Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs-Senate

March 19, 2019 ·10 Minutes Upon Adjournment ·OSC ·2:04:42
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 10, 2026

SJR15 A. Clark THE ARKANSAS TERM LIMITS AMENDMENT. 1:02

Senator Travis Porter opened the hearing with a critique of the proposed constitutional amendment, arguing that it would effectively allow legislators to serve indefinitely by setting 12- or 16-year limits with four-year gaps and raising concerns about the ambiguous impact on constitutional officers. [2:23] [2:54] [3:24] [3:57] [4:31] [5:02]

Tom Steele, representing the Arkansas Term Limits advocacy group, warned that the bill’s popular name duplicates the name of their citizen-initiated amendment, creating potential voter confusion and urging the committee to change the title. [6:05] [6:36] [7:07] [7:40] [8:13]

Senator Alan Clark responded by defending the amendment’s reduction of legislative term limits to 12 years, explaining his own amendment to remove judicial term limits from the proposal and emphasizing the goal of “good government”. [10:32] [11:05] [11:39] [12:11] [12:44] [13:14] [13:46] [14:17] [14:49] [15:21] [15:55] [16:28] [16:58] [17:29] [18:02] [18:32] [19:03]

The committee moved to adopt the amendment (including Clark’s judicial carve-out), a second was offered, and the amendment was approved by voice vote; the final language now sets a 12-year limit with a four-year waiting period and excludes the judiciary. [21:49] [21:54] [22:01] [22:43] [23:13] [23:48]

SB4 T. Garner TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS LEGISLATIVE STUDY ON VETERANS AFFAIRS. 27:56

Senator Trent Garner explained that SB 4, originally intended to create a veteran-suicide task force, was amended to establish an interim study subcommittee to address cost concerns while still pursuing the legislative study on veterans affairs. [28:06] [28:40] [29:11] [29:20] [29:27] [29:43]

After a brief question-and-answer exchange, the committee voted to concur with the bill, with members indicating “aye” and the measure being adopted. [30:56] [31:08]

SB409 Flippo TO ALLOW FOR THE ELECTRONIC NOTIFICATION OF AN INVITATION FOR BIDS AND THE ELECTRONIC SUBMISSION OF BIDS; AND TO REQUIRE CERTAIN ENTITIES TO ACCEP… 31:32

Senator Scott Flippo introduced Senate Bill 409, explaining that it would permit cities, counties and school districts to post bid invitations and accept electronic submissions instead of newspaper notices, noting that the language has not changed since the amendment adopted last week and that the change would save taxpayers money. [31:33] [31:36] [31:45] [31:52] [32:08] [32:15] [32:48] [33:23]

Committee members sought clarification on the bill’s wording, with Senator Hickey questioning underlined language on page 3 and Senator Will Bond asking how vendors would learn of online bids, prompting Ted Fleming of Central Bidding to testify that membership is free, fees apply only to downloading bid documents, and vendors are notified through commodity codes and training sessions. [35:05] [35:11] [35:34] [35:37] [35:43] [36:00] [36:33] [36:39] [37:10] [37:29] [37:41] [38:12] [38:43]

Support was voiced by Robin Keene of the Arkansas Association of Educational Administrators, who praised the secure-website option for school districts while retaining newspaper advertising, whereas Len Hamilton and Ashley Wimberley of the Arkansas Gazette warned that the bill could lead to newspaper layoffs, lacked public input and security standards, and appeared to favor a private vendor, and Jason Carter of the Arkansas Municipal League and Senator Bill Sample raised further concerns about contractor awareness, competition and the integrity of a private-website system. [39:27] [39:57] [40:11] [41:07] [41:41] [42:11] [42:43] [43:15] [43:49] [44:23] [44:55] [45:26] [45:57] [46:28] [49:46] [50:22] [50:57] [51:28] [52:04] [52:34] [53:05] [53:37] [54:13] [54:44] [55:15] [1:08:16] [1:08:48] [1:09:20] [1:09:51] [1:10:24] [1:10:57] [1:11:31] [1:12:01] [1:12:32] [1:18:37] [1:19:10] [1:19:18] [1:19:43] [1:20:13]

The Arkansas County Judges Association and the Association of Counties testified that SB 409 does not favor any particular vendor, pointing out that electronic bidding is already used by the state highway department and that counties could adopt the system voluntarily with optional paper bids during a transition period. [1:22:40] [1:23:07] [1:23:17] [1:23:27] [1:23:37] [1:24:11] [1:24:43] [1:25:18] [1:25:53]

Several senators, including Trent Garner and Jimmy Hickey, expressed worries about transparency and the potential to limit competition if bids were posted on any website, questioning vendor discovery and audit provisions, while Senator Breanne Davis countered that vendors routinely monitor online notices via alerts and that any electronic platform would be subject to Legislative Audit oversight, after which Senator Flippo reiterated that the bill merely offers an optional electronic bidding process to save taxpayers money and the chair moved to pass the bill as amended, which was approved unanimously with all ayes and no noes. [1:26:21] [1:26:26] [1:26:58] [1:27:08] [1:27:25] [1:27:29] [1:27:59] [1:28:32] [1:29:02] [1:29:38] [1:30:01] [1:30:15] [1:30:18] [1:31:08] [1:31:19] [1:31:50] [1:32:07] [1:32:24] [1:32:36] [1:32:58] [1:33:09] [1:33:24] [1:33:40] [1:33:45] [1:34:00] [1:34:11] [1:34:45] [1:35:15] [1:35:50] [1:36:23] [1:36:55] [1:37:30] [1:37:54] [1:38:00]

SB258 Bond TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS PERSONAL INCOME; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF ARKANSAS LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1990… 1:38:55

Senator Will Bond introduced SB 258, explaining that it would raise the penalty for personal use of campaign or carry-over funds from a misdemeanor to a felony when the amount exceeds $2,500, with a scaling structure for larger sums. [1:39:02] [1:39:35] [1:40:08] [1:40:39] [1:41:19]

The chair opened the floor for questions, and Senator Jimmy Hickey praised the bill as a deterrent, while Senator Bond offered to answer any further inquiries. [1:41:47] [1:41:51] [1:42:13] [1:42:23] [1:42:43]

A motion to adopt the amendment as presented was made, seconded, and approved unanimously by voice vote. [1:41:51] [1:42:13] [1:42:23] [1:42:43] [1:42:59]

SB515 M. Johnson TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HERITAGE PROTECTION ACT. 1:43:48

Senator Mark Johnson presented SB 515, the Arkansas Heritage Protection Act, defining “monument” broadly to include statues, plaques, streets, schools, bridges and other public-property commemorations, and prohibiting their relocation, alteration or destruction except for necessary maintenance. [1:44:03] [1:44:36] [1:45:06] [1:45:39] [1:46:10] [1:46:41]

Senators Trent Garner and Jimmy Hickey raised concerns that the definition and the Class D felony penalty were overly broad, potentially criminalizing minor acts such as a youth removing a street sign, and suggested a tiered offense structure or amendments to narrow scope. [1:51:36] [1:51:53] [1:52:25] [1:52:55] [1:56:07] [1:56:38] [1:56:46] [1:57:15]

The chair offered to recess the committee and allow the sponsor to return with revised language, indicating the bill would be taken up again after the break. [1:55:09] [1:55:32] [1:55:34]

HB1420 Boyd TO AMEND CANDIDATE FILING AND PETITION CIRCULATION PERIODS; TO AMEND THE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTION DATE NOTIFICATION PROCESS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGE… 1:59:55

Lindsay Bailey introduced HB 1420, outlining three uniformity measures: one-week filing periods for county-clerk candidate filings, a 90-day uniform petition-circulation period, and a standardized notification timeline for school-board election date changes. [2:00:07] [2:00:28] [2:00:58] [2:01:28]

Committee members asked clarification about the current filing periods, confirming that the bill would shift some jurisdictions from a two-week to a one-week window, and no opposition was voiced. [2:02:07] [2:02:20] [2:02:31] [2:02:35] [2:02:49]

The chair closed the discussion without a vote, leaving the bill pending. [2:01:58] [2:02:07] [2:02:20] [2:02:31] [2:02:35] [2:02:49]

HB1444 Breaux TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DATE TO HOLD CERTAIN RUNOFF ELECTIONS. 2:02:55

The chair moved to pass the bill, it was seconded, and the committee approved it by voice vote. [2:02:59] [2:03:09] [2:03:12] [2:03:40] [2:03:45] [2:04:09] [2:04:15]

Bills discussed (8)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB409 Act 1075 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “your bill number it's uh senate bill 409 mr chairman”
TO ALLOW FOR THE ELECTRONIC NOTIFICATION OF AN INVITATION FOR BIDS AND ELECTRONIC SUBMISSION OF … Flippo Notification that SB409 is now Act 1075
SB4 Act 551 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB4 T. Garner TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS LEGISLATIVE STUDY ON VETER…”
TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS LEGISLATIVE STUDY ON VETERANS AFFAIRS. T. Garner Notification that SB4 is now Act 551
HB1420 Act 597 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1420 Boyd TO AMEND CANDIDATE FILING AND PETITION CIRCULATION PER…”
TO AMEND CANDIDATE FILING AND PETITION CIRCULATION PERIODS; TO AMEND THE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTION DATE … Boyd Notification that HB1420 is now Act 597
HB1444 Act 642 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1444 Breaux TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DATE TO HOLD CERTAIN…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DATE TO HOLD CERTAIN RUNOFF ELECTIONS. Breaux Notification that HB1444 is now Act 642
SB258 Act 879 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB258 Bond TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS P…”
TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS PERSONAL INCOME; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS … Bond Notification that SB258 is now Act 879
SB515 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB515 M. Johnson TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HERITAGE PROTECTION ACT.”
TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HERITAGE PROTECTION ACT. M. Johnson Recommended for study in the Interim Committee on …
SCR15 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “addressing SCR 15. All right, so then getting on to this bill. We come to thi…”
Pre-2017 bill
SJR15 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SJR15 A. Clark THE ARKANSAS TERM LIMITS AMENDMENT.”
THE ARKANSAS TERM LIMITS AMENDMENT. A. Clark Reviewed by the Governor

