Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Judiciary Committee - Senate

March 27, 2019 ·15 Minutes Upon Adjournment ·Room 171 ·3:12:02
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 9, 2026

HB1799 Rushing TO CREATE "TARA'S LAW"; AND TO AMEND GRANDPARENTS' RIGHTS IN CUSTODY AND VISITATION MATTERS. 1:15

Representative Laurie Rushing presented House Bill 1799, “Tara’s Law,” proposing amendments to Arkansas’s grandparent visitation rights and explaining her personal motivation and three-year development of the bill. [2:06] [2:24] [2:55] [3:27] [4:01] [4:33] [5:04]

She detailed that the bill would add three new grounds for grandparents to petition for visitation: a parent found unfit, clear and convincing evidence that visitation is in the child’s best interest, and step-parent adoption after a biological parent’s death, borrowing language from several other states. [5:41] [6:14] [6:47] [7:26]

Circuit Judge Tom Smith testified that the bill’s language had been vetted with judges and that the committee took no official position, after which no committee members asked further questions. [7:57] [8:24] [8:30] [9:05] [9:21]

The committee moved to pass the bill, with Senator Flowers making the motion, Senator Letty seconding, and the motion carried unanimously, resulting in the passage of HB 1799. [9:36]

HB 1831 Boyd 11:43

Representative Justin Boyd introduced House Bill 1831, which would facilitate criminal-record sealing by removing the five-year look-back period for non-violent felonies and eliminating the $50 sealing fee. [13:51] [14:05] [14:38]

Prosecutor Daniel Shue explained that the change would allow immediate sealing after a sentence is completed, improving re-entry prospects for individuals who have satisfied their obligations. [15:08] [15:40]

Senators Stubblefield and Cooper questioned the origin of the five-year period and whether the bill conflicted with other legislation, receiving clarification that the measure only affects sealing and does not alter other rights or processes. [14:57] [16:21] [16:42] [16:58] [17:06] [17:16] [17:25] [17:45]

The committee approved the measure without opposition, with Senator Rice moving, Senator Letty seconding, and the motion carried, passing HB 1831. [18:46] [18:51] [18:57]

SB378 Elliott TO BE KNOWN AS "THE EQUITY IN SENTENCING ACT". 20:25

Senator Joyce Elliott presented Senate Bill 378, the “Equity in Sentencing Act,” proposing that individuals sentenced under the 2011 drug-sentence law be allowed to have their sentences reviewed and potentially set aside if they would be equivalent to current sentencing standards. [20:55] [21:32] [22:04] [22:41]

Several senators, including Stephanie Flowers and Terry Rice, voiced concerns about the bill’s impact on other offenses, the appropriate role of the parole board, and suggested pursuing a resolution or an interim study rather than direct legislative action. [23:56] [24:23] [25:12] [25:46] [26:22] [26:54] [27:27] [27:58] [28:12] [28:46] [29:01] [29:22] [30:01] [30:33] [31:09] [31:43] [31:52] [32:26] [32:59]

Prosecutor-attorney Larry Froelich testified that the bill would only affect controlled-substance offenses and warned it could create unfunded mandates for the DOC and parole board, while the chair noted insufficient information to make a decision. [29:01] [29:22] [30:01] [30:33] [31:09] [31:43] [31:52] [32:26] [32:59] [33:36] [34:08] [47:26] [47:43]

The committee did not adopt SB 378; instead members moved toward drafting a Senate resolution urging the governor to act on parole-board recommendations and considered an interim study, with no formal vote recorded on the bill. [40:49] [41:02] [41:10] [41:41] [42:12] [42:47] [43:23] [44:03] [44:35] [45:06] [45:43] [45:54] [46:22] [46:55] [47:26] [47:43] [47:59] [48:28] [48:31] [49:05] [49:26] [49:48] [50:27]

SB558 G. Stubblefield TO REPEAL ARKANSAS CODE § 16-30-104 CONCERNING THE CONTRACTUAL WAIVER OF A JURY TRIAL; TO MAKE THE REPEAL OF ARKANSAS CODE § 1630-104 RET… 53:45

Senator Gary Stubblefield introduced Senate Bill 558, which would repeal Arkansas Code § 16-30-104, make the repeal retroactive, and declare an emergency, noting that the measure originated in the 2017 special session. [54:51] [55:21] [56:10]

The committee heard testimony from trial lawyer Joey McCutcheon asserting that pre-litigation jury-waiver clauses violate constitutional rights, from bank counsel defending the waivers as efficient and consistent with federal practice, and from consumer Kenneth Tilley describing personal harm caused by such a waiver, while several senators questioned the retroactive impact and the necessity of legislative action. [56:59] [57:32] [58:22] [58:54] [59:24] [59:57] [1:00:31] [1:01:03] [1:03:54] [1:04:29] [1:05:04] [1:05:40] [1:06:12] [1:06:45] [1:11:20] [1:11:34] [1:11:44] [1:11:52] [1:12:10] [1:12:18] [1:12:50] [1:13:22] [1:13:57]

A motion for immediate consideration was moved by Senator Flowers, seconded by Senator Ballinger and carried, but a subsequent motion to pass the bill failed, and the chair declared the measure defeated. [1:32:35] [1:32:44] [1:32:59] [1:33:13] [1:33:24] [1:33:34] [1:33:54] [1:34:02]

HB1686 A. Collins TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PURPOSES OF DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE. 1:35:41

Representative Andrew Collins introduced HB 1686, explaining that it would amend the marital-property definition to create a statutory exception for the “active appreciation” of non-marital property-reinstating the 30-year precedent reflected in Moore v. Moore and the Lehman case and clarifying that only appreciation resulting from a spouse’s time, effort, or skill becomes marital property. [1:36:06] [1:36:28] [1:36:58] [1:37:32] [1:38:03] [1:38:37]

Senators Will Bond and Stephanie Flowers questioned the necessity and scope of the amendment, particularly the “time, effort, or skill” language, while Sylvester Smith testified that the bill could unduly burden small-business owners by forcing sales to buy out spouses. [1:39:10] [1:39:40] [1:39:54] [1:40:11] [1:40:42] [1:41:20] [1:41:48] [1:41:50] [1:43:34] [1:44:08] [1:44:49] [1:45:27] [1:46:00] [1:46:31]

The committee further debated how to distinguish active from passive appreciation, using examples of farms, family businesses, and a hardware store to illustrate that passive appreciation remains non-marital while active appreciation would be treated as marital property. [1:40:42] [1:41:20] [1:41:48] [1:41:50] [1:42:14] [1:42:22] [1:42:28] [1:42:36] [1:49:05] [1:49:20] [1:49:54] [1:50:29] [1:51:00] [1:51:26] [1:51:35] [1:52:07] [1:52:20]

A motion to pass the bill was made by Senator Bond and seconded by Senator Ballinger; after a roll-call vote the measure failed by a 3-to-2 margin. [2:12:28] [2:13:03] [2:13:11] [2:13:26] [2:13:32] [2:13:42] [2:13:58]

HB1488 Penzo TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ADOPTION PROCESS WHEN A LICENSED CHILD PLACEMENT AGENCY IS NOT USED; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 2:15:29

The committee first adopted a compromise amendment to HB 1488, with Senator Ballinger moving and Senator Cooper seconding, and the motion carried unanimously. [2:16:46] [2:16:59]

Representative Penzo then presented HB 1488, arguing that current adoption law permits unlicensed agents to exploit vulnerable mothers-particularly in the Marshallese community-and that the bill would prohibit such practices and increase transparency. [2:17:10] [2:17:31] [2:18:05] [2:18:39] [2:19:13] [2:19:44] [2:20:12] [2:20:15]

The Arkansas Bar Association’s legislation committee, represented by Glenn Hoggard, testified that the bill’s new accounting and filing requirements would burden the adoption system, and after extensive debate and concerns raised by Senator Flowers about out-of-state family members, the committee voted to postpone the measure, pulling it down for further consideration on Monday. [2:27:03] [2:27:15] [2:27:51] [2:28:23] [2:28:57] [2:29:30] [2:30:00] [2:30:10] [2:32:41] [2:32:55] [2:33:26] [2:33:57] [2:34:01] [2:34:38] [2:35:09] [2:36:57] [2:37:11] [2:37:18] [2:37:21] [2:37:27] [2:37:57] [2:38:32] [2:39:07] [2:39:13] [2:39:17] [2:39:33] [2:39:36]

SB625 B. Ballinger TO ALLOW A PARENT TO APPOINT A TEMPORARY GUARDIAN FOR HIS OR HER MINOR CHILD IN THE EVENT OF THE DEATH OF THE PARENT. 2:40:22

Senator Ballinger introduced SB 625, which would allow parents to create a notarized affidavit naming a temporary guardian that becomes effective immediately upon the parents’ death, providing a 90-day emergency guardianship without a court hearing. [2:40:44] [2:41:18] [2:41:37] [2:41:48] [2:42:19] [2:42:55] [2:43:31]

Attorney Sylvester Smith explained the mechanism and addressed concerns raised by Senator Flowers about unfit guardians, revocation, and notice, noting that the temporary appointment could be challenged in court and that the affidavit could be revoked through a petition. [2:46:15] [2:46:37] [2:46:41] [2:46:56] [2:47:10] [2:47:21] [2:47:34] [2:47:43] [2:47:59] [2:48:18] [2:49:54] [2:50:18] [2:50:26] [2:50:58]

After a non-debate motion was carried, the committee voted 5-2 to pass SB 625, with Senator Ballinger’s bill declared approved. [2:54:51] [2:55:23] [2:55:30] [2:55:40] [2:55:53] [2:56:05]

SB319 B. Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EMINENT DOMAIN; AND TO ADD NEW DEFINITIONS UNDER EMINENT DOMAIN. 2:56:55

Senator Ballinger presented SB 319 to amend Arkansas’ eminent-domain statutes by codifying existing case law that bars taking property for purely economic purposes and by defining “blight” and “abandoned property” as limited public-use exceptions. [2:56:58] [2:57:33] [2:57:53] [2:58:05] [2:58:39] [2:59:12]

After brief discussion, including testimony from Lanny Richman of the Arkansas Municipal League who noted the bill aligns with Arkansas precedent but cautioned about potential impacts of Amendment 97, the committee moved to adopt the amendment and the bill as amended. [3:00:46] [3:00:52] [3:00:55] [3:01:20] [3:01:40] [3:01:56] [3:02:26] [3:03:07] [3:03:18] [3:03:30]

The committee approved the measure by a 5-2 vote, with Senator Stubblefield seconding the motion and the chair announcing the bill’s passage. [3:04:01] [3:04:16]

SB579 A. Clark TO REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF ALL EVIDENCE IN THE POSSESSION OF THE STATE TO A CRIMINAL DEFENDANT, WHETHER THE EVIDENCE IS INCULPATORY, EXCULPATO… 3:05:53

Senator Alan Clark introduced SB579, explaining that it would require the state to disclose all evidence in its possession to a criminal defendant-whether inculpatory, exculpatory, or neither-and noted that the bill is “short and sweet.” [3:05:54] [3:06:09]

[582-584] [3:07:10] [3:07:44] [3:08:15]

[586-588] [3:08:46] [3:09:03] [3:09:16]

[587-588] [3:09:03] [3:09:16]

Bills discussed (12)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1831 Act 680 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB 1831 Boyd”
TO AMEND THE COMPREHENSIVE CRIMINAL RECORD SEALING ACT OF 2013. Boyd Notification that HB1831 is now Act 680
HB1799 Act 679 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Representative Brushing, you are recognized to present House Bill 1799.”
TO CREATE "TARA'S LAW"; AND TO AMEND GRANDPARENTS' RIGHTS IN CUSTODY AND VISITATION MATTERS. Rushing Notification that HB1799 is now Act 679
SB378 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “MS. GOING TOO FAST. MR. SB 378. MS. THAT'S THE RIGHT ONE, YES. MR. SEN. ELLIOTT HAS”
TO BE KNOWN AS THE "PAROLE EQUITY ACT. Elliott Sine Die adjournment
SB517 · 2 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…u were last in the committee on this bill, Senator Bunn ran Senate Bill 517. Yes. And I think at least my sentiment is, well, number on…”
CONCERNING LIFE SENTENCES IMPOSED FOR NONVIOLENT FELONY OFFENSES INVOLVING A CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE; CONCERNING CRIMINAL SENTENCES; … Bond Sine Die adjournment
HB1488 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1488 Penzo TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ADOPTION PROCESS WHEN…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ADOPTION PROCESS WHEN A LICENSED CHILD PLACEMENT AGENCY IS … Penzo Sine Die adjournment
HB1686 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1686 A. Collins TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FO…”
TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PURPOSES OF DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN … A. Collins Died on House at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1814 Act 1049 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…thank you, committee. Do you have another bill? Yes, I do. House Bill 1814.”
CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF HARASSING COMMUNICATIONS. Rushing Notification that HB1814 is now Act 1049
SB319 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB319 B. Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EMINENT DOMAIN; AN…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EMINENT DOMAIN; AND TO ADD NEW DEFINITIONS UNDER EMINENT DOMAIN. B. Ballinger Sine Die adjournment
SB344 Act 806 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB344 B. Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING OF A ME…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING OF A MECHANIC'S OR MATERIALMAN'S LIEN. B. Ballinger Notification that SB344 is now Act 806
SB558 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB558 G. Stubblefield TO REPEAL ARKANSAS CODE § 16-30-104 CONCERN…”
TO REPEAL ARKANSAS CODE § 16-30-104 CONCERNING THE CONTRACTUAL WAIVER OF A JURY TRIAL; TO … G. Stubblefield Sine Die adjournment
SB579 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB579 A. Clark TO REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF ALL EVIDENCE IN THE P…”
TO REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF ALL EVIDENCE IN THE POSSESSION OF THE STATE TO A … A. Clark Recommended for study in the Interim Committee on …
SB625 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB625 B. Ballinger TO ALLOW A PARENT TO APPOINT A TEMPORARY GUARD…”
TO ALLOW A PARENT TO APPOINT A TEMPORARY GUARDIAN FOR HIS OR HER MINOR CHILD … B. Ballinger Sine Die adjournment

