Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee

February 5, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1116 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1116”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1158 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…resentative Copeland in the room. So Representative Womack, House Bill 1158. Okay, Representative Womack, I believe you need to introdu…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
First off, I want to remind members of the three P's, People Policy Procedure. That's the three things it takes to pass a bill, and we've had at least one procedural issue today. So for that reason, we will not be hearing Representative Ballinger's bill, for those of you that are here, regarding the hair braiding, whether you're in interest for it or against it or media or whatever. If you're here for the hair braiding, that will not be heard because it is hung on the House floor right now. Stay seated, Representative Meeks. Thank you. But it's on the House floor right now having a member's own amendment instead of being amended in the committee. So we will hear that, I guess, next week, but I'll let Representative Ballinger notify those or whatever the case. So if you're here for that, we're not going to be hearing that. I want to make a few more announcements before we get started regarding procedure. If you want to file, let's see, constitutional amendments February 11th. That's coming up next week. Appropriation bills, March 2nd, and all other bills, March 9th. So if you've got this great idea you're working on and you know it's important to get a bill filed, you better be working pretty hard on it. Those deadlines will hit here quicker than you can imagine. And like I said, the three Ps, people, policy, procedure, don't get messed up on procedure. Committee photographed Tuesday at 10 a.m. For those of us that need to fix our hair nicely, take a little extra time. next week before we get I guess we'll be ironic we're fixing our hair before Representative Bellinger's coming yeah I understand you're really dreading that bill is that right Representative Meeks thank you thank you one show only alright where are we at Phil we got all the announcements done alright Representative Lowry we're going to hear your bill first that's House Bill 1116 you
▶ Play
Speaker 8 1:58
are recognized to introduce your bill sir thank you very much mr chairman well this feels
▶ Play
like deja vu all over again uh bringing this bill back to you but it is uh new and improved uh we are still being able to do the original intent which is to enable 17 year olds to be more employable. Some employers have said that the restrictions on child labor laws have been overly restrictive, have created significant compliance costs, and so what they've done, rather than breaking the law, they've just decided not to employ 17-year-olds. So we have changed the ages now so that the child labor laws apply to 16 years of age and under. I had made some changes that I did not realize had some unintended consequences. Those changes have now been taken away. We're back to the original bill, which is that the child labor laws restrict to 54 hours in a week, six days in a week, 10 hours in a day. I know some of those in the agriculture community were concerned about those changes. So we are now back to the original wording. The Department of Labor is happy about that because they didn't want to have to spend a lot of time, and I don't blame them going out and reeducating. I know that the staff attorney has also talked with a number of you that had raised issues the last time about the hours and days changes, and from what I've heard, everyone is satisfied. I will, in full disclosure, tell you that in the process of amending it back to a new and improved and better bill, I've also added an emergency clause. So that is one significant change that I wanted to bring to your attention. So that is the nuts and bolts of it If you have any questions, I'll be glad to entertain Representative Payton, you have
▶ Play
a question Is that right, sir? You're recognized for a question Thank you, Mr. Chair
▶ Play
And I'd like to thank you, Representative Lowry, for changing your bill I do appreciate it, and I like your bill And plan to vote for
▶ Play
it. Thank you very much Well, thank you very much Members, you've heard an explanation Any other questions? Seeing none, anyone signed up to speak for or against this? Greg, is this the bill you want to speak for or against? I can't tell for sure. Contractor's board. Is that for this bill? Okay, very good. Seeing no one to speak for or against this bill, we have representative Wardlaw, you recognize, for motion? Well, it's due pass. All the amendments are engrossed. So we have a motion do pass. Any comments on that motion? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Thank you, Representative Lowry, for working on this bill, making it better, and congratulations. Thank you, Chairman, and thank you, committee. Okay, next up. Okay, we're going to skip by Representative Hammer. He's going to defer his. I don't see Representative Copeland in the room. So Representative Womack, House Bill 1158. Okay, Representative Womack, I believe you need to introduce an amendment first. Is that right? Yes, sir. All right, you are recognized to explain your amendment. Members, you should find that amendment on your tablet.
