Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Revenue & Taxation Committee

January 27, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (1)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB6 · 9 mentions in transcript
Matched: “…nt as well? Members, without objection, we're going to take Senate Bill 6 up out of order without objection to the committee today. S…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
Representative, Speaker Gilliam, are you here today? Got you. OK, thank you. Chair sees a quorum, and anybody wanting to speak for the bill or against the bill, would you please sign in, and along with the amendment as well? Members, without objection, we're going to take Senate Bill 6 up out of order without objection to the committee today. So we're going to be looking at Senate Bill 6. First of all, I want towards Speaker Gillum. Speaker Gillum, I want to tell you that personally, I appreciate your leadership, everything that you've done. I know that this has kind of been a work in progress. But long story short, I want to tell you that I certainly appreciate you. So my vice chair is Senator Kim Hendren. And do you have any remarks? Speaker Gillum, you ready, sir? Mr. Chair, I'm ready if you are. Okay, please identify yourself and feel free to present your bill.
▶ Play
All right. Representative Jeremy Gillum, I'm here today to present Senate Bill 6. And I believe that at this point you've had about a week to look at Senate Bill 6. We've had lots of discussions individually, both with Senator Desmang and myself and with the members of this committee and through the chamber. So I feel like we probably have covered most of the ground, And so I do not wish to be redundant today to cover ground that has already been plowed. I do believe, and I want at this time, Mr. Chair, if it's with your approval, we'd like to address the proposed amendment that I believe is actually on the tablets. Feel free to present that, Mr. Speaker. All right. What is new from what you've looked at over the last week is this Amendment 1 for Senate Bill 6. And quite simply, what we're doing here is we're adding a few co-sponsors. There will be probably a second amendment with more co-sponsors that will come shortly and will be added on as well. But for the purposes of today, you have a few co-sponsors. And then we have the introduction of a couple of new lines of language that you'll see there on the amendment, which addresses the threshold for exemptions on capital gains. The Senate amendment that was applied last week removed the increased rate of 50% and maintained the preexisting rate of 30%. What this amendment would do would be to introduce a new rate of 40% that would be applied moving forward from February 1st on so that January would remain the same at the 50% that it currently is. The rationale behind that is that we made a promise to the citizens of the state that we were going to allow them to conduct business in a particular manner. They began this year conducting business in that manner based on the promise that we had made from the 89th General Assembly. We did not feel that it was proper and responsible to yank the rug out from under them and go back on our words. So the 50% will maintain for January, and then moving forward in February will go to the 40%. So that, in a nutshell, ladies and gentlemen, is the amendment to the bill. And as I said, you have seen the previous bill. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'll be happy to answer any questions if there are any new items that have come up of interest that need to be covered.
▶ Play
I guess, Mr. Speaker, I appreciate that and appreciate your testimony towards that. I guess my first question would be, how would you say this is going to impact the budget? I know we just got the budget out, and the governor just put that out, and some of the committee members have kind of wading through that. But how do you see this affecting the governor's budget? That's a great question, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. I think this is the same process that is employed every session. You have a proposed budget. It is not the actual final budget. It's a proposed budget. So just like the previous general assemblies, when there was a proposed budget, whether it be Governor Beebe or any of his predecessors, our final budget will be decided through the process of the Budget Committee and the General Assembly over the next two months. And so the overall impact is going to be fluid as we move through, just like it always is. Each member is going to introduce appropriation bills or new bills that will have fiscal impacts that would adjust it as well. So at this time, based on the numbers that we're seeing, I do not foresee. Senator Desmang and the governor, we've all looked at this, a final adjustment that will be very much different than what the governor proposed today based on the numbers that we're seeing. So revenues are looking up, and at the end of the day, I think we'll be able to make sure that there's no services cut with
▶ Play
this whatsoever. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Members, any questions for the speaker on the amendment? We're talking about the amendment. Representative Hendren, you're recognized.