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 9, 2026
them. Do we have any Senate bills that are urgent? Because we will get to you. But if you need to go ahead. Okay. Senate bills that are urgent. Okay. Okay. All right. I'm going to start with Representative Rushing then. Representative Boyd, while she's coming to the table, because of the miscommunication with you, they're getting copies of your bill. And once we see it, if there are six votes to hear it, we will. That'll be up to committee. Representative Rushing, what are
▶ Play
we looking at first? If you don't mind, Mr. Chair, we'll do 1799 first. House Bill
▶ Play
1799. Give us a moment to find it.
▶ Play
Speaker 11 1:19
The staff is going to hand out Representative Boyd's
▶ Play
bill so that y'all can have it to review. Representative Brushing, you are recognized to present House Bill 1799.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, Committee, and thank you for hearing this today. House Bill 1799, which will be known as Tara's Law if this, I like to say, this lonely little bill sitting on Capitol Hill makes it through the process. We go back to schoolhouse rock days. But first, I would like to kind of address why I want to call this Tara's Law. And so who was Tara? Tara was a beautiful and accomplished woman that grew up playing basketball, being a cheerleader, and playing the piano. She was crowned as Miss Fountain Lake, Miss Teen Hot Springs Village, and Miss Teen Hot Springs. She was accepted and graduated high school at the Arkansas School for Math and Science and Arts. She graduated the University of Oklahoma with a bachelor's degree of science in healthcare administration. She was a wife, a mother, a sister, a granddaughter, a niece, and to me she was my daughter. I was a young mother at the age of 18, so Tara and I basically grew up together. She endured the ups and downs of my life. Tara was my best friend. Two years ago, 10 months, 11 days, at the age of 29, Tara passed away unexpectedly and left behind three beautiful children and a family that was devastated. So why do I want to tell you about Tara? Because I know Tara and I know her heart and what happened next is something that she would have never wanted to happen. Since she passed away and her husband and the babies left my house on May 28th, 2016 with hugs, kisses, a bag of chocolate chip cookies and tons of memories, Tara's side of the family has been denied any type of contact with her children. We went from having contact via phone, FaceTime, or personal visits daily to spending Christmases, Thanksgiving, and all holidays and birthdays together to not even being allowed to send a birthday card or Christmas presents without having them returned. So the bill that I bring for you today is a bill that I've been working on for over three years now, well, almost three years now. And it's the grandparents' visitation rights. What I first want to point out is this is not a new bill to Arkansas. Arkansas does have grandparent visitation rights. What I want to do with this bill is just to make some amendments to make it easier for grandparents that truly have a relationship or had a relationship with their children's children to be able to petition the courts in order to continue that relationship to benefit that child and also those grandparents. By no means is this bill something that we want to allow bad grandparents back in to the lives when parents have said that this is not what they want and it would be harmful to the children. So basically what we have done after three years of work and my first bill that I submitted this session when I went to Aging Children and Youth in the House Committee. We had lots of discussion. The Judicial Council and the court judges were there. So we scratched that bill totally. And we've gone back and with the help of them, I think that we have a bill that it came out of committee in the House side with no opposing votes. It came off the floor with only one no vote. But let me tell you what basically this would do. It would add three different places of why grandparents could petition for rights to see their grandchildren. Not custody. Remember, this is just visitation rights. This is not custody rights. And it would be if the court finds a parent unfit. So if a court has already ruled that a parent is unfit, then that grandparent can come in and and make a claim that they want a petition to have visitations to that child. Also, if a court finds by clear and convincing evidence of compelling circumstances that seeing the grandparents are in the child's best interest, both sets of these language, these two circumstances were taken from South Carolina grandparent rights statute that was signed into law in 2014 by Governor Nikki Haley, and it seems to be working beautifully in that state. The third reason this bill adds that a grandparent may petition the court is in the event a step-parent of either biological parent of the child adopts a child due to the death of a biological parent of the child. Death is the only reason, so it does not interfere with the adoptions just if a step-parent adopts after the death of a biological parent. This language was actually taken from Louisiana, and it was also taken from North Carolina, which is where my grandchildren are. So even if we pass this law, this doesn't help me, but because this language is in the North Carolina law, it is allowing me to be able to go through the process there. And that language is in Louisiana, Minnesota, Michigan, Massachusetts, Colorado, Kentucky, Kansas, Iowa, Wisconsin, Vermont, Texas, South Dakota, Pennsylvania, New Mexico, North Carolina, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Arizona, Alaska, Indiana, Illinois, and Georgia. These are not new ideas. They are taken from legislation across other states that seem to be working. and they're working in in conjunction with the supreme court ruling of troxel versus scramble and i do have tom smith here from uh the juvenile court in bentonville bentonville is that correct and uh he would like to add just just something from the courts if that's okay judge would you identify yourself again for this
▶ Play
afternoon for the record thank you chairman committee my name
▶ Play
Speaker 33 8:30
is Tom Smith. I'm a circuit judge in Benton County. I serve on the Judicial Council. We wanted the committee to know that we took no official position on this bill. However, we also thought it was very important for you all to know exactly how much the representative worked with judges to get language that was not objectionable and was able to work very closely with several different judges as she worked on getting this language just right to present to you all.
▶ Play
And with that, I'm open for any questions. Questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Seeing no questions, is there anyone here to speak against the bill? Is there anyone here to speak for the bill? Seeing none, Representative Rushin, would you
▶ Play
like to close for your bill? I just would appreciate a good vote from this committee,
▶ Play
and thank you for your time for hearing me. I'm closed. Motion to pass from Senator Flowers. Second from Senator Letty. Any further discussion? Hearing none, all for the motion signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed? Motion carried. Congratulations, Representative Rushin. You have passed your bill. Thank you, and thank you, committee. Do you have another bill? Yes, I do. House Bill 1814. C in 1814. When did it come out of House Judiciary? Or when did it come from the
▶ Play
floor, I should say? um it came from floor a couple days ago but if you're not seeing it i can come back and so that's not
▶ Play
a problem hold on just a moment but it appears it hasn't had enough time to
▶ Play
Speaker 12 10:45
make it to the agenda it was just read yesterday the 26th and referred to our committee
▶ Play
Speaker 25 10:51
Okay. Yeah. Am I here a day
▶ Play
early? Yes. Okay. If you'll remind me, Representative Rush, and I'll try to run the bill. All right. Thank you. Just don't remind me so I don't forget. Okay. Okay. As the committee had a chance to review Representative Boyd's bill, which is. 1631. 1831
▶ Play
House Bill 1831 I think you just handed it to me, didn't you? Yes, ma'am
▶ Play
President Boyd, before I ask the committee any more questions, was this controversial
▶ Play
Speaker 71 12:02
in the House? We had 95 votes on the floor in Jerobovo.
▶ Play
But was there any opposition in committee? Was there opposition in committee? No, sir. Okay. There's no opposition. I mean, I'm not saying anything, but I don't know what it is. Again, committee, we had sent out notice to folks that they needed to get in and run their bills or they'd be put on the deferred list, and we had Representative Boyd on the list, although his bill wasn't on the agenda yet, and so he came to run his bill. So if you would be pleased to hear it, it would take, one of you would have to make a motion, and it would take six votes. We've got a motion from Senator Cooper, a second from Senator Rice. Any discussion? Hearing none, all for the motion is signified by saying aye. Aye. All opposed?
▶ Play
Speaker 76 12:56
Motion carried. I have a question, though. Okay. Do the members of the audience, do the prosecutors have a copy of it, 1831? HB 1831?
▶ Play
Speaker 48 13:04
They do. Okay. Yes, okay. Representative Boyd. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. And if you will allow, my Sebastian County prosecutor is going to join us as well. If I'd have known he
▶ Play
was Sebastian County, we might not have been so friendly to him in this whole session. If you would identify yourself for the record, that was an attempt at a joke.
▶ Play
Daniel Hsu, I'm prosecuting attorney, 12th Judicial District, Sebastian County, and I am the legislative chairman for the Arkansas Prosecuting Attorneys Association, and this is my representative. May I begin? You are recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 86 13:48
to present your bill. Representative Boyd. All right.
▶ Play
House Bill 1831. This bill is about incentive and hope for those paying a debt to society. This bill is about removing barriers to re-enter society, obtain meaningful employment and housing. In the words of Brian Graham, a case manager for Restore Hope Arkansas, this legislative policy will be used as an incentive and goal-setting tool. This would be a powerful motivator for offenders. This bill does three things. First, it acknowledges the intent of the legislature to further study the criminal record sealing process. Two, it removes the five-year look-back period for nonviolent felonies. and again, I want to reiterate, nonviolent, and three, it removes the $50 record-sealing fee. It does not change any other laws regarding which records are or are not sealed or viewed once they are sealed, and there is no known opposition to this bill. That said, we'd be happy to answer any questions and, again, reiterate my prosecutors here if we have legal things that go over my head. Questions from the committee? Senator Stubblefield. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. The Representative Boyd, the five-year look back for the nonviolent felonies? Yes, sir. Can you explain why was that put in there?
▶ Play
Really, it was intellectual integrity. In Sebastian County, I used to use primarily suspended imposition of sentence. So you would be placed on a suspended sentence. You'd pay your restitution. You'd pay your fine. And at the end of that five-year suspended sentence, you'd come in and you'd seal the record. Well, whenever you went back, and I say you, the legislature went back in 2013, they said you had to wait five years after it was completed. This puts it to where you can do it immediately after the sentence is completed. And, again, once you've paid your fine, you've paid your restitution, you've done everything that you're supposed to do, then you should be able to get your record sealed, not wait five years after that. It just gets people back in the workforce and earning money, hopefully where you never see them again in the criminal justice system. I
▶ Play
totally agree with that. I mean, I love that part of the bill. I was just wondering, when was
▶ Play
Speaker 98 16:07
it, five years? How long has that been in place? Since 2013. 2013. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Other
▶ Play
questions from the committee? Senator Cooper? Thank you, Mr. Chair. For the attorney, prosecutor, have you seen the bill that I've got over in the House right now that the attorney general's office worked with me on? It's not completed yet, but it's an occupational licensing bill. What we're doing in that is not having to do with sealing records, but I was just wondering if you've looked at this and see if there's anything in conflict with that, if you
▶ Play
know. Short answer to that is I'm not aware of that bill. Be happy to compare it if you need that. I'm not aware
▶ Play
of that bill. Okay. I'm not opposed to what you're doing here. I don't see anything in conflict with it, but I'd like for you to look at that bill in connection with this one and see if there's anything in conflict with it. I think I would have heard about it if
▶ Play
there was. Senator, can I just clarify? This only does the three things, and so like the health care boards that can look at sealed records, the law enforcement, it doesn't change any of that. It just makes, it removes a barrier to, actually it removes two barriers to be able to get your record sealed sooner and with no cost.
▶ Play
That bill has nothing to do with sealing records, so, okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 107 17:48
I think we're good. Thank you. Senator Stouperfield. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Boyd, would this bill in any way, having these records sealed immediately, would they expedite a person's right who has been convicted of a felony where their Second Amendment rights have been taken away? Would it help restore those rights quicker? uh
▶ Play
not necessarily i mean what this does is the sealing of the record so you can go out and apply for work and get get employment for right so this
▶ Play
would have no connection to those all still remain in effect
▶ Play
that you can vote and you know your rights are restored those are all this doesn't affect those okay all right thank you mr other questions from the committee Seeing
▶ Play
none, is there anyone here to speak against the bill? Anyone here to speak for the bill? Seeing none, Representative Boyd, would you
▶ Play
like to close for your bill? Thank you for the opportunity to hear this, and I appreciate it, and I'd appreciate someone giving me a due pass and a good vote. Thank you. Motion to
▶ Play
do pass from Senator Rice. Second from Senator Letting. Any further discussion? Hearing none, all for the motion signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed? Motion carried. Congratulations, Representative Boyd. You have passed your bill. Senator Elliott, are you here to run a Senate bill? Yes, sir. Senator, 487. 487. 487. I don't see it. Yes. $487, not in our packet for some reason. $387. MS. GOING TOO FAST. MR. SB 378. MS. THAT'S THE RIGHT ONE, YES. MR. SEN. ELLIOTT HAS
▶ Play
TRIED TO THROW US OFF THE TRACK TWICE. MS. I MIGHT HAVE BETTER LUCK WITH THE
▶ Play
OTHER ONE. I THOUGHT I'D TRY THAT. MR.
▶ Play
SEN. ELLIOTT, YOU ARE RECOGNIZED TO PRESENT YOUR BILL. MS. THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. Between the time, since the time I was here last, and you'd ask us to, you know, get with prosecutors and try to find out what we can find out to respond to the questions that you all had regarding the folks that were on the list that would be affected by this bill. And in the interest of time, I won't just try to go back through the bill in any kind of lengthy way, except just to say for people who might not know what we're talking about, our proposal is to look at those folks who would be affected differently if they were being sentenced under the bill that we passed in 2011 for drug sentences. And most people got extremely long sentences. and our proposal is to bring some equity to that sentence and from that they got many years ago in the 90s or so, that if they have served the amount of time that they would serve today if they were sentenced, then that sentence would be set aside. And they would have to go to court and petition the court. They would have to make sure the information is, they bring the information themselves over with their attorney or whomever is helping them. And we are not at all talking about any of the sentences they have except the drug sentence. So if they also have a burglary sentence, they have to serve that. that's not connected. If they have an assault or whatever it may be, they still have to serve that. And the problem we have is what we've tried to work out with the information we've gotten from the prosecutors because she requested it. Was there anything else that would inform the sentence they got for the drug offense? And I don't have a way of fixing that if they did, because the sentence they have is the sentence they have. But we did get information, and I think all of you probably got information as well. And so we're just here kind of at the mercy of the committee to find out what it is you think we can do, because what is, is. And that's not anything we can fix. We're just trying to come up with a solution to give people an opportunity to have sentencing that's equitable as much as possible to what they would get today. And we don't have any kind of agreement with the prosecutors. They will still be opposed. And it is just strictly up to this committee what you want to do in this situation we find ourselves in, which is a difficult situation, no question about it. But that is what this bill is about. So with the information you have and the information that we've seen, I guess I'm just open to any discussion that the committee has, any questions we can
▶ Play
possibly answer, Mr. Chair. Senator Flowers. Thank you, Senator Elliott. Since you were last in the committee on this bill, Senator Bunn ran Senate Bill 517. Yes. And I think at least my sentiment is, well, number one, you said to have their sentence set aside. Well, I, yeah. I don't think that's the correct term. That's not, yeah, that is not. Okay, maybe commuted or something, but it wouldn't be set aside. But the other thing is, my feeling is, we don't know what other sentences these individuals that have been identified responsive to your Bill 378 and Senator Bunn's Bill 517. And I'm very uncomfortable just summarily as a legislative committee recommending in place of a parole board or the governor's right to commute sentences, pardon, that kind of thing. And so what I suggested when Senator Bond brought his bill before the committee is that maybe the committee do a motion to do a resolution, Senate resolution, encouraging and urging the governor to consider those persons that the parole board has considered and recommended for parole or something like that. because I don't want it on my head. And, you know, you get to a point where somebody has a life sentence, and some people that were presented with Senator Bunn's bill, they've been in there for more than 30 years. And, you know, at a point, my experience is you get to a point you're institutionalized. And so just to release people that are not really ready to transition and you don't know where they're going back to, I'm very hesitant about that. I am, particularly if they have other offenses. But somebody that's institutionalized, I've dealt with institutionalized persons. I don't think they're less human than anybody else. But when you are contained in a facility, imprisoned, and you're used to going to sleep at a certain time, being ordered to get up at a certain time, eat at a certain time, I have some reservations. And I think that should go to the parole board and our suggestion to the governor to consider. and maybe expedite his consideration, because I do know that these requests and applications to the governor take at least a year. So if he could expedite it and if our committee could do a motion, a Senate resolution for Senate resolution, encouraging and urging the governor to consider what the parole board has recommended concerning these inmates that are referenced and have been identified per your bill and Senator Bond's bill. And maybe if they've got some other charges that they're on and sentencing that they're serving time for, they'll, you know, I mean, I don't know what they'll do, but I don't think the parole board is going to recommend parole unless they are in a position to be released early.
▶ Play
Yeah, and we are not, beyond what we were discussing regarding the drug sentence, we were not requesting the parole board to release them if they have these other
▶ Play
charges that they have to serve. But the point is, the parole board has recommended release of some, according to the testimony of some of the individuals. But because it takes so long, I mean, I would suggest and I would make a motion at the proper time for the committee to do a Senate resolution encouraging and urging the governor to act expeditiously on any applications and any recommendations from the Parole Board on individuals that have been identified pursuant to Senate Bill 378 and Senate Bill 517. I would just
▶ Play
remind you. Would you please? Oh, I'm sorry. My name is Larry Froelich, attorney. Thank you. I participated in the drafting of the bill, and I just wanted to make sure you understood that nothing in this bill would affect any other punishments besides those under the Controlled Substances Act so that also the, I guess I don't know if I should take exception, but we lock someone up under an extreme sentence, and all the ones that we've listed here. And I was impressed by how our data and the prosecutor's data are pretty much exactly the same. For example, Mr. Dixon, who got life plus 30 for drug sentences with no prior convictions, and there are many in that situation and all this bill would do would be to reduce their punishments to the maximum that's allowed under current law. And then that they would become institutionalized then that would mean that they would never be able to get out because if they've been in there for a long time well, then they would never get out. I don't have the figures on that, but when a person passes a certain age, I think it's like 51, the likelihood that they're going to reoffend is very low. Now, we could, there is a way for the parole board to handle this, Senator, And we have an amendment that would charge the DOC and the parole board with the obligation to enforce the provisions of our bill. And we didn't want to submit that to you because there's no provision for paying them to do that. It's like it would become an unfunded mandate to parole and DOC. If you'd like for us to submit the bill in the form that would switch the obligation to parole and the department, well, we certainly could do that if that would change your view. Okay, before we
▶ Play
go further, have members of the committee reviewed the information that came from the prosecutors? Because I have not. It's in my office, but I have not. I've got it here. Okay. Well, hold on. The information that you have, is it going to sway anyone? We're late in the session, and we've got things to consider. So is it going to sway anyone, since we've heard from everyone before, is it going to sway anyone one way or the other on this bill?
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, you know, this is one thing when it came in the other day and the lawyer attended the table, didn't have data that I'd already looked up off a common website. Again, I just keep saying it and saying it. You can't get back in the head of a jury what all they're looking at. Yes, drug charges have been, sentences have been lowered, But these people, if you look, and the prosecutors did an extensive packet of information that easily looked at. And, again, there may be, as I said the other day, one or two that deserve an extra look. And I would be open to, I don't want to do it just willy-nilly here today, but I would be interested in seeing wording that Senator Flyers or somebody could come up with in a resolution that might steer some interest to look towards this, but there's no way that I'm going to support this today. Thank you.
▶ Play
Senator Flowers. And it could be, even if, I don't know if a person can apply for a commutation of just one part of a sentence after being convicted of several offenses and getting several offenses. But it might be a way that they can apply, and the resolution can be encouraging and urging the governor to even consider just commuting that lifetime sentence to whatever is under Act, I forgot the number of it. 570. 570 for the drug offense. And then otherwise, consider the recommendation and expedite these cases. Well, Mr. Chair, if we
▶ Play
Speaker 153 34:33
are not going to do
▶ Play
anything further with this bill in here, I don't want to waste your time here this evening when you
▶ Play
have other things to do. Well, and that's what I'm asking, Senator Elliott. I'm not trying to cut you short, but all of us are... I don't want to waste your time. I'm not sure that... Because I'm very sympathetic, but I'm not sure that I have heard the information to sway enough to make that decision at this time. And I know that I can see at least two others that are not, and there would only have to be one more. So I don't want to go into it at length if that's going to be the case. Okay. And I don't want to cut you short either if that's not
