House Revenue and Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (4)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB320
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB320”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1007
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “With regard to House Bill 1007, DFA is neutral on that bill. With regard to the streamline…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1406
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ank you committee and Mr. Chairman Members are moving on to House Bill 1406. Representative Bentley, are you here? Hey, Representative…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1427
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1427”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Speaker 1
0:06
doing buddy hi good morning mr. chair Wow that's a loud system you look you look it has to be allowed
Speaker 6
0:20
big table yeah you just behave yourself down there we're gonna do good you ready I'm ready go ahead buddy all right members you're looking at 10 07 which reduces income tax by the amount that we would collect off of Internet sales tax in the event that Congress ever does pass the interstate commerce, if you will,
bill that would allow states to collect income tax off of out-of-state vendors that sell into the state via, typically it's via Internet. Right now, and I'll tell some of my history and some of the history of this bill, just make sure there's not too much confusion, but I don't want to take too long, Mr. Chair, So if your committee is up to date on this, I won't bother, but I kind of want to give them. You can have this all day long. Well, I don't want that, so we'll be much more brief than that. Four years ago when I sat on this committee, I got introduced to the Streamline Sales Tax Group,
which is a pack of states that is trying to put together policy and trying to find a clean way to collect sales tax across the states because we're losing a lot of revenue, estimated between $5 and $6 billion between all the states by companies, you know, and Amazon's always the first one that comes to mind. It's not demonizing that group. They're actually very cooperative in this effort. But companies like Amazon that sell maybe out of whatever state, import to Arkansas,
we purchase online, and I'm going to say out of the 20 members here in this room, at least some of you don't realize that there is a form that you need to fill out and mail in your sales tax when you do that and I'm going to say that a lot of our schools and other entities that do a lot of online purchases don't know that and we are missing out on state income tax not to mention as representative Tucker pointed out to me a lot of county and city sales taxes that should be collected on this that our members or people in our state don't realize they should be filling
out this form and mailing it in. It is also difficult on our vendors, our brick-and-mortar businesses in our hometowns that buy the Little League uniforms and sponsor those type of things and take care of their communities. They're selling less and less because they're working against anywhere from a 6-10% discount that online sellers are able to give inadvertently through lack of sales tax collection that online sellers do not collect and yet we make our brick-and-mortar people collect it.
So that issue is not solved in this bill. We can't solve that issue. We, being the state of Arkansas, cannot force a vendor in Illinois to collect our sales tax until Congress passes a bill that's sitting in Chairman Goodlatte's committee right now and has been sitting there about a year. Until they pass a bill that allows us to collect that, we can't do it. So over the years, I've had the opportunity to actually go and lobby different U.S. congressmen from different states,
Utah, Texas, Arkansas, Missouri, on down the line on several trips to D.C. and talk to these people, what's it going to take for you to pass this? And one of their big concerns is they want to be able to tell their constituents, in our case, our own congressmen, whether that's Womack or Westerman or whoever, they want to be able to tell the people of the state of Arkansas that Arkansas is going to be responsible with that money. They don't want to just allow us to collect the sales tax and it grow government, so to speak.
And so they want to know that we're going to be responsible. So many states are doing exactly what we're doing. We're showing Congress. We're sending them a message. We're saying we're going to be responsible with this money. As a matter of fact, we've already got a plan, and in this case our plan would be to cut income tax, which goes along with our governor's plan and I think the plan of many in this committee that we think that income tax is a burden that we'd like to reduce the most when we have that opportunity. So this would trigger, if the sales taxes are able to be collected
on interstate sales, this would trigger a reduction of income taxes in a bracket after it pays for the remaining food sales taxes that still need to be reduced and after the money comes off the top for our schools and all the normal procedures of income tax collection. So that's the gist of what this bill does. When we get into the very mechanics of it, those of you that are better at mechanics than I am, I'm sure that folks from Department of Finance and Administration, see I did not use an acronym,
will be able to come over and sit down and explain that. So that's my explanation of the bill, if you will, and the history
of it, Mr. Chairman. Representative Lincoln, have you done any, I don't know if you can even do this, but have you done any type of research to see how many people is not paying versus how many people is
Speaker 6
5:16
paying and the costs associated with that? If we were to do that research, Mr. Chairman, we would need to put them in jail because
it's illegal not to pay your taxes. I understand. What about, say, like you capture $100 million one year and you turn around and you're going to capture, say, $40 million, $60 million the following year,
is the tax bracket, is it going to fluctuate, or how do
Speaker 6
5:36
you perceive that? Because it's going to be very difficult to measure beyond the first year. We won't be precise in the measurement of new income off of Internet sales tax even the first year, but after the first year, it would be even more diluted. The reason being is we don't exactly just ask somebody when they file to collect sales tax with the state of Arkansas, are you only going to do online sales into the state from another state? And we don't ask them, do you have a nexus here or don't have a nexus here?
