House Revenue and Taxation Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (3)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1412
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Thank you, sir. Members, we're moving on to House Bill 1412. 14-12, and this is a, back when we started the session, we…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB570
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB570”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB70
· 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…nd. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. This is Senate Bill 70. It's Senator Samples' sponsor of it. It's the Arkansas His…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Here, sir. Representative Gene, I just want to see you walk back and forth. Can you come back here one more time for me, please? How you doing this morning? Doing good. Anybody in audience want to speak for or against this bill, please sign in. Representative Gene, do you have somebody with you? Patricia, you want to come up here? Yes, thank
Well, y'all may have some questions that, since this is Senator Samples' bill, I always need help. I understand. Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. This is Senate Bill 70. It's Senator Samples' sponsor of it. It's the Arkansas Historic Rehabilitation Income Tax Credit. Say right off, it has no revenue impact. It's neutral. What the bill does is clarify the meaning of certifying rehabilitation and adds a one-time period where you can claim this in a 24-month period.
And that's what this bill does. And Ms. Blickwith, with me, can answer any technical questions. Once again, it has no fiscal impact. So pretty much this is
kind of a technical cleanup bill? Correct. And just keeping somebody from double-dipping in the fund in a 24-month period? Correct. Members, do we have any questions? Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
The one question I have is I noticed that we're adding an effective date that started back in 2009 and runs through 2027, putting a sunset on this.
Can you kind of give us some background on that? Sure. Thank you very much, Representative. My name is Patricia Blick. I'm the Assistant Director of the Arkansas Historic Preservation Program, which is part of the Department of Arkansas Heritage. And what we found is that when the bill was adopted, It was originally going to sunset in 2017, and then it was extended to 2021, and that was not codified. So as far as the sunset goes, we're looking back to the entire code to extend it to 2027.
Does that answer your question? Yes, ma'am. It sure does. All right. Thank you. Thank you,
Mr. Chair. Motion to the proper time. You bet. Members, any other questions? Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill for the bill? Representative Gene, you closed for your bill, sir? Representative Meeks, do you recognize and make your motion, sir? I do pass. Members, motion for do pass on Representative Jean's bill. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, sir. You passed your bill. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you members of the committee.
Thank you, sir. Members, we're moving on to House Bill 1412. 14-12, and this is a, back when we started the session, we had discussed the fact that there's going to be some bills come through this committee that's very important, but with respect to the governor's budget and RSA schedule, we'll not entertain a motion for this, but this is one of these bills that we feel like is pretty important for the memberships
and the public to hear this bill, and so we agreed to it. I would say to the veterans in the room, my father's retired military, I served several years in the Air Force myself, and I understand some of the struggles that you guys have faced in your life and your careers, and I certainly appreciate you, and I know this committee appreciates you also. So with that being said, Representative Feit, you're recognized, ma'am, to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee members.
I bring to you House Bill 1412. We say we want to attract more jobs. We say, to attract jobs, we need a skilled workforce. I say, we have a skilled workforce. Unfortunately, they are leaving Arkansas and going to Tennessee, Missouri, Oklahoma, Texas, even Maine. Who is this workforce? They are highly skilled, work-ready, experienced retired military, typically aged 38 to 44.
Why are they leaving, and how do we retain them? That's what we're here today to talk about. I have several guests with me. First, I would like to ask our esteemed Lieutenant Governor, Tim Griffin, to come and join me at the
table. Welcome, Lieutenant Governor. Please recognize yourself, and you may proceed. Thank
you. Thank you for having me. You want to make an introduction first? He's got a few things, but that's it.
I'm ready. You're good to go, buddy. So, first of all, I want to make it real clear that I volunteered and really wanted to come testify today. This tax exemption issue is a personal one for me, not only because hopefully I'm going to reach my 20 years and get a retirement one day, but because I believe in this and have spoken out on this for a long time. So this is an economic development issue, first and foremost.
We are already known as a state that attracts retirees. That's a no-brainer. We get a lot of retirees here. But we lose a lot, particularly with regard to military retirees, because when they're about to retire and they're trying to figure out where they're going to be a permanent resident, They look at the states around us. They look all over the country. And I think you'll be getting a handout a little later that shows that we are an island of high taxes when it comes to military retirement pay.
The states around us, and it's not just the ones we know, Texas and Tennessee, they got better tax policy, period. But it's not just them. It's all around us we get beat on this. And if you don't think that folks make a determination of where they're going to live based on how much money is going to be on their pocket, I would just ask you to think again. And a lot of other states are already beating us on this, not just these that have adopted it,
but the lieutenant governor in New Mexico, lieutenant governor Sanchez, has taken this up as one of his key issues. The governor of Iowa has started something called Home Base Iowa, and they have a whole list of things that make Iowa attractive to veteran retirees. And he's done a video. They have a website. So what I would say is let's try to keep these veterans here.