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 10, 2026
Okay, call this meeting back to order. Okay, I mean Senator Clark, do you have an amendment for your bill?
▶ Play
I do. I wasn't going to present it yet, but I do have one. I wasn't going to present it yet, but
▶ Play
I do have one. Okay. What would your pleasure be then if
▶ Play
Speaker 10 0:48
you don't? Y'all were still had
▶ Play
people that want to speak against the bill. That's fine. Travis Porter.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I'll let you
▶ Play
go a minute. Introduce yourself for the record
▶ Play
you recognize. Travis Porter, speaking for myself, thank you very much. On question, I just picked up this amendment about two minutes ago. We're not addressing that amendment yet, that's not part of the bill. All right. The term, and I'm speaking only on the term limits basically for the legislature that addressed in this amendment. The term limits that exist now in the legislature were approved in 2014 by the Ethics, Transparency, and Financial Reform Amendment, which was placed on the ballot by the legislature. This amendment, with sort of a deceptive ballot title and popular name, resulted in a narrow passage. And while the public didn't get ethics, transparency, or financial reform, what they did get was legislative term limits increased to- Let me interrupt, and
▶ Play
I don't mean it ugly. We've been here since 7.30. We're not addressing that bill. We're
▶ Play
addressing SCR 15. All right, so then getting on to this bill. We come to this proposed constitutional amendment. This bill, as currently written, establishes term limits for judges and justices, and quote, which amends term limits applicable to the members of the General Assembly. This bill actually provides for unlimited service in the General Assembly, as long as either 16-year terms or 12-year terms, depending on when the legislature was elected, are broken by four-year intervals of service. I think it was stated earlier that it actually reduced term limits to 12 years, but that depends on when the legislature was elected. If you're elected for 2021, it's 16 years ad infinitum. And if you're elected after that, it's 12 years ad infinitum with the four-year intervals. I do have one concern about this, a couple of concerns. One of them has to do with, in the title, it says, concerning the terms served by certain elected constitutional officers. And then, in the Legislative of 10, it says, it's intended, the General Assembly finds that this proposed amendment addresses the subject of terms served by certain elected constitutional officers by amending the term limits applicable to the General Assembly. And in the closing remarks, I would request for clarification that we have an understanding of how amending the term limits for legislature affects those of constitutional officers when it's not addressed in the bill. This bill, when it was first brought up, I recall one of the senators in this committee stating that we, quote, are not your enemy, unquote. Now, those are words out of one of the senators on this committee, they're not my words. However, I think we all have to admit that a struggle exists. The people in the state of Arkansas want citizen legislators, not career politicians. And what do we call this struggle that exists when the legislature basically continues to subvert the will of the people, because this doesn't reduce term limits, but it simply makes it possible for legislators to serve basically forever. And so a question I have then is, why is the legislature revisiting term limits now? In 2014, the legislature got 16 years, all of which can be served in one job. Apparently that's not enough. Earlier discussion centered around It takes a while to learn the job. Well, how much time does it take? 16 years or more. So I would hope that this bill would not be passed out of committee. These are the kind of things that frankly don't endear the legislature of the people of Arkansas. Thank you very much. You want to have any questions?
▶ Play
Okay, thank you, Mr. Porter. Tom Steele. If you would introduce yourself for the record and you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. My name is Tom Steele. I'm chairman of Arkansas Term Limits. And I'll be very brief today. I only have one item to ask about. As you know, our organization has sponsored an initiative petition for counting this year, three election cycles in a row. And the popular name of our amendment has been the Arkansas Term Limits Amendment. We also have already filed our amendment with the Secretary of State's office pursuant to a new law that was passed here a few weeks ago. We've also created our ballot quest committee to advocate for the passage of the Arkansas Term Limits Amendment, a citizen initiative. And I'd like to point out that there seems to be a little bit of a conflict with SDR 15, which wants to use the same popular name, Arkansas Term Limits Amendment. Now, I don't know how that gets resolved. We've already filed ours. We've been using that proper name for about six years. I think it's possible that some people might feel like this is an attempt to perhaps piggyback on any goodwill that our amendments have created over the last few years, perhaps maybe even confuse the voters about exactly what this bill is since we've been campaigning for six years on the Arkansas Term Limit Amendment. This looks like it might be an attempt to lead people to believe that this is the same amendment when of course it's not. But at any rate, I don't know how this gets resolved. I'm hoping that you guys recognize that there's a little bit of a conflict here and just make some simple adjustment to your popular name so that the voters aren't confused or they don't somehow think that perhaps this has something to do with the citizens initiative. And while there's a lot of other things I could comment on this bill, but I think it's all been said before. And so I'll just close with that statement. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 40 8:21
you. No questions, I assume. Thank you. appreciate your comments.
▶ Play
Okay. All right, that ends the testimony from earlier this morning. That ends the testimony from earlier this morning. Senator Clark, you're recognized. Okay, if I may respond.
▶ Play
I'll start with the subtitle. It's not mine. I didn't didn't have anything to do with the actual text the title, of the subtitle, or of the amendment. I went to BLR and said write it. So it is what it is. And I wouldn't want to have any, it's no intentional desire of mine to have it confused because the amendment that that was offered by Arkansas term limits, I thought was awful. I thought it was some of the most terrible ideas on government that there have been, that you would not only go back to six years in the House where you would have an average of two years experience every time that the legislature met, then you would come up and most senators would serve about four years and only served two years with half of the and make the people's branch weaker than it already is and to try to get anything done to reform government, et cetera, which is the main thing that I have worked on, the six years that I have been here, it concerns me, more than concerns me, and then they would have made it permanent. So what I worked on and have been working on is a good government bill and a good government amendment, as I shared with you before. I don't think there's anything wrong with the 16 years, but there has been talk ever since that amendment, the ethics amendment, that it was deceptive. and I offered an amendment the very next session and have been since. This amendment takes us to 12 years total, which is only two years longer than what Arkansas term limits had offered. It's the same as what California and Oklahoma is. And while it keeps you from having career politicians, also gives folks the time to have the experience to actually make a difference and to get things done. The four years set out is not, I know there are people that will come back, and we know that absolutely because we know the history in other states. We know that in other states that do something like this, although only one of them is as strict as ours, We know that of 617 legislators, we know that 30 were term limited and came back, which is 5%. So we know that the vast majority of legislators will have their term limits reduced. We know that a few will serve longer. And again, this was done for the purpose of good government. If you ever have a Thomas Jefferson, a Benjamin Franklin, if you have someone who serves in their 20s and 30s, who might, the people might want to send again in their 50s or 60s, it certainly is a good idea not to have that permanent term limit because it doesn't just limit the person, it limits the people, it limits the voters that they can elect whoever that they want to elect. So addressing that, I also want to address the judge's concerns because I think the judge's concerns were valid because if we do the judicial term limits, it's a sea change. It's something very different. But nevertheless, I want to address what they said from the other side because I think there's two sides to every argument. You know, one of the first things that was said is that if a judge who is term limited, is that a judge who's term limited in their last term is not gonna do their job. Well, I hope not. I hope that's not true. I don't think that's true. I know legislators continue to do their jobs. I can't imagine a judge determined not to do their job, but if a judge was not going to do their job in their last term because they were term limited, does it not become a problem if you know that you're never going to have anyone run against you how well you're going to conduct your docket, how well? And let me say, you know, I'm a preacher's kid. So I guess some of the mystique, you know, a lot of people, you know a lot of people seem to overly criticize preachers but other people think well you can't criticize preachers well you know preachers put their pants on one letter at a time like everybody else does i'm also the child of school teachers and they do the same uh and so do firemen and policemen and soldiers and so do judges and uh and this idea that somehow when you put on the black robe that somehow you're different from everybody else you're not and uh the uh you know But this, I think, one of the things, you know, I had a friend that was elected to county treasurer, and when he was elected, we had, someone had been there for a long time before and a very competent, very intelligent person, and it turned out that they wrote checks for the county. It took all day. They had a check-writing machine, but they only wrote one at a time. Well, we'd had technology to change that for 20 years. and but with no competition there was no reason to look for a better way to do it and as I have said in courts with relatives and with constituents and with those who needed my help and set their all blame day because nobody could tell us when our court document might come up as a manager I said there's got to be a better way to do this And so the idea that term limiting would cause it to work worse, I think is asinine. The idea that only bad lawyers would run, well, number one, being a bad lawyer doesn't mean you'd be a bad judge. Because one of the things that we know in our industry is that one of the worst mistakes that gets made is you promote good salesmen to be sales managers. And the fact that you are the best salesman in the country doesn't make you a good sales manager at all. And the fact that you're a good football player doesn't make you a good referee. But beyond that, the fact is that it wouldn't just be those that were bad lawyers that would run for these jobs because there is... The thing that I kept hearing is that, you know, that maybe what's being said is the executive branch is public service. The legislative branch is public service, but the judiciary is a career. Okay. I thought they were all public service. And this idea that there's no incentive to run, well, 16 years and you get retirement, you may not be able to get it right away, but after you turn 65, The 16 years, what you get on retirement is a pretty good steady income. That's a pretty good incentive if you didn't ever run for another judgeship for another four years. The idea that there's not other people, because judges aren't that much, attorneys aren't that much different from business people. A lot of us could have chose to do either one. Some of us, there's a lot of people who do both. and, you know, there's a whole lot of business people that aren't here doing what I'm doing and what Jimmy's doing and what Phil's doing and what Ron Caldwell's doing. You know, we're all business people because they can't afford to. And when I say they can't afford to, it's not, they might could buy and sell us, but they're making so much money out there, they think it'd be crazy to come do the public service to serve here. And so it's a choice. It's not whether you can or you can't, it's whether you decide to or not. And, you know, I'm in my peak earning years, but I chose, I ended up having to close one store because I couldn't keep two stores running and do this. And so instead of making more money and putting it back for my retirement and making and building my business, as these attorneys talked about, I'm here working for the people. And that's a choice that I made and I don't regret that, But that's a choice that people have to decide they make. And attorneys aren't different from business people. And I just wanted to point out that while the things they said are valid, there's more to it than that. And also, one of my dad's attorneys over the years was a former judge. And I want to tell you, former judges are in demand in the attorney field. So the idea that there's no career out there. But anyway, I wanted to reply to those things. Having said that, I have an amendment here that takes the judiciary out of the term limits because a great number of you have indicated that you would like to do that. I had a term limit. I had an amendment already the last time I was here to take judiciary out of the term limit. So it is entirely up to you. I believe that we do need to change term limits because we need to, it is up to, it is invested in us, this generation, this legislature, this session to protect good government in Arkansas and there is nowhere where good government is more important than the people's branch, the legislature, and if we don't do something and do it right, someone else is going to do it and do it terribly wrong. And so the most important thing is that we do the 12 years, that we do the four year set out so that But some, if they want to, I certainly don't want to come back. When I'm gone, I'll be gone. And I'm not, if I had the job done, I'd be gone now. I hope to get it, get the things done that we're working on and head back home and go back to my regular life. But the amendment's here to do what you want to with, and I'll be happy to do whatever the committee wants me to do. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 20:09
One thing that I, I mean, I think that I'm, I think as much as I think it'd probably be a good idea to leave the amendment in, or leave the judiciary in and not approve the I still think that that makes it a better resolution. I do also get that this committee, there's a lot of things we ought to be concerned about, and not the least of which is what's going to actually remain on the ballot. That's something that we have to be concerned about, which I hate, it's like the judiciary gets to decide what our resolution looks like, and then if they don't get to decide what the resolution looks like, they get to decide whether it's on the ballot or not. I mean, that's just the world that we're in. But it's still a reality that we have to deal with. One of the things that I'm a little bit concerned about is currently there's legislation that is in the House. I don't think they voted on it today. They'll vote on it tomorrow. That removes the 70-year-old threshold for the retirement, where they lose their retirement after 70. I don't know what's going to happen with that. But I do think the idea and the value of the term limits become way more important if the legislation is approved saying that there's no longer a cap at 70 years for the retirement. So, I mean, that's just an issue that I think this committee should consider when they're deciding whether or not they're going to adopt an amendment and where we're at in the process is, you know, are we going to do both? And if we do, is that really what we want as a body?
▶ Play
Speaker 61 21:44
Senator Higley, you're sounding. You were looking at it. Do you have a
▶ Play
move to pass over? Is there a second? Second. All in favor of the amendment, say aye. Aye. All opposed? Amendments passed. So that's part
▶ Play
