Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

April 7, 2016

April 7, 2016 ·House ·1:17:56
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (2)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1001 · 7 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Representative Collins moves that we place House Bill 1001 on second reading for the purpose of amendment. All in favo…”
Pre-2017 bill
HR1001 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “RESOLUTION HR1001”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
Wow. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
The House will now be called to order. I invite the members, the staff, the press, and guests in the galleries to stand and be led in prayer by our House Chaplain Tim Noll, and then to remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance to be led by Representative Greg
▶ Play
Speaker 6 2:11
Letting. Let's pray. Father, we love you. God, yesterday we came together, and it was a good day to be together. God, as we even looked in your word in Philippians, talking about unity and things like that, Father, right below that, you know what it says, but whatever's pure, whatever's noble, whatever's lovely, to meditate, to concentrate on these things. And so, Father, the only pure, lovely, noble thing that I know of is you. So, God, I pray that everybody in here today, that we concentrate on you, and that that's our focus as our representatives make decisions for this great state. God, I pray that they make them in humble submission to you, and that, God, throughout today, through our individual lives, throughout the meeting of this house, that your name is glorified. God, be with our families, and I pray for health, both physically and mentally, for this body. God, thank you for this great state. Thank you for this country. And we ask all these things in Jesus' precious
▶ Play
Speaker 10 3:11
name. Amen. Amen. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America
▶ Play
Speaker 11 3:19
and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
▶ Play
All right, let's hit our yellow present buttons. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, let's cast it the ballot, Mr. Clerk. 96 present, Chair sees a quorum. Are there any requests for leave? Representative Hickerson. Leave for Representative Deffenbaugh. Is leave granted for Representative Deffenbaugh? All right, so noted. Representative Letting. Leave for Representative Wright. Is leave granted for Representative Wright? Leave. All right, so noted. All right, Representative Eves. Leave for Representative Drown. Is leave granted for Representative Drown? Leave. All right, so noted. Representative Vaught. Leave for Representative Michelle Gray. Is leave granted for Representative Michelle Gray? Leave. All right, so noted. Any others? All right, Representative Vines moves that we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal without objection. So ordered. There are no reports from select committees, no reports from standing committees, any no unfinished business at this time, okay, all right, there are no executive communications that we've been made aware of. Real quick, members, we've got some special guests of Representative Gossage's in the North Gallery. We have the County Line School AP Government class. Let's welcome them. Members, we're going to move to the red calendar. Representative Collins moves that we place House Bill 1001 on second reading for the purpose of amendment. All in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. All right, the ayes have it. Mr. Clerk, please read
▶ Play
Speaker 24 6:11
Amendment No. 1. Amendment No. 1 to House Bill 1001. Representative
▶ Play
Collins, you're recognized to explain the amendment.
▶ Play
I did a poor job of allowing members to sign up to be sponsors of this bill, therefore I need to amend the bill to add a co-sponsor, so I'd appreciate your
▶ Play
support. All right, Representative Collins has explained the amendment. Would anyone like to speak against the amendment for the amendment? All right, Representative Collins, a signal that he's closed for the amendment. Question now before the House is the passage of Amendment 1 to House Bill 1001. All in favor say aye. All opposed say nay. All right, the ayes have it. Please send the bill to engrossing, Mr. Clerk. Mr. Clerk, please read House
▶ Play
Speaker 24 7:18
Resolution 1001. House Resolution 1001 by Representative Beck, honoring Corporal Robert L. Moses for his dedicated service to the Office of Secretary of State and to the State Capitol
▶ Play
Police. Representative Beck, you're recognized to present the resolution.
▶ Play
Thank you Mr. Speaker. I know I speak for the whole house here when I say that we certainly appreciate Officer Moe's contributions and all the service that he's given us and the protection that he's given us during his six years here. So I would like to first of all just commend him for that. Second, I have a House resolution here. The House resolution is to honor Corporal Robert L. Mosey for his dedication and service to the Office of Secretary of State and to the State Capitol Police. And I'd like to share a few of the highlights that are in this resolution. Corporal Robert L. Moses started with the Capitol Police in March 29, 2010 and his final day will be April 7, 2016 During his six years here he has served well in the Secretary of State's office and the State Capitol Police He also has 14 years of service in law enforcement And that began in Menifee as a police officer in the Menifee district. While he was here, he's also served as a firearm trainer for the Capitol Police. So he's helped train the Capitol Police in the use of their firearms. He's also a certified professional law enforcement instructor, a certified firearm instructor. He has over 2,000 hours of law enforcement training, and we're certainly going to miss him, but he's continuing to help us out. He's going to work as a parole and probation services for the District Department of Community Corrections back home, as he told me earlier this morning. And so I certainly appreciate a favorable vote on this, and I would like to please join me in thanking Officer Moseys for his
▶ Play
work. Representative Beck has explained the resolution. Would anyone like to speak against the resolution? Representative Beck has signaled he's closed for the resolution. The question now before the House is the passage of House Resolution 1001. All in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed say no. Resolution passes. Mr. Clerk. Members, we're now going to move to the supplemental calendar that's on your desk.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 11:08
the morning hour is now closed clerk please read house bill 1001 house bill 1001 by representative Collins to amend title 23 of the Arkansas code to provide a health insurance to qualifying individuals to create the Arkansas works
▶ Play
program and to declare an emergency representative Collins you're recognized to
▶ Play
present House Bill 1001 good morning everybody yesterday we spent a long time in the committee meeting going through this in a lot of detail and I did that because this is a topic that's going to be in front of us over the next several weeks, not just today. I've asked the staff to get a brief presentation to each of you so it'll be on your desk. They're working on that now. And I'm going to use some of that this morning. Again, yesterday I went through it in a lot of detail with all the footnotes and references and all those things. I'm not going to do that here, but I want people to know that that's available for anybody. Also, all of the numbers that I'm using and the facts that we've compiled come from the Stephen Group, which is a consultant that the Health Care Task Force has hired. In other words, a consultant that works for all of you. John is actually here today. He may even get up in the gallery if he can make it up, and I can introduce him. But he's available for anybody to talk to directly. And John comes to us with a fair-minded point of view. Full disclosure, I voted against John and his group when we were picking the consultant because I thought he brought a palpable bias against the private option. And I was concerned that he would not assess the factors in an unbiased way. I would submit to you that working with him and his team has been fantastic. They're hard workers. I've got lots of confidence in what he put, but it was the anti-PO members of the task force that voted for John's team to do these analyses. So I just say that in terms of where the numbers come from. So today I want to do three things. I want to go back and just give a little bit of history because we all come to this from different places and we spent different amounts of time on it. The second thing I want to do is walk through some of the numbers that we're looking at today. This is a very emotional issue. It's emotional for me. It's emotional for many of us, but it also has extraordinary financial implications and no amount of emotions can wash away the financial impact of what we're going to do for or against the people of Arkansas. And then the third thing I want to do is just touch on a couple areas of the bill. I know people have had an opportunity to read it. I know the governor talked about it, so I'm not planning to get into that in detail. So with that, I want to go back to the passage of the ACA, Obamacare, and the consternation that it caused nationally, because certainly in Arkansas, the majority of people were not excited about that, and there's been a lot of opposition to it, a lot of work to fight it, but the reality is what we have today is the outcome of health care policy in Washington, D.C. Now, there's always a question when you're evaluating what does success look like. For example, in football, if I say the Razorbacks are a great team, I don't mean they can beat the Dallas Cowboys. What I mean is they have a legitimate shot to be the national champion in college football. That's a realistic goal. To win the Super Bowl is not. So in this business, what is a realistic goal for you to hold yourselves accountable to the people of your district and the people of Arkansas? In my view, when I ask myself that question, I say there are 50 other teams, I mean states, 50 states. We have to be number one, the best. Thank God for Mississippi. That is over. Number one response in major issues in this country. When the law was passed, there were 50 states, and we had a decision to make. Washington, D.C., gave us two options, D.C. Obamacare option number one and D.C. Obamacare option number two. That's what they fed us, right down our throats. 49 states picked one of the two options. One state said, D.C., uh-uh, not good enough. Those options are not good enough. We need something better than either of the other two options. And that's what we did. We created an animal called the private option, which enables us to get our money back from Washington but does not force us to expand the fee-for-service format of Medicaid but rather use private market principles to provide health insurance the way working people get their insurance with insurance policies. Now, was that perfect? Of course not. It was not perfect. That's not my claim. My claim is out of 50 responses to Obamacare that it was the best. And that's merely what my claim is. So when we did that, there was a lot of concern that it was hopes, dreams, and prayers. And all we had to go on were promises, estimates, plants. But today, we have more than that, and so that's the good news. Today, we actually have results from several years of all 50 responses to the Obamacare law. And what does that mean for us? Well, what it means is some of the things people were concerned about before, we can answer. And I just want to touch on some of those. One thing people said was, we cannot trust the feds. They're completely untrustworthy. They've made promises to us in this deal, and they will not keep their promises. The most significant promise they made was that they were going to pay 100% of the cost of the policies during the term of the private option. And people said, there's no way that will happen. They will not honor that promise. Three years later they have honored it and and all of the other substantial promises they made. Another concern was we're going to encourage people in Arkansas to stop working. We're going to create a welfare culture where which is completely out of control and put us behind from an employment standpoint. Now it's the spring of 2016. The recent unemployment reports have just come out, Arkansas's unemployment rate is 4.2%. That's a 40-year low for our state. The national unemployment rate is 4.9%. That means Arkansas's unemployment rate is 20% below the national average. Is that because of the private option? Of course I'm not making that argument. I'm merely making the argument that the predictions of disaster from an employment situation have not come true. As a skeptic, the first thing I looked at when I saw that employment report was those numbers are artificial. In Arkansas, I bet you everybody's so depressed they're not going to work. They're not in the workforce, and that's the reason our numbers are so low. Oops, wrong again. Arkansas was number two out of 50 states in people moving into the labor force while our unemployment rate dropped to 4.2%. I could cover several more of these, but I'm just going to cover two. One of the things people said was, the