They get out of the military. They've got health care. They've got instant. Remember, active duty retirees have instant income, instant income when they get out. So what they usually do is they use that income as a base, and then they go pursue some other dream. They start a franchise. They start a small business. They want to be a defense contractor and make good money. And we've got a lot of defense contractors who need skilled employees in the state from Camden all the way up to this part of the state.
And so there are a lot of different reasons to do this. And this is certainly, we're not talking about millions of people. We're talking about a relatively limited number. But they're very important people, and they're the type of citizens that you want. They're active in their communities, and they're highly skilled, and they've served their country. And again, other states have seen the wisdom in it, and so we're really lagging behind in this area.
So this is a no-brainer for me on the policy side. Now, how could anybody be against this? Well, generally, they're not on the substance. Very, very, very few people are against this on substance. if they are I'd like to hear why so the issue I always hear is well how do we pay for it how can we afford to do this I'd say a few things on that first of all how can we afford not to do it number one number two most of the cost estimates are what we call static not dynamic
and that's just the way DF&A works and that's why I don't put a lot of stock in a lot of their numbers, to be honest with you, because I fought in the Congress to have at the federal level dynamic scoring, and I believe in dynamic scoring here. What is dynamic scoring? It means that when you make a change in revenue, you can't just calculate how much revenue is going to go out because of that change and declare that to be the cost. You have to look at the economic changes,
Meaning, how many people do you attract that start to put money into the economy? And I believe that that number is significant. But even if you buy static scoring as the gospel on this, you're talking about $10 to $15 million out of a $5 billion budget. And I would just point out to folks, last year, and you're all very familiar with it, I'm sure, Last year, DHS paid $4 million to a contractor to do nothing.
To do nothing. They basically lit $4 million on fire over at DHS. Wasted money. You remember the article. It was in the Democrat Gazette. And here's the thing. If you would have gone back a year before that and said, hey, DHS, we're going to cut your budget $4 million because we believe there's some waste. What would you have heard? Oh, well, you can't cut that. We're going to lose this and lose that and lose that. No one would have said, that's fine, we're wasting $4 million anyway, right?
So here's the question. How many other $4 million are lurking out there of waste like this? You've got to assume DHS didn't know about it. If they'd have known about it, hopefully they'd have stopped it, right? So how many other pots of money are out there? So I just don't buy that there's not money for this. I don't buy the premise, how can we afford it? I would say, how can we afford not to do this? That is really the issue for me.
I think this is a no-brainer. I support it 110%, and they're going to get into some more of the details, but this isn't hard, folks, in my view. and I will do anything I can to help and answer questions and be here for y'all on this and I want to thank Senator Irvin for introducing a similar bill on the Senate side Thank
you sir Representative Fyder any more remarks? I have other
guests to introduce but with the chair's indulgence if there are specific questions for Lieutenant Governor because he has to leave for another engagement Fair enough, Jim.
I'll say it's birthday. Fair enough. Members, any questions for the lieutenant governor? Representative Meeks,
you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Lieutenant Governor, the question that I have, and let me first preface this by saying I'm a veteran myself, and I definitely understand what we're trying to accomplish here. My only concern is this, and I think you may have already addressed it, but I'd be interested in your feedback.
If I were to go around the state to Arkansans and say, would you be in favor of giving a tax cut to a special interest group, you and I both know that universally the answer would probably be no, that we're not in favor of giving tax cuts to special interest groups. Now, if we were to then say, would you support this proposal, I suspect that most Arkansans would probably say yes after we've identified what special interest group that we're talking
about. My concern is if, and I think you've probably addressed this when we go to the static versus the dynamic scoring, is this is saying like it's $13 million general revenue impact, and I agree there's probably $13 million of waste that we could all put our fingers on and find that difference. But kind of getting to more of a philosophical level, any time you give one group a tax cut, that means the burden of that tax cut then has to shift to all the other taxpayers of the state.
And so, you know, $13 million in the grand scheme of things, probably not a lot. If you were to go to the majority of Arkansans, probably most of them, I don't know, would say, okay, I'll pay a few more pennies a year in order to do this for the veterans. So I'm wondering if you can kind of address that. And in your research, and maybe Representative Feit can help, too, with this in your research, when you're looking at the dynamic scoring or when you're looking at some of these other states, what has been the positive economic impact?
Do you have any numbers to say, hey, that, you know, when, I don't know, Kansas or Louisiana or whatever, when they did this, this was the outcome, positive or negative, to the state and to the resource would be my first question. Then secondly, would you agree or disagree, would most Arkansans in your mind be willing to pay a few extra pennies of taxes in order to give a tax break to the veterans of the state? First
of all, I don't buy your premise. I wouldn't raise taxes on anybody to pay for this.
