Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

House Meeting January 11, 2017

January 11, 2017 ·House ·1:52:07
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (4)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HR1001 · 4 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HR1001 GillamTO ADOPT THE RULES OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1026 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “committee on house rules to whom was refer to House Bill 1026 and House Bill 1058 may leave the report that we've had the…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1058 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…tee on house rules to whom was refer to House Bill 1026 and House Bill 1058 may leave the report that we've had the same under consider…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1066 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1066 THE GENERAL APPROPRIATION ACT FOR THE 2017-2018 FISCAL YEAR”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
Unknown speaker 0:00
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Members, at this time, the House will be called to order. I invite you to stand along with staff, press, and guests in the galleries to be led in prayer today by our House Chaplain Tim Knoll and then to remain standing for the Pledge of Allegiance just once today by Representative Greg Letting. good afternoon let's pray father we love you and god i thank you that um in a time of in a world as everything everything changes sometimes seemingly chaotic god that we can trust that that you are eternal you are self-existent you are never changing god whenever whenever we get we get to thinking about those things i thank you that that we can trust uh that that you never change you always love us you always look out for the best of us and And I think that at a time like this, it's so important for representatives to remember that and to know that as they're away from their families and all that, God, that they can turn to you, they can trust you, and know that you're never going to change. You're never going to leave us. You're never going to forsake us. And, God, for that, we are truly thankful. We are so indebted. God, we love you. I pray for the session today. I pray that there is unity. I pray that there is mutual respect as our representatives do the business of the state. God, we love you and we praise you. We ask it in Jesus' name. Amen. Amen. All right, members, you know what to do. Press your yellow present button to indicate your presence in the chamber. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. All right, let's cast out the ballot, Mr. Clerk. 98 present. Chair of Cesar Cuomo, are there any requests for leave?
▶ Play
Speaker 12 5:57
Representative Blake? Leave for, I'm sorry, leave for Representative Michael John Gray. Is leave
▶ Play
granted for Representative Michael John Gray? So noted. Representative Tucker? Request for leave for
▶ Play
Speaker 14 6:14
Representative Michelle Gray. Alright, is leave granted
▶ Play
for Representative Michelle Gray? all right so noted representative eaves okay i just thought you since you were standing okay all right representative lane jean moves at this time we dispense with the reading of the previous day's journal without objection so ordered are there reports from select committees please read the reports mr clerk mr speaker weird
▶ Play
Speaker 12 6:45
committee on house rules to whom was refer to House Bill 1026 and House Bill 1058 may leave the report that we've had the same under consideration here with the return of the same with the recommendation they do pass respectfully submitted. Andy Davis, Chair.
▶ Play
Are there any reports from standing committees? Any unfinished business? Any executive
▶ Play
communications? Mr. Clerk, read House Resolution 1001.
▶ Play
Speaker 12 7:38
House Resolution 1001 by Representative Gillum, to adopt the rules of the House of Representatives of the 91st General
▶ Play
Assembly. Mr. Gillum, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Members, I come before you, and before I get started, I want to say thank you to this body because the last couple of days as we've been discussing this resolution, I appreciate the spirit in which those discussions have taken place. They've been everything that I hope that we do with each topic as we move through. We've had discussions on this, and I really just want to start by saying thank you for the spirit of which we're going to take a look at this. And so before you, today I have House Resolution 1001, which is our House Rules. A lot of times, there's not much fanfare when we go through with that. This time, I decided to keep things interesting. We'd actually have some discussion on the House Rules. so there's two kind of main principle things that i think most of the discussion has centered around and i want to to talk a little bit today about those there are some other grammatical changes and semicolons and colons being changed and and you can see those and and pick out those yourself but i i want to discuss kind of why you have before you what you have and how we got to this point and why I'm presenting it to you. I believe strongly that we as a body should function based on the merits, the skill sets, and experiences and passions that each of you possess and bring into this body. I strongly feel like you are not a number that you randomly picked out of a bowl right here when you entered into this chamber i believe that this body should operate in fairness as it in conjunction with the senate and the rest of state government county municipal government and that is why i bring before you what you have today two years ago as i took the oath of office to be your speaker many many of you came to me with several suggestions on rules changes and i made a commitment to to each and every one of you that we would look into those things some bore fruit for us to continue to look at and to continue to examine others in talking with folks we realized uh there wasn't consensus and so we've taken different approaches and still could possibly come back to them but there were a couple things and that's what you have here today that stood out that continued repeatedly to be a focus of discussions we had one of which was our committee selection process and that seniority system and that randomness and how it affected your ability to represent your constituents and the outcomes for the state of Arkansas so begin to look at this at the end of last session and begin to research it begin to visit with folks not just within this chamber but from around the country i had some assumptions early on some apprehensions and was very surprised at what the data actually showed me as i looked and some things that i had said to members and good friends in this chamber very quickly and early on about oh, those aren't good ideas, I've come around on because the data and the evidence supports strong consideration for those ideas. So what you have before you is not a perfect plan on how we would do it because there is no perfect plan. But what this does is meet the most goals and objectives that we as a body have discussed that we want accomplished when it comes to the committee compositions and the outcomes legislatively for the state of Arkansas, the vetting process. And so I'm going to walk through some of these issues. I definitely know that I'll miss some key areas and will be open for questions. I'm not going to run from the well. I believe this is important for us to have this discussion. Now, I'll take a quick unanimous vote if you want to give me that, but i don't anticipate that coming so we're going to make sure that we have this discussion and that we do it right so with that being said when you look at what is written here on page five of house resolution one when you're looking at rule 11f i want you to understand something this may be a new topic of discussion here in arkansas but it's not new the data and the research bears out something striking and that is that almost every state in the country is doing what i'm proposing it's not reinvention of the wheel it's just bringing the wheel to arkansas there are 44 states and i want to apologize to the rules committee and those that were there yesterday i miscounted said 46 there are 44 states and texas is kind of a hybrid i know you're keeping notes charles keep that won't be the last time you do demerit for me texas is a hybrid so maybe that's 44 and a half so what i'm asking us to do is become the 45th state that does it in this manner so when i started looking at this and realized that that that many states were doing this i backed up from some of the apprehensions and assumptions that i had made going into this and started doing the research i have the the honor and the privilege on an annual basis serving you as the speaker of attending the speakers conference so i was able to sit with my colleagues from around the country and ask them about how they do their system the pros the cons what works what doesn't now as you know arkansas is one of only a dozen states or so that has term limits and so some of these men and women have years of experience doing their job so I called upon that experience and their wisdom and asked for their counsel and what I found consistently was the alignment of the skill sets and passions worked tremendously better in those states because of the system they had were the Speaker, who was elected by the entire body, who they've entrusted to lead the Chamber, that they have said with that vote, we trust your judgment, to work in collaboration with the members and leadership from the partisan caucuses to arrive at a list of names for each of those committees that would benefit their states. now for me coming in as a freshman and this is an example that uh that i've heard many times over with uh varying degrees of uh of the of the actual details of your experiences but coming in i had a skill set and experience that had just come off of two years advising the u.s secretary of agriculture couldn't get on agriculture we have folks in the health care profession that are considered by their peers to be tops in their field in the entire state that come in, we as a body and the state does not get their benefit of their service on those committees, their expertise, because of our current system. And so in talking with my colleagues from around the country and the members that are in this body, I feel like that the best appropriate approach for us moving forward is for the speaker to consider not only the political composition of our chamber but to focus on the geographic and demographic diversities of not only our house but the state of the skills the expertise and the preferences and seniority of individual appointees and when I say seniority I'm not talking about that number that you randomly picked from right here as much as i am talking about the years you've been in this chamber and so and the years you've been on this earth i think there's factors that need to be considered in there as well i feel like that they must and it's why it's in the language consult in good faith with the majority leader and the minority leader to discuss what is important to them the things that they know from talking to their members they may have different vantage points or gather different intel that i feel like would be vital to the process and so i've you have that on page five that language that clearly states that when you move throughout in some of the other language you'll see that one of the key focuses that also is in this is maintaining geographic diversity and discussions that i've had with the missouri speaker and several others on this one of the things that i came to really realize was that our system and the way that we have done it had one component that was right and that was making sure that all of the state had a voice on the committees that was one thing that they were envious of in some in some states because they didn't have that they had entire halves of states that had no representation on particular committees because of the dynamic that they had maybe with automatic proportional controls or other factors and so and they really said that was that was a key component of why those states had been successful and when you look at the list of folks that are in that bar from Alabama all the way to Wisconsin, and many, many in between. They're the states that we continually cite when you're at the well and you're presenting legislation trying to say we need to be more like them. So I asked the question. I said, well, how is it that you're ahead of us on these particular areas? And they said that in their opinion, this played a factor. They were able to align those skill sets and experiences on those committees for a better outcome. as i said earlier i believe you're more than just a random number and i believe the state is better off by us taking advantage of who you are and what you bring to this institution and aligning it but i think that we still must keep that geographic representation and that's why you find that language still in here that the speaker would still appoint from the five congressional districts making sure that out of the 20 members on a committee we have that balance throughout the state i think it is key to being able to have us move forward now one of the things that i think makes this appropriate for us to have this discussion at