Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Revenue & Taxation Committee

March 12, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB356 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Senate Bill 356, please sign in. Thank you, sir. Can you”
Pre-2017 bill
SB756 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Members, we're going to look at Senate Bill 756 now. We're passing some literature out also for that bill a…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1941 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1941”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Of course, Representative Hendricks got to be in education, so he's going to chair 356 while I go to the end of the table without objection. Anybody want to hear us speak against the bill or for the bill for
▶ Play
Speaker 3 0:17
Senate Bill 356, please sign in. Thank you, sir. Can you
▶ Play
Speaker 8 0:30
pull that thing up for me on here? Come on.
▶ Play
Speaker 10 0:37
Maybe I'll show you how to use it.
▶ Play
I know. Mr. Chairman, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 356.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, Senate Bill 356 is something Senator Jake Files and myself have been working on throughout the session. And this bill has to do with claiming unclaimed savings bonds floating out around the United States. Since the 1940s, they've been billions of dollars of savings bonds, unclaimed savings bonds been floating around, and nobody's claiming those bonds. This bill gives the state of Arkansas to claim the unclaimed savings bond through title of those savings bonds to capture that revenue, if you will. So I have Jonathan, please say his last name for me. Compretta. Thank you very much. I have him to answer any questions. So with that, Mr. Chair, with your indulgence, I'm good
▶ Play
to answer. Any representative of me, can you recognize for a
▶ Play
question? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Always good for a question or two. How much money are we talking about here, do
▶ Play
Speaker 23 1:49
you know? Well, nationwide we estimate that there's $16.5 billion of matured, unclaimed U.S. savings bonds proceeds that are sitting in the U.S. Treasury. So there's no way to really get a good figure for Arkansas, but it would be a significant amount. And kind of digging into
▶ Play
the details here a little bit, how would you go about determining whether that would be something that we could claim it as an Arkansas bond? I mean, it would be based upon where it was purchased at, where the person lived. Correct. It would be when you
▶ Play
Speaker 23 2:18
purchase a savings bond, you have to use your address or residence at the time. So it would be bonds
▶ Play
that were purchased at the time that someone lived in Arkansas. Okay. And then the final question I have here is I noticed that after as soon as five years that the state can start making a claim, what was kind of the thought of that process? why five years and not, you know, further out to make sure that it truly has been
▶ Play
Speaker 23 2:45
abandoned? That kind of goes along with other areas that Arkansas has for unclaimed property. It kind of coincides with the law. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, if you're in indulgence, I'd also add Mississippi, Louisiana, Missouri, Kansas, Kentucky, North Carolina, and Iowa all have this also. And this, Representative Meeks, back to your question, I think this goes in line with what the auditor does on unclaimed property as well anyway. And just a point of clarification, the auditor, Representative Lee, is on board with this. And since those other states have done it,
▶ Play
how much have they been able to? The first state to do it is Kansas, and they're actually in
▶ Play
Speaker 23 3:27
litigation with the U.S. Treasury right now trying to get those proceeds because, as you can imagine, the U.S. Treasury is fighting this.
▶ Play
Sure. Okay. All right. Thank you. Any other question? Is
▶ Play
there anybody in the audience? Representative Layman, you're recognized. Just like a general question, but what is the process to make sure that it's, you know, unclaimed? I mean, in general, what's the process to determine that
▶ Play
Speaker 23 3:58
it's unclaimed? The way this statute reads, it would be five years that a bond would have to have been matured and unclaimed, And then two years after that, so a total of seven, the state would have to go to court here in Arkansas to have a judge determine that the bonds are unclaimed, abandoned, and that it's cheated to the state. And then from that point in time, the state would have to make a claim to the U.S. Treasury to try to gain access to the records to determine which bond proceeds up there would meet that definition. Even after that, there's a provision, if you look at line 23 of the bill, that even after the state has taken title, someone can still provide a, if they make a valid claim, those proceeds can be paid to them.
▶ Play
Speaker 14 4:49
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Meeks. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman, for your indulgence. And that brings me up to another question. When those bonds are purchased from the United States from the federal government, is there anything within those provisions that says if it's abandoned that that money just stays with the federal government? At what point, and this may be why the litigation is occurring, at what point would we as a state since we didn't pay, it was just somebody that happened to live here at the time how would we be able to claim rights
▶ Play
Speaker 23 5:21
on that money versus the federal government? There's a regulation at the U.S. Treasury that says that they'll recognize if a state takes title to the bond through a valid judicial proceeding, that they will recognize that right. They're now kind of going back on that saying the states don't have that right. States have tried to take custody of these bonds in the past to try to reunite them with the original owner or the rightful owner, and they've been fought by the U.S. Treasury trying to do that. Okay. All right. Thank you. Any other
▶ Play
questions? anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill speak for the bill Mr. Representative Jetty if you close for your bill yes sir Mr. Chairman I am closed what's the pleasure of the committee motion do pass Representative Layton all in favor say aye all opposed no motion carried thank you Mr. Chairman thank you members
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 6:22
Thank you.
▶ Play
Members, we're going to look at Senate Bill 756 now. We're passing some literature out also for that bill as well. Anybody here that's not signed in to speak for or against the bill, please do so.
▶ Play
Good morning, Representative Bragg. How you doing, sir? Just fine. When you get ready, you're ready to go, sir. Okay, thank you, Mr. Chair, and I have with me Mike Shannon and Tom Gibbons that will want to say a few comments, too, but I'll introduce this bill. This bill concerns some changes that have been made by the assessment coordination department in the way billboards are assessed for real property tax purposes. Billboard valuation for ad valorem taxes in Arkansas has historically been done using the cost approach and with a straight-line depreciation of 16 years. This is what the ACD has recommended for the assessors to use for quite a few years. There's three accepted methods of valuation. One is income, one is the sales comparison, and one is the cost approach. With the income method, it requires knowing the net operating income of a business, and this could be difficult to find out that kind of information when it comes to trying to value a billboard asset. The sales comparison approach is much like real estate uses. If you're selling a house in a neighborhood, then they go find a house of comparable size and characteristics and look for sales in that area that are similar to that. But it also requires a verifiable value for that. This would be difficult with billboards because sometimes they're sold in groups. You might sell one billboard at a time. You might sell several at a time in a group. So it would be difficult to do a comparable sales approach for that. Because of the difficulty of these methods, the ACD recommends that these structures be valued using the cost approach. as real estate, and this provides a uniform method of evaluation. Let me read something from the guidelines that come from their manual. It says, Due to the many difficulties inherent in the appraisal of billboards when applying the sales comparison and the income approach to value, ACD recommends that for assessment purposes in Arkansas, these structures should be treated as real estate and appraised using the cost approach with the exception of digital display faces, which should be classified as personal property due to their shorter economic lifespan. The cost approach provides an efficient methodology to uniformly value billboard structures. The replacement costs new, less depreciation, avoids the complicated allocation process and other issues associated with the income and sales comparison approaches. So let me emphasize the requirement here to appraise as real estate with a uniform valuation. The Arkansas Code 26-1-101 says real property and lands means not only the land itself, whether laid out in towns or otherwise, with all things therein contained, but also all buildings, structures, improvements, and other fixtures of whatever kind they're on and all rights and privileges belonging in or anywise appertaining thereto. So the cost approach has been an accepted method of valuation for these billboards for years. It provides a uniform valuation, and the cost in one county would be the same as in another county, and that's what provides the uniformity for it. It's determined by a pretty detailed guideline. It depends on the size, the square footage of the sign, whether it's a single sign, stacked sign, single pole, multi-pole. So it's a very, very good guideline to use for valuation and provides a good uniform method across the state. This procedure has been in place for years and has been proven very effective over the years. But this year, ACD has adopted several additions to the valuation method that not only conflict with their stated guidelines, but it also adds variability in the uniformity of the assessment. And they have added what's called a location adjustment factor. It's based on traffic count around the sign. And a multiplier or an adjustment factor, it could range anywhere from