March 26, 2019·15 Minutes Upon Adjournment·Room 149·1:17:13
VideoTranscript
Summary
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 10, 2026
HB1325 Lowery TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CUSTODY OF A CHILD. 1:21
Representative Mark Lowery introduced HB 1325, proposing a rebuttable presumption that joint custody serves the child’s best interest, outlining the bill’s legislative intent, citing comparative state examples, and noting his collaboration with the Judicial Council to streamline custody-determination factors.
[1:43][2:18][2:52][3:24][4:00][4:35][5:10][5:41][6:12]
Committee members, including Rep. Nicole Clowney and Rep. Sarah Capp, questioned the adequacy of the 2013 law and the absence of statistical evidence, prompting Lowery to acknowledge reliance on anecdotal observations and to suggest measures such as county-wide “peacemakers” to foster parental cooperation.
[6:51][7:15][7:48][8:22][9:00][9:39][10:43][11:15][11:41][11:50][12:02][13:09][13:26][13:49][14:00]
Thank you, Madam Chairman, and thank you, committee members, for coming after hours to hear this presentation. Just to give you a little bit of background, previous to 2013, case law in the state of Arkansas regarding joint custody was that the state of Arkansas did not favor joint custody. But in 2013 session, I was fortunate to get to carry legislation that actually established new statutory language, new case precedent. And I think one of the best summaries I've seen of what that law did appears in a family court review article from 2014 in Hofstra Law that says in 2013, Arkansas amended its child custody laws to indicate that joint custody is favored and defining it as the approximate and reasonable equal division of time with the child by both parents individually as agreed to by the parents or as ordered by the court they go on to speculate that you know whether favored will be interpreted as a presumption a preference or simply a general expression of public policy supportive of an increased role for the non-custodial parent remains to be seen and that's why we're here today is to try and answer this question for this this author of where where this brings us six years later and where it brings us is to House Bill 1325. The main phrase, it's only a three-page bill, but on the very first page, it makes the most clear and concise point, and it is that we are establishing that there is a rebuttable presumption that joint custody is in the best interest of the child. What that obviously would mean is that the court would presume from the very beginning that joint custody would be in the best interest of the child and then would entertain evidence from either side that would rebut that or refute that. One of the reasons in looking at what other states have done, California, for instance, decreed that it's a matter of public policy to assure children of substantial contact with both parents post-dissolution and to promote shared parenting unless it would be contrary to the child's best interest. Joint custody presumptions in several other states have been triggered by parental agreement. The West Virginia statute holds that if each of the child's parents has been exercising a reasonable share of parenting functions for the child, the court shall presume that joint legal custody is in the child's best interest. I think we all would agree that while divorce is a sad circumstance, especially where children are involved, an even sadder circumstance would be that if you have two loving parents who want to be involved in the child's lives, that divorce itself should not separate them from that. And, you know, I've mentioned this before in talking about the relocation bill earlier, that, you know, I've experienced some of that personal sting as well. I did not know that articles or order of divorce was being filed against me until I was driving to work, and the Pulaski County Court called me and said, do you want to be served, or do you want to come pick up your divorce papers? And I said, my what? Just the night before, I had been tucking my two kids into bed, And in one fell swoop like that, I went from tucking my two-year-old, my four-year-old into bed every night to only getting to see them every other weekend and some Wednesday night playtime. So I understand that sting. And I'm only, my children are now 28 and 30, and I've really only been realizing or being able to get out of them in our conversations. You know, obviously you don't want to have a lot of these conversations with the children when they're in their teenage years, but now that they're adults and they're also looking at my daughter's, my daughter got married last year and she's now expecting my first grandchild, we start having these conversations about how it affected them being separated from a parent who wanted to be involved. And so that's really all we're trying to do here is recognize that if it is considered to be favored by the state of Arkansas, that it's not a large leap for us to assume that joint custody would be a rebuttable presumption and that that would be the starting point for the court to start. It certainly would not eliminate them looking at any of the other factors or all of the factors related to what is in the best interest of the child. I will just tell you that I have worked with the Administrative Office of the Courts and the Judicial Council on this. They had made two suggestions, one of which I did embrace, and that is I took out all of the factors that would be considered because Judge Van Smith, who's actually here, if you have any questions for him, said that all of those factors are really all the things that the court already considers when trying to decide what's in the best interest of the child so that it was not necessary to enumerate them and that actually if you enumerate them, it probably created a burden on one or both parents to think that they needed to hire experts. And that just really creates even more divisiveness in something that we would hope that two parents, even if they've decided that they don't want to be together, that those two parents would cooperate in being able to make sure that the children have the love and the attention of both parents. The other provision that I could not agree to, which was removing the rebuttable presumption of just basically leaving it like it is. But still, even at that, the Judicial Council and the Administrative Office of the Courts has chosen to be neutral on this bill. There are also some witnesses who would like to come forward, involve with the Parental Equality Group and testify on this. But at this point, I'm open for any questions, and will try to do my best to answer them. Representative Clowney,
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Lowry, I couldn't agree with you more that when you've got a situation where you have two parents who want to have joint custody and it's in the best interest of the child, that should happen. Under current Arkansas law, that can and does happen every day. Could you just expand a little bit more on why you think the way that the law stands today is insufficient?
Well, I have, you know, I've felt from the very beginning because I did try to start in 2013 with a rebuttable presumption. I really felt like and worked with Andrew Parkers with the chamber and Governor Beebe's office worked with me on it. Judge Smith is someone I met with on it. And so we moved away from the rebuttable presumption. And to be honest, I've been pleased to talk to attorneys that work in child custody issues that have said that the 2013 law made a significant impact, that there were some courts where even when the two parents agreed, the judges felt like that they were handcuffed, that they could not order joint custody. So that's one thing that 2013 has done. But we still have a long ways to go, I think, in terms of overcoming, the Hofstra Law Review article is very compelling because it looks at the history going back to the 1700s, 1800s, about how did we get from there to where we are now. And a lot of it was the perception, the feeling that the mother was the number one caretaker. They were in the house most of the time working with the children. That has changed through the years, as you well know, because you wear a lot of different hats, being a mom and being a legislator. So as those things have changed, we've really not changed our law or our perception of the way custody issues should be. Fathers have become much more active. They've become equal partners. And so the rebuttable presumption is to get us to that point where we recognize that that is a sea change that has happened in the social fabric of America, and specifically in the state of Arkansas, and that the judges should be comfortable in being able to start at that point and then take testimony that might compel them to go one way or the other. If you don't have the rebuttable presumption, then you have in some courts a presumption that it is going to be the mother that has sole custody. And then it's left to the father in that case. The burden of proof is on them that they have to prove that they were an equal partner as well. well, what we're doing here is saying that if you come before the court and there's equal partnering, there's equal parenting, that we should start at that point of presumption of joint custody and then allow the court to move from there. You recognize for a follow-up?
Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you for that answer. That helps. You mentioned in your answer that judges, you've heard that judges often feel handcuffed by the current state of the law, that they feel like they can't. They did
Representative Lowry, I also agree that joint custody is an absolutely wonderful thing when you have two parents that are mature and able to work together for the best interest of the child. But oftentimes in litigation, when cases are contested, you've got two parents who are at odds. Oftentimes if their marriage is ending, there is a lot of frustration and hurt there. So an important component with joint custody is that parents, again are able to cooperate and able to communicate so do you have any statistics or anything to show us that what happened in 2013 isn't working across courtrooms in Arkansas to justify changing the presumption to where we start out there no I don't I
understand that you know, there may be most of the information would probably be anecdotal. And I know Judge Smith, if I understand correctly, had both pro and con anecdotal information, but there's not any statistical information that I know of. You're recognized for a
follow-up. Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm just trying to understand like what the basis is for why you want to change the law, if we have something in place now that are changing outcomes for people, I mean, what's the justification for, again, moving to a rebuttable presumption?
rebuttable presumption? Okay, why are we moving to? Well, I think that the witnesses that are signed up to speak can maybe best speak to that because while the 2013 law, which I'm proud of, may have had a dramatic impact, it didn't solve all the problems when it comes to litigating custody, and especially in shared parenting situations. Any other
Chair. In a divorce, nobody's happy. And as Representative Kapp brought up, they don't get along anyway. So I know in our county we have something called peacemakers, that every couple who have children must go through it. Um, before they're granted a divorce, do you think that across the state we could do something similar, which is helping them to work together as parents of children in a divided family? Well, I think anything
that would create peace in a parenting, a co-parenting situation would be helpful. Um, you know, I think sometimes we just, we just maybe presume, that because we are shifting a burden of proof or whatever related to joint custody that those parents are going to be using the children against one another. And we presume that that's the only situation where the children would be used. I mean, that's been the case in other cases where one parent is arguing for sole custody and a lot of times uses the children as pawns. What this does is it helps the judge to start from a point where he or she can then entertain information that would tell them really what is the best standards. The best standard is not what the parent or the parent's attorney come in and say. The best standard is what is in the best interest of the child. And starting at a rebuttable presumption of joint custody allows the judge to basically have a clean slate, say that we're starting from this because the state of Arkansas does favor joint custody, and now we're going to develop testimony. Even if we have to go so far as to appoint an ad litem to represent the child, we're going to act, our decision-making is going to be best based on what is in
the best interest of the child. Representative Kapp, you're recognized. In regards to your statement about looking at the best interest of the child, If we're talking about examining truly what's in the best interest of the child, we're going to look at all of those factors regarding the circumstances of the parents, their situation, that individual child's characteristics that come into play in regards for their needs. So in a situation where we are examining that specific child and what is best for them, shouldn't we be looking at the totality of the circumstances? Well, absolutely, and that's
why the Judicial Council asked me to remove mandating the factors that they would look at because they felt that they are already looking at those factors. Those are the factors, the ones that were enumerated originally in the bill are the factors they use in evaluating what is in the best interest of
the child. You're recognized for a follow-up? What I'm trying to just garner from your statements, I mean, is it your belief that we should immediately begin at joint custody? Is that what
you're advocating for? That is what I'm advocating for, is the judge would start from that hinge point. And then as proceedings go and testimony is entered, whether that is from the two parents or also from an ad litem, then that information is able to sway them one way or the other or stay exactly where it is with the rebuttable presumption. Members, any other questions?
We have some folks who have signed up to speak for and against the bill. Speaking against the bill, Lauren Hoover. Ms. Hoover, if you'll come to the end of the table and identify yourself, then you may begin.
They told me to do this. Thank you, Madam Chairman. As the chairman stated, my name is Lauren Hoover. I have a firm here in Little Rock, LaCera, Dixon, Hoover, and Rogers. Our firm, we practice 90% domestic relations litigation. Within that is child custody, guardianships, divorces, paternity, child support, et cetera. I've had an opportunity to visit with Representative Lowry, and I appreciate his time that he has taken in speaking with me. Um, one of those instances that I spoke with representative Lowry was about is as a result of the 2013 change that provided that joint custody was favored. Um, he mentioned a judge that would not even approve joint custody, even if the parties agreed upon that judge was out of Garland County. And in fact, I brought today some cases and I'm not here to do a teacher, a law class, but it has been recognized as the public policy of the state of Arkansas, that our legislature has determined to favor joint custody, that is a case that came out of that same judge's court in which he awarded in a contentious custody case, he awarded joint custody. The legislature, when the 2013 amendment was enacted, people really weren't sure how much of a change it would have. And I can tell you as a practitioner that it'll be my 13th year practicing law this September. when I first started practicing, unless a mother was an alcoholic, abused prescription drugs, used illegal drugs, was crazy, or some combination thereof, she was going to have primary physical custody. Those, frankly, are not even terms that we use on a regular basis anymore as a practice, all right? So what the joint custody bill did in 2013, what I have seen just from judges that wouldn't even award it, even it was agreed upon. What I have seen is that has freed the court from worrying and being concerned that they did not have the ability to do that. There were some courts along the state that would always, that would approve joint custody arrangements if the parties agreed upon, but certainly would not order it. And that would be the more typical thing until the 2013 amendment. People would agree to joint custody. It was rarely ordered. I would say that of all the cases my firm has tried, and since 2013, that the majority of the cases end up with joint custody. The cases where joint custody has not been appropriate are your obvious cases where someone has a substance abuse problem, where someone has not been active or involved. The problem is starting with the rebuttable presumption. So I've said all that stuff, that great stuff about joint custody, and you go, well, why aren't you for a rebuttable presumption? when I can tell you why. A rebuttable presumption in and of itself is defined as an assumption that a fact exists, a legal inference, based on the known or proven existence of some other fact or group of facts. You can have two good parents, but it is for the courts in the state of Arkansas to examine whether those facts are actually the facts, not to assume those facts when we're talking about minor children in the state of Arkansas while their parents are going through a divorce. And not only with the way that the bill is set up right now, this bill in the existing Paternity Code language, folks, under Arkansas Code Annotated 910109, Subsection A1, Capital A, once a paternity court has found that the putative father is the father, that court shall follow the same guidelines as if it were a case involving a child born of a marriage involving custody, visitation, and support. That flips us back to 13-101. Is it really the intent of the legislature then, when we're talking about a rebuttable presumption, to allow any parent, but think of a paternity case, to show up and we're just going to assume the facts and evidence that both should have joint custody? It should be proven. The fact that it's favored allows it to be ordered, but it should still be proven. It's my experience that as a practitioner, this joint custody bill, we still litigate these issues quite a bit. The rebuttable presumption, if anyone believes the rebuttable presumption, will reduce the litigiousness of litigants in divorce, custody cases, or paternity cases. If this bill is passed, I just want you to know I get to remodel my kitchen. because I'm going to be hired by just about everyone to come in and fight this, especially if you look at the end of the House Bill 1325, that there is a rebuttable presumption that joint custody is in the best interest of the child if the court orders a modification of a child custody decree. So what we're going to have, folks, is that everybody that didn't like what they got earlier is going to come in and they're going to argue a material change or they're going to try to create a material change. And whether or not one actually exists or a court finds one, litigation has consequences for minor children. And if anyone doesn't think that it does, they've not been around that courthouse. I was involved in a case yesterday, both excellent parents. If anything, the rebuttable presumption idea, I watched two good parents sit there and tear each other apart over minute details to try to avoid joint custody. They were arguing about a day and a half. They were arguing about a day and a half. No bill is going to fix people that want to fight over a day and a half. But joint custody with the 2013 amendment, y'all have given the courts not only the ability to award it, but the same discretion that they've had before after consideration of the totality of the circumstances that you mentioned, Representative Kapp. They've been able to do that. We cannot, this is not a one-size-fits-all solution. The courts need to have the handcuffs taken off to award joint custody, but it is the court's role as an arbiter of best interest to be able to examine the facts and not have to start out with an assumption of the facts. And that is what a rebuttable presumption does, and that is why it is not in the best interest of minor children in the state of Arkansas. I am happy
to answer any questions. Representative Fudd, you're recognized. I'd like to make a motion. What is your motion? A motion that we limit debate to three minutes per witness. Members, we have a motion on the table to limit debate to three minutes of witness. Is there any discussion on the motion? All in favor of the – Representative Asaway, you have discussion?