of your bill. Okay, so the bill now says the judiciary's taken out. The section that said only the legislature can change, only the legislature can put term limits on the ballot is taken out, so it changes legislative term limits to 12 years. The Senate two years would count. It changes it from lifetime to successive, puts in a four-year waiting period, and as we know, it is almost exactly 5% that return after that four years. So it does, I think it's good government. It gives you, we're already having a 25% turnover, which is healthy. It brings in new blood, but it gives you time to have experience, and it gives the people the ability to re-elect someone in the future that they feel like they would really like to have back here, but we know from experience that it's a very small number. So it does all the right things for good government. And it irritates me for the people who talked about the ethics amendment being dishonest. I'll just say this for the record, it irritates me that they come back and say that this creates, that this is about creating lifetime politicians and that people can come back, that it's so people can come back over and over and over when you know that it's only 5%, that 95 out of 100 in the House will be serving 12 years or less, and that 33 out of 35 in the Senate will be serving 12 years or less total between the House and the Senate. It irritates me that the same people that talk about deception, being deceived, continue to be deceptive. But whatever time you decide to vote on this, I would appreciate this being your amendment, and I think it's the right one, and I appreciate you giving me time today.
▶ Play
Speaker 66 24:08
Senator Bond, you have a question?
▶ Play
Speaker 67 24:13
I think you have a question.
▶ Play
Pardon? Make a motion. I'll ask if there's anyone here that we should. Of course, we've spoken all day except for the amendment. So if there's anyone here who would wish to speak.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, I was just, so this morning we talked about not voting on these, that there was a process. Are we still going to follow? I thought we had a rule on it. I mean, I'm fine
▶ Play
Speaker 80 25:12
with whatever y'all want to do, but I will. Senator
▶ Play
Bond, we can vote as many as we want out of here. The process is, at what order they go to the floor. So we don't necessarily send them to the floor. We can vote this out, and then Senator Caldwell, myself, and Senator Ingram can choose
▶ Play
Speaker 89 25:35
to put it on the floor or not.
▶ Play
Thank you for the clarification. I appreciate it. Are you agreeable with that, Senator Pond? I mean, you know, I mean, you've been in on every conversation, so I just, yeah, fair enough. Take your name for the record and you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Chairman. My name is Tom Steele, Chairman of the Arkansas Tournament. I only wanted to reiterate there is a conflict within these two ballot titles. And if this thing gets popular names, if you guys pass this thing out of this committee without addressing that, I'm hoping that maybe that, I know we don't ask questions, but I'm hoping maybe you guys can elaborate on what's going to happen if we have two ballot issues, I mean two proposed constitutional on the ballot with the same popular name. So I only want to point out that you guys haven't addressed that. I came here primarily just to get that on the record. So I'm just curious whether or not you guys are going to do anything to address that problem because we're going to get to this point where we're going to have two, hopefully, we'll have both of these proposed amendments on the ballot. And it seems like now will be the time to address that. Thank you. Senator Sam? Never mind.
▶ Play
Okay. Okay, so we understand we're going to vote but not send it to the floor.
▶ Play
Speaker 97 27:02
Okay. Senator Teeke, you have a motion. If I move, do pass on
▶ Play
Mr. J.R. 15. Second. There's a second. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say no. Ayes have it. Congratulations. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. Members,
▶ Play
Speaker 102 27:25
the judge is seven years old. They all today. We've only got 36 votes. You had a bill. I've
▶ Play
Speaker 67 27:30
got two bills, I can run a little.
▶ Play
Speaker 89 27:32
Let's go. What bill? SB 4 is first. SB 4. SB 4? I think
▶ Play
it's a concurrent house amendment. SB 4 should be a concurrent house amendment. State's name for the record, you're recognized. Senator Trent Garner, South Arkansas. So passed this out a few weeks ago, it was a task force to be created about veteran suicide. It's a non-controversial bill in here, non-controversial bill in the Senate. Went to the House and made it through committee and then died on the floor for 50 votes, re-referred, and then had an amendment done to it. The contention was in the House that they didn't want to do task force. So they made it an interim study. I think they're going to create a new subcommittee to do that. I mean, I think the task force would be appropriate in this situation, but I think that I'm cognizant of the worry of cost of a task force on the house end. So rather than creating a fight when it comes to our veterans, I decided that this is probably the best course of action to move forward with this. That being said, I want to be stated publicly and with force that if any task force comes from the House, it will be met with a very extremely critical eye for me if that's the will of the House. So with that, I'll take any questions. Question from the committee? Senator Garner,
▶ Play
could you point out exactly what was changed from whenever it left out of here? Do you know exactly? Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Now, this wasn't my amendment, so I'm kind of going off what I can remember. Instead of being a task force, it will be a study, an interim study. You know, instead of creating a task force of members, it will be a subcommittee created, I believe, of the House Ag and then state agencies. So it will be a subcommittee of us created. Okay. Senator Flippo, you get a tardy slip?
▶ Play
your name was called no you have a question you have a question you closed for your bill I'm closed Mr. Pryor Anybody here who wishes to speak for or against the bill? Pleasure of the committee. Is that concurring? It's concurring, yes, sir. All in favor, say
▶ Play
aye. Aye. All opposed. Congratulations. I have SR3, which could take a little bit more time. It's up
▶ Play
to you. I can wait until Senator Filippo. We've got other folks here all day long. If we get late, then we can do it next week. Senator Filippo? what's
▶ Play
your bill number it's uh senate bill 409 mr chairman
▶ Play
Speaker 20 31:36
senate bill 409 yes sir everybody have time have we made any adjustments no
▶ Play
it's the same bill that we had last Thursday. We have an amendment. It was adopted in committee. But we adopted, we have
▶ Play
an amendment that we adopted last week, yes sir. Okay. All right. Attorney Hake, do you have the amendment? It should be that that we do it. Senator Flippo, you recognize if it was. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Adopted amendment, you can tell us what you changed.
▶ Play
Oh, we haven't changed anything since we adopted the amendment last Thursday. Okay, Thursday, I thought she'd left. Yeah, there's been no more amendments, Mr. Chairman. You just let me know when you'd like me to proceed. Anyone have any questions on this bill? Would you like to explain your bill again? Briefly, yes, sir. All right, members. So just real briefly, one of the hiccups that we had last weekend with the press is they wanted to see amendment from and change it from or to and, and I've opted not to do that, so we left the same language that was in there on Thursday is still in this bill that you're seeing today. So what this does is it leaves the options for the cities, counties, and schools that are for their electronic notification for an invitation for bids and the electronic submission of bids, that they have the option to do that online and not post that notification in the newspaper. The heart of this, in my opinion, and I'll just cut straight to the matter, is this is going to save the county's money, this is going to save the city's money, this is going to save the city's money, this is going to save the city's money, and thus it's going to save the taxpayers' money. Who it's going to cost money is going to be the press, especially print media. And I understand their objections to this bill. And if I'm in their position, I'd probably be up here speaking against it myself. My responsibility as a legislator is not to the media, it is to the taxpayers. And to make sure that they're getting the best bang for their buck. I think Senate Bill 409 does that. It's a good bill. I'd appreciate a good vote. I know there's going to be some questions, so I don't want to spend too much time rehashing what we talked about last week. But if there are any questions from committee members, I'm happy to answer them. And before I forget, I also have Mr. Ted Fleming here with Central Bidding. He was here last weekend. So if you have any questions for
▶ Play
Speaker 139 34:48
him as well. Okay. All right. Questions
▶ Play
from the committee? I just got one just as the... Yes, sir. I'm looking at the bill that we had the other day and I understand we have the amendment. Now is this language on page three, line 33 and 34, that's correct, is that right? By still being underlined? I thought we had decided that that is actually not new language.
▶ Play
So it's in different sections and I believe that's why it's underlined. I think there's another page, Senator, where it's not. So it was my understanding that as BLR was drafting this bill that because they split it up into different sections, that's why they had underlined it. That's why they had it as
▶ Play
new language. Fair enough, but the substance of that is, the substance of that is what's currently in the statute. Correct, yes, sir, yes, sir,
▶ Play
Speaker 143 35:43
that's correct. I just think that's important to point out. And I understand maybe the Bureau intended to underline it. I understand the question, and that is correct. Thank
▶ Play
you. Anyone else? Chair Clark. Just, and Senator Flipa, maybe for, not for your name, just shout out of my mind. I apologize. Mr. Fleming. So general practice has been to advertise in newspapers. My understanding is now they're bringing those up online also. If a county, state, or whoever goes to the online bid, how will the construction folks or whoever know where to go to look? How does that work? Chairman, members of Gritty, Ted Fleming,
▶ Play
Speaker 151 36:33
co-founder and COO of Central Bidding. There's a number of ways that can be done. One is that companies like mine notify vendors via what they call commodity codes. So we understand that it's important to notify people based on what it is that they're having interested in the state. We also work closely with the association of general contractors, people like that, to make sure they understand how to do it. We do training sessions around the state, not just me, but other entities that do the same thing we do. So we make sure that there is wide knowledge of where and how to get the information. and therefore it's bringing in more competition. One of the things about electronic bidding and everything you'll read from the National Association of State Procurement Officers to the National Institute of Government Purchasing says that electronic bidding results in an increased competition, which is one of the things that drive down pricing. It increases competition because we're notifying a lot more people through an electronic bidding process than you are through
▶ Play
a newspaper. So two follow-ups on that. The bill does not require a certain vendor, right? So your practice is one thing, so others. So do I have to have a membership to your site to see the bid, to see the bid documents?
▶ Play
Speaker 151 37:41
How does that work? Speaking specifically to mine, but you're right, there are a group of people who do the same thing we do, but specific to mine. You would become a member. Membership is at no charge to you. And if you join as a member, you're automatically notified of anything that's posted to our website in any of the states that we work in. So there's no charge for any of that process. And you're right, this is a complete option. If the cities, counties, and school boards want to continue using a newspaper, but there's nothing in here that says they can't do that. They could advertise them both. It just gives them the options. How does the site make money if it's all free? It's not all free. What happens is if a vendor determines that they want to download the bid specs and bid documents from us, that's where the fee is. So a vendor can see all the front-end documents, the advertisement, they can be notified of it, and they can place bids for free. What we charge for as a model of ours, plus we have plenty of competitors, is the actual bid documents. Right now, contractors pay for those bid documents from the architect engineering firms. what they would do is instead of buying it from them, they have another option, and it's, again, their option to buy them from us as well. So we're not changing what they pay for today.
▶ Play
It's just changing how they get it. Thank you. Any other questions? Okay. We have Robin Keene to come and speak for the bill. Ms. Keene, if you would turn your mic on, introduce yourself for the record, tell us
▶ Play
who you're with and you're recognized. Ms. Mr. Chairman and committee members, my name is Robin Keene and I'm with the Arkansas Association of Educational Administrators and I want to thank you for allowing me to speak in favor of Senate Bill 409 today. I do represent public school districts in Arkansas and we believe Senate Bill 409 creates the flexibility for school districts to be able to advertise for bidding through an electronic website, a secure website. This gives the school district the the option of advertising in the traditional method as well as a secure website. Any questions for
▶ Play
Ms. Keene? If not, thank you very much. Thank you. To speak against the bill, we have Lynn Hamilton and Ashley Wimberley. If y'all would please turn your mics on and introduce yourself for the record, you're recognized. I'm Len Hamilton, I'm President of the Arkansas
▶ Play
Speaker 186 40:57
Democrat Gazette. Ashley Wimberley, Executive Director of the Arkansas Press
▶ Play
Association. I'll go first and I think Ashley will follow me we really appreciate the time that you all allowed us to come back we appreciate the last four days that we've spent researching this and we spent most the last four days actually doing this because there's a lot behind this proposal this is not some simple little proposal that should be taken lightly. This will have major, far-reaching effects on people doing biddings. It'll have major, far-reaching effects on the people who are trying to learn about public notices. And, obviously, it'll have a far-reaching effect on the newspaper industry. We have 109 newspapers in Arkansas, and if this passes, becomes legislation, it will mean layoffs, more layoffs at newspapers. It will mean less public access, public access to printing bids, and it's not something that should be done simply and easily without just a whole lot of thought. It's not something that should be done in a closed process. proposed legislation has been developed in a closed manner. There's been no publicity about it. No one, various stakeholders were not privy to the ongoings. There was no public input. I'm not hearing that contractors sat down with Mr. Fleming or anyone else to learn about how much he charges and if If you notice, Mr. Fleming said, yes, that's how I make my money. I charge contractors, but you didn't hear how much he charges. If you all would not pass this legislation, we understand in the newspaper business that things on paper are moving to the web, and there's a right way to do that, and we don't object to that. if it truly benefits the public, but this doesn't. If there were an open process, a public study or a legislative study, then all stakeholders could be heard, and everyone would feel the comfort of knowing that you all are making a good decision. I'm a novice at this. The last few days is the only time in my life I've ever been here talking to legislatures and being involved in the way a bill is produced. And I admire the stamina that you all have. I applaud you for the job you're doing. I know you're looking at hundreds of bills, and you have to look at them quickly. Please don't look at this one quickly. Please back this up, and if we're going to move everything off the newspapers and put them on a website, starting with this, think about it and do it really well for the public. I'm asking, you know, forget newspapers for a minute. And this is for the public, and this bill is not good for the public in Arkansas. It's not good for our Kansans. It's not good for Arkansas businesses. There's so many things that are left out of this bill. This bill has no minimum standards of any kind regarding security. How do we know that bid's submitted to any website? And this bill does allow any website. Somebody can create a website in its bedroom, and some state agency can decide that I'll use that website. How do we know there's any security for the bids? How do we know that