Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Agriculture, Forestry & Economic Development 5/19/16

May 19, 2016 ·Committee Room 138 ·22:12
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (1)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1008 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…air sees a quorum and the first item on our agenda today is House Bill 1008. Representative Beck, you are recognized to”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
and I might be remiss but I think this is Miss Brown's first AG committee meeting within her new position and we would like to welcome her as our staff person to this committee and look forward to working with her Okay, the chair sees a quorum and the first item on our agenda today is House Bill 1008. Representative Beck, you are recognized to
▶ Play
present your bill. Thank you. This bill basically is a way to look at it. It's a fix to a fix. In 2009, we did some changes as to how people were put on our levy district boards. And we left some gaps in there, and this will clear that up a little bit. But before I talk about that, I want to talk a little bit about the levy districts and the levy boards. The levy districts were set up many years ago, and each one has a levy board. And the board is a function to maintain that levy. Now, they have the ability to charge taxes to the individuals protected by the levy on that levy district to make sure that the levies are maintained. The problem is, initially, the levy districts and the levy boards were functioning very well. But as time went on, people were appointed to these boards. The boards became non-functionals. We have some levy districts and levy boards that are functioning very well to this day. Some are totally non-existent. The one thing to remember about this bill is, if your levy district is functioning as it should be, This bill does absolutely nothing. There's no change whatsoever associated with this bill as far as the functionality of that levy board. However, if that levy board is not functioning as it should be, and there's vacancies left on this, this bill will take away, I shouldn't say take away, It actually gives the county judge a procedure whereby they can make sure that that vacancy gets filled and the reports are being conducted as they should. Another interesting or another neat thing to this bill, I think, is actually that it actually helps to form a communication line between the Arkansas Natural Resources Commission and the levy districts. And this is really done by, as you look through the bill, you'll notice that it talks about the reporting that goes back and forth and how the county clerks or the clerks in the counties are going to make sure that each one gets this. What's going to happen is when we do that, you know, the people on the levy districts will be able to know who to talk to at the Arkansas Natural Resources Commission and vice versa. So that's the main purpose of this bill. Let me see if there are any other – I think that's about all I have. If someone has some questions. Representative
▶ Play
Speaker 13 3:33
Meeks, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Since I'm a co-sponsor,
▶ Play
I'll probably vote for this. Thank you. No, seriously. The only question I had is you'd mentioned the county judges. If the boards are not functioning properly, it gives the county judge an opportunity to get that board back up and going and get those vacancies filled. But my understanding is sometimes these levy districts will cross county lines. So if you've, and correct me if I'm wrong with that, but if you've got multiple county judges, do both those county judges can act on it or one, or is there
▶ Play
differentiation? That's a good question, actually. As I understand, what's going to happen is you're going to post in the local newspaper and the county website that there's a vacancy on that board. And then the landowners within that district have the right to come and vote for whoever they want. And then the majority of the people there, whoever they vote for, fills that vacancy. So it could be across county lines, actually. Okay. All right. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 13 4:39
you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Motion to the
▶ Play
proper time. Good. Thank you. Are all of the boards elected or appointed the same way?
▶ Play
Speaker 20 4:49
Right now or underneath this? Yeah. As it is
▶ Play
right now, there's probably – that's part of the confusion that's right now. It's exactly – if you look at the original configuration for the – I read – went back and read the way they were initially started, and then there's some changes that we made in 2009. Basically, the levy board can appoint – someone on the board can appoint someone else to be on that board. But there was a lot of confusion around this. What this does is it clears this up and it says, okay, if a levy – if there's a vacancy on that board, and it's not filled all right then the county judge is obligated to follow the procedure in this bill that basically says you post you post when the meeting is going to be the landowners can show up at that point and elect someone to that board so so with
▶ Play
this bill then a county judge does not have the authority to appoint someone to fill the vacancies on that
▶ Play
board No, it just, it's done by the majority of the people showing up at the meeting.