a 1.0 to 1.95 based on the range of an average daily traffic count around that sign. Now, traffic count is an intangible property. It cannot be considered a structure or a part of the fixture of the sign. in Arkansas Code 26-3-302A exempts all intangible personal property from the ad valorem taxation. It states all intangible personal property in this state shall be exempt from all ad valorem tax levies of counties, cities, and school districts in the state. So the use of this location adjustment based on traffic count is clearly an illegal taxation of intangible property. It also creates a non-uniform taxation across the state by using an arbitrary measure of value based on the traffic count. If you can think of a sign out in the middle of a bean field on Interstate 40 with a traffic count of 30,000 or 40,000 cars per acre or per sign or per day, it is the same value as a sign next to a Walmart in a smaller town that might have 7,000 cars per day. So it's just a very arbitrary method. They've also made a change in the depreciation schedule. It has been a 16-year straight-line depreciation, which provides for uniformity across the state. It's been changed to 20-year for wooden structures with what's called an effective life, and it's been doubled to 40 years for metal structure. Now, the effective life means an appraiser could go out and look at a 15-year-old sign and in his judgment say, well, that sign doesn't look like it's but maybe five years old and affect the depreciation schedule on that sign. So the cost approach is the recommended method. It provides uniformity. The location factor adds the taxation of an intangible property to the valuation, which is illegal according to the code. And the depreciation method adds a totally subjective valuation also. So this bill does not reduce any taxes currently in place. It's not a reduction to the counties in revenue. It merely prevents a tax increase. So this bill retains the status quo of the way the valuation method is being done now. At this time, I'd like to let Mr. Mike
▶ Play
Shannon. Thank you. My name is Mike Shannon. I'm an attorney with the Qualabomb Grooms and Toll Firm. I'm here representing Lamar Outdoor Advertising and the Arkansas Outdoor Advertisers Association. I appreciate your time. The major points I want to make are, number one, the taxes are not reduced by this bill. In fact, this bill actually increases the depreciation period from 16 years to 20 years, that is, from what was recommended previously. What this bill does is it averts a 300% to 400% tax increase, a tax increase that was subjected to no legislative oversight, was not subjected to the vote of any people in any county, and it wasn't even subjected to a rule-making process by the Assessment Coordination Division. That's not where tax increases should come from. They should come from the legislature or they should come from a vote of the people. It stops a tactic not used anywhere else in the nation is this traffic count adjustment. Not a single state in the nation applies such an adjustment for good reason because it creates an illegal tax on intangible property. Finally, what this bill does is it protects small businesses and landowners from absorbing this massive tax increase. If this tax increase goes through, billboard companies will have less money to pay to landowners in lease amounts, and they'll have to charge more money to companies like Brown's Country Restaurant and Store, who advertise this. the Blackwell Travel Center, U.S. Pizza, Galloway Inn, Pest Control, Adams Pest Control. These are the people who are going to absorb this 300 to 400 percent tax increase that the Assessment Coordination Division wants to levy. It does three things, this bill. It makes sure off-premise advertising signs are valued using the cost approach, and that's cost to construct as new. And as Representative Redd, that is consistent with the ACD's own guidance. The ACD recognizes that the cost approach provides an efficient methodology to uniformly value billboard structures. and it, and I'm quoting, avoids the complicated allocation process and other issues associated with the income and sales comparison approaches. That's the ACD's own language. They do that, they say that, and then they throw in something that nobody, no other state in the nation has done is a traffic count adjustment. And the traffic count adjustment has nothing to do with the cost to construct as new. The billboard costs the same to construct in Faulkner County as it does in Grant County, as it does in Washington County. It doesn't cost any more to construct just because there's more cars running in front of that particular board. The second thing this bill does is it eliminates that illegal traffic count adjustment, which I've just said has nothing to do with the cost to construct. And finally, it sets the method for determining depreciation. and that period is a longer period than what has been recommended by the ACD in the past decades with regard to depreciation periods for billboards. As we say, Arkansas Code Annotated 26-3-302 prohibits the taxation of intangible properties, but the assessors are trying to do just that with their taxation of the permit that is required for a billboard to operate. It would be like taxing a radio station's tower in a property tax situation to include the license that that radio tower has to have to operate. We don't do that. It's undisputed that the use permits across the country are intangible property. Without a permit to operate, that billboard is worth nothing more than the steel. and so that's what we tax we tax the cost to construct as new we don't increase it we don't include goodwill or blue sky or those kind of those things are already being taxed in our income tax those things are already being taxed other ways where this bill avoids double taxation As I said, tax increases should come from one of two places, the legislature or a vote of the people. Neither one of those happened here, and we didn't even get any rulemaking procedures, so no due process was applied to this guide that the Assessment Coordination Division has tried to put out to its assessors. We had no recourse other than try to run this legislation. As I said, the companies believe that we're looking at a 300% to 400% tax increase. Under what circumstances would anybody want a 300% to 400% tax increase on their businesses and the property that their business owns? Nobody. It's not fair, and we should stop it. again who's going to ultimately foot the cost of this bill it's the landowners and the people that pay to advertise on this bill and we would appreciate a good vote and I'd like to introduce Mr.
▶ Play
Gibbons at this time Mr. Gibbons recognize yourself
▶ Play
for the record please and if you don't care I'm not trying to be belligerent to y'all we got about a million people signed up to talk for and against this bill so just try to keep our remarks just a little bit briefer If
▶ Play
Speaker 57 20:45
you don't care for me, please, sir. I'll be brief, Mr. Chairman. My name is Tom Gibbons, Vice President and General Manager for Lamar Outdoor Advertising at a Little Rock. Thank you, sir. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today. You bet, sir. Chairman and committee members. I just wanted to run through really a brief model of what we do day to day. I want to use, for instance, a piece of property in St. Francis County along I-40. We may have a billboard site there. We pay a lease to the landowner. That landowner, annually we pay him a certain set income for having the right to have the sign on the property. He pays taxes on that income. That particular location is going to generate tax dollars for the state by reaching the transient traffic that's running up and down I-40. if a 400% tax increase is placed upon our industry as Mr. Shannon stated where the burden is going to fall either the landowner's payment is going to be reduced or the advertiser's payment is going to be increased and what I say to that is why would you want to put a burden and more of an increase on someone who is trying to promote business out of their pocket and, in some cases, spend money to advertise for public service. That was one thing I wanted to cover. Second thing I wanted to cover was you may hear in the opposition that Lamar recently is considered a REIT, which is a real estate investment trust company. That is merely the IRS federal determination, and it has nothing to do with state property taxes. The benefit of our corporation and to the investors is that in a REIT, the income tax that we would normally pay is passed out to the investors in a dividend, and, of course, the investors pay the income tax on the dividend payments.
▶ Play
That's really all I have to cover. And on the read issue, I just want one thing is that this bill does not prevent the billboards from being treated as personal or real property. That's not an issue that we're talking about here. Representative
▶ Play
Bragg, you good to answer your question, sir? Yes. On page 2, line 20, when you're looking at the, I'm sorry, line 27, the 20%, how did you guys come up with the 20%?
▶ Play
20% is a residual value. It's consistent with what other states use near us, and it's not the value that it's taxed to begin with. That is the lowest value at the end of the depreciation period. So really what you're saying is market, a
▶ Play
standard market. At the end of your depreciation period,
▶ Play
it's not going to go any lower than that. You start out at a depreciation period of 100%. It's worth 100% of the cost to construct as new. If that goes down as you depreciate, as you go throughout your depreciation schedule, it will go no lower than 20%. So there's been some misreporting on that issue to think that billboards are only being taxed at 20% of value. That is not correct. That is the bare minimum at the end of
▶ Play
the depreciation period. Thank you very
▶ Play
much. Representative Lemons, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Throughout the document or throughout the bill, I've noticed, specifically it shows up on line 16, subparagraph B, the term off-premise advertising. Just for clarification, I understand that that pertains to a billboard. However, if someone has a billboard on their property, would that also be
▶ Play
exempt? If they are, yes, if they are using it to advertise off-premise advertising. But what if they are advertising their own
▶ Play
business right there on their own billboard? That's technically an on-premise sign. So would that still be exempt from, or would that still be included in this bill?