website's going to be up? When, you know, the law, the new law, the bill says, well, it has to be posted on a website for a week. You all know websites crash. How do we know? What guarantee is there that can be said, it can be written into law, But this doesn't do it because it's been a really quick, simple process that does not benefit the people of Arkansas. There is someone who benefits, but it's not the people of Arkansas. There are no standards, no limits on performance, no limits on cost. This is carte blanche for Mr. Fleming and people like him. There's absolutely no requirement here for limiting cost or setting boundaries of any kind. If we build multiple sites, and that's what this bill allows, Ms. King from the School Boards Association says, yeah, this is great for us. We'll get to put it on a website. The school boards can go use any website they want. So can the counties. So can the cities. One city can choose one website and another one can choose another. How will the public ever know where the notices are? And you all ask Mr. Fleming, well, you know, how did, I think Senator Bond asked Mr. Fleming, how are you going to get the word out? And he said something that I didn't understand. How is it possible that every citizen in Arkansas and every contractor in Arkansas is going to know about Mr. Fleming's website? It makes no sense. It truly doesn't. We don't know. And if there's not just one website, if it's not just Mr. Fleming's website, How do we know that every one of these websites will be run by scrupulous people? We don't. And there's no security requirements of any kind in this bill. Mr. Fleming's role in this has not been very well defined. I haven't heard yet said why he's here. How did he get here? Thursday when we all last met, we walked out of this room. I met Mr. Fleming for the first time. And he told me he's been in Arkansas for the last two months working with these agencies. This has been set up for two months, folks. And Mr. Fleming, he's a sharp guy. I mean, I like him personally from what little I know. He makes a really good first impression. He's incredibly hardworking if he's been here for two months working with these agencies. And he said just a few minutes ago, well, this law doesn't require people to work with my software company, but he's got a two-month head start. How was Mr. Fleming selected for this head start? Please don't do this. Please don't rush it. And if we do need one vendor, let's do it in a process that's open to the public. and let's do it on a public website. Why do we want to give all of this Arkansas business from all of these contractors, the Arkansas contractors he's going to charge money to, why do we want to give that to a private Louisiana company? How does that make sense? If we do a study where all stakeholders are involved and we create an official public site, everyone in Arkansas will know where to find it. All the bidders will know. So it won't be hard to get the word out, but if we end up with one private site in Louisiana taking money from us, what guarantee do we have that they'll do anything in the way of promoting this site, ensuring security? We have no guarantee. This bill provides nothing. If we create a public site, if that's what you want to do and take everything away from newspapers, let's do it right. Let's create a site where the public will really know what's going on, vendors will know what's going on, and let's do a bidding process for the vendor. We have Arkansas software companies who are way behind on this race to get the money from these state agencies. I don't understand how that even makes business sense for any of us. There are no clear winners here. Let's talk about pricing for just a minute. We gave you all lots of material, and we emailed it to you, and Ashley and I came up with literally two dozen bullet points on why this is a bad idea, and we're not going to go over all 24 of those bullet points here in this meeting, but I've got it all here if you want to see it, and for some reason you haven't. But I went out to Mr. Fleming's website, and when I met with him, Like I said, he's a really great guy, and he offered Thursday to give me a username and password so I could fully explore his website. Well, Friday came, and that didn't show up. I gave him my business card so he could send it to me. That didn't show up. So Friday, I called Mr. Fleming's number. He gave me his business card, real cordial. I called his business phone number, and I got a voice message, and I said, Mr. Fleming had promised me a username and password so I could really explore his website. Please have him contact me with that. I can get a response to my phone call. Sent Mr. Fleming an email. Please give me a username and password so I can explore your website. Have any of you all looked at his website? Has anybody looked at his website other than the people who are proposing this legislation? It has well over 100 pages. Mr. Fleming has a business that is called Central Auction House. It's multiple businesses, and this whole bidding process is one little part of it. I don't know if you looked in your material, but here's a screenshot from his website. You heard him say it cost nothing. I went on his website as somebody who would be a potential contractor who knew nothing about Mr. Fleming, but I've got his website. And so I found all these bids from a few agencies in Louisiana and Mississippi, and that's where he is. and no other states that I could find on his website. And he does business with different local agencies, not the entire, all the agencies, and not the state government, as I could tell, at least not all the state. But so anyhow, I clicked on one of the construction jobs like I'm a bidder. This is the page that came up. Mr. Fleming's website offers me the opportunity for a six-month membership at a price of $499. If I'm one little Arkansas contractor, first thing I see is a six-month membership for $500 before I can even see the information on the bids. Or I have an option actually of a 12-month membership, and that's $700 to me. So let's say we set this up, and he sells these memberships. And there's nothing on there, by the way. If you come on as an individual who knows nothing about his website, there's nothing on there that says there's some kind of free option. Mr. Fleming told me Friday that actually bidders only have to pay $49. That's what he told me out in the hallway. Now, he didn't say anything about this option that's on his website, and he didn't tell you all anything about it. So let's say I'm a bidder, though, and I pay the $500 or the $700 a year for his membership so I can submit a bid on an Arkansas construction project, and I win the bid. So what am I going to do? I'm going to take that $700, I'm going to build it into my cost, and city government's going to pay me back my $700. That $700 is more expensive than an ad in a newspaper, folks. Now, let's say there are 10 bidders in Arkansas that decide that, well, I've got to sign up on the membership because I've heard nothing about anything free or nothing about anything $49. All I've done is come to this website, and I lose the bid, and I'm one in nine who lose the bid, and we've each paid $500 or $700. Mr. Fleming has just made $3,000 to $5,000 on us. That doesn't make sense. These bidders now don't pay anything in many cases to get what the information they need, and the public knows everything that's going on. The public in Arkansas will know nothing, and the bidders will be out with lots of money. Arkansas people don't win here. The Arkansas contractors don't win. Contractors. I almost forgot. I wanted you to hear this. We've, in the last two days, really, I've contacted my contractor friends, and I said, would you come testify? Help us with this. The contractors I talked to told me they couldn't come testify. The small contractors say, if we testify publicly against these agencies, it won't be good for us. We'll be hurt in the future. They were fearful to come testify to you. These are small contractors, and I understood that, and I couldn't ask them to jeopardize their business. But we did talk to one large contractor. You all are familiar with Naviholtz contracting. You may know Brad Heshrman. He's the COO, Chief Operating Officer at Naviholtz. And he said he couldn't be here today, and I wasn't going to ask him to come at 10 o'clock this morning and sit here all day long. Mr. Hedgeman just simply couldn't do it. But he gave me something to read to you. He said, quote, I see no value or public benefit in this legislation. The current process works fine and serves the taxpayers well, so why make changes to a proven system? We do not support this bill, end quote. The contractors lose in this. It costs them a lot of money. The public loses. The cities end up paying just as much or more because the money that they would have spent on legal notices and newspapers comes back. The only clear winner in this is a Louisiana software company or some other little software company that did not go through a formal bidding process become the big winner. That's all I have. Thank you very much. I hope you'll vote against this legislation and I'm telling you that as a citizen, this is bad for Arkansas. Forget newspapers. Senator Tappel? You have a question? My question. Okay. You're right. Good. Thank you. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 183 56:01
Chair. I've heard the word efficiency over and
▶ Play
Speaker 186 56:09
over again today, But I want to remind everyone the key word should be transparency. If we're in a transition here You don't say you don't look at what some of the constituents we read and what did these constituent Constituents read if you're in a transition you run in both That's how most people see notices is some may look at a website some read newspapers So you do both that is what every other state is doing and the other in the other states where mr Fleming is operating there was no legislation needed for him to operate the newspapers handled the front end he makes his money on the back end. There's no legislation needed for him to make his $49 or $700 or $500, whatever it is. So the key word here is transparency. We understand at the Press Association there is a transition, and that's why we were proactive several years ago when we already created this website where we have our newspapers upload the public notices, and they're free. So why in the world as a state would we send someone to a private website to pay for notices that are already free on a website that we provide in our state. That makes no sense to market that. That's added value when you run in newspapers. It's not a question of newspapers or websites. It's both. The key word here is transparency. I understand it's easier for the government agencies. I do. It's less costly. I understand that, too. But what I think what we really need to do to serve the taxpayers is be transparent. Don't put the burden on them. to go to all these you know hundreds possibly hundreds of websites you have no idea if you've missed a bid it'd be like my kids call and say mom where are you going to leave the house key and i'm going to say one of a hundred places you know just find it we don't you don't operate that way so um again if the only measure is efficiency we can just pack them on the door somewhere if the key is transparency they're not contractor notices they're public notices so all of the public can see these notices. So you want to put them in the most, you know, on websites and in newspapers. And again, Mr. Fleming doesn't need any kind of legislation to operate in the way that he's operating in Louisiana and Mississippi. Why is Arkansas different? Why is he taking over the entire process in Arkansas first when he's done that nowhere else in the state or in the country. Excuse me. So again, this is bad legislation. Again, Lynn said, put aside newspapers. The key for, the reason for public notices is to simply be transparent. So we hope you'll vote no on this today. We just, we don't understand it and we simply don't think it's smart to take the approach of going to one Louisiana vendor. There's one Louisiana company represented on one side of this argument. I'm here representing 109 Arkansas small businesses. Thank you.
▶ Play
How much money does the Arkansas Democrat Gazette make from this bidding process, from
▶ Play
having to put the notices up there? I don't know the total amount of money we make, but I can tell you how much a notice costs, Senator Garner. A legal notice in the Arkansas Democrat that covers the entire state is probably more expensive than any of the little other smaller newspapers in Arkansas. It's about $22 an inch, so if you run a 10-inch legal notice, that's $220.
▶ Play
And you can't give a ballpark of the estimated revenue that you get from these?
▶ Play
I don't have that off the top of my
▶ Play
head, no, sir. And under current law, it's required that they be listed in the newspaper, is that
▶ Play
Speaker 186 59:44
correct? Yes, I believe it is, yeah. Let me correct that. It's actually newspapers or a construction trade
▶ Play
journal. Thank you. Or the trade journals. She's right, yes. That's right. It's about either or. Yeah. The county or state agencies right now are required by law to either put it in the paper or into these trade journals, I guess, for lack of a better term. They have no other options. As far as I know.
▶ Play
Speaker 186 1:00:03
Well, they can view them on the press association website for free, and we have people who do that. They're not required to have a subscription to any Arkansas newspaper to read the notices on our website. You're saying
▶ Play
Speaker 199 1:00:16
to run, yeah. That's correct. You have to pay to run it, correct? That's correct.
▶ Play
I think a key point here, and I mentioned it and what I was saying, I don't want it to get lost, is that the winning contractors will take the cost they're paying to Mr. Fleming or whoever the website owner is, they'll send it right back to the city, that's $600, $500 cost, whatever it is, is about twice what they had been cost in a newspaper. Thank you, but there's no,
▶ Play
you're basing a price point on one company. I understand he came here to talk. The way the law reads, it can be any company, and the counties can make that decision themselves. So this will instantly become a competitive bid, and if I think if I'm a county and you come there and say a $700 entry fee, I would immediately reject that bid to go to somebody else. I mean, we obviously understand people can make money, but if the thought that counties are going to make sweetheart deals where you have to pay $700 to get bidden, I mean, the reality of that is, I don't think that'll fly on Arkansas. I think the competitive forces will force that
▶ Play
to not happen. Senator Garner, I think you're right. In so many cases, people are honorable, but the problem is with this legislation is it doesn't protect us against the dishonorable people. There's no guarantee that anyone has to do anything. There are no standards in this legislation.
▶ Play
Speaker 186 1:01:43
Thank you, Mr. Chair. One thing I did wanted to mention is several other state press associations have websites as well where they have their newspapers upload the notices. And in 13 states, the legislature has made that a law that the newspapers have to upload the notices. So it's comprehensive. And we work to keep it comprehensive all the time. But I would be absolutely fine with the Arkansas Press Association being the public site for public notices in Arkansas as added value for newspapers. And making that a law would make our members know how important it is to upload those notices as well. So in 13 states, that has been the solution to this problem.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 1:02:22
Senator Ballinger. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I mean, I don't know anything about this vendor, so I can't argue that he's honorable or dishonorable. I can't either. My guess is that he will probably, the vendors who take part in this, they'll probably be a fairly cross-section of society. They'll probably be honorable ones and dishonorable ones. That'd be what I guess. But would you say that when we talk about, dealing with local press, that's probably the case with them as well, when you say there's probably honorable ones and dishonorable ones. Senator Ballinger, people
▶ Play
are human beings no matter what their job is, but the way the current law works is there's an affidavit process, there's a proof of publication process, and this bill doesn't address any of that. There are no safeguards in this bill, and there's multiple safeguards built into the present. And there are also regulations on our pricing,
▶ Play
Speaker 186 1:03:08
which there are no regulations on the pricing for the website in this bill. Sure, but the regulation, the
▶ Play
Speaker 54 1:03:13
