House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (3)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1136
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…u, committee members. I'm pleased to bring before you today House Bill 1136. I'll go into a little bit of history about why this is bro…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1158
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1158”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1165
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…needs to do to fully address the problem, and we feel that House Bill 1165 does fully address the problem. Does this take”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Representative McGee, we have some, this is a scope of practice bill. Yes. And we have some information on scope of practice changes that I think we'd like to pass out just before you get started. Is that right, Phil? Okay. We're going to pass this information. It's not exactly specific to your bill, just more specific to scope of practice changes and some information on it. But it's not specific to your bill. Do you want me to go ahead then,
Speaker 5
0:32
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee members. I'm pleased to bring before you today House Bill 1136. I'll go into a little bit of history about why this is brought up and why I brought this here for you to consider. This has to do with prescription, two things. One, prescription of medications, and two, also adoption of appropriate oversight by the appropriate boards here in the state.
Prior to, I think it was October of 2014, hydrocodone products were listed by the DEA as a Schedule III drug. And just to give you a little bit of information about schedules of drugs, for those of you that don't know, Drugs are scheduled by the DEA as a Class 1, Schedule 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5. And in a Schedule 1 drug, those are drugs that have a high potential for abuse
and no currently acceptable medical value. Think of things like LSD and heroin and that sort of thing as a Schedule 1 drug. Schedule 2 drugs are drugs of which hydrocodone products now are Schedule 2 that have a high potential for abuse but less potential for abuse than Schedule I drugs. But use of those drugs can potentially lead to psychological or physical dependence,
and they're considered dangerous, but they're also drugs that are used for medical reasons. And then you go down through the other schedules, and the drugs become less potential for abuse and less potential for relocation to other areas. Anyway, the DEA came out and moved hydrocodone products to Schedule II. Is that the Drug Enforcement Agency? That's the Drug Enforcement Agency, Federal Drug Enforcement Agency. Okay, the Federal Drug Enforcement Agency came out and moved hydrocodone products to Schedule II,
And what that did, it's not that it's that much more dangerous on a Schedule 3. What that did in practical terms from a physician's standpoint is prior to that time, we could call in a prescription for your Schedule 2 drug, or we could write your prescription and give you multiple refills on it. So, for instance, you have a surgery performed, and I want to give you, you know, 10 hydrocodone tablets with three refills. I could do that. And I could call that in or I could send that in electronically to the pharmacist.
Now what happens, practically speaking, is I have to give you a written prescription for however many drugs you need, and there can be no refills. And if you have to have a refill, you have to recontact me and actually have to come back to my office and see me to obtain another prescription for the drug. And all of those things were done because we do have a tremendous problem in this country with prescription drug abuse on the market. so anyway what that did for the advanced nurse practitioners prior to that is they were able to use schedule three drugs and they still can but now one of the drugs hydrocodone products
which they use frequently they can't because of that and what my bill does is basically it allows them to it restores for them and allows them to use hydrocodone products under their with the collaborative agreement with their physician just as they did before they still will have to write prescriptions they'll have to sign them do all the things that physicians have to do the second thing that the bill does is is it directs the nursing board to basically get in contact with the medical board and then adopt rule and regulation consistent with the medical board
policies and i think that's a good thing that levels the playing field for all groups of providers and uh for your information i do have some uh if we can talk about it the medical board has a fairly extensive process that they've gone through and rule and regulation they've adopted for those that prescribe narcotics as physicians, and we're just asking that the nursing board go to the medical board and adopt similar rule and regulation. So that's really the bill in essence. It restores their ability that they had prior to October, and then it directs the nursing board
to get similar rule and regulation for their providers. And I'm open to any questions. Members, you've heard an explanation of
the bill. Is there any questions you do? Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative McGee, my
question is, does your bill create a loophole for what the Drug Enforcement Agency was trying to accomplish when they reclassified it? Well, I don't think that
Speaker 5
5:16
it really creates a loophole for what they were doing.
When they did that, I don't think they were singling out nurse practitioners and saying that we don't want you to prescribe Schedule 2s. That's up to us at the state. What it really did is they're going to have to live under the same rules that we do. When they write a prescription, they'll have to write it out. There'll be no refills. There won't be any phone refills or electronic refills, and those patients will have to come back to them.
So the reclassification by the DEA accomplishes a lot more than what you're undoing? I think that it
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bentley, you're recognized for a question. Representative McGee, can you tell us what other states are doing besides us on this?
Speaker 5
6:02
Has anybody else passed in legislation to help the nurse practitioners? I don't know. I know that we did in the last session. The same thing affected other groups of medical providers, and we passed similar legislation for other groups here in Arkansas. Just a quick follow-up, if that's okay,
Chairman? Yes, ma'am. We do have such a serious problem in our state and in our community. I do recently, we had a drug bust, you know, in Perry County, some hydrocodones.
Do you think in your estimate this is going to increase the hydrocodone on the street
Speaker 5
6:29
at all? I don't think so. I think one of the things that this will do is people that, you know, really the realistic, there are a lot of reasons there's a lot of hydrocodone that gets on the streets. And one of the things, one of the reasons I wanted to have the nursing board look at the medical board's rule and regulation was because they do address a lot of things such as chronic pain problems and how the patients have to come back and be reevaluated monthly,
and a lot of physicians have pain contracts with patients that are on chronic pain medications. So I think that doing those things, that helps actually reduce the amount that will be out there on the street. They're not able to write for an unlimited amount of drugs. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Where is our Surgeon General on this bill? Have you consulted with him?
I've spoken with him, and he's okay with this.
Okay, may I have just a second question on that? Yes, sir. Maybe I'm – is there a similar bill or another bill dealing with nurse practitioners on our agenda that request this? Is there something similar?
