Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Agriculture, Forestry, and Economic Development

March 20, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (6)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1620 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…e are now going to move on to our special order of business house bill 1620 representative servilo you are recognized, sir. Let me take…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB855 · 4 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…now recognize Representative Lane Jean for the re-referred Senate Bill 855. Representative Jean, you are recognized, or Chairman Jean,…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB120 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…clearly, how I would like to point the significant parts of HB 120. First, the bill defines what a commercial breeder in Arkan…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1569 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “and that would be let's see which bill house bill 1569 you're recognized for your amendment thank you”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1839 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1839”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1859 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1859”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Billo's bill at 9 o'clock, 1620. We're going to go ahead and get started with a few preliminary things. The chair now recognizes Representative Camille Bennett. Representative Bennett, you are recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And I'm looking
▶ Play
for the bill number. 1838. Thank you. So regarding bill number 1838, I just want to say I ask that this bill be withdrawn, and we have been working diligently with the University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff to resolve this matter. I want to thank everybody so much for their help here, and hopefully we'll move forward with a much better relationship and thank the committee for their indulgence. Anybody want to say anything else? Okay, so
▶ Play
you are withdrawing your bill then. Yes, sir. Thank you. Okay, thank you. representative all right next up uh representative vault do you have an amendment to your bill and that would be let's see which bill house bill 1569 you're recognized for your amendment thank you
▶ Play
mr chair it's my bill my amendment i had a actually had a misspelled word on there so i'd appreciate
▶ Play
a good vote any questions from the membership anybody speak against the bill for the bill. Representative Eubanks, you're recognized for a motion. Motion do pass. Motion do pass. As amended. The amendment. All in favor signify by saying aye. Opposed? Representative Vaught, your amendment is passed. Thank you Mr. Chair. Now run your bill. The bill is the same bill
▶ Play
as it was before and the only difference was that we left non off so it was just
▶ Play
Speaker 18 1:57
a mistake it was just she left it off she didn't mean to so all right
▶ Play
are you opposed for your bill yes sir any questions from the committee anybody speak against the bill for the bill representative payton you're recognized for a motion motion do pass as amended all in favor signify by saying aye opposed your bill is passed Congratulations, Representative Vaught. We now recognize Representative Lane Jean for the re-referred Senate Bill 855. Representative Jean, you are recognized, or Chairman Jean, Your Most Highness, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 20 2:41
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You need to kind of watch these titles. members of the committee
▶ Play
we passed this bill out 855 which is the abandoned unpaved road easement bill that was passed out Wednesday with some input from the general assembly we have added on page 2 line on this amendment it strengthens the right of people that was I hearing something? a cricket? it was in your head sir
▶ Play
go ahead with your bell okay we are
▶ Play
in the agri committee uh but anyway what this does on on page two it strengthens for people that are uh landowners that have to have ingress and egress through this property it gives it stronger language that they will have ability to cross this property and also hunting leases people that have that rent hunting leases will be able to cross these private roads And that's the amendment, and I move that
▶ Play
we adopt the amendment. Representative Jean has moved that we adopt the amendment. Are there any questions from the committee for Representative Jean? Anybody to speak against the bill, for the bill, or the amendment? Representative Jean is closed. The question before the committee is the passage of the amendment to Senate Bill 855. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed, nay. Representative Jen, your amendment has passed. Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, I move that we adopt the bill 855 as amended. All right. Any questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Anybody speak against the bill as amended, for the bill as amended? committee the question before the committee is the passage of senate bill 855 as amended all in favor signify by saying aye opposed nay representative jane your bill has passed thank you mr chair thank you members of the committee all right committee we are now going to move on to our special order of business house bill 1620 representative servilo you are recognized, sir. Let me take just a minute here before you start, Representative. Folks, we all know this is a contentious issue. There's people for and against it. Let me start out by saying that, first of all, nobody condones the abuse or mistreatment of any type of animal, Dogs, cats, horses, cattle, anything. Nobody wants any animal abused. This is a committee meeting. We are discussing the bill and its content and effects there. We want everybody to have a chance to voice their opinion and their concerns there on both sides, but this isn't a football game. We don't need a lot of cheering and booing and everything else. It is a committee meeting, so let's try to keep things in order. Representative Servillo. Your tablet isn't working. technical difficulties hold on just a second here this new age
