House Agriculture, Forestry & Economic Development
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (5)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB47
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB47”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1111
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…th let's see on your screen there we're going and skip over House Bill 1111 by Representative Saban.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1179
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “The next bill up is House Bill 1179. Representative Ratcliffe? I'd like to put that on the defe…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1008
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1008”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1010
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1010”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 16, 2026
are here to speak for or against a bill would you please sign up on the sign up sheet and we'll get you up here at the appropriate time. Seeing it's 10 o'clock this meeting of the house ag committee will come to order. We're going to start out here with let's see on your screen there we're going and skip over House Bill 1111 by Representative Saban.
The next bill up is House Bill 1179. Representative Ratcliffe? I'd like to put that on the deferred list for now. Okay. We'll move that to deferred list. All right. Next up, Senate Bill 47. Representative Shepard, you're going to present this bill? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Members, Senate Bill 47 is a bill that is sponsored by Senator Pierce, along with myself and Representative Bain. It concerns the unitization of Bryan expansion units in South Arkansas. I've got a couple of individuals who will come to the table in a second who can shed more light on this. But in Union and Columbia counties, we have – brine is produced in those areas of the state.
It's a very big economic development issue. We have a couple of companies that deal with this and employ a lot of people in our area. Actually, Representative Bain, myself, and Representative Gene, our districts are probably the only districts in the state and maybe in the United States that actually have brine produced. So we brought this bill. This bill very simply does a couple things.
First and foremost, previously, in order to unitize for the production of brine, there had to be both a production and an injection or disposal well in the unit. So it required two wells in order to unitize. This bill would allow expansion units based only on one well. So you could have a production well or you could have a disposal well. You didn't have to have both wells. This will allow for a greater opportunity to expand.
And the reason why this is important, as I alluded to earlier, these companies are very important to our communities. They employ a lot of people in South Arkansas. This will allow them to expand their operations. This bill also brings the production of brine more in line with what occurs in the oil and gas industry. And so what we're doing is bringing brine production more in line with what goes on in the oil and gas industry.
As you know, my area of the state, oil and gas production is very, very important. I independently vetted this bill with a number of my constituents and have really run across no opposition. It's my understanding we have Director Bingle from the Oil and Gas Commission, and I don't pretend to speak for him, but I understand that they take no position for or against this bill,
and so I would appreciate a good vote. At this time, I would ask Patty Cardin, who's with Great Lakes Solutions from Eldorado, to come to the table. She can give a little bit more by way of background and a little more specific information. And then after she gives her statement, I would also ask Chris Lawson, who is an attorney with the Friday firm who represents Great Lakes and who was involved in drafting this bill to also come to the table.
He can answer any technical or more specific questions that the committee might have. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ms.
Speaker 12
4:25
Patty, you're recognized. Good morning. Mr. Chairman, thank you for allowing me a few minutes. And, members, we appreciate your time. Matthew's first done a very good job of explaining what
we're doing here. Ma'am, if you would introduce yourself again and who you're
Speaker 12
4:38
with. Certainly. Thank you. Patty Cardin. I am with Great Lakes Solutions. We're a chemtrail company. I'm the manager of our land and public relations there at our facilities in South Arkansas.
So with that, to expand a little bit on what Matthew just explained, our organization is, we're unique. We're a specialty chemical manufacturer. We are located in South Arkansas because of a very unique natural resource that is 7,000 to 8,000 feet, and it's the brine reserve that he mentioned. It has high concentrations of bromine. We extract the bromine from the brine, and bromine is used globally, produces products for the oil and gas industry, housing, automotive, furniture, electronics, flame retardants.