Speaker 5
7:40
There's another bill that I think is going to come up later, but it's far more expansive than this. Could you explain expansive to me? Well, I think that they're looking for all Schedule IIs and other things. Okay, so your bill
you're recognized. You might give us some examples. I know we've talked privately about situations, why you think they should continue to prescribe hydrocodone in situations where they're working with surgeons and
Speaker 5
8:22
those kind of things. Well, in a lot of situations, general surgeons, for instance, will have nurse practitioners that work with them
and manage postoperative pain, orthopedic surgeons and that sort of thing. And I've had a number of calls from APNs who, once the law was changed by the Drug Enforcement Registration, have not been able to prescribe. So it's just going to restore that back to where we were back in October of 2014. Okay, seeing no further
questions from, oh, I'm sorry, Representative Wormack. You're recognized. Dr. McGee, is there anything
else that's new in this bill?
Well, you said it restores it back to the way it was. Does it restore it exactly,
Speaker 5
9:11
or are there any other changes? Well, there is some language in it that, oh, let me see where the bill is at. It deals with physician's assistants, the same sort of thing. Physician assistants who work with a collaborative agreement under a physician, then they're also affected by this. but they fall under the medical board for rule and regulation, physicians and citizens do.
I may just be slow. Would you elaborate a little about the difference in this, what will be the difference now than before? You said
Speaker 5
9:49
this bill just restores it to the way it was. Prior to the DEA moving hydrocodone products to Schedule II, prior to that time, those people that had those prescriptive authority who had a collaborative agreement with the physician they had prescriptive authority to use hydrocodone products but it was a schedule three
when it goes to schedule two they don't have the rights to use schedule twos at the present time so this just puts them back to where they
were before and there's no other changes from okay no Thank you.
Seeing no further questions from the members, we have a couple people signed up. It looks like both of them are against this. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Thank you. Mary, and I always say this wrong, Garnica, but come on up.
Introduce yourself properly for the record, and you're recognized to testify. I'm
Speaker 55
10:55
Dr. Mary Garnica. I'm an APRN for 20 years. And what is APRN? An advanced practice registered nurse. Thank you. Family nurse practitioner. I'm here to speak against this bill for a couple of reasons.
First of all, as Dr. McGee talked about, the change that took place in October did, in fact, change a situation that was current for 20 years, which is that APRNs in the state did have the authority to prescribe Schedule III medications. What we understand from the Board of Nursing is that for 20 years, we've had a very solid safety record in the prescriptive authority that was granted back in 1995.
While acknowledging that the problem of diversion of street drugs is a serious problem nationally, there's really no evidence that this has anything to do with the classification of prescriber that's prescribing the drug. There are a lot of other factors that may be involved there. Having said that, I want to offer, I guess, a different way of looking at why we have concerns about this bill, And it's primarily because in the practice of an APRN, there are patients who are within the scope
who are being managed and assessed and cared for by that APRN that have health conditions that require other scheduled medications. Example of that would be patients with ADHD. Another example of that would be someone with acute debilitating pain. And as Dr. McGee noted, what happens with a Schedule II prescription, whether it's a hydrocodone combination or whether it's another drug,
is that if that collaborating physician is not available to provide the prescription, that means that the patient, for example, maybe an elderly person who's in a terrible amount of pain, cancer or something like that, will have a significant delay and will continue to be in pain. until that prescription is filled. So that would be one example. Another example is folks with ADHD will be coming back monthly for evaluation
to get the prescription medication that's needed. And very many times, especially in the rural areas where we have a very significant physician shortage, oftentimes that care provider is an APRN. Another important principle of prescribing that has to do with safety is that it is safer for the clinician who knows the patient well and has an established relationship with the patient to be the one that prescribes that medication.
When you add another layer by simply having a requirement for a signature from a physician who really may never have seen that patient, You're not really making that care any safer, but you are creating delay, and you could be adding to the cost because in cases of outpatient care, you may have someone who has to make an additional visit to a physician to get that medication. So we're speaking against the bill because we feel that it really doesn't go,
it doesn't really do what it needs to do to fully address the problem, and we feel that House Bill 1165 does fully address the problem. Does this take
it back to where it was before the Drug Enforcement Agency changed and moved oxycodone to Schedule II? Mr. Chair, yes, it does do that, but it does do some additional things
Speaker 55
14:48
that have been needed for a very long time. The other thing I might mention... So this bill does other additional things? It does. It
would. And so this bill is, I'm not really trying not to be an argumentative.
I'm trying to understand. I'm guessing most people at this table are trying to understand exactly what.
Speaker 55
15:08
Oh, no, this bill does not. I'm sorry. 1165 does some addition. We're not debating
1165. I understand. I'm asking you if this bill takes it back to where it was before DEA made the change. It does seem to do that. so what you want is do you want this committee to kill this bill not pass this bill and instead pass a different one I'm trying to figure out what you want I'm trying to figure out why you're
Speaker 55
15:34
arguing against this bill that would be primarily why
we feel that it really doesn't address the need fully as it should what
if neither one passed well then the problem would continue it seems like it would be worse it seems I mean So, again, I don't want to argue. Members, questions? Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. Oh, Representative Womack, you're
recognized. Is there a good reason we should not pass this bill today and then in hopes that you'll get your next bill passed also?
I mean, is there a good reason that
Speaker 55
16:13
we should avoid this bill? Well, again, it just addresses something that, yes, the DEA change created back in October, but it doesn't address anything beyond that, and we just feel that the other bill is a better public policy solution. That's all. So this bill
does not make your situation any better at all? No. Because we really can't, as the Chair eloquently stated,
So we can't take that bill into this debate. So I'm not, honestly, I'm not real clear why you don't feel like we're at least taking a little step in the
Speaker 55
16:55
right direction here. Well, it's not to be criticizing moving the hydrocodone back to where APRNs can prescribe it, because certainly that's something that needs to happen. Our, again, our opposition is primarily because we feel that APRNs have established a good safety record
and 43 other states have already authorized APRNs to prescribe the full schedule too.
