May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 11, 2026
SB177 T. Garner CONCERNING SEX OFFENDER REGISTRATION REQUIREMENTS. 0:28
Senator Trent Garner explained that the bill would update the code to require electronic transmission of sex-offender data to the Arkansas Crime Information Center, removing outdated written-form requirements and imposing no new burden on law enforcement.
[0:35]
The chair sought questions and Garner clarified that the data is sent to the ACIC, not to offenders.
[1:05]
After brief discussion, Representative Tosh moved to pass SB 177, no opposition was recorded and the motion carried, enacting the bill.
[1:39][2:13]
SB227 M. Pitsch CONCERNING THE RECORDING AND INDEXING OF COURT PROCEEDINGS; AND TO PERMIT THE ELECTRONIC AND INTERNET-BASED INDEXING OF CERTAIN COURT DOCUMENTS. 2:36
Senator Mathew Pitsch outlined that SB 227 would permit circuit clerks to create electronic alphabetical indexes of court judgments when they have scanning capability, without mandating the practice.
[2:48]
The chair noted there were no members signed up to speak for or against the measure and opened the floor for questions, none were offered.
[3:14]
Representative Crawford moved to do pass the bill, the committee voted aye with no opposition and the measure was adopted.
[3:34]
SB109 Irvin TO AMEND THE OFFENSE OF BATTERY IN THE FIRST DEGREE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 4:15
Representative Murdoch introduced SB 109, which would elevate the offense of battery against police officers to a Class Y felony (and to a Class B felony for corrections officers) and includes an emergency clause.
[4:45]
The chair reported that no members had signed up to speak for or against the bill and opened the floor for discussion, which yielded none.
[4:52]
Representative Tosh moved to do pass the bill as amended, the committee voted aye with no opposition and the measure was adopted.
[4:52][5:20]
SB14 L.Chesterfield CONCERNING THE FEE TO ATTEND A VICTIM IMPACT PANEL THAT IS REQUIRED BY LAW OF ANY PERSON CONVICTED OF DRIVING OR BOATING WHILE INTOXICATED,… 5:52
Representative Lanny Fite introduced SB 14, proposing to raise the fee charged to individuals required to attend a victim-impact panel for DUI-related offenses by $10, citing support from Mothers Against Drunk Driving and the need for additional outreach funding.
[6:10][6:25]
Committee members raised concerns about protecting the privacy of minors mandated to attend the program, which Fite assured would be maintained under existing law.
[7:32][8:02][8:26][8:33]
Following the amendment, Representative Fyke moved to do pass SB 14 as amended, the motion carried with all votes in favor, and the bill was enacted.
[12:50]
The chair, Rep. Carol Dalby, called a motion to limit each member’s remarks to three minutes, which was seconded, debated briefly, and adopted unanimously (aye vote).
[14:47][15:18][15:42][15:49]
SB116 B. Ballinger REQUIRING AN INMATE IN THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO FIRST EXHAUST ALL AVAILABLE ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES AS A CONDITION PRECEDENT TO FILIN… 57:12
Representative Sarah Capp introduced Senate Bill 116, explaining that it would extend the Prison Litigation Reform Act’s administrative-exhaustion requirement to Arkansas state-court civil-rights claims in order to preserve judicial resources and encourage resolution through the Department of Corrections grievance process.
[58:07][58:18][58:52][59:28]
Committee members raised numerous concerns-including why the statute of limitations is not tolled during the grievance period, whether the bill would limit inmates’ rights or affect pre-trial detainees, the lack of a set time-frame for exhaustion, how inmates would be notified of the new requirement, and the potential for courts to dismiss valid claims without prejudice-receiving answers from Director Wendy Kelly (Jamie Scott) that the grievance process is short, already robust, and that the bill does not alter federal-court procedures, though it would allow dismissal for failure to exhaust administrative remedies.
[1:01:11][1:01:29][1:01:40][1:01:55][1:02:03][1:02:14][1:02:29][1:04:35][1:04:53][1:04:58][1:06:33][1:07:09][1:07:23][1:10:47][1:11:04][1:11:14][1:11:26][1:11:36][1:11:45][1:11:52][1:12:11][1:12:21][1:12:44]
After the discussion, the chair announced that Senate Bill 116 was being withdrawn for the time being pending further amendments.
[1:15:54][1:16:02]
Welcome to House Judiciary. Judiciary is now called to order. Chair sees the quorum. Our first bill that we're going to take up today will be Senate Bill 177. Senator Garner is at the end of the table and you are recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Madam Chairwoman and members
of the committee. SB 177 is a very simple bill brought to me by the director of Arkansas Crime Information Center. It does two main things. Right now, under our current law, sex offenders have to comply with different time standards, where there's three days, five days, seven days, or even ten days. This is make it a uniform five days business days so that they all know that's the timeline they have to do it The second part is right now local law enforcement agencies when they send data to them They usually they almost every one of them actually all of them sent it through electronic means But in the code, they're still the way to do it through written form They just want to clean that up to make sure they do the best practices This is already how it's done and it should be no burden on our law enforcement just to make sure we remove that from the code
Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Any other questions by committee members? We do have one individual who has signed up to speak against the bill. Ms. Swanson, if you'll come to the end of the table, please. Oh, you're for it now? Okay. I'd like to make a note of that. Duly noted, Ms. Swanson, this is the second time. Senator Garner, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed, Madam Chairwoman. The Senator has closed for his bill. Do we have a motion on the floor? We have a motion from Representative Tosh. Motion to pass. We have a motion to do pass. Representative House, you have your hand up. We have a motion to do pass, is there any further discussion on Senate Bill 177? I see no discussion, all in favor of motion do pass, please say yes or aye. All opposed say no. Motion is carried, congratulations you have passed your bill. The next bill we're going to take up is going to be Senate Bill 227, going to recognize Senator Pitch. Thank
you, Madam Chair. Senate Bill 227 was brought to us by the Arkansas counties, specifically the Arkansas County clerks. What this bill does is it allows those who have the ability to do electronic data. The meat of the bill is found on line 30, part B. A clerk may make only an electronic alphabetical index under subsection of this section if he or she is able to electronically scan the judgments so that they can be used. This allows circuit clerks to use electronic databases when available. It's not a mandate. So I entertain any questions,
Madam Chairman or woman. Are there any questions of Senator Pitch? I don't believe we have anyone who has signed up to speak for or against the bill, and we do. Representative Crawford has made a motion to do pass. Is there any discussion on the motion? All in favor say aye. All opposed say no. Congratulations, Senator. passed your bill. Thank you, Madam Chairman. Our next bill that we're going to take up will be Senate Bill 109. I believe Representative Murdoch is here to present that bill. Representative
murdoch you're recognized thank you madam chair and committee assembly 109 is a bill that deals with an excluded group of law enforcement officers who were excluded from a when battery is committed against law enforcement officer is a class y felony for policemen and regular law enforcement officers. For those in correctional institutions, it's a class B. What this bill would do would just put them on par and make all of those be a class
Y felony. Are there any questions of Representative Murdoch? We do not have anyone who has signed up for or against this bill. Also has an emergency clause on there? Yes ma'am. So what is the will of the committee? Motion do pass. I have a motion do pass by Representative Tosh. Is there any discussion on the motion to do pass and this would be on the bill and the emergency clause? Is there any discussion? All in favor of the motion please say aye. Aye. Any opposed say no. Congratulations Representative you have passed your bill thank you chair and thank you committee our next bill I would like to take up the Senate bill 14 senator Chesterfield have you received your amendment yet you're certainly recognized to go ahead and present your bill members there will be an amendment on that but we'll allow the senator since she's here and has been here a couple of days, go ahead and present your bill. And then when the amendment comes, you can present your amendment, and we'll take
it up at the proper time. Thank you, Madam Chair, and good morning, members of the committee. It's an honor to be back in the judiciary. This bill is a very simple bill. It adds $10 to the fee for those persons who receive assistance in overcoming alcoholism. And Mothers Against Drunk Driving have endorsed this bill. And what we want to do is to increase the number of areas where we can serve individuals. We have a growing number of young people who are beginning to drink much earlier. Arkansas ranks 13th in the nation in deaths due to drunk driving. And so we feel that if we can just increase the fee, there's no cost to the state. If we can increase this fee to $10, we can do more outreach, not only in communities, but within the schools as well. And my amendment simply adds that except for community corrections, they would like to be held harmless, and it keeps the bill with no cost to the state. I'd be happy to take any questions. Representative Fite, you're recognized. Thank you,
Thank you, Madam Chair. Senator, just to make sure I understand, I noticed in the statute here it refers to also to those people charged with minor in possession, which is most of the time is going to be someone of a juvenile age. I guess there's provisions that have been taken to make sure that their identity is protected if they're mandatorily mandated to attend one of these schools. Would you tell me what's in place to make sure?