▶ Play
It's not included in this bill, but it's also not included in the guidance that the ACD has put out that we disagree with. So it's really not an issue
▶ Play
one way or the other. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. You bet. Representative Meeks, you recognize her. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Having worked with those two gentlemen on another bill recently, it's good to see you all again. The questions that I have is on this change that the ACD has done here, according to your testimony, I'm hoping they're going to be here to testify, but it's kind of troubling that they would do something like this and not bring it before the legislative body, especially considering the recent passage of Issue 1. When did they come up with this new rule or new
▶ Play
way of doing the assessment, do you know? Right. We saw a draft of the guideline mid to, I guess, late summer, early fall sometime at that time in 2014, and I believe the guide was published a few weeks before Governor Hutchinson's order with regard to making sure that any new regulations come before it get reviewed to determine what impact they're going to have on businesses. So they got that in before that happened. Kind of under the wire, that sounds like.
▶ Play
Yes. Okay. The next question that I have is, according to your testimony, that they are wanting to evaluate these based upon traffic counts, and this may be better left for them. Have they given you any indication who's going to do those traffic counts, who's going to pay for those traffic counts, how that's going to come about?
▶ Play
I think they're going to use, to the extent they can, traffic counts from the Arkansas Highway Department. I don't know how accurate those would be for particular signs or particular locations, so I don't know exactly what the source of that data is going to be.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Representative Jane, you recognize, sir? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I want to get clear because y'all were talking about the additional revenue assessment coming in to the future date.
▶ Play
This is not in place right now. Is this correct? Well, it is for 2014. It has been placed upon their website as the guidance and the recommendations that the Assessment Coordination Division gives to the 75 county assessors and the way they're telling them to value billboards. So it is currently, and I know at least one county, I think Crawford County, has already attempted to do that even before this guidance moved ahead of it. But it is the current recommendation of the ACD.
▶ Play
Well, I guess what I'm asking, because this will be assessed on property tax, and property tax is always a year lagging, so I guess in May we'll start getting our new property tax. Will that be included? Of course, you've got until October to pay it. Will that be included on this new method of assessing? I presume that what will
▶ Play
happen is they'll be assessed, It may already have been assessed as of January 1 of this year. Of course, we pay in arrears, and we won't ultimately pay for that until 2016, but it is in effect as we speak now. We just hadn't paid for
▶ Play
it yet because it's lagging. That's right. That's right. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
You bet. Representative Collins, you're recognized,
▶ Play
sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And what I'm just trying to understand a little bit, because it's highly unusual that somebody would change a tax structure to double or triple or dramatically increase taxes in such a one fell swoop type of an approach. In fact, the only times I tend to see that in our society is when we've kind of made a collective judgment that a product or service has moved from the goods and services camp into the sin camp. and we will dramatically increase taxes to try and eliminate something or reduce that behavior. And so I'm just trying to get a sense. Is the eyesore criticism, do you think that's underneath some of this or is this just about a different way of thinking about the money? I'm just trying to get a handle on what is driving such a, to me, wildly significant change in how we tax a business industry. It's
▶ Play
hard for me to speculate what's in the minds of the folks that put this in, but I believe that they view it as a way to increase significantly the revenue that comes into the counties without subjecting that to anybody that's accountable to the people of the state of Arkansas, either the voters themselves or the legislature here that you're accountable to your residents and so it's a way to increase taxes without increasing taxes without going through the hoops that you got to jump through to increase taxes whether or not there's any sort of animus with regard to billboards and and people not liking billboards I don't know it's possible but it may be it may be part of the thinking that listen hey people don't there are people out there who don't like billboards and so that's a way that we can kind of maybe slip this in and nobody will see. So that may be exactly what you're thinking there. Representative Landerman,
▶ Play
you recognize, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just to try to get an idea of the impact of this, if this change went into effect, do you have an estimate or a number on the total number of businesses in Arkansas that might be affected by this, and, you know, what is the estimate of the total
▶ Play
financial impact? Well, it's hard to do because it's in each individual company. I mean, but this will, our estimate, based on the numbers that we run, are 300 to 400 percent increase in our property taxes. We believe there are approximately 4,500 separate landowners that we lease land from, I don't know how many different local businesses that you rent from, 50,000 plus different businesses that use billboards to advertise their own businesses, advertise where to get off the interstate to get to their restaurant, where to see their pest control, what number to call to get their service. that's what we're talking about here so it's hard to do like I say this was not a rule so it wasn't subject to any sort of requirement that a fiscal impact statement be done it was just a guide and that's the part of the problem that we have with
▶ Play
this increase follow up Mr. Chairman could I have a follow up yes sir you can we talk about billboards here it doesn't say billboards anywhere in this bill just a question that came to my mind Could this not apply to TVs and other things that are used to advertise off-site products? And the only example I can think of, but I know there's others, when I pull up to a gas station and I pump gas, there's a TV there, and they're advertising things that do not belong to that gas station. Is that
▶ Play
not the same thing? It would be. That's why we try to use the off-premises advertising sign. That's the name of this. And so the TVs that you pull up, I don't know how those are valued, whether they're valued as personal property or real property or what goes into that. So I really can't testify as to whether that would be included. I can tell you what an off-premise advertising sign is a billboard. It is a space that gets leased by the owner of the billboard to advertisers that want to place advertisements there. Some of those are digital, some of those are static, and so you talk about having TVs. So that's typically what we're doing. But I don't think this would affect the smaller TVs that you're talking about because I don't think they're going to want
▶ Play
Speaker 57 33:55
to put those over onto real property. If I could add, it probably would most likely impact any corporations, media companies. that had contracts with cities for bus benches, bus shelters, signage of that type would be considered off-premise
▶ Play
signage. Thank you. Representative Speaks, you recognize ma'am.
▶ Play
Thank you. I wanted to ask, was this really brought about by just the ACD or is this the assessors that's pushing this? Who's really behind all of this?
▶ Play
I think the assessors were certainly involved in the meeting, and I think if you ask the ACD, they'll say that the assessors asked them for some method to value billboards. And so I can't, again, can't put my mind into each and every assessor and what they wanted or didn't want. but the guide was certainly put together by the ACD and I'm sure they had input from the assessors
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, I'm going to be asking ACD to come up and testify here shortly Are you finished, ma'am? Mr. Vice Chair, you're
▶ Play
recognized, sir Thank you, Mr. Chairman I was out and missed some of this This bill raises a lot of questions. Some of us old-timers have been around a long time, and it impacts three or four things that have bothered me for a long time, and maybe you can help me deal with this and try to answer it. As I understand what this bill does, you're saying that even though the billboard costs so much, we're going to tax how much taxes you pay on it, but how much income it generates because of where it's located. Is that somewhere right? Well, the
▶ Play
bill prevents that from happening. That's right, but that's what the ACD is
▶ Play
doing with this. This bill is trying to prevent that, correct? That's correct. Well, let me ask you three or four questions that really come to mind. We own some chicken houses, about four of them, and they're worth about probably a million dollars if you go to replace them or more. And what I found, there are two things that put the fear of God in me. One is when I look in my rearview mirror and see a state trooper behind me or when I'm sitting comfortably on my couch and I look out the window and here comes a red car in the driveway with ACD or assessor down the side of it. Because it's probably going to cost me both ways. And in Arkansas, as I understand it, there are two ways you can get your property taxes raised. One, you can vote on it, which we agree. The other is the assessor can come and assess it. And they'll do that if you build something on your house, a back room or an outhouse or whatever. Before you know it, it's been increased your appraised value. so my question is is that if we're if we're going to do that and we're going to assess this this becomes assessing intangibles and with regards that to the chicken house illustration I put on them on the million-dollar chicken farm or whatever it is or cattle whatever if it's livestock you're going to pay a tax on property tax on that but if I take that million dollars and I buy Apple stock because they got the new watch out there's a fancy if I buy Apple stock Doc, how much property tax do I pay on the stock that I've taken that million dollars out of that chicken house and put into Apple?