program will never work, you'll never be able to keep the costs down, and the feds are going to hang Arkansas for all the excess costs. That was a legitimate concern because the feds have said, you must be able to operate this program on a certain cost per member, And if we don't do that, then it's true. Arkansas taxpayers would then have to foot the bill for the difference. And every month, those numbers are meticulously managed. And over three years, Arkansas taxpayers have had to pay exactly zero dollars for cost overages of the private option. All of the costs were managed to the agreements and what the Fed said. Finally, the question was, will it even do any good? We're going to go through all this, and will it even help anybody? Will anybody be better off? Well, the numbers have come out in the 50 states. Arkansas lags one state in the percentage of uninsured population improvement. We improved almost 10 points on that front. So the good news from that is that we've got experience and facts to work with to help us make the next round of decisions. The last point that I want to make on where we've been and where we're going are what are the other teams, excuse me, what are the other states doing? Who's following whom? So I mentioned before there were 49 states that chose D.C. Obamacare option number one or D.C. Obamacare option number two. There was one state that said we're going to do something different. In order to do something different, you need what's called an 11-15 waiver from the federal government. But there are now a half a dozen states that have chosen to move away from option number one or option number two and pursue their own 1115 waiver. And there are other states that are looking at customized approaches as well. So the evidence says other states are following the approach that Arkansas has taken in terms of an 1115 waiver as opposed to choosing DC number one or DC option number two. Okay, so that's where we've been and where we're going with that piece. Now what I want to do is I want to talk about what are the impacts of this specific choice in front of us as we work to improve on the private option. And the governor hit the highlights yesterday, the several areas of improvement. We're looking to get more personal responsibility, people to take more responsibility for themselves. If you're making more than one times the federal poverty level, we're going to put a $19 a month copay in there for people to pay for their insurance. We're looking for people to at least get work training and work referrals. We're looking for people to do healthy lifestyles, preventative healthcare. We're building some unique incentives to try and encourage those kinds of things. For example, allowing people to have dental care, which is not required as part of the program, something that can be taken away from people that do not follow the rules, and that's one of the ways we're going to try and get people to follow the rules. So what are the numbers on this one? You're all going to get a copy of this. It looks like it's on your desk today, so TSG is the Steven Group. This is the group that all of us have hired as the legislative task force consultant. I'm going to do a poor job of taking their information and trying to communicate it to you, but I think this packet has the core numbers for us to consider. I'm going to try and blow through this relatively quickly. If you want a box by box description, there's a video from yesterday where I did that. The first page talks about our budget. This is the budget that we're responsible for. The very top number that you see over to the right, over the five-year period of this term, why are we doing a five-year waiver? How did we come up with five years? The law and the waiver requirements from the federal government perspective use five-year terms. All of those waivers can be amended and adjusted throughout the five years, but that's the reason for five-year projections. As you can see at the top, the federal government will be shipping $9 billion to Arkansas over the five years in order to fund this program. The next section talks about the costs we will have to incur from the private option and the savings we will get from the private option. Over five years, the five years of this time period, the net of those is a $200 million savings. other words, our share, 5%, 7%, 10% over this period, less the benefits, will net our budget $200 million to the good in a five-year period. But that's only the spending half of the equation. The income half of the equation is $500 million to the good. It comes from two sources. I'm going to use an analogy. When you go into a store and you buy underwear or candy bars or cleaning products, you pay Arkansas sales tax. When you go to the gas pump, you do not pay Arkansas sales tax. You pay a gasoline tax. When you buy an insurance policy in Arkansas, You do not pay Arkansas sales tax. You pay a premium tax. So insurance policies in Arkansas have a premium tax. The private option is insurance policies, so there is a premium tax, and the collections for that over the next five years will be $200 million into the Treasury. The other area of benefit that's captured on this report is taxes, income taxes, from the spend in our state. The $9 billion mostly goes, not exclusively, mostly goes to pay for people, doctors, nurses, janitors, all kinds of people. They pay state income taxes. So I wanted to use a dynamic analysis. I've got a dynamic analysis. It shows many, many, many, many, many, many hundreds of millions of dollars more benefit than I'm showing here. This just basically reflects about a 4% state income tax benefit from the dollars that flow in, $300 million. So the net savings to the budget is $200 million over five years, the net increase in revenue to our budget is $500 million, that's $750 million over five years, which works out to $150 million per year to our budget that we have to live with. What I would say is, Collins, you must be a liar. And the reason you must be a liar is because the governor has been saying it's only $100 million, and he's been saying that loudly. He's a thoughtful man, he's a trustworthy man, and he got a lot more votes than you did. Neither one of us is lying. The difference is the governor based his numbers on the projections, the estimates, the hopes and dreams of the people that were calculating what the private option would deliver. These numbers are based on the actuals, what we've actually seen and experienced over the next three years. So the $100 million was a guess. The $150 million is what we're going to have to live with. The next thing I want to talk about is page three. What I've laid out is the $150 million direct hit to the net general revenue budget, which we'll all have to live with to the good or to the bad. The second set of numbers is a billion dollars that won't hit us in the face on the first day. But I promise you it will hit us in the face. Where does it come from? It comes from something called uncompensated care. The reason is because you have three choices in our world today. D.C. option number one, D.C. option number two, and an 1115 customized program. If we move off of Arkansas Works, we move into D.C. option number two. I call it EMTALICARE, EMTALICARE, Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act Care. In 1986, the federal government passed an unfunded mandate to all the states. When you watch the debates, Donald Trump describes it with a euphemism. He says, I, Donald Trump, will not let people fall down in the streets in my health care plan. That is a euphemism for this law called AntalliCare. He's a much better communicator than I am. AntalliCare means that if somebody does not have money, they can go to the emergency room and they can get care. And who pays for the care? Who do you think pays for the care? It goes on the books of the hospital. It's uncompensated care. Now, we cannot eliminate that because even with Arkansas Works, we still have people going to the emergency room. In fact, the top line showcases how much that is. 135 million a year, 141 million a year. With Arkansas Works, with the private option, we tell the hospitals, your budgets are flush with help from paying customers. You need to manage your uncompensated care inside your own profit and loss sheets. So we don't help with that at all. So we're not worried about this. We ignore the first three quarters of a billion and let the hospitals eat it. But what we find if we don't have the private option is that there is not only the initial $130, $140 million a year, but an incremental $200 million a year that comes in as more and more people go to the emergency rooms. Now, the Stevens Group has done an intensive, extensive, and exhaustive analysis to find out, are these numbers fantasy numbers or are they real numbers? One of the things that we have in all businesses is costs versus charges. Charges, of course, are higher than cost. The feds and other people keep track of cost factors in order to scale down charges to a number that approximates actual cost. Representative Farrar has been like a dog with a bone on this, and he confirms to me that these numbers are the cost numbers, not the much higher charge numbers. These are real numbers for us to consider. So the bottom line is, Arkansas Works saves $150 million a year on the budget, and it saves $200 million a year in uncompensated care to hospitals. Now I claim that's $350 million in new taxes all of you will have to put on our Kansans. Somebody could argue with me and say, Charlie, that $200 million is not our problem, it's not my problem. Well, there are over 100 hospitals in Arkansas, 19 of them are on the financially vulnerable list. 58 hospitals have already closed since Obamacare happened, most of them in non-expansion states. When those hospitals start to struggle in a major way, we're going to have to deal with that. Also, what hospitals do when they don't have this money is they raise their prices, which drives insurance rates dramatically higher. So when your consumers call and say, my insurance rates are skyrocketing, so hospitals can pay for this money, what we'll find is we're going to have to deal with it that way as well. The next thing I want to do is I want to talk about the federal debt. If you look at the overall effects of the 20 federal tax increases from Obamacare and the Medicare reimbursement reductions from Obamacare, and you look at the money that then flows back to the states, we've got much of that summarized on this chart on page 4. So over the five-year period, Obamacare exchanges will give $4.9 billion in tax credits in Arkansas. They're much greater than that in Texas. Obamacare exchanges in Mississippi and Tennessee and Alabama and all the Obamacare Option 1 states have this same factor because on their Obamacare exchanges, they pay support, they pay subsidies in Texas and Mississippi and Alabama to families making up to four times the poverty level. That means if you have a family of four and you're making $90,000 a year in Alabama, Mississippi, or Texas, you can get Obamacare subsidies on the exchange. And this number reflects the amount of money in Arkansas that the federal government returns to us for those exchange subsidies, $4.9 billion. The next number talks about the amount of money the feds are sucking out of our state. That's the $10 billion number. That's the 20 federal tax increases and the Medicare reimbursement reductions. So in the absence of Arkansas Works, what we have is a net Obamacare outflow from our people of $5 billion. So if we don't accept Arkansas Works, they took $10 billion in taxes and Medicare reimbursement reductions. They gave us back $5 billion for health care reimbursements for people making up to $90,000, and that leaves $5 billion on the table to pay down the national net. I want to skip page 5 and just go to page 6. Page 6 is a pictorial of the hospital closures. This is not very good if you want to dig down deeper. I can get you more specific information on hospitals, hospital closures, the hospitals that are in your district, and those types of things. We can do that separately, but that graph kind of lays that out. The one, as a skeptic, the one number on page 7 that I want to draw your attention to is the notion that perhaps it's all a coincidence, and the hospitals that are closing really have nothing to do with whether or not states are expanding Medicaid and getting their money back or not. And what we're finding is 40% of the population lives in states that have not expanded and receiving their money back, but 73% of the hospital closures are in those states. And so that's a top line of the information which people are free to get a lot more as we move forward. The last thing I want to do is just touch on a couple things on the bill that are very reassuring to me. The first one is, in the bill, we have delineated that if the feds reduce their commitments to their portion of the payments, that we will walk away. And we have a 30-day reaction period and 120-day in the program. We've had this in our legislation previously. The feds honored all those commitments, as I said earlier, but we maintain that right in Arkansas Works, if they choose in the future to violate their agreements, that we can walk away. There are also other triggers and other elements of a similar nature, and one of the things we've done legally to protect ourselves, there are multiple elements inside that legislation that dictate this is not an entitlement, you're not guaranteed to get this forever, and even though I, like all of you, know that, you know, what does that mean in people's minds? From a legal standpoint, we're very, very protected there that if things change and we need to adjust, we can do it, just like we've been in a position to do that in the past. The last thing I will say on this is the goal that the governor, and I think many of us here, would love to be able to do is move to a world where we, in our state, get to control the health care spending decisions and have the feds give us a block grant to support that flexibility. Does Arkansas Works do that? Absolutely not. The Arkansas Razorbacks have not beaten the Dallas Cowboys in the Super Bowl. I'm not claiming they have. I'm not claiming they have. But Arkansas Works moves us closer to that vision when we're employing the give people a hand-up, not just a hand-out mentality, than any other of the 49 other states that are out there, and the governor is committed to continuing to work with the new president to try and push that even further, someday hopefully achieving our goal of beating the Dallas Cowboys in the Super Bowl by getting a block grant where we can employ this and make the
▶ Play
decisions here in Arkansas. Thank you very much. All right, Representative Collins has thoroughly, exhaustively explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? Representative Bentley, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker, colleagues, thank you so much for letting me speak today. And I want to thank my voters for giving me the opportunity to be here in this prestigious house and be a member of this great assembly that I am honored to be a part of. In 2014, Arkansas voters made history changing the balance of power in our statehouse for the first time in 138 years. What caused this change in history? I believe many of those hardworking Arkansans were angry at a change in their health care system that they did not want but was forced upon them. I believe they were voting for change. They saw the direction that they were going, and they wanted us to make a difference. Like many of you, I went door-to-door in my district for month after month after month. I promised that I would vote to end the Obamacare-Medicaid expansion, the only part of Obamacare that we as a state legislature could change. But as Congressman Bruce Westerman has stated, the Medicaid exchange is the most egregious part because it alone will add billions to our national debt. I won in a district that had never voted for a Republican before because they believed in individual responsibility. They believed that we don't fix an unsustainable government program by adding more people on it. Many of you in here voted for SB 96. in our last general session to end the private option and ask the task force to find options for the state as we move forward with Medicaid. Today's vote is very different. Do we vote to support Medicaid expansion under Obamacare or do we end to vote this entitlement program once and for all as we said that we would do? The private option has done exactly what President Obama wanted it to do. It has addicted us to billions of American tax dollars in our general revenue so that anyone who would, excuse me, so that somehow we cannot exist without it. It is to the point that anyone who would suggest stopping the private option is considered totally stupid. Why would anybody want to stop this? Well, let me give you a couple of reasons. on why we might want to stop this program. For one, I don't believe that we will make Arkansas prosperous by bankrupting our children's future and making our state totally dependent upon federal dollars. There is no free money in Washington. This year alone, the federal government spent $300 billion just on interest payments for our national debt. We are on an unsustainable path with Medicaid. How can we possibly think that adding more able-bodied adults to the Medicaid rolls will save us money in the long run? It is time for us to look past the next election and plan for the next decade. Where do we want Arkansas to be? Do we want to be a welfare state, or do we want to be a state living within our own means, working together to meet the needs of our constituents. We can implement common-sense solutions that will help Arkansas to be healthier. The second reason why we should vote against Medicaid expansion is because like all government programs, we have seen plenty of waste, fraud, and abuse in the first year of the private option. For instance, 43% of the recipients never went to the doctor. Not once did they go see the doctor. Meanwhile, we have young families who have seen their insurance rates go through the roof. Folks who are working two jobs just to make premiums on insurance plans that have such a high deductible that they can't even afford to go see the doctor when they need to. I hear from these folks every time that I'm out in my district. These are folks that care about their neighbors, but they are sick and tired of working to pay taxes so that others can do absolutely nothing and get free health care. Not only have we seen massive waste in Medicaid expansion, we have seen from the Stevens Group that we have fraud as well. We have recipients on the private option who live in 40 other states and many who have fraudulent Social Security numbers. As far as abuse goes, I have talked to receptionists and doctor's offices who have seen private option patients every week for something as small as a hangnail or a rash. Government programs have never been the answer for getting our state healthy, or we would not be the least healthiest state in the nation. I want to work together with this body to make Arkansas one of the healthiest states in the Union, but I don't believe that we have to add billions to our national debt to do that. we certainly need to start educating our children on how important it is to have a healthy and active lifestyle and to eat right we have great Christian clinics all across this state and we need to incentivize those Christian clinics we have a health department clinic in every single county in our state and it's time that we utilize those health clinics more in closing you do not have to attend many health care task force meetings to see that this vote is not about the health of our Kansans. It is about keeping the spigot of American tax dollars open into our state from Washington. I ask you, remember the vote and the promise that you made to your constituents. They did not make a mistake when they voted for you and your conservative values. We will have to make cuts in our spending if we do this. I understand that. but I believe that we can do it together in a responsible manner that will not hurt the important services of our constituents. Let's vote no on continuing Medicaid expansion and make the change our voters sent us here to make. Let's not betray their confidence in us. Let's make a difference. Thank you. Representative Bentley has
▶ Play
spoken against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Against the bill. Representative Copeland, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Thank you, colleagues, and I'll make sure that I cut out the portions that have already been covered and just address the main points here. Number one, I want to look at this from very quickly from a political standpoint. Some of you know that I just recently challenged a sitting senator from my own party for a Senate in our Senate district, Senate District 34. The reason I did that was because I felt like my colleague needed to answer for their vote. But we started out, we were greatly outspent, two to one. We obviously had to start much later than our colleague. We lost early voting by 20 points. We won voting day by 18 points. And we saw the tide turn when people started learning and knowing the facts and knowing what was going on. Now, keep in mind, those of us that are politically minded, That was with the Chamber of Commerce spending $25,000 against me. That's with my own House caucus giving money to my opponent. That's with the governor coming out and doing two press conferences against me. That is with the lieutenant governor maxing out to my opponent. That is with a continual and concerted effort against me. And many of those people were people that
▶ Play
had. Representative Bell, please get your microphone.
▶ Play
Point of order, Mr. Speaker, the representative is
▶ Play
not speaking on the bill. All right. I'm going to rule that that is accurate. Representative Copeland, please speak on the
▶ Play
bill. Okay. My whole point of this was that the political ramifications of it. Second thing regarding the bill is any accusation that those of us that do not care about the poor, you know, I spend every day working with the poor, and I don't think there's any greater thing that we could be doing, and the greatest commandment that we have is to help the poor. But let me remind us of something, that if a person in Arkansas were to go on the national exchange on Obamacare, they have to be at 100 percent of the poverty line, and they have to work 28 hours a week to be on Obamacare to receive a subsidy. But in Arkansas, we have chosen those that have voted for this legislation that we're now considering again. And we have said you don't have to work a lick to be able to get it. I don't think there's one person in this body that wants hardworking people to be deprived of anything. We don't want people that cannot help themselves to be deprived of anything. But the fact is we can't pay for everybody's everything. So what I'm asking is that we ask people that can work to work, the people that can't work, that we are to help them. The last point that I'll make is my colleague did not mention the employment part of this, that we're expanding. What we're doing is we're expanding expanded Medicaid. And the reason we're expanding expanded Medicaid is that we're now offering this to employers who can take someone who's on fully private insurance, and if they qualify, now they'll get a subsidy back from the government. Then their children then qualify to become on Medicaid. We don't get a match for those Medicaid dollars. That could be up to 26,000 additional people, not counting the 80,000 employees that will be on there. So I would contend that the monetary disaster is not in us getting rid of this. The final thing in conjunction with that that I would make is this. We've heard $100 million by the governor. My colleague says it's $300 million. Our own budget process says that if we were to end this program as of December 31st, which we said we were going to do, if we ended this program as of December 31, 2016, our total cost would be $33 million for this year, $33 million. And I would contend you can find $33 million in state government in an ashtray. And so we're not talking about something that is something that is just out of the ordinary, extraordinary. And what we have done in Arkansas is we have expanded and we have made our state a dependent state upon the government. I don't think that's anything to brag about. I think we need to enhance and strengthen Medicaid. We need to strengthen it and work on it and make it better. But what we don't need to do is continue to expand what we've already expanded. We dug a hole in 2013. We're still digging a hole. We're getting ready to dig a deeper hole. We need to put the shovel down and quit digging. Thank you so much. Members, Representative
▶ Play
Copeland has spoken against the bill. Would anyone like to speak for the bill? Representative Brown, you're recognized to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm as ideological as any of my conservative colleagues. I do not believe that we need to do things at the state level that create problems for our people at the federal level to rein in government. I really was opposed to the private option, but as Representative Collins has pointed out, It hasn't been a totally broken program, and with our unique way of expanding Medicaid, we have done some good for our people in Arkansas. With Arkansas Works, we can continue to encourage people to take care of themselves. We have seen, and I cannot go over the details of the finances as well as Representative Collins, but he has been on the task force, and I have not. But we have seen him lay out the numbers, and the numbers speak for themselves. If we do not go forward with this, we are going to put our people in Arkansas in a tremendous amount of jeopardy. I believe that people, healthy people, need to get out and go to work. I honestly believe that. I have worked all my life. Nothing's been handed to me on a silver platter. But I believe that given the hand we've been dealt, that Arkansas Works is the best way for us to go forward Because as long as we have the Affordable Care Act, we're going to have to deal with it one way or another, option one or option two, or our hybrid. And I commend my colleagues for the work they've done on the task force, and I would encourage you to make a good vote on this bill. Thank
▶ Play
you. Representative Brown has spoken for the bill. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to speak against the bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and thank you, colleagues. We've probably been doing this long enough, and I don't know if it can make any difference, so I'll keep it short. First, I mean, I do appreciate the comments of my colleague here. I think there are political ramifications because of the fact that there are people back home who are paying attention, they're watching this, and they know that, you know, we're not going to spend $1.8 billion a year insuring 300,000 people and it not cost us money at some point in the future. What I would say, just to make sure we keep the record straight, is our caucus actually didn't give to your opponents, so I don't know. we need a visit about that and see how that confusion came, but that never happened. But you know, there are a lot of numbers. Man, Charlie is good at this. Boy, you can just stand up here and speak a whole bunch of numbers. But one thing that, one number I do know is right now it's $19.2 trillion. That's our debt. $19.2 trillion. If we don't spend almost $2 billion here in Arkansas, $1.8 billion a year here in Arkansas, that money won't be appropriated. Now $1.8 billion is just a drop in a bucket. It's just a very small amount. But it's my drop. It's our drop. It's our opportunity. You know, we can't ask our congressional. We can't ask Representative Westerman and Representative Womack and Representative Hill. We can't ask our senators. We can't ask Representative Crawford. We can't ask them to go to D.C. and reform entitlements, take that hard step, you know, touch that third rail that we're going to have to do if we're not going to bankrupt our country. We can't ask them to do it if we can't do that here. and we can't make a little bit of hard decisions here and we can't just say you know what i understand there are some people who are out there hurting i understand that i understand what it is to struggle i totally get that but at the same time you know we have a lot of people who are hurting i i love the conversation i had with representative miller actually a long time ago and we just talked about it again where he's got a guy who's uh who's a constituent who's struggling a paraplegic, but he has a family farm that's been passed down from generation to generation to generation, and he can't get services because he has assets. Well, you know, I almost agree that that's probably right. I mean, he should probably have to sell his family farm to take care of himself. That's hard. I mean, that's tough. That may be how it should be. This program doesn't have that option. You can have a family farm where you can have a lot of assets. If you're a farmer in particular, there's a lot of ability that you can, you know, have your four-wheeler and your truck and all that stuff owned by the farm. You can have a business. You can have a whole bunch of stuff. And it makes no difference at all because we can't do an asset test. Why can't we do an asset test? Well, because Barack Obama says we can't. We can't do a work requirement. Everybody here would like to put in a work requirement. Well, we can't do that. Why? Because Barack Obama says we can't. But one thing I'll tell you for sure is President Obama will not be president in just a few short months. come january 20th we'll have a new president this program ends on december 31st we got 20 days from when this program ends to when we have a new administration and who knows what kind of flexibility we'll have if we're going to put together a long-term health plan for arkansas let's not do it now when we have i mean you know universally at least on my side of the aisle everybody hates obamacare so why should we put it together under a barack obama administration All we have to do is just wait just a little while. Just wait just a little while and work out a deal under a new administration. Maybe we get that block grant. Work out a deal. I mean, you know, who knows what kind of flexibilities may be out there. And instead, we're going to lock ourselves into five years, and that, to me, doesn't sound like a good deal. So I'd appreciate a no vote.
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger has spoken against the bill. Representative Collins, would you
▶ Play
like to close for your bill? All right. I'm sold. I'm ready to solve the national debt. I just need one thing from my friends that want to do that. Today, the federal government is sucking our people dry with 20 tax increases and another $500 million, $700 million a year in Medicare reimbursement reductions to our seniors. So here's what I ask of my colleagues. Can you please, please, please not put the entire U.S. debt on the little old state of Arkansas? Why do the fat cats in L.A., all those rich people driving their Maseratis, get off scot-free? Why do all the bigwigs in New York with all their hotels, they don't have to pay the national debt. Just the waitresses, the flight attendants, the farmers, the small business owners in Arkansas, this 1% of the country, we're going to pay off the debt. If we can get everyone else in the boat and we can convince the rest of the country that we're going to eliminate the expansion amounts so that we can have all 50 states contribute to the debt, then I think Donald Trump would agree that we're not dumb politicians making a crappy deal, but we're actually making a good deal for the future of the country. That's condition number one. Condition number two, today our budget is over $25 billion, and almost 80% of it, $20 billion, 10 times the private option money, comes from the federal government. So given my commitment to this principle, I would like to see if we can get the other 50 states and Arkansas to start looking at returning much more of this money to the Feds. I would actually vote for tax increases versus just paying down the debt, but I'm willing to consider both. Because if this $2 billion is so essential to the national debt, I'm confused why the other $20 billion isn't equally important. The third thing that I would say is we intended on this call to have a managed care bill before this body. That managed care bill returns $1 billion to the federal government in Medicaid re-inductions. The managed care bill saves $1.4 billion over five years, 70% of that goes back to the feds to reduce the national deficit. We could go full managed care throughout the entire Medicaid program, and our consultants have said that would save $2.4 billion, 70% of that would go to the national debt. So I'm going to be working hard to make sure that we can pass managed care and make a significant contribution to the federal debt. The second thing I want to touch on briefly is fraud, waste, and abuse, because I agree with my colleague, there is fraud, waste, and abuse in the private option program. What we have learned is that all 50 states have an extraordinarily poor record on fraud, waste and abuse for every single government program. Traditional Medicaid, Medicare, our seniors, unemployment insurance, all of them are atrocious. Our task force has looked