2013 Boys State
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (8)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1001
· 5 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…read Amendment Number 1 to Bill 1001? Amendment Number 1 to House Bill 1001.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…te on the bill now the question for the house is passage of house bill 1,001. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say nay. Nay.…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1002
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1002”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1003
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1003”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1004
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1004”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1005
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1005”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1006
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1006”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB1
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB1”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
Speaker 1
0:00
...issue of importance to Arkansans, from children's education to banking laws, and from the courts to agriculture. Chosen representatives also serve on five joint committees, along with members of the state's Senate, the other body of our legislature. These committees deal with everything from the state's budget to energy and information technology. Sessions of the House are interesting and informative to watch. You are welcome to visit and get a bird's-eye view of your representatives and democracy in action from the viewing gallery high above the House floor.
After all, it's your House. You elect its members, and they meet to represent you. If you can't observe the sessions in person, you can follow news coverage gathered here in the Media Gallery. And every session is broadcast live on television and on the House's website for your viewing. We invite you to learn more at www.arkansahouse.org and to get involved. It's your house. Welcome.
Every Arkansan has a house right inside the state capitol, the Arkansas House of Representatives. and what happens in this house affects the lives of everyone in our state as it has for nearly two centuries. The Arkansas legislature began meeting back in 1820, nearly two decades before Arkansas became a state. In fact, the territorial legislature was instrumental in helping Arkansas gain statehood in 1836.
For 80 years, the House of Representatives met in what we now call the old State House. In 1911, the House of Representatives relocated in the then-unfinished State Capitol building, where it is still at work today. There are 100 members of the House who meet here in the House chamber every year. Each is elected for up to three two-year terms and represents a district of the state and an equal number of citizens. The Speaker of the House, elected by fellow members, presides over the sessions.
Besides meeting as a body, representatives serve on two of ten standing committees during and between sessions. These committees address every issue of importance to Arkansans, from children's education to banking laws, and from the courts to agriculture. Chosen representatives also serve on five joint committees along with members of the State Senate, the other body of our legislature. These committees deal with everything from the state's budget to energy and information technology.
Sessions of the House are interesting and informative to watch. You are welcome to visit and get a bird's eye view of your representatives and democracy in action from the viewing gallery high above the House floor. After all, it's your House. You elect its members and they meet to represent you. If you can't observe the sessions in person, you can follow news coverage gathered here in the media gallery, and every session is broadcast live on television and on the House's website for your viewing. We invite you to learn more at www.arkansashouse.org and to
get involved. It's your House. Welcome. Every Arkansan has a house right inside the state capitol, the Arkansas House of Representatives. And what happens in this house affects the lives of everyone in our state as it has for nearly two centuries. The Arkansas Legislature began meeting back in 1820, nearly two decades before Arkansas
became a state. In fact, the territorial legislature was instrumental in it.
Speaker 8
4:06
It's a bit daunting. I encourage you to sit back, try your best to relax and take it all in. I am Eddie Armstrong, State Representative for House District 37. That's my good seat right there. That's a little bit of Norfolk Rock, Maumelle and Southeast Jacksonville. I serve as a freshman, first-year legislator in this body, and I have to tell you that it's a real humbling and wonderful, blessed experience to A, be elected by the people,
but B, to be able to serve in this esteemed group with a limited amount of people to make bills and laws that will change the lives for a countless number of Arkansans all across this state. I wanted to take a moment this morning to recognize my colleagues that are standing around the room and i'll go by their names and if they please just wave wave their hands and be recognized we'll start with representative stephen meeks who you saw yesterday he could not be here this morning but representative warwick sabin who you saw yesterday
representative nate steel nate's from nashville arkansas representative darren williams who you just heard from the great example for us all here is our speaker pro tem here from little rock Representative Mark Lowry from Maumelle. Representative Greg Letting from Fayetteville. Representative Monty. This is funny. He's typically a few minutes late.
He'll come running in. Tall guy. Give him a hard time. Representative Monty Hodges from Blaville. Representative Kim Hammer from Benton, Arkansas. and Representative Jim Dotson from Bentonville, Arkansas. Guys, last thing, and I'll turn it back over to our parliamentarian. I mentioned, you know, you're going to be maybe a little nervous when you're here in the well. Just a few pointers to encourage you. If you're presenting a bill today, it's not so much necessary.
I'm one to read from paper. But if you have your bill. Duncan. Oh, how could I forget my vice chair? I apologize. The incomparable joint budget vice chair, Duncan Baird, who's a great friend of mine from Northwest Arkansas. Apologize, Duncan. You're at the top of the page, so sorry. Duncan's been a good mentor and friend. I'll pay for that later. Thanks, Darren. But my point was, when you're down here and you're preparing to present your bills, I was saying that I typically read from paper.
This process is about a lot of reading, and if you do your homework and you're well prepared, I know you guys are getting this in the vacuum, but when you come down today, you do not have to read the entire bill in its entirety. Give the highlights of the bill. Let it be known how the bill made it out of committee. If it passed unanimously, if it passed by majority of the vote, explain the bill as clearly as you possibly can. You are welcome to take as many questions as you'd like, which means you stay in the well, But as Nate has told me many times, get down there, read your bill, and get out.
So once you've read your bill, if no one stands up and holds their mic, which I think Buddy's going to explain to you to ask to be recognized for questioning, read your bill or explain your bill and remove yourself from the well so that the process can continue to move forward today. I congratulate you again for your efforts and your leadership back in your districts, and I hope that you take this process serious today and come away with here with some newfound knowledge, and don't hesitate to ask us any questions. Thank you guys for being here.
Speaker 78
7:42
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Gentlemen, when the speaker recognizes you from the speaker's rostrum, he's going to use the name at the desk where you're sitting. So become familiar with the desk, like Mr. Mayberry here, Mr. Jett. For the purposes of the Boise State, that's who you're going to be from the speaker's view. so that's the realize that if you want to ask a question or be recognized for a motion please stand at your desk and hold up your microphone and the parliamentarian and the speaker will be
scanning the floor constantly to see who wants to be recognized and so that's that that's important you need to get this get recognition also if you during the debate if you if someone is speaking and you would like an opportunity to participate in the debate please stand and using eye contact give a thumbs up if you want to speak for a bill or thumbs down if you want to speak against the bill and the parliamentarian will keep a list of members who want to speak and we'll try to keep
them in order of as you are recognized so you'll have that opportunity with
that mr speaker The 2013 session of Arkansas Boys State will please come to order. I invite the members, staff, and guests in the gallery to stand and be led in prayer by the House Chaplain, Gibson Fisher, and remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance. Please bow.
Speaker 17
9:25
Dear Lord, I thank you for this day. I thank you for the opportunity that you've given all of us to come to Boys State this week and create lifelong relationships with our brothers. I also thank the capital of Arkansas for letting us come into their building and run a session and learn more about the government of the United States of America. I ask you, Lord, to please be with us during this session and make it the best as possible. Amen. Now I'd like to lead you on the pledge.
Speaker 21
10:05
of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with the liberty
of justice for all. Please be seated. As first order of business, the chair appoints the following members, Mr. McElroy, Mr. McGee, and can I have another volunteer?
to notify the Senate that the House is organized and ready for business. Mr. Thompson? Mr. Thompson, thank you. Representative Gray has moved we put Bill 1001, excuse me, on second reading for amendment.
All in favor please say aye. I do believe the ayes have it. Mr. Clerk, will you please read Amendment Number 1 to Bill 1001? Amendment Number 1 to House Bill 1001.
Mr. Gray, you're recognized. And this is my bill and my amendment, and I'd appreciate a good vote. It's over unemployment benefits, and I'd appreciate a good vote for this. Sorry. Mr. Gray has explained the amendment.
Would anyone like to speak against it, for it? Mr. Gray is closed for the amendment. Question for the House is passage now. So, Amendment 1, we're going to be voting. Question for the House is passage of Amendment 1, House Bill 1001.
All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say nay. Nay. The ayes have it. The bill
Speaker 78
12:48
is sent to, send the bill to engrossing. Gentlemen, what just happened, the first bill on the agenda had an amendment, and it was a member's amendment, and the process moved quickly and efficiently, which is what happens in the House of Representatives. and under real circumstances, the bill would go to engrossing
where the amendment would be added to the bill and then it would be available for consideration later. So, and it will be available for consideration in just a few moments. The
Thank you. Mr. Clerk, will you please read House Bill 1001? House Bill 1001 by Representative Gray, and it reads, to limit unemployment benefits and to require random drug tests, public service work, and disqualification from employment benefits. Representative Gray, you are recognized to explain the bill.
