Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Revenue & Taxation Committee

April 5, 2013
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1234 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1234”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…reciate a good vote as chairman I'd like to move do pass on House bill 1 2 3 4 all in favor any opposed congratulations represented…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB688 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB688”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
At that particular time, leasing required that sales tax be paid upon registration on the full price of the lease. We were able to change that. We amended it so the customer, the consumer, had an option of paying on monthly payments or on the registration of the vehicle. Because of the negative fiscal impact that was shown at that time, there was a surcharge placed of 1.5 percent. And that surcharge with sunset once we received once we got to a 10% least penetration Well, I don't think we've ever gotten to 1% so it was in Retrospect that was probably a little a pretty high bar to set what this bill does basically is takes away the option of paying on the capitalized front-end cost which Bless orders aren't doing anyway and sets it on the monthly payment. This is a a great benefit to for local tax jurisdiction city and county because it does not have the $25 cap secondly we lowered by statute lowered the lease penetration sunset from 10% to 3% and honestly I don't see us making that in this decade but at least it's a more viable viable bar set so those basically are the two options. We've worked with DF&A for several months to try to create a more friendly atmosphere for leasing in the state because the manufacturers are
▶ Play
pushing it pretty hard. Thank you. I see in the DF&A impact statement that we're talking about the 1.5% rental tax expiring. What is that tax in neighboring states? I know
▶ Play
of no other state that has that. At that particular time, Mr. Chairman, there was, I forget what the fiscal impact was because all leases were being taxed at the front end and not on monthly payments. So I know of no other state that has a surcharge. All right. Thank you very much.
▶ Play
Any members of the committee have a question? Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Yeah, thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. Question, just to make sure I'm understanding what we're doing here is whenever someone leases a vehicle, the tax, instead of it being paid up front like you would with the purchase of a vehicle, you're just pushing that out over the lease period of the vehicle. Is that correct? That is correct. A typical retail purchase now is seven and a half years. A typical lease is 36 months, so you're going to recycle that twice during the same period of time. Okay, so if I lease a car, I'm paying that tax during the 36-month lease when that lease is up. If I purchase the car, do you pay the outstanding balance due on the tax, or how does that work? You would pay the residual value of the vehicle. You have to pay tax again. Okay, and then if you release the car to somebody else than that whatever that value is would you just go to that person? Okay, I just want to make sure I'm understanding and I'll be interested in hearing DFA's yeah All right, thank you Mr. Thompson you
▶ Play
recognize for a question. Thank you Mr. Chair. Would you get credit for that tax that you had
▶ Play
already paid if you bought it at the end of the lease? No, sir the the statute the way it's the way it's Stated now that you have to actually own the vehicle and unless he does not own the vehicle the less or does so there's no there's no tax credit you would get a credit if it's first time leasing you're trading in a vehicle against the lease but a if you're in a lease and you roll it over and go into another lease there's not a tax there's not a tax credit you just continue to pay on
▶ Play
Speaker 14 3:28
your monthly payments but if you roll it over and buy it you do yeah they actually own the vehicle until you purchase it exactly okay yes
▶ Play
sir but but isn't it also true that if you know if If, let's say, the new vehicle costs $25,000, you leased it for three years, and then you choose to buy it at the three-year point, the value is no longer $25,000. You'll pay a lower number, so the tax that you've been paying during the lease period was really consistent with the depreciation value of the car, at least in some measure. Does that make sense? That is exactly
▶ Play
right. Okay, thank you. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. A question that Representative Thompson asked kind of triggered another one on me. Who's going to be responsible for keeping track of all these taxes and making those tax payments to DF&A? The lessor collects the tax. For example, General Motors, all their leases go through Ally, and they have a system already set up. And the state maintains numbers they can calculate once we hit a certain percentage penetration. Right now, I think we're less than 1%. Okay, and these organizations or entities are buying, taking on this new responsibility? They have it already. They're already doing it? Yes, sir. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Does any other
▶ Play
member have a question? Seeing none, is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak against the bill? Seeing none, is there anyone who would like to speak for the bill? Seeing none, Representative Wren, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed, Mr. Chairman and Committee. Representative Thompson, you're recognized for a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Motion do pass. The motion do pass on the table. All in favor? Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative Wren. You've passed the bill. Representative Williams, you're recognized to present HB 1234.