As far as I know, individuals' privacy will be maintained. It's not a part of the bill, but it should be a part of the code. So we want to make sure that our young people, as well as our adults, have their identity protected. And so we want to do that. But at the same time, we want to give them the help that they need, and it's getting increasingly difficult to operate on $10. Follow-up. You're
recognized for your follow-up. And again, I think you answered my question, but there are provisions in place to make sure that the identity of the minors that are mandated to attend these organizations, these classes, that it is protected under state law. Is that correct? As far as I am concerned, yes, sir. Senator Chesterfield, I've been
notified that your amendment is in transit. Maybe you can... I'm feeling like the village idiot here needing you to. Oh, no, no, no, no, no. Adopt an amendment that's not here. Well, if you want to go ahead and discuss your amendment, then we'll pass the amendment out. Because I want you to go ahead and have this opportunity. So if you'll go ahead and
discuss your amendment, then we'll pass it out. All right, thank you. The amendment merely holds the Department of Corrections harmless, community corrections, excuse me, harmless. The increase to $20 would cause a hardship on the state, and it would add to the cost of the bill. We don't want the bill to have any fiscal impact on the state, and this would preclude that from happening. That's what the amendment does, and it adds this handsome gentleman here as the sponsor in the House, but if any of you want to sign on, please let me know. I think it's a great cause, and I
get here. Thank you so much, and I apologize to the committee, but Brent is on his way. May I introduce some ladies from Mothers Against Drunk Driving? Certainly. All right, there's our chair. Would you come forward and may I just ask him to come forward? Yes, ma'am. One of them is down from Nashville, not far from our hometown. Senator? I mean, Representative, would you introduce yourself, please? You're recognized. Introduce
and an advocate. We appreciate your work in coming to our meeting today. You're always welcome to be here. I think your amendment is here, so we're getting it signed. As soon as Representative Love signs them, we'll be ready for you to formally present it. All right, members, you now have before you the amendment to Senate Bill 14. You've heard the Senator explain it, so at this point in time, are there any questions in regard to the amendment, just the amendment? I'll give you a few moments. Has everyone had a chance to read the amendment? Do I have a motion in regard to the amendment? Representative Fyke? Motion to pass on the amendment, adopt the amendment, I'm sorry. Motion to adopt the amendment. Is there any discussion? All in favor of adopting the amendment, please say aye. Aye. All opposed? It has been adopted. Now, Senator Chesterfield, are you now closed for your bill? I'm closed
out my welcome. Do we have any discussion in regard to Senate Bill 14? Before I get to the discussion part, do I have a motion in regard to Senate Bill 14? Representative Fyke? We have a motion to do pass now. Is there any discussion on the motion to do pass that's now on the table? We have a motion to do pass as amended. All in favor, please say aye. Aye. All opposed? The motion has carried. Your bill has passed as amended. Thank
you, Madam Chair, and thank you, ladies and gentlemen of the committee. We do appreciate it, and the mothers against joint driving, the state will benefit. We appreciate you very
much. Thank you, Senator. Senator Elliott, do you have a bill to present? I'm glad you recognize that this is the real world down here. Thank you. All right members we're now going to turn our attention to House Resolution 1013. House Resolution 1013 I understand last week we kind of got a little off the rail while I was over in another committee no fault of anybody particular there was just a lot of things going on. I have watched the tape a couple of times, so the committee will know where we are and what we're doing. I've watched the tape a couple of times, then Buddy Johnson, the House Parliamentarian, I have also gone through the tape a couple of times. There were at some point at least three improper motions on the table, so we have looked at it and have made a determination of which Mr. Johnson has agreed also that this is the proper place to start. We have on the table that the committee never took up, and we're going to start from that point. There was a motion on the table by Representative Fite to limit debate. So at this point in time, so that everybody is very clear, that's the point we're going to, I am going to ask Representative Fite to restate her motion so that we're all very clear as to what the motion is, and if she'll restate her motion, then we'll take that motion up. Thank
Members, you have heard her motion to limit debate to three minutes per person. Is there any discussion on the motion? All in favor of the motion, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. The ayes have it. The debate will be limited to three minutes per person. And Judy, will you help me keep time? You got the timer? Okay. The chair is going to recognize Ms. Linda Collins to the table, this is an individual who has signed up against Ms. Collins, I meant for, I'm sorry, well, you know, hey, we never know. Ms. Collins, if you'll come to the table. Ms. Collins, we welcome you back to our committee and welcome you back to the House. You're familiar with how we proceed, and so at this time I would ask that you please state your name and
you will have three minutes. I'm Linda Collins, and I am former senator, just ended her term, but I'm also a member like you are of the House. So, I've been proud to serve with some of you out there on this committee. And so, if you're ready for me, Madam Chair, I'd like to go ahead and make my presentation if you don't mind. As a legislator, many of you, and in this body, supported the laws that we're discussing in this resolution. It's pretty specific and plain. This is a resolution and it affirms the laws that we have, our statute right now, that are on the books. And that basically is what this resolution is about. Like I said, many of you have supported the legislation and I know that I was here at times and supported legislation. And so for me, I just want to bring this back to what the resolution is about. It is affirming the laws that we have on the books and pretty much that's all it is. so it's pretty easy. I'd like for you to have a good vote for this. I'm a legislator that worked across both sides of the aisle on gun legislation. I served as vice chair and chair of judiciary in the Senate. And again, this is a resolution. You're not changing the laws. You're just affirming the statute that's there. So I'm just trying to bring this back from where we left it in the last meeting last week and like I said I've worked with Democrats and Republicans on both sides of the aisle probably the only person that's ever had the majority leader stand on the Senate floor on gun legislation and we passed it because it was good legislation so I encourage you to support this bill and I know there's probably not much questions but of course madam chair that's what I have to say thank you are
there any questions of miss Collins miss Collins I see no questions thank you very much for coming thank you I'll look for a good vote thank you we have Laura Hardy from moms demand action who is signed up to speak against the bill. Ms. Hardy, come to the end of the table and please state your name
