Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Revenue & Tax

February 10, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1247 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…Fyatt, are you ready to go, sir? Members, we're looking at House Bill 1247 and anybody in the audience want to speak for or against th…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1235 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1235”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1308 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…tern Energy. Okay. Committee members, we're bringing to you House Bill 1308, and basically what this bill does, it's pretty much summed…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 16, 2026
out of order. I'm sorry, my apologies. This is actually in order. This will be one of the few bills we're going to run in order. So anybody wants to speak for or against the bill in the audience, please sign in to do so. Good morning, Representative Saban. Morning, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Recognize yourself and you're pleased to go ahead and present your bill. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. You have before you House Bill 1235, which is proposing to amend the Equity Investment Incentive Act of 2007. And put simply, what this would allow is for convertible financing to qualify for the current equity investment tax credit. And it looks complicated, but the concept is pretty simple. And as many of you know, in my quote-unquote real job at the Arkansas Regional Innovation Hub, I work with a lot of startup companies and investors who are looking to invest in startups. And what I've heard from them is that this equity investment tax credit that we have is actually really good. It helps to incentivize investment in startup companies. The problem is it doesn't allow for convertible financing or convertible debt. And to explain that concept in a nutshell, in a lot of other states, when people are investing in startups, they tend to use convertible debt as a really optimal financing instrument, because with a lot of startup companies, you don't really know what your equity position would be in that company on the front end, because the company hasn't started doing business yet. So I was trying to think of a really good example to kind of talk about how this works, and I kind of settled on the TV show Shark Tank, if you all are familiar with that. Usually the most entertaining part of Shark Tank when a startup company is kind of pitching in front of investors is when the investor says, you know, I propose to make a $250,000 investment in exchange for 50% equity in your company, company, basically saying that the company is worth about half a million dollars. And then the entrepreneur will say, well, $250,000, that should only be a 25 percent equity stake because my company is worth a million dollars. And they kind of have a long back and forth about it. The truth is neither the investor nor the entrepreneur really knows the value of that company yet because it hasn't started doing business. So what a lot of these investors like to do in a lot of other places is they'd prefer to make a loan on the front end, basically loan that $250,000, and then after the company has done some business, then they can settle on what that equity stake really amounts to. And that's a pretty common way a lot of these startup companies get their investment in other places. The problem is in Arkansas, we don't allow when that loan converts to equity, we don't allow for it to qualify for this equity investment tax credit, which means a lot of investors end up not investing in startup companies here through the convertible financing instrument that they would prefer because they don't qualify for the tax credit. So I went to AEDC, ADFA, and DF&A about a year ago. I brought this to them. They worked with me on this. I'm not aware of any opposition to this bill. Basically, the investors like it. Obviously, the startup companies like it. It ought to probably promote more investment in our startups here in Arkansas. Like I said, I worked with all of our relevant state agencies. They're on board, and there's no fiscal impact because we're not touching the cap on the credit. So with that, I'd be glad to take any questions. Representative Davis, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Saban, I understand we're not increasing the cap. Can you tell me if we generally hit the cap,
▶ Play
or do we generally come in under the cap currently? I think we're doing right at about the cap right now. My understanding is that there are a lot of investors who are interested in increasing the cap, quite honestly. They feel like that would probably generate more activity, and especially after we allow for convertible financing, Hopefully, if you all approve this bill, there may be, you know, obviously more investments that would qualify. And I wish somebody from DF&A was here, and there may be somebody here who could probably direct that question. Oh, you're here, John. Hey. Good. The expert's here. But my understanding is we haven't been really hitting the cap all that much lately, but we'll
▶ Play
let you talk about it. Mr. Chair, members of the committee, my name's John Tice, and I'm with the Department of Finance and Administration. Actually, the cap is enforced or followed by the Department of Economic Development and not DFA. But when Representative Sabin brought this bill to us, that was a question that we asked as well of AEDC. The answer we got at that time was that some years we have hit the cap and then other years we have not. Two or three years ago we did hit the cap limit, and I believe the last couple of years we have not. But we're close. how close is
▶ Play
a follow up question can you put any numbers to it how close is close are we doing 6 million out of
▶ Play
Speaker 15 5:30
6 and a quarter are we doing 5 million I'm sorry that would be a question for AEDC DFA doesn't monitor that number ok thank you
▶ Play
thank you Mr. Chairman how was that just a second John how was that 6.2 how was that number derived at
▶ Play
do you know I remember when it was passed in the legislature and there were two programs at that time that are combined together to determine the 6.25 limit and that was just a legislative determination about six to eight years ago and how they arrived at it, I don't
▶ Play
remember. Thank you. Representative Lemons. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Great minds think a lot alike.