Have you been collecting tax? Have you not been collecting tax? There are sellers out there in other states right now voluntarily collecting the sales tax and mailing them to the state. And I know that Tom actually works on this and knows much more about it than I do, could give you a number of the amount of income tax we're already sales tax I'm sorry we're already collecting from vendors that are voluntarily doing it so that back back to answer your question more directly mr. chairman we would only measure the first year and use that amount so if we capture an
example a hundred million dollars and then after we reduce the seven seventy million dollars estimated for this food sales tax and we take the money off the top for the schools we would reduce about thirty million dollars from the income tax, and that is the $30 million that would be reduced from then on. It would be virtually impossible to measure after that how much is just online sales tax collection. Members, before we
start asking questions, I want to have DFA, I'm going to use DFA, come to the end of the table because there is
one thing that we need to kind of clear up going forward. John, if you don't care, recognize yourself, and then clue the members in on the committee
on the discussion that we had a while ago, please. Mr. Chair, members of the committee, my name is John Tice. I'm with the Department of Finance and Administration. The bill that you have before you would capture revenues from the streamlined sales tax taxpayers if Congress ever extends that authority to the states.
The current projections out of the ones DFA rely on the most regularly are from the University of Tennessee. They seem to be the most reasonable, and they estimate that Arkansas could collect somewhere in the neighborhood of just over $100 million in additional revenue. Representative Link did mention that we currently have taxpayers who are voluntarily collecting. At this moment, we have about 2,300 taxpayers who are regularly collecting and remitting tax on a voluntary basis to DFA.
That's because the state of Arkansas adopted those streamlined elements from the streamlined group trying to simplify our state laws. Those 2,300 volunteers currently pay about $10 million a year in state income tax. and Representative Jett you want me to address something specific and I've Yes please the Terry
Smith bill from several years ago Approximately 20
years ago a senator from Hot Springs named Terry Smith
introduced a bill at that time that would use the revenues from the streamlined sales tax if Congress ever extended that authority his bill said that if we collect 150% more than the sales tax on food, then the sales tax on food would go away. This bill covers some of that same territory by reserving approximately $70 million to state general revenue, which approximates the amount of sales tax currently collected by food.
So we have another bill covering basically the same territory. The question was raised, do the two bills conflict? And at this point, it's impossible to know whether they conflict. My initial reaction is most likely that they do not, that this bill will take effect and we'll be able to implement it in view of the Terry Smith bill, although it would be easy to repeal the Terry Smith bill
and allow this bill to cover that
same territory. Thank you. Representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And Representative Link is one of your cohorts during that whole debate back then and whatnot. I definitely appreciate you bringing this forward here. The question that I have is the $70 million is based upon the grocery tax from your testimony. And my understanding is the sale on food, that tax that remains, that's within the Constitution. Is that correct or no?
Thanks. A portion of it, of the current collections, are in the Constitution. A portion of it is in state code. The provisions of the Arkansas Constitution say that those constitutional levies will apply as long as the state tax applies. So there has been some confusion among commenters on that issue, whether if the legislature repeals all of the state sales tax on food, do the constitutional levies remain?
It is my opinion and I think the opinion of DFA that under the Constitution, those constitutional levies cannot be collected if the state sales tax is repealed. Okay, and that was going to be my question is how you were going to
apply the $70 million in this statute if you had a constitutional amendment that said that you had to collect the taxes. But I think that sounds like that issue will resolve itself. All right, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I have a motion at the proper time. Representative Leibniz. Yes, Representative Leibniz.
I have a question. I hope I can frame this to where you can understand my question here. But it has to do with local cities and counties. The sales tax is made up of a state, county, and city tax. So does this affect the whole sales tax, or do the cities and the counties get their portion of that? City can get up to 2%. County can get up to, I think, 1.5%. I mean, does that money go back to them? Because these sales, even though they're made over the Internet, those people live locally.
They use local police, fire streets, and so forth, and the local entity needs their money from that. Some years ago, Representative Leigh, I mean, some
Speaker 6
12:14
years ago, and I can't tell you exactly how many, I believe just six or so, we put in line the streamlined sales tax agreement in Arkansas, and we were one of the first states to do this, where we charge at the destination of the product. So even if you have a delivery company, we'll use a Lowe's who delivers a refrigerator outside the city limits. They don't collect the city sales tax. They collect the sales tax at wherever that refrigerator is delivered to.