▶ Play
the case. No, Mr. Chair, I'll just leave it at this and you can go on to your
▶ Play
Speaker 162 35:43
next title. Do I want to
▶ Play
do what? Well? Would you like to close and have a vote?
▶ Play
Well, why don't we do that? Either way, it's the same result. You know, one way or the other might be better.
▶ Play
I don't know who's where. Yeah. How do you feel about
▶ Play
the resolution? I think the resolution is, I think what we're trying to do is certainly better. if we have to go to a resolution we could certainly do that after a vote
▶ Play
if we need to let me ask the committee because we've got the prosecutors signed up to speak against but we've been through this before so I don't think they're going to tell us anything new so if you want to we'll
▶ Play
Speaker 169 36:31
do that next. But if y'all want to
▶ Play
do anything different, tell me. Otherwise, I'm going to let Senator Elliott close for a bill, and then if somebody wants to make a motion, we will, and we'll see where it goes. Should I go ahead and close, Mr. Chair? Yes.
▶ Play
Well, one of the things I think that is a reality is this is a hard thing to deal with if we're looking for something that's just going to be clean and straight ahead. And And one of the values of being on this committee is your judgment. And that's kind of where we are. Because we know we have a system. We've got the information that is very clear that this has been very inequitable sentence. And I think for reasons that people thought were good reasons. And I know the prosecutors haven't changed their mind. They've been up front with us and they've said they're still going to be against it. And their reason for being against it is that we've made a deal. and I've said what I had to say about making a deal. When you know better, surely you do better. But if we're gonna be held to a standard of somehow making this just a clean deal where we don't have to dig deep into our consciences and make a judgment of do we think this is so egregious that we can live with having one standard for people today who commit the same crime and knowing fully well we've got people who committed those crimes many years ago and we are willing, are we really willing to leave them in prison? Now, when people get out of prison, if they don't have other sentences to serve, when people get out of prison, they don't just get out of prison. And that's why we have transformational housing. And if they don't have transformational housing, there are people sitting in prison right now and have been for years because there's not been transformational housing they can go to. They don't just get to go out and just be a part of society without having some assistance. So this is a time I ask you to draw on your judgment. What do you think is the right thing to do? Because if you hold us to this standard of, we can't change our minds, we can't see things today in light of today, then that leaves us just in the same situation we've been in for years where we will continue to pay thousands and thousands of dollars for people to be in prison, and a few who could probably be out now who have just a drug charge. But if anybody has any other charge, they have to serve that time for that charge. We are not trying to do anything with that. So I would just ask you to exercise that judgment, and let's think differently about what we're doing to people's lives, both those who were victims and those who were in prison and their families' lives. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and
▶ Play
thanks, Committee. Action from the Committee. Senator Cooper? Just for your information and the Committee's information, I don't personally have any objection to these cases being looked at on a case-by-case basis if there's merit there on individuals, but I don't know that I'm in favor of taking the whole group as a lump. But if there's some review that maybe the authorities could use to see if there's any merit there on an individual case-by-case basis, I wouldn't oppose that. Okay. Mr. Chair, may I clear up something? I'm sorry just
▶ Play
to that. and I'm not going to go back through the whole thing again, but when they go to court, it would have to be on a case-by-case basis. And if they were going to ever be paroled, it's on a case-by-case basis. That's why they
▶ Play
would go to court. Any action on this bill? Motion, do pass from Senator Leading, second from Senator Bond. Discussion?
▶ Play
I have discussion. Senator Flowers? You know, we have a process. and it's the parole board. And to bring people back to court after appeal time has expired, I mean, it's through the parole board or through the governor's office. And when we start doing this as a legislative body, I think that's a problem. That's a problem because we're saying to a system, Even though it was an old law, it's different now. It's inequitable, as you say, because for those offenses today, they wouldn't be looking at the maximum punishment as they were before whatever it was. So, but I just don't think we should just go around the process. at least allow us to say to the process, to the system, which is the parole board, but they've already spoken on some of these cases that came in here the other day with Senator Bunn. Those people testified that the parole board had recommended that they get out, those that could. One lady came in here, her husband, I think he had multiple charges, charges. But the lifetime sentence that he got on the drug case, that was the one that was keeping him in. And the parole board, I think she said, had said he could recommend it for him to get out. And so she said he had applied to the governor's office in January of this year. So what I'm suggesting is a motion for a Senate resolution to encourage and urge the governor to look at these applications based on either the parole or their application straight to him for a commutation of the sentence. But, and you mentioned about transition houses and stuff. If somebody has served their term, they don't have to wait to get a transition house. They've maxed out the time. They've flattened out, and they are out. You can't keep them. So I don't know where that comes from. But some people that are eligible for parole and are recommended for parole, they're going to have to show a place to stay or get into a transition house. And all I'm saying is that we need to be, as a legislative committee, conscious of our communities that we live in. And, I mean, I've had clients that are institutionalized, and they'll tell you they are. They get out, they go do something else because they don't have a place to stay, or they want to watch the Super Bowl, or they're cold when it's in the winter. They just can't function. The family is not there to help them. And so when you, this, I just don't want it on my conscience. And like I said before, the bill itself had all these people calling, thinking their relatives, their loved one was just going to get out just because of these bills. And that's not necessarily the case, even if the bill passed. And it was wrong to make them believe that, but I would prefer and would offer a motion for the committee to have drafted a Senate resolution urging the governor's office to expedite applications for pardons, gardens, commutations that have been recommended by the parole board for the named individuals. And then that way, the parole board and the governor's office can look at individual cases.
▶ Play
Okay. We have a motion on the table. Well, the committee, what I would tell you and I would tell Senator Elliott is I deal sometimes daily with folks that think that they have not been treated correctly in the child welfare system. and I have to make a decision that they've got some kind of clear and compelling evidence that that's the case because you have to whether it seems like I do or not you at some point you have to trust the system to work you have to as the prosecutors have mentioned and Senator Rice has mentioned you have to trust the juries you have to trust the prosecutors You have to trust law enforcement. You have to trust that there was a defense attorney. And knowing that there's going to be exceptions and knowing that the law has been changed and I apologize that I had to be out and didn't hear all the testimony, maybe I might have heard clear and compelling evidence. But I haven't. Because if I heard clear and compelling evidence on two or three cases, I would be working with you to try to find a way to work on those two or three cases. But I certainly don't see 90 cases that I would be comfortable with this law affecting. And for that reason, while I'm very sympathetic and would like, if there are some compelling cases that need to be fixed, I would like to work to help you with them. I can't support this bill
▶ Play
as it is now. Other discussion? Senator Bond. Well, I know there's a motion there. Senator Elliott's bill, but the motion's not incongruent with her getting a vote either. But that's what I was going to ask after the vote, depending on how it goes, was at least at 517, maybe I think there's a lot of energy on the committee to figure out if there's some way to deal with some of these people that's fair. Send it to interim study maybe and really dig in. Not necessarily her bill, but 517 at least. I don't want to speak for her bill, but to have a resolution, if there would be some language anybody could agree to, and then also send at least 517 to interim study and possibly send her Elliott's bill, depending on the
▶ Play
outcome. There are people, I think the prosecutors would agree, there are people who slip through the system. There are people that are there longer than they should be, and I don't think any of us want that to be. And so however it's addressed, whether it be a resolution, whether it be an interim study, I think we can find something we can support there to try to find the people that need to be helped without possibly making a mistake of helping people that we would be sorry we helped. I think that is probably a number of our concern. Other discussion? Hearing none, all for the motion. do pass. Signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed? No. Okay. Your bill failed, Senator Elliott. Would the committee like to
▶ Play
take other action? I'll make a motion. What's your motion, Senator Flowers? My motion is that this Senate Judiciary Committee have prepared a Senate resolution that would encourage and urge the governor of the state of Arkansas to consider the recommendations for parole commutation that have been made by the parole board as well as any of these individuals that are named in the information that was provided by Senator Elliott and Senator Bunn regarding individuals that have a lifetime sentence for controlled substance under the old law. and act expeditiously on those applications. I hope you wrote all that down, Allison. Senator Rice?
▶ Play
Just for discussion on the motion, I would personally like to see something drafted and
▶ Play
Speaker 196 50:49
bounce it off various members to have input and then go from there.
▶ Play
What I sense the will of the committee is that they would like to have something drafted and they would like to see it before they actually
▶ Play
have a motion. That's basically what I'm saying. It wasn't clear, definitely. I wouldn't just want the Bureau to do something and fly out of here, but we need to look at it. Yes, but I just don't think the committee wants to.
▶ Play
And vote on it. So, Senator Flowers, I know you're willing to work on this. If any one of you is willing to work to help get this done, Senator Bond, any of the others, and Senator Elliott, look at that. Anything that we would do with interim study would, of course, be on the Senate floor as far as sending bills to interim study. But, again, I think, Senator Elliott, you've done a good job of raising the issue and making us aware there's a problem, and hopefully we can find a solution.
▶ Play
Senator Stubblefield, did you have something? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I just want to say I think an in-depth interim study would be much more effective than a resolution. I've seen resolutions in what. You can do both. And I understand we can do both, but I think there needs to be emphasis on an interim study and doing an in-depth study on each individual case because, you know, if just one, if we could just remedy one of these, it would be worth it.
▶ Play
I think you have a committee here that is willing to work with you on an interim study, Senator Elliott, but something for you to consider. Okay, so we'll work on that. Does that go for Senator Bunn's bill, too? Sure. Okay. Senator Stofield, do you have a Senate bill? I do. Okay. Is there anyone here not on the committee that has a bill? Well, we will take Senate bills first, since House bills just have to go from here to the floor, and Senate bills have to fly all the way across the building and into a House committee. Okay. Okay. Senator Stubblefield, what bill do you have? Senator Bill 558. Mr. Chairman, SB 558. The committee, since we're down until the last weeks, and we'll let the public know this, too, if we see that something has support, we may want to move quicker to vote on it and get it out if we see something's not going to have support we may want to move quicker to stop it so that we can get everything all of our business done that needs to be done without being here till midnight but so again it will be up to you to make the motions but we're down to that point that everybody understands that we're in a time crunch and y'all have no one has worked harder than y'all have and people have had plenty of opportunity to be here so we'll do what we need to do. Senator Stouffield
▶ Play
you're recognized to run your bill. Thank you Mr. Chairman. Thank you committee. Those of you who were here during the 2017 special session probably remember this bill. In fact it was especially if you served on judiciary. This is a bill that was extracted from this committee that dealt with the rules of civil procedure in regard to waiving the rights to a trial by jury. I've had issues with this bill for only on two years now, and some of those are pretty strong in regard to our constitutional rights, to the right to a trial by jury. Mr. Chairman, if you don't mind, I have some individuals I would like to
▶ Play
Speaker 208 55:39
call up to testify. That'll be fine.
▶ Play
A few folks would turn on your mics one at a time
▶ Play
and identify yourself for the record. Thank you, Joey McCutcheon, trial lawyer and citizen from Fort Smith. Josh Allen, attorney here
▶ Play
Speaker 299 56:01
in Little Rock. Okay, Senator Stouffville. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chairman. I am going to let, since I am not an attorney, I am going to let these gentlemen defer to them for an explanation of this bill and what it does.
▶ Play
Y'all are recognized. Thank you. Chairman Clark and members of the committee, a hero of mine is Patrick Henry. Patrick Henry once said, is the relinquishment of the trial by jury and the liberty of the press necessary for your liberty? Will the abandonment of your most sacred rights tend to the security of your liberty? Liberty, the greatest of all earthly blessings. Give us that precious jewel and you may take everything else. Guard with precious attention the public liberty. Suspect everyone who approaches that jewel. In 1874, our founding fathers proposed our Constitution, Article 2, Section 7. And they said in that Article 2, Section 7 in our Bill of Rights, our Declaration of Rights, that the right to trial by jury shall remain inviolate. But a jury trial may be waived by parties in all cases in the manner prescribed by law. And as Senator Stubblefield referred to, Senate Bill 558 simply restores the right to trial by jury, which that statute, which I think was in last year's special session, took away. And that statute simply read a written provision in a contract to borrow money or to lend money in which the parties agree to waive their respective rights to a trial by jury under Arkansas Constitution, Article 2, Section 7, is valid and enforceable. Well, to have a contract, you have to have a meeting of the minds or in agreements of the parties. And by nature, by the way, this contract, and I think as the senators know, only apply to these banking contract pre-suit, pre-dispute, jury waiver clauses, only to one particular special interest, that is the banks. These contracts are, in essence, take-it-or-leave-it contracts. We've all sat probably at a bank, and we get a form agreement. We get a standard form agreement. There's no equal bargaining power. Many of us may be lawyers, doctors, business folks, but many folks are just everyday Arkansans, and there's no equal bargaining power. And certainly there's no ability to modify these contracts. You take it or you leave it. And that's where the rub, in my opinion, comes when they put that we are waiving our right to trial by jury in these contracts. As mentioned in this bill, unknowingly, unwillingly, and it's non-negotiable. They don't negotiate. You take it or you leave it. So the question arises, should consumers, everyday Arkansans, be forced to give up their constitutional right to trial by jury simply because they're doing business with a powerful bank, or for that matter, any other special interest group? And I think the timing of it is very significant because our Arkansas rule of civil procedure says that the waiver of a right to trial by jury can only take place after litigation begins. And that's important because at that point, after litigations begin, generally folks have attorneys who are representing them. They fully understand their right to trial by jury. They're not unknowingly giving up one of the most valuable constitutional rights that we have. And it's for those reasons that I would ask a favorable vote on Senator Stubblefield's bill. Can I add one thing, Senator? Senator Clark, may I add one thing? Please. Also here today is Kenneth Tilley, who is the victim of one of these unconscionable banking agreements. And he had called me, I think it's been a couple of years ago now, but certainly called me last year when this bill was running. He took this, his case, all the way to the Supreme Court, got a decision, and it was promptly, in special session last year, it was promptly, that decision was promptly taken away. after he had spent time, effort, and energy to protect not only his right to trial by jury, that precious liberty, that precious jewel, but also the rights of our Kansans. So thank you, Senator Clark. Okay. Before we, the committee at this
▶ Play
point, we would normally go to questions. we have actually got two of the folks at the end of the table signed up to speak for and one has spoken and I think the other one is dealt. Are you Josh Allen? And you're not, you don't have anything to add? If it would be okay with the committee I would like to bring are the against together or is it one at a time? They'll come together. If it's okay with the committee I'd like to bring them on up before we start questioning. Y'all stay there at the end of the table because this should, on one hand, we're going to, we've heard the constitutional civil liberty side. Now we're going to find, we'll hear if you'll excuse me for saying it this way, while it's going to be a complete financial disaster and then the committee will get to decide between. So if y'all come to the table and identify yourself for the record. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Speaker 239 1:03:21
I'm John W. Adams, Market President and CEO of First Security Bank in Conway. Good afternoon. I'm Hunter Wendell.
▶ Play
Speaker 237 1:03:28
I'm legal counsel from Auburn National Bank. I hope I didn't take away too
▶ Play
much of your thunder. Y'all are recognized. I can start, and I appreciate y'all's
▶ Play
Speaker 237 1:03:39
time today. If you would turn your mic off, except when you're speaking. Thank you. Y'all hear me? Pull it closer if you can. Senate Bill 558 will put Arkansas law further at odds with federal law and the vast majority of the states on this issue. It's a minority position because it's a bad position. Jury waiver provisions are as old as the common law itself. While jury trials are a fundamental part of our legal tradition, so is the right to contract. They're an efficient and quick means of resolving disputes, and they allow disputes to be resolved in a more timely and inexpensive manner. You know, as an in-house attorney who negotiates loan documents on a daily basis, I take issue with the findings in this piece of law. I've certainly negotiated jury waivers, and really I think that those findings are a bit of a red herring anyway, with all due respect to the sponsor and to the proponents of this bill. As the lawyers in the room know, before jury waiver provisions or similar provisions are even enforced, the court will generally look to whether they have been voluntarily and willingly entered into. As a part of that analysis, they look at the disparate bargaining power of the parties. They look at whether the terms were negotiable and a whole host of other things, decide whether it was willingly and voluntarily entered into. So if the legislature is concerned about those specific issues, I think that those concerns are alleviated by the fact that the courts already generally look at them. You know, if Senate Bill 558 is adopted, lenders and bars will be forced to litigate these issues before juries, which will resort in significantly higher legal costs. But I think there's a more important point to be made, and that is that this isn't about jury waivers or jury trials versus bench trials. Those are only two means of dispute resolution. Arbitration is still valid in Arkansas law. They're widely used, widely enforced. And, you know, bench trials are seen as a middle ground between the two. the passage of Senate Bill 558 by invalidating that middle ground may have the unintended consequences of pushing more borrowers into arbitration clauses. And, you know, rather than protect a borrower's day in court, it may ensure they don't have one at all, whether before a judge or a jury. So, you know, not only is it bad law and policy, I think it's not going to do what it would allege us to do. And that's why I think the majority of the bodies have considered this issue this issue of the year, of the years, including the Arkansas General Assembly just last year, have decided to uphold the validity of jury waiver provisions for the same reason they adopted it last year. I would respectfully ask that you oppose this misguided attempt to undo it. I think the case that prompted this is still before the Supreme Court, so it's not really prudent to discuss it too much, but I do think that decision, you know, speaks for itself and is widely available, so I'd encourage you to look at that, and I think I'll leave my comments at that this
▶ Play
Speaker 239 1:07:11
time. Thank you. Mr. Adams. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to basically, you know, look at this as a part of policy. Uh, is it good business for Arkansas for, um, this, uh, to be taken away? Um, when we look at, um, the, the Act 13, it does not necessarily take away the right to a jury trial. In fact, that's insured by the U.S. Constitution, so, uh, no one is going to take away that, um, ability. Uh, this gives the person entering into the contract the right to waive that, and by waiving that, they may be getting a more expedient, a less expensive resolution to the contract issue that they have that really doesn't require the court expense, the expense and time of a jury trial that's going to delay this process. So in contract matters, this expediency can be very important. Time is money. Getting these matters in front of a judge, this is a local judge who's going to decide these issues for you. We think that that in itself is a good thing for Arkansas. If you look at the other states, this is allowed in 48 states under federal law. This isn't something that Arkansas banks just came up with to say we want to do it this way in Arkansas. This is something that's allowed in 48 states. There are only two states that don't allow this. So when the General Assembly adopted Act 13, which allows for the jury trial waivers, we saw it as almost an emergency measure to ensure that capital and loan funds could flow into the state of Arkansas. We frankly are unsure how some of the national banks and the larger banks out of state. I've been a community banker for 35 years. I'm working for an Arkansas bank now. But it's unclear how some of the other out-of-state lenders may react to this bill. They may ask the borrowers to put the jurisdiction of the litigation in another state. So instead of facing an Arkansas judge, you may be facing a New York judge when it comes to these terms. We think these matters belong in the state of Arkansas, especially these small contract matters. I've served on the Conway Development Corporation's Economic Development Committee for 15 years. We've done a lot of great economic work in Conway. We're always, you know, trying to get capital and loan funds into our state. And I say this just frankly. We have a lot of things against us as a state when we're recruiting industry and trying to get loans and other funding from outside sources. We don't need another bad policy to help hurt us in that case. I respect the rights of people to litigate this. I respect the rights of people to mark through the waiver of jury trial and not agree to it. I mean, that's clearly their right, and that's what they have to do. Now, it may, you know, cause them to go to another bank, but we certainly negotiate those, and those are freely negotiated along with a whole lot of other contract specifics and contracts. So this isn't the only thing that's negotiable in those contracts. So the backlogs that this would cause in the court system based on the inability to try the cases in front of judges, all of those things. It's clearly something that the other states, I think, have seen as expedient and a great way to solve some of these issues. I would hope that Arkansas would continue what Act 13 did. I'll also speak for the Arkansas Bankers Association, which I'm on the board of, and we certainly oppose Senate Bill 558. Thank you for your time. Would
