House Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (9)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1160
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1160”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB543
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…these bills deal with opioid overdoses. We will be running Senate Bill 543 which is the Joshua Ashley Pauly Act and then after that 88…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB880
· 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB880”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1426
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1426”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1578
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1578”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1711
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1711”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1749
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1749”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1868
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1868”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1876
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1876”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 15, 2026
of the issue but we would like to try to accommodate some folks here so tell us which
bill you're running first. The first one we will run and actually Mr. Chairman as I stated both of these bills deal with opioid overdoses. We will be running Senate Bill 543 which is the Joshua Ashley Pauly Act and then after that 880 which should once we hear the first one the other one is just really a companion bill to it which is dealing with immunity for emergency responders.
And I do have an amendment, sir. Actually, I guess we should deal with them separately, but 543, I do have an amendment, which is an agreed-to amendment with the Prosecuting Attorneys Association. Members, that amendment is on your tablet. It should be that
J&B 346, the amendment. So we're going to hear the amendment first. I'm sorry, Senator, I kind of cut you off You said this is agreed to with This is agreed to, Mr. McMahon
with the Prosecuting Attorney's Association This bill, when you hear it, is basically what you call a 9-1-1 Good Samaritan bill, which states that if someone is with another person who begins to suffer due to an overdose of prescription drugs that if they call 9-1-1, that they themselves would not be charged with simple possession, and we clarified that language specifically. I was a little uncomfortable that somebody might try to drive a truck through the language,
and so we tightened it up to be possession of a controlled substance. And as you'll see, the amendment deals with that particular language that's before you, and so I'd appreciate a good vote to adopt that amendment and then vote on the bill in its entirety. All right, members,
you've heard an explanation of the amendment. What's the will of this committee? We have a motion to adopt the amendment. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? All right, the amendment's adopted. Go ahead and present your bill in its entirety now if you would, Senator. Yes, sir. Mr. Chairman, if it pleases you as
well, I have the parents of Joshua Ashley Pauley here with me as well as Chief Flory with the Chiefs of Police Association. And I'm sorry, sir, I don't have your name, but you can introduce it. Introduce yourself later. They want to say few words on this as well. And of course, Representative Bragg is here to carry this for me on the floor. Members, the Joshua Ashley Pauly Act really comes out of a story that is too often heard now around the country. I was unaware until I began to study and dig into this
issue that literally prescription drug overdoses are now the leading cause of accidental death in the nation outstripping automobile deaths. When I heard that, that got my attention because all my life growing up, typically automobile deaths were one of the leading cause of death in our country. But today, opioid overdoses now are the leading cause of death. And what we have seen happening, if you've been to some of the National Conference of State Legislature
meetings around the country, we're trying to figure out a way to try to save lives. With opioid overdoses, immediately the central nervous system is attacked, the respiratory system is attacked, and typically people will die if they do not receive attention, much like a heart attack, very quickly after that. There are drugs that you're going to hear in the next bill, the naloxone bill, which can be administered, which will bring them back, bring their breathing ability back very, very quickly. And what happened in Joshua Ashley Pauley's case was a case in Conway, Arkansas,
in which he suffered from a drug overdose. And when he did, it is said that because of fear of possibly getting in trouble, his friends with him did not actually make that call. He literally was less than a couple of blocks from the emergency room at the Conway Regional Hospital, and he died there in that house when he could have been saved had he only had somebody that would come and help. And with that, Mr. Chairman, I believe it would benefit on that particular story
to let the parents have a moment to
say a few words. My name is Ken Ashley Pauley. My wife, Kimberly, 25 years we've been married. Thank you for all of your hard work, first of all. I apologize for the emotions I can't keep them back so I'm not going to try to work on that Mr. Rayford thank you so much
for all your hard work I wanted to talk about Josh and I wrote a few things down but then I thought this isn't about Josh so there's a lot to find out about him if you want to find out there's ways to find out so real quickly I'll just tell you He was a 20-year-old UCA student. He was a Dean's List student. He was an athlete. He was an artist. He resembles that young man standing right there in that white sweater so much.
He was a beautiful person. He was a leader. And he was a young kid that made bad choices. Josh got into something he couldn't get out of. And apparently the people that were with him couldn't help him. But I'll just try to do this quickly. Day before Mother's Day, we were having a date night at home, like you do when your kids are old enough, they don't want you or need you anymore. Our phone rings.
My wife just drops the phone. she tells me Josh was brought into the hospital 45 minutes ago blue with no pulse the hospital is 6 minutes from us we got there knowing it wasn't Josh it had to be somebody else this is not Josh we didn't come to Arkansas 20 years ago for this to happen to our kids anyway the story goes that three boys that afternoon made a decision to drink a mixture
from what I understand of promethazine Xanax and hydrocodone and it was put into a Mountain Dew bottle it's called syrup I encourage you to look for the definition when you get home or somewhere or lean it's what the kids do nowadays from what I understand I learned the last 10 months a lot of things from all these other kids that have come to our homes and shared information these kids can get these products out of their mother's medicine cabinet, their father, grandfather, their friends, parents,
and they get all the information off the internet, and they go make these mixtures. And in order to get into a party sometimes, you've got to take a swig at the door. Anyway, these three boys got into this stuff called syrup or lean, and two of them left and went across the street to have some food. One of them was my son. He was with another man. they'd known each other since they were five years old, all three of these boys. From what I understand, my son said to him, I messed up.
I need some help. The hospital was a block and a half away. Instead of going to the hospital, the boy carried my son back into that house, took a video of him, passed out on the couch with graphic figures drawn on this thing, and sent it to all his friends. He had time to do that, but not call 911. He then left and went to work and left my son with the other young man. These boys grew up together. Great athletes, great kids, great people, great families. They made a bad choice and they
got scared. The boy my son was left with told me his own words. I checked your son. He was snoring weird. I couldn't wake him up. He was bigger than me, so I just checked on him later. he said he checked on him 15 minutes later and he had the same thing weird, snoring, couldn't wake him up he said he put a glass of water next to him in case he woke up he said he went upstairs to play more music
he came back down and he said to me my son was dead and I asked this young man why did you not do anything and he said because we were scared and others were telling me if he wakes up he'll get in trouble for nothing well that told me there was communication going on when my son lied there dying that these kids could have done something and it even really touches a raw nerve in me that we no longer have the human decency in our society
to reach out and help each other because we're hiding in a silent culture called electronics and technology the parents of 20 years ago are now beyond being the babies of this generation we now have passed it on to our kids there's so much going on I have a cell phone at home that breaks my heart because of the information that goes out of it and comes in on it and that was Joshua's phone anyhow Mr. Raper had mentioned about statistics
my number is it's over a million families that are touched every day. Maybe that's a year. Every year. But the ripple effect goes on. Mother's Day is coming up. That's the day my son died. My wife's first Mother's Day. We'll never have another Mother's Day that means what it used to mean to us. The ripple effect is just bad choices. And as parents, we make the choice
when we touch our kid and say, You go do what you need to do. Stay in touch with me. And we don't follow up. We don't parent well anymore. We. Anyway, it's a game changer. Kids are lured into it. We donated Joshua's organs before they took the organs. They told us we don't want his liver because it won't be any good. When they came back, they said the liver was pristine. Your son died of an accidental overdose.
which when you take it creates effects in the body just like Senator Rayford explained to us so it's not always a bad thing going on these kids get lured in by artists there's words molly that is out there those words find them I really can't say anything else about this we need you folks to continue your job
I don't know if it costs anything to say yes let's start saving lives but Arkansas is always first in pregnancy or bad health or overeating let's be first in saving lives folks I've been on a challenge trying to tell people that the acronym for Josh is just offer simple help and then all of this started and I thought thank you God we're making a difference people are going to do something So thank you very much. I'm done, and let's just do the right thing.
Thank you, folks. Mr. Chairman, thank you for allowing them to speak, and I appreciate the courage that they've shown throughout this process and bring this to your attention. Members, before you in the findings, you have statistics about this issue and what's happening across the country. I would be happy to entertain questions. We have law enforcement here to also speak if you'd like to have a question to them as well. But this is simply a bill which states it does not allow people to go out and do drug-related crimes and not be held accountable.
What it says in a situation similar to this, if there is an emergency and they're trying to save a life and they call 911, they simply wouldn't be prosecuted for simple possession or if they'd ingested themselves. In North Carolina, they already say that this particular law is saving lives. In my findings, you see that there were 14 states that have already taken this approach as well to try to save lives. That's actually up to nearly 20 now with the District of Columbia involved. So in terms of saving lives in the state of Arkansas, I don't want to hear another story like the Ashley Pawleys,
and we hope that this will make a difference in the lives of young people and all people in the state of Arkansas. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman. Madam Chair, no explanation of the bill. Questions from the committee? Seeing no questions of the committee, anyone sign and speak for or against this bill? Seeing none, what's the will of this committee? Motion. We have many motions do pass. Any discussion on the motion itself?
Hearing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Congratulations, Senator. That bill has passed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, committee. Yes, sir. Now you want to present
kind of a companion bill. What number is that? Senate Bill 880. 880, okay. And, Mr. Chairman, this bill does have an amendment. This deals with the use of medical tourniquets as well as naloxone, which is the opioid antidote drug. And we noticed in passing the bill that the immunity on the tourniquet issue
was not exactly tightened up. And so we would appreciate the adoption of the amendment and then consideration of the
bill. All right, members, your amendment is on the tablet. and I think I heard somebody say motion was that for an adoption of the amendment we have a motion for the adoption of the amendment any questions on the on the amendment hearing none all in favor of adoption any opposed okay your amendment has been adopted Senator Raper if you would present your bill 880
thank you mr. chairman I would like to yield because you basically have heard some of the issues in my presentation I would like to yield to chief Flory to speak specifically about naloxone as well as the tourniquet. Thank you, Senator Raypert. Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, thank
Speaker 26
14:35
you very much for the opportunity to be here today. Thank you for the passage of the Pauley bill. I think that's going to go a long way in helping save lives. Certainly as a law enforcement professional, we support that. I'm the police chief of the city of Hot Springs. I have 36 years of law enforcement experience, having worked over 30 years in the state of Texas as a police chief.
I'm also a paramedic and have been for nearly 40 years. Hang on with me just a second. Let's go ahead and get your name for the record, too. David Florey. David Florey. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Florey. I'm also a member of the executive board of the Arkansas Association of Chiefs of Police as one of their vice presidents. I have with me today Clay Goddard. Clay is a major with the Special Operations Team of MEMS. He oversees all the tactical paramedic training programs. He is a former member of the United States Navy SEAL Team II as a former medic in the military. I'd like for an opportunity for him to speak as well.
Along with this bill, with the Austin Poly bill, oftentimes in law enforcement, we're We're the first to arrive on the scene of an overdose, an accidental overdose oftentimes, before medical personnel are cleared to come into the scene. Oftentimes, having been first on scene, we don't have an opportunity to take much action while waiting for EMS personnel to get there. Many states, I believe 27 of them, have adopted bills similar to this, giving civil and criminal immunity to law enforcement officers and law enforcement agencies
who train their personnel in the carrying and the use of naloxone sold under the trade name of Narcan to offset the effects of an overdose from an opiate derivative drug such as heroin, morphine, fentanyl, and so forth. What we are hoping the committee passes is a civil and criminal liability Good Samaritan bill where law enforcement in Arkansas can train police officers to carry naloxone, Narcan, in a very simple device, what we call a MAD device,
where we insert the drug through the nasal passages in a very simple procedure, which, again, will reverse the effects of the drug where someone has had their respiratory drive depressed and is not breathing. We took the opportunity as a chief's association to approach Senator Rapert and also asked for an opportunity to have a similar immunity bill for the use of law enforcement use of mechanical tourniquets. Clay and I both are heavily involved in teaching police officers across the state of Arkansas in the use of tourniquets.