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members. pleasure to be before this committee my first time this session I am pleased to be here to present to you a house bill one two what is it three four yes which was the repeal of the grocery tax in 2007 we the General Assembly working with the governor began the repeal of one of the most regressive taxes in the state of Arkansas and that's the grocery tax for decades that tax set at about six percent we reduced it in 2007 to three percent in 2009 we took another one percent off to two percent and then in 2011 we reduced it a half percent down to 1.5 percent where it currently stands so the last these past six years we've reduced 926 million dollars worth of taxes off of Arkansas working families we have one final reduction to make and that's what we bring before for you today it's the one eight reduce it to one eight percent one eighth a percent one eight percent will remain because the voters in Arkansas put that on constitutional we're not going to take that take that off but given the current economic situation where we are we're trying to do this as fiscally responsible as we can by only allowing this tax to be imposed when the director DF&A determines that we have met certain thresholds basically a trigger that you've heard about this placed in the bill and once the director determined that we are for six month period of time that we're able to implement this this tax cut then we will do so I'm pleased that this bill is sponsored by many of you all in this committee and over 60 of our members of the house and I would appreciate a good vote and we'll be happy to take the easy questions and I'll defer the hard questions to the FNA representative Williams could you or should we wait for DFNA
▶ Play
can you can you just top line how those triggers work I think I've heard it but I'm just what I'd
▶ Play
appreciate if you just run that out for me it might be more succinct if I ask someone from DFA mr. leathers will come and give that to
▶ Play
you thank you mr. leathers you're recognized please state your name and position for the record mr. chairman Tim leathers on deputy
▶ Play
Speaker 33 7:34
director from DFA and we have all the experts that spent time drafting this bill to figure it out if we need to go into a great detail but I'll kind of hit the high points on this the this is designed to be able to trigger the tax exemption on food so that it's not impacting general revenues or general revenue calculations in the future it's triggered by certain items that are taken out of general revenue that are not tax collections but their payouts that we have to make and if you guys have looked at the bottom line that we show you when we bring in the revenue report every month and you'll notice on the bottom there's several payouts that we make through economic development desegregation transfers and those sort of things this is triggered by a group of those payouts and when those drop below seventy million dollars at that point then we know that we've had a significant increase in the money we have available for general revenue without a tax crease increase or anything that's economically determined and at that point it triggers the tax exemption and we'll begin the tax exemption so it's all based on the trigger of those items below that come off the top of general revenue we stop paying those out to the amount that we get to 70 million in this triggers thank you very much committee
▶ Play
are there any questions for representative Williams or mr. leathers representative house you recognize for a question a
▶ Play
Speaker 35 9:23
couple questions representative Williams is first of all if would you consider
▶ Play
amending the bill on the floor and adding a couple sponsors I'd be happy to do that I
▶ Play
apologize if I didn't get around the US I thought I got around everybody but I'll be more than happy to well I would love to I would love to have you on as a co-sponsor and while representative house is wanting to join I'll be happy to
▶ Play
anybody else who would like to get on there this does not in any way change the definition of food and food ingredients cities will continue to be able to to tax restaurant sales with this tax this I mean this tax won't affect this this uses the current definition
▶ Play
Speaker 33 10:12
we have for food and it as with the current definition for food and the way we do it will retain the local taxes they won't be impacted at all either in restaurants or otherwise or
▶ Play
grocery stores yes sir okay thank you very much
▶ Play
representative Bragg you organized for a question thank you mr. chairman on the revenue impact statement it says no impact to state general revenues reduced revenue collections are all set by reduced budgetary expenditures how does that balance with the triggers I mean at what point is that
▶ Play
Speaker 33 10:54
determined it requires that this be monitored by the fiscal chief fiscal officer of the state who's the director of DFA my boss sitting over there and we go when we have a six month period that we know that those expenditures that come off the top have decreased to that point and that we've had six months of experience and we know they're going away then at that point it triggers and we under the law we reduce the sales tax on food put that notice out just as if you had passed it during the session we worked hard on trying to get it so that we could be able to constitutionally do this with a trigger and and make it work and we think we've got a fashion to do that at the same time protect the general revenue club by doing that okay thank you representative hutchinson you recognize for
▶ Play
a question thank you mr. chair my question
▶ Play
got answered thank you all right are there any other questions
▶ Play
from the committee seeing none is there anyone that would like to speak against the bill anyone that would like to speak for the bill if not representative Williams would you like
▶ Play
to close for your bill thank you mr. chairman again I would just like to say I think this is a positive step for the working families of Arkansas the grocery tax it's one of the most aggressive taxes that we have and this is a very good for the state
▶ Play
of Arkansas and I would appreciate a good vote as chairman I'd like to move do pass on House bill 1 2 3 4 all in favor any opposed congratulations represented Williams you passed the bill thank you mr. chairman thank you committee committee if if I can get a motion will be adjourned representative Wren all right thank you very much we're adjourned
▶ Play

Agenda

SB688

0:00 - 5:26 25 segments 4 speakers

HB1234

5:26 - 12:44 27 segments 7 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
15 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Chair Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 14
1 segment
Representative Darrin Williams Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 33
7 segments
Speaker 35
1 segment
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Representative Ken Bragg Unverified
1 segment
Representative John K. Hutchison Unverified
1 segment