pricing, I would say is probably going to be the market. The county, I mean, the value of this is going to be because it's cheaper, and if they, on the back end, are pricing it out, I mean, all that will have to be worked into the bid process. I think, like Senator Garner says, the competition's going to make it where they have to be competitive. I think the affidavit process, all that, I mean, each, you know, I think the code section actually requires that information to be provided. I mean, I think in the end, what you'll have is a question of competition between internet provider, whoever that is, not internet provider, but the person who's providing the publication on the internet versus the local paper. And I'd say a lot of counties, they may want to help subsidize their local paper. They may want to continue to spend that money locally in order to prop up their paper. That may be great. But I think the point that I'm trying to get to is, I get that there could be some concerns. I do feel like this process is, this is how you make laws, right? This is what we're doing. this is open. Anybody in the state of Arkansas has a right to be here. I mean, I think it is public. And frankly, that's a big risk for this guy to come in and put this together because he's going to immediately have competition that's going to all the work that he's laid into helping get this bill up. He's going to be competitive. And if he isn't, you know, if he's a jerk, then he's not going to get any of the business. So, but I think that my point, you know, in asking a question and I hate to belabor it, is same thing. You know, I think that there probably are people out there, local papers, you know, people in the press or trade general who are not, they're not scrupulous, probably Internet. My hope is local counties and all that. I mean, you would say that'll be their job to decide, you know, who is the, who are the right people to do business
▶ Play
with, right? Senator Ballinger, one point is market forces are at work right now in newspaper processing, pricing, and that is because the current law, the current state law, says that we cannot charge more than our classified advertising rates for a legal ad, and classified advertising rates have crashed because of all kinds of competition for classified ads. There aren't many in the newspapers. We can't charge almost anything. We're limited. The market forces have limited us to a very low rate. That's just simply the truth.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 1:05:40
And you may feel like that's a low rate. I'll tell you, my clients don't feel like that's a low rate. When we have to, I mean, when I pay out $600 to give someone a notification of a quiet title action or something, that's not, that isn't, I mean, they don't feel like that's cheap. But I get the fact that you all, you're trying to make it in a change in industry. I totally get that. But in the end, all of us is providing one more mechanism for ultimately it'll be counties and
▶ Play
cities to make that decision. A final point that I'll make on this topic is that if you allow market forces to determine which website is gonna handle your public notices in Conway and a different one in Greenbrier and a different one in Damascus, how in the world are the bidders ever gonna know where to go? How's the public gonna know where to look?
▶ Play
Speaker 186 1:06:38
This is a flawed process. I have not heard of another single state who would push their public notices to a private website. I have not heard of that. I've also not heard of a system where there was a bill so loosely written that it would just give hundreds of options on websites. In New Jersey
▶ Play
or wherever. Anywhere, yeah. or some kid's bedroom. I mean, it just, it makes, it's just terrible legislation for the people of Arkansas, I'm sorry. I hope your minds are open to this and I know you all have thought a lot about it and you have a lot of other bills to think about, but if you will, if you will please slow this down and study it, you'll realize how horrible this is for the people of Arkansas. Any other questions? Okay, thank you very much. Thank you, sir. Jason Carter. Four. The next three will be four. If you would please introduce yourself, who you're with and
▶ Play
you're recognized. My name's Jason Carter, I'm with the Arkansas Municipal League and I just wanted to take a minute and thank Senator Filippo for bringing this bill and thank you Mr. Chairman and members of the committee to be able to speak about it. There's a few points I want to talk to but to be brief, they are cost, fair competition, accuracy, and the speed and responsiveness in which we can engage in business in local government. I speak to you from my experience as a city attorney. I was a city attorney for more than 10 years. And also, I was a general manager for our electric utility in North Little Rock. So I did that for two and a half years. So I'm pretty familiar with the procurement process and I think I could address any questions you may have about that. Pardon me. Regarding cost, I'd ask you to, you know, draw your attention to the fact that this is an option. You know, I think someone mentioned earlier that we have a duty of stewardship to the people that we represent. And to the extent that we can reduce cost and still have transparency and still have fair competition, we should do that. And I don't know whether web-based bidding is going to reduce our cost or not. I don't know that that's gonna satisfy the need that we have, but it might. And I think that it's worthy to have that option on the table to explore it. Honestly, among all of my concerns about web-based bidding or my thoughts about it, cost is probably my least concern. My greater concerns are about fair competition, accuracy in the bidding process, and the speed and responsiveness in which we serve our community. I believe we need strong and fair competition among bidders to get a good price and product for our citizens. Right now, when we run bidding processes, we typically reach out to contractors and call them to make sure that they know that there is a bid invitation in the newspaper. And that's one of the methods that we use to try to make sure that we get responsive bids and to projects that we bid out. As far as accuracy, I believe that automated systems tend to reduce human error, and I think that's important in a bidding process, to have good communication between government and bidders. And last, as to the speed and responsiveness of the government, if we are to maintain public trust, we've gotta be able to respond in a timely fashion to the needs that are expressed by our citizens. and timely these days has gotten very time compressed, the time in which we're expected to respond. Right now when we do notices in the newspaper for bidding, our projects are driven by the publication schedule of the paper. So Democrat Gazette has a daily, at least locally has daily publications, but then many newspapers are weekly publications and then you have to back up and say, well when do I have to have it to the paper in order to make it into the paper and then it's got to run for its two week period. If there is an error in that advertisement that sets you back a whole week in the process about trying to be timely and get bids in. So it seems that a web-based process would move faster. I know that we've had a lot of conversation here today about a particular web-based provider. I can't really address any of that. We haven't explored that option because that option's never been available to us. So I can't speak to what may or may not be out there about options to have web-based bidding versus newspaper publications for bids. But we would like to have that option if at all possible
▶ Play
and that's why I'd ask you to support this bill. I come in here kind of open about this, but I got some questions. How does this not limit the number of bidders? And I heard what you said and I tried to listen close and you mentioned you want strong and fair competition. You told me that, or you told us that you call, you know, the bidders to tell them it's in the paper. However, whenever it is in the paper, it is out there to the public and it's not limited to just the ones that you called. How can you guarantee me, and these other people that were at the table, I apologize, I don't even know your names, but anyway, they had brought up some points that if there is a bunch of websites out there, how
▶ Play
is the public gonna know that? That's what I'm interested in. So, and let me just make sure I understand your question, Senator Hickey, is how will a contractor know to look for the website to where they can go go and be notified about when a bid invitation goes out and so that they can respond to it. Is
▶ Play
that your? Well, I think it is. If you'll try to answer that, I'm going to add on to it, so I'm not going to limit that.
▶ Play
That's fair. Thank you. Obviously, as I stated earlier, we try to reach out to our contractors to make sure that they're aware when we have bids going out. We have more direct communication where we have an idea about who is bidding, but I think as a city, it would be incumbent upon us to publicize that information. It would be in our interest to do so, to make sure that that information is as widespread as possible. Where would you publish that? I may publish it in the newspaper. We could Publish it in whatever manner we think that is widestly available. You're going to get a standing
▶ Play
ovation on that. What, you know, and I guess, you know, in looking at this, and I like this gentleman's thought and the way that he's doing it, but these people have brought up some good points. Because, and I have, and here's the thing, I've got my cities and my county judges and they've all jumped on, but I'm not down here to do stuff unless I think it's really the right thing. So the way I'm looking at it is you call Sample Hickey, we've both got a different construction company, and say we're putting this out, it's on this website. But it's how does Joe Q Public, Mr. Ballinger over there, if you didn't call him, how does he know it's on that website? And I am struggling with that transparency part of this. So I need to
▶ Play
get comfortable somewhere or somehow. We communicate with our citizens in a variety of manner. I mean, some of it is
▶ Play
through. Let me interrupt and ask you what keeps you from communicating with your specified or your preferred citizens and not your unpreferred citizens. That's what I can't get a grasp on. I think that would be unfair competition for us to do that. Well, but that happens every day. You know, I don't mean it ugly, but, I mean, we would never be the wiser on that if you call your preferred bidders and you didn't call your unpreferred bidders when it's still
▶ Play
Speaker 59 1:15:32
a public bid. And, Senator Caldwell, I
▶ Play
would say that I don't think that that changes, whether it's in the newspaper or on the website. I think that same issue would... Well, the newspaper
▶ Play
is published. They all can read it. But if you're not... There again, let's go back to the website. If your unpreferred bidders don't buy a subscription to your website, then they don't have access to that
▶ Play
Speaker 59 1:15:57
information. or am I missing a point here? And I can't speak
▶ Play
to how vendors would operate. My response to that would be that we would only use a system that allowed full and fair competition. That's the only type of site that should be used. For $700 a year. I can't speak to what a vendor may charge or may not charge. but you know we like the opportunity to be able to advertise for bids on our own website you know and for for people to see that kind of information for having a bid tracking system that may be something that we would use
▶ Play
a vendor for. Okay. For the moment anybody else? Fair enough. Thank you. I appreciate it, and I'm not getting on you. I still don't see where the public broadcast of requests for bid is out there when you have a private website that you have to pay $700 a year to access. I don't understand. And then when you're advertising for public bid, then, you know, we... Could I respond to that? Absolutely, I'm not here to prove
▶ Play
Speaker 224 1:17:18
you right or wrong. We're trying to solve problems. Thank you, and I would ask you to consider this,
▶ Play
is that our local elected officials, they're not potted plants. They serve the people, and they're there to have a transparent and competitive process. They deal with contractors who want to be treated fairly. I think what the request is in this bill is to give an option to those leaders that if they want to be able to use a web process, if they thought that worked best for their community, to let them do it, to let them try that process rather than have that prohibited. And there was, I think, some comment at the table before about perhaps we'd use a website and newspaper advertising at the same time. I don't see how this bill prohibits that for a community that thinks that that's in their best interest. I think that would be something that they could do if they chose to do it. We just ask for the flexibility. Senator Sample. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 230 1:18:27
you. I was just saying a while ago, and let me say this.
▶ Play
Say I had a website, and I wasn't a very scrupulous person. Senator Caldwell bid on the job, but Senator Hickey is my friend, and he's going to bid on the job. Senator Hickey might keep me a little bit of money back, and so I would know what Senator Caldwell's bid is, and so I just take and give Senator Hickey what Senator Caldwell's bid is. I mean, how are you going to prevent that? Because it looks awfully open-ended to
▶ Play
me. Well, and I appreciate the concern, Senator Sample, because we have to have integrity in any kind of bidding process. And if there's not integrity in the process, we can't get bidders, and people won't participate in a process that they don't believe that there's integrity in. Go ahead. you alluded a while ago
▶ Play
that you like to put your bids on your website. So why do you need another website when all of your contractors know to look on your website and find the jobs that's available? Why do you need to pay $700 or $800 a year? Why would I need to pay that much? Because I could go to your website and not have to pay that That sounds
▶ Play
like a fair question, Senator Sample, and I don't know that we would necessarily have to have a contractor to do that. If we're confident in advertising with our own website, we would probably require some assistance. But I just don't see the point in this when you can do it yourself, and you already have
▶ Play
that means. but we, I don't believe we do, Senator. I think it's in the,
▶ Play
Senator Hirster. I may be wrong, but as a contractor, I'm pretty sure that when they get on this site, they also get access to the plans and the bid specifications. Is that not
▶ Play
accurate? I believe that that's the way I heard the testimony earlier. And so as a contractor,
▶ Play
if I go to bid anywhere, if I don't go here, that I have to go somewhere else and I have to put a deposit down or I have to buy those plans. That's a cost, whether I get the job or not, for every contractor. As part of this, you get access to those plans and bid docs and specifications. That's something that you, as a governmental body, probably wouldn't have access to or you had to buy them or get them from your, and you would have to host those and provide them out. I think that's, I'm sure we'll hear more of that later. Anyway, I just hear a lot about it. just being a website, but it's access to the plans and bid docs.
▶ Play
Anyone else? Nope. Thank you very much. Appreciate your testimony. Thank you. I wanna ask, you got Lindsey Bailey, in Savannah Watt, Association of Arkansas Counties and Arkansas County Judges. if you would please uh introduce yourself for the record and then you're recognized
▶ Play
Lindsay Bailey, Association of Arkansas Counties. Susanna Watt,
▶ Play
Speaker 248 1:22:40
Arkansas County Judges Association. The reason that I'm here today is on, the County Judges Association supports this legislation and we had been brought concerns that possibly only a specific vendor would be able to apply for this. So we have a handout for you guys. I don't know if you've already received it. Okay, you already have it in front of you that lists specific, just a few vendors. There could be more that would be eligible to apply for bidding in Arkansas under this legislation. This
▶ Play
Speaker 252 1:23:17
legislation isn't specific to any particular vendor. Okay, I'll pick up from
▶ Play