Please come forward to the well, to the
passed unanimously out of committee. And what it's going to do is we're setting a time limit of 26 weeks on unemployment.
And after that, you can get it if you do public service work, and you can apply for this. And also, there will be random drug tests, and if you fail the drug test, then your unemployment will be removed. So, any questions? I appreciate a good vote. Thank you.
representative Williams for what purpose do you rise um I have a question about this bill I was wondering how this will be paid for he's I'm sorry representative grace left the well okay representative gray is open for the bill would anyone like to speak against
the bill. Please raise your stand up. Representative Malone, I think. For what purpose do you rise? I just wanted to point out that statistically only 10% of people receiving welfare are on drugs, so it would be unnecessary, in my opinion, and a waste of money to do the random drug test.
Thank you. Representative Malone has spoken against the bill. Is there anyone who wishes to speak for the bill? Against the bill? Representative Perry, for what purpose do you rise? You're recognized.
Speaker 62
17:01
Well, I believe if you're going to drug test just for somebody being on welfare, I just feel like that would be stereotypical. Just saying somebody that's on welfare, just on drugs, it's going to cause a lot of commotion, a lot of lawsuits and a lot of unnecessary things. And just like he pointed out before, it's only 10%. So there's just a lot of unnecessary money that's going
forward. Representative Perry has spoken against the bill.
Representative McGee, for what purpose do you write? You can speak for or against the bill. this bill is not for welfare it is for unemployment every time y'all bring up a statistic it is for welfare the bill was brought up for the unemployment is two
entirely different things. Thank you. Representative McGee has spoken for the bill. Representative Davis, Speaker Pro Tem, you are recognized to speak
Speaker 78
18:34
against the bill. all right uh when you take unemployment benefits it takes an enormous psychological toll against
your pride because as men we feel that it is our duty to be able to provide for our families and And when you take, like, charity in a way, which really, well, what this is, it is already a psychological toll. And then when you drug test them, it's an even more of a psychological toll saying, oh my gosh, you know, people who, you know, it's really stereotyping. People who take this kind of welfare or, you know, unemployment are using drugs.
Like, that kind of, this kind of psychological toll works against them. The purpose of unemployment benefits is to help these people through a hard time in their lives of being unemployed and to want to give them, you know, so they can stay on their feet and not lose their homes, not be able to continue to feed their families. And this kind of drug test saying, oh, Daddy, where were you? Oh, I was taking a drug test because the government thinks that I'm doing drugs even though I'm trying to get a job.
This is just further distracting them from where they should be trying to move towards their lives. And it's a psychological thing. So vote this bill down. Representative Edwards, for what purpose do
you rise? To speak against him. Oh. Oh, I got a question for him. Oh, okay. Why should you be afraid of taking a drug test if you know you're going to pass it? It's not being afraid of taking it.
Speaker 78
20:18
It's a psychological suspicion. Nobody likes to be suspected against. Nobody likes to be accused of using drugs. And when you take a drug test, you're pretty much being accused of using drugs. and it's a I mean you've been accused of you know taking the cookie from the cookie jar even though you didn't do it it's it's a it's very psychological it's not actually about if you do drugs or not it's it's psychological because you
are are you going to be in a really bad psychological place if you are taking unemployment benefits because you know you have a job that's that's a it's a social convention to have a job and to provide for your family so that kind of suspicion works against you
thank you the speaker pro temp is spoken against the bill representative Dotson do you still wish to rise you were recognized speak for
Speaker 78
21:25
I feel that the point of unemployment is to help people who have been in unfortunate circumstances and I don't feel that it's really a charity I feel that it's just something that we're doing to help somebody get back on his
or her feet and for that purpose I feel that the drug test would be beneficial because well like like representative Edwards said why would you be afraid to take it if you know you're going to pass it and I understand where you come from from when you say that it's like being falsely accused of being on drugs, but you've got to
come to a point where you think, do we feel that we need to just keep doing something when there's the possibility that someone's abusing it, or if we take the right stance to make sure that nobody is abusing it at all uh
oh i'm sorry you're recognized ask a question are you aware that florida passed a similar bill several years ago and that it's costing more money than it saves them
where did you get that statistic i just recently received this information from who what are the uh house representatives all righty well i
Speaker 78
23:12
i mean i'm not saying that you're wrong or anything i mean that sounds like that's good but so what i mean does that say that we're going to have the same circumstances well
don't are we not giving away this money uh so we can save money true we are not doing that excuse me but we you're not really supposed to have a discourse between
two speakers. It's just a question and an answer. Representative Wuerr, for what purpose do you rise? You're recognized. Okay.
You want to check for drugs, but it's been statistically proven that alcohol can do more damage than some drugs that are illegal right now. So why is it that you check for these drugs but you do
Speaker 78
24:09
not slander alcohol the amendment is for
drug tests not alcohol tests representative Cozark for
what purpose do you rise I have a question you're recognized um is isn't alcohol part of a drug test isn't there? Not that I'm aware of. Okay, let's see. I can go. Representative Dotson has spoken for the bill. Is there anyone who
wish to speak against the bill? Representative Ballinger? Rice. Representative Rice, you were recognized to speak against the bill. Don't these people who have this unemployment, aren't they earning their money? So if they're So if they're on drugs, it's their business, not ours.
And it's kind of discrimination, us, you know, saying, well, we're going to drug test you because we think, because you're on unemployment, that we're just going to drug test you. Representative Collins, for what purpose do you rise? To ask a question.
Because they work for their money first. They were working, now they're unemployed. Representative Cozart, for what purpose do you rise? I have a comment.
No, sorry, comments aren't allowed exactly. Do you have a question? I have a question. You're recognized. Isn't there some employment, like... Benefits? Huh? And benefits? Oh, and in work, there are some employment in workplaces that do do drug tests,
Okay. Representative Copenhagen, for what purpose do you rise? I have a question. you're recognized so you're saying that if people on unemployment are doing drugs it's none of our business so are you saying that the state of arkansas should supply their drug addiction i'm not saying that i'm saying they earn their money they want to do it we shouldn't
i mean if they're on that we shouldn't bother them thank you Representative Rice has spoken against the bill. Representative Ballinger, for what purpose do you rise? Oh, you're right, can I speak for the bill? Excuse me. Thank you, Speaker.
I just wanted to make two points about things that have been brought up. The reason, we have drug tests in most jobs that, most jobs require drug tests, so why not require drug tests for this unemployment? And also, the point of this bill isn't to punish them in any way. It's just to push them to look for a job. We're not trying to pay them to relax and sit back. It is to get them off their feet, yes, and to keep them going, but we want them to look for jobs.
Representative Ballinger has spoken for the bill. Is there anyone who wishes to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Bain, you are recognized to speak for the bill. um earlier it said that the drug tested would psychologically hurt them and maybe that would
do that but i think that that would be beneficial maybe pushing them to want to find a job quicker i know that our economy is hard to do that and also for the um drug testing well i think it is our business in a sense because the taxpayer detained if you said 10 people do do drugs then I think it is our business because we're the ones paying for that. So, thank you. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Meeks, you recognize to speak against the bill.
Speaker 122
29:11
um since the bill is trying to enact for extended unemployment that you have to do uh public service is that not nearly the same thing as just giving them a job because they're doing work to earn this money, so I'm just questioning that.
I mean, why do we call it, why are we giving them unemployment, but we're basically giving them a job? Representative Ballinger, for what purpose do
Speaker 122
29:56
that we should just pay them to do nothing? But I'm just questioning the part of the
bill that for the extended unemployment, that they have to do public service. Representative Dotson, for what purpose do
ask everyone, when I ask for what purpose do you rise, you're either, if you're asking a question, say to ask a question, please. Okay, question. You're recognized.
Speaker 78
30:29
Go ahead. Thank you. I just wanted to know whenever you said that it would be the same thing as giving them a job, I don't feel that it's the same thing at all because they're not getting the money because they're doing the public service.
They're doing the public service in order to receive the benefit. Is that
not the same thing? I don't think so. Representative Gillum, for what purpose do you rise? ask a question you're recognized uh just to clarify is your uh are you
worried that someone could indefinitely work for public service and still be paid that they could somehow that's
Speaker 122
31:12
that's kind of what i'm worried about because i mean basically the point of enacting
that is so that they can't just ride on unemployment for so long they have to go out and get a job but with that you're i mean they're just going to keep continuing to do the public service Which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but, I mean, why not just make these things actual jobs, like government jobs, so that they don't have to, like, file for unemployment and stuff like that and have to go through the humiliation of unemployment.