for the record. Good morning. My name is Laura Cartwright Hardy, and as you said, I'm with Moms Demand Action. I also am a resident of downtown Little Rock. My husband and I live downtown as do my grown children and my five grandchildren. I'm a volunteer with the Arkansas chapter of Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in America, which is a grassroots movement of American mothers and others who fight for public safety measures to protect us from gun violence. We support the right of law-abiding citizens to carry concealed handguns in public places with permits and safety training. But this resolution is not about law-abiding citizens. In fact, with permitless carry, people of any background can carry loaded handguns with without undergoing background checks. Currently, criminal records search to make sure that individuals who want to carry guns should be able to carry guns, not a person with a dangerous history, a person who's prohibited by law from having handguns, a felon, domestic abuser, other people with dangerous histories can't carry hidden loaded handguns in public permitless carry only weakens the ability of law enforcement to protect the safety of the public this resolution will encourage people to carry loaded handguns in public without permits or firearm safety training it will also encourage them to break current law and is not based in any fact or legal legal reasoning. The case that this resolution cites did not address or resolve any questions about vagaries in current Arkansas law concerning the concealed carry permit requirement. This non-binding resolution will confuse people and will hamper law enforcement's ability to protect us and to carry out their duties and will give people incentive to carry without a permit. Further, permitless carry is extremely dangerous and we shouldn't encourage it here in Arkansas. The few states that have eliminated their permitting requirement have seen substantial increase in firearm violence. I'll just mention too, according to the Department of Public Safety in Arizona, since they enacted permitless carry in 2010, the rate of aggravated assaults committed by firearms in the state increased by 39% by 2017. Alaska was the first state in 2003 to enact permitless carry. Aggravated assaults, according to their Department of Public Safety, committed with a firearm have increased incrementally, and since 2003, the rate of aggravated assaults committed with a firearm increased by 82% as of 2017. Individuals caring without permits are less likely to follow Arkansas law because they won't have training They won't know what to do and I think is that my time? Yes, ma'am. That is your time if you can
people Are there any questions of this witness? thank you miss hardy appreciate it next individual we have uh signed up is miss jennifer helms miss helms you're recognized to come and they will please state your name
my name is jennifer helms i'm here as an arkansas citizen thank you madam chair and thank you to the committee for hearing my testimony today I want to speak in support of House Resolution 1013 to clarify gun rights. My story may not be unique, but perhaps not one you'll hear from others in testimony today. I speak as a mother as well as a citizen who supports our Second Amendment rights. A few short years ago, as a mother of a then-teenager, I wanted to do my due diligence in teaching my son the more grown-up rights and responsibilities of American citizens. I made sure he knew his constitutional rights, and I provided opportunities for him to learn and become proficient in the use of a gun for self-protection as well as sport. During his last year of college, he shared a story with me that had me terribly concerned as a mom. He and his friends lived in a house not far from campus, and one night they heard gunfire outside their house. They looked out the front windows, and not 25 feet away from their front door, there was a man on the ground surrounded by police. There was literally a shootout in front of his house. I don't know all the details of that scene, but my son later informed me that the house across the street was a drug house. The very first words out of my mouth were, are your guns locked and loaded in case you're in danger? He assured me that he and his friends were well protected in their house. But here's my point today. My next question to him should not have to be, have you asked your local law enforcement if you have their permission to carry your weapon outside of your house for protection. He had asked me numerous times over the previous college years if open carry was allowed, must it be concealed only, and was a permit really required for a concealed weapon. With my best effort, I had tried to answer that question, but when I went looking for information, I only found conflicting answers. There is a great deal of confusion in our state as to how you can carry open or concealed, And what happens if a law enforcement officer interprets the Arkansas Code differently than a citizen interprets it? And this confusion simply should not exist. I shouldn't worry that my law-abiding Dean's List law school-bound son might be arrested and prosecuted for strapping on a holstered weapon for self-defense just because someone interprets the law in an arbitrary way or has decided without any evidence that he might have unlawful intent and arrest him and hurt my son's reputation and ruin our family finances for a lawsuit or that he would lose the opportunity to pursue a law career. Excuse me. There's no statute that forbids concealed carry or expressly prohibits or provides a penalty for concealed carry. In 2018, the Attorney General opined on this matter in a letter to Senator Linda Collins in which she stated the following opinion regarding concealed license. Given the current state of the law, it's not entirely clear whether it's lawful to carry a concealed handgun without a concealed carry license. Moreover, and relatedly, it is not entirely clear whether carrying a concealed handgun without a concealed carry license will expose a citizen to conviction. Ms. Hardy,
your time has expired. Are there any questions? Are you? I'm out. Do you want me to finish the closing remark? One more sentence. Okay. When law enforcement entities misunderstand
the law or choose to play loose with its interpretation, this has a negative effect on ordinary citizens because government then sits in a position of intimidation over the individual. And that's the way I felt as a mom. I'm sorry. I
think I called you by the wrong last name, Ms. Helms. I apologize. Are there any questions? Thank you very much for coming. Mr. Tate, where are you? You had, as I watched the tape, you spoke last week. Do you have anything additional that you would like to use your three minutes for? I believe that you have pretty much said a good bit, but I will allow if you have something new that you would like to add in your three minutes. hang on just a
last time that he prevented others that haven't had a chance to speak yet, and I would respectfully request that until others have spoken one time, that he not
we're not going to have any clapping. I will recognize your request, Representative Brent Smith. I'm sorry. I didn't mean to call you by your first name. Mr. Tate, I will come back to you, but I have another individual who is signed up against. and I will let that individual come ahead of you. So I will come back to you. You bet. I have Jeff Warkham. I'm sorry if I'm pronouncing your last name wrong. You had it right the first time. If you'll please state your name, and then your three minutes
will begin. Thank you, Madam Chair. My name is Jeff Wonka. I'm an attorney here in North Little Rock. I had a few things to speak on about this particular bill and this particular resolution, and that is the main crux of the issue. We're dealing with a resolution instead of a bill. And if we're trying to make some clarity, if you have a straight-up bill that says this is allowed, this is not allowed, that is going to be your better approach to go. A couple of things that were brought up last time by some of the representatives, specifically Representative Blake, I believe that you were exactly right. You have to do something. If you actually want to make some clarity, pass a bill instead of a resolution that says this is what you may do in our state, this is what you may not do in our state. Representative Scott, you stated that there was a separation of powers issue that was going on in this, and by attempting to clarify. I don't think that's what we have here. It's not – y'all are a co-equal branch with the judiciary. You were stating that you wanted to hear what the Arkansas Supreme Court had to say because it was only the Court of Appeals that spoke in the Taft case. The time for them to bring that up to the Supreme Court has long since passed. It's not going to happen there unless there is a secondary appeal that's out there in another case that makes it up there. that's going to be the extent of what we have as far as interpretation for this particular thing for this particular bill and statute that's in place it had nothing to do with the second amendment in the taft case at all it was all about do you have the ability to come up and talk with an individual to see what it is that they are doing was there a crime being committed and what happened in the taft case was they figured out he wasn't doing anything illegal he didn't have the intent to use a firearm unlawfully upon another person which is what that clarified and what you're hearing from a lot of these people that are here i'm only against this because it's just a resolution instead of a bill and actually doing something it's like a loud gong making a lot of noise and doing nothing all we're doing is saying hey look at this and then it goes away there's zero clarification in the statute there's still going to be different law enforcement agencies that think there is a different criteria and why they can come up and begin speaking with someone whether it's a person of color whether it's a person that's in an end of in a place that they don't think they should be or anything else and that's the issue that you have make something that says this is what you may do as opposed to a resolution that's all