this time because i've had a lot of people that said why are we doing this why did i start looking at this back when i did beyond just the input that i had for members and the requests but i think because of the error that we're moving into and the modification of term limits i think it's appropriate for us to take some time to look at our systems and how we're doing things because for the incoming class right now under our current system you can have your numbers for a long time and i think your districts and i think you get punished for that and so i feel like that now is an appropriate time to have this discussion if for no other reason that reason but i think that there are also others i feel like that you deserve the right to be evaluated and to have your districts have that ability to have you on committees not just because you came in and and picked a number but i think because you being able to make the case of what you bring to the table i think is extremely important and i think it's why now is an appropriate time for us to make these changes as i mentioned i think that geographic alignment is important i think your skill sets are important i think that we should move beyond the games that have become our current system and that's what they've become let's be honest uh with each other here you know in no way these last several years have we actually been allowing this process to work like it was probably intended to years ago. I think for where we're at now and moving forward, I think a realignment of how we're doing this is appropriate, and I think that it will be a key to our success as we move forward representing this state. I think that with some of those other options and systems that were out there and i've had discussions with several members uh to discuss the proportional dynamics and and putting in locked in numbers that would say well you have to have a certain number of people in this committee and and it sounds great in theory but what when i talked to the states that had that and there are five of them colorado hawaii illinois massachusetts and missouri they all generally said about the same thing and they said that functionally what that does is limit the potential of the body we need to move beyond just trying to fill quotas on those committees but to actually match those those skills those experiences and they cited several examples and things that have occurred here uh where i mentioned earlier people not being able to get on committees that had those skill sets they've had the same thing happen in reverse because they were locked into specific numbers and so they'd say sorry but there's no room for you on this committee even though they would have been tremendous value and the state's going to fluctuate it's going to be nimble i believe that giving the body that flexibility for those numbers to adjust as the makeup of experiences and skills adjust within the chamber is going to be key and vital so that's why that you see the language that you see before you in this regard i've had a lot of folks that have mentioned caution and apprehension about the speaker being able to do this i understand that i was there a couple years ago i can tell you this having done this job what i'm offering for my successors is not power it's an administrative function and to be honest with them and this may change their mind but it's a headache this meeting and going through this is not something that will be easy But I think that's why doing it in collaboration with the other individuals is going to be important, and I think will yield the outcomes that will make this state proud. From a functional standpoint, having studied this institution for the last five years and having the benefit of having Tim Massanelli and Bill Stovall, Buddy Johnson, and several others that have been around this chamber for a long time, I've come to understand certain things about this body historically. and that's the inherent checks and balances that exist and studying who has won those speakers races all those years ago and walking with Mr. Massinelli through the hallway learning the history I've come to understand something this body when presented with candidates for the speaker does a pretty good job of vetting out who's going to be fair who's going to be mindful and who is going to protect the body and the members of the institution now some of the fairness issues are subjective there's always going to be members that are going to think well i didn't quite get what i wanted to get and that's going to happen and this system won't make everybody happy it won't get everybody on the committees they want if 40 people want to be on insurance and commerce there's only 20 slots i mean 20 people are going to be disappointed there's nothing you can do about that so i'm not offering you perfection here today what i'm offering you is an improvement upon what we have. So with that in mind, I want to move to the other section that would be a change. What I'm going to propose we do is align ourselves with everyone else in this building in the state, and I'm going, and you see in this proposal here to lift the self-imposed restriction that we had amongst ourselves on fundraising during the fiscal session. We're not taking up policy bills. No one else has this. It was something that was done whenever the fiscal sessions were put in place, and I think that at the time it had good intentions, but I think from a functional standpoint, I think we're at a point to where the appropriate move for us would be to remove this at this time now and yesterday in the in the rules committee i spoke to the point that um that there are nobody else has this i mean and i talked about county government city government and how you know they're able to take checks in same day they're having city council meetings the same day they're having quorum court meetings and no one says anything about that i've traveled around the state i've had the privilege of speaking in engagements and visiting with folks for various meetings around the state the last two years i broached this subject on numerous times not every time but but the vast majority of them i've had this discussion the state understands this they've responded very favorably when when visiting with them about this they understand the functionality of this and so i feel like that it is appropriate to include this in at this time one final item that i wanted to briefly mention also and it has something to do with the committees is I want to align the language with legislative council with their requirements, limiting the number of members that can be on council to one county to that which is with audit, which limits it to two counties. That is something that I think functionally as we move forward with the way that our state is growing and changing, I think that this body needs that flexibility as well. so council would now have the ability to have two people from a county instead of one which I think will benefit us and it's something that I've had several members over the last really four years that have brought up on numerous occasions and mentioned to me so members friends as I've stated numerous times in my proposal here and presentation, I don't bring to you a perfect system that is infallible, but I bring to you something that has been researched, that has been studied, and something that I feel confident will be a benefit to this body. I would not bring this before you now if i didn't have supreme confidence in your ability and your successor's abilities to continue to pick men and women that are honorable that are fair and that will put this institution first and foremost in the speaker's position i believe that i believe in you and i believe in this institution and those that will follow all of us this will not affect me i have stated very publicly that this will be my last term in the House of Representatives. But one of the things that has motivated me to run for speaker the first time and to come back for a second time was to do the things necessary to create an environment of success not only for the members but to better the institution. I have fallen in love with this place and I would not be coming before you today if I had not vetted this, looked at it, and visited with several, several members, not only of this body, but from around this great nation of ours, and looking at the different possibilities and contingencies and things that could happen. And so I present this to you now, and Mr. Chair, I will
▶ Play
stay here if there are any questions. Representative Murdoch, for what purpose? Question. you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question thank you mr. speaker thank you for first of all having the courage to come and stand before us and take these questions that you know will be probably numerous as well as challenging the the question one of your points that you talk about that you talk about the speaker having the ability to look at us make determinations from our resumes or what he or she will think are our strengths or weaknesses. Now, let's just say that the speaker doesn't need to do that or the speaker at that time can do that. This is a representative form of government that we serve in. Though the speaker serves about 30,000 constituents, as the rest of us, we're all the same when we get here in terms of serving this state. My constituency may have sent me here for a purpose different than what you see in me. And when I represent them, what's important that I do is represent the people that I serve. What's not important is that you, or whoever the speaker would be, would be in the position of telling me where to serve or how to best serve the people I represent that elected me. So, though the intent may be good, the purpose of how we do what we do is so that people that represent various parts of the state have an opportunity to represent their state, their part of the state, their district, in a manner that they were sent there to do. which may not even be if you will the speakers business the speaker represents a district himself or herself so if you will there are several things and I'm sure others will get to them but that's a very important piece to staying with me is that I'm sitting here from a district they want me to represent their concerns and I even put their concerns in front of mine so you can't or the speaker can't know all of the hundred members and what they must do. He must be concerned with his business and that speaker doing the business of the speaker. So again, that's a major concern. That's why I can't support it. It's because of that reason, because we're sent here to represent our districts and it's not the speaker's job to tell us where to go and how to best do that. Thank you. I'm
▶ Play
not sure if there was really a question there.
▶ Play
It was a speech. Don't you agree with what
▶ Play
I said? Representative Murdoch, and you and I visited about this earlier, and like I mentioned just now, here's the crux of where we find ourselves. And I think to a large part of your point, I think you are where I was at mentally and where I'm at on this. The people sent you here to represent them. Our current system, in many, many instances, not all, but in many, prevents many members from being able to do that because of just the random draw of their seniority. They're not able to get on committees that could represent or benefit their committees or what they campaigned on or something that matters in their districts because of a random system. I used this example yesterday, and David and Meeks and I were talking about this, but Stephen was sick our first year we drew. And so David drew for him, and then he drew right after him. Stephen got the best position out of our entire class. David drew next, and he's 25 down below. Okay? Literally, their course of action was decided by a draw. That's it. I contend that that in no way meets the principles in which you just described for representative government in the fact of how that went down. There was literally no chance for them to make a case to anybody at all, period, to have a discussion. to to visit with them bring in their resume or because i use that term just because i've gotten like 20 this uh this cycle a lot of these things happen right now and it's something that a lot of people don't get to see because uh of just the dynamics and everybody's gone a lot during the interim but members continually come and approach the speaker and that's it's been this way long before me and will be this way long after me and bring in and sit and discuss and say look these are my passions this is what i've done in previous lives how can i best serve can you help me and we move and we go there's times where we engineer eight-way trades if we have to get somebody on a committee uh we we do our best to make sure uh that we help them and so it's the thing that i want everybody to understand is whoever is in this position and it's this way before and it'll be this way after and it's been this way with me it's not one human being doing this there's always a team you might not always see the team sometimes you might not like the team but there's always a team of people around no speaker has ever done this job by themselves they have always been successful because of the people that interacted and worked with them and so this will not be one person sitting in some office that says well i'm going to decide this person's future and that this is a collaborative effort it has to be in order for this this body to function and operate and as i've discussed this around the country i have continually found that to be the example there is no way that you have that many states in this nation doing this repeatedly year cycle after cycle year after year if this system was broken and horrible it wouldn't Which is why I re-approached my thought process and came back to this and researched it and looked into it, because the simple numbers do not lie. Representative Meeks, Stephen
▶ Play
Meeks, for what purpose? Question, please. You're recognized for a question and one follow-up. Thank you, sir. I appreciate that, because I did have two questions. My first question is sort of the practicality. practicality would the speaker designate be the one that would develop this because during our body we've had several situations where we had a speech speaker designate who then did not eventually become the speaker so will we be looking at you know we make our selections currently right after the election will we not know our committees until the new speaker is sworn in and then my second my follow-up question would be you know the second district We've got like the Pulaski County rule, and I assume all those would be gone under this new
▶ Play
system. Both excellent questions. To the second one, first, the Pulaski County rule would be removed in this situation. I think that the collaborative nature of the selection process at this point would necessitate its removal. To the first, yes, the designate would be the one working in conjunction with the majority and minority leaders and the members and visiting with everybody so the selections would be made after they become the speaker that's why the language is the way it is so the first day of session would be when all of these things would be announced and i and i looked at this to make sure that it wouldn't impact the flow of things and because we have the ability to introduce bills into committees that we're not a part of it doesn't have a immediate practical uh you know issue that would come about from that okay so it would be finalized first day of
▶ Play
session under the new speaker and one
▶ Play
thing that's also key and i failed to mention this earlier and i apologize members was that these are not at will decisions these are firm they're set you make these appointments they're in there this isn't something that if some somebody does something that speaker doesn't like they get to remove them or anything like that these are firms set in positions that do not move the logistics behind it first of all would be too chaotic in the middle of a session to try to start moving people around it's not fair but it's also i just i don't think it's the right
▶ Play
move either so these would be firm solid decisions representative blake for what purpose question
▶ Play
Speaker 12 37:45
you recognize for a question mr speaker do you agree that uh allowing the speaker to assign all members to their A and B would give the speaker more power?
▶ Play
I don't. I think, and I understand the initial thought of that had that. So when I called around, I talked to Robin Voss in Wisconsin, Beth Harwell in Tennessee, Strauss in Texas, started calling around saying, okay look how how is this work in your districts the one thing that was almost unanimous across the board was this was an administrative function okay but the the influence of the speaker is in the ability to continue to get the members to work with them to collaborate with them and so if the speaker doesn't have this is something that uh that uh bill stovall was fond of saying is that if you don't have 51 votes you don't have anything and so as the speaker working with the members and helping them to be successful is the way that i view this i don't view this as some sort of power trip or because i have faith that the men and the women who are going to follow behind me in this position are going to view this for what it is which is an opportunity to assist this body and the members to align ourselves better and to help the members be successful in representing their district. And that's the way
▶ Play
Speaker 12 39:25
that I view this. Follow-up. I appreciate your answer on how you do this, but in my opinion, compared to how the rules are now, allowing members to choose which selection, which A and B selection committee they want to be on, and going into a new system where the speaker automatically decides where that person goes is the definition of getting more power from where you were before. And my follow-up question is, why does this speaker or any other speaker need more power? They don't need
▶ Play
more power because it's not more power. it's an administrative function it's more work as i stated earlier uh this isn't more power because you have to make this body work you have to be able to have the committee's function and i'll use a case in point representative blake i don't think this state is better off by representative george mcgill not being on aging children and youth and that's because the system we've got right now i think having a man of his stature and wisdom and his skill set having chaired that committee uh and and gone through those meetings and everything i think we're at a detriment because he's not on there and that's what i bring before you now as a chance an opportunity to move forward i can't predict that there will never be a bad actor in that chair just like your districts can't predict there won't be a bad actor in your chair but that doesn't have they don't give up on the faith and send people down to this chamber to do good for this state. I'll be honest with you folks. I flat out reject the notion that there's not going to be any other good, solid, decent human beings come behind me. I think there will continue to be. As long as you focus and demand excellence out of the Speaker and those candidates, you will get
▶ Play
it. Representative Hammer, for what purpose? Question, please. You're
▶ Play
Speaker 66 41:29
recognized for a question. Thank you. To my recollection, there's never been anybody that's been voted into office in November, turn around and come in in January and be elected as Speaker of the House because of the probability and that would severely. So as I look at it, someone who earns the right to be the Speaker of the House has had at least two years to prove themselves before the body that is going to elect them the next term around to be the Speaker-designate. So a whole lot of what you're talking about today is built on the trust and at least a two-year buffer in order for people to know if that person is somebody they want to put this kind of trust and power in. is that a proper interpretation
▶ Play
or proper view it is and that's that's a key point that i i have not addressed until now you've entrusted me at this time in our state's history but the body has always entrusted the speakers with certain things you've trusted their judgment on bill assignments you've trusted their judgment on a whole host of other things okay so i see this as a continuation of that trust that you place in them i don't think they win unless they've exhibited those factors i hope that it was something that you looked at when you cast your votes for me that you thought i was worthy of that trust that i cared about this institution and as i said earlier i reject the notion that the people that will come behind me are anything but good and decent people. There are great people in this chamber, and I believe in them, and I believe in your ability to select those individuals. I'm putting my faith in you. One follow-up, Mr. Speaker.
▶ Play
Speaker 66 43:22
Yes, sir. Other Mr. Speaker. One follow-up, please. Sorry, forced to have it. Go ahead. Thank you. Sometimes there's that perception, which I don't always agree, that one committee has more power than the other when it comes to the A's and to the B's. So I guess what I'd like you to explain in your discussion with other speakers around the country, how does this not, or how does it help from creating the perception that some committees are minimized against other committees, and what value would the change of the rule help to do to eliminate that perception? Thank you.
▶ Play
That's a good question, Representative Hammer. That varied around as far as their perceptions. The structures of some of these states are different than what we've got now as far as the A's and the B's and things like that. So what I found on a pretty consistent basis was a lot of those perceptions were going to be subjective. And certain members, lobbyists, citizens were always going to view things differently. There wasn't a consistent pattern that could be addressed or dealt with. And so the way I view it here, I mean, there are some people who think that city, county, and local affairs is the most important committee. You won't ever change their mind. There are others that think that public health is. And so there's not really any way to get around that per se. What it is, the one thing that they did mention, though, was making sure that the members had a full grasp of the committees, the structure of those committees, and which ones did what function when you were visiting with them to align them with both their wishes, their passions, and those skill sets.
▶ Play
Representative Walker, you were standing earlier.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. For what purpose? For now, questions. You
▶ Play
recognize for a question? Yes, sir.
▶ Play
I'd like to preface my question by commenting, Mr. Speaker, that I haven't had the benefit of these private meetings as a legislator with you and the members of this secret committee at any time since you've been speaker. Nobody's ever come to me and some other people that I know to let me know what you're even thinking. But my questions are these. When you talk in terms of trying to put people on committees in accordance with their skill sets, I take it that you have some predetermined skill set criteria that have been predetermined so that we'll all know what your skill set criteria are. and that there's some way of uniformly applying them because you may have a situation where 20 people want to be on aging and you're going to have to make some selection. And the question is, what criteria do you apply in order to be fair? Good question. That's the first question. Okay, we're going to take them one at a time. But part of that question is this. We don't have, when we run for office, the skill set criteria, nor do we have a criterion that people be college graduates. So when we start talking about skill sets, we're talking about something that is a subjective judgment, and it is impossible, and I suggest to you, like it was impossible in one of the cases that I had where a superintendent said in defending his choice of a person that he could look at a person and tell how intelligent he was. I'd like to know how you determine among people you don't know and the people who are on your private committee, how are they going to know who have, who meet those criteria best?
▶ Play
Fair question. Let me answer it by this. And let's start by saying, first and foremost, one of the reasons that this is a good benefit, most of us don't have to know, we don't have to have visits with you to know what you're thinking. and you do a pretty good job of letting us all know that individually anyway. But on this particular issue here. I thought we should talk to Nick. This particular issue here, though, when I talk about skill sets, everybody knows in this body that you're an attorney. And so I've had the privilege of serving with you and see you in action, and I know you are a very accomplished and bright attorney. And so when I refer to that and the experiences, It's what you bring into this chamber. And then visiting with people. And look, like I said, I've not even done this perfect. I've not followed this system because I wasn't picking the committees. I wasn't talking to everybody about who wants to be on education and who wants to be on judiciary and those committees because it wasn't our system. So part of the reason I didn't ask you what committee you wanted to be on, well, actually, this time you did come to my office and I did ask that question. I almost forgot you came and sat in with Mr. Ragland and I, We discussed back in the fall where you wanted to be at. I got notes from the meeting in my office because you actually told me you would go anywhere you wanted to go because you didn't figure it mattered because there wasn't going to be enough Democrats in the chamber to do anything anyway. I put the quote down and wrote it. That's not
▶ Play
an indication that I'm making a committed selection, though. No. I asked where you wanted to go. I'm sorry, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. Representative Walker, you can have one follow-up. But what I'm talking about is the opportunity that my successors would be able to visit with the individual members. Under this system, they would visit with the individual members, find out what their passions were, find out where they wanted to serve, and then discuss with them their life experiences, discuss with them where they've worked, where they've gone to school, things of that nature, trying to work with them to get them where they wanted to go, and then in visiting with the minority leader, the majority leader, finding out, you know, the overall fits and composites. And, sir, it's not going to be a perfect system. I realize that. But I'm not talking about some arbitrary judgment where the speaker would just look at an individual and say, oh, well, they need to go here. I'm talking about a detailed process of visits and conversations that I think will get us a better outcome than just a random number drawn out of a bowl. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. Sir, you've already had