in order to get the brine we have our footprint in south arkansas covers 160,000 acres approximately and within those acres we are governed under three brine units you've read the bill so you understand the brine unit concept so we have three brine units that we currently are producing from within those units we have approximately 70 wells some are the supply some are the re-injection because once we take the bromine from the brine we put that water salt water back
into the same formation that's regulated by the commission as well the reserve is very unique it's the second largest brine reserve in the world the first being the Dead Sea in Israel so as Matthew said very very unique to South Arkansas our business there we've been producing brine in south arkansas for 50 years this year as a matter of fact so um our footprint is significant our economic impact is significant we have about 500 employees uh currently our um an average capital
investment ranges from our kimchurra company to 35 to 45 million dollars a year our in-lieu royalty payments that you you see in the bill and our taxes our operating expenses um generate i mean it's about 150 million dollars uh operating expenses for us to do business in south arkansas so a significant imprint um with that um this bill would as as matthew said allow for those
brine units that we discussed to expand outside those units as we see the demand to grow. So with that, I can turn it back over to Matthew.
Members, are there any questions for Ms. Cardin? Representative Mapes, you're recognized.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have two questions. And the first question is, by allowing this, what do you see as the projected revenue increase, production increase, the economic impact to that area of the state?
Speaker 12
7:43
As we, the areas that we would expand in, like I mentioned that 160,000 acres, as we grow, they're going to be smaller, smaller areas. but everyone that we pull, all the mineral owners that we pull into a new unit will receive the statutory in-law royalty for their brine interest that they have in that proposed area. So, yes, that will be taking on new lessors as we expand. And as we grow and the need is there for more production wells or pipelines in the area,
then it does mean jobs and economic development for us as we grow outside our existing boundaries.
Okay. So it sounds like good jobs, Bill. The other question that I have is, since you're pulling this water out of the aquifer, you're pulling the bromine out, and you're sending the water back down into the aquifer, from an environmental standpoint, I don't know if it's relevant or not, but could you say that the water is cleaner going back down into the aquifer than what it came out of the aquifer since you're taking that chemical out?
Speaker 12
8:50
Well, basically all we're doing is taking the bromine molecule out of the brine water, and then the brine water goes back into the formation. So it's basically the same as it was
when it came out, more or less. Right. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. Thank you. Any other questions for Ms. Cardin? Representative McElroy? We'll take your motion in a minute
I think there's some other speakers here Representative McElroy, I appreciate that We'll get back to you with that Representative
Hendren Mr. Chairman, used to we had some books in here and we don't have them anymore We got this thing here on the desk Used to we could tell how the other body voted on this Is there a way to find this thing in here?
I appreciate the Senator's comments, but I'd like to see it on my book here. Is there a
You know how to do that. He'll show me how to do it. Thank you. Representative Howells. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I do have a question. As I was looking through the provisions of this bill as it relates to the unparticipating owner, royalty owners, whether it's a landowner who has never leased or perhaps someone else has a lease on oil, gas, and other minerals.
in the oil and gas business you if you're an oil driller you have to go to that owner and make the best offer you can or you have ever offered to someone else for those mineral leases would there be any treatment in your industry than it is with the oil and gas business I think
why don't we let Mr. Lawson if that's okay with the chairman answer that question if you would. Thank you.
Very well. Mr. Lawson, if you would
state your name. Thank you, Mr.
Speaker 42
11:05
Chairman. My name is Chris Lawson. I am with Friday Eldridge and Clark, and I have represented Great Lakes Chemical for approximately 15 years as outside council. I want to make sure I understand your question, and maybe I should premise your question by explaining this part of the proposed bill. I had two primary responsibilities in preparing this bill
in connection with the Bureau of Legislative Research. And those two primary goals were, number one, to ensure that any mineral interest owner in what we are now calling an expanded unit under this amendment would be treated exactly the same as any mineral interest owner in an existing unit. And also that there would be no adverse consequence to any mineral interest owner in an existing unit.
The second primary purpose for me, or the primary commission to me in preparing this legislation, was to ensure that by creating the opportunity for expansion units, the operator of the brine production unit would be subject to the same regulatory controls, responsibilities, and duties as they are currently now responsible to the oil and gas commission for existing units.
