Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Agriculture, Forestry and Economic Development Committee

February 11, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1350 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…. Okay, we're going to recognize Representative Shepard for House Bill 1350.”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1214 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1214”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Do you want to run your bill now, Representative Shepard? You all make up your mind. Arm wrestle for it or something. Okay, we're going to recognize Representative Shepard for House Bill 1350.
▶ Play
You're recognized, Representative Shepard. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Colleagues, I'm here on House Bill 1350, which is a bill that I'm sponsoring that would exempt veterinarians from the prescription drug monitoring program. A few years back, we implemented the Prescription Drug Monitoring Program that requires a report be sent to the Department of Health on the prescription of certain drugs by pharmacists and others, and in that, veterinarians were included in that legislation. over the past recent months i've received contact from a number of veterinarians on this because of the burden that it is on them many of the veterinarians in my area are you know they don't have a significant number of employees it's a burden on them to complete these reports on a regular basis they already maintain the information in their offices but it's a significant burden to them, and so they have asked me to run this legislation to exempt them. I would note I believe Mississippi exempted veterinarians from this requirement, I believe, in the last year. They took up similar legislation and passed that to exempt veterinarians from that. I did visit before filing this, of course, being an attorney and being the chairman of the Judiciary Committee. I'm always concerned about the effect that it might have on law enforcement and their ability to find and prosecute those who would use drugs, prescription drugs, illegally. I spoke with a couple of prosecutors, several prosecutors from some of the more populous counties in our state. They didn't seem to have any issue with this. they were really not aware of any time that they had utilized the reporting from a veterinarian to actually prosecute, and in fact, it indicated that if there were problems with a particular veterinarian, that they would likely come to the surface by other means, and that in those cases, they would issue a warrant to go get the information from the veterinarian. And so with that being said, I would certainly ask for favorable consideration and be glad to answer any questions on this.
▶ Play
Does anybody have any questions for Representative Shepard? Okay. Representative Jane? Question. You're recognized. I noticed that I guess the vets
▶ Play
had a member on the Drug Monitoring Program Committee. That will be dropped off now? Yes. Under this legislation, they
▶ Play
would be dropped off. It seemed, in working with BLR, it seemed only fair that if the veterinarians were being exempted, that there was no need for a representative on that particular group. And another thing that in drafting this, there was some discussion about how would you determine which veterinarians would be exempted. I had looked at some language. At one point, there was a draft that BLR had proposed to say veterinarians who are residents of the state of Arkansas, which to me would be problematic for border areas where you don't know if a vet may be living out of state. And so that's why we arrived at this language to say a veterinarian licensed by the Veterinary Medical Examining Board. So there is already state oversight of those particular vets, and we would have good information on who those veterinarians are. Okay. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Any other questions for Representative Shepard? Did you have anybody testify for your bill there, Representative? no i
▶ Play
guess i could have brought some veterinarians but i
▶ Play
Speaker 15 4:50
decided to go it alone today okay very well does
▶ Play
anybody like to speak uh against the bill please come forward and state your name and who you're with
▶ Play
Speaker 18 5:03
i'm mark riley with the arkansas pharmacist association and first of all i want to apologize to represent shepherd i really just heard about this yesterday afternoon and i'm really i don't know if this is available i'm really not for against i'm just some information i think that the committee needs to think about as they make this decision we don't have a official position on it and i certainly understand the hassle that this causes this costs veterinarians in general my opinion i've been very involved in the pdmp program the reporting and i've worked with vets on a lot of medications through the years. But my concern, or the thing that I really wanted to bring up, is that in general, my opinion is that if you write controlled substance prescriptions, you ought to report to the PDMP, because that's the whole purpose of the PDMP. I'm sure 99% or more of the vets are clean just like the physicians and the dentists and everyone else that write are, but the facts are is the program's in place to catch outliers. It's to catch outliers in writing, to catch outliers in people who are using and abusing the system by going. And so if we don't have reporting, my only concern is if we don't have reporting, you can have vet shopping by people just like you do doctor shopping. And so that information will not be in the PDMP, and so there's just a loophole there for abuse that could happen. Again, I know the situation with vets and animals is a different situation, But I just want to speak in terms of education and concern in general about the process of exempting anybody that writes prescribed controlled substances of being exempt from the reporting.
▶ Play
And I'll take any questions, if there are any. Any questions for Mr. Raleigh from the committee? Representative Ratcliffe?