All right, seeing no further questions, thank you for your testimony. Next up is Dr. Byrd. and if you would introduce yourself for the record and you're recognized to give testimony.
Speaker 71
17:45
Thank you. I'm Dr. Darlene Byrd. I'm also a family nurse practitioner. I had a statement, but let me just instead of repeating some things. From my standpoint, this bill, there's a couple things wrong with this bill. Number one, it doesn't go far enough because being able to prescribe Schedule II is an access to health care issue across the board for pain management and the care of children and adults with attention deficit disorder.
Number two, this bill adds and changes our collaborative practice agreement. On page one, on line 31, it says, and expressly authorized by the collaborative practice agreement. My understanding of this, and Representative McGee, you can please correct me if I'm misinterpreting this,
is that how we prescribe hydrocodone would have to be detailed in the collaborative practice agreement. As it stands right now with the collaborative practice agreement, that is not the appropriate place to address that. The appropriate place to address who and how and how many is in the required prescriptive protocols. The collaborative practice agreement is just the agreement between the APN and the physician,
how we would operate, how we handle emergencies, how we handle absences of the collaborative practice physician, et cetera. So I would like to see that corrected so that it goes to the specific, more appropriate place to address that. The other thing is on page 2, line 3, where it says that the state medical board shall review the proposed rules to verify that the rules are consistent, blah, blah, blah, blah.
The Board of Nursing has been regulating the practice of nursing for over 100 years. They've done an excellent job. Adding another step to the administrative process in promulgating rules is just, again, delaying the process, and we don't feel like that we need another review by the medical board. when they can do that review through the public comments, through the administrative process.
So those are the concerns that I have with this bill. Hi, members. I've heard
the testimony. Any questions? Representative Orlmack, you're recognized. It's kind of a wide-open question, but do
you feel that there's room to reach some sort of agreement with your couple concerns? I do. Okay. And you would be open to that?
I would be open to that. Okay. Thank you. Representative Sullivan, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Did I understand correctly that 43 other states have
Speaker 71
21:26
a less restrictive bill than what this bill would be? Yes, sir. And I went back at noon and looked up on the DEA website, and there's at least 43 other states that has, for advanced practice registered nurses, have full Schedule 2
through 5 prescriptive authority. Is there any data that suggests in those 43 other states that this bill is going to bring harm to patients?
I mean, if we make it more restrictive, are we making, is that going to cause harm to patients by making it more restrictive? Is there any data to support that? I'm not sure if I understand you. I'm saying a double negative, aren't I? Yeah, I'm trying to. Okay, so in states that do allow that, is there evidence to say that that's a good practice and patients are doing better in a less restrictive environment?
Speaker 71
22:19
They are not a less, they have a more open, okay, so they're not as restricted as we would be. Yes, and
is there evidence to support that patients are doing all right in that environment? It depends
Speaker 71
22:37
on how you want to find the answers to that question of you're looking at outcomes data. I'm sure there is, or you can look at regulatory data as far as disciplines to our APNs, but I don't have that information readily available.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Representative Payton, you're recognized
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ma'am, the way things stand today with the reclassification by the Drug Enforcement Agency, would this bill passing make it less restrictive than the way
Speaker 71
23:14
things are today? as far as being able to prescribe hydrocodone only less restrictive I'm not sure if I'm understanding where you're coming from
the passing of this bill would relieve restrictions that are currently on there today as far as being
overall goal would be to move towards less restriction? My overall goal would be to
Speaker 71
23:42
be able to prescribe all the schedules in order to have full access for patient care. Unfortunately, we don't have that in front of us for
consideration. I know that, yes, sir. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Seeing no further questions from the committee, thank you, Dr. Byrd, for your testimony.
Representative McGee, are you closed for the bill? Would you like to close
Speaker 5
24:19
for your bill? Thank you, Mr. Chair, for allowing me the moment to close for this. What I'd like the audience to know, too, is that I'm Dr. Stephen McGee. I'm a board-certified ophthalmologist. I graduated from the University of Arkansas Medical Science Center.
I practice vitriol retinal disease here in Little Rock. I brought this bill before the committee because of problems that APNs were having. And in most instances, most APNs that I visit with, this was a problem particularly with chronic pain management and a problem in surgeons' offices where they were prescribing it. Most APNs, in fact, all of the advanced practical nurse that I've talked to, this will alleviate their difficulties, their prescriptive difficulties. I have specifically talked to many of them about
we've got into a little bit of discussion here about other Schedule II products of which I'm opposed to allow that most of them don't use those products that's a dramatic expansion in the scope of practice I could have brought this bill forth and said APNs, you are practicing medicine you are prescribing dangerous drugs why don't we just put you under the medical board I didn't do that I didn't think that would fly very far There would be quite a bit of opposition to that. But I did bring forth a recommendation or legislation to require the nursing board to create a level playing field.
I think that they should go to the medical board and look and adopt the medical boards. There's no reason to reinvent the wheel. Go to the source for the physicians who regulate my profession and look at those rules and regulations, and they should live by that. So I think it's a good bill, and I appreciate a good vote from the committee. Thank you. All right, members, you've heard
the bill. What's the will of this committee? We have a motion due passed from Representative Wardlaw. Is there any discussion on the motion?