▶ Play
it be all right with the committee? if, since we have one person here to speak for the bill who, according to Mr. McCutcheon, supposedly suffered injury from the law as it is, to hear them before we go to questions? I
▶ Play
Speaker 74 1:11:16
have a question on that. What's
▶ Play
your question? So is this the person who is presently engaged in litigation? I don't think we need to be hearing cases that are presently in litigation. We are not a
▶ Play
court. I'm not a court, and we're not a court, which is that that would be entirely up to someone whether they want to testify or not. If I was a judge in a court, I would certainly not, but we're
▶ Play
not. We're the legislature. Well, I personally don't think we need to be filing retroactive bills and affecting matters that are pending in courts. And I'd rather not hear that. Mr. Tilley, you are signed up
▶ Play
to testify. Do you wish to testify? And may I ask, is Mr. McCutcheon your attorney? No. Okay. Are you represented by an attorney? Yes. Are you have you talked to your attorney about testifying? Yes, Senator. I'm his attorney. You're his attorney. Yes. All right. So you have your attorneys present. OK. So would you identify yourself for the record? Kenneth Tilley. Would you? I'm sorry. I thought I did. Mr. Adams, would you turn your mic off, please?
▶ Play
uh yes my name is kenneth tilly and uh it's on it's on okay can you hear me now yeah yes my name is kenneth tilly uh the bill last year had a retroactivity clause in it that killed my right to jury trial that was remanded to me by the Supreme Court. So that's one of the reasons we're here, to reestablish justice for me and all others. What this Act 13 does, in my opinion, is it opens the door for corrupt banking. It allows them to have the ability to force any citizen to waive that trial, their right to trial by jury in order to receive a loan. I do not believe there's anyone going to negotiate that and not sign that waiver. They're going to be forced to do it in order to receive the loan. And I just truly believe that we have to pass 558 to restore our constitutional rights, Restore Rule 39, the Arkansas Rules of Civil Procedure, which explains the manner in which we can waive that right. And I believe anything less than that is just injustice.
▶ Play
Okay. We're going to go to questions. Senator Flowers, do you no longer have a question? Mr. Adams, you made a statement that got my attention. You said anyone who doesn't wish to sign the contract with that clause in it can go to another bank. Is that something like I can, if I don't agree with the user agreement on Microsoft Word, I can just go
▶ Play
Speaker 239 1:15:16
get another operating system? Each loan negotiation, especially those that are retained by attorneys on both sides, have the ability to negotiate any agreement within the contract itself. So those are certainly options for people. We're not talking theory, though. I
▶ Play
probably have more clout than Mr. Tilly, possibly. And I don't know Mr. Tilly. He may have all kinds of clout. but I don't think I would have any luck in scratching that out I do scratch something out here and then and say no I'm not going to do that but I don't think I'd have any luck at
▶ Play
Speaker 63 1:15:56
all in scratching that out and going to a bank and going to another bank and going to another bank and going to another bank. Do you think I would? You know this
▶ Play
Speaker 258 1:16:07
isn't something that's new that we've just inserted in this clause I remember
▶ Play
voting for it last time because everybody said we need to do this. So now I'm asking, you said you could go to another bank. I'm asking, could I? How many banks would I have to go to to find somebody that would let me scratch that out? You know, I can't answer that, sir. How many do you think that somebody's actually going to let me scratch
▶ Play
Speaker 239 1:16:32
it out? I think that's a possibility, yes. A slim possibility. That's, it depends on what type of loan it is. Absolutely.
▶ Play
Okay. Committee? Senator Cooper. Thank you, Mr. Chair. What's the significance of March 18, 2018? Who is that addressed to? Is that when the last session of the legislature passed this? Senator Cooper, I
▶ Play
believe that is the date we had the special session. Okay. Mr. Adams, could
▶ Play
you turn your mic off again? I think that is the
▶ Play
date of the special session we had when we extracted this bill out of the judiciary. Senator Stofield, we're still
▶ Play
not hearing you on the mic. I'm sorry, Mr. Chairman. Now it's on.
▶ Play
Like I said, that's the date we pulled this bill out of committee and voted on it quickly. If most of you remember, and some of you serving on the judiciary now remember how that whole incident happened, it was voted on very quickly, and that process was taken care of very quickly, because we had voted that down in judiciary and then it was pulled from this committee and brought to the floor and signed out and then we voted on it on the Senate floor.
▶ Play
I just wanted to make sure that it wasn't significant to this case. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 270 1:18:00
Senator Bellinger. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My question is probably for the bank counsel. I guess the first thing is if there's something that you have no choice about and you have to do that is that called a right or is that called something else what would you call that either one of you guys with the bank council let me it's a leading question let me kind of tell you where I'm going is that if it's something that you have no ability to do then it isn't a right it's an obligation right so in this case if So trial by jury, as an attorney, I'm all for it, and I think that you should be very careful about waiving trial by jury. I think, you know, in answer to the chairman's question, if there were a lot of people who really were adamant about that, then it would happen more. You're probably going to have a hard time getting a secondary market loan that's the lower interest rate, if you're willing, because those are big nationally focused. Would that be right? Yes. But you could probably get an in-house loan from a bank with a higher interest rate because you can actually go negotiate, especially with the local banks, right, likely. And so that's the thing is that if you wanted to trade off and say, I'm not willing to waive my trial by jury, may have to take a higher interest rate, so I'm willing to go do this through, and even maybe a hard money lender, right, even if you don't go to the bank, right? Yes, correct. So you can do that. And this thing is, you know, I'm very familiar with the Senator Subblefield because I carried this legislation in 2018. And I did it in kind of an answer to Senator Clark because of civil liberties, right? If you have no choice, if the state of Arkansas is coming and saying, nope, you don't have any right to waive that trial by jury, No matter how, we think that you are not smart enough to be able to protect your own rights and negotiate your own rights. You're not smart enough to do it. We're going to take that away from you, the ability to do that. That's not libertarian. That's not civil liberties. That's, you know, totalitarian, if anything. So, you know, all this is is just that you're empowering two grownups to be able to negotiate and decide whether or not, I mean, is that
▶ Play
Speaker 239 1:20:22
the way you'd characterize it? Yes. Okay. Absolutely. And I think the situation is that they have, even with a bench trial, you have the full power of the court to resolve the matter. The question is, is the court the place, is the judge the place to make this resolution? Or do we ensure this long trial process on these civil contract matters that, frankly, could be decided very quickly in front of a judge?
▶ Play
Speaker 278 1:20:50
Senator Bond? so just a little historical refresher for me so when
▶ Play
I started practicing law there was a division between chancery and circuit and you just couldn't get a jury trial on certain things right I mean there's a whole body of law on that and I know this case I need a little refresher on what the case did to that because typically you weren't entitled to a jury trial on a mortgage breach or debt obligation and Mr. McCutcheon may want to respond to that. That's my recollection. But at some point, I mean, in certain actions you were, or there was a cleanup doctrine or different things like that, that we don't deal with as much today. So what did the case that was decided change with regards to that? What happened? I can't remember how we got to this point. If somebody could describe that briefly. Senator,
▶ Play
Speaker 279 1:21:42
what the case basically did three things, two of them with the jury trial. What it did is it eliminated... Pull that a little closer, too. You can pull them. Scoot up. It eliminated the cleanup doctrine. So basically now, if you have, for example, in this case, there was foreclosure claim and then counterclaims for fraud, breach of contract, whatnot. What the case said was, obviously, the foreclosure claim still traditionally is inequity. There's no jury trial. In the past, the cleanup doctrine also allowed a judge who was sitting in equity to determine the legal claims, the fraud. So what this case is, it eliminated the cleanup doctrine and said the legal claims go to a jury. The equitable claims stay just for the court to decide. And then obviously there's the jury trial
▶ Play
waiver issue, but yeah. And so as that, and then there was a lot of angst about that. So as that last case, Dan, somebody said it's still on appeal possibly. Is that
▶ Play
Speaker 279 1:22:57
right? Yes, it was after the Supreme Court decision came down in December 2017, and then Act 13 was passed in March. Before a jury trial was scheduled on remand in that case, when Act 13 became effective, there was preliminary briefing on whether or not Act 13 would apply. The trial judge ruled that it did apply to this case, and so again declined to allow a jury trial. There's agreement that we weren't going to have another bench trial, so now it's back up on appeal as to whether or not Act 13 could be applied retroactively to this case. That's what's currently pending on appeal. Yeah, so the constitutionality of Act 13 itself. Right, yeah, there's a lot of, there's other issues with it,
▶ Play
but that's. So if that case, short of the passage of our legislation, if you were back on remand under the precedent of that case, the judge would have decided the foreclosure action, then you would have had a jury trial on the other issues? Is that the
▶ Play
Speaker 279 1:23:58
way it would have gone? The foreclosure action part of it was affirmed, actually, on appeals. So that was already decided. dealt with. What was left was for the counterclaims, legal counterclaims to be sent to. To get a jury trial
▶ Play
on that. Great. All right. Okay, and so if we were to pass this, it would take it back to that point? Is that the opinion? That's, yes. So one other thing, and then I'll be quiet. My recollection of this bill, Senator Stufffield's maybe better, is that Senator Hutchinson had a bill that applied to waivers in a lot of context. We voted against it in the committee. And I think they put an amendment on and yanked it out. That's my recollection of it, I think. So, all right, thank you very much. I appreciate the refresher. I couldn't quite remember. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. McCutcheon, let me come back to you. You presented to us how important jury trials are. It's not that like we haven't had that discussion before. and Constitution and the sacredness, et cetera. And then you said that there was somebody here who had been harmed because of this law. You're not his attorney. That's correct. Okay, and you brought one case. Tell me about the harm. Tell me, setting aside theory, Tell me about the harm. Tell me what's egregious. Tell me what it is where people are using an example of somebody actually being harmed, what's happened, and why it so badly needs to be fixed.
▶ Play
Well, if it happened to Kenneth Tilley— But I don't know what happened to Kenneth Tilley. Well, what happened to Kenneth Tilley was he signed what they call a pre-dispute jury waiver clause unknowingly and unwittingly. And that was, again, when he was sitting in the banker's office with the banker shuffling forms,
▶ Play
which happens. But that's the law, so that's what people do, and that's what you're wanting to change. But what happened as
▶ Play
a result of that that's terrible? What happened as a result of that is that he lost the ability to have a trial by jury and was forced to have a bench trial. So that pertains to the sacredness, what our Constitution, specifically Article 2, Section 7, says that our right to trial by jury
▶ Play
shall remain inviolate. We can have the discussion on theory outside in the hall, but on what? But what this, I mean, we have bench trials all the time. We have jury trials. What was it here where losing the right to a jury trial caused
▶ Play
so much harm? Well, I mean, what caused so much harm is he didn't have 12 of his neighbors making the decision or he was not afforded that right. And again, Senator Clark, we have the right under our Arkansas rules of procedure, a jury trial cannot be waived pre-litigation. And that's meant to protect the little guy, the consumers out here, not the bankers and not their lawyers who present a form contract, who have unequal bargaining power. Kenneth Tilley wanted a loan, and he would have signed anything. But you've heard me, Mr. McCutcheon.
▶ Play
You've heard me talk to the bankers. I'm kind of on your side on that. But what I haven't heard is how a consumer has been harmed. You said you couldn't have the trial. But if you had a different trial, unless justice wasn't served, then just because theory we should have had one trial over the other i'm not as impressed again we can have we can argue that theory how are people actually being harmed not not in that they can't have the trial but what is the harm in having the wrong trial uh well maybe
▶ Play
we could reflect back to Thomas Jefferson, uh, and maybe we could reflect back to King George and, and we would, we would know the answer to that is this is a, a clear violation of our constitutional rights, our right to trial by jury, which is fundamental, fundamental to our system of justice. And, uh, Kenneth Tilley was hurt in the way of damages. Clearly, uh, you know, when, when he has to, when he has to go before a judge, again, I wasn't there. If he had to go before a judge or a jury and he did not have that right, now he has the right post-litigation after he has a lawyer who can advise him, okay, you have the right to give up your trial by jury. So my fundamental problem with this, this is an elitist piece of litigation that is special interest driven for a bank, period. And why Why should banks get any more privilege than, say, nursing homes that were taken? I think we all get that. I
▶ Play
thought there might be a case where somebody was terribly damaged because of the law. I think this is the case.
▶ Play
I think if Mr. Tilly wants to answer it, he was driven into bankruptcy because of
▶ Play
this case. So if it's unconstitutional, why don't you argue that in your litigation? In fact, that was argued in the litigation. So then it should go on through the courts, and if the court doesn't find that the law that we have in Arkansas is
▶ Play
unconstitutional, then it's not. The Supreme Court has found that it was unconstitutional because there was no law. Now there is a law, and we're trying to undo that law because we feel like the Constitution is more valuable, and our Bill of Rights are much more valuable than a law which was ramrodded through a special session, which was not designed to even hear litigate. which was not even designed to hear bills. I mean, the question becomes, how is this even heard last year in a special session?
▶ Play
I don't know. I wasn't on judiciary. Obviously, Mr. Ballinger has claimed responsibility for this. I guess it's his bill. I don't know, but it seems like this needs to be handled through the courts. I think the answer will be clear
▶ Play
when it goes back up on this particular issue. If the legislature has said, as our Constitution reads, Senator, the right to trial by jury shall remain inviolate, but a right to jury trial may be waived by the parties in all cases in the manner prescribed by law. And right now, as this stands under Senator Ballinger's bill, the manner prescribed by law is that Mr. Tilly and other consumers in this state can waive their right to trial by jury unknowingly, unwillingly. So when it goes back up, this issue has already been decided. This issue has been decided, Senator.
▶ Play
Well, wait a minute. Well, I'll come back to you. We've had enough. Okay. I'm going to go with Senator Ballinger, and then we'll come back
▶ Play
Speaker 270 1:31:56
to you. Senator Ballinger? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. McCutcheon, you and I tend to agree probably on Second Amendment issues, so this is probably the best Bill of Rights issue for us to talk about. If I passed a law up here that required you to carry a gun,
▶ Play
would that be in furtherance of the Second Amendment? Required me to carry a gun? I believe our Second Amendment is a right. Right? Yes. Just like I believe
▶ Play
Speaker 270 1:32:23
the right to trial by juries. Sure, but if I passed a law
▶ Play
Speaker 287 1:32:27
that required you to carry a gun, is that in furtherance of the second amendment? I
▶ Play
Speaker 180 1:32:35
think that's unconstitutional. I agree. Senator Flowers. Motion for immediate consideration. Motion for immediate consideration. I've got a second from Senator Ballinger.
▶ Play
That is non-debatable. All for the motion signified by saying
▶ Play
Speaker 299 1:32:59
aye. All opposed? Motion carried. You can't vote both ways. Okay, so the motion passed,
▶ Play
so do we have a motion on the bill?
▶ Play
motion Mr. Chairman, I just want to say one thing
▶ Play
if it's okay you know, anytime we had a motion for immediate consideration I would do it for anybody, I'd do it for you I understand, I move do pass motion do pass, I have a second there can be no discussion all for the motion signify by saying aye All opposed? No. Senator Stubblefield, I am sorry, but the bill failed. Can we
▶ Play
have a roll call? Yes, you
▶ Play
can ask for a roll call,
▶ Play
Speaker 308 1:34:18
Senator Stubblefield. Senator Stubblefield? Yes. Senator Cooper? No. Senator Rice, Senator Bond, Senator Ballinger, Senator Letting, Senator Letting, Senator
▶ Play
Speaker 313 1:34:34
flowers four twos three okay
▶ Play
four three I'm sorry I didn't see one over there okay four three Senator Stoverfield okay Senator Ballinger, is it okay if you with Representative Collins goes next?
▶ Play
Speaker 167 1:35:12
What bill is this? Representative Collins, what bill do you have? Is it a retroactive bill? 1686. Representative Penzo, do you have a bill?
▶ Play
Okay. Representative Collins, what bill do you have? 1686, you said? Yes. Does everybody got it? Representative Collins, you are recognized to present
▶ Play
your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. If this may look a little familiar to you all, a similar bill by Senator Johnson passed through your committee, I believe, last week, Senate Bill 547. We were working on our bill, Senator Hammer and I, and Senator Johnson and Chris Ritchie were doing a similar bill, and we were unaware, and they both passed their respective houses last week. I think we talked, and the language in ours was a little bit tighter and a little bit closer to the way the precedent has been over the 30-year period from the Lehman case until the recent Supreme Court case that changed it, as I'll explain a little bit about that. So I think that this bill is probably the one that we prefer, but I will go ahead and give you the brief rundown on it so I can bring you up to speed and make sure that any questions are answered. um so this bill clarifies how active appreciation of non-marital property is treated in divorce for 30 years from that layman versus layman case i referenced the arkansas courts held that active appreciation or an increase in value due to the time effort or skill of either spouse during the marriage is an endeavor belonging to the marital estate and then like all uh marital property is presumed to be subject to equitable distribution upon divorce. The 2016 case that I mentioned is Moore v. Moore. That was also referenced here in the findings in our bill. It was a sua sponte holding that held a new interpretation that the marital property statute that we have did not indicate with adequate clarity that active appreciation of non-marital property was itself marital. So if we as a body wish to restore the traditional approach that we had in our state for 30 years, we need to clearly state the exception in statute. And so that's exactly what this bill does. Very briefly, and you can see how it works. This is an additional section here. It's really on the second page. It's kind of where the meat of it is. 5A is the exception to marital property for general appreciation or passive appreciation, and then we clarify in 5b that when the increase in value or appreciation results from the time, effort, or skill of a spouse, there's a presumption that that's marital property. That's exactly the language that was used in layman. The idea is that it's important to have fairness and stability in the law. It's for lawyers, judges, accountants, everybody else who depends on consistency. We talked to the Judicial Council about this they're fine with it the family law bar has expressed some interest in getting this done so it was not a controversial issue in the house but happy to discuss further answer any questions however y'all want to do it also brought representative house with me who has an interest in some experience with this so he can help answer some questions too
▶ Play
questions from the committee Senator Bond Representative Collins we share the same district so with regards to Senator Johnson's bill I think it was, kind of my question to him was why do we need this I always suspect any change in marital property law is related to not anything nefarious but maybe a concern of someone in their constituency but I think I wound up voting against act because I didn't think it was detailed enough. This does lay it out. Why do we think we need to put it in statute? I noticed the do not codify section. Why do we think we need to stick this in
▶ Play
the statute? Well, I think that the holding of the Supreme Court when they ruled on it was that we didn't have language that said clearly that there was an exception for active appreciation. And, you know, and I see the point. If you look at the language, it's not there. If you do a plain reading of the statute, it doesn't spell it out in ink. And so that's exactly what we're trying to do here. As it stands, the court is finding that to be non-marital property at the current moment. So if we want to revert back, I think they've been pretty clear that we need to heed their holding and put it in statute. So it's
▶ Play
in the, we're having an issue with the way the statute's being interpreted contrary to prior law. Right. Right. Okay. I'm good with that. Thank you. Thank you. Senator Flowers?
▶ Play
Yeah. Well, I think the reason we need your bill is because of Senator Blake Johnson's bill the other week, because he gave the whole separate property. He changed that to marital. Yours is just the increase, the improvement. That's right. And so a judge, and that has been the practice that I've experienced, the judge separates out, how much increase has been, um, uh, has the property, the separate property been enhanced by with marital, uh, funds? That's right. And so you don't give the whole
▶ Play
thing. Yeah. And that's an important distinction is that if it's brought into the marriage, it's non-marital property and that underlying property stays non-marital property. We're only for the increase, the improvement. The active improvement. If it's passive, if you buy stocks and bonds and it increases in value over the course of the marriage, that's non-marital because that's passive. If it results in the time, effort, or skill of the spouse, only then is it active and only then is it marital. Just that