Since implementing the training in Hot Springs two years ago, my police officers have to save the lives of six people who otherwise would have bled to death had our officers not been trained in carrying mechanical tourniquets. The tourniquets that we recommend, which is specifically mentioned in the bill, are two different tourniquets that are recommended by the military's Committee on Tactical Combat Casualty Care. Again, Clay and I both are instructors in that arena, and so we ask for consideration for passage of that bill.
I yield to Clay Goddard for further information.
What, I mean, it always comes down, we've always got to consider money in time we talk about anything. Sometimes it's hard to do because I know we're talking about human lives and health committee, we always are, but how much money are we talking about? Are the forces paying for this? Are the local community, states, how's that going
Speaker 26
17:52
to work financially? Yes, Mr. Chairman. Any law enforcement agency that chooses to provide training to their police officers would bear the full expense for the training and equipment to include the Narcan and or tourniquets.
But Mr. Goddard could probably speak more specifically to an opportunity that with passage of this bill will encourage the Arkansas Health Department at free charge to issue tourniquets to police officers across the state of Arkansas.
Okay, so the Arkansas Department of Health will be providing the tourniquets Not in all cases, sir Many
Speaker 26
18:25
agencies, Hot Springs being one of them Springdale Police Department Fayetteville Police Department, I know specifically because I've trained both of those entire departments
Many other agencies have already outfitted their police officers in the use of or outfitted their officers in tourniquets and borne that whole expense by their own agency to include the training. This bill only addresses the remedy of an officer. If an agency chooses to provide the training with Narcan and or with tourniquets, they are immune from civil penalty for the use of those devices. Very good. That's the essence
of the bill, Mr. Chairman. And actually, it's a good
question. No one has approached me from any agency with any cost effect or anything to the state. It's been central to providing immunity for them to, if they're in this situation, if they use a tourniquet or use the naloxone, that there wouldn't be any repercussions against them, sir. Very good. Members, any questions
from Mr. Flory? Seeing none, Senator Riper, are you ready to close for your bill? I'm close for the bill. If you've got more time, you're close for the bill. Members, for an explanation, no one signed up to speak for or against us,
Seeing no one coming forward from the audience, what's the will of this committee? We have a motion to do pass. I think Representative Branson got that in first. Members, any discussion of that motion? Hearing or seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? And your bill is passed. Thank you, committee, Mr. Chairman. Okay, Representative Hammer, you are first on this long list of House bills we want to hear. if there's any senators in this room
I know Senator Sample came up here we plan to hear I know we're going to have to come back in here this afternoon and we plan to hear only Senate bills this afternoon I know I said it would be a Senate day today and it looks like it's going to work better if we hear the Senate bills this afternoon we're going to try to get some House bills heard this morning so seeing no senators we'll have some hammer fuel to take and start telling us what all you intend to do at the end of that table that would be great I see you have a pile of paperwork yeah what what is that oh I've got a copy
here yeah that's that's good okay which bill are you running first
Representative, do you have amendments to this bill? The amendment, Mr. Chairman, should already be engrossed in the bill. It was ran as members' own, so it should be on the tablet as it is being
presented. The amendments are engrossed, members, so if you would present your bill as amended. Now, I think we've heard this bill before, and I believe this will be the last time we could hear this bill. But I think you've amended a lot of the
language, so let's hear the bill, sir. All right, and, Mr. Chairman, I can't get my tablet to pull up, but I'm going to go off memory on this.
As the bill is amended, it would give nurse practitioners the ability to prescribe Schedule 2 through 5 under the collaborative agreement, working in conjunction with the doctor. I think this relieved some, maybe not all, of the heartburn that some had around the table, but it basically maintains the collaborative agreement. And I could bring some folks to the table that could tell you of situations where we have doctors in Little Rock that are on ecologists that are prescribing to patients that are geographically way out of the area,
and it is a hindrance to them to be able to work with the local practitioner that that patient has seen, and this would help address an issue such as that. So with that, I'll be glad to ask any questions or whatever motion comes out of the
committee. Representative, will I be recognized for a question? Motion? Hang on.
No one has signed up to speak for or against this bill. Yes, we do. Okay. I was thinking there would be. If there's a representative hammer bill, it's not going to be. Ugly job.
All right. All right. Here we go. We're trying to clarify which one of your bills people the most are signed to speak for and against. We've got two fours and one against, so we'll start with the four.
Cassie Gonzalez is to speak for the
bill. Mr. Chair. Yes. I'd just like the members, if this has been passed out, to draw attention to this. It kind of is a companion piece that goes
right? Okay, Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. I understand that the map talks about Schedule IIs. I guess my question, though, is in how many of these states is that done under supervision of a doctor
and not an APN practicing out alone? I really don't. Maybe Cassie can
answer that question. I'm going to take the first run at it, though, and just say this, that at a minimum, it'd be great if they're practicing without the supervision of a physician in the majority of the state, because that would only go to build the argument that I had originally when this bill was presented. So at minimum, they would at least have to have a collaborative agreement, I would think, which in the state of Arkansas, you can see the colors on there.
So as I presented the bill earlier, if they didn't have to have the collaborative arrangement and as a nurse practitioner, are they able to do that on a stand-alone basis, that would be great. So I can't really answer your question. Cassie may want to take a run at that if that would
be acceptable to you. Yeah, I mean, I guess my question is, you know, the majority of nurses, I would think, would be working in doctor's offices under the supervision of a physician. And it's my understanding that in most of the states where they have class 2 privileges,
that is the situation. They're actually working under the supervision of a physician and not out by themselves prescribing Schedule IIs like Oxycontin. All
right. Chair, can Cassie go ahead? Yes, obviously introduce yourself for the record as you've done before,
Speaker 59
25:20
and you're recognized. Cassie Gonzalez, family nurse practitioner, Representative Ferguson. I think 17 states have complete independent practice for nurse practitioners, so that would reflect this map. Now, I do not know the detail of those states that are, other than that, that are working how they're working.
Either it's a collaborative practice agreement or under direct supervision. Most nurse practitioners are in collaborative practice agreements in those other states. They would be there. Committee, today I would like to bring to you some of my thoughts on this as a nurse practitioner working in rural southwest Arkansas. Two things that come to mind in two patients that I would like to bring forth to you. One, we are in a family practice clinic setting, taking care of a vast variety of patients from acute to chronic needs.
But one patient that sticks out in my mind, we have a mid-50-year-old female who has MS. And if you know that disease, it's a progressive disease. She sees a neurologist here in Little Rock who is taking care of most of her needs. But one of her plan of care is a fentanyl patch that helps control some of her pain. When she came to our clinic, she asked if we could see her for her acute and chronic needs, and we agreed to do that. In doing so, we worked out a collaborating agreement with this physician that's a neurologist here in Little Rock,
and he called our clinic, asked if we could write her fentanyl patch for her for the reason that she doesn't have to drive to Little Rock to get this. As you all know, Schedule II medications have to be hand-scripted on a script. That patient has to take that script literally to a pharmacy to be filled. So with doing that, that collaboration between us and her neurologist just allows the patient to drive a 10-minute drive to our clinic to pick up that hand script versus driving an hour and 30 minutes to her neurologist here in Little Rock.
So, you know, I ask that question of can nurse practitioners prescribe Schedule II? majority of the time we are not initiating a new medication for that patient the majority of the time we're just trying to refill medications for the ease and the convenience of patients yes there is abuse that goes on and we understand that we do utilize our prescription monitoring website that is up and available that also connects us with multiple states so that we can watch patients and watch for abuse but but our biggest concern is for these patients to be able
to get quick care and not have to drive an hour, an hour and 30 minutes to go pick up narcotic scripts for their specialists, which are very indicated for their disease. I have another patient in our clinic who's in her mid-70s. She's seen a neurosurgeon here in Little Rock, and the same thing. She's not a candidate for surgery, and so pain management with Schedule 2 medication is her only alternative. And so all we are doing is just trying to use collaboration with these specialist physicians to be able to control pain management as in our
telemedicine bill or representative ferguson's telemedicine bill we could utilize the same same aspect we could in a family practice setting in rural arkansas collaborate with these physicians across the state to get the patient the best needed care and yet if the collaborating physician that's via telemedicine or like we are doing just via phone talking to these physicians the specialists, if they indicate that a Schedule II prescription is necessary, they're going to have to handwrite that prescription and mail it to the patient. Now, if this bill passed, we could write
that prescription for them under the supervision and direction of that physician. So I ask you today to please consider the bill for those reasons. Members, any
questions? Seeing none, we have someone speak against this. It would be David Roten. Actually, Mr. Chairman,
Scott Smith. Mr. Roden's down in another committee hearing, so sorry about that. You wrote very poorly, and I
All right, Mr. Smith, you recognize. Give testimony. Scott Smith with Arkansas Medical Society. Around the country, every 19 minutes, there's a death associated with Schedule IIs. It's a serious category of drugs, what this bill would do. And, you know, at one time it was amended to address 39 counties. It was amended, changed, parts of it were taken out. And so as this bill is amended now, what you'd be passing would apply to the whole state.
And that would be over 1,000 APNs who never prescribed these drugs before would be prescribing. And the committee that would be set up under this bill made up of folks that have not prescribed either before. Some serious concerns that we have with this bill. These are serious drugs that we're talking oxycodone, hydrocodone. We got their ADHD drugs as well that are arguably overprescribed today.
And so that's simply where we are in our
concerns with the bill. All right, Mayor Smith, do you take a question maybe?
Yes, sir. All right. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Smith, can you explain the governing board of these nurse practitioners, and do they have experience in prescribing
these type drugs, and is that a concern of yours as well? Well, I'm not aware of them having experience, and if they have been licensed and practiced in Arkansas exclusively,
well, then they would not have had an opportunity to prescribe Schedule 2s. But I don't know specifically about the warden makeup. Maybe there's some who have been out of state, but no, they wouldn't if they're from Arkansas. All right. Thank you
I'm Sue Tedford, Executive Director of the Board of Nursing. When an APRN is educated, every basic education program is in prescribing Schedule II through five medications. So every nurse is educated through her basic educational program. Many of our nurses come from out of state. They come from the states they've been prescribing Schedule II drugs. So a lot of our nurses do have experience in prescribing the Schedule IIs.
According to the DEA, 43 states allow APRNs to prescribe Schedule 2, and none of the states that currently allow prescribing Schedule 2 have ever rescinded that privileges due to any misprescribing of Schedule 2 by APRNs. As you heard in previous testimony, a lot of the drug problems that are coming on and going around are from prescriptions gotten out of the medicine cabinets. They're not always by prescribing physicians, nurses, or any of that.
It's coming from the medicine cabinets of their family and their friends. So this is not going to put any more drugs out there. What it's going to do is make it easier for the families, as Ms. Cassie said, for them to get the medications that they need because they do have to go in the office. It has to be a written prescription, so the families and patients need the access.
Members, any questions? Seeing none, that's everyone. I'm sorry. Representative Henderson, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. In these other states where your APRNs prescribe, have any of them lost their license due to misconduct, abuse of prescribing? I don't know of any, but if I had to guess, absolutely,
I'm sure there have been. We have disciplined nurses in Arkansas for misprescribing. Just like everybody else, there is some of those that misprescribe.