Yeah, go ahead. Is there any way I can clarify what would happen if we, say, passed one of these other bills? I mean, I'm a little confused on, so we give them access to all Schedule 2s, but yet there's this clause in here about the medical
board and nursing. And Representative McGee, you may correct. I'm going to go off my limited knowledge of what I'm getting ready to say, but the other bills, as I understand, would give them prescriptive authority over
Yeah, it would just kind of, instead of getting a small circle, they'd get a big circle with a small one in it so it would it would give more but it wouldn't take away any of what
this is doing as i understand it that's why i would understand it and make a yes yes please so so the kind of there's something in here i agree with and it's hard for me to go that you should go to medical school and have extra you know residency and training and then potentially be held to a more restrictive standard than a nurse
practitioner who's had less education and less training. So there's a clause in here that I like, but my question is, so this part about consultation between the boards, the nursing board and the medical board, my question is if we expand it to all Schedule 2s at a later date with another bill, does that clause go away or does that remain? That's
a reasonably good question. Representative McGee, do you? Well, I certainly would
Speaker 5
27:44
like for it to remain, but I don't know that it would. Someone else would have to give me that interpretation later.
I've got two people up here who kind of want to talk about this. Representative Meeks, do you have some sort of answer on this? Yeah,
this goes back to any other bills. If there's a conflict between the two bills, then whatever bill the governor signs last is what actually takes precedence. So if there's not a conflict, then, of course, if there's two bills, there's no conflicts, then both bills would go into law. If there is a conflict, whichever one the governor signs last is the one that will take precedence and go into law. That's true.
Thank you. Okay. All right. Thank you for the discussion. I like discussion on motions.
All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Representative McGee. That bill has passed. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Chair. Are you ready to run the other one while you're at the table, or are we waiting on that one? I'd prefer to wait on the second bill. Yes, sir. Thank you. Representative Ladyman, are you here to run the four-eyed bill? Would you go to the end of the table and let me talk to you about that a little bit? And this discussion we had yesterday, so all the members kind of knows what's coming,
I think most of the audience. You filed this, was it yesterday? No, before yesterday. Here's what I want to do and why I want to do it, and so you know you're not being picked on. We had the same discussion with a senior member yesterday, Representative Ladyman. This is going to be a highly debated bill. It's going to be very argumentative. We're going to have a lot of people from both sides. I'm not here debating policy at all. And you're a good person. So there's three things. There's people, policy, and procedure. I am concerned about a rushed procedure on a bill that's going to have so many people involved.
And I'm wondering even if we might want to set a special order of business so that everybody knows when to get here and that type of thing. Because I'm afraid if we run this on a Thursday afternoon with such limited notice, we're going to have people on one side or the other very angry they didn't get to have input. And that's the proper procedure I'm concerned about. And again, we had this discussion before, so the president's kind of setting this committee on that. Would you consider setting either a special notice or would you consider running this next week, maybe next Tuesday or Thursday?
Yes. Yes, I could do that. Would you like a special order of business or would it just be at your convenience of when
you come in Tuesday or Thursday? At my convenience, I
think. Yes, sir. We will not set a special order of business, but I don't want to hear that today, and I hope you understand why, and I'm certainly not picking on you.
Speaker 56
30:23
I think you're a good guy, and I want to hear a good debate on the policy. Yes, that
would be fine. Thank you for understanding. Thank you. All right. Let's see. We're going back up to we passed over Representative Womack's bill.
You're ready now? You got everything in order? Good. If you would, go to the end of the
table and you'll be recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. Given the late hour of the day and the fact that we spent quite a bit of time on this bill last week and in between the last time we presented it,
we've individually spent a lot of time discussing this bill and answering questions, I'm going to be very, very brief in my opening statements. I want to start with what this bill does not do. This bill does not do away with licensing, and this bill does not automatically fill the courts with frivolous lawsuits because, as I'm sure all of you have read the bill, there is no provision for damages. What this bill does do is it establishes in the law that a person has the right
to an occupation free from irrational regulation. It expands freedom, creates jobs, limits the heavy hand of government, and helps consumers. All those things that we all campaigned about, this is where we begin. And with that short explanation, I am happy to take questions. Members, any questions? You've heard an explanation
of the bill. We've got a good number of people signed up to speak for and against this. You have a question from Representative Miller.
You're recognized. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Representative Womack. One of the main concerns that I've heard raised a lot about this bill is that this is going to allow non-licensed, say, folks to come in to a property and do electrical work. One example is if we have these new electrical receptacles,
the GFI plug-ins. And in order to be licensed to install those, you know, you have to be trained and receive special licensing and all that kind of stuff. Is this going to just open it up for your average handyman to come in and be able to change one of those out and be covered under
that? No, this bill absolutely does not do away with that occupational license requirement. So, no.
Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Any other questions from committee members? Seeing none, we will move to our list of folks that are signed up to speak for and against. And in lieu of that question, Representative Miller, I think we might call up just slightly out of order Mr. David Stevens might be first to speak. This is against the bill. Mr. Stevens, if you would, introduce yourself and what you do, and you're recognized to give testimony.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. I'm David Stevens, and I'm an Arkansas licensed German electrician. I live in North Faulkner County in the town of Guy, and I'm here to speak against the bill. Specifically, Representative Womack says it does not take away that license occupation. That's correct. It wouldn't take it away. But what it will do is it encourages the handyman, as you say, to go do a licensed occupation job,
which is against current law in the state of Arkansas. It encourages, this law encourages a person to do something that's against current state law. One example would be, you know, similar to what Representative Miller said, If I've got somebody coming in to remodel a bathroom, all right, they're doing the tile, they're doing the sheetrock, so on and so on, well, could you change out those two receptacles while you're doing this? Sure I can.