▶ Play
part. Like a house that is being improved. You can look at the value before the improvement and after. And so the increase, the improve less what the value was before is now marital property under your bill. That's right. Okay. Motion at the proper time. Other questions from the committee? I just
▶ Play
can't pass it up. I question your wisdom of bringing Representative House with you. Somebody
▶ Play
might understand this better if I did it in an interpretive dance.
▶ Play
No, no, please do. That would be worth staying here, Representative House, I am sure. I could offer a real-life
▶ Play
example when you get to the floor if you have a question. A lady owned a rather substantial farm, 600 acres in Cleburne County, married. Husband moved on to the farm, worked the farm for 30 years. She got a real estate license, a very successful real estate practice, found somebody a lot cuter than the guy she'd been married to for 30 years, divorced him, then sought to keep the farm out as non-marital property. He had improved it, built barns, fences, and everything like that. The court said, no, no, no, no, no. He contributed to the value, and it was apportioned as marital property. That's a real life case. And then the Supreme Court goes and just says, no, that don't seem right and changed it. This puts it back.
▶ Play
Is there anyone here to speak against the bill? Sylvester Smith.
▶ Play
Good afternoon, members of the committee. My name is Sylvester Smith. I'm speaking today on behalf of the National Federation of Independent Business and the 3,900 small business owners that we represent. I may be the lone voice in the wilderness on this issue, but I want to make sure that the committee understands the statute as it's written now says that if I have a business that my father left to me, that my grandfather left to him, that is my property separate and apart from the marriage. And what happened is there was a series of case law where judges, in my opinion, bastardized the statute and said and created this legal fiction of active appreciation. And so if I'm riding on a septic tank truck or working in a bakery, then my work increased the value of the business. That increased value becomes a marital asset. Well, what the court did in Morey is they went back to the traditional statutory interpretation and said, no, if you had it before, whether you inherited it, you started it, whatever, it's a premarital asset. And so we're asking that you retain the statute as is or potentially amend this bill so that if the non-owning spouse actively invests or participates in the business, that would become marital property. What this provision says is just because I work in the business during the term of my marriage, then that business then becomes the increase becomes marital property. And for those of you who own businesses or work with people who own businesses, a lot of them don't have, would not have the resources to buy a spouse out of the business. And so you're going to force these businesses, you're going to force these farms up for sale to generate the cash so that a person could buy the spouse out of that interest. And so I've asked Representative Collins to look at an amendment where you could protect people from, I do believe Moore went too far, to Representative House's point. When a spouse invests time, energy, money, or effort into growth, that should be marital property. And right now, under more, it is not. However, this measure goes too far. It takes the pendulum too far in the other direction. I'll close just with this. I think it's very important that you consider the fact that this treats small business owners differently than any other party in the state. If I am a high net worth individual that buys stocks and I generate my income from stocks, this won't affect me because it's passive. I didn't work in it. But if I've got a farm and I'm working that farm every day, my spouse has nothing to do with it because I work for a living, then now that increase that was created by my work, my ingenuity, now becomes marital property. And so if you're going to do this, then I ask that you do it for everyone. Make it so that if my spouse has a job and her salary goes up from $50,000 to $100,000, let me get part of that salary increase. Let her buy me out of that. That would be equitable. And so what's happening now under Moore is courts are able to do other things like give the non-owning spouse homes, cars, cash, things that were not a larger portion of the other marital assets to make up for them not having that business. And they also have the option of alimony. In Moore, the non-owning spouse got $5,000 a month alimony until she turned 65. And so judges have other arrows in their quiver to provide equity other than taking a premarital asset, a business that may have been in a family for five generations, and forcing it on the auction block to buy a spouse out of it
▶ Play
Speaker 348 1:47:06
that had nothing to do with it. And so I'd
▶ Play
really ask you to consider that implication. Mr. Flowers? So then what you're saying is, and I didn't pay attention closely because I'm thinking improvement in terms of the situation or the scenario I gave you, a house that was owned, talking to the sponsor, by a party prior to the marriage, a separate property. and marital income went in to renovate it or, you know, increase the value, expand it, whatever. Your bill says time, effort, or skill of the spouse causes appreciation. I was thinking in terms of money. So maybe I like Senator Blake Johnson's bill better. I don't know, but his bill seemed to suggest that increase. As I recall, it was, if it improved in value, if the value was increased during the marriage, the only part I didn't like was the whole thing became marital property, so that if he had a 40-acre farm, that it was his separate property coming into the marriage, and they had a house on a few acres that was fenced in of the 40 and they improved the house, built onto it, remodeled it and all this kind of stuff using marital funds, then the increase would be looked at just to the, my thinking and my experience was the court would only consider what increase there was to that part of that property. not the whole 40 acres. That's right. That's what
▶ Play
this bill does as well. It's the same concept. It's just a little bit broader because sometimes it's not just physical property. It's, you know, the example, and if I may, and I'm sorry if I spoke over you, but the example in Lehman v. Lehman was when they actually held that there was an active appreciation doctrine in Arkansas. It was a hardware store, and he got some stock from his parents prior to the marriage. And then during the marriage, he and his wife both worked at the hardware store. Sometimes his wife stayed home with the kids at his request. And over the years, it was the time, effort, and skill of either spouse that went into layman's, and the growth in that became the active appreciation that was marital. And the key, and I think that the reason that, you know, and I talked with Mr. Smith prior, and he mentioned this possible amendment to make it only about the time, effort, and skill of the non-owning spouse. The reason that doesn't work is that there are a lot of situations where, for example, the non-owning spouse stays home, and it's not a direct contribution, but it belongs to the marital estate. And that's really the key, and that's why this is held in most states that have equitable distribution, this act of appreciation doctrine. It's because the time, effort, and skill of either spouse, the act of appreciation belongs to the marital estate. It's a fruit of the marriage, and that was what the court held in layman. It's less about whether something has grown from nonmarital property at the outset and more about whether this act of appreciation is itself something that belongs to the marriage and most courts, including ours, for a long time has found that it is. I hope that answers your question.
▶ Play
Well, in that instance then, and from what Attorney Smith is saying, so the appreciation of the business, he says for small businesses, it's not a good bill. So what are you saying what the worth is? the time of divorce as opposed to what the value of that business was when they first married?
▶ Play
Yes. So for a business like that, that is non-marital at the outset, that principal part, that non-marital principal part, stays non- marital. It's going to go back with that owning spouse, whoever owned it at the outset. The property, the physical, probably. As well as stock. You know, if if it's stock in a family business, if it's a family farm, whatever it is, whatever we're talking about that comes into the marriage as non-marital property will stay non-marital property. The appreciation, the growth in value resulting from the time, effort, or skill of either spouse is the only part we're talking about reverting back to marital property as it's been interpreted for the vast majority of the time that it's been interpreted by Arkansas courts. So that's the profits? It's the increase in value. it's not exactly profits, but it's increase in value. How
▶ Play
would that be appraised? How do you determine that? What kind of person would you use? I mean, because if a marriage is maybe a 20-year, 30-year marriage, how would you determine that?
▶ Play
Who would be able to give you? Aren't courts already doing that? But isn't that a
▶ Play
question aside from the bill? No. Yeah, well, the senator has a good question. Let's use the hardware store. As far as proving it, bringing it in, I've had cases like that back when I was litigating. Yeah, you bring in appraisers, and they say it was worth this much today, and it would have been worth this much so many years ago. The farm example I had, we knew pretty much a per acre price at the time of the marriage, and we had an appraisal done at the time of the divorce. If you try to value the actual contributions, I mean, 25, 30 years, and let's flip it around, usually it's the wife that's staying home, taking care of the kids, sleeping with him, cooking for him, taking care of his clothes, doing the shopping, taking the kids to school, all the activities, entertaining his guests so that his time is freed up to deal with the business. Nobody in this room, I doubt, will ever say that that female's contribution is not worth something. It absolutely is. It frees up that male to do his thing. So you look at whatever assets you have at the end. You put a value on it, and the marital asset may have been zero at the time of the marriage, or it may have a book value. All of these things are considered and the courts can reach an equitable result. We can't write a statute that's going to cover every situation because it's impossible. So the court does equity. What is fair between the parties? It's
▶ Play
good law. Most of the time, unfortunately not all the time, but most of the time when y'all ask me to change law, I ask why. So I've heard some why and this bill doesn't do as the more I've listened to what I originally thought it does I don't think so property comes into a marriage and farms been used as the law stands now if both spouses work on the farm, as the law stands now, is there any doubt that the change in value is marital property? It's
▶ Play
non-marital property as of right now. It all goes back to the spouse who owned it, no matter how much work both spouses put into it during the marriage. Okay. So, all right. So,
▶ Play
so you want to change it for that reason. That makes sense. But then as I listened, though, if the spouse that brought the property into the marriage works and increases the value of the property and the other spouse is elsewhere doing whatever, however valuable that may be, but the, the, the value of the property increases.
▶ Play
it becomes marital property. That's right. Just like anything else that comes into the marriage during the marriage. Well,
▶ Play
no, hold on, because I want to come back to Bishop Spitt. Because we talked about the farm, we talked about the family business, okay? Because spouse stays home, takes care of the children, while the other spouse takes the job working for state government. and goes from minimum to as high as they can go, what part of that is marital property? That money
▶ Play
that comes in during the marriage for either person's salary is marital property because it's, again, from the marriage. So it's just
▶ Play
treating it like that. Any money that comes in is marital property, yes, but the money-making capability, is it marital property?
▶ Play
That non-marital property reverts back. That farm that came in at the outset of the marriage goes back to the person who brought it into
▶ Play
the marriage. No, the spouse, whichever spouse it is, was making $30,000. Now they're making half a million a year. their now capacity to earn half a million a year is that marital property.
▶ Play
A good example of what you're talking about is like a doctor. Start off getting through medical school, and now he's making tons
▶ Play
of money. Not necessarily because the doctor
▶ Play
could have his own practice, but go ahead. Working with the state government, it makes no difference. That's earning capacity. The capacity itself is not marital property, but there is an unequal position between the parties as far as future earning capacity or present earning capacity at the time of divorce. In that instance, the court usually adjusts that relationship using alimony.
▶ Play
But that exists in a farm or a
▶ Play
family business also. In one case, you're talking about real property or personal property. A job is not property.
▶ Play
But coming from a small business, a small business is often a job. Let me rephrase it. Employment is not an item of property. Yeah, but I'm just saying that for the majority of people, a small business is a job. Absolutely. They end up working more hours, et cetera, but it's actually just a job. It requires more investment, et cetera, but the—and, of course, because I'm right there with you on the part where the spouses are both working, and because I've heard different people talking about this bill, both spouses are working in that, increasing the value, but there does seem as Mr. Smith pointed out there does seem to be an equity between a farm a family business or somebody working for somebody
▶ Play
else okay I hear what you're saying let's just say the spouse is home taking care of the kids that's work that's part of the economic unit no doubt and if you're working say a job at the courthouse and somebody else is running the farm that is still part of the economic partnership we call marriage. You go into not only a spiritual and a physical and an emotional, but also a financial partnership when you marry. And so whatever each of you happen to contribute to the marriage inures to the other in the marital estate. And that's the way the court looks at it. It's a marital estate. But some things are excluded by law out of fairness and right. Well, but tell me if I'm wrong, though. I become a Hollywood actor,
▶ Play
and I'm getting $20 million a movie, okay? I may have, or my wife becomes a Hollywood actress, and she's getting $20 million a movie, okay? And she may have to pay me alimony, okay? But I don't get any part of property other than the things that are there. But if it's, if one of us has, starts a business, runs a business, not only, and is making, is bringing down 20 million, not only is there the alimony, there is the, there's the division of property. And as Mr. Smith brought out, you know, a family farm that's been in the family for three or four generations gives me some
▶ Play
pause. Yes, sir. What you're talking about, and if somebody wants to protect a family asset and it's done every day, they use a prenuptial agreement. And they say, look, this farm's been in the family for years. No matter what I do, it's going to be passed on to the next generation. That's how they protect that interest. As far as the acting and the ability to earn future earnings, that is compensated in other ways. But it's not regarded by the court as property. But can I turn that around on you
▶ Play
and say that you could do a prenuptial agreement to do exactly what you want to
▶ Play
do? Well, if there's prenuptial agreement, then everybody has a lawyer in order to be valid. Both parties have to have a lawyer. They have to enter into it with legal advice before the courts are going to uphold it. And this happens in a number of estates. That's the way the law works. We're talking about property division, not potential earnings in this bill.
▶ Play
Senator Flowers. So, you know, you're making me like Senator Blake Johnson's bill a lot better. Now, this case that you are speaking of, Arkansas Supreme Court? Yes, ma'am. And so does Senator Blake Johnson's bill that we just passed out of the Senate, does it square with that layman case as well?
▶ Play
I can't speak exactly to it. The intent in both bills is the same, to get to the same place. The reason
▶ Play
that the other bill doesn't— But he just said increased in value. I don't remember his
▶ Play
saying time, effort, or skill. And that was part of the problem, because ours has been vetted, and it's been the standard for 30 years in the
▶ Play
state. There's a lot of case law interpreting exactly what it does mean. No, but my experience in these kinds of cases, it's been where you can see an appreciation, and generally it was about marital income going into the business to appreciate and increase the value. Not time, skill, or effort. Or raising children or cooking or cleaning. No, those were considerations for other things. The court can consider that, and if there are children, they can make a decision as to whether to use some of that separate property for the benefit of that. So I can see where you're saying it's been used, But yours, I don't like the time, effort, and skill part. You know, you can trace money, see where it came from, whether it was owned by or held by the person before the marriage, how much it's increased since the marriage. But this time, effort, and skill concerning somebody's separate property, a business, I don't it does get to be kind of scary if I may I think the reason
▶ Play
it's so important to have time effort and skill in there is for an example like the hardware store the closely held corporation which actually is something that frequently comes up because it's not necessarily investment of income if you're working at a store if a husband and wife are together working at a store that's time effort and skill that's not investing income necessarily but it's definitely a contribution, definitely active appreciation from the labors of that couple. It definitely belongs to the marital estate. But
▶ Play
you don't distinguish that in your bill as it coming from the non-owning spouse.
▶ Play
But that's important not to do that, in my opinion, because if we do that, then that discounts the contributions of the person, the other spouse, who may stay home as a consequence of the other needing to work at the hardware
▶ Play
store, for example, as happened in this case. But if the business is owned by other family members of that spouse who brought the property into the marital estate, I mean, you make it more difficult to calculate, and then you're affecting other people's interests. If it's a family business, one of the spouses had an interest prior to the marriage, and now you're trying to complicate it. I mean, he might have eight brothers and sisters that are part of the business. If you think about the equity
▶ Play
argument, again, if you've got a marriage that's been going on for 20 years, and you've had both of these spouses contributing to the success of this business, and you're going to leave that one spouse with nothing simply because she did not have the gift of stock from prior to the marriage.
▶ Play
But you don't say that one spouse. You're saying you're not distinguishing the spouse that is not the one that brought the property into the marriage. And that's the problem that I have with this. If they make contributions, yeah, they should have an interest in that increase. But But if they don't, I don't understand that logic. It's just like
▶ Play
if someone makes a salary at a job. They've got one spouse making $100,000. The other stays home. You can't say that the other one who stays home is entitled to no split of that income that's been made over the marriage by the person
▶ Play
with the salary. But that's income. That's your income. Now you're talking about the business itself.
▶ Play
I can see the income. The appreciation of the business. The appreciation of the business. The underlying base of the business remains non-marital. But the active appreciation is like income in that it's growth. It's something that's developed during the marriage, part of the marriage, part of the marital estate. And again, I mean, this is not just something we're creating out of nowhere. This has been the court's approach in Arkansas and most other states that have equitable distribution. For 30 years, this is how Arkansas courts did it with no response from the legislature. You know, just as a matter of practice, we're expected to read the cases and the holdings of the Supreme Court, and if we've got an issue with it, we can change it in law. That's what we're trying to do here. For 30 years, we didn't do that, and that's a tacit endorsement of the approach that the court took. So, again, this isn't anything radical or different. It's simply just reverting to how the courts have done it with very little disruption for 30 years in our state. But that's not what the courts are doing now? No, because they took a fresh look at it. They took a new read on it. There was some recusals on the court during that decision, and that's what they came up with. So it puts it back on us to make the change if we want to go back to the way it's been. So let me
▶ Play
ask you one more question. Sure. Spouse inherits the hardware store. And under the scenario we've been using, works in the hardware store, value rises. Let me give you another scenario. Spouse inherits the hardware store. Never works in it. It's over here. It's something they own. Okay? Somebody runs it. Has the same increase in value. Under your bill, it's not marital property, right?
▶ Play
I believe that would be passive appreciation of the investment. That would be non-marital property. That's right. If neither one does anything, no time, effort, or skill is expended, that's
▶ Play
passive. It's like an investment in stock. Okay. All right. You've answered my question.
▶ Play
Other questions from the committee? Senator Bond? Well, and I think, you know, Senator Johnson and Representative Ritchie's bill is SB 547, and the language there, it's a little confusing the way the statute's written, number one, because the statute says, for the purpose of this section, marital property means property acquired by either spouse subsequent to the marriage except. And then if you go down to where Senator Johnson changed, it said property acquired before the marriage that has not been structurally enhanced through the use of marital funds or increased in usefulness or value through the use of marital funds. And so the difference is exactly what you're saying. If you don't spend marital funds on the increase in value now, under this statute, it will clearly not be considered marital property. And I'd say if someone does, even if the spouse works in it now, it wouldn't be marital property under
▶ Play
Speaker 330 2:10:09
the current rulings, right? Under the current rulings, that's right. And this bill fixes
▶ Play
that. So I think it's the correct way the statute should be and was interpreted for many years. But that's my opinion on it. The two different bills actually, as they said at the beginning, do a little bit different thing. Senator Johnson's requiring marital funds be used and not recognizing the efforts of one of the spouses either. So
▶ Play
Speaker 329 2:10:35
thank you. I was wrong. I have one more question. Okay. Both spouses bring
▶ Play
a farm into the merits. They work on one. It increases in value. They don't work on the other one, and it increases in value. Under this law, they would both be entitled to split the
▶ Play
one, but one spouse would not be entitled to anything off of the other. They'd split the active appreciation on the one. The active appreciation on the one, but nothing off of the other. Well, the passive appreciation on the other would go back to the previous owner, and the passive appreciation on the one that they worked on would also be attributed to the original owner. There can be passive and active appreciation in the same investment. So. Senator
▶ Play
Bond. Well, and one other thing, just to ask you, If you look down at page 2, lines 14, this just establishes the presumption that
▶ Play
Speaker 386 2:11:45
it's marital property. It can be defeated by whichever spouse is fighting against it, I guess. It can be
▶ Play
defeated, first of all, and then second of all, marital property doesn't mean 50-50. It means it's going to be equitably distributed by the court in view of other factors, Jim. That's right. Other questions from the committee? Hearing
▶ Play
none. I'm going to ask, although we don't have anybody else signed up, anyone else here to speak for the bill? Anyone else here to speak against the bill? Hearing none,
▶ Play
would you like to close for your bill, Representative Collins? I'm closed, and I appreciate it. Action from the committee.