▶ Play
Somewhere in the fray, I lost my copy, but the three amendments, the first clarifies my intent that we want to preserve the truth in advertising. The second clarifies my intent that the bill applies only to the private sector. and a third change like the second change is a result of the request of the Attorney General and a third change lessens the level of scrutiny that courts will apply to occupational regulations. Members, any questions on the amendment?
▶ Play
Seeing none, what's the will? We have a due pass on the amendment. Seeing no discussion, all in favor, aye? Aye. Any opposed? All right, Representative Womack, your amendment has been adopted. In this committee, you are recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Right
▶ Play
now, Arkansas is a leader in the number of occupations that it regulates. That's like being a leader in debt or unemployment. You don't want to be at the top of that list. This bill gives people who want to work for a living just one thing. It gives them their day in court. It establishes in the law that people have the right to practice a legal occupation. When people who want to work are foiled by irrational regulations, this bill says you can defend yourself in court. This bill does not create a new ground for suit or cause of action. It only creates a new defense. The bill poses no threat at all to reasonable regulation. In fact, it won't have any immediate large-scale effect. What it could do is undercut unreasonable regulations. But this bill only can have an effect one person at a time. The way this bill works to have any effect at all is that the first defendant has to show in court that the regulation makes doing his or her job very difficult or very costly. It's only then that the regulatory agency would have to defend the regulation. And if a defendant can't make a case in court that the requirement is unreasonable, this bill will have no effect in court. If you read the bill, you'll see that there's no provision for damages, which I think will completely eliminate the fear of multiple lawsuits. And any regulation that is truly aimed at protecting the people's health and safety is completely untouched by this bill. All this bill does is let new qualified workers enter the job pool. And I would be happy to answer any questions. Members, you've heard an explanation of the bill.
▶ Play
Representative Bentley, you're recognized for a question. Can you give us some more? I don't want us to have
▶ Play
our licensing end up in the court and our hands be off it. And why can't we do this in the legislature? Richard, can you explain that to me, Richard, why we can't do that? Sure, that's a great question.
▶ Play
We actually passed that new amendment. That will only apply to new regulations. This gives an avenue to be retroactive to laws that are on the books today that may be unreasonable. Great
▶ Play
question. Vice Chair Ferguson, you're recognized for a question. Yeah, on page four, it says it applies to occupations in which state laws impose a fiduciary duty on the person performing the occupation. What occupations would this apply to? I mean, some examples, I guess. What occupations are you speaking about? It's most occupations. I mean, can you give me some examples? Realtors, lawyers. and i mean are you not concerned about the ramifications of this for lawsuits i mean that's pretty far-reaching no ma'am
▶ Play
like i said there's no uh the only way anyone would bring us a case would be if they had truly been burdened and and had a cost that they were willing to take a case up on their own time and their own money and all they win should they be able to prove in court that the regulatory agency overreached and kept them from working all they win is a right to work so that i don't see i don't think there's a pile of attorneys out there that want to take these cases for you know if they win their case they get a piece of another job that pays nearly nothing so i but does this not put
▶ Play
the burden on the state to defend those suits
▶ Play
yes ma'am on the agency and that's i believe that's where it should be i mean if they're going to impose a regulation, then they ought to have a reason
▶ Play
to impose it. I mean, maybe it's the Attorney General okay with this?
▶ Play
Yes, ma'am. It's been through their office and they actually, like I said, were a reason for a couple of these amendments and they feel that they, as amended, they can defend this no problem. Thank you. Representative Fite, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Womack, would this give any recourse to someone who felt that they had been unfairly fined by one of these boards? As I'm understanding you saying this, this would not give them recourse through this bill, perhaps through another avenue, or am I misinterpreting that? Let's say that I felt that I had been unfairly burdened by a board who had imposed a fine on me. Could I get some help through this bill?