I would find waste. I would find ways to reduce spending elsewhere. I just named $4 million that, I mean, that's just the tip of the iceberg, folks. That's one we found out about because it ended up in the paper. So that's number one. Number two, I suspect, I don't know, I haven't looked at your record, but I suspect you voted for the active duty tax exemption in 2011, did you not? Probably.
Well, that's the same as this, so you'd probably support this one. But I think that in an ideal world, I would love to hit the reset button on our entire tax code. But I hadn't heard anybody talking about that, and I don't have the ability to make that happen on my own. So pending that, we've got to compete in other ways. You make a good point. The state of Texas and the state of Tennessee, they don't have carve-outs.
You know why? Because they don't have an income tax. So you're right on that. So they have a little different perspective on that. So here's the deal. If we wait to give relief until our entire tax code is reformed the way it ought to be, we'll probably all be gone. You know what I'm saying? Sure. And we had this same problem at the federal level. I'd like to see massive reform, and on ways and means, in the Congress I worked on that. But I also knew that if I waited until we had complete comprehensive tax reform at the federal level
before I provided any kind of relief to anybody, boy, that's going to be a long wait. You had to be Methuselah to be around for that one. So I don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good on this. And, yeah, I'm sure if you said call veterans special interest groups, there's a lot of different special interest groups. But you made the point yourself. When you provide more information to the voter, they agree with it. Sure, sure. I mean, that's a case for it. So, look, the tax code's got all kind of problems.
And I'd like to see it start over completely. not just income but a bunch of our tax system I know the power to do that I'm here to say until that happens we got to make some things right and this is a this is an easy lift it seems to me all right thank you thank you mr. chairman thank you chairman for let if I may leave my boy turns five and I'm gonna be out of town tomorrow so I'm gonna take him to lunch at school he doesn't know it so I'm gonna surprise him with some nuggets thank you very much lieutenant
Thank you, Governor. Appreciate you. Members, there's any other question for Representative Fyfe before we start asking folks to come? Representative Fyfe, do you
have somebody else? I'm sorry, go ahead, Representative Flowers. Thank you so much. I would just say before Lieutenant Governor Griffin leaves that I am halfway in agreement with him. I am very, very supportive of this bill, and I do agree that when we are considering tax credits and tax policy, this is really a matter of priority and that we need to be
looking at ways in which we can provide tax relief for measures that will demonstrate a more dynamic return or that reflects dynamic numbers rather than static. So I wanted to say that, but I would also say that if we are of his belief I don't know if he's still here, of his belief that the perfect should not be the enemy of the good. This is really a conversation about the merits of this bill
and this is really a conversation about how this can help Arkansas. So I would start by saying that I wouldn't indict waste at DHS than I would at any other agency. Those are issues on their own face where we do need to look at that waste. But DHS does a lot of important, excellent work for us, just like DEQ, just like the agriculture department. So I would say that first, and excuse me for sounding this way.
I'm a bit sick, but nothing contagious. And I would also say that there's, I think we talked about a measure with regard to savings around unemployment last week. And while I was staunchly against it, I talked with the sponsor afterward and came to a much greater understanding. So I just think it's important that we talk about these things holistically and comprehensively and not in a vacuum.
So that said, and thank you for indulging me, Mr. Chair. Thank you. I want to ask my first question. May I call my guest first, please? Yeah, let
me. Okay. Are you good? I did have a question, but I can wait. Okay. Representative Fyke, go ahead. Thank you. I think my guest could probably help us, Representative Flowers, with all the questions. We do not have groups, first let me say, we do not have groups of retired firemen or retired policemen ready to move to Arkansas, buy houses, and settle their families here.
So that's a whole separate issue. So let's keep on track here. I want to call Colonel Berry of the Military Officers Association and Dr. Hamilton, economics professor of UALR, and let them identify themselves and then help us to answer questions. And I'm going to scoot over so there's room at the table. If you gentlemen don't
care, identify yourself for the record, and you may
proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm Don Berry from representing the Arkansas Veterans Coalition.
through one of its member organizations, the Military Officers Association of America. The Veterans Coalition, made up of 18 veteran service organizations nationally and state-registered, representing 250,000 veterans in Arkansas. And on this particular issue, the 25,000 of those who are military retired who are living here in Arkansas, 19,000 of which are active duty retired and about 3,000 each of Air National Guard as well as Air Reserve who are part of that makeup for a total of about 25,000.
