hickey. All those in favor say aye. Aye.
All those opposed. Thank you, gentlemen. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. Our next report is the Arkansas Educational Television Commission, June 30, 2018 report, and this report contains five findings. The first finding, the agency entered into an agreement with the Public Broadcasting Service in March 2018 for the agency to produce a television program entitled State of the Art. The agency subsequently signed another agreement with a vendor to produce and distribute this program. Both of the agreements were for $100,000. The A.C. did not follow state procurement law regarding the agreement it signed with the vendor. At the time of these agreements were signed, the director of the A.C. also served as the executive director of the Arkansas Educational Telecommunications Network Foundation. Before the A.C. received any payments from PBS or remitted any payments to the vendor, it assigned the rights under these agreements to the foundation. As a result, any future revenue generated from this television program may be redirected to the foundation. In April 2018, the foundation received the first payment of $40,000 from PBS and remitted it to the vendor. The AC received a letter in November 2018 from PBS acknowledging and accepting the assignment of the rights of both agreements from the AC to the foundation. Per discussion with agency personnel, the rights were assigned to the foundation because it was too difficult to adhere to state processes. the state processes were too slow, they needed to pay the vendor quickly, and it takes too much time to set the vendors up in ACEs. The use of agency staff, facilities, equipment, and other resources for these agreements, which were assigned to the foundation, appear to violate the public purpose doctrine. This finding has been referred to the prosecuting attorney. The second finding, Arkansas Code requires the completion of a competitive bid form authorized by the state procurement director to ensure that all bids are for comparable items and to allow for proper selection of the vendor. The agency authorized payments to four vendors, totaling almost $158,000 without using the competitive bid form as prescribed in Arkansas Code. The third finding, Arkansas Code requires the Attorney General to provide legal services for all state officials, departments, institutions, and agencies. Arkansas Code also states that no special counsel should be employed or additional expense paid for these services. If the Attorney General is unable to provide the legal services needed, the Governor may authorize employment of special counsel. The H.C. engaged in services of special counsel prior to obtaining authorization from the governor. The fourth finding, the Chief Fiscal Officer of the state issues rules concerning state-owned vehicles and publishes the State of Arkansas Vehicle Use and Management Handbook. Certain information must be maintained in a vehicle use log, which is a written record carried in the vehicle at all times. The director of the H.C. commuted in a state vehicle from April 2017 through October 2018. However, no vehicle use log was maintained. The handbook also requires employees to reimburse the cost of their personal use of state vehicles, and because a vehicle log was not maintained, we could not determine an accurate amount of reimbursement due for personal use of the vehicle. However, based on fuel card receipts, appointment calendars, and other documents, the agency was able to calculate total commuting miles of over 6,800 miles for the period September 17 through July 2018, which would require reimbursement of approximately $2,800 to the agency. And this finding has also been referred to the prosecuting attorney. In the last finding, the agency made two payments to a vendor in April and June 2018, totaling $10,000. According to the invoice from the vendor, the payments were for AETN training. However, no documentation exists regarding the details of the training, including, but not limited to, dates of the training, course materials, outlines, or syllabi, and attendees at the training. Without proper documentation, we
to make a statement about these findings. Each of these findings, we agree with the assessment of the legislative audit. We have taken proper measures to correct each of these findings. Finding number one, dealing particularly with the procurement issues related to our agreement with Public Broadcasting Service and an outside production company. We, upon learning of this finding, we worked with Department of Finance Administration and Office of State Procurement to obtain the proper procurement method and approvals to complete that project. The second finding dealing with the lack of competitive bid forms, We, in fact, did not have a tabulation form attached with these invoices. We had copies of three quotations from the vendors that we solicited that were plainly evident what we were requesting and the information that they were submitting for their bid. That was the basis of awarding these bids. They were all bid. We just didn't take the quotations and then summarize them on a bid tabulation form. That was the basis of this finding. We have subsequently made sure that we were diligent in completing this bid tabulation form. Um, even, even if we had all of the quotations we needed, we were going to put that same information on the bid tabulation form so we could properly follow state procedures. Um, the third finding, uh, dealing with the, uh, uh, engagement of outside legal counsel, We agree that services were provided by our outside legal counsel before the final written approval of the governor was received. We had submitted our request and believed we were getting that approval. We just didn't wait until we got the signed form. Going forward, we will not engage any further legal counsel before we have the signed approval document. Number four, the item on the state vehicle. Once we learned of the issue with the mileage reimbursement, The vehicle was returned to the agency fleet and was no longer used for commuting. There were, in fact, vehicle logs for this vehicle. They were not exactly in the format prescribed by the Department of Finance, the motor vehicle section. However, they had the appropriate mileage documentation on them. But be that as it may, that vehicle was returned to the fleet, and we've worked with the Department of Finance for resolution of any reimbursement required. The fifth finding, the agency did make two payments to a vendor for AETN training, and we did not attach proper documentation to the invoice. documentation does exist in the form of video recordings of the actual training sessions that took place and back and forth email rosters amongst those that attended the trainings discussing that but this documentation was not in the payment file so we will going forward we'll make sure we have sign in sheets that type of documentation to properly back up the training that would pay for.