▶ Play
Motion to do pass. Motion to do pass from Senator Bond. Second from Senator Ballinger. Any further discussion? Hearing none, all for the motion. signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed? No. Representative Collins, I'm only counting three. I believe that your bill has failed. What? i
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:13:11
don't represent senator ballinger and and that's what probably roll call is the best best measure i i just know that we're late in the process so it's uh it's like if the bill is going to get passed then it's and going to become law we'll have
▶ Play
to work on the roll call is probably
▶ Play
Speaker 308 2:13:32
the appropriate measure. So did you call a roll call? Roll call. Senator Stubblefield. Senator Cooper. Yes. Senator Rice. Senator Bond. Yes. Senator Ballinger. Yes. Senator Letting. Senator Letting. Yes. Senator Flowers. Senator Flowers. there were there were three three to two the uh the bill
▶ Play
has failed would anyone like to make a motion that the vote but that that by which the bill failed we have a motion to expunge second from senator cooper uh all for the motion signify by saying aye representative collins i sense that you could pass the bill i think there probably needs to be some more discussion with members of the committee. Um, I think there's probably a real issue there, but, uh, thank you. Thank you. Senator Ballinger, represent Depenso. Is it easy? Well, the only reason I ask, because we're going to take you anyway, but Senator Ballinger has Senate bills that we got to get to the other end. So, okay. So, yeah, come on to the table.
▶ Play
Speaker 409 2:14:52
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Can I have Jeff Williams join us as well? You may.
▶ Play
What was the bill number again? I think you're doing 1488. House Bill 1488. Is that correct? That's correct. And we have an amendment. Mr. Williams, would you like to go ahead and identify yourself for the record?
▶ Play
Speaker 404 2:15:56
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Jeff Williams. I'm here not in my official capacity. i'm here simply as a citizen of the state of arkansas okay uh represent
▶ Play
penzo you are recognized to present your bill and uh we have an amendment it appears that needs to be adopted that is correct what is there anything we need
▶ Play
Speaker 295 2:16:21
to know about the amendment um it's the bill so
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:16:23
the just for the the uh purposes of the committee the amendment is the bill so that way you're not I'm trying to look back and forth, and it is a compromise. So there was another piece of legislation, this piece, that had been on our desk for a while, and so the amendment is to incorporate a lot of the concerns that people had to alleviate those and get everybody sort of on the same page. Okay. Senator
▶ Play
Ballinger, would you like to make a motion to adopt the amendment? I'll make a motion to adopt. Okay, motion, second from Senator Cooper. Any discussion? Hearing none, all for the motion signify by saying aye. All opposed? Okay. The amendment is adopted. Representative, Senator, would you like to present the bill as amended?
▶ Play
Speaker 409 2:17:10
Yes. House Bill 1488 is to, we found that there's some gaps in the adoption law, allowing some practitioners to broker the buying and selling of babies in Arkansas. A lack of transparency is how money is transferred from adoptive to biological parents, and this has led to payments of exorbitant amounts of money. There are rampant conflicts of interest in which loyalties of adoption practitioners are unclear to the biological and adoptive parents. Unlicensed agents are approaching pregnant women and offering them cash if they'll go to an attorney's office and agree to place their babies up for adoption a lot of times this results in mothers signing away parental rights not knowing they'll never see their child again these practitioners are making 500 to 3500 dollars in finders fees sometimes these adoptions involve out-of-state parties such that jurisdiction in arkansas is suspect many concerns with these practices have likened them to human trafficking. This bill would work to stop all of that. One of these unlicensed agents was arrested last week in the Marshall Islands on human trafficking charges because he was harassing and intimidating pregnant women to come to Arkansas with him to put a child up for adoption. If a third world country has the moral fortitude to call this human trafficking, we should also. So I'll let Senator Ballinger kind of discuss a little bit about the Billswell. And I'll
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:18:57
keep it really short. I've had the opportunity, actually, to take part in doing some adoptions and working with the gentleman who actually does quite a few of the adoptions for Marshall League. So this is something that is kind of, and former Representative Williams, Jeff, when he was representative, started working on this for that community because we have a really large Marshallese population, and their culture itself lends itself to adoption. They do a lot of adoptions in that culture. And I had worked with a gentleman who actually speaks Marshallese, who spent a lot of time in the Marshall Islands, and he's an attorney, so he ended up doing a lot of these adoptions. Well, one of the problems is because of the fact that there is some trafficking, that the practitioners who spend a lot of time working with the Marshallese, marshallese they have concerns about about this they'd like to see this get cleaned up to make it where it's an easier process for them to to be able to do this and and have the bad actors weed it out so um anyway that's the basically that's how i got involved in it and it was was through that and and i'm happy to try to do whatever i can to to help my
▶ Play
Speaker 412 2:20:12
colleagues here mr williams Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee members.
▶ Play
Speaker 404 2:20:15
I want to very quickly provide just a little bit of a background on this. As was alluded to earlier, I've been involved in this process now for nearly two years since I first really started to become aware of this. My background, and it goes much further back than that, because as an adoptive father, I adopted my daughter some 15 years ago, close to 16 years ago, and I had an opportunity through that to learn a little bit about the adoption process here in Arkansas. But where this really began on this particular issue goes back to a meeting that I was asked to attend while I was a state legislator with the circuit judges in Washington County. All of them were asked for this meeting, and the vast majority, I think one was missing out of this meeting, and they expressed a concern that they were seeing in their courts, and they knew that was going across the state of Arkansas with adoptions that were occurring in their courtrooms and the concerns that they had about things such as the lack of understanding of the proceedings by some of the individuals who were in front of their courts, primarily the biological parents that were involved in this process. And they asked if we could start taking a look at that and see if there's some ways that we could tighten up some of the laws here in Arkansas. And that's where I kind of proceeded. I began to talk to many stakeholders over the last couple of years, many conference calls in adjusting the language of this to ensure that we tightened everything up in a manner that was suitable to all involved. And as we have amended and amended and amended this legislation dozens of times in an attempt to ensure that we had the best piece of legislation possible before bringing it to the legislature. And we got the input from adoption attorneys across the state of Arkansas, from circuit judges, from just about every type of agencies, adoption agencies, everybody involved with this. This is about as solid a piece of legislation as we could have possibly brought forward this. Is it perfect? No, I don't think I've seen a piece of legislation that comes out of here that's absolutely perfect. Are there additional changes that could have occurred? There's a possibility that that could have occurred. But I don't believe that the changes that we have not, or the changes that we've chosen not to make, I do not believe strengthen the laws and the issues that are going on here in Arkansas. Some of the things that have been addressed may speak about, you know, Some of the concerns that I've heard from attorneys across the state, those primarily adult fault in adoption, is that this is simply an issue within the Marshallese community. But it doesn't take long to realize that this goes far beyond the Marshallese community. But it does go into communities that are at-risk communities. It goes into any community that's a low-income community, high-drug communities, areas of our state that are affected by this. We see this as not just in northwest Arkansas, but north central Arkansas, northeast Arkansas, southwest Arkansas, all over the state, especially as our immigrant population continues to grow. And honestly, as the drug problems here in Arkansas continue to grow, they find these people who are in desperate situations, and they use that to their advantage to be able to do this. Now, I'm not saying this is all those attorneys, because it is absolutely not. But it is a few of those attorneys who are taking advantage of the system that we have here in Arkansas, the laws that we have here, and in some cases the vague language that exists in Arkansas law. So we went through, tightened up some of the language, worked with all those folks to be able to ensure that we were still meeting the needs without impacting legitimate adoptions across the state of Arkansas. As you read through this, you're going to see that there is some additional work that's going to be necessary to occur. There's going to be additional accounting that's going to be required. That's going to be done. It's going to require additional counseling to ensure that the adoptive and the biological parents all understand what's going on during this process. It's going to help, but this legislation is going to help cut off the funnel of money that was referred to a moment ago by Representative Penzo and allow the courts to be able to ensure that everybody understands what's going on, that the money is cut off to those who would take advantage of the system, and it's going to help ensure that the children who are involved in this process are going to good homes with parents who want to care for them, that biological parents will be able to understand the entire process and understand the requirements that they're going to have and the end results of this entire piece of legislation. There was discussions about how this might, during this discussion, There were many discussions, but during this discussion, some of the things you saw or we heard was that this could possibly reduce adoptions in Arkansas. I don't believe that a simple accountability and a simple accounting process is going to reduce it. I think in the end, it's going to make adoptions more affordable here in Arkansas and thereby increase the opportunities for individuals who otherwise can't afford to adopt to be able to adopt. I think that in the end, what we're going to do is to help families who desperately desire to have a child. We're going to help the biological parents to ensure that they understand what is occurring with them and what's occurring during this entire process. We're going to help the courts out by ensuring that they have the ability to be able to make those involved accountable for their actions that occur. And in that, we'll improve the situation here in Arkansas and reduce what has been mentioned here, the human traffic thing that exists in Arkansas. This is quite a bit of change that's occurring in the adoption law, but it's all for the good. It's all going to benefit the people that it needs to benefit. And I hope that after we get through the explanation of this, that you'll all be supportive of this. Thank you.
▶ Play
committee uh rather than going straight to questions uh we've got one signed up to speak against and so i'm going to have him come and then we'll go to questions uh glenn hogger if you'll identify yourself for the record
▶ Play
thank you chairman clark members of committee good afternoon uh well good evening uh my name is glenn hoggard i am before you today wearing my arkansas bar association hat i sit on the bar association's legislation committee the legislation committee has taken a position in opposition of this bill. There are four Arkansas attorneys who are members of the American Academy of Adoption Attorneys. All four of those attorneys individually came to our committee and said, you need to oppose this bill. The bill is designed to address issues with adoptions in minority communities, but in doing so, it harms the adoption process otherwise by adding requirements. Now, I will tell you, quite frankly, Chairman Clark, while Representative Williams has been at this for two years, I've been at it for about three weeks, and I'm not an adoption attorney, and I'll take questions, but I'm afraid the answer's going to be I don't know. Kay McLeod, who is one of the adoption attorneys, who's a member of, they call it 4A, the American Academy of Adoption Attorneys, will be speaking on 1788, I guess it's 1789 tomorrow. It's a House bill, it's a companion bill to this bill. I do want to read one paragraph from a letter that she wrote to the attorney who I believe Senator Ballinger referenced earlier. These bills, House Bill 1488 and House Bill 1789, do a disservice to the larger adoption community in Arkansas by creating a cumbersome punitive procedure that is likely to result in clogged courts and failed adoptions. We should be creating a more adoption-friendly system, not a less set of adoption laws. We should give women with unplanned pregnancies a viable option for the future well-being of their child if they choose not to parent. The adoption attorneys have problems with the accounting provision. They have problems with some of the filing requirements that are imposed on all adoptions, not just on ones that are in minority communities and communities that are perhaps being taken advantage of now. There was a big issue initially with the fact that an out-of-state person, it would have been impossible for them to adopt. I think the amendment that we all just adopted only makes it difficult for an out-of-state person to adopt as opposed to impossible. In my experience, this is my second session to sit on the art bar legislation committee when the four state experts in any legal field come to our committee and say we're all opposed to this and they do it independently of one another, that speaks volumes to us and that was the primary reason as a committee that we voted to oppose that with their request to do so. And as I said earlier, Senator Clark, I'll be happy to take your questions. I'm, as I mentioned earlier, not an adoption attorney, so I'm afraid I'm ill-equipped to do so.
▶ Play
AND BEFORE WE GO TO QUESTIONS, ANY IDEA WHY THE ADOPTION ATTORNEYS DIDN'T CHOOSE TO BE HERE? SO TO MY
▶ Play
KNOWLEDGE, MS. MCLEOD HAD A COURT HEARING TODAY THAT WAS SCHEDULED AGAINST THIS PARTICULAR MEETING, AND I'VE HAD MR. ROBINS CHECK WITH HER TO SEE IF SHE COULD GET HERE TONIGHT AT THE HOUR, AND SHE WAS RETURNING FROM WHEREVER SHE HAD HER HEARING. SHE'S THE ONLY ONE OF THE FOUR ATTORNEYS THAT IS IN LITTLE ROCK. She had already made her plans to testify against the bill tomorrow.
▶ Play
Okay. Senator Flowers? So, you know, this is nine pages, and I don't know the difference between what was in the bill before it was amended or not. It's just a lot to congest and try to review in a few minutes. are, you know, and I'm tired, and I'm also hungry, and, but, you know, I'm wondering about the family member, say a grandparent or an aunt who is out of state, who wants to help the young mother to be in terms of her ability to adopt. Is this making it more difficult or what? And in terms of this money that family members lots of times help people with, you know, that are young people, that are a young lady that's pregnant. I'm wondering how does this affect that? That's just a question that comes to me in my mind before I've even read all this. And I would ask that Senator Ballinger at least give us some time to look at this and maybe come back at the next meeting so we can see. Because I don't know if you filed this amendment yesterday, 326. So the lawyers that Mr. Hoggard is talking about, they probably don't know about it either. So I would think, out of fairness, and so we won't be rushing bills out of here to allow us some time to look at this. In response to that, you know, I'm going
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:32:41
to go with the will of the committee. We are late in the process, so we'd have to get right back to it. What I would say is this language has actually been the exact language that was entered into the bill that he's referring to on the House side for a long time, and it has been circulated. Their opposition is to this language that they have had a chance to see. um but it's it and i i think it's a little bit a little bit disappointing because i think most of the those attorneys are are excellent at doing adoptions they're already keeping track of a lot of this stuff i get i mean anytime that you start to start muddying the water if they feel like everything's going well and they're doing a good job you know when when uh you know a good friend of mine is one of the one of those four and when he goes into a court and he's doing adoption The judge doesn't even think twice about it when he does it because he knows that he's legit. The problem is that there are a lot of bad actors out there who aren't legit, and it is encumbering the process. But having said all that, what I would say is, you know, if the committee would commit to giving it another hearing, another opportunity, I'm okay with it, although it's not even like I'm the second, I'm not even the Senate sponsor of this, Mr. Eads is, So I would defer to Representative Penzo on
▶ Play
that. Both of you, Senator E. Tighten behind the post back there. I can see you. Yeah, I don't blame him. I didn't know he was back there. I was making good out of him. And Senator Ballinger, our co-sponsors. But I'm just saying, you know, this is a lot. I have not read this. And like I said, I am very concerned about family members that come to the aid of their young relatives who are pregnant and how difficult the process will become on them. And, you know, that's something that concerns me, and I'd like to just look at it. I mean, I do family law, and I don't want to be voting on a bill that I don't know what it does. I know about Marshallese people, and generally the mom is the one that kind of sets the standards up there for a family. So, I mean, I remember when they were having problems with tuberculosis up there, and the father didn't have the child in their name, And so y'all are running down here to get some legislation. You can't make them go to the health department. So I just need more time. And I think the committee and Arkansas kids need
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:35:22
more time. I guess my question would be for the chair, are we planning on working
▶ Play
Speaker 402 2:35:30
on Friday? No. Okay. Monday morning? Monday afternoon. Was that
▶ Play
Monday morning? and earlier, like 9 o'clock, like public health is doing.
▶ Play
Speaker 409 2:35:41
They're meeting a little earlier. Mayor, my only concern is that we've been asked to amend and amend and amend by several different groups, and I'm just worried that we won't get a chance to have this heard before the end of session and then me get it back to the House, run it through committee again, get it through the House committee. So this would be like a Senate bill we're trying to get over to the House side because it's got to be, since it's been amended, I guess I'm just worried that I might not have the opportunity if we're delayed. So, I mean, do you think we could, if we do it Monday, I mean, is that something I can for sure? You can absolutely do it Monday. then i guess
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:36:32
what i'd recommend is for us to to if if the committee or if the chair is okay with setting a special order of business to hear this on monday and then we'll pull it down and people have all the time they need to to and and if somebody sees something that is a is a a change that's not real substantive that that moves their opinion then they should let us know and that way we'll have the opportunity to adopt it right away. Again, we can
▶ Play
hear it Monday, and Senator Flowers has asked you to pull it down. We can take a vote today. This is entirely up to you. I think we've
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:37:11
decided to pull it down and do it Monday. We know how dangerous Senator Flowers is, so we're going to...
▶ Play
I mean, you know, we're talking about, you know, changes in the law for children and families so it it deserves our attention yeah these folks have have been through
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:37:27
the ringer and worked with a ton of people and spent hours working with people on it you all haven't so that's that's just the reality of it and and the reason why it's just not getting to you is because they've done such a great job of working with people who are concerned and listening to them over years but the truth is this committee is not had a chance to hear it. So it may be appropriate. Senator Ballinger, do you have another bill? Okay. So, so I, I mean, I guess this is the thing is we have two shots at it. So, uh, you know, the, the question is, you know, if we went ahead and, and took a vote on it, then, um, then gave, then we'd still have time to, to listen to potentially on Monday. So they, I guess they're getting getting signs of their opinion about maybe there's a chance that it could pass today so i don't let me say this i'm just going to say let's go ahead and and pull it down and do it on monday and and then what what i would want is that this committee if if we do that and we support it and we get it we get it done then you know i'd want this committee's support and trying to help us get to it through the process so we can we can do things like suspend rules and pick up bills and concurrent amendments and all that stuff if we're really going to get out next week then it's going to be take you know some real effort from the committee I think to get it done so if I got the commitment from the committee to really help with this bill if this is the bill that you you all choose to let out then uh then I'll say let's go ahead and
▶ Play
pull it down would be my recommendation well you got my commitment to that I'll read the bill and and uh pay attention to what is presented uh on monday i guess that's the i
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:39:17
guess my point is that if you read the bill and you like it then i just want your y'all's commitment to try to help get it done through the process so it's in that just means you know being supportive as we request somebody maybe to suspend the rules to to concurrent amendment or whatever i'm always
▶ Play
supportive of good law let's okay let's do something
▶ Play
i've got people who are talking about making motions and so Let's do something. Let's pull it down. Let's vote on it.
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:39:44
Let's do something. He just said he's pulling it down. Okay. So what's his next bill? Okay, Senator Bellinger, what else you got? Thank you, committee. Okay, so my next bill should be a pretty easy one, Senate Bill 625, sorry. And so if we can deal with that one quickly. The other one may be easy also, but it may not be quite as easy. And I'll have Mr. Sylvester Smith as the person who brought the idea to me. So if he's still. Okay, I have you. Since he asked me to vote against something, I voted for it anyway a little bit ago. Hopefully it'll make up for that. So Senate bills, and let me say this. I just visited with the Judicial Council on this, and they're neutral, but they actually think that it's a good idea and they're going to send me some potential changes. But what I told them is we'll look at those, and we may, incorporating this may become a judicial council bill, something that they'd like to see get done. But at this point, we don't have that language to look at. And so through the process, we may have an amendment. But for the same reason why I was concerned about the last bill, we're going to go ahead and run it. and they're not opposed to it as it sits. And so, essentially, in short, what this bill does is provide a mechanism for doing an emergency guardianship that would be a temporary guardianship for children upon the death of the parents. To me, it's something that I think we're probably doing now in practice, but without any real legal authority to do so. And I think it's probably, to me, it's a good mechanism to get it done. But I'll let Mr. Smith kind of explain it. Thank
▶ Play
