Aging, Children and Youth Committee
Video
Transcript
Bills discussed (8)
| Bill | Title | Sponsor | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
|
HB1048
· 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1048 D. Meeks TO PERMIT VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; TO CREATE A LICE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HCR1006
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…resolution has passed. Thank you so much. Next up, we have House Concurrent Resolution 1006 by Representative Watson.”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1004
· 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…e the resolutions and the joint resolutions first. So I see House Resolution 1004, Representative Boyd, You are recognized to present your re…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1059
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1059 House TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF VIOLATION…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1060
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1060 House CONCERNING THE MILITARY JUSTICE PUNISHMENT FOR CONTEM…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1184
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1184 D. Meeks TO REQUIRE STATE BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS TO PROMULG…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HB1261
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1261 Davis TO AMEND THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE COMMITTEE RESPONSIBLE…”
|
Pre-2017 bill | ||
|
HR1012
· 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1012 D. Meeks CONGRATULATING THE UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL ARKANSAS…”
|
Pre-2017 bill |
Machine transcript
May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
- Source
- Whisper
- Model
- ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
- Processing date
- October 14, 2026
The chair sees a quorum. Reminder, those wishing to speak for or against a bell, please sign in at the desk right over here. Without objection, we are going to take the resolutions and the joint resolutions first. So I see House Resolution 1004, Representative Boyd, You are recognized to present your resolution.
Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee members. I'm going to try to go through this pretty quickly. If at any point I need to slow down, feel free to let me know. But the resolution is there. I hope you have all read it. It has some really good information. But this really was brought to me as a constituent issue about littering and the impact on economic development. So that was kind of where I started looking at this and going, okay, what can we do? So I contacted Bureau of Legislative Research and asked them to research, and, hey, what is the most effective way to reduce littering
or deal with littering or whatever you want to say? And in that study, one, they came back, and it wasn't just, hey, we need to find people more we need to throw them in jail or what have you they came back with actually the best thing to do is prevent it in the first place and you need campaigns to do that so the other thing is we are spending in excess of five million dollars a year of state money not necessarily just out of general revenue but state dollars that could otherwise be appropriated to something else to handle litter pickup so with that said if you'll grant me i'd like to invite
Ms. Doss with the Arkansas Canoe Club to just
say a couple words if that's okay. Please introduce yourself to the committee. Hello. My name is Debbie Doss and I'm here representing the Arkansas Canoe Club. We've got 1,400 members. We're the largest paddling sport organization in the country right now with eight chapters in Arkansas
and all the surrounding states. The club has been involved with the litter issue probably ever since our inception back in 1976. so we helped write the rules for litter for AGFC about 20 years ago and we've continued to see this problem get worse and worse and more recently we've been involved with the Friends of Fish Creek
Last year, we got 26,000 pounds of trash out of Fish Creek. And if you go there today, it looks like nothing happened. So this has a huge impact on our state. I believe it has a very detrimental effect on our tourism industry in particular and other businesses, small businesses. businesses don't want to locate that's been proven by
research they don't want to locate in a place that is trashed out frankly so you know it's bad for wildlife bad for public health bad for business it needs a solution I think it's caused a lot by I think poverty is part of it, and I think apathy is part of it, carelessness,
and I think there are some solutions out there. We very much applaud the resolution, and I think it will help us raise awareness and move forward on working on some solutions for this problem. and we support the resolution and we'd like to be involved in anything that goes forward on this issue. Thank you.
Thank you. Are there any questions by the committee? Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for or against the resolution? You recognize for your motion. Do pass. Is there any discussion of the motion? Okay, the motion before us is do pass for House Resolution 1004.
What's the will of the committee? All those in favor say aye. Aye. Against, no. Okay, congratulations Representative Boyd. Your resolution has passed. Thank you so much. Next up, we have House Concurrent Resolution 1006 by Representative Watson.
Representative Watson, you're recognized to present your resolution.
Speaker 30
5:58
thank you madam chair colleagues this is the this is a fun time I'm not going to spend much time on it at all this is HCR 1006 house concurrent resolution basically it is congratulating the Prescott High School Curly Wolves football
team and winning the state 3A championship I do believe in giving credit when and where it is due. This is a little small community in my district, kind of a depressed little town, and hopefully they can wear this under a cuff for a while, and again, I'm not going to read it all, but again, I would appreciate a favorable vote on this, and this is a congratulations on the Prescott High School going all the way to the state championship.