That's our response to these findings. Thank you. Let me start with questions myself. So let's go to finding number one. I think what's concerned to me is that as a government agency, you entered into this agreement with PBS to make this documentary, and you did that using government resources through the agency. But the rights to that documentary and any revenue that will be generated to it was signed off to the foundation, which is a private nonprofit. So what you did is acquire the agreement under the government agency, PBS, or excuse me, through AETN, but yet the foundation is the one that will reap the rewards of this, even though they may be the ones who are paying it out. So any future revenue or proceeds that come from that will now be going
to this private nonprofit. Is that correct? That is not correct now. But it was at the time of the founding. The original intent was that, yes. But we've subsequently signed an agreement with the AE10 Foundation that besides the payment that was cited in the finding, any other revenue that was generated as a result of this particular agreement with PBS would be the property of AE-10, and nothing further could be deposited into AE-10 foundation funds. All right. With that, I'll open to
excuse me. Thank you. For either one of you, the training, I think under Finding Five, I think that was where the training was, if I'm not mistaken. I just wondered, what was the
training and who provided the training? Do you recall? Yes. Craig Renaud, who is a documentarian, he instructed staff. We have a creative challenge, and media is changing drastically in the way content is made, the way it's distributed, is very, very different today than it has been in the past. I'm sure you all know that. This was training in editing and sound, in approach to documentaries and approach to subjects. It was a practical, hands-on workshop session, multiple sessions, for our production staff. Okay. Thank you for that.
And then I'll go ahead and ask if that's all right with Chairman. The finding four were talked about, and it sounds like obviously now that everyone knows the proper procedure, that everybody's handling that. What about the 2864? Was that reimbursed to the agency, or what's
very much. Thank you. Any more questions from committee? Senator Hickey. Yes, mine is the same as the chairman's own finding number one. Who in particular within the organization authorized this to take place? I did. Okay. I'm going to tell you it's very concerning to me because in here it says, per discussions with agency personnel, the rights were assigned to the foundation because it was too difficult to adhere to state processes, State processes were too slow, and the agency needed to pay the vendor quickly. The issue I have with that is it looks like to me that it was intentionally circumvented, you know, by doing that. And, you know, we spent a year to a year and a half down here developing a whole new procurement process, had a whole new task force. So whenever the other agencies within this state are complying with it, like I say, that's very concerning to me, especially whenever
it looks like it was just outright intentional to do. It was not intentional, and it was an opportunity. It was a new model for AETN. AETN has never been part of a national production with PBS, And this was a project that already had creative elements attached to it. It was something that PBS wanted to do with their local Arkansas station so that we could, as Arkansas, the state, and the agency and the network could reap the benefits of telling a local Arkansas story nationally. So there really was not a thought process of that type. It was to be able to capture this huge opportunity for Arkansas because it did have time constraints, but there really was not an active intent to go afoul of procurement. Excuse me, if I could add
real quick. And the agreement with PBS allowed for the possibility of an affiliate organization being involved in the process. Again, we passed a lot of
of the state of Arkansas? Yes, sir. We do. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. I'm going to follow up on that. Um, to what Senator Hickey said at the beginning of his question, Director Pledger, you're the agency director and you're also the executive director of the private nonprofit foundation. So you're on those dual roles, correct? When it came to passing this off to the other thing, was that something you did? You signed off directly, you were aware of as your dual roles of both of those? I mean, I guess let me clarify my question. So whenever it was passed off, you're in the head
one that you're in control of? Well, yes, but there really was no intent to do anything other than put something together that would benefit the state of Arkansas in a lot of