▶ Play
How much is the property tax on that? I don't believe they charge you property tax on Apple stock. Or
▶ Play
maybe I could take that to a million dollars and buy a CD down at my local bank. How much tax is there
▶ Play
on that? I don't believe there's any property tax on that. Certainly, as you make income on that CD, you're going to have to report that and pay income tax just like billboard
▶ Play
companies. That's what I put on my stock as well, right? Yes, sir. So I can either walk through the chicken house and pick up dead chickens through the manure every day and pay property tax on it, or I can buy Apple stock and not pay any property taxes and set up and watch television, I guess. So that's what prompts some of my questions to say this, is that are we moving in that direction to tax these other things? For instance, if you have a radio station, you have a license to do that, an FCC license. Is this step that they're looking at here on these billboards, Does that mean you've got to have an FCC license to get on the air? Well, any time you sell one of those things, that has value. The license, the franchise, if you're a car dealer, you've got to franchise. Is this a step that we're trying to prevent here to move towards taxing all those things?
▶ Play
I believe so, Your Honor. I mean, Your Honor, I'm a lawyer. He's certainly good with it, Your Honor. He likes it,
▶ Play
Your Honor. Don't pump him up. Please don't pump him up. I'm taking too long here, and Mr. Chairman, let me, but I just, maybe this is the wrong person, but I hope somebody in the discussion of this day will answer those questions and what we're doing here, because I'd like to understand it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
I think it would prevent that, and I think it would prevent, you're already paying income taxes that you're making off the chickens that you sell, and you're paying real estate taxes on the houses. You don't want to pay real estate tax on the house and the income, and then pay
▶ Play
income taxes as well. Representative Fyatt, you
▶ Play
Speaker 75 39:09
recognize, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Under this bill, if I'm understanding properly, a sign built on the interstate and then a sign built on the secondary road, they would be taxed equally? Is that correct? As
▶ Play
far as property tax is concerned, that's true. If they generate different amounts of income, certainly you pay different amounts of income tax on that, but that's not what we're talking about today.
▶ Play
Okay. Members, no other question from the community? I'm going to ask folks from ACD to come up. I think Representative Meeks got a couple questions for those folks. I think we have the new director as well with us. Gentlemen, if you don't care, when you get to the end of the table, just recognize yourself for us, and you're good to go.
▶ Play
Speaker 117 39:59
Dan Seibert, Assessment Coordination Department. Bear Chaney, the new director of the assessment coordination department. This is my second day on the job, so I'm going to let Dan be the one to answer the questions. He's been working on this since it started. I'm sorry,
▶ Play
Speaker 28 40:18
sir. Go ahead. I was just going to answer questions or I can make
▶ Play
a brief statement. Representative Meeks, do you have a question for him,
▶ Play
sir? Yeah, and maybe in that, then that can get into your statement as well. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The question I have is, you know, as we've heard, this is an increase in taxes, and I'm interested in hearing your response. And if this is an increase in tax, I'm very troubled that this new methodology has occurred without coming before this legislative body. So can you please kind of address that for us? Okay. It's not
▶ Play
Speaker 115 40:56
an increase in tax. It's an equalization in tax. The assessors came to us. Let me just give you a brief history. Yes, please. In June of 2013, at the annual Arkansas Assessors Summer Meeting, the county assessors asked ACD to research and develop a billboard valuation guide that could be used statewide by all 75 counties. They felt this was needed because currently there was no standardized method in the valuation of billboards like there is for other types of property. The methods being used to classify and value billboards varied from county to county and in some instances was not being valued at all. This has created numerous conflicts with billboard operators doing businesses in multiple counties. So what we were doing is we provide valuation guides already for commercial properties, residential properties, personal property. There was no guide for billboard valuation, so we developed the guide they could use to develop the billboards. and and that guide
▶ Play
that you developed what did you base that off of did you have discussions among yourselves did you see what other states were doing how
▶ Play
Speaker 115 42:05
did you base that that from the meeting in June of 2013 we started doing research looking at what other states were doing and then we called to open forum type meetings we invited county assessors reappraisal contractors Arkansas Highway and transportation department appraisal staff and members of the billboard industry. And the purpose of the meetings was to provide interested parties an opportunity to provide us comments and feedback that they would like us to consider in the development of the valuation guide. And we also outlined in our last meeting, we outlined what the recommendations was going to be that ACD
▶ Play
Speaker 122 42:43
would put forth in their guidelines. Okay. And then my final question
▶ Play
would be the traffic counts. Where are you going to get that data? How are you going to – because that is a very superfluous number. It varies from season to season, year to year. How are you going to make sure, and how can you have an accurate taxing on that? Are you going to buy that data? Talk to us
▶ Play
Speaker 115 43:10
a little bit about that. No, sir. We'll get the data from – it's already available to the public on the Arkansas Highway Transportation's website. They have average daily traffic counts for the entire state. They have approximately 12,000 permanent count stations. That's where they get that count every year, so they release those numbers on a yearly
▶ Play
basis. Okay, so the assessor would have to go to that closest count station, wherever that is, and look it up and try to go
▶ Play
Speaker 115 43:35
from there? Correct. There's maps so they could look where the billboard's at along with what the traffic county is
▶ Play
for that particular location of the road. And this will be my real final question. How much extra revenue do you anticipate this raising versus
▶ Play
Speaker 115 43:51
what was raised the year prior? I can't give you an estimate on that. I don't have the information available. The information that I would have to have to determine that has not been made available. Compared to what the billboard companies are assessing now, what they turn on their renditions currently, it will say on their renditions like one billboard sign, and it will have a value. In order to compare what the difference is, I would need to know, or we would need to know what type of sign it was, what size of sign it was, how tall the sign was, the age of the sign. So in order for us to compare it to the cost guide, we'd have to know all that information.
▶ Play
Representative Jean, you recognize, sir? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Either one of the gentlemen down there, I'm on rules and regs, and I don't remember this coming through. kind of explain to me why it didn't come through rules and regs and kind of give me the history. Have you all done anything like
▶ Play
Speaker 115 44:53
this in the past? The assessors, they get their values from valuation guides that we provide to the assessors. We use for commercial property, we use Marshall and Swift Valuation Service. There's a residential valuation guide that's put out by our office. There is personal property guidelines. These are all valuation guidelines that we provide to the assessors. They don't have to use those guidelines, but they're there for them to use if they want. So this is not, this is not, this guide, this valuation guide is not a rule
▶ Play
that they have to use this guide. Yes, sir, go ahead. And whatever happens on this bill happens, but would you agree that maybe in the future, if we need to change legislation and rules that this would be a good idea to run if something needs to be changed in the interim the rules and regs committee of legislative council would be a good place to go through something like this. Yes, sir. Thank you. Mr. Vice Chair,
▶ Play
you recognize her. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I've got to get out and get a picture taken down there in a cursey righty building, but I want to get this question in And Mr. Cheney, I'll congratulate you because he's up from my neck of the woods. In fact, our assessor just replaced Debbie Asbury, I believe. And Debbie and I have sparred for the last 15 years down here, and I know it will be better with you. But my question specifically is, this to me, if you do it on billboards, are you fixing to do the same thing on car dealerships and value their franchise? And
▶ Play
Speaker 115 46:32
if not, why not? No, sir. The use of the traffic count for the location factor, to use the cost approach, you determine a cost from a cost manual. And based on sales comparisons, income and expense information, that number developed from the cost manual is developed based on those factors.
▶ Play
That's exactly how you value a franchise for a car dealership. There's so much in that. I mean, what's the difference? And I guess what's the difference on a radio station? The license, based on the coverage that you have with your signal strength, why not value that and put that property tax appraisal on that? Okay. We're not saying that the permit should
▶ Play
Speaker 115 47:15
be valued. We agree that the permit is an intangible. We're not saying that that permit should be valued. I guess to compare this, you could compare this to, since billboards lease advertising space, so they lease space, so you could compare this to an apartment complex. Like in Fayetteville, Arkansas, an apartment complex, you could have two identical apartments, but one that is next door to the University of Arkansas, they are going to be able to generate more rents based on their location compared to an apartment across town. They would also sell that. That apartment complex could sell for a larger value than the apartment complex across town. So the assessors have to determine market value, and the market value includes location.