Representative Ferguson, you recognize for a question? I guess, wouldn't you agree that the whole reason behind the DEA tightening the prescribing of Schedule 2s with written prescription is all is because we have such a huge prescription drug problem, and you're asking us to sort of override the DEA and extend that Schedule II to more groups. I mean, it's already a big problem. How do you rationalize that?
I'm not sure I know what the thinking behind the DEA was, but the prescribing of Schedule II, I mean, it's been by physicians, the problems out there, and you're right, adding another group can increase the problem, but they are educated to know when and what's appropriate to prescribe these drugs
and for what patients. I guess my question is, would you not agree that if they need something as serious as a Schedule II, they need to be referred back to their doctor?
Well, a lot, as Ms. Gonzalez testified, a lot of the times the APRNs are refilling prescriptions that have already been initially assessed by a physician. So if it's just a refill, then you've already had the physician assessment. Representative Sullivan, you're
just heard that every 19 minutes, I guess there's a problem with these scheduled drugs, with people taking these kinds of drugs, yet in 40 states, the
ability to prescribe meds by APNs has never been withdrawn. So I would assume then that there is no evidence in those 40 states that the APN prescription has anything to do with that statistic. I'm not sure I'm following you. Too complicated a question. We heard there's a problem every 19 minutes. But in 40 states where they're doing this, they haven't ever, it hasn't been attributed to your profession. Correct.
I don't know of any study that says it's the APRNs or
the physicians who's causing the problem. Right.
Thank you. All right, members, for an explanation of the bill, I'm sorry, Representative Fayette, you're recognized. Motion to limit debate. I don't even think I'll accept that motion, so I think we're
to the right point. Are you closed for your bill, Representative Hammer? I'd like to just make a couple comments, and I'm closed and ready for immediate consideration. Okay, let's hear them. Okay. First thing, in the state of Florida, for example, APRNs cannot prescribe scheduled true drugs,
but yet they have one of the higher problems when it comes to the narcotic drugs that we're talking about. So I think you can poke holes in all the arguments that have been made here today, but the one argument you can't poke a hole in is that you've got a patient who needs to be able to access their medicine without having to make a trip an hour and a half up into Little Rock to see their oncologist. I find that just unacceptable that we would subject those individuals for regular maintenance pain medicine to have to be subjected to drive all the way to Little Rock because of that. I wouldn't want my family doing that, and I've been in cases where my families have had to have that kind of medicine because they were battling diseases that were causing them to die.
So I do not accept that argument. If that's the best you can make, I think it's pretty weak. Number two, the other thing is that we're talking about doing this under collaborative agreement. It's not like they can go out and just willy-nilly write these prescriptions. They're under a collaborative agreement. And the one point that was not mentioned that is in this bill is that I believe it's amended into this bill that the nursing board would establish a committee made up of APRNs in order to address one of the issues that was concerned. That wasn't even talked about, but that is in this bill. And for that reason, I think we've got all the merit to allow this to happen,
and I would appreciate a good vote, and I move to pass. I remember sharing
explanation we have a motion on the table do pass do we have any discussion of the motion seeing no discussion of the motion all in favor say aye I'll oppose a no chair rules and those have it I have one hand I have two hands for roll call. Let's call the roll, Mr. Vice.
Speaker 94
37:59
Representative Love. Yes. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Hammer. Yes. Representative Branscombe. Yes. Representative Meeks. Yes. Representative Overby. No. Representative Ritchie. No. Representative Ritchie. No. Representative McGee. No.
Representative Miller. Yes. Representative Womack. Yes. Representative Bragg. Yes. Representative Fite. Yes. Representative Payton. Yes. Representative Lundstrom. Representative Lundstrom? Representative Bentley? Representative Boyd? Representative Boyd? Representative
Henderson? Representative Sullivan? Representative Ferguson? 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11.
Hi, Representative Hammer. You've got 11 votes yes, 4 nays, 5 not voting, and your bill is passed. And what's next? Has the chair received
an amendment on the mandated contraceptives? And I don't know what bill number that is unless I look here. Bill number
1868. Yes. Yes, we'll have an amendment up here. Let me get it on my timeline. Mr. Chair, can I ask Phil a question?
Please do. Did that come in the last five minutes? Yes, sir. Okay. Could I have that amendment passed out, please, if the chair allows? We're going to try to get that on the tablet. Okay. Thank
this amendment does. I wasn't even going to run this amendment that you're seeing today until I heard discussion on the floor yesterday about the problem that we have
with unplanned pregnancies in the state of Arkansas and what a problem it is. And really, I debated running this. This bill, basically, if you allow it to go through with the amendment, Everything that's in the bill before it's amended, the Department of Health can do now with regards to offering to young mothers the opportunity to have birth control devices, one of which is the five-year implant. What this amendment would actually do is direct the Department of Human Services to contact CMS
and to seek permission in order to go ahead and offer to those who would like to have the five-year implant $2,500. The purpose and the idea behind that, which it seems pretty extreme, especially coming out of a preacher, is that there are times in lives when people, and I don't like using the word mistake because I don't think any baby is a mistake of God. I just, I can't accept that philosophy, that mindset. But there are times in life where individuals need to call timeout, and they need to get their life together before they bring any more responsibility into the world.
And what this would actually do is allow them that if they got the five-year implant to be entitled to receive $2,500, the purpose behind the money would be, and it would be controlled in which it would be given. It's not like we're going to cut anybody a $2,500 check. but if you have one baby out of wedlock and you want to get your life together sometimes you need a little help doing that and if you're willing to get the five year implant so that you can slow down and think about your actions before you go any further that's what it would be intended the bill is specifically stated hang on, are we still on the amendment
because we now have it on the tablet by the way I know the $2,500 is in the amendment I'm reading that and members you should be able to see 1868 the amendment should be on your tablet now so before we get into the bill I want to make sure that we have the amendment adds the $2,500 to it yes sir sure does members you've heard the amendment you should be able to see the amendment on your tablet what's the will of this committee do pass we have a motion to adopt the amendment representative Lindstrom all those in favor say aye
any opposed all right the amendment is adopted and so now present your bill as amended. Thank you Mr. Chair.
What this would do is simply direct DHS to contact CMS and say if we did this is it possible does it meet the federal guidelines and if they come back and say yes it does then we as a committee would or you know as a legislative body would take that up. Do I agree with the idea of paying people to stop having babies? No but
based on testimony I heard yesterday and like I said after yesterday's meeting I thought we need to explore every option even the ones that make some of us cringe a little bit and just see what CMS would allow. Could DHS write them a letter and say is this possible? Yes, but as many of you have seen around this place sometimes when we leave and we're gaveled out for the session some of the things we think they're going to get done don't get done so this would be legislatively put in place requiring DHS to ask and that would require action whenever the answer came back. I'll be glad to answer any questions.
My first question, wow, where do you even start? Mr. Seelig here from Department of Human Services. There you are. John, I'm going to leave it to you to kind of explain to us in a more objective manner what's going on here. And in all fair. Is this like a waiver application almost of some sort? I mean, where does the $2,500 come from? And just tell us about it. Actually, Mr. Chair, I
haven't seen the amendment, so if I can, I'm John Seedy with the Department of Human Services.
I think I understand what it does, but if I can just ask, Representative Hammer, the amendment at this point just asked us to ask whether it's permissible. It doesn't then require us to do it if they say yes, or it does require that we
fund it if they say yes. Mr. Chair the way I'd answer that question it would not require them but it would establish and part of the reason $2,500 honestly there's no scientific
evidence behind why that number you could put at $500 you could put $5,000 part of what I hope would happen is that CMS would work with us in order to be able to achieve whether or not that number is a close number that it would be something that would require us to at least put it on the table for discussion. Let me, from the chair, preach for a moment. Yes, sir, you may. You get to do
that every Sunday, so let me, from the chair, preach for a moment. I kind of like the idea, kind of like you're saying,
but we are right here at the end of the committee. We're trying to change an entire concept of what you're doing, and I think this is something that I think Mr. Seelig might look at and perhaps would be able to implement in the rules using yourself. I think you're sitting on council this year, aren't you? Are you still on audit? But we have enough friends on council that I think that we might want to look at this. I don't think it's any place for this committee and this legislature to be trying to look at this on the last two days of running bills. I think it's a great concept, but I think that we ought to look at it through the interim.
This is me preaching. I don't do it too much from up here, but I'm concerned about the questions back and forth between an agency director and a legislator about trying to figure out what's going on, us possibly passing this in the next five minutes and it becoming law when I'm not sure that it's thought through as well as
it could be. May I respond to that? Please do. With regards to is it thought through, it's been sitting out there for a while. It's just I chose to amend it at the end to add the 2,500. It was subject to a conversation that was had on the House floor yesterday that made me, and that conversation substantiated the fact
that we have a problem in the state of Arkansas with unplanned pregnancies and it's a growing problem it's not a shrinking problem so part of that was precipitated from that and that's and i'm not and i'm going to be honest representative first and i uh really honestly god honest truth when you said that yesterday i thought well why hold back why not go ahead and do it now the other thing mr chair is that i don't know if people realize and understand it but there was a law that was passed back in 2000 2001 as i've been told by research that But back then, they passed a law that said a mother who has a child out of wedlock
will only be able to receive services or will only be able to receive certain subsidies for a two-year period. Other states in the nation went as high as five, but back in 2000 and 2001, I was told, the state of Arkansas said, no, that's only going to happen for two years. So if you're 15 years old now, which is when we begin to see a lot of problems as far as children having unplanned pregnancies. And there are people out there thinking that at 15 you're going to be able to have a baby and just have subsidies until 18.
They're fixing to be a rude awakening in the state of Arkansas because of a law that was passed back in 2000 that said you can only, as the mother, get that assistance for two years. And then after that, the baby will be able to have assistance, but the mother won't. Based on the conversation yesterday, that's why I decided to go ahead and run the bill today. but I'll be glad to send it into interim study. I'm not in disagreement with you. My vice chair is
that. I am so happy that Representative Hammer and I can both agree on a bill.
Write it down. No, actually the task force that I talked about with my bill yesterday looked at some things that have been done in this regard. Actually, the Bill Gates Foundation did a study in Malau where they paid young women not to have children and to attend school. And the money, the reimbursements were based on school attendance and not getting pregnant. And I think it's a great concept. I can tell you some of the concerns that came out of the task force,
and I would hope we would pass this and then look at the parameters and rules because my health department tells me that about 50% of the long-acting contraceptives that are placed, actually the girls end up coming back in three or four months and have them removed. So I think that's one issue. I'm certainly a proponent of the long-acting contraceptives, the LARCs, but that is something that could be addressed in rules, certainly. But as I've said yesterday, when we're spending $328 million on combined federal and state funding
on deliveries for Medicaid babies, I think the savings in the long term would be great compared to the $2,500. But I do think there need to be some parameters and rules around how it's administered. Thank you for indulging me. Do we have any idea Mr. Seelig what this would cost? Is this like are we
applying for a waiver? What are we doing here? I was just texting staff to see I don't know whether it would take a waiver
I think at best what the federal government would fund is probably the normal about 75% of the cost so we'd pay 25% and I just if you create this incentive and certainly we would like to reduce the number of teen pregnancies I don't have any estimate of how many people would take advantage of this and so what the state's share of that would be okay Okay.
Rep. Sam Hammer, let's move this interim and do something. I love the idea. I like the concept. I think there's a major money savings out there, but I am very concerned at us doing this, basically, nearly the last health meeting of the session.