Representative Mayberry, for what purpose do you rise?
I motion for immediate... I don't think now is the time to make a motion because he has the floor right now. Later, when no one's up there speaking, would be the proper time to make a motion. However, Representative Bain, for what purpose do you rise? Can you leave real quick? Oh, I can. I'll make a motion for immediate consideration. Wait, wait, wait. No. Still not time to make a motion.
All right. Representative Meeks. motion for immediate consideration you have to be recognized by me i'm sorry so representative bain for what purpose do you rise i make a motion for immediate consideration let's hear your motion will you please immediately consider eyes to move on and vote uh a proper motion has been made not debatable the question for the house is the motion
to immediately consider house bill 1001 all in favor say aye all opposed say nay I believe the ayes have it can we
Speaker 78
33:20
explain what that was you're recognized yes please thank you mr. speaker what happened just there is there a motion made for immediate consideration which is just a motion to end debate and vote immediately
so that wasn't a vote on the bill if you were wanting to vote right now you would have voted aye if you wanted to have more debate you would have voted no that's what that
was thank you there'll be another vote on the bill now the question for the house is passage of house bill 1,001. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say nay. Nay. I believe the ayes have it. Do I see five hands? All right, we're going to do a roll call by division.
All in favor, please rise at your desk. and
on the bill you're voting on the bill whether you want to pass or not this is in favor Okay, I got 54.
With the nays, please stand. It'll be easier to count the numbers. Don't forget to count the speaker pro temp. By a vote of 54 to 36, Bill 1001 does pass.
Mr. Clerk, please read House Bill 1002. House Bill 1002 is presented by Representative Clawwitter, and it reads to legalize, license, and tax marijuana. Mr. Clawwitter, you're recognized. You're recognized. Come on, up.
Speaker 16
36:06
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Basically, this bill takes the, it legalizes marijuana,
but it also puts a restriction on your possession, and you have to have a license to sell it, and it also taxes it, because that's it. Thank you, Representative.
Is Representative Collins, for what purpose do you rise? Would this be legalization? You have to state your purpose, which would be, I guess, a question. Ask a question. You're recognized. Would this be legalization for recreational use or medicinal use? Recreational. Thank you. Representative Cozart. Question. You're recognized. Is there an age restriction?
Yes, 18. Representative Ferguson, for what purpose do you rise? I have a question. You're recognized. What
Speaker 170
37:18
type of tax would you have on marijuana, like a state sales tax or any other type of tax? A sales tax, it would be in
the same category as tobacco. Okay, thank you. Representative Rice, for what purpose do you rise? Is that age restriction?
I don't forget to state your purpose. To ask a question. Yes, you're recognized. Is that age number to smoke it or to
thank you. Representative Hammer, for what purpose do you rise? To ask a question. You're recognized. Okay, so alcohol, the whole reason the drinking age is at 21 is because it has an effect on brain cells, tobacco, it does not, and THC and marijuana has an effect on brain cells, so why would the age be 21, or be 18, not 21?
It actually doesn't have an effect on brain cells. Where that came from was when they tested it, they tested it on monkeys, and they pumped so much smoke in at once, it suffocated them, and the first thing to die when you suffocate is your brain cells. Representative Clemmer, for what purpose do you rise? Question. You're recognized. Did you say
Speaker 176
38:40
that you were going to try to limit how much each person had? Yes. How do you plan on doing that?
Um, they'll be the same way, it'll be checked by like police if you get caught or whatever. If you have more than an ounce on your possession, you'll be, uh, all right, except for the consequences. Representative Holcomb, for what purpose do you rise? To ask a question. You're recognized. Uh, Representative Claywood's, uh, Clawwaiter, excuse me, has left the well, so we can't have any more questions. I apologize. Is there anyone who wishes to speak against the bill? Uh, Representative Blaine, for what purpose do you rise? You're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to say that it's been proven that marijuana is definitely like a gateway drug. So I don't think it's right for the generation that's coming up to have an ability whenever they can't think, they can't process through Leah until like age 25 to be able to smoke a gateway drug that will probably hurt them. Representative Overby, for what purpose do you rise? your question. You're recognized.
Speaker 78
40:03
When it's been medically proven that marijuana has less
long-term adverse effects than alcohol, how would you say it's a gateway
drug? Well, I wasn't talking about medically. He was saying recreational use, so that recreationally it would be. I don't mean
Speaker 78
40:14
medically, like for medicine purposes. I mean physically it doesn't harm your body as much as alcohol, so how would you consider that more of a gateway drug than alcohol, which is already legal?
Because it's just been proven it's a gateway drug. I don't know. That's all. Thank you. All right, the representative list has left the well, so do I have anyone to speak for the bill?
Representative Word, for what purpose do you rise? You're recognized. I would
just like to say that whether we like it or not, people are going to get their hands on marijuana. So if we take it off the black market, then there would be less crime involved.
Thank you, Representative. There are no questions. you may be seated and well uh representative spoke for the bill so representative grilliam grilliam gilliam excuse me you recognize speak against the bill okay so the only problem i have with this bill
i don't really care whether you smoke what you want it doesn't matter to me the last line in the bill says that the taxes
for would be used for a drug abuse program there's nothing wrong with that but i feel like the entire point of de-legalizing marijuana and then taxing it so we can make money off it and do some more productive things with it you know improving roads schools and things like that so i think it would be nice if we could see where this
tax money could go to things other than just uh drug abuse programs representative catlett for what purpose do you
Speaker 78
42:25
rise Opposed question. You're recognized. So you don't think, okay, so the point was made that marijuana is a gateway drug.
So you don't think it's important enough to put money into drug abuse education programs to prevent the possibility of it being a gateway drug? No, I'm just saying that,
let's be honest, we're going to make a lot of money off this if we do legalize it. And I think there's going to, we're going to have more money than we know what to do with for just drug abuse programs. I think it should be expanded so that there's more, we can do more things with
Speaker 170
42:59
that. Representative Ferguson, for what purpose do you rise? You're recognized. Well, that's loud.
Since he said that it's basically counterproductive to tax a drug and then use that tax to fund drug abuse education programs, do you think that we should instead use it to support just general education programs? I didn't say it
was counterproductive, I just think that the money can be spent in a wider, doing a wider array of things
than just drug prevention. Thank you, Representative. Representative Malone, you are recognized to speak for the bill.
Oh, you're not, you don't wish to? Is there anyone to speak for the bill then? Very well then, the, I, Representative, I recognize the Speaker Pro Tem to speak
Speaker 78
43:59
for the bill. Alrighty, so let's look at the prison population in the United States. Since marijuana is criminalized right now, the United States government is putting many relatively nonviolent offenders in prison.
they are being grouped in with people who steal who rape and they murder and everybody knows that when you go to prison there there is almost a you come out hardened in a way there are a lot of bad influences they have gangs there are just you're around people that haven't made the best decisions of their lives and the united states has less than five percent of the world's population but 25 greater than 25 percent of the world's prison population that's 2.3 million people
in the united states are in prison and we only have 300 million
people so uh representative dawson for what purpose do you rise what purpose do you write
Speaker 78
45:03
question you're recognized um i just i i get what you're saying and i feel the same way really but i just don't feel that if we only allow one ounce on a person at a time that legalizing it i'm getting to the question part um if only one
ounce is allowed on us at a time how that could um really change the population in prisons uh point Point of clarification, I don't believe in the bill that actually specifies one ounce. Like, if you read the
bill. Thank you. Representative Linderman, for what purpose do you rise? You're recognized. Okay, so you're saying
Speaker 78
45:51
that you want to legalize marijuana to lower the number of people in prison, right?
To lower the amount of people in prison because of the adverse effects of what happens once you go to prison. Okay, so that's the same thing as saying, well, let's make murder legal just to lower the number. If something's wrong, it's wrong. Absolutely not. With murder, you are hurting another human being. With the usage of marijuana, who else are you hurting besides yourself? You're hurting yourself. You can't make something legal when it's wrong just to lower the number of people in prison. it's it's not you
representatives please try to keep your questions concise and to the point and
also try to avoid discourse and try to remain civil please uh representative i think representative uh word for what purpose do you rise push to make an amendment to the bill i don't think you do not have the floor so i don't believe you can propose an amendment at this moment representative uh care for what purpose do you rise question you're recognized thank you mr speaker what is your reason why are
Speaker 78
47:03
I was gonna talk about more about the militarization militarization of the drug war in the board of the United States of Mexico but I didn't get the chance to talk about that so I also talk about that right now on the border there There are so many people being killed by the drug cartels. The corruption of the police in Mexico is a huge problem. Living in Arkansas, I'm sure we don't know the extent, but Time Magazine, NPR, they've done some great documentaries of what is actually being going on.
And so that's just one argument for the militarization of the border. and number two the prison population is it's very expensive to keep people in prison and many people who work also use marijuana so they can still be productive members of society even though they can they have a couple hours of
fun in their lives thank you representative mcgee for what purpose do you rise ask a question you're recognized okay you just said that using marijuana
only hurt yourself but then you come back and say that it is okay for society if everybody's hurting themselves or most people are harming themselves how is that good for
Speaker 78
48:23
society it's it's i said that they're harming themselves for the for to appease you almost it could be argued that it doesn't hurt yourself but i'm not going to argue that at this moment um you know you can still be a productive member of society you're not hurting the state uh representative malone for what purpose do you rise i
would like to speak for the bill uh someone else is has the
has the will right now so that's not the proper time to do it sorry representative alexander for what purpose do you rise i would like to ask a question you're recognized well the speaker's left the well so i'm sorry We need to speak against the bill. Representative Dodson, you're recognized to speak against
Speaker 78
49:31
the bill. Dodson. um to go back on with the question that i asked earlier i i know how you know the mexican cartels
are i know it's a bad industry and that people are getting killed every day because of this and that legalizing it would sort of help that out. But whoever proposed the bill said that it would be limited to having one ounce on a person at a time. And if that's the case, then what is one ounce going to do?
I mean, is anybody aware of how much one ounce is? I mean, you know, that's a lot this way, but that's not much for people I know. So, I mean, you know, I don't know. I just wanted to bring that up. If
you wanted to ask a question, but the speakers left the well, so. I believe we have a motion somewhere.
Motion. Edwards. Representative Edwards, for what purpose do you rise? I would like to make a motion. What is the motion? I would like to limit debate to one minute for each sided. For each speaker, I believe you mean? Yes. That is a proper motion, and it is not debatable. So the question for the House is a motion to limit debate to one minute for each speaker. all in favor say aye
all opposed because it requires a two-thirds aye vote I'm going to say that the nays do have it represent we now representative Representative Barrett, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
All right, just to be real about it, I don't know, like, where the Mexican cartel came from or whatever, but, and if you know people that are smoking an ounce, they probably smoke every day, all day, so your friends would probably be mad that you're going against it. And there's no proven fag that it says it's a gateway drug. And if people are going to smoke it, why not make money off of it? You know, go ahead and tax the heck out of it. Let us get us a little bit out of debt. And, I mean, it's not going to really do anything but help us. So, question?
Representative Overby, for what purpose do you rise? Okay, Representative Care, for what purpose do you rise? Question. You're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The bill actually does not legalize the use of marijuana. It only legalizes the production, sale, and possession of it, not actually the use. I think it's recreational.
It says that nowhere in the bill. I mean, you can still smoke it. Representatives, please try to maintain decorum, and that means keeping talking
minimum. Representatives Ballinger, for what purpose do you rise?
For what purpose? What? Question? Speak. I've been waiting to speak. Okay, well, we're getting to you. You're next on the list for next, but so. Now he's left the well, so we're now looking for negative speakers. You are next on the list, so Representative Ballinger, you are recognized, speak, and negation.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'd like to make a point that legalizing this drug will not get rid of the black market. Actually, it'll probably increase it just like gambling did once it was legalized. The more black market illegal gambling started taking place. So that's one point. And another point, a lot of you have been saying that marijuana is not a gateway drug. It is. Alcohol does not get you high. Alcohol makes you drunk. They're two completely different things. uh representative catlett for what purpose do you rise ask a question you're recognized um so you
Speaker 78
54:34
think that the black market will actually grow in size after marijuana is legalized much like alcohol yes representative mcgee
for what purpose do you rise i don't have the question okay representative richie for what purpose do you rise question you're recognized um you said that alcohol doesn't get you high, would you rather have a drunk person drive you home or a stoned person drive you home? Neither. Representative Armstrong, for what purpose do you rise?
Speaker 229
55:08
Question? Question, yes. You're recognized. Do you have any evidence that it is a gateway drug, like specific evidence, a case study or
something? I mean, no one has specific evidence, but you've seen cases where many people have smoked the drug and then have had their stories about how they have moved on to different drugs and then they just can't get out of the more in-depth drugs like methamphetamines or cocaine or heroin, things like that. Representative Lowry, for what purpose do you rise? You're recognized.
How has the black market in terms of alcohol grown since it was legalized? I did not say alcohol. I said gambling. Representative Armstrong, for what purpose do you rise? The representative has left the well, so no more questions. Representative Gillum, for what purpose do you rise? Motion. Let us hear the motion. Motion to put this back to committee. All right. A motion has been made as a proper motion.
It is debatable. So Representative Gillum, would you like to come down and explain your motion? so i
think that we should probably send this back to committee for amendment because there are some specifics of the bill that people don't really know about like how much marijuana one could carry on someone at any given time without being arrested i think that the tax issue is probably a really big idea so i think if we were to send this back to committee get change to the
bill's wording a little bit and then bring it
back before us we could probably have a lot better bill thank you representative Gilliam has explained the motion and we are now would anyone like to speak for the motion against the motion excuse me against the motion for the motion representative Gilliam would you like to close for the motion oh oh you have the floor
Speaker 78
57:10
sir yes thank you mr. speaker just wanted to point out that that
is an entirely proper motion and y'all are free to do that but if you do send it back to committee today obviously you're not going to be getting back into committee to discuss this bill so it means you won't be taking a vote on this bill so if you want to be able to vote on it today you do
need to vote against that motion but again that is an entirely proper motion you can send it back to committee thank you representative letting us spoken against the motion uh would anyone like speak for the motion against the motion. You can't vote yet. Representative Gillum,
would you like to close for the motion? Please come forward. All right. The question for the House is the motion to refer House Bill 1002 to committee. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, say nay. Nay.
The chair cannot determine, so we are going to take a standing vote. All in favor of the motion, please rise. All opposed, please rise.
Have a seat. By a vote of 32 to 55, the motion does fail, so the bill will not be sent back to committee.
Representative Overby, you're recognized to speak in affirmation of the bill, speak for the bill. All right,
Speaker 78
59:43
I want to get an opinion out of this thing. I have a 1991 medical case study here that was done by the Federal Institute of Medicine that says the vast majority of those who do try another drug never become addicted to it, But the majority of marijuana users do not ever try another drug, a drug, and fewer than 10% of those who ever, according to the Federal Institute of Medicine.
Speaker 244
1:00:06
Mr. Gillum, what's your point? I'll read secondhand testimony from the well. How am I going to bank my opinion? Are you
Speaker 8
1:00:26
you guys know, one of our rules, and Greg could explain this, we are not allowed to bring laptops. You're not allowed to bring phones and read any information you pull from Google or, you know, some constituent sends you a letter.
You cannot take it up here and literally read it. You can speak to the points of it, but
Speaker 249
1:00:44
that's why he called Point of Order, because that's against House rules. You
still have something to say. Point well taken. Representative, you still have the floor if you wish to continue. Regardless of point, based
Speaker 78
1:00:57
on prior knowledge, I know that there's no medical studies that prove that marijuana is a gateway drug there or that you become addicted to it. I'm sorry, the speaker has left the well.
Representative Miller, you're recognized to speak against the bill. Say, for what purpose do you rise? Miller? Okay, I guess not. So, Representative Hammer, you're recognized to speak against the devil. Representative Hammer, for what purpose do you rise? Representative Hutchinson, for what purpose do you rise?
Okay, so is there anyone who wishes to speak again? Representative McGee, for what purpose do you rise? Motion to affirm me. You say I have a motion, but I have a motion. I have a motion, Mr. Speaker, for immediate consideration. Immediate consideration. It's a proper motion. Not debatable. The question before the House is immediate consideration. House Bill 1002. All in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed? Aye. The ayes do have it.
The question for the House is passage of House Bill 1002. All in favor, please say aye. Aye. All opposed? Aye. The ayes do have it. Do I have five votes for roll call? Okay, we do have enough to do roll call, so we're going to take a standing vote on this.
All in favor of House Bill 1002, please rise. Let's do this.
Will all the nays please rise.
This bill, by a vote of 40 to 51, does not pass. And take this as a lesson that don't be afraid to ask for roll call, because I can obviously be wrong. Chief Clerk, please read House Bill 1003.
House Bill 1003 is being presented by Representative Whitney, and it is concerning the issuance of a driver's license to a person after he or she is 16 years of age. Representative Whitney, you are, yes, you have the floor. Yes, sir. Thank
Speaker 261
1:05:06
you, Mr. Speaker. um i wrote a speech and by god i'm going to read it uh my bill is to repeal intermediate
licenses this license restricts young people such as the boys state delegation to no driving between 11 pm and 4 a.m and not no more than one non-family member under the age of 21. these restrictions are inconvenient unnecessarily unnecessary and largely unenforced this bill would allow a driver to go through the current permit process of driving uh crashing conviction free for six months with a parent in the car and then uh passing
written and driving tests before getting their full license just like a 25 year old would have or a 40 year old i believe this is ample experience for one to have before getting the full license uh part of the reason i want to introduce this bill is because uh honestly two weeks ago i got pulled over for the first time and um i it was just for uh i didn't get a ticket or anything i wasn't speeding but uh the cop when he called in my driver's license number uh he had to ask me
what an intermediate license was and i that kind of made me mad you know like he doesn't know what law is he's asking me and his quote was even um you know the law better than i do i was like if this isn't even going to be enforced why do we have it and it's you know i mean it's restricting me from a lot of things anyways um this story and the stories i get from my friends that they've been pulled over before and with full cars of under 21 year old people and they don't even get a secondary offense or anything it's just a testament to how loosely
it's in force and how unnecessary it actually is representative
ballinger for what purpose do you rise i wasn't done but to ask a question you're recognized with this bill would we be totally eliminating the hours so that uh teenagers could be driving at all times or just a certain time limit that's still restricted
Speaker 261
1:07:15
uh the bill as is would eliminate the uh restricted hours and um I believe that that would be very beneficial to a lot of the delegation because I don't know about y'all,
but I play football, and literally every game I'm past 11. So what am I supposed to do, not drive home or come get a parent to pick me up when I've got a car in the parking lot? So it's
just very confusing and unnecessary. Representative Baird, for what purpose do you rise? Okay. You may be seated then, Representative. I apologize, Representative. Representative Hammer, for what purpose do you rise?
I have a question. You are recognized. All right, I can understand the inconvenience aspect because, you know, myself, it's happened to me too. But do you not think that the safety due to driving experience of 16 and 17-year-olds would, the safety would definitely go down? If we remove constraints. My point
Speaker 261
1:08:21
is, if it's not being enforced, it's not like the law is there as it is. I've never heard of anyone to get a ticket or anything for having too many people in the car.
So nothing would really change in that the law just wouldn't be there. You know, we would just get regular licenses. And therefore, I don't believe the safety would go
Speaker 78
1:08:51
rise? You are recognized. How would this bill contradict with the curfew hours of minors in local neighborhoods? The
for what purpose do you rise?
You are recognized. Does the law not already state
Speaker 122
1:09:09
that you can be out during those hours if you have a school activity, work, or a religious activity during that time? That is not explicitly stated in anything that
Speaker 261
1:09:21
I've read when I went to go get my driver's license or on the back of my driver's license or even when I looked it up. Representative McLean, for
what purpose do you rise? you're recognized um whenever i got my driver's license i did read that when you're coming back
from a sport event or a church event then you're excused past curfew hours but like you're supposed to drive directly home and i was also wondering if you could continue to explain what you were saying
Speaker 261
1:10:00
before the question started. Thank you. What I would say to that is if it isn't, in fact, and I am mistaken that it isn't infringing upon our ability to participate in extracurricular activities, I would say it's infringing upon our ability to have a social life. You know, I mean,
let's be real. I mean, I'm not saying, you know, like parties or whatever, but you can't always be home before 11 and still maintain a good healthy relationships with some of your friends and etc.
Representative Cozart, for what purpose do you rise? You're recognized. Will
Speaker 261
1:10:37
this bill take away the passenger restraints as well? Yes it would because I believe they're not even enforced right now so it's not even like that it's enforced right now so it's not even like
it's a law. Thank you. No problem.
Representative Rice, for what purpose do you rise? Question. You're recognized. I'm just going to say I'm for this bill, but I was wondering, with the intermediate license, there is no texting and no cell phone law. How would that be changed? Well,
Speaker 261
1:11:08
that is actually what I was going to continue to do before, to speak on before they started asking questions and stuff. But pretty much I'm this law is not enforceable it's just much like the uh let me look at my notes here I'm sorry
it's much like the texting and driving act in which the first three years that the act like after the act was passed there was only eight filed charges I mean um it's just not a very um logical thing to say that this bill is enforceable or texting and driving bill is very enforceable because it's been proven that it isn't enforceable if only eight files are charged in three years, you know, so. Representative Ferguson,
Speaker 170
1:11:54
for what purpose do you rise?
To ask a question. You are recognized. You mentioned the current law impeding your social life. What exactly do you do during those hours between 11 and 4 o'clock in the morning? Shouldn't you be in bed sleeping or, like, I'm just
Speaker 261
1:12:14
curious. I would answer that question with a counter question. Have you ever been out past 11 the past three months?
Speaker 170
1:12:22
Yes, and I have driven home legally because I was coming home from a school activity.
What school activity were you on? Guys, try to keep the discourse to the
minimum. Out of curiosity. Thank you. Seeing as there are no more questioners, you can continue with your speech if I interrupted you, or you can just be seated. Thank you. Representative Collins, you are recognized to speak in negation to the bill. That's the bill.
Speaker 78
1:13:04
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Statistics have shown that 16-year-olds have the most car crashes of any age group and that within 16 and 17-year-olds, the death rate goes up with the addition of every single passenger. And so if we allow 16-year-olds to have as many people in the car, it increases the dangerousness of driving for not only us, but also other people.
And I know from personal experience, people who have lost friends recently while they were breaking this law, and we can't just think about convenience. I mean, you have to put that aside. We all like to drive. We all like to be out late. But you have to keep in mind other people who are on the road, and they want to feel safe. And a lot of times I don't feel safe with other 16-year-old
drivers. Representative Rice, for what purpose do you rise?
I was going to make an emotion, but there's still the speaker. Right. Representative Malone, for what purpose do you rise? Did you ask a question? You are recognized. If there's enough data to make a statistic that the more passengers that are in a car cause more deaths, isn't it evident that it is not enforced at all for 16-year-olds? Yes, I think
Speaker 78
1:14:32
it should be enforced. How would you propose that would it be enforced? um like he said he said he's had friends who've been pulled over breaking that law but they haven't
been charged with anything and i think they should have been but
like uh how would a police officer know if it was night it's dark that he was carrying more than one individual in his vehicle or she? He can pull you over. You can't just pull over any vehicle. They can see inside the car. Once again, guys, try to keep the back and forth questioning to a minimum. Representative Armstrong, for what purpose do you rise? You are recognized.
Speaker 229
1:15:19
How would the police officer know if the person driving was under the age of 18? I mean, I know a lot of us here, like, we may look over 18 ourselves, so how would the police officer just, like randomly have to stop cars and ask if hey
Speaker 78
1:15:34
are you under 18 and if so you have this many people i don't think that they should pull over every single car at night but it is dangerous statistics have shown that 16 year olds are dangerous drivers and the death rate has gone up with each additional passenger so it's not safe for them to be out especially at night so we have to put
aside the convenience for people our age and think about making it safer for everyone out there
representative word for what purpose do you rise question you're recognized so
would you not feel that perhaps educating more on how to drive properly would be better than to enforce the law that is take consuming time consuming no representative
broadway for what purpose do you
rise i have a question you're recognized okay so if you say they can't pull them over you don't want them to pull over everybody and then if you can't tell if they're 18 or not and you can't see them in the dark and see how many passengers have
Speaker 78
1:16:44
how are you going to make this work and since the the things not already enforced? 16 year old drivers aren't the best of drivers. I know friends who have been pulled over for just not not being safe drivers and they were breaking
that law and the police officer let him off without a warning, but you can't pull over anyone. So if he has reason to believe that they're breaking a law, then he can pull you over. But I'm not suggesting that he pull over everyone just to be checking. Representative
Hutchinson, for what purpose do you rise? You're recognized. The speaker has left the well, I'm sorry. Representative Rice, for what purpose do you rise?