▶ Play
Representative Lehman, you're recognized, sir. You're recognized, sir. You bet. No, you're good. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. I thought you said Lehman. I'm sorry. I imagine I did. I'm sorry. I have a question or maybe a scenario here, but movable billboards. Have you ever been to Las Vegas and seen these cars that go around and have the billboards on there and they advertise the stuff? Yes. Okay. In Jonesboro, where I'm from, recently the cable company had a spat with other satellites, and so they had one of these movable boards. So my question is, how do you get a traffic count on a billboard like that? That's off-premises. That guide would not
▶ Play
Speaker 115 48:52
apply to the movable billboard. That would be considered personal property since it's attached to a vehicle. Okay, thank you.
▶ Play
Members, any other questions? I'm sorry, Representative Flowers,
▶ Play
you recognize me. Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I just have a couple of questions on both sides. I guess in the first section, I've heard a lot, and it's been explained to be by a supporter of the bill. I guess the analogy that I was given was it would be like if I have a rental property and I'm paying market value on the property and then the change that you all are making would be that you determine what I'm actually making in rents and make an assessment on the market value based upon the money that I'm making as well. would you agree that the analogy is something like that to an
▶ Play
Speaker 115 49:56
extent but your rental property that you're that you're referring to it's already being valued at market value where the billboards are not being valued at market value all we're saying is the billboards should be treated like all other property owners in real estate so so your rental property you're talking about that's already being valued using a cost approach and those cost numbers now a cost guide just has a base number and then you have to adjust that number for location and time if the guide is two years old then you have to make an adjustment for what the construction cost has increased or decreased over that two year period and the location so your guide would be your rental property
▶ Play
is already being treated that way and then I guess The other question I had with regard to what's in the bill in Section 2 and the valuation, how is what's in the bill in terms of the depreciation period different than what you all have been doing before the change? So before you all made these changes, or even with what the changes are now, does defining the depreciation in the legislation, does that make a difference?
▶ Play
Speaker 115 51:13
Yes. Before this, the billboards generally across the state were turned in on personal property renditions. They were self-reported numbers. They were based on an age. They looked in the personal property guide for whatever age the billboard and straight-line depreciation was used. Our guidelines recommend that billboards are treated as real estate. The difference in our depreciation schedule and what we differ is they're saying there should be a 20-year depreciation schedule used for all billboards. But you have wood billboards and you have steel billboards. Our opinion is a wood billboard is not going to last as long as a steel billboard. So there should be a difference in the – what they disagree on our guide is we're saying a 20-year depreciation schedule should be used on wood billboards and a 40-year depreciation schedule used on steel billboards. And that's based off what the research we found on the ages of typical billboards out there that's currently out there right
▶ Play
now. Mr. Chair, can I just have a word? Yes, ma'am, you can. So are these billboards treated and assessed in the way that, say, for example, my land and house are treated as real property? I know you kind of just said that when you referred to it as real property. or are they treated as personal property like a vehicle?
▶ Play
Speaker 115 52:37
They were previously treated as personal property, but after we've looked at what most of the billboard manufacturers have converted their businesses over to REITs, real estate investment trust companies, that's where we recommend, and for the most part, they're a permanent fixture to the ground. They don't move them around. I mean, they can, but they typically don't. So we're saying they should be valued as real estate. So they haven't been valued the same as what the property you're referring to previously. We're just trying to bring it up to a – we're trying to bring everybody up to an equal level playing field where everybody's paying the same – everybody's property is
▶ Play
valued the same. Representative Hodges, you recognize her? Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is going back to Representative Gene asked the question, and it's been brought up about the legality of this process of taxing this billboard. But you mentioned that you provide the assessors with an evaluation process on property, So I'm just confused. Why would it have to be brought to the legislatures to decide on that if it's a process that you already provide for the assessors anyway? Right,
▶ Play
Speaker 115 53:57
and that's why this wasn't brought before rules. It was just the assessors asked us to develop an evaluation guide. We developed the guide, and we published the guide out. We did the research starting in 2013. We released the guide. the assessors wanted something by the start of 2015. So that's why the guide was published on our agency's website at the end of 2014. Got a follow-up?
▶ Play
Yes, sir. So it's really not illegal if you guys have been given the authority to provide that to the assessors and they just implemented it, why would it have to go through another process? Am I correct in thinking that way? Correct. Thank you. Representative Meeks, you recognize?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just a follow-up to that. Since you're publishing it as a guide, based upon your testimony to Representative Gene or Representative Hodges, the assessors don't have to use that. Is that correct? They can still use their own methods, what we've been doing all along? Correct.
▶ Play
Speaker 115 54:58
Previously, they were letting the self-reported values come in. Some counties were using a guide that's published out in North Carolina, which is kind of what this guide has developed from. Okay,
▶ Play
so we've got 75 different counties, 75 different assessors, so we could have 75 different ways of doing this, in other words?
▶ Play
Speaker 115 55:15
You could, but that's why the assessors, they wanted a standardized method, so they asked us to develop a guide that all 75 could use. That way,
▶ Play
everybody was on the same sheet of music. Okay, but there's nothing that says they have to do it, so we could still be going a different direction. Now, if this law passes, then would it create some uniformity across the state with this, or would it still be kind of, you know, every assessor
▶ Play
Speaker 115 55:41
for themselves? Well, they would have to use the guide in conjunction with what the bill states, with what's in the sections of the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 148 55:48
The bill, okay, all right. But there again, it's
▶ Play
Speaker 75 55:57
up to them whether they use the guide or not. Representative Fite, you recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chair. They have a claim here
▶ Play
Speaker 115 56:05
that there will be a 300% to 400% increase. Is that correct? I can't give you that exact number I know it would be an increase from what they're paying I can give you an example over here across Markham Street there's a billboard on the side of the side of the Markham Street right now currently the value that's being rendered by the billboard company is $1,100 total appraised value it's probably about an $11 tax bill a year by using this valuation guide it would put it on at around $20,000, $25,000 is what the value of that billboard would be, so the tax bill would go to $250 a year, but all we're saying is they need to be brought up to what everybody else so it would be it is an increase, but it's not an increase, it's equalizing them compared to what everybody else's, the way everybody else's property is already being valued Members, there's
▶ Play
no other questions We're going to move into the for and the against from the audience, and I recognize I'm representing Elaine Jean. Mr. Chair,
▶ Play
with hearing opening arguments on for and against, I move that we limit debate to 10 minutes
▶ Play
aside. That's a non-debatable motion, members. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, say no. Okay, audience, what that means is we're in a limited debate. We have several folks sign up for and against this. We're going to start off with the Guinness folks. The four folks, keep in mind, Representative Bragg is going to close for his bill. Disregard that. Okay, Representative Bragg, you're not going to be included in the ten minutes, so you'll be free to close for your motion, sir, okay? So we're going to start off with...