ways. okay ma'am because we've had this issue before with some other agencies where you had this dual role of being the government employee this in your case the ceo of it and also having a private non-profit or some other capacity as well and i think there's some really public purpose uh public um youth doctrine issues that could really arise from this so that i'll take any more questions with that was the will of the committee we have a motion for following this review we have a second second all those in favor say aye all those opposed thank you
thank you all thank you Our next report is the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace, June 30, 2018 report, and this report contains one finding. This audit was performed by a private CPA firm. It wasn't performed by a legislative audit. Also, AHIM is now part of the insurance department as a result of Act 107 of 2019 in this year's session. An audit adjustment was needed to properly state revenues and expenses in AHIM's 2018 financial statements. Invoices relating to services performed in the prior year were not recorded as accounts payable and related expenses. And since the invoices were reimbursable by a third party, they should also have been recorded as accounts receivable and related revenue. That concludes the finding
proceed with the statement. Yes, our statement will be short. This finding results from actions of the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace when it was a separate entity from us. It's now been merged into us, or we've acquired it, in essence, and now it falls under the state's procurement rules and the state's auditing and accounting
processes. Thank you. Any questions from the committee? Go ahead. Is there any outstanding invoices or accounts receivable, payables, et cetera, et cetera, after they
Yes, there were several, and they were the responsibility of the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace, but they did have some funds left over, and we've been trying to work with the creditors to cancel services like Comcast and things like that, and frankly, they're still kind of crawling out of the woodwork. Apparently, they did not pay everything prior to their dissolution. Any more questions from committee?
With no further questions, I will entertain a motion to file this report. Motion by Senator Bledsoe. Do we have a second? Second. Second. All those in favor
say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Thank you. I'll also add, Mr. Chairman, on AHIM, we presented a letter to the executive committee today that will also be presented in the summer tomorrow that we went through during the session and looked at AHIM to make sure that the money was spent in proportion to the way it should have been and that there wasn't anything out of the ordinary for them, and we presented that letter today. There were no issues that really came to our attention, so that will be
presented tomorrow as well. Thank you, Tom. Our next report is the Arkansas Public Employees Retirement System June 30, 2018 report, which contains two findings. The first finding is the agency did not report the apparent loss of public funds to Arkansas legislative audit in accordance with Arkansas Code and the State Financial Management Guide. At June 30, 2018, the Public Employees and the State Police Retirement Plans maintained an accounts receivable balance for benefit overpayments of approximately $765,000. We examined 12 individuals with accounts receivable balances greater than $10,000, totaling over $271,000 for the 12 individuals. The cause of these overpayments included benefits continuing after the death of the retiree, disability payments made to eligible members, and benefits claimed using forged documents. Management failed to notify us in 11 of these 12 instances, with the one notification being made in June 2018 for an overpayment of approximately $11,000 discovered by the agency in February 2014. The second finding, which is kind of related to the first, is that the State Financial Management Guide requires agencies to diligently and actively pursue the collection of receivables. Again we examined the 12 accounts of $10,000 or greater at June 30, 2018 to determine if if any additional collection procedures have been pursued beyond written correspondence from the agency. In 11 of the 12, no additional collection procedures were conducted, and for the remaining count, no additional collection procedures were deemed necessary by management since a payment plan had been established and was being followed by the debtor. All the receivables examined existed at June 30, 2018 and were delinquent by six months or more when we performed this test. Additionally, general accepted accounting principles and the financial management guide required management to establish an allowance for doubtful accounts, which is an estimate of the total amount of receivables that are considered uncollectible. At June 30, 2018, the agency had made no such estimate, and an allowance for doubtful accounts had not been established. The agency's lack of additional procedures to collect overpayments resulted in a collection rate of about 25%. Mr. Chairman, that concludes the findings for the Public Employees Retirement System.