I wish to make a motion to... What is the motion? Immediate consideration. A proper motion has been made for immediate consideration. Will those in favor please say aye. Aye. Those opposed say nay. I tentatively say that the ayes do have it, and we will be moving into a vote. The question before the House is the passage of House Bill 1003.
All in favor, please say aye. Aye. All opposed, please say nay. Nay. The chair cannot determine, so we'll take a standing vote. The question is still passage of Bill 103, Bill 1003. All those in favor, do you have a point of order? You do? No, they're fine. All right, thank you. All those in favor of Bill 1003, please stand.
rise.
By a vote of, you may be seated, thank you. By a vote of 66 ayes to 22 nays, Bill 1003 does pass. Mr. Speaker, thank you. Mr. Armstrong, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Gentlemen, well, first and foremost, I think
Speaker 8
1:19:56
we've got a few new members of the body that have come in. I think we've got Representative Marshall Wright, and I wanted to recognize our chief of staff, a good friend, Gabe Holmstrom. They come out and wave their hands if they're back there still. Gabe is the right-hand man to our speaker, Davey Carter, continues to keep the daily order of business in place. And Mr. Qualls, I see you wanted to say hello. So what we're about to do is suspend the rules to hear a Senate bill out of the regular order of our calendar.
And what I mean by that is we get these calendars each morning we come in, and the calendar requires that we hear a few resolutions oftentimes, but then we'll have our regular House bills, and our House bills go to a certain point. Sometimes these are two or three pages long, and then we take up our regular Senate bill. So what we're about to do is suspend the rules. It's the only way this can happen is if we suspend the rules and take up a Senate bill out of order of our regular calendar. And the reason we're doing this is in order for us to hopefully send the bill, if it should pass out of this chamber, to the governor's desk for passage or veto.
And so with that, it's a companion bill to House Bill 1001. And I turn it back over to you, Mr.
Speaker. Thank you. Mr. Miller, moves that we take out of proper order Senate Bill 1. All in favor, please say aye. All opposed, say nay. The ayes do have it. Mr. Clerk, will you please read Senate Bill 1?
I got it. Senate Bill 1, presented by Senator Liddell. To limit unemployment benefits and to require random drug tests, public service work, and disqualification from unemployment benefits. Representative Miller, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm speaking on behalf of Senator Little, and this is a companion bill to my bill,
and we've already voted on that and passed it, and I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you. Thank you. So we are now, do we have anyone who wishes to speak against the bill? For the bill. Very well then. Mr. Miller, would you like to close for the bill? All right. The question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 1. So, guys, if you can't find Senate Bill 1, it's the other packet.
it. It was the packet beneath the packet of House bills. It's the act to limit, no, yes. Huh. Yes. It's short title is an act to limit unemployment benefits to require random drug tests, ETC. The question for the House is the passage of Senate Bill 1. All in favor, please say aye. All opposed. The ayes do have it. We're now going back to our regular order
and Mr. Clerk, will you please read House Bill 1004? House Bill 1004 is presented by Representative Hayes and is to provide incentives for using compressed natural gas and installing consult compressed natural gas stations and faculties or facilities. Thank you. Representative Hayes, would you like to open on the bill? Yes, Laura.
Thank you Mr. Speaker. As you can see in the bill, it clearly states that this is for compressed natural gas stations as an alternative fuel source for gasoline and diesel. We will be providing tax incentives to gas stations and companies who establish these in counties. It's purely for alternative fuel sources and
and I believe it has some economic benefits as well. If you have any questions, I can take some of those. Representative Malone, for what purpose do you rise? I have one concern. While compressed natural gas... Don't forget to say, I have a question. Sorry, I have a question. You are recognized. I have one concern, one question. While compressed natural gas is a great alternative to the current fossil fuel sources, it is still a fossil fuel, and do you believe we should move towards more renewable sources, such as solar or electricity, as in other countries, in European ones mainly?
They have moved towards that, and it has seemed to create many benefits for them. In response to your bill, I believe that it should be a gradual change, and radical change seems to be very unfavorable in public opinion, so I think a gradual change would benefit us better. Okay, thank you. No problem. Representative Ballinger, for what purpose do you rise? To ask a question? You are recognized. How much would this cost? Would we be doing this at a slow rate, or would we just be go ahead and put these natural gas stations everywhere?
Like Representative Malone just asked, it would be a gradual change. It's not going to happen overnight. It's not going to happen in a year. It's going to be a gradual change to help our environment and our economy. Thank you. Representative Hammer, for what purpose do you rise? I have a question. You are recognized. You know, it says converting diesel-powered motors and gasoline-powered, and it's really not how much it would cost, it's going to cost. And how do you plan to get this conversion out to the public?
Are you just going to, like, put it in new vehicles, or are you going to put it in already used vehicles that are on the roads? There are some cars that are being made now that can run on compressed natural gas. And there are ways to convert your normal engine to run on compressed natural gas. So that's the solution. How do you plan to get it out? Guys, remember to keep the discourse to a minimum. You have to be recognized again, I believe, to ask another question.
I'm sorry. Representative, word for what purpose do you rise? You're
recognized. My concerns are similar to the representative over there, but I have a question of why do you limit the grant to just natural gas engines? Why not other alternative fuel sources? As he
said earlier, I believe a gradual change would be the best, as I've seen with other policies where it seems to be swift, radical change.
People don't really want to get involved with that. Sorry, there are other representatives wishing to ask questions, but I may recognize you later. Representative Gillum, for what purpose do you rise? Question. You are recognized. I was just
wondering, you said that it was going to be a gradual change, but a lot of the numbers in here seem to insinuate that you'd be throwing a lot of money at this program, 20%, 40%, 50%. I'm just wondering, where is this money going to come from to pay for these pretty radical changes?
Thank you. Representative Dotson? Yes, Representative Dotson, for what purpose do you rise? Question. You are recognized. I
Speaker 78
1:28:14
just want to know how you see this idea will be taken advantage of because Honda used to offer a CNG-powered Civic, especially in California and Oklahoma, one of the two states that has the most CNG stations. And as of two years ago, Honda doesn't offer that vehicle anymore because of poor sales.
So why would we expect
grants? I believe people will take advantage of these grants due to the overwhelming fact that you can fill up for $1.58 on the Arkansas average compared to $3.65 on normal gasoline. I mean, it might be expensive to convert your car or to buy a new car that runs on CNG,
but if you continue to buy a full tank of gas, CNG, at $1.50, it's going to make a big difference. I mean, it'll save you money in the long run. I know initially it may seem like you're spending more money, but I think that it'll actually save you money in the end, and that's a big incentive for people. Representative Hutchison, for what purpose do you rise?
You are recognized. My question is along the same lines as Representative Hammer. If you believe that if we have a very good production in converting diesel-powered motor vehicles like buses and large vehicles of that size, and it proves productive, could you have a mass conversion, if you're willing to, to trucks, cars of normal size to the everyday public? Are you meaning the everyday public? I don't believe that if we pass this bill that everyone's going to immediately throw up their arms
and say, oh, CNG, how a great savior. You know, I don't think they're going to immediately conform to it. I think it's going to be gradual. Have a gradual change. Yeah, it's not going to be an overnight thing. People aren't going to immediately. People will want to do research and see how this can benefit them. I don't think it's going to benefit us in any way to just throw it out there and say convert now. If people see that it is productive.
Yes, Representative Edwards, for what purpose do you rise? A question? You're recognized. What will be the mileage on those vehicles? I actually don't have a great idea. um i've heard differing differing opinions on that so i can't really give you a clear concise
answer thank you uh representative overby for what purpose do you rise i have a question you're right nice all right i don't see a major problem the
Speaker 78
1:31:34
bill but we're offering tax credits so we lose money paying from the citizen but then also while we're losing that money how where are we going to get the money to pay for 50% of everyone who decides to convert? We have to pay for half of their conversion. And every year they fill up, we have to pay for 20% of everything they filled up for. That's an insane amount of money.
I couldn't hear you. How are we going to get the money to pay for half of everyone's conversions plus 20% of their yearly expenditure on CNG, especially after we give them a tax credit on
the fact that they converted? I believe that we can find the money by purely...
That's a very difficult question to answer, actually. That's a good question. I appreciate that. Representative word, for what purpose do you rise?
I would just like to address that not one, most of the consumers, like some of them, can afford to switch over to natural gas. But while those who are left behind in the gasoline department, their prices for gasoline will rise because the consumer population in that area has decreased.