And that was set up so that we could put in place, so Congress could put in place this very same thing. So if a widget is delivered from Indiana that someone ordered off of the Internet to a person who sits inside the city limits of Jonesboro, all the taxes would be collected from that person in Indiana exactly to that doorstep in Jonesboro and all the sales taxes would be due to that doorstep in Jonesboro. So your bill would
not change that? the city county would still get their portion. City
Speaker 6
13:09
county would get exactly as if that person bought that product right down the street yes. Okay. Thank
you. Representative Dotson you recognize sir. Thank you Mr. Chair. I apologize. I'm a little late if this question has already been asked but on your bill here it looks as if this goes into the 4.5% income tax bracket only specifically is that correct? That's right. Is there a reason why we picked that and not evenly across the entire... We picked
Speaker 6
13:39
evenly across the entire specter. I did first and then I found out how ignorant I am and Mr. Tice can attest to that and tell
you're smart enough to figure that out though. The issue that Representative Link ran into was how to reasonably apportion that amount of savings, that tax savings, across all income ranges.
And he originally, in the bill that's originally introduced, said to do it equally. Well, it was difficult to determine what equal meant. Did equal meant an equal dollar amount? Did it mean an equal percentage? And you could come up with two or three other ways of splitting that money. Ultimately, what Representative Link decided was the easiest way to apply it and provide broad-range benefits was to just pick a single tax rate and say we're going to reduce that tax rate from 4.5% down to maybe 4.2% or 4.1% or something like that.
That way it does get applied equally to everyone paying that particular bracket. and it avoided a whole host of questions and possible uncertainty by doing it that way. Thank you, Mr. Chaston. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Tucker? Yes,
Speaker 41
15:09
sir. Following up on Representative Dotson's questions, do you know, just say, for example, we collect $100 million, the first $70 is reserved, as you mentioned, and then we collect $30 more. Do you know how much that would reduce the rate of tax for that 4.5% bracket?
I've not made an effort to calculate that. Sorry. And so, follow, Mr. Chair? Can you just explain, I understand what would happen in year one of the bill, but I guess I'm just not exactly clear on what would happen in year two moving
Speaker 6
15:40
forward. Can you just help me understand? Moving forward, that bracket would not change ever again. It would be, you know, unless another body comes in and changes it for some reason another way. But with this bill, it only reduces it by whatever percentage that is. one time. So if it goes from 4.5
to 4.2, it'll stay at 4.2 moving forward. And what that does, it allows a natural growth of revenue into Arkansas. We don't continually reduce it by that amount. We're not trying to set aside the internet sales tax amount over and over and over. We're just recognizing that as a new income to Arkansas. It's a new income that should be collected now. Our members should, our state citizens should be paying it now but it's by all means I guess you could say a new income so we reduce it
by that amount and then and then from then on let's say that we collect a hundred and fifty million even though we wouldn't know it because from that after that first year these are simply going to be vendors we don't recognize them as out-of-state vendors we don't recognize them internet vendors they're just vendors to the state of Arkansas from then on just as if it's the hardware store down the street they're just a vendor so we don't try to separate out their payments and the amount of money they're collecting any longer. So we just move forward and let the coffers of the state grow at that natural rate from then on. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
You're welcome. Representative Speaks. Didn't you say this is not legal right now unless the federal government passes this? If the
Speaker 6
17:15
federal government does not pass, we cannot demand someone in Indiana collects sales tax for the state of Arkansas. That's your responsibility as a taxpayer in the state to remit that yourself. People are not doing that. That's why we're missing approximately $100 million a year from the state revenues.
What's the cost of this? In looking at this, it looks like it's going to be quite a cost to the F&A to get
it all in order to go. Representative Speaks, the cost should be minimal to DFA because over the last several years, last 10 or 12 years, we've been working with the streamline organization to try to implement this federal law and be ready to implement it when Congress does act. As part of those efforts that the states have worked together, we've devised some processes
that are already in place to collect. And as I said, we are, in fact, already collecting from 2,300 companies that voluntarily came in and said, we don't care whether Congress requires us to pay the Arkansas tax or not. We're going to come in and voluntarily collect the tax. And we're collecting about $10 million from those volunteers. So if we now get those folks that are mandated, then we will just add those to that list of volunteers. One of the things we have in place currently is on the DFA website, you can go in,
and if a seller is in Indiana and they're selling to a customer in Arkansas, the Indiana seller can go to the DFA website, type in the address of the customer, and the DFA website will say, here's the state tax rate that's due, here's the city tax rate that's due, and here is the county tax rate that was due. For example, I grew up two miles outside the city limits of the town of DeWitt in Arkansas County. I've gone in, typed in my home address, and the website is good enough.
It noticed that the home I grew up in owed Arkansas County local tax but did not owe the DeWitt city tax. We've done that over and over, and it has a very high rate of accuracy. Representative Davis.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Lincoln, I understand, right, so if Congress were to allow us to do this, and this was in place, the actual rate of reduction at the 4.5% bracket would be determined by DFNA,
not by this body. It would be determined by
Speaker 6
19:48
this body right now, because we will set that rate depending on how much money is collected. That's what this will do. Okay. But we can't determine that until we know how much money is going to come in. Heck, we don't know. It might be $200 million. There may be people doing way more purchases on the internet than we suspect. It may be $70 million. We've got to take a guess at something, and $100 million is as close a guess as we can get. I understand.