that I had madam chair are there any questions thank you appreciate it our next individual to speak for the bill would be mr. Calvert you're recognized
Thank you chair, thank you committee, my name is Paul Calvert. A while after Act 746 passed, I put a billboard sign letting people know that they were now allowed to carry without a permit because the law had changed. After seeing my sign, I understand that citizens were regularly being given false information by various government officials when they called to get clarification. So I spent my own money to spread the truth about the current law and government officials were allegedly turning around and spending my tax dollars to give out untruthful information to citizens who are asking about the law. There are people who have actually been arrested and had their guns illegally confiscated due to this confusion. In my case, I've had some myself, former police chief, A.J. Geary, and city attorney, Mike Murphy, this is from Conway, who is now an appeals court judge, worked together with the mayor to have Townsler to keep me and others from openly carrying while passing out flyers at the Toad Suck Days Festival there in Conway, in spite of the fact that the prosecutor, Cody Highland, was on a TV report declaring they had no legal authority to keep us out since the festival was not solely on a city park, where the state law, 573-122, still prohibits carrying loaded firearms. Police Chief A.J. Gary had the corrupt gall to tell me that I might be arrested if I went ahead and openly carried it to the festival. Coming from the police chief, I think most reasonable people would feel like that was a threat. In fact, this treacherous intimidation by the city officials did scare me out of carrying out my plan to organize maybe a dozen or so people to openly carry at the festival and pass out flyers, letting people know that the law had changed. I bet we could have made contact with at least 50,000 people in that effort to spread the word, but we were intimidated out of it by the city officials who were never prosecuted for these violations of federal law, and it is a violation of federal law to intimidate people out of exercising their rights. It's Title 18, Sections 241 and 242 of the Federal Code. I think this resolution should help to encourage some local jurisdictions to stop violating the rights of innocent people. In the previous hearing, it was brought up that maybe we should wait for the Supreme Court to make a decision. I don't think we should wait. If the Supreme Court overturns a recent Taft decision by ruling against our right to keep and bear arms, I think a different resolution would be highly appropriate for the legislature to take up. That resolution would be an impeachment resolution. For each of the justices who support such treasurer, that would clearly qualify as an act of gross misconduct in office. More recently, just a few miles from my home, there was a young man who had his firearm confiscated by Greenbrier police, and they kept his firearm without legal justification for I believe it was about two or three months. Greenbrier police chief and the officer on duty, Lucas Emberton, were pretty clearly confused about the law, and they violated the rights of this young man by keeping his weapon without legal justification. Lucas Emberton was also verbally abusive to the young man, who was quite respectful. Neither the chief nor the officer were prosecuted for their violation of this man's rights. I thank you
I agree you're absolutely correct. Thank you. Any further questions? Thank you, Mr. Calvert. members we have three other individuals who have signed up to speak for and then we have mr. Tate who has signed up to speak against representative Smith has asked that everybody be heard first so with the committee's permission we will hear the next three individuals who have spoken for and then we will have mr. Tate because we you've as I understand your request was let people who have not spoken speak first and so that takes us a little out of order but as I have any objection from the committee that we handle it this way they still have three minutes all right with that our next individual who has signed up to speak is skip Kelly skip Kelly mr. Kelly is waving his time and the next individual be Richard Bernard mr. Bernard come to the end of the table, please, and identify yourself, and then your three
minutes will begin. My name is Richard Bernard. Thank you, Madam Chair and members, for letting me speak today. I'm here representing the Arkansas Liberty Coalition. While we recognize the struggle that law enforcement has had since the passage of Act 2746 in 2013, we have worked with many chiefs sheriffs and departments across the state to educate them on constitutional carry on wednesday february 7th for city was had a lawsuit filed against it this is in direct response to the jonathan chadwick arrest of november 1st of 2018 with the jamie taft versus arkansas decision from the arkansas court of appeals on october 17th of 2018 Mr. Chadwick should have never been stopped, let alone charged under 5-73-120. With the state not appealing the appeals court decision, the appeals court decision stands as case law. It would take a case in the opposite, an appeals court case, the opposite of what the Taft case was to go to the Supreme Court. This concludes my testimony today, Madam Chair. Any questions? Do we have any questions of Mr.
Bernard? Thank you, Mr. Bernard. Thank you, Madam Chair. The next individual who is signed up to speak for is Tim Loggins. Am I saying that correctly? Mr. Chair, yes, ma'am. I'll wait my time.
Smith here. Okay, thank you. All right. With that, I believe we have had everyone who is here to speak for or against, except for Mr. Tate. And Mr. Tate, at this time, you're recognized. Please identify yourself for the record, and then you may begin.
Sherman Tate, Tate and Associates, Madam Chair, members of the committee, I appreciate the opportunity to come again and speak against this bill. Simply stated, I'm against the bill and urging that you vote this bill down, or this resolution rather down, because it would be a step in the right direction in terms of discouraging any further gun legislation. We have enough gun legislation, and this only proceeds to carry us back to the 1600s and the 1700s. And I would remind the committee that I am a proponent of the Second Amendment. I am a combat veteran. I do own guns, and I don't plan to give them up. But I don't want to walk around out on the street carrying them, nor do I want everybody else to be walking around out on the street carrying weapons. Let's keep them in our houses, and let's protect ourselves, our property, against militia and any intruders. That's Second Amendment. Madam Chair, I would urge the committee to vote no against this House resolution.
Are there any questions of Mr. Tate? Thank you, Mr. Tate. We have one who is not a for or against, and I'm going to go ahead and permit them. As the Sheriff's Association, Mr. David White has requested just information purposes, and I'm going to allow that because I think that was maybe not offered the last time, so we'll let them testify. Please state your name, and you have three minutes to offer your information.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Do we get three minutes apiece, or is that three minutes total? We'll see. Thank you, Madam Chair. My name is Scott Bradley. I'm the director of the Arkansas Sheriff's Association. I just want to make it clear that sheriffs do support our Second Amendment. We always have. We did not take a stand when open carry came about. We stayed completely neutral. We understand that we can't be everywhere all the time. Okay? I just want to make that clear. There's a lot of talk about the Jamie Taft case, and that's the information that we would like to talk about today. Sheriff David White is to my right. And that incident took place in his county. So that's basically why we're here today. Sheriff, would you like to speak?