▶ Play
Where's the list? Ms. Debbie Ashbury, are you here? Mr. Chairman, committee members, Debbie Asbury of course until two days ago I was the director at the assessment coordination department have been at that department since 1989 and in 2001 was appointed by Governor Mike Huckabee and then was reappointed under Mike Beebe. And so I have a lot of experience in the property tax field. And I'm going to, since Dan was brought up first, and if I refer to him as my employee, just understand that he worked for me for a long time. and I still haven't gotten over the not being there yet. One of the things that I wanted to talk about was that property taxes, all property taxes, especially real estate property, is valued based using the cost approach or the income approach or the sales comparison approach. If this bill would pass, basically there are going to be other people standing in line for this same type of legislation. It doesn't matter whether it's going to be the oil and gas companies. It doesn't matter whether it's going to be real estate, your houses. What this bill basically says, and there are states that have gotten away from using just the cost approach with no location factor applied. It's very simple terms that we all understand that when we buy a house somewhere, you've looked at two different houses, maybe in two different school districts. You may have moved from a county, from a Stone County or Arkansas County, and moved to Little Rock. You may have bought the same type of property, same house, maybe less, because guess what? In Little Rock, you cannot buy the same amount of property that you would buy in another county. What this legislation would do, and like I said, there's just going to be people lining up to make this happen. This is setting one of the worst precedents that could ever be set in this state. And I appreciate Representative Hendren, Senator to me, for recognizing me for fighting against him for the last 15 years because I did on some legislation that he had tried to pass. so basically what this legislation would do it would say that whether you owned a house in st francis county or you owned a house in phillips county if you had a house there that looked like a house out in chenal they would both be valued for the same value not what you're going to buy it for what you're going to pay property taxes on and what that would do is that would that house that you might live in over in St. Francis County that you're living in for $150,000, $250,000 max, you're going to live, you're going to buy it out here and it's going to cost you a half a million dollars, you know, upwards. That is because it is done based on the sales, looking at comparables, not comparables from across the state, but comparables in set different neighborhoods. So the argument is that all of the value in these billboards is intangible. It's not intangible. It's based on their location, no different than a house. The intangible value in a billboard is the $40 that they pay for their permit. The other part of it is based on where they are. If they were all the same and they should be valued the same, why do they rent them differently? They range all the way from, and all we have are costs that are on the major roads. We have lots of information that came from the Beautification Act with billboards. There's probably about 3,900 billboards across the state that are under the Beautification Act. And we roughly guess that there are about, maybe about 3,000 that are on the secondary roads. But here in the metropolitan area in Little Rock, for example, the billboard that they talked about that's right across the street on 3rd Street, that is, they're paying about $11 here. That billboard is 20 years old and it's still standing. it doesn't look like it's about ready to fall down and get moved anywhere so that was the reason for the 40-year depreciation schedule you you can look at anything that you have that's steel do you expect it to be gone in less than 20 years probably not we don't expect our houses to be gone in less than 20 years so just a big general terms and and one of the and this is a story that many people across the state and the assessors will be shaking their head about this I had an old instructor that if you just excuse me just a second
▶ Play
just let you know you're down to about
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:03:51
four minutes for this side so I can do it this is and put it in very very simple terms for every dollar and this is an equalization guideline it's saying they need to be paying exactly what all of us are already paying because we're paying on our houses based on a cost with a factor to adjust it because of where we live so here in Pulaski County but the but the fact is that there are going to be repercussions at the state level because for every dollar that's not collected out there at the local level that people are paying less than they should the Supreme Court has said that you the state you legislators have to find that same dollar somewhere to fund the schools and this the money that's that's here that should be here is unrealized we don't know but as we all know and because it's all the taxes they're just a big vicious circle. So we know that if we have the Department of Ed has to come up with 22 million, 30 million dollars to fund the schools, then guess what? For every one of those dollars, but if there's more collected at the local level, then it is much easier for, then the Department of Ed doesn't have to come up with as much money. And you're looked at as that body to go are you going to increase the sales tax are you going to increase the income tax are you going to increase gross sales tax are you going to increase something else what are you going to increase so for for every dollar that is not collected out there at the local level you the legislators are looked at to try and find that and i know under the um under governor ace's legislation he's trying to wants to find some tax breaks for people that that that totally do deserve them. Ms. Ashbury, you've got two minutes left. Representative
▶ Play
Collins wants to ask a question. Can you take a question from him? Yes. Ma'am, I
▶ Play
think you make some excellent points. One of the points is that we, the legislature, are responsible for raising the revenue. I agree with that. The other point you raised, I think, is a good one, and actually I hope everybody's watching, that in a world where people make what I'm going to consider a pretty significant overreach, and it's not that your points aren't accurate and don't have lots and lots of merit. But billboards did not change last year from what they were 10 years ago, 20 years ago, 30 years ago. And what we've got in business and in industry are certain processes and plans and investment cycles and all of these different things. And when we make a dramatic change to the business environment, we do two things that are very significant. Number one, we create incredible uncertainty, which just kills the confidence in the overall regulatory scheme. And number two, we dramatically change investment payout profiles. So what I would just suggest and get your perspective on is if we can find a way to move in a transitional way in the future with all regulatory agencies versus these big kaboom, all of a sudden the landscape is dramatically different proposals, the legislature won't have to overreach in response, in my view. Does that sound like it's
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:19
fair and makes sense? It totally makes sense. We knew there were some weaknesses out there with billboards. There are other weaknesses out there. And there's only so many things that this department, the assessment coordination department, can do to you take a big boat that needs to be fixed, and it moves very slowly. And this is one of those things that we've seen has needed to be fixed, and the assessors finally said, we don't like this anymore. We're going to ask you to put a guide together for us. And I know there are many, many assessors here, and that should go to show you that they, the same as I, realize that all this is is bringing the billboard industry up to what everybody else is paying. and when you look at what they're going to do overall, you know, the thought is that if they rent a billboard for $1,000 a month they're going to have to raise it to $2,000 that is not going to be the case I don't know what that number would be that would be something you would have to ask them if they had these increases they're going to spread it across those I think they said 50,000 advertisers they're going to spread it across all of them it's not going to be two or three people that are going to take that burden
▶ Play
thank you ma'am Representative Jean you recognize her we have 46 seconds left for the against I
▶ Play
thought an hour and a half would be enough but there's still some more I'd like to make a motion also to add five a side. Would you give five more to and then 15 total for the other side? Yes. That's a motion.
▶ Play
Members, I understand what Representative Gene's asking for. He's asking to add five minutes to the against and then the four of the fours will have a total of 15 minutes. That's a non-debatable motion. Any discussion? I'm sorry. All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? Mr. Sylvester Smith, are you here today, sir? Yes, sir. Please have a seat at the end of
▶ Play
the table and just recognize yourself. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Sylvester Smith, and I am the State Director for the National Federation of Independent Business. Good to be here with you today. I'll try to keep my comments brief and not repeat anything that's been said too many times. This is why I'm here today, and I will say that I do represent some billboard companies, and I have sign owners in my membership. But for us, it's not just about the impact to the billboard company. I've not heard much discussion today about the impact to the actual landowners. I've heard in discussion with some of you that you've been told that the people who will be impacted that are primarily folks who own these big sign companies that are out of state. But there are roughly 4,500 billboard land leases in Arkansas, and all that land is owned by or the predominantly Arkansans own that land. Now, the second part of this new tax scheme that hasn't been addressed is the part that's going to impact the landowners. I'm an attorney. I studied state and local taxation under Tim Leathers, so if I tell you something wrong, you blame Tim. Don't blame me. But the way I read these proposed regulations, if this sheet of paper is my 1,000-acre parcel of land and I'm paying $1,000 for it and then I've got a billboard that sits on this corner, they're going to create a secondary parcel in this corner and they're going to, in addition to the $1,000 I'm paying in property taxes currently, they're going to add another amount due to the fact that I have a billboard lease here. Now that in and of itself, plain and simple, is double taxation. I'm already paying a property tax why should I pay a secondary tax just because I happen to have a billboard there so what they are doing is they are taxing an intangible that intangible being the lease that I've made with the billboard company now I've long respected Senator Hendren and I have to say I agree with him and the main reason I'm here today is not just because of the current impact of this new tax scheme to billboard owners and land owners who lease land to billboard companies but once we say in Arkansas that it is an appropriate means of local taxation to include the value of a lease into the replacement value of an item, where is that going to stop? And I believe that in the next decade we'll be here and we'll be having this fight with radio broadcasters saying