Good follow-up question, Mr. Chairman. I understand that, you know, there's just a lot of things we don't know.
We don't know how much revenue it's going to generate. We don't know, you know, what the offset would be. I'm curious if you considered, like, a floor at the 4.5% rate, you know, down to four and then anything any additional revenue if there were if there was more revenue that would go you know beyond a cut down to four would would be applied to a different bracket would that be too
Speaker 6
20:42
complicated you know I don't suspect and maybe I exaggerated because I did exaggerate but I don't
suspect that would ever be that much more money the highest models we see say around 130 130 to 150 million the lower models are a little less than hundred million and so the state uses as we know DFNA to do and they've been in this business and doing this a long time, they use that $100 million model. Okay, so they have modeled it. It's not going to be anything absolutely crazy, I can't imagine, unless every model out there is off, and there's a lot of people trying to figure this out. There's a lot of money missing out there that we're not collecting in sales tax, and most
of us agree in this room probably that sales tax is the most fair tax we have, and yet we're avoiding it by not collecting it on all vendors, and so we hope that Congress will take this message from us and take it from the 28 or 30 other states that's doing similar legislation to this this year and have already done some and realize that states need this money, we have a plan for this money, and they need to go ahead and take action and put this in place for us. Very good, thank you. Representative Hodges.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Why was the $70 million amount selected? Talking about the food sales
Speaker 6
21:56
tax, right? Yes. The history of that, and Mr. Dice has kind of mentioned the history of that, that's a 20-year-old bill, and that's the best projections I guess we have on what that would
cost would be $70 million. Actually, the $70 million is approximately the current amount that is collected on sales tax on food.
So the $70 million would repay the sales tax for the sales tax on food that's currently being collected. Thank you. Representative Lederman, you got another question? sir? Okay.
Members, are there any other questions? Representative Speaks. So I take it DF&A is pushing this. No, I brought this bill
Speaker 6
22:44
myself. I know you did, but I mean I've not been pushed by these guys. First time I've stood here and talked to them was
10 minutes before this meeting. But I mean, you are behind
this is what I mean, for this being passed at this time. Representative Speaks.
With regard to House Bill 1007, DFA is neutral on that bill. With regard to the streamlined sales tax and the efforts to get Congress to pass that authorizing legislation, DFA is firmly behind that and has been working on it literally for 25 years. Ms. Danvall, you recognize. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
If I understand this correct, this will not take place unless Congress is, am I correct? That's correct. Congress taking action
Speaker 6
23:29
is the trigger to this bill doing something. And that's why this bill was written
is to push Congress to actually do something. It's to give them, if you
Speaker 6
23:36
want to use the word cover, it's to give them cover our congressmen so that they know what we're going to do with this money. Thank you
Mr. Chair. Politician needing cover that's kind of a
new concept. Yeah. Yes sir Mr. Latham. Thank you Mr. Chair. I think
in my opinion one of the groups that's pushing this is local businesses because they're not competitive with internet companies. So that's my opinion of that. But I guess my question is how did you arrive that this was the best use for this money? In other words, to give it back as an income tax? I agree with that. But did you look at other options? You know, a lot of cities and counties have trouble with their roads and their streets. You know, that money could be used for that or even the highway transportation did you look at other ways to use the money and then why
Speaker 6
24:27
did you settle on this particular one so I believe that sales tax is the most fair tax that we collect I believe income tax is the least fair tax that we collect so if we can increase one
and decrease the other I think we've done a good thing thank you you bet anybody honest want to speak against the bill for the bill represent like
Speaker 6
24:52
you close for your bill sir I just want to say this is probably the most thorough vetting of any bill I've been in so congratulations to this committee and I think that obviously I think this is
right thing to do I've worked pretty hard on not just this bill but on this issue for the last four years and and I hope to continue working on it and I hope that you know somebody in this room will see the importance of this to the economy of the state not just our income tax coffers our sales tax coffers but as Representative Ladyman mentioned to the businesses that's in our communities that are buying Little League uniforms, that are supporting their Rotary clubs, they're supporting their Lions clubs and doing all those things we need them to be on a level playing field they're not asking us not to buy things
on the internet, I mean we understand open commerce but it's unfair that we're giving people on the internet an 8 to 10% discount over our hometown vendors and I hope that Congress will take action soon and I hope that this will help them We will send that message to them that we're going to be responsible with that money We really need to do that to protect our hometown brick-and-mortar businesses So with that I certainly appreciate a good vote and I appreciate all the questions Thank you Representative Link. Representative
Meeks, you're recognized for your motion sir Motion to pass. Members, motion to do pass by Representative Meeks. All in favor say aye
Aye. Any opposed, no The ayes have it. Congratulations Representative Link. You passed your bill sir Thank you committee and Mr. Chairman Members are moving on to House Bill 1406. Representative Bentley, are you here? Hey, Representative Link, can you please see if Representative Bentley is in the hallway and tell her we're ready to run her bill? Bentley, please. Thank you, sir.
