House Insurance and Commerce
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (1)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB882
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB882”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
Even though I did two committee meetings, I just couldn't get to it, and I, A, felt terrible about that, and B, set this meeting up. So without objection, Senator Rape, you're recognized to present Senate Bill 882. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. And one thing I just want to tell the committee members as well,
I know we have the Health Care Task Force at 10 a.m., and there's a couple of us that are actually on that, so my goal is to wrap here no later than that. I think we should have plenty of time for Senate Bill 882. Senator Raper, you're recognized to
present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. If it pleases the chairman, I would ask that I have a couple people be presenting here with me on the bill. Mr. Parker from the chamber and I think that the Arkansas Trial Lawyers Association has someone here to help as well.
That's fine just have those individuals at the end of the
table and then have them introduce themselves and who
Speaker 13
1:10
they're with. Mr. Parker. I'm George Wise. I'm the president of the Arkansas Trial Lawyers Association.
Speaker 15
1:18
Good morning Mr. Chairman. Andrew Parker Director of Governmental Affairs for the Arkansas State Chamber of
Commerce. Gentlemen, you're recognized. Thank you. Members, just to preface this just a little bit for you,
over the past couple of years since I started chairing Insurance and Commerce, I have begun attending National Conference of Insurance Legislature meetings, which some of you, I think, have attended and some of you have not. I believe Representative Ferguson is now a member there. And I was happy to actually make the recommendation for Representative Ferguson to join the National Conference of Insurance Legislators. And at that meeting, this particular issue began to be brought to the forefront over the past couple of years.
It's been, obviously, an issue that has, from my perspective, been very contentious at that level. One of the reasons why that it's been very contentious is because the consumer litigation funding industry, of whom I believe that you possibly have someone here that will testify against this bill, is Oasis Legal Funding. And they have made it contentious in that they want to pass a bill, a model resolution that would be adopted in all states that has no caps on this particular type of business.
And what they do is they make loans to people that are plaintiffs, typically, in a lawsuit. It does not have anything to do with legal funding that a law firm will seek to help them in their representation or defense or their presentation of a case. It's simply for the plaintiffs involved when they might have some bills out there and they are referred to what's called a consumer litigation funding agency. Now, as opposed to them getting a loan at a local bank
or doing something locally in which they get help with bills, they are referred to one of these entities. And what makes these entities unique is that they will sit down with you, and I'll use an actual real example. A gentleman in Oklahoma had $6,000 in bills. He told his attorney, he said, I need to take care of some bills here. And he said, well, the case is not settled yet. They talked it out, and he said, tell you what, go see one of these companies.
And to my knowledge, I believe that Oasis said in the Senate that he actually came to them. And so the gentleman sat down with him, and the discussion goes something like this. Sir, we've looked at your case. We've talked with your attorney, and it appears he's going to be successful in this. And we understand you have some bills to take care of us. Yes, sir, I do. And he says, well, I've got $6,000 that I need to take care of. So they said, sir, we'll take care of that $6,000 for you, and if your attorney wins your case for you, then we'll get our payback at that time.
But if he doesn't win, you don't owe us a dime. Does that sound familiar? It sounds like some of the pitches that you'll hear from attorneys. Well, the problem, to get to the point, the bottom line is, is that that particular individual that borrowed $6,000 when his case settled, he owed them $18,000 in return. What you'll find in front of you is a letter from the U.S. Chamber Institute for Legal Reform. And what you'll find on there is that this particular type of industry
is charging as much as 200% interest. And some will argue and say, oh, well, it's not interest because we're not alone. Well, they're charging 200% of what the original amount that was loaned to them. Whether it's a fee, whether it's a premium, whether it's an interest charge, it's as much as 200%. I'm looking at several of you that were here long enough to remember the payday lending situation that we had in Arkansas. Fortunately, we called that for what it is, and it was an abuse of consumers, and we took care of it here in the state of Arkansas.
Through my service at the National Conference of Insurance Legislators and through my review of this particular type of business, I believe that Arkansas needs to make sure that our consumers, that our citizens are not taken advantage of here. I have no problem with people being in business. I have no problem with people making money on what they do. But I believe in the state of Arkansas and simply what this bill says, that if you're going to do business here, then you're going to be subject to the usury cap, which is 17%.
If it's good enough for bankers, it ought to be good enough for these particular people involved. And with that, Mr. Chairman, I would like for Andrew Parker with the State Chamber of Commerce to have a moment, and then George Wise with the Trial Lawyers
Association. Gentlemen, when you speak, please introduce yourself and who you're with, and you're
Speaker 15
6:18
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Andrew Parker with the Arkansas State Chamber. I appreciate the opportunity to be here today. I appreciate Senator Raypert for bringing this legislation.