Mr. Chair, I concur 100%, and quite honestly, I apologize to the Chair because I manipulated the meeting a little bit to get the information out there that a law that was passed in 2000 is going to begin to directly have impact today that if you're a child that's 15-year-old and you're thinking about going out and having a baby, according to what I understand, research told me that you, as the parent, are only going to be able to have about two years' worth of assistance, and then it's going to dry up. and there are some out there that think they can have babies and have several babies
and have a lifelong ability to receive subsidies, that's fixing to come to the end. I don't know that's been promoted as much as it ought to be. So I'll be glad to move this into interim study. Thank you. Very good. Thank you. Without objection,
we will move this interim study, and I think it's one of those that truly needs to be studied in the interim instead of just going there to die. So I think this committee will do that on the floor. I'm sorry. Okay. Okay, so there is an objection from staff to move that to him from staff. I'm just kidding.
I know, I know. We can't do it. He will do
that on the floor. All right. Rev. Sam Hammer, did you have one more before you leave them to the table? I think I have one more, sir, and it's the background check. One
is House Bill 1876. This isn't a manipulation of the committee, is it? No, sir. Straight up, straight out. 1876. And the amendment looks like it is engrossed.
It is, okay. All right, you recognize, present 1876. About two years ago, I had somebody come to me. I'm going to leave the school unnamed, but it is not actually a medical program with regards to physicians, but it is regarding a therapy, a physical therapy program, whereby I got a call from one of my constituents and said, hey, I didn't get to go to school, and then I found out that some of the ones that did when they got through school that they actually couldn't pass their state
and federal background check, and they weren't able to go into their field, and if that would have been known on the front end instead of the back end, I wouldn't have got bumped out of the slot, and that's what this bill is all about. Now, I did text because I wanted to be able to provide current information because I've had research trying to collect information from all the schools that offer various programs that once they successfully complete that program physical therapy or medical school whatever that they have to have a state and federal background check before they're able to get licensed and as of probably yesterday
I think there was a total of six that we documented I think the numbers probably higher than that but that's one I can hang my hat on and so what this bill does is require that once you require once you declare that you are going to go into a medical field profession in school that you at that point have to take a federal and state background check and the reason behind it is that if you've got something in your past and you could be a 17 year old that goes to college not declare that you're going to go into a medical profession field that's going to eventually require a federal background or state background check
before you get your licensure you can have a lot of things happen in two years that's going to put a black mark that's going to prohibit you from getting that license later so what this does is say that once you declare that in school, then you have to get the federal and state background check because why let you go through school, take somebody else's slot who could have passed and gotten through, and you've taken their slot instead. That's the merit of the bill, and the idea. I'll be
glad to take any questions. Okay. I'm trying to fight down my
cynicism, Representative Hammer, but is this necessary? I mean, really? Well, yes, sir, and I'll tell you why it's necessary. Because I had a
constituent come to me that was very mad because they wanted to go to school in central Arkansas for physical therapy. They got turned down. One of the people that took their slot, made it all the way through school, went to get their license. That person before they start
school, just as a point of qualification, I believe, had to sign that says they're not a felon. They've committed fraud, did they not? Because they have to sign that says I'm not a felon before
they start school. I'm not sure that we should require them to take. But anyway, that's just me being me right now members any questions from the real committee well
can I can I address that sure I'm sorry they sign it with the school and maybe somebody from higher ed could come in a step or somebody else and say I don't know that that would constitute you lied versus fraud this is going to clear up all the gray area and put it in a black or white position that if you're going to enroll in in you know you get halfway through college say at UCA and you're going to enter in their physical therapy program and you can't pass a background check at that point this clears up
all that issue and why should we have people that could and want to be prohibited because of those that said yeah and they thought they could skirt by and get out of it. What's that background cost you know? I think according to what state police on that bill that got killed unmercifully on the floor yesterday if I remember right. It was about we're talking about
somewhere in the $35 $45 range. Alright members any other questions? Seeing none is there anyone from the audience speaking for against this bill?
We don't have anyone signed up for it. Were you wanting to speak forward against this bill? No, we can't ask questions. All right. Members, what's the will of this committee? I'll make a motion due pass. We have a motion due pass. What's the discussion on the motion? Hearing or seeing none, all in favor say aye. All opposed? Surprisingly, your bill passes.
Actually, not surprising anymore. All right. Are you done, Rep. Miller? I'm going to put you down there for a couple bills. Are you ready for that? All right.
Hi, Representative Miller. I think you're ready to tell us the first bill number you have. Is that that CFCO bill? the 1749 1749 and I think the amendment is engrossed mr. chair could I ask
table as well certainly okay we uh we do have an amendment basically my concern has been for a long time since i've
learned of the waiting list hang on hang on we're trying we're trying to find an amendment we don't have an amendment here it should be engrossed already now if it's engrossed if you have amended this on the House floor, then it's engrossed into the bill. Yes, yes. Okay, okay, that's what I was trying to clarify first. Okay, I'm sorry. All right, so you're presenting the bill as amended, and we're reading the bill as amended here. Okay, you recognize it. Yes, sir. Okay, thank you.
Anyway, again, I've been very concerned for a long time about the individuals that are on this waiting list. CFCO was first presented. I first learned about it sometime last year. and I was not overly... And the CFCO is community
first choice option. Yes, sir. I apologize for... That's no problem. We'll use CFCO from now on. I think everybody knows that,
but it's a community first choice option. Yes, that's my bad. Anyway, I was not overly keen on it because it's another federal program.
I thought we had an opportunity to take steps at the state level to fix this problem. However, we've not been able to generate any traction with that. and basically, y'all, we have gone over and above to take care of populations in this state. I will remind us that we have just appropriated $2 billion to take care of folks on the private option.
A couple of things about that. Number one, no one on the private option is disabled, not one soul. Number two, of the population that's on the private option, 90% of them are healthy. We only have 10% that are medically frail. Folks, the population that we're looking at here, between 2,500 and 3,000 folks that are on this waiting list are medically frail.
Some of the opponents of this bill have said this is an uncapped entitlement program under Obamacare. I think my record shows that I hate Obamacare as much as anybody. But when something's right, it's right. When it's wrong, it's wrong. It may be an uncapped entitlement program under Obamacare, but to be eligible for this uncapped entitlement program,
you have to be severely disabled, unlike many of our other programs that we're spending billions of dollars on. And I visited with the governor and others, and there was some concern about jumping in and signing up on this and so I proposed an amendment where we give until September 1st of this year
for our executive branch and DHS to look into coming up with alternative ways to fund this without us having to do CFCO. My number one concern is eliminating the waiting list. I want these folks to have coverage. It's not right for us to cover everyone else and turn our backs on this population. And so the amendment says that they have until September 1st to gather information,
and then a decision will be made by September 15th as to whether or not we can take that course of action or we have to do CFCO. And I'm going to let Representative Love speak for a minute. Representative
Love, you're recognized. I'm sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I kind of take it as granted. If you as a representative at this table, you're recognized. Well,
thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you, committee. I'm still waiting for the lightning to strike because me and Representative Miller are at the end of the table together.
But in all seriousness, as he stated, right is right. I mean, you will hear testimony from DHS and others in regards to how we can fix this. I actually was in consultation with DHS the entire time that me and Representative Miller were discussing it. And all this does, all this legislation does is provide a mechanism for us to draw down matching funds, which we are already doing.
It's no expansion to the Medicaid budget. We are actually drawing, we're actually utilizing the funds that we already have. And since the match is better, what it does is it allows us to cover all the people that would apply for the waivers. So this is just common sense. This is right is right. we need to provide an option for those and allow them to have a choice if they want to go into a facility or a nursing home well that's that's their choice but
if they want to stay at home with loved ones for people that care for for people to care for them they should have that option as well and so all we're doing is just providing the option so that so that people with disability will have that choice and as I stated you will hear a lot of testimony from others to and for and against this but I believe that this is the right thing to do and I'm supportive of it I've been working with Representative Miller for a while on this and I tell you I get a lot of positive feedback in regards to CFCO
and I think it's the right thing to do Arkansas needs to take the step and with With that, I will close, Mr. Chairman, and we will entertain any questions that you have. Well,
we just got a couple to start with. Representative Meeks is first, and I'll get to
you, Representative Overly. Thank you, Representative Miller and Representative Love. You know, I agree with you. We need to do something with the waiting list, and, you know, I look forward to doing that through our health care task force, you know, that we would consider those on the waiting list that we actually have. And so, you know, I'll work with you all on that to make sure that we address that issue.
My concern is on, and again, I'm thinking that I'm looking at the right bill and the way that it's engrossed, but on the second page, starting in line nine, it says the waiting list for the alternative community service waivers, commonly known as the development and de-Selves waiver, shall be eliminated by September 1, 2016. That gives me the most heartburn because of that particular timeline, especially when I think we were given testimony before by some folks that said even if we were to implement CFCO, it would take anywhere from two to three years
to eliminate the waiting list simply because of the fact we don't have the resources currently in place, meaning we would have to be able to hire doctors or get doctors or medical professional or whatever. And they were saying, you know, realistically, we could only eliminate 100 to 150 off of that 2800 waiting list. And so I'm kind of concerned on that particular deadline that you've put in. And then, like I said, the other one that you may want to address is I think that this can be done without this bill through the current health care task force that we have
set up. Well, thank you, Representative Meeks. And number one, I understand what you're saying, And I can agree. I have two things. Number one, I don't want to see the can kicked any further down the road. It has been kicked down the road for 10 years. And these folks deserve better than that. And so if there's a – I've had no one suggest to me a deadline.
I've asked. I've had no one suggest to me when the date to have everybody off the waiting list should be. September 1 of 2016 is a product of my own personal genius. So I'm just being honest. That's what it is. So if there is someone here, if you, do you have a better deadline? I'm happy to entertain that. Well, it's interesting
to ask members a question, but sure.
I'll be glad to respond to that. I mean,
I think realistically, I mean, I don't know if you've talked to Director Sealing or anything else, but, again, my recollection from committee meetings was that we would only be able to deal with maybe 100 to 150 at the most, getting them off the waiting list per month because of the fact we didn't have the resources in place. And they said it would be probably two years to three years. And so if we were to start right now, we're talking, you know, 2017, 2018 realistically
because we don't have the resources currently in place and it would take that long to
get the resources in place. As of right now, Representative Meeks, the reason why we don't have the resources in place is because we don't have the mechanism to draw down for the matching funds. And I think that's the biggest piece of this legislation is putting a mechanism in place. If we allow for two more years to lapse on this issue, then that means that will be another three, three-and-a-half years, you're stating.
If we use your math about 18 months to put it in place, that means there's two years for us to enact the legislation and then another 18 months. So that's three-and-a-half more years that people would have to wait in order to get the services that they deserve. And so I don't think, I believe, addressing this issue at this time, even if it takes us 18 months, I think that's still within the September 1, 2016 date that we set. All right.
so if you want to continue, that would be great. Right. Again, even if we were to start today, this bill was to pass today. The bill says that the waiting list will be or shall be, which is pretty much you have to have the waiting list eliminated, by September 1, 2016. I'm saying that that date is not realistic in order for us to be able to do so. You put us in a position to where we've got a date that we possibly cannot meet, number one, and number two, the funding. Yes, we're going to get 76% matched by the federal government,
but that still leaves us 24%. Has the governor or anybody said, okay, here's what our cost is going to be and this is how we're going to be able to meet the cost, whether it's $10 million, $20 million, $30 million. Do we know how all that's going to work? So those are my two big issues
that I hope you can address. I think that's a better question for John Selig. I will tell you this. No. Director Selig, and I'm going to tell you that I believe I saw him somewhere over there. We had this conversation. We had this conversation, and this is the question I want you to ask him,
is do we currently have the money in the budget, in the Medicaid budget, to fulfill this obligation, he will tell you yes. We are not having to come up with any additional money. The match itself will take care of the people on the waiting list. This is just a mechanism. It's common. I don't want to say that, but it's really a good bill, good benefits for the state. Mr. Chair, if I could respond to that also.
Sure. Okay. Representative Meeks, last summer when we redid the contract for PALCO, the money was allocated then or appropriated then for this CFCO. On PALCO's part, obviously not the whole part. So that's one thing. Thank you. All right, I
Wonders never cease because Representative Meeks and I were agreeing completely, but I still don't understand, even though I agree, that people with disabilities in my heart is in the place that I want them to have every advantage that they can have. But what I don't understand is we have set up a task force,
but we're making bills that to me is contradicting what the task force is set out to do am i wrong i don't understand how
you would think it is contradicting this is a issue that was very important to me obviously it's very important to a lot of folks and i do want the task force to have a hand in this. I do want them to opine. I want to ensure
that this gets done. And one thing I've learned in my short time down here is that the only way to ensure that something gets done, and even then it's a gamble, is
to pass a bill. All right. Representative Payton, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Either one of y'all may want to answer this, but basically I've been in on a lot of meetings through the interim where they discuss the efficiencies of the current program that has the waiting list.
So we have people that are already on this program, already providing an example or a test case, and CFCO that we've referred to has come in and said, You know, this program is so efficient in its operation that they want to change the name of it and create a new program called CFCO based on that history. Now, your bill, the way I read it, and you correct me if I'm wrong, does it say that we have to go the CFCO route,
or is it within the purview of the executive branch to just cover the waiting list under the existing program that
has proven so efficient? It is totally up to the executive branch if they can find a way and wish to expand the existing program without going CFCO.
So the task force and the advice that they give the executive branch, the executive branch, even if your bill passes, has the opportunity to choose of any of the known routes or create a currently unknown route as long as the waiting list gets covered. That's right. And that's September 1st of 2016. That was the deadline that is in the bill as far as having the list covered by
the interest. Can I continue a little bit? Well, I've got two more waiting.
Would it be okay if I come back to you, Representative Payton? Yes, sir.
Okay, Representative Bentley, you're recognized. Forgive me for asking a couple questions, representatives, but does this cover the elderly population at all? Or
just fill me in a little bit on it, Representative Miller, on the
knowledgeable about it than I am. Don't talk bad about yourself like that. Yes, I believe that there are some elderly folks on what I refer to as the DD waiver or waiting list.
And there are, you know, if CFCO is enacted, basically takes most of these waivers and bundles them together, I don't know an exact number as far as what the percentages are of elderly folks on that waiting list. So I can't tell you that. All right. Representative
Hammer, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Regarding the population that would automatically be, and if I'm misstating this, you correct me,
The population that would automatically have that list eliminated according to the September deadline that's in the bill, do we know how many people that is based on today's number? There
was one number that was given to Representative Love is a little over 3,000, and I had a number given to me that was just a shade bit under 3,000. And his numbers may have been more recent than mine.
And how did that number get substantiated? How do we know that's a real number?
I believe, Representative Hammer, you can direct that question to John Selig from DHS because DDS maintains the wait list. All right. I want to move back
to Representative Payton. You've had a couple. Representative Payton, you can continue. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. we're winding down the session we're pretty close to voting on a budget between now and next September your deadline
how many budgets will we have an opportunity to design and
least one more so two and it's within the executive branch's authority at any time to cover the existing program and eliminate the waiting list How many years has that been within the executive branch's authority to do? How long has the waiting list existed?
Well, I'm going to say that we know the waiting list is almost or at least 10 years old. Some have been on this waiting list for 10 years. I know that it has been within the state's discretion as to whether or not we could have put in additional monies to have funded and covered the waiting list in years past and it's never been brought up So without a
mandate that your bill creates you have no faith that the waiting list would go away?
this bill passed Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right, members, I'd like to bring up Mr. John Selig, if I could, and I think he maybe will shed different light or more light on some of these questions and continue this conversation. And you'll recognize Mr. Selig, and just tell us if you have any testimony before you want questions. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I mean, I would just say, I mean, we are completely in agreement with the sentiment that we do need to serve people on this waiting list. These are, as you all know, these are families who are trying to keep their, often their children with disabilities at home with them or people with disabilities who are hoping to live in the community. That's their choice. The governor has expressed his strong commitment to having a continuum of choices so that people can live in the best place possible. His concern is, I want to thank Representative Mix and others' voice, just the timing on this.
He would like this to be taken up as part of the broader Medicaid reform look that the task force is doing. And our estimate is, I believe, I don't have the numbers in front of me, but that it would take about two years to serve people in an orderly fashion because you do have to develop, make sure the plan of care is appropriate. You have to work with the local provider and the family. You don't simply say get on the program. You obviously develop services to make sure that they work well for the client. client, and our estimate is that it would take about two years to serve the entire waiting list.
And just the last, there was a question about, I believe it was Representative Hammer, about how many people are on the waiting list. It is about 3,000 people, and we have gone out and contacted those people over the last few months. I haven't seen the latest numbers, but I believe 80 to 90 percent of those people, we have verified that they are, in fact, still eligible and still do want the service. I don't have the exact number, but a large percentage of those have confirmed
to us that they do want the service. Representative Payton. Oh, I'm sorry. Representative
Love, do you have? Well, I did want to direct a couple of questions to Director Selig in regards to the timeline
that he was using because if we don't have this legislation, if we don't enact this legislation, that means that the task force can't act until the next session. And so I think that's the bone of contention here is if we want to kick the can down the road, If we want to wait for another 48 months, from your testimony, it's 24 months to actually enact the program. It's going to be another session, which is two years from now, to actually pass the legislation. That would be four years now. And so, I mean, the task force cannot enact any legislation.
Well, if the task force and the governor were to say, this is the direction we want to go say at the end of this calendar year, we could then immediately begin implementation, well, within the next pretty short period, begin implementation of the program. Then once you begin implementation, just to work people off of that waiting list in an orally fashion takes two years. So you are looking out probably three years by the time you get the person who's number 3,000 at this point. All right.
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Director Seelick, did we already enter into a contract with a company, I believe, called PALCO to hire a number of people that would be responsible for managing the expansion of this program? No, so we
do have a contract with PALCO, but their only involvement, it's not specific to CFCO, if people on community first choice decided they wanted to what's called self-direct their care, where they make the decisions about their care,
the PALCO contract would do some of the support of that, but it does not actually provide the care and support for the people on CFCO. That would be local developmental disability
providers that do that work. If I remember that contract, it was over 300 new hires. I don't have
that number. The PALCO contract was primarily for people who are currently on other services like Elder Choice who are currently out in the community, not for this new waiver population.
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, sir. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. John, just real quick, and
don't belabor the point, how do you go about what is the process to determine the true number of individuals that are out there waiting on this service so we can have a comfort level about knowing if you say 3,000, it is, what's the method to establish
that? At the time they get on the waiting list, they have to – we have already looked at their medical eligibility to see if they meet an institutional level of care.
So then we – and these clients, by and large, that's not going to change for them, for people with developmental disabilities. So what we do is then verify with them that, in fact, they're still interested, that they haven't gotten services elsewhere, that they haven't moved out of state, and consequently that they still qualify for the service. So we're pretty confident when we contact them that if they still want it, they're probably still eligible. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right, Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank
you, and I think Director Saley pretty much already touched on it.
And I would just, again, want clarification on this, is that if the Health Care Task Force came up with something, an idea or a solution to this, then you pretty much already have the ability to go out and to start implementing. You don't necessarily, and I know, you know, because you don't know necessarily the solution, but you still have a kind of a range or a number of things that you could do without needing us to pass a law or to pass this. Is that correct?
Yes, sir. I don't know that we need legislation. Depending on what the task force came up with, it might require, for example, approval, probably would require approval from the federal government, including CFCL. We would have to get approval. We submitted something there, but it's just pending. We would ask them to hold on it. So it would take approval from the federal government, and we'd have to make sure that we have a funding source for
it. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Bragg, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Selig, assuming this $3,000 number or whatever, do we have any idea what the impact of the cost and impact of the budget would be?
Yes, sir. Our estimate, under the current state matching plan, where we pay about 25%, the cost of serving that population would be about $40 million a year in state funds. Is that budgeted now? No, sir, it's not. Thank you. Representative Ferguson,
you're recognized. How long would we have to
pass any legislation now to access the additional 6% through the ACA, that money, or can that be done at any time? No, ma'am, we would
just need to come through the normal promulgation process in order to get CFCO passed.
so it would come through public health through rules and regs and through legislative council. Okay, thank you. And the ACA was Affordable Care Act? Okay. Just making
sure. Okay, we have more people signed to speak. Mr. Selig, anything else? I mean, you've kind of heard a lot. Okay. I have a question for Mr. Selig, if I could ask it. It's kind of odd to
we'll let you ask one okay thank you Mr. Sealy when you were talking about the promulgation process or what that was a big word you used you were talking about the debate that we had last summer in ALC when it was pulled down so it would have to come back through that process and we would be we would be up, it would be up for a vote basically in ALC before you could move
forward. Yes, sir. Okay, thank you. We're going to recognize a few people to speak for this. No one's called for limited debate yet because I think people are moving along pretty good and this is important. Let's call up Mr. Mark George first. so to keep us from forcing the hand of limiting debate limit yourself please you are if you introduce yourself for the record you recognize begin i'll be as brief
Speaker 184
1:25:56
as i can thank you my name
is mark george i am the father of tessa george a 17 year old with down syndrome 12 years ago TESA was the plaintiff in the lawsuit that temporarily eliminated the waiting list. Since that time, I have been advocating for a permanent elimination of that waiting list. In my opinion, the CFCO is the best route to do that.
Now, I was a member of the CFCO Development and Implementation Council, which was a group set up to work with DHS, DDS, in constructing, analyzing, going through all the details of this plan. Following up on kind of one of the other questions that I heard earlier, the services offered under the CFCO, the way we structured it, were essentially lifted verbatim from the current waiver program.
a few items were left in the waiver program job training and some other things but essentially it's the same plan it works the same way if we keep the waiver people go through an assessment program they develop a plan of care they choose from the services the CFCO exact same procedure the difference is better matching
but the implementation of it is almost exactly the same I do understand the budget implications I really do but going back 12 years ago when I first filed this lawsuit it's based on the fact that the Americans with a Disabilities Act says that people should have a choice of the setting in which
they receive care. The ADA is budget blind. In fact, the Olmstead decision that was a major case related to the ADA specifically said that budgetary considerations alone cannot excuse compliance with the law. But I understand the budget is a real issue. What I'd like this committee to focus on is the overarching consideration is we need to do
this. We'll figure out the budget later. We're not going to let the budget stand in the way of doing what we're supposed to do. We'll use the budget to help us achieve the goal that we're trying to accomplish and I'm not here to issue threats or anything but it is the law and so whether or not the people on the waiting list eventually get services September 2016 whenever it's going to happen somehow some way it's going to happen we have an opportunity to direct how that works
it's not something in my opinion the task force has a role this is medicaid but the waiting list is is funded by medicaid but the waiting list is a reflection of the ada so in some sense it's really not under the purview of the task force the budgetary considerations the medicaid aspect but the waiting list doesn't have to be funded through medicaid it's economical makes fiscal
sense to do so but it doesn't have to be so i'd like us to kind of you know approach this in the pieces that it needs you have to make the commitment and this is what he's saying the commitment is the waiting list will be gone by a date certain you know if you adopt a cfco technically the waiting list is gone. There won't be a waiting list. Now, there'll be a time delay when people get services, but technically the waiting list will be gone. So we've accomplished
that. The time frame, when I won my lawsuit, or when my daughter won her lawsuit, yes, it took time for everybody on that list to be assimilated into the system, but it was done. DDS did a great job there are several providers here that bent over backwards they got the job done all we're asking for is the authority to move forward to do we
have a motion represent meeks and what would
you like to limit debate to five per side five per side we have motion undebatable limit debate five minutes per side. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Motion passes. We're going to limit debate five minutes per side. You can carry on, Mr. George. Just keep in mind that these two people need to close
Speaker 184
1:31:20
That's fine. I made my point. If there are any questions, I'd be happy to answer them now. I took more than my
share of time. Thank you. Seeing no questions, Mr. Keith Vine, you're recognized.