the Arkansas Public Employees Retirement System. And good afternoon. I'm Jay Wills. I'm the Deputy Director of the Arkansas Public Employees Retirement System. I'll be speaking to you about this because it occurred under my watch as Acting Executive Director, and it also occurred under my area of responsibility as both the Deputy Director and the former lawyer. On the first finding, as far as submitting losses in excess of $1,000, we corrected that immediately upon getting that finding from legislative audit, and we agreed that we did not comply with the existing law at that time. by way of explanation, but not excuse, we were focusing more on higher amounts simply because due to our payment streams that we pay out every month, it's not unusual for us to get an $1,000 or more, quote, loss on the front end until we can figure out where it came out and if we can get back. We have now taken an every week. I receive a copy as well as Duncan. We get a copy of every assumed loss that has shown up that week of $1,000 and more, and those have been going out every week since we got this finding and put this procedure in place. The procedure, by the way, was put in place within a week of our receiving the finding. So if there are any questions about the first finding, the second one is related to it, but kind of the other side of the coin, but I'll be happy to take any questions on the first finding if you all would like that. Oh, by the way, excuse me, we also set up an accounts receivable immediately for losses, which is now on the books. Sir, since they're so related, I'll
Certainly, happy to do so. The second one talks about collections, basically. And in the past, we've had a difficult time collecting overpayments, especially in the cases of deceased members or their survivors. Um, we have, um, at least three, two separate death services that report to us as well as Social Security and the Health Department. Uh, we also have staff that goes through the obituaries every day, but it is not unusual for several months to pass before we learn of a death of either a retiree or that retiree's beneficiary. Um, and at the time that we learn about it, there is no ongoing payment stream to stop or to recover it from. We stop the payment stream as soon as we learn about the death. We have attempted to learn who has been withdrawing those, but bank regulations and rules have, the banks have typically responded to us, we can't do that without running afoul of banking privacy laws, and we're not going to tell you, which is a little bit frustrating. We have approached the prosecuting attorneys in several jurisdictions, and they're all great folks. We've only had one that would help us that actually issued a prosecuting attorney's subpoena for bank records, at which time we did learn who was taking out the monies. We are going to try to explore legislation in the next substantive session to make a small exception for retirement systems who are trying to recover overpayments as far as disclosing people who've been taking money out of accounts. Nonetheless, we at my direction did not file suit on any of these things against people because many years ago I was an assistant attorney general and I had the late Richard Arnold in a case I inherited from another assistant attorney general slap me in the face with the idea that we had filed a counterclaim in a case that had been filed against the state and federal court. we had raised sovereign immunity as a defense, but the people handling the case before I got it filed a counterclaim. And Judge Arnold explained to me, and I got to research it, and I believe this is the current law, that to the extent a state invokes the jurisdiction of one of its own courts by initiating action or filing a counterclaim, you waive the state's sovereign immunity with respect to all things in that action or other things reasonably arising out of them. We also, the current governor, has requested that state agencies not waive sovereign immunity without getting express permission from the governor's office to do so. I've explained that to legislative office over a series of years on this. When we got this finding, the very next day, we requested an opinion from the state attorney general asking the question which I've just told you what I believe the law is. That question was asked on December 8th. We have yet to receive a response although the attorney general has acknowledged receiving our opinion request. But at this point in front of you all I'm loathe to do something that might waive the state's sovereign immunity especially sitting on a nine billion dollar fund which gets every lawyer within hailing distance interested in possible counterclaims. We are exploring. We're, first of all, waiting on the Attorney General to tell us whether or not we should do so or could do so. I do believe that there is no mechanism in state law right now for us to sell our bad accounts, so to speak, at a discounted rate, since these are trust funds, not state agency funds, so that we could start a third-party recovery. But that's why we are where we are. And it was at my express direction we did not file lawsuits against people for two reasons. One, the sovereign immunity, and two, who do we sue? Because nobody will tell us who's been taking the money out of the accounts. And if we just sue everybody that's on the account, being a public entity, we're very likely to run into some due process or equal protection problems for frivolously suing citizens in the state of Arkansas. I'll be happy to take any questions or suggestions about what to do in this case, but that's where we are right now. We are waiting on the response to our question from the Attorney General, and we will certainly follow whatever advice we get from the Attorney General.
