Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House State Agencies & Govt'l Affairs Commitee

March 9, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (10)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1669 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Members, we're going to hear House Bill 1669 by Representative Womack. He has an amendment that he would…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1016 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HJR1016”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1027 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HJR1027”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1024 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HR1024”
Pre-2017 bill
SB365 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB365”
Pre-2017 bill
SB723 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB723”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1005 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…sponsor. All right, in committee, there is an amendment for HJR 1005 that Representative Shepard has added to the bill. It's a m…”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1015 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “I have a bill, HJR 1015, that described the process for election of members of the…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1031 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1031”
Pre-2017 bill
SB345 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…started. We are going to take Representative Davis to hear Senate Bill 345, I'm sorry, 365, before we move on into constitutional amen…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
All right, Chair sees a quorum. We'll go ahead and get started. We are going to take Representative Davis to hear Senate Bill 345, I'm sorry, 365, before we move on into constitutional amendments discussion. So, Representative Davis, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 365. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Members, this is a bill just to allow Arkansas Game and Fish officers and highway officers their estates to receive payment for any leave or holiday pay should they pass away while still under employment. This is currently in special language on their budget. We're just moving it to statute similar to what we did with the flag bill earlier in the session. Well, there's nothing new here. It's currently in special language, just putting it in statute. Representative Link, you're recognized for a question. Representative Davis, I thank you for the second bill you brought to us. I know that you're changing things out of special language, and I like that, putting it in statute and making it. If we're going to make it permanent, make it permanent. Dad, come here long ways down there. It is a long table. Yeah. Thankfully, I've got trifocals. I can look right there and see you just fine. The question I had about this the other day is we're doing this for two groups of officers, it looks like. We've seen in this committee several times where bills come back for they'll be written for a group of officers, and we come back and amend another group, and then two years later we'll amend another group and another group. Why don't we just make this for all officers in the state just right off the bat instead of having to come back and amend and amend and amend? I asked the Bureau the same question, and essentially there already is a statute that allows this for state employees in general. But I guess because these are under commissions, not directly under our purview, they were deemed to be excluded from that statute. Okay. So an example, an officer with the state parks have officers. State parks, state police already get this. They would already be getting this. Okay. That makes sense. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Additional questions from members? Seeing Representative Hickerson, did you have a question? All right. I'll hold on to that for a moment. Is there anyone here from the public to speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Davis, you close for your bill. I'll close. Thank you. All right. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Hickerson, you're recognized for a motion. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Motion to do pass. I've got a motion. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, Representative Davis. You have passed your bill. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. All right, committee. Next up, we are going to hear from Representative Mayberry on Representative Mayberry you're going to have to remind the chair which one of yours you are presenting today ok we're going to hear HJR 1024 and welcome the Lieutenant Governor to the room as well Mr. Griffin if you would please introduce yourself for the record Tim Griffin Lieutenant Governor thanks for having me Representative Mayberry, you're recognized to proceed, H.J.R. 1024. Did everybody get the sheets of paper that I didn't pass out? Chair, I haven't been notified of your handout, but we'll get it distributed. Staff, go ahead and distribute the handout. Thank you. While that's being passed out, I just want to remind you all that when I came last time, I presented you with three different constitutional amendments, all dealing with the lieutenant governor's office, and I basically said let's use it or lose it, and let's start discussion. If we ignore some of the more recent events, shame on us. We don't want to just look the other way. I think that it's our job to solve some problems, and obviously I think we have a few problems with this office. And so it started discussion, and so I'm here