▶ Play
thank you mr. chairman and thank you mr. vice chair and my colleagues and committee members. Thank you for this opportunity. Let me present. Representative Cerville,
▶ Play
I'll get that mic up in your face there to where we can
▶ Play
Speaker 36 7:03
hear you, sir. Is that? We're not
▶ Play
hearing you, sir. Okay, is that better? Is that better? Okay. Well, thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Vice Chair and members and colleagues, allowing me to present HB 1620. Let me say first, this bill is not an HSUS bill. It is not a foreign bill. As you can look at my campaign card, on the front of it is my wife, myself, and my two dogs. I love my animals like so many people. This issue, I believe, is an issue that resonates with the people of Arkansas. And I think as my friend and has been so cordial, Chairman Douglas, to allow me to come here and encourage me to come here, However, I look at this as if we took this bill to the people of Arkansas, this bill would pass. I would like to say that I appreciate the work of the Farm Bureau does in Arkansas. However, we disagree on this puppy mill bill. For the record, I did ask the Farm Bureau to sit down with me and see if we could come to a point of agreement. They declined my offer, which I understand. Let me be clear. There is a difference in drafting a bill and amending a bill, and I believe it's the sponsor's responsibility to draft the bill. And then the steps of revising and amending the bill is when parties come together and sit down and work together. So this is not about me. This bill is about the people of Arkansas. The reason the bill is lengthy is because the attorney and I tried to define the elements of the bill clearly, how I would like to point the significant parts of HB 120. First, the bill defines what a commercial breeder in Arkansas is, And that would be a breeder that has 10 female dogs that produce two litters in an 18-month period, and they sell their dogs commercially. The bill describes human care of the dog as it maintains the health of the dogs that will be sold to the public. And that's real important as many stories have come to me where people have bought from puppy millers and the animals have been ill and there's no recourse. I think what you see in the bill is suggestions such as potable water, appropriate nutrients at least one time a day. And after reading this, I thought I might even adopt that feeding one time a day to my waistline. Starving is one of the common elements seen in puppy mills. Here's one of the examples of starvation. Pulaski County woman was arrested after Sherps. Deputies found 26 starving animals at her home. One of the four-month-old puppies died of salvation despite the effort with the blood transfusion. And that brings up a point, there is a cost to all of this, and it depends where the cost lies. Does it lie with the folks that come and rescue the animals, or does the cost go back to the taxpayers? This legislation I had suggested would not start until January 1, 2016, so that the agencies could set up oversight properly. Hopefully by that time, puppy millers will have received the word that they're not wanted in Arkansas. The process that I went through was to find an agency that I could put this bill under, and we did not have one. So we moved to health department because we think there are issues there. As you know, there are animals will transmit diseases. So when we decided that that might not be the right place, we moved it over to the veterinarian board. However, we found out there's only one person on staff, and this would be, even though there would be a financial part of the bill that might help them, it would be overworked. The next step is what I called a suggestion agri, actually livestock and poultry, and what I was told is that they don't cover domestic animals. So I think that's clear that we have a differential between farm animals and domestic animals, and domestic animals is what we live with and sleep with in some cases. But, you know, they're our friends, and it was once a dog's man's best friend. And through 18 months of chemotherapy, Buddy, my dog, rescue dog, was right by my side. So with all of that, let me just give you some information that I think is significant in us looking at this bill. As in many cases, inspections are problematic. Dealers are not overseeing. The USDA, which we've heard a lot about it, the Office of Inspection General, conducted an interview audit of their oversight of this particular facility. In May 2010, they released a damaging report confirming that the USDA had not been doing its job of enforcing the regulations. As part of the investigation, auditors found or visited 81 facilities and reviewed records documenting 28,443 violations over a two-year period of time. So how does this relate to Arkansas? Well, the Arkansas Crime Information Center recorded over 51% increase in the arrests from 2013 to 2014. However, the reporting system of Act 33, passed in 2009, is inconsistent. After contacting