▶ Play
I have a question if there are no other members that have one. Mr. Speaker, this reduces it by, what, $9 to $12 million? Yes, sir. Where do we get that $9 to $12 million? Well, as I
▶ Play
was attempting to explain previously, from the budget process as a whole, we'll decide as a General Assembly on what the final budget will be, as you well know, having served in this General Assembly. So we'll be able to make that determination as a body. But based on the forecasting figures and the numbers that we're looking at, I do not foresee that this will have a negative impact on the proposed budget as well because I think the collections are actually going to be over and above what the proposed budget was, similar to what it was in the 89th and the 88th General Assemblies. When Governor Beebe proposed his proposed budget, there was no room at the time, based on testimony, for any additional tax cuts whatsoever. And as you well know from both of those General Assemblies, we were able to do additional tax cuts in the last session in a fairly large amount, as well as in the 88th as well. So at the end of the day, I do not foresee this having to come out of any of the priority budget items that the governor's laid out, nor do I foresee coming out of any central services or having a negative impact on the budget whatsoever. The reason I ask that question, of
▶ Play
course, I wasn't here the last session whenever these capital gains changes were made. But I guess the thing that concerns, and I've had some calls back. In fact, one of the calls I got this morning from a constituent says this. If we're sure that we're going to have this money, and I don't dispute that may possibly have, there won't be any GIF funds probably left over, which a lot of us think maybe they shouldn't be anyway. That's what some people call slush funds, as you know, at the end. So we go back and we spend it for various things around the state, some of which may be a little bit dubious. But those won't be there, as I understand about this. But what I understand you're saying is that we anticipate that this won't hit education or prisons or Medicare or health department. And my question, what this person called me this morning, and he's been active in politics around the state for a while, and the question was this, if we're sure of that, then why don't we just defer this change until the end of this first fiscal year, and then if the money's there, let's take care of it then. and so that posed an interesting question to me because if it goes the other way and that's one of the things I think we have to maybe especially guys as we get older we have to think what's going to happen when we do this what happens if it's the other way is there a possibility that if it goes the other way and the funds are not there then the guy that's building fence for me today at $11 an hour is not going to get his taxes reduced as much But we are, in fact, going to reduce my taxes because I'm about to sell some cows and make $1,000 a head, I hope, on them because I'm going to sell them. Now, is it a possibility, Mr. Chairman, that that
▶ Play
could happen? Well, there's always the possibility that revenues will not come in as projected and that any of the proposed budgets that any executive branch sends out won't be able to be funded at their particular levels. I mean, we run into that possibility every time that we're here in session. So I would say that it doesn't look like it's likely, and to be perfectly honest and with all due respect, I mean, we could play the what-if game from now until May and get nothing accomplished. And so at the end of the day, Senator, President Desmaye, myself, the governor, we've looked at this. We feel like it's responsible and prudent to take this course of action at this time to fulfill both our predetermined obligations that we've made to the voters, the promises we've made to them, but also moving forward in a responsible manner. And keep in mind, too, that the overall vision of what we're trying to do here is to lower the effective tax rate for the middle class on their incomes. And I feel like that this amendment is a proper addition to Senate Bill 6.
▶ Play
And I agree, and I'll just sum up by this, is that I agree with you about playing what-if games, but I think that works both ways. And that's the concern I have about that. What if it goes the other way? And the other way, if we support this wisdom, what if it goes this other way? So, by the way, is the administration agreeable to this? Have they signed on to this amendment?
▶ Play
Yes. I've spent a tremendous amount of time with the governor working through this, making sure that he was fully aware of it. There's no one being surprised by this at all.