today to first of all tell you that I'm only going to propose one. I'm keeping House Resolution 1024, and I am dropping the remaining two, because I believe that this is the idea that others have said sounds like a good idea. As a matter of fact, our own Lieutenant Governor Tim Griffin is here in support of this amendment. And I'm going to let him speak, but first of all, just briefly show you some of the information regarding this position. To give you some information from another person who worked in this office, Steve Brawner, very first sentence here in his article, he said, I was the communications director in the lieutenant governor's office, my boss, Lieutenant Governor Winn Rockefeller, was a very good man, but the lieutenant governorship, at least the way it is designed in Arkansas, is not a useful office. That's a gentleman who worked in the office under Lieutenant Governor Winn Rockefeller. He goes on to say in his story that the governor and the lieutenant governor could be yoked together on one ticket. That way the governor and lieutenant governor could be a team, maybe even share staff. and I'm proud to say that we have a lieutenant governor and a governor right now who are doing that. They are working together as a team and it's wonderful to see but by our constitution we are not guaranteed that that's going to happen again. We very likely could have two from very different parties who don't see the same way. They're not going to want to work together and even if you have two people from the same party you're not guaranteed that they're going to want to work together so I think we should follow an example that we're already seeing put in front of us with our current lieutenant governor and our governor and I'm going to let him share his points of view on on this topic thank you thank you Griffin you're recognized thank you mr. chairman first of all I think that Arkansans benefit when the governor and the lieutenant governor work together as a team and I think you've got a unique situation now Now the governor has described it as historic, and that's because he and I have, the governor and I have known each other for a long time. We have a close working relationship, and I think you've seen that in his willingness to include me in his key senior staff meetings, to give me opportunities to serve, such as the chair of his review on Common Core. And in a host of other ways, I work on a daily basis with his office and his office with mine. And so I think that Arkansans get more value for their taxpayer dollars when the governor and the lieutenant governor are rowing in the same direction, if you will. So I think that currently it's working great, but as Representative Mayberry said, there's no guarantee that in the future that that would happen because it is unique that a governor would have just by happenstance the relationship that he and I have and that there would be the trust between us. So I think right now it's working great. The question is down the road How could we reform the office so that there is a greater chance that we could replicate this? If it is working so well, let's look at what's working well, the cooperation, and how do we make sure that that happens in the future and it's not just by chance. In my view, and I've worked with Representative Mayberry on this amendment, In my view, the way you do that is that you join the governor and the lieutenant governor so they run as a ticket. Why would that help? Well, it would help because you would have the governor selecting the lieutenant governor so it's someone clearly that they have trust in and is of their party. Otherwise, they wouldn't select them. And so it ensures that you have, from the get-go, a trust level that looks like what you're seeing now, which, as I said, is a better value for the taxpayer. Also, there are other parts of this amendment that Representative Mayberry didn't mention, but that I've supported from the start. From the first week that I took office, I supported the fact or an amendment that would allow the governor to retain his power when he leaves the state. Now, it may seem counterintuitive that a lieutenant governor would want to give up some of his power, but for me, this is a good government initiative. There's no reason why, if the governor is going to go to Memphis, that he needs to stop being the governor because he crossed over the Mississippi River. It just didn't make any sense. That's an archaic, anachronistic provision that we need to change. It made sense at the time, but it doesn't make sense now. When the President of the United States leaves the country, he's still the President of the United States. And so I think we need to do that. Now, you're not going to save a ton of money, but there is some bureaucratic action related to that when the governor leaves the state and the power goes to the lieutenant governor. So that's another part of this, which I wholeheartedly support and have supported from the get-go. I've said repeatedly that this office is an important office. There are a number of states, I think it's 26 states, have the governor and the lieutenant governor run as a team. And as we've seen twice in the last two decades, the lieutenant governor has become the permanent governor, including Governor Huckabee. And so this is an important office in my view. This is a way, this particular amendment, this is a way that we can ensure that in the future, the type of value that I believe you're getting now from this office, the taxpayers will continue to get into the future. So I support it wholeheartedly and happy to take any questions. All right. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Yes, thank you, Lieutenant Gattaburner, for being here. Good explanation. And just wondering about some logistics of that partnership. Would that mean that you would transition to a full-time position probably and, you know, an adjustment in salary, of course? No. You would be still part-time? Correct. I would not be, in my view, I don't think there's anything in here that would indicate a change to that. Correct. Actually, none of this would, well, there's one part of it that would go into effect sooner than the other parts. This does not affect anyone's position as lieutenant governor or governor until 2022. After? After the two people who currently are in office, after they finish their term and could potentially fulfill another term. So that doesn't kick in until 2022. There is a piece of it that would kick in earlier than that, and it would kick in if this is one of the proposed constitutional amendments, and if it is passed by the voters, it would kick in in January of that next year to allow the governor to retain his powers when he goes out of state. And then also you will notice that it does allow the Citizens Commission to come back in and adjust it if there needs to be an adjustment in salary or in hours or something, but that would be on down the road. And if I could, I would say that I agree with the – in fact, I appreciate the Citizens Commission not giving me a raise. I don't have to take any of those calls about why I got a raise. I did not get one recommended by the Citizens Commission. I am more than happy with that. And I would recommend if they met again in light of this that they not give me a raise. I do not. This is a part-time job. I think it ought to stay part-time. And so I just want to be clear for the press here. I would not accept and would not recommend a pay increase. I ran for this position as a part-time position, even though nothing I do in life is part-time. Thank you. All right. Representative Mayberry or Lieutenant Governor Griffin, I probably would direct the question maybe to both of you and whichever one of you would like to answer it. but the only question that comes to my mind is why do this now when we have four more general elections before the effective date? Because it's been part of discussion. I mean, I don't think we can turn away from what we've seen the last year, and I think we need to address it sooner rather than later, that we give everybody a heads up to know the next set of folks who might be running for offices to understand what it is in the future? I would also say as a practical matter, I know and you know from your time in politics that you can't count on anything happening immediately in politics. If you've got a good idea, it's a good idea today. It's going to be a good idea tomorrow, and we ought to pursue it, ought to pursue it this session, and keep on pursuing it until we get it done. Representative Dotson, did you have a question? You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Looking through this, upon a vacancy in office, it states that the governor shall appoint someone to replace if the lieutenant governor had a vacancy in office. Is there any sort of confirmation process? I'm not seeing one in here by the Senate or anything else that would cover, Or is it just a governor's appointment and that's it, someone who is unelected by the people, has never been voted on before, could serve as lieutenant governor and possibly become governor before the end of that term? That's a very good question. And if that is of concern, we certainly can make an amendment to address that if you would like us to. I'd be willing to, you know. But, again, it is the governor who already has chosen the lieutenant governor as the running mate, so you've already kind of given him that authority. But I do understand you'd be concerned. The people elected them. people elected that person as a team. So if that would give some clarity, we certainly could move forward with that if that was the will of the committee. Thank you. I would just point with that. I would be OK with that. I would point out that there is ample precedent for governors choosing individuals to fill out to complete a senator's term, a congressman's term, to become a president, Naming a vice president, I mean, there's ample, so this is not a novel idea. I would be open to that change, but there's ample precedent for that. And at the next election, if people were mad about that, they'd have an opportunity to express it. Additional questions from members? All right, either one of you have anything to add? Appreciate y'all letting me come say a few words. Well, thank you for joining us, Governor Griffin, and Representative Mayberry. We'll continue to keep yours under discussion as we move forward here. Thank you. All right, committee. We have a number of constitutional amendments that we've been discussing. We've heard from a number of people. There's been a lot of discussion. I've asked all of you to prepare a list of what you believe your top choices are. Where's everybody at in that process, just by way of discussion here? Representative Bennett? No senators have asked to present, and so you're welcome to include a Senate one in your list, but they have not asked to present to us. and that offer has been extended. Representative Wardlaw? Question. Will we not meet jointly, the House and the Senate, to discuss the three? We will be meeting jointly to discuss up to 12. Can you give us an update of what that procedure looked like and when it will happen? Yes. That procedure was originally scheduled to begin today at this time, and the Senate is not quite as far along in the process as we are at this point. And so we are awaiting somebody getting narrowed down to six. Follow-up? Yes. If they would work on Friday, would that not make that easier for them? Representative Wardlaw, I have bills pending in the Senate, and I'm going to not comment on that at this point. Anyway, committee, Representative Bennett, did you have a question or a point? Oh, okay, okay. Additional discussion? Who all has your list of six that we're ready to proceed with? Representative Tosh is on point. Anybody else? All right, well, we have – Representative Dawson, you had an amendment to – that you wanted to discuss with the committee on your constitutional amendment proposal. Which one is that? HGR. All right, you're recognized to present your amendment to your amendment proposal. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. HJR 1016, this particular bill is basically a merging of a couple of ideas that have been floated around. I have a bill, HJR 1015, that described the process for election of members of the judicial branch And also Representative Shepard had another bill that was HGR 1005 that talked about a merit-based selection process for Supreme Court justices. Basically what this bill, HGR 1016, is a merging of those two, two various processes. This would set up a panel or a commission that would nominate some choices for the governor to select from to determine Supreme Court justice individuals, and then they would also be voted on in a merit-based reelection type process of whether they could vote yes or no to retain them in office if they wanted to run for or seek re-election. That would be for Supreme Court justices, and then for the remaining judicial branches, it would move to an election process very similar to what I described before this committee in HJR 1015 for all the rest of the judicial branch members. And there is, because of the speed on Friday to try to get this amendment before the committee today and be engrossed on your tablets there for this afternoon, there are a couple of corrections. I'm going to have to do another amendment to this amendment in order to clarify those. So if you have any ideas as you read over this on anything that would make this better, please get with me as quickly as possible so I can incorporate those into the bill when I go to amend it one last time, hopefully. I'll try to answer any questions. Questions from the committee for Representative Dotson. Representative Dotson, apparently you did a great job explaining. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And your amendment is already engrossed into the original proposal, correct? All right, Representative Ladyman, did you have an amendment to H.J.R. 1027 you'd like to present? All right, you're recognized to present. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, I have an amendment to HJR 1027. That constitutional amendment was the gist of that was to give county officers a four-year term when they're reelected instead of a two-year term. That was the gist of the original Amendment. Representative Layton, if you'd hold on just a moment. The committee, is the amendment showing up on your tablet yet? It's not showing up on mine yet either. If you'll hold on just a moment, Representative Layton, let's let technology catch up with us here. HJR 1027. And we do have a paper copy coming around. yes I do thank you did everyone get their copy all right representative Leiteman you can go ahead we all have paper copies now Thank you, Mr. Chair. The one change to this amendment, or what the amendment changes, is it just removes the justices of the peace from the group. So the JPs would not be included in this constitutional amendment. It would just be the other officers. All right, Representative Leibn, that was the change that the committee suggested to you, I think, the last time you presented it. This was done in response to the last time when I presented this to you, and I got some feedback from the committee since that's a legislative group and not an executive group. And that also would track with municipal and state offices. So that's the change. So answer any questions that you might have. All right. Are there questions for Representative Ladyman on his amendment or the overall resolution? Seeing none, Representative Ladyman, we'll keep it in the hopper and continue to move forward. All right. Thank you. Put a gold star on your list, Representative Wardlaw. All right, committee. we do have a project that we need to get wrapped up here and for those of you who aren't aware the speaker has asked all of us to throughout the rest of this week to begin double meetings we intend to do that since we've been pretty much doing double meetings we'll basically continue with our schedule right now it appears that most everyone has some sort of a list but I don't know that we're complete I'm going to suggest if the committee is in agreement I'd originally planned on tomorrow afternoon meeting for formal adoption but I'm going to ask everybody to bring your list of six and share them informally with each other between now and the next meeting and let's Wednesday afternoon let's plan on formal adoption and referral to the joint committee of six so come prepared to do that bring bring your top six and we for everyone's information the process that we've got we've outlined at this point is everybody will bring six to our meeting we will confer to see if any have 11 if any of those have 11 then we will Chair will hear motions to refer any of them that have 11 or more on the list. If we have less than 6 that have 11, we'll take whatever that number is. For example, if there are only 3 that have 11, we'll ask everyone to then list our top 3. If anything has 11, we'll take a motion to refer. If not, we'll continue until