So you'd be driving up the gasoline prices for them and further driving them into poverty. So if I
understand your question correctly, you're saying that if less people need gasoline, they're going to increase the prices of gasoline? Yes, because it has to be recognized. Laws of supply and demand there. All right, I guess I'll take that as the end of that question.
Okay, the speaker has left the well. I'm sorry, people, if you wanted to ask a question. But we are now looking at Representative McGee. You are recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you, Speaker. Due to the fact that we do not know how much it would cost the state to do the 50% back on the conversions and 20% back on gas, I would like for us to vote no because of the fact that it could greatly inhibit our ability to help other colleges in the state that need it.
Thank you, Representative McLean, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Actually, Representative, were you wishing to speak? Representative McLean. I think that this
sections of this bill would be a great idea to start off doing this. doing this compressed natural gas is cleaner burning and it's something that's
here and now like we already have materials that we can use to convert engines and then it will help reduce our dependence on foreign oil and it will be able to use local fuels it's like you heard before it's half the price of gasoline and it will help you in the long run if you decide to stick with it. And I would say though that I think it would be better if we started off maybe
funding more stations and then getting money from that to start doing incentives towards people once people have more stations to work with because that's what holds back a lot of people is there's not stations everywhere and I know that if there was a station near me then I would like to do that but that's what's holding me back and representative hammer for what purpose do you rise you are recognized what are we going to do once we drain natural gas resources
because it is also a fossil fuel therefore it takes time to develop well Well, we haven't drained our gasoline sources yet, so... All right, it'll help us for now. While we're still doing research on other things, there's a bunch of other alternative fuels that we're researching, too. Representative Payton, for what purpose do you rise? You're recognized. If you don't
Speaker 78
1:36:29
know how much it's going to cost people in tax dollars, how are you willing to have them
use their own personal finances in order to convert their engines
for it? Like, what was your question? How are you going to convince people to use their own personal finances in order to convert their engines? Like I said, we wouldn't be doing the convincing. The thing that holds people back is they don't have stations all around them. There's like, what, three in Arkansas, I think? And if I had a station near me,
And I'm pretty sure a lot of people will convert if they had stations near them. Representative Malone, for what purpose do you rise? I was going to make a motion, but I cannot at this point. All right, thank you. Representative Bain, oh, the speaker's left the well. I'm sorry. Representative Malone, for what purpose do you rise? I want to motion to refer.
to make a motion what is let let us hear the motion i would like to send this back to the committee to uh deal with the uh percentages to edit those because we seem not to have a reason to be able to pay for this okay a motion has been made it is proper motion uh the question is So, Representative Mullen, please come and explain your motion.
I would like to send this back to the committee because the percentages don't seem to fit with any of our way to make up money for this. And I think we need to change, though, so it's not as expensive for the community. All right. Is there anyone who should speak against the motion? For the motion. Oh, I'm sorry. Were you against the motion? Did I not see you? Or for?
You're recognized. Why I'm against this motion is that I think there are some things in this bill that are unfixable, specifically the percentages. I mean, we have no idea about the numbers. We can't really know about the numbers because we can't gauge the interest. We can't gauge the amount of money in sort of programs like this. So I think we should just put this up to a vote right now. Thank
you, Mr. Speaker. Thank you. Representative Bain, for what purpose do you rise?
What is the motion? I'll make a motion to immediate consideration. A motion has been made. It is a proper motion. The question is the immediate consideration of the motion to send this bill to committee. So all those in favor of immediately voting on the motion, please say aye. I. All opposed? The ayes do have it, so we are now, the question for the House is now the motion to send it back to committee. All in favor, please say aye.
Aye. All opposed? Aye. The ayes do have it. Representative Letting, for
Speaker 306
1:40:08
what purpose do you rise? A motion to convene as a committee of a whole to hear a special address. A motion has
been made to convene this committee. Convenience Committee, the question is to convene to hear a special address.
All in favor of motion, please say aye. Aye. Opposed? Aye. The ayes have it. Mr. Governor, you are recognized. Mr. Speaker, thank you for just a second.
Speaker 8
1:40:36
Before we recognize him, what just happened, gentlemen, we had a motion made to convene as a committee of a whole. What that typically means is that in some cases we would have our senator colleagues come down to the House. we'd all be in one chamber in order to hear a special address or a special presentation, and that typically only comes by way of an address from the governor
or if we're having a presentation on something that's dealing with a very high-end topic like our health care expansion bill that we had to take up in the 89th General Assembly. So you just all know that we're basically just meeting as a body of the whole to hear an address. Thanks, Mr. Speaker. All right.
Speaker 309
1:41:25
Mr. Governor. Oh, y'all, that isn't necessary, but thank you anyway.
Well, I've been looking around the Capitol, and I just thought I'd come by, stop in, see how everything was going in here, and it looks like a lot of good debates, so I'm glad to see that. I don't know about you guys, but I'm having a really good time, so I hope y'all are too. or, I mean, how's it going? Okay. Well, that's all I really had to say. I'm sorry I interrupted you guys, but I hope y'all didn't mind. So, I mean, that's all I got.
moving back to, Oh, Representative Letting, for what purpose do you rise? I rise in response to progress. Motion to be made is a proper motion to response to progress. I believe that's essentially just saying we're moving back to the normal order of things, yes. So the question is response to progress, and all in favor, please say aye.
Aye. All opposed? Aye. The ayes do have it, and we're going back to the normal order of things, essentially. And I believe we just sent Bill 1004 to committee, so now we are moving on to Bill 1005. House Bill 1005 is presented by Representative Davis, and it is to establish new eligibility requirements for the Arkansas Academic Challenge Scholarship Program for traditional students.
Jeff, a point of order, representative of Overby? Very well then, representative of Overby, for what purpose do you rise? Let us hear the motion. Okay, so apparently our mic system's dead, so y'all are going to have to really speak up.
So let us hear the motion again, please. Senate bill number three you said I've been told Senate bill three isn't over here yet because Senate bill, Senate hasn't passed it so we can't really debate on it yet so the motion's out of order unfortunately but we're now, bill 1005
has been read so So, Representative
Speaker 313
1:44:35
Davis, would you like to open on this bill? You have the floor. Thank you.
What I'm trying to make is to make a grade point average 3.25 or higher, an 82 or 0.26 or higher, or a grade point average of 3.0 and an 82 or a 0.25. Thank you. Sorry, Representative. Representative McGee,
for what purpose do you rise? You are recognized.
Thank you. Representative Malone, for what
Speaker 313
1:46:03
purpose do you rise? You're recognized. Representative Ferguson, for what purpose do
I'm sorry. The speaker has left the well. We are now looking for negative speakers. Is there
Speaker 313
1:48:10
anyone who wishes to speak? Representative Shepard, you were recognized to speak negatively. There are students all over that have learning disabilities that's the best they can do in the 19th century. always
But it's just harder for them because some of the people already on the last day in the last semester I'm on those kids because I was on them because they were able to do it. So I feel that patients are great because of the school. This will be for meetings for our students across the state. Because there are those students who are on their college. Do you want to have an exchange?
Thank you. Representative has spoken in negation to the bill. So Representative Ballinger, you are recognized to speak in affirmation of the bill.
recognized.
It will allow everybody to get involved with the faculty to be able to make part of our community. I don't think it's a good thing. Thank you. Representative Edwards, for what purpose do you rise? Recognized. So this is Bill saying that if you are a part of the veteran calling, All right, Representative Cozart, for what purpose do you rise?
Someone else has the well right now, so now would not be the proper time.
Speaker 313
1:50:55
Representative Williams, for what purpose do you rise? You are recognized. Thank you. Representative Gillum, for
what purpose do you rise?
You're recognized. Thank you, Representative. You may be seated. Representative Dotson, you're recognized to speak against this bill.
Speaker 78
1:52:38
that they would receive $1,500, and then the next year $2,500, then $3,500, then $4,500, correct? and the purpose of that was so that those people who went their first year and dropped out
wouldn't be throwing away $5,000.
Speaker 322
1:53:13
recognized. So the requirements for the Arkansas, the reformed one that is going on right now, is 3.25 GPA, or an ACT score of 26 higher, or a grade point average of 3.0 and an ACT score of 21.
Do you believe that is the elite of the elite? Like you say, you want the elite to, you want to get more than the elite, but do you believe
Speaker 78
1:53:44
this defines elite? If you are sitting here asking me if a 19 is not a struggle for some people who want to go to college, then you're insane. I'm not saying that. Guys,
try not to use kind of offensive terms like that, frankly.