We also offer disability to our members if they become disabled, but they have to stay disabled in order to be entitled to those disability payments if they're under normal retirement age, which is age 65. In doing so, they are required to supply us the first, I think, four years with annual statements, which we follow up in the years following as far as any earnings they've made or any work they've had. Some people just don't tell us that they've gone back to work, and we have no way of knowing that. Some people don't know. It's not necessarily bad intention. It's they just don't familiarize themselves with the income limits or the requirements of maintaining yourself on APR's disability before you reach retirement age. That's another major area that we see it, But far and away, decedent overpayments are our biggest category. The third is minor children that are survivors are entitled to get survivor benefits if they stay in college up to 24. Unfortunately, some people lie to us about whether or not they're in college. Now, those people we can pursue, and we've done it fairly successfully. But that's the rare thing. The biggest thing by far is decedent overpayments. and we just don't know we're overpaying until we get notice of the death.
basis? I believe... Jason, we're... Yes. Yes, sir, we do. I think we're paying two or three... Two services. Two services plus Social Security plus our own staff is tasked to it on a daily basis. We go after it aggressively. The problem, as I expect you know, in Arkansas is not everybody goes through probate when they die, especially like in small communities where maybe grandma's getting a check from APERS. The kids are taking care of her. The grandchildren, when she dies, they don't know where the money's coming from. They've just got a magic bank account that keeps filling up with money over there. I'm not saying it's necessarily criminal. But we're really hamstrung because we have no access to bank records after a death. We'll try to correct that with some proposed legislation. But we can't, the banks just won't tell us. And I can't sue people unless I've got reasonable cause to
believe that they've done so. You answered my question. If you're utilizing those resources, you're doing everything that any major insurance company would do. So it's just a matter of timing on some of them. It is. We really
do, Duncan's heard this more than he cares to, but we really do try to be like Caesar's wife over there at APERS. We sit on too much money and got too much people interested in it to do anything other than cut square corners.
thing, you know, as an attorney, you know, there's a lot of times that people have grounds to sue. It's, you know, it's appropriate to sue. However, it's not cost-effective to sue. It's not worth filing the lawsuit. And so I totally get that. One thing, though, that perked my attention, and I may be wrong, but if you can correct me, is like, you know, how in the world can you waive, by bringing a lawsuit, waive sovereign immunity? You know, especially under the more recent Supreme Court decision. I mean, legislatively, we can't waive sovereign immunity, so how could you do that?
That's just, that's decisional law from both the state Supreme Court and the federal courts. in my recollection, I'll be happy when I get back to try to supply you with sites to that. I'm really touchy about that because somebody's going to come after a big fund
at Cleet's High. Sure, but what I would say is that maybe you need to update your... I mean, all of us needed to update our information, but there is under the current Supreme Court jurisprudence, I can't imagine any way that you could... I mean, the issue is that what I have to do when I have a client who comes in and feels like they've been wrong is look at it, look at the facts, and see the likelihood of recovering, you know, understanding the law, the facts, all that stuff. And so, you know, I totally get probably more often than not it's not worthwhile for you to file a suit to go back and collect. But if one of your things that you guys are relying on is you're worried about waiving sovereign immunity that you can't, that's not a very, very good evaluation unless I'm just completely, you know. which is
why we asked for an attorney general's opinion on it, because I was relying on old law based on my experience as well. And so I thought, let's just get an explicit statement of the current law. I agree with you that under the recent decision on sovereign immunity, it's hard for anybody to sue the state in court. Do I want to be the test case, though, on the waiver thing with a $9 billion agency? No, sir. Well,
yeah, except for what I would say is that, you know, obviously, you know, bad facts make back laws, so you don't want to be in a stupid place and filing a stupid lawsuit. But at the same time, you know, if what you're talking about is a lot of money and it is cost effective, your job is to try to collect as much of it as you can. So, you know, having an evaluation of I don't want to waive sovereign immunity when you have a court that says you can't, no matter how hard you try, no matter even if the legislature says that they want to, you can't do it. Well, then that tells me that you probably ought to evaluate it like you don't have to worry about waiving sovereign immunity, you may have to worry about wasting money trying to throw good money after bad money. That's legit. But at the same time, I would say you all should consider and reevaluate from where you were a year ago is not where we are today. Certainly. And I understand that