Yes, ma'am. Thank you, Madam Chair. The Jamie Tapp v. State of Arkansas was a court of appeals case that originated in my county. There's a lot of things going on out there, and I just wanted everybody to understand what exactly happened in that case. We got a call from a business owner right outside of Mountain Harbor, and the business owner is very pro-gun, has several people go in there, open carry, and he has never called us on a gun before ever. On this particular incident, he has a guy enter his business sweating profusely, very nervous, does not make contact with anybody, does not buy anything in the business, and walks out. He makes a second entrance into the building goes to the restroom and that's when the store owner sees a Gun trying to be concealed in his waistband in his back again He does not make contact with anybody he does not buy anything and come to find out he had been kicked out of a vehicle Because he was so geeked out of his head The driver of the vehicle kicked him out right there close the store we get the business owner calls me directly I have two deputies respond to the call they encounter the subject matching the description on the side of the highway initiated the blue lights and made a stop on him at that time mr. Taft didn't even acknowledge the blue lights and tried to keep walking one of the deputies addressed him and he finally turned around reaching his back of his waistband where the gun was the next thing that happens is of course they take action they put him down at gunpoint and take his substantial amount of methamphetamine away from him and his firearm he was also a convicted felon that's that is the case that is not what was heard the suppression is very limited the suppression area was very limited and that's what the case was based on the Court of Appeals was a very limited information in the suppression hearing it was not a jury trial or anything like that but that is the crux of the case that's a case as it happened and it's not a gun case in my opinion it's still not a gun case it was turned into
Yes, ma'am. Thank you. The case was about whether or not we had reasonable suspicion to turn our blue lights on on the stop. That's what the case was. And they ruled that we did not have reasonable suspicion, even though the circuit court judge said we did have enough reasonable suspicion at that time to make the stop. Members, do
Thank you, Sheriff White. Under your department now, after the TAF case, has the TAF case changed the way that you all deal with concealed or unconcealed firearm holders? Concealed carry? Yes, sir. No,
we deal with guns on people all the time, We live in a hunting culture, and we have people that shoot guns. We deal with a lot of people in Montgomery County that have guns. This case is different because of the behavior of the person and the call, and we have a due diligence to answer that call and serve our community. And so when we get calls like that, a suspicious person, you're talking about an individual who called us that sees people, you know, it's right outside of Mountain Harbor. So in the summer, he sees thousands of people come through his business. And knowing that, and he has a pretty good judge of character, we will answer those calls. Absolutely, we will. Thank you. Thank you,
I understand you to say the person reached in the back of his pocket and pulled out this weapon as the officer was attempting to. No, he did not pull it out. He reached
one follow-up question. Thank you very much. Obviously, thank you, Madam Chair. obviously that gave you officer the right to proceed as he did is that right as far
as his use of force policy in his training he absolutely had had right to do that the the the thing was again going back to the the ruling just to clarify what you're trying to ask me is that we didn't have any any right to turn the blue lights on on the side of the highway and get out
with him that's what the ruling was all right I see no other questions represent global be sure you turn your microphone off thank you madam I see no other questions thank y'all very much for coming representative Smith you're recognized to close for your bill no I'd like
ask for a due pass. Thank you. Members, we now have a motion to do pass on the table, which then, at this point, members will be recognized to discuss the motion that is now on the table to do pass on this resolution. Representative Blake, I believe
you're the first one in the queue. You're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chairman. As was agreed to some of the testimonies and the people who testified that this is a non-binding resolution. A non-binding resolution is a motion adopted by a deliberative body that cannot progress into law. A non-binding resolution cannot progress into law. Non-binding resolution gives no clarity. It doesn't hold any weight. It literally changes nothing. So this resolution does nothing but muddy the water. Let's not set a precedent to go around our process to mislead Arkansans and our constituents into thinking that we're actually doing something when we're doing nothing but talking. That is what a non-abiding resolution is. That's what we're doing today with this resolution. We're talking. We're confusing people even further. So respect our process. Let's respect our chamber. If this is something that needs clarification, if this is something that needs to move forward, run a bill. This is a non-binding resolution. People here are showed up to think we are giving clarity to the law that we are going to become a constitutional open carry state. That's not what's happening. Thank you representing Crawford you're
representative Crawford we're not asking questions at this point the representative is closed for his bill okay I just want to clarify that we're discussing the motion which is okay I do pass on his resolution so if you'll limit your discussion to that please okay being a
freshman I wanted to double check on that we are clarifying the law and I think I told you guys the last time we were here I let my conceal and carry lapse I was in a precarious situation and did not know I could protect myself. That's what this does. It just clarifies. Thank you. Representative Scott, you're recognized. Did you? Representative, no problem. Representative Clowney, you're
to make two quick points. The first point is that, as we heard just now and as folks who study the law know, the Taft decision is far from clear. It's a Court of Appeals case. It's about the Fourth Amendment, not the Second Amendment, as we just heard, and it wasn't a case that was decided by the highest court in our state. The Supreme Court tomorrow could overturn it. We'd have to come back and reclarify, I guess, through a different resolution. I don't know what the procedure would be, but we don't know. The Taft decision is far from clear. I would say secondly, even more importantly in my mind, the women and men who protect our communities, whose lives are on the line day in and day out to keep our community safe, do not agree with the assessment of the law as clear as the proponents of this resolution would have us believe. They don't agree with the assessment that Arkansas is a permitless carry state. I went home this weekend and I checked with my local law enforcement because I wanted to know what they had to say. Chief Tabor of the Fayetteville Police Department told me that this would make law enforcement's job harder, not easier. He told me that it would confuse Arkansans about their gun rights. He told me it's bad for law enforcement and it's bad for the citizens of Arkansas. If legislators are interested in clarifying the law, they should introduce a bill. Just FYI, here are a list of resolutions that we're hearing today congratulating Anna Claire Ritchie as a recipient of a Prudential Spirit of Community Award, committing the Bentonville High School Wind Ensemble. Those are things that resolutions are reserved to do. They're important, but they're not bills. If we want to talk about whether Arkansas should be a permitless carry state, let's introduce a bill and have that conversation. This resolution states that Arkansas is a permitless carry state. Law enforcement does not agree with that assessment, so neither can I, so I will vote no. Thank you.
Any further discussion on the motion to do pass? Members, we have the motion to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. The ayes have it. You have passed your resolution. Thank you. Now, members, let's move on. Let's take a look at our calendar because we have another hour and I anticipate we're going to be working so we're going to get caught back up representative rushing House bill 1040 you've indicated that you're probably next week on House bill 1040 I'll let the audience clear so that everyone can hear If y'all could clear as quickly as possible, we'd appreciate it so we could continue on with our meeting. Okay, can everyone hear, I want to make sure everybody on the committee can hear. Alright, House Bill 1040, Representative Rushing is anticipating, is indicated to the chair that this will run next week, so there's some amendments to it, she'll have those filed I think fairly quickly, so watch your computer and watch those amendments. House Bill 1114, Representative Lowry has indicated to me next week will be the time that it will run. House Bill 1240, that is being moved to deferred. Representative Maddox, you have your microphone on is for a particular reason? Or you just like having it on? You like lights?
I would like to make a point of personal privilege at the right moment, if there is a right moment for that. We'll see. We'll see. Thank you. Just let me know
if it's appropriate. And I'll try to remember. How will that work? So House Bill 1240, Representative Petty has asked that that be moved to deferred. Senate Bill 10, Senator Garner, that has been amended, and he is ready to bring that bill back up. and he was ready to bring it back up today, but I did not know how long the resolution discussion would take, so he will be back another day. So be prepared on that one. It has been amended. The amendments have been aggrossed. Yes. House Bill 1279, Representative Gassaway. I anticipate filing amendments any day now. Watch for the amendments there. House Bill 1280, once again, Representative Gassaway. amendments coming soon we're all waiting with bated breath for the amendments we have taken up and have heard Senate bill 14 today house resolution 1013 today that moves us to house bill 1294 without objection the chair would like to set house bill 1294 for special order on Tuesday, February the 26th at 10 o'clock. Do we have any objections? I see no objections, so please mark that. It will be heard that day that it will not be moved off. I anticipate that we will have members from MAD here for that and other individuals who will be coming to testify and the representative asks for that to be on a special order. So mark that down. Tuesday, September 26th at 10 o'clock. Oh, gosh. Well, that would be good, but I don't even know where September came from other than I can't read my own handwriting. My twos look like a seven. February 26th. Senate Bill 116. I have not heard from the Senate sponsor, oh, are you ready to run that today? Okay. Well, Representative Kapp, you're recognized. Go to the end of the table. Members, turn to Senate Bill 116. Senate Bill 116. Yes, Representative Fyke. Madam
Department of Corrections to join me at the end of the table? Yes, ma'am. If there are any members of Department of Corrections, there we go. Okay, members, once again, this is Senate Bill 116, Senate Bill 116.
