Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Revenue & Taxation Committee

February 3, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1132 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1132”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1201 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1201”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
Representative Hodges, you're free to speak for your bill, sir. Excuse me, Representative Hodges, one thing. Members, also, you're going to find in front of you a letter from George Hopkins from representing Teachers' Retirement System also that he wanted to pass out. Couldn't be here today, but he wanted to put those out. Let you guys read his letter. Representative Hodges, identify yourself, sir, and go ahead.
▶ Play
Speaker 6 0:32
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm representing Monte Hodges. Thank you, committee, for being here today. I'm going to have Senior Investment Manager Rod Grave with Arkansas Teacher of Retirement come up with me, if you don't mind. And he'll answer some questions after I get through presenting the bill for those that may have some complicated questions. Okay.
▶ Play
Please identify yourself for the record, please. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 6 1:11
I'm Rod Graves, Senior Investment Manager with Arkansas Teacher Retirement System. George Hopkins couldn't be here today. He's out of state on some teacher retirement business. But the bill you have before you is House Bill 1132, which is a recycling tax credit bill. For those that served in the 89th General Assembly, we passed Amendment 82 for the Big River Steel Project, which was an economic incentive piece of legislation that I think was passed back in 2008-2009 to help recruit a large industry in the state. It had stipulations on it and all that, but long story short, Arkansas Teachers Retirement was one of the investors in that project. There was a tax credit involved, a recycling tax credit involved with that piece of legislation during that time, but it only applied to the steel industry. So what the Arkansas Teachers Retirement is wanting to do is kind of, because they've made some other investments, We have another company called Blue Oak, which is an e-waste recycling business also that is in my district that they are investors in, but they can't utilize those recycling tax credits because it's not a steel-related industry. So they're wanting to kind of broaden it a little bit so they're able to use those tax credits, those recycling tax credits for other entities since, you know, recycling is becoming a big thing now and we're going to see more of it, more businesses that are into the recycling type of business. So we want to be able to open that up. So that is pretty much the gist of this bill. So there was a fiscal impact study done on it and had a zero physical impact when the F&A did their fiscal impact study on it.
▶ Play
Anyone have any questions? Yes, Representative Hodge. I guess how many entities are you talking about that teachers retirement? Right
▶ Play
Speaker 6 3:38
now, they're investing in Big River Steel and Blue Oak at the present time, if I'm not mistaken. That's correct. So the tax credit flow back just to one right
▶ Play
now? Just to one right now, that's correct. Representative Meeks, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So
▶ Play
I'm just trying to get my head wrapped around here, what we're trying to do. So the teacher retirement system is getting these tax credits. are they then wanting to are they going to use those tax credits for themselves or are they wanting to be able to give those tax credits to somebody else for somebody else to use help me kind of understand what we're doing there we'll add yes sir given that teacher retirement and the other retirement systems are tax exempt organizations the tax credits don't have any real value to the systems. So this bill would allow not only teacher retirement, but the other retirement systems in the state to be able to reallocate their share of those tax credits to other equity investors in the same project. Okay. And would the teacher retirement system receive any benefit for giving those tax credits to the other investors? Yes, sir. That would be the idea. Benefit of enhanced dividends from the investments. We would expect maybe not say a dollar for dollar type, but somewhere maybe 75 to 80 percent of the INCREDIT would flow back to the systems to enhance their investment. Okay, so the teacher retirement system would not necessarily be selling these to the investor. They would just be giving them to the investor on the hopes that their dividends, it would increase the profitability of who they're investing in, and they would benefit from those increased dividends, basically, is what we're trying to do here? Right, right. It wouldn't be a sell, and it would never be anything on the open market. The reallocation would strictly only be allowed between the equity investors in the same project as long as a retirement system is involved. Okay, and so going further, if the retirement system, they can't just give these tax credits to anybody. They have to give them to strictly their partners. Am I understanding that correctly? Yes, sir, in the same project. Within the same project, okay. And my final question is, I know we're just doing it to the teacher retirement system. Would there be any benefit or, and this may be beyond the scope of what you're trying to accomplish here, But I'm always cautious about narrowly