▶ Play
your follow-up. Representative De La Rosa, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for a
▶ Play
Speaker 62 50:01
question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, first of all, I'd like to say that I appreciate that you're doing this now where we're not discussing you personally but rather future speakers because that would put us in a very awkward position. I've got kind of a two-part question, and I don't have as much trust in us, I think, as you do. I believe in balance of power. So my questions have to do with that. First of all, why do you think that this system will work better than what we do now? Because what we do now is we do the seniority by caucus, and then we trade. So you really have to kind of push and fight for whatever it is that you really have a passion for and convince someone else that that you want that and why you want it so we're sort of doing that right now already amongst ourselves and i know not everybody gets what they want but nobody's not everybody's gonna get what they want in your system so why would this work better than what we do now and as the second part so i don't have to ask for follow-up um let's say we did get a speaker that was not wonderful what would stop a speaker from creating his own personal a or b a and b committees that he could route anything he wanted through by loading it with his buddies well and let me
▶ Play
answer the second part of your question first i would pause it to you that from the functionality of the chamber and i think i referenced this earlier, that the way that this place runs, you have to be able to have the support of the body. If a speaker did go rogue like that and decide to load up, say, 20 people in education and try to route everything through education, there are constraints within our statutes in the constitution about routing things i mean you can't just go crazy on how things go you can't send a pro-life bill to transportation you don't the body has mechanisms to pull back in line this is not a dictatorship where they have free reign and so that's why i i've rejected the premise that this is more power is because there are constraints as to how this job is done and the body has that opportunity every day to exhibit those constraints challenge the the speaker uh and and and take the case if something's been done inappropriately and that will still function that will still go and i wish i wish you had my confidence in the institution and i do realize that because i've had the time uh to to study this institution uh to to see how it's run that i i'm at a greater comfort level than others and i appreciate that that's part of the reason why i wanted to make sure we had a robust discussion here today to do hopefully i would allay those fears we'll see in a minute if i've done that so i feel like that there are checks and balances within the inherent structure that we have i feel like that the members will continue to select as they've done in the past the men and women that need to be in this position and we'll be able to move
▶ Play
Speaker 66 53:27
this state forward. Representative Hendren, for what purpose? An inquiry and then perhaps a question. What's your inquiry? I have three amendments on the desk to this particular resolution and I've discussed this with leadership two years ago and I've discussed it with this year and I was told by the leadership that there would be an opportunity to have a vote on those amendments to this amendment, this resolution. And in fact, I was as told as late today that the parliamentarian had indicated that these, if they were filed, they would be considered and voted on before we vote the resolution or something to that effect. But certainly I know that I was told and committed by you, Mr. Speaker, and by leadership that there would be an opportunity to vote up or down these amendments that I have prepared for this document. And they're House Resolution Amendments 5, 6, and 7. I have copies here at my desk. Representative Henry,
▶ Play
you have not filed any amendments to this resolution.
▶ Play
Speaker 66 54:28
I just filed them this morning, Mr. Speaker. And I have a copy of them right here
▶ Play
on my desk. They are stand-alone resolutions to amend the rules.
▶ Play
Speaker 66 54:40
They are amendments to this resolution. House Resolution Amendment 5, 6, and 7. And I have them here on my desk. But I guess, I hope you can find them because they're back there and I've got copies of them. But I hope at least we can be congenial enough of 55 that we'll consider these anyway.
▶ Play
Are you saying they've been filed with the bill clerk?
▶ Play
Speaker 66 55:08
Absolutely, right back there. In fact, I have copies of them. In fact, if you'd like, I'll read them to you here. House Resolution 1006, a resolution to amend the rules of the House.
▶ Play
Hang on, sir. You asked me for it. Mr. Hendren, these would be stand-alone resolutions that, as any other resolution, would need to go through the Rules Committee to be considered by the Rules Committee as amendments to the House rules. these are not amendments in the sense that they try to amend hr 1001 uh on on the spot today and a further inquiry
▶ Play
Speaker 66 55:51
mr speaker we've been we've heard here a couple of times today and i believe this since 1979 on the other end that 51 members in this body or 30 18 members in the other end as the speaker just said can do what they please and I'm asking these were filed in good faith with what I had been told by staff that work for the legislature here and I just ask and if nothing else I'd ask the body at least let us hear them so I guess my question is can I make a motion that we allow
▶ Play
these amendments to be heard you could Mr. Hendren but that motion would require are two-thirds majority of the House because they have not even been read. They haven't been introduced in the House of Representatives. They've been filed. They haven't been read and assigned to committee. Based
▶ Play
Speaker 66 56:47
on what rule are you saying two-thirds vote? You
▶ Play
filed them today. They have not been read across the desk. My question, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 66 56:53
Parliamentarian, though, based on what rule are you just saying it takes two-thirds of a vote? Is that not a rule adopted by this body? it's
▶ Play
in the current rules of the house that are the temporary rules while we consider these as the permanent rules
▶ Play
Speaker 66 57:09
as the speaker just indicated this body can change any rule that pleases if it's not does not violate the constitution with 51 votes is that correct no sir it's not representative henry do you have a question i do yes i'd like the speaker i'd like for you to clarify that you're just telling me that the Arkansas Senate and the Arkansas House of Representatives cannot change their rules with a majority vote if it does not violate the Arkansas Constitution. Is that what you've just
▶ Play
said? Sir, you just heard the explanation from the parliamentarian. Do you have a question for the— I guess the answer then
▶ Play
Speaker 66 57:48
is yes, right? That we cannot do that.
▶ Play
Is that what you just said? He explained the rules to you, sir. Representative Vaught, for what purpose?
▶ Play
Speaker 88 58:09
Question. You're recognized for a question. Mr. Speaker, I've heard several times about empowering a speaker. So how have other states responded to the concerns about empowering or burdening the speaker with this responsibility?
▶ Play
Excellent question. These rules have been in place around the country and the other states for many, many, many years. And they view them as administrative. The members of that body views them as administrative. And talking with some of those members at some conferences, even just last month, I asked some members in Nevada. I said, how do you react to this? And they said, it's just a functional administrative thing. We visit, we talk, and they do their best to get us where we wanted to go, where our caucuses are wanting us to go it's a collaborative effort i have not encountered hostility in these other states or fear of this and the large part is because they've been doing it i mean this is a part of their system it's what they know which is why i understand the caution that we have here today to make a change
▶ Play
from what we've got representative servilo for what purpose a question you recognize for a question
▶ Play
Speaker 66 59:35
mr thank you mr speaker mr speaker have you met with all 99 people in this body to see what they are qualified for uh on the special select committees no on the
▶ Play
special select committees we solicited information uh and requested it from the members now i was able to meet at various times but it wasn't in a straight two-week block but over the course of the spring the summer and the fall i was able to have conversations with i think most all of the returning members now the new members coming in uh was not able to individually have a meeting with each and every one I tried my best we did solicit that information through two or three different sources one of which was email the other was through just conversation with members we did try to go and visit as much as we could during the orientation process with as many people as we could I'm not saying that we got them all and that we got it all right but there was an effort was made and I will say this a lot of folks did not respond back to the email request from Miss Kay I had several that did not and so we tried phone calls we tried to do some things to catch up and fill
▶ Play
in fill in the blanks representative Brown for what
▶ Play
Speaker 88 1:01:07
purpose you're recognized for a question thank you mr. speaker first of all I want to commend you for your efforts to do something that's more equitable and fair and reflects the talents of the body here I really thought that our believe that our current selection process is very it just doesn't align people with their skills to a committee and one thing that most i hear a lot of people questioning you about is how do you know what's on our resume how do you know what we're really good at the one thing that i want to clarify this is my only question that those of us who may consider ourselves generalists you would take into consideration what we really want to do is that not correct absolutely thank
▶ Play
you representative gates for what purpose You're recognized for
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:02:07
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Chair, I appreciate having spoken in opposition to you and you inviting me into your office. I appreciate that opportunity and the demeanor which you didn't berate me or take it personal that we were in opposition on this issue and the fact that you're not even talking about yourself but successors, and I think most of us would all agree. My question is, how would this not come into play if you have a member that is wanting to jockey for the position of speaker to not turn around and use those promised committee assignments for support for a speaker?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:02:50
Okay, I mean, you have that dynamic that exists now when it comes to the chairs and the vice chairs, and believe me, having gone through this twice, I can tell you they come at you hard and fast. you know the first time especially uh in a full-way race there were a lot of offers made to me uh you know we'll deliver this block of vote if you promise us x number of chairmanships and those kind of things i rejected that philosophy uh and because i tell you one thing about that that the speaker's race and and how this works everybody finds out pretty dadgum fast who's talk to who and what was said uh and so i think just for that same same notion of the fact that it doesn't really play out and work uh if you go to start promising chairs and all that stuff i think the same thing happens here i mean you've still got a job to do you've got to put 20 people on these committees and you you need to do it fair or balanced across the spectrum of the state of arkansas you need to do it fair and balanced among the membership and i think you're going to see that bear out i truly believe it or i would not be standing in front of you answering all of these questions i
▶ Play
think that's all thank you representative balts for what purpose motion i can't take a motion as long as
▶ Play
Speaker 95 1:04:21
the speaker is in the well representative de
▶ Play
la rosa for what purpose question what is your question um it's a
▶ Play
Speaker 62 1:04:34
procedural question based on what representative pendrin was speaking about earlier in the future it's a multi-part question because i'm trying to get to the end of it the way that this works if this body wants to change rules it has to be proposed in a resolution it has to be read across the desk it has to go to the rules committee it has to pass the rules committee and it has to come back to this chamber to be voted on with a simple majority is that correct that's correct okay so my question is in the future if this body adopts these rules and we decided the speaker does have too much power and we want to undo that the only way that we could undo that to change it would be to file a resolution to change the rules which would go through the rules committee which is an appointed committee by the speaker so it would be speaker appointed people reviewing this before it could come back to the full body
▶ Play
Speaker 97 1:05:34
is that correct that the procedure for how this
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:39
would work with the two-thirds vote the body could pull the bill out of committee and vote on it but we
▶ Play
Speaker 62 1:05:47
okay so it would take two-thirds of us if we wanted to pull his bill out of committee right now that's how it works right now and that's how it would work in the future
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:05:55
the bill would need to be in committee first before it could be pulled out
▶ Play
Speaker 62 1:05:59
i'm just running into difficulty i'm thinking in the future if we ever want to undo it how would we undo something i think we need to consider that that that was my question i don't even know that you could answer that but that that was a question for the parliamentarian yes thank you representative
▶ Play
Speaker 93 1:06:16
whitaker for what purpose parliamentary inquiry what is
▶ Play
your inquiry thank you mr speaker mr Mr. Parliamentarian, just for clarification, my understanding is that because House Resolution 1001 is up for vote, that in order to, if, for the sake of argument, the Speaker has done a wonderful job and convinced me to vote yes on one of these provisions, but I'm still not wanting to vote yes on the other provision, I have to vote no, because I don't want the second thing to happen. Is that true? It's all or nothing here on this vote. Because no one's spoken to the campaign contribution question. I'm just curious. We get two for one on this, right? The question
▶ Play
Speaker 64 1:07:08
before the House right now is passage of House
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:11
Resolution 1001 in its entirety. Exactly, and that's what I wanted to clarify. Thank you. It's not divisible.
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:07:24
Representative Lowry, for what purpose? Question? You recognize her? Question of the parliamentarian, actually. Procedural question. You recognize her question? And I ask this question not even knowing the content of Representative Hendren's amendments or the merits thereof. My question would be, if we were wanting to take them up and either vote them up or vote them down, could we do so by moving into a committee of the whole to discuss this resolution and then be able to entertain the amendments?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:07:58
the proper way to consider amendments to house resolution 1001 would first for would be first for the amendments to be introduced to the resolution that has not been done there there's there are no resolution i mean amendments to consider to this particular resolution yes mr hendron did file resolutions to amend the house rules in particular ways he they were filed today but they have not been even read across the desk nor
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:08:37
signed to committee follow up then could the mechanism be to move into a committee of the whole and then allow introduction of
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:08:47
those amendments to this resolution the proper approach to considering resolutions to this amendment would be to first place the resolution back on second reading for the purpose of amendment. And then if that motion passed, then the amendments could be considered and adopted one at a time to change the resolution in any manner the body chooses. All right, thank you very much.
▶ Play
Speaker 88 1:09:21
Representative Rushing, for what purpose? Question. You're recognized for a question. Thank you. Mr. Speaker, I say this with all due respect to any future speaker in the House and to all the lobbyists in the House, but as we know, a speaker, usually a year or so before they run for speaker, create a speaker pack, and lobbyists continue to feed the speaker pack with donations, which is legal and acceptable. But how do we ensure that a lobbyist doesn't make some kind of influential decision to donate to one person running to speaker because they think that they can stack a committee now that that speaker is going to be in charge of making all those appointments? Fair question.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:10:06
I would say the checks and balances that exist there, not only the transparency that we have through campaign finance reports, uh that everybody tracks who gets what but i also see this from experience most all of the folks in in the lobbying community they pretty much give to everybody running they're hedging their bets to sit because they don't know where the body's going to break and who's going to go so they don't they don't ever pick a horse they stay out of it because they know how this is going to work and that they could be on the losing side of that so much like they do in a lot of our campaigns they'll contribute to both candidates uh and they'll do that they do that here as well and so i don't foresee any significant change in the way that that dynamic is created they're going they lobby now uh for you know oh we really love this person to be chair that person to be chair uh you know and and that they make those requests now it doesn't mean that anybody heeds them or takes them or does anything the same would be there on the committee assignments as well
▶ Play
Representative Hammer, for what purpose? Question of the parliamentarian, please. You're recognized for a question. I'd
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:11:22
like to leave. I want to make sure that I'm thinking processes correctly. We vote on House Resolution 1001 and say it passes out of here. Representative Hendren's amendments are going to be read across the desk, sent to rules, and they'll either be voted out of rules or they'll die in rules, one or the other. If they should happen to pass, that will overlay whatever we vote out of here today. So there's a procedure that if we don't like what 1001 reads as now, depending on what Representative Hendren's bill say, that would be a proper way to handle moving this forward. Is that a
▶ Play
Speaker 98 1:12:00
fair observation? That would be one way
▶ Play
of moving forward. Thank you. Representative Hendren,
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:12:10
for what purpose? an inquiry and then a question again I understand Mr. Speaker that the parliamentarian just indicated that a procedure could be used for this was to put this back on second reading a motion to do that for purpose of amendment then consider those amendments I so move and I'll be glad to give a reason why but I move we put it back on second reading for
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:12:39
purpose of amendment Mr. Andrew, there would never be an improper motion because there are no amendments to consider to House Resolution 1001.
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:12:49
Okay, then my follow-up question, if that's the rule there, to your knowledge, is there a preparation now being made for someone and one of our colleagues here to make a motion of immediate consideration? And if that happens, none of us will get to speak against this bill. It'll just be an immediate vote. Is
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:13:08
that correct? If the body chooses to immediately consider the resolution once the well is empty, that would be the decision of the body, and it would be a vote of two-thirds of the quorum.
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:13:19
But what my question is, if that motion is made, I'm just inquiring, Mr. Chairman, if that motion is made, as my understanding, the rules currently as they are now, there will be no debate. There will be no opportunity for anybody to speak against that. Is that correct? we'll just vote that's that's
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:13:40
incorrect mr hendron if the motion was made the motion would have to be adopted before immediate consideration would take place so you can debate the proposal for immediate consideration and discuss the bill you cannot the motion to immediately consider is not debatable but
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:13:59
then you can after you do that immediately consider implies no debate doesn't You're exactly right, but the
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:14:05
body would have to adopt the motion to invoke immediate consideration. Thank you, members. Appreciate your patience. Hopefully, I've at least attempted to answer your questions.
▶ Play
Representative, Speaker Gillum has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? representative henry you're recognized to speak against the bill thank you
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:14:46
mr speaker and colleagues i didn't want to come down here and talk about this today in fact before i left gravite this morning marilee said don't you act angry or upset or mad she said And just ask God to give you some patience and likability, which I don't know whether I can do. So I'm just going to take a moment to do that before I start telling you what my heart tells me about this deal. And I just ask you to listen to it. Coming up on 40 years, and I'm almost 79 years old on February the 6th, ronald reagan and i had a birthday together not the same year but close i'll be 79 years old and for that period of the last 40 years i've had the privilege of representing part of northwest arkansas sometimes clear over to eureka springs and barryville uh in the arkansas legislature first as a member of the i'm just going to say the name folks there's nothing wrong about the democrats and now i'm a republican and i don't deny either one of those and i'm proud of the history on both of those but 40 years gives you a bit of experience and you lose a bit of hair as you can see right down here now and so i just i just want you to take a minute to think about what we're doing and why do we hurry into it so many questions have been raised here by folks that need to be talked about and i appreciate the speaker said he wanted to have this a full hearing and vetting today that's that's important and we need to do that and that's what i wanted to do colleagues i acted in good faith i did what the staff down here told me to do and what leadership had told me would happen if i did it and frankly i think that's important it's been stated by some of our colleagues today the best judgment on me or you are the constituents that vote us in or out down here not one of you colleagues of mine in two years less than two years now all of you except me and i'm not whining because i'm already past god's term limit which is three score years and ten but all of you except me will have opportunity to come back for up to ten years thanks to senator john uh wood's uh ethics amendment that we just put on that the folks just adopted for this state i think that's right anybody am i wrong about that i think every one of my colleagues here are entitled to another 10 years in this chamber whereas used to you could do it but i had to do it part on down on the other end part of it here which tends to break up some of this fiefdom business that i talk about it when you can just stay six years now you can go spend another 10 down on the end but you start you start at the bottom and there's really nothing a whole lot wrong with that except i want to talk about that in these rules here one of the reasons that they're bad so age age has has some curses but it also has some blessings experience and i've sat right over here i told that representative i sat right there when steve charles sat down on the end he was a tall we couldn't even put have a seat in there for him he had to set it out and stand up he was about six eights paid for the Razorbacks I think how much was he he was a big guy let me get down to this deal here I started to ask this question but I'm not going to do it I haven't read this deal and I'm going to wager to say and there's not one of my colleagues that have read it you know how many can anybody tell me how many pages there are in this rule change 56 56 pages i'm not going to criticize pelosi anymore don't think you ought to either 56 pages and then we and the rules committee has seen it but not the rest of us some have been dealing with this for three or four years i dealt with it in 2000 when i came in here as a freshman then i dealt with it two years ago when i came back as a freshman again let me say something about that somebody said we ought to all be equal i agree with that who was it back there murdoch i guess it was said each one of us reps about represents about 30 30 000 people some folks just more equal than other folks around here and that's the way it works when you come in here when you return down here who was it that i was talking oh andy mayberry when you come back down here folks when they draw that number out of the hat randomly we guys that come back we don't