Yes. Thank you, Madam Chair. I would just ask that we not move to limit the debate at this time. We've heard the against side get sufficient time to make a compelling argument for why folks should be against this bill. I think those who are for the bill, and I think there are some in attendance who have signed up to speak, need to also have a sufficient and equal amount of time to explain to this committee and attempt to persuade them why they should be for this bill. And so with that, I would ask that at least at this time we not limit
the debate. Thank you. Members, we have a motion on the floor to limit the debate to three minutes per individual who has signed up to speak. Any further discussion? All in favor of the motion, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say no. No. The noes have it. We'll continue, and we may revisit that in a little bit. Any questions of Ms. Hoover? Representative
Kapp, are you recognized for a question? Thank you, Ms. Hoover, for coming today and sharing with us the information you provided. Just curious, have you noticed anything in your practice in regards to a female being given some type of preference over in a courtroom versus a male for judges? Or are you seeing across the board that moms are getting custody just as many times as dads are getting custody? What I see is that both
parents are sharing custody. And I don't see the preference, as I testified to earlier, when I started practicing in 2006, Representative Gassaway and I, we're the same age in terms of our practice. definitely that was the case when I started practicing is that mom had to have real problems in order for dad to have joint custody or receive custody that is simply not the case it is my experience that since the 2013 bill yes it's slow rolled so but we're in 2019 now I'd say the majority of the cases that are both tried and settled in my firm and with my colleagues are joint custody cases representative house
thank you madam chair uh thank you miss hoover for coming and sharing your experiences with us uh the best joint custody arrangement and this is a question the best joint custody arrangement i ever experienced with a client was uh the kids stayed place in one stayed in place in one house and mom and dad left every weekend or every couple of days. It was beautiful. It's the only time I've really ever seen true joint custody work. Making the kids move is not a good idea. What does this have to do with perhaps child support? Normally in joint custody, no money flows, but that's not necessarily a good thing. But can you explore
that a little bit for us? Sure. Representative couch thank you for the question under the current law under 913 101 child support is within the discretion of the court now I'm pleased to state that representative Lowry has a bill before this committee as well it is 18 he has a bill that is being proposed regarding the income shares model and he has my support on that bill that is a let me just go back so child support is in the discretion of the court in joint custody it used to be you'd hear people say oh they just want joint custody so they don't have to pay child support that's not what's happening either but the problem is is we're catching up with the modern realities of parenting okay that both parents are in the workforce both parents are actively involved in the raising the caregiving the decision making affecting the children what we're doing as a as a method in my firm as well as the practice both, I believe, in Northwest Arkansas and in Central, where I practice, I've been calculating child support for both parents. I will calculate, for example, if you and I were getting divorced, I would calculate your child support under our current law based on the number of children we have. And then I'd likewise calculate what my child support obligation would be under the current law based on the number of children we have. If the numbers were similar, there'd be no child support. If the numbers were different, there was a difference based on a disparity in income or there were other special considerations that we see under our current child support considerations, then an offset may be ordered. That's a common approach. Other counties just simply decline it, but it is my experience both in Pulaski, Garland, Faulkner, Hot Spring County, Lone Oak County that we're doing an offset of child support. With the income share model that Representative Lowry has proposed that is going to be on the agenda here, we will take into consideration both parents' income, regardless of the custodial arrangement. That bill is HB 1802, and that will be based off gross income, which is a breath of fresh air. But it will allow more equality as it is where you're not just necessarily looking for a non-custodial parent paying child support. I'm seeing I don't use words like non-custodial parent anymore. I don't use words like primary physical custodian anymore because the Arkansas legislature and the Arkansas Supreme Court have told us 60-40, that's joint custody. 50-50, that's joint custody. Somewhere around there, approximate reasonable ankle division, joint custody. So child support, we're still trying to balance that out. The income shares model that Representative Lowry has proposed and just what we've just been doing in practice allows that to be considered by the court. Members,
any other questions? Thank you, Ms. Hoover. We appreciate you coming and testifying. Thank you. To speak for the bill is Gina Indelicata. If you'll just state your name and who you're with,
you may begin. Good evening, Madam Chair and members of the committee, and thank you for allowing me your time. My name is Gina Indelicato, and I'm a registered nurse and stepmom, and I support House Bill 1325. Although this is not something I'm comfortable doing, I know it's okay to stand up for what I believe in. Custody laws were likely created with best interest in mind. However, the law has been applied in a manner to keep good, fit, and loving parents out of their children's lives for no reason at all. When you enter into family court, you believe with any court justice will prevail. It's no secret it is where constitutional liberties are ignored and unfair judgments are ordered simply because the court has the power to do so. As a wife and stepmom, I have had to experience this injustice firsthand. In fact, my nightmare began 10 years ago. I will briefly share my husband's story. He graduated first in his class from high school, from Hendricks, and from UAMS, and attended the prestigious Washington University for residency. In short, possibly one of the more qualified fathers you could hope for a child to have in their life, and someone you would readily trust to operate on you or a loved one. During residency, his wife maliciously relocated out of state with his two-year-old son, filed for divorce, and was given primary custody, with my husband being granted the standard 6 p.m. Friday to 6 p.m. Sunday every other weekend visitation schedule. This continued for years until the alienation and target parent abuse required intervention. My husband sought a change in custody, a battle that cost us years of stress and over $100,000. He used all the financial resources we had to fight for a child that was his to protect. Still, it wasn't enough. Despite providing overwhelming evidence of willful conflict and a judge acknowledging that mom doesn't always act appropriately, he modified the visitation schedule to extended weekend time, thus granting custody from approximately 15% to approximately 40%, but with mom maintaining primary custody. If there is a law in place that would marginalize a father like my husband from his child's life, and that system is flawed. Unfortunately, my stepson has recently become a mental health statistic with depression and suicidal thoughts due to the toxicity of his environment. This could have all been prevented. Destroying families does not protect children. The research and evidence supports joint physical custody. Children need fair access to both of their parents. With two adequate parents, courts have no basis to distinguish one party as primary and the other as visitor. When there is a law in place that does not support equality, it opens the door for a host of abuses, privilege, entitlements, and power. And here, that leads to mental and emotional trauma children must spend the rest of their lives getting over. Our current laws have hurt too many parents, children, and families across the state and across the nation. I do not believe equality and ethical standards are some dramatic departure of the law, but instead must be upheld by the law. Now is the long overdue time to make this change in favor of a presumption of joint shared parenting. I vote yes for House Bill 1325 as a vote for upholding a parent's constitutional rights, a vote in favor of our children, and a vote for our future. Thank you. We have