▶ Play
That was a question I was going to ask. Thank you, sir. Representative Collins, you recognize, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sabin, I just want to make sure I understand what we're proposing here. Today, if I make a cash investment in the company and get an equity position, I'm eligible for this credit. With this bill, if I made a loan to the company that was convertible into equity, I would not be eligible at that moment. However, if three years later I converted that loan into equity, at that point I would be eligible. Is that correct?
▶ Play
Am I understanding this correctly? If we pass the bill, that's correct. Okay, thank you very much. Members, any other question? Anybody for the audience want to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Saban, you closed for your bill, sir? Yes, sir, I'm closed. We have a motion from Representative Dawson. Do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Congratulations, Representative Saban, you passed your bill Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee Representative Fyatt, are you ready to go, sir? Members, we're looking at House Bill 1247 and anybody in the audience want to speak for or against this bill, please sign in Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
House Bill 1247 is doing no more than striking obsolete language from Arkansas Antiquette Code 2660108. I think in your impact statement, if you looked at it, there's no impact to revenue at all, but at the bottom of it, let me draw it up here just a second, at the bottom of it, it says that DF&A currently prepares and maintains real estate transfer affidavits and compliance receipts in an electronic format. All this bill is doing is striking out. In the old way, they had carbon copies, three carbon copies that they used and they filed. They no longer use that. I think one of the deputy clerks this morning told me she had been working in the circuit clerk's office since 1993 and had never seen one of those before. At this point, I would take any questions anybody might have.
▶ Play
Representative Fite, do you have any pushback from any other state agencies anywhere that you
▶ Play
know of? No. As a matter of fact, there was a letter sent on behalf of DF&A in June of 2013 requesting that the circuit clerks do it the way, striking this language, and doing it the way they're doing it right now. Members, any questions? Representative McGill? Motion to pass. I'll
▶ Play
hold that just a second. Anybody in audience want to speak against the bill? For the bill? Representative Fite, you close for your bill? I'm close. Representative McGill, you're clear to make your motion, sir? Motion to pass. I have a motion from Representative McGill to do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, sir. You passed your bill. Thank you. And last but not least, Representative Meeks, 1308. And this will be out of order, so this will be without rejection, members.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee members. And as I say, turnabout is fair play, so I'm going to take my turn here at the end of the table and let you all ask me the tough questions. And just in case you do, I'm going to introduce this gentleman to my left, who's here to take those tough questions. So at the pleasure of the chair, I'll let him introduce himself,
▶ Play
Speaker 33 10:45
and then I'll talk about what the bill
▶ Play
does. Please recognize yourself, sir. Murray Williams from Southwestern Energy. Okay. Committee members, we're bringing to you House Bill 1308, and basically what this bill does, it's pretty much summed up in line 22, payment not required, pending an assessment appeal. Basically, a lot of this is cleanup language. The substantive change here is what we're doing. I think the best way to understand it is through an example. If you buy your house for $100,000, you're going to pay your property tax based upon what that assessed value is. Once every three to five years, as you know, the counties are reassessed. And let's say, for example, that the assessor comes out and says that your house is now $500,000, and you have to pay tax on a $500,000 assessment for a house that was only $100,000. dollars. Right now, on real property, you have the ability to challenge that ruling and that tax money is basically set aside until a decision is made one way or the other or you're for or against you as you go through that appeal process. With personal property tax, that is not the case. You and I are familiar with personal property tax. Once a year, we got our vehicles assessed. that tax is collected. The assessor then will distribute it to the local schools and county and so forth. There's a situation that has arisen, and Southwestern Energy is probably one of the few companies in the state or few entities with the state where this would actually come into effect, where they would, for example, have a million-dollar piece of equipment, a compressor station, and so forth, that the assessor comes out and says that it's worth $5 million. So Southwest Energy is paying the tax on the assessed value of $5 million. That is then distributed to the schools. Well, the company then comes back and says, wait a minute, we only spent $1 million. How is that, you know, how do you get that assessment? So they appeal the assessment. And let's say the situation arises where the appeal is ruled in the company's favor and we're going to drop back to $1 million. dollars the problem comes in is the tax that is collected on that assessment between the 1 million and the 5 million dollars that's already been distributed out to the schools it wasn't held in escrow or in an account while the appeal was pending so now the county assessor has to go out to the local schools and say give me the money back or they've got to make up that difference somewhere in order to return it back to to the company so basically what we're asking is that the same procedure that's done for real property be done for personal property. In situations where there's a dispute over the assessed value, that the money basically be held aside or be held in escrow until a determination is made one way or the other on that appeal. There is an amendment that we are working on. The only concern raised with this bill is the counties have expressed an interest that the part that is not under dispute to go ahead and let those payments go forward and only hold the section that's under dispute, which we think that's a reasonable compromise. So we're going to work to get that amended down on the Senate end. So with that, that's basically what the bill does. It just creates an opportunity under a situation where there's a dispute for the money that's under dispute to be held until that dispute is settled. And with that, we'll be happy to try to take any questions. Okay, Representative Mick, let me
▶ Play
make sure I'm, for the members also, you wanted to make a motion, or we're going to do pass this out of committee's current intention, but then you're going to amend it on the Senate end to fix that language, right?
▶ Play
Correct. Right now, what the bill says is that we're going to take all the money and set it aside until the dispute's settled. And what the counties want to do, and they have no opposition to, is we're just going to set aside the money that's in dispute. and let the rest of the money go ahead and flow out to the schools and counties. Thank you. Richard Collins, you recognize her. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, have you considered just amending the bill now versus having it go all the way over there and then coming all the way back for this kind of a tweak? I mean, this thing should just sail through once you
▶ Play
get that, I would imagine. Yeah, and we had actually talked about doing that, but the folks with the counties said go ahead and pass it through, and we'll do the tweak on the Senate side. Well, I mean, we are not opposed to doing it now, but the thought was to go ahead and let's get
▶ Play
it through the process. Can't do verbal amendments, so without the amendment in the committee, not unless you just want to hold up and come back Thursday, and we'll do whatever you're asking to do. I guess your intention is to just go ahead and just fulfill it today, right?
▶ Play
Right, yeah, go ahead and get it passed through today and get it passed through the House and then amend it back
▶ Play
Speaker 28 15:55
and make the tweak on the Senate end. Got you. Members, any questions? Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 42 16:02
Eaves. Just curious, how long does a company have to appeal the assessment? The Board of Equalization, you go through the Board of Equalization process, and it's usually 30 days after that. It usually happens in August, and then you go to the county court, which is around November, December, and then depending on the judge and the circuit court, it could take one or two years for the circuit court. Members, any other
▶ Play
questions? Representative Lemons, you recognize her.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Meeks, I'm a little bit concerned about line number 35. Penalties shall not be added to the taxes due. Granted, I totally agree with the concept there, but I'm a little bit concerned that people will use this as an opportunity to hold off on paying their taxes in a timely manner. So is anyone concerned about if this goes through that we're going to flood the courts on the
▶ Play
appeal process and no penalty? That section is actually part of the cleanup language. It's already in code. When we presented this to the legal staff, they rearranged some things, and this is part of what's being rearranged. That section is already actually in code. What you're protecting against is that while this is being held, that the companies are not being assessed any penalties because it's basically, in essence, the tax is not being paid because that part that's in dispute is being held. And so it's not fair to create a situation where they're being penalized until while they're waiting for an outcome. I totally agree with that.
▶ Play
I'm just not quite warm and fuzzy with that one line because I'm afraid that people will use this as an avenue to hold off on paying their taxes in a duly fashion. But thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Flowers, you recognize me. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm just wondering, so what happens now if there is an appeals process and then it's the ruling is that money should be returned to the tax entity that is, you know, making the appeal. Is there a certain amount of time in which the money has to be returned? Is there interest that's paid to the taxpayer for that money in the two-year period?
▶ Play
Speaker 42 18:40
I'm just curious as to what happens now. We haven't came across that situation yet because we are still in circuit court right now, but it would be depending upon the judge, whatever the circuit judge said. Mr. Chair, can I do a quick follow-up?
▶ Play
So you mean this has happened yet?