This initiative, this legislative initiative, addresses about 24,000 of the 25,000 total, and those are the DOD paid retirees. The Uniformed Services Bill would also address, in addition to the Armed Forces, members of the Public Health Service and NOAA, who are also members of the Uniformed Services. Lieutenant Governor Griffin basically captured the main points of the positions of where we are.
I think as far as, if I may, to respond again to Representative Meeks' point at recognizing special classes or carve-outs are really an anthema to all of us. We recognize that the special interest group that we're really trying to approach here are those that aren't in Arkansas. So in actuality, it's those who are coming up on retirement. We can go into a little bit more of the details. Dr. Hamilton, who did our study with UALR at the Institute of Economic Advancement, did the dynamic scoring for us.
And we can tell the positive side of the story, too, is the fact that as a result of a tax exemption, what the upside of that is. And we can go into the numbers there. Many of you are aware, military retirees now at the year 15 point are given a $30,000 payment. with a commitment to state a year 20. So for five years, they have that $30,000 that they can put in the bank, which is the nest egg, which is the starter kit for a business, a small business, wherever they are.
SBA has determined that if you are a veteran, you have double the chance of success of launching a special business. Lieutenant Governor also mentioned other states and initiatives. Iowa most recently enacted legislation, and they did it because they were losing retirees to Illinois and to Kansas. and to Missouri, all of whom surrounded them had 100% exemption. So they were much like Arkansas, and they did that and enacted that legislation in their last session. In this session this year, not only in addition to New Mexico, but South Carolina, Maryland,
as well as Maine are initiating legislations to the same take. Some of those states have partial exemptions to this point. Connecticut, with a 50% exemption, is enacting legislation to take themselves to 100% because they're surrounded by New York and Massachusetts. They're drawing off of their talent and affecting their business operations within their growth in Connecticut. So Arkansas is not unlike others that are in a dwindling number of states
that do not offer an exemption for military retirement pay or uniformed services retirement pay. we are one of ten states in the country whose active duty military retired population number has shrunk in the last four years we are the only southern state and every single one of the six of the ten states that are in that bottom ten all are like us in tax military retirement benefits
active duty military about year six become nomads They are basically operating most probably outside of where they live or reside as their official residence. And as such, about year six, they will find the opportunity place to start settling down. If they are in Arkansan and they pass through a state such as Nevada or Washington or Alaska, they all of a sudden become a Nevadan, a Washingtonian, or an Alaskan
because at that point in time, up until this past year, those states were all, Arkansas was taxing the active duty pay. That's going forward now. That's a great step that Arkansas has taken. But the career opportunity is the second career opportunity is when we talk about it to the point, and Dr. Hamilton will talk about that in just a minute. For every 250,000, 250 is the average growth of all of our neighbors with the exception of Arkansas. Arkansas is flat, as I said. When excluding Tennessee and Texas, all of our other neighbor
states average 250 military retiree families a year moving there. Were 250 military retirees moving to Arkansas a year, that amounts to $19 million in after-tax consumption spending going into the economy, which generates $1.9 million in new general tax revenue at a cost of the legislation of somewhere between $10 to $13 million. You're talking about somewhere in the neighborhood of a five- to a six-year payback
where at what point in time that the retirees moving into the state are actually creating greater revenue streams after the first five years. So we're in the positive side of the curve. I did want to say when we were around the state, the Municipal League of Arkansas as well as the Association of Arkansas counties both endorse our initiatives with their legislative committees last year for presentation to this session of the legislature. And at this
point in time, I'd like to offer whatever questions you may
have, sir. Thank you, Colonel. Members, any other questions for the Colonel? Representative Flowers, you recognize me, ma'am. Thank you. Thank you. I want to thank you for that presentation important information. I guess I just had a question about, and I think we went over this when we talked, you were talking about the return that we could see in terms of the taxes
of the population that would retire here if this bill were passed. Can you give me an estimate on and how long it would take Arkansas to see that return. Along with most of the other states
have enacted this legislation with the exception of Iowa who has most recently enacted and been very aggressive towards going back to the market to go pull our Iowans back in
or other state members. None of the other states have they basically passed the law and they just let it sit and let people wander in. An approach that we would like to see would be more of an integrated approach. Texas goes after businesses in other states to draw them to Arkansas or to Texas. We think the same methodology of parks and tourism model with economic development as well as workforce, higher education, all provide a package approach
approach towards attracting those approaching military retiree families, both the military member and the spouse, about year 15 as they're making those decisions of where they're going to go. And the numbers that we're looking at doing in the case of our baseline model of 250 a year, that's 1,500 new a year, or 1,500 that would be coming in in a period of six years. There are 6,000 Arkansans approaching that on active duty.