▶ Play
So how do you decide which county judge is going to do this if you have a multi-county district? I might
▶ Play
ask, I think that it would be the majority, you mean which county would it be in? Yes. I think it would be in both, it would be in both counties, but it would be posted for
▶ Play
a single meeting for the Levy District. Well, do not some of these districts encompass
▶ Play
Speaker 29 6:19
four or five different counties? I don't think
▶ Play
so. Do you not actually have three different kind of boards you're talking about here, drainage boards, levee boards, and irrigation boards? There are different, okay, and
▶ Play
I might need some help as far as explaining this. Now, there are different levees, and this pertains to the levees that are maintained, which would be part of the core and the navigation system. There are what they call family levies, and I forget what the other type of levy is. This is not to pertain to them, as I understand. Is that correct? Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Speaker 35 6:59
Mr. Chairman, members of the committee, Mark Whitmore with the Association of Arkansas Counties. First of all, I think, as this committee might want to know,
▶ Play
Speaker 36 7:07
there are different types of districts. They're formed in different manners, kind of like fire departments. They're different type of animals here. And like you've indicated, some of these districts are small family boards. Some of them are in the same county. Some of them have multiple counties. Some of them are elected actually by the people going in and voting. Some of them are appointed by a circuit judge. Some of them are appointed by a county judge. To answer Mr. Meek's question and Chairman Hillman, depending on where the vacancy occurs, the ones that have multiple counties typically have an allocation amongst the counties about who their representative is on those boards. So if the deficiency or vacancy was in Lawrence County, that's where the county clerk or the landowner would petition that we've got what we call continuing vacancy, that the board's been notified that there's a vacancy, they hadn't addressed it. And, in fact, this law, like the previous law in 2009, gave them an entire year to get rid of that defect. And if they don't, that's when, like Mr. Beck is saying, the landowners show up and by a majority vote they feel that deficiency or vacancy in that county's representation in that multi-county situation. But we're not changing that
▶ Play
part of it in this bill,
▶ Play
Speaker 36 8:29
right? No, no. All we're doing is creating the existing safety net in 2009 had a couple problems. One problem was it had the prosecutors involved, and that just added delay. And also it had a confusion that Mr. Beck is talking about is that you had to figure out what animal to go to. You didn't know whether to go to circuit court and file a formal petition and get a lawyer and go through the circuit court formal process, or could you simply go to county court. And what this does is eliminate those barriers. A, it eliminates the prosecutor, and B, it eliminates the confusion between circuit court and county court. And it simply puts it at the local level. And, of course, county judges, by law, are local courts, and they're a lot less informal than a circuit court. And also, by the way, like Mr. Beck said, it provided public notice in the newspaper. And so everybody in the county would know that there's a weakness on this board. and it would be right for the people to go ahead
▶ Play
and fill that vacancy. Okay. My last question, Representative Beck, is this going to fix the problem or are we going to have future legislation to kind of round out and see what else we might need to do? Well,
▶ Play
there may be additional legislation, but I think this will fix the problem that it's meant to address, which is to get these boards functioning. There might be something related to the boards and their authority at some point, but I think this will fix the problem of the boards being nonfunctional. Do you not think that
▶ Play
the problem is not having the boards functioning or not having the levies fixed? Well, I guess. I'm wondering if it would take additional legislation in order to see that the levies were indeed kept in repair and some sort of oversight by some state agency or the quorum court or something like that? I think there is some
▶ Play
oversight. I hesitate. The Corps does do an evaluation of these levies to tell you that. And they have reports. As a matter of fact, when I first started looking into this, the first thing I heard from the Corps, some representatives from the Corps, was this, is that they do reports, and they say, like, this area needs this repair, and they send out this report, and some of these levee districts do not even respond to these reports because it's a totally non-function. So in that aspect, I guess trying to get back to your question there is that I think if that continues on, you'll have a functioning board to address these
▶ Play
issues. So you're saying that the Corps of Engineers inspects each and every one of these levees, and gives them a report if there's a defect in the levy, even the family levies and the private levies and things like that? Not the family levies. Okay. Should there be someone that looks over those with knowledge of where they need to be repaired on a state level? As I understand it,
▶ Play
and you jump in here, but as I understand it, this only refers to the levy districts that were turned over from the Corps. Okay.