Thank you, Madam chair. Uh, my name is Patrick Fraley. Uh, I'm also a noncustodial parent and I do have visitation every other weekend, uh, for this primary reason that my ex-wife was given custody. Uh, my situation is certainly not unique. Uh, every day courts are deciding who should be the primary parent based on a few hours of half-truths and unverified stories. One parent is in stripped of their natural rights to be the parent, despite no wrongdoing by that parent or any acknowledgement of how this actually hurts the child. It's time that we'd only recognize that children need both parents, but put it into practice by creating a presumption of joint custody. There's really no disputing that secondary to an intact family, that joint custody is the best outcome for children. At latest count, there have been 60 studies in the English language comparing joint custody to sole custody. The vast majority of these studies show that joint custody results in better academic, behavioral, physical, and emotional health. What's more is these results are independent of inter-parental conflict and income, meaning if you don't get along you still have benefits to the child. The American Psychological Association published a consensus statement in 2014 that included over 100 of the leading researchers and experts in the field all recommending joint custody over sole custody. Surveys of children of divorce as well as the public in general strongly favor joint custody. I could keep going about the evidence behind it, but the fact is at this point the burden of proof should be on those who oppose joint custody rather than those who support it. One of the questions I believe has been posed is do we need a presumption of joint custody since it's already favored? answer to that is a very easy yes. So favored status really doesn't have any significant power in the courts, which that means you can leave judges to continue to award sole custody with little to no justification. So these judgments do vary significantly from county to county and courtroom to courtroom. So we may have someone that stands up here and says, well, I've seen this work great in my courtroom. That's not going to be the same thing across the state. What creating a presumption does is it implements what the legislature decided was the right thing to do six years ago, yet is not being done. And a side argument to this is if we do think it's being done, then there's really no reason to not have a presumption in this law. One of the common arguments against a presumption, another one that's been posed today, is that it does remove a judge's discretion, so this is false. A presumption is nothing more than a defined starting point, not a required endpoint. Every case should be and is looked at individually. It does mean, however, that there should be just cause to deviate. There must be a higher evidentiary standard to deprive a parent of their rights as well as a child's right to both parents. That said, unfit or abusive parents won't be given custody by this bill. These are things that are looked at in every situation. So another question that was posed was, what if the parents don't get along or don't agree to joint custody? Some of these studies done in joint custody have shown that joint custody still works. As I mentioned, it still has that improvement to the children. Between the parents, they've shown that the conflict remains equal or decreases between the two, meaning you're not going to make them argue more because they're sharing custody. What you're doing is you're removing one from being in a position of authority over the other parent. Parents of joint custody have also been shown to have equal or greater satisfaction with the custody arrangement when compared to those with primary or sole custody. This includes those that did not agree to joint custody in the first place. Having a parent fight over who gets custody in court is certainly a way to increase conflict, relitigation and legal fees. There is a big difference between when two parents step into court with the understanding that unless a parent has proven unfit or there's some outside circumstance, that they will have joint custody versus letting them sit in there to fight it out over who gets to be primary custody with maybe joint custody being favored. I do want to point out also that there are similar bills moving forward in multiple States, including Missouri, Illinois, Kansas, Tennessee, and Oklahoma. So this is something that's moving around the country and it's very close to us as well. Uh, it is time for us to acknowledge the joint custody is in the best interest of the child. Uh, the legislature, almost overwhelmingly agreed to this in 2013. So I'm asking that we can start making this happen and put it into practice by
Cap, do you have a question, Mr. Fraley, again, thank you for, for testifying and giving us your opinion was your, I have two questions. Um, was your divorce out of Pulaski County? Uh, yes. Okay. And my recognize, you're recognized for a follow up. Thank you. And from looking on, on court connect, which is public record, um, from your testimony here, with Representative Gasway's bill, there's 26 pages of activity in regards to your case. And so my question is, in a situation such as that, to where you're testifying as a non-custodial parent, when you have a lot of conflict and there's concerns with the parties of being able to communicate and work things out together without seeking court intervention, do you not think that that comes into play for a circuit judge in trying to make a determination in regards to who's going to be ultimately responsible for that child? If you have two parents that, again, are hitting roadblocks with communicating. I think that not having joint custody or not having a
presumption leads to those situations. So what courts are really good at doing is pointing one parent against the other one, and that's really what happened in my case. It was a fairly cordial relationship, and all of a sudden it's, I'm taking the child, and the child is mine, and there's really no recourse I have. So I'll also say that this isn't going to impact me one way or the other. I do have a high-conflict parent on the other side. I've been spending the last few years bobbing and weaving whatever accusations or attempts to go back to court that have been filed, Uh, and I continue, I will continue to do that for the next several years, but this contentious relationship that's there, uh, has been created by not having joint custody. If you put two people on an even playing field, that's different from putting one person in charge of the other one, which is essentially what happens when you
get primary custody. Thank you, Mr. Frehley. Uh, we have Mr. Hoggard who has signed up to speak against the bill. mr. Hoggard if you'll come to the end of the table and state your name and then you may
proceed thank you madam chair good evening members of the committee my name is Glenn Hoggard despite my youthful appearance I've been practicing law in Arkansas since 2000 it. Um, first of all, I need to walk a tight line. I sit on the bar association's legislation committee. As such, we take positions on behalf of the bar. We have not taken a position on this bill. We did refer the bill to our family law section and ask for commentary from the members of the family law section. We received a number of comments, all of which were opposed to this bill. I will readily tell the committee today that that was before some amendments were made, but there are a number of practitioners who had vast problems with adopting a presumption, a rebuttable presumption nonetheless. I want to say to representative Larry, thank you for passing joint custody in 2013. I, like I suspect a lot of members of the bar were afraid of that and we probably opposed it then, but the bar is often resistant to change. I know you may find that difficult to believe, but we like doing things the way we've been doing them for a long time. Joint custody has been, as Ms. Hoover said, a real game changer in that both parents are far more involved now than ever before. A significant portion of my practice is as a domestic relations attorney ad litem. The, that role is to serve the court and to work with the parents and to give a recommendation to the court about what should happen. I tend to refer to it as a special master, but that's not actually what you are. It's statutory in nature. Right now, when I'm dealing with two parents as an attorney ad litem and attempting to decide what my recommendation should be to the court on custody. I start at the statutory preference for joint custody. If this law is enacted and changes to a rebuttable presumption, I can tell you without any doubt in my mind that the litigants that have attorneys are going to want to litigate rebuttable presumption. I have a tool. I have an arrow in my quiver right now that joint custody is preferred. And I can start from that point and make the parents work towards seeing that that is a justifiable and appropriate resolution, despite the fact that they may be warring with one another. If we go away from preferred and make it the legal standard of rebuttable presumption, that is going to be a litigated matter frequently. One of the things that worries me about this, this we've only been doing joint custody for six years in legal terms that's a very brief period of time and what worries me about this is we're about to take what we're getting right and what it's taken us this long to change to get right and we're going to turn it upside down and create I'll put it this way we're going to throw a monkey wrench in the process by making a change if you adopt this to go to rebuttal presumption that is going to be continually litigated it's going to mean that you're going to have longer cases. You're going to have greater pleadings. You're going to have greater dockets on the judges. There's a ton of things that this will cause to happen from the practice of law standpoint that will not be correctable if this is adopted. The problem that I see, despite the testimony of the witnesses and the results that they've had that favor this. I don't think this bill changes their situation. I don't think that it makes their situation better. I don't think that not having the preference for joint custody creates a result that's different for them than what they would get with just having it as a preference. It's still going to be a litigated matter. And in my view, it will be a much greater litigated matter if this adopted. Thank you, Chairman Dalby, and I'll be happy to answer
a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. I just, I just, I frankly disagree with one thing you said when you said it will cause more litigation if it's the rebuttable presumption. In my opinion, if you can sit both parents down and say the rebuttable presumption is joint, you will then be able to not strong-arm them, but say, this is what a court's going to do, let's work this out, as opposed to just being favored. And I think those of us, I don't do as much as I did at one time, but if you can settle these type cases, that's always best for everyone, in most cases. So I think it will actually help judges and help people settle if they go in knowing the judge is going to lean towards, or at least the presumption is going to be joint custody. So could you explain why you said it would make
it more difficult to settle cases? Yes, sir. So if I'm counsel for one of the litigants and it's a rebuttable presumption as opposed to just the preferred standard, then that's something I can litigate. That's something I've got case law on. That's something that's going to allow me to make my claims. And it is sort of a mini custody battle within a custody battle. So if there's a rebuttal presumption for joint custody, then I get to come in. I say, here are these things that are wrong with the other parent, and I don't have to put on a full-blown case. And that means you're going to get a free shot at the rebuttal presumption issue instead of the full-blown custody case, which means it's going to make it tougher to settle because it's going to be easier to litigate at rebuttal presumption than it would be for full-blown custody. For me, as the attorney ad litem, I guess let me tell you what my bias is. As an attorney ad litem, my bias is my job is to try to get all the cases that I'm assigned to settled if I possibly can. Now, that's probably not a politically correct thing to say, but that's the reality of it. So if there's a rebuttable presumption and the litigant for one of the parties has the shot at trying rebuttable presumption, whereas I don't have the ability to say that joint custody is something that is in the realm of things that I can recommend, if it's going to start at joint custody as the rebuttable presumption, I've lost that tool to bring them together and to settle their case. and their attorneys will litigate it. I
the way you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Hoggard, would you agree with me, though, that currently, and I know the law says that joint custody is favored, but that certainly just because it has a favored status does not mean that the judge is bound to follow that or to award that. I know I found myself making that argument many times to no avail that the judges don't get to write the law. They just have to follow it, and they didn't care what I said. And so would you not agree with me now that the position that we start from is it's each side starts from an all-or-nothing position. Each side now asks for custody and that the other person to get visitation. And even though it's favored, you're still kind of an all-or-nothing approach. Is that not what you see in
the courts? So there's only three possible situations there. One parent's for joint custody and the other's not. They both oppose joint custody, or they both favor joint custody. That's it. That's the parameter. And, yes, I see all of that, and I see plenty of folks that want to fight for custody, and they don't really care what we call the preference and what we don't call the preference. The thing that bothers me about the dynamic of your question is, a number of you know that if I have any expertise at all, it's probably in the area of dependency neglect. And we're all the time trying to legislate around bad judging. Again, probably not a politically correct thing to say. You can't legislate around bad judging. You can't do it. If you make this the law and you say to domestic relations judges, there should be a rebuttable presumption, what's in your example? Let's just use your example. What's to keep the judge from saying, well, that's all well and good, but it's been rebutted.
We're right back where we were. Directness for follow-up. And I don't disagree with that, But I think the point is, don't you see this as changing the framework and changing the starting point? I mean, the framework now, wouldn't you agree with me, is that typically one person gets custody, the other person gets visitation, which is no rights other than to just visit with their child. And so this would fundamentally change the framework and the starting point that judges start from.
Would you agree? No, I agree with Ms. Hoover on this. What my experience has been since 2013 is we've gone to a paradigm of joint custody being the default position. Now, it doesn't always happen. It doesn't always get ruled on that way. But in my practice in central Arkansas, north central Arkansas, I'd say that's far and away the majority of what's happened. It's taken some time. It didn't happen in 2013, and it didn't happen in 2014 either. But that's where I am now in 2019.
Representative Clowney. You're recognized for a question. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you for your testimony. I think there are a lot of lawyers on this committee and there are a lot of non-lawyers on this committee. So I kind of want to just take this back, bird's eye view. I think we all agree that, you know, joint custody is best when it is best. But can, and we all agree that parents' rights are very, very important. But at the end of the day, what this all is about is about those kids. It's about the best interest of the children. Can you talk about how you see this rebuttable presumption, whether the rebuttable presumption in and of itself is or is not in the best interest of the children? In other words, how do you see this litigation process that you're describing play out affecting the
children? All right. So, mind you, I'm speculating as to what the result will be. So, I'm looking at my crystal ball. Right now, as an ad litem, where I'm representing both the best interests of the child and the child's expressed wishes if they're of an appropriate age. That's the standard for the domestic relations attorney ad litem. Right now, I can go to the parents and say, why should I not recommend joint custody? Because that is the preferred result. That is, what is the preferred result in an Arkansas domestic relations case? And that gives me the ability to bring them together. If we go to rebuttable presumption, the problem that I foresee is that it creates this ability for the litigants, really for their attorneys, to take on the case under rebuttable presumption, that standard. Right now, it's a preference. And that preference just inures to best interest of the child ruling. But if it's a rebuttal presumption, that's a legal standard that we all know how to address and that good domestic relations attorneys like Ms. Hoover know how to address. And they will be able to litigate that far more readily than what happens at present in my practice. So I think that's harmful, not helpful. I think that means that there's an arrow that's out of my quiver when I try to get these cases settled, when I try to get these folks together for what's the best interest of the child. I'll say this, Representative Clowney, I wish that I could tell you with 100% certainty that that's going to be the way it turns out. I've already admitted in 2013 when joint custody became the preferred status, I didn't think it would turn out as well as it has. So my predictor I'm already admitting is not real good. But that's exactly what I see happening. And let me tell you why this makes all the sense in the world, if you'll consider it. Attorneys litigate. They're hired by clients who are in a dispute. They're unhappy with one another. They're divorcing from one another. They're fighting over custody. They're fighting over property division. They're fighting to see who's right and who wins. Yeah, rebuttable presumption is going to give them a gold field in which to make those arguments. and it creates one more place for the litigants to fight with one another that doesn't exist now. Thank you. Thank you.
Madam Chair, I need to do one thing. I want to make sure that I said in the event that I didn't, I'm speaking for Glenn Hoggard today. I'm not speaking for the bar association. Duly
name. Thank you, Madam Chair. Lance Ryder. I'm just a dad. I fought for years. I've been on the short end of the stick. I can tell you it started in 2001 my kids was in a they were living in a bad situation took me 10 years to get them out I run into roadblocks everywhere I turned bad attorneys bad judges I don't know I'm I'm a lineman I don't do I don't do law I don't know but it was a long hard road I am currently in a joint custody situation and I promise you there's a lot less conflict in this in this situation than there has been in the past what I want to do today is I would like to read a text that my daughter sent me she's 21 years old she just had her first child and here's what she sent me out of the blue there was no text before this this just came through Thursday said hey I just want to say thank you for fighting for us all those years when mom found out I was pregnant she was so happy and said now that I had kids I would forgive her because I would realize why she did all the things that she did but it seems every day i wonder more and more how she could have did the things she did and i realize more and more why you did the things you did i know i was ungrateful and sometimes a downright brat i know i didn't appreciate all the court and fighting back then and i was a mama's girl and couldn't see what she did wrong i know i've never thanked you for fighting for us so i want to say thanks i know i wouldn't be who i am today if it wasn't for you i'm so thankful there was someone to fight for us and to make sure we we're on the right path sierra which is her stepkids mother reminds me of mom more and more every day and it breaks my heart for the kids because i know it's hurting them even if they can't see it now i find myself being more like you every day and parenting in the same ways So thanks for being so strict and never giving up no matter how stressful it was or how unappreciated you were
I love you Represent cap. Did you have a question? Yes, madam chair. Thank you. Thank you, sir For your testimony, and I'd like to ask you what year you were award awarded joint custody And then what the split is whether it's 50 50 time or 60 40 or what exactly you guys are
doing in transitioning the child it's it's 50 50 uh it's been probably two years uh and we we she we live about well actually she's out of state right now so i have him full time but when she's she's a traveling nurse and when she's home and and working in local the we live just a few miles apart and she has him a week and i have him a week and there's just it's it's great there's not much conflict there's nobody arguing bickering about time i mean it's it's it's really been so great compared to my first first battle and i mean we decided we threw an ad litem attorney which has helped me when i got custody of my oldest two kids it was i found a great attorney and then i had an ad litem we hired an ad litem for the first time and that ad litem helped me The judge basically said, is this case ever going to end? Because it had been going on 10 years and that item stepped in at that point and said, not unless something changes because she's going to keep screwing up and he's going to keep bringing her back. Something's got to give and the judge finally ruled in my favor. And that's how I ended up with custody and basically 2011. Thank you, Mr.
table, state your name, and you may give your statement. Good evening. My name is Cash Jackson. Thank you to this committee for staying late and hearing our testimony. I do greatly appreciate your services and your sacrifices that you make to hear such important matters. I'm a father of three. I'm a 20-year Navy veteran, retired in 2016, and went through a very adversarial divorce, to say the least. I was awarded the standard every other weekend, a couple hours on Wednesdays, and to date, I had been to court over 100 times. So the argument that 50-50 equal custody would result in more litigation, simply there's no data to support that. There's no empirical data that can support that 50-50, a rebuttable presumption, will result in more litigation. But we do have not only anecdotal, but plenty of statistical data that supports that the current model results in tremendous litigation. The average divorce cost just in the state of Arkansas, I believe, is about $11,000. And that's significant in this state. You know, given the how much money people make here, comparatively to the state of Illinois, where I was divorced, that average divorce there was $20,000. I spent right at $60,000. Before I left the Navy, I was virtually bankrupted. I went from having exceptional credit and being a father to my children to every other weekend visitor to my kids. My experience in family court has absolutely decimated my family. And it's what's driven me to fight for something like this. Me fighting for this battle here in Arkansas does me no direct benefit whatsoever. But what I do know is the benefit that it has for kids. And that's what I want the committee to understand and to hear. One thing that one of the opponents said earlier that really troubled me was that she believed that you needed to prove that this was the best scenario, if I understood her correctly. in what world do we live in where you must prove that you're a fit parent it is the state's obligation it is their constitutional obligation that if you're an unfit parent that the state does the due diligence of finding you to be an unfit parent until that has occurred then both parents underneath the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment are presumed to be fit not only underneath Supreme Court previous rulings, they're presumed to be fit, but they should have the equal access to those kids. And when we say that, you know, child support was mentioned earlier, and it's not something that I bring up because it's not what's important, but when we say that, well, the children need, you know, a lifestyle that they were accustomed to living. Okay, well, let's take that to this aspect. They were accustomed to having the other parent, mother or father, in their life an equal amount of time. So why do we never make that argument that the children should maintain the same lifestyle that they had before? What we currently experience and what we have is an adversarial system that pits children between two parents who only love and want to spend more time with their kids. And I want to ask you this. I don't know how many of you in here are parents. I presume it's safe to say that some of you are. But if you were to go before two different judges in this state, in the way that the statutes are currently written, as testified by one of the opponents, the judges do have the discretion to either award joint custody or not. But if you were to set foot in front of a judge, and that judge said to you, you have a newborn, that you're going to get to spend the next 3.6 years with this child. The other parent, they're going to get the remainder of that time until this child turns 18, 3.6 years out of 18 years. Now put yourself in the position of that child. As a child, because I didn't grow up with my father, and I know how that harmed me as into my adulthood, imagine what that does to our children, and I don't want you just to imagine it, I want you to understand the systemic impact that's happening across our country. Twenty million American children growing up absent their biological father. Twenty million children. Now what's the societal impact that you as legislators need to be concerned with, not merely that it can happen to you or to your children or your grandchildren, but you should understand the systemic effects that's happening across our country. Sixty-three percent of youth suicides are from fatherless homes. That's from the U.S. Department of Health Census. That's five times the national average. Ninety percent of all homeless and runaway children are from fatherless homes, 32 times the average. Eighty-five percent of all children who show behavior disorders come from fatherless homes, 20 times the average. from Center for Disease Control. 80% of rapists with anger problems come from fatherless homes, 14 times the average. 71% of all high school dropouts come from fatherless homes, nine times the average. Those are just a few of the numbers, and they go far deeper than that. Every piece of legislation that you guys rule on has the ability to negatively or positively impact our current and future generations. And right now, you have a profound decision to make. There are roughly 20 to 30 states that are pushing shared parenting legislation. This is the way of the future. Arkansas has the ability right now to decide, are they going to be a leader in that future, or are they gonna wait to follow other states and what they're doing? We have macro data that supports this is what is best for kids. rebuttable presumption where you are presumed to be a fit and loving parent as most of us are. Those that are not, the judges will retain the criteria necessary to not award joint custody to them. I'm asking you to support HB 1325 and thank you so much for your time tonight. I'll take any questions if you