▶ Play
Sure. What this bill does is provide a defense for you to go and say, look, I have the right to work, and this particular place where we've bumped heads is an overreach. It has nothing to do with maintaining public health and safety standards. This does nothing to do away with the licensing we have in place. It simply puts the burden on the state to prove that it's a matter of public health and safety if they're going to regulate it. We're not undoing any licensing. It just provides a defense for those people who have been cost through unreasonable regulation.
▶ Play
Follow-up? Thank you. That helps a lot. Let me give you an example, and would you tell me if this would apply? Perhaps I contract to do something, and the contracting board says you have to have a special license if your equipment cost more than $5,000, for example. And then someone, maybe a competitor, turns me in and says, her equipment, in fact, cost $6,000. No public safety issues were involved here, and I got fined by the board. I could come back and say, the law says I had a right to work because I was not endangering anyone and I was unfairly fined. Am
▶ Play
I understanding this correctly? That's a pretty specific question. I'm not sure I understand exactly. But to be clear, what it does, it provides a defense for people who have been unrightly caused due to unreasonable regulation. Again, it does not undo any license that we have now in place. And it does not provide an avenue to undo that. You know, anything that needs licensing. And the beauty of this deal is the court gets to decide. You don't have a board that's protecting its own self-interest making that decision. You don't have an individual that feels like he's been wronged and the world's doing him right. He's not making that decision. We have a non-biased third party of the court. And, again, it's only at the court if this person chooses to, at their own expense, take this suit up and is able to prevail in that lawsuit. So it's pretty high standard. Representative Bragg, you're
▶ Play
Speaker 48 13:25
next for a question Thank you, Mr. Chairman Representative Womack,
▶ Play
I'm making an assumption here Say there's a person that's under a license and there's 500 others in the state and this one person challenges the restriction and they win Does that apply to every other person that has a license?
▶ Play
It only applies to that case That case And he only wins the right to do that job, whatever
▶ Play
he was. So they would operate under a different set of standards
▶ Play
than the other? Well, I think the intent here is over the long term, should that regulatory agency lose that case, they'll simply quit pushing because that has been proven in court once. That's an unreasonable regulation. So I think they'll just quit overreaching, I think, is where we're headed with this.
▶ Play
okay and if they win that that challenge but it doesn't do away with the licensing requirement so it's just for that one particular individual the licensing requirement stays in place for all the others yes sir and i and i like i said i have
▶ Play
no interest in filling the courts up with court cases and i think we've gone out of the way to make sure that doesn't happen here
▶ Play
Speaker 57 14:43
okay all right thank you mr chair representative wardlaw you're
▶ Play
recognized for questions sir Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Womack, you and I had a discussion before the committee, and you answered my question very well, and I'd like to bring that to the committee. I asked you why this bill was necessary, and you brought up the points about the boards and commissions that already oversee these licensures. Would you go through that for the committee, please? Sure. I think Representative Wardlaw's question was why go to court, and the reason is because any time there's a disagreement over what is a reasonable regulation and what is not, the person that's imposing that regulation, whatever that agency is, has a vested interest in protecting that interest. And the person that's on the other side of that issue, they're very biased too. So you get this person gets their day in court to say, yes, this is unreasonable. And so an unbiased third party is the one that makes that decision. That's the reason we're here. I think Representative Love, did I move?
▶ Play
There you are. Hang on with me just a second. I want to ask a question and then get to use. Representative Will, I read this bill numerous times yesterday and really concentrated, and it's difficult to read. I'm sorry. I'm lacking your explanation, but it's difficult to read. Is there not something in place now? we'll pick any board out there and a member of that board feels like they've been wronged by a regulation which of course goes through the regulations process of this body now. Most of them do anyway rules and regulations. But if they feel like they've been wronged they could not sue this board now? May I bring Mr. Greenberg
▶ Play
to the table to help answer that question? Sure. Thank you.