we get to where we have 6 or where we have nothing that can get 11. So that's the process that we're intending to work with right now. Representative Bennett. Mr. Chair, if I might suggest something, and I've not been through this process, so I'll defer to your knowledge of it. But if we just ran through the list number by number and people threw their hand up, we could at least eliminate a few. If nobody's hand in here goes up on one of the amendments, then we would know that that one doesn't have 11. Representative Bennett, this process has, in my limited experience, has never gone smoothly. It's a difficult process. I'm open to whatever, again, the committee would like to do. We could run through really quickly and see if there are any that the committee is just simply not interested in moving forward with and take them off of everyone's list if they're pretty clear that they're not going to move forward. At this point, I don't know that taking positive votes is difficult as well because we don't know for sure what all everyone's for. Is there any consensus among the committee right now of anything that you would like to see go forward? All right, Representative Hickerson. I'm sorry, Mr. Chairman. Amy gave me a list of all the amendments that are on the agenda, and she marked the ones that have been heard. Now, are we talking about all of these or just the ones that have been presented to us because there are only 10? As of the close of this meeting today, everything that's a shell amendment that hasn't been filled in I'm going to move to the deferred list because it's pretty clear that people haven't presented there have been numerous opportunities to present many of us have made the trek here in the afternoons to give people an opportunity to present and they haven't been presented so as of close this meeting today if it hasn't been heard or presented to this committee we're going to move them to deferred list that leaves us I think with about what you said about 10. So it's not as daunting a task as we think. Well yes if maybe Amy or Sherry could get everyone a list between yeah. And so once again I think in line because this morning as I went through this again what I came up with is there are really only as I see it about 8 that are viable and that even have any chance at all. So my suggestion is, yes, let's get that list of 10. And you guys look through it. Give everything due diligence. A lot of folks put a lot of hours into these things. And let's come Wednesday. We'll have our regular meeting in the morning. We won't take amendments up at that point. But let's come Wednesday afternoon prepared to send some to the joint committee and hopefully be ready the first part of next week to get to joint meetings and get something done with this. Again, this is, in my experience around the legislature, the most difficult thing to do in an orderly fashion that we do around here, and I'm doing my best, but if any of you have suggestions, please feel free to refer them to the chair, and we'll try to get this expedited. Yes, Sherry, if you want to go through the list for the committee, that would be wonderful. H.J.R. 1012, H.J.R. 1002, H.J.R. 1005, H.J.R. 1006, H.J.R. 1015, H.J.R. 1008, H.J.R. 1024, H.J.R. 1025, H.J.R. 1017 1027 and 1016 in H.J.R. 1007 1025 is not in it so there's just 11 in the mix 1025 was one of the ones that's being withdrawn by the sponsor. All right, in committee, there is an amendment for HJR 1005 that Representative Shepard has added to the bill. It's a minor amendment, but it does have an effect on the bill. It alters the makeup of the selection committee. So please take a look at that as you continue your considerations. He asked if he needed to be here to present it, and I suggested to him that all of you all could look at that on your own, and he agreed that it wasn't a substantial modification. But please be aware of that and take a look at that as you continue your consideration. All right, committee, I think that's where we are with constitutional amendments. We do have some folks here that would like to go ahead and run bills today, And since we do have them on the agenda, I'm going to go ahead and move forward with those without objection. Okay. Representative Hodges, you still in the room? Yep, there you are. We're going to go ahead and hear from you on H.R. 1031. And he does have a handout that's going to be coming around to you. No. This is not a HJR. This is an HR. This is just a House resolution. Representative Hodges, you are recognized to present HR 1031. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, Committee, for hearing from me today. I know it's been a long day, and I appreciate you taking the time. What I have for you today is a resolution that we will be hopefully sending to the Congress, and I apologize if there's a little bit of Article V fatigue out there. I know that I have a little bit of it, but I think this bill is so important that I still think it's worth our consideration. The amendment is called the Regulation Freedom Amendment, and really I think the text makes it clear and is worth reading. It says that whenever a quarter of the members of the U.S. House or the U.S. Senate transmit to the President their written declaration of opposition to a proposed federal regulation, it shall require a majority vote of the House and Senate to adopt that regulation. So in essence, it just gives Congress a little more oversight and control over federal regulations. And I don't think it's any secret that regulations have been growing at an alarming rate these past few years. In 2013 alone, the Federal Register was over 80,000 pages, and it's estimated to cost our economy about $73 billion a year. And