If you would introduce yourself for the record and you can recognize give testimony. Keep it in mind that the
people next to you will want to close for their bill. Thank you. My name is Keith Veyer. No offense. I'm taking it. I'm CEO at Arkansas Support Network in Springdale, also currently president of the Arkansas Waiver Association. And I'm just here to speak. I'm just here to I'd beg if it would help. I'm just here to speak on behalf of 3,000 families who have one of my staff people
describes folks who have children with disabilities as ordinary people in extraordinary circumstances, and that's exactly what we're talking about. And you have the power to make a change for those people. I would say when you ask the question of Representative Miller, if he does not trust the process, I don't trust the process. If we don't pass legislation, I don't see us changing things. I've been around for 40 years doing this work, and I do not see us changing unless we make it happen. So I'm just asking you, make this happen.
This is the right thing for those 3,000 families. It's the right thing to do. Thank
you. Seeing no questions, thank you for your testimony. Justin Nichols, you're recognized. Introduce yourself for the record, and you're recognized. Give testimony. My name
Speaker 190
1:32:54
is Justin Nichols. I'm with Disability Rights Arkansas, and I'll be brief. We support passage of this bill because it's time to end the waiting list. already several people have died waiting for services, and that doesn't need to continue to happen in Arkansas. And another aspect of this bill is that it allows families
to do things together that they can't presently do, like worship in church, go out for dinner, just little things like that. And for that reason, among many others, we support this bill, and I'll yield my time to anyone else. All right.
Seeing no questions, thank you for your testimony. We have no one else signed up to speak against this bill, so So, Representative Miller, you're recognized close for your bill. You have three and a half
minutes. All right. Well, I can't reach the microphone.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. A couple of things I want to point out is, number one, well, first and foremost, If the deadline date is what the hang-up is here, colleagues, I will give you my word as a gentleman and a redneck from Cleburne County that I will be happy to amend that after consulting with DHS on the Senate end
due to our lack of time left in the session, if we can pass it today. I will be happy to amend that. we have appropriated so much money to go to so many different things. And I just feel like this is absolutely crucial. One thing I kept hearing is if, if the task force, if this, if that, if, if, if.
Folks, these folks have been hearing if for a long time. Let's pass some legislation that gives them a guarantee, and not if, but when. It is my fear that if we don't do something in this session, the can's just going to get kicked further down the road. And I have a lot of confidence in the folks that are on the task force. And I have a lot of confidence in our governor. And I have a lot of confidence in our DHS system. And I believe we have good people all around.
But if this issue does not stay at the forefront, it goes away. The next thing you know, we're back here in two years having the same discussion, fighting the same fight. And so, again, with that, I ask you to listen to Representative Love. Committee, I'm going to be
real quick because I know we touched on the cost of it and where we're going to find the money. This is an e-mail that I received from John Selig.
It says in our quote, this is his e-mail, By our estimates, CFC would not actually require additional funding. The improved federal match rate would result in less state spending, saving Medicaid over $350 million in the next 12 years. Now, if that alone is not reason to enact this legislation, I don't know what would be, what is. I would urge you to consider this bill a good bill.
It's saving money for the state. And with that, Mr. Chairman, I close.
Thank you. Madam Chair, any explanation of the bill? What's the will of this committee? We have a motion due passed from Representative Payton. Any discussion of that motion? Representative Banks, you're recognized for discussion. Thank
you, Mr. Chair. I think that our heart is in the same place we want to do something with this waiting list and regardless of what happens today something is going to be done I just think that it's going to be done should be done through the task force
Senator Hendren and I and myself and a couple of others have already asked to get information to be able to consider that particular piece to make sure that these folks are no longer that this is no longer kicked down the road And so, you know, based on the fact that I think that the health care task force would be the ones to actually move forward with this, I'm asking my colleagues to vote no on this bill. Thank you. Any other discussion in the motion?
Representative Payton, you're recognized. Since it's my motion, I want to
ask you all to vote for it.
Representative Miller's bill is wide open. It doesn't require CFCO or whatever that is. It gives the executive branch, the task force, and a lot of other people the opportunity to explore how we can eliminate this waiting list. I've been in business all my life if you don't set a date to accomplish something it doesn't get accomplished we have two budgets going to pass this legislative body between now and this deadline we have another session where the date could be amended and put off if it had to be
so I'm just asking you to vote yes and let's get the ball rolling these people deserve to be covered I'll add
my own discussion And then since we're having this, and I think it's a good discussion, I don't like, and I know we talked about amending the date, but I also like the date of on or before September 1st, the department shall report to the governor and legislative council because you're right, it doesn't mandate that anything happens. It mandates that something needs to be reported of how we're going to do it. I would rather see this coincide with task force mandates
so that it's a complete package coming together, not one group over here trying to figure out how we're going to do CFCO and another large task force trying to figure out how we're going to guide health care for the state of Arkansas in the future. And we've heard from Mr. Seelig and virtually the governor that yes, this is going to be part of the overall task force as a CFCO and how it's going to integrate into the health care of Arkansas. I think we need to have faith in that task force and let them do what they need to in that timeline
instead of forcing a second decision and a second timeline to take place beside that parallel I don't like that parallel thing. Representative Hammer, do you have discussion? Yes,
sir, and actually a question of the chair in discussion. I really sometimes have an uncomfortable feeling that somebody is quoted and it may bear weight on the decision that is made without that person having a chance to respond to it. Chair would allow I like to hear why Mr. Selig says it's not going to cost any money because if it's not going to cost any money, that's a great bearing on the decision, I think.
It's going to cost somebody, but it's going to impact that.
Well, unfortunately, Representative Hammer, we've kind of got past that. We've got a motion on four, and we're past that discussion. I do agree with you, but we're kind of past that point. Very good. Thank you. Any other discussion of the motion itself? Hearing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. No. Chair rules and no's have it. Representative Webb, two hands up for roll call.
Speaker 94
1:40:00
Mr. Price, if you would, call the roll. okay representative love yes representative Wardlaw representative Wardlaw representative Hammer representative Branscombe representative Branscombe representative Meeks Representative Overby, Representative Ritchie, Representative Ritchie, Representative McGee,
Representative Miller, Representative Miller, Representative Womack, Representative Bragg, Representative Feit, Representative Payton, Representative Lundstrom
Representative Bentley Representative Boyd Representative Boyd Representative Henderson Representative Sullivan Vice Chair Ferguson Chair Link
7, 8, 9 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 1, 2, 3 Representative Miller with 9 yeas, 6 nays and 5 not voting your bill has failed. We need to get two people who have been waiting for quite some time. I know we talked about running some other bills
but you're fine with that. I need to get a couple more people in this table. Representative Talley, your first up. Actually, we've got three more bills to run in the next 12 minutes. That should be the end of this meeting. Representative Talley, tell your bill number so I don't have to look it up 1711 all right we have an amendment for that bill it should be on the tablet whenever I can get to it
and you are first recognized to present your amendment which again is on the tab tablet members. So Representative Talley, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I bring
before you an amendment for House Bill 1711. Just some clarifying language. We're trying to update some language for the embalmers and this helps do that and an amendment we've added. We appreciate your vote on that. So we can look at the whole bill. Members voted
an explanation of the amendment. We have a motion to adopt the amendment by Representative Payton. All those in favor, aye. Any opposed? And you can present your bill as
amended. Thank you committee. I bring before you this morning House Bill 1711 amending the state board of embalmers and funeral directors law. This legislation is under mainly some general updates to the law that has not been done for what I've found to be about 40 years out there we haven't updated this law. So we're trying to go back in and update that law and it's for the betterment of the health and the welfare of the licensees as well as the public out there as we're dealing with these situations. This is something we're all going to deal with it someday and so we're trying to update that legislation update those laws
help them be better organized and better professional about how they're how they're operating in today's environment with some current situations we've had across the state in the past few years this bill is lengthy mainly because it's been so long since we've been in updated it so but if you look to that the different edits we're making there it's mainly just good update language mr chairman at your discretion i've got amy good here with us to answer any questions if There are specific questions on those updates, and I would certainly appreciate a good vote.
Representative Talley, did you say that this bill will help with the health and the welfare of the embalmers?
I mean, because it's not going to be their customers, right? Well, Mr.
Chair, you're exactly right. This is an industry that people are dying to support across the state of Arkansas. And so we are trying to help the licensees and the public out there, Mr. Chairman. You brought it up. How is it going to help the
– seriously, though, how is it going to help the health of the embalmers? Is there something in here that they were doing that was dangerous that just now makes it less dangerous? Well, what it
does, it sets up rules of how they operate and carry on business. Isn't there
– isn't – and so maybe, Ms. Goode, go ahead and introduce yourself with the records.
I do have a couple of questions, more serious questions,
sirs. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. My name is Amy Goode. I'm the Executive Secretary for the Embalmers and Funeral
Ductors Board. Okay, Ms. Good, I know there's a State Board of Embalmers and Funeral Directors. Yes, sir. Do they not write their own rules and regulations? I mean, because we're changing a lot of statute here that looks like it could be changing, it could have been rules changed under the direction of that board instead of us having to go in and do statute.
So tell me a little more about that. There is some things that have been done by rule over the years, mainly the licensing of crematories and transports. There was nothing specifically written in the statute how those licenses would be issued. So we thought it would be best just to clarify in the statute the different requirements the board would like to see amended in the statute to encompass everything that we do.
So it may have very well could have been. There's a new form of cremation that's coming down the pike, I guess you could say. And we want to be proactive instead of reactive, and we want to clear language that we have the right not only in the statute but by rule to create rules and regulations for that. Does
this create an apprenticeship, or was the apprenticeship already created and this makes the apprentice do more than they had to do before?
It was already there. The only thing we're really changing in the apprenticeship is mainly with the embalmers apprenticeship, that they should register as an apprentice no more than 12 months prior to starting mortuary school. Or within 12 months of starting an apprenticeship, they should begin mortuary school. We've had problems over the years with perpetual apprentices. Well said. Members, any
other questions? Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I'm trying to figure out the page here. On page 9, it talks about, and this is new language, it says a price list, statement of funeral goods and services, publication, advertisement, or other document. Can you expound on that and why that, are you saying that they have to put a price list up or is that something? That's
something that's required by FTC law. They have to have a general price list with an effective date. What we're trying to put here is that their price list, their statement of funeral goods and services,
all their advertisements should match the name that we have on file with the board. Okay. Thank you,
believe there's anyone signed up to speak for or against this bill. Anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? Seeing none, Representative Talley, you're recognized close for your bill if you'd like. I'm closed, Mr. Chair. I appreciate a good vote. May I show you an explanation of the bill? What's the will of this committee?