Representative Kapp, you are recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Senate Bill 116 is specifically in regards to the Federal Prison Litigation Reform Act of 1995, has included an administrative exhaustion requirement for federal claims for nearly 25 years. Arkansas promptly added the exhaustion requirement for claims under federal law in state court. The purpose of the PLRA is not to limit claims which inmates can bring. The purpose is to preserve limited judicial resources for consideration of claims which could not be resolved by using the inmate grievance process. The purpose of the PLRA exhaustion requirement had been described as follows. To allow correctional authorities to address complaints about a program administered by those authorities before being subject to suit. To reduce the volume of litigation to the extent that complaints are satisfactorily resolved in the grievance process. And to improve litigation by the preparation of a useful and thorough administrative record. The PLRA enhances judicial efficiency in federal court, the most common forum for prisoner litigation. Current Arkansas law does the same for state court actions. SB 116 would enhance that efficiency further without interfering with a prisoner's access to the courts to pursue any claim. An informal poll conducted by the ADC legal department or other states find that numerous states have adopted some form of a PLRA style exhaustion requirement for state law claim. claims. What prompted this bill is in Harmon v. Jackson, the Supreme Court case that came down in May of 2018. Inmate Harmon had not exhausted the ADC's grievance process. He brought claims under the Arkansas Civil Rights Act, which were claims that could have been brought in federal court under federal law. Although Jackson's suit would have been dismissed in federal court because he had not exhausted the grievance process because there was no specific exhaustion requirement for the similar state law claims. The court found that the matter had to be remanded to the trial court for proceedings undertaking without benefits which would have provided by the application of the PLRA. And in regards to anything that I may have missed, I'm going to let you take over from
there. Hi, my name is Wendy Kelly. I'm the director of the Arkansas Department of Correction. And again, this doesn't limit inmate lawsuits. It just requires them to go through the grievance process so we have a possibility of addressing their claims without bogging down the state court. Do
you madam chair to either of you who can answer. I was just curious why the statute of limitations Doesn't told during the time the application for administrative remedies is pending. That's struck through language. Just curious about the reason for that Our grievance procedure requires that
it be finished in a certain number of days I think it's 76, but I'm not sure off the top of my head, but we only have some they have to bring their grievance within so many days and then we have five days to answer at the first level, 20 days at the second level and third days at the third level so it's not a lengthy process that would require a tolling
same question Madam Chair Representative Blake you're recognized for your question does this thank you Madam Chair does this legislation reduce the rights of people who are incarcerated to bring claims? Does it, is it, are, with statute of limitations, are we saying that they have to exhaust all other, what was the wording, administrative remedies, does that fall within that same statute
I was referring to. It's a fairly short process, and what this does is simply require them to use the grievance procedure before they file in state court. It's been the law in federal court since 1995, I believe, and we have a very robust grievance procedure. There's about 2,000 step one grievances filed by inmates each month throughout the system. Those are cut in half when you look at which ones aren't resolved and go on to step two. And that's cut again to about 350 a month is the average of appeals that are filed to the third and final level. So the grievance procedure does work, and it is required in the federal court system. It simply isn't required in the state court system. So they still can go to court. It just requires them to use the grievance procedure first to give us an opportunity to resolve it at the
agency level. You're recognized for a follow-up. Thank you, Madam Chair. Now, the definition of an incarcerated person here on, what's that, page 2, line 8 says, is being held in custody for a trial or sentencing. So we are, those people who are being held in custody, who haven't had their trial yet, they still have to go through the grievance process before they
can file. The bill specifically says that this does not apply to these particular types of proceedings in regards to petitions for writ of habeas corpus and things of that nature. And I know that those were concerns that were brought in regards to some other entities that they had. So individuals that are incarcerated and that needed to file those type of administrative remedies, they would still have the ability to do that. So there is exceptions built in
Madam Chair. I think the real question is, what is the, is there, does the bill have a length of time for which the administrative remedies must be complied with, 60 or 90 days or something like that, comparable to the federal statute? The bill
does not, and the federal statute simply requires that we have a grievance procedure and that it's fair and that we follow it. So if an inmate attempts to use the grievance procedure and we do something to thwart his ability or her ability to use it, then the court doesn't apply that barrier when they go to court. The same thing would a judge in state court if an inmate went in and said, I tried to file a grievance and this is the reason I wasn't able to do it, then they wouldn't apply this because the requirement that they use the administrative remedies requires us to have them available to them, if that makes sense. I don't think there's any judge that's going to say, well, because she says she had it available even though he didn't get to use it, I'm going to not let him go forward with this claim. But this is requiring them to use the same process that's required to get into federal court in order to get into state court, except with regard to criminal matters. Our grievance procedure has nothing to do with their criminal cases. They don't have to file a grievance for that, and this makes clear that that's not what this is intended to do. This is if they're going to sue because they didn't get to go to rec five days that week, or if they're going to sue us over, I'm trying to think of some of the things that I get sued over, which is about 10 times a week. There are a lot of lawsuits out there. This is not going to stop that. This is just going to put the rules the same for state or federal court. Representative Gassaway, you're recognized.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Ms. Kelly, my experience has been what I have seen with these cases is that most of them at the federal level get summarily dismissed and pretty quickly because they failed to state a claim. They failed to include sufficient facts, whatever the case may be, but there are occasionally, I believe, legitimate claims that are made, civil rights violations that are made by inmates, and so my concern would be that if this requires an exhaustion of administrative remedies before you can bring a claim, if someone brings a claim that may be legitimate, but for whatever reason they failed to exhaust their administrative remedies and they bring that claim in state court, does that give the circuit court then the power to dismiss their claim as legitimate as it may be because they failed to exhaust their administrative remedies through the prison system? If we
establish that the remedies were available for them and they simply failed to go forward with them, yes, this would allow the court to dismiss those for failure to exhaust their administrative remedies.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Just for clarification, just to make sure I understand, I ran a bill the other day that was trying to give, and we passed it, but it gave the Department of Corrections or Community of Corrections the authority to issue administrative directives to transitional facilities. And the point was that even though they were not part of the Community of Corrections or Department of Corrections, they were still housing inmates that were still in the custody of the state of Arkansas. And so I just want to make sure in this process that those transitional houses are reentry facilities, that that protection is in place there for the state as it relates to this bill. Could you address that for me, please? Does that make sense? Unfortunately, I'm not going to
be able to give you a clear answer because the transitional houses are operated by the Department of Community Corrections, and I'm not familiar with their grievance procedure. This was for those that are incarcerated in the Arkansas Department of Corrections. We do have a grievance procedure. It was reviewed and is reviewed by federal courts quite often, actually. It has to be clear. Everything has to be spelled out in the policy. And this is, again, simply requiring them to use it to get into state court the same way they have to use it to get into federal court. Okay, thank
you for that answer. And I think that's where the community of correction was trying to go, is to make sure that they had things in place to protect that inmate's basic individual rights as state and federal law. So I appreciate your comments on
that. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Scott, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. Just a couple concerns. I'm strongly against us limiting the inmates' rights, and I think I'm – is there a solution on how you're going to let the inmates know about the new process? And also, my question is, and I think Representative Gassaway kind of hit on it, I just want to know a straight. Will this limit inmates being able to bring a case before federal court because they have exhausted whatever administrative or whatever their grievance procedure is there? Y'all would be the person that deems if someone has the ability to bring a lawsuit for whatever reason against the state for, like you said, you get like 1,000 or so cases a month. No, ma'am, if I understand your question correctly, this does not have anything to do with cases they bring in federal court. The Prison Litigation Reform Act already exists and governs federal court. This would add the same exhaustion requirement to get into state court.
the first question, but she didn't answer it. Okay, you want to ask it again? I'm sorry. I'm sorry just for more clarity how will the inmates be notified of this process we give anytime we make any change to the grievance policy we post it for 30 days for comments before it becomes finalized we post it in on every bulletin board throughout the department and for inmates that are in restrictive housing they're given a copy of it and the same thing would apply if this law is passed then we would incorporate it into the policy and we would give them all a copy of it they get 30 days notice if that answers your
question i'll come back to you i've got some others in the queue i think representative clowney i'll come back to you and then representative scott i'll come back to you
representing clowney you're recognized thank you madam chair um just to follow up on representative gasway's question if um one of these circumstances arises where somebody's case is dismissed for failure failure to exhaust Is there anything that precludes them from exhausting those administrative remedies and then coming back to court once that's been done? This does not. This
simply says they have to exhaust the administrative remedies. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Scott, you're recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think I'm also concerned about the reading level of inmates in the state, and I think statistics show that the average reading level might be a third grade. And so what about the inmates who can't read since it's just going to be posted for 30 days? Do you have a way or something in mind to kind of make sure that they understand the process? I think that's fair if we're going to change this. It's generally speaking what happens is it's posted. If there's an inmate that has difficulty, if they let staff know, then it would be explained to them. But we have tutors available at all of the institutions. We have the school district is available. We have GED graduates every year. We have college courses being offered throughout the institutions. So there are a lot of inmates that do have the ability to read and, in fact, excel in the education system. But if I post it in this room today and there's someone in here that doesn't know how to read unless they tell me I'm not going to know that to offer them additional assistance. But the intent would never be to not let them know about the change.