All right, thank you very much. Representative Gene, would you care to run Senate Bill 320? Members, without objection, we're going to take a bill out of order. This, I don't think it's going to take very long. Representative Gene is going to run Senator Malik's bill. So it would be House bill, I mean, I'm sorry, Senate Bill 320.
Representative Gene, you recognize her when you want
to start. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. I'm running for Senator Malek. This is Senate Bill 320, and what it does is require the Department of Finance Administration to annually report the activities of the Multistate Tax Commission to eliminate their meeting. I think they have a meeting one time a year, like 3 o'clock in the afternoon, and there's no activity other than they are handed a report and they don't vote on anything.
They don't do any business. So all this bill does is make it where they'll get the report by email or mail and they won't have to have a meeting that they have nothing to vote on or do. They just receive the report from DF&A. And if I can, very simple bill, that's all it does. If I can entertain any questions, I will or I'll bring John Types up here because I think he attends those meetings. Well, that is correct. I'll
tell the members I actually serve on that, and everything he just said is actually you show up,
get a handed report, and we leave. Okay. If there's no questions, I'd appreciate
a good vote. Motion at the proper time. Members, any questions? Anybody from
the audience speak against the bill or for the bill? Representative Lederman, you recognize for your motion, sir. Make a motion and pass. Members have a motion and do pass by Representative Lederman, say all in favor say aye any opposed no I just have it congratulations you passed your bill
morning mr. represent Bentley you we're good to go on your bill please recognize yourself and you're good to get
started Representative Mary Bentley, and I apologize about that. I promised a colleague I'd run across the hall and make a vote real quick. So, sorry about the inconvenience on that. I'm putting forth a bill this
morning. Hold on a second. I'm sorry. Members, we have an amendment with this. We're going to take care of the amendment first. Correct. Yeah. The amendments are on your tablets.
Sorry about that. No, that's fine. This amendment really clarifies this bill is a cleanup bill. And if it's okay with you guys, I'd like to bring Kevin Newhouse here from the Secretary of State. I'm running this bill for the Secretary of State's office, and we'll
acknowledge him at this time if that's okay. Kevin, please take a seat and recognize yourself with
Speaker 101
29:50
the committee for the record. I'm Kevin Newhouse from the Secretary of State's office. Thank you. Go ahead. Are we ready?
Okay, so the amendment we have this morning clarifies a little bit of the language on here. we want the Secretary of State's office to be able to dispute concerning interest or penalties associated with corporate franchise tax. So if there's fees or penalties that have applied because of past due taxes they want to be able to work with the individual that's owing these taxes to maybe reduce them or change them to help this company be able to dissolve. Mostly it's companies that have dissolved and they want to get them off the books. So that's what this amendment
talks, but just kind of clears up line 26. They're just saying that they want to compromise dispute concerning interest or penalties associated with a franchise tax. And then the second part of the amendment is on page 2, deleting section E on there. Lines 9 through 12. And that would be the amendment. Anybody have questions on the amendment? Representative Deves,
you're recognized for your question, sir. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. How are they handling disputes currently.
Speaker 101
30:57
Want to add us to that, Kevin? Right now we can't negotiate fees and interest that are owed by corporations, many of whom have kind of gone into revoke status or no longer in good standing. So right now we don't have any authority to negotiate some of that stuff. You know, when you have if I could just say just a little bit
as a business owner at the end of the year as a private business
I'm able to wipe that company off of my list if I need to. If they've gone out of business they're no longer in I can just wipe that company out of my records. I don't have to keep up with it year after year. I can just make a copy of it and keep it a file. But they have not been able to do that so at the present time I think they have 16,000 companies. It's a lot of time and effort that we're paying as taxpayers to have that keep up with those 16,000 companies that no longer exist. So we're trying to help the Secretary of State's office get rid of these companies resolve it so we can get them off the books and not have to waste the time keeping up with these companies that no longer exist.
You have a question, Representative Hodges? You're recognized, sir.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. How does that work? Do they currently send them into a collection agency or all the judgment or how is that done currently when they owe
Speaker 101
32:15
those taxes? I mean, there is no collection agency. You know, we just try to, the 16,000, she referenced with 16,000 companies that are, have been revoked three years or longer. And so a lot of these companies, part of the reason they go out of business is they don't have the money to pay some of this stuff.
And so they just stay on our books is, you know, revoked. And, you know, there's not a lot we can do as far as helping them out or reaching out to them. So they just kind of stay on the books. And if I could answer that, too, Representative Hodges, I've used collection agencies
before, but once these companies have gone out, there's not a whole lot you can do. You're just wasting more money. You're throwing good money after bad money. There's no money there. There's no money there. And so it just is a waste of a lot of taxpayers' money
trying to keep going after and keeping these on
the books. Representative Meeks, you recognize her? Yes, Mr. Chairman. And I wanted to move adoption of the amendment so
that way we can discuss the main bill. Members, any discussion on that? So that's all in favor of the move of adoption. Say aye. Any opposed, no? Okay, we move on to the bill. Let's show it is adopted.