Did I hear something? Representative McGee, has a motion to do pass? Any discussion of that motion? Seeing and hearing none, all those in favor say aye. Any opposed say nay. And your bill is passed. Thank you for your patience, Representative Talley. Representative Tucker. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Yes, sir. Tell us your bill number on the way to the end of the table, please, Mr. Tucker. 1426. 1426. Now there's a fiscal impact on it, and it's on the tablet.
There's a fiscal impact on this bill, and it's on the tablet. You guys can see that toward the bottom. Oh, yeah, this bill. Welcome, Representative Tucker. You recognize and present your bill. When
it coming before the committee. Well, a great opportunity for us, yes, sir. Thank
Speaker 219
1:49:25
you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, members of the committee. Basically, this bill provides for paid maternity leave for state employees,
and it's not very often when we can vote on a single bill that directly impacts both workforce development and also that strengthens families, family values, and family development, and this is a bill that does both of those things. And I'll discuss the fiscal impact, but essentially the mechanics of the bill are for state employees, and it doesn't include employees of higher ed institutions, they ask to be excluded, but it does include employees of the higher ed department. State employees are eligible for a mother who gives birth to a baby.
They're eligible for up to six weeks of paid leave after the birth of their baby, capped at their weekly income, capped at $500 per week. So that's part of the bill. Another part of the bill that I amended in is, as you all likely know, under the federal Family Medical and Leave Act, employers are required to hold a job for an employee for 12 weeks, and a lot of times that can be a hardship on an employer because they have to hold that spot for the employee for 12 weeks when they don't know if the employee is coming back or not.
And in this circumstance, without the amendment, it would have been possible for an employee to take the benefit, the paid maternity benefit and then not return to employment. So I amended the bill so that if an employee takes the benefit, they have to come back and work for four times as long as however much of the benefit that they took. So, for example, if they take one week of paid maternity leave, then the employee has to return and work for four weeks. And the mechanics of how that would work is the employee would sign a contract on the front end and the employee would only be bound to repay the maternity leave if they left voluntarily.
They're not bound if they're terminated or if they have to leave for another medical reason or other circumstances outside their control. So that's kind of the mechanics of what the bill does. The rationale behind the bill, as I mentioned, is there are really two different categories of benefits for the bill. One is on the workforce side and then one is on the family side. On the workforce side, studies show that women are statistically more likely to be employed 12 months after giving birth if they're eligible for paid maternity leave. They're much less likely to be on government assistance of some form 12 months after they give birth
if they're eligible for paid maternity leave. It attracts smart young women to work, in this case, for the state of Arkansas because they know they're not going to be faced with a choice of having a baby or facing a financial crisis in their families, which is a choice they should not have to make. also on the workforce side I'm going to talk about the cost in a minute but on the workforce side a lot of times employers recoup a significant amount of the cost of the paid maternity leave
because when you provide a benefit like this it boosts employee morale it reduces absenteeism and it also reduces turnover and for anybody who's an employer they know that if you have turnover that can cost your business a lot more than retaining a good employee and this substantially increases your chances of retaining a good employee who just so happens to be a young woman who gives birth to a baby. On the family values side of the equation, all the statistics show that for a mother to stay home for a baby reduces the incidence of infant mortality, it improves infant health,
it reduces the incidence of postpartum depression, and I think everyone understands that in the first few weeks of life, the bond between mother and child is crucial for the family nucleus and for the development of that child for the rest of that child's life. And so that's why I say this bill really helps the workforce development in this instance just for the state workforce, but it also improves and promotes family values and strengthens families in Arkansas. There is a fiscal impact for the bill, and I'm sure there will be some questions on that
and I'll be glad to take them, but basically the way that we or the BLR assessed the fiscal impact is it took the number of female employees of childbearing age across the state and multiplied it by the fertility rate in Arkansas, and they determined that about 118 women per year would be eligible for this benefit. The maximum benefit is $500 per week for six weeks, so the maximum benefit per employee is $3,000. 118 employees times $3,000 is $354,000, and that's the fiscal impact you have before you.
Now, that estimate is conservatively high, and I think it's good to estimate conservatively, but I'll tell you why it's high. For one thing, unfortunately, Arkansas has a high teen pregnancy rate, and so the pregnancy rate for working women is actually going to be somewhat less than it is for all Arkansans, and so the fertility rate for Arkansas state employees, female employees is going to be lower, and so likely you're going to have fewer than 118 women per year who are eligible for this benefit. The fiscal impact also assumes that everyone who
takes the benefit will earn the $500 maximum cap, which is not necessarily the case, and the fiscal impact also assumes that every eligible employee will take the full six weeks, which is also not necessarily the case and then finally the point that i already mentioned a lot of times employers recoup a lot of the cost because they have reduced turnover they have reduced absenteeism and they have improved improved employee morale and the final question you might have or i'm sure there will be some others but where does the money come from and i i've discussed this with chairman gene
and essentially this is not a general revenue hit necessarily because it would come from whatever source the agency's funds are. And so, for example, if an agency is funded exclusively through special revenue, then the cost for this benefit, the static cost, not the dynamic cost as I discussed, but the static cost would come out of the special revenue that funds that agency. And so whatever the cost for this program is, whether it's $250,000 or $300,000 or $350,000, that's going to be spread across
not just the $5 billion general revenue budget that we have, but across all the monies that the state legislature appropriates, which is upwards of $20 billion. And so it's really a very small cost. It does a lot for the women who work for the state of Arkansas and for strengthening family values in Arkansas. And so Senator Missy Irvin has agreed to carry this on the Senate end. And so I hope we can get it through the House and get it to the Senate before the session closes. But with that, I'd be happy to take any questions. Mr. Chairman? Sure. I'll put you in queue.
Representative Love. I want to say first to Representative Hammer. This could affect the fiscal impact of your contraceptive bill you had earlier. Representative Fyatt, you're recognized for a question. Thank
you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Tucker, you and I talked about this at length, and we talked about some amendments, and I'm pleased to see that you made those amendments. Are you seeing this as a way to make us as a state more competitive with private industry as far as attracting young, bright female workers to come
Speaker 219
1:56:38
and work for the state of Arkansas? Yes, ma'am, absolutely. And it's not just being competitive with the private sector, but also with surrounding states. There are several states in the United States who provide a paid maternity leave benefit, but I don't think any of them are adjoining states to Arkansas. And so if we're talking about having the most effective workforce we can have for the people of Arkansas, the state employees. I think this is a key tool to attract bright young women who are also interested in having families that they know
if they come work for the state, they won't have to choose between having a career and having a baby. And so I think, yes ma'am, that's a great question.
I appreciate you raising it. Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Tucker, does this in any way affect employees that are not state employees like contractors that the state contracts with, are they required to meet any of these standards? No, sir. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Representative Bragg, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Concerning the fiscal impact, we're talking about people that are already on the payroll. That woman's been budgeted for that year anyway. She's probably not budgeting a pregnancy for that year. If they're having a baby, I'm not sure there's a big fiscal impact. That salary's been budgeted anyway, right?
Speaker 219
1:58:07
That's a great point, Representative Bragg. In fact, if the employee takes a $500 cap, in that case
the benefit would be even less than what their weekly income would be. So I think that's a
very intelligent way to look at that. Representative Overby? Do state employees, do they not have one
Speaker 219
1:58:36
day a month sick leave? Yes, ma'am, they do. And in the state employee benefit statutory framework, it's laid out kind of how leave is prioritized.
And so, as I mentioned, under the federal FMLA right now, every employer of a certain size is required to allow for 12 weeks of unpaid leave. And so state employees are currently eligible to use sick leave during that period. And this would just allow them to not have to use their sick leave. And I think, you know, as a practical matter, it's what some women do is they save their sick leave for when they have a baby. And that's a hardship as well, even if you can plan for it, but not everybody can plan for that.
And so this just would allow the benefits specifically for the incidence of
this $500 instead of using their sick leave. They would save their sick leave that way? Yes, ma'am. That's exactly right. Thank you. Representative Hammer, you recognize?
Okay, thank you, Mr. Chair. Just to follow up on that, so they would get to keep their sick leave,
plus they would get the benefit, is that what I understood you to say? Yes, Mr. Hammer, that's right. Okay. The fiscal impact based on the estimate, how does that play out? Say you have DHS and they have 20 ladies that have babies, Is that going to come straight off their bottom line, or can you help me understand? I see the total amount, but how does that play out by agency, or how does that spread out through the budget?
Speaker 219
2:00:24
Well, I think Representative Bragg made an excellent point as to how to help explain that. Let's just say you have an employee who earns $1,000 a week. If they take, and that's been budgeted for, And it's not accounted for in the budget that an employee is going to have a baby. And so that employee is budgeted to be paid $1,000 a week for 52 weeks a year. And under the current system, the employee could take 12 weeks of unpaid leave, in which case DHS would save $12,000.
And under this scenario, the employee would take six weeks of paid leave at $500 a week. And so that would be $500 per week less than their weekly salary. And so, I mean, the way Representative Bragg put it, which is the first time I thought about it that way, is that it might actually save DHS. Well, DHS would save $12,000 under the current system, and they would save $9,000 because they would pay $3,000 out in a benefit this way.
Ordinarily, and it's not common for Department of Finance and Admin to be in this committee
because they're normally not having to deal with fiscal impact studies, but ordinarily they would come to the table and explain their impact. They're not really dumb by any means, and so I'm really curious that we are judging or we're misinterpreting or we're giving a different interpretation of the fiscal impact than what they've done. Most of us have been in revenue finance at some point in time, heard fiscal impact presented. I'm guessing that for us to say that they were wrong here and there's not actually a fiscal impact and we're actually going to save money,
I think we're really throwing a lot of judgment out there in an area we don't know. And I think we really need to be cautious about that. I may even want to bring somebody from DF&A in here if possible. I don't know that we could do that at 12, 10 in the afternoon when we're fixing to shut this committee down. But I do want to caution the committee that we're throwing a lot of guesses out there on something that we don't know about right now. So I'm sorry. Continue your question if you'd like, Representative
Hamley. Just one follow-up, if I may. Sure. Do we know in the illustration, and maybe this over the line, Chair, call me on the line,
but in the illustration, $1,000 per week, I'm just curious as to was there in the fiscal study, it might be a savings if you were making $1,000 a week, but what if you're only making $450 a week? How would that directly impact the financial statement or what's been discussed? Thank
Speaker 219
2:02:52
you. And I appreciate your caution, Mr. Chairman, and agree and respect that caution. And so in the scenario that DF&A prepared this, let me answer your question first as to how my understanding was coming into the room.
So let's just say you have, going back to the hypothetical I gave earlier, an employee that earns more than $500 a week. If that employee took the full six weeks of leave, the benefit would be $3,000. And so if DHS had 20 employees who were eligible for the year, then the cost of DHS would be $60,000. The static cost to DHS would be $60,000 in one fiscal year out of however many billions of dollars they have in their budget. But again, that's the static cost.