have one. Thank you, Mr. Jackson. Our next individual we have signed up is for informational purposes only. I'm not sure if you have anything you want to share, Judge Van Smith, but I know you're here. If you, if you want, if
you'll take a few minutes. Thank you, Madam Chair. Uh, I'm Van Smith and I'm a circuit judge in Little Rock and I'm here on behalf of the judicial council and the judicial council has taken no position on this. They feel like it's a policy decision uh there obviously there was debate on both sides but uh the official position is that we take no position uh i want to say one thing i talked i worked with representative larry in 2013 on the uh joint custody bill and uh i was happy to do that and i echo some of the other people here joint custody has really worked i mean that simple bill has changed how judges see custody cases in Arkansas, and I've got a theory. I don't know if this is right or not, but I think as older judges transition out and newer judges with a different mindset begin, then I think even more of the joint custody will be prevalent in the state. Thank you, Judge Smith. We
you recognize the close for your bill? Thank you, Madam Chairman, and thank you, committee, for your patience. I know it's not an easy issue to navigate through, but I just want to reference a couple of things that I heard. I appreciate Judge Smith so much because working with him in 2013, six years ago, and then even through this bill, he's been extremely helpful. And Mr. Hoggard made comments that he was not supportive of the 2013 bill, and he was not alone. There were a lot of attorneys that were opposing it. There were a lot of attorneys and judges saying the sky is going to fall. And you've heard by testimony today that the sky has not fallen, that it's actually been very positive in the state of Arkansas. He also referenced that he, as an ad litem, feels like if he can communicate to the two parties that joint custody is Arkansas's preference, then he can head off a lot of litigation. I don't see where that changes. There's not, as a matter of fact, it probably makes it even easier for his job. Preference equals presumption. All you have to do is just substitute in the same word in saying to those parties. I just think you ought to know that there's a presumption that this isn't in the best interest of the child, and then you head off the litigation. So I just want to thank you for your patience and appreciate all those who have come forward to testify, and I would appreciate a due pass vote.
Members, Representative Lowry has closed for his bill. What's the wishes of the committee? Representative Gassaway? we have a motion to do pass on the table any discussion
representing cap I've given this case or this particular bill a lot of thought I've spent a lot of time reading cases and talking to my judges and lawyers across the state I'm I'm a no, and I'm a no because every case is different. Every child is different, and every family is different. And I think that the court should look to the facts of each case and decide what is best for the child without an arbitrary presumption of joint custody. I don't think that this bill is focused on the children, but what is more convenient and best for the parent. And children do not calculate percentages. Love is not divisible. Children need parents who keep their life together across two homes, not parents who divide their lives precisely in equal halves. Representative House, did
you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Representative Lowry. I appreciate this, and I really do appreciate what you did in 13 with this bill. Gosh, my experience at one time was very extensive in this sort of thing, and I remember that there was a presumption that the mother was always the best person to have custody of the child. That was a rebuttable presumption. I remember the tender years doctrine where it was a rebuttable presumption that mother had custody of the small children, the babies, no matter what. And that was almost never rebuttable. I remember the rebuttable presumption that it was better for the children to stay in the home and for dad to move out. it was a rebuttable presumption that mother could not leave the state with the children I remember these things and how difficult and usually the rule of thumb was you had to prove that the mother was unfit before dad could get custody of the kids I'm scared to death of rebuttable presumptions. I've seen how evil they can work. I mean, I've got to remember what happens when you're sitting in judgment of one of these things, and a couple of people walk in, they're dressed nice, and they're all smiles, and yes, sir, and no, sir, and they commence to tear each other apart, and they're still smiling, and yes, sir, and no, sir, and the judge is sitting they're trying to figure out what to do it's not easy anybody can it's kind of like Dayton anybody be nice for a couple of hours right and and that's what happens the voice of experience down there at the other table I think I think you've got it right the first time the 13 I don't think we need to go one step further to a rebuttable presumption I appreciate all these folks is con testimony and what they had to say about it and and I really appreciate representative cap what she said every case is different and gosh I've seen some horrible situations and I've seen a few that just worked out beautifully so again I could congratulate you the success that you have may have what you did in 13 was wonderful and it it's proven so thank you members we have a motion on
you madam chair I've seen a lot of progress in this area of the law and it's just going to take a while you know for for judges to come around and I think Judge Smith hit the nail on the head the younger judges you go before two judges you can get two results I mean we are not this is not a science who gets custody of the force but it's just going to take some time you know we have various laws and there's social laws where they affect people these affect children as well as parents the worst of them particularly the parents normally will often surface during circumstances like these like divorces so I think the court is on the right it's made some great progress in a short time and our favor and this way judges try to do anyway they've tried to really make make the parties a favor John John called custody and circumstances you know will affect the others and ultimately that rule so I'm I I appreciate Mr. Lowry, Representative Lowry, for bringing forth this bill. But in due time, things will get much better. Representative Maddox, do you have
Crawford? Thank you. I will speak from a non-attorney point of view. Some days it's good not to be an attorney, and some days you wish you were. So today I'm glad I'm not because I'm going by my heart. My son just got a divorce. He is the custodial of a joint custody. I love what you said about the kids should stay in the house. I'm going to present that. But we're in a crazy world. We're in a world where parents get divorced as often as they get married anymore. And my vote would be as not being an attorney and not knowing all the things you guys know, but knowing the heart of the kids would be to vote for this bill. And thank you for bringing in. I'm so glad you brought 13 in. And let's let Arkansas be a leader for once instead of behind. Any other discussion?
Members, we have a motion on the table for a due pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. No. The no's have it. The bill has failed. Members, we are adjourned. You
TO OFFER TESTIMONY ON A BILL, PLEASE SIGN IN TO BE RECOGNIZED BY THE CHAIR
Number AL ORDER O
Sponsor BUSINESS, MARCH 26, 2019, 15 MINUTES UPON ADJOURNMENT
Subtitle
HB1325 Lowery TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CUSTODY OF A CHILD.
1:21 - 1:17:16196 segments19 speakers
Representative Mark Lowery introduced HB 1325, proposing a rebuttable presumption that joint custody serves the child’s best interest, outlining the bill’s legislative intent, citing comparative state examples, and noting his collaboration with the Judicial Council to streamline custody-determination factors.
[1:43][2:18][2:52][3:24][4:00][4:35][5:10][5:41][6:12]
Committee members, including Rep. Nicole Clowney and Rep. Sarah Capp, questioned the adequacy of the 2013 law and the absence of statistical evidence, prompting Lowery to acknowledge reliance on anecdotal observations and to suggest measures such as county-wide “peacemakers” to foster parental cooperation.