you, Senator, Mr. Chair, if I may. Yes, you recognize Mr. Smith. My name is Sylvester Smith, and I'm acting this afternoon now in my individual capacity. As I think a lot of you know, when I'm not here before working with you, I have a law practice. And I've discovered that a lot of parents erroneously believe that if they plan for their future children's caretaking after they die by nominating a guardian in their will, that that's sufficient and that a court would be required to abide by that. However, under Arkansas law, such nominations are only advisory. And so what happens is I have two beautiful children that mean the world to me. My wife and I have a plan for my best friend and his wife to raise her, but there's no mechanism that requires a judge to accept that plan. And so if my mother or an aunt or my brother were to come and say, well, we would be better suited to care for these children because we're blood relatives, then a judge, at his or her discretion, could then name my mother or my brother as the guardian for my children and go against my wish. And please understand that, you know, I respect the capacity of judges, but due to the long dockets judges have, these hearings are often done in an hour blocks. And so a judge has to take, in an hour, a determination that's going to impact my children for the rest of their life and would overwhelm or overcome my judgment and my wife's judgment when we've known all of the potential candidates for a lifetime. And so we're just asking to allow for a smooth process and trust the parents to make a parental decision with regard to what happens with their children. And so what would happen is my wife and I would have a notarized sworn statement signed by both of us and signed by the family that would take our children. And then once we go on to glory, if we're on a plane together and it goes down, then my friends would be able to present that document and it would become a 90-day temporary guardianship. And so what would then happen is when it comes time for my, that would give my children 90 days to kind of transition out of the misery of losing both their parents and to know that there's stability and certainty for them until such time that my friends could petition a Pulaski County court to name them permanent guardians. And at that time, the judge could have an hour hearing. My mother, if she disagreed with the appointment, could come and object. But unless the judge is able to find that our friends are unfit, the judge would then have to respect our wishes. And so what this will do several things number one provide certainty safety and security for newly orphaned children secondarily it will allow the parents to control what happens to the kids when they go on to glory thirdly it'll save families from having to hire guys like me to immediately do this in a very challenging time and then it'll allow for a peaceful transition versus something that's oftentimes becomes a family dispute. With
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:44:44
that, we're happy to try to
▶ Play
answer any questions. Senator Flowers. So this temporary guardian, based on the notarized statement of the parent or the parents, Yes. And the appointment being immediately effective upon the death of the appointing parent, if the other parent is deceased, or upon the death of both parents, do you have to go to court to get letters of guardianship, temporary letters of guardianship?
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:45:30
Well, and I'll just say, the answer is not for the temporary. And so that is the benefit of this, is that you have a guardian right away. But do they have letters? Letters of temporary guardianship? The letters of temporary guardianship would essentially be within the document that's created itself. So that would be, you would have a guardianship that would happen immediately upon the death of the parents. they would have legal guardianship that would be there temporarily until you go petition the probate court. You get an administrator and you get letters issued. And then at that point, you can work on doing the permanent guardianship. But it will bridge that
▶ Play
gap. But you're skipping the part about, I mean, if that person that has been named in that sworn affidavit is unfit and a court hasn't even seen it. I mean, you're putting a child with somebody unfit for 90 days until the court sees it and gives letters, issues, an order allowing letters of temporary guardianship? Senator
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:46:41
Flatters, I would just say that it's the document from the parents. Like, if both parents didn't sign off on it, there's no issue. So we're not doing something statutorily that happens on its own. Well, but I'm thinking in the
▶ Play
circumstance of a parent who has made, has created this sworn affidavit five years ago, or at the time of the baby's birth. And the baby now is 15 years old when they lose their parents. Mother, father haven't even thought about what they signed 15 years ago. and here somebody comes up with this?
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:47:21
And it would be, that's the reason why it's being temporary is so important because then you'd go through the same process of opening the probate, petitioning for permanent guardianship. Yeah, but you
▶ Play
can get a temporary guardianship now, ex parte. It doesn't take, but go prepare the petition, pay the fee, and go up to the judges chambers and the court will at least inquire and that child should be served too. So, I mean, what about the ward's ability to protest? They may not even want to go with
▶ Play
this person. If I may, Madam Vice Chair, what we are anticipating is that a parent that would be prudent enough to take this step would be concerned enough about the welfare of their children to modify the document if there were a circumstance in which the nominee were unfit. And so what we're doing here is we're trusting the people who know these folks best to make these determinations. And then I just remind you, Madam Chair, that at least in my experience in Pulaski County, you've been practicing law far longer than I have, what happens is when the judge gets that ex parte petition, he or she doesn't make any sort of inquiry into the fitness of the person, they read the petition and they sign the order, which it is temporary, and so you really don't have... But they
▶ Play
can say. They can inquire. Yes, ma'am, they can. And they do inquire. I've never seen a judge didn't inquire. If the person doesn't have a felony or isn't otherwise disqualified by the statute? Not in an ex
▶ Play
parte order. Normally, they just take the person's word for it based upon the sworn affidavit, and so I think that what would happen to address your concern about a person that was unfit is my mother would then be able to challenge the temporary appointment and have it overturned. But what this does is it just allows for the party, the families to make these determinations and be able to get some certainty for a brief period of time without having to
▶ Play
go to court. I think it's quite, it's not unreasonable to think that parents do things at the time of birth of a child, set them aside, don't even think about them anymore. And the circumstances change. But that document remains. Maybe they would have given it to that person. You know, how do you revoke it if you don't have it? What do you do? create another document and and and so that document uh where is it and the person who is named he or she is holding this other document when it was revoked i i think this is pretty dangerous here if i may if i may
▶ Play
sender i i respect and appreciate all of your concerns i would just argue that the way that we're managing this is we're just putting it into to the guardianship statute, and so you would be able to revoke it if there is an issue the same way you revoke any other temporary guardianship just by petitioning a court of competent jurisdiction to do so. They're dead. How are they going to revoke it? Well, grandma or auntie or whomever the other interested parties would be that would take up the children, because one of the whole points of this is to avoid fights when there's multiple people in the family that want to care for the children. And again, we're just asking the government to respect the knowledge of the parents and the fact that they care for their children. And if they're prudent enough to do this, they'll stay on top of it and they'll modify the documents if necessary. Senator Ballin. Well, two things. I
▶ Play
sort of agree with Senator Flowers about some of the issues in the bill, but are we having issues with this? Have there been reported cases where, I mean a parent passed away and had a letter and then the judge disagreed and the kids were in limbo. Has that happened? It's not been my
▶ Play
experience that the kids are in limbo but it has been my experience where the parents would nominate Joe and then the judge would
▶ Play
decide Paul. Is there a particular instance though? I call this bill a little bit late in the sessions like picking up snakes. You know you don't you're just asking for trouble. It's not a real issue that's occurring out there. It's something that maybe should be addressed, but we don't have to. I think, and I'll be quite, I think simpler solution would be just to say, it's a, I think right now it's a presumption if you have in your will who gets your kids, the court, that the court's supposed to presume that is correct. Is that wrong? Am I wrong about
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:52:07
that? What I would say is that there is a problem that exists every single time that that both parents are die and there are minor children because as soon as that happens right now there are children without a guardian they now the question is what how does that practically affect things i don't know but you know all of a sudden now you're you're facing a situation where there is if there is something as far as health care if there is something as far as school if there is something as far as all these practical things you know you are put in a situation where where you know maybe your grandma and you just lost you just lost your child and now you've got to go go to court to get your ex parte hearing within days if you've got something that's coming up whereas if this document where mom and dad sign this and say grandma is the emergency guardian and also you know hopefully she'll have a will and it'll it'll put grandma's permanent guardian it'll make it where they're able to take that document and go and take care of all those things because now they are the legal temporary
▶ Play
guardians of the kids. Well, two things. One, is there a specific example where we know that has occurred, where there's been a problem? And two, wouldn't it be easier just to say if you're the person nominated in the will to take custody of the kids is presumed to take custody until otherwise ordered by the court or something because the temporary guardianship statute does have notice requirements where you have to serve other people. If you can, you can serve it. There are notice requirements. Who are... And I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 429 2:53:46
not... The proposed ward. Yeah, but in
▶ Play
this case, if I may, and I don't want to speak out of turn, the proposed
▶ Play
ward is a minor child. Right, but they still get notice in certain proceedings if they're over 13 years old, right? Yeah, they... I think it is. So they could get counsel on that item. I just think it's picking up snakes.
▶ Play
There's an easier way to do it. If I may respond to that, Senator Bond, Mr. Chair, in the will, there's no countervailing document where the nominee agrees to accept the appointment. And so if you make that automatic, what happens if the person hasn't agreed to accept it? And so I get your point, but there would be issues with whatever approach you take here where there may be some problem that arises. Mr. Stubblefield. You
▶ Play
can. You can. Okay. We have a motion for immediate consideration. We got a second from Senator Cooper. It is a non-debatable motion. So all for the motion, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed. Motion carried. Action from the committee. Motion to pass. Motion to pass from Senator Stubblefield. Second from Senator Ballinger. No discussion, so all for the motion signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed? No. Senator Ballinger, your bill has passed, and Senator Flowers has called roll call. I mean, you know, we're going to
▶ Play
be back with that, like a retroactive case. they brought up here a little while ago. Allison, if you
▶ Play
Speaker 308 2:55:40
would call the roll. Senator Stubblefield. Aye. Senator Cooper. Aye. Senator Rice. Aye. Senator Bond. No. Senator Ballinger. Aye. Senator Letting. Senator Letting. Senator Flowers. No. I think I've
▶ Play
only missed one this session. So that was 5-2. Congratulations, Senator Ballinger, you have passed your bill. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:56:16
you very much, committee. I have one more if you guys have the stomach for it. You bring it on. All right. So this one has an amendment to it. It is Senate Bill 319. The amendment looks like a lot, but it's basically just codifying legislative intent. So essentially what it is is that by doing this, what we're trying to do is codify the case law in Arkansas that deals with eminent domain. So after the Kelo decision that happened nationally that basically said that you could actually take property for purely economic purposes, Well, when Kelo went through, it caused some people to have some concerns. But actually in Arkansas, our case law is pretty solid on that, where you're not actually able to take property for just purely economic reasons. And so what we're doing is just for the stability and clarity is we're codifying what we feel like is the case law in the state. And so that legislative intent just clarifies that. It was a compromise to help some of the folks who were concerned about about property rights to feel good about what we're doing so if i'll make a motion to
▶ Play
adopt the amendment i have a second from senator cooper i think uh any discussion here none all for the motion signify by saying aye aye all opposed
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:57:53
motion carried your bill is amended okay so senate bill 319 is just like i said basically what we're wanting to do is codify the case law to make it clear that that you're not able to take property for for purely purely economic purposes one of the things that they do is they'll they will um um use blight as an as a an example or ability to to take property if that and sort of get around that and so what we're doing is we're also defining blight and requiring there actually be some affirmative steps if you're if you're going to condemn property because with blighted property but or because it's blighted um and and we just we worked actually with a practitioner who who um who had had some concerns and and did some amendments and that's why we're just now getting to it late but the uh the the meat of it is would come into um 18 it's actually line 9 on page 3 where you actually get a cause of action you have a limited or you have the purposes and there's actually the amendment also takes out it and so if you're on line 13 it says for public or private use that was a an error and that's one of the things that was amended out so but if you're going to take property it's got to be for public use or if it's blighted as is defined in here or as abandoned property as defined in here and that's the only way that the state can can do it is if it's going to be a public use or it's blighted property or it's abandoned property i'm happy to answer any questions about it it just essentially is a good bill for protecting property rights, codifying our case law that limits the ability for a state actor to take property unless it's legitimately for a public good. Senator Ross.
▶ Play
Senator Ballinger, does what you stated, this allows property to be taken for public use? Correct. That's what this bill does. It's not already in law. Well, so this is
▶ Play
Speaker 270 2:59:56
the thing, is that you have two protections. One is you have a constitutional protection that says basically that, that you've got to give just compensation. Is this more protective than what's in current law? And the answer is yes, but only because of the fact that it's codifying what the current courts do. So the reason why it's more protective is that it's not as malleable as case law. So a Supreme Court decision establishing strong, good case law is only as good as the next Supreme Court decision. And so that's what we're codifying, that good case law. What I
▶ Play
don't want to do is do one thing that strengthens something, but find out later that it's two steps back that allows some other things to happen. Do we have anybody signed up for this? yes
▶ Play
we have someone signed up to speak against okay and terry
▶ Play
Speaker 270 3:00:55
i i'm sorry senator rice it's getting late one of the things that i would say is that it was actually institute for justice that is has all over the country is trying to get states to to codify their their their law not not even their case laws they're trying to codify the law to make it where where the a state is it cannot take property for purely private or economic, after Kilo, what they're trying to do is get states to protect property rights. Well, in visiting with them, they feel pretty good about Arkansas's law, our case law. The problem is our statutes don't match up to it. So it is definitely an intent to try to protect property rights, the legislation. Other
▶ Play
questions from the committee? Hearing none, we have Lanny Richman II signed up to speak against, if you'll identify yourself for the record.
▶ Play
Yes, my name is Lanny Richman. I'm a staff attorney with the Arkansas Municipal League. You may proceed. Thank you. Yes, the Municipal League, and I don't want to oversell our position. This is not something we are vehemently opposed to, because Senator Ballinger is absolutely correct. In Arkansas, any sort of economic development taking would be extraordinarily limited. The case law is quite clear. Comically enough, in the Kelo decision at the Connecticut Supreme Court, they even identified Arkansas as a place that it couldn't happen. The Municipal League's only concern is that we expanded economic development powers of municipalities in 2017 with Amendment 97 to the Arkansas Constitution. And we think that there's an argument that that may have expanded the public purpose doctrine to include takings like this. If it did, it would still be severely limited by that amendment and by the enacting statutes, which would have been Act 685 of 2017. That is really our only concern because otherwise these things don't happen. And that's it. Questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Hearing none, is there anyone here to speak for the bill? Anyone else to speak against the bill? Senator Ballinger, would you like to close for your bill?
▶ Play
Speaker 270 3:03:18
Yes, and essentially, you know, I'm visiting with the Municipal League. You know, I'd ask them if there was any, and this is only kind of the last couple days, if there's any amendments that we could do, and the answer was basically we couldn't. And I think that his presentation presented it well, is that essentially the case law itself is pretty well settled. But they hope to change case law to make it where it's easier to take property for economic purposes. And that's going to be a little bit more difficult for them to do that. And I don't blame them. They have a position that they want to take to do that. But I think that's kind of our job, if we can, to protect property rights to do that. And that would be consistent with our job in the state constitution. And having said all that, I just make a motion do pass.
▶ Play
We have a motion do pass. Second from Senator Stubblefield. Any further discussion? Hearing none, all for the motion signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed?
▶ Play
Speaker 270 3:04:16
Aye. Motion carried. Congratulations, Senator Boundary. You have passed your bill. Okay, thank you. And my motion was to pass it as amended. The bill as
▶ Play
amended, yes. Thank you. Senator Cooper, did you have? You're going to pass over? Okay, I have a Senate bill. Senator Stouffield, can you take the chair? Not really.
▶ Play
Are y'all ready? Senator Clark, you're recognized to present your
▶ Play
bill. Thank you. This is SB 579. Allison, I forgot to bring SB 12 with me. Do you have your mic on? I do. I can probably do 12 from memory, though, so that's okay. SB 579, are you ready,
▶ Play
Speaker 214 3:05:49
Mr. Chair? Everyone have the bill? Okay,
▶ Play
we're ready, Senator Clark. 579 is short and sweet. Requires the disclosure of all evidence in the possession of the state to a criminal defendant where the evidence is inculpatory, exculpatory, or neither inculpatory nor exculpatory and for other purposes. That's what it does. And since following the bill, I am told that the court has such rules. and I think that's what some folks signed up to speak on the bill will say but I think it's something we need to do and I'll be happy to take
▶ Play
questions. Okay any questions from the committee? Seeing none do you have someone from the audience you would like to come up? No I thought there might be
▶ Play
Speaker 215 3:06:55
someone signed up. No one signed up? We have Mr. Bob, you want
▶ Play
to go to the table? Recognize yourself for the record.
▶ Play
Speaker 466 3:07:10
Bob McMahon, prosecutor coordinator, representing the Prosecutor Association. And I'll be brief because this is similar to what we talked about a little bit earlier today. It's the position of our association that I guess we're speaking against the bill, but really more so speaking on the bill. There are court rules, rules of criminal procedure that, in our opinion, cover every bit of this. It starts at Rule 17, and that's discovery rules that the prosecutor is obligated to do. And then it goes on to talk about, after our obligations, the rule is Rule 17, and it'll break it down into 17.1, 17.2, 0.3, all the way up to 0.5. And it basically talks about how to do that. It talks about a prosecutor's performance of those obligations. It talks about possible sanctions. Another part of the rule talks about material held by other government or personnel. And then there's a continuing obligation for us to continue to do that, you know, even after the fact. So I think most of this is covered. There is case law that's out there, United States Supreme Court cases. I'm sure Arkansas court cases as well that talk about, you know, disclosing exculpatory information and all that. So it's just our position that it's already covered by these rules. And I guess it's similar to the discussion we had a little earlier with regard to separation of powers. And I know, you know, we have a difference of opinion probably on how that will play out. But those are our concerns. I mean, I'll be happy to answer any questions, but it's, again, very similar to what we said earlier. And I probably don't really have anything else
▶ Play
to add. All right. Are there any questions from committee members to Mr. McMahon? All right. If not, no one else has signed up to speak against the bill?
▶ Play
Senator Clark? Thank you, Mr. Chair. This bill was brought to me by attorneys who don't think it's adequately covered, and I think this will do it, and I would appreciate a good vote and would move to pass. All right, we have a motion
▶ Play
to do pass. We have a second and a second. Any discussion? All those in favor say aye. All opposed? No. I didn't hear any no's.
▶ Play
No. Your bill passed, Senator Clark. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Y'all ready to hear SB12? I'm just, I'm done, I'm done, I'm done. Thank you, committee. I know that some of you are not feeling well and you're tired. About Monday, well, let's first talk about Friday. I would be the first to meet on Friday, but I will not be here. I had a funeral that was moved to Friday because I couldn't be there Thursday. So I will definitely not be here on Friday. So if y'all wanted to meet without me, we could set that on
▶ Play
the schedule. But since I asked you that question, the ArcLeg site changed the meetings for Senate and House that were showing Friday meetings as nobody, no scheduled meetings.
▶ Play
OK, so anyway, I would meet anytime, but I can't do that. So back to Monday, schedules are running long. we are set to meet on adjournment. Does anybody want to change that to earlier? It would meet upon adjournment
▶ Play
Speaker 398 3:11:09
and so we get just purely from logistics. What I don't want is to be so late that they're not able to read the bills across the desk and then make it work. Although we'll the issue with the one bill that we have that we have to talk about is we are admitting it so we'll have to take it back to the House. well we'll hear you I can't guarantee
▶ Play
you how people will vote but we'll hear your bill first I don't know what time we'll because I hate so everybody's good with Monday upon adjournment okay okay we will meet Monday upon adjournment Senate bills if there are any we'll take priority and then we'll go to house bills Thank you. We'll see you tomorrow. We are adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

