The chair introduced a draft amendment to Rule 8 that would require a “motion to expunge” to be listed on the agenda, prompting Senator Elliott to ask how the notation would appear for bills such as SB 1020 and receive clarification that a line indicating the expunge motion would be added two days before the meeting.
[1:41][2:13][2:43][3:00][3:16][3:50][4:42][4:56][5:16][5:28]
A motion to adopt the revised rules was made, seconded and carried unanimously, formally adopting the rules as presented.
[5:35]
The chair opened the segment by introducing agency representatives, beginning with Ted Thomas of the Arkansas Public Service Commission, who explained the commission’s rate-case authority, consumer-complaint handling and pipeline-safety responsibilities.
[7:38][7:46][8:16][8:50]
Chris Hallett of the Employee Benefits Division then presented the division’s membership, fiscal position and cost-saving measures, highlighting a $70 million reduction in claims and $5 million in administrative savings.
[9:51][10:25][10:56][11:29][12:00][12:32][13:08][13:40][14:14][14:48]
Welcome to the first meeting of the Senate Insurance and Commerce Committee. Appreciate all of you for being here. And I'm told that they're still having a slight issue with some of the sound. I don't know if it's better in the back or not, but bear with us. We're going to keep working until they get this new technology all in order. But I want to welcome everybody here and also just say that right off the bat that I'm pretty excited about the committee. As you know, we do have some membership changes. Those of you that work with the committee, I couldn't ask for a better vice chair in Senator Bledsoe. Having our number one here is excellent. And I believe, if I'm not mistaken, we may have one of the strongest female committees in here. In fact, I want a little associate membership of the Women's Caucus over this deal. But I'm excited about that. And I will tell you, especially for all of those of you that are here that represent the agencies and those of you that work with this committee on issues, you have probably one of the most experienced and seasoned committees that's here of everybody that's here. And so I'm excited about that. Very excited about my friend Senator Teague being back on this committee. We thought putting you here would allow you to get out quicker, but apparently you like on the other end. I don't know what you're talking about. Well, yeah, but we do appreciate everyone. We're not going to belabor this and we'll get right into the issues that are here. I'd like to first talk about the committee rules. For those of you that are new to the committee, we have operated with rules in place. A draft of those is in each of your folders. Rule number eight was expanded to clarify how notification is given if a bill receiving do not pass motion is to again be considered. This was apparently an issue the staff has discussed some. We did not have a necessary problem with it. I think there may have been some problems in other committees. So take a look at that. One of the issues that has come up in the past few sessions, just to clarify, if you've been on a committee that does it, But we do request a written amendment to be able to handle something here in committee so that there's no confusion. So if you want to take a look at that. In fact, what I would like to do is, if no one has a question or problem with that, is just to ask for you to please give us a motion for the adoption. Yes, Senator, make sure and push your – and I will remind the committee as we get started, you're live streaming now on the committee. And I know we like to have fun and enjoy each other. But just remember that when you have people that are going to be viewing this from all over, that they may not necessarily get the humor. And so let's make sure to try to keep our comments focused on the issues in hand. Senator Elliott? Well,
I guarantee you it's difficult to make fun of expungement. So what I'm wondering about that, where it said on number eight, it shall reflect a motion to expunge, the agenda shall. In what way? Will it just outright say this is a motion to expunge, or what will it say?