That's not the dynamic cost that I think employers have found that participate in programs like these, that they recoup a significant amount of that cost because of the factors that I mentioned. But you can just, to answer your second question, Representative Hammer, you can just take that down. And if the employee earned $300 a week, then that's the maximum amount of the benefit they would be eligible for. The benefit that would be paid to them would be $300 per week instead of $500 per week. And so if they took the leave for six weeks, they would be eligible for a total $1,800 benefit instead of a $3,000 benefit.
And so that would reduce the cost to the agency. I hope that answers
your question. Wouldn't it also be fair to consider that if we have an employee and we need them to do something, so if they're gone, we're probably having to hire a temporary. So to say that we're saving money by them being gone is probably also something we cannot assume without DF&A in here to explain the report. I mean, we don't hire employees just to give them a job and hand them money. We hire them to do something. And we've got to pay somebody to get something done while they're gone.
So, again, I want to throw a lot of caution in here about how much money we're, quote, saving by paying these people to be gone. It
doesn't work that way in business. Representative Payton, you're recognized. Well, thank you, Mr. Chair. You just pretty much stated my question. Is it your belief that the average state employee can be absent for six consecutive weeks without us hiring a replacement or having extra staff hired on an annual basis to fill these gaps?
Speaker 219
2:05:20
It's not just my belief. It's the current federal law, and it's not just for six weeks. It's for 12 weeks. And, again, I'm not arguing. I mean, I take Representative Bragg's point, but I respect your caution. I'm not arguing that we're saving money, so I'm just going to go ahead and say we'll take the fiscal impact as it is that it costs money. But it goes back to a point that I made in my original presentation. Under the law right now, you have to hold that spot for 12 weeks for someone on an unpaid basis. And so state agents, all different employers,
including the state government, account for that in different ways. You know, and where I work, we don't hire a temporary worker. Everyone just kind of shoulders a little bit extra of the load while a person's out after they have a baby or for whatever other reason. But under the, it actually, I think the current law can handicap an employer because you have to hold a spot for that employee for 12 weeks, not knowing whether or not they're going to return. And one thing I actually like about this bill is that it guarantees that the employee will return at the end of the leave period so the employer is not held holding a bag for a number of weeks
without any certainty as to whether or not the employee is going to return. In this case, we know the employee is going to return. Generally speaking, I'm sure there are exceptions, but generally speaking, we know that's going to save the employer money because turnover is a high cost to employers, again, as a general basis. And so for those reasons, I think it's a positive step. Thank you. All right. We have no
one signed up to speak for or against this or to lend any testimony. Would you have someone like speak for or against this?
Would you come to the table and introduce yourself and you'll recognize and give
testimony? Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Eleanor Wheeler. I am a policy analyst with Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. I know we're short on time, so
a little closer to you, if you would. I'm sorry. Thank you. This helps employers by removing uncertainty, as I was mentioned, and by reducing turnover, which can cost up to five times an employee's annual salary.
Also attracts smart young women to our state and keeps families financially stable during a transitional time. We know that kids do better when their parents can take time to care for them without undue financial hardship. Most kids, more and more kids these days, live in a single-parent household or with both parents working. And without paid maternity leave options, parents would be forced to make the tough decision between their jobs and their kids' health. Kids are shown to have better health outcomes and recover faster when cared for by their parents.
and many Arkansas State employees will end up really benefiting from this bill. Thank you. Seeing no questions,
thank you for your testimony. We have more testimony? All right. Are you speaking for or against this? Four. All right. Tell us your name. You're recognized. Give testimony. My name is
Speaker 236
2:08:23
Cozetta Jones. I'm with the Arkansas State Employees Association, and we are here to speak.
for the bill. When I first saw this bill, I was confused as to in 2015, we don't have maternity leave for state employees, so I was a bit shocked by that. I've worked in retail before, and we had maternity leave, so it surprises me that the state of Arkansas doesn't provide maternity leave for their employees. I am a former state employee as well, and again, I'm surprised that as a state employee, I did not have access to this. As As Representative Tucker has said, this is good public policy.
It's good public health policy as well. And I'm just amazed that this is a conversation today. And I'm like, we are in public health, right? Because this is good for families. And I've heard a lot of discussion about protecting the middle class family this session. We can't forget or exclude that state employees are part of that discussion as well. We cannot exclude state employees that they're not a part of this machine that is the economy of the state of Arkansas. They deserve the same consideration as any other citizen in this state.
So with that, I would appreciate a good vote for this. Would
you take a question? Go ahead. Representative Hammer. Thank you, Mr. Chair. When you were in retail and you referred to the maternity leave, was that maternity leave paid for the entire time that the employees were off? Yes. Okay, thank you. Thank you for your testimony. Representative
Speaker 219
2:10:05
your bill? Just very briefly. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Her reaction is actually the reaction I've gotten most often,
which is that you mean we don't already do this. And so I would just like to echo that and, again, And just to reiterate, this strengthens the workforce for the state of Arkansas, attracts smart young women to work for us. But not only that, it helps strengthen families in Arkansas, particularly at the critical time when you have a newborn baby. And so families shouldn't have to choose between having, especially young mothers, between having a career and having a baby. So I appreciate a good vote. Thank you very much. What's will of the committee?
I've got Representative Blub. It's all excited and ready to make this motion. well I think the amendments we did did we hear an amendment it's engrossed well no we'd have a moon we had the fiscal impact so you have a motion do pass in a discussion that motion seeing none all in favor say aye all opposed chair rules eyes have it represent lindstrom what is it 1578 is that yours
If you would, go to the end table and present that bill. Do you have an amendment for the bill? The
amendment's engrossed. thank you colleagues i will make this as short i realize in the effort of time we need to move
along house bill 1578 actually updates information provided for abortions for women seeking abortions It requires a written consent and informed consent for an abortion from a woman, and it requires that she receive information from a doctor or a medical professional to help that woman be more informed about the risks, the alternatives, and also to give her some waiting period before she has the abortion performed. I am open for questions.
I know that's fast, but this is basically updating our abortion law and making it easier for women to get good information before they make this difficult decision.
question? Representative Love, you're recognized. Representative Lundstrom, I see you have just off of this initial look that you have ADH providing, I guess, information. Yes. I'm just wondering. The Department of Health will
do the promulgation of the rules once we move this along, hopefully.
Okay. Is there going to be, like, is there going to be information provided to people? Is there? Yes. I mean, okay,
so. When a woman goes to get an abortion right now, she signs up for the abortion and goes the next day. This would change that and upgrade it to when she goes to get an abortion, she would go in and sit down and meet with the health care provider, get information, have time to think about it and discuss it, and then
come back. Okay, so are we, okay, I guess this question, I see Robert Brick over there. I'm going to ask them, in regards to the information that they're going to receive,
is there going to be a fiscal impact on the
agency? Yes, there is some fiscal impact because we're updating the information. Okay, do we have the fiscal impact? It's approximately $50,000. And remember, we're updating 14 years' worth. So this will probably go another 14 or
be updated again, hopefully. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. Representative Lundstrom, you know, my concern was for poor women accessing care.
Does the bill, I know we had talked, does it allow for the woman to have the initial consultation locally so she's not driving? Physician locally or a
health care provider that can be a social worker, psychiatrist. So they're not having to make an additional trip.
Correct, but what my goal is that they will
get good information on the front end. Sure. And have time to think that
through. We all want them to be informed before they have an abortion, certainly. Thank you. Thank you.
Okay, members, seeing no further questions, Ms. Ashley Wright, you are signed up to speak against this. If you come to the end of the table, introduce yourself for the record, and your recognized gift testimony. Thank you, Mr.
Chair. Good morning, committee members. Afternoon now. My name is Ashley Wright, and I'm speaking on behalf of my client, Planned Parenthood of the Heartland. Planned Parenthood of the Heartland is opposed to House Bill 1578.
We do appreciate this amendment, and it does alleviate some of our concerns. However, we still feel that this bill will negatively impact women. We feel that it will shame women for their reproductive health care decisions by blocking access to safe and legal medical procedure by more than doubling the government-mandated waiting period of 48 hours and also requiring physicians to provide medically inaccurate information. Planned Parenthood sees firsthand how important it is for women to have accurate information regarding all of their options when facing a pregnancy,
including becoming a parent, adoption, and abortion. Planned Parenthood provides every woman with counseling, support, and medically accurate information regarding all of these options. House Bill 1578 increases access barriers by more than doubling the government-mandated waiting period to 48 hours. This would require women to schedule the abortion procedure in addition to scheduling time off work, child care, and travel arrangements over the course of several days. This greatly increases access barriers and is burdensome to low-income women in rural parts of the state.
Abortion is a deeply personal and complex decision that cannot be made for someone else. Like with all medical decisions, a woman should have accurate information regarding all of her options, and the information should support the woman, help her make a decision for herself, and enable her to take care of her health and well-being. This bill would require physicians to share medically inaccurate information with their patients and would require the Arkansas Department of Health to publish materials with medically inaccurate information not found in fact. This bill would require a physician to provide a woman with resources
that discuss, quote, the adverse psychological effects of abortion, despite the fact that these risks do not exist and are not recognized by the American Psychological Association or the American Psychiatric Association. The information provided may also include referral information to groups that are not medical providers and will not necessarily provide the woman with medically accurate information about women's health generally or her own particular health status. This bill also makes no exceptions for women who are victims of rape or incest
or for serious fetal anomalies from receiving this medically inaccurate information. Abortion is a deeply personal and very complex decision and must be left to the woman, her family, and her faith with the truthful counsel of her doctor or health care provider. We all want women to have the information and support they need to make a carefully considered decision about a pregnancy. House Bill 1578 interferes with women's ability to make the best health care decisions for themselves and for their families by not providing them with medically accurate information.
I urge you to not advance House Bill 1578. Thank you.
Members, any questions of testimony? Hearing none, Representative Blundstrom, you'll recognize, close for your bill if you'd like.
Thank you. Actually, medical information, accurate information is being provided. What is given to a woman at this point, and it is a difficult time, we would agree on that, is that she meets one-on-one with a medical professional so that she can make good decisions for her life and for her child.
And I'm asking you to give women good information and to pass this bill. Thank you.
What's the will of the committee? We have multiple due passes. Any discussion of the motion? Hearing or seeing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. Motion passes. Bill passes. All right, we are shutting down for now. We're going to session. We will come back about 3, 3.30, whenever the speaker lets us out. We're going to hear Senate bills this afternoon.
Agenda
SB543
SB880
HB1160
HB1868
HB1876
HB1749
HB1711
HB1426
HB1578
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Chair
Unverified
Senator Jason Rapert
Unverified
Ken Ashley
Unverified
Speaker 26
Speaker 39
Representative Kim Hammer
Unverified
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson
Unverified
Speaker 59
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Chair
Unverified
Speaker 66
Debbie Hall
Unverified
Representative Ken Henderson
Unverified
Representative Dan Sullivan
Unverified
Speaker 94
Representative Ken Bragg
Unverified
Representative Josh Miller
Unverified
Representative Fredrick J. Love
Unverified
Representative Stephen Meeks
Unverified
Representative Betty Overbey
Unverified
Representative John Payton
Unverified
Representative Mary Bentley Chair
Unverified
Speaker 150
Speaker 181
Speaker 184
Keith Veyer
Unverified
Speaker 190
Speaker 205
Representative Brent Talley
Unverified
Amy Goode
Unverified
Speaker 172
Speaker 219
Representative Charlene Fite
Unverified
Speaker 196
Eleanor Wheeler
Unverified
Speaker 236
Representative Robin Lundstrum
Unverified
Ashley Wright
Unverified