But, by the way, the team they beat is – that is correct. Do you remember the score? You are real close. It was 37-26. I'm not going to rub nothing in. I wouldn't do that. But the team did rush for 3,300 yards. It's a new score record and passed for 2,429, 5,797 yards, a grand total. Fourth in the history. I'll leave it alone. seriously I appreciate a favorable vote. Thank you. Are there any questions by the
committee? Representative Meeks? Thank you. I'm always interested in unusual mascot names so you know wolves is a pretty common name but where is the curly wolves and if you know that maybe the history of it or why they're named the curly wolves that
Speaker 30
7:40
would be appreciated. Let me go ahead and say this so you can bring me in. You have ESPN right? I was visiting with my colleague right here a fellow sports cancer sports broadcaster Carlton Wing just a while ago and I said I hope that
they might ask that question I have to I have to refer that when he comes up to head coach Tommy Poole I can't get that in deep that's a good question thank you Thank
you. Representative Wing, you're recognized. It typically currently means ornery, so a feisty wolf. That fits into a T. Thank you. Representative
Speaker 30
8:26
Gray. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Watson, I'm gladly supportive of this resolution,
but it's not exciting for everyone being a Newport Greyhound. That little town from DePesto in your district kind of handed us one on the way to the championship there. So I want to extend my count and congratulations to the Prescott Co-Ulbs as well, and a motion at the proper time, Madam Chair. As a freshman, Representative Gray, I'm going to move that for the future. I was hesitant about doing that. Thank you. Is there
anyone in the audience who wishes to speak for or against this resolution? All right.
Representative Gray, you're recognized for your motion. Motion do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Against? No. Congratulations, Representative Watson. Your resolution has passed. At this time, we will move to House Bill 1048 by Representative David Meeks.
You're recognized, Representative Meeks, to present your bill. Hi, Madam
Chair. My name is, of course, Representative David Meeks, and I have with me Mr. Nolan, who is with the Safe Families Program, and this is what my bill is all about. People have been asking me, what do you mean by voluntary respite care? If I'd have thought a little bit more before I filed a bill, I would have put Safe Families legislation actually in the title because that is what this bill represents as
you all know we have a crisis in our foster care system with children being brought in and not enough homes really in order to have those children and really in a safe home and so we're always looking for ways to improve the system to make the system better and working with the governor working with a bipartisan group of legislators and just folks from around the state one of the goals and one of the focus that we set is what can we do to keep children from
coming into foster care what can we do either resources or finding alternative ways where our children would be safe in a place to where that their parents or whoever is raising them can get whatever crisis or whatever thing is going on in their life out of the way so that they can get their children back and you know continue to raise them in a safe environment and one of those ways is with
the safe families program this is really an amazing program when I first learned about it oh about two years ago I was really excited about it coming to the state of Arkansas and so I'm going to turn it over now to mr. Nolan he'll He'll introduce himself, and then he'll give you some detail about what this program is. Well, thank you,
Speaker 47
11:38
Representative Meeks, Madam Chair, and members of the committee. It's my privilege to introduce to you a little bit more about House Bill 1048,
and it's really about helping families, helping families in crisis. And so Safe Families for Children is a national and international movement of compassion. It's in over 30 states across the United States, and there's 108 chapters across those 30-plus states. And so it's been implemented here for now, well, across the United States now for 14 years. There's also over 25 locations in the United Kingdom.
There's two locations in Canada. There's one in even Kenya, in Nairobi, Kenya, and it seems like each day there's more popping up to help children and families in need. And so this bill, as it's introduced, does not replace foster care. It's not adoption. It's not foster care, and it doesn't replace it. But it does give families the ability to seek help before their crisis gets to the point of abuse and neglect.
And so it really is about giving parents the ability to 100% voluntarily seek help before entry into the system. and that's really about preventative care for those families. The way we do that is through utilizing a network of volunteers who have been screened, trained, and approved, and monitored by Bethany Christian Services, who is one of the implementers of Safe Families for Children. So the provisions of this bill really allow for us to be able to do that screening,
monitoring, and assessment to those families in a way that doesn't provide unnecessary barriers for families seeking assistance before entry into the child welfare system. And so the impact on families and the community really is immense, and we've seen over 28,000 children utilize this service across the country, and that represents over in child welfare speak over 800,000 days care and with the 90 94 percent
success rate of returning those children back to their families before abuse and neglect happens we're seeing a transformation in the number of children entering the child welfare system all across the country and if you can imagine the impact that that has not only on the child but on the family, on the community, and frankly, on the finances and the budget of the child welfare system. So, again, it's my privilege to introduce this. I know we've worked for many months with the Department of Human Services,
the Governor's Office, Office of Chief Counsel, and I believe we've come together to work on a bill that really serves the children and
families of Arkansas well. Thank you, Mr. Dillon, and I cannot re-emphasize this enough that this bill is voluntary as far as a family is concerned, meaning the courts are not involved in this whatsoever. This is a way for parents to get the help that they need, and we think about the fact
that maybe a parent is having a drug problem and needs to go into rehab, and they don't have a family member that they might be able to safely place the child with. Maybe it's a single mom, and she has a car accident and is not able to because she's in the hospital. This is a way for that child to go to a safe family while that mother is recovering. We see that a lot. I'm sure that maybe most of the members on the committee
know of a child that's living with an aunt, an uncle, grandparent already and so this is a way for those folks who may not have that resource to have a safe home for that child to go to while they're getting their house in order and it's a it's like I said it's a great program and so I hope that the members of the committee will strongly support this bill there were a couple of concerns and I will go ahead and address them these folks are not licensed by the state and that is you know by design by purpose okay we do
not want families to have to be licensed by the state we think that the safe families program already has enough things in place to protect children and mr. Nolan correct me if I'm wrong but out of those 28,000 children that had been placed there was one allegation against the family and that allegation was proven be false so it is a very successful program the bill does require that these families do go through background checks and through fingerprinting and and so
we've got that protection in place with them the safe families program has their own training that they actually do to again make sure that the families are prepared and they again they again impeccable 28,000 kids and no true allegations have been found so they're doing it right and so I would say much better the job and we could probably learn from what they're doing and do a better job there was also concerned with their developmental disabilities area
that you know that this they have a voluntary rescue program as well and they were afraid that you know this bill coming in could be used as a loophole and so I've got an amendment that I'm having drafted up right now and if you'll allow me to get this bill out of committee I'll make sure that that again it's just a very minor change I'll make sure that it gets on the Senate side in order to actually close that loophole and so members I want to make sure again that y'all realize how important this is to our state and to our families that we
We pass this bill out, allow these programs to operate in our state, and allow our children to have a safe place to go to without having to be pulled into foster care. So with that said, we'll be glad to take
any questions. Thank you, Representative Meeks. And those of us who were on this committee during the interim period and others of you who may not have been on the committee but may have been in the audience heard a very long presentation of this concept during the interim, which answered a lot of our questions.
So I know some of you, though, who are new members will have questions, and maybe some of the older members, too. So we'll
proceed to the question list. Representative Blake. Thank you, Madam Chair. Representative Meeks, I wasn't on the committee last year, so this sounds very similar to to a situation we had, I think you ran a bill on, a couple years ago, which was rehoming. And I'm trying to figure out how is this bill different from rehoming?
Sure. Number one, this is a contract. Whenever they go to the Safe Families Program, it is a contract between the host family and the parent who's volunteering to actually do that there are safeguards in place and I can let mr. Nolan expound on it just a little bit to keep that from happening to keep you know from the parents saying well I just need three months and at the end of the three months renewing it for another three or another six months and you know to keep them from you know from an extending two
or four or five years again we do not want that to happen all right but I will say this when folks ask me about this you know that can happen right now with regardless of whether we pass this law I can place you know I've adopted three boys but at any point I could place my three boys with an aunt and uncle cousin maybe even somebody at church and there's miss there's not anything necessarily illegal about I can go to a judge and transfer custody of that and
and it would be indefinitely, and that would not re-trigger the homing law. So if I wanted to right now, I could do that regardless of whether this law passes, but there are safeguards
Speaker 47
20:12
in place, and I can let Mr. Nolan talk about that a little further. Well, thank you, Representative Blake, for your question. And I will say, first and foremost, that Bethany Christian Services is an outspoken advocate for children, and we're an outspoken advocate for or against the practice of rehoming. legislatively we've been involved in Washington DC to speak out against the
practice of rehoming as well so you've got my support on that and it was one of the questions that was addressed previously but thank you for your question and as Representative Meeks mentioned we do have practices in place to prevent that and so the process by which we do this is through a power of attorney much like a traveling baseball team does you know parents signs a power of attorney to the coach to get medical care that type of thing that's medical care and education is all that that power of attorney allows that host family to do the volunteer family and so through
our screening processes and intake we are identifying those families that are that truly have a temporary crisis and working with those volunteers and families to ensure that they're making progress on those goals and if it gets to the point where it appears they're not making privates or they're just not interested in parenting their children, we make the
appropriate call to protective services. Yes, one follow-up. Representative Meeks, you said that our current system allows someone to be able to do this
now and not break the law, and this bill is setting it in law that makes it okay for this group to do it. Do you agree that just because we can do it now that it's the right practice? Well, you know, I would
say this, is that it's going to depend on situations. I mean, again, obviously if a parent is in crisis, they're going to do what they feel is in the best interest of their kid. And right now there is not a, and I may need to clarify this,
But there is not a credible way to do that with somebody who does not have a relative or a church family. And really, this is what that is geared toward. You know, if you have an aunt, an uncle, somebody at church that you feel comfortable with doing it, you can do it right now. But there are families in many parts of the state that do not have somebody that they feel comfortable with placing their children with. And this gives a credible, reputable way to actually do that in order for that child to be safe.