And so let me just say that I'm familiar with how this process works. When I was prosecutor, I, along with the sheriff and other— Representative Gassaway, do you have a question? We'll get back to
to your question? It provides context to the question. All right, I'll let you proceed. All right, thank you. And so when I was prosecutor, I, along with several other county officials, have been sued in federal court probably more than once, if I recall, by prisoners, and those cases were summarily dismissed by the federal courts for a multitude of reasons. But I go back to, and I want to echo on Representative Clowney's question, which is that if someone does not exhaust their administrative remedies and they have a legitimate case, so a case where a prisoner is beaten without cause, and they have a legitimate civil rights case and they fail to exhaust their administrative remedies, and I think this goes to Representative Clowney's question, there's nothing in this bill that says that the circuit court judge and state court has to dismiss the case either with or without prejudice, and if a circuit court judge makes the decision to dismiss the case with prejudice, that could potentially cause them to not be able to refile, and so can you speak to that and how you believe that will operate under this bill as it's presently written? Well, while I used to
be in the Attorney General's office for about 16 years, I'm not anymore, and so I don't defend these cases, but whatever the circuit court judge decided would either be appealed or not appealed. But we have policies within the department where every use of force is reviewed. It has to be reported to our internal affairs department. A file is opened, it's then investigated or reviewed and sent back to the warden, the deputy warden, and I sign off on every one of those. I don't know how to answer your question about, except to say that if such a thing were to happen, there would be consequences taken regardless of any lawsuit. You're recognized for
your follow-up. Would you be opposed to adding some language that would give the judge discretion to dismiss these cases without prejudice so that they could be refiled in the event a prisoner had failed to exhaust all their administrative remedies? Are you
you guys. Okay, with permission of the chair, Senate Bill 116 has been withdrawn for the present time and look to be some amendments to come back to. Thank you. All right, moving on down to our calendar, House Bill 1325. The representative has indicated he would like to possibly run that next week. He may try to run it Thursday, but I think when we move over to Thursday, you're going to see we have a number of things for this Thursday. Senate Bill 82. Representative Kapp, are you handling that for Senator Clark? I can't remember. Would you like
I thought that might be your will. You also have a couple of other bills coming up, I'm assuming that we want to move those off to another day? Okay. I'll be happy to do that. Sorry. On the next page, on page two, we have, and I'll take about five of these all in a row, House Bill 1379, House Bill 1380, House Bill 1384, House Bill 1389, and House Bill 1403. They're all together. those will be, the bill sponsors have indicated they will be ready for those on Thursday. Correct, Representative Fite? That is correct. Thank you, Madam Chair. Okay. Thursday of this week. House Bill 1411, Representative Birch has been contacting me about that. I've been trying to give her a fairly good date, certain, because I think she has a witness that she would like to bring, so we're anticipating next Tuesday. I'm not sure her witness could be here Thursday. Senate Bill 152, Senator Irvin, I'm sure she will come when she can on that one. Senate Bill 183, Representative Kapp, are you handling that one also? Senate Bill 183 from Senator Clark to privet certain registered sex offenders from holding a position of trust. Okay, that's not yours. We have heard Senate Bill 227 this morning. House Bill 1126, I'm anticipating that will be Tuesday. I've indicated that. Bless that representative's heart. I have moved him several different times, but I'm going to try to get him in on Tuesday. House Bill 1029, House Bill 1029, I will try to find out from the representative when he will be prepared to run that. Moving down to Senate Bill 91 and Senate Bill 86 are both Senator Clark's bills. Is anyone in this committee handling those? I've not heard from the senator, so we'll come back to that one. Senate Bill 8, Senator Garner. I know he is ready to run that one. I just told him he just couldn't do it today. Then we have the last one is Senate Bill 267, and I've not heard from Senator Stubblefield. Is there anyone in the committee handling that one? Okay. Well,
Okay. Yes, you are. I'd forgotten about that. I'm sorry. Thank you for reminding me. Yes, Senate Bill 152, put that on for Thursday. I'm anticipating we will be meeting for two hours Thursday, starting at 10 o'clock, and we'll go into session later. Representative rushing. I'm handling
Senate Bill 183 for Senator Clark. It will probably be better Thursday, but if it worked better for next week, I'd run it next week, too. I think we're going
to have two hours, so if you'll be prepared Thursday, we'll get there. I'm not sure that Representative Fight and Representative McCullough will take all of that time, so if you'll be prepared on that one, we'll go with that one. Members, I think that that takes us through our calendar. Now, don't think we've come to the end of our day and it's all wonderful and great because guess what? The Senate is actually starting to send things over. So please watch. You can go on to the computer, see what's in their Senate, what they've passed over, kind of try to keep ahead of those kinds of things. Also for new members, there is a tab on your computer that says recently filed bills if you will watch those you'll get a pretty good idea which ones are heading toward the house judiciary I appreciate your hard work today I appreciate your attention I appreciate you letting us go back and pick up to where mr. Johnson I felt were the proper place to begin and the resolution I appreciate your attention to that for your calendars Please mark your personal calendars next Wednesday evening on the 20th. The House Judiciary will be having a dinner, so there will be more information coming. That will be next Wednesday on the 20th. I will refrain, but once again, find your best bib and tucker or your best blue jeans. I know of no other business before this committee today. prepare to come on Thursday at 10 o'clock and prepare for two hours and with that this meeting is adjourned
HB1040 Rushing TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS HOT CHECK LAW.
HB1114 Lowery TO CREATE THE PARENT-CHILD INTRASTATE RELOCATION ACT; TO PROVIDE FACTORS FOR A COURT TO CONSIDER WHEN DETERMINING WHETHER OR NOT A CHANGE OF A CHILD’S PRINCIPAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE IS IN THE CHILD’S BEST INTEREST.
HB1240 Petty TO CREATE AN ACT KNOWN AS "SARAH'S LAW".
SB10 T. Garner PROHIBITING A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER FROM PARTICIPATING IN CERTAIN HALLOWEEN-RELATED ACTIVITIES.
HB1279 Gazaway TO AMEND THE OFFENSE OF SEXUALLY GROOMING A CHILD.
HB1280 Gazaway CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF PUBLIC INTOXICATION.
SB14 L.Chesterfield CONCERNING THE FEE TO ATTEND A VICTIM IMPACT PANEL THAT IS REQUIRED BY LAW OF ANY PERSON CONVICTED OF DRIVING OR BOATING WHILE INTOXICATED, REFUSAL TO SUBMIT TO A CHEMICAL TEST, OR POSSESSION OF ALCOHOL BY A MINOR.
5:52 - 14:3931 segments6 speakers
Representative Lanny Fite introduced SB 14, proposing to raise the fee charged to individuals required to attend a victim-impact panel for DUI-related offenses by $10, citing support from Mothers Against Drunk Driving and the need for additional outreach funding.
[6:10][6:25]
Committee members raised concerns about protecting the privacy of minors mandated to attend the program, which Fite assured would be maintained under existing law.