Well, he's going to change out the GFI receptacle. He hasn't had the proper training and doesn't have the proper knowledge, may or may not. He reverses a polarity on that receptacle or hooks it up wrong. It doesn't protect the consumer, which is who we're supposed to be looking out for. in the end run of this. They're up there doing their hair, curling iron, hairdryer, whatever falls in the sink, and because he didn't have the expertise to know how to hook it up, then that's, you know, it doesn't take that occupational license away,
but it encourages someone other than a licensed trained professional to do that work, which is against current Arkansas state law. I'll go ahead
and say this and ask this. So what you're saying is it kind of takes some of the teeth out of the law, so it
encourages people to break an existing law. It encourages people to break the existing law because currently to do electric work in Arkansas, you have to be trained. You have to go through 576 hours of instruction-related classroom hours
and apprenticeship program and 8,000 hours of on-the-job training. That's current Arkansas law to be an electrician. If you have hours out of state to come in and apply for a state electrical license, you have to show, I believe, 16,000 on-the-job training hours to be a licensed electrician. This law definitely encourages persons that are not licensed to do this occupation to break current state law. Members, any questions? Representative Payton, you're recognized. I
don't know exactly how to word this question.
I may have to follow up a time or two. But what currently prevents somebody who's remodeling the bathroom from doing those receptacles? We have a law in Arkansas
that says to do electrical work, you must be a licensed electrician. And does this
bill change that? No, but it, no, sir. And so where is the language that you see that
encourages somebody to break that law? On page 3, line 36, and on page 4, line 1,
a non-licensed person shall not use the title licensed in performing a lawful occupation for which an occupational license is required. So as long as you don't say that you're licensed, I encourage you to go ahead and do that. If I could follow up. Yes,
sir. To the best of your knowledge, if this law passed, would they still be subject to penalty for doing a job where state law requires that they have a license?
Yes, sir. I believe they would. They could still be fined by an inspector. If they don't have a license and they do electric work without a license, they could be fined by an
inspector. Does this bill in any way lower the fine or the penalty for doing unlicensed work where we have a law that requires a license? I don't believe
it does, but I can't believe it would be good policy to encourage citizens or workers to break another current state law. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, or Mr. Chair.
Again, another promotion. I love it. Seeing no further questions, Mr. Stevens, thank you for your testimony. Thank you. Next person for this bill would be David Mitchell. Mr. Mitchell, if you would introduce yourself and tell us what you do. and you recognize begin and there's there's handouts do you have handouts you would like us to I gave okay wait we're gonna we're gonna get some handouts for you as you as you begin so all right so you're
introduced well my name is David Mitchell I'm a professor of economics and the
co-director of the Arkansas Center for Research and Economics we're an Arkansas focused education and policy center at UCA and so I'm going to only really talk about occupational licensing as a whole and in general. Occupational licensing is an expensive legal requirement that must be met before people have the right to work. And it includes education, it includes experience, it includes testing, all of which are expensive. And we say that Arkansas is a right-to-work state. It's not a right-to-work state. Arkansas has more occupational licensing than any of our neighbors
and any of the other southern states. That's true for both the number of occupations and the amount education and experience that's required to be licensed. It's burdensome in terms of education experience expense. It's expensive to get the right to work in Arkansas. Arkansas requires that 128 different occupations be licensed compared to Missouri, 41, Kansas 56, New York 77. Of these 128 licensed occupations, 52 are lower wage jobs. That means that when we looked at the
average income for each of these positions and we looked at the national average for all across you know the average for all people is these were in the bottom half of the average. And Arkansas licensure for lower wage jobs requires an average of six hundred and eighty-nine days of education and experience. Mississippi requires a hundred and fifty-five days. And our research which is what you have going around so it's our research finds that if Arkansas reduced its low-wage licensing just to the rate of Missouri, we could add, and this is shocking,
8,668 more jobs to the state of Arkansas. That's a lot of jobs. That would reduce our employment from 5.7 percent to 5.1 percent. Further, our research shows that if we reduce occupational licensing to that of Missouri, that African-American poverty rates would fall by 5.3 percent, that these jobs will raise these people and their families out of poverty and 22,773 people will be raised out of poverty. That's exciting stuff.
So passing this bill will empower Arkansans because it will help reduce unnecessary and inappropriate licensing. That's what I'm going to hear to talk about is only the total amount of licensing. Mr. Mitchell, I'm sorry.
No, that's fine. I don't exactly want to interrupt you, but I think Representative Womack, He's talked to me enough. I'm not exactly for this. I'm not exactly against it. I'm probably the most neutral person in here, so I want to ask you this. You think we have so many license procedures because we have so few unions? Because the first three states you named are highly union states.
Maybe they're monitoring themselves, and we as a state are monitoring so we don't have unions. Does that factor into
your numbers? Well, none of the southern states are high union states. Missouri? Well, Missouri is only half southern, maybe. That's one of the first three you mentioned. So I gave you Missouri, Kansas, and New York. So you thought, oh, high union states. But we have more licensing, both in terms of occupations and in terms of total burden, than any of our neighbors or any of the other southern states. So compared to the other southern states, our competitors for jobs, we don't look that good.
that's right. Representative Ritchie, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Now, does this bill reduce occupational license, the amount of occupational license that were required in the state of Arkansas? Because I thought we just heard that it didn't. First of all, I'm not
a lawyer. My impression is that what this bill does is it gives people a redress to say, wait a second, there's no safety issue here.
Let me go to the court and make my case. And in theory, that should get rid of some of the most egregious ones. So I wonder, for example, why it takes so long to become a painting contractor. It takes five years. So if someone could come and say, hey, maybe you don't have to have five years' experience to be a painting contractor. We could reduce that burden. And that would allow more people to work. But that's not in this
bill. So my question is, why are we talking about something that's not in the bill? Oh, okay.
Well, I mean, that's a good question, I guess.
But, but, but to think about occupational licensing as a way of preventing people from getting a job is the important part. The key to remember is that occupational licensing is only occasionally about consumer protection. It's often about the privileged few making sure they don't have to compete with the other people. And it's really, it's an anti-competition bill. I mean, anti-competition, anti-competition rule to have occupational licensing. So if you can't think of a reason why it's a safety issue, then it's probably not.