Sorry. Try to maintain decorum on both sides, please. I'm not saying that at all. I'm just saying, do you know what the average ACT score in Arkansas is right now? I don't know, but I know people who struggle to get that 19, and they want to go to college, and they deserve to go
Speaker 78
1:54:23
to college. They do. They do, and that's why they should have the right to apply
for the scholarship. Okay. Thank you. Representative Ballinger, for what purpose do you rise?
You're recognized. Yes, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. The speaker has left the well, so. Representative Mayberry, you're recognized to speak for the bill. Well, what
is the Arkansas Childhood Scholarship? What is the purpose of it? It's to keep the smart people in Arkansas to stay in Arkansas, trying to convince them.
Give them a scholarship so they can stay. And a 2.5 and 19, that basically means that anybody can get it. I mean, not anybody, but it's a low standard. And when you have a lot of people that can get it, that means there's less money. When you raise the standard, it's more money. And then that means that it's going to help keep the smart people in Arkansas. You want the smart people to stay in Arkansas because it'll make us a better state. And so what's the point of keeping it low and so it'll be less money?
And then people will want to leave out of state because they get more money. And so that's
why I'm for it. No question. Very well then. Speakers left the well. Representative McGee, for what purpose do you rise? To make a motion. What is the motion? For immediate consideration. A motion has been made as proper motion. The question for the House is immediate consideration. All those in favor, please say aye.
Aye. All opposed? Aye. The ayes do have it. So we are now moving into a vote. So, the question is the passage of House Bill 1005. All in favor, please say aye. Aye. All opposed. Aye. The ayes have it. Aye. If you, roll call, roll call. All right, do I see five? Yes, I see five. All right, we're moving into a roll call then. So all those in favor of the bill, please stand.
By a vote of 56 ayes to 31 nays, the bill does pass. Will the clerk please read... Wait, first, do we have any motions? All right, thank you. Will the clerk please read House Bill 1006? House Bill 1006.
One moment, please. Representative Crossett, would you like to speak for the amendment? All right. Representative Crossett moves we place House Bill 1006 on second reading for amendment. All in favor say aye, please. Aye. Opposed, say nay.
All right, this is saying, this is trying to accept or talk about this amendment right here. All right, the amendment that's already attached to Bill 1006. So if you're in favor of considering that amendment, please say aye. Aye. All opposed, say nay. Say nay. The ayes have it. Read Amendment No. 1, please.
Amendment No. 1 to House Bill 1006. All right. Representative Crossett, you are recognized to explain the amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This amendment to the bill, all it does is give the school and the security guard the option to carry non-lethal or lethal weapons. Examples, a taser gun or a beanbag gun.
Thank you, Representative. Yes. Does anyone wish to speak against the amendment to Bill 1006? All right, four. for the amendment? Representative Crossett, would you like to close on your amendment? All right, thank you. So the question is the passage of Amendment No. 1 to House Bill 1006.
All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Those opposed, say nay. Nay. The ayes do have it. Will the clerk please read House Bill 1006? House Bill 1006 is presented by Representative Ellis and is concerning school security. All right.
Guys, don't forget, we have amended this, so just keep that in mind, that the bill as it is written has the amendment on it, so don't forget that. All right. Okay, Representative Ellis, would you like to open on this bill, recognized to open? Okay. One moment. We only have about five minutes left to do all of this, so guys, we're going to need to go fairly quickly. Okay, one thing I have to say real quick is we have security guards in here,
but what would actually be is police officers from the police department, just inputting that real quick whenever it goes to Senate. So what this bill would do is it would allow for every 500 students, there would be a police officer there to protect. And this year our school had like 11 bomb threats, which is really ridiculous. A lot of it's at the junior high. So this would ensure safety, and it would also have the capability against the ability for the teachers to have firearms. And it would allow, like, you know, you might have a crazy teacher or something like that, and you'd have a trained official carrying the firearm or carrying the nonlethal weapon according to the school's choice.
So thank you. Thank you. Sorry, the speaker's left the well. But does anyone wish to speak against the bill? Representative Gillum, you're recognized to speak against the bill. I guess since I was going
to ask a question, but then my only concern with this bill is how it would affect charter schools and private schools. I think it would be a little unfair to force a private school to hire more personnel if
they deem it unfit. Same with charter schools who don't get as much money as private schools. They're already having to make do with a lot less money than public schools usually get and to hire another security guard and pay their salaries kind of a lot
of money so representative speakers left the well sorry if you want to speak but representative thompson for what purpose do you rise let us hear the motion i have a motion for immediate consideration a motion that's been made is a proper motion the question is immediate consideration of house bill 1006 all those in
favor please say aye all those opposed say nay the ayes do have it and we are moving into a vote on bill house bill 1006 the question for the house is the passage of house bill 1006 all those in favor please say aye those opposed the The FBI's do have it.
Representative Bain moves that we take Senate Bill 5 out of proper order and consider it now. So all those in favor of considering Senate Bill 5 now, please say aye. Those opposed, the ayes do have it. And we are on Senate Bill 5, which remember is in the other packet. Mr. Clerk, please read Senate Bill 5. Senate Bill 5 is presented by Senator Powers and it is concerning school security.
Representative Fain, you're recognized to open. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Just like I said, all this bill does is it allows police departments to allow police officers to go into the school. They can check the school grounds, and there would be one police officer for every 500 students. It would allow for the teachers not to be trained, and it would be a trained official on campus. And that is all. Thank you.
Thank you. Is there anyone who wishes to speak in negation to the bill? Representative Overby, for what purpose do you rise? Make a motion. What is the motion? Motion for immediate consideration. A motion has been made for immediate consideration. It is a proper motion. All those in favor of an immediate vote on the bill, please say aye. Aye. Those opposed, say nay. Nay. The ayes do have it, so the question before the House is the passage of Senate Bill 5.
All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Those opposed? The ayes do have it, Mr. Speaker Pro Tem. And Senate Bill 5 does pass. Representative Womack, for what purpose do you rise? I'd like to make a motion. What is the motion? I'd like to make a motion to adjourn motion has been made it is proper motion all those all those opposed are all of this all those in favor of adjourning please say aye
it Can we all can we all get a hand for the representatives and everyone who
Speaker 8
2:07:28
came down and gave their day? help us. Gentlemen, before we adjourn, just real quickly, Mr. Speaker, you deserve a round of applause. It's a very intimidating job. Guys, this work isn't, as you can see, that
easy. And without our staff here, Emily Leathers, John Allen, Buddy Johnson, a lot of the things just like you were going through today. We were clueless when we were freshmen here, too, and they helped us out a great deal. So please give a round of applause to Justin and our staff as well. I think with that, Mr. Qualls, your junior counselor, Representative Meeks has a few words, but congratulations and job well done, gentlemen. Gentlemen, I'll just say,
again, it's a pleasure to have you here today.
And for those of you interested in following the regular legislators that are on Twitter, if you follow the handle A-R-L-E-G, A-R-L-E-G, you can see what we're actually doing down here and give us your feedback and follow us on Twitter. Again, thank you guys for being here today. One
other thing, Representative Dotson, I just wanted to let you guys know, you see these cameras that are behind us, in front of us and all over the place. all of the legislature's live streaming.
So anything that's coming before the House, if you want to watch the process during the session or even go to the ArkansasHouse.org website and watch the rest of us guys actually debate bills live. If you have an interest in that, go there. Thank you, guys. You did awesome. Thank you. I just want to make sure that you guys pick up any papers or anything else you brought and clean up the spaces before you go. We'll be going downstairs and we'll be heading out the back of the Capitol onto the grounds to have lunch.
Agenda
HB1001
HB1002
HB1003
SB1
HB1004
HB1005
HB1006
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Speaker 1
Speaker 8
Speaker 78
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 17
Speaker 19
Speaker 21
Speaker 48
Speaker 56
Speaker 62
Speaker 80
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Speaker 109
Speaker 122
Representative Jeremy Gillam
Unverified
Speaker 148
Speaker 16
Speaker 170
Speaker 164
Speaker 176
Speaker 202
Representative Jonathan Barnett
Unverified
Speaker 220
Speaker 229
Speaker 244
Speaker 249
Speaker 261
Speaker 4
Speaker 125
Representative James McLean
Unverified
Speaker 306
Speaker 309
Speaker 33
Speaker 313
Speaker 322
Representative Andy Mayberry
Unverified
Speaker 83
Speaker 256
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified