House Education Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (2)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
SB847
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…welcome to take the end of the arena down there to present SB 847. and we would like to recognize Representative Lowry for a…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
SB926
· 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…ir. Mr. Ladyman, take a seat. You are recognized to present SB 926. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, this is SB 926”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
Unknown speaker
0:00
I'm not seeing Senator Cooper. Mr. Ladyman's here to run that bill. Mr. Ladyman's here. Yes, sir. Mr. Ladyman, take a seat. You are recognized to present SB 926. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yes, this is SB 926
by Senator Cooper Just to give you a quick summary of this bill It changes a current law by eliminating the position of school district coordinator Arkansas Code 6-12-315 established this position of school district coordinator for any county in the state that contains all or part of six school districts This code allowed for a county which had not had a school district coordinator for five years or more to abolish the position. A very limited number of counties were covered
by this code and all affected counties in the state except Craighead County have eliminated the position. Recently the school district coordinator position in Craighead County has become open. This bill would repeal this code and allow this position in Craighead County to be eliminated now. All of the school superintendents in Craighead County are in agreement with this bill. I'd take any questions. Any questions? Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I understood that this was an effort to repeal the position of school district coordinator across the board throughout the state. I don't know how you can have it to be local legislation just limited to Craighead County, but you're saying that it's limited just to Craighead County? Well, the position has actually already been eliminated in all other counties with six school districts. They've been vacant for over five years,
so there's no one in those positions. The only one was Craighead County, and this will eliminate that position, which is open currently. Thank you for your explanation. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any other questions? Anyone in the audience like to speak against the bill? For the bill? Would you like to close for that bill? I just recommend a good vote. What's the will of the committee? I have a due pass from a bunch of them. I'll take Mr. Representative Gossage's due pass. All those in favor say aye.
Any opposed, no? Thank you. You have passed your bill. Thank you, committee. I'm going to recognize Representative Gossage for just a second.
And it is a very small compared to what they really do for us, but we do thank y'all. Senator Clark, you are welcome to take the end of the arena down there to present SB 847. and we would like to recognize Representative Lowry for a motion.
Yes, Mr. Chairman, I make a motion that we expunge the vote by which the three amendments passed earlier in the day. All right, I have a motion to expunge. All those in favor for expunging the vote of the three amendments. Question. Yes, sir? I want your question, Representative. If the motion to expunge fails, do we go further? It would have to run as is, I would guess, as it is amended already.
What we're doing is taking the amendments off and add a new amendment. We're reamending. All right. Thank you. All right. We have the motion to expunge the vote of the three amendments. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Motion. The motion has passed on that. I have Representative Lowry again. You're recognized for another motion. Yes. At this time, I would make a motion that we adopt. I believe it would be numbered amendment number four.
I don't have a number on it, but it would be the current amendment to this bill. I will give you all time to look at that. That we adopt the amendment that is before us, whatever number it is. House Amendment 4, but it's probably Amendment 5. I'll give you all a few seconds.
All right. I have a motion to adopt the amendment for the bill. Any questions on the amendment? Seeing no questions. All those in favor of adopting amendment, say aye.
Aye. Any opposed, no. Amendment is adopted. You are recognized to present the bill as amended. SB 847, as amended, gives charter schools right of access. for empty school buildings where a charter school already exists and where there's an empty building deemed to not be used by the public school facilities director.
It places the power to decide with the public school facilities division of ADE. It gives the public school the right to appeal. The appeal is not just to one person. It's to a commission. It guarantees with the latest version of the amendment that no building can be claimed by a charter school that is on the same campus or adjacent to a building that's being used by the school.
Most of you have heard everything else I have to say, And assuming that you don't want to hear it again, I'm going to be open for questions. Nobody signed up. All right. Representative Walker, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. How does this change your original bill from what it was before the amendments were presented? Okay. 5A, it changes from one person making a decision on appeal to a commission.
As I said, the latest amendment says a school district is not required to lease a public school academic facility. to an open enrollment public charter school if the public school academic facility subject to a lease is located on the same physical campus next to or adjacent to an academic facility that is currently used by the school district. Thank you. Mr. Chair, may I follow up unless there is someone else to ask a question? I see no others at this time.
You may follow up. Thank you. Under ordinary procedure, a school district has the power to make the decision, and someone seeking to use a facility has to go through the school board of that community, and then if there is an appeal to be made to the Department of Education, it goes from a decision by the school board, and the burden of proof is upon the appellant, rather than in this case the burden of proof is upon the school board as
to why a person seeking the use of the building should not use it. Why would you change the normal burden of proof and the normal path for decision making in school districts? Representative Walker, I have a dream that one day at K-12 Education Arkansas be about the kids, not about school boards, not about superintendents, not about turf and not about lines, not about charter schools
or public schools that will make decisions based on what's best for the kids of the state of Arkansas. Mr. Chair, may I ask for an answer to my question and my question was, what is the reason for putting the burden of proof on the denying school board rather than upon the person seeking to use the facilities when you come before the State Department of Education? Can you tell me that other than that you have a dream that we can't get into? Sure, I can.
There's no burden of proof on the charter school they're looking for a building. The burden of proof is upon the school to say we're using this building. We have some other purpose for it. There's some reason why it's setting empty and why it should continue to set empty year after year after year. All right. That's the own answer you have. I still have other questions after some others, Mr. Chair. Thank you for giving me those two.
Mr. Lowry, you're recognized for a question. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Clark, it's my understanding the appeal process would be open to either party, the charter school or the school district, to appeal if the decision went against them. Is that correct? That is correct. So the burden of proof would be on whoever was denied and has chosen to appeal the decision. That is correct, Representative Lara. Okay, thank you very much. Representative Walker, you're recognizing one more question, then I'm going to have to move to testimony.
We're running out of time. That's fine. I understand. With Senate, in due respect to Senator Lara's effort to help you, the burden of proof cannot be on both parties. somebody has to be the decision-maker and someone has to be appealing the decision of the decision-maker normally in a case if this were a student a student would have to go to the superintendent and then to the school board and if it were a 504 kid then you go to the State Department of Education in this situation the burden of proof according to what representative Lyra
says is is being placed on whoever doesn't get his way if the school board doesn't get his way then he or she it has to appeal and if the charter school doesn't get it its way it can appeal but the decision maker is not the school board so I don't see how this changes anything and I don't see any benefit to anybody by the process that you have adopted thank you if you could respond to the burden of proof any further than what representative Lowry attempted to up you on. I'd appreciate it.
Seeing no other questions, I'm going to go to the audience. And audience, you have one minute when you come to the end of the table. And I hate to do that to you, but we have to go back in session, and we'd love to finish this up against the bill. And I'm sorry about the time, but speak quickly. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Richard Abernathy, Executive Director of AAEA. And we do have several concerns over this bill and you know typically if a bill this late in a session is
amended and amended and amended it might need some additional study. We would like to see this bill placed in a study and then we'd be glad to help come up with some legislation that might solve any issue. One of the issues I keep hearing over and over and over about and you may hear it in a few minutes is about the KIPP program in Helena. I'd like to remind this body that the state is in charge of the Helena School District, and so that decision would be up to the state. Another issue, we have some facilities right now, and the underutilized part of that facility will be determined by the director of the facilities division.
What is the definition of underutilized? Because it's talking about academic purposes, administrative purposes, those type of things. On page 3, page 3, starting on line 12, is talking about the ABC program. with ABC program. Seems to be on a level playing field. That's it. There's issues with this bill. Thank you. Anybody like to speak for the bill? You have one minute from the time you set out.
Scott Shirey, Executive Director, Kip Delta Public Schools. In front of you, you see pictures of what is an abandoned building in Helena. It's been, believe it or not, three years ago that housed children. And the right of refusal has not worked in this case because those buildings have sat empty. In a recent report, Helena West Helena reported they had $7 million and they were financially stable. If we returned 100% of our students to Helena West Helena tomorrow, they would still have
excess facility. And I'm here as a community member as much as anything, that this is hurting our community and hurting kids. Our students are in trailers with no cafeteria, no library, walking to and from class in the rain, and to have that sitting there in our community is tragic, and I believe we can work together. This has worked well in Blyville where we've worked with the community, but for our kids to walk to school in the rain and empty facilities,
is being led to rot. I'm sorry, your time is up. And Randy, are you to speak for the bill? I'm going to let you come back. I'm going to take on the guess, and you can come back and speak. Thank you. I have anyone against the bill? Yes, sir. Dr. Protho. Dr. Protho. Thank you, Mr. Chairperson, members of the committee. Tony Protho, director of the Arkansas School Board Association.
I'd like to echo once again that this facility that we're talking about with Helena West Helena can be currently leased to KIPP charter schools by the Commission of Education. Also, the property that are across the state, many of these properties have been paid for by taxpayer dollars that were before partnership funds. the school patrons are still paying for those facilities
and once again in many cases this may take away the aspect of local control for those boards to be able to utilize one of the things I think about would be if a district is consolidating to try to get more financially efficient close down a campus it would automatically be available at that point for a charter school to come in and provide direct competition for kids because of a financial decision that was made within the district. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Four. That's your name and who you're with and you're recognized. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Randy Zook with the Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce, but I'm here today as Chairman of the Board of the Kip Public School in Helena. And I'm also here as a taxpayer. It strains belief that we let taxpayer-funded facilities rot and fall apart rather than allowing public charter schools to have access to them because I remind the committee and all the members,
these kids are children of taxpayers. These schools are being operated with taxpayer dollars. We're simply choking them from access to reasonable facilities while at the same time we let taxpayer-funded assets deteriorate and fall apart, become eyesores, crack houses, and all kinds of other undesirable outcomes from the abandonment of these buildings. So I would urge you to vote due pass, and I hope we can get a good vote on the bill.
Thank you very much. Thank you. Do I have anyone else against or for? Good. Thank you. Senator Clark would you like to close for your bill Thank you Mr. Chairman As Mr. Zook just pointed out the children attending these schools where they don't have facilities are the children of taxpayers We have buildings it's embarrassing
One of the things that I hear month after month in the interim is that we need to address NSLA but the NSLA funding which is for the our euphemism for poverty and that we need to address subgroups which is our euphemism for minorities
and then we have schools that come in and do a tremendous job and we'd rather let buildings fall down under the name of local control than stand up and give these kids a place to go to school. That we'll give a billion dollars to facilities funding as we should and not one falling down building. As Senator Cheatham said, retired school teacher sitting on our education committee
looking at these pictures who in the past has gone the other way looked at these gentlemen when they came up and he choked up he barely got it out with tears in his eyes he said it's time it's time we quit making excuses we quit finding a way to be against charter schools and that we treat these children equally to our other children I'd appreciate a good vote What's the will of the committee? Representative Lowry I have a due pass as amended.
I have a due pass as amended by Representative Lowry. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? No. The ayes have it. Roll call. I have two hands. I will roll call. I knew it was coming. Representative Letting. Representative Letting. Representative Murdoch, Representative Murdoch, Representative Deffenbaugh, Representative Harris, Representative Eubanks, Representative Radliff, Representative Gillum, Representative Walker, Representative Bell, Representative Balz, Representative
Douglas. Yes. Representative Lowry. Yes. Representative McElroy. No. Representative Armstrong. Representative Armstrong. Representative Gossage. Yes. Representative Sabin. Representative Saban. Representative Hodges. Yes. Representative Gray. Representative Gray.
Representative Lampkin. No. Sorry, your bill has failed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. Representative, how much time do we have, Mr. Speaker, before we have to be back? Is it time? It's time. Okay. We will meet tomorrow morning to concur on amendments from the Senate and two House amendments to concur on at 10 o'clock.
Agenda
SB926
SB847
Documents
No documents posted.