It's probably a privilege issue. Who gets to make the rules and who has to not have
a job? Representative Fyatt, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Would you agree that Arkansas makes it difficult because of our licensure requirements and all of our regulations, that we make it difficult for a young person to go into business for him or herself? We do make it
difficult for people to get that job, to go into business for themselves. Yeah, we make it hard for young people.
Yes. Representative Payton, I don't know if you had a question. Oh, Representative Miller does. Okay. We saw somebody looking over here. We weren't sure. I don't
have a motion. Let's hear your motion. I would love to make a motion that we limit debate to 10 minutes per
side. We have a motion to limit debate to 10 minutes per side. That includes a closing.
That's not debatable for discussion, so all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed. Mr. Phil Price will be our timekeeper, and we will keep time, and it will be 10 minutes per side. So that includes a closing, so those speaking forward want to make sure that Representative Womack has time to properly close for his bill. Okay, Mr. Mitchell, we see no further questions. If you're done with testimony, do you have a question? I'm sorry.
Speaker 105
44:53
Representative Wardle has a question. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sir,
if you could. Yeah. If you could give me an example of some of these occupations that require a license in
Arkansas but not in Missouri or Oklahoma or Texas. For example, door repairman, door repair contractor in Arkansas has to have five years of education and experience, pass an exam, and pay fees to obtain the license. No other strait is more restrictive.
Most states require no experience or education or don't even require a license to be a door repairman. I mean, that would be a position that a young person
repairmen, I think. All right. Do you want more? Flora Sanders is almost identical situation. So a lot of the construction trades have very difficult and strict requirements on getting your job and being a licensed contractor.
We just require a tremendous amount of burden in terms of education and experience to be a licensed contractor in the state of Arkansas, including for things like painting and floor sanding and door repair. You know, it's not clear to me that that's good for jobs. Representative Ward-Law, you finished.
Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And
try to bring it back around to this bill. So what you're saying or what I think that you're saying is that if this bill passes, that somebody who wanted to be a door repairman
could say that the regulations that we have in Arkansas is egregious and then could potentially take them to court to get those regulations actually thrown out. Is that correct? Well, I'm
follow-up, if I may, Mr. Chairman. Could they do that now? Because right now, if there is a law that we pass that people don't like, they can take it to court and have it ruled unconstitutional, but I don't know. And, again, this may be a question for you or for a
lawyer. I'm going to let the lawyers deal with the legal stuff.
I think that, I mean, you're asking an unlicensed lawyer, so first of all, I don't want to answer any questions about it.
Speaker 17
47:05
But, too. Maybe that's something that Representative Olmack can address. I'll let someone
else answer the questions about the legal stuff, if that makes
sense. I'll answer the question about economics. If somebody has a regulation that they don't like, could they take it to court in much the same manner that they do a law? But I'll let somebody else answer that if we can.
Speaker 126
47:21
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Mitchell. We're
going to call up Mr. Tom Curry, who's against this bill. If you would, introduce yourself for the record, tell us what you do, and you're recognized to begin testimony.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Tom Curry. I'm an attorney in Arkadelphia. I'm a member of the Arkansas Bar Association's Legislation Committee, which has voted to take a position adverse to this bill. We oppose this bill. The bill itself is framed as an anti-regulation matter But it is in fact the professor's right It is in fact an attack on professional and occupational licensing The first problem that I have with the bill is that it's internally inconsistent It starts up with establishing a right to engage in a lawful occupation
Which means if there is a job or something out there Like say for instance selling liquor in a wet county And it's been lawful to do that any person can now do that lawful occupation. It forbids persons entering into an occupation without a license, but then it comes back and says if you try to prosecute someone or you engage in an administrative action to stop someone from engaging in an occupation without a license, that they can raise as a defense the right to engage in this legal occupation.
So now where you have, when you were talking earlier about any handyman doing electrician's work, yeah, what's going to happen is that handyman will start doing electrician work, and if the electrical licensing board wants to stop him, they would have to take him to court, and then he would raise as a defense this right to engage in this lawful occupation. So now we have to get to the standard. The standard, there's two hurdles that would have to be jumped to prevent him from engaging in that practice. One, you would have to show that there is a substantial burden.
Well, first you have to show a compelling state interest. And a compelling state interest is a loaded legal term. When you talk about a compelling state interest, that's the highest burden we're going to be looking for. But it's going to have to be a compelling state interest, not only that, but a compelling state interest to public health or safety. So it would appear that doctors and lawyers would at least probably jump that hurdle. Their licensing requirements would probably be protected in every county in Arkansas as
to that hurdle. Then you get to the second hurdle. You have to show that the regulation is the least restrictive alternative. The statute lists from least restrictive to most restrictive various alternatives. is listed as the most restrictive alternative. What that means is when a state agency, say the electrician's board, wants to stop that handyman from doing electrical work, they're going to have to show that licensing is the least restrictive alternative, which the bill says they cannot do.
It is the most restrictive alternative. The result of that is when you're talking about can someone be fined for doing work for which they're licensed? The answer is no, they cannot be fined. Because when the state electrical board tries to find that handyman, he's going to go into court, and then the electrical board is going to have to show that this is a, goes to a substantial public interest of public health and safety, which they may or may not be able to do. But then they're going to have to show that licensing is the least restrictive alternative, which the statute says they cannot
do. So any fine that's imposed will never be collected. The short answer is if I decide tomorrow and I am A, colorblind and can't tell a positive wire from a negative wire and B, know nothing about electricity, if I decide I want to start doing electrical work, I can do it and there's nothing the electrical board can do to stop me if this bill passes. But it's not just electricians. Attorneys have licenses. If this bill passes, the bill is probably unconstitutional
as it applies to lawyers because of Amendment 28 to the Constitution, which puts the practice of law in the hands of the Supreme Court. But certified public accountants, architects, engineers, contractors, teachers, electricians, plumbers, real estate appraisers, bail bondsmen, barbers, beauticians, insurance agents, adjusters, real estate agents, investment advisors, funeral directors, embalmers, all require licensing. If this bill becomes law, you can do all of those jobs without a license.