Well, what was explained to me is that the committee would actually put that on the agenda so that there would be some notification of the public and of the members that there's going to be a motion to expunge that. Apparently this happened, and staff, I'll ask you to chime in if you want, especially if I make a mistake with it. But in the past, there had been some of the bills that did not get a due pass recommendation. And then time passed, maybe even a good amount of time had passed. And suddenly then somebody walks in someday, says, has a motion to expunge. And all of a sudden, this is live again in the committee. Nobody knows about this except those of you that are in the room. and suddenly you have this thing then pass out of the committee and get on the floor. And I think I've explained that appropriately. Again, we have not had that issue in our committee. In fact, I ask a lot of questions, Senator Elliott, about why was the need for this and what's going on with it. My perception after thinking about it is that, well, we've never had a problem. We've always tried to give proper notice anyway, and so if it's a matter of trying to get the committees to have this squared up for each other, then I'm okay with you. But just one last little thing I
just want to be sure. I'm thinking now in terms of the public understanding. Say if I've had a do not pass and I want to put it back on the agenda and I come to you or staff, whoever it might be, to put it on the agenda. Say it's, you know, insurance for all. So that's the, or it's Senate Bill 1020. If I put Senate Bill 1020 on there, right by that, is there going to be a notation about motion to expunge? That's the main thing I want to know. Senator Elliott,
as I understand it, there would actually be a line on the agenda that says this, you know, the committee will consider a motion to expunge the vote on this. So it would be out on the agenda two days before the committee would actually meet. That's great.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Right. And you had the same questions I had. I was unaware that they had had a problem with some of that happening, but I think it was all pretty easy for us to quickly see how that could become a problem if that was the nature of the way it was handled. So with that, I have a motion to approve the rules from Senator English, to have a second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, no. So the rules are adopted and with that I want to go right into introduction of state agency personnel. There should be a list of staff contacts and agency contacts and important dates for the 19th session attached to the right side of your meeting folders so take a look at that as well and of course at any time we all have good communication but as you know anytime that you need something please let us know i would ask i think that staff just for the committee members i think staff we have all of your cell phone numbers many of you i've already communicating with but especially due to the fact that they have the committee's now live streaming do your very best to be here if you can at 10 a.m i'm going to start as soon as we have a quorum present and so that we can handle our business efficiently. But if you do have a new number or something's changed, let us know so that we can properly get in touch with you. I want to start. We do have some agency heads, directors, and personnel that are here this morning, and we're going to give them an opportunity to greet us. There may be some changes on their staff, some new people that are going to be serving in different roles. And so the first one that I have on my list here is Mr. Ted Thomas. Ted, if you would come up and get you a place here, and if you have staff that's going to be with you. I think Donna Gray is your director. I don't know if she's with you here. It looks like she might not be able to attend now that I see this. So if you would, please state your name and who you represent for the record, and I appreciate you
being here this morning. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Ted Thomas, chairman of the Arkansas Public Service Commission. Normally, you'll see a lot of Donna Gray, who's our executive director, with general staff. We have an arrangement where general staff is a separate party, like the utility, the Attorney General, the industrial customers, and other folks. But over here, that separation doesn't exist. We'll speak with the same voice, Donna and I. Of course, Donna is in the role that John Bethel used to be in, so you all are familiar with him. Of course, our main issue is we have a regulated monopoly model where the utility has a service territory. In exchange for that service territory, the state sets their rates. That's our primary responsibility. We do that through a proceeding called a rate case. All of that's online. That is our main responsibility. We also deal with consumer complaints. So if you have folks who have issues with the utilities, we have a staff of professionals that deal with those issues. Two other kind of, they're all important but less obvious than our rate-making authority, is we do pipeline safety regulation for intrastate natural gas lines. And we also do tax assessment for the utilities and common carriers, trains, trucks, barges, and we certify that to the county. We don't touch the money. We certify that to the counties who collect the money and our utility assessments to DF&A who collect the money. That's the tax division. They have a separate appropriation. So that's kind of the waterfront that we cover. I'd be glad to take any questions. All right, members, any questions?