And this is really what the focus of that bill is, because it would be horrible for a parent. They're in a crisis. They're desperate. They don't want their children to be pulled into foster care, but they don't have anybody that they know. And this program is a way for them to get the help that they need while they get their life back in order. Representative Birch Thank you, Madam Chair
One of my biggest concerns about this is that there's not a licensing
there's no oversight, there's nothing by the state One of the biggest things that this legislative body has been addressing over the last few years is concerns about how DHS works and the transparency and what they have to do and one of the number one things that DHS now is required should be doing anyway, but also the judicial authority is there, is that we look for family. So if there's a child that's in crisis, DHS is required to go search for the family. So there's nothing in here that if a mom is trying
to avoid trouble or avoid getting into an investigation, and I appreciate that parents are going to do what's in the best interest of the child, I beg to differ having been in the DCFS system for 12 plus years that's not always the case they may want to but they're not able to so my concern with this is that the failure to have any oversight and the failure to require anyone to look for other family members like DHS is required to do DCFS has to go out and say where's the other parent give a reasonable responsible view or our
search for the other parent and for those folks this would allow that to be completely bypassed so if there is a parent or grandparent out there who can't find the kids and would like to find the kids and would like to be involved with
the kids this allows bypass am I missing something I think so and again I'll start off and I'll let Mr. Nolan expound if he actually wants to this is not a way for parents to avoid getting their kids into foster care if they are abusing physically abusing if there if there's extreme neglect or
or anything of that nature, they're not going to be able to go to safe families, and safe families will take their kids in. DCFS, and you see that in the bill. When you read the bill, the bill specifically states that if there are things going on in that home that would normally pull the kid into foster care, that will still happen. That will still happen. So I want, hopefully, to lay your concerns in that if, again, if a child's being well-treated in any way, shape, or form,
and they're in immediate danger, that that child will still or can still be pulled into foster care. So this is not going to be a way to get around that particular issue. Again, I let Mr. Nolan speak more about their policies and procedures to make sure that the right decision is made with the child either going into the Safe Families Program or whether, if that is the case, they need to be pulled into foster care.
Speaker 47
26:04
Thank you, Representative Birch, for your question. And you're correct that we don't want children to be hidden from the system.
That was one of the conversations we had with DHS to begin with. Nor is it a way for child protection investigators to not allow a child into the system. And so our practices for screening, part of that process includes identifying other family members in the community, in the area, anybody that can help that's already a family member. Because it is in the best interest of the child to be with a family member. But in the absence of those family members or adequate family members who are able to
care for a child, then at least Safe Families can be a resource for those families. So our selection process for who can care for a family and also the process for entry into the safe families for children program is very rigorous and we don't accept everyone because we were selecting only those who have no other options excuse me representative gray thank you madam chair I don't think
Speaker 30
27:17
that anyone here would question your motives or your heart when it comes to the foster care system or foster children. So I always appreciate you bringing any issues like this to light. I do have some questions about coming from a world where I prefer less government oversight when we can have it, I don't necessarily think in the area of child care that is always the best way to go about things. Can you address the, I believe in your opening you said that these would not be licensed families,
but they would be screened by Bethany Christian Services. Bethany standards may or may not be higher than the states. I'm not seeing them, so I won't question your method of screening by any means, sir. but their accountability is to Bethany and not to the state of Arkansas or those of us that are trying our best to pass laws that protect children that are in these situations. So two questions, Madam Chair, if you'll forgive. One question.
We'll circle back around to you. Can you first address the reason there wouldn't be some licensing of either the families or the organization through the state? Thank you, Madam Chair. Sure. Pretty much the way
that these programs work, they're doing almost everything that the state would actually normally do. And at me as a foster parent, I don't have a license in my back pocket
that actually says that I'm a foster parent. So there's no, you know, I'm not paying a fee to be a foster parent necessarily. but the process is very very similar except you're not going through the state to get like the training you know the state requires 30 hours of pride training and there's a good reason for that because of the situations that you'll get in foster care but you're not going to see and save families and so we're not requiring them to do a certain amount of hours of training but where
the similarities exist to me is very important, and that is they're getting the background checks done. They're getting the fingerprinting done to make sure that there's nothing in the background that would pop up and say, hey, this is not a person that we want to be placing a child with. When you look at those particular similarities, that is where it's really important. training they're doing specific to the kind of situations that their families
will deal with in those situations that those families will see. So we're not requiring that you know that particular amount of training. We're also you know as far as going into the home you know DCFS says oh you've got to have this many square foot you've got to have a lot of these other things again that may not pertain to this actual host family there. And so that's why you know know licensing again when we get into semantics they're doing what they're
required to do or what they need to do to make sure that the host family is ready for the situations that they will see and so to me the state does not need to be involved with giving the okay to actually do that I think again their record speaks for themselves 28,000 children no allegations that have been proven true on what there is. And that record is a lot better than the state. As I said, we need to do better. And I want Mr. Noah if he wants to expound or make another point.
And Representative Gray had a follow-up that maybe will tie in
Speaker 30
31:14
with this. Thank you, Madam Chair. I do, specifically to the licensing question. Representative Meeks, I appreciate your answer. And I have no doubt the background checks, the fingerprinting, the accountability within the organization my question would be without a license and requirement to the state for the organization background checks fingerprints all those safeguards that you mentioned who will they be accountable to if they don't have to obtain all if there's
no requirement from the state um to um i can do background checks on you can do a background check on me but if you're not required to meet a certain level by that it won't matter what what that background check is. And so I'm a little confused there if you could clear
Speaker 47
32:02
that up, please. And thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Representative Gray, for your question. It's a question that's been asked in all of the locations where Safe Families Chapter has launched. So in no location is the state required to license Safe Families for Children.
And the reason being is because this is voluntary. It's a relationship between two families. It's not a relationship with an agency. And so our role in this process is to be the facilitator, the conduit to connect those two families. And we do that through the screening process because we don't want a family to choose just anyone to care for their children. We want to give them an option for a family who at least has been vetted by the process. And that's what the provisions of this bill does, is it eliminates those requirements to license a family
to just voluntarily help somebody for three days or 30 days or whatever it might be and allow those two families to connect. So the relationship isn't with the agency. It's a relationship between those two families, and we allow that and facilitate that to happen. So as far as accountability, the Safe Families for Children program in itself has a strict requirement for launching. And I can, you know, there's others here who have been through that process for screening and launching a chapter.
Originally based out of Chicago, every new chapter has to meet certain requirements and certain community requirements in order to launch a chapter. And so for me to even present the option of launching a Safe Families chapter in Arkansas, I had to get the approval of our Safe Families headquarters in Chicago. and so there are checks and balances within within us as well as you know Bethany's been around for 75 years and so we were accredited and all that good
stuff so we follow those requirements for best practices of child welfare so that's that that really gets to what our role is we're the facilitator we're not we're not placing children ourselves the families are choosing families are placing from one family to another again I just want to point out you know he
made a very important point. They're operating in 30 states, and I believe I heard him say, correct me wrong, they're not required to be licensed in any of those states. And we're talking states that run the gamut from the reddest of red states to the
bluest of blue states. None of them require licensing successful, successful program for our children. Representative Tucker. Thank you, Madam Chair. First, Representative Meeks, you
Speaker 63
34:38
just, in responding to Representative Birch, you mentioned that in the bill there's language that if there are circumstances that require them to go into state services, and I just was looking for that language in the bill, and I couldn't find if you could help me. I would appreciate that.
Yeah, let me it's toward the end there. It says nothing in this subdivision shall be interpreted to prevent or otherwise limit the investigation of child maltreatment or a finding of child maltreatment where there is evidence of child maltreatment beyond the parents near witness or excuse me near written agreement with a voluntary respite care provider so that right there allows our DCFS to come in and investigate
and then take the children uh into foster care custody you know if there is uh child maltreatment that reaches that level. So they would be able to pull in. So underneath that particular section, that's what allows DCFS to come in if they have
to. Representative Wing. Thank you, Madam Chair. As you mentioned, so 30 states have resolved this issue to their satisfaction, and they are good with this program,
and I think your track record does speak for itself. I mean, those are incredible numbers to be able to report in the work that you do. But is there any safeguards, and how have other states perhaps dealt with this issue, safeguards against another organization coming in, since this organization is not specifically named in the bill, that might not have as good a track record? How have other states resolved
Speaker 47
36:34
that concern? well I can only speak to the safe families piece but when it comes to statutory requirements of
state involvement in a child's life through child protection investigation that's really where the entry into child welfare in this process is starts and so we're talking about children and the family is completely removed from the child welfare system already. And so it's relationship to relationship, much like you would do on your own, but, again, providing the screening conduit to do that. So it really hasn't been an issue. Yeah, I have not heard of any
other issues, but I mean that is a good point,
and I would like to say that, you know, that is where we, and I'm talking about me and other folks, have to get the word out that here is a credible, reputable organization that you can do it. You know, as I pointed out before, and you all might be getting tired of hearing me this, anybody right now can place their child with anybody else, whether or not they do it through this organization or something else. And that's very important. So we want to give folks a credible, reputable organization