▶ Play
Speaker 36 11:49
All right. Let me, I guess, speak to your question, Mr. Hillman. This law, what it's trying to address is not the broader question of how are we going to get money to fix the levees. What it's trying to address is where there's a non-functioning board. And the landowners that live behind that levee, when they take their grandchildren to the church or school, they see that hump of dirt out there and they're assuming it's functioning. And it's not. We have some of these dormant levies. I know Mr. Beck had one in Conaway County. Senator Rayford had one in Perry County. And unbeknownst to the people behind that levy, that board wasn't functioning. And what this simply does is to try to get the boards up and running at the will of the people, or they could dissolve. But as far as getting money, I think in terms of your question, this will get the information that the county clerks have today. It's been filed since 2009, and all that information will be at the state level. And after that, what y'all might want to do in the next session is decide, are you going to tackle some money issues or not?
▶ Play
Speaker 37 12:53
I think the information is going to be helpful. Okay. You
▶ Play
finally got to where I was wanting someone to go. Any other questions from the committee? Yes, sir. Mr. Hendren. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This meeting does not be as important as some of the others. I couldn't even get into some of those a while ago. So what's the latest weather forecast for where these levees are? Are we expecting a lot of the flooding between now and January? I don't know. And the reason I ask that question, because this is obviously we're in an emergency special session here, and I'm just curious as to why on this call. But I guess I could answer that question.
▶ Play
Speaker 36 13:40
Who said that? This is Mark. Yeah, I'd like to hear that. Maybe it'll
▶ Play
apply to some of these other items on this list. Most of
▶ Play
Speaker 36 13:47
them in Arkansas, the way the rain falls, most of it comes in January and February. And so what will happen is we're going to try to fix this bill with this emergency clause, find out where there's non-functioning levies, get these boards up and running. Because if you're in the middle of a session and January and February comes, people like Senator Representative Beck, we're going to try to fix the problem before the rains come. So I don't know when the rains will fall, but that's when
▶ Play
they normally do. Are any of these levees down in southwest Arkansas where the Kansas City Southern Railroad runs? And the reason I ask that question, I've been talking to some of the Kansas City Southern officials up there because it goes through western Arkansas, as you know. And they tell me they've got about some bridges to wash out down there on their main line. And I thought, well, maybe this is how we're going to fix that before the bridges wash out and
▶ Play
Speaker 36 14:39
they shut down the coal trains. Well, this bill encompasses a lot of different types of levees, and where they're not functioning, we don't know. I mean, where the ones that are not functioning, they just, we don't know where they're located. I can't say that. I know there's levees statewide. South Arkansas and East Arkansas has a lot of water, but I don't know where the non-functioning ones are.
▶ Play
So we've got levees that we don't know where they're
▶ Play
Speaker 36 15:02
functioning or not, right? And this doesn't do anything to help that. This bill does help that. This bill will help identify those and get the county clerk and a landowner can file an affidavit and alert as to a vacancy, put it in the newspaper, alert the landowners of a vacancy, give them an entire year to get those appointments done, just like the previous law in 2009. And then this makes it real simple that if they don't fix it within a year, don't get another appointment done, that the landowners will have a hearing and they'll at that meeting go ahead and appoint a levy. And the prosecutors are not doing this now? They're
▶ Play
not as attentive as they should be. That's very well politically said. They're not
▶ Play
Speaker 36 15:45
doing their jobs now then, right? I just think it's more confusing for them because it had the dichotomy of whether or not you go to circuit court or county court. And so we think it's simpler. Lesson learned in 2009. Eliminating the prosecutors should make it easier. Eliminating the circuit court will make it easier. Eliminating
▶ Play
the prosecutors should make it easier. I've heard that before. One of the things that Representative Beck said on this thing was that it talks about taxes. They tax themselves. Do they tax themselves by a vote in this district, or do these commissioners decide the tax rate? And the reason I ask that question is because if I don't like your taxes, then I go to my county judge and get your rear thrown off that board and get me another one that doesn't like taxes. Do they vote for the taxes on the owners inside this
▶ Play
levy? As I understand it, the levy district, the levy board, has the right to levy taxes on the property protected by that levy. And that tax
▶ Play
is devoted on by that board? Yes. That's rather curious. Then I noticed another thing in this bill here. Now let's the county judge levy a fine from $100 to $1,000, up to $1,000. Is that right? Yes. Without any due process, he just says you are now fined $1,000, and it goes
▶ Play
Speaker 36 17:07
into the county clerk's fund. Senator Hendren, that existed under the old law under page 2, section D. It already had the fine. We had some questions about the parameters on the fine, and so Carrie Locke, in order to make it real explicit that the parameters on the fine are the same as they were in 2009. So you
▶ Play
took it out one section and put it back on page 4? No,
▶ Play
Speaker 36 17:28
we duplicated it from one section and regurgitated it on page four so that y'all could read it, you know, so it declines. That's a very
▶ Play
good word for what we're doing down here. Thanks. All
▶ Play
right, we've got a couple more people on the list, Representative Armstrong, and then we're going to move on.