several law enforcement agencies within the state, including AOC, it was confirmed that it is common practice for agencies to issue citations or tickets for the cruelty to animals. So what we have here is a failure to communicate. The question I bring to you, is Act 33 to cruelty of animals working, or is the cruelty of animals a larger problem than we know? So how does this relate to citizens of Arkansas? solved. Under this, under ACIC state code 562.103, cruelty of animals, and 562.104, aggravated cruelty of when a arrest is made, the penalty of a conviction would carry a fine, but more More importantly, restitution for recovering the dogs, the restitution would cover the cost of housing, transportation, veterinarian care to bring the dogs back to health. Who is paying for that? Normally, it would be these rescue groups. The statistics does not lie. Restitution is not happening. So what if our rescue groups can't financially come to the rescue of these animals? One option is to take them to the North Little Rock Animal Shelter. What I found while I was serving on the Pulaski County Quorum Court is that it costs $47.50 per animal, animals that are picked up and brought to them. So if these dogs are not adopted because of their health issue or they're just not cute and cuddly, then they are killed. And this is the fate of probably 70 to 80 percent of these animals. Ultimately, you and I pay for that, either with city or county tax dollars. What I've tried to do is define HB 1620 in some of the basic parameters so we become more proactive instead of reactive to this growing issue in Arkansas. The document, once again, I said is lengthy because we tried to spell that out. One of the things you will find that are not covered under this bill is hunting dogs. Also, our racing dogs are not covered, and certainly our livestock and farm animals are not covered. We understand, and I think this is where a real opportunity has come into play. There is a company called Out of Missouri, which is the hunt corporation that is really basically a middleman that buys animals from breeders and then sell them to people or different pet shops and so forth. And these animals come under USDA that are sold to pet shops. But the people that are selling animals on the Internet or through the paper do not come under the USDA regulation. So one of the things I will tell you, we do have a code that we do have a humane treatment to wolf and wolf-dog hybrids. And so when I look at that and thinking that we're going to, you know, have some oversight on a wolf or a wolf-dog hybrid, then, you know, this is not unreasonable. Anyway, the statistics from the Hunt Corporation, let me see if I have them right here. Representative Servillo,
▶ Play
please try to keep that mic in your face there to where we can
▶ Play
Speaker 35 18:15
hear you. We're having trouble hearing you from time to time. Okay, sir. I'm sorry. The Hunt Corporation is one
▶ Play
of the largest, according to newspaper articles, they sold 85,000 puppies in 2002. One article reported that the average price of each dog was $2,000. They reported $26 million in that same year. Now, that was 2002. I would have to say, as you know, with the price of animals, that could probably have increased since 2002. So the same agency that is in charge with inspecting, and I gave you those statistics about the 28,000 infractions, the same agency that is in charge with inspecting kettles and brokers is the same agency that underwrote $3.5 million in loans to a business it inspects overseas. That's the hunt. As a broker, puppies to pet stores is covered under this Animal Welfare Act, which is enforced by the USDA. USDA, the same agency that is in charge with inspecting kennels and brokers, is the same agency that underwrote a $3.5 million loan to this business. I bring that point up for I see where the positive, this is an opportunity. We're unique as an agricultural state. Our livestock dogs, our farm dogs are unique. And with that, I would say to you, we have a great opportunity. Instead of becoming known in the top ten as the breeders of puppy mills, We could become, hopefully in the top ten, breeders of quality livestock dogs or pets or whatever it may be. This is not a small number. This is a commercial business, 85,000 puppies by one company. That's significant. What I'd like to do is I'd like to bring that business to Arkansas. As you know, as we sell, many of our good breeders, and this was not intended to look at the people that are doing the right job. I have had so many calls, and I want to apologize to the public. I have not been able to respond to all the emails and phone calls. I know that the members of this committee have received some also. But I did not want to make this a public spectacle. I will tell you that I've been saddened that on both sides there has been a lot of etimosity and disrespect. I do not condone that. I would say to both of those sides, let's come together. We do have a problem here. I know everybody knows that. Let's come together, sit down, and work. That's what it's all about. And so if we can't do that, we can't cure our problems. So, once again, I'm going to close and not go into too many more details. We've carefully crafted this bill. However, I think the most significant thing, if we're going to remedy this problem, would be that we need the registration of our breeders. Okay, now, think about this. It's 10 female dogs. Committee, I'm willing to change that on your recommendation. But I would say 10 female dogs producing two litters and at least two litters, could be three litters, in 18 months that are selling their animals are a commercial business. Now, as you guys have heard me say this so many times, my barber has to have a license. I'm more than willing to change us removing license and registration. We have a $250 licensing fee. I'm willing, with the comments of this committee, to lower that down. I mean, whatever is reasonable. But I think one of the other points besides the registration, which would basically give your name, it would also you would also tell, recommend, not recommend you would also indicate who the veterinarian that is overseeing your animals and so it's not it's not greasious in its approach but it's just trying to identify the breeders and then from the standpoint I think this becomes a positive issue for their registration mark because what it basically says, if that breeder advertises that you know that they've come under the scrutiny of the state and that they're legitimate. You know, no more of this meet me at the flea market and that's the case. You can, Shane Broadway, our Speaker of the House many, several years back, he could tell you the story. You know, these guys are not bad. I'm sorry, ladies, the ladies, they're not. Let me tell you, Mr. Payton showed me a picture, Representative Payton, of his little one-year-old grandson in the cage cuddled up with his little puppy. You know, he respects his work dogs. I know that. Mr. Gene has been known to adopt animals and to neuter them. They're not bad. We don't want to encroach on that. But what we need to do, the statistics prove this, that we need to be able to identify the good players. And I think with that identification that we can give them an opportunity to grow their business. And let me tell you, and Representative Brown will tell you, she found an animal down in Texarkana she wanted to buy. It was half the price that other people had advertised when she called them, wanted to come by to inspect the facility and look at the dogs. They said you can't do that. You have to meet us at the flea market. That's a dead giveaway. That's what we need. And I think if we know who the good players are then we can promote that. And I think the main thing is send a message to these bad guys that you're not wanted in Arkansas. Anyway that's where I am and like I said I am willing with the recommendation of this committee to do whatever I need to at least once again get a registration and an annual inspection unless you have an annual inspection you're not going to be able to distinguish the bad from the good and I think the annual inspection would be positive in regards to when the inspector goes in he's not there to put you under the microscope, but he's there. He or she could recommend certain steps that improve your facility to breed the better dogs and so forth. So with all that, I brought you a token of peace. But anyway, there's so many people here that need to speak, and so or questions. Mr. Speaker, let me turn it back over
▶ Play
to you. All right, thank you, Representative Cervillo, for your presentation. Committee, are there any questions for Representative Cervillo? Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Representative Cervillo, you and I both have a couple of mutual friends that are very passionate about this issue, and so we've had an opportunity to speak about it. But I've studied your bill, and in your presentation, you made many references to puppy mills. There's no definition in your bill of a puppy mill. As a matter of fact, I don't see that terminology used in your bill at all. And it does seek to regulate commercial breeders. So what confidence do you have that these breeders that you refer to as puppy mills will register and subject themselves to the regulations in your bill? That's a great question. I think that that would be limited in scope. I don't think they're going to come out of the woodwork and identify themselves. I think the thing that we with an annual inspection and with whatever the registration would be, that whoever would be inspecting would know that they've come under this scrutiny. And so if they don't, I mean, it's an infraction. I mean, I think it's a situation where, you know, it's just like speeding. I mean, this is the requirement, and if you go over the speed limit, then you're subject to whatever the penalty is. and if the folks are doing this. And remember, it's got to be 10 female dogs, and as I said, I'm open to move that up. But that's, you know, when you look at it, 10 female dogs having three litters in 18 months, and as you know, some of these animals are sold up to $2,000. And so that's a large commercial business. Now, let me tell you one thing in talking to one of the breeders, small breeders. they pay income tax the good breeders do pay income tax they don't pay sales tax because we don't have any we have no identification that's what the registration would also do, give us an opportunity to recoup some of this financial aspect of it Representative Payton you had a
▶ Play
follow up I had a follow
▶ Play
up but he just brought up something that I'd like to ask so you see your bill as a first step towards being able to identify and collect sales tax on the commercial business? I would say, too, on a commercial business, I think that's the standard within a government. Well, my follow-up is you mentioned in your opening a Pulaski County woman that was arrested. She had 26 dogs at home. Do you have any evidence whether she was breeding or was she a pet lover that kind of got out of control and had too many dogs at home? Once again, another good question. I can't tell you. All I know is that she was arrested, and so obviously there had to be some abuse or whatever it comes in. And she was arrested, so obviously there's a law against it. There is a law against it, yes. Act 33, most definitely in the code I gave you there. So I'll wrap it up real quick with one more follow-up. I respect your attempt to punish the bad actors. I don't see how regulating the reputable breeders and passing laws are going to bring the bad actors out of the woodwork. I think you still have to investigate that. So do you have anything in your bill that is an investigative arm other than the fact that we're going to pay a visit to those willing to register and make sure they're subjecting themselves to the new regulations? that doesn't mean we're going to find the ones that are the bad actors acting underneath the law. So what in your bill actually addresses the problem, finds the bad actors? Well, sir, that is a public awareness. I mean, you cannot regulate that. I believe that you're looking at law enforcement, whether it's many of the county sheriffs, when they can identify. that's why the public awareness is so important but when they can identify they can go in and make that bust but the question is do they have ample support for going in and doing that and with this regulation once again you look at the conditions and I think that gives them the appropriate steps to make that decision. If they don't have some type of registration number then they're out of you know out of compliance to begin with but but exactly i'm not going to you know i'm not going to try to defend um what you're saying because i do agree with you it's the bad action and i think what what you want to look at is what the states that have continued to to be progressive in in their enforcement of this that that they are moving out of those states the problem is because we've been so lax, I think we were 46th in this Act 33 of actually enforcing cruelty, 46th throughout the nation, that they have been able to move around and end up, I hate to say this because the information I was told is that we have, they're in the top ten with these puppy millers. So I wish, I wish you, you know, you could help me or the committee could help me We have a lot of problems out there, as you know, beyond animals that we seek to get a remedy of, but there's just bad players.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Representative Payton. Representative McElroy, I think you were next on the queue there. And let me remind the members this. We do have a limited time. This is the day that Representative Cervillo chose. We are going into session at 10 o'clock, so we will have to be wrapped up a few minutes before that, about five minutes before
▶ Play
10, so let's get to the point. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I was planning on quitting after about 35 minutes, but I'll speed up. Mr. Savillo, I appreciate you being brave enough to take on such a heated discussion. and I just wanted to ask one of these lines here says does not subject a dog to temperatures that would compromise a dog's health. Is there a
▶ Play
Speaker 57 32:39
maximum and a minimum in there or is it pretty
▶ Play
vague? No sir what I found out in my research after we did have a definite low or high temperature was that in some cases these livestock animals thrive in cold, cold weather. And so that's why you know, that was just a process of learning. I think the real issue there, and I know this as a fact, in Moralton back a few years ago, there was the county shelter that was in a metal building with temperatures up into the 100 degrees without any ventilation and so forth, and of course I called down there and the animal control guy said it was none of my business to out of his business, and certainly as you know, as timid as I am, like Mr. Representative Douglas, we started the process. Channel 11 went out there and did a story on it, and I'd like to share with you today that they have an updated facility, and so it can be done. And I think back to Representative Payton, the fact is it's hard to identify these. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Ratliff, I thank you. We're next.
▶ Play
Speaker 58 34:04
Representative, I'm kind of like everybody else here. All I've heard in the media is puppy meals and when we get to reading this bill, it wasn't in there. But I got, my other question is, have you compared this bill to the USDA law that we had a federal law that works they came in by my farm one day and busted a guy with dogs and they made him he can't even have a pet to a mouse anymore they tore him up and took all of his money he had and everything took his farm away from him I mean you can't
▶ Play
get any more stricter than that well thank you you're right There is, if you look at the statistics from our Arkansas crime lab, that's not happening, as I said, with restitution. There could be some reasons there. However, in our Act, Act 33, our law here, it's cited the first time, the second time, the third time, and then on the fourth time it becomes a D felony. It doesn't take four times to get to that point. Now, what they did, now once again, that's the USDA, but based on Act 33, what we have here, they're not busting and taking away the farms and so forth. That's not evident here. It can be isolated cases. Well, you know, I've
▶ Play
Speaker 58 35:33
always heard federal law supersedes the state law, and they took that man's car away from him, too.
▶ Play
He had to walk away. Well, you know, once again, the statistics, if these people are arrested and charged and found guilty. They went to prison, too.
▶ Play
Speaker 58 35:52
Well, you know, I... I don't know how much you get any more strict for myself. Okay. Thank you. All right.