defining things like this. Would there be any benefit to saying we're going to open this to all nonprofits versus just saying, okay, we're just going to give this one nonprofit, if you will, this benefit, but nobody else? It's my understanding the bill currently only affects public retirement systems in Arkansas. And there's five, I'm sorry. And that's my concern is that we're only giving the benefit to this one narrow group. So I don't know if I, we're not giving a competitive advantage by any means here, but why would, if this is such a good thing, would it not maybe benefit to open it to all nonprofits versus, you kind of understand what I'm saying is this is a very narrow benefit we're giving to one specific group versus maybe opening it up and making it a broader benefit to the rest of the state. And that may be beyond the scope of what you're trying to do here,
▶ Play
Speaker 6 7:30
but I'm just wondering what your thoughts might be on that. I mean, I'm kind of confused about your
▶ Play
question, Representative Meeks. well the question I'm asking is we're giving we're looking at we're giving this to a one specific public entity in Arkansas the retirement system and just to them would and like I said I'm very cautious about giving a benefit to one group versus another group versus another group would there be any advantage to say instead of just giving this just to the teacher retirement system Why don't we do this to all non-profits and let all non-profits, and maybe the gentleman sitting with you might, since he's involved in this, maybe can answer this better. Would other non-profits even have any need to be able to use these tax credits elsewhere? Does that still make sense of what I'm trying to get at? instead of just giving it to the benefiting this one group how can we get more people to benefit from what you're trying to do here maybe it's a better way to okay or could we get more people to
▶ Play
Speaker 6 8:46
benefit from what you're trying to do here the the Arkansas teacher retirement are the ones that are making the investment so I think that's the reason that you know as part of the their initial investment with Big River Steel I think that's probably why we're dealing with this particular piece of legislation because they were the they're the they're the best they're the one that's making the investment into these projects but if another
▶ Play
nonprofit were to make the same investments they wouldn't get this benefit you see I'm saying or another retirement system or to make this same investment they wouldn't get the benefit of this so that's what I'm kind of saying is is is there opportunity here to maybe more people to benefit from what you're trying to do instead of just limiting it to what is that not I don't I'm trying not to put you on the spot here and I know and I know I am a certain degree yeah you but the question I'm asking is is can more people benefit from what
▶ Play
Speaker 6 9:48
you're trying to do here instead of just this one entity I would assume if they if if if if they were wanting to I mean I mean, if they're wanting to pass some legislation to benefit from a tax credit, I'm not sure if we'd be open to it, but, you know, I don't know if I can answer that question intelligently enough or not.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Representative Laterman, you recognize, sir. Thank you. My question may be a little complicated, too, and I hope I can explain it to you, but Blue Oak, as I understand, that's a startup industry. it's very small profit margin it's recycling and this company or this startup it's going to be a difficult process for them to get into operation so are they looking at other options like even moving or doing other things I mean is this a thing that's going to help them to make it or to be profitable I assume the other
▶ Play
Speaker 6 10:52
partners are for profit is that correct? Yes. Now, are you
▶ Play
talking about the other five? Yes, the other people
▶ Play
Speaker 6 11:00
that would take advantage of this tax credit.
▶ Play
No, they're all non-profit, aren't they? The other systems mentioned in the bill as well, I think, not non-profit but the other retirement systems, the other equity investors in Blue Oak are for-profit entities. Okay. So my question,
▶ Play
I guess, is they need this, since they're a startup business and very difficult to start up a business like this. This is something that they
▶ Play
need to become profitable. Is that correct? This would really only apply to the investors in the recycling facility, not necessarily helping to increase the actual profitability of the operations of the facility. I think what it does, though, is with Blue Oak in particular, there were lots of discussions of taking it to other states or other areas for the startup. And while this is started up, and I think you talked about the permanence of this facility, for instance, the foundation of the plant being built now currently is a six-foot deep slab of concrete. It's a very permanent facility planned on staying the, you know, the operational part here. There may be subsequent phases that, you know, the ability to reallocate these tax credits could help bring additional investors in for should they add phase two or three to the current Blue Oak or whether through expansion in its current area or even in other states. And I think, you know, the ability to recycle the or to reallocate the recycling tax credits could help keep some of those additional phases as well as other potential recycling facilities here in Arkansas.
▶ Play
Thank you. Members, any other questions? Representative Meeks, you want DFA? Mr. Tyster, Mr. Leathers, Mr. Walter, somebody, can we get you at the end of the table, please? Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, committee members, my name is John Tice. I'm with the Department of Finance and Administration. Representative, make sure
▶ Play
you recognize, sir. Thank you. Mr. Tice, just a quick question. I don't want to sound like I'm beating a dead horse here, but on the revenue impact, you all put that there would be no revenue impact on this. My question would be if they're getting recycling tax credits that they are not using, that seems like that would create a tax savings to the state or savings to the state that now is then going to be given to somebody else that they're going to claim, whatever that amount is, whether it's $1,000 or $10,000. So can you kind of talk us through that a little bit and what you think that impact might be? I mean, if they're not using the credits now, but then somebody will be using the credits in the future.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. Our thought process on that was the recycling credit has been around for many years, and it provides a 30% income tax credit for an investment in recycling equipment. The General Assembly enacted that credit with the assumption that all of the investors would be for-profit investors who would be able to use that credit. If the General Assembly decides we should allow a non-profit investor to invest, that allowing that non-profit investor, in this case the retirement system, to allocate their portion of the credits to other for-profit entities who are investing in that same project doesn't really increase the amount of the credit. No new credits are being created. You're just shuffling which of the investors get to use the credit. That's how we arrived at the no revenue impact. Okay,
▶ Play
so do we know how much of the... so right I guess my question is though if the teacher retirement system is getting those credits right now and they're not using them well because they can't what is the portion that they're not using how much is that
▶ Play
do you know I do not have any information about the teacher retirement specific investment in this project
▶ Play
okay because that would be you know we're not getting the we're not losing that income because we're not paying that credit out right now, but then next year we will be paying that credit out. So if we're not paying it out now, next year we will be paying it out, there's going to be a minus to the state's
▶ Play
Speaker 18 15:39
bottom line. Am I thinking? Am I
▶ Play
thinking correctly there? I understand your thought process. We just looked at it a different way in terms of this is simply fulfilling the legislative intent when the recycling credit was enacted, and is allowing those very credits that the General Assembly enacted to be used as the General Assembly intended. It's not creating anything new. It's just reshuffling among investors. Okay, but we don't know what that reshuffling amounts to. No, we don't. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. Representative McGill, you recognize her.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Hodges, would you give me some idea of job opportunities that would be created with
▶ Play
Speaker 6 16:25
this entity? Blue Oaks is going to create 38 to 50 jobs. And if I'm not mistaken, those salaries are going to be $40,000 plus a year. Now, of course, those that were here in the 89th General Assembly know that the Big River Steel Project, the base salary is going to start off at $75,000 a year. and start off at 300 employees. During construction phase, about 1,200 employees. So you can see what type of impact that it would make on the state. But that's what we're looking at. It's good salaries and quite a few people put to work. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You're
▶ Play
welcome. Members, any other questions? Anybody in the audience want to speak against
▶ Play
Speaker 6 17:22
the bill? I'm sorry. Representative Hodges? Chair, I want to let Rod Graves kind of elaborate on the question that Meek posed about the impact, the negative impact on using that credit would make on the state. Yes,
▶ Play
sir. Thank you. So if these recycling tax credits are reallocated to for-profit investors, they would, in turn, you know, that wouldn't happen for nothing. So in turn, they would increase dividend payments to the retirement system that had done the reallocation. So, you know, a good portion of whatever impact that might have would be returned back to the state through the enhanced dividends of the investment. That would help you, Representative Meeks. Good.
▶ Play
Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill? Anybody want to speak for the bill? Representative Meeks, you're welcome. Make your motion, sir. Motion for do pass. All in favor, say aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, Representative Hodges. You passed your bill. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 6 18:40
Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee, and thank you, Meeks.