now they're trying to tax the value of my radio tower due to the fact that I've got this license and the license makes money. And, Senator, your chicken house, your chicken house is not only a structure, It's also an ongoing business enterprise. They're going to come to you and they're going to say, how much are you making in that chicken house, Senator? We need some of that also. So I think in the broad scheme of this thing is this takes our property tax and it inappropriately considers the activity that is going on or with that property and adds it into the valuation in a way that considers that income and really, in effect, creates a hybrid income tax via the property tax. Now, I'm going to tell you, I've been up here a long time. I've been up here, Senator, you remember my mom, Judy Smith. I came up here as a page. I've been here since I was 15. And the one thing that I've learned in the 23 years that I've been here is when you see the government gore your neighbor's ox, you can sit there silently if you want, but it won't be long before your ox is gored next. So that's why we're here. We need to just set the standard that, first of all, taxation needs to come, it needs to happen through an appropriate process. It needs to either come through the legislature. It needs to come through a vote of a county or local legislative body or a vote of the people. Now, I want to address the other issue as to whether or not this should have come before you. I agree with Representative Meeks. I think that this should come before you, and here's why. No, it's not a regulation, but in the legal realm, we have this concept called color of law, and some things are not laws, but they look like laws, and I've had my members tell me that their county assessor has told them, your property is being valued this way because the law says it should. When something comes out of Little Rock, it might not be a law, but boy, once it gets out in rural Arkansas, it certainly does look that way. And you can't argue with City Hall. So we need some uniformity. We need to give these assessors appropriate guidance. And let me say this very last and very important thing. Assessors play an important role in our government. And they have a job to do, and they're very good at it. Their job is to maximize the value of property to deliver as much revenue as possible to their counties. And the ACD can say all day that, no, we won't ever value car lots this way. I assure you, if you let the camel get its nose under the tent, sometime in the future they will. Because the same traffic count methodology that's being applied to billboards can be applied to any commercial building. The same concept of let's value the revenue that's being applied to billboards can be applied to any going business enterprise that's happening in any commercial building. And, yes, Representative Flowers, residential facilities. They're not taxing houses differently because one of them is a rent house and one of them is single-family occupied. They're not doing that. But if you start letting them do this, yeah, one day they will because I agree, counties need more money. That's all I have, Mr. Chairman, and if someone does have a question that I can answer, I will certainly try. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, you recognize, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The question I had is based upon that 1,000-acre example that you gave. So just make sure I'm understanding what you're telling us is that on that 1,000 acres I put up the billboard instead of increasing the valuation on the total 1,000 acres because of an improvement, if you will. They're not going to do that. They're going to leave the 1,000 acres alone, and then they're going to carve out and slap on another tax on that
▶ Play
little chunk. Yes, sir. I believe it's page 34 of the valuation guide. It talks about billboard land sites. And the second part of that that I didn't mention, a lot of these billboards are sitting on farmland. And here in Arkansas, we value our farmers, and they get special tax treatment with regard to their land. So a part of that new valuation process is that the section of land under that billboard is to now be treated as commercial land, which is taxed at a higher rate. Now, let me tell you, Max Brantley wrote a powerful art blog piece in which he endorsed the process that the assessors are using. And he said that there are properties where there's going to be a 1,500 percent increase. And you heard the ACD staff members say from $15 to $250. Can you imagine your tax bill going up year over year 1,500 percent? No one's told you this is coming. There's no way you can plan for that. What are you going to do? You're going to lay some folks off. You're going to jack up your prices. You're going to renegotiate things with your vendors. And as Representative Collins so eloquently stated, there's no way to plan for that. Now, the whole tenor of this new administration and, frankly, this new conservative majority in this legislative body has been, let's make this state more business friendly. You don't want these companies writing articles in their trade magazines all across the country about how, don't go to Arkansas, your taxes will get shot up 15% year over year. The other
▶ Play
question I have is, and maybe this is a much broader issue. It seems like in the testimony from the ACD that they publish guides, and it seems like there's an awful lot of latitude from county to county to county. In your opinion, is there maybe a bigger issue here that we need to create some more uniformity across the state? Because it seems like there's an awful lot of flexibility in what the assessors do. It's not a shot at the assessors themselves, but it seems like there's a lot of flexibility and a lot of leeway on setting these valuations and these taxes. Representative, I'm a home
▶ Play
rule guy. I believe in home rule, and I believe that the local county ought to be able to set policies as they see fit. And as long as their voters have the opportunity to hold them accountable for said policies, then I have no issue with it. And that's another problem with this. This didn't go before some quorum court where there was public comment, and all the little landowners in that county had an opportunity to hear, hey, my taxes are going up 1,500 percent. Let me go up here and tell them about it. This was basically tax policy that was created via a regulative type model that did not go through the administrative procedures tax. And it's being treated, I promise you, at the local level like it has the power of law, even though, as you've been told, yes, it is a guide. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Flowers,
▶ Play
you have a question, ma'am? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Smith I really appreciate your perspective and the clarity you provided me on this and you really the real estate and rent house analogy you gave me was had an impact on how I thought about it however the last witness also gave me a lot of food for thought because where when we talked You described it as sort of a tax on the income made. She made a pretty salient argument about this really being about market value and how important the comps are from one side to the other and gave the analogy of real estate. So what are your thoughts about that? How would you respond to that? Well, first of all, and again, I
▶ Play
would yield to some of these fellows on that, But my perspective from studying this issue is that billboards should be treated as they have for generations, and that's as personal property, because a billboard can be moved. If you violate the lease, if the lease terminates, if you want to move it, you can. And now they're on vehicles and they're moving around. So they should be treated as they always have been as personal property. I think the key issue where the last speaker talked about was the location valuation. And that certainly is a part of this that would be prohibited by this bill. My primary concern, though, is that the entire scheme is designed to reach into the value. A billboard is two things. It's A, a structure, often made of steel, and it's B, a permitted business enterprise. And they are blurring the lines. No one has a problem with them taxing the steel, the structure. If this thing falls down tomorrow, what would it cost to replace it, just like they do your house? The problem is when they blur the lines and they start taxing the business value of it that is derived from a permit. And that's where we get into the whole issue of taxing intangibles and taxing lease revenue. And the question is, once that starts, where does it stop? And my argument is it won't stop here. It won't stop now. And it won't end with billboards.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Flowers. Representative Fyde, you recognize,
▶ Play
Speaker 75 1:20:35
sir? Mr. Smith, I need a little clarification here. Is Max Brantley for this bill or against this
▶ Play
bill? Max Brantley is 100% against this bill, and frankly, I respect Max, but that would likely be enough to make me for
▶ Play
Speaker 168 1:20:49
it, if I were sitting where you were. Members,
▶ Play
any questions? Mr. Ferguson, you're recognized,
▶ Play
sir. I have one question for Mr. Smith, get some clarity on what you said. Are you telling me that a person who leases a piece of land for billboard purposes, that that individual's personal property taxes will go up? Their real estate property taxes
▶ Play
will go up? Yes, sir. That's what you're saying? Yes, sir. Okay.
▶ Play
Thank you. We're going to go back to Ms. Collier. Ms. Collier, is your name? I'm assuming you're speaking for the bill. Is that correct? Thank you, members. You're welcome. Recognize yourself for the committee, please, and you may proceed. And we're down, members, just be aware we're down to five minutes and
▶ Play
Speaker 174 1:21:48
48 seconds for the fours, okay? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I will be very brief. I think that everyone who has spoken against this bill has done a very excellent job in basically laying out our arguments. I just do have a few comments. First, I would like to let you know that we do have many assessors here today, and if they'd raise their hand so that you can see that they are here. As an association, we are against this bill, and I would like to just let you know a couple of things. I don't want to get into a lot of the details that you've already heard. Assessors by the Arkansas Constitution are mandated to appraise by market value You've heard all of the different approaches, the different ways that we have to do this But that's basically what it all comes down to And I know that's a very simplistic way of saying it But we have to be able to justify our values When we have taxpayers that go to equalization boards in the summer and appeal their values, as the assessor, we have to be able to stand behind those values. And we cannot stand there and say, well, we made everyone else pay market, but not this group. That is not the way our business works, and that is not what we've been mandated to do. And yes, location, location, location. It is a mantra, and that is what we have to look at when we are valuing things. And we really are very strong about allowing a specific industry to begin having special considerations. It is a very dangerous door to walk through. And I would just very like to caution you to really think about that, you know, as you are considering this bill. And, again, I just would like to thank you for allowing me to speak for our association, and I just cannot tell you how strongly we
▶ Play
are against this particular bill. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am. Any questions for Ms. Collier, members? If not, we're down to six minutes and 15 seconds, and we're down to David Hamilton.