there. This was not an AAC package bill, but the Association of Counties does support it as well as the county judges. Senator Flippo and Representative Wardlaw have done an extensive study over state and local procurement practices during the interim, and I think this was something that they came out with that made a lot of sense. From what I understand, this isn't something new. I think the highway RDOT has been doing this for about close to 10 years now, and in fact, I think now for RDOT, this is mandatory. I don't think they accept paper bids any longer at all. So this is not a new process, and it's something that the state is already using. There would be three steps to this process when the integrity, when the transparency is brought up. As you all know, your county judges and quorum courts are elected officials just like you are. For this to take place in a county, first it's optional. The county doesn't have to do this. It's something that they can decide that they want to do if it's in the interest of the county and its constituents. If the county judge wanted to do this, I imagine they would send out an RFP and get feedback on that. The big hurdle then that they would have to jump is the quorum court. And I know you all are stewards of the state money. The quorum court is the stewards of the county money. And I dare not even say that they're a little tighter with it than even you all are. So if this is something that is not going to be a cost benefit to the county, I do not see any way a quorum court would ever appropriate for it. And that, of course, would also lead to competitiveness among the vendors that Susanna mentioned. I think the, let's see, $220 per square inch for advertising in a paper was mentioned. I will say if that is over $50,000, that has to be done twice, two different weeks. During the transition period, a county could, and if they wanted, if they got the feedback from their constituents, they certainly could do both. In the first six months or a year that they started doing this, they could also run the ads in the paper. There's nothing that prevents that if they chose to do so, and if that would make the public more comfortable. also if this is a chosen option for the county I read in the bill that for contractors it is optional that if they choose this option they still have to accept bids in paper form if the if the contractor chooses to submit their bid that way and those were just a few points I wanted to put out there and I will not belabor the the point Thank you, this
▶ Play
might seem unrelated, but let me just give me a little add to you. So last session we had a bill dealing with notice of mental rights, that made the Arkansas Association of County support it, and whenever that happened, we heard from newspapers in our district and otherwise, it said to me this will hurt the people of Arkansas, they won't be able to find their mental rights when they're delinquent, all this stuff. That was moved to a website, I believe, to Arkansas County Control. Since that happened and that became lull, I have not heard one single complaint on that issue. And it seems like it's working absolutely fine. Have you heard anything about that? Because some of those same concerns we're hearing today, even though this is a separate thing because you have the bidding process. With that bill, have you heard anything related since it's similar in the nature that required notice and we changed
▶ Play
that to a website? Yes, I believe you're referring to ArkansasTransparency.gov. We've heard no complaints. We've heard nothing but good things. We didn't have any problems getting the information from our county people, and it's been a smooth process.
▶ Play
Thank you. Senator Hickey? Same question I asked, I guess that was the Municipal League that was up here. How are we not gonna limit, how are we not gonna limit the number of bidders, the number of people that look at this? and I heard somebody up here bring up the Arkansas Department of Transportation. I don't even see how that relates. Everybody out here knows that if they're gonna be putting out these construction projects, you can be assured that people that are doing road jobs that are multi-million, they're tying in directly with their website. But what we've got here, and I can use whoever, I can use ABC School District. If we allow ABC school district to go out and the way the bill's written, the way that I'm reading it here is it says that they can pick where they want to put it because it says, wherever it was, that they can select the website they want to put it on. So they can put it on any website in the world. How, how is that transparent? How, and these other people brought that up. How, how do people know to go to look for that? Let's just say that they won't turf on a football field. I don't care what we say. But in your public school system, and they put it on that website, and then they call three or four of their buddies and say, hey, we put this thing on that website, You all bid on it. How does another person that is in another state that may do it for 60% of the cost, how do they know to go to that website before it expires so that they could bid on it? The transparency is what I want you all to sell that to me. I mean, you're here wanting something like this, but I want to make sure, because here's the thing. Yeah, the cities and counties, we're talking about they're not going to have to put the money up for the for the advertisement. But in all actuality, the ones that are going to be trying to pull up the bid, they're the ones that's going to be putting the money. But in addition to that, we possibly could limit the number of bidders out there, which was going to make the cost could go up astronomically. So I'm just, I am struggling big time with this part. So I need
▶ Play
somebody to to make me feel better. Sure, Senator Hickey, and I think your question actually lends to the answer. Going back to what is required right now, a couple of publications in a local newspaper that may run in one county or a large portion of one county, that's not reaching those people out of state that you're
▶ Play
talking about. A hundred years of history has proven that they understand the process today where on a new undefined website, they won't understand the process. Sure. I think that's the point that
▶ Play
Senator Hickey makes. So we have open school board, city council, and quorum court meetings. They love to go to local civics clubs and share their new ideas. They have county websites. They have county judge social media pages. They go on their local TV stations. And I know it was laughed at, but yes, they would probably put something in the newspaper to this effect saying what they would be doing. Thank you, ma'am.
▶ Play
You want in? Question? Turn your mic. Statement, I guess. I mean, I served on the rest of the school board for nine years, and we had to put bids out for everything and run it in the paper, and there's all these requirements around the time and how to do it and stuff like that. I mean, I think, too, that just to make a point, not to necessarily be on one side or the other on this, but I think a lot of vendors also have things like Google alerts and stuff like that. I mean, we had people who get email alerts anytime something pops up online that is some type of bid that would be something for their business. And so, I mean, I got calls a lot just as a school board member, and we saw people participate in the process that way. So, I mean, I just wanted to say that because, you know, it's not that they're just randomly searching, you know, guessing what websites could be out there. It's that a lot of these vendors and even large vendors, they're going to be getting Google Alerts or something like that to their email to notify them that there
▶ Play
are projects for them to bid on. That's correct. And I would say just one more thing that I forgot to mention. Any website that we use, any process or vendor association, it will be subject to leg audit. so any kind of unscrupulous activities that you all mentioned, that would be subject to leg audit and they would be looking at that. They, leg audit audits every portion of
▶ Play
that process. Yeah, yes sir. Yes ma'am and I chaired that for four years and I promise you they are circumventing the current bid process in every way, shape or fashion. Whenever we allow them, whenever we allow them the option to possibly be able to just go to put it on a website and that not be transparent, they could say, well, I complied with the law. So I don't know that that's going to be a good argument at all. And I'm not being disrespectful to you. I'm just, the more I've looked at this, the more concerns
▶ Play
I've got. No disrespect taken. And I think with everything, it is a transition. And once it's in place, I think that the vendors and the public will be used to it and we'll know
▶ Play
where to go, and it'll be fine. Thank
▶ Play
you. Do you have a question? No? Well, I was looking for that part in the bill that said that leg audit would be audited in this process.
▶ Play
Speaker 171 1:33:40
Yeah. Ask it again. Ask your question again.
▶ Play
Where does it say in this bill that Leg Audit will be auditing this process? Because I've looked this bill over it. So many times I don't know exactly what's written in it. I haven't seen that. That would just be a part of
▶ Play
the general audit of the county judge's office. I'm like Senator Hickey.
▶ Play
I've sat on Leg Audit for many years. it's caused me to be very skeptical about anything like that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Question? Thank you all very much. Senator
▶ Play
Flippo, would you like to come close for your bill?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, members. I know it's been a long day for everybody, so I will be brief with my remarks. You know, two things that I heard here were transparency, and I guess that's where I'll start off with, is I think with any new process, there's the possibility that there will be kinks in a system. I don't know that, for me personally, That's a reason enough not to move forward with something. I cannot, in my right mind, imagine how the counties, the cities, the schools are going to benefit if they have a diluted bidding process that leads to fewer contractors bidding on these projects. I would agree with Senator Hickey's comment. There's a good likelihood that's going to drive up the cost. Senator Hickey, we sat on that procurement study together for almost a year and a half. Our purpose is not to cost the taxpayers of this state more money. It's to save money. You raised good questions. Other members of this committee did too. I'm glad I wasn't up here because I don't know that I could have answered every one of them. But what I do know is that the sky is not going to fall. Our construction costs are not going to be inflated and shoot through the roof if we pass this bill today. Secondly, I heard Mr. Hamilton and Mr. Wimbley talk about, you know, they just really emphasized, this does not benefit the state of Arkansas whatsoever. And I just completely disagree with that. This is not mandating that counties, cities, or schools, or any other state entity, you know, use the bidding, online bidding process. It merely gives them the option. It merely gives them the option. If they decide to advertise in the newspaper to do it online, they can do those concurrently together. There's nothing in theirs that's going to prohibit them. Ms. Wimberly said that she's looking out for 109 small businesses here and I assume that means newspapers ladies and gentlemen I do not pay taxes so other people can have jobs I am empathetic with any industry that's going through difficult times I'm a small business owner myself in rural Marion County I have a small assisted living facility, don't take Medicaid Medicare, private pay private insurance, let me tell you it's tough and taxpayers aren't coming to bail out me when I go through tough times. The way that we get our news is changing, or the way people consume the news is changing, our bidding process is changing, and we got to change with it. I understand that there's been comments here that says, you know, that the way that this bill is written, we're going to be the first state in the country to have done it this way. I say good. It's about time Arkansas is first than something. We might as well be blazing the trail and saving the taxpayers' money and streamlining our procurement process. And members, I know that you all have had time to digest the information here. I don't think anything else I'm gonna say is gonna make any kind of a difference. I will just tell you this, I think it's a good bill
▶ Play
and I would appreciate a good vote. Players, committee? Motion to pass. Motion to pass, a second. As amended. As amended. As amended. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? No. Noes have it. I didn't hear enough on the, Senator Flipper, I didn't hear five ayes. So, yes, sir.
▶ Play
Senator Bond, do you have a bill? Turn your mic off. Do you want me to? Senate Bill 278 has an amendment. I think it was passed out earlier. The amendment just changes a section reference from F5 to F4. or it was just a typographical era. This is the bill, just to be clear, that raises the penalty if you use your campaign or carryover funds for personal use, it raises it to a felony if that is in excess of $2,500. And the bill's pretty simple. We initially had it drafted where it tried to put in a bunch of new language after talking with different people, having it reviewed by the Ethics Commission. We essentially just went back and made it simpler and left pretty much the original language in with some additions. I need to get a copy of the bill, actually, in case somebody has a question. But the idea is that under current Arkansas law, if you use your campaign funds or carryover funds for solely personal use, you can only be guilty of a misdemeanor. This raises it to a felony, and the felony, if it's over $2,500, you can see in the bill where it's scaled depending on how much money proven by a prosecutor that you use for personal use.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:40:08
Let me grab my copy of the bill real quick. The amendment
▶ Play
just changes on line three, or on page three, line nine, that reference to F5 would be to F4. We just got that wrong. And then everything else remains the same. And you can see there on page three, it's class D felony if the value is 2,500 or more, C if it's more than 5,000, B if it's more than 25,000. Still a misdemeanor if it's less than 2,500. I'd move adoption of the amendment whenever the committee is ready.
▶ Play
Anybody have a question for Senator Bonn? Second on the amendment. Anybody have a question on the bill or the amendment, excuse me, on the amendment? Move adoption for amendment. Those in favor say aye. Aye. Those opposed. I'm ready for your bill.
▶ Play
Sir, I'm happy to answer any questions, and you can see. Do I have a question on the bill?
▶ Play
Comment, I appreciate you bringing stuff like this because this type of stuff has meat in it. The stuff that we tried to get through as far as just reporting requirements and everything like that. I don't really see where things like that help a lot, but at least with things like this, it acts as a deterrent, so I appreciate you bringing the bill. Well, and a
▶ Play
lot of different folks, even more than the ones listed on the bill right now, had a hand in knocking it around and drafting it, so I wish I could take more credit for it, but a lot of folks looked at it. Motion to
▶ Play
pass at the appropriate time. Any other questions? Any other questions at the proper time? Motion do pass. Motion do pass. Second. As amended. As amended. Second. By a certain sample. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed. Congratulations. Thank you. Thank you. Yes sir. I'll run out later Senator Mark Johnson I know you waited a long time sir and I apologize we started at 730 this morning so Thank you
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman and I appreciate how hard y'all are all working This is Senate Bill 515 515 If you
▶ Play
would introduce yourself for the record, you recognize, present your bill.
▶ Play