▶ Play
Speaker 23 6:56
You're talking about – thank you, Mr. Chairman. You're talking about controlled substances. Can you give us
▶ Play
Speaker 18 7:02
an example of hydrocodone? Any kind of pain medication, and again, I don't even know what all veterinarians use, but they do use a lot of, you know, particularly big animals, fentanyl and Demerol and those kinds of drugs too at times. Most of those are injected in the office though. There is another concern, if I may, and that generally speaking, not all time, but veterinarians have a very high percentage of writing the drug and dispensing it, which brings in even another concern because now you don't have checks and balances about one person writing a prescription and somebody else dispensing it, so there's two different people involved in the process. And so that, I think, again, while I think all the vets I've ever known have been pretty honest, you know, guys and gals, but it does, it's all about the potential. It's not about what most people are doing, but it's about the
▶ Play
outliers. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Any other questions from
▶ Play
Speaker 17 8:03
Mr. Riley? Thank you, sir. Thank you.
▶ Play
Anyone speak for the bill, against the bill? Representative Shepard, would you
▶ Play
like to close for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just a couple final comments. I think certainly the concerns raised, Those are certainly things that I have thought through before bringing this piece of legislation. I think that there's some distinctions between pharmacists and vets that make me feel more comfortable with the legislation. A pharmacist, when they're filling a prescription, they're filling a prescription for a person. And so that information, when it is reported, it can be valuable in terms of the fact that they're able to look and see what that person is receiving. and that may demonstrate that there's some abuse or that there's some illegal activity coming on or occurring. A veterinarian obviously is not prescribing for a person, and so it's kind of a different ballgame in terms of the prescriptions being filled. Additionally, as I said before, my understanding for my veterinarians is they have to maintain this information, much of this information internally in their office. This, what we did in the past with the prescription monitoring, just added additional paperwork for them to fill and just doesn't seem to be, in the course of my review and consideration of the drafting of this, I'm not aware of this information actually being utilized for any criminal prosecution. And so I think that this is a positive step to take. I'm certainly sympathetic to the pharmacist's concerns. If they have to do it, they probably would want everybody else to. But I think in this case, it would be acceptable, and we should pass this to allow veterinarians to be exempted. Again, it's not as if they're going to be operating without oversight. They are licensed. There is a board that oversees them. There are records they have to keep internally. And, again, as the prosecutors indicated to me, if there was an issue, They'll get a search warrant, they'll get the information, and then they'll proceed accordingly. So with that, I would move due pass at the
▶ Play
appropriate time. Representative Shepard has moved due pass. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? Nay. Representative Shepard, your bill is passed. Congratulations. All right, Representative Eubanks, moving on here. Are you ready for House Bill 1214? I think so. Well, you're recognized to present your bill. I believe you have an amendment first. I don't know if it's been passed out or if it's on the tablet yet.
▶ Play
Speaker 35 11:08
Well, I can put it up once you want it. You want the second? Okay. You want the second? No.
▶ Play
Pardon me. One amendment. Let's get some clarification. You've amended it once, and that was engrossed. We need the second amendment up? Correct. Is that? Okay. Can we get the second amendment up there? Can we do? Give us just a second for technical. Okay. Should be on everyone's tablet now. you ready everybody find that representative Eubanks you are recognized to present your amendment I
▶ Play
started on this bill a couple of weeks ago and filed it and I've met with Marvin Childers with the poultry federation and he gave me some suggestions and I amended it the first time and we met again this morning and I've amended it again to include some things that he felt might clarify the language of the bill and I don't know whether I've actually satisfied him with regard to that or not. Apparently there was some miscommunication with regard to one paragraph in the bill but I've also included a sentence regarding the bankers' concerns And if you will look on that one part, I don't know what line it would be. I think it's page 2, line 27. I'd met with the Bankers Association yesterday, and they thought there might be some unintended consequences regarding the lenders. And I had asked for them to send me some language that might clarify it, you know, protect them possibly. uh they did not send me anything but i think that was part of the miscommunication that we may have had with uh the poultry federation but uh nonetheless i went ahead and inserted a line since i had not heard from them that says the lender is not obligated to make any additional loans to the borrower if additional investments are required to comply with the related production contract uh i know we have to speak to this amendment first so uh before we get to the bill So I'm not trying to make business any harder for the poultry integrators or the banking association. I just felt like this was something that needs to be addressed. I've tried to address the needs of these two entities, and so the amendment is before you, and I would like to have it adopted.