Thank you, community. I appreciate that. So as we said, we have the Secretary of State's office has been unable to negotiate fees or penalties related to corporate taxes. So as a company goes out, they're no longer in business. We've tied up individuals. We've tied up business names because we cannot get rid of these fees or negotiate with them, trying to bring them down to a point where they can pay them off and get rid of this company off the books. So year after year, they keep adding up, and there's no way for them to clean up their books. So we're wasting taxpayer dollars on their employees who have to keep up with these companies that have gone out of business, the whole idea behind this bill.
So I take any questions you guys
might have regarding that. Representative Meeks, you recognize her. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I like what you're doing here. The question I have is, based upon what you're doing now and what this bill would allow you to do, do you have any idea of how much savings it would be to the Secretary of State's office in manpower? and perhaps how much would you be able to collect that you're not able to collect by having this negotiation power?
I'm sorry, we haven't crunched those numbers. Okay. President Flowers, you recognize, ma'am? Thank you. Do you have any idea how much in penalties and fees are outstanding at this
Speaker 101
35:08
time? It really kind of depends on a company-by-company basis.
I mean, some of these, you know, they only collect past income taxes back to three previous years. it's hard for me to kind of come up with a number of how much is outstanding total. Any given company that's in revoke status, no matter how long they've been that way, they only have three years of past franchise taxes due.
And it's the penalties and interest on top of that is what we're looking to negotiate. Did that
answer your question, Representative Flowers? No, but I don't think he has the information, so I just left it. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. You bet. Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized, sir.
Speaker 119
36:07
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Will this allow the Secretary of State's office to automatically remove those 16,000 businesses off the books,
or will those businesses still have to come to you and ask to work something out? they would still need to
Speaker 101
36:21
come ask to be removed from the books but this would make things a lot simpler yeah this just will give them the ability to
go come to my company to work this out right now they do not have the ability to do
it at all you good represent Gonzalez you had a quiz look on your face there so
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Most
of these are the kind of scenario that you're describing. I just want to make sure that for what I'm going to call serial company creators who either because they're dodging something or because of other reasons are creating dozens and dozens of LLCs, one of the things that we have in the current is there comes a point when they go to create something new where there's so much of a backlog of the mess they've
created in the past that they get stopped. I just want to make sure I understand how that type of a scenario would unfold. Somebody for example that's formed 10 LLCs in the last five years all of those are no longer active, the person claims but they haven't paid any of the fees and they want to create a new LLC for some new venture. How would that type
Speaker 101
37:44
of a person be handled? The law prevents somebody from creating a new company when they're a part of a previous company that's in bad standing.
So if they are linked in any way or as an officer or whatever to a company that's in revoked status, they are not able to go in and create a new company. Excellent. Thank you very much. I think that's part of the reason Representative Collins
did this bill, because individuals wanted to move forward with their life, maybe start a new business, and because their name was linked to another company that owed fees or fines, they were not able to
do so. Representative Kim Hendren, you're recognized, sir.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I almost feel like the one that Collins just talked about here. I've done a few of these. But isn't the only lever you have now, basically, I think, to what he was talking about, If you've got two or three of these corporations or LLCs that are sitting out there and you haven't taken care of the franchise's taxes every year and you come to develop another one, then you've got a problem. And then you either pay the fines, and some of them I think I've heard them, $2,000 or $3,000 in fines and fees to get back in good standing.
Not me, Charlie, but somebody I know. But to get back in good standing. But to follow up on his question, say that somebody doesn't, And that's what you're after. You're somebody that has left the state or was never in the state that has four or five of these and never plans to do anything about it. Are you planning now just to be able to wipe those off? Or how do you just settle that by negotiation? Or what does this do, give you a free hand to do whatever
Speaker 101
39:27
you need to do to do that? It would be settled by negotiation. I mean, I don't know that we'd necessarily look at wiping everybody off the books
because you do have some of those problem children who just continually start a new business and you'd be kind of allowing them to continue practicing that type of business. This would be more of a negotiation for, you know, really to try to help out some of the others. One clears a lot of it off the books, but help out some of the others who, you know, have good intentions and you know aren't kind of your you know the problem children so to speak
is it not probably true that if you did wipe those off the books a person had several of those but even if that individual came back later even you wiped them off the books would there still be some accountability for that person if they wanted to start over yes thank
you thank you mr chairman you bet representative
speaks you recognize ma'am how many years before you will wipe them off your books, you know, are you going to hold them on the books? I didn't see that in this law.
Speaker 101
40:41
I don't know that there's a timetable, because we're still going to require these people to come in and, you know, dissolve themselves. So I think a lot, part of the reason a lot of these companies haven't come in to dissolve is, you know, because they don't want to pay these fees and they leave everything off the books or they leave it on the books. For us, this would be for people who come in who would like to dissolve their company
and, you know, look to have a little bit of a break on wiping it, wiping their company off the books so they can either start anew or just kind of be in good standing overall. But the people who never come in and try to dissolve, I don't know that we can necessarily wipe them off the books completely. Representative Dostoy, you recognize her?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think Representative Spieth got to part of my question. So if I understand this correctly, this would not automatically set up any type of a time frame that you would look back and start clearing these off. This would be company or taxpayer initiated. So they come and they start to ask to be cleared off the books. And this just allows you the mechanism to negotiate and do that. Correct. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You bet.
Representative Flowers, do you have another question, ma'am?
Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm just still, I guess, unclear about what can be done now and what can't be done. And when you say that you can't do anything now, are you legally prohibited from negotiating? Yes, there's no way they can negotiate penalties and fees at this point at all. And so, Mr. Chair, can I? When I look at this and it says the stricken language,
a corporation may seek relief from any proposed assessment of taxes pursuant to the Arkansas Administrative Procedures Act, and then later down below it says this method shall be the exclusive method for seeking relief. What does that mean? It sounds like there's something, some sort of procedure that's in place now. In section one?
again? I'm sorry. Well, so this sounds like you're seeking this measure because your hands are tied and you're, Representative Bentley said you're legally prohibited, right? Correct. So if you're legally prohibited, and when I'm reading this language that's stricken, right under Section 1, a corporation may seek relief from any proposed assessment of taxes pursuant to the Arkansas Administrative Procedures Act, and then down below, this method shall be the exclusive method for seeking relief.
It just sounds like this would be in place of something else, maybe. And I just want to be clear before I vote for anything that might put in place a whole structure to wipe off and to negotiate and whatever, to be clear about what it is we're replacing. And that's what I'm not clear about. All I'm hearing is you can't do it. And I ask this question that you're legally prohibited, but I don't see, you know what I mean? I'm just trying to be clear about what's in place now.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We have Belinda Harris-Ritter here. Is it okay if she comes? A lawyer from the AG's
office can answer this question for us. Thank you.
record. Belinda Harris-Ritter, Assistant Attorney General. Okay. Can
Speaker 141
44:52
you take care of Representative Flowers' question? I hope I can. Thank you. In the part that you're looking at, Representative Flowers, where it says, a corporation may seek relief from any proposed assessment of taxes pursuant to the Arkansas
Administrative Procedures Act that can go through the Administrative Procedures Act procedures related to the taxes, but the taxes that are levied and the fees and penalties that are assessed are going to stay the same or they're not going to be anything. There's not going to be a negotiation. If they win, most likely that will do away with the taxes, which would do away with the fees and penalties. This would give them the opportunity at the Secretary of State's office to negotiate on not the taxes, but the fees and the penalties. Does that help?
Yes. Can I? Just to be clear. So for all of those businesses that are in arrears with fees and penalties, this would just be a way to give relief on the fees and penalties, but not necessarily wipe out any taxes that are in arrears. Right. It's my understanding it
Speaker 141
45:59
would not wipe out the taxes. This addresses the fees and the penalties. And it's a shorter process. It doesn't have to go through the APA procedure for the whole thing.
They can just negotiate it. And so that's the procedure right now, is the fees and penalties have to move along with the current procedures along with the taxes. Yes.
Okay. Thank you. So what I'm understanding, ma'am, is really this bill gives the AG office no heartburn. Is that correct? That's correct. Okay, thank you.
Representative Vaught, you recognize, ma'am. Thank you, Mr. Chair. How many of the 16,000 businesses have come to you wanting to negotiate?
I mean, is there several that's already come to you wanting to negotiate? Not many, no. Okay. Okay, and can I have a follow-up? You bet. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You bet. The other thing is, do you send out a letter that's requesting them to settle up with you, and if so, is there
Speaker 101
47:08
a penalty when they don't respond to that letter? There is no penalty. There have been, they have tried to reach out to several of these companies to get them to settle up,
but a lot of times their contact information isn't correct. So that's kind of part of our... Can I,
this bill do much good? If you don't have very many of the 16,000 already coming to you wanting to settle up, then how will this bill really help you? If you're not reaching out to them or already have contact information, How will this bill essentially help?
Speaker 101
47:51
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We do have a decent amount of the contact information, and so we would reach out to each of these companies to give them the opportunity to come in. We do have some people who have, you know, discussed with us, you know, negotiating the fees which we haven't been able to help them out with at this point but there's
a good chunk of the $16,000 that we will be able to reach at some point or through this process or if we're able to do this and hopefully they will come forward and we'll be able to help them out. Representative
Chair. Speaking with someone who has paid this fee and who has come to you and asked to have it waived, so I've got some experience doing this, how would this, we've talked about how this affects businesses that have closed, are gone, that they're not there anymore, the number you gave, but my question is, how would this affect new entrepreneurs?