▶ Play
You would introduce yourself for the record, and you're
▶ Play
recognized. My name is Dean Greenberg. I run a public interest organization called the Advance Arkansas Institute. And I want to tell you, Mr. Chairman Link, that's actually a profound question. It really kind of illuminates the difficulty that people who are in regulated occupations face, and it has to do with the nature of the law and the nature of the legal burdens that they currently face. So let me ask you to imagine two universes. the way the law is now, and the second universe, what would happen if this law were passed, okay? The way this works, the way the law works now, where we are now, is that when there's a regulation, the courts, by the nature of the law, don't examine that regulation, and whatever regulation is passed is presumed to be appropriate and correct. I could state it in a more technical way, but that's the way it works in the real world. If this law were passed, if Representative Womack's law bill were passed then that would change and there'd have to be some kind of independent justification independent examination of the way the law works but historically for nearly a century maybe more like 75 years the Supreme Court has interpreted regulations as being kind of self-justifying the Supreme Court has interpreted regulations as saying well you know if if a regulatory body passed it it must have been a good idea or if the let if the legislature passed it it must have been a good idea and it doesn't have to be justified well we know that sometimes legislatures and regulatory bodies make mistakes and sometimes they're overly affected by the pressures of special interest groups which create things like monopolies and anti-competitive practices and I think that that's those sorts of monopolies and anti-competitive practices they're really bad for consumers and that's what that sort of monopoly or anti-competitive practice is really what this bill kind of targets to make sure that you preserve health and safety regulations while also making sure that consumers are treated fairly. And so I hope I've answered your question by saying there's a big difference between the way the law is and the way the law should be. And that difference is that these over-regulations right now, you can't bring a suit. You can't get these over-regulations examined because courts, for the most part, will accept them at face value.
▶ Play
Okay. Let me continue and by no means take this as an argument. I'm going to ask questions. I'm not arguing with you, and I don't have, quite honestly, the equipment to do that. So I'll try to ask these. Are we moving then? Right now, most of these boards and commissions or whatever you want to call them are regulating their own industries from within their industry, at least they're supposed to be. And what you're saying, I mean, it could happen as perhaps whatever the widget industry makes regulations that maybe keeps a smaller manufacturer of widgets out but helps a larger manufacturer thrive, which then eventually creates that monopoly. And you're saying that the board could be – is that – Yeah, for Representative Womack, if you would take care of your phone. well he's a he's a busy and popular man I see but I'm guessing these are all people in favor so let me I'm sorry let me but I could give you some real
▶ Play
world examples of how to have that process
▶ Play
so what I'm going to continue the question here and again I'm not being argumentative really I'm going to continue the question so right now this this board or whatever regulates themselves and and they could be because of larger members within that board of the widget board could regulate toward certain manufacturers and against others but right now could those smaller manufacturers not take that to court or you're saying they really can't or they're ignored in court so my widget company gets overrun with a regulation and I'm not able to compete because of my own industry board hurting me I can't somehow or another go to the court
▶ Play
system now? Well I'll say two things about that First, I think in the real world, we have seen some instances where, you know, on a lot of these boards and commissions, you have consumer representatives. And I think there have been some cases where, in recent Arkansas history, consumer representation has failed. You know, there's a somewhat famous case over in Fort Smith where an orthodontist was called before the Board of Dental Examiners, and the orthodontist was told that the prices he was charging were too low and he shouldn't offer the practices that he was offering, the tooth cleaning practices. And I really wonder what the consumer representative on that board was thinking and how it was thought that this practice of preventing dentists or people who are trained as dentists from offering dental services at low prices was really protecting the public. We had the milk board a couple of years ago when the state legislature passed a law and it looked as if a consequence of this was going to lead to higher milk prices. And I really wonder what the consumer representative on that board thought that he or she was doing in order to protect consumers by creating higher milk prices. But I don't know if that completely speaks to your question. I think a more general answer to your question is if one of these boards and commissions decides to create a regulation and a member of the regulated industry wants to take the board or whatever to court or defend against that in court, they really can't do so because, again, the current state of the law is that, by and large, if there's a regulation that's created or imposed, there's really no way to challenge it, and it's taken at face value. There's a more technical way to put it, and if I can start talking less like a person and more like a lawyer and start talking about different levels of scrutiny, but if I keep on speaking like a person I'll just say by and large there's no way to challenge the rationality of these or the appropriateness of these regulations and so no you really don't have a day in court when you're hit with what I consider to be irrational or unfair regulations