▶ Play
All right, any questions from the committee on the amendment? Any one to speak for or against the amendment for the amendment Representative Shepard you're recognized for a motion I move we adopt the amendment Motion's been made to adopt the amendment All those in favor signify by saying aye Opposed Motion carries Your amendment has passed. You may proceed with your bill as amended. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Give you a little background as to why I brought this bill to the committee and why I think it's necessary. I was in the poultry business for 38 years, one month, nine days, and ten hours. In that time, the business changed considerably. I got into business in November 76, and at that time, and it's common practice to get 100% financing for poultry operations, and I assume it might be similar for hog operations, turkey operations, whatever. But at that particular time, you could get the financing, and it would cash flow on a five-year note. it wasn't but a few years and building costs escalated equipment costs escalated and everything and it pretty soon it became common uh practice that it was seven years to uh in order to finance this and it would in order for it to cash flow and then again it was a few more years and it was 10 years well we find ourselves today that the the common term of a mortgage for one of these operations is 15 years in order for it to cash flow. Now, I don't know exactly how long all the contracts are for the various integrators across the state. I believe seven years is a common term for Tyson Foods. That was who I grew for. But with the term of the contract being seven years and with the term of the loans being 15, then I felt like that many growers, farmers were getting into the business and maybe did not understand what the financial commitment was that they were making. Now, federal law, as Marvin has pointed out to me, already includes this, and it states that it must be on the front page in a conspicuous manner. I guess I've defined what conspicuous is with regard to Arkansas, and that it'd be in boldface print on the first page. Now, federal law says it does have to be on the first page. And you can look on the bill and see exactly what that language is that's included in the amendment. that the it's a notice that the grower's execution of the production contract establishes that the grower understands and acknowledges that additional large capital investments including without limitation the purchase of additional equipment the completion of improvements and the upgrade of structures housing poultry or livestock may be required of the grower during the term of the production contract I would just I wanted it to be expanded it somewhat than what the federal law necessarily says, so that they have a better understanding of what those capital investments may include. But I thought we needed to go a little bit further, and so I thought that the lenders, to reinforce this, also include, and it is an attached as a separate document with the you know, the application for loans and the mortgage. And I included also the same basic disclosure that the borrower may be required to make additional investments to comply with the related production contract before the term of this agreement, the mortgage agreement, is complete so that they know going into this that before their initial mortgage has been paid off, they may be required to seek additional financial arrangements in order to maintain their production contract. Well, after meeting with, like I said earlier with the amendment, after meeting with the Bankers Association and they were worried about some unintended consequences and I don't know what all they were because they didn't send me the language. And like I said, if there was some miscommunication between us and them or between the Poultry Federation and me, then I apologize. But like I said, I went ahead and included a line that says the lender is not obligated to make any additional loans to the borrower if additional investments are required to comply with the related production contract. in the last oh five to eight years i've i've i've witnessed people that have growers have gone bankrupt they uh they made the initial loan and either bought an existing farm operation or built one, and before that mortgage was completed, they were required to make some additional investments, and they were not able to get additional financing. So it forced them into a decision that they didn't necessarily want to make. They either were forced into a sale or they were forced into bankruptcy. And I just want a disclosure so that they are made aware, as best as possible, what they are getting into, so they know the possible consequences. And with that, I'll take any questions. Representative
▶ Play
Meigs, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The question I have, and it sounds like this is one of those deals where in concept it's simple, but the devil's in the details. Seems that way. Yep. The question I have is when you get in these situations and you say that additional equipment or capital improvements may be required, who's the one who determines that there's a new requirement there that has to be met? The integrator. Okay, so the integrator comes and says, you've got to do this. now is it typically like a new technology that's come down the line or a new regulation or is it you know their poultry houses are falling down what are what are give us some examples of what might trigger that lots
▶ Play
of times it has to do with new technology over the last 10 years or maybe even longer you've gone to tunnel ventilated houses where all the fans are at one end and all the air was you know coming into the house from from the one end the opposite end of the house and then they went to cool cells which was a fairly large investment where you you have evaporative cooling pads put on the end of the chicken house and then the fans draw that air through those cooling the house and and keeping the the poultry comfortable so that they uh they they're happy and they eat and they drink and they gain weight which is uh you know the whole purpose of it another one is that we've gone to controllers or computers that we have uh we we've had to add uh control rooms that were on before uh the new specs came out on new buildings then you had to add a control room that was outside it was attached to the building didn't necessarily have to be but it was separate it was outside of the environment of being in the chicken house because of the electronics and everything. But that controller then can monitor all the conditions within the house, and it includes alarms and that sort of thing so that the grower knows what's taking place in the house, and it keeps a record of it. So would