So to premise my answer to your question, I would say that there is no change in the responsibilities of the operator to the mineral interest owner. Now, I want to be sure you'd asked a specific question about particular language in a lease, I believe, that would be oil, gas, and all other minerals. Is that part of your
question? Yes, because I can, on the surface, think of three circumstances
is when somebody in an adjacent piece of property to a unit to be expanded would have a mineral interest either under ownership of the surface, a lease of the ownership of the surface of the oil, gas, and other minerals, or there was a third, yeah, an assignment or something. But anyway, they have some subsurface rights, and normally if the landowner says i don't want to play i don't want to participate
the commission has generally at least in oil and gas business said you go make your best offer to that landowner that mineral interest holder and you make the best offer that you have ever given to anybody else correct in the unit
Speaker 42
13:56
itself that's correct so so if you that that's the qualifying part in the unit let me let me go back and try to try to answer that and in a logical way that i that as best i can if if there is a mineral interest owner in any of the three ways that
you've described and the brine operator is attempting to unitize acreage which includes that mineral interest then the operator as in the oil and gas industry and as in the existing brine production unitization process must go to that owner and attempt to secure a lease and, you know, conduct due diligence to find out first who owns the mineral interest involved and then to carry on and to do their due diligence to provide, you know,
the proper communication with the operator about what's going on. if following a unitization application where the operator has 75 percent of the interest already leased and yet there's someone who is refusing to sign a lease, then the process would be that they could be integrated into the unit and they would be given a chance to sign a lease or to be integrated at the highest rate at which a bonus had been paid on an existing lease within that
unit, or they can elect to participate in the
unit. Now, when you use the words in that unit, you're talking about the language of this bill. Is that correct? Correct. If there was an application made for
the unit that I'm talking about. Let me use a concrete example in the oil and gas field that I think I'm aware of. If Game and Fish and the next section over, the next unit over, is paid a bonus of $1,500, but in that particular unit they had secured leases for $25 an acre,
hasn't the commission usually told the developer, you go make the very best offer you've made, and if that happens to be the $1,500, that that's been the rule? Is that a correct statement of the law?
Speaker 42
16:14
We're fortunate today, Representative, to have Shane Corey here as general counsel of the commission. And I expect from his actions that he's willing to talk to you about that. I am not an oil and gas lawyer.
I'm a brine lawyer, and I think it might be best for him to comment on that question. Well, I'm not an oil and
Speaker 52
16:43
here. Absolutely. My name is Shane Corey. I'm Deputy Director and General Counselor for the Oil and Gas Commission. I was hoping I could just come up and whisper it to Matthew the answer, but I think the biggest difference we have, while we all say that the production of brine and production of oil and gas is very similar, there are a few key differences.
Specifically, there are the same requirements when we are force pooling or integrating brine owners. The difference is the terminology of unit. In the Fayetteville Shale, in the gas area where you're more familiar with this, and the examples you're given, the unit is a section, township, and range, 640 acres. In the brine unit itself, some of those units themselves, the current ones are 160,000 acres. 160,000 acres is one large unit. So if you're going to add an expansion unit, it has to be under this statute at least 1,280 acres,
unless the commission determined another or lesser or larger area was capable. And then you would look within that expansion unit to provide the highest cash bonus if you came to the commission. The key difference between brine and oil and gas is a royalty. Brine has, in Arkansas law, a statutory in lieu of royalty payment, so you're getting paid a set amount per acre for each brine mineral acre you own, Whereas in oil and gas, it is more of a, you know, it's based on the volume of gas or oil that you're producing.
So to answer the question is, yes, you would have to come to the commission if you have owners in excess of that 75% who have refused to lease. The commission would hear it. They would determine the appropriate cash bonus for those unleashed royalty or brine royalty owners and then set the statutory in lieu of royalty payment for every brine acre they own. So
the commission, as their attorney, I think you can speak for them.
You tell me if you can't, we can assure that those small landowners that would like to hold out for better royalty payments, that the commission is going to decide what those royalty payments in lieu of cash bonuses is
Speaker 52
18:56
going to be? The commission would determine the cash bonus, the royalty, the in lieu of royalty payment is decided in the statute itself. There's a formula that's tied to an index and has a multiplier, so it is set in Arkansas law itself.
The commission would not have authority to adjust the statutory in lieu of royalty payment as that's done by virtue of the law adopted by the assembly
itself. Is there a quick number, one-sixteenth, one-eighth of the value, anything like that that we would all understand? Well, there's a formula
Speaker 52
19:29
that gives you a dollar amount per acre, and I think according to Great Lakes, and I was going to say 50, but I think it's $51.43 per acre per year right now. So you get a set number per acre as opposed to a volume calculation like you do in oil and gas.
Then the adjacent. Representative House. I'm sorry. If we could, we've got several other questions here. If we could go on and come back to you if we have time here. Representative Gene, I think you were next on the
but I've got to ask this publicly. Does my company, Applemark Corporation, support you in this endeavor? we have
Speaker 12
20:19
uh talked with albemarle they've seen the draft of this and they've had no objections
uh and you're going to create a new standalone unit is that
Speaker 42
20:32
correct you want to answer that it would be standalone in the sense it has to be independently created with boundaries
but it would be adjacent to an existing unit well since me and shep Matthew Shepard, Representative Shepard, know this area by as well as anybody in this committee.
Speaker 12
20:51
Geographically, where would this area be? Well, at this time, we're just planning for our future growth as we identify
areas that are outside. The 160,000 acres that we're talking about in our units, right now that covers almost over to the Columbia County line. This is all our production is in Union County. So it encompasses from almost the Union and Columbia County line over to, I'm sorry, to east of El Dorado. So we're looking, it could be any areas outside any of those existing boundaries right now. But that's what you're looking for is areas outside, but you
have no plan of where you're going right now. We are looking at a couple of
Speaker 12
21:32
areas outside our west unit and outside our south unit. Okay. We have three brine units at this time. They're known as the West, Central, and South
brine units. Because Albemarle also has a plant right inside of
operating the plant. They're no longer operating that. No, sir.
Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think that with regard to future expansion, the likelihood is that it's contiguous to where Great Lakes has already operated, hence the need for this bill, which would allow them to expand without the need of actually placing two wells into a unit
they can place it contiguous to their existing units. Then they could place one well in the expansion unit and take advantage of the other wells that they have
Speaker 72
22:17
on the adjacent units, correct? Representative Beck? Yes, thanks for coming. My question
is with the formation of these units, and I'm going to talk about oil and gas a little bit and see if it relates. In oil and gas, you basically use a section line, which is a predetermined surveyed area.
These units, would they be bisections? Would you pull in whole sections, or would you pull in parts of sections? Or who
would determine the boundaries and how this thing would be formed? The Oil and Gas Commission ultimately determines the units, correct? And in South Arkansas, which has been producing oil for almost 100 years, the units don't necessarily translate to a section line. And it can be very irregular in nature. But, again, we've got 50 years of experience in dealing with brine,
almost 100 years in dealing with oil and gas. This is something that people in south Arkansas are very familiar with and very used
Speaker 56
23:24
to dealing with. I'd just add that ultimately gas is predominantly developed on a section basis.
Speaker 52
23:32
The statutory language actually says a 640-acre unit unless the commission deems otherwise for oil and gas. As Representative Shepard said, most oil is not on a 640-acre unit.
The language in this bill would add an expansion unit of 1,280 acres unless another amount is determined by the commission. So ultimately, it would be a request from the applicant that's approved by the commission as to the size of
Speaker 42
24:00
the expansion unit. Thank you. And maybe just to talk about, just briefly about the geology of that, because this is one aquifer, one of the most important things the operator has to bring to the commission is evidence that the boundaries that they are projecting or recommending to be approved
represent the entire area of brine displacement within that area. In other words, everyone who's being affected by this displacement is included in the unit. Thank you.
Representative House, did you get your curiosities fully satisfied here? Mr. Chairman,
no, I haven't. I've got maybe one more question. Okay, very well. Is there anything about this statute that would prohibit an entrepreneur from coming in outside the present unit
and buying up the brine mineral interest before the commission acts, letting the free market operate to purchase those interests ahead of the expansion? From the oil and gas commission side,
Speaker 52
25:11
no. there's nothing that would prohibit that also in addition in order to even make an application to the commission the applicant's going to have to have the approval of 75 percent of the working interest owners and the royalty interest owners so I think that's another incentive that the
the applicant whoever's making the application is going to have to work with either other working interest owners who have already taken those leases or the royalty owners to meet that threshold prior to coming to the commission
believe we've covered it thank you mr. chairman thank you committee for your consideration
is there anybody which speak against the bill for the bill what is the pleasure of the committee
seeing as how Representative McElroy had a motion and has left the room does anybody else have a motion Representative Eubanks
amendment has been engrossed so okay members question before the house is the passage of Senate Bill
47. All in favor signify by saying aye. Opposed? Nay. Representative Shepard your bill has passed. Congratulations. Now then the next item on the agenda is House Bill 1214. We're going to pass over that and since we're going to call this the Matthew Shepard Day, Representative Matthew Shepard. Representative Shepard you're recognized for your resolution.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Committee, you have before you House Resolution
1010, which is to congratulate a constituent of mine, Senator Malik's daughter, Victoria, who was elected National Secretary for FFA. She's actually going to, she travels quite a bit, but she's actually going to be here next week. And I would like myself and Representative Overby would like to honor her with this resolution and we appreciate a good vote Representative House Motion for immediate consideration
although that is a proper motion all in favor say aye All opposed Motion for immediate consideration Representative House Motion do pass All in favor say aye Opposed nay Motion carries Your resolution is passed Representative Shepard Thank you Mr. Chairman And Representative Shepard If you would go ahead I believe you are also going to
Present House Resolution 1008 You're recognized Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members,
Resolution 1008, which is actually the chairman's resolution, but I'm sure all of us very much are supportive of, which commends Arkansas's farmers, ranchers, and foresters for their contributions. And with that, I would certainly appreciate a good vote.
I have a motion to pass. Anybody speak for or against the resolution? All right. Committee members, all in favor of the resolution, signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed, nay. Motion passes. Representative Shepard, thank you for your presentations today. Thank you. Do you want to remind them about the field trip tomorrow? You bet. You bet. We've got that right here. Members, a couple more items here. That's all the bills we have to present today and resolutions.
Thank Mr. Shepard for his presentations. I would also like to remind everyone that an Ag Committee dinner is going to be held tonight, sponsored by Arkansas Farm Bureau. It's for all committee members and their spouses if they wish to attend. It's going to be at the Wyndham Riverfront Steakhouse starting at 6 o'clock. We're going to eat at 6.30. So that's one item. Then tomorrow, Thursday, this is a very important item here at the Poultry Federation at 12 noon.
There's going to be a luncheon, and we are going to be informed and discuss opportunities for expanding our ag exports into Cuba with the recent change in the diplomatic relationships there. So that would be very, very good. I don't know if they've got Cuban cigars for us or not, but we can always hope. All right, with that, any other business come before the committee?
Representative Hendren? Can we get that record on these computers here?
Because he had it, but it was on his iPad, and I haven't got an iPad down here. And I don't want to have to ask what's his name down
there every time what the record is. Okay, we'll have to ask for some technical assistance from our staff here. Maybe while they're
fixing the House machine on voting up there, they can fix this too, you reckon? Yep, we hope. representative
jane representative henry you can just ask for us to have more paper more
paper okay with that here motion to adjourn all in favor say aye we're adjourned thank you
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Dan M. Douglas
Unverified
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd
Unverified
Speaker 12
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Representative Kim Hendren
Unverified
Speaker 29
Speaker 31
Representative Douglas House
Unverified
Speaker 42
Speaker 52
Speaker 61
Representative Lane Jean
Unverified
Speaker 72
Representative Rick Beck
Unverified
Speaker 56
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 4