May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin
Processing date
November 19, 2026
D. Update on Early Childhood Education from the Arkansas Department of Education (ADE) [Exhibit D] 6:50
The ADE Office of Early Childhood reported that it secured a $14.7 million PDG grant, used to deliver $3.5 million in class-transition payments, $899 k in workforce stipends to 1,623 providers, and approved ten curricula with nine additional curricula under review for full adoption by 2028.
[8:25][9:00][9:37]
It highlighted professional-development activity, noting roughly 3,987 PD opportunities provided, collection of over 5,000 provider surveys, and that 3,700 class observations were completed in 2025-2026 across about 3,500 classrooms.
[10:10][10:47][11:24][11:57][12:30][13:01][13:31]
The presentation broke down funding sources, distinguishing the state-funded Arkansas Better Chance program ($114 million) from the federally funded School Readiness Assistance ($124 million), adding the $14.7 million federal grant and separate Head Start allocations that together support licensed early-childhood providers.
[14:02][14:32][15:03][15:37][16:10][16:46]
C. Presentation of Early Childhood Policy - Dr. Cynthia Osborne, Prenatal-to-3 Policy Impact Center, Vanderbilt University 55:11
Dr. Cynthia Osborne presented research showing a strong correlation (0.92) between third-grade test scores and 11th-grade outcomes, and a notable link (0.72) between kindergarten readiness and third-grade performance, emphasizing that early learning occurs before kindergarten and that gaps persist without targeted investment.
[55:14][55:50][56:25][57:02][57:33][58:05][58:42]
She highlighted that current public spending heavily favors K-12 (over $15,000 per student) while investing only $1,900-$3,700 per child in the birth-to-three period, and outlined 17 evidence-based policy strategies-such as child-care subsidies, Early Head Start, and workforce development-to improve early brain development and family resources.
[59:13][59:49][1:00:24][1:00:59][1:01:32][1:02:04][1:02:40]
After the presentation, Rep. Denise Garner thanked Dr. Osborne, invited questions, and the committee noted interest in further discussion, with no motions or votes taken.
[1:16:37][1:16:49][1:17:10]
E. Overview of Home Visiting [Exhibit E] - Tyra Greenwood, Director, Arkansas Home Visiting Network, Arkansas Children’s Hospital 1:18:03
Tyra Greenwood, Director of the Arkansas Home Visiting Network, described the program’s evolution since the 1980s, its nine current models (including Family Connects, Baby Back Home, Healthy Families America, Nurse-Family Partnership, HIPPY, and PAT), and the collaborative funding structure involving state departments, the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, and private partners.
[1:18:11][1:18:23][1:18:29][1:19:01][1:19:32][1:20:05][1:20:42][1:21:20][1:22:00][1:22:36]
Committee members asked whether the programs have sufficient capacity and waiting lists, and how depression-screening data ties to Arkansas’s high infant and maternal mortality; Greenwood explained limited coverage in some areas, ongoing capacity constraints, and that benchmarks measure not only screening rates but also successful referrals and services provided.
[1:38:34][1:38:49][1:39:04][1:39:38][1:39:47][1:40:11][1:40:41][1:40:50][1:41:13]
F. Presentation of Healthy Steps [Exhibit F] - Anna Strong, Executive Director, Arkansas Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics 1:42:01
Anna Strong, Executive Director of the Arkansas Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, presented Healthy Steps-an evidence-based, interdisciplinary pediatric primary-care program that embeds a specialist in practices to provide universal screenings, referrals, and intensive supports for families with children under three, funded by the Blue and You Foundation, Walmart Foundation, Arkansas Community Foundation and an HRSA grant, and now operating in 17-20 sites across the state.
[1:43:18][1:43:49][1:44:22][1:44:53][1:45:25][1:45:58][1:46:04][1:46:10][1:46:33][1:47:04][1:47:39][1:48:11][1:48:43][1:49:15][1:49:48][1:50:19][1:50:56][1:51:28]
She highlighted that the program has reached over 70,000 children, produced a 6.2-fold increase in maternal-depression screening and higher rates of wellness and developmental visits, and demonstrated a 163 % return on investment supported by a supplemental $3.44 per-member-per-month Medicaid payment.
[1:51:59][1:52:31][1:53:04][1:53:38][1:54:13][1:54:48][1:55:23][1:55:58]
G. Overview of After School and Summer Programs - Dr. Laveta Willis-Hale, Network Director, Arkansas Out of School Network [Exhibits G1-G2] 2:04:14
Dr. Laveta Willis-Hale, Network Director of the Arkansas Out of School Network, presented a data-intensive overview of the state’s after-school and summer learning effort funded through the ARP ESSER III allocation, explaining the project’s origins in 2021, its partnership with Arkansas State University and the American Institute of Research, and the design that linked program activities to academic, behavioral, attendance and social-emotional outcomes.
[2:04:46][2:05:18][2:05:58][2:06:33][2:07:09][2:07:48][2:08:25][2:08:58]
The presentation also emphasized collaborative partnerships, noting that fewer than 20 % of programs formally partnered with school districts but staff reported strong bilateral relationships that facilitated student recruitment, transportation and program design, and the evaluation found positive stakeholder feedback about increased family and community engagement.
[2:28:00][2:28:33][2:29:09][2:29:44]
In the ensuing Q&A, Rep. Denise Garner asked where the “missing” children were spending unsupervised time, prompting Dr. Willis-Hale to describe that many are left at home alone or with grandparents, underscoring a critical supervision gap, while Rep. Justin Gonzales highlighted the prohibitive cost of participation for low-income families and praised the study as a blueprint for future action.
[2:37:47][2:38:06][2:38:19][2:41:45][2:42:19]
to order. And we need to consideration the motion to approve last meeting's minutes, if I could get a motion for that. Motion. Second. All in favor? Aye. Thank you very much. And first thing on the list, on the agenda, is the presentation of Dr. Cynthia Osborne. Cynthia is a I cannot hear you anymore, Rep Garner.
great let's go ahead and do that that That means the Department of OEC, we are ready for your report. Thank you all, and thank you all for being flexible. We appreciate you guys. thank you yes ma'am if you'll introduce yourselves for the
you all for having us and allowing us to come talk to you about early childhood i'm ashlyn abney the education division director for the office of early childhood
us. Okay. We thought it would be a great idea just to start out today talking about the foundation for early learning because we know that there's been a lot of talk about that lately for early childhood in general. And so the slide that you're looking at right now explains that a little bit for you visually and how quickly and fast the brain of children develop over time. So you can see the majority of that happens between birth and three years of age, so it's critical from birth to five years of age, and I would even say prenatally up through five, but that is our why, and that is why we are here today, because high-quality education impacts everything else that we do in the K-12 world. So all three of us sitting here today have our former principals, and we can talk to you all along the day about how very important that is. But if we want to be successful there, we believe that we need to be successful down in the birth to five years of age. And so we know that if we focus our time and energy there, that we have higher outcomes of high school graduation. We have higher outcomes of health when we become adults. And we know that the investments that we put into early childhood have big payoff later on in life. The LEARDS Act helps us to see the vision of those things in action. And so our task in the Office of Early Childhood is to make sure that children are ready for kindergarten. And so what we do is we look at three focus areas, and then we have a belief on the fourth one. So on your screen, we think that families can access resources that they need in order to make sure that their children are ready for kindergarten, regardless of the type of care that they are in. We also are tasked with making sure that there's high-quality learning experiences that are being provided to the children amongst our provider base. And then we also need to make sure that we have accessible seats for those children. And we believe that if we can conquer those three things, then the local and state economies will thrive because the families will be thriving. We wanted to give you some updates on what we have been accomplishing in the last 10 months in the Office of Early Childhood. So we applied for and won a $14.7 million PDG grant, and as part of that grant, what we've been able to do is provide over $3.5 million in class transition payments. Some of you all will remember that that is our quality improvement rating system that we're working towards, moving to looking at interactions between the adults and the children in the child care facilities. And then also, we have distributed a little over $899,000 in workforce stoppings. This would be funds that went directly to child care providers, so we were proud of that. And roughly 1,623 providers participated in that. Also, as part of that, we were looking at our high-quality instructional materials. So this is much more than just curriculum, So we wanted to make sure we pointed that out to you all today because chances are you will hear us talk a lot about that moving forward. But as of right now, we have 10 curriculum that have been approved that are available currently for our providers to use. And then we have nine more that are currently under review. So our goal is in 2028, and Dr. Barnes might talk more about this in a moment, but we are looking at that time where providers will be using an approved curriculum on the list. Right now, while we're still looking at different curriculum and adding curriculum to our lists, providers can use what they are currently using, and many of them have already chosen a curriculum that is actually on the approved list. Another thing that we wanted to do to make sure that we were spending the funding correctly is we wanted to really look harder at our professional development trainings that we are providing. And so as a part of that, we wanted to start hearing directly from providers on whether or not the trainings that we were providing for them were something that they found useful in their daily work. And so I'm happy to report to you all that we've received today over 5,000 surveys of information that has come directly from providers, letting us know how that training is going, how it is impacting their work. And so far, it's been mostly positive. There have been some things that we've heard from providers that were not exactly the way that I would want them to be. And so my team and I have the opportunity now to look into that at a deeper level and to see if it's adjustments that we need to make on our side in terms of the trainings that we are providing or if it's something else that we need to take a look at. And so all of these things we have been working on help us, we believe, to see the vision through all the way to the end, which is under learns for our portion is a unified system for the children in the birth to five arena. So I mentioned earlier that we are working on our quality rating and improvement system, and we are using a tool called CLASS. It is looking at the interactions between the adults and the children. And so the first two blocks of information you see on your screen there is information from our 2025-2026 year. And so once we get updated information on this year, we'll be glad to bring that back to the committee and give you some updates on that. But in 2025-2026, there were 3,700 class observations that were completed. Those are in roughly 3,500 classrooms, and that is a mix of ages. So those observations would have happened in infant rooms and in toddler rooms, preschool rooms as well. So many times we will hear, well, isn't early childhood just babysitting? and we are here to tell you that no it is not babysitting it's our belief that education starts then not only with what we showed you in terms of how fast the brains are developing in the young children but also the information that they are taking in so these interactions mean everything to us in terms of what the children are hearing on a daily basis and then of course what they're storing in their brains and then learning further down the road. So back to those professional development hours, as of July, 2026, we had roughly 3,987 professional development opportunities that were given to the providers. And that could have been a mix of PD trainings that they went to or coaching that they received, or it may be even technical assistance that they received. Okay, so many of you have heard me say this before, but I think it bears repeating again. Just to make sure that we are all on the same page about the different funding streams that the Office of Early Childhood receives, and then a few that we do not receive, but interact with the same group of children that we have. So a few months back, and some of you have seen this, we decided to maybe visually help explain some of this information that anything that is state funded will show up in green and anything that is federally funded that comes to us will show up in blue. And so on this screen, you will see that from the state side, we currently have a program called Arkansas Better Chance, or most of the time you will hear it as ABC. So, with ABC, we have $114 million that we use for this group of children. And then you'll see under our office, but in blue, we have what's called school readiness assistance. This is commonly referred to as vouchers or child care assistance, vouchers, or SRA. So, if you hear any of that, just know that that's all the same funding stream. Those acronyms and words are used interchangeably. At our office, we call it SRA. So under SRA, we have $124 million that we are allotted from the federal government. That's why you'll see it there in blue. And then, like I mentioned, we were awarded the $14.7 million and the PDG grant. That is a federal grant as well. So just for fun, we also have funding that goes to providers that we also are working with, but the funding does not come through the Office of Early Childhood. It adds Head Start money, and early Head Start money. It comes from the federal government directly down to local grantees and programs. So there's roughly $128 million in funding that comes to our state through the Head Start office. And where we intersect with Head Start and Early Head Start is that first we license them. So all of these entities will have a child care license that's issued out of the Office of Early Childhood. And so we will make visits, and we work with them in partnership. We also were recently awarded last year, that's come now under the Office of Early Childhood, what is called the State Head Start Collaboration Office. So that employee is housed in our office and works in partnership out with the different Head Starts and Early Head Starts around our state. And then through the federal government also comes to the Department of Human Services, though, what is called most frequently EIDT. You might have heard of EIDT centers. That is Early Intervention Day Treatment Centers. And so, again, they work in partnership with the Office of Early Childhood, But the Office of Early Childhood has no say in the spending of that money, which is primarily through a Medicaid program. So when you put all of that together, then that is what the Office of Early Childhood looks at in terms of regulations for the licensed facilities with these different funding streams. But it's so important to remember that this is the same set of children, though, birth to five. So what we thought would be helpful today is for us to look at the early childhood system in Arkansas and what the current landscape looks like. And for that, I'm going to pass it over