▶ Play
Next, I think, Representative Beck, before you start, members, let's limit one question here. We have a lot of people that have traveled here that want to speak. We're not going to be able to get to all of them because of time limitations, but they do need to be heard both for and against the bill. So Representative Beck, you're
▶ Play
recognized for one question. Thank you, Chairman. You made reference to the shelter that I've been involved with cleaning up in Marlton. Was this a puppy mill by your definition? No. Would this regulation in any way affect that? No. That's
▶ Play
all. Okay. Thank you. Representative Pitch, I think you were next there.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Cervello, I went through this bill, and you wrote, I quoted you, we have carefully crafted this bill. I find many places in the bill generic, not detail, like law statutes need to be. But in trying to get to one question per the chairman's request, Am I wrong in seeing this as a fee and a government bureaucracy that could, in fact, harm existing kennel owners per the American Kennel Club, the Pet Industry Joint Advisory Council? Oftentimes when we write a bill, we hurt those that are following good practice and trying to catch the bad ones per Representative Payton's comments. And I see this as a tax increase, a bureaucracy increase, and a lot of generic terms that are hard to define. Can
▶ Play
you help us with that? Yes, I can. I think you make a valid point. I'm with you. Let's get rid of all the licensing. I mean, why can't my barber have a license? I mean, you know, because he's a commercial business. If you look at the breeders that are making, I mean, that's part of their livelihood. Is there any difference than my barber? And so it's not, so if you, I will support whatever you come up with and let's deal away with these licenses. You know, there's, how many licenses do we have in Arkansas? But the point is, is it fair for my barber to have to have a license when somebody else is producing? And think about this, 10 dogs, in some cases more. if they have three litters in 18 months you're talking about hundreds of dogs and so no I mean it's not the small people that's why we put a minimum of 10 dogs and at least two litters in 18 months but I will tell you this let me get Puppy Uniform Protection and Safety Act so this describes it says it amends the Animal Welfare Act to define a high volume retail breeder as a person who in commerce for compensation or profits has an ownership interest in or custody of one or more breeding female dogs and number two, sales by way of means of convenience on more than 50 of its offsprings of such dogs for the use as pets in any one year considered a breeder of dogs to be a dealer requires dealers to include on licensing applications and animal renewals the total number of dogs exempt from exercise on premises of the dealers in the preceding year by the licensed veterinarian. So when you look at that, that's a definition by Puppy Uniform Protection and Safety Act that many of the Animal Welfare Act. Okay, I have one question
▶ Play
I'm going to ask real quick and maybe more of a statement you can answer this. It says here that the kennels will be inspected by an authorized person. You go back to the definition of that authorized person means Department of Health. It's delegate or law enforcement officers. It doesn't give any specifics for training for those individuals or what type of certification that they need to be able to inspect to look for the proper diseases or something. If we have somebody inspecting, don't we want them to know what diseases and conditions to look for? That's just a concern I have. You can mention that shortly and then we'll
▶ Play
Speaker 35 40:33
get on with the... That's a good point and I agree with you. Why
▶ Play
don't we I can add that to the bill. Okay. Any more questions from the committee before we get on to testimony here? Okay, with not saying any, first on the list is to speak against Bill is Beverly Fox. Beverly, if you would come up and speak. And ma'am, I want you to get your point across, but brevity is important here because of the number of people we've got. We want try to get as many. Representative Payton, you have
▶ Play
a question? Yes, Mr. Chair. To make sure both sides get equal amount of time, could we make a motion that we limit debate
▶ Play
to 10 minutes per side? 10 minutes per side? That's probably about all we've got time for. That would be fine. Motion does a proper motion. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? Motion carried. Mr. Leopard, would you be the timekeeper? Ma'am, you are... Well, they're signed up to speak against it if they've got a sticker on saying they're against it. I don't see that makes any difference there. But, ma'am, go ahead, please, and remember, we've got ten minutes for both sides starting now. Thank you. You're recognized. Please state your name and who you're with. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Beverly Clarkson.
▶ Play
Oh, okay. My name is Beverly Fox, and I am a USDA-licensed federal dog breeder. I resent the implications of being referred to as a puppy mill or a puppy miller. There is no definition of this in a dictionary, and it is a phrase that has been coined by the Humane Society of the United States. I have several issues with this bill. One primarily is that why should shelters and rescues be held exempt from regulation, but breeders should be regulated? I know of people that have purchased or acquired animals from shelters and rescues, and they've been sick too, and they've had problems with their animals as far as getting the representation or the financial back, the money that they've induced, because a lot of these rescues charge big money for the adoptions. I resent the fact that oh gosh, I lost my train of thought, and I know you're trying to I don't know where he gets his figures of three litters in 18 months, but I don't have a dog that'll do that. my dogs usually cycle and breed maybe seven to eight months apart and they don't have huge litters I have some that have one and I have some that might have five so the numbers here are incorrect the numbers of breeders in this state that has been uh not mentioned today but where I've read someone's saying that there are like 600 breeders in our state how do they know there's only 127 licensed USDA breeders in the state. I am inspected yearly by my USDA inspector. I am inspected by AKC. I am inspected by my veterinarian. I have a lot of investment and time in my animals and my facility not to mistreat them in any way. I've seen children that are mistreated a lot worse than animals are. And I think that there's a bigger issue here that needs to be addressed other than animals. We need to be focusing on people and the care we provide for people. Animals were given to us by God to maintain. They're not, we weren't given to them to take care of them. And you're not ever going to catch or as they've said, you're not going to have all the bad breeders come forward. I've seen bad breeder kennels too And there are some out there, and I don't approve of them either. But you're not going to get those breeders to come up and license like this gentleman thinks they are. They're going to hide with their head in the sand, and they'll go
▶ Play
underground, and they'll still sell their animals. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am. All right, next, to speak against the bill, we have, or speak for the bill, excuse me, excuse me, Ms. Melanie Stapleton. Melanie? Okay. Please tell your name and who you're with.