▶ Play
I said to move over here where I was supposed to be, and actually the reason to move over here
▶ Play
is so she can tell me what to do. Well, things didn't get
▶ Play
any prettier, Senator Chair, I can tell you that, sir. Representative Jett, you're recognized to present your amendment to, what is this, House
▶ Play
Bill what? House Bill 1201. 1201. Thank you. My name is Representative Jett, and members, I'm going to start off talking about the overall piece of legislation, what we're doing. I'm going to circle back around to the amendment. Basically, on the Big River Steel bill we did last year, for some of you new members, we did the Amendment 82 project, Big River Steel. We gave those folks 14 years of carryover tax credits. And then what we found was we found the existing steel mills are getting three years' worth of existing tax credits, if you will. So basically all we're doing here is we're putting everybody on the same level playing field. When we put this piece of legislation together, we run it by DFA to get it scored, and those folks are very gracious to always work with us and appreciate you, Mr. Tice, and your department working. But we found some language in the bill, the original bill, did not satisfy DFA. So they come back and graciously helped us put some technical corrections together for this bill. And this is the amendment that we're looking at, first of all. If you see the amendment, you'll see basically just technical corrections in the language. So that's explaining the amendment. Mr. Chairman? Any questions to Representative Yves Jetta on
▶ Play
the amendment? Representative Neal, you're recognized. Motion at the proper time. Any other question? Representative Neal, you're a motion. Do pass, adopt the amendment, right? Do we have any discussion on this? Any comment or discussion about the motion? If not, all in favor say aye. All opposed, no. You've adopted your amendment, Mr. Chairman. Congratulations. Now you're ready to present your
▶ Play
bill, I assume, right? Yes, sir. Thank you very much, members. Basically, members, what I said a while ago, this is just putting everybody back in the same level playing field and playing in the same sandbox, if you will. I think there are six steel mills out there. We gave Big River Steel through Act 82, 14 years of tax carryover credits. The other existing steel mills that use recycling equipment are getting three years, and we're just basically extending that to the 14 years. And also, technology has actually outpaced the formula that we use for the existing scrap metals, and there's a process now to where we can actually use more old cars, I'm told, more scrap metal, and then use a new formulation and make the steel come out bigger and better. So how this works is basically they, if you're in a steel mill business, you go to AEDQ. They approve your process. They give you a certificate, and they give it back to you. You apply that back to your tax credits, back to DFA. So with that, I've got any questions. I've got a very smart guy sitting next to me off to my right that's going to answer any questions that you might ask. Okay, thank you. This
▶ Play
is the point that the public has a chance to tell us what they think about what we're doing down here. So if anybody wants to speak for or against it, what's that? Members first, but if you want to speak for or against this bill, I'll sign the list. Where is the list? Okay, okay. Who was first here? I guess Meeks, you're the top dog here, right? Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank
▶ Play
you. Got to ask the question, just because I had the opportunity. But I'll make it an easy one because you're the chairman. And I will return that favor. Thank you, sir. The question that I have is, by going from the three years to the 14 years, generally speaking, and the gentleman to your right may be a better person to answer this, how long do they anticipate a normal tax credit? I mean, will they use a full 14 years on average? Do they think they could use them up in four years, five years? What's the anticipated timeline for them to be able to use the tax credits up? Please introduce yourself, I'm told.
▶ Play
My name is Mike Parker. I'm a tax lawyer here in Little Rock in private practice, and I worked on this bill. I've got clients in the steel industry who are interested in it. Mr. Mix, usually my clients have used the tax credits within the three- or four-year time period. The problem that they ran into, some of these investments in these mills are tens of millions of dollars or more. There was a situation in 2008 that they built, invested over $100 million in some new technology, and that hit just the same time that the bottom fell out of the economy. And these cycles occur from time to time. For example, right now there's a downturn in the steel business because of what's going on with drilling and the fact that a lot of the sheet steel goes into making tube that goes into drilling. So it's very cyclical. So under normal circumstances, their experience has been that they've used it within the four-year period, but they are faced with these situations with the large investments that, based on circumstances beyond their control, it may take longer than that to come out of a cycle when one's as deep, for example, as it was in 2008 to 2010. So was that clear?
▶ Play
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, definitely. Yeah, that was a very good answer. So could I make the assumption that by us doing this, it might
▶ Play
encourage more of those big investments within the state? These mills compete with our other mills around the country, and the tax credits that are available to this program are important in that competition, and adding some additional assurance that those credits will actually be realized will improve our competitive
▶ Play
advantage in that respect. Sounds good. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. Representative Jean. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Jett, I do support this bill, and you said there were six mills in the state that used
▶ Play
this tax credit? I might have said that, but I'm not 100%
▶ Play
sure that's right, so I'm going to defer to my buddy to my right. Well, I'll ask Mr. Parker. There are steel mills in Fort Smith, in Newport, and then the Nucor facility actually is made up of three mills, maybe four mills depending on how you count within that company group, and then, of course, the new steel mill. So this would be available to any qualified manufacturer of steel as defined in the bill and in other legislation that we've adopted from time to time. Is it more
▶ Play
like four instead of six? I
▶ Play
think depending on how you count, yes, sir. Okay. There is a Fort Smith. There is a Newport. There are two mills, at least two separate, actually three separate entities that run mills in Mississippi County now, plus one more. So, I mean, you can count it different ways.
▶ Play
Okay. A plant like SMI, which rolls steel for a fence post in my area, they wouldn't qualify for this, would they?
▶ Play
You know, I'm not familiar with SMI's technology and what they do, and I don't know if they're a qualified manufacturer of steel. Within this definition, one of the requirements is that you will have invested $120 million in a steel mill at some point in the life, so I don't know if. Now, SMI, depending on what they do, they could qualify for recycling tax credits. A lot of different industries qualify for recycling tax credits generally, but I'm just not familiar with their process. Is this 14-year? Is this
▶ Play
if you've already been involved in these tax credits for 10 or 12 years, does it continue on? Is this a new 14 for everybody, or how does this work? Well, the
▶ Play
14 is just for qualified manufacturers of steel. Actually, in 2001, legislation was introduced to support a major investment in a new facility. It had the 14 years in it as well for a steel industry for just the reasons that I mentioned to you before in terms of these particular type projects just are very, very expensive. So for that particular project, the 14-year concept was originally introduced. When the legislation was introduced in the last session, it just picked up that same language and applied it to the new legislation two years ago. This, once again, is picking up that same language for qualified manufacturers of steel in general because, indeed, what we want to have happen is we want those $100 million-plus projects to occur. And just based on the fluctuations in the economy, the present limitation just didn't quite mesh with big investments in the way that we felt like the legislature wanted it to.
▶ Play
Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any other questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience wish to speak for or against this bill? if not Mr. Chairman you wish to close for your bill close my bill sir what's the pleasure of the committee motion do pass we got a bunch of them there what do you do now I don't think bunch is a member of this committee is he a freshman over representative makes a motion do pass any discussion all in favor say aye all opposed no Congratulations, Mr. Chairman, you've passed your bill.
▶ Play
Hey, members, we're going to do group pictures, committee pictures Thursday, and right now, we're looking at the bills that we have. Everything else has fiscal impacts. The speaker wants us to put those on the third calendar until we get something else comes up, not costing the state any money, until we get to the back side. Representative Lane Jean gets everything, his budget back to us. Any discussion or anybody needs to make a comment? If not, we're adjourned. How are you doing, brother?
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 30:35
Good.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1132

0:35 - 19:50 71 segments 8 speakers

HB1201

19:50 - 30:37 35 segments 5 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Joe Jett Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 6
16 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
37 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Chair Unverified
4 segments
Chair Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 18
1 segment
Representative George B. McGill Unverified
1 segment
Representative Kim Hendren Chair Unverified
8 segments
Mike Parker Unverified
12 segments
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
5 segments