to my partner, Dr. Barnes. Thank you, Ashlyn. Good afternoon. This slide in front of you provides a current snapshot of the Arkansas Better Chance program as well as the School Readiness Assistance Waitlist. Arkansas Better Chance serves approximately 23,004 children across its service models with approximately $107.02 million in funding for direct services. That is about 94% of our full appropriation, excluding any contracts or administrative costs. Of those children, there are 19,761 that are in center-based care, including about 18,438 pre-kindergarten children. An additional 3,243 children are served through home visiting programs, such as the HIPPY and the Parents as Teachers program. Of the center-based ABC children shown, 17,171 children are in school-based programs. Those are children being served through public schools, through education service cooperatives, and through institutions of higher education. And about 2,590 students are in privately owned community-based programs. We've also included on this slide information regarding the School Readiness Assistance Waitlist. As Ashlyn has pointed out already, the School Readiness Assistance Program is funded through a federal child care and development funding. And currently, the statewide wait list includes 3,584 children across all age groups. Of those 3,584 children, 2,487 of them are birth through age 5 children, which represents about 69.4% of the total wait list count. Within that birth-to-five group, there are about 573 infants, 904 toddlers, and 1,010 pre-kindergarten-age children. The county data that's shown on the right side of the bottom slide depicts the number of the birth-to-five children currently on the wait list for the top 10 counties in the state, with 559 birth to five children on the wait list in Pulaski County, followed by 180 in Washington County and 146 in Benton County. OEC utilizes these data not only to understand where the demand for assistance is greatest, but also to guide the allocation of available resources and identify opportunities to connect families affected by the school readiness assistance wait list with available Arkansas Better Chance resources, particularly where existing ABC capacity may help address the unmet need. Next slide. One of the things that you've asked for us to provide for you is some information on the wait list in comparison to other states across our region. We believe it's helpful to look at those surrounding states because as this comparison illustrates, Arkansas is not alone. reporting a waitlist for child care assistance. Louisiana, Missouri, Tennessee, Mississippi, and Texas all report children or families awaiting assistance. Oklahoma has taken a different approach. They just decided to freeze the new applications altogether. While the reported numbers vary considerably, these reports show that waitlist and restrictions on new applications occur in all states across our region. It is important for us to recognize that the figures on this slide reflect different reporting periods and state practices. For instance, Mississippi reports families instead of children impacted. In addition, the population-based percentages shown on the slide should not be interpreted as standardized measures of unmet need. We only provide this information to place Arkansas's current wait list within a broader regional context. I want to conclude by saying thank you so much for giving us the opportunity to be able to share with you information about our early childhood programs in Arkansas, and we are open to any questions that you have. Thank you guys. Thank you
guys so much, and thank you for your support in this committee. This is my last committee, and I appreciate everything you've done to try to make sure that we're kept abreast of everything that's happening in the department. So thank you very much for that. Questions? Representative
Brown. Thank you, Madam Chair. Dr. Barnes, I just had a quick question. You answered all my others that I had noted. But you said, and I don't want to misquote, I'm not going to try to quote, But when you were describing that last slide of the counties and the number of children birth through five on a wait list. Yes, ma'am. And so that helps you determine where to place resources, I believe. Yes, ma'am. How, of course, it looks like the greatest need is in Pulaski County, or the greatest number of children. But is that somehow proportionately distributed, or do we focus on
one county? How do you do that? Well, we, of course, what happens is families will apply for need based on the school readiness assistance application. They conduct that application. They will ask for those resources to be provided. Currently, anyone that is not in priority one status, those are children that are identified as special needs. Anyone that is homeless, designee, if they are foster care or if they are TANF eligible would be all placed on a wait list. So what happens is those children are there. And so I would imagine because Pulaski County is the largest county that's in our state, that the bulk of children that are on there are attributable to Pulaski County. And looking at the resources, though, for ABC and how that connects, we look for available ABC slots that are out there. And we look for children that would qualify for that ABC programming. And we try to match those children and families to available ABC resources in their area.
There may be a school or a community-based program that is an ABC participant. would have access to those slots and so we try to see what is available in their slots if they have unfilled slots and we try to match those children that are on the SRA wait list currently to those ABC slots that are
that more efficiently now we have pulled slots back we pay on based not only on a role and we based on enrollment in the past what we've done was we've given slots to a site and we had these slots just available now we look at giving those slots to the site they have to enroll after a certain period of time if they do not enroll those completely those slots are pulled back and they are redistributed across the state to other providers what is that period of time we have i
believe we have a 90 day period i can help with that one so we are currently in the process right now rep brown of uh sending out the notices we will be doing that within the next week or so of the programs that are not meeting their full enrollment, and we give them three different notices of opportunity to increase their enrollment before those seats are taken back. So we will start now, and then there is a 30-day wait for them to get their enrollment up, and then by the end of December, if not, that is when we will start potentially looking at bringing those seats. back. Thank you. Yes, ma'am. We
you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon. So let me say, first of all, the governor said that she was going to give $20 million to early childhood or child care. Do you all have any targeted targeted initiatives that you're planning on using that money for so to
me that that money those funds would go towards the arkansas better chance program for this because it'd be state funded okay and so what we're looking at doing right now is trying to determine really the priority is the priority to remove students from or children from the sra wait list and if so how do we do that with state funds right to incentivize pre-k kids being able to be funded in the abc programs looking at like the priority of areas or regions that need more seats for abc and so right now it's really just kind of a collective effort talking to people we've heard a lot of people talk about raising the rates we do have a market rate survey out right now so we don't want to get ahead
have a market rate study? The RFP is out right now. They're currently working on that. Okay. And so it's in the process. So the market rate survey and cost analysis as a whole for cost of services is something we're
few months? Yes, sir. We're anticipating that to be done. Probably around March or so, Senator Love. We will get preliminary information, though, anticipated either the end of this month or mid-month in December. So we're hoping to get some information back that we can already start using and trying to develop some plans around
it. All right, good deal. I think once you got into the market rate study, I think that was my questions. All right, let me ask you one last thing, though. So, you know, I was last year with the SRA. I think they cut $8 million out. Wasn't that correct? Now, some federal information said that the state could plan on backfilling that money. Have you all thought about doing any of that in regards to, I mean, because I will tell you, I mean, A lot of the providers that I talk to do say that, hey, the ABC is not paying as much as the SRA, and that's kind of hurting our whole model. And I know that you're saying the market rate study is out, and you will have that information. But are we still not going to backfill the $8 million that we lost during the shutdown last time?
No, that's a good question. One of the things, again, since this is the state-funded portion, right, the conversation, especially around ABC, because right now most of our ABC programs are schools, right, and they run the program because the calendar year and everything is established according to the school calendar. It's a 178-day ABC program. And so some conversations, again, that we've been having in terms of what could this look like moving forward is how do we deliver a more robust mixed delivery system so that our state ABC-funded program also has more private providers who are providing that year-round service? Yes. How do we provide a more competitive rate? So looking at our current policies, our current ABC rules, what adjustments need to be made there to be able to provide a much more robust? I don't think we're necessarily trying to take the $8 million from the new $20 million from the state and say we're going to put it in the SRA program but more or less making our ABC program much more competitive and also looking at where can we streamline, where can we streamline with rates, where can we streamline with how people get qualified for services in the program. And so those are some of the
so now does ABC have a wait list? So we don't keep a wait list the same way for ABC as we do for SRA. SRA are families applying for assistance, and so we have that wait list. With ABC, what you have is we have programs that request a certain number of seats, and then those seats are given out, right? And so we have a set number of seats that are given every year. We do have regularly school districts mainly asking for more seats in which we don't have enough to give them, and they're denied. But we're not keeping this ongoing wait list with ABC the same way that you see it with SRA.
Okay. Did that make sense? Yeah, it makes sense. I'm just trying to kind of piece everything together because I know we gave $20 million, and that's great, But if the need is higher, I'm just trying to see how we can make sure that we're getting everything that we need, especially in our rural communities. Because I will tell you, I was in Blindville, and they were telling me that their Head Start program was either the funding was getting cut. And so have you all heard about anything about that federal? Yeah, not anything
that's what was told to me. And so those are the kind of concerns that I have to just make sure that each and every child, no matter where they are, they're getting what they need and the families are getting what they need. So those are
kind of... Yeah, I agree with everything that you said there in terms of looking at each of the programs and determining what is needed. What we want for the new money being put into the program is to find the most efficient, effective way to get as many families as possible. I think over and over again from this committee each month when we've come, a lot of the conversation has centered around the SRA wait list. And so we do feel like that is a pressing matter, especially with infants and toddlers. We know that there is a big need for infant and toddler seats around the state. So, again, looking at what we need to do in our state-funded
It was like 3,000. The current wait list for SRA was 3,584, but that includes school-age children. Okay, yeah. Who are doing like after-school care or summer. The birth-to-five age group for the conversation we're kind of having today is around 2,400.