I think there's also an interesting question about whether the alcohol beverage control regulations that require licensing to engage in that lawful occupation are enforceable. But at a minimum, ladies and gentlemen, what you're going to have is multiple litigation. And state agencies are going to have to come into court and try to defend their licensing requirements with state money trying to defend these requirements or trying to defend these laws that this legislature has passed in the past.
And money is going to be spent. and every one of these licensing requirements is going to be up for grabs and it's going to require legislation. And this legislature, if this bill passes, gives up the right to regulate professions and occupations. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Mr.
Curry. Members, any questions? Seeing none, we will move to the next person signed up to speak for, which is Paul Abelard.
And if you would, introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized again.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Paul Avalar. I'm an attorney with the Institute for Justice. I'm here today because part of what I do is sue to protect the right to earn an honest living, as you may remember from this morning with the Arkansas hair braiders. I'm testifying mostly about the standards of review question, because last time this bill was debated, there were a number of questions related to that. And I'd like to touch on those.
The bill itself says not compelling state interest. The bill says that an interest has to be important, and public health and safety is certainly important. What the real issue with the bill is, where it really does its work. Oh, I'm sorry. Do you have a point
Speaker 140
53:49
of order, Representative Omey? Point of order, please. Yes, sir. Can I reserve at least one minute for a close? We will throw
our hands up when there's two minutes left. when there's eight minutes used. Yes, sir. Thank you, sir.
Mr. Avalor, go ahead. I'm sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Where this bill really does its work is when it says that the government is tasked with proving that its rules and regulations are the least restrictive means to further the public interest in public health and safety. The way the law works today, and some people have asked, well, can't you go to court today? Yes, you can, but as a practical matter, no, you can't. Today, occupational licensing laws, any laws that affect economic liberty, are subject to what the Supreme Court has called rational basis review.
The joke amongst lawyers like me is that rational basis review requires neither a rationale nor a basis. It is essentially a rubber stamp to do whatever the government wants to do. And while that may seem attractive to some, the problem is that many regulations are not, in fact, written by the legislature. What the legislature does is it passes very broad bills, and then it creates a specialty committee or board to enforce those licensing laws or those other regulations.
Those boards are staffed almost entirely with people who are in the regulated industry. And so the people who are running the boards and making state policy have an economic interest in protecting themselves from competition. The legislature, for example, I doubt very much understood that it was licensing the practice of hair braiding when it created a cosmetology license. And yet, in practice, that is what happened. What this bill does, well, let's talk about what this bill does not do.
It does not affect fiduciaries. It says so right in the bill. And so lawyers are not, in fact, affected by this, nor my understanding is that real estate agents are not affected by this either when they're acting in a fiduciary capacity. It requires an important state interest, but public health and safety is an important state interest. Enriching certain elements of an industry at the cost of others is not an important government interest. And so what this bill does is it requires courts to look at the facts of a situation
and determine whether or not what the rule being applied really does is protect some people as opposed to protect the public and protect consumers. Finally, the least restrictive alternative, to achieve public health. It's not that every licensing law will go away. That's certainly not the case. It is the case, however, that licensing laws and other regulations will have to be shown that they are the thing that is protecting the public and that some other less restrictive means of doing so will not protect the public just as well.
Reforms to occupational licensing laws are really a bipartisan issue. Governors from Texas to Massachusetts have now called for very significant reforms to occupational licensing laws. Professor Alan Kruger, who served as President Obama's first chief economic advisor during his first term, has called for massive reforms. And the most recent proposed budget from the Obama administration includes $15 million for states to analyze the costs and benefits of their licensing rules, because in the words of Betsy Stevenson of the President's Council on Economic Advisors,
quote, we would like all states to ask whether licensing requirements meet a cost-benefit test, unquote. Many licensing laws today do not. I'd note also that licensing laws, as was indicated earlier, tend to fall heaviest on the poor, on women, on immigrants, minorities, people who don't have the sorts of resources that it takes to oftentimes meet and achieve these licenses. And so with that, I'd like to answer any questions that this committee has.
I guess I have a question. is why would you want to target all boards instead of just boards you see as a problem? And I think the hair-braiding bill this morning is a perfect example because you could
have sued and accomplished what you did this morning. We did sue. That's obviously what prompted the case. Again, the ability of a lot of people to sue for what are patently ridiculous laws is very much limited by the current jurisprudence on constitutional issues
as it relates to economic liberty. Maybe the best example is a case that we did out of Louisiana. Louisiana is the only state in the nation that licenses florists. To be a florist in Louisiana, you have to have the approval of the floral board, which consists entirely of other florists. We represented a woman named Sandy Meadows who had been a florist for years but didn't have a license. And the state of Louisiana threatened to shut down her employer unless they fired her because she was not allowed to arrange flowers without the state's permission.
When we sued, the judge said that, well, the licensing florist was perfectly constitutional, notwithstanding that every other state in the union doesn't need to do it, because there could be infected dirt on a flower somewhere and that a license... Excuse me. There's two minutes.
Do you want to let him continue, Representative? Okay. I will
wrap this up. The judge said that there may be infected dirt somewhere and maybe a license could help alleviate that threat to the public, despite the fact that there was no evidence of any infected dirt anywhere and nothing in the licensing exams tested florists on infected dirt.
This is the sort of problem, the sort of hurdle that entrepreneurs and workers have to overcome today under current law. What this bill does is it gives them a stronger voice to fight against rules that aren't really meant to protect the public. Thank you
very much. All right. Thank you, Mr. Avalar. Seeing no further questions, we'll bring up Mr. Jimmy Corley to testify against this bill. If you would introduce yourself and tell
us what you do, and you're recognized to begin.