start drawing randomly we go to the head of the line did you know that it's nice and he just done it he just did it and so many other things it's so easy to get away from being treating people as we want to be treated I think that's part of the golden rule love your neighbors yourself and kind of treat them the way you want to be treated. And I hope that some way down the time we'll have a chance to talk about those, whatever we call them, changes that dealt with these issues. So I think, and let me talk specifically about this bill that we ain't read, that we're getting ready to pass. The history of this deal, basically this stuff was passed in 1997 when Huckabee gained governor and the Democrats down here said, hey, we've got to watch this Republican governor. We're going to have to take care of that. That's the way things work down here, folks. You say, I don't believe it does. Well, I'll tell you instances where they have worked, and I've seen it. So I want you to go to page 5, if you don't mind, in this deal here that I'm speaking against. page 5 it's section 54 I've got 28 on this one but I printed out two or three and let me read it to you section 54 now we were told here a while ago that the speaker the person appointing these things does not have authority to take you off of a committee, to take you out of chairman as a committee, let's read it. The Speaker of the House shall appoint a chairperson and a vice chairperson of each standing committee and each select committee who shall serve at the pleasure of the Speaker. Let me tell you something, folks. That gets my dander up because I heard a speaker here when I wasn't down here that went around to some of these committee meetings and got on to the chairman because they weren't doing what he wanted on a particular issue and said I'll take you off as chairman. Now you're right it says you can't take him off the committee and you know they can't take you and me out of the house either. Our people have to do that but they can sure assign your office to the restroom ladies and gentlemen and if you don't watch it that's what happens down here and I still maintain in this member's opinion 51 members in this house can do whatever we please if it does not violate the United States Constitution or the Constitution of the state of Arkansas. So that's just fact. And I look through this thing, and normally resolutions and bills that I've seen down here the last off and on 40 years, when you change something, you line it out, and when you add something, you underline it. I don't see any of that in these rules. I don't see any of it. And I
▶ Play
Speaker 114 1:22:34
don't know what they've changed. it's just not the way
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:22:43
to run a railroad it just it's just not so we need to we need to at least look at a little bit one i know we've taken a lot of time here it is it's ten it's five minutes to three i ain't been here since 130 down here but you need to hear some of this stuff a lot said about qualifying you for and other states are doing this or that or something else let me tell you something folks for 14 years I sat down on the other end and we never had to have anybody tell us what we were qualified to do because as a state senator I represented 135th of the population of the state of Arkansas and I was proud to do it and my accountability was not to the president pro tem or the lieutenant governor or the governor Huckabee tried to do that to me one time He called me down to office and had Ted Thomas tell me, you know, Ted's about 6'9", and they set me behind a little desk, and he said, that's when I was down here, by the way. He said, Representative, if you want to have a good relationship with this governor, don't you get in the paper like you said in Springdale helping these handicapped kids. Let me tell you something, folks. That gets my dander up. That's why I represent the people. And in a year and a half, every one of you except me, because I'm too old for two reasons, every one of you, my colleagues, are going to be out explaining to your voters, what did I do on that day of January the 11th when I had the chance to change the rules so that everybody, we are equal in fact, and that we judge what we are. We're accountable to our people rather than accountable to somebody else that can appoint somebody else. I had a lot of other notes, but I know Kim Hammer is going to get tired standing up over there in a little bit, so I better hurry on here. I go to my Benton County Republican Committee meeting. As most of you know, Republicanism really started in northwest Arkansas a few years ago. And I was a Democrat then, proud to be one. And I don't apologize today or any time else for being a Democrat. some of the stuff they believe like some of our republicans some of their stuff is foolishness but republicans got some of that too as you may know the last and I go to my committee meetings I hope you go if you're a democrat you ought to go be a part of your organization because those foot soldiers put you down here and it's easy to get down here and forget it if you remember the story of Moses in the bible holding his arms up but the democratic party and the republican I actually went to a Democratic Party in a meeting in Benton County here about a year ago. Walked in, I thought I was going to the Republican Party. But I saw a lot of folks I knew. We just had a great meeting and I gave them a report. That's the way it ought to be. But the Benton County Central Committee asked me last week, when we wound up down here, folks, let me get specific. When we wound up down here, the way we're doing things now, with 73, 74, 75, or 76 Republicans out of 100, oh i could say something about that when i was down here first time we had 15 or 20 when in the senate i beat the only republican down there they asked me said how can you have three quarters majority from the people three million people in arkansas that have voted for you you heard the governor talk about our population we got the vote counts said how can we have 75 percent of of one party but the other party controls the revenue and tax committee they asked me that Robin Lundstrom was in that meeting you heard the question Robin and then they asked me what are you going to do about it I'm doing what I'm doing this afternoon folks this ain't easy the ones that have panned out these appointments they ain't going to be happy with me but you know thank the Lord your people put you in down here and your people will have an opportunity to take you out and take me out just like God puts us in and god has a chance to take us out so the minimum i'd say colleagues and i got a bunch of stuff here that we could read the minimum i'd ask you to do and let's let's at least hear another guy's idea let's just hear what those amendments are that through through the gyration of the rules i'm not able to present you're not even going to hear them today is that the kind of government is that the kind of government you want you don't even hear somebody else somebody asked have you talk to everybody no i tried to but didn't get to talk to everybody now i don't fault a guy for trying but but you know right in here we're getting paid to be here today we call the road we're all supposed to be here so uh if the house is not on fire and it's not burning down why do we need to jump in and pass this today why don't you let me present my amendments so if they're not going to do it then i'm going to have to vote against this bad bill
▶ Play
Representative Hendren has spoken against the resolution. Would anyone like to speak for the resolution? Representative Hammer, you're recognized to speak for the resolution. You're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:27:58
Mr. Speaker. i come down here having received none of the a or b appointments for committee chair first of all so i will tell you fair enough that speaker didn't pay me any favors i will also tell you that having been in the house for what is now my fourth term and it will be my final term because i'm either going to be here i'm going to be on the other end one way or the other i'm going to be out of here that i have nothing vested in how i vote in this as far as whether it's going to benefit me or whether it's going to cost me personally so let me just divorce myself from any concept or idea that there's any favoritism or anything other than what I feel is genuinely what is a good idea for the future is it a great idea is it a perfect idea no it is not but one of the things I remember when I came in here four terms ago was sitting as a freshman and sitting through the selection process of the committee and it's a big learning curve some get ahead of it sooner some of us are like us and you're like me maybe you're in the in the d plus or the c minus category it takes you a little longer to get there but as i think about the freshmen that have come in here and i've started listening to some of the expertise i thought about my friend lanny fight for one thing when he first came in here when you're a freshman the chances of you getting where you need to be are hindered because of the way the process currently is so that necessary that doesn't necessarily mean that you are going to be where you are best suited as far as the expertise that you bring into this chamber and that you bring into those committees. I mentioned a while ago when I asked the speaker about the perception of some committees that hold greater clout than others, and in reality, they all hold their respective weight. It's just the perception, and part of that perception, I think, is built around the idea that maybe people who want to be where they want to get to aren't allowed to get there by the current process, whereas if we put our trust and that's what it boils down to our trust our speaker currently didn't get to be our speaker first time around we had two years to observe him it'll be the same thing for you when you choose your next speaker we've had the chance to look around and say who do we think will be true to their word and who will be true to what they say and who will do what is best and who will do what is right and sometimes in this institution you just have to put your trust in one person and hope they do right and if they don't vote them out the next time and don't give them a second term but when it comes to the appointment the chances to get you on the committee where you best use yourself and i remember it wasn't long ago that we had a freshman body i think upwards of 40 and everybody above us that was above us we didn't stand a greater chance and if you're now one of what i think is 17 i may be off on my math you stood even lesser of a chance so i want you to think about that as far as leveling the playing field for you getting to where you can best use your skills and talents and use your expertise that this would be a good way to move it forward. Now, I'll say this in closing because probably most of us have our mind made up by now. As far as the process, the process is fine the way it is now that if you don't like what's on the board today to be voted on, you could go ahead and vote it out. You've got three amendments you know. It can run the process, and it could overlay what we're going to vote out of here today, and you can fix it after we get out of here today. It's not like this is the last chance. And for that part, I showed up in rules the other day because I was interested in hearing. This does not prohibit you as a member showing up in any committee, voicing your opinion, and giving your two cents worth, or at least being educated on something if you choose to invest the time to show up. And if you don't, and you show up in the chamber and you're just now finding out about it, that's nobody else's fault but your own. So don't blame anybody else. So I would just encourage you a good vote. Let's get it out of here. You don't like it, come to rules. When the next ones come up, listen, voice your opinion, then come back in here and vote and let the process that's in place
▶ Play