There are many more than those who are former Arkansans who have become Tennesseans or they live in Mississippi or Oklahoma that need to come home during our approach around the state that they have said that they want to come home. They have family here. The most recent reason
why people move and why I am here is because of family. So you're saying that it would take about It could take about six years at a really conservative way of looking at it.
250 is the average. If we market it, that's a 1% growth. 250 a year gets a 25,000 retiree population. So 1% growth gets us a payback in five years. And that's not even considering businesses or other
jobs that those folks who would return. could contribute to in terms of the growth that we could see. So it really could be less than five years. That's correct. Okay. Members, any other questions for the Colonel?
Mr. Alexander or Mr. Hamilton, do you have a statement, sir?
Yes, sir. My name is Gregory Hamilton, and I'm a research economist. I'm a research economist at the Institute for Economic Advancement at the University of Arkansas, Little Rock. And I'd like to thank the members for the opportunity to present the findings from a study I did entitled The Analysis of the Fiscal Impacts Associated with the Exempting Federal Military Retirees' Pensions from Arkansas State Personal Income Tax.
I'll read a brief statement summarizing the study and then answer questions. There are fiscal economic consequences when a state lowers and exempts military retirees federal retirement pensions from state personal income taxes. The fiscal cost of exemption is the foregone income tax revenues that would have been paid by the retirees. This is a reoccurring fiscal overhang. However, over time, the overhang diminishes as the current cohort of military retirees diminishes.
Tax expenditures affect locational decisions of military retirees. A state becomes a more attractive place for retirees wanting to reduce their tax burdens. Attracting military retirees is an appeal to the state. They bring permanent source of income with them. They are usually older requiring less state and local government services because their children are likely older and they have their own provider of medical insurance.
They are skilled workers with many transferable skills and often are seeking a second career. The study's research question asks, will an income tax policy that exempts military retirees' pension income from state income tax be beneficial to the state in the long run? The study analyzed the costs and benefits of the tax policy that exempts retired military service personnel from the state's personal income tax. The cost of the policy is the foregone tax revenues that could have been paid to the state by the military retirees.
As a consequence of the reduction in state revenues, a shortfall is created in the state budget that is assumed to be offset by reduction in state spending across the spectrum of state programs. The economic effects of these tax and expenditure changes on the state's economy are partially offset by additional disposable income received by retired military service personnel. As military retirees spend this additional income, additional tax revenues are generated from the transactions
compensated in part for the initial loss of income tax revenues. The overall net change in state tax revenues is a measure of the tax impact of the policy. The benefits of the tax policy come from additional economic activity of the new retired military service personnel attracted to the state. The implementation of the tax policy will cause the state to become relatively more attractive to retirees, increasing the likelihood that they will relocate to Arkansas.
Military retirees bring a new stable source of funding from outside the state to support economic activity within the state. In addition, there's a workforce development potential associated with occupational skills and experience levels of the retired military service personnel and their spouses. The spending associated with the new retired military service personnel and their families create new economic activity in the state. With this new economic activity, tax revenues will be generated as well as additional government expenditures associated with provision of government services.
To answer the study's question, the study simulated fiscal impacts of this tax policy using a Remy model of Arkansas and it cross-checked analysis using a fiscal impact model derived from the in-plan model of Arkansas. The simulations found, although the magnitudes of the findings differed, Both approaches were able to identify benefits and cost flows that demonstrated a positive impact on the state budget from the income tax exemption and induced migration of military retirees within the time frame of the study.
The primary reason for differences was the underlying assumptions of the model and techniques employed for several key economic and demographic variables. These key variables included the effective income tax rate, the level of military retirees' migration into the state, the spouse and retirees' labor force participation characteristics, the post-retirement earnings of military retirees and their spouses. The remedy analysis was a dynamic, focused on migration of military retirees and their spouses.
Their earnings were based on state average earnings. The simulation focused on identifying the time frames when the fiscal benefits of military retirees exceeded the cost of the income tax exemption for different migration levels and effective income tax rates. The in-plan model focused on potential earnings of military retirees at different levels of migration and effective income tax rates. Earning estimates were based on educational attainment levels of military retirees and the average state wage for the spouse.
Their combined annual family income estimated was at approximately $90,000. Remy's simulation used a lower earnings level than the family income approach. The variation in effective income tax rates was a critical factor in these simulations. With an effective tax rate of 4.4% and an annual level new military retirees of 250 to the state, the benefits associated with the new migrants offset the cost of the exemption in 2027.
At a 2.5% effective income tax rate, the benefits began to exceed the cost in the year 2025. Simulation based upon family income approximately of $90,000 a year found that when migrations reached the level of 250 new retired military service personnel annual, the benefits of tax exemptions exceeded the cost in year 2020 at a 2.57 percent effective tax rate. To achieve this outcome requires military retiree population to increase by 5.8 percent over the six years.