▶ Play
in many cases. Professor Womack you'd like to add to that? I'm going to bring it down off the lawyer just a little bit it's it's presumed now that that regulation is okay you know if you take at the court today, even though 99 of us may think that's completely crazy, it's presumed in the court
▶ Play
of law that that regulation. And how will this be different now
▶ Play
if your bill passes? We have a law that says you have the right to that occupation, and the third part of the court will then be able to look at that regulation and say, you know, yeah, you broke that rule, but that rule is completely crazy or yeah you're breaking the rule and you should be fined and you should not be allowed to work because that affects public health and safety and that's our job government is here to do that so i mean that's the that's the difference did that
▶ Play
make sense i understand the explanation i don't know if it makes sense i'm going to call on representative i am going to call my vice chair
▶ Play
i don't want people to leave here thinking that what he said about the dental board is accurate. Dr. Burris was not denied cleaning teeth because he was cheaper. He was denied because he was in violation of the board rules that when he became a specialist orthodontist, that he would no longer practice general dentistry, that he would practice orthodontics and work on referrals from general dentists who would take care of the comprehensive dental needs at a general practice level. Representative Love, you're recognized for a question. I'm
▶ Play
not sure I want to ask a question now.
▶ Play
No, I guess I understand the spirit of your bill, but what I'm worried about is the number of lawsuits that could potentially be filed and the number of fictitious lawsuits that could potentially be filed just because someone feels that this regulation is an overburden or unreasonable regulation. And so talk to me about, because I'm pretty sure the number of lawsuits are going to increase, and as the number of lawsuits increase, that means the cost is going to increase in whatever industry that you begin to file lawsuits in. And when I think about this, I think about the medical industry and a number of fictitious lawsuits that are filed in the court system and how it runs up the cost. So talk to me about that. That's a good question, and I agree with your
▶ Play
concern. Honestly, it's been there the whole time. But if you'll read the bill, you'll see there's no provision for damages. If you challenge that and you win your case, you get to work. That's all you get. So you have to foot the bill for the attorney, and you have to. That prevents people from taking lawsuits that are frivolous. they're not going to want to pay an attorney to win a case but you know potentially win a case where all they do is get to work you see what i'm saying there's no incentive for those lawyers to take these cases so the only people that are going to take these cases are people that have truly been infringed upon i i tried to to go out of the way to make sure that those cases don't those fearless cases don't show up in court and i've been given a reasonable level of assurance from several attorneys that that they have no interest in taking cases for no money so i think we're i think we're okay on that one okay i'm again it's real simple there's there are no there's no provision for damages in the
▶ Play
bill it's that's just the bottom line but the the provision for damages in the bill in fouling lawsuits and continuously keeping the the court system kind of clogged up And then also in the fact that the attorney general's office, which is funded by taxpayer dollars, is going to have to defend these agencies. That's going to, I mean, the cost to the taxpayer itself is going to go up. I mean, that cannot be denied. Mr. Greenberg, I think we can be in agreement that the AG's office is going to defend these agencies, whether we like it or not. So the cost to the taxpayer itself is going to go up for the sheer fact that the AG's budget is going to have to go
▶ Play
Speaker 77 27:19
up to carry out the defense of the lawsuits. We might just
▶ Play
disagree on the number of people that are going to take these cases to court. I mean, I don't imagine there's a long line of people that want to foot the bill to hire an attorney to sue somebody to win a right to work. I just don't see I'll just say that we'll
▶ Play
have to agree to disagree on this one but thank you. Thank you Mr. Chairman Yes
▶ Play
sir. Representative Fite you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you Mr. Chair Would the AG's office defend boards? I know they would defend agencies but would they in fact defend boards?