you all. Representative Walker. if you do a 180 i'm in this other corner um so i'm gonna piggyback a little bit off of representative brown over the unused spots with the abc um if i remember correctly here recently you mentioned and you mentioned it too just a little bit ago about the rule change to to allow you to pull those unused spots back um i'm curious on how that's going to work if you've already sent out a letter that denied the additional slots for schools that or people that are
needing it so what happens with that is we constantly are looking at the enrollment of the abc slots across the board and like stacy mentioned predominantly those are at schools but they're also at educational co-ops and community centers themselves we take a look at every one of those guys and we look to see what their current enrollment is we will have allocated a certain number of seats let's say just a hundred for discussion sake and we let's say that we allocated a hundred and we said here's a hundred seats that you can use in your community but looking at the reports and the information that we get in they're only using 75 let's say and so we will start noticing them up. First of all, we're only paying for the 75, not the 100 slots. So that's their first indicator that, okay, we need to get our enrollment up. Then what will happen is we'll send out the first letter. That's the letter I mentioned that's going to go out to them. I think it's scheduled for midweek next week. But it will say to them, we've noticed you're allocated a certain number of seats but you have only used x amount 75 and so we give them up until potentially the end of december sometimes we'll hear from them and they will say i've given you these slots back i just can't feel them in my community sometimes that happens that's rare but sometimes otherwise those seats come back that's the point then that we look at who have we heard from because we're continually continuously looking also at a funding request and so a coordinated funding request that we use so we can hear back from people about I need 25 more slots in my area and so there are some indicators and criteria that we look at to see where do we need to allocate those slots for one of them for an example is we'll look to see if there's 40 percent of the children being served or less in a particular community those will be the first guys that we look at to see is there a need in that particular county and in that community we might also look at from the centers that we've heard from while we don't maintain a wait list oftentimes they do and so they will we can ask for more information from them to help us make that determination on where those seats need
to be reallocated okay so the way i'm understanding it is um you'll recognize how many seats need to be pulled back and then you'll reach out to areas that were denied and see how you could allocate these unused spots that way or do they just reapply for it and then you look at it going into the next funding year? We can
do it in the immediate. And so we do, I don't, I cannot say that we reach back out to everybody that we've denied. Generally speaking, we've heard from them several times. So they will be on our radar and we will know that they have requested it. We keep that documentation of who has requested it that we haven't been able to help support and so we will look at it across our board again based on our criteria based on the information also in conjunction with what they have given to
us it's most let me add something on this too one of the things that we started here recently we started the local leads right so we have local leads that represent the entire state and one of the primary um responsibilities of a local lead is to really identify the need in their region all right the this is the first time in the that we've been able to come to you guys and say percentage by counties who needs what right and that's because of the data collection that's been going on across the state the last few years um and us trying to get really good idea of where the demand and the need is so not only can we report to you the percentage of people on wait lists by counties but we also know the number of students that are the number of ABC seats the number of families that are receiving SRA within a region and so you know I think two years ago when we came to you and talked about ABC we were still paying you based on the number of seats that you had whether you had kids enrolled in it or not right so it was not super efficient and so once we started getting really tight on you if we give you 20 slots we expect you to have 20 seats filled we only pay you for what you have filled but if you've been consistently under the number we give you we then start noticing you up as ashlyn said that we're going to recoup those seats so that we can allot them to someone else before the year is over so that that funding gets used when we every year go through our funding request or seat request for abc you know if if you asked for 20 and you asked for 15 and i only gave you 10 and i gave you look we know who we gave what to and again we're going back to our county maps and our local lead maps and determining where in the state is there a demand or a need for or where they haven't received anything so that we're trying to be much more specific and deliberate about making sure what we have is being used as most efficiently and effectively as possible i don't know if that helped answer kind of that question let
me add to that because there is one thing that we changed which is it used to be that we would do those coordinated funding requests once a year but we started realizing that that wasn't the best way to do it and so what we've done now is it's open all throughout the year at any time people can submit in to their local lead like Stacy mentioned what it is that their need is at their at the community or local level so we constantly have that information as well so there's a lot of different data points that we can look at both the coordinated funding requests then also from hearing from the different providers that call in also with the documentation of who we weren't able to support at the time and then the criteria that we use just with the information on that particular county and what we know about it because we also use child count too to help us understand how many children are there locally that need to be served so all of those things together help us to make those decisions and i
appreciate y'all's answer on that that does help i guess the only thing i'd like to add is just and you don't have the data right now um and it may be a year before you have this data but i would like to know um if you're able to do this presentation later on how many unused seats in the state were pulled back and how they were distributed through the state thank you we can absolutely thank you madam chair
you madam chair um thank you for this presentation and i have a couple of questions um i was curious as to um you mentioned the qualifications of a student that would go into abc and you mentioned priority one if they're priority one etc and so i think you had mentioned those can where i'm wondering maybe this is at the district level decision or not but i'm wondering about english language learners can you address that as far as in terms of let me that particular group i
appreciate that let me first explain that the priority one that i stated is reference to school readiness assistance not in reference to abc okay but in reference to abc english language learners is a category that would allow them to qualify for services currently okay okay
thank you thank you for that clarification i may ask a couple of more questions okay um and then i also wanted to compliment you on um out of the modules the curriculum i briefly glanced and five out of the ten are translated into spanish and that's wonderful and would love to see possibly some translation into Marshallese based on the population in our area. I was curious as to if you had any idea of other curriculum that might possibly be bilingual. If it's bilingual, then parents will be seeing both when it comes, because there's high parent engagement. That's the thing I love about early childhood education so that they're they're exposed to both all of the time I don't know if that's something that you've thought about with bilingual curriculum we really
appreciate that we try to look for high quality instructional materials that will provide providers the ability to judge from those different material options and find one that is going to be best suited for the children and families that they serve so part of our process is just making the net large enough to where we can allow the providers to be able to look and discriminate between those and choose one that will allow us to meet our standards the CETL standards that we have that that is the first and foremost part of having a curriculum is measuring those standards but then once we have that allowing providers the freedom and ability to choose between ones that would best support them
okay all right and my final question for those who are not maybe they are not they don't qualify or they're not high priority but their stay-at-home moms or their grandparents taking care of their grandchildren while both parents work I wondered about would they have access to this curriculum or just to ensure that they, you know, that they can also be a major facilitator, supporter with being kindergarten ready?
We do allow for, of course, anyone that's in the state can take any curricula that's approved and utilize that. Of course, there could be costs associated with adoption of that. we are looking for some no-cost or low-cost options that would be allowable for children and families to be able to access that would be aligned to our standards and would be a quality program. Okay. Thank
Representative Brown. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think I forgot one of my questions because I was listening to everybody else. I had a question about, well, you did answer something for me that I did not understand. So the allocations of ABC allocations, those are based on the community versus a particular provider. Is that correct? Okay. Did the local leads provide that information to you about, you know, how many seats are needed? They
do. local leads work in partnership with the providers and so they will know a local lead will know or should know what their catchment area is in need of and so remember a catchment area is made up of several counties and local leads have different size catchment areas depending on what area of the state they are in but yes ma'am to answer your question the providers will talk to the local leads to let the local leads know, I'm in need of some more ABC slots. Or they'll say, I have X number of children that are waiting to get into child care that could use an SRA voucher. So there's a lot of conversation that goes back and forth. And then the local leads will report up to us to let us know what the need in the community is. So that's the primary way that we receive the information but we also receive it in various ways either directly from a provider sometimes from community leaders sometimes from parents themselves
and I remembered my other question um the um so you license all early childhood education providers yes ma'am do we I remember when the SRA funds were cut, and then we had children on the ABC waiting list. The audience was full of providers that were very distraught about those funds being cut. Do we know of those providers, are most of them dependent, their business model is dependent on state and federal funding of their programs? or their students to, I mean, that was concerning because, you know, if that's the basis of
Yes, ma'am. I don't know that I can say most, but what I can tell you is many providers do have a single source funding stream, and oftentimes those happen to be either SRA or the ABC funding stream. okay thank you very much yes ma'am thank
madam chair so let me let me go back because I think I want to pick up kind of where representative Brown was in regards to kind of the funding models in the funding stream but let me ask you first in regards to the unseat the unused seats model that we had previously just historically do you do you know why we funded the the the seats that were unused that really came from COVID when
you know there was a time period in there especially it was imperative of keeping our early childhood centers open but you had folks going home being quarantined and those providers were not receiving funding then when those kids were gone right so there became the practice to ensure and guarantee that seats were being paid for okay so we did we didn't we did
mean it because they were getting they were receiving funding whether the kid was there or not so there was no incentive to go out and make sure and attract or
recruit folks to to come okay because i i want to also ask because i know for in the last couple of years we we've lost providers and you know people there's different numbers that say we've lost seven you know i don't know how many providers here but here's what I want to ask you because sometimes those child care providers provide dual services and when I mean dual services they also provide services for disabled children as well. Do we know how many providers we've lost that actually kind of had those dual populations that provided those those types of services i don't think so senator love that's a great question
and so let me take that one back and see if we can break it down even further to see of the ones that we know that have closed what tops of uh services they were providing i don't know that because here's here's the
the reason why i asked that question is because the fact that you know like here and just say here in central arkansas here in little rock we may have multiple providers like that so if one goes out of business or whatever i have a child that needs these services then i could go to someone else and i and i know this because i actually my daughter needed services like that and so but you know if you're down and just say uh somewhere in southern arkansas where that was the only provider and they went out of business then what happens when that child needs services and so that that was that's kind of the impetus of my question is is like are we really are we actually looking at how that may have impacted you know the services being provided especially to children that really were that were disabled that really needed those services so
that's that's kind of it's probably one too that we need to um loop in our special education department at the department of ed because that also impacts um two other funding streams part c and part b is what we refer to those as um for services educational services for children so we can
so much thank you madam chair thank you senator representative in it thank you madam chair i have a couple questions um i have our house which is a organization in my district and they um work with the homeless population um i do have a question on your list of priority your prioritized people is homeless people on that list and are we talking about the homeless that live in shelters versus homeless people are
or couch surfing uh so yes homeless uh is part of our priority and currently we are looking at and defining homeless as people who don't have an actual home so they sometimes um temporarily will be housed with a relative or a friend or some other person in the community maybe a faith-based top situation but in um in our world they are still considered homeless and you did say that it is on one of your list of prior part okay
so again i just want to thank you guys so much for all of your help and um we appreciate you for being here thank you thank you so we're going to try to go back to Dr. Osborne and I just wanted to let you know that you're that her you've been handed a slide deck to look at and then also on your computer handout C early childhood is the slide slide set as well so you have those those options Dr. Osborne are you ready I am and
to switch a slide, we'll navigate it from here. Okay, sounds great. Thank you. Well, I wish I was there with you in person. That would have made life a lot easier. But I'm Cynthia Osborne. at Vanderbilt University that just is still trying to dig out of a major cyber attack that occurred last week. And I just want to clarify that we're a research center at Vanderbilt. And so the work that we do, we're not advocates, but we do like to provide education to state elected officials, state administrators, advocates, coalition leads, to help them meet the goals that they have. So thank you for inviting me to be part of the conversation today to talk about early childhood and really why investing so early is important. I've moved to slide three, and this one is animated, so bear with me if this is a little bit difficult to walk through. But the title of it is Why Invest in Early Childhood. And if you clip down, it'll pull up the box that says third grade test scores and we all know that there's a big emphasis on making sure that our kids are proficient by the time that they are in third grade you know states are holding kids back states are putting a lot of money into this age because the research says that this is when you switch from learning how to read to reading to using reading to learn and there's been research across the country that has looked at the correlation between what your third grade test scores look like and your 11th grade test scores so if you click down one you'll see two boxes there if you click once more there is a correlation that is incredibly strong 0.92 the highest the correlation can be is one and so this basically says that if you were in the 60th percentile in third grade, you are likely to be in the 60th percentile in 11th grade. And more recently, folks have looked at kindergarten readiness. So if you now click down, you can click two if you'd like. And what they have found is that the correlation between where kids are when they enter kindergarten and their third grade test scores is also very high. not as high as in our older grades, but it's still 0.72. So again, that says that about 72% of kids are going to be the same percentile in kindergarten as they are in third grade. It doesn't mean that kids aren't learning, but it means that we're not kind of closing gaps and giving kids those opportunities for advancement that we often think about. I'm a former teacher, and this was always something we wanted to do, was to make it so that kids could be more and more successful. And if you click down a few more, just to kind of finish this thought, that where learning takes place, when the brain is most plastic, when it's ready to receive information and build those skills, the life skills about being a good listener and a good team member and a critical thinker, building those early literacy and early numeracy skills, all of that is taking place before they get to kindergarten, and especially in those first three years of life. But if you click down to what is technically slide four, and it says low public investment in the earliest years, you can see that although what I just showed you about Where learning actually takes place is in those earliest years. When we look across the country at where we invest, we're investing most per year, per student, once they start kindergarten. And we're not seeing a big return on those investments, but we see really big returns on any investments that we make of our littlest ones. And so, you know, from birth to three, we're investing around $1,900 per kid per year. In our pre-K programs, we're investing around $3,700, but we're investing more than $15,000 per kid per year in our older kids. And what the research tells us is that we need to think about when we are investing so that we could get the biggest return. And slide five is just there to reiterate, I believe it was Dr. Barnes that was saying, that it really is. The research is so clear that it is beginning prenatally up to age three. That's the most rapid and sensitive period of development. More than one million neural connections are being formed per second during that period. And it's the front part of our brain called the prefrontal cortex, and it's the part of our brain that really sets us apart from all other mammals, that that's the part that is really expecting input from its environment at age three, this kind of peak plasticity. And that if we can provide our children with safe, stable, nurturing, stimulating environments in this developmental period, that really sets them on track for lifelong health and well-being. But if we miss that window, if they're exposed to adversity or neglect or just not in these nurturing environments, that we're really leaving potential on the table, that our children are not developing at their optimal pace. They're not kind of reaching their full potential. And doing so over the rest of their life course becomes increasingly difficult to do and very, very expensive. The next slide that is there just really shows how these investments, the slide six that says resources are correlated with brain development, This shows that when neuroscientists correlated the kind of size of that prefrontal cortex with family resources, they showed that when children are exposed to these environments in which resources are stable, that the parents have limited levels of stress, we know where we're eating, where we're sleeping, all of those things, that that gray matter, that part of our brain that really sets us apart is actually meeting its full potential and it's reaching a much higher density than when our kids are in environments in which the resources are unstable or very very low so we're really able to measure the brain's development but what we wanted to