▶ Play
this be a situation where you've got like a seven-year contract with Tyson and you've got a 15-year mortgage, and it comes time to renew after that seven years to create a new contract, and that's where the expense would occur? Because I guess my question is, whoever that integrator is, when we start a contract, we say these are the conditions that I'm going to be growing these chickens in, how would they come midstream and say, okay, there's this new technology? Or is that included in
▶ Play
the technology? I think the normal practice has been as best as possible to be at the end of the contracts. But sometimes when they've wanted this new technology installed, they've given a time frame my experience and my complex was that it was about a year year and a half that they were made aware, the grower was made aware of what was going to take place but even like their contract states it can take place mid-contract so there's writing
▶ Play
in the contract that says that the grower or the integrator or the Tyson or whoever can come in the middle of the contract and basically change the terms of the contract? That's my understanding of the
▶ Play
language in the contract, yes. Okay, and that's
▶ Play
kind of what I'm getting to. It seems like if they weren't coming in and changing basically the requirements of the contract that this wouldn't be necessary, but I guess that's a common... Unfortunately, it is. Okay,
▶ Play
all right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Representative Hendren, did you have a question? Yes, sir. Yes, sir, Mr. Chairman. Representative Eubanks, I guess you're smarter than I am because you said you're out of the business, and I'm still in that business. As a matter of fact, my son-in-law, they're loading 125,000 chickens this morning out of our poultry farm up in northwest Arkansas. I have a couple of three questions about this, and this is why I firmly believe in citizen legislators, because around this table most of us do something that when these bills we pass them, they impact us. And we've just installed – we just spent $35,000 to install permanent doors over those cooling cells that you just discussed, as well as new nipples on our watering system. So that's a perpetual thing for a farmer. However, let me just say is that it provides something for you to eat when you go to Chick-fil-A, or it also provides jobs for people that are good, well-paying jobs. So to ask that, the primary question I have here, does this bill help the banker? Does it help the companies,
▶ Play
or does it help the grower? Well, actually, I think it just helps the grower because I think it just, in the form of a disclosure, so they know what kind of business they're getting into, what kind of investment they're making, what kind of consequences that they may face down the road. Poultry business has been great for Arkansas. It was great for me. But because of circumstances outside the— Do you want to buy back in? Not at my age, no. Maybe that's a message for me, too. But I don't want to put any undue requirements or hardship on either the bankers or the integrators, and I really don't feel like this bill does that.
▶ Play
One of the things that Marvin Childers mentioned to me, and I'm sure he probably did to you, was there's a federal regulation, they already do this. That's correct. You mentioned that in your explanation. Yes. Here's what bothers me about this, and maybe the banker's not going to like what I'm about to say, but I was in a bank one time a few years ago borrowing money to build a radio station, and we were talking about that, and many farmers don't understand the difference between simple interest and compound interest. Sometimes car dealers don't explain that as well as they ought to, so we have this APR thing that's out there now. What I'm concerned about this bill is what you're doing is putting another notice on it, but probably everybody around this table signs documents that they don't read. Somebody puts it out in front of them and says, well, this is a good deal, sign it. So my question is, why not tell that banker, that lender, that, by the way, our loan was for 15 years. We finally got it paid off because it's been more than that, and after you get it paid off, if you maintain it, it's a good profitable business, as you just said. Why not instruct that lender to explain to that farmer like me that maybe can't make change or can't write in cursive writing, why not require that he explain to them this is what may happen to you. In five or ten years, you may be required to put – we had $35,000 just recently. You may have to put that in there, and if you have to put that in there, I may not loan you the money. And if I don't loan you the money,
▶ Play
you may lose your farm. Well, I'm not opposed to that, but I was trying to keep it as
▶ Play
unrestrictive as possible. I guess the point I'm making is that another notice across the top of that paper is not going to help me much, but if you make that banker in the pinstripe suit, explain to this farmer in the overalls what deal I'm getting into, I might think longer. I might negotiate a harder deal with the banker.
▶ Play
Speaker 64 27:48
I will support your bill, sir. That's a pretty
▶ Play
good answer. Any other questions for Representative Eubanks? Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1350

0:36 - 11:08 32 segments 7 speakers

HB1214

11:08 - 28:31 48 segments 6 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Dan M. Douglas Chair Unverified
16 segments
Representative Matthew J. Shepherd Unverified
14 segments
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 15
1 segment
Speaker 18
6 segments
Speaker 23
1 segment
Speaker 17
1 segment
Speaker 35
1 segment
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
24 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Chair Unverified
8 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 64
1 segment