At a 4.4 percent effective income tax rate, annual migration to 150 retirees provides sufficient revenues to offset the overhang by 2022. Over this period, the military retiree population needs to increase by 9.3%. To reiterate, the key factors that affect the fiscal impacts of the income tax policy are the effective income tax rate, the level of military retirees' migration into the state, the spouse and retirees' labor force participation characteristics,
and the post-retirement earnings of military retirees and their spouses. Thank you. Thank you,
sir. Members, any questions? If not, Representative Feit, are you good? Start calling up folks in the audience. Want to speak for the bill? We're going to start calling up folks to speak for the bill. Members, or audience, if you don't care, please keep your remarks kind of brief in respect to the members' time. But first, is there a Jim?
I can't read the last name on the list. Is there a Jim in the audience? I want to speak for the bill. Sir, come to
the end of the table and say your name and recognize yourself. All right. That one's off. Get it on. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee members. I appreciate it. My name is Jim Gorday. I'm a currently Alaska resident in the active duty guard. with retirement scheduled at 2019, and I'm here to talk about essentially what this bill means to me and the impacts it will have directly with the military member.
I'm about 43, have friends that are roughly 43, a lot of whom are coming to the end of their active duty military service. A friend of mine just retired a week ago, headed out of state with his wife, who happens to be a doctor, and their kids. So my issue, or my question is, what is the overall impact to somebody like me? That's all I'm here to answer. To somebody like me, it represents an investment. It represents risk.
It represents cost. There's a belief of a benefit. There's an inclusion. There's an acceptance that five, ten, twenty years from now, this is going to turn around and be beneficial. The fact of the matter is we accept, as military members, a fair amount of risk. Typically, we're not driven by pocketbook, but more principle. But we typically thrive on mutual acceptance of risk. That's kind of how we see things. And so we're asking you guys to maybe risk a little bit on the front end,
and the reward can be quite great on the back end. My mom's 84 years old. One of the things that determines whether or not she's going to retire or be in Arkansas is what I'm going to do in four years. Right now, Hot Springs, Heber Springs, I'm a great emissary and ambassador for Arkansas, but honestly, I may not be here in four years, so moving her doesn't make sense. So I love all the facts and figures, but the fact of the matter is where I'm going to be in four years impacts decisions now,
impacts Arkansas economy now. When you're able to lay out and look at what Arkansas offers in terms of a retiree environment, you've got to realize these guys are not 60. They're not 80. They're 45. They've got a lot of years ahead of them in terms of revenue and tax revenue, whether via income tax or sales tax. These guys are young. They're bright. And they've got family. And the second and third order effects of that is my kids go to school in-state, they'll stay in-state, if I'm here in four years, they'll stay in-state, my mom, I can attract other people in, my in-laws, there's all sorts of opportunities there to be had.
So, think in line of what we look for. If you look around the region, you'll notice that other states are adopting these measures. And while we like to look at the pocketbook, really that affects us in terms of an inclusion aspect of it. It reflects poorly on Arkansas because of the fact that other states are willing to recognize service and willing to risk on their veterans and willing to accept an upfront cost with a long-term investment
in a qualified, smart, hardworking group of folks. And I would counter that we're not asking really for a tax cut. I hate that term. we're vibrant members of a tax base. We will provide plenty of income given the duration of our stay. That's not a question. You shouldn't look short term and go, hey, well, I'm not going
to get X thousands of dollars from you today. Well, you will if I retire and I stay. I guarantee I'm going to move to a job that's going to produce income tax. There's no if, ands, or buts about it. what's the what's the cost of me walking out the state what's the cost of me to our education system to our property tax base to our property values to hot springs to heber springs what's the cost of me taking my mom to some other state going to florida going to some place that maybe has
a little more bang for the buck in terms of my retired federal income because i i'm stuck i i I've got to earn a living for the next 20 years. I've got no ifs, ands, or buts about it. I'm not going to make it on retiree pay. It's not enough. It's not enough for me, and it's not enough for my retired mom who's on a fixed income. So I'm going to generate a great deal of revenue. I will in terms of a taxable income. But I just may not be attracted to stay here if you don't, as a state legislator, legislation,
if you don't recognize the worth and are willing to invest in us. We're not asking for much. Just invest in our future. And guys, four, five, three, two years from retirement, they will look at that. And when you're driven by principle and not pocketbook, those little gestures mean a great deal, especially when other states are doing such a great job of attracting us. So I appreciate your time. I love the state of Arkansas.