▶ Play
What about when it reaches the other end? How do they feel down there? I'm going to let them make that determination. Have we asked
▶ Play
them about it? I have visited with President Desmang, and he feels confident that there's support on his end, but I have not interfered in their business and talked to the
▶ Play
individual members. So Desmang thinks they can pass it? He does. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Thank you, Representative Hendren. Members, any other questions? Representative
▶ Play
Lederman, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Speaker, I would talk about the other side of the question that Mr. Hendren talked about. I've got a lot of calls from people who are opposed to cutting the capital gains exemption because they say that those are the people who generate jobs, and I tend to agree with that. But could you tell us or do you have a number on how many people actually are affected by this capital gains with the amendment? Rough
▶ Play
number. The numbers that the Department of Finance have looked at is around 100,000, and I know that there are some members that have looked at the equation slightly different, and it may have been up to 150,000, but we're looking at, you know, roughly between 100,000 to 150,000, depending on what set of numbers that you're looking at, that would be affected by the original passage of the legislation back two years ago. So the important thing to keep in mind about what we're doing here with this amendment is we're still raising that exemption we're still offering tax relief to that group of people. Thank
▶ Play
you. Thank you Mr. Representative Landman. Any other questions members? Representative Flowers, you're recognized ma'am. Thank
▶ Play
you. I just wanted to get clarity on what I think I heard today. Is it the case that of the hundred thousand people who would be affected that about 10,000 of them would benefit by receiving about half of that those dollars the estimated four to six to be honest with you represent
▶ Play
the flowers you know that was testimony given by the Department of Finance and I am not as well versed on that as far as the specifics of who and what what I think is important to remember with this though is that regardless of, you know, how those numbers break out and everything, the important thing to remember is this. We had made a commitment to those individuals, regardless of who they are and how they fit into the equation. We made, we gave our word that they were going to be able to conduct business a certain way. And I think that's important for us to remember is that this helps us honor that,
▶ Play
but also moving forward responsibly. Thank you. Members, any other questions? Is there anybody in the audience want to speak for the amendment? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the amendment? The chair will entertain a motion from the committee. I have a motion due passed. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Sounds like the ayes have. Congratulations, Mr. Speaker, you passed your amendment. Now we're on to the amended Senate Bill 6. Members, as
▶ Play
I stated before, on the actual amendment, I know, or excuse me, on the bill itself, we've gone back and forth in discussions over the last week as far as the details of the bill. I'll be happy to discuss any of the bill at this time if you have any questions on any new ground that we might need to plow.
▶ Play
Okay. Okay. First of all, I'm going to take Representative Jean. We're going to ask for DFA to come up for a couple questions here in a second, but first of all, members, are there any questions for the speaker on Senate Bill 6 as amended? If not, we'd like to have Mr. Leathers or Mr. Tyus from DFA or Mr. Walther, somebody from DFA come up, please, for a couple questions. Thank you.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, Tim Leathers from the Department of Finance and Administration. I have our other folks there if we get some hard questions that
▶ Play
I can't answer. Tim, I got 100% faith in you, buddy. Thank you, sir.
▶ Play
Representative Jean, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Mr. Leathers. I was looking at your revenue impact. You have fiscal year 16, a $12.8 million reduction. Yes, sir. How much will that change with this
▶ Play
amendment? Well, we're trying to get a handle on that number. If it had just been, there's a provision in there just for January that we hadn't seen before, so we're going to work on that. But it was about to be an additional $9.7 million in there. So it
▶ Play
would be that amount added to the impact. So the fiscal, and this is not exact, the fiscal impact for 2016 will be well over $20 million. Yes, sir. Okay. And then what could we add with what we did to the fiscal 2017? You have $80.6 million. How much will that add? It's $9.7 million again because
▶ Play
we're talking about full year, so it's the same amount. So it will be
▶ Play
a little over $90 million. Yes, sir. Now, the one thing I didn't say, because we have affected tax policy for fiscal year 15, which we're in now until June 30th, all the changes that we made, what will that do to the bottom line for the rest of the year?
▶ Play
I don't know that we have a – since we've been in a state of flux with the bill and everything, I don't know we have a bottom line on that. But we did build in some money for the current fiscal year for 2015 where we will, by changing some of the changes that took effect this year, where we will have obviously an increase in revenue this year to some degree. And we'll work to define that based on this bill with this amendment as it comes out or however it comes out of here and report back to the committee with our amount of where we're trying to get that. I'm making it sound difficult, and it is because with these, when we have half-year impacts in what we're doing and we're trying to gauge when taxpayers are going to pay and this type of capital gains in particular are paid by taxpayers that estimate and they do it at certain times during the year. so it's like hitting a moving target with all the changes. I don't have an exact number for that yet, but we will get that for you. How soon do you think? I think we can have it by tomorrow morning at any rate. And I'm not going to get you to ballpark at our memo. I'm afraid to do that because then somebody will write it up somewhere and I'll be wrong again. Thank you, Mr. Letters. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Thank you, Representative Jean. And, Tim, if you don't care, please disseminate that to all the committee members if you don't care.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. We'll get it to your staff as soon as that's ready. We'll try and get it prepared
▶ Play
by tomorrow morning. Thank you very much. Members, any other questions for Representative Hendren?