who has a great track record that these families can go to knowing that their kid is going to be placed in a safe home rather than, you know, some just person off the street that they met, they're desperate to actually do it, we want to give them that credible, reputable thing, organization to do it. And I would like to say, you know, that's why we put the background checks in into statute. So let's say there is an organization that is not doing what they're supposed to be doing, then there is recourse for that parent and then also, too, as well, you know,
other prosecutors and whatever else that if their organization is not doing what they're supposed to be doing they're committing fraud then that allows that recourse to actually take place. Representative
Birch. Thank you Madam Chair. You mentioned Representative makes the beginning that maybe if it had safe families legislation name in it that are that you were interested in maybe trying to put that in there as it's written what stops any church
group, anyone, from forming this kind of organization internal and doing exactly what you're talking about with this vetted organization? What in this legislation stops that from happening? Nothing. And, you know, I would encourage churches, and
again, I'll let Mr. Nillman expound on that, but that's what we want to do. That was the whole reason that the, one of the reasons anyways that the governor started his restore hope he wanted to get faith-based
organizations involved and like I said I know Bethany they do a good job of working with churches and other faith-based organizations to spread the word and so you know our hope is that our churches will get behind this particular program and not try to really start their own program but if they do again I think there's enough in there to say hey look if you're going start an organization like this your people still have to go through background checks they still have to to to go you know and get their fingerprinting done or whatever um in order to
do that but you know there is i mean their people do turn to the churches and we want to make sure uh that you know the churches are prepared to do this they again they have a good reputable organization that they can look to and either join them or do their own thing uh to help people in need. Representative Birch, follow-up.
Thank you, Madam Chair. With that in mind, in organizations like the call, Children of Arkansas Love for a Lifetime, all those are partnered with DHS through
the governor's program, right? I mean, there's some oversight and official responsibility through the state. I just don't see that here. Help me. Help me. I absolutely
understand your concerns. Again, 30 states that they're in, and in those 30 states, they have very limited or little interaction with the particular state. They're pretty much free to operate, and they have been very successful in actually doing that.
So, again, track record already speaks for itself, but there are safeguards in place to where if the state needs to get involved because something is going bad, they're able to do so. Again, if the child is being maltreated, the parent can't just put them into the Safe Families program and think they're going to be protected or they're going to be sheltered from it. No. If at any time a child is placed with a host family and DCF does an investigation, gets a report of child maltreatment, DCFS can get involved and bring that child into foster care.
I want to make sure that you guys understand that the state does not have to be involved in every little thing. I think that this is a good example of where we can keep the state out of it as much as possible and get our children into a safe environment, give that parent who needs just a little bit of extra help, maybe needs a little bit of time to get their wife in order without having to involve judges, without having to involve our child welfare system. The child goes into a safe home. Mom and dad get whatever issue they have settled,
and then that child comes back. Again, they're not pulled into foster care. Mom and dad were able to go on and raise that child to be a successful individual with a successful life. I'll let Mr. Nola, if he
Speaker 47
42:09
wants to expound that question again. Well, again, I appreciate the concern for children and families because that's really what it's all about. It's about keeping children safe. And so, again, it boils down to what the activities are. With the other agencies licensed or whatever they're involved in, our role is simply as a screening vetting process.
We want to make sure that the right people, right two people, are connected. So just like big brothers, big sisters, does a background check and screening process on their volunteers. That's what we're asking to do without having to fall under licensing guidelines. Similarly, foreign exchange students, the same type of process is, you know, background check screening process has been done. I was an exchange student, so I'm familiar with it. But I do appreciate the concern for children and families. My background actually is in law enforcement, and I was a police officer for a number of years.
So I saw that side of it, actually investigating the cases of abuse and neglect. And I worked in the foster care system, much like you mentioned you have, and I saw those children in foster care and help them get into stable and safe families, safe environments. But I also saw that if we can prevent this abuse from happening in the first place by connecting them with resources and combating that social isolation and all those protective factors that keep children safe, then let's do that and that's what drives me here today is that ability to help families
before the system gets involved or needs to statutorily get involved so that they can get the help that they need and that's really what it's all about and that's that's why there have been these questions in all of the other states it's always raised you know there's always that question of liability if the state assumes responsibility for licensing the program are they then responsible to some degree for the liability? Yes. But at this point, with the agency doing the screening and the functions that we do,
the agency's holding the liability for that aspect of it. So that's something we're willing to do because we are familiar and comfortable, and that's where our expertise is in that screening process.