I'm Senator Mark Johnson of District 15. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. This is a bill that I was approached prior to being sworn in by the ladies that are the daughters of the War of 1812. And with the rash of destruction of historic monuments around the country, they were very concerned about that problem cropping up in Arkansas. they are actually going to restore and enhance this fairly small monument right over here on the corner. It's an obelisk. It's actually a water fountain. They found that there are many, many more veterans of the War of 1812 that served our state. Of course, we came along in 1819 as a territory and a state in 1836, but many of the people who helped build Arkansas in the early days actually fought in the War of 1812. before they immigrated to our state. The bill definitely, it simply does this. It defines a monument as a statue, memorial, gravestone plate, name plate, plaque, historic flag display, school, street, bridge, building, preserve, or reserve that is located on public property and has been erected for or named or dedicated in honor of a historical person, historical event, military organization, military or military unit, including without reservation. And it shows a whole lot of wars. And the wars start from the French and Indian War up until Operation Iraqi Freedom. And that is a list of them. It basically is the veterans that have served our country. It could also include a monument or facility that's listed on the National Register of Historic Places. It doesn't mean a temporary exhibit or a temporary structure. It says person means an individual or entity and public property means all in real personal property, real or personal property leased, owned or leased by a state, county, municipality, or other entity or subdivision of the state. Now, the guts of it says a monument shall not be relocated, removed, altered, renamed, dedicated, vandalized, damaged, destroyed, or otherwise disturbed. Now, it does not prohibit proper maintenance by taking proper and appropriate measures by any governmental entity. In other words, if you need to fix a problem, there's a structural problem, a water main breaks under a monument and you need to move it and fix it, this doesn't prohibit that. And if there's a question about whether, what would represent disturbing a monument. This entity exercising control could petition the Arkansas History Commission for a waiver from the requirements in this, and this is our safety valve for the unforeseen things that might come up where, while we're protecting these monuments, we'd have an opportunity to, if something needed to be done, we have an entity that cares in their mandate about protecting our history to make sure that they could do the things they need to do, but maintain that the monument is protected. And Mr. Chairman, if I could make one brief caveat from the bill as written. I've been working with some folks from the city of Little Rock that have had some questions about streets. And they said, and I'm paraphrasing, that they didn't know if Lee Avenue, for example, was named after General Robert E. Lee or Charles Lee or my friend Bobby Lee. I mean, they didn't know. But we also know we have streets in West Little Rock, up around where Senator Bond lives that are named after presidents. So that could be considered a monument. So what we want to do is, I have agreed with them that if we get this thing out of the Senate, I will amend it in the House to clean up the language related to streets. I don't think that's our major concern and while I might not like the fact that they changed the name, that they named after me, a street named after me, maybe changing it to Hickey Street or something like that, but I wouldn't prohibit them from doing so. So I'm gonna try to clean that language up, but I'm hoping that I could get a good vote today and we could
▶ Play
Speaker 54 1:48:58
move this forward. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It would be, I guess, probably be good for us to talk about how you clean that language up. But in this, honestly, I don't know the answer to this question. So one of the things, when you say that a monument is all of these things, and then you start with saying it's located on public property, which I think is the intent of the legislation, but the one caveat to that is down here on page two, line 19, has been listed on the National Registry of Historic Places. That could actually reach into private property, right? No, it
▶ Play
would have to be, Senator, a National Register item that is on public property. So a lot of people's homes, historic homes, might be on the National Register, but this would have nothing to do with those.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 1:49:50
And I don't think a home would be covered because so what you have here is starting line 29, 30, You know, monument means all these things, so it's either a statue of memorial, gravestone, plate, nameplate, plaque, historic flag, display, school, street, bridge, building, preserve, building, preserve, or reserve, which that's interesting. I don't know what those are, but that, so that's what this is. When we're talking about a monument, that is this. You know, I, something that's located on public property. I, I, been enacted or named after something. And then you come down to the very end of I, I, and then it says or. So that's like, that's Q on line 19. Or then I, I, I, you know, three has been listed on the National Registry of Historic Places. I don't, I think maybe you
▶ Play
Speaker 303 1:50:42
mean and there. I agree with you.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 1:50:46
So, of course, I don't know if that would work.
▶ Play
The and might need to be up a little higher, but I understand what you're saying is that it sets that out as a separate thing and it probably should be made clear that it's and. You're saying that, and if I understand you correctly, that a facility that was on the national register that was privately owned, which I intend to not cover in this, would be, could potentially be covered. So I will be glad to in my amendment we're going to do. Amendment to make sure that,
▶ Play
Speaker 54 1:51:23
because I agree with what you're trying to do with the legislation when we're talking about public property, but when we're talking about private property, all of a
▶ Play
sudden it changes things. I think it's a constructive idea. Thank you,
▶ Play
Senator. Senator Gardner. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So I agree with your intent on this too, but I think this bill came up last time and I had a huge problem. Let me explain why. Monument is extremely broad. So right now that calls school, street, bridges, et cetera. Then you go down to what can happen. If somebody defaces it or destroys or damages otherwise, then you go down to the very end, this is a Class D felony. Six years in prison, $10,000. So if I'm a dumb 18-year-old kid, and my school's named after General MacArthur, and I go up there and steal the sign, I've destroyed and damaged that sign, I'm now a Class D felony. If I have a street sign like dumb kids do, and I pull that down, that's a Class D felony if it's named after a military thing. This is extremely broad. I think I know what you're intending with this bill, but you're gonna have people who are doing relatively minor things. I mean, if I, South Arkansas, people shoot signs all the time with guns. They'll be destroying it, things like that. I'm not discouraging that behavior, and I think there is a consequence that should happen, but not a class D felony. A 18-year-old kid who does that now has a felony for the rest of his life for pulling a sign down, and by the red letter or black letter of this law, that could happen. I think I agree with your intent, but we need to work on the definition, the punishment otherwise to make sure we're good on that so that your intent is taken care of. Somebody destroys a monument that's a, like we have here in the Capitol, they woke up and hit it with a sledgehammer, good. We can punish them. A dumb kid who takes a street sign, I think you
▶ Play
don't intend to be that as well. Is that correct? Certainly, I agree with the things that you stated, Senator Garner, and especially the fact that you say dumb kids, because we either, in my case, maybe been or had some dumb kids, and I won't, you're too young. Yours are too young to even be dumb or smart. They're just little kids right now. They're just cute. They're cute, that's the best way to describe it. But the point that I'm getting, I agree with you. I know that there was some earlier legislation, I think it had to do with desecrating cemetery monuments where we had a two-tiered section of the law where it was sort of a first offense, it's a little, a much lesser offense, but second offense did go to a felony. And again, I think of the situation that when the person ran over the Ten Commandments monument like the day after it was installed, and that's the kind of thing we're trying to address here. And I'll be glad to, in that amendment that I'm talking about doing in the house, take care of streets. Streets are different. If you take down a street sign, that's a street sign. If you rename something, that's a different thing. And let me, if I could, to follow up on that, the issue with schools came up. There's a junior high in Fort Smith. No, Senator Pitt is still around. It's called Darby Junior High. It was named after William Darby, the Darby's Rangers. and they're going to rebuild it and they were concerned that this would somehow touch that and that's why we put the language in that if you rebuild a new Darby junior high, that's not what we're trying to address here but I pledge to work with you and Senator Ballinger and others just to clean that up. I think it's important because if a
▶ Play
kid goes to a new Darby high and they're throwing eggs on it and it damages that sign, I'm now filling. I mean, that's how it could go. Senator Johnson, let me offer a suggestion. You
▶ Play
do the way you want, you want to call for a vote, then I'll call for a vote. But we are recessed Thursday and Friday, but BLR is not. Yes, sir. And we'll come back here Tuesday. If you'd like to work on an amendment and bring it back to this committee, instead of sending it to the House, send it down there already amended. That's your choice. I think that's a great idea, Senator,
▶ Play
and I would be appreciated if this, Well, they
▶ Play
should not be very busy Thursday and Friday. Would you, I'm sorry, I'll be glad to answer other questions before we get to
▶ Play
that. We're going to be in recess Thursday and Friday. Yes, sir,
▶ Play
I understand. But we'll be back here Tuesday, Senator Tick. And I agree with that 100%. I'll be honest, I don't even want to vote for it. Coming out of here, I get so tired of this stuff. We're saying we're going to fix it on the House. I think it's the responsibility of the Senate, and I may have been guilty of it myself, so I'm not, but I really do get tired of that. want us to send stuff down that that's correct. Let me ask you on this offense stuff with the Class D felony. Are you planning on just trying to lower that or are you possibly going to do maybe like a first offense, second offense, maybe a third offense? Can we look at something like that because you know if we get, like me, I promise you I was one of those dumb kids. I'll just say it the way it is. maybe as a dumb adult now, but I think if we could have a first offense in there and if they've done something like that and they've been caught so big and if the second one, if you want to throw them under the bus, then so big, you know,
▶ Play
I'll be for it, but Senator Garner's got a pretty good point right there. I think it's an excellent point, Senator Hickey, and if I might, let me do clarify, I'm not as tolerant, shall we say, of some official acts by officials to try to destroy a monument as opposed to something like some of the things that happened in New Orleans, for example. But as far as the dumb kid scenario, Senator Garner said, I'm in total agreement with that's not who we're trying to get. I think we can break that into some two-tiered things where if you're a public official and you do something that would violate that act, that would have some teeth in it immediately, but if you're a juvenile or a young person that, as we say, does something stupid, that we'd have a little more forgiveness. Yes, sir, I think you're on
▶ Play
the right track. I appreciate you, too, Senator.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 1:57:41
Thank you, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. What I would say is there are as vandalism statutes on the book, so what you may be able to do is just point at them for the desecration that it would be vandalism in the first degree or second degree, I mean, that may be something you check with BLR. Something that I, just for, and I think I have the answer with Senator Hickey's line of questions, is what I would hate for you to do is put a lot of work into it and not have the support of the committee. I mean, I would say that I agree, and I agree with Senator Hickey, even though I asked the committee to let something out earlier, and I appreciate the fact the committee did. this is fairly complex and it seems like I would prefer it to be fixed here but I also don't want you to do the work without the committee being on board with the bill, with what you're actually trying to accomplish and I don't mind saying that I would support in it but it looks like you probably have the support of the committee with the amendments. Okay and I feel good about the questions y'all have asked, I'll
▶ Play
be happy to answer any more but I pledge to go back and get this Yes sir Mr. Chairman I will pull this down and we will We'll try to incorporate all that in before Tuesday. I'll try to have you first on the list. Right. Thank you, sir.
▶ Play
Senator Fitzley. Yes, sir. Senator Valder. I have a couple of bills. Come. Come. Come. Go. I can't be any more tired when I go home than what I am right now. That's
▶ Play
Speaker 115 1:59:06
a point. At some point, you start getting energy back.
▶ Play
Second wind. Woo! And, committee, let me compliment you all again today. Y'all put in long, hard hours, all session, and I appreciate it very much. Today's no exception.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 1:59:21
Thank you so much, committee, for your forbearance. And let me say this, that if you all have any questions, I hate to open myself up like this, but if there are concerns with this legislation, then we can pull it down and work on it next week, but I think it'll be okay. So I guess we'll take them in order, House Bill 1420. House Bill 1420. Yep. In the beginning of the session, I was an expert on every piece of legislation that I brought. At least I could pretend like I was. Now I've even lost that ability to do that. So
▶ Play
I'm just going to lean real hard on Lindsey to explain what we're
▶ Play
doing here. Lindsey, if you would introduce yourself for the record. Lindsey Bailey, Association of Arkansas Counties. This is an AAC package bill brought from the County Clerks Association. And it's a little bit long, but it does three things. First, any filing period for a candidate who files in the county clerk's office, it would make two uniform one-week filing periods, one before the primary and one before the general election. So for county, city, school board, those guys who file for office in the county clerk's office, they would all have the same one-week filing periods. The second thing it does is petition circulations that are also turned into the county clerk's office. So, again, no petitions or filings in the Secretary of State's office. They would all have a uniform 90-day petition circulation period. This is just for the sake of uniformity. The third thing it does, back in 2017, you all put the school elections in with the general and primary elections. This just sets out the process that if a school board wants to change their date from the general to the primary or vice versa, that they give it to the clerk 100 days before the primary filing period. It sets out the process to do that. This is a agreed-to bill with School Board Association and the Municipal League.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 2:01:28
I'm happy to answer any questions that you have and then, but I don't want to hang up, keep us around any longer. So I think you guys heard what the bill does and it has been out there, no, absolutely no opposition, no complaints from anyone about this legislation.
▶ Play
I'll give the committee a few minutes to cut your base and see if they want to ask
▶ Play
any questions. So is the, and I didn't find it in here, I know for state legislature it's a one-week filing period now. I know that. Is this a change going to one week for these folks from two weeks or is
▶ Play
it already one week? Yes, I believe some of the city folks may have two weeks right now. I can't remember exactly. it's been a long time since I drafted this bill back in the summer, but we spoke with everyone and they're all okay with the one
▶ Play
Speaker 54 2:02:35
week period. And I think this actually mirrors what we have to do
▶ Play
from the legislative process. You have a question? You're good. There's one. Another question? Thank you. Okay. Close for
▶ Play
Speaker 54 2:02:56
your bill. I'm closed my bill and
▶ Play
I do move do pass. Move do pass. Is there a second? Second. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed. Congratulations. The next bill is what I've been
▶ Play
Speaker 324 2:03:09
looking for. The easy one. Yeah. 1444. 1444.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 2:03:12
and this bill is is another we actually have dealt with another one very similar to this and the fact that it's it kind of brings back in line with other areas in the law where what you have is a four-week period rather than a two-week period from the general primary election to the to the earth of the runoff no i'm sorry yes that's right
▶ Play
Speaker 319 2:03:40
from two weeks to four weeks just why
▶ Play
again for uniformity so that all of the runoffs are at the same time we had a situation after this last general where the city of Little Rock would have had a county runoff at three weeks and a city runoff at four weeks and we want those for the sake of voters to be at the same time Also, two weeks is not enough time to do the logic and accuracy testing and do
▶ Play
a week of early voting. I'll buy that. Thank you. Question? Mr. Bond, you good? Why? Motion? Yeah, I'll make a motion do pass. Motion do pass. Is there a second? Second. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed? Thank you very much, committee. Senator Pitch, coming back. Okay. We're adjourned. Thank you, committee. Again, I cannot tell you how proud I am of how hard you work.
▶ Play