We're fortunate to be here, and you guys, it's a great state. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. But I guarantee the only thing that weighs on my mind, not just me, but how am I going to pay for me and my extended family, my in-laws, my elderly in-laws, my elderly mother, and those kind of decisions, these kind of decisions impact that. So I thank you for your time again. I couldn't be more humbled to be here in front of you. Thank you very much. Is there
anybody in the audience who want to speak against the bill?
I'm assuming probably not. Ms. Ashley Little? Is there an Ashley Little? Bill Bax? Thank you very much, sir. Amy Madison? Is there Ms. Amy? Please state your name for the record, and you may proceed, ma'am. Thank you,
Speaker 75
43:48
Mr. Chairman. I'm Amy Madison I represent the other side I'm a wife of a retiree so this does affect my family
it does affect he stayed here and remained here and became an Arkansan when we could have gone to Nebraska his home state he chose to continue his education here his children are here so therefore I am begging and implore you to you know think about this and think about the other side we follow our spouses to wherever they go we follow our family members wherever they go and this was not a easy thing for him to choose to stay in Arkansas or to leave this was a
you know one of those things that he desired to stay here and remains here works here he is one of those workforces that you hear about a trained workforce in my line of work when we try to recruit industries here I live in Jacksonville I can say we have a trained workforce that is ready for you upon you know when they retire they're not looking to go be put out in the pasture my husband is very young we are a very young family so we this is affects our
family, whether you choose to or not, but we choose to stay here in Arkansas, but we choose to, you know, that you think of this not as a special interest group, but as Arkansans who have whose spouses who have signed up to protect your freedoms. And that's all I have to say. Thank you very much, ma'am. Mr. Will Beans? Sir, when you get to the table, please
recognize yourself and you may proceed good morning mr. chairman representatives my
name is William beams I'm the chairman of the Arkansas veterans coalition legislative committee I'm also the state chief of staff for the veterans for foreign wars there's been a lot of numbers put out here today and it a lot of times eyes tend to glaze over when we go through all these numbers and That's understandable. What it boils down to is in the next five years, DOD reports that there's going to be a million people separating from service. They are not going to wait until five years from now
to decide where they're going to go. They have a $30,000 retirement benefit, as Colonel Barry talked about, and they're deciding today where they're going to take their family in five years. So waiting five years to start attracting these people is not going to work. They're going to go every place around us accept Arkansas we can't afford that the reason we can't afford that is based on estimates of Colonel Barry's math with the exception of Texas and Tennessee we're going to attract on average 250 families what that 250 families
represents is a hundred and fifty million dollars a year in federal transfer transfer dollars coming into the state now we're about to enjoy a one percent tax cut I think that was a hundred and two million dollars is what That added up, too, that the governor found in the budget and redistributed and put it back in the pockets of Arkansans. We now have a few hundred dollars more per family to spend over the course of the next year. That did nothing to bring new money into the state of Arkansas. By passing this bill and attracting new people who will bring federal transfer dollars into the state,
we will be bringing new money into the economy, which will feed businesses, which will feed our population, which will in turn grow the state of Arkansas. These are just points that I didn't hear brought up this morning that I thought was very important to bring up. So if anybody has any questions, I'm open for them. Members, does anybody have any questions? If not, thank you very much, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, representatives. And last on the list is Ms. Christine Oldham.
Pass. representative johnson you got something to say thank you mr chairman i do bob johnson state representative district 42 district 42 includes little rock air force base also includes the largest number of military tirees of any other district in the state but i'm here to talk about my other job my job is a cpa in Jacksonville, Arkansas. I'm a practicing CPA in Jacksonville, Arkansas. Every year I lose one
to three clients who retire from active duty and they move out of state. But I want to give you two examples that are right now, right fresh today. In September, I had an employee that had been with me almost four years. They moved to Iowa. Her husband was retired military. They did all these new incentive programs. They moved to Iowa. Their daughter had just graduated the University of Arkansas and is at UMS doing her internship in nutrition. She was going
to stay in Arkansas, but now her parents left. She's going to go to Iowa and work in Iowa and take her Arkansas degree to Iowa. So, one, it left a hole in my staff, my accountant The accountant's gone, and so now I've had to replace that person. Saturday, a new client comes in that's married a local Jacksonville girl. He's going to retire in two years. Two years, he told me he's going to retire, and I'm going to move out of state.
And, of course, that brought up this bill, and we talked about it. I said, if we pass this bill, would you consider staying? He said, yeah, we'd consider because my wife and all of her family's here. we have to look at it's not just who we're going to bring in, it's also who we're losing every year we have retirees walking out of the state now I'm one of eight tax repairs in Jacksonville so I don't know how many walk out of the state every year but it does impact my business
it impacts the spouses and they're good, young, solid workers where Jim was working, they had to replace him And so it hurts our state as these trained, diligent workers leave and they have good worth ethics and they don't require benefits and they have 20, 25, 30 years of good production left and I'm having to watch them walk out of my business. Thank you. Thank you very much.