I think, really, if you look at the amendment that we passed last November giving the state legislature control over our regulations, I think this is even a toned-down version of what they did. So, really, I don't think it's too radical of a suggestion because, you know, this legislature now has full control over all regulations proposed in state government, and this would at least require a quarter of the House or the Senate to even vote on that regulation. So I think it's a common sense approach, and I think it's measured and could be a successful model. It has been supported by the National Farm Bureau, and really a reason that I personally wanted to run the bill is kind of an example from my district. One of the largest employers in my district, they manufacture lights for tow trucks and other emergency vehicles, and he was telling me about a regulation that prevents them from making lights for these trucks that are wireless. They have the technology to make them, but there's some random regulation that prevents them from making any of these lights that are wireless. And he said he's tried to fight that for years. Last time I talked with him, he was going to fly to Iowa to speak at a court case to try to have this law overturned so this is time away from his business time to fly the cost of being there all to get this silly regulation overturned that if this law were in place he would have a much better shot at getting his voice heard and like I said this is one of the biggest employers in my district they have about 43 employees if you listen to I mean anyone speak I don't think it's any you know secret that a lot of people are opposed to these regulations if you listen to someone like Peter Thiel, who was the founder of PayPal and one of the first outside investors in Facebook. He's sort of one of the leading figures of anti-regulation. He's been talking about things lately about, you know, it took 15 months to build the Empire State Building 100 years ago. And if you look at how long it's taken us to build the Freedom Tower in New York today, the regulations have really just bogged down our economy and prevented us from really progressing, I think. And he talks about some of the biomedical field. You know, 10 or 20 years ago, everyone thought biomed was going to be this great industry to get invested with. We were going to have all these cures for these diseases, and now it takes at least a year and a billion dollars to approve any drugs. And he says that in today's world, we would not be able to approve the polio vaccine. So I think if you take this in sum, I think this body should approve this resolution. We can send it to the Congress. At least it sends a message, if nothing else. I hope that enough states get on board that it becomes a reality, but if not, I think we owe it to our constituents to let them know that these regulations are out of control and that we're trying to do something to stop that. And with that, I'll yield some time to Mr. Greenberg if he wants to add anything. actually I think representative Hodges done an excellent job of covering this I guess I would just say you know there is a place for federal regulation but there's also a place for the people's control over the people who it who issue these regulations and of course you know the people have control over the state legislature and the federal legislature but the people don't really have control over the regulators and this is a way for the people to exercise their control through the Congress to have democratic self-rule and self-government. All right. Are there questions from the committee for Representative Hodges? Seeing none, is there anyone here from the public to speak for or against the resolution? Representative Hodges, do you have anything additional to add? I'm closed. All right. It was a pleasure to the committee. We've got a motion from Representative Womack. Do pass. All in favor say, or any discussion on the motion? All right. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. Call the roll. Representative Link. No. Representative Wardlaw. No. Representative Hickerson. No. Representative Walker. Representative Walker. Representative Bale. Oh, that's not supposed to be up there. Representative Douglas. Yes. Representative Ladyman. Yes. Representative Drown. Yes. Representative Gray. Yes. Representative Gray. Representative Ritchie. No. Representative Tosh. Yes. Representative McGee. No. I didn't hear what he said. No. Representative Dotson. Yes. Representative Armstrong. Representative Armstrong. Representative Miller. Representative Miller. Representative Womack. Yes. Representative Holcomb, Representative Holcomb, Representative Fite, Representative Ballinger, Representative Ballinger, Representative Bennett. Your bill fails. Thank you, Chairman. Thanks, Committee. up, I believe we have Representative Broadway here to present Senate Bill 723. Thank you so much. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair. I'm here on behalf of Senator Hickey. This bill was brought to us by legislative audit. I have Mr. Roger Norman here to address questions by committee. Basically, this bill, as thick as it is, changes the name of the Division of Legislative Audit to Arkansas Legislative Audit. Prior to 1979, there were two divisions, the Division of Local Affairs and the Division of Legislative Audit. they were combined under one umbrella which is now the Division of Legislative Audit but it's actually not a division anymore it's an entity unto itself thus the name change there are a lot of very small changes in language but there is nothing that changes the substantive law in any way but I will leave this to Mr. Norman to again address any questions you all might have but that is our bill. I've had a question the same question for everybody that's brought a renaming bill in here including the one I brought and that is give us an approximate idea of what the costs associated with the renaming are. Clearly there's some letterhead changes and other things that have to take place. Well each time that there's new chair we redo the letterhead but mainly it's done electronically so it's going to be very little cost we visited with the Bureau as far as the the code revision and as it's like with with with any entity they'll change our title but other than that as subsequently language changes it will change in the code I see very little cost associated with this all we have to do is change it on the reports that we do primarily in our letterhead I would add that this has been presented to our executive committee and the full committee and they have approved it. Questions from the committee? All right. Seeing none, anyone here from the public speak for or against the bill? All right. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a motion. I've got a motion of due pass. Is there discussion on the Motion? Seeing none, all in favor say aye. Anyone opposed? Congratulations Representative Broadway, you've passed your bill. That's all I have if I may be excused. You may. All right, is there anyone else here to present a bill? Representative Branscombe? All right, you are recognized to present. Remind me of the bill number, Representative Branscombe. And committee, this is a bill that was just filed, I believe, Friday. So we do need to waive the rule. Without objection, we'll go ahead and hear from Representative Branscombe. Hearing no objection, Representative Branscombe, you're recognized to proceed. Thank you, committee. This bill puts the language in Amendment 1 that was passed back in November for the new Constitutional Amendment 1 that regulates the rules before any agency can do anything what I consider big would have to go through rules and regs and I've worked with Marty Garrett with the Bureau for the last two months and this is kind of what we've come up with. Other than that, I'm going to learn about the bill as we go to be honest with you. I don't know a whole lot about it. I know that, but it's kind of big. It kind of does a lot, but we'll figure it out as we go. Are there questions from the committee? Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. Can we not review rules and keep them from becoming antiquated without a new law? Well, you've got to remember, this is putting the enabling legislation in Amendment 1. So you're saying that we're going to have to review some laws that might be in conflict to the new rules? No. Okay. Not my understanding. All right. Go ahead. When an amendment was passed, I'm assuming that you probably voted for it. You're understanding that – I'm not going on record there. Well, maybe you didn't vote for it. Go ahead. But it passed, so we've got it. So as chair of the legislative council, I've kind of – working with Senator Samples, This is kind of what we've come up with, the enabling legislation. Now, as time goes on, we will be working through it, and I think probably changes will be made, but until we kind of get it figured out, this is where we are. Revenue Douglas, to directly answer your question, I think where you're going, question one that was on the ballot but only allowed this legislative body to pass legislation that allowed us to approve rather than review. But absent passing some legislation, then that ballot question has no effect. Correct. All right, additional questions from the committee? Representative Bennett, you're recognized for a question. And I apologize, I haven't had a chance to read this. I'm seeing some language in here, though, that requires us to review rules. Correct. As my recollection of the ballot was that we could choose to, but that not every rule would come through us before it became effective. Probably correct. So this is going beyond the scope of the constitutional amendment? Not in my understanding, it's not. This is where that we've kind of got to work through it as we go. The way it is now, when HSE wants to do something, they come before council or maybe through rules and regs, so this is what we're going to do. We're telling you about it, but there's nothing you can do about it, theoretically. Now, they say before a rule or administrative change is made, they're going to present it before council and we get to hear it and if I'm sure most of it will continue to go through but the membership legislators will have a chance to hear it and say no we don't want to do this and it won't be able and they won't be able to do it as in before they've got a totus and and done it anyway. Representative Bennett, do you have a follow-up? I wish I did. Well, thank you. Representative Bennett, it is my understanding of that amendment that the must-review language would be what would mandate that the agency have to come in front of us. So if we didn't include that language, then we would be back to the may approve, which we have to enact legislation to force them to come in front of us. And if I might, Mr. Chair, you know, I guess my concern from just a procedural standpoint is this place has a tendency to allow things to bog down in the minutia, and I don't want our agencies to be unable to operate because they're backed up because one or more people around here don't want the rules to move forward. So I just want to be sure that whatever process we're putting into place is efficient and our agencies can continue to operate. And I agree with that. I mean, it is my intent, as with Senator Samples, I've talked extensively