[7:32][8:02][8:26][8:33]
Following the amendment, Representative Fyke moved to do pass SB 14 as amended, the motion carried with all votes in favor, and the bill was enacted.
[12:50]
The chair, Rep. Carol Dalby, called a motion to limit each member’s remarks to three minutes, which was seconded, debated briefly, and adopted unanimously (aye vote).
[14:47][15:18][15:42][15:49]
HB1294 Della Rosa RESTORING PROSECUTORIAL DISCRETION IN THE RESOLUTION OF DRIVING OR BOATING WHILE INTOXICATED CASES.
SB116 B. Ballinger REQUIRING AN INMATE IN THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO FIRST EXHAUST ALL AVAILABLE ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES AS A CONDITION PRECEDENT TO FILING A CLAIM UNDER THE ARKANSAS CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1993 OR ANY OTHER STATE LAW.
57:12 - 4:15
Representative Sarah Capp introduced Senate Bill 116, explaining that it would extend the Prison Litigation Reform Act’s administrative-exhaustion requirement to Arkansas state-court civil-rights claims in order to preserve judicial resources and encourage resolution through the Department of Corrections grievance process.
[58:07][58:18][58:52][59:28]
Committee members raised numerous concerns-including why the statute of limitations is not tolled during the grievance period, whether the bill would limit inmates’ rights or affect pre-trial detainees, the lack of a set time-frame for exhaustion, how inmates would be notified of the new requirement, and the potential for courts to dismiss valid claims without prejudice-receiving answers from Director Wendy Kelly (Jamie Scott) that the grievance process is short, already robust, and that the bill does not alter federal-court procedures, though it would allow dismissal for failure to exhaust administrative remedies.
[1:01:11][1:01:29][1:01:40][1:01:55][1:02:03][1:02:14][1:02:29][1:04:35][1:04:53][1:04:58][1:06:33][1:07:09][1:07:23][1:10:47][1:11:04][1:11:14][1:11:26][1:11:36][1:11:45][1:11:52][1:12:11][1:12:21][1:12:44]
After the discussion, the chair announced that Senate Bill 116 was being withdrawn for the time being pending further amendments.
[1:15:54][1:16:02]
HB1325 Lowery TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING CUSTODY OF A CHILD.
SB82 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING REPORTS FILED WITH THE COURT BEFORE A HEARING HELD UNDER THE ARKANSAS JUVENILE CODE OF 1989.
HB1367 Capp CONCERNING THE SENTENCING PROCEDURE FOR A PERSON CONVICTED OF DRIVING OR BOATING WHILE INTOXICATED.
HB1369 Capp CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF FAILURE TO APPEAR; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PENDING CHARGE".
SB109 Irvin TO AMEND THE OFFENSE OF BATTERY IN THE FIRST DEGREE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
4:15 - 2:36
Representative Murdoch introduced SB 109, which would elevate the offense of battery against police officers to a Class Y felony (and to a Class B felony for corrections officers) and includes an emergency clause.
[4:45]
The chair reported that no members had signed up to speak for or against the bill and opened the floor for discussion, which yielded none.
[4:52]
Representative Tosh moved to do pass the bill as amended, the committee voted aye with no opposition and the measure was adopted.
[4:52][5:20]
HB1379 C. Fite TO RECONCILE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE OFFENSES OF DOMESTIC BATTERING IN THE FIRST DEGREE AND BATTERY IN THE FIRST DEGREE; AND TO INCREASE THE PENALTIES FOR BATTERY OFFENSES UNDER CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES.
HB1380 C. Fite CREATING A PRIVILEGE OF COMMUNICATION BETWEEN A VICTIM OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AND THE PERSONNEL OF A DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SHELTER OR CENTER; AND TO MAKE CONFIDENTIAL COMMUNICATIONS BETWEEN A VICTIM AND A VICTIM ADVOCATE.
HB1384 C. Fite TO CLARIFY WHEN THE DIVISION OF YOUTH SERVICES MAY RELEASE INFORMATION ABOUT A JUVENILE TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
HB1389 C. Fite TO AMEND STATUTES CONCERNING THEFT OF PROPERTY; AND TO CLARIFY THAT A BACKUP DEEP CYCLE BATTERY IS UTILITY PROPERTY.
HB1403 McCullough CONCERNING THE SENTENCE ENHANCEMENT AVAILABLE AGAINST A PERSON WHO COMMITS CERTAIN OFFENSES IN THE PRESENCE OF A CHILD; AND TO ADD CERTAIN OFFENSES ELIGIBLE FOR THE SENTENCE ENHANCEMENT.
HB1411 Burch CONCERNING THE DEFINITION OF "MOTOR VEHICLE" UNDER THE OMNIBUS DWI OR BWI ACT; AND CONCERNING A TEST FOR BLOOD ALCOHOL CONTENT WHEN A MOTOR VEHICLE OR BOATING ACCIDENT OCCURS.
SB183 A. Clark TO PROHIBIT CERTAIN REGISTERED SEX OFFENDERS FROM HOLDING A POSITION OF PUBLIC TRUST.
SB227 M. Pitsch CONCERNING THE RECORDING AND INDEXING OF COURT PROCEEDINGS; AND TO PERMIT THE ELECTRONIC AND INTERNET-BASED INDEXING OF CERTAIN COURT DOCUMENTS.
2:36 - 0:28
Senator Mathew Pitsch outlined that SB 227 would permit circuit clerks to create electronic alphabetical indexes of court judgments when they have scanning capability, without mandating the practice.
[2:48]
The chair noted there were no members signed up to speak for or against the measure and opened the floor for questions, none were offered.
[3:14]
Representative Crawford moved to do pass the bill, the committee voted aye with no opposition and the measure was adopted.
[3:34]
SB91 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE RESUMPTION OF SERVICES FOR CERTAIN PARENTS.
SB8 T. Garner TO PROHIBIT A REGISTERED SEX OFFENDER FROM RECORDING A PERSON UNDER FOURTEEN (14) YEARS OF AGE IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO PROHIBIT THE UNLAWFUL USE OF A RECORDING OF A PERSON UNDER FOURTEEN (14) YEARS OF AGE ONLINE.
SB177 T. Garner CONCERNING SEX OFFENDER REGISTRATION REQUIREMENTS.
0:28 - 1:21:52252 segments37 speakers
Senator Trent Garner explained that the bill would update the code to require electronic transmission of sex-offender data to the Arkansas Crime Information Center, removing outdated written-form requirements and imposing no new burden on law enforcement.
[0:35]
The chair sought questions and Garner clarified that the data is sent to the ACIC, not to offenders.
[1:05]
After brief discussion, Representative Tosh moved to pass SB 177, no opposition was recorded and the motion carried, enacting the bill.
[1:39][2:13]
SB267 G.Stubblefield TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT A PERSON WITH A LICENSE TO CARRY A CONCEALED HANDGUN WHO FAILS TO FILE A RENEWAL APPLICATION BEFORE THE EXPIRATION DATE PAYS A LATE FEE.
HB1009 Dotson PROHIBITING CERTAIN SEX OFFENDERS FROM ENTERING UPON A SCHOOL CAMPUS.
HB1059 Pilkington CONCERNING THE USE OF PHYSICAL FORCE IN SELF-DEFENSE OR IN THE DEFENSE OF OTHERS.
HB1307 Dotson PERMITTING A BANK OR BANKING INSTITUTION TO UTILIZE THE SMALL CLAIMS DIVISION OF A DISTRICT COURT.
HB1373 Della Rosa CONCERNING CRIMINAL HISTORY AND CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS; AND CONCERNING THE RESULTS OF A CRIMINAL HISTORY OR CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECK WHEN A PERSON HAS A LAWFULLY SEALED CRIMINAL HISTORY OR BACKGROUND.