And the reason I ask that question is, you know, I started a small business with my son, and we didn't realize through our own ignorance that we had to pay this franchise fee. So we got a letter saying that we had fees because we were late. We didn't know we were late because we didn't know we owed it. We didn't get notification until the fees were assessed. And when I called your office or Secretary of State's office and talked to them, they said they could not negotiate that fee. So in my opinion, this law addresses that particular problem. Is that true? Yes, exactly.
It does on page two. Okay. So that would help people other than those 16,000. This would help new entrepreneurs, and I think that's a
good thing. Thank you. You bet. Representative
Collins, you recognize her. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And this is really just a point of clarification, which I think is just a yes, and then after that I'd have a motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. We're using the words a little interchangeably, but one word is the tax. A second word is fees, as in late fees or other fees assessed in addition to the tax.
And a third word is interest, which may have to do with interest on the taxes or interest on the fees. Those are three very distinct buckets. When it comes to taxes, the franchise tax itself, there remains zero room for negotiation. with regard to late or other fees and with regard to interest, there would be newly created room for negotiation. So zero negotiation on the taxes. You must pay your full tax.
But negotiation on the other two elements is what this bill does. Is that correct? Yes. Motion at the proper time, Mr. Chair. You
bet. Thank you very much for clearing that up. You have a question? Okay. Anybody, any other members have a question? Anybody not speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Bentley, are you closed for your bill, ma'am? Yes, sir. Representative Collins, you're recognized to make your motion, sir. I move do pass. Motion do pass as amended.
Excuse me, do pass as amended. Members, motion by Representative Collins do pass as amended. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no. Congratulations, ma'am, you passed your bill. Thank you, Chairman of Committee. I appreciate your time. Remember, sit tight just for a second. We're going to run one more bill. I promise you it'll take less than five seconds to run this bill.
DFA, just changing some dates around. Mr. Chairman, I'll make a motion at the proper time, please. And I'm closing my bill. Any questions for the chairman?
They want to look and see what the bill is first, Mr. Chairman. 1427. You can't blame
me for trying, though, could you? Thank you. Representative Lane, Jr., you have a question for me, sir?
mills in this one, I promise you all. Motion at the proper time. Representative Meeker, recognize. This might get me in trouble with the chairman, but this is probably a good question for Mr. Tice. I noticed in the language that we're striking January 2011 and updating it to January 2015. So we're basically updating the code to come in compliance.
Is that pretty much what we're doing here? Representative Meeks, that's correct. Under the Arkansas Constitution, we are not allowed to adopt provisions of the Internal Revenue Code as they exist today or may be subsequently amended. We can only adopt those provisions as they exist today. The provisions that are being updated by this bill all expired at the end of 2013, and Arkansas adopted those with that expiration date. At the end of December 2014, the U.S. Congress came back in
and reenacted all of those provisions effective for 2014. So what this bill does is say those provisions Arkansas had previously adopted that subsequently expired and that for Arkansas purposes have expired, we're reenacting those for the tax year 2014 so that taxpayers don't end up getting whipsawed and have one set of rules for federal purposes and a separate set of rules for state purposes. It continues those rules seamlessly. Okay. So right now we have
a difference of rules between us and the IRS creating more confusion in an already confused tax code.
reason to pass the bill then. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Dodson. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I noticed in the bill there's a few sections that say 2011. Was there a reason why we didn't update this two
years ago to say 2013? The expiration date at that time was out into the future. It was going to be 2013 or 2014 expiration date, so there was no need to update those 2011 provisions at that time.
They were still effective last time this General Assembly met. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Any other questions? Anyone in the audience want to speak for or against the bill? Is there a motion? Representative Meek makes a motion to do pass. All in favor say aye. All opposed? Pass your bill, Mr. Chairman. Thank you very much. What's that? Oh, I get to sign it again, huh?
I just signed that deal in cursing. Members, without objection, this meeting is adjourned.
Agenda
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Joe Jett Chair
Unverified
Speaker 1
Speaker 6
John Tice
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
Representative Jim Dotson
Unverified
Speaker 33
Speaker 41
Representative Nelda Speaks
Unverified
Representative Andy Davis
Unverified
Representative Monte Hodges
Unverified
Representative DeAnn Vaught Chair
Unverified
Representative Mary Bentley
Unverified
Speaker 101
Representative Les Eaves
Unverified
Representative Vivian Flowers Chair
Unverified
Speaker 119
Representative Charlie Collins
Unverified
Representative Kim Hendren Chair
Unverified
Speaker 141
Speaker 151
Speaker 162
Speaker 42
Speaker 164
Speaker 87