▶ Play
Hi, my name is Melanie Stapleton, and I'm a concerned Arkansan. I appreciate the opportunity to come here today. I've taken time off of work just to be here. I often take time off of work to help dogs. In February of 2014, I personally assisted in the rescue of 121 dogs from a puppy mill in Jefferson County. I wanted to go ahead and define for you puppy mills since that came up as one of y'all's questions. These are large-scale commercial breeders focused on making a profit with crowded facilities living in filth. It's just a phrase to easily encompass what it is that we are discussing here for commercial breeders. So back to my story, 121 dogs. Can you imagine living in a small trailer with 121 dogs? It smelled as bad as it sounds. Supporters like me have been labeled as animal rights extremists. I think that the unregulated puppy millers in Arkansas are extreme in their neglect. My hope is that you have not already been swayed by misinformation. This bill, HB 1620, is not about farming. It's not about hunting. It's not about overburdening the taxpayers. it's not about over-regulating the limited animal cruelty laws that are in place it is about holding those in the breeding industry accountable for basic food water and shelter it is about protecting me as the consumer making sure that i'm going to get a healthy dog it is about shifting a large financial burden that our city shelters are already facing And putting that into a small cost of doing business, $250 to register and $100 to be inspected, a small cost of doing business, shifting that to those who are in the business. Thank you. And if there's any questions, I'd be happy
▶ Play
to answer. thank you vice chair thank you ma'am any questions for represent micro go ahead if you've got a question for
▶ Play
just one you said that you helped uh clean up a puppy mill how how did how did they get you know how did um how were they exposed i guess Yeah, so unfortunately,
▶ Play
since there's not a registry, there's not any ongoing, you know, once a year you get inspected, you have to kind of wait until it gets so bad that consumers reported them for animal cruelty. With 121 dogs, there should be just a standard of care to give them food, water, and shelter. It is kind of silly to have to put regulation in place, but we need it.
▶ Play
You're welcome. Thank you, ma'am, for your testimony. Let's see. Next, against the bill, David Remy, or sir, you're recognized. Please state your name and who
▶ Play
Speaker 80 48:35
you're with and present your testimony.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, committee members, my name is David Remy. I'm a licensed USDA breeder here in Arkansas. I'm very much opposed to this bill. I feel like it's going to put regulations on us as licensed breeders that we are already inspected by USDA. We are adhering to the laws of the United States government. We're inspected sometimes more than once a year. If there are violations that are found within our kennel, we are given maybe 24 hours, 36 hours to correct those situations. We feel like that this bill should regulate the rescues and the humane societies in the state. They should come under the same regulations that we are under. There are many small farmers within the state of Arkansas that supplement their income through raising dogs. This is going to put an undue hardship on them. It's going to create a financial hardship for them if they cannot support themselves. I ask you to vote against House Bill 1620. This puts much more regulations in bureaucracy. This is not only coming from a state representative, but I feel like this is the HSUS trying to get in the foothold in Arkansas. This is a bigger issue rather than just the dogs here in Arkansas. Thank you. Representative Meats, I think you had a question. Mr. Ramey, if you don't mind, sir. Yes,
▶ Play
sir, if you don't mind. The question I have is the main purpose of this bill is to create a license and inspections of these kennels. But it sounds like the USDA is already doing that, that there already has inspections that you already need to be licensed. Can you kind of tell us what's the difference between what 1620 does
▶ Play
and what you're already doing? Well, we're already doing this. I think probably that USDA has been put, a lot of pressure has been put under them to do a broader inspection and be sure that our licensed breeders are maintaining their kennels like they should. I have noticed that they're very concerned about the cleaning of teeth. We spend a lot of money in taking our dogs to our vets to see that their teeth are cleaned to keep disease down. And they come, especially if they find any discrepancies, they come back very often. So it's not that we're not being looked at. We're already being looked at very much in the inspections. And it's gotten a lot stricter in the number of years that I've been doing this. OK, thank you,
▶ Play
sir. All right, next for the bill, we have David Bash. David, if you'd come up and introduce yourself and let us hear what you've got to
▶ Play
Speaker 84 52:06
say. Thank you. I'm David Bash. I guess I'm just a citizen who's concerned about suffering in this world the animals do suffer and as we've heard in many examples but also we got to keep in mind that the people who end up with these animals also do suffer so
▶ Play
I think your microphone went off there representative could
▶ Play
Speaker 84 52:32