▶ Play
Recognize yourself for the members, please. Good morning. I'm David Hamilton. I'm with Sy's Sign Company in Hot Springs, Arkansas. And our company is basically consists of three divisions. We have an electrical sign company for on-premise businesses. We have a graphics division, and we have a billboard division. And basically what I wanted to state was that we believe that the bill is a reasonable method for valuing and taxing billboards. And an important consideration that really hasn't been talked a lot about is the actual application of the bill. It provides a straightforward method to determine the value of the billboards. It provides us a straightforward method to determine the depreciation schedule. It also sets a reasonable ongoing residual value. And the tax method or formula will be easier for businesses to implement and to apply and to determine things on their books, especially businesses that operate in more than one county in the state. The results, I think, will be fair and a reasonable tax, and we would appreciate you voting in favor of it. One last thing I'd like to address is the example that was brought up about location, location, location, and a house here is worth this amount and a house in another part of the city is worth a different amount. That's, to a large extent, captured in the billboard evaluation when you look at the cost method that's proposed by this bill. As an example, with Lamar's structures, a lot of those are on the interstate. Those structures are 14-foot by 48-foot structures. We don't even have any billboards that big. In our area in Hot Springs, most of our billboards are 12 by 24. So they're half the size of the structure. So Tom, who testified earlier, in his company, a lot of those billboards will almost automatically be worth twice as much under this because their location is on the freeway. Ours, which are on secondary roads, are smaller structures, and they would naturally be valued less. So I did want to make that one point on the location issue.
▶ Play
Thank you. I'll get Representative Gene back in his chair, and he's going to be recognized for a
▶ Play
question here. Not a motion, but a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Hamilton, and I'm just going to ask this, and you may not know, but maybe somebody that follows up on either side can tell me before we cut off debate, is if this passes, will the counties lose any revenue?
▶ Play
Do you know? They should gain revenue from this. They'll gain revenue, but
▶ Play
they won't gain as much if it doesn't pass. Is that correct? That's correct. Do we kind of have an idea? And just for anybody else coming up later on, do you have any idea what margin we're talking about? I can't answer that question. Well, maybe somebody else will sneak it in. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Excuse me. I'm giving you a promotion, Mr. Chair. As long as I get
▶ Play
a pay raise with it, I'll be all right. Members, any other questions for this gentleman? If not, thank you, sir. Anybody else here against want to speak against the bill? There is two minutes and 47 seconds for against the bill. If not, is there Jim Madelone? Please come to the end of the
▶ Play
Speaker 185 1:28:29
table and recognize yourself, sir. Hi, Jim Madelone with Ashby Street Outdoor Advertising in Fayetteville, Arkansas. I appreciate you giving me some time. My company, we have a relatively small business, all Arkansas-based. All of our locations are in Arkansas. The effect of not having this bill based on the recommendations from the counties would put a serious impact on us. We pay a substantial amount of property taxes now. This would, in effect, I mean, obviously raising rates to advertisers is relatively unrealistic because rates are so sensitive now. What would really happen is I would probably lose revenue by losing advertisers in an attempt to raise rates. And based on my staff of eight people, probably what would happen with the threefold increase would be I would have to lay off one or two of my eight people I have on staff. So it's just a dramatic increase. I don't know. I've heard some people say it's not a tax increase. I can tell you that when you're paying a certain amount every year and all of a sudden now you have to pay three times more than that, that feels like a tax increase to me. So I appreciate your consideration.
▶ Play
That's pretty much all I have. Thank you, members. Anybody have questions? If not, I think that's just about finishing up for the for and against. Representative Bragg, are you ready to close for your
▶ Play
bill? I think everybody at the table is. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think we all are. We've heard a lot of testimony, and I'll be brief. There was mention made of the Constitution. I'd like to read a section of the Constitution concerning this issue. It says, All real and tangible personal property subject to taxation shall be taxed according to its value, that value to be ascertained in such a manner as the General Assembly shall direct, making the same equal and uniform throughout the state. The ACD has recommended the cost approach to valuation, not income or comparable sales. When you start talking about market value, you get into more of an issue of comparable sales. The location has been mentioned. Location takes into account when the owner negotiates a lease price with his customer. That customer will realize a value, a lesser or greater value in it. There was mention made of need for income for schools. Well, everybody understands that need, but let's go through the legislative or elective process to meet that need. By introducing the traffic count adjustment, you've created, I like the word Mr. Smith used, a hybrid approach to valuation, and you get away from the cost approach, and you're getting into assessing an intangible asset, which according to our statute is against the law. We're not asking for special consideration. We're merely asking in this bill to not increase taxes. It does not reduce any current revenue that any county or school is receiving. We're just merely, in this bill, asking to maintain the status quo. And I'll close with that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Appreciate a good vote. Thank you, Mr. Leader. Members, I think
▶ Play
we just kind of beat this thing pretty good, so we'll take a motion. Motion to do pass. I have a motion for do pass. Any discussion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. Ayes have it. Congratulations. You passed your bill, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. You're welcome. Members, we're going to let the room kind of clear out a little bit, and we'll move on. We've got one or two more here that we're going to try to take for lunch. Is Representative Gates in the room? Representative Neal, you good to run your bill, sir? Members, this is going to be House Bill 1941. I did not shoot this to you yesterday in the text, but Representative Neal is wanting to run this bill, and we're good, and we have a little time, so we're going to knock this out. So House Bill 1941. Anybody in the audience want to sign in or against this bill, please do so now.
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:32:55
Representative Neal, we're good to go, buddy, when you are. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, committee. This bill will exempt the advertising and promotion tax info that individual restaurants and hotel motels collect from the FOI Act. the press and public will still be able to get the total A&P tax collected in the city, which is reasonable just not what each individual pays in. This will protect the private gross profit information of these businesses from being put in the paper for their competitors to see.
▶ Play
It's a pretty simple bill. I have a question, Representative. Are you good? You good, Ripson
▶ Play
Davis? Ripson Davis, you're good, sir. Go ahead. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Neal, does this in any way exempt any information from FOI that would be related to a city's campaign or other process to try to change how A&P taxes are either collected or spent or raised or has it anything to do with exempting anything from a city or other municipalities that may have
▶ Play
Speaker 190 1:34:07
an A&P tax? No, sir. All this does is keeps individual businesses, restaurants and hotels, what they each individually collected out of the paper. That's it. So only exempting private businesses
▶ Play
information, nothing from the cities. That's right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Landman, you recognize, sir. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Representative, is there any organized opposition to this bill that you know of?
▶ Play
Not that I know of. Thank you. Members, any other questions? Anybody nod, he's going to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative Neal, you closed for your bill, sir? Yes, sir. What's the motion do pass? Representative Meeks, motion do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations. You have passed your bill. Representative Mickey Gates, are you in the room? if not members we're going to adjourn I think this is what we're going to do Tuesday morning we'll make plans we've got a couple more long bills so right now we're going to plan to go on Tuesday morning and then upon adjournment we might be coming back staff's going to put it on the calendar right now come back upon adjournment 30 minutes after adjournment back in this room take care of some more bills so with that being said we are adjourned
▶ Play

Agenda

SB356

0:13 - 7:08 32 segments 10 speakers

SB756

7:08 - 1:32:41 261 segments 26 speakers

HB1941

1:32:41 - 1:35:24 9 segments 4 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Joe Jett Chair Unverified
42 segments
Speaker 3
1 segment
Speaker 8
1 segment
Speaker 10
1 segment
Representative Kim Hendren Chair Unverified
16 segments
Chair Unverified
19 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
23 segments
Speaker 23
10 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 14
1 segment
Representative Ken Bragg Unverified
19 segments
Anthony Roulette Unverified
41 segments
Speaker 57
7 segments
Representative Tim Lemons Unverified
3 segments
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
11 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
7 segments
Representative Nelda Speaks Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 75
3 segments
Speaker 117
1 segment
Speaker 28
1 segment
Speaker 115
30 segments
Speaker 122
1 segment
Representative Vivian Flowers Chair Unverified
8 segments
Representative Monte Hodges Chair Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 148
1 segment
Sylvester Smith Unverified
21 segments
Speaker 168
1 segment
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 174
5 segments
Lawrence Williams Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 185
3 segments
Speaker 190
2 segments
Representative Andy Davis Chair Unverified
3 segments