Call to Order

-1:59 - 11:43 32 segments 7 speakers

SB344 B. Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE FILING OF A MECHANIC'S OR MATERIALMAN'S LIEN.

HB 1831 Boyd

11:43 - 20:25 39 segments 12 speakers

Representative Justin Boyd introduced House Bill 1831, which would facilitate criminal-record sealing by removing the five-year look-back period for non-violent felonies and eliminating the $50 sealing fee. [13:51] [14:05] [14:38]

Prosecutor Daniel Shue explained that the change would allow immediate sealing after a sentence is completed, improving re-entry prospects for individuals who have satisfied their obligations. [15:08] [15:40]

Senators Stubblefield and Cooper questioned the origin of the five-year period and whether the bill conflicted with other legislation, receiving clarification that the measure only affects sealing and does not alter other rights or processes. [14:57] [16:21] [16:42] [16:58] [17:06] [17:16] [17:25] [17:45]

The committee approved the measure without opposition, with Senator Rice moving, Senator Letty seconding, and the motion carried, passing HB 1831. [18:46] [18:51] [18:57]

SB378 Elliott TO BE KNOWN AS "THE EQUITY IN SENTENCING ACT".

20:25 - 2:56:55 476 segments 43 speakers

Senator Joyce Elliott presented Senate Bill 378, the “Equity in Sentencing Act,” proposing that individuals sentenced under the 2011 drug-sentence law be allowed to have their sentences reviewed and potentially set aside if they would be equivalent to current sentencing standards. [20:55] [21:32] [22:04] [22:41]

Several senators, including Stephanie Flowers and Terry Rice, voiced concerns about the bill’s impact on other offenses, the appropriate role of the parole board, and suggested pursuing a resolution or an interim study rather than direct legislative action. [23:56] [24:23] [25:12] [25:46] [26:22] [26:54] [27:27] [27:58] [28:12] [28:46] [29:01] [29:22] [30:01] [30:33] [31:09] [31:43] [31:52] [32:26] [32:59]

Prosecutor-attorney Larry Froelich testified that the bill would only affect controlled-substance offenses and warned it could create unfunded mandates for the DOC and parole board, while the chair noted insufficient information to make a decision. [29:01] [29:22] [30:01] [30:33] [31:09] [31:43] [31:52] [32:26] [32:59] [33:36] [34:08] [47:26] [47:43]

The committee did not adopt SB 378; instead members moved toward drafting a Senate resolution urging the governor to act on parole-board recommendations and considered an interim study, with no formal vote recorded on the bill. [40:49] [41:02] [41:10] [41:41] [42:12] [42:47] [43:23] [44:03] [44:35] [45:06] [45:43] [45:54] [46:22] [46:55] [47:26] [47:43] [47:59] [48:28] [48:31] [49:05] [49:26] [49:48] [50:27]

SB319 B. Ballinger TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING EMINENT DOMAIN; AND TO ADD NEW DEFINITIONS UNDER EMINENT DOMAIN.

2:56:55 - 53:45

Senator Ballinger presented SB 319 to amend Arkansas’ eminent-domain statutes by codifying existing case law that bars taking property for purely economic purposes and by defining “blight” and “abandoned property” as limited public-use exceptions. [2:56:58] [2:57:33] [2:57:53] [2:58:05] [2:58:39] [2:59:12]

After brief discussion, including testimony from Lanny Richman of the Arkansas Municipal League who noted the bill aligns with Arkansas precedent but cautioned about potential impacts of Amendment 97, the committee moved to adopt the amendment and the bill as amended. [3:00:46] [3:00:52] [3:00:55] [3:01:20] [3:01:40] [3:01:56] [3:02:26] [3:03:07] [3:03:18] [3:03:30]

The committee approved the measure by a 5-2 vote, with Senator Stubblefield seconding the motion and the chair announcing the bill’s passage. [3:04:01] [3:04:16]

SB558 G. Stubblefield TO REPEAL ARKANSAS CODE § 16-30-104 CONCERNING THE CONTRACTUAL WAIVER OF A JURY TRIAL; TO MAKE THE REPEAL OF ARKANSAS CODE § 1630-104 RETROACTIVE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

53:45 - 2:15:29 264 segments 30 speakers

Senator Gary Stubblefield introduced Senate Bill 558, which would repeal Arkansas Code § 16-30-104, make the repeal retroactive, and declare an emergency, noting that the measure originated in the 2017 special session. [54:51] [55:21] [56:10]

The committee heard testimony from trial lawyer Joey McCutcheon asserting that pre-litigation jury-waiver clauses violate constitutional rights, from bank counsel defending the waivers as efficient and consistent with federal practice, and from consumer Kenneth Tilley describing personal harm caused by such a waiver, while several senators questioned the retroactive impact and the necessity of legislative action. [56:59] [57:32] [58:22] [58:54] [59:24] [59:57] [1:00:31] [1:01:03] [1:03:54] [1:04:29] [1:05:04] [1:05:40] [1:06:12] [1:06:45] [1:11:20] [1:11:34] [1:11:44] [1:11:52] [1:12:10] [1:12:18] [1:12:50] [1:13:22] [1:13:57]

A motion for immediate consideration was moved by Senator Flowers, seconded by Senator Ballinger and carried, but a subsequent motion to pass the bill failed, and the chair declared the measure defeated. [1:32:35] [1:32:44] [1:32:59] [1:33:13] [1:33:24] [1:33:34] [1:33:54] [1:34:02]

HB1488 Penzo TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE ADOPTION PROCESS WHEN A LICENSED CHILD PLACEMENT AGENCY IS NOT USED; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

2:15:29 - 3:05:53 154 segments 17 speakers

The committee first adopted a compromise amendment to HB 1488, with Senator Ballinger moving and Senator Cooper seconding, and the motion carried unanimously. [2:16:46] [2:16:59]

Representative Penzo then presented HB 1488, arguing that current adoption law permits unlicensed agents to exploit vulnerable mothers-particularly in the Marshallese community-and that the bill would prohibit such practices and increase transparency. [2:17:10] [2:17:31] [2:18:05] [2:18:39] [2:19:13] [2:19:44] [2:20:12] [2:20:15]

The Arkansas Bar Association’s legislation committee, represented by Glenn Hoggard, testified that the bill’s new accounting and filing requirements would burden the adoption system, and after extensive debate and concerns raised by Senator Flowers about out-of-state family members, the committee voted to postpone the measure, pulling it down for further consideration on Monday. [2:27:03] [2:27:15] [2:27:51] [2:28:23] [2:28:57] [2:29:30] [2:30:00] [2:30:10] [2:32:41] [2:32:55] [2:33:26] [2:33:57] [2:34:01] [2:34:38] [2:35:09] [2:36:57] [2:37:11] [2:37:18] [2:37:21] [2:37:27] [2:37:57] [2:38:32] [2:39:07] [2:39:13] [2:39:17] [2:39:33] [2:39:36]

SB579 A. Clark TO REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF ALL EVIDENCE IN THE POSSESSION OF THE STATE TO A CRIMINAL DEFENDANT, WHETHER THE EVIDENCE IS INCULPATORY, EXCULPATORY, OR NEITHER INCULPATORY NOR EXCULPATORY.

3:05:53 - 1:35:41

Senator Alan Clark introduced SB579, explaining that it would require the state to disclose all evidence in its possession to a criminal defendant-whether inculpatory, exculpatory, or neither-and noted that the bill is “short and sweet.” [3:05:54] [3:06:09]

[582-584] [3:07:10] [3:07:44] [3:08:15]

[586-588] [3:08:46] [3:09:03] [3:09:16]

[587-588] [3:09:03] [3:09:16]

HB1686 A. Collins TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "MARITAL PROPERTY" FOR PURPOSES OF DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE.

1:35:41 - 1:15

Representative Andrew Collins introduced HB 1686, explaining that it would amend the marital-property definition to create a statutory exception for the “active appreciation” of non-marital property-reinstating the 30-year precedent reflected in Moore v. Moore and the Lehman case and clarifying that only appreciation resulting from a spouse’s time, effort, or skill becomes marital property. [1:36:06] [1:36:28] [1:36:58] [1:37:32] [1:38:03] [1:38:37]

Senators Will Bond and Stephanie Flowers questioned the necessity and scope of the amendment, particularly the “time, effort, or skill” language, while Sylvester Smith testified that the bill could unduly burden small-business owners by forcing sales to buy out spouses. [1:39:10] [1:39:40] [1:39:54] [1:40:11] [1:40:42] [1:41:20] [1:41:48] [1:41:50] [1:43:34] [1:44:08] [1:44:49] [1:45:27] [1:46:00] [1:46:31]

The committee further debated how to distinguish active from passive appreciation, using examples of farms, family businesses, and a hardware store to illustrate that passive appreciation remains non-marital while active appreciation would be treated as marital property. [1:40:42] [1:41:20] [1:41:48] [1:41:50] [1:42:14] [1:42:22] [1:42:28] [1:42:36] [1:49:05] [1:49:20] [1:49:54] [1:50:29] [1:51:00] [1:51:26] [1:51:35] [1:52:07] [1:52:20]

A motion to pass the bill was made by Senator Bond and seconded by Senator Ballinger; after a roll-call vote the measure failed by a 3-to-2 margin. [2:12:28] [2:13:03] [2:13:11] [2:13:26] [2:13:32] [2:13:42] [2:13:58]

HB1799 Rushing TO CREATE "TARA'S LAW"; AND TO AMEND GRANDPARENTS' RIGHTS IN CUSTODY AND VISITATION MATTERS.

1:15 - 2:40:22 487 segments 55 speakers

Representative Laurie Rushing presented House Bill 1799, “Tara’s Law,” proposing amendments to Arkansas’s grandparent visitation rights and explaining her personal motivation and three-year development of the bill. [2:06] [2:24] [2:55] [3:27] [4:01] [4:33] [5:04]

She detailed that the bill would add three new grounds for grandparents to petition for visitation: a parent found unfit, clear and convincing evidence that visitation is in the child’s best interest, and step-parent adoption after a biological parent’s death, borrowing language from several other states. [5:41] [6:14] [6:47] [7:26]

Circuit Judge Tom Smith testified that the bill’s language had been vetted with judges and that the committee took no official position, after which no committee members asked further questions. [7:57] [8:24] [8:30] [9:05] [9:21]

The committee moved to pass the bill, with Senator Flowers making the motion, Senator Letty seconding, and the motion carried unanimously, resulting in the passage of HB 1799. [9:36]

SB625 B. Ballinger TO ALLOW A PARENT TO APPOINT A TEMPORARY GUARDIAN FOR HIS OR HER MINOR CHILD IN THE EVENT OF THE DEATH OF THE PARENT.

2:40:22 - 3:12:01 105 segments 14 speakers

Senator Ballinger introduced SB 625, which would allow parents to create a notarized affidavit naming a temporary guardian that becomes effective immediately upon the parents’ death, providing a 90-day emergency guardianship without a court hearing. [2:40:44] [2:41:18] [2:41:37] [2:41:48] [2:42:19] [2:42:55] [2:43:31]

Attorney Sylvester Smith explained the mechanism and addressed concerns raised by Senator Flowers about unfit guardians, revocation, and notice, noting that the temporary appointment could be challenged in court and that the affidavit could be revoked through a petition. [2:46:15] [2:46:37] [2:46:41] [2:46:56] [2:47:10] [2:47:21] [2:47:34] [2:47:43] [2:47:59] [2:48:18] [2:49:54] [2:50:18] [2:50:26] [2:50:58]

After a non-debate motion was carried, the committee voted 5-2 to pass SB 625, with Senator Ballinger’s bill declared approved. [2:54:51] [2:55:23] [2:55:30] [2:55:40] [2:55:53] [2:56:05]

Adjourned

3:12:01 - 3:22:01

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Senator Alan Clark Chair Unverified
142 segments
Representative Laurie Rushing Unverified
16 segments
Speaker 11
1 segment
Speaker 33
1 segment
Speaker 12
1 segment
Speaker 25
1 segment
Senator Stephanie Flowers Unverified
76 segments
Speaker 71
1 segment
Speaker 76
1 segment
Speaker 48
1 segment
Representative Justin Boyd Unverified
7 segments
Daniel Shue Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 86
1 segment
Senator Gary Stubblefield Unverified
19 segments
Speaker 98
2 segments
Senator John Cooper Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 107
1 segment
Senator Joyce Elliott Unverified
22 segments
Larry Froelich Unverified
5 segments
Senator Terry Rice Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 153
1 segment
Speaker 162
1 segment
Speaker 169
1 segment
Senator Will Bond Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 196
1 segment
Speaker 208
1 segment
Joey Mccutcheon Unverified
25 segments
Speaker 299
2 segments
Speaker 239
12 segments
Speaker 237
8 segments
Speaker 74
1 segment
Kenneth Tilly Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 63
1 segment
Speaker 258
1 segment
Speaker 270
51 segments
Speaker 278
1 segment
Speaker 279
8 segments
Speaker 287
1 segment
Speaker 180
1 segment
Speaker 308
5 segments
Speaker 313
1 segment
Speaker 167
1 segment
Representative Andrew Collins Unverified
37 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
17 segments
Sylvester Smith Unverified
25 segments
Speaker 348
1 segment
Speaker 330
1 segment
Speaker 329
1 segment
Speaker 386
1 segment
Speaker 409
7 segments
Speaker 404
13 segments
Speaker 295
1 segment
Speaker 412
1 segment
Glenn Hoggard Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 402
1 segment
Speaker 429
1 segment
Lanny Richman Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 214
1 segment
Speaker 215
1 segment
Speaker 466
3 segments
Speaker 398
2 segments