for Mr. Thomas. Seeing none, that's a nice way to start. So thank you for being here. We do appreciate it and look forward to working with you. Next person that we have on our list this morning is Chris Hallett, who is the Director of Employee Benefits Division. For those of you that are new and also want to say, Senator Johnson, welcome to you. It's nice to have you on the committee as a new member. But Chris is with Employee Benefits Division. Just for sake of a little history for some of us here, as you know, a few years ago, we actually legislature abolished the board and started over at EBD. And Chris is actually a new appointee and has been a fresh face there. And we have not had nearly the issues that we were experiencing in calls from teachers around the state. And so we do appreciate the work that you're doing and the hard work of the board. And if you would, please state your name and who you represent for the record and you're recognized. Sure. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee members. My name is Chris Hallett. I'm
the executive director for the Employee Benefits Division under DF&A. We basically, as you addressed, Mr. Chair, we have about 155,000 in our membership. They're consisting of the state employees of about 30,000 strong as far as number of contracts and about 66,000 on the public school side. So it's about a third, two-thirds mix when you consider that. Today actually is my 32nd month on the job and I'm very proud of what we've done with some of the low-hanging fruit and making some of the modifications that we felt would put the path on better fiscal flushness and some sound actions. Of course, it's always a work in progress, and we do take insight and input from the Senate and as well as the House Insurance and Commerce, and there's been a, going back to 2012, there's been a task force created, and we'll see what that can do to help, I guess, guide the plan and some decisions there. Presently, we're reaping some benefits of some early decisions. We've had the one rate increase right after I arrived in 16. But aside from that, we've been able to hedge against inflationary costs on the medical and pharmacy side and have a fiscal flushness that we're about the top fifth highest or fifth best position on the ASC side and on public schools since the EBD took over that in 2003, fall of 2003 and 2004 were the best fiscal flushness that we've ever seen on that plan. And as you're aware, we are self-funded, so from that we collect premiums from the members, and then we have the state and district contributions that come in on behalf of them as the employer to our funds. So it's like basically a checkbook with about five zeros on the end of it, and from that checkbook we pay the claims associated with that. So as of the end of last year, we're about $13 million net allocated resources on ASC, and we have about right at $61 million on PSC. And that's after all the allocations set aside for premium funding and such for the plan year 2019. from that standpoint we're from 16 to 17 we're down we were down about about 22 million dollars in claims without a degradation of any of the services or provisions provided to to the participants and as of last July we're down about another 50 million total so when you go from May of 16 to present, we're about $70 million in a decrease in the overall claims cost. Administrative costs, we have some significant cost savings through bundling costs using the buying power of the plan and buying down the administrative costs. To put it in a frame of reference, we've had, when I walked in the door, we had about 14 vendors or I like calling them partners, vendors, just kind of semantics, but from that partners, and we've been able to kind of shed our partnerships. We have a bundled service contract that combines actuarial medical management, the carrier contract, and there's some light ACA work that we do there. We started that. We implemented that last fall. It went into effect 1-1, and we were spending about $40 million dollars a year in administrative costs for those same five services. And I'm proud to say we have that down about, well, $35.7 million a year. So we've saved right at $5 million. I have a projection that we'll probably be able to squeeze a little bit more out of that. And the previous comments, Mr. Chair, I think one of the concerns or one of the pieces that I think is noteworthy have mentioned is having fees associated or some of their dollars on the line if they're not able to deliver from the vendor performance reporting piece. So we have 25 percent of their money of that 35 million be up for grabs every year if they're not falling in the agreement with their contract. So that's significant. I don't believe that's ever been done. And from that, I'll stand from any questions. All right. Thank you.
That's a good overview. Members, do you have any questions for Chris at this time? Chris, we do appreciate it, and there may be some questions that come up with some legislation later, so we'll be working on wellness, sir. All right. Thank you very, very much. Members, next on our list is actually Mike Preston, who I believe has set But Amy Fetcher, Executive Vice President of Operations. And, Ms. Amy, you are recognized. And if you would state your name and your position, who you represent for the record.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. Mike Preston, the Executive Director, does regret that he could not be here today. He's a new father and has a son that's about a week old. That's wonderful. And I think his wife had other duties for him today. Understandable. He's tending to family matters. I am the executive vice president at AEDC, as well as the chief transformation officer for Governor Hutchinson. I have both roles. As Governor Hutchinson themed his inauguration this week, Together for Success, we really see economic development in that same lens. It takes all of us. It's a team sport. It takes the legislature, the governor, the agency, as well as the local communities to bring the companies here. Our focus is growing jobs and the economy. We help recruit businesses and industry to the state as well as working to support existing businesses. Our largest division in the agency is the one that supports existing businesses throughout the state. We also work with local communities to help them prepare for companies and the things they need to do locally before they work with the company that they're trying to recruit. We also are always looking globally and recruiting there, and we have three foreign offices currently in Europe, in China, and in Japan. One of our most famous divisions right now is our film office within AEDC, and many of you may have started watching the HBO series True Detective last Sunday night. The third season was filmed entirely in the state of Arkansas, around Fayetteville and in Northwest, and the storyline is written. The whole story is in Arkansas, and many movies have had their scene in Arkansas, but they didn't film here, and we worked really hard to make sure that this one was filmed here. The producer tells us of the three seasons, this is the best season, And if the first two episodes were any indication of that, it looks like it will be. In 2015, our agency was one of the first agencies to experience transformation. In a special session in May of that year, we merged the Department of Rural Services and the Arkansas Science and Technology Authority into AEDC. And it's been a really successful merger for us. Since 2015, AEDC has returned over $6 million in general revenue to the state. We, along with other agencies, have been a pilot for what transformation is going to look like statewide. As for jobs and the economy, when the governor took office four years ago, we now have 83,000 more people employed than we did in 2015. And we have worked over 400 projects at the agency with 16,000 new jobs announced, representing $8 billion in capital investment in the state. We have done a lot of good work over the last four years, but there is a lot more to do. One of our focuses right now, when you get unemployment down to 3.5%, then employers are screaming for workers, and we're looking to help them improve their labor participation rate and make sure we have the workers for the companies coming into the state. So with that, I'm happy to take any questions from the
committee. I believe if he makes it back to his seat that Senator Teague had a question. He must have drank a lot of Coke already this morning. Yeah. Senator Teague, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. Amy, tell me what you guys do for rural Arkansas. I know you have the Rural Development Commission, and I appreciate everything they do. Lots of funds flow out to rural Arkansas. I appreciate that. But I don't see you trying to get 25 jobs in Murfreesboro or 50 jobs in Mount Ida. Do you have any programs that try to recruit smaller jobs? We don't need 1,000 technology jobs, but we need 25 welders or 50 assemblers or something like that. Do you do anything along those lines?