▶ Play
Speaker 42 19:06
The law is silent to personal property tax, so there's no. Representative Collins, recognize her. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And
▶ Play
Representative Lemons, thank you for bringing that point up. Representative Meeks, I just want to make sure I understand. If somebody has a tax in dispute and they've paid the money into an escrow, So it doesn't seem like there would ever be any penalty associated with that because the taxpayer has given the money. Is this presuming that the taxpayer is only paying their opinion of what the tax should be and then the amount that's in dispute? So in your example, the taxpayer could say, I'm going to pay 20% of the tax on $1 million, my opinion, of what it's worth. you think it's worth $5 million and I should pay another four times what I've already paid and then appeal, and then if I lose, my repercussion is I simply pay what you said I owed in the beginning and I kept the use of my own money for months and months. Is this setting that scenario up? No, no.
▶ Play
Currently, they would have to pay the $5 million, the tax into the $5 million. And what we're wanting to do with the amendment is saying that the $4 million, if you will, on our example, that will sit, that's the disputed amount, that will sit in an escrow account that neither party will have access to until a final determination is made. The $1 million that everybody agrees to, that will go ahead and be paid
▶ Play
and processed through the system. And the Line 35 component simply says that because the tax due is sitting in an escrow account, the taxer cannot then say to the person who paid, hey, I've really got you now. You put the $4 million tax over here, but that's really not in my pocket, so I'm going to penalize you even though you really have effectively given up control of the money. That's all
▶ Play
you're protecting here? Correct, correct. And like I said, to my understanding, this is actually already, this is part of the cleanup language. It's already in there
▶ Play
under the real property. Okay. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. And again, I would just, you know, obviously it's your bill and it's your call, but I just, you know, would suggest you think about the notion of making the amendment. This discussion we have has been very, very productive, and my hypothesis is if you amended the bill, it could fly through the committee, and then we wouldn't have to have another discussion on this bill. So again, I would just make that
▶ Play
suggestion for your consideration mr. chairman after conferring with my sponsors back here they they are agreeable to doing that so like I said there this is not something that has to be done today so if that's okay with committee we'll be happy to go ahead and get this amended
▶ Play
and then come back to you would you care to answer one more
▶ Play
question oh yeah yeah yeah definitely go ahead representative speaks why is this going to the circuit clerk judge I I thought the county judge is the one who handled that. If you're not pleased with what the, when you have gone through the other, you go to the county judge. Is that not right? Yes, ma'am.
▶ Play
Speaker 42 22:36
You go to the Board of Equalization first, and then you go to the county judge, and then you appeal to the circuit court.
▶ Play
So you wasn't happy when you went to the county judge? Yes, ma'am. Okay. And
▶ Play
Speaker 42 22:47
then you can go to the Supreme Court after the
▶ Play
circuit court. See, and I can't understand. What I can't understand is, because I've worked with that, why that it's take, I mean, yes, I understand when you have to go through the court system. But when you've withheld that money and you've paid it out to your schools and all your entities that's going to get that, immediately when that's done, then we just withhold that from the schools and what money they get or all the other. and then immediately you are paid I don't know if I'm yeah
▶ Play
Speaker 68 23:29
I mean maybe different places do it different
▶ Play
but I just I mean I can't understand excuse me represent speaks can you just get with them
▶ Play
after the after the meeting and I'll try to catch me and
▶ Play
in these situations we may be out I don't know Craig me farm but we may be dealing with tens of thousands of dollars that we're trying to pull back from the school district or the county that they shouldn't have got and for a local school district to suddenly either have to come up with $10,000 or to lose $10,000 to try to create this refund you know that's a hit to those budgets that we're trying to we're trying to prevent that from happening
▶ Play
is what we're trying to do. Thank you guys very much members that's that's gonna be it for today any discussion without objection we're just
▶ Play
Speaker 42 24:15
meeting is adjourned then. Sorry. I'm going to talk to Jonathan. He said he could get some language from the AAC. Okay. Okay. And we'll get it over
▶ Play
to you. Yeah. Yeah. Give me just a minute. Yeah. Go ahead and get with them and kind of get the language worked up. That's all good and handy. Yes. Yeah. I was going to say you keep working with them.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1235

0:24 - 7:50 22 segments 7 speakers

HB1247

7:50 - 10:15 7 segments 3 speakers

HB1308

10:15 - 24:36 57 segments 10 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Joe Jett Chair Unverified
14 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
9 segments
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
2 segments
John Tice Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 15
2 segments
Representative Tim Lemons Unverified
4 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
10 segments
Representative Lanny Fite Unverified
3 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 33
1 segment
Speaker 28
1 segment
Speaker 42
7 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Chair Unverified
3 segments
Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 68
1 segment