you help him with it yeah don't know where to restart but anyway there are a lot of examples of people who get stuck with the animal who is in poor health from one of these commercial breeders who are not properly taking care of their animals and they get into large expenses and stuff. So I think it's for the benefit of both our citizens as well as, of course, the animals. So as I'd like to quote maybe a philosopher from the mid-20th century, you know, whenever people say we mustn't be sentimental, you can take it they're going to do something cruel and if they add we must be realistic they mean they're going to make money out of it
▶ Play
so I do appreciate your attendance any questions for Mr. Bash thank you sir appreciate your testimony folks I know a lot of you have come to speak for and against the bill here we are running out of time here because we have to allow Mr. Cervillo Time to close for his bill and committee action, and then we have to be in session here. At this time, Mr. Cervillo, do you want to go ahead and close for your bill? Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Yes, sir. What I would like to say is that I appreciate what the commercial breeders do here in Arkansas, and that is not what this bill was intended to do. I do want to just cite with you the statistics that I talked to earlier, and this came from the USDA Office of Inspector General. As part of that investigation, auditors visited 81 facilities and reviewed records documenting 28,443 violations over a two-year period of time. They, once again, the USDA had not been doing its job. They have cited that in their audit. Now, let me give you one closing example of what I want to try to eliminate, and I think the people here that support some oversight or better oversight than what we have. And this was back in September 28, 2010. and David Yoder had pleaded guilty to 74 counts of illegal destruction of animals. Basically, it ended up being 93 dogs because the puppies, 15 puppies, were involved in this. What he did is he took a whelping box that he fitted with a metal door and with a hole in it. He put an exhaust pipe of a three-horsepower motor engine and pumped carbon monoxide gas into the box filled with his dogs. He killed 93 animals. He killed dogs in groups of five, all coming out this in front of the other dogs in the kennel. The point that I make there is that these dogs were ill, and they were inspected. And so this was his solution. He was fined. I mean, so obviously he has broken the law. He was fined $505. That is what we're trying to do. We're trying to become humane and trying to oversight not the bad, I mean, not the good players. You know, this discussion has been good. I do appreciate I know the folks here and I know you well, I serve with you and I know you have your intentions and of course I've been at the bunt of some of the jokes but I think it's been a good discussion I think we see there is a problem I don't want to overregulate anything but I think we have a problem and if we don't step up and do something the problem is going to escalate. What I would like to do at this time Mr. Chair I have confirmed the fact that I'm going to do an interim study on this issue I know that I've fallen short and I apologize to this committee this is an enormous undertaking and I wish I could have done better and I'm sorry that I've disappointed the people that are here that have worked so hard come so many miles to speak but what I would like to do with your permission, Mr. Chair, is to take down my bill, go to work on this. I will tell you I am dedicated, and I will be back if the voters so choose to bring me back in two years. We will reintroduce a bill, and hopefully it will be with both sides at the table and the fact that we've done our due diligence. We haven't taken the good players and put them under more regulations but identified the bad players. And I think, you know, we've had some good comments here. I really do in regards to how do – I think the issue is how do we identify them. So I appreciate your time and thank you so much for your consideration. and with the chair's permission, I'd like to end. So your
▶ Play
wish at this time is to pull your bill down and refer it to interim studies. Is that correct? Yes, sir. Okay. Well, that's your prerogative, Representative, and with that, thank you very much. You have shed a lot of light on some issues. With that, members, we've got to get to session. The committee is adjourned. Folks, I'm sorry we were limited on time. Thank you for coming. Thank you for participating in your governmental process. I wish we had more time to hear more from everybody.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1839

0:42 - 1:29 4 segments 2 speakers

HB1859

1:29 - 2:47 6 segments 4 speakers

SB855

2:47 - 5:10 9 segments 2 speakers

HB1620

5:10 - 58:37 142 segments 15 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Dan M. Douglas Chair Unverified
40 segments
Representative Camille Bennett Unverified
2 segments
Representative DeAnn Vaught Unverified
1 segment
Representative Jon S. Eubanks Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 18
1 segment
Speaker 20
1 segment
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
4 segments
Representative James J. Sorvillo Unverified
75 segments
Speaker 36
1 segment
Speaker 35
2 segments
Representative Mark D. McElroy Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 57
1 segment
Speaker 58
4 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
1 segment
Representative Mathew W. Pitsch Unverified
2 segments
Beverly Fox Unverified
6 segments
Melanie Stapleton Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 80
1 segment
David Remy Unverified
7 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 84
3 segments