nationwide for a system that keeps track of this and reduces fraud, waste, and abuse and are unable to find a system anywhere in the United States of America. So one of the things the task force is moving forward with is a verification system that's going to use modern technology the way the credit cards do, and we're going to be coming back to the legislature to use some of the savings from the healthcare savings approach in order to pay for this system, which we intend to house in DF&A, to make Arkansas number one of 50 states for tracking fraud, waste, and abuse, not just in Arkansas Works, but in all of our programs, and using cross-checks and people's changes as red flags to be able to tackle this problem once and for all. The second to last thing I want to do is I want to introduce John, if you would please stand up in the gallery. I think he's got Sheila with him. She's the contracts expert on his team, and there may be other people up there as well. But, John, if you would wave to everybody, this is a person that the people of Arkansas have paid over a million dollars to to crunch numbers. So I don't want you to take my word for it. I would like you to get in touch with John. If you don't know how to do it, you can come through me, and I'm happy to put you in touch with John to walk through the numbers so that you can get an unbiased opinion on the numbers. And my final comment is this. If you think it's expensive to treat hangnails and rashes in the doctor's office, you have no idea what it costs in the emergency room, and that's what's going to break the
▶ Play
bank. Thank you very much. our representative collins is closed for his bill we have four pairs on the desk representative deanne bought votes yes representative michelle gray votes no this was witnessed by representative mickey gates representative vaut is the present member. Are there any procedural objections to this pair? Please do not vote either of these two voting machines. Representative Les Eves votes yes. Representative Trevor Drown votes no. This was witnessed by Representative John Eubanks. Representative Eves is the present member. Are there any procedural objections to this pair? Please do not vote either of these two voting machines. Representative James Ratliff votes yes. Representative Gary Deffenbaugh votes no. This was witnessed by Representative Lane Jean. Representative Ratliff is the present member. Are there any procedural objections to this pair? All right, please do not vote either of these two voting machines. All right, Representative Marshall Wright votes yes. Representative Bruce Cozart votes no. This is witnessed by Representative Greg Letting. Representative Cozart is the present member are there any procedural objections to this pair please do not vote either of these two voting machines the question now before the house is the passage of House bill 1001 prepare the machine mr. clerk Okay, members, we're going to hold off on that request for the clerk, the voting machine is giving us a little bit of fits, so we're going to stand in recess. timed out on us with Representative Ballinger's speech. So we're going to stand in recess till 11, we're going to try 11.15, see if that gives us enough time.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:04:31
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 71 1:14:31
All right, members, the House is called back into
▶ Play
order. If everyone could please take their seats. As we left off, Representative Collins had closed for House Bill 1001. We had four pairs on the desk. I'm going to remind the present members to not vote their machines. All right, at this time, prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. The question before the House that you're voting on is the passage of House Bill 1001. All right, you're voting on the bill and its emergency clause. Everyone voted. Let's cast up the ballots, Mr. Clerk. With 70 yeas and 30 nays, the bill and its emergency clause have passed. time I'm going to recognize Representative Stephen Meeks. Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker, after the announcements, reading of the bills, transferring of the bills, placing the calendars on the desk, members amending their own bills with their own amendments, members withdrawing their own bills, finalizing resolutions, reading communications, and any remaining committee reports, I move that we adjourn until 9 a.m. tomorrow
▶ Play
morning. There's a proper motion. It's non-debatable. All in favor, say aye opposed say nay all right motion passes representative Collins you're recognized announcement
▶ Play
we're going to have an insurance commerce meeting this afternoon at 2 o'clock in room 149 everyone hears that announcement okay
▶ Play
representative Charlene fight thank you
▶ Play
mr. speaker on behalf of representative McGill and myself from the aging children youth committee we We have brought a packet that will be in all of your mailboxes. This is for child abuse prevention awareness, which is the month of April. We have a blue ribbon for you, along with information about the child advocacy centers. And we hope that you will read this and proudly wear your blue ribbon. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you. All right, members, the desk will remain open for the reading of bills, and upon completion of the items named in the adjourned resolution, the House will be adjourned until 9 a.m. tomorrow morning.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:17:53
You
▶ Play

Agenda

MOTION TO AMEND

Call to Order

1:57 - 6:21 14 segments 5 speakers

HB1001 TO AMEND TITLE 23 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE TO PROVIDE HB1001 Col HEALTH INSURANCE TO QUALIFYING INDIVIDUALS; TO DPA 1CREATE THE ARKANSAS WORKS PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

6:21 - 7:21 4 segments 3 speakers

RESOLUTION HR1001

7:21 - 11:17 9 segments 3 speakers

End of Morning Hour

11:17 - 11:44 1 segment 1 speaker

REGULAR BILLS

TO AMEND TITLE 23 OF THE ARKANSAS CODE TO PROVIDE Collins HB1001

11:44 - 1:17:55 139 segments 10 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Jeremy Gillam Chair Unverified
34 segments
Speaker 6
3 segments
Speaker 10
1 segment
Speaker 11
1 segment
Speaker 24
3 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
60 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
5 segments
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
13 segments
Representative Donnie Copeland Unverified
10 segments
Representative Nate Bell Unverified
1 segment
Representative Karilyn Brown Unverified
5 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 71
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
2 segments
Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
1 segment