[6:51][7:15][7:48][8:22][9:00][9:39][10:43][11:15][11:41][11:50][12:02][13:09][13:26][13:49][14:00]
TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC CONFIDENCE IN THE INTEGRITY OF JUDICIAL
REGULAR AGENDA
Number Sponsor Subtitle
SB183 A. Clark TO PROHIBIT CERTAIN REGISTERED SEX OFFENDERS FROM HOLDING A POSITION OF PUBLIC TRUST.
HB1680 Gazaway CONCERNING THE DEFINITION OF "TARGET GROUP" AS IT APPLIES TO COMMUNITY CORRECTION.
HB1732 Womack TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING GARNISHMENT AGAINST THE STATE OR A SUBDIVISION OF THE STATE; AND TO ALLOW FOR INCOME TAX REFUNDS TO BE SUBJECT TO GARNISHMENT BY JUDGMENT CREDITORS.
HB1733 Gazaway CONCERNING A THREAT TO COMMIT AN ACT OF MASS VIOLENCE ON SCHOOL PROPERTY.
HB1734 Gazaway CONCERNING THE AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES TO A VIOLATION OF AN ORDER OF PROTECTION; AND CREATING A DEFENSE TO A VIOLATION OF A NO CONTACT ORDER.
HB1756 Clowney CONCERNING THE WAIVER OF COUNSEL BY MINORS IN CRIMINAL COURT.
SB464 Hester TO ENSURE THE CONFIDENTIALITY OF CERTAIN PROCEDURES INVOLVED IN THE EXECUTION OF A PERSON FOR A CAPITAL OFFENSE.
HB1788 A. Collins THE BAIL DATA AND TRANSPARENCY ACT.
HB1802 Lowery TO REVISE THE FAMILY SUPPORT CHART TO REFLECT PAY OR AND RECIPIENT INCOME.
SB9 T. Garner GRANTING A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER EMPLOYED WITH THE SOCIAL SECURITY ADMINISTRATION OR THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF STATE THE AUTHORITY TO ARREST.
SB84 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING PERMANENCY GOALS THAT ARE AUTHORIZED BY THE COURT AT A PERMANENCY PLANNING HEARING.
SB206 Irvin CONCERNING THE TERMINATION OF A PERSON'S OBLIGATION TO REGISTER AS A SEX OFFENDER; AND CONCERNING LIFETIME REGISTRATION FOR CERTAIN REPEAT OFFENDERS.
HB1809 Love TO CREATE AN ADDITIONAL TERM OF IMPRISONMENT FOR OFFENSES THAT CONSTITUTE SERIOUS ACTS OF VIOLENCE AGAINST A PERSON AT A CHURCH OR OTHER PLACE OF WORSHIP.
HB1810 Penzo TO PROVIDE FOR QUALIFIED SPOUSAL TRUSTS IN ARKANSAS.
HB1820 Gonzales CONCERNING FIREARMS; CONCERNING FIREARM NOISE SUPPRESSORS AND MACHINE GUNS; AND CONCERNING COMPLIANCE WITH THE NATIONAL FIREARMS ACT.
HB1843 Gates CONCERNING A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND THE SCOPE OF WHERE A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY MAY CARRY AND POSSESS A HANDGUN.
HB1844 Gates CONCERNING WHAT CONSTITUTES CRIMINALLY INJURIOUS CONDUCT UNDER THE ARKANSAS CRIME VICTIMS REPARATIONS ACT.
HB1851 Bentley CONCERNING THE ISSUANCE OF AN ORDER OF PROTECTION.
HB1866 Petty CONCERNING EXECUTIVE CLEMENCY, PARDON, AND COMMUTATION OF SENTENCE.
HB1635 Petty CONCERNING AN INCREASE IN THE SENTENCING RANGE FOR REPEAT FELONY SEX OFFENDERS; CONCERNING SEX OFFENDER REGISTRATION REQUIREMENTS; AND CONCERNING SEX OFFENSESAND SEX OFFENDERS.
HB1828 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD INTRASTATE RELOCATION ACT; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING WHETHER OR NOT A CHANGE OF PRINCIPAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE OF A CHILD IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CHILD.
HB1880 Dalby CONCERNING THE DISTRICT COURTS OF INDEPENDENCE, FULTON, AND IZARD COUNTIES.
SB375 Rapert TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING COURT REPORTS THAT ARE REQUIRED UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989.
SB451 J. Cooper TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR PROFESSIONS AND OCCUPATIONS TO OBTAIN CONSISTENCY REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS AND DISQUALIFYING OFFENSES FOR LICENSURE.
HB1898 L. Johnson CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF DISORDERLY CONDUCT; TO CREATE THE OFFENSE OF AGGRAVATED DISORDERLY CONDUCT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR INJUNCTIVE RELIEF.
SB547 B. Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN AN ACTION FOR DIVORCE.
HB1486 Gazaway TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CUSTODY OF A CHILD BORN OUTSIDE OF MARRIAGE.
SB511 Hill CONCERNING THE THIRTIETH JUDICIAL DISTRICT; AND CONCERNING LONOKE COUNTY STATE DISTRICT COURT AS IT WILL BE CONSTITUTED IN 2021.
SB573 G. Leding CONCERNING PROGRAMS AVAILABLE TO MINORS IN A STATE CORRECTIONAL FACILITY; CONCERNING PAROLE DISCHARGE FOR OFFENDERS WHO ARE MINORS; AND CONCERNING THEREINSTATEMENT OF CERTAIN RIGHTS FOR MINORS WHO ARE OFFENDERS.
SB8 T. Garner TO PROHIBIT A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER FROM RECORDING A PERSON UNDER FOURTEEN (14) YEARS OF AGE IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO PROHIBIT THE UNLAWFUL USE OF ARE CORDING OF A PERSON UNDER FOURTEEN (14) YEARS OF AGE ONLINE.
HB1059 Pilkington CONCERNING THE USE OF PHYSICAL FORCE IN SELF-DEFENSE OR IN THE DEFENSE OF OTHERS.
HB1307 Dotson PERMITTING A BANK OR BANKING INSTITUTION TO UTILIZE THE SMALL CLAIMS DIVISION OF A DISTRICT COURT.
HB1450 Wooten CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN BY A RETIRED CERTIFIED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.
HB1294 Della Rosa RESTORING PROSECUTORIAL DISCRETION IN THE RESOLUTION OF DRIVING OR BOATING WHILE INTOXICATED CASES.
Stubblefield TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PERSON WITH A LICENSE TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN WHO FAILS TO FILE A RENEWAL APPLICATION BEFORE THE EXPIRATION DATE PAYS A LATE FEE.
HB1494 V. Flowers CONCERNING THE IMPOSITION OF THE DEATH PENALTY ON A DEFENDANT WITH A SERIOUS MENTAL ILLNESS.
HB1540 Boyd TO ESTABLISH A PROCESS BY WHICH RECORDS OF CERTAIN CRIMINAL OFFENSES ARE AUTOMATICALLY REMOVED AFTER A CERTAIN PERIOD OF TIME; AND CONCERNING THE RECORDS OF APERSON'S CRIMINAL HISTORY.