work. Thank you. Representative Hammer has spoken for the resolution. Would anyone like to speak against the resolution? Representative Walker, you recognize to speak against the resolution. Mr. Chair. You recognize, Mr. Representative Walker.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. To the members of the legislature, several things first. This is not an issue for me about the trust in Speaker Gillum, because he is not going to be taking any action under this proposal. It is a question of the trust of anyone to exercise a vote for me so that when Mr. Representative Hemmer talks about the trust in the Speaker, I mean, I wonder if that trust goes so far as to allow the Speaker to vote for him on every bill. We were elected to come here and voice our own opinions, address our own issues, establish our own priorities. That is our duty in response to the mandate that we have, and that's what we said to the voters that we would do. Now, I didn't read all 50-some pages of this. In fact, it's just coming out. There's been great criticism about us for not paying attention and doing due diligence, as Representative Hendren has done in addressing these issues. I'm certain that he knows what he's talking about. And I find that I agree with much of what he said he and I have the benefit of being the two oldest members here and we're in opposite parties and oftentimes takes take opposite positions but on this one we are aligned the other thing is that in terms of the power of the speaker the speaker basically in my opinion guides the legislature but he does not make the determinations for us of what legislation goes forward or what the vote on it is going to be. He is another legislature, legislator, and he may help maneuver the vote to get the outcome that maybe the majority desires. He did mention that when I spoke with him in terms of committee assignments and the like, I told him that's not really for discussion, in part because it does not matter when you have 26 people in your party which committee your own because you'll never have a majority on anything unless somehow another you find a way to have someplace somewhere but wherever that is you're not going to have much power you may have a voice now that brings me to the issue of what he has said i did ask the question, as you may recall, about how anyone can know what each one of you know. I had a superintendent once say that a person that was rejected for a position did not have intelligence because he could look at him and tell. That became a very easy case to win because you can't just look at a person and determine whether that person is intelligent, is brilliant, or is dumb. Some of the people that some of us may think look the most ignorant may perhaps be among the most intelligent, and we have seen that many times. The other thing is that when we start talking about the skill set, remember, we don't have to run with the skill set. There is nothing that says that we have to identify our skill sets. The main thing we run to do is get one vote more than our opponent. And when we do, then we have that ominous responsibility of doing the best we can to represent, if we are in good faith, our constituency to the best of our ability. And in terms of the power of the speaker, I think that it is already abundant, unnecessarily great. I sent each of you an email a few minutes before the legislature began. And I had wondered whether or not it was sent to you, whether or not you got it. And when I went out to get a copy of it to see what I had said, I was told that it wasn't sent because they had to get the speaker's approval to send it to you. Well, I don't know of any rule that says before we communicate with each other by email or otherwise, we've got to get the speaker's approval. I understand that the speaker is now approved and you have it before you. But I do say this. We cannot allow the speaker to be one who exercises all the determinations that we were elected to fill. This is basically a fight between the majority. The minority can only, even if all of us voted together, which I doubt if we will, there'd be only 24 votes. But at the same time, you all have 76 people. Many of those people want to be on the same committee. How do you make a choice? There are no written criteria. It's a matter of judgment. And as someone has said, included Representative Hendren, and Ms. Brown, I think. What you may do is you may have people lined up on the front end trying to persuade the outcome of committee selections by the appointment of the speaker. That's not something that we want to experiment with. I appreciate your giving me the time of day and for listening to me, and I would appreciate it if you would read the email that I sent to you. We're all theoretically equal when we come here. Our voices may differ. Some of us may never say anything. But those people who may never say anything in this body may be otherwise influential in helping to shape legislation. We contribute to the outcome of this body in different ways. And it's not on the basis of someone looking at me or listening to me or knowing about from where I come, determining that I have an appropriate skill set. What is an appropriate skill set? I suggest that Speaker Gilliam doesn't know whether I can sing or dance, but I imagine he presumes that I may. But the point is that you can't make those presumptions. He doesn't know what my skill set is. He may know what he sees and what he thinks. But it is for us to make those determinations ourselves to the extent that the rules allow. And it's for that reason I join my colleague, Representative Hendren, and ask that you all exercise your vote to at least defer this decision. There's no reason for its haste to at least defer this decision until we can at least read it or until such time as we have a basis for changing the rules before we begin. Thank you. Representative Walker
▶ Play
has spoken against the bill. Speaker Gillen, would you like to close for your
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:39:52
bill? What's your motion, Representative Lowry?
▶ Play
My motion is immediate consideration. That motion would prevent the speaker for closing for his bill. Speaker Gillen, would you like to close
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:40:17
for your bill? Fine. You're recognized. Members, I just want to take a minute again. Thank you for hearing my presentation on this resolution and the rules. It's up for you to decide whether this is the course of action most appropriate for us moving forward. I present to you after what I feel is due diligence and several months of work that this is an appropriate course for us and is worthy of consideration. I do want to comment on a couple of things that came about. When you read this, you'll notice the select committee language stayed the same. And so earlier, when Representative Hendren was discussing the ability to come off of committees and everything, what he read and referenced was the select committee language. It does not apply to the standing committees. I don't believe that I used the words whether or not someone was qualified to be on a committee. If I did, I misspoke and I apologize. This is not about somebody's qualifications as much as it is when you read on page 5 outlining their, It clearly lists preferences, experiences, along with seniority, and their skills. This is a collaborative effort, ladies and gentlemen. This is not proposing a dictatorship. You can't know the future. I think Representative Brown had mentioned earlier, there's no way to predict every possible outcome. some have said well what if this went bad i challenge you today what if it goes great i choose to look at this as a glass half full opportunity for us as i've stated many times before i put my faith in this institution and in you something was mentioned uh and i can't remember if it was uh in representative walker's uh comments or representative hindrance comments First, Representative Walker, I apologize to you. My feeble attempt at humor earlier, I think, came across inappropriate, and I apologize. I meant no disrespect by that. But in talking about the stacking of the committees and everything, I posit to you now that the authority vested in this particular position to decide where the bills go makes that a moot point. There's no point in a speaker doing that because of the system that we already have now. and mr. Walker again the confusion on the email stuff since the staff works for the body that there is some sometimes some gray areas there on because they're not just personal staff and and so for the communication issues there I deeply apologize to you for that as well as I close my comments again asking you to look at what's actually on paper not let the fear of the unknown drive us if we did this on every piece of legislation and carried it out to the exponential degrees of what might possibly happen we'd never get anything done around here i i ask you to look at the states and and i probably maybe should have because interest of time obviously wasn't something we were concerned about for today breeding all of these lists was something i thought i would try to spare you from go but think about that 44 other states do this this is not some new radical crazy idea it works around the entire nation every day and has for years i realize it's new concept to us but it is not new these other states are working just fine their integrity of their processes are just fine i believe arkansas will also be just fine under these guidelines ladies and gentlemen again i thank you for your patience i felt like that this was something worthy of us taking time for debate and questions and i ask you today to please vote for this and allow us to move forward with the session by putting in place our rules there will be opportunity as has been amply stated for discussion and modification along the way. That process is not closed to you. Thank you again for your time and your attention and your patience today. I ask you again to please vote for this.
▶ Play
Thank you. Speaker Gillum has closed for the bill. Before we vote, we have a pair on the desk. Representative Michelle Gray votes yes. Representative Mickey Gates votes no. Witnessed by Representative Deanne Vaught. Representative Gates is the present member are there any procedural objections to this pair please do not vote either of these two voting machines the question before the house is passage of HR 1001 prepare the machine mr. clerk has everyone voted has everyone voted cast up the ballot mr. clerk With 75 yeas, 23 nays, and one present, the resolution is passed. The morning hour is ended. We're going to the yellow budget
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:46:56
calendar now. Chairman Gene, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Colleagues, we have one item, House Bill 1066. It's the general appropriation. As we said last year, nothing can get rolling by our Constitution until this is passed. And remember, we need 75 votes. What this does is gets the circuit courts, the trial judges, and their travel and reimbursement and the interim expenses on the House and Senate in for their reimbursement. But the general appropriation has to be passed before any other appropriations are passed. Any questions? I appreciate a good vote. Mr. Speaker had the clerk on the bill in the third reading.
▶ Play
Mr. Clerk, read the bill for the third time. House Bill 1066. Representative Jean has explained the bill. Would anyone like to speak against the bill? For the bill? He's closed for the bill. Representative Jean indicates he's closed for the bill. The question before the house is the adoption of HB 1066. Prepare the machine, Mr. Clerk. you're voting on the bill and the emergency clause as everyone voted cast up the ballot mr. clerk with 96 yeas zero nays and zero present the bill is passed and the emergency clause Representative Vaught, you're recognized to present that Accountable Plan. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Speaker 88 1:48:50
Speaker. You all have a purple booklet on your desk. Before you is the guidelines for the Accountability Reimbursement Plan that we will follow for the 91st General Assembly, and I would appreciate a good vote. And Mr. Speaker, with that, I would make a motion to adopt the accountability plan.
▶ Play
That's a proper motion. Would anyone like to speak against the motion? For the motion, Representative Vaught is closed for the motion. Question before the House is the adoption of the Accountable Reimbursement Plan. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, nay. is adopted. Representative Meeks, you recognize for a motion. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. After the announcements, reading of the bills, transferring of the bills, placing the calendars on the desk, members amending their own bills with their own amendments, members withdrawing their own bills, finalizing resolutions, reading communications, and any remaining committee reports, I move that we adjourn until 10 a.m. tomorrow morning. Proper motion, non-debatable. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion carries. Are there any announcements? Representative Cozart, you recognize. Announcement. House Education will meet in room 138 in the morning at 9 o'clock. Representative Jett, you're Announcement,
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:50:28
Reverend Attacks, meet at 9 o'clock, room 151, organizational meeting. Representative
▶ Play
Shepard, you're recognized. Announcement, House Judiciary
▶ Play
Speaker 120 1:50:36
will meet tomorrow morning, 9 a.m., room 149. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized. Announcement, Public Health will meet at 9 a.m. in room 130.
▶ Play
Representative Lemons, you're recognized. Announcement, Municipal League is having their own meeting. annual winter
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:50:57
meeting tonight banquet and we're all invited it's it's seven o'clock at the state house convention center representative holcomb you're recognized announcement
▶ Play
public transportation meet at nine o'clock in the morning big mac b you got an email that said 10 but we'll be meeting at nine thank you
▶ Play
i recognize the parliamentarian at this time for an
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:51:27
announcement Ladies and gentlemen of the House, thank you, Mr. Speaker. On the accountable plan, on the very last page is an acknowledgment page. If you would, after reviewing the plan, sign this and turn this into the clerk's office, and then we'll be in good
▶ Play
shape. Thank you. The desk will remain open for the reading of the bills until 4.30 p.m. And upon completion of the items named in the adjourn resolution, the House will be adjourned until 10 AM tomorrow morning.
▶ Play