▶ Play
You're recognized. I asked the chairman privately here, and I'd just like to ask Tim Leathers or whoever. I know there are requirements for financial impact statements on bills that I've introduced, we all introduced. is there any such requirement for an amendment such as the one that was just adopted?
▶ Play
That would be subject to the committee chair sir you'd have to ask them we we provide those as you know during the session and we give you the fiscal impact on all the tax bills and we will have one with this amendment on it we had one with Senate bill 6 with the previous amendment and we will be doing one for this amendment if it's attached to the bill. So that means if
▶ Play
If we, to have, you're saying we're required to have it on a bill, but not as amended as the committee considers it for final passage? That would be a matter of your rules, sir. Does somebody know the rules? Yeah, Representative
▶ Play
Andrews, I've been told by staff that we're not required by law to have this, by the rules, to have it in committee.
▶ Play
On any bill? Yes, sir. We can hear a bill without having to finish it. But without
▶ Play
voting on it. That's my question. Okay.
▶ Play
Thank you. Members, any of the question? Representative Flowers, you recognize me now. Thank you. Mr. Leathers, I was wondering if you might be able to answer the question that I asked before about the percentage of those who would benefit from the capital gains deduction. Yes, I might correct some. In joint budget this morning, I gave you the number of $100,000. That's kind of our typical year of the taxpayers that have any capital gain. And out of that, I try to remember a percentage of a large part of that goes to incomes over $250,000 because they are the business-type taxpayers that are having business transactions. So out of that dollar tax savings, about 50% goes to incomes above that level. Exactly what percentage of the tax filers, I don't have that with me. We're going to go back and try and see if we can determine that. I thought I'd heard 10% at one time, but when I said that, I wanted to go back and make sure that that's the case. And, Mr. Chair, if I could just ask one more quick question. Yes, ma'am. For those taxpayers who would benefit at the lower end of the range, so a taxpayer paying, earning $21,000 taxable income, what would be the dollar amount, ballpark, of their benefit from this tax
▶ Play
Speaker 32 20:26
cut? Well, like, for the middle
▶ Play
income tax from the 21 to, the additional that's being done by this bill, from the 21 to the 75,000 where the governor's targeting that for that relief, the amount of that is roughly, yeah, it's $540,000, $540 per taxpayer if they get the full amount of that within those brackets at $75,000? Are you wanting to know the full amount that that whole bracket gets? I was just wondering what the benefit would be for the person at the lower end of that range. So this is benefiting those taxpayers with an income of $21,000 to $75,000. Am I not correct? Probably the best way for us to address that is just to give you some examples. Yes. And what I'd like to do is if you give us some time, we'll go back and get some examples that we've prepared of different taxpayers at different ranges, and it will show you the tax relief after 2016 when everything's in place. The taxpayers will be paying as opposed to last year in 2014 and kind of give you some idea by looking at different tax levels within there rather than us trying to pick the lower end and that sort of thing, if that's okay? And so, yes, but that $500 figure, is that applicable as an average or? That's if you get the maximum amount if you're at $75,000 on the top end of that middle income range. So we know the
▶ Play
Speaker 57 22:14
maximum, we just don't know the minimum.
▶ Play
So the minimum, do you guys have that?
▶ Play
Speaker 59 22:29
Where's the minimum? $21,000 is $16. Okay, the minimum
▶ Play
at $21,000 would be $16. Thank you. Members, are there any other questions? Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Leathers. Do we have anybody here speaking against the bill? Want to speak against the bill? Anybody want to speak for the bill? Members, the motion before the committee is passage of Senate Bill 6 as amended. Have a motion? Have a motion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Two no's. Congratulations, Mr. Speaker. You passed your bill, Senate Bill 6, as amended. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. Thank you. Without objection, committee, this committee is adjourned. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

No agenda available.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Joe Jett Chair Unverified
17 segments
Representative Jeremy Gillam Unverified
20 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
12 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
2 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
25 segments
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 32
1 segment
Speaker 57
1 segment
Speaker 59
1 segment