do at the center if you go to slide seven that says effective state policy solutions for a healthy start is that we wanted to identify what it is that states can do to help to create those conditions. What are the most rigorous studies that have been done to show us that if a state were to implement a policy or program at scale, they start to see changes in those conditions that we know nurture that early brain development. And to date, we've identified 17 different policies and strategies. And at another time, I would love to come back and talk more and more about how Arkansas is doing on many of these. And you are actually making very good progress on some, and you have opportunities for another. On slide eight, there's a QR code that will take you to the Arkansas roadmap and let you explore kind of all of the policies and strategies. But child care and access to child care is one of those. Early Head Start is another one. Other sorts of programs such as shared book reading and literacy coaches, strengthening the child care workforce, early intervention services. there are numerous policies that will help to make it so that our kids' early childhood experiences promote their optimal well-being. And I want to show, kind of just walk you through what it looks like when we start to think about how these policies intersect to provide resources for families so that you can also see how important having access to child care subsidy is for families in order to really provide those resource-rich environments for their kids. In slide nine, it says how do state policy choices impact family resources? And I'm going to be clicking through these because they layer on top of one another pretty quickly. So I'll just go by slide number. And if I get off in any way or if you need me to slow down or provide better direction, I'm happy to do that. It's a little bit like feeling a little blind right now. If you go to slide number 10, you can see that these are the major policy choices that states make to provide resources to households. These are the policy choices that increase wages through minimum wage policy. And the range across the country is 20 states still have the federal minimum of $7.25. And there are states that are now nearly half of states have $19 or higher, or $15 or higher, rather, excuse me. We also know that there are two approaches that states are using to help families protect those earnings, especially meager earnings. That they are providing families with time after having a child to care for that child and to bond and protecting some of those earnings through a paid family medical leave program. They're protecting the earnings by subsidizing child care so that families are unable to work and not spend all of their money on child care. And then the third way that states are really making it so that families have access to more resources, these are working families, is through tax credits, either earned income tax credits, child tax credits, but the range of what is offered is quite varied across the country. And the next slide shows that when you put all those policies together, I'm going to walk you through this so you understand what these colors really denote, you'll see that the top 10 states that are the quote unquote most generous families and working families in those states have more than twice the resources than they do in the bottom 10 states. and I want to show you how these kind of contribute. So slide 12 and the next slide introduces you to Lena. And Lena is our stylized mom. She's a single mom with an infant and a toddler. And we use her to be able to show how a family within your state kind of looks relative to various different policy decisions and how she compares across the country. So Lena works full time at a minimum wage job. She never takes a day off. She's never sick. She never has kids that are sick that need her to must care. So she's a bit, you know, of a wonder woman there. And unlike a lot of moms, Lena applies for and receives everything that she's eligible for. You've talked about wait lists for child care subsidies. Those are very common. And in fact, only about 15% of families that are eligible for a subsidy actually receive one. And that's true for a lot of the benefits that are available for family. She also pays her, files her taxes, pays her taxes and gets any tax credits. She did just have an infant and she takes 12 weeks of leave from her job to bond and heal after having this baby. And she is one of the 56% of folks across the country that's eligible, the federal family and medical leave act. Now that's unpaid leave, unless she lives in a state that does provide paid leave. In order to work, she sends her children to child care, and in this case, so that we can compare her across the country, she sends them to what the federal government calls the equal access target. This is a child care facility that charges the 75th percentile of the market rate. It charges a rate that 75% of folks would charge less than, and 25% would charge more. To go to the next slide, I'm going to walk you through here in slide 13 how it is that Lena ranks number 30th if she lives in Arkansas, out of 51, we include D.C., and how she has just over $36,000 in resources to provide for her children and where those resources come from. So the next slide starts with her earnings. And the minimum wage in Arkansas, as you all know, is $11 an hour. And so working full-time every hour for 52 weeks, she earns just under $23,000 a year. So that is her full-time earnings. If you go to the next slide, remember I mentioned that she did just have her baby. So she takes those 12 weeks of leave off that she needs in order to bond and heal with her baby. And it's job protected but unpaid. And so you can see on slide 15, and even if you go to 16, that she loses around $5,300 in her earnings. that paid family medical leave is used to protect earnings in 15 states now and obviously many state employees have a paid family medical leave program but if you go to slide 17 you can see that in order to work she has to send her children to child care now if we compare the cost of child care in Arkansas to any other state in the nation, you are actually the least expensive state when it comes to child care. Your market rate is the lowest compared to every other state. That doesn't mean that it's cheap, though. She still has to come up with around $16,000 a year to send her infant and toddler to child care at the 75th percentile. And so that absorbs nearly all of her earnings. She has around $17,600 in earnings after those three months off, but she has to spend over $16,000 of that, leaving her with just under $1,500. However, she's eligible for and receives a child care subsidy, and she is one of the lucky ones, right? On slide 18, you can see that at her income, the child care subsidy covers nearly all of those child care costs. So it really protects those earnings. This is a woman working full-time and with a child care subsidy, she's able to protect her earnings. If she doesn't have that subsidy, work doesn't really pay. There's no way that she's going to work full-time and only be left with $1,400 a year. So she's probably going to quit work and turn to public assistance. But by protecting those earnings with a child care subsidy, that keeps her employed. On slide 19, you can see the contribution of federal resources. The green are federal nutrition benefits, SNAP and WIC, and the purple are federal tax credits, the earned income tax credit and the child tax credit. And this more than doubles the level of resources that she has available to her. You can see how important SNAP and WIC are to supplementing her income to provide food for her family. And those tax credits come once a year, but they play a really important role in additional resources. Now, in Arkansas, she doesn't get any tax credits, and so there's no additional supplements to her earnings. So slide 20 shows, again, how in Arkansas LENA has these $36,000
to slide 22, so 21 and then to 22, I want to show you what LENA looks like in some other states, just so you get a sense of the range across the country. If Lena were to live in Virginia, the minimum wage is slightly larger, and they have an earned income tax credit that supplements her earnings. So her resources are somewhat higher in Virginia. This past year, Virginia expanded its minimum wage and passed paid family medical leave and expanded its tax credits. And so her resources, if she lived in Virginia, will be even higher in the next year. In Colorado, you can see what it looks like for Lena if she lives in Colorado. The Navy shows that her wages are higher. And that light blue shows that her wages are protected through that paid family medical leave program. So this is a program in which she pays into every paycheck. And then when she needs it, there is a benefit that comes to her. And then she also has, in the blues at the very end, the supplements for her earnings through the state tax credit. So that just kind of shows you the range, and I would be able to share with you any state that you'd be interested in. And then just in my last minute here, I just wanted to ask you to go down to slide 24, because we often think about our very low-wage workers and how important child care subsidies are for them and the social safety net, and it really is. But I wanted to just show what happens as Lena enters the labor force and earns higher and higher wages. She moves from a minimum wage job up that economic ladder. And when she goes from, let's say, $20 to $30 an hour, that is an additional $20,000 in earnings, going from $20 to $30 an hour. But you can see that those bottom two bars there, that she doesn't have $20,000 more in resources. She has a little bit more, but really only around $500 more. And that's because at these higher wages, families face what we call benefits cliff. They often have to pay more out-of-pocket for things like child care taxes, and they're much less likely to receive any of their benefits, like, in this case, SNAP and lower tax credits. So their earnings go up, but their overall resources are actually not going up dollar for dollar. But there's a lot of families across the country that face these benefits cliffs, and states are thinking about how do we create, rather than a cliff, an off-ramp so that we can allow more families to move up that economic ladder and maintain those resources that they have needed so desperately to be able to afford to provide for their families. Okay, so I will stop there, and I appreciate your flexibility. The next couple slides will show you how you can access the resources that I was sharing with you today, but I'm also more than happy to provide any of them directly to you and to answer any questions that you have. Thank you for your time on that. Thank
I think you must have done a great job explaining. Well, it might just be hard to listen over the phone, too. It's a lot of information to take in. But please, if anyone does have any questions, Rep. Gardner, you definitely know how to get a hold of us, and we are here to answer questions
for folks. Great. Thank you very much. We appreciate everything you're doing, and I look forward to seeing you soon. Thank you. Thank you. Bye-bye. Bye-bye. Next on the agenda is an overview of home visiting. We're going to start from the beginning and zero to three. Thank you, Ms. Greenwood, for being here. If you would just introduce yourself for the record, that would be great.
going to start with a very broad overview about what the arkansas home visiting network is and we have had an investment in home visiting in arkansas since the mid 80s and there were a lot of different models that were added over time and if we fast forward to 2012. We had about seven models operating in the state through similar funding sources spread out all over and the maternal infant early childhood home visiting opportunity through HRSA came about and it allowed Arkansas through the Department of Health to apply for funding that would expand home visiting through all of the models that we were implementing but also to create a network of the agencies that fund and implement home visiting to consolidate administration into one kind of top agency to help us share resources and maximize the amount of funding that was going to direct services. And so as it is today, there is Arkansas Children's who acts as the primary administrator. And our partners are the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, and they run our training institute and our evaluation center that collects and analyzes all of the data about home visiting implementation in the state. And then all of our funding partners, so that would be the Department of Education, the Department of Health, and the Department of Human Services, and some private philanthropy and then 60-plus agencies including co-ops and school districts and community-based agencies that actually implement home visiting services directly within their communities these are the nine models that are currently being implemented throughout the state um we we also provide um training and technical support for early head start um although we're not funded to do so they are included in our cooperative network family connects is our smallest program it is a universal home visiting model that is being extensively piloted in union county only and it provides um a home visit following three weeks post delivery with every single family that gives birth in union county and it has been a fantastic pilot we're very excited about it following baby back home is um was is a promising approach that we are evaluating to reach model status now model status through home v means that that that the model itself can produce at least a 20-year body of rigorous research that shows that it can achieve the outcomes that it claims that it can replicate it in many sites across the nation and so it takes a while to reach that model status but Fallen Baby Back Home was developed at UAMS here in Arkansas and it sends a nurse and social work pair on home visits when a child is born and discharged from a NICU and it has had some great evaluation results especially in infant mortality so we're very proud that they're a part of our network. Healthy Families America HFA as we call it is primarily funded through maybe actually solely funded through MIECHV at present but I think that we are looking to expand HFA under family first prevention. And they target children that are zero to three that are very high risk and need heavier case management. So teen moms, parents with a history of mental illness, just very high, high risk families in our state. And then Nurse Family Partnership, which is run directly by the Department of Health, is a home visiting model that serves first-time moms that are less than 28 weeks gestation. And our largest two models in this state are HIPPY, which is home instruction for parents of preschool youngsters, and PAT, parents as teachers. Collectively, in any year, this is what home visiting altogether looks like across our state. So we serve around 8,500 families annually. We have the capacity to serve 6,000 simultaneously. So as families either leave the program voluntarily or complete the program and new families come on board, that might put us serving over that 6,000 in any given year. We make an average of 125,000 home visits plus annually across the state. We deliver around 15,500 developmental screenings to children, and 90% of our Arkansas home visiting caregivers receive depression screening within three months of giving birth, which is important, as I'm sure you know, to ensure that moms are healthy and providing the care, the best possible care that they can. 84% of home visiting children receive well-child care visits, and that is compared to 71% at the national average. And I just wanted to, I didn't want to bring all of the data, because there is a lot, and at the end of this presentation there will be some information where you can reach out to us if you want to see the vast extent of the data that exists. but I do want to highlight some of our key MIECHV benchmark comparisons. And this information is available on the HRSA-MIECHV website. You can just pull up Arkansas, and you can see all of our data. It's out there for everyone to see. And first, I want to take a look at depression screening, which I referenced. And as you can see, our cohort of home visiting families are screened and receive referral and follow-up at a significantly higher rate than the national average. And postpartum care, it's a very similar situation. So this would be percent of mothers that received a postpartum visit with a health health care provider within eight weeks of delivery. And again, our cohort of home visiting families are exceeding that national average. And the two models that I really want to dig into are the two parents, teachers and hippie, which are funded through state dollars through Arkansas Better Chance. And I just want to talk about them a little and dig down a little deeper into what they are achieving collectively in the state. So parents as teachers in Arkansas can serve zero to five. However, the majority of our PAT programs are licensed to serve zero to three. And if there's not a hippie program in their community, often they will go ahead and receive the two to five-year-old license. The main focus is on school readiness, parental involvement, and positive parenting practices. um the population for the funding of course is targeted so they have to meet all arkansas better chance guidelines or all make the guidelines because both funding sources fund both of these models and so it would be any caregiver in the at-risk population with a child under the age of three we use parent educators most of them have a bachelor's degree in early childhood education or related field. However, PAT has released a little bit of those restrictions, and we are able to hire home visitors that do have an associate's degree or CDA with follow-up training, and they've done that nationwide. And visits range bi-weekly to monthly, really depending on the risk assessment that the family completes, what level of care they really require. And I don't know if you all are familiar with Hippie. It is our oldest model in this state. And really its primary focus is on parental involvement and school readiness. So it will be any caregiver with a child aged 2 to 5 throughout our state that qualified for eligibility under the funding source that is being used to implement it. We use home-based educators. A lot of those home-based educators are former parents who participated in the program. Most of the school districts and co-ops actively recruit them to be new home-based educators. Sometimes we will recruit existing paraprofessionals, but under ABC guidelines, any home visitor has to have a minimum of working towards either a community health worker certification or a paraprofessional certification. Visits are delivered weekly. They're anywhere from 45 to 60 minutes long, and each curricula covers 30 weeks. until up until they complete kindergarten for mcv up into h4 up to and through h4 for abc funding and this is the coverage map for hippie and pat just so you can get an idea of where we're at and at home visiting collectively we touch every county but not every county with every model and some of those counties it's a very light touch but this map kind of gives gives a good perspective of where HIPPY and PAT are available to parents across the state. And the reason I really wanted to dig into them is because there are two areas in which they are really not just knocking it out of the park, I would say, but pulling our state average up as a whole for all home visiting models in the McVee benchmark comparison. And that is in early language and literacy, parental involvement, and educational attainment. So when I dig in to the local data that I have, and I'm really drilling down into these reports to see which models are bringing these benchmarks up and which ones are, you know, causing them to come down a little, What I see is that Hippie alone has a 97% benchmark attainment rate for increasing the percent of time that parents read, talk, sing to their child in the home, which is a key benchmark for school readiness. And they, by themselves, are helping raise all of the models collectively up past the benchmark threshold. and as you can see, it is the same for parent-child interaction, but I will say this is PAT and Hippie collectively together raising this benchmark up for our whole state in terms of the home-visiting population. And the one that surprises us the most that we've looked at is primary caregiver education, And so when we look at this, this is also primarily hippie, but also some PAT families in this group. What we are seeing is that when it comes to the parents that we serve that come into the program without a high school diploma, once they complete the PAT or the HIPPY program, they are at least at a minimum getting an equivalent degree before the end of that program. So some of them might be a high school diploma, some of them might be beyond, but they are at least getting the equivalency of a high school diploma before they leave our program, which I think is pretty amazing. And I do have, I think, a lot of times the description of these programs are best in the parents' own words. So I do have a few videos that I've put into the presentation that you're welcome to look at. I would like to play one that is really about, that is from a hippie mom who receives services through the Greenbrier School District, if I can get
actually we're here at children's hospital and we were in the nephrology department that's where i help you with your kidney and grace has a rare kidney disorder it's called nephrotic syndrome So the doctors did a referral to Hippie, and I thought one on earth is Hippie.
except for contact info and questions. Can I close it out? Okay. Let's try that. and then they said well it's the homeschool instructions for parents of preschool preschoolers and youngsters and i was like oh okay and next thing i know somebody came out and did an evaluation did all the paperwork and it was amazing i'm so thankful when you think about hippie or you think about social services sometimes you think about a certain demographic of people or a certain area of the state and we're a family that has been blessed by the lord to have all of our needs met and we were blessed when we got here but that journey was something that was very very hard and if i had to do that without the help of the lord through hippie i don't know how we would have to have this team come alongside and walk us through early childhood development walk us through those early learning strategies she's thriving i can't tell you how much it meant at the age of three four and five to have the team come alongside and help us each day i know that this is true of probably all of your hippie home visitors that they just it almost feels like you have a natural bond with that person but from the get-go from the first phone call sarah made sure that we felt comfortable we felt welcome that whatever needs we had that she would go above and beyond to make sure that they were taken care of anytime that grace was sick if we couldn't meet that week she would reschedule and i don't know how she did it because she's an incredible mom of multiple children that she raised as well and in the midst of it she put our family as a priority and i know it wasn't just our family it was every family that she visits to have that kind of true loving care from somebody who you know is essentially a stranger that's just referred to you it makes you feel like your family. Sarah made you just feel like it was no big deal that it's okay to ask for help if you had something you were concerned about just say it and she would take care of it. Hippie came in and provided us that community and so if we didn't have a home visitor we wouldn't have had help at the home and that's that was critical to have that support network through a just through one referral we were able to get a safety net of a support network and when you think about that safety net that's our social emotional societal well-being every week we're getting that check-in who else would be doing that and there's so many other families out there that are probably facing something similar whether it be the burdens of depression or anxiety or the overwhelming nature of motherhood or the economic impacts it can be so much that it becomes so daunting to even get out of the house so to have somebody just say I'm gonna come by on Monday do you need anything I'll even bring you some coffee like that is the mom that maybe a lot of these moms don't have. How many times people think oh well if the family had more education themselves or maybe if the family had more money or maybe if we if we try to give them these services it wasn't that it was the actual support network it was a live person you know there's so many things that the waiver provided us that I didn't even realize I needed until it was already six months into the program that I look back and I realized how much our quality of life improved to where she was able to thrive and we were able to continue advocating and get her to where now she's been in remission for over three years and she's doing incredibly we're still at home school and we're just excited about what the future holds but we know it started with a firm foundation
in Hippie and the waiver program. So if I could describe the two programs simply, I would say that both Hippie and Parents as Teachers help teach parents how to prepare their own children for school. And they do that by using an early childhood curriculum and going out with the home and working with the parent every week or every two weeks, depending on the model, teaching them how to deliver the curriculum to their child, monitoring how that curriculum is being delivered and making adjustments where necessary, monitoring the child's development and their progression through their curriculum directly, and taking a look at parent-child interactions to see how they can encourage parents to improve those interactions to help their children develop more appropriately. And within all of that, they are also assessing what those parents need to produce healthy children, healthy households, and they're helping them figure out how to independently meet those needs. Awesome. Tyra, thank you so
much for bringing us the information about the programs. They're amazing programs, and they've got wonderful data to back them up. So thank you very much. Oh, I am seeing one question. Representative Gonzalez-Werthin. Thank you,
Madam Chair. Thank you for your presentation. I was curious. I have a couple of questions. So do we have enough of these programs, Hippie and Pat, and are there waiting lists? kind of
go along with that yes um it uh it really varies by funding stream by program by model but no we are we are we are serving a very small percentage of what we are capable and could serve especially through um like the mcv program that that funds like a variety of models and even I think PAT and HIPPY as it is, they're kind of where they have been, right, for forever. And there's not more funding that's available really to expand HIPPY or PAT there where they're at. And I do think that there are pockets of the state where there is no HIPPY or PAT coverage or very little coverage that could definitely benefit from an expansion of both
of those programs. Thank you. Follow it, Madam Chair? Certainly. So I was curious as to, you mentioned the depression screenings within the first eight weeks, I believe. And in light of Arkansas having a very high infant mortality rate and high maternal mortality rate, I wondered if you have data to show where you were able to identify and assist that mom who may be suffering from depression or some other ailment that would keep her, you know, keep her alive and well with her child. And the same thing, recognizing that something may not be quite right with the infant. Just curious, I guess I'm wondering about these two programs, mostly, I guess, parents as teachers since it's, what, birth under three years. Do you have any information on that? So
I can expand on the benchmark, and that is not just how many did we screen. I mean, I put that data up. There are so many slides. But it is to actually meet the benchmark, and I'll preface this by saying that there are 12 national benchmarks that we have to meet to stay in good standing, and we have to show annually improvement in at least nine, or I mean at least six of those 12. We show improvement in nine annually and consistently. And four, the depression screening benchmark, it is not just how many moms we have screened, but how many have flagged needing services and actually received those services. Okay. Amazing. Thank
you very much. Yes. I'm not seeing any other questions, so I appreciate you being here. Thank you for the presentation. We know where to find you if we do have questions, so thank you very much. Thank you. Appreciate you. Our next presentation is on Healthy Steps with Anna Strong. That's Exigate F in your packet.
if you'd introduce yourself. Yes, good afternoon. Good afternoon, you all, and thank you for having me. I'm Anna Strong. I am the Executive Director of the Arkansas Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, which is the membership organization that supports pediatricians in the state of Arkansas. We have about 500 members statewide, and you guys will see my face up here during session, and I love the work I have the privilege to do to help support children and to elevate the voices of pediatricians as they advocate for their patients in the state of Arkansas. I'm going to talk with you today a little bit about Healthy Steps, which is something I've been working on for about the past six years in the state of Arkansas. And it is a program that supports children under the age of three and their families in Arkansas through their pediatrician or their primary care doctor's offices. As I do this, I just want to start with a little story that helps tie together some of what you've heard today in a way that shows you the value that healthy steps brings so think about a new mom she's a single mom she is at home with her baby and she is she's home from the hospital she had a c-section doesn't have a lot of family support here and she goes to her her baby's one month checkup at the pediatrician's office while she's there she gets a screening for maternal depression she is able to touch base with the the pediatrician's office a few times over those first few weeks of her baby's life. And while there, we find that she is depressed because she's having a lot of challenges right now. She's not back at work yet because she has a new baby. She had a C-section, and so she's short on funds. The Healthy Steps specialist in this office is able to help her find a therapist that works with her health insurance, is able to help her access a food pantry, access diapers, is able to help her with lactation directly right there on site while she's at the pediatric office, is able to provide her some parenting guidance to help her understand how we might think about baby's nutrition, baby's sleeping through the night, things like that. And then eventually the Healthy Step Specialist is able to help mom to access child care that meets their family's needs, might help that family access home visiting services like you just heard about. But that Healthy Step Specialist is there to walk alongside that family and make sure that the family is succeeding and thriving despite the challenges they may be facing. So I'm here to talk with you a little bit about how the work we've been doing through policy that has been passed by our legislature, as well as a lot of collaborative efforts and efforts through DHS to help make sure that our pediatric settings and other places that are providing primary care to kids in our state have all the tools in place to help support families with young children and ensure that families thrive. And one of the ways that we are doing that is through Healthy Steps. I'm going to
if I do that. Does it work? Yeah. So Healthy Steps is an evidence-based interdisciplinary pediatric primary care program. It helps to promote nurturing parenting and healthy development for babies and toddlers. And we do this in places like rural Arkansas. We do this in places where there are a lot of families of low income, and we do that to make sure that all families have access to the tools that they need to thrive. And the way that Healthy Steps works is an extra set of hands called a Healthy Steps specialist is integrated into the health care team to help provide short-term consultations to families that have have needs they help provide referrals to community resources and they provide intensive supports like integrated behavioral health care and other supports for those families when that when needed and they do all this universally so no matter what health insurance coverage a child has if a site is a healthy steps practice then every child and family of that child gets the services and supports from the Healthy Steps program. Now, why do we look at a pediatric setting? We do this because almost all families take their babies to see a health care provider in that first year of life. It's a high-touch environment where we have 12 to 13 well-child visits in those first few years of life, and that reaches people in a way that a child care program can't always do. You know, not every child goes to child care. Not every child goes to a faith community, et cetera. And we know that many of those visits occur during that really tough first year of life that can be often really challenging for a family. While it is also beautiful and wonderful, it can be really hard. We rolled out Healthy Steps in the state of Arkansas with the help of many partners and funders. The two major funders of the first demonstration of Healthy Steps, which was in seven sites, ranging from all the way up from Rogers down to Hot Springs and from Fort Smith over to Jonesboro. We have helped roll out Healthy Steps, thanks to the Blue and You Foundation for a Healthier Arkansas, the Walmart Foundation, and the Arkansas Community Foundation, and then the partners that have been working together on kind of the strategy, the policy, and the collaboration and the partnerships that are needed for this are Arkansas Children's Care Network, Arkansas Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, and Excel by Eight. And we've added UAMS to that list as well as we've rolled out an expanded reach in Arkansas. UIMS received a grant from the Health Resources and Services Administration to help expand Healthy Steps into many of the primary care sites across the state of Arkansas, and so that has expanded our reach to almost 20 practices. I think we're in 17 right now in Arkansas, and UIMS did expand that through family medicine as well, so that was a really great additional reach to help support those families. Also, I'll tell you a little more at the end about what's coming next. So the way Healthy Steps works is there are three tiers of delivery and three tiers of support. Like I said, you don't have to be on a certain kind of health insurance or a certain, you know, income to receive Healthy Steps supports. Any family can access those supports at a Healthy Steps practice. And so everyone gets child developmental screening. So this is making sure baby's walking, talking, crawling, et cetera, on target. and behavioral screenings that help make sure that we don't have early signs of trauma or early signs of developmental delays or other things. We screen for family needs like maternal depression, like other risk factors like being homeless, food insecure, domestic violence, et cetera. And then there is a family support line that allows families to directly contact the healthy subspecialists if they have questions about their baby's development. If a family has a need in those screenings or otherwise shares a need with the healthy sub-specialist or with the pediatrician or family doctor, they are able to get additional supports from the healthy sub-specialist like child development guidance. So if they are worried about their toddler hitting or biting at school, we can talk through some of those challenges. If they're worried about how to help a toddler make choices on the way in and out, do we pick the red shoes or the blue shoes today and not, hey, will you put on your shoes to the one and a half year old? Also things like toilet training, sleep, and other things like that are part of the healthy sub-specialist repertoire. And then finally, positive parenting guidance and information. So really helping to make sure we're using positive discipline strategies that we're connecting to early learning resources, reading in the home, and doing all of the things that we know help those babies' brains develop on target. And then finally, if a family has high needs, So let's think about a family where a parent is incarcerated, a family where we may have a teen parent, et cetera. We are able to bring the Healthy Step Specialist in for all of the four visits together with that pediatrician or family doctor and have all the supports provided together with team-based care. And so all of those eight core components that we already talked through help to produce some really amazing outcomes that have been well-studied. we know that our health care provider workforce is uh is bolstered by this they feel like they have the team they have they feel like they have the team that they need to help families with all of the needs they may have not just their strictly health care needs we're able to work on maternal depression early literacy and school readiness child safety and reducing risk factors for child abuse and neglect breastfeeding early childhood obesity prevention and then screening and connection to services as well as several others on here that i can talk more about if you'd like here in arkansas we've reached over 70 000 kids through our two groups of sites and this is data from arkansas children's care network and the university of arkansas for medical sciences that they've shared with us and given us permission to share but we are serving about 16 000 kids going going forward through arkansas children's care network which is nearly half of the births in arkansas per year and uams has served about 2300 as of this february and that number is being updated right now the number the needs that we are collecting there's a ton of data behind this but we know that maternal depression food insecurity child care affordability and access and income supports are some of the top needs that that we are hearing from the people who are in healthy steps and who are who are taking these screenings but the great news about this is that the healthy step specialist helps to address those right on the spot they're able to proactively follow up with families once they find and identify needs to kind of what we call closed loop referrals making sure that if you send someone to the food pantry down the street we're making sure that you've gotten to the food pantry and then some of the data that is this is hot off the presses and this is i think the first time we've shared this publicly but we've been working on a return on investment study with those first seven sites that rolled out back in 2022 in arkansas and we know that the moms of children attending a healthy healthy steps pediatric clinic are 6.2 times more likely to have a maternal depression screening the moms at a non-healthy steps pediatric clinic and that compared to non-healthy steps mom we know that moms who have high touch so they've been to at least 13 visits at their pediatric clinic they're 10 times more likely to have a maternal depression screening than those at a non-healthy steps pediatric clinic we also know that those moms are more likely to have a depression diagnosis but they are also likely more likely to access health care appropriately including appropriate use of outpatient care improved initiation of antidepressants and lower overall pharmacy expenditures which is an access sign of like learning to access to the health care system in all the right ways and then when it comes to the kids we have found that healthy steps children are who are toddlers are about seven percent like higher seven percent more likely to have a wellness visit and that kids under age one had a 19 percent higher rate of developmental screenings that we know are still kind of new in arkansas all of this work is is grounded in perinatal health policy that we have worked on here in Arkansas with many partners in this space. The supplemental $3.44 per member per month payment through Medicaid is really the sustainability linchpin here. We know about two-thirds of our babies and toddlers are covered by Medicaid or our kids first in the state of Arkansas, and so Medicaid was our first reach on this to try to see, and they have been such great partners in this work over at the Division of Medical Services. We've also been able to turn on recommended screenings like maternal depression being paid in the in the child's medical home through the child's medicine medicaid that is able to be covered now as well as those developmental screenings we were one of the last states to get there but we do it now and so there have been several other pieces that you can see on here including healthy moms healthy babies governor sanders bill from last session and we we are so grateful for the work there to think about the mom and baby as a whole and what we are doing to help support families we also think there's a lot of potential through breastfeeding and lactation services community health workers and others in helping to sustain the work of our healthy steps programs in the state of Arkansas and I'm going to breeze through a couple of national data points all that before was Arkansas but a couple things here we do know that healthy steps at the national level has shown short-term Medicaid cost savings so a hundred and sixty three percent return on investment means that for every dollar we invest into healthy steps we should save two dollars and 63 cents both through the child's health care access and adults the adults health care access and other systems and that does cut across multiple sectors so we see a lot of savings in health in the health care space some of those are short term and some of those are over the longer term but we do know that there are also savings in the education category child welfare criminal justice etc down the road as we think about longer term and HEDIS is one of the ways we measure our health care system effectiveness these are really important measures that we have to submit nationally to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services as a state we know that Healthy Steps helps nationally helps to support several of our HEDIS measures and things that we are doing here in Arkansas to make sure that we're hitting some of those benchmarks at the national level and then i'll wrap up by just sharing a little bit about what's next for us we've recently received a rural health transformation program grant here in arkansas and we'll be rolling out two rural healthy step sites we're very very excited about that work and we will be we are working on our agenda for next legislative session including multi-payer investment in healthy steps right now it is just medicaid making that investment in sustainability for healthy steps looking at how we could offer and pay for preventive mental health and child development support in medical homes the trump administration actually just put out earlier this year a guide on how to do that and cover those payments through medicaid in the state of in across the country improving access to existing we are really doing so well in offering this dyadic therapy called infant and early childhood mental health we are doing a great job in arkansas on offering that, but we don't have a lot of uptake, so we're trying to do our best to break down some barriers to that. And then finally, we're working with NYIT, the College of Osteopathic Medicine in Jonesboro, and several other partners on some rural Arkansas-focused solutions that include Healthy Steps as well. So there's a lot ahead. I am more than happy to talk with you guys more about this, but I know I've probably taken plenty of time today. Again, Anna Strong, here is my information and i'm happy to to chat or take any questions you may have
thank you very much madam chair um miss strong uh thank you for this presentation i think it's great yeah so uh one quick observation so healthy steps is not available statewide it is uh it is really based
on each practice is not available statewide i do have a map of all of the sites that are this one is not one it has one site that we've only lost one site and one of them is in jonesboro but this is pretty accurate i think we will probably have a couple more hopefully in south arkansas with that rural health transformation grant but a practice has it's a it's a pretty big investment it costs it may cost not a small amount of money to train and hire somebody and then it takes a lot of work to get there um it's all it's a heavy um we call it a practice transformation effort for a reason it takes a lot of rethinking about how you care for families with little with infants and toddlers so we're trying to reach as many as we can um we have a we're going to have a um in partnership with arkansas children's care network have a booth set up at the medicaid conference this year where we have part providers from all over the state coming so we're
but what happens when dad's raising that baby love it that we actually have a fantastic story from early on about a dad who was kind of unexpectedly the sole caregiver of an infant and the amount of support and i i will just say i believe that healthy steps changed his life in such powerful ways so it's not by any means limited to moms we just know a lot of the times moms are bringing the babies in in those first weeks of life and really kind of develop that relationship we have male healthy step specialists we have had um lots of dads too i should i should be better and say
caregiver depression instead of just maternal um and i should have asked our previous speaker but i'll ask you when you have these programs you go and do the home visit are are you providing any of the like the tools the rattles the bright colored stuff that keep children fat get children fascinated yeah this this one is not
actually home visiting it all occurs in the pediatrician's office okay but i know um again it kind of some of that work and i don't know i guess i guess tyra's not here anymore um but but we some of the healthy steps practices do develop partnerships with community organizations and are able to distribute um books i know they almost all connect with their dolly partner imagination library their local libraries um and are doing lots of works to get those things into kids hands um so yes sometimes
no problem representative gonzalez-worth yes thank you madam chair i was just curious based on the results that you have presented do you see any any of the services that are currently being provided um by healthy steps as a natural part of any pediatrician's daily work just just curious yes i think
the american academy of pediatrics at the national level publishes this giant book called bright futures and it's about yay thick and it is what is supposed to happen in every well child visit in a child across a child's life from prenatal through adulthood it's a lot and our pediatricians have received one eight percent raise in the past 19 years through fee for service in their visits I will just tell you have gotten shorter and shorter and so in the space of about 10 minutes maybe 15 minutes of what they get for a well child visit sometimes it's hard to cover all of these topics and to do all of the screenings that they're kind of expected and asked to do and some of the feedback we've gotten is that healthy steps really helps them to do all of the things that they want to do but don't always have time to do and so that is one of the things that I think we've really been working on is trying to set the stage for what you know how can we build the team to do this and this allows them to have that little extra revenue source to help start to build a bigger team to help care for those broader needs of children. So it's not that our pediatricians or other care providers don't want to do all of those things, but this is really helping them make sure that they check them all off. And there are a lot of, I will just also say, to be a healthy step site, you have to turn in annual data reports to their national office. And so there's a high level of fidelity to the model, the evidence-based model that they have to have. So they are checking off a lot of really deep, detailed reports every year saying that they are doing all of these pieces which is really lovely okay thank you
good afternoon thanks so much thank you and now we'll hear from dr levita willis hale who's going to talk to us a little bit about the arkansas out of school network and we really appreciate you guys hanging in here and I know there are a lot of folks listening on online as well because of other meetings. So thank y'all. Thank you for staying.
I'm Dr. Levita Wills-Hale. I'm the director of the Arkansas Out-of-School Network. We are a sponsored initiative of Arkansas State University housed within the College of Education and Behavioral Sciences. We are a statewide network of after-school and summer program stakeholders. We provide leadership development, technical assistance, professional development, and cross-sector partnerships and collaborations on behalf of those programs within our state. Each state has a statewide after-school network, and we proudly serve as a network here in Arkansas. And today, I am here to give you an overview of not only after-school in Arkansas, but some very important developments and findings from our ARP ESSER III project in Arkansas. And so I've already spoken to the network and our work. Our mission is really simple. We want to ensure that young people ages 5 to 19 have safe, healthy, and enriching learning experiences when they're not in school. I might also add today that to supplement the findings from the ARP ESSER III evaluation report, I also provided the executive summary along with the slide deck. And I will say that this presentation is rather data-intensive, but the executive summary also provides clear information as well. And so just to go ahead and move into the history and how this all began, in 2021, as you all know, we were still dealing with the effects and impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. Most importantly, the state of Arkansas, like every state, was looking to use the American Rescue Plan education dollars through the Elementary and Secondary Relief Act, and this was ESSER III. Within ESSER III, there was a specific dedicated set-aside to support after-school and summer learning programs to mitigate the learning loss and learning disruption that was caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. And so the overarching goal was to offer these additional supports to schools and communities to address the issue of student learning loss and, again, the disruption. The Arkansas Outer School Network became the lead implementation partner, along with our fiscal sponsor, Arkansas State University. We chose the American Institute of Research to conduct the third-party independent evaluation. And to this end, the American Institution of Research, commonly referred to as AIR, entered into a data sharing agreement with the Department of Education to access comparison data, student level data, to compare those students who were participating in the ARP ESSER III project with their non-participating peers. Through this agreement, AIR was able to look at the participation rates in our programs and compare those with the stated outcomes of the project. And so what you have before you in this graphic is just simply a design looking at what we prioritize in the implementation of the project. And we looked at several things, such as school community context. We looked at the point of service quality. But most specifically, we looked at those processes, activities, and program-specific activities that would lead to specific stated outcomes within the ESSER III project. And again, this project prioritized academics, it prioritized behavior, school, and program attendance, and in terms of academics, reading and mathematics were paramount, and then looking at other activities such as STEM learning, engagement, career-connected learning, and obviously social development or durable skill development. This just gives a deeper approach in thinking about the implementation of the study, the outcome and effectiveness aspects. So it's not just to look at youth outcomes, but to look at how those outcomes were achieved, and then looking at support from continuous quality improvement to look at how those staff inputs, how those program activities all interacted together to achieve those outcomes, and then looking at how do we gather feedback and make real-time adjustments. This was a three-year study, and so the program began in 2021 and ended in the summer of 2024. So there were some significant questions in terms of implementing the project. So to think about the landscape, the unique landscape of programming in Arkansas as it respects to these new funds. And so one of the things that we were key to think about or key to consider were where and how would we ensure broad access. And so a statewide grant competition was implemented, and we prioritized rural isolated areas of the state. We prioritized those areas of the state that had, or those districts in areas of the state that had high percentages of free and reduced lunch rate students, as well as those areas where there was little to no access of programming. So again, there were effectiveness questions. How are the programs performing with respect to the metrics of interest? And really, we wanted to know how does performance of these evaluation questions, what are the perspectives of the stakeholders, what does the participation and how is this new funding impactful, what other factors may help explain? Again, we mentioned previously alterations in the program. In other words, we recognized that there was no one-size-fits-all approach, but these programs were still held to those standardized outcomes and impact questions. And so what effect does participation in programming have on those youth outcomes? And in order to do this, we engaged in several data collection activities. I already described for you the data portal, but this is just a closer look. Program activities, looking at staffing, looking at specific day-to-day schools served and what those partners look like, youth enrollment, and then again, access to the DESE Data Student Data Clearinghouse. It was also important for us to really engage with youth and parents through consistent focused surveys to really determine, was the program effective, how was it working, what were their perceptions about the program. And then those were conducted through targeted interviews and focus groups on a regular basis, and I will say also observations. So there were real site visits from not only the AIR staff, the evaluation team, but also our team in terms of supporting and follow-up and coaching. Again, these are the specific research questions. So if you look at this, these are all driven around the student characteristics associated with each unique student population of the initiative-funded programs. to what extent that students attending these programs have experiences associated with those positive youth outcomes. And one of the things that we were also key about is structuring this so that we were aligning with positive youth development approaches, which is the whole child, not only the academic, but a part of our requirements was to address clearly academic content to address behavior in school behavior and also trying to look at those dynamics that would impact school attendance as you all know or may recall coming out of covid arkansas like every state in the nation student populations were experiencing having to rebound school day attendance and as a matter of fact the lead statistician with usdoe indicated that school attendance and school behavior had a severe impact as a result of COVID and so one of the strategies was really trying to think about how to increase school attachment and schooling school day attendance and engagement and so looking at these research questions there were six and from the perspective again of what effect did participation in these funded programs have on student outcomes, and also some of the qualitative aspects, which, from the perspective of the stakeholders, how did initiative programs benefit the students, family members, and communities? I want to talk a little bit about student characteristics. And so if we look across all three years of the program, the initiative served 20,201 unique, unduplicated students, And these students were concentrated in grades K-5. They comprised more than 54%. But I just want to kind of stick and think about that 20,000 number. That is the largest sample to date of Arkansas student participation in after-school and summer learning programs. And again, this was a longitudinal study taken over a three-year period. So this is really significant for Arkansas after school and summer learning programs because here to date, one of the challenges was that there was no real state-level data, comprehensive data sets on these types of programs. Most students served during each program period identified as either non-Hispanic white at roughly 33 percent or black at 31 percent and the majority of the students 61 percent received free or reduced price lunch and then english language learners comprised more than 20 percent of the students at the start of the initiative but we did note a decrease during subsequent program periods we do not know for certain however this could be a result of population characteristics mobility within this population or where programs were funded if we look at the number of funded programs this is another I think highlight to consider we started an initial and I would say this was an open grant competition so this was a competitive process we started with 53 organizations that served 110 sites and each cycle of the program programs had to reapply so there may be some duplication of organizations within these numbers in the summer of 2022 we saw an increase to 61 organizations serving 102 sites. In the school year of 2022 through 23, you see 81 organizations serving 137 sites. So we increased, I would say, the scale in terms of the number of organizations, but they were serving fewer, excuse me, and they also served a greater number of sites. Again, we see a slight drop in summer of 2023, 72 organizations, 128 sites. And we go on from there, from 60 organizations serving 98 sites. And then a smaller number in the summer of 2024, 51 organizations serving 88 sites. Altogether, that means we had 252 organizations, excuse me, 101 organizations cumulatively serving 252 sites. And again, this is important because it allowed Arkansas, these funds, the $25 million, allowed Arkansas to scale appropriately to meet the needs of students across the state to address COVID learning loss. Another interesting data point of these 110 programs serving the 252 sites, we see that across all program periods, at least 70% of these organizations' administered program were non-school-based organizations. And notably, local education agencies comprived only 18% of the organizations that provided programming in the summer of 2024. Now, there may be a number of reasons for this. But I also think it's because we had an open grant competition that was open to any entity, youth-serving entity in the state of Arkansas that met the financial criteria, being a nonprofit organization or a school-based or school-linked entity. So our 252 organizations represented not only schools but community-based organizations. Those community-based organizations included faith-based organizations, boys and girls clubs, 4-H programs, a number of programs. We even had municipalities. We had the city of Wilmot in southeast Arkansas, and we also had Pulaski County Youth Services here in the Pulaski County area. And across all those programs, there was consistent that most program providers in Arkansas serving school-age children and out-of-school time programs tend to be community-based sites. But I would also add that we saw a strong tendency around school-community partnerships and community engagement. Even when there was no school-based program, there was still an opportunity for partnerships with schools. Again, this just tells you, gives you a visual depiction of those characteristics of those program types across the school year, excuse me, the different years of the program, and you can see the percentages there. Staffing was another key issue. Traditionally in after school and summer programs, you see a mix of staff. You may see certified school day teachers. You may see other non-teaching school staff. You see college and high school students. You also see a mixture of parents and community volunteers, and there may be subcontractors coming in to provide a particular subject matter content. And so we see a variety here. If we go on to the next slide, we'll see the visual depiction there by percentage, percentage of paid staff each year. What this represents to us, pardon me, is that these funds were leveraged, or programs and organizations were able to supplement a high-cost input, which is always a high cost for staffing. But you see there where you see that offset, excuse me, with volunteer supports. And even if you look at the 2023-2024, you see a higher percentage of volunteer staff during that summer than any other period, and then finally a third. And so if you're looking at this, you see a third of these programs, excuse me, more than 30% of the labor in these programs was volunteer labor, which I think is very significant and admirable to be able to leverage the funds in that way. And so if we think about program goals, design, and delivery, we see at least 73%, and I want to just go back and say and highlight the fact that one of the requirements for the funding was to address academics, behavior, attendance, as well as the social engagement, the social learning, and the emotional stability and resiliency of students coming out of the pandemic. And so we see here that at least 73% reported that academics was among their top tier three goals. And so our effort here was to systematize and standardize across all programs a fidelity to academic learning, as well as the social, emotional, cognitive, and physical development of students. So based on survey data from 74 sites, they indicated that reading and mathematics, at least 55%, respectively, and 50% on mathematics were a part of their curricular design, as well as small group tutoring, group homework, help, and very important strategies to helping young people rebound and regain their academic footing. Across both school year and summer program periods, we noted that 60% of the sites offered activities related to both academic career development and 40% offered activities related to, again, those personal competencies, those behavioral and social dynamics, again, focusing on the ability of young people not only to relate to their peers but also to sustain and develop positive interaction with the adults in the program. Again, here's just a visual depiction of what that looks like, what that data point looks like graphically across program years. Here we have another look, again, of what the sites offered related to the academic and career development, where we see more than 60% of the sites offered both content. And this is important. We often say that after-school and summer programs are critical education infrastructure, supplementing school-day learning but not repeating school-day learning for an opportunity offered more varied but structured content. And here we find this input and ability and capacity of programs to provide evidence-based strategies to support workforce, career exploration, and workforce preparedness opportunities. I want to move now to the student outcomes. One of the things if we think about this large sample size of a little more than 20,000 students, we see that at the time the assessment matrices were mathematics and English language arts in terms of the academic inputs. And we see that at least 60% of all students earned A's or B's in English language arts and mathematics. And I will just say, again, according to the U.S. Department of Education's lead statistician, as her analysis of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, that mathematics was a key concern and that the students were faring worse than initially anticipated based on their data. And so we know we still have a concern with mathematics in our state. But what this study suggests is that the approach of intensive academics coupled with those whole child approaches and other activities were able to impact not only English language arts, but also mathematics. Again, we see the proportion of students' grades 9 through 11 with lower cumulative grade points. They were generally higher during the summer, so their participation was higher in the summer versus the school year, which might indicate that programs were actively targeting these students who needed more help during the summer. And anecdotally, school districts and other programs shared with us their concern about this older student population and literacy, fluency, and computational thinking. And so this was a challenge, and these programs were trying to really help older students regain their footing. Approximately 75% of students served during the first half of the initiative were not chronically absent. And beginning in the 2023-24 school year, we see the proportion of students who were not chronically absent decreased to nearly two-thirds or 68%. So you have a bit of a variance there, but overall we see that our students did not regress. In the first half of this program initiative, we actually see attendance, school day attendance, improve. And so across all program periods, the majority of the students served, or 78%, had no recorded disciplinary incidents, whereas 15 to 22% experienced one or more incidents. And so what we see there is not necessarily a high degree of significance, But we do see that the students in the program were able to not only maintain but slightly improve their in-school behavior, which was, again, a significant one of the research questions, and these findings bear that out. There were other just aspects about this. You can drill down in here and think about participation. I think the takeaway here is simple. those students who had higher participation rates in the ARP ESSER III program had higher degree of relevancy, and that showed up in the data in terms of positive youth outcomes. I want to talk a little bit about the notion of collaborative partnerships, and I can certainly answer more questions about student participation and student partnerships. But one of the things, and we conducted our focus groups with other entities, the program director through program director and partner interviews conducted in 2022 and 2023 by our third-party evaluation team. And these were site visits conducting focus groups that helped the evaluation team really understand how these key partners were supporting these initiative-funded sites. And what we found is that we looked at the aggregated data in the data portal, which suggested that fewer than 20% of the programs partnered with school districts during the initiative, but we also found that a majority of the program staff interviewed reported that they partnered with local schools, And those interactions were predominantly positive, which suggests to us, again, whether this was a school-based or community-based entity, the participants and the stakeholder institutions found value in the program, identifying student needs, including communication about how specific students were doing, recruiting and retaining students, referring students to the program. So this wasn't a one-way program. This was bilateral. This was cooperative. And informing the design of programming. So this was, in many ways, a collaborative input from the very beginning, where you have community-based partners and school partners deciding how this particular program would be implemented within a particular setting. And providing staff for the program, including hiring teachers to serve as program staff, providing program space and supplies, including offering classroom space and program meals. And again, a big ticket item was transportation. So we saw a lot of collaboration around transportation to the program. Again, these were about positive or primitive partnerships. You see the visual depiction there, and these were some kind of outgoing stakeholder perspectives, highlighting the increased opportunities for family and community engagement, which was really important. Stakeholders shared how the initiative exposed students to new opportunities, including not only sports programs, but opportunities to spend time outside, off screen, which is really important. Going on field trips, students also were able to make new friends and develop their interests. Stakeholders noted that the initiative provided safe spaces for students, both physically, emotionally, citing the importance of the student or the trusted adult relationship with the students. So this is a summary depiction, and I would just note the map where you see the scale, and every dot represents a location, and in many a site or an organization, I should see, and you even see some in lower Arkansas. And again, we've talked about the 252 organizations and proposals. This project, it was 25 million, 23 million went directly to the awards, 110 programs, 20,000, more than 20,000 unique students served, And again, this is just a repeat of the stated impacts. And so I think if you reflect on those earlier research questions and thinking about how this would impact students, you see that a high degree of significance in terms of particularly those academic inputs based on those earlier research questions. I want to shift just a bit and just kind of talk about the state of afterschool. This is provided by the After School Alliance, which is a lead thought partner nationally and policy advocacy group at the federal level. They provide a state-level overview really about every four years, but it's really coming now every three years. I just want to call your attention to the 41,407 children based on October 2025 data who participate in an after school currently participate in after school and summer programs again this is an aggregate number reflects all programs whether school-based community-based programs and so I would just say that this is the 2025 data in 2020 when this report came out we were at 61,000 a little more than 61,000 in terms of participation in after school and summer programs. What this represents is a loss of scale and infrastructure in our state, which is very concerning. One of the things that we know about these numbers is that when parents, if you dig down in this report, barriers are transportation and cost and lack of convenience in terms of the location to participation. But we're averaging about 6.5 hours a week. Our average cost is about ninety six dollars and forty cents based on this report and so what this means is we have two hundred and fifty five almost two hundred and fifty fifty six thousand children who are not in a program and and I think of that number we have two hundred and fourteen thousand excuse me who are not in a program, but would participate in a program if one were available. And so this is America After 3 data, and so we have a ways to go in terms of meeting the needs of students in Arkansas. I just want to, many of you may know that we do receive federal funds for afterschool and summer, but those funds are only able to serve about a little more than 12,000 youth in each cycle. And so this is the picture. If you look at this map, you see there are really some sparse areas. If you compare that to the ESSER map earlier, you'll see that there was much more, there were more sites and more access and more opportunity. And so really we're back to square one with the only real dedicated revenue for comprehensive community-based, school-based, programs being, we're left only with the federal funding, so there is no dedicated stated revenue to support these programs. I will just note that in terms of closing the participation gap, I noted earlier what the data reflects is the reasons. It's not because parents don't want these programs, it's generally because, again, it's the lack of access, transportation, cost, and other barriers. I will note that there are surrounding states who are meeting this challenge. We have Alabama that has general revenue supporting this. Tennessee uses their lottery, a portion of their lottery funds to support this. Georgia has a public-private partnership to support their efforts. Texas has dedicated general revenue. And South Carolina apportions a part in their state budget to the South Carolina After School Alliance, who then, because of their expertise, can make smaller grants to programs. And so we do have other models, and every state is working to achieve this, and so are we. One of the things that we are looking at now is, as we look at the upcoming session, is are there any creative ways to create more access to programs? like these again we covered with the arp esser funds we covered pretty much every corner of the state from smaller communities like mansfield or mountain view or mountain home cutter morning star near hot springs all the way down to uh ashville excuse me ash down in nashville smaller communities near Texarkana, Hamburg, Stuttgart, and other areas that, and even Clarendon and other areas that generally do not have access to these kinds of programs. And Greenbrier is another location that had a mobile learning lab, converted a school bus and took them even further into remote areas in that area and in that county. And so this was a creative, innovative approach to programming, and I'll have my contact up. I also provided, again, the executive summary, which provides a deeper dive. And anyone who wants the 164 comprehensive evaluation detailed report, I'll be more than happy to provide that as well. Thank you so much. I'm
excited to see this data. Obviously, I think we've known for a long time the importance of afternoon and summer programs, but to have the data is pretty amazing. One of the questions that I have is where are the five of the six kids or I'm not looking at the data right in front of me. Yeah, the five of the six kids that are missing out, where are they going after school and during the summer? Do we know what
they're doing? Are they at home or latchkey? Unfortunately, many of them are, you know, What we find is if they're a family with multiple children, the older children are watching the younger ones. In some cases, if there is a grandparent who is not working and has the capacity and ability, sometimes they're with their grandparents. Unfortunately, more often than not, they're at home alone or they are what we call, say, roaming, which means that they're left to their own devices and unsupervised. which means that we have a problem really between that critical time of 3 to 6 p.m. and certainly during the summer months.
toward for ideas? Yes, I would agree with that. And there are other states who have successfully done this and it's not necessarily something that was easy for them to achieve. It took a long time, and as some of you may know, in our state, our first request for dedicated state revenue came in 2011 with the Positive Youth Development Grant Program Act, and we actually used the framework and regulations of that act to inform this work So we were not recreating the wheel so that we would have an opportunity to test whether or not that model was valid or relevant to Arkansas. And we found that it was. And so we will continue to try. And, yes, I think those states could provide a lot of strategy and information and insight as to what their approach is.
kids are not getting after school or summer. I think there are always opportunities for us to increase our engagement with the public. As a statewide after school network, you know, we hear these stories over and over again of the positive impact. But we also hear the stories, unfortunately, of program closures and programs being restructured. And we work on increasing that awareness, but I think that's something that we certainly need to do more of and as often as we can. And so this opportunity today, I think, is a step really in a really positive direction in terms of raising awareness. Anything that you, I mean,
I think this is great. We can share this report and information. I think that's great. I'm not seeing any other questions. I'm sorry. Representative Gonzalez-Werthin.
Thank you, Madam Chair. I just want to thank you for all of your work and effort in this report and just the amount of work it took to do a three-year longitudinal study, everything that came in and out, but when we look at the results and, I mean, looking at, yes, we do have 21 CCLC programs, 21 century programs in Arkansas, but a small number of youth, you know, that are being able to be served, and time and time again, we have parents that really, really want to send their kids and I was asking a parent just here recently that she has two two children two sons in elementary school and she said I I would love to be able to send them to after school program but I can't afford six hundred dollars a week you know and so if you're low-income family single parent that the programs are are just outrageously expensive and so with this this gives us really a really wonderful blueprint template I'm sure we'll continue to be in conversations this one
data point or one one just briefly that I did not add is that the my team and I really were the administrators of the process and I am pleased to report to you that we did not have one issue of malfeasance with this project these programs and organizations were tested and deemed to be fiscally sound from the onset we had a real really stringent process around purchasing and so we were monitoring and keeping track of what was allowable and what was not and so we're really proud as an organization that we were able to support programs so that they met the needs of students at at the same time being responsible for these dollars. And so that's something that I think it's important for you to note as well. And clearly we would not have been able to do that without the support of Arkansas State University as well.
Thank you. - Great. Well, thank you so much. Thank you for being here today. Thank you for staying so long. I apologize for the technical issues. And thank you for your work all these years on after school and summer. appreciate you thank you all thank you and committee with that is there any other business seeing none this meeting is adjourned
C. Presentation of Early Childhood Policy - Dr. Cynthia Osborne, Prenatal-to-3 Policy Impact Center, Vanderbilt University
55:11 - 6:505 documents
Dr. Cynthia Osborne presented research showing a strong correlation (0.92) between third-grade test scores and 11th-grade outcomes, and a notable link (0.72) between kindergarten readiness and third-grade performance, emphasizing that early learning occurs before kindergarten and that gaps persist without targeted investment.
[55:14][55:50][56:25][57:02][57:33][58:05][58:42]
She highlighted that current public spending heavily favors K-12 (over $15,000 per student) while investing only $1,900-$3,700 per child in the birth-to-three period, and outlined 17 evidence-based policy strategies-such as child-care subsidies, Early Head Start, and workforce development-to improve early brain development and family resources.
[59:13][59:49][1:00:24][1:00:59][1:01:32][1:02:04][1:02:40]
After the presentation, Rep. Denise Garner thanked Dr. Osborne, invited questions, and the committee noted interest in further discussion, with no motions or votes taken.
[1:16:37][1:16:49][1:17:10]
D. Update on Early Childhood Education from the Arkansas Department of Education (ADE) [Exhibit D]
6:50 - 1:18:03188 segments14 speakers1 document
The ADE Office of Early Childhood reported that it secured a $14.7 million PDG grant, used to deliver $3.5 million in class-transition payments, $899 k in workforce stipends to 1,623 providers, and approved ten curricula with nine additional curricula under review for full adoption by 2028.
[8:25][9:00][9:37]
It highlighted professional-development activity, noting roughly 3,987 PD opportunities provided, collection of over 5,000 provider surveys, and that 3,700 class observations were completed in 2025-2026 across about 3,500 classrooms.
[10:10][10:47][11:24][11:57][12:30][13:01][13:31]
The presentation broke down funding sources, distinguishing the state-funded Arkansas Better Chance program ($114 million) from the federally funded School Readiness Assistance ($124 million), adding the $14.7 million federal grant and separate Head Start allocations that together support licensed early-childhood providers.
[14:02][14:32][15:03][15:37][16:10][16:46]
E. Overview of Home Visiting [Exhibit E] - Tyra Greenwood, Director, Arkansas Home Visiting Network, Arkansas Children’s Hospital
1:18:03 - 1:42:0155 segments6 speakers2 documents
Tyra Greenwood, Director of the Arkansas Home Visiting Network, described the program’s evolution since the 1980s, its nine current models (including Family Connects, Baby Back Home, Healthy Families America, Nurse-Family Partnership, HIPPY, and PAT), and the collaborative funding structure involving state departments, the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, and private partners.
[1:18:11][1:18:23][1:18:29][1:19:01][1:19:32][1:20:05][1:20:42][1:21:20][1:22:00][1:22:36]
Committee members asked whether the programs have sufficient capacity and waiting lists, and how depression-screening data ties to Arkansas’s high infant and maternal mortality; Greenwood explained limited coverage in some areas, ongoing capacity constraints, and that benchmarks measure not only screening rates but also successful referrals and services provided.
[1:38:34][1:38:49][1:39:04][1:39:38][1:39:47][1:40:11][1:40:41][1:40:50][1:41:13]
Anna Strong, Executive Director of the Arkansas Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, presented Healthy Steps-an evidence-based, interdisciplinary pediatric primary-care program that embeds a specialist in practices to provide universal screenings, referrals, and intensive supports for families with children under three, funded by the Blue and You Foundation, Walmart Foundation, Arkansas Community Foundation and an HRSA grant, and now operating in 17-20 sites across the state.
[1:43:18][1:43:49][1:44:22][1:44:53][1:45:25][1:45:58][1:46:04][1:46:10][1:46:33][1:47:04][1:47:39][1:48:11][1:48:43][1:49:15][1:49:48][1:50:19][1:50:56][1:51:28]
She highlighted that the program has reached over 70,000 children, produced a 6.2-fold increase in maternal-depression screening and higher rates of wellness and developmental visits, and demonstrated a 163 % return on investment supported by a supplemental $3.44 per-member-per-month Medicaid payment.
[1:51:59][1:52:31][1:53:04][1:53:38][1:54:13][1:54:48][1:55:23][1:55:58]
G. Overview of After School and Summer Programs - Dr. Laveta Willis-Hale, Network Director, Arkansas Out of School Network [Exhibits G1-G2]
2:04:14 - 2:43:5075 segments3 speakers4 documents
Dr. Laveta Willis-Hale, Network Director of the Arkansas Out of School Network, presented a data-intensive overview of the state’s after-school and summer learning effort funded through the ARP ESSER III allocation, explaining the project’s origins in 2021, its partnership with Arkansas State University and the American Institute of Research, and the design that linked program activities to academic, behavioral, attendance and social-emotional outcomes.
[2:04:46][2:05:18][2:05:58][2:06:33][2:07:09][2:07:48][2:08:25][2:08:58]
The presentation also emphasized collaborative partnerships, noting that fewer than 20 % of programs formally partnered with school districts but staff reported strong bilateral relationships that facilitated student recruitment, transportation and program design, and the evaluation found positive stakeholder feedback about increased family and community engagement.
[2:28:00][2:28:33][2:29:09][2:29:44]
In the ensuing Q&A, Rep. Denise Garner asked where the “missing” children were spending unsupervised time, prompting Dr. Willis-Hale to describe that many are left at home alone or with grandparents, underscoring a critical supervision gap, while Rep. Justin Gonzales highlighted the prohibitive cost of participation for low-income families and praised the study as a blueprint for future action.
[2:37:47][2:38:06][2:38:19][2:41:45][2:42:19]