We have a couple divisions at the agency that try to focus on the rural communities, rural services, as you mentioned, giving out small community development grants as well as our community development division that works with those. Sometimes it is harder to attract in the more rural areas the businesses, but it is a focus for the agency. So I've never
heard of y'all coming to somebody and saying, we have 25 welding jobs or 50 jobs. You want to come say we have 400 or something. But I'm working on legislation that would address that issue, but it would be easier if we just did it, figured out a way to do more for rural Arkansas. So, and I'm not being ugly. I've just, those are my people. And there's got to be businesses that need to find a place to put a building with 25 people. So, anyway, thank you for your tolerance, Mr. Chairman. Very well. Senator Elliott.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I suppose because I'm a Southwesterner like Senator Teague here, I really had some of this questions similar. How much money, how much funds do you have dedicated toward rural development? Do you know how many millions of dollars you have dedicated to? In the Rural
Services Division? Yeah, yes. I believe we get $500,000 per year of general revenue is what the state has in the budget for that. And then formerly we had the GIF money coming there, and that's no longer there. But it's right around a million dollars total from various funding sources. We have some coming from the Game and Fish and the Unpaved Roads Program
and things like that. And I think that's significant in that it's a small amount of money for the state to be primarily rural. And that's a concern I have as well because in so many parts of our state, even if we could recruit some big company, there's no need to have them there. So I really wanted to put on your radar because I've talked with Mike about how we can expand our economy through the arts and many of the rural areas. And we have created, and some people in this room, Senator Urban and who else? And Senator Teague are all a part of that. And everybody else is invited to join. But I really wish AEDC would think about this in terms of, you know, there is, I don't know, there's Nashville, Arkansas. What in the world is it we can do? And how do our policies need to change so that we are not just chasing the next big box whatever? Because that's just not what real Arkansas is. And so that's what I really want. I hope Senator Teague's legislation is along that line. because one point whatever million dollars is not even remotely close to what we need to do, I don't think. So have you ever had in your mind what it would take or how we do need to change policies so that we are addressing rural Arkansas?
Well, and some of the other programs throughout the agency can be utilized, some of the statutory incentive programs, if they meet a certain threshold. It's harder to meet that threshold in the rural areas because usually it's much fewer jobs. I couldn't give you a specific number, but we'll certainly take that into consideration and take it back to the agency and think about that some more. Well, and lastly, I guess the way
I would suggest you think about it is how do we grow from where we are? Not necessarily recruiting somebody, but how do we grow from where we are? Because there are people there with gifts and talents and things they want to do, But we have no way of developing them is the big thing, just like what I said with the arts. There are opportunities there, but there's no way to develop it. And, Senator Teague, I'm going to depend on you to get that
legislation right so we can do that. We also have a couple of divisions. I mentioned the existing business resource division as well as our manufacturing solutions division that goes out and works with those local companies on any kind of training needs and expanding their base. So we do have some resources for that as
well. Last thing, Mr. Chair, and we'll talk about this more a bit later, but I've been thinking about AEDC and other departments and agencies in terms of education. We in the Education Committee struggle, for example, to get teachers, say, I'll just keep going with Nashville since I was talking about Nashville, maybe Willisville. We need to get teachers to come there, but there are all kinds of reasons they won't come, and one of those has to do with the lack of development in that community. And I just think it's about time we start to not look to the education folks to fix that, but to economic development and some others. And so I would really ask, if you see a school district in trouble, and they can't get teachers because there's nowhere to live, nowhere to shop, nowhere to work, those kind of things, I think that's something we all need to be thinking about collectively, because we can never fix it in the education committee. But
I'm willing to work together, though. Yes, I agree. Senator, those are great points. and actually it's a good opportunity to assign some homework since we talk about education. And I would on that, in response to AEDC, I've reached out, spoke with Mike Preston about the opportunity zones. And that is, and not that we all haven't studied that, but that's new legislation. And I would like the committee to please take some time, if you can, to read a little bit about the opportunity zones. Arkansas, actually, as every other state has, was requested to designate opportunity zones in our state. And those opportunity zones are powerful tools. When you talk about what can we do, that's where I would like us to really look hard. In fact, I don't mind saying that I've already asked the Bureau to draw up legislation which would allow Arkansas to mirror the federal legislation on the opportunity zones, which would allow it to be an even more powerful tool for people in our state. And I would ask for your department to please reach out to me on that. I have had conversations with the governor's office about it and some others. I believe it's very, very powerful. I think even our federal delegation is going to be very supportive. We'd like to see us take advantage of it. And that's how you get growth to happen is when you create an environment to attract people to those areas of our state. In fact, I will put an ask and we'll let you go. And that ask is the next time, if there is a next time, that there are requests for where those zones go. The only thing I would say that I'm disappointed about is there are areas in my district that absolutely would have been really great potential for opportunity zones. And the legislature was not given an opportunity to weigh in. And I know it was a very quick process. I know that it was a process by which you had to get it done and that issue went out, but it really did not involve the legislature and the legislators, which many times Senator Elliott may be speaking every month or so with people in her district about an issue in an area. And because when I spoke with the department, I was advised, well, we didn't know that there was any projects for that area. Well, maybe that's because you didn't ask the legislature. It's not a negative thing. It's just a want for the future. If we get another bite at that apple on some of those zones, please include the legislature in some of those discussions and take this as a charge from this committee to please ensure that that does happen. Because there are absolutely projects in one of the lowest population in poorest counties in the state where they have put together intermodal facilities and have been working together jointly, and they absolutely now have missed that opportunity on this first thing. So thank you for all you do. We do appreciate the great successes, and we look forward to working with you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Next on the list, we're now to Mr. Edmund Waters, who is the commissioner for the Securities Department, and I'd like to recognize Edmund and his team. to come and introduce themselves. And we have about 25 minutes, just so everyone knows we're going to be going into session, unless that's changed at 11. And so if you would, please, we'll make your presentation. Just saying that for the members, that we'll get into the weeds of some things a little bit later, but I want to make sure you get to all
have your representation. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Edmund Waters, I am the Securities Commissioner. I have with me Ann McDougall, who is the Deputy Commissioner and has been with our department for 35 years. As some of you may know, a valuable and incredible asset and resource to the department as well as to this state. Behind me, we have a couple of our attorneys. We have seven all total, but our general counsel, David Smith, is back on the back pew back there with Campbell McLaurin, who is the associate general counsel. So they do a great job as well. David has been with the state for 30 years. I am the newcomer to the group. I've been here for four years. Prior to that, I had a 40-year career in the private industry with about over half of that in the securities industry. But what I can tell you, and I'll try to be brief so we can get out of here, the job that we do is an important work. It's a serious work. I'm very proud of what we do there. We currently have over 120,000 individuals that are registered to do business in the state of Arkansas. When I got here four years ago, we had just around 100,000. So it has grown tremendously. We are a special revenue agency. We take in about six times the amount of money that it costs to operate the department, which put us a little over $18 million this past year on about a $3, $3.5 million budget. So the majority of that excess money goes to the general revenue of the state. We are also an enforcement agency with seven attorneys, 15 examiners. So we do enforce the regulations of the state. We work well. I feel like I have a good background. As I mentioned, I'm not an attorney. I'm the first commissioner, I think, that we've determined that it's been a non-attorney. So I have an industry experience. We have a good working relationship with the securities industry. They are a vital part of the economic well-being of the state. And is there anything I've forgotten? I always forget that. About two-thirds of what we do is securities-related. The rest is we do regulate the residential mortgage lending industry, the money transmission. That would be a Western Union-type operation as well. So we do that as well. Well, thank you
very much. And actually, I believe maybe we should say it's a long time coming that you have somebody that's got industry experience and not necessarily just an attorney. You have a great legal staff there. It is good. I will tell you, I've had great comments from people across the state that's proud of what you're doing. And as you know, I personally am proud of some of the enforcement actions that you went forward with, because obviously there's always someone trying to recreate the wheel and do something that colors outside of the line. So thank you for what you do. Members, do you have any questions for Commissioner Waters and his staff? If not, we appreciate you for being here. I think there will be some legislation related to the department that we'll be working on, and we do look forward to it, and thank you for your time this morning. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Next on our list, and we have three more presentations, This will be Candace Franks and Commissioner Franks with the Arkansas Bank Department. I sure do thank you for being here and would ask that you state your name and go ahead and introduce both of yourselves and
who you represent. Sorry, good morning. I'm Candace Franks. I'm your bank commissioner, and this is John Allen, my deputy commissioner as well. And the state bank department regulates Arkansas state chartered banks. We currently have 79 banks, 77 bank holding companies, one trust company, and re-regulate Arkansas Capital Corporation as well. These institutions hold over $1 billion in total assets. We went over the $1 billion mark at the end of this past year. So we're very proud of our institutions. Our total assets have grown more than 50% over the last four years. in the State Bank Department is maintaining our examination staff in the same level we had in 2009. We continue to examine this explosion of assets with a good increase in good use of technology as well as having a very experienced staff, which I'm very, very proud of. We are a special revenue agency. We're completely supported by the assessments that our banks pay to the department. Our banks are generally performing quite well. You know, we had about a 10-year downturn that was very devastating for many in our industry. Arkansas, fortunately, has very good bankers and very conservative bankers, and we did maintain well during the downturn, but we're glad that that's passed us, and we are recovering and doing quite well at this time. We do have two really housekeeping bills. Senator Rayford is sponsoring those for us that will come before this committee, and we look forward to working with you during this session. Very good. Members, do you have
any questions for Commissioner Franks? Commissioner, I will ask a question just for the sake of hearing that number. That $1 billion in assets is actually only on the banks that you actually regulate. That is not the total assets of all the banks in the state, correct?
That's correct. We've gone over $100 billion in total assets, and that does not include the national banks. There are 13 national banks in the state as well. And what was the number again? Over $100 billion in just the state chartered banks. There's about the national banks have a little over $7 billion in total assets. Right. Well, I'm glad
you said that again because my ear, I'm getting a little older, Candace. And I thought you said $1 billion, and so I want to hit that again. So thank you. It's quite a benchmark for us,
I will tell you that I'm already getting just a couple of calls on a couple of bills that I'm working on, so I'd love for your staff to visit with me briefly, and let's talk about that. But we look forward to working with you, and thank you for the job that you do. And I apologize for the line of sight, Mike's. There's no way you and I can see each other. But I think in the future we may ask that they go ahead and pull these down a little bit because you can't see the person there at the end. So thank you very much for coming. And you're dismissed, and we will move to our next presenter, which will be Mr. Alan Kerr with the Arkansas Insurance Department. And while he's taking his seat, members, I will tell you, I know Senator Elliott has attended it maybe once or twice. But I would really urge you and actually ask you to please consider attending one of the National Council of Insurance Legislators meeting. The next one actually is