Representative Kavanaugh. Thank you, Madam Chair. My question is, we keep talking about that the child, we're not taking away the right for DHS if there's a child maltreatment. What safeguards do you have built into your processes that allow you to see if a child is actually being maltreated by one of these safe families,
or the maltreatment is so bad they should not be going into a safe family to begin with? What are those safeguards?
Speaker 47
44:47
Thank you, Representative Kavanaugh, for your question. and I appreciate it because that really is the crux of why Safe Families is so successful. So there's a couple of factors that go into that. First of all, our screening intake process is a triage that identifies what the temporary crisis need is and basically screens whether or not that should be referred to child protection investigators to begin with.
First questions out of the gate have to do with what's the nature of your crisis and what does the child need. Following up on that, presuming the parent chooses a host family to care for their child, then we have what we call family coaches, much like case coaches, who will check on that child within 48 hours to make sure that they're in a safe environment, that the volunteer host family's questions are answered, connect to resources, that type of thing. We actually check on that child and that family within 48 hours,
and then once a week for the first month and then if it goes longer than once a month or once a if it goes longer than a month then we check in with that family once a month so we use those checks and balances within the our processes to make sure that that child is in a safe environment where we see success happening is when when we encourage and that's part of this process we actually encourage a relationship between the parent going through the crisis and the host family that is caring for their child.
So they're in communication every day, every other day, whatever it might be, because that child needs to stay connected to their parent. Parent chose that family for that child, and so through that relationship that develops, there's an ongoing communication stream and network so that they can continue to work through whatever crisis drove them to that point. Representative Tucker. Thank you,
Speaker 63
46:38
Madam Chair. Representative Wing and Representative Birch really kind of hit on my primary concern because as we
know the the statute doesn't name this organization individually and so any other organization can come into play and in your responses today you've emphasized the fact that this is a voluntary relationship and I understand and respect that at the same time correct me if I'm wrong but I would think that most of these relationships are with unknown other families because you know if my wife and I had a crisis for example I'm gonna put my kids with my parents or my sister, and I'm not going to call y'all up to arrange for a contract for that. And so I would think that when there needs to be more accountability measures in place
when a family that doesn't have a person they know to place their kids with, you know, needs that. And so I guess part of my question is how do you account for that accountability when you have an unknown, unfamiliar relationship with the host family? And then, you know, I guess the question more for Representative Meeks would be, I understand that this organization has a lot of great protocols in place. And so we're sort of assuming with this bill that they would be the only one to do it. And I was wondering if you would consider amending the bill to put some of the protocols into the legislation
just to make sure that if someone else were to come into play, we know they already comply with them. But if another organization were to come into this arena, that they would have to abide by some of those same protocols. could you repeat the first question what the how the relationship yeah just how do you so i mean you've described you've emphasized that this is a voluntary relationship and i respect that but when you have an unknown host family and i know there's a technical term in the bill but you know
what i'm talking about not the parents but the the other host family and so how do you as an organization, you know, in the relationship with the state or lack of relationship with the state, how do you account for the accountability between the parent family and
Speaker 47
48:40
the unknown host family? Well, again, it's a relationship, and so the placing parent gets to choose the host family, so I don't necessarily think they need between two consenting adults to have a monitored relationship between them, if I'm not understanding it correctly.
But it's two adults, and they're agreeing to do this together. And so there's not really an oversight I need to have in their relationship back and forth other than that we want them to work together to address the crisis. And I'll add to what he's saying because, you
know, the fact that I think their process may be a little bit better than what we actually do in foster care because of the fact that they're able to meet the host family, and it's a volunteer thing, And so if the parent is not comfortable with that host family, maybe they don't hit it off right,
maybe they're just something else that they don't like, then they don't choose the host family. Whereas in foster care, your child gets taken, and you really have no choice as to the foster family it goes to. I mean, it's usually whoever the first family is that your caseworker can find an opening for. So in a lot of cases, I think that their process is a lot better because, again, the parents right off the beginning can have a relationship with that host family that doesn't happen all the time in our foster care system and when you're
talking again about the other organizations that may pop up and may not have the same protocols in there I mean obviously I you know I'll be glad to hold the bill today and I'll be glad to discuss the concerns that you have and whatever suggestions representative Tucker that you may have to make this better even stronger but I would like to reiterate that people can do this right now with somebody who may not be reputable who has not gone through the
background checks and so what this is is we're putting into place a clear way for a reputable, credible organization to come in and vet families and put them through protocols that have worked in 30 other states to make sure that our child has a safe place. Because otherwise, right now, again, the two options for parents is to either put them with somebody that they kind of know, that they're not sure, you know, maybe what kind
of record, if there's something lurking in the background that they didn't know about, or to have to call up DCFS and say, hey, I need you to come. There's nothing else I can do with my child. And that's what we're trying to avoid. We're trying to avoid those types of situations that are going to put that child in a bad location and to put them with a reputable organization that has a track record of success. So did that answer your question, Representative Tucker? Sure.