the only response I would make to that very respectfully is we don't know who to sue. I'm sorry, do what? We don't know who to sue. Remember, the banks won't
you brought up, you said you don't want to waive cyber immunity. That's one of your reasonings. So I'm just saying, you know, totally get it. Like sometimes it doesn't make sense to file a lawsuit. You probably shouldn't file a lawsuit. But if you're going to come in here and say that you don't want to waive cyber immunity and that's why you're not suing, then you need to be able to back that up with some sort of law, not just, you know, good words. That's
a good idea to do that. Let me interrupt here. So we're talking about the suing and the sovereign immunity, and that's one section of this. But I think the concern that we have after talking to the staff here is that you have these rather large payments that are out there in the ether. And some of them are because of death benefits and the issues with that. But some of them we found manifest fraud, people forging documents, people taking this money outside. And outside of that written response, there's very little done for these criminal actions to hold them accountable in the system. That's what I think we're concerned about, is if you have somebody who is defrauding the system, taking that money and using it for their own personal reasons, and there's not really a mechanism other than your written response in which they can or cannot respond, there's no action outside of that, how are you going to move forward to make sure those people who are doing the wrong part of it, and it may not be a large number. The data indicates otherwise, but it may not be a large number. How are we making sure they're held accountable and how are we recouping that money if that
does happen? I would certainly think that once we would identify somebody that occasioned a significant loss by what we think is probably criminal conduct, we would likely refer that to the local prosecutor once we identified them. We've never referred anybody to a prosecutor yet that I recall as I sit here. But I think also I agree with you that we do have a duty. we're under we're fiduciaries as well so we have a duty to the fund as well as to um the legislature as well to aggressively pursue them so y'all never found an example
only one i can think of off the top of my head was somebody in east arkansas who claimed to the survivors who claimed to have been in college when he or she actually wasn't that's the only one that i'm aware of i think we saw that and i think we
tom would you like speak more on it sure yeah i think there were two or three when i looked at the sample out of that 12 that mike looked at there were two or three i think that were surviving dependents like that same thing where they were saying
they were in college when they actually were not but they had not they'd i'll sure check on that i'm not aware of that but certainly if we've identified somebody's been lying to us to get money we'll refer that to a prosecutor. Thank you. Any more questions from committee? With that, I entertain a motion.
All those opposed? Thank you. Thank you. Our next report is the White River Planning and Development District June 30, 2018 report. This report contains four findings. This audit was also performed by a private CPA firm. The first finding was that the district had a limited number of personnel, effectively precluding them from having adequate segregation of dues relating to the billing, collection, recording, coding, and classification of transactions that affect the general ledger. The second finding, during oversight agency monitoring visits, transactions were noted that were not fully supported by required documentation. Deficiencies were noted in the areas of competitive procurement, contracts, board approvals, cost allocation, policies, and other technical requirements. The documentation matters caused the oversight agency to identify expenditures as a question cost. The third finding, during their oversight agency monitoring visit, it was also discovered that reimbursement for indirect costs that were allocated to non-major national emergency grants under the Department of Labor were not allowable under their grant award. The fourth finding, direct rental costs were charged to the Workforce Innovation Opportunity Act federal program. Rental costs were also included in indirect costs which were then allocated to the program, resulting in duplicate charges to the federal program. In addition, vehicle mileage was charged to the program, while the actual cost of renting and operating the