with, you know, I'm not interested in the little stuff. I mean, I don't care whether the highway department uses what color paint they use for the striping or whether they put down markers in the center. That's, you know, that's not the intention of this council. But it's something big, which remains to be seen, I guess, which we'll figure it out, and then if there's controversy and there's some member that say that you have something that some agency is going to do, and you're not for that, then you'll have an opportunity to voice that as before. You would just have to listen to it and go on. that's my I can give you that pledge as Sherry is I have no intention of being bogged down on a lot of those stuff I mean that's kind of what to use the infamous crime analogy I mean I want it to be big not the little dinky stuff Representative Hickerson you had a question just motion at the proper time Representative Link you're recognized for a question how does the emergency rules work now Now, did we change that? We all know that things come up there in an emergency. We've seen, especially with the plant board, where there may be an outbreak in order to protect the farms, and the farmers have to implement a rule immediately. They don't have time to wait for us to convene and so on and so forth. How does the emergence of rulemaking work now? Well, I'm not sure. I don't know. Would it be possible for Ms. Garrity to come in here and present this with you, you think? Because, I mean, I think that's pretty important. Yeah, I mean, that's a valid point. Yeah. Because if something had an emergency and they needed to do it quickly, then you wouldn't have time for council to get called and to pass this out if something was needed to be done quickly. Yeah. Mr. Chair, I'd love for you maybe to bring back Ms. Garrity. You're right, this is big. Yeah, it's pretty big. I think we might want to vet questions like that better. Yep, that'd be fine. Okay. would you like to just pull your bill down today yeah that'd be fine then we'll bring it back and I'll have Ms. Garrity here with me okay is there any objection to that members okay we'll go that route thank you representative Thank you. Members, we're going to hear House Bill 1669 by Representative Womack. He has an amendment that he would like to present. Representative Womack, you're recognized. Present your amendment. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. I'm bringing you back, House Bill 1669. I had a pull down the other day. Representative Womack, if you'll give us just a moment. It looks like we're going to have to pass that out on paper. I don't think it's made it to the tablets, so if you'll delay just a moment. I've got one. Thank you. Yeah, I'm good. Thanks. I think everyone has a copy of the amendment and they probably have House Bill 1669 pulled up by now. If you are recognized, present your amendment. Thank you. This is an amendment, if you'll remember members, Mr. Tosh, Representative Tosh had asked a question that I wasn't completely clear about and the Municipal League had a couple of concerns, so I pulled the bill down and these amendments simply clarify my responses to that and these are agreed on by everybody, so I hope we can adopt these, please. Members, any questions on the amendment? Seeing or hearing none, we have a motion on amendment by Representative Wardlaw to accept the amendment. Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. All those opposed nay. And that amendment is adopted. Are you going to present your bill now? Yes, sir, please. All right, so you'd like to present 1669 as amended. Yes, sir. Members, I won't make you sit through this again. If you'll remember, this is a bill to protect citizens' right to observe and record public events, and there's no opposition at this point. So unless there's new questions, I would just appreciate a good vote. Members, you've heard of an explanation of the bill as amended. Do we have any questions? Seeing or hearing none, what's the will of this committee? I have a motion due passed by Representative Hickerson. Any discussion on that motion? Seeing or hearing none, seeing or hearing no one from the audience I just want to come forward to speak for or against. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? And the ayes have it as amended. Yes, we did accept that motion as amended. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. Thank you. Committee, there's a lot of us shuffling around here. Bill filing deadline was occurring, and I had a couple I had to go sign. All right. Is there any further business coming from the committee? All right. Just want to remind everyone we will be making a final decision on six amendments Wednesday afternoon, 30 minutes after adjournment. Please come prepared to send no more than six out of here. Also, the speaker has asked us to clear the deck this week of all bills that were filed previous to this big flurry of filing. So, if you have a bill that is on the deferred list, that's been sitting around, if you have a bill that's been rolling back and forth here for weeks and weeks and weeks, have it ready to run this week. We're going to move on into this big stack that's just been filed and continue to try to get the people's business done here so we can go home. So with that, being no further business coming from the committee, we stand adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB365

0:24 - 3:40 6 segments

HR1024

3:40 - 19:24 29 segments

HJR1016

19:24 - 21:55 4 segments

HJR1027

21:55 - 32:53 20 segments

HR1031

32:53 - 40:31 13 segments

SB723

40:31 - 51:53 21 segments

HB1669

51:53 - 55:37 7 segments

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers