Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Agriculture, Forestry and Economic Development

March 25, 2015
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (7)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1854 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…re on 17-18. Representative Gray, would you like to present House Bill 1854?”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1960 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1960”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1718 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1718”
Pre-2017 bill
SB554 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…ything else you need? That's it. Thank you, sir. All right. Senate Bill 554. Representative Neal, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Cha…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB854 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB854”
Pre-2017 bill
SB910 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB910”
Pre-2017 bill
SB954 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB954”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 15, 2026
Yes, we had a little malfunction here the other day, and we need to expunge the vote on House Bill 1960 so we can incur an amendment from the Senate. No,
▶ Play
we need to expunge the do pass as amended. Okay. Okay, the motion then is to do pass, I mean to expunge the vote as amended? Yes, sir. Okay, any questions? Anybody want to speak for or against? Those in favor of the motion say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Mr. Ratliff, you have expunged the vote.
▶ Play
Now I'd like to concur the amendment from the Senate. We have to expunge the amendment as well. Oh, we
▶ Play
need to expunge the amendment as well. Okay. We need to do that, too. Okay. Motion to expunge the amendment.
▶ Play
All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Motion carried. Okay. Now then. Now, are we ready to concur? We're ready to rock and roll. Okay. Now we need to concur the amendment that come from the Senate on House Bill 1960. Would you like to explain the amendment? Let's see. The amendment from the Senate was, let me think, oh, it was to store the records from the livestock and poultry with a private entity.
▶ Play
Okay. Question on the amendment? Representative Hendren, did you have your hand up? Yes, sir, I did, and I used
▶ Play
that a little bit. that. Are you comfortable with that? Because that bunch down on the other end, you can't necessarily trust what they send back up here. Yeah,
▶ Play
we're hoping that's Cattlemen's Association is what we're hoping. Is that a speaking from experience, sir? Representative Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I noticed that in the amendment, we're taking out the $1 per brand, and we're putting in a reasonable fee. Can you kind of speak to that and you know what is a considered a reasonable fee and who makes that determination and well that will be determined by livestock and poultry commission uh they all agreed to take the one dollar out at this time uh the brands really right now they're not not that many people uh adding brands so they've got the books all pretty well took care of and they're stored in the county clerk's offices and uh so it's really one of those deals where it's not It's really not collecting no money at all, hardly. Okay, but the poultry commission, they would be the ones who would set that fee in? Yes, sir. Okay. They would have to
▶ Play
come back to ALC before they could raise that. Is that correct? I think that's
▶ Play
correct now with that Amendment 3. Okay. Any
▶ Play
other questions on the amendment? What's the pleasure of the committee? Do pass on the amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no, to concur in the Senate Amendment. Okay. You got anything else you need? That's it. Thank you, sir. All right. Senate Bill 554. Representative Neal, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You're recognized to present your amendment. Yes,
▶ Play
sir. We had to re-refer this. The Senate had an amendment. They didn't get on down there, and they forgot to get it on when we went through here the first time. So what the amendment does is just put a two-year sunset on the oil and gas section of the balanced budget amendment for the governor, and it adds a House sponsor. And that's it. Any questions? Prayers
▶ Play
of the committee? Motion do pass. All in favor say aye. Opposed, no. Motion carried. Well, that's the amendment.
▶ Play
Speaker 10 3:44
You have to do pass as amended. Do
▶ Play
pass as amended. All right. Is that the motion? I thought it was. Well, no, you do pass on the amendment. So we need to do it again. On the bill itself. Okay. Is there a motion? Do pass on the bill as amended. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Motion carried. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. I don't see Representative Bain in here on 17-18. Representative Gray, would you like to present House Bill 1854? You're recognized to explain your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. First procedural question, there's an amendment to this bill that we need to adopt the amendment first. We need to adopt the amendment first if you have an amendment. You're recognized to explain your amendment. We have an amendment that's a little two-line amendment that clarifies some of the legal language. If you guys will adopt that, it'll make it easier to explain the whole bill. Is there questions on the amendment? What's the pleasure? Committee. Is it not on the
▶ Play
Speaker 29 5:07
tablet? It should be. We're on 1854, right? Yes. Is that amendment stayed on L417? Yes, sir.
▶ Play
okay I was waiting for representative Payton to do you not have the amendment yet okay all right
▶ Play
representative makes you recognized for a question all right thank you mr. chair uh just real quick I noticed the amendment is you're adding or catfish like species in the amendment is
▶ Play
that correct am I looking at the right thing no no so we're deleting that we're
▶ Play
Speaker 44 6:05
deleting that line from from the bill okay
▶ Play
all right so we're deleting that all together yes sir all right okay represent meeks you have
▶ Play
a follow-up any other questions on the amendment see none what's opposed to the committee motion do pass all in favor say aye. Opposed no. You have passed your amendment. Now we can discuss, you can present the bill as amended. Thank you Mr. Chair. Thank you Mitty. Good morning. 1854 closes a loophole in the labeling laws. Arkansas has a law that requires catfish and anything that falls into the species of catfish to be labeled on menus currently as does federal law to be labeled on menus as imported. There's a loophole here that allows for imported fish typically from Southeast Asia that was before that law was passed that was sold as catfish to now be labeled as farm-raised fish or farm-raised southern fish. And so what this bill does and the only thing this bill does is ask that we close that loophole by requiring that imported, if it's imported, be put before that fish as well on the menu. in the same manner as we already treat catfish. It doesn't affect any other seafood groups. It gives these guys six months to comply with this law. It's really that simple. We've amended it, changed it, met with the Hospitality Association, addressed their concerns with it. That's simply all it's doing is asking that we add imported to the species of the catfish-like fish that are being served in Representative's catfish. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'm open to any questions. Okay. Representative Payton.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gray on page 3, line 29. The way I'm understanding this, every menu in Arkansas that currently says farm-raised catfish, is going to have to be changed to include the whole phrase that you've got there in quotes, farm-raised catfish or catfish-like species. It doesn't matter what they're selling. If they're selling farm-raised Arkansas catfish, they're still going to have to put what's within your quotes on their menu, on their signage. How is that telling the customer the difference? I mean, everything in the quotes is what
▶ Play
we're requiring to be put on. Representative Payne is a good question, and I had that question this morning. and I just left the attorneys drafting, and that's one of the amendments here for line 21 and line 27 of page 5 to clarify. And we sat down the only to clarify those requirements. The only requirement in this bill, because of that confusion, is that it say imported if you're selling the catfish-like species. The federal law already requires imported if you're selling U.S. farm-reached catfish or imported catfish. That's already federal law. So I understand. And that's why I said the confusion of and that's why this amendment is here. Well, and that's
▶ Play
why I studied your amendment so much. It doesn't affect Section 3 on page 3. Your amendment is on page 5 in Section 5 on the labeling about imported. But on page three, in section three, we're requiring the label to include all of that, not either or. One second, Mr. Payton.
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman, may I ask someone from Catfish Farbs to come to the table to address that? Yes, you may. And I
▶ Play
Speaker 54 10:30
appreciate your point, Mr. Payton. Identify yourself for the record, please. Chad Causey, Catfish Farmers of Arkansas, Catfish Institute. Representative, I've had extensive conversations with Bureau of Standards who would be enforcing this new extension of the labeling laws, and they did not interpret that that would be the requirement on the label, that it was meant to be an either-or, if
▶ Play
Speaker 56 10:54
it's farm-raised, as you refer to, farm-raised catfish
▶ Play
Speaker 54 10:57
or catfish-like species, as those both have separate definitions within the definitions section of the law? Well, I understand the intent, but it's
▶ Play
all within one set of quotes. There's not two separate sets of quotes there. so we're going to be putting the whole line on the labeling
▶ Play
Speaker 54 11:22
representative the bureau said they would not require that on the all on the line to my knowledge so you know the intent is that if the two definitions are separate and they are defined as separate both catfish and catfish like so they could not be the same thing.
▶ Play
I appreciate your answer. Other questions? Anybody in the audience wish to speak against this bill? We have several signed up to speak for it. The first one is Carter Harrison. Mr. Harrison, if you would like to speak for this bill, go down to the end of the table and have a seat and identify yourself.
▶ Play
Speaker 68 12:41
And brevity would be appreciated. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members
▶ Play
of the committee. Is your green light on? Pull it up a little bit closer, please, Carter. Okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 68 13:11
My name is Carter Harrison. I'm from Carlisle, Arkansas. I've been making a living catering fried U.S. farm-raised catfish for over 35 years. I take my mobile kitchen, King Cat, company name, all over the state. I serve picnics, festivals, multiple special events, a southern-style catfish spread with all the trimmings. The catfish I serve is from managed spawns in Arkansas, Mississippi, and Alabama, raised on corn and soybeans, free from chemicals, pollutants, and unapproved drugs. I'm here on behalf of local businesses like mine who are buying American-grown catfish to serve their customers. Our competition is buying a cheaper, uninspected foreign fish and taking advantage of the good reputation of U.S. farm-raised catfish. This is misleading consumers and putting the entire industry at risk of a loss of confidence in the safety of our product. We believe the public has a right to know what they're being served and we would appreciate a positive vote on this issue to preserve the hard-earned reputation of the U.S. farm-raised catfish industry. I especially want to thank Representative Gray for his work on behalf of our industry. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. I'm happy to answer any questions. Great. Anybody have questions? Mr.
▶ Play
Harrison, Mr. Payton. Thank you for coming
▶ Play
today. Appreciate you being willing to put your views out there and take questions. If I go to a restaurant and order a steak and it says on the menu that it's Angus aged beef I expect it to be. But if it just says a steak I don't expect it to be Angus and I don't expect it to be aged. I realize you're proud of your product and you have some bragging rights about your product. Wouldn't you rather just have people brag on those points that you just bragged on when they advertise it
▶ Play
Speaker 68 15:33
uh well of course i think the issue is for our customers to know whether or not they're being served an imported fish or an american grown fish that they've been eating for a
▶ Play
number of years So are there cases where people are labeling non-American-grown, high-quality fish and actually saying that they're Arkansas catfish?
▶ Play
Speaker 68 16:04
Well, there have been rumors of issues where foreign fish have been brought in to the country and repacked and marketed. Would that not already be illegal? It would be, and if
▶ Play
it's found, it's... Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gene. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Harrison. If you're buying catfish right now in the market, what is what I call, you think farm-raised, you think it's on the farm, but not necessarily. What does it cost for you when you buy Arkansas, Mississippi, Alabama catfish? How much a pound are you paying right now? Of course, I buy fresh fish. I
▶ Play
Speaker 68 16:46
pay a premium price. What do you pay a pound? over six dollars a pound in some instances okay do you
▶ Play
have any idea what this imported catfish is per pound i don't shop import it well i mean do you have any idea what what
▶ Play
Speaker 68 17:05
it cost i've been given prices substantially less well you
▶ Play
have a ballpark we're not going to hold you
▶ Play
Speaker 68 17:12
anything we just ballpark and stuff here well uh if there's someone
▶ Play
here that can shed light beside myself well my point is is if if it just says farm raised that could be from anywhere and if you're you're selling arkansas local catfish comes out of our our catfish ponds and uh for i don't know i think i ate a three peaks dinner the other day for 12.99 or something like that and they're bringing in this this imported catfish at a much reduced cost and sell it for the same thing. You're not getting the same
▶ Play
Speaker 68 17:51
qualities. Would you agree? The consumer
▶ Play
is not getting the quality. Right. That's what I'm talking about the consumer. Okay. So all this bill is asking on the amendment is that we place that this is imported catfish. Doesn't tell what country they come from, but this will be imported fish that the restaurant is serving rather than what I call American-grown catfish. Is that correct? that's correct
▶ Play
ok thank you other questions from the committee alright thank you Mr. Harrison anybody in the audience to speak against the bill the next one we have signed up to speak for the bill is Joey Lowry Mr. Lowry, when you sit down, identify yourself and who you represent, and you're recognized to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. My name is Joey Lowry. I'm here to testify in favor of House Bill 1854. This bill will provide consumers with more information on the origin of the fish they order while dining at restaurants. I live in Searcy, Arkansas. I have a 500-acre catfish farm up near Newport. I've been farming catfish since the mid-80s, and in them 30 years, I can attest that Arkansas catfish farmers grow some of the best grain-fed catfish in the world. We believe that the quality of our product meets and exceeds alternative products around the world. catfish is a staple of community events and i can't imagine a campaign being run in this state without some catfish fries being involved years ago the arkansas general assembly was the first legislative body in the u.s to require restriction on what can be sold as catfish This law doesn't prevent anyone from offering anything. It just provides consumers with the knowledge they need to make informed decisions when they're at restaurants. This bill provides additional information for consumers on three species of fish from Southeast Asia that are commonly sold in restaurants around Arkansas. The current law prevents them from being called catfish, but there's ways to get around that law. I've seen fish being sold at establishments being called Delta farm-raised catfish. It's not the Mekong Delta. That's not specified. Southern fried fish, white fish, a host of other names. This bill only requires that if the fish is one of the catfish-like species listed in the bill, it must be accompanied by the simple term imported. That's all. I wish we didn't even have to bring this up in Arkansas. We've worked for years to deal with the complete lack of adequate inspection of imported catfish-like species by the Food and Drug Administration. They inspect less than 2% of the fish that come into this country. Less than one-tenth of 1% are checked for chemical residues and illegal antibiotics. This battle continues in Washington with no clear end in sight. We've made progress, but the battle continues. This bill offered by Representative Gray gives consumers additional knowledge to at least know that the fish offered on the menu comes from another country. I have confidence in my product, but I don't have confidence in a product from somewhere overseas that hasn't been properly inspected. If that fish is sold as Delta fried fish, there's too much of a chance that consumers might think he or she is eating my product. We feel that this is a common sense bill and it will help consumers make informed decisions about the fish they eat. And more importantly passing this bill is the right thing to do. Thank you for your time and I urge your support for this bill. I'll take any questions. Thank you Mr. Lowry. Any
▶ Play
questions from the committee? Mr. Payton. I don't want to beat a dead
▶ Play
horse. Do you have a copy of the bill in front of you? Or have you read the bill? I haven't read it. You've not read the bill? Well, I mean, I haven't read it extensively. And I live close to Searcy, so we're kind of neighbors. Yeah. Would you want your Arkansas grain-fed, farm-raised catfish to be labeled as a catfish-like product? No. Section 3 of this bill. Well, it may not be the intent, but Section 3 says a catfish or catfish-like product shall not be offered for direct retail sale for human consumption by a processor, distributor, or retailer unless the catfish or catfish-like product name is specifically labeled in the following manner. Quote, farm-raised catfish are catfish-like species, unquote. So that entire label will have to be placed on your product. Well,
▶ Play
it's catfish-like species and some, what it amounts to, the way I understand this, if this fish is imported, if it comes from another country, you just have to have the word imported. Well, and I'd be for the bill if
▶ Play
Section 5 is what we were voting on. But Section 3 is going to require your product to be labeled on menus and on boxes where it is sold to have that entire label, farm-raised catfish or catfish-like species. That's what Section 3 of this bill requires. That's not my understanding. I'm sorry. I wish it wasn't what it said. I'm sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
All right. Any other questions? Okay. Thank you, Mr. Lowry. Anyone to speak against the bill? Anyone for the bill? The last one we have is Mr. Causey. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 54 25:17
you, Mr. Chairman. Chad Causey with Catfish Farmers of Arkansas. I'll be brief. I just want to indicate the Catfish Farmers of Arkansas support. Mr. Lowry has spoken very well for his reasons in favor of this bill. And, Representative, you're absolutely right that there is an underlying law in Arkansas. It was one of the first in the country passed. In 2005, at the federal level, they issued and passed a law on country of origin labeling to require the actual origin and the country that that product comes from for seafood and shellfish from production and processing through to the grocery store, but not to restaurants and other vendors that offer food. Arkansas was one of the first in the country to offer a marketing and labeling law for catfish. And under the current law, as it exists, if it's not ictalurus, you cannot call it catfish. That's the law. So if anybody's doing that and it's not ictalurus, some ictalurus is imported. So there are instances where it's labeled as imported catfish. But that's the only type of fish, ictalurus, that can be listed. What this bill does is it gets at what Mr. Lowry was talking about, which is there are a host of other imports that primarily come from Southeast Asia. That's pangaceous, that's claridae, that's saluridae. Those are in the order of saluriforms. Catfish, ictalurus is also in that same order. But just to give you a little example, it is about the same resemblance between domestic cattle and pigs. So that's the equivalent. And I like both. I eat beef and I eat pork. But when I eat beef, I want to know it's beef and not something that close to beef, which is pork. And, again, Mr. Lowry said it right. We wish we weren't here. If the federal regulators were doing their job at FDA, we wouldn't be. But the fact is we've tried and passed the law, actually, believe it or not, to move catfish inspection from FDA, because they don't do the job, to USDA FSIS, where they inspect beef, pork, and poultry, and they do it very well and give American consumers a lot of confidence. Unfortunately, the current administration is still sitting on that rule. seven years after that law was passed by Congress. I know that's not something that y'all can deal with here. We wish we had a solution there, but the fact is that FDA inspects less than 2% of all seafood that enters this country. 91% of seafood consumed by Americans is imported. Less than one-tenth of 1% of that seafood is tested for the flesh for unapproved animal drugs and other unapproved antibiotics that might come in. So they're not looking at it, even domestically. So this is a way to at least provide some additional knowledge and information for consumers. I think that Representative Gray has done a yeoman's work in trying to meet the hospitality industry more than halfway. I understand your concerns about the bill language. in my conversations with Bureau who would be enforcing this piece they were not under the belief that that would be the case again that is the intent I just repeat that for the record but we'd be happy to try to work with you any way we can on that concern but with that we support this and I have some things and I'll certainly leave these for the committee but in consideration of time I'll just mention a couple But, you know, the Pangasius that comes in here, some of it's fine. There's not a thing wrong with it. But a lot of it, it isn't. And what they do is they move this stuff around on the path of least resistance in the global market. Russia has banned Pangasius fish from import. Brazil has banned it. We have not. If you look at an Oceania study from 2012, extensive study, two years in the making, upwards of 50% of every fish that you order at a restaurant isn't what it says it is. The Asian catfish that they say has been sold as Alaska and Pacific cod. It's been sold as grouper. It's been sold as, I believe, snapper and a host of other things. Oh, I think sea bass, too. So North Carolina State, one last comment, did a study a couple of years ago. they sampled fish from restaurants in the Raleigh-Durham area. 25% of the samples that they found had high trace amounts or high amounts, above trace amounts, of formaldehyde. That is what we would commonly use here as embalming fluid. It's certainly illegal to use that for anything remotely close to preserving food products, yet they found elevated levels of this in imported product. Again, that's just 25%. That's not everybody. A lot of restaurants serve this product, and it's a good product, and it's a healthy product, and we want them to keep serving it if that's what they choose. But we would just like, if it is imported, to give Arkansas consumers the opportunity to know that it's not U.S. raised, and it's not U.S. farm raised. And with that, I would yield and answer any questions that the committee may have.
▶ Play
Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a
▶ Play
question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I just want to kind of reiterate what Representative Payton has gone over and make sure that y'all are okay with it, that the new labeling is going to require it to say farm-raised catfish or catfish-like species on the menus. Mr. Meeks,
▶ Play
Speaker 54 31:07
that again, that is not the intent and that is not our understanding of how the Bureau would interpret the bill as drafted. Okay, so is the Bureau going to
▶ Play
try to correct that or try to get that amended? Because, you know, the Bureau is not the ones that they're responsible for interpreting the law. But the way the law reads, in quotes, farm-raised catfish are catfish-like species. So what the intent is and what it does are sometimes two different things. So I just want to make sure that you all are aware that that is going to be, as the law is written,
▶ Play
will be the requirement unless it's amended. Mr. Mates, if you'll let me, I can address that as a close, if that's okay. Any other questions? Thank you, Mr. Causey. That's all we had signed up to speak for or against the bill. So Representative Gray, you are recognized to close for your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. members thank you for all your questions representative payton i appreciate your concerns first about um identification of the comparison with angus beef versus farm-raised beef i think that that's a conversation i've had a lot of times this week and i think it's just fair i mean but you expect it to be beef you know and if they call it a ribeye it needs you expect it to be a beef ribeye and if they're going to call it farm-raised catfish or farm-raised fish We expect it to be – that connotation is automatically a domestic connotation, and as you've heard, that's not always the case. But I appreciate those questions. To the concern, and I absolutely appreciate your concern with Section 3 of the bill, I have literally left the Bureau to walk into this meeting because of concerns very much like that, and that's why the amendment to Section 5 came along. We've vetted it, went through it, vetted it with the Hospitality Association. You are, and to your credit, the first person that has made that assertion in the bill. I understand why you're in it that way. I don't necessarily agree with it, but I can assure this committee that as soon as I leave the end of this table, I'm going back for some legal clarification. And if you are, in fact, if that is going to be the effect and consequence, you'll send me back in here this afternoon. I can assure you that. Because everybody else that's looked at it has not seen that to be the intent nor the consequences of the bill. But I think it's a fair point and worth asking. And I appreciate you bringing it up. With that, Mr. Chair, I close in committee. I'd appreciate a good vote. All right. Mr. Randolph. Recommend do pass. Okay, we have a motion to do pass. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. No. Representative Gray, you've passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank
▶ Play
you, committee. As amended. Thank you. As amended.
▶ Play
All right, committee, next up we have Senate Bill 854, Senator Sanders you're recognized to present your bill welcome to the committee sir members
▶ Play
good to be here with you I'm former state representative David Sanders current senator David Sanders members this bill I hope you've had time to look at it what this bill does is it's an amendment to the existing laws regarding tax credits for the film industry and the only reason I'm here at the end of the table today as I've worked with the agency in charge of administering this in terms of selecting and looking at this. I think this credit is good in many ways because it only works if someone spends money, and that's good. It's performance-based. The spending must occur in the state. we have a couple opportunities on the table and I might I guess Joe Adams will be here to speak for the bill and a few others but we have some folks that are involved in the entertainment industry who would like to stick close to home and like to see us make more movies here I think this is these tax credits that we're talking about wouldn't be issued until 2016 if you look at sort of the analysis of these things you've got to take into consideration a few things not just the state impact but the local impact and local revenue impact so I'm happy to answer
▶ Play
any questions if you have any Representative McElwell you have
▶ Play
a question for the Senator Thank you Senator for bringing this bill I've actually been in four movies myself I was in mud You should be down here with me I was in mud And for your Republicans, I was also in W, so there we are. But I went down to Louisiana, and Louisiana does – they have the tax credit. Does this bill mirror their – Well, I think it's a
▶ Play
little different. I mean, Louisiana does things a little bit differently than what we do. I think it's probably a little bit better. Is it a little bigger? Well, again, a lot of it has to do with the administration. They've got bigger. You know, as you know, Representative McElroy, part of the reason why they boosted their tax credits was to try to get people to locate and do movies out in south Louisiana. But we all know what has happened as a result. It's northwestern Louisiana that has sort of turned in, Shreveport has turned into sort of the Mecca. So, yeah, I think it's a fair comparison. I think we've got some opportunities here, and we've got some on the table. And, again, I wouldn't be down here talking to you if we didn't have some opportunities on the table right now.
▶ Play
Robert Redford, I mean, Representative McElroy, you had a follow-up? We had a
▶ Play
follow-up. And we did shoot most of the murder, about half of it, in Deshaies County and I was a county judge, and I was able to help them with 130 extra. So the local, I understand. If you were to judge, Representative
▶ Play
Douglas, if you could expand, Representative McElroy, What was the local impact from a
▶ Play
revenue standpoint? There was 130 extras that I helped the casting agent with. They hired locally, and we averaged about $70 a day, which probably turned over 13, 14 times in the economy there, plus people would hire their vehicles, you know, their cars were in it. I had one question, though. I see it says at least in the old language, it was 75% of the film content is produced in the workforce, including without limitation extras and day players, was 75% and it's lowered to 50% in this
▶ Play
bill. So, again, that's language that we worked with the agency and tried to get ironed out.
▶ Play
Well, I was just wondering why, you know, it was asking maybe someone from the other group. But anyway,
▶ Play
I'm all for it. Don't get me wrong. All right, Walter Brennan, we've got to move on. Thank you. I'll sign an autograph here if they get done. Okay. Representative Gene. Well, we
▶ Play
went down the pig trail. I just wanted to ask Representative McElroy, was he a member of the Screen Actors Guild? Only $2,300 stocked me. Representative
▶ Play
Meigs, did I say you had a hand up? All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm almost tempted to ask you, Senator, since you're talking about upcoming opportunities, if that means we're going to see you in a motion picture in the near future. Absolutely not. No, no. Kind of getting to the substance of the bill, I have a few questions. The first one, I notice you're adding several sections dealing with
▶ Play
the armed forces. Can you kind of go into what the background of that is? Well, again, I think when you look at what we're trying to do and what we're working with here is trying to iron out a bill. And I think what you look at historically, Representative Edwards and I worked on this in the last session. What we've been trying to do is to work with folks at AEDC and to try to get a bill that mirrors what we need or mirrors what other states have done. And so what they have worked with us on is to get it to where it is. Again, with regard to those particular elements, I think it opens up opportunities. Okay, because I noticed there's
▶ Play
other sections where it talks about someone has to be honorably discharged from the armed forces and so forth, So I didn't know how that all played into the motion picture industry coming to Arkansas. Trying to get them over to Matt Pitch's district. Okay. The final question is I noticed that it does have a $6 million potential fiscal impact is what DF&A scored it at. Now, this is a tax credit. So the assumption is that before they get that credit, they're going to be spending that money here within the state. So a two-part question Where, if at any point Does this fit in the governor's budget And then based on any research you've done Using more of a dynamic What kind of fiscal impact do you see Yeah, I think in the analysis In fairness
▶ Play
to DF&A And again, they don't support it And I think John's here to speak against it Which is fine I signed on to run this bill When I was told that the administration was supportive of it And I'm just kind of following through on my commitment and I think it's a good bill. To your point Representative Meeks, I think when you look at the scoring that they have looked at that is only from a state perspective. It doesn't take into consideration the local revenue impact and then what would potentially come back. I think on any tax credit you've got to watch it closely. You want to make sure that it has the desired impact. We've got a number of them in the state and I will tell you my preference on most of these is to eliminate as many tax credits as possible and focus maybe mainly on the income tax. I think you and I both share that. This is one that I certainly support. We've got – I think what it does do is also opens us up to the possibility of getting multi-year commitments, and that's really where the money is. I know back in the – I guess it may have been last summer or maybe right after the session, we had an opportunity to get an HBO miniseries, which would have been a multi-year commitment, which would have been a dramatic impact. It could have been a dramatic impact for the state. So I just want to – I mean, if we're going to do this, we ought to give ourselves a chance to do it. If not, we probably ought to come back and just repeal the whole thing and kill the film office and all that. So that's my thought. Representative Hendren,
▶ Play
I think – did you have a question
▶ Play
there? Yes, sir. Representative Meeks has asked most of them. I'm just going to say, Senator Sanders, how are you going to pay for this? Is this one we again put out to year after next, so it's not in the budget this year? Yeah, you wouldn't see any impact until 2016. And I guess the next question, we had a similar bill to this yesterday in revenue tax, and it wasn't for the movie industry. It was for low-income people. How would you, if you had the choice of voting for one for the movie industry here to give an income tax credit to low-income families and saying that they would spend
▶ Play
the money as well. Which one would you choose? Well, it's a great question,
▶ Play
Representative Hendren. I think two things. To answer that one in the direct comparison of those two bills, I'll tell you what I would do and what I am actually planning on doing because I think it's important. When you look at the earned income tax credit, the proposal that we've had at the state level, what I have told folks is what we ought to be doing is making sure that all those individuals who qualify for the federal earned income tax credit are utilizing that federal earned income tax credit before we come in with a state tax credit. And what my commitment has been on that particular item is to travel the state to speak to whatever community and get everybody aware that there is a federal earned income tax credit available to them. So I have a little bit of history there. with regard to this again I wouldn't be here at the end of the table unless there was I had worked with the folks that run this operate this and if there wasn't if there weren't quite frankly projects on the table so that's why I'm here but I think you can do both and again I don't think it's choosing I think y'all made the right decision on the state, I don't see how in the world we should pursue a state earned income tax credit until we get greater use of the federal earned income tax credit. Thank you. Representative Pitch, I thank
▶ Play
you. You had a question there? Yes, I did. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. As you mentioned, we've used what's available in my district several times. But one of the things I'd like to ask you, and I'm very supportive of this bill, as you can imagine but my question is we actually have people who make movies in this state do and we pretty much tax them as entities of this state with no representation if you will to use that and in talking with my entity that makes movies five-star productions they were very supportive of this but had questions how that could be applied as a to a local entity not just a movie entity coming say from LA or whatever. Could you comment to that? I think it applies to both
▶ Play
Speaker 125 45:33
and I think what you want
▶ Play
in any instance like this is we have a lot of homegrown talent. We have a history of homegrown talent when it comes to the movie industry both from the production side and from the talent side and obviously we look at what's happening with technology today and the ability to do things at a much lower cost. I think it's a good fit. I think we have a lot of opportunity because of the regional diversity of our state in terms of the geography, what it looks like. I mean, I think you can go a little bit down south and get into the Washtenaw National Forest, and I think it's a great opportunity to do some filming as well, but I think it does open up to the homegrown industry. I think it's an encouragement to further develop that talent and that industry. Thank you. Representative
▶ Play
Payton, you had a question? Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I, too, support this. I hope to be in the movie someday. But my question is on the transfer and the sale of the tax credits and the use of the tax credits. It seems very restrictive on the movie industry that earns the tax credits. It has to be used in the same year. So as they're racking up expenses and the film is not going to be hitting the streets until a year or 18 months later, they can't use their tax credit. And it allows for the sale of the tax credit, but they're allowed a one-time and whole or in part. So if they can't find a buyer for the entire tax credit, then they can't sell to two buyers, it would appear to me. Am I interpreting that right? I just want to make sure the tax credit helps the film industry and not whoever's
▶ Play
going to buy them. No, I think it does. And, again, you don't want to throw the doors too far open. I mean, you want to be somewhat restrictive and you want to be somewhat measured in how you approach this. And I think that was a thought there. I certainly appreciate that.
▶ Play
It's just we're kind of forcing them to sell the credits on a fire sale basis.
▶ Play
Yeah, I understand. I understand. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I can't comment on whether or not I think you need to talk to Representative McElroy about your film future. Well, my horse was in the movie. Well, yeah, I mean, look, you've got a big, great Western character,
▶ Play
perhaps. All right, any other questions? Representative Patton, I mean House. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Senator, don't take this personal. I don't like this bill. Didn't like it two years ago. Sure. Still don't. You earn income. Correct me if I'm wrong. You earn income tax credits based on the amount you spend, and the credits are issued. Is that correct? Yes, sir. And then you turn around and sell those income tax credits to somebody that does need them that they can apply to theirs. So, in effect, up to $10 million, the state of Arkansas is just subsidizing the production of movies. You are.
▶ Play
I mean, listen, Representative House, I will agree with you 100%, and that's what we're doing. And the point I think that we have to do, that we have to look at and probably need to do a better job as the legislature, is look at and make sure that the state is getting – the state in terms of locality, everyone involved on these – everyone's getting the bang for the buck. It's bottom line. And I'll tell you, if we see that it isn't working and the state's getting taken to the cleaners – and I know the state has gotten taken to the cleaners a few times on some tax credits. In fact, I've watched some. I was on revenue and tax last session. I saw some things sell out of there that shouldn't have sailed out of there, and guess what? There was sort of a point of neutrality on some of those, and it didn't work out. My commitment is this. It probably doesn't mean a whole lot, but I'll say it anyway. If, in fact, this isn't working, I'll be the first person at the end of the table trying to undo it in the next session. I hear you.
▶ Play
Follow-up, Mr. Chair. Certainly. As I watch the flow of money, the money will come out of the state. This is the backwards move. The money comes out of the state treasurer. It goes into a taxpayer. It goes from that taxpayer to the production company, that production company, to the citizens. And that's the flow of the money. In between there, let me finish, but in between there, a movie gets made. So there's no
▶ Play
net revenue to the state of Arkansas. A movie gets made, and, again, the expenses for that movie are expensed, and that's where you see the impact. Yeah, I mean, they
▶ Play
spend the money. I got that. But there's no net revenue to the state. It can't be. Well, I
▶ Play
mean, there is an impact. And, again, I think you have to look at it, to Mr. Meeks' point, and the points we've been made, you have to look at it from sort of more of a dynamic perspective and the impact overall and not just sort of a zero-sum ledger type. approach um you know we've got like i said we've got a lot of we've got a lot of tax tax credits thank you mr chair for letting
▶ Play
me throw the baby ruth in the swimming pool
▶ Play
all right you're welcome um all right any other questions for senator sanders if not we have one person signed up to speak against the bill john thais would you uh come introduce yourself and and tell us all about it.
▶ Play
Speaker 146 51:14
Mr. Chair, committee. Mr. Chair, committee members. Well, can't tell when
▶ Play
it's on and when it's off. I'm John Tice with the Department of Finance and Administration, and I have several reasons that DFA opposes the bill. First, as you've already indicated, is the revenue cost. Governor does not have this provision in its balanced budget. This will require adjustments to that balanced budget, and at this point, there's no money available. Second, this is amending a current law that calls for an appropriation of money. Currently, there is money available if a film project comes in. The General Assembly makes an appropriation, determines how much the state budget can afford. This bill just creates an upper limit of $10 million. The General Assembly has no knowledge whether $1 million will come out or whether $10 million will come out, depending on the film activity. That kind of uncertainty creates issues trying to balance the budget. The credit in this case is very generous. It ranges from 25% up to 40%, depending on the kind of expenditure. That exceeds any incentive we provide to any current manufacturing plant that establishes a location and regularly hires and employs folks for long-term purposes. Also, this is a sellable credit, which creates an additional problem. Under the current appropriation, the state appropriates a dollar. The film company gets a dollar. Under this bill, the state provides a tax credit that costs the state $1. But the person receiving that tax credit, the one you're trying to benefit, the film production company, sells it for up to $0.85. So you're providing a dollar's worth of state revenue to provide $0.85 of benefit, as opposed to the current law, which provides a dollar's worth of benefit for a dollar's worth of appropriation. That's not an efficient use of state money. I will point out that this credit is very, very similar to credits provided in other states. I provided in the revenue impact, I provided a chart of other states that have a similar impact. In each of those states, their legislative branch or their economic development branch or their state revenue department has analyzed how much money did we as a state spend versus how much money did the state receive back. You'll notice Maryland says for film credits of almost $62 million, they report receiving back $3.8 million in state revenue. That's the worst performance of any state. They range from Massachusetts $411 million allowed $55 million in state money that came back. This is not your investment of $411 plus another $55. This is, we just saw economic benefit to the state of $0.13 on the dollar. Again, not a good rate of return. I received information just this week that as a result of this poor performance of film credits of this nature in other states, that the Massachusetts governor in his budget has recommended eliminating that state's film credit. Michigan, which is on this list, is receiving $0.17 for every dollar spent. Their house just last week passed a bill to end that state's film credit. Louisiana, which is also on this list, they're completely overhauling their film credit because of audit issues that they have found during the course of these credits being filmed. So the main point of my opposition is this is not in the governor's balanced budget, and if we're going to do something of this nature, it's best served by a dollar-for-dollar, make an appropriation, provide that appropriation to the film company as opposed to a sellable credit that waters down. While the state still has the full cost, the benefit being provided gets watered down. I'd be glad to answer any questions. Representative Banks
▶ Play
Thank you Mr. Chairman Mr. Tyson in
▶ Play
your research on this how much would a production company have to spend in Arkansas to say get that million dollar credit or ten million dollar credit how much would they actually have to spend in order to get that The bill
▶ Play
has some thresholds requiring certain expenditures I don't remember those right off the top of my head For some reason, the number $200,000 is in the back of my head, but without referring to the bill, I would have to trust my memory.
▶ Play
So they would have to spend $200,000 before they started getting these credits? That is my memory,
▶ Play
if I'm remembering the bill correctly.
▶ Play
Okay, and then how much would they need to spend to get, say, a
▶ Play
million dollars worth of these credits? The credit amount is 25% to 40% of the expenditures. If all of the expenditures were at the 25% level, then that would be $4 million. Okay. All right.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
All right. Any other questions for Mr. Thais? Say none. Thank you for your testimony, sir. All right, members. We have four people signed up to speak for the bill. We'll start out with Gary Newton here. I think Gary's got a little different perspective than maybe some. All of you all that are signed to speak for the bill, we'd love to hear you. But if you get repetitive on it, in the interest of time, we need to move on. Gary, you're recognized. Introduce yourself, please. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chairman. Gary Newton here today is the chairman of the Arkansas Motion Picture Institute and is a founder of the Arkansas Production Alliance, which is a private sector partnership among the Little Rock Regional Chamber of Commerce, the Northwest Arkansas Council, the Arkansas Economic Development Commission, and Eureka Springs. In the ten years since I've been back to my native Arkansas, this issue has come up in every session. we finally got incentives in place to be able to compete not strongly but to be able to be in the game that said just because one has the structure in place one does not always have the appropriation nor does one have the funding and just a year and a half ago Senator Sanders referenced a project that was the biggest gut check that I think that we've had in this state in that we had a native son who chooses for the first time in history to make his home in Arkansas, repped by the biggest agency in the world, managed by the industry-leading production company, and with a series at HBO Cinemax. We were the first choice for that project, but because we weren't prepared for success, we lost that project to northern Mississippi for its proximity to Memphis. And one year later, when we had the opportunity to again try to compete for the series which at that time had an eight episode order from hbo we again were not able to compete right now that series with a little rock or an arkansas native executive producer and creator is in production in new orleans i say all that because that was potentially a six-year 300 million dollar project that would have put arkansans to work every day for six to eight months of the year, and finally elevate us to the position of our neighbors. Louisiana is now the number one motion picture production center in the world, surpassing Southern California. Georgia is fifth on that line. The states that were referenced by the gentleman earlier were Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan. I would reference our touch states. We're sending content creators out of Arkansas, trained at SAU Tech in Camden to populate the industry in Louisiana. There are, we've pleaded for this throughout the years for best practice economic impact studies to look at the industry in this state compared to those that are, look at that local spend and not just a narrow view of it. And the numbers, when you use those, actually justify the investment. I hate economic development incentives. As a former chamber guy, I hate them, but that's the game. I hate the designated hitter rule, too, but that's the game we have to play. And you cannot simply be in this business. And to Senator Sanders' point earlier, we should either get in or get out. And I believe it's the time to at least get in. We are blessed with an unexploited state with the richest backlot in America. Within 30 minutes, you can be in the mountains, the delta, the timberlands. and time is everything in production. My wish is that we keep content creators in Arkansas and export content instead of the other way around. Thank you. I'm
▶ Play
carrying questions for Mr. Newton. Representative Hendren. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You mentioned several cities.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1960

0:29 - 3:26 17 segments 5 speakers

SB954

3:26 - 4:34 5 segments 2 speakers

HB1854

4:34 - 34:39 90 segments 13 speakers

SB854

34:39 - 1:20:06 88 segments 13 speakers

SB910

1:20:06 - 1:23:03

HB1718

1:23:03 - 1:33:03

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Stephen Meeks Chair Unverified
24 segments
Representative Mark D. McElroy Chair Unverified
40 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
3 segments
Representative Micah S. Neal Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 10
1 segment
Speaker 29
1 segment
Speaker 44
1 segment
Representative John Payton Unverified
17 segments
Speaker 54
18 segments
Speaker 56
1 segment
Speaker 68
10 segments
Representative Lane Jean Unverified
8 segments
Joey Lowry Unverified
9 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
1 segment
Senator David J. Sanders Unverified
12 segments
Chair Unverified
27 segments
Representative Mathew W. Pitsch Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 125
1 segment
Representative Douglas House Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 146
1 segment
John Tice Unverified
12 segments
Gary Newton Unverified
7 segments