Jimmy Corley, Executive Director for the State Board of Public Accountancy.
Quickly, Mr. Curry has expressed a lot of our views this afternoon. I'll just add a couple. First of all, I think it's unnecessary. I've been in my position about five years. Any board decision, order, or fine can be appealed by the individual in circuit court. I also think it adds costs due to frivolous lawsuits. I do like the provision in the bill that says no damages are allowed. However, there's a pretty big incentive here.
If a person could gain access to, say, being a CPA without taking a CPA exam, that's a pretty big carrot. And so I think there is incentive for frivolous lawsuits. I have a staff of nine people. No attorneys. We rely on the Attorney General's office for legal assistance. He has approximately 15 other boards. I get about two days a month worth of legal work out of that office. I don't think we'd have any way to defend ourselves in court. Finally, I think there's a better way. I think most of us agree that there are some professions that need regulating,
medical, pharmacy, in my case, I think accounting as well, and some that maybe don't. However, this bill is too broad. I think a better approach would be to a more granular approach where you drill in, maybe a task force, whatever you have, what have you, and find out where the real issues are instead of a broad bill that affects every board in the state. Thank you.
All right. Members, any questions? Seeing none, everyone that has signed up to speak for this has spoken.
We've got about, oh, 30 seconds are left. If anyone else, any of those that are signed up want to speak against this, I will tell you that next in line is Mr. Tom Hunt. If you want to. Well, we won't hold your introduction against you. How's that? Thank you very much. If you could be brief, and we
appreciate that. I will. Thank you very much. My name is Tom Hunt. I'm the executive director of the Arkansas HVACR Association. And tell us what that is. That's the heating, air conditioning, ventilation, and refrigeration industry, sir.
Thank you. I love the idea of people coming into the business. We encourage people to do that. However, if you want a job in the heat and air conditioning business tomorrow, we'll get you one. We're just saying you need to have a couple of years and some experience under your belt before you set yourself up as a contractor. If you want to install a furnace, we'll find you a contractor that will let you install a furnace under their supervision because we don't want your lack of knowledge to create a situation where we can have backdrafting and carbon monoxide poisoning.
I had a lot of these things I wanted to talk to you about, but I'm sure my 30 seconds has expired. I'm saying we've got jobs. We're not keeping people from working. The only thing we're asking is that before a person hangs out a shingle and becomes a contractor, they have sufficient experience to protect the health and safety of the community that we try
to serve. All right, Mr. Hunt, thank you. I'm going to give a little bit of leniency if any of my members, any of the members have questions, saying none. Thank you for your testimony.
The time is up for those against. We've got, what, about two and a half minutes it looks like? Yeah, about two and a half minutes for you to close. Representative Womack. Thank you, Mr.
and I think we all do, Any regulation that is in the public's health and safety, that's the government's job. That's what they're there for. Nobody has an issue with that. But the reality is that we're near the top of the list for anti-employment regulations and rules in the state of Arkansas,
and that's a list that we don't want to be at the top. We want to be at the top of the list for job creation and economic freedom and just freedom in general. This bill absolutely does not undo licensing. You can't find that anywhere. That is not the goal of this bill. The bottom line is this. If you believe that there are instances of overreach and unjustifiable regulation or requirements that put on people or businesses of this state, then you need to vote for this bill, and all that does is give a man or woman his day in court.
So I ask for a good vote, and I have a motion at the proper
time. Well, you are recognized for that motion. I have a motion due pass. All right. We have a motion due pass, members. Do we have any discussion on this motion? I will end a little discussion, then we'll move on to the vote if no one else has. If nothing else, Representative Wollmack, pass or fail, you've brought the attention that I had no idea there's any sort of licensing involved for sanding floors, and I'm wondering if that's commercial residential or whatever.
so if nothing else if this thing passes, fails or whatever I'm guessing that maybe the next bill might just have some sort of almost a task force to look into just what are we regulating and so I appreciate you bringing this. It's been a great debate and it's been very informational. Members, any other discussion? Seeing none, all those in favor? Aye. All those opposed? No. Chair of rules, it knows have it. Roll call. Seeing roll call.
Speaker 150
1:05:33
Call roll, Mr. Price. Representative Love. Representative Love. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Hammer. Representative Hammer. Representative Branscombe. Yes. Representative Meeks.
Unknown speaker
1:06:03
Yes. Representative Overby. No. Representative Ritchie. Yes. Representative McGee. No. Representative Miller. Yes. Representative Womack. Yes. Representative Bragg. No.
Speaker 152
1:06:34
Representative Fite. Yes. Representative Payton. Yes. Representative Lundstrom. No. Representative Bentley. Yes. Representative Boyd. No. Representative Henderson. No. Representative Sullivan. Yes.
yeses, 7 nays to not voting.
This bill is passed. Congratulations. All right, members. It's 4.30. I'm agreed we will adjourn for the day
Agenda
HB1136
HB1158
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Chair
Unverified
Speaker 5
Representative John Payton Chair
Unverified
Representative Mary Bentley
Unverified
Representative Dan Sullivan Chair
Unverified
Representative Deborah Ferguson
Unverified
Representative Richard Womack
Unverified
Speaker 55
Speaker 71
Representative Justin Boyd
Unverified
Speaker 98
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Speaker 56
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
David Mitchell
Unverified
Representative Chris Richey
Unverified
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Speaker 105
Representative Jeff Wardlaw
Unverified
Speaker 124
Speaker 17
Speaker 126
Tom Curry
Unverified
Paul Avalar
Unverified
Speaker 140
Jimmy Corley
Unverified
Tom Hunt
Unverified
Speaker 69
Speaker 150
Speaker 152
Speaker 160
Speaker 162