in Nashville that will be coming up. And I know Senator Elliott was there, and she will tell you, when you go to those meetings, you are strapped to the desk working. It is not a social event, and it has been very important. and I will give it by way of update, tell you that we did pass a national pharmacy benefit manager model at the December meeting of NCOIL. The Arkansas bill was the basis for the beginning of that model. That bill is now being introduced in Texas. I know it's been introduced in Indiana. And the work that we did here last year is absolutely having an effect, and I appreciate everyone. But I would invite you, I'm now past president of that, I'm still on the board for a couple of years, but we would really like you to come. That entity meets about three times a year. It's typically a spring meeting, a summer meeting, and a winter meeting to end that. And it's an opportunity for you not only to attend and immediately be involved at the committee structure, Cecile Bledsoe, Senator Bledsoe, by virtue of her position, is automatically an executive committee member there if she begins to attend. And it covers health issues, anything dealing with insurance in the arena and the financial services. And it absolutely has been an important part of me being able to handle a lot of the issues that we deal with. And as you know, Commissioner Kerr also sits on the NAIC and has served as a chairman there on the committees. And every single meeting of NCOIL, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, which means several commissioners from different states around the country, are present there for a dialogue about issues that are ongoing. And so I've given you my invitation to that. If you don't have information on it, let me know and we'll get it for you. And with that, Commissioner, I want to say thank you for all of your work on the PBM model. Wherever I go, I just spoke at the AMA conference in Scottsdale on the issue. And as soon as I get there, it's a discussion of what we did in Arkansas, what they are going to be able to do. And so we thank you for all the work that you've done on
that. With that, you're recognized for all of your comments. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. My name is Alan Kerr. I am the Arkansas Insurance Commissioner. This gentleman rising above the microphones next to me is my chief deputy, Russ Galbraith. I also have with me my public information officer, Ryan James, this morning. Happy to be here. Most of you know me, but just a short history. I have been in the insurance business since 1980, been in just about every kind of insurance you can think of and every facet of it. I served as a state representative for three terms, which is all the terms they let me serve at that point in time. I was term limited and became insurance commissioner. And since I've been commissioner, you've got a handout here, a report, our most recent report. I'm going to hit some of the highlights in there. Um, we've, uh, increased licenses, uh, license producers and adjusters by 54.8%. Uh, we have increased, uh, business entity licenses by 39.6%. And, uh, we have lowered our state employee prescription claims cost. We have a division in our, uh, department that handles the workers' comp for the state of Arkansas, uh, by 28%. We've reduced that. Our department has 15 divisions. One of them is, it appears I'm still running an insurance agency. We handle the insurance for the state of Arkansas, all their property, all their automobiles, their cyber insurance, and everything that that entails. And several divisions, we have a finance division that goes out and audits insurance companies, anybody from State Farm to MetLife to whoever you can think of that does business in Arkansas. We audit them on a regular basis. so we have a full division that does that. We are a contributory agency. We contribute to the state, bottom line. We have added 85 companies since I've been commissioner, new companies in the state of Arkansas. We have increased total premiums by $2.2 billion. Okay? And first thing you're going to think of, Well, has he been raising rates? No, that's because of some of the things that economic development's been doing and increasing business in Arkansas. So, you know, rising tide lifts all boats. So if you've got more business in Arkansas, you're going to have more insurance premium being purchased and moved. What that does, that is a benefit to the state of Arkansas by we've increased collections by 60 million dollars. and Senator Johnson, before you get any ideas, that goes straight to general revenue, and you'd have to go arm wrestle Senator T for that in budget. So, but, you know, we work closely with some of the other agencies and do the best we can for the people of Arkansas. saw. And with that, Mr. Chairman, I'll cut it short and answer any questions.
All right. Members, do you have any questions for Commissioner Kerr? Well, we do appreciate you for coming and presenting your report. I will take the opportunity, since you're here, this is not a new issue, but I have had some phone calls this week from some citizens related to notices that they are getting to raising their long-term care insurance rates. You may or may not be getting some of those calls. Oh, yes, sir. Yes. And as we all know, that is one of the largest elephants in the room for the insurance industry across the country. We have seen a lot of those companies that have merged or gone out of business. We have even seen changes to the Guarantee Association as a result of the potential liability there that lies in the long-term care insurance arena and the possibility that some of them may not survive. Right. And when we see citizens that are getting notices of 100% increases in their premium rates that will come in over the next few years from Genworth, which is the largest and the most stable that we have left, it's a big concern. I'm actually going to be meeting with some of them, and I've actually recommended that we introduce them to your staff. I'm sure you've got some answers to that, and I just wanted you to know it's an issue that I'm beginning to hear a lot from, and the other legislators may hear it too. Anything on that in a