turn on. Byron Sutherland, physical officer at WRPDD. I'm Jan Smith, the Executive Director of the White River Planning and Development District. Thank you. Do you have a statement? We will respond to each of the findings. The first finding, of course, we have a staff of 25 people that work in our office in Batesville, and four of those people are in our accounting department. We have the fiscal officer, two fiscal clerks, and an assistant fiscal officer. We also have two additional staff that do some internal monitoring and review of financial documents. Thank you. Continue. On finding number two, we did have some documents that we had a difficult time finding, but subsequently we were able to locate them. We found all the documents that we felt that ADWS was asking for, and we have submitted all those. So we feel that finding two has been resolved. We have not heard back yet from DWS, but we are in constant contact with them and have met with them a number of times. On finding number three, this resulted. We took over the Workforce Innovation Opportunities Program about three years ago. We started it from scratch with our existing staff people and hiring a few additional folks. um we operate with a general management system in our accounting department where it applies the indirect cost rate and the fringe benefit rate on a monthly basis on all employees at the time we were we were not i guess understanding that the neg participants of the program were considered our employees and and that fringe benefit or the indirect cost rate excuse me was being charged to that program. As soon as it was brought to our attention, we contacted our general management system and worked with the programmers to have that stopped immediately. And then since then, we have, through disbursements, repaid that amount of money to the program. On finding number four, again, the indirect cost rate, and it covers a part of the rents that is paid for the workforce program staff that are housed in our building. We also have six vehicles that are pool cars, and those costs were being charged in the indirect cost. Again, that turned out to be a problem, so we immediately stopped doing it that way and have gone back to direct charge of those costs that can be identified and have changed up our policies and procedures. Thank you, ma'am. Any questions for the committee? Well, I'll just say
I appreciate it. It looks like you're following the recommendations in each one of your agency responses, so we appreciate that. With that, I'll entertain a motion to file this report. I have a motion. I have a second. All
those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Thank you. Thank you. Our last report today is the Arkansas Board of Examiners and Counseling, June 30, 18. report which has one finding. The state financial management guide states that daily deposits should be made to the treasury and or commercial bank account. Weekly deposits are allowable if an agency receives only minimal amounts of cash and or checks. However, in the last week of the month of all deposits must be delivered to the treasury of state or the commercial bank account for for deposit prior to noon on the last business day. During the last four months of the fiscal year, the agency did not deposit checks as required on the last day of the month. Additionally, as of June 30th, the agency held in excess of 175 checks, totaling over $46,000 that were not deposited in a timely manner.
online renewal process, and I can say that that has greatly decreased the paperwork and paper checks and money orders that have flown into the office. So presently, we're doing that online renewal system, and the money's getting deposited directly into the Treasury.
Thank you. Any questions from committee? see no questions i will entertain a motion to file this report motion by senator dismayne do we have a second second all those in favor say aye all those opposed thank you ma'am all right move on to item d uh the next meeting will be held june 6 2019 and with that we're adjourned
The committee first entertained and approved a motion to file all audit reports that contained no findings, with Senator Garner moving, Senator Bledsoe seconding, and the motion carried unanimously, and then turned to the Secretary of State audit, which identified a single finding that the agency failed to follow Attorney General Opinion 98-087 on historic-site procurement; the agency’s chief deputy and director pledged to review and strengthen procurement procedures, and the report was filed after Senator Hickey seconded the motion.
[1:35][1:42][1:47][2:17][2:23][2:35][2:41][2:52][3:05][3:08][3:24][3:56][4:27][4:33][5:04][5:12][5:24][5:35][9:37][9:46][9:58]
The Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace audit revealed a single accounting finding related to unrecorded invoices and receivables; the Insurance Department explained the issue arose when the marketplace operated as a separate entity and noted ongoing resolution efforts, and the committee subsequently moved to file the report, seconded and approved, before proceeding to introduce the next report on the White River Planning and Development District.
[27:05][27:16][27:43][27:59][28:12][28:19][28:30][28:50][29:00][29:02][29:34][29:42][29:48][47:57][48:18][48:49][49:11]
The White River Planning and Development District, represented by Byron Sutherland and Executive Director Jan Smith, addressed four audit findings by confirming staff numbers, locating missing documents, correcting the improper application of indirect-cost and fringe-benefit rates to the Workforce Innovation Opportunities Program and building-related expenses, and revising policies to charge vehicle costs directly; Senator Trent Garner moved to file the agency’s report, which was seconded and adopted without opposition.
[49:19][49:30][49:35][49:50][50:21][50:52][51:22][51:54][52:22][52:27][52:40]
Finally, the Arkansas Board of Examiners and Counseling, represented by Executive Director Lenora Erickson and Board Chair Robbie Klein, reported that an online renewal system now deposits fees directly to the Treasury, remedying the prior finding of untimely check deposits, and Senator Garner again moved to file this report, a motion that was seconded and carried unanimously.
[52:59][53:19][53:25][53:31][53:35][53:41][53:49][54:04]