▶ Play
I mean I think they'd defend regulatory bodies I might just make two points on this. First, I've certainly been in a situation where I've had clients and I've had to tell them, look, you're doing something possibly immoral and possibly illegal. Maybe you should stop. That's a situation that the Attorney General, my recommendation is to stop. That's a situation the Attorney General might find itself in if it finds that it's dealing with a board or a regulatory agency that's really overreaching its bounds. And so I think that this really might lead to drawing back when a regulatory agency is going over its bounds. And so I tend to think that this is a minor problem that this legislation really targets. The notion that this is going to lead to some large number of lawsuits because there are a large number of overregulatory bodies is in itself a kind of confession it's really kind of eloquent and I'm not sure I share that picture that we're just we're filled with these bodies that are constantly over-regulating I think that it's a small problem but if you really think that we're gonna have a lot of these lawsuits because there are a whole lot there's a whole lot of regulatory overreach maybe we do have a serious problem this bill needs to target
▶ Play
Speaker 63 29:24
Representative Fyatt, do you have a follow-up or anything? Okay.
▶ Play
Representative Bragg, I'm sorry, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. One more. I've
▶ Play
got to try to put this in practical applications to understand, and so another kind of theoretical. Somebody gets a license from a board, and there's multiple components to that license. say electrician you know there may be 20 components that you have to I don't know but you know to get the one license and they challenge you know the requirement for that license and they win so I'm struggling with the fact that that puts them in a there may be other parts of that license that might be valid so does that put them in a situation where they can do work that is valid under certain parts of the license that all the other electricians don't have to follow? Or they have to follow, but this one
▶ Play
doesn't? No, sir, it does not undo any current licensing. In that case, that guy could do that one specific thing where he won the challenge. So
▶ Play
he would challenge a specific part of the license. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes,
▶ Play
sir. Representative Lindstrom. Is there anyone from the Attorney General's office that
▶ Play
might speak to this as well in the room? Don't see your
▶ Play
hands or heads rising. Sean, do you? I'd like to, in response to that, two of those amendments were because of the Attorney General's office. So there gives you a little assurance that they're okay with it if
▶ Play
they signed off on those. I see that someone's in here but I'm not sure that he wants to particularly be brought to the end of the table or have an
▶ Play
Speaker 84 31:30
opinion on this and I understand Representative Sullivan, you're up next Yes sir, Representative Womack is it true that one lawsuit would have the impact of changing the threshold, then that commission would then understand that legally they've set the bar at a too high level. So one lawsuit could change the threshold that would then reduce the amount of regulations and over time reduce the cost for the consumer considerably. That is exactly the intent of this.