Agenda

Attendance

5:48 - 7:42 9 segments 4 speakers

HR1001 GillamTO ADOPT THE RULES OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE NINETY-FIRST GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

7:42 - 3:26

Prayer and Pledge of Allegiance

3:26 - 1:46:39 274 segments 17 speakers

End of Morning Hour

1:46:39 - 1:49:03 7 segments 3 speakers

REPRESENTATIVE VAUGHT PRESENTATION AND ADOPTION OF HOUSE ACCOUNTABLE PLAN

1:49:03 - 1:47:17

Budget Calendar

1:47:17 - 1:47:51 2 segments 2 speakers

HB1066 THE GENERAL APPROPRIATION ACT FOR THE 2017-2018 FISCAL YEAR

1:47:51 - 1:52:01 17 segments 7 speakers

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Chair Unverified
126 segments
Speaker 12
6 segments
Speaker 14
1 segment
Representative Stephen Meeks Chair Unverified
45 segments
Representative Fred Allen Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 66
67 segments
Representative John W. Walker Unverified
19 segments
Speaker 62
8 segments
Speaker 88
7 segments
Speaker 95
1 segment
Speaker 97
1 segment
Speaker 93
1 segment
Representative David Whitaker Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 64
1 segment
Speaker 98
1 segment
Speaker 114
1 segment
Speaker 120
1 segment
Representative Mike Holcomb Unverified
1 segment