20-second? Other than we're doing everything we can to make sure that the investment these folks have made into those policies remains and that they don't lose that investment, and we don't want them to reach the point where they're having to file a claim and suddenly it's gone. So it's a very tight rope we have to walk between keeping them solvent and not increasing premium. So unfortunately, that particular industry started in the mid-80s and had some horrible actuary projections. Horrible. On top of that, people living a lot longer and using those policies a lot longer than they have projected. So not to get too far into the weeds, I'd like to sit down
with you and your constituents and the folks that are calling and see what we can do to help. I look forward to that. Thank you very much. Appreciate you both for being here. Yes, sir. Last presenter on the list, actually members Cheryl Sluderman with ADFA met with me earlier today. She was unable to be here, but I believe Brad Henry, vice president for development finance, is going to present on behalf of them. And we do appreciate it, sir. And you've got about four minutes. If you could keep it to that, that'd be
wonderful. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I can keep it brief. Our monthly board meeting is actually today. So that's where our president, Mr. Luterman, is today. So I am, as chairman said, my name is Brad Henry. I'm the vice president of development finance for the Arkansas Development Finance Authority. At ADFA, we're responsible for providing financing for affordable housing, economic development, state facilities, and student loans, which we were one of the first agencies that experienced transformation ourselves when the Student Loan Authority merged with ADFA in 2017. Typically, our financing is provided through the issuing of bonds. We're usually the largest issuer of bonds in the state each year. We have approximately 55 employees and over $300 million in assets. We're effectively the state's development bank. Commissioner Franks, they come take a look at us each year, just like all the other banks. We're a cash agency. We don't receive gross revenues from the state. We do receive federal funds. We do manage several HUD programs. And with that, I'll take questions. All right. Members, any questions for Brad at this time?
Seeing none, Brad, I might as well put this out as an ask. I had someone approach me. It was very intriguing. And I actually told them that I felt ADFA would be the appropriate entity to have the discussion. I don't want to get anybody too excited, but I do want to mention to you, obviously we know that with the federal government shutdown, we have federal loan programs for agriculture that are at play right now that are suspended until this gets resolved. One of the bankers visited with me about whether or not the state might be interested in the possibility that we would guarantee some of those loans. They absolutely have only a 2% default rate in that space. It's one of the safest spaces in the country. So I thought it was intriguing that they would bring that up because what happens is that the federal government makes money off of those loans. And if that, it's interesting, it'd be something for research, but by all means, so that nobody gets too excited, there's no legislation to do that, but it's something we could look at. With that, members, are there any other questions that you have today? I do want to tell you before we end that we do have three bills that are on the agenda. Not with us coming back after the holiday, We may just wait to take those up at maybe Thursday and not Tuesday. One of the most important bills that's already been filed, and many of you are aware that the Health Insurance Marketplace Oversight Committee voted unanimously to draft legislation to abolish the Board of Directors of AHIM and put them at AID. That legislation has been filed. Deborah Ferguson in the House has been working very closely with me on that, as well as members of the committee, and we will be taking that up. And that actually, due to some situations that we've become aware of, will include an emergency clause, and so we look forward to dealing with that and ask you to please reach out, AID, and to me and others to talk about that. With that, I think Senator Teague has something. Mr. Chairman, I don't know
that? Wow, you know, I didn't even know all of that. But I will say just that we do appreciate the work of the Efficiency Committee and what they did. This room has absolutely improved, much nicer. And with that, the last comment I will say, and we thank you for your presentation, Brad, is that it's very fitting that the committee meets today because it is the birthday of Ben Franklin who started Mutual Insurance in America. And so we're very happy to have you. We look forward to a great session and thank you members for your work. And with that we are adjourned.
The chair introduced a draft amendment to Rule 8 that would require a “motion to expunge” to be listed on the agenda, prompting Senator Elliott to ask how the notation would appear for bills such as SB 1020 and receive clarification that a line indicating the expunge motion would be added two days before the meeting.
[1:41][2:13][2:43][3:00][3:16][3:50][4:42][4:56][5:16][5:28]
A motion to adopt the revised rules was made, seconded and carried unanimously, formally adopting the rules as presented.
[5:35]
The chair opened the segment by introducing agency representatives, beginning with Ted Thomas of the Arkansas Public Service Commission, who explained the commission’s rate-case authority, consumer-complaint handling and pipeline-safety responsibilities.
[7:38][7:46][8:16][8:50]
Chris Hallett of the Employee Benefits Division then presented the division’s membership, fiscal position and cost-saving measures, highlighting a $70 million reduction in claims and $5 million in administrative savings.
[9:51][10:25][10:56][11:29][12:00][12:32][13:08][13:40][14:14][14:48]