I did a couple of searches when getting ready to speak about this bill, and in 2014, lawsuit lending firms spent millions of dollars on over 16,000 TV ads that were run during the day and late at night. And in May of 2014 alone, total ad buys exceeded $5.8 million. dollars. A simple internet search that I did for just the terms lawsuit lending revealed hundreds of websites dedicated to practice, and the headlines of lawsuitlending.com reads,
when clients need cash fast, lawsuit lending will help pay the bills. Obviously, this is an attractive offer to anybody who's in a vulnerable position, and that's cutting to the chase the reason why the state chamber is particularly involved, there's an argument about whether or not this activity is lending or not, and as a result, not subject to the usury laws that the senator referred to. They share with the public that this is lending activities.
They should be governed to the same rules that all other lending institutions are governed by. um defendants wind up paying higher settlement fees as a result of lawsuit lending activities being involved not to adequately compensate the plaintiffs but to cover these increasingly large debts to the lawsuit lenders uh settlement offers are frequently ignored for the hope to get additional funds out of the defendants most of the defendants is is no surprise or businesses
large and small. It doesn't do anything positive for the plaintiffs. All it does is make everything more expensive for all the parties involved. Attorney generals and legislatures across the U.S. are dealing with the same problem. The attorney general in Colorado and the legislatures in Oklahoma, Mississippi, Louisiana, Tennessee, Georgia, and others are trying to address this issue right now, not to eliminate the practice, but to make sure that activity is governed reasonably, and that parties aren't charged these 100% to 200% exorbitant interest rates.
With that, I'm going to be quiet and turn it over to Mr. Wise. Mr. Wise. Thank you, Mr. Chairman,
Speaker 13
8:53
committee, for hearing me. And thank you, Senator Rapert, for bringing a bill which is really good. Sir, could you introduce yourself and who you're with, please? I'm sorry. I did earlier. I'm sorry, George Wise, I am the president of the Arkansas Trial Lawyers Association. This is good public policy. Anytime the trial lawyers in the chamber agree on an issue, you ought to know that it's good public policy.
What this bill does is it prevents someone injured in, for example, a car crash or in a biodefected product, it prevents them from becoming a victim twice. A lot of the clients that we represent face hard times when they're injured through no fault of their own. They're already a victim. If they have to pay interest, as Senator Rapert said, of 150 to 200 percent, they're being victimized again.
These lawsuit lending companies prey on the misfortune that our clients are facing, and they shouldn't be allowed to charge what I think are loan shark rates of interest. I want to give you an example and then I'll take some questions. We had a lawsuit that I worked on. It was a fairly catastrophic injury. It involved multiple defendants. It took us four years to get it resolved. It went on from 2007 to 2011.
During that time, against our advice, and we never advise our clients to pay this type of interest, but against our advice, our client borrowed $51,000 over those four years. At the end of that case, he owed $196,000, $196,000 that he had to pay back out of his settlement. The payback is contractual. There's no way to not pay these people back.
Now, they will tell you that there's not an option for these people. Well, there is an option. We know that there's a gentleman here in Arkansas who does the same thing. He charges the 17% and is always charged whatever the usury rate was, and he stays in business. And under the example that I gave you, this involved two companies, but had they charged 17% over those four years, they still would have generated a profit of $34,000.
That's what 17% interest would have been over four years on $51,000. So there's an ability for a company to operate and to provide the service to clients who have been injured, but it doesn't need to be at 200% and I'll be happy to take any questions Sir, my question
would be it sounds like the business model is similar to the commercials that I see for lawyers who would suggest that if you think you have
a claim you could pay no money and then if you win your claim then the lawyers would be paid. Is that an element of what these people do?
Speaker 13
12:08
Well except that they're not just loaning money to anyone who asks them to loan money. They're screening the cases very carefully so that even though they say you're not going to owe us anything, if you lose your case, they're not going to loan money on a case that's not going to pay off.
Mr. Chairman, what really is troublesome about it is you invoke a third party into the interest of the outcome of a lawsuit.
Typically, when you have a lawsuit, you have a plaintiff, you have a defendant. they argue their particular case they argue their perspective you actually are inputting a third party into a case that now has a vested financial interest in the outcome of that case which i believe poses some ethical issues and concerns as well in terms of this uh you may have some some that have some questions i'll save the remainder of my comments for closing
And, again, just as a follow-up to that, Mr. Cousins, it seems to me that the practice is really two things in one.
It's an insurance policy and it's a loan. The insurance policy is an all-or-nothing bet that you will receive. So if I said, gosh, I think I'm going to get $100,000, but I might get $0,000 or I might get $20,000, and somebody gives me $10,000 up front, the amount I pay back could be zero if, in fact, my case gets thrown out. Is that correct? And if it is, the reason I'm saying that is then what you're really selling is more than a loan but also an insurance policy, if I'm not mistaken.
Well, I don't know that I would call it per se an insurance policy, But what you have is a situation where these companies are not out loaning money to anyone that asks. They're working with cases in which they see, and most often that's going to be against companies they know that have deep pockets, and they know that has a case where likely there is going to be a judgment. And what's happening is that they are causing an increase for every single person sitting at this table
and every single person in this Capitol today because they have a potential to extend litigation, to cause it to lengthen, which therein is a cost to everyone concerned. And back to a point that may or may not be made here today. They have tried to confuse the argument by saying, well, it's not alone. I actually sat in front of these people in San Francisco. I asked the question to them, if you're not alone, then maybe you're a security. They don't want to be a security.
They don't want to be alone. They simply want to be an it. And the reason for that is they want no regulation. They want no caps. And I think that the bottom line is this is payday lending on steroids, no matter what they call it, Mr.
Chairman. Thank you, Senator Apert. Are there any questions from the committee? Seeing none, I know we have people signed up to speak against the bill. We've got ten minutes total. I see two people signed up to speak against the bill and just the two that have already
spoken for it. So if you keep your comments brief, we'll see if we can just go ahead and do those. Dan Greenberg, you're recognized to speak against the
bill. Thanks, Mr. Chairman. My name is Dan Greenberg. I'm with an organization called the Advance Arkansas Institute, which is a public interest, limited government organization.
I think you put your finger on something very important in your questions. You suggested that it's difficult to predict what the percentage rate of this loan is going to be because you never know the outcome of the court case that it involves. I think that's exactly right. What this legislation does is it requires the statement of a percentage rate at the time that the deal is done. And as you just pointed out, that's impossible to predict. And so what this bill does, it creates a criminal penalty for not obeying a disclosure regulation that is impossible to follow.
I want to get away from abstractions. The consequence of this legislation is that you're reducing the value of an asset that people hold, that is the possible judgment on a lawsuit. you're going to force some people into bankruptcy who are litigants, and you're going to force other people who are litigants into settling for pennies on the dollar. I also think this legislation is going to block businesses from coming into the state, just like similar legislation that's been passed in Tennessee is pushing businesses out of Tennessee. Now, there are many states which actually regulate this in a very different way.
I'd say the modern trend is legislation that's very similar to Oklahoma's. That has a business model that was praised by the Chamber of Commerce just two years ago. And I think that if this legislature were going to follow Oklahoma's model, you'd have a model that's healthy for businesses and healthy for consumers. This bill takes a very different and destructive path because it does three things. Like I said, it creates regulations that are impossible to comply with. Also it creates a business model that meets people's real and legitimate needs.
And finally, it locks the doors of the courthouse against people who have actually been injured with real injuries, and it ignores the trend towards healthy and focused regulation that you can see in other states. You've already heard people testify before this committee, discuss the question of whether this is a loan. And the sponsor and I have spoken about other transactions, which definitely are loans. But this transaction is not a loan, because the basic fundamental fact of a loan is the the borrower has to pay the money back, and there's no such thing as a loan where you don't have to pay the money back.
And so it's a great concern to me when you put something into the usury model, which is not a loan. I think that's a square peg in a round hole. And we all know that when you do meat-axe regulation on financial instruments, you're going to end up with bad consequences. As I said before, it's not just this is the wrong regulation. This is an impossible regulation to comply with because the seller has to disclose the interest rate
or face the possibility of fines and jail time. And I don't see there's any way to calculate the kind of interest rate on this in advance. It's like trying to calculate the annual yield on a stock purchase in advance. It's a figure that's inherently impossible to predict. I don't know how a judge is going to deal with a rule like that. I don't know how a judge is going to deal with required disclosure of a figure that's impossible to predict, but my guess is not very well.
And I also want to say, I think that there are sometimes good reasons for people to make this kind of transaction. Some of you might be asking, why would anyone in their right mind ever sell an interest in a future judgment? Well, I'll tell you why, because of the basic facts of life. Sometimes lawsuits take years to resolve, and sometimes people need the money now. Half the families in America have, rather, they don't have $2,000 in savings to their name,
according to a bankrate.com survey I recently saw, and some of those people are going to need a little bit of a bump in savings to tide them over to their next paycheck. That's why people borrow money. That's why they mortgage their land, and that's why people are best situated when they have more choices about how to raise money. I think the business model, a consumer lawsuit lending that we're talking about, does offer service in some cases, and that some people are going to have short-term needs that this product is going to fulfill. Well, you heard testimony just before that this product doesn't do anything positive for the plaintiff. Well, sure it does.
It gives people short-term cash in much the same way that companies that sell stock get a short-term cash infusion in exchange for a piece of the asset. There is no other state in the union that requires this kind of advanced disclosure. before anybody could ever know what the percentage could be, and I think that's because regulators and other states realize that this is, again, it's not a loan, it's an investment with a variable return, not a fixed one. So this bill is really poised to make history, although I think it's history of a really destructive kind.
And I guess I should also add that there's not one state in the union that currently imposes an interest rate cap on consumer lawsuit lending. Excuse me. I'm sorry. Dan.
I apologize. No, no, no. I wasn't very smart. I thought we could get through this. And we've got a hard stop at 10. There's just absolutely no way we cannot stop at 10. So, sir, if you'd be gracious enough to. And I apologize, Mr. Chairman. No, no, you don't need to apologize. If you would be gracious enough to let someone else, just because we've got a few minutes and I want to give Senator Rapert time to close him, and we've just got a hard stop at 10.
I tried to work around that, and it's impossible for me to do
it. I need to finish my sentence. Yes, sir. There's only one state, okay, that currently has such an interest rate, and it has not gone into effect yet. That is Tennessee, and I believe that the consequence of that is that businesses who offer this model
apologize for taking your time, Mr. Chairman. Thank you very much. I'd like to propose that we have 90 seconds per side for additional for and against testimony and then give Senator Rape at the remaining time to close.
All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Okay, we've got 90 seconds remaining for for and against. Is there anyone that would like to speak for the bill? Against the bill, we've got Eric Shuler. Sir, you have 90 seconds to speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr.
Chairman. My name is Eric Shuler. I'm the Director of Government Affairs for Oasis Legal Finance.
In the quick time that I have, I just want to clarify a couple of things. One, the case that Senator Raper talked about regarding Oklahoma, the gentleman from Oklahoma, that was our case. The person only had to pay back $6,000. At the end of the day, the person walked away with a check for $65,000 in hand. That was because he was able to save his home and keep the lights on. I just want to give you a couple quick quotes from other states in which have passed where we feel proper regulation.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce supported the bill in Oklahoma and stated, Governor Fallon, Senator Corrine, and Representative Osborne should be created curbing laws or lending abuses, and hopefully other states will follow their footsteps. We agree. Oklahoma sent in a good structure. And Senator Corrine on the floor of the Senate said, we specifically define these transactions not as a loan. It's a litigation financing agreement, so you do not have to involve yourself. There is no cap. In the state of Ohio, when the regulation passed there, it says these are not loans.
This is not payday lending. All we're asking for, if you want to regulate this industry, let's regulate it properly and not just shove it into some category that will definitely put the industry totally out of business and take this option away from Arkansas consumers. I'd be happy to answer
any questions. Thank you. Representative Lauer, you're recognized for a question. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Okay, your very last statement was to do it, to regulate it accurately or correctly.
What would you suggest is the way, especially in terms of this interest rate issue, to regulate correctly? We're willing to
sit down and discuss that issue. But one of the things that Senator Raper brought up in his testimony, which has been brought up in other cases, is introduction of a third party. In this, where you're defying this transaction, you're not stopping a third party influence. In the bills that we passed, to include the bill in Oklahoma, it specifically states the funding companies cannot have a say in the settlement process.
If that is your concern, then let's put in proper regulation that states that. Let's put in proper regulations of notice and disclosures. Let's put in proper regulation that there could be no quid pro quo between funding companies and- Let me make a
proposal, given that I've got several people telling me we need more time, we need more time. I understand that, and I want to respect it. And we've got a hard stop at 10 a.m., which is a minute and a half. So what my proposal is is that we recess the committee until 1 p.m. today, and we'll finish this discussion and this bill at 1 p.m.
So I would do that without objection, but I want to put it to a vote of the committee. So I move that we recess this committee discussion until 1 p.m. today where we will finish this bill and close out the committee. All in favor? Any opposed? Thank you very much. We're going to recess until 1 p.m. today. We'll pick up, we'll throw out the 90-second time limit, and, sir, you'll be able to continue. And, Senator Raper, you'll have ample time to close before we vote on the bill. We're in recess until 1 p.m. today.
Agenda
SB882
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlie Collins Chair
Unverified
Senator Jason Rapert
Unverified
Speaker 13
Speaker 15
Dan Greenberg
Unverified
Speaker 33
Eric Shuler
Unverified