Representative Fyatt, even though we're not taking a motion, do you want to close for your bill now? I'm sorry. Yes. Representative Tucker, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. I just wanted to take one second because it's obvious we have a lot of veterans here with us in the committee today, and I just want to thank all of you for being here and thank you for your service to our country. And I also want to thank
Representative Fyde and Colonel Berry for taking the lead on this legislation. And we so appreciate that, Representative Tucker. In light of the gravity of this, I think it will let several folks, if you so do, choose to say something.
Representative Lederman, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I don't know whether this is a question or a statement, but listening to all this, and Bob, you may be able to answer this question with your accounting background, but we've talked a lot about loss of tax revenue. You know, we take the number of people, what they would pay in income tax, and you come up with a number that we're going to lose and we have to make up. It leaves a hole in the budget. That's the way the discussion has gone. I'm not an accountant, but the way I look at this, if we don't pass this, it's almost like an income avoidance.
I've worked in cost avoidance, but it's an income avoidance because we're avoiding that income that would be coming into the state. Because these people are not paying taxes now, so we're not losing that tax. We would actually be gaining income. Is that the way you would see that from an
accounting standpoint, Bob? Thank you. Yes. You're not just talking about one person. You're talking about the spouse that is also working, and that job is leaving as well, and they have to be retrained if that job is not replaced.
So we're losing – taxable income is walking out of all four corners of our state every day, and I think that's your question. Yes, it's not just the tax dollars that we're not collecting. It's the income dollars we're not producing. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You bet. Mr. Tice, Representative Fyton,
hold that thought on closing. And, John Tice, if you don't care, please go to the end of the table for us. Recognize yourself.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. My name is John Tice. I'm with the Department of Finance and Administration. Kind of to follow up on Mr. Leiterman's question, I do think I need to remind you of the revenue impact and what that's based upon. Certainly, the governor's presented the balanced budget, and that balanced budget had certain things which you as the legislature have already considered that were part of that budget. This bill was not part of that budget, and adjustments would have to be made accordingly.
The cost that comes, certainly I recognize what Mr. Johnson said and the issues of folks flowing in and flowing out of Arkansas. The impact is based on current tax filings and current reports to DFA. As Mr. Berry said, and we agree with his number, there's about 25,000 current retirees. In addition, there's almost 5,000 additional spouses that currently file and currently pay income tax. and the revenue impact that you have before you is based on the taxes being paid by those existing Arkansas residents.
for DFA? Thank you, Mr. Tice. Representative Fyatt, you
recognize close for your bill, ma'am. Thank you. And we understand that there will not be a vote today, but I thank you for letting us bring this presentation to you. In closing, I asked someone that I trust very much about this issue, and that is my son-in-law, Brian, that many of our military here today know. He was a pilot trainer out at the military base here in Little Rock, in Jacksonville.
And Brian told me that he and his buddies sat around and talked about this all the time as they were approaching retirement, and that all of them said, unless my wife pitches a hissy fit we will not stay in Arkansas because I can cross over the border and take a seven percent increase in my income. In fact I won't be having my money taken away from me if I go to another state and they saw this as better for their families so they were taking their skills and crossing the border. My son-in-law is a FedEx pilot now and he can live
pretty much anywhere where he can fly to Memphis, fly in and out of Memphis. He could have settled in Little Rock, and I guarantee you, my stepdaughter could have kept a baby shop and business all by herself. But they did not settle here. They settled in Tennessee because it was better for them. And there are many, many, many like them, and I would like to see this workforce remain in Arkansas. We spend a lot of money every year to attract tourists, and I'm glad we do. We should. but why are we unwilling to attract this workforce
who will not be here just for a few days they will be here for the long haul let's put out the welcome mat and say Arkansas wants you thank you Mr. Chair, thank you committee thank you
ma'am members anybody want to make a statement or closing statement or anything before we close if not one more time for the veterans we appreciate your guys' service we'll look at this thing in due diligence applause applause applause Representative Fyatt, thank you, ma'am, for bringing this, and this meeting is adjourned.
Agenda
SB570
HB1412
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Joe Jett Chair
Unverified
Speaker 6
Representative Lane Jean
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Patricia Blick
Unverified
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Representative Vivian Flowers
Unverified
Chair
Unverified
Gregory Hamilton
Unverified
Jim Gorday
Unverified
Speaker 75
William Beams
Unverified
Representative Bob Johnson
Unverified
Representative Clarke Tucker
Unverified
Representative Jack Ladyman
Unverified
John Tice
Unverified