▶ Play
You said it perfectly that the government realized whatever the agency is realizes that this is too far and simply quits reaching that far. That is absolutely the intent. And I don't think anything's, this is not an earth shattering thing tomorrow that's going to change, but over a period of time, it absolutely will set people free and allow lower-income people to get a start in business. I mean, we kind of intentionally keep people from being prosperous by not, you know, setting hurdles they can't get over to start a business. So you said that very well. Thank you. One short
▶ Play
Speaker 84 32:38
follow-up. Yes, sir. Yeah, so just to make sure I understand, one lawsuit that the Attorney General's office defends will cause these boards to most likely back off of enforcing that regulation. So the likelihood of us facing multiple lawsuits to change the threshold is unlikely. That's true. And the likelihood that the cost will go down considerably over time is very likely. Yes, sir. Thank you. Which benefits workers
▶ Play
and consumers. Members, seeing no more
▶ Play
questions, is there anyone from the audience would like to speak for or against this bill. Okay. Mr. Greg Crow, you are Crow? I'm sorry. It looked like an E up here. It's one of those mornings. Yes, sir. If you would introduce yourself and you're recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 90 33:32
sir. Greg Crow. I'm the administrator of the Contractors Licensing Board and I put a question mark really first on this and against is when they made me pick a choice. I really more than anything else was asking for more time. This bill was amended Tuesday. It was a shell bill at first and then it was amended Tuesday. I saw it Tuesday afternoon. We started trying to figure out what I meant. It is hard to read and I understand that's a lawyer's fault and I get that. There's a whole lot of agents I've talked to that have said we didn't even know it. Let me look at it. Let me talk to my lawyer. Let me talk to my chairman. We don't really know yet. That's the first thing, and I respect Representative Womack very much, and I did ask him, and I understand why he didn't want to hold up, and I get that. But that was the first thing I'll ask. My second overall biggest concern is that it appears to me that this bill shifts a lot of legislative power to the judiciary, and I don't think that's really a good policy, but that's y'all's decision. but it basically tells the courts to, if y'all pass a law and say, do something, the court is supposed to look at it and make its own independent decision, not giving, specifically says, don't give any weight to what the legislature said as to whether it was necessary or not, and make its own independent decision. I prefer the legislature make laws, not the courts. That's just, I think that works better for everybody. I am concerned to some extent about if I've been, Representative Womack told me that, or Mr. Greenberg may have told me that it only applies to someone who's been charged with, say, unlicensed activity or something, not someone necessarily applying for a license. I don't see that. Maybe I'm missing. Again, I've read the bill a bunch of times, but I didn't see that in the bill. And I also haven't seen in the bill where it only applies to that one individual. and again I agree that if agencies are overreaching yes there needs to be something done about it but I don't think turning the legislative power over to the judiciary is a good idea but again more than anything else I just ask for more time let the agencies look at it let's figure out what it means if there's some way we can reach an agreement I can't promise I won't be opposed to it after talking but I sure would like more time but I understand if that's not going to happen Members, any questions from Mr. Crow? Seeing
▶ Play
none, thank you. No one else has signed up, seeing no one else in the audience that has expressed interest to speak for or against. Members, Representative Womack, would you like to
▶ Play
close for your bill? I will be very brief. His concerns about the courts making the rules and regulations, This is the avenue to allow us to tap into old laws that are currently on the books. Going from here forward, the legislature will have that. This is very simply only aimed at regulations that are truly go too far. This does not undo licensing. We're not changing the world today. As Representative Sullivan said, this is a long-term approach to removing some of Arkansas's over-regulation. I think we're number two in the nation for onerous regulation, and this is the first step in pushing back and setting people free. So I ask for a good vote. Members, you've heard an explanation.
▶ Play
What's the will of this committee? We have a motion due passed as amended. any conversation discussion of that motion seeing none all in favor all opposed chair rules knows have it members that is all we have for today I don't see that anyone else come in to run your bill so we will see you Tuesday don't forget your picture
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1116

2:22 - 6:06 11 segments 4 speakers

HB1158

6:06 - 37:37 112 segments 16 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
34 segments
Speaker 8
1 segment
Representative Mark Lowery Unverified
4 segments
Dan Greenberg Unverified
14 segments
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
37 segments
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
1 segment
Representative Deborah Ferguson Unverified
6 segments
Representative Lanny Fite Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 48
1 segment
Representative Ken Bragg Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 57
1 segment
Representative Richard Womack Unverified
2 segments
Representative Fredrick J. Love Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 77
1 segment
Speaker 63
1 segment
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 84
4 segments
Speaker 90
5 segments