Agenda

Call To Order

0:06 - 27:56 75 segments 17 speakers

SB4 T. Garner TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS LEGISLATIVE STUDY ON VETERANS AFFAIRS.

27:56 - 1:02

Senator Trent Garner explained that SB 4, originally intended to create a veteran-suicide task force, was amended to establish an interim study subcommittee to address cost concerns while still pursuing the legislative study on veterans affairs. [28:06] [28:40] [29:11] [29:20] [29:27] [29:43]

After a brief question-and-answer exchange, the committee voted to concur with the bill, with members indicating “aye” and the measure being adopted. [30:56] [31:08]

SJR15 A. Clark THE ARKANSAS TERM LIMITS AMENDMENT.

1:02 - 1:38:55 283 segments 37 speakers

Senator Travis Porter opened the hearing with a critique of the proposed constitutional amendment, arguing that it would effectively allow legislators to serve indefinitely by setting 12- or 16-year limits with four-year gaps and raising concerns about the ambiguous impact on constitutional officers. [2:23] [2:54] [3:24] [3:57] [4:31] [5:02]

Tom Steele, representing the Arkansas Term Limits advocacy group, warned that the bill’s popular name duplicates the name of their citizen-initiated amendment, creating potential voter confusion and urging the committee to change the title. [6:05] [6:36] [7:07] [7:40] [8:13]

Senator Alan Clark responded by defending the amendment’s reduction of legislative term limits to 12 years, explaining his own amendment to remove judicial term limits from the proposal and emphasizing the goal of “good government”. [10:32] [11:05] [11:39] [12:11] [12:44] [13:14] [13:46] [14:17] [14:49] [15:21] [15:55] [16:28] [16:58] [17:29] [18:02] [18:32] [19:03]

The committee moved to adopt the amendment (including Clark’s judicial carve-out), a second was offered, and the amendment was approved by voice vote; the final language now sets a 12-year limit with a four-year waiting period and excludes the judiciary. [21:49] [21:54] [22:01] [22:43] [23:13] [23:48]

SB258 Bond TO INCREASE THE PENALTY FOR TAKING CAMPAIGN FUNDS AS PERSONAL INCOME; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF ARKANSAS LAW RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1990 AND INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1996.

1:38:55 - 1:43:48 13 segments 4 speakers

Senator Will Bond introduced SB 258, explaining that it would raise the penalty for personal use of campaign or carry-over funds from a misdemeanor to a felony when the amount exceeds $2,500, with a scaling structure for larger sums. [1:39:02] [1:39:35] [1:40:08] [1:40:39] [1:41:19]

The chair opened the floor for questions, and Senator Jimmy Hickey praised the bill as a deterrent, while Senator Bond offered to answer any further inquiries. [1:41:47] [1:41:51] [1:42:13] [1:42:23] [1:42:43]

A motion to adopt the amendment as presented was made, seconded, and approved unanimously by voice vote. [1:41:51] [1:42:13] [1:42:23] [1:42:43] [1:42:59]

SB515 M. Johnson TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS HERITAGE PROTECTION ACT.

1:43:48 - 1:59:55 51 segments 7 speakers

Senator Mark Johnson presented SB 515, the Arkansas Heritage Protection Act, defining “monument” broadly to include statues, plaques, streets, schools, bridges and other public-property commemorations, and prohibiting their relocation, alteration or destruction except for necessary maintenance. [1:44:03] [1:44:36] [1:45:06] [1:45:39] [1:46:10] [1:46:41]

Senators Trent Garner and Jimmy Hickey raised concerns that the definition and the Class D felony penalty were overly broad, potentially criminalizing minor acts such as a youth removing a street sign, and suggested a tiered offense structure or amendments to narrow scope. [1:51:36] [1:51:53] [1:52:25] [1:52:55] [1:56:07] [1:56:38] [1:56:46] [1:57:15]

The chair offered to recess the committee and allow the sponsor to return with revised language, indicating the bill would be taken up again after the break. [1:55:09] [1:55:32] [1:55:34]

HB1420 Boyd TO AMEND CANDIDATE FILING AND PETITION CIRCULATION PERIODS; TO AMEND THE ANNUAL SCHOOL ELECTION DATE NOTIFICATION PROCESS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

1:59:55 - 31:32

Lindsay Bailey introduced HB 1420, outlining three uniformity measures: one-week filing periods for county-clerk candidate filings, a 90-day uniform petition-circulation period, and a standardized notification timeline for school-board election date changes. [2:00:07] [2:00:28] [2:00:58] [2:01:28]

Committee members asked clarification about the current filing periods, confirming that the bill would shift some jurisdictions from a two-week to a one-week window, and no opposition was voiced. [2:02:07] [2:02:20] [2:02:31] [2:02:35] [2:02:49]

The chair closed the discussion without a vote, leaving the bill pending. [2:01:58] [2:02:07] [2:02:20] [2:02:31] [2:02:35] [2:02:49]

SB409 Flippo TO ALLOW FOR THE ELECTRONIC NOTIFICATION OF AN INVITATION FOR BIDS AND THE ELECTRONIC SUBMISSION OF BIDS; AND TO REQUIRE CERTAIN ENTITIES TO ACCEPT THE ELECTRONIC SUBMISSION OF BIDS.

31:32 - 2:02:55 277 segments 29 speakers

Senator Scott Flippo introduced Senate Bill 409, explaining that it would permit cities, counties and school districts to post bid invitations and accept electronic submissions instead of newspaper notices, noting that the language has not changed since the amendment adopted last week and that the change would save taxpayers money. [31:33] [31:36] [31:45] [31:52] [32:08] [32:15] [32:48] [33:23]

Committee members sought clarification on the bill’s wording, with Senator Hickey questioning underlined language on page 3 and Senator Will Bond asking how vendors would learn of online bids, prompting Ted Fleming of Central Bidding to testify that membership is free, fees apply only to downloading bid documents, and vendors are notified through commodity codes and training sessions. [35:05] [35:11] [35:34] [35:37] [35:43] [36:00] [36:33] [36:39] [37:10] [37:29] [37:41] [38:12] [38:43]

Support was voiced by Robin Keene of the Arkansas Association of Educational Administrators, who praised the secure-website option for school districts while retaining newspaper advertising, whereas Len Hamilton and Ashley Wimberley of the Arkansas Gazette warned that the bill could lead to newspaper layoffs, lacked public input and security standards, and appeared to favor a private vendor, and Jason Carter of the Arkansas Municipal League and Senator Bill Sample raised further concerns about contractor awareness, competition and the integrity of a private-website system. [39:27] [39:57] [40:11] [41:07] [41:41] [42:11] [42:43] [43:15] [43:49] [44:23] [44:55] [45:26] [45:57] [46:28] [49:46] [50:22] [50:57] [51:28] [52:04] [52:34] [53:05] [53:37] [54:13] [54:44] [55:15] [1:08:16] [1:08:48] [1:09:20] [1:09:51] [1:10:24] [1:10:57] [1:11:31] [1:12:01] [1:12:32] [1:18:37] [1:19:10] [1:19:18] [1:19:43] [1:20:13]

The Arkansas County Judges Association and the Association of Counties testified that SB 409 does not favor any particular vendor, pointing out that electronic bidding is already used by the state highway department and that counties could adopt the system voluntarily with optional paper bids during a transition period. [1:22:40] [1:23:07] [1:23:17] [1:23:27] [1:23:37] [1:24:11] [1:24:43] [1:25:18] [1:25:53]

Several senators, including Trent Garner and Jimmy Hickey, expressed worries about transparency and the potential to limit competition if bids were posted on any website, questioning vendor discovery and audit provisions, while Senator Breanne Davis countered that vendors routinely monitor online notices via alerts and that any electronic platform would be subject to Legislative Audit oversight, after which Senator Flippo reiterated that the bill merely offers an optional electronic bidding process to save taxpayers money and the chair moved to pass the bill as amended, which was approved unanimously with all ayes and no noes. [1:26:21] [1:26:26] [1:26:58] [1:27:08] [1:27:25] [1:27:29] [1:27:59] [1:28:32] [1:29:02] [1:29:38] [1:30:01] [1:30:15] [1:30:18] [1:31:08] [1:31:19] [1:31:50] [1:32:07] [1:32:24] [1:32:36] [1:32:58] [1:33:09] [1:33:24] [1:33:40] [1:33:45] [1:34:00] [1:34:11] [1:34:45] [1:35:15] [1:35:50] [1:36:23] [1:36:55] [1:37:30] [1:37:54] [1:38:00]

HB1444 Breaux TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE DATE TO HOLD CERTAIN RUNOFF ELECTIONS.

2:02:55 - 2:04:38 8 segments 5 speakers

The chair moved to pass the bill, it was seconded, and the committee approved it by voice vote. [2:02:59] [2:03:09] [2:03:12] [2:03:40] [2:03:45] [2:04:09] [2:04:15]

Adjournment

2:04:38 - 2:14:38

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Senator Ronald Caldwell Chair Unverified
94 segments
Senator Alan Clark Unverified
26 segments
Speaker 10
1 segment
Travis Porter Unverified
9 segments
Tom Steele Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 40
1 segment
Speaker 54
27 segments
Speaker 61
1 segment
Speaker 66
1 segment
Speaker 67
2 segments
Senator Will Bond Unverified
12 segments
Speaker 80
1 segment
Senator Bart Hester Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 89
2 segments
Speaker 97
1 segment
Speaker 102
1 segment
Senator Trent Garner Unverified
22 segments
Senator Jimmy Hickey, Jr Unverified
24 segments
Senator Scott Flippo Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 20
1 segment
Speaker 139
1 segment
Speaker 143
1 segment
Speaker 151
5 segments
Robin Keene Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 186
14 segments
Speaker 183
1 segment
Speaker 199
1 segment
Jason Carter Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 59
2 segments
Speaker 224
1 segment
Speaker 230
1 segment
Senator Bill Sample Unverified
7 segments
Lindsay Bailey Unverified
22 segments
Speaker 248
2 segments
Speaker 252
1 segment
Senator Breanne Davis Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 171
1 segment
Senator Mark Johnson Unverified
24 segments
Speaker 303
1 segment
Speaker 115
1 segment
Speaker 324
1 segment
Speaker 319
1 segment