▶ Play
Do you have a hard time filling your vacancies on this board because of the fine system and the way it's
▶ Play
Speaker 36 17:57
set up? first of all you won't get fined if you fill the vacancies and what this does just like the old nine bill it gave people an entire year to go ahead and eliminate the vacancy that they're supposed to it's the failure to file the reports the initial report and the subsequent reports that causes the fine and so they could avoid all this just by doing what the law already imposes on them and by filling the vacancy it's the failure to fill the vacancy and not file your reports that causes those so if anything the final promote the idea that they'll do what the lordy says and
▶ Play
fill the vacancies one more question the the the vacancies is created because people don't want to serve or or it's left up to
▶ Play
the person to do the appointment there are many reasons that the vacancies you know some people over the years have they're no longer landowners in district and some people have been appointed and and not really had the passion around it and everything what this does is is simply make sure that we got people on those boards that understand their responsibilities and
▶ Play
you know we'll take care of the levies thank you thank you mr chair
▶ Play
Speaker 67 19:13
Yes, sir. Judge McElroy, do you have a question you really have to ask? Please, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Beck, would you say that some of the non-participation comes from, I think, that it's kind of like your house, as long as the roof's not leaking, it's not raining, it's not a big deal. I live down in the Delta area where it's flat as a pool table, and we have the levee that protects us from the Mississippi River. In 1927, we still have family members that remember the flood coming up to the bottom of their windows and family members ground. Members, I would caution you, this is very, very important, and I think our levee system, like our road system, is in disrepair. and been ignored for years, and, you know, we really need to get behind this bill and try to help the people protect their property. And wouldn't you agree, Representative Beck? I agree with that, but I'd like to add one
▶ Play
thing. I think maybe the word of interest, everyone gets interested in the levees when the predictions of the river coming up get high. When the water gets over their boots. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Representative Beck.
▶ Play
McElroy. Representative Meeks, you are recognized for a motion. Move, do pass. Okay, motion been made, do pass. Anyone wish to speak for the motion or against, or anyone wish to speak against the motion? Anyone for the motion? Anyone in the audience want to speak for or against the motion? Seeing none, those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, no. Motion carried. and that concludes our meeting except for the chairman wants to squeak one word out
▶ Play
ladies guard your heart i'm doing my barrier of white impersonation here members uh i want to remind you that we do have the real development conference uh next week in rogers please register for that if you haven't uh i need a show of hands next wednesday night We have a dinner planned at Mr. B's Steakhouse in Rogers. I'd like to say, if you plan on attending, raise your hand to where I can get a count there. This is being sponsored by AT&T, and it's perfectly legal. Okay, all right. You're not paying for it yourself, members, so we have about five here. Okay, thank you all, and look forward to seeing you at 1 o'clock Thursday at the Ag meeting in Rogers. Thank you. We're damn sure better. Okay, meeting is adjourned. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1008 IDENTIFYING FOR AND BOARD FILLING SAFEGUARDS Beck TO EXISTING ENHANCE TO AND AN DECLARE DISTRICTS FOR VACANCIES IMPROVEMENT CERTAIN

0:48 - 22:05 87 segments 13 speakers

EMERGENCY.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative David Hillman Chair Unverified
19 segments
Representative Rick Beck Unverified
22 segments
Speaker 13
2 segments
Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 20
1 segment
Speaker 29
1 segment
Speaker 35
1 segment
Speaker 36
20 segments
Speaker 37
1 segment
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
12 segments
Representative Eddie L. Armstrong Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 67
1 segment
Representative Mark D. McElroy Unverified
3 segments