Okay. Thanks. Representative Meigs, I wanted to be sure that I understood what you were saying. Are you planning to
pull the bill down for today? Well, what I would like to do is, again, because I've still got to make a couple of other amendments. Like I said, I've got one from the Developmental Disabilities that's being drafted by BLR. Obviously, I would like to get with Representative Tucker and see what he thinks that we need to do to make this bill even stronger. I may end up disagreeing with him, but I do want to go ahead and hear him out on what he has to say.
But, Madam Chair, I'll be glad to, you know, let's go ahead and finish this out. If there are any other questions, I know a gentleman has driven here or has come here to speak against the bill, so I'll be glad to hear, you know, what he has to say. And then at that point, you know, I'll be glad to go ahead and hold the bill and address any of the concerns that any of the members may have with this bill.
The person who you said drove in to speak against the bill has not signed in Oh,
I thought that he Mr. Kelly, I thought he'd come up and
spoken We do not have that on our list We'll check Okay, alright, thank you I think Representative Gray had an
Speaker 30
52:55
additional question Madam Chair with due respect to Mr. Kelly and Representative Meats, I think we're all kind of asking the same questions here at your discretion I'd like to move for immediate consideration or at least let's pull this bill down
and move on. Okay I think it's Representative Meeks has stated that it's his intention to work on this bill some more but we wanted to give our audience members who
have driven in to speak for against the bill the opportunity to do that. I have Ms. Veronica Smith signed up to speak for the bill. I make a motion
on the table to do pass motion. We have to have that before we can have immediate consideration. Thank you, Madam Chair. Okay, at this time I will recognize Ms. Veronica Smith to
Speaker 78
54:08
speak for the bill. Thank you, Madam Fyke and Legislative Committee members. I appreciate your time today. I'm the new Director for Bethany Christian Services
and very excited about this opportunity to take care of children in Arkansas. I actually came to Bethany because of the opportunity after being with UAMS in Arkansas Children's Hospital for 20-plus years. There are a number of beautiful testimonies available on YouTube of families who have been through this process, parents who were reluctant to actually come to the program but chose to do so and absolutely has changed their lives.
This is an opportunity for the crisis in Arkansas that we have in foster care for us to take care of children prior to that stage. These are not kids that are yet in neglect. They are kids that are in families that may have just lost their job and have become homeless and just need a place to stay while mom gets herself back on her feet. Just this past week at Bethany, we had a client that had multiple children and needed to go to
the hospital, and she had no one to care for her multiple small children. Instead, she was going to take them to the hospital with her. Bethany worked with her. We brought a family. We actually traveled to another state. We escorted a family back here to Arkansas to stay with those children so that she could go to the hospital and actually take care of what she needed to take care of for that time period. That's a short period of time that is needed and we're just asking to be able to do
this program in a way that we can officially do it and feel comfortable about doing it so that those parents have a choice. So thank you for your time today and if you have any questions for me I'd be happy to try to answer them.
Are there any questions from the committee? Representative Watson.
Speaker 30
56:20
Yes my concern, we know the number of cases, let's be
realistic, we know these number of cases that are happening that we've all been talking about are going to increase over a period of time. That's a given. Mr. know when you said you spent considerable amount of time in law enforcement as well as I I've seen quite a few of these cases they're not fun but they're real and they are gonna happen my question just real quickly is caseload caseload for the future increased number of occurrences quite frankly question is are y'all up for the number of cases are y'all up for the increase
Speaker 47
57:02
can not handle that well it takes time to build volunteers but I was actually at a church speaking to your group yesterday and there were about 30 people there who are ready to make this happen I've been communicating with other faith communities as well and believe it or not but there's people coming out of the woodwork to take in these kids at their own cost and help these families and so So speaking to caseload, I mean, we serve these families for an average of 30 days.
Nationally, that's our average, because we're talking about short-term temporary crises, not the long-term chronic issues that crop up. And so, again, it's that preventative work that we're doing. So we're going to do our best, but there are already people that have been knocking our door for now two years to get this, to be part of this, and they're just waiting for this to happen. And I would
like to add, too, that is the case. I've heard a lot of people, you know, when they filed this bill, they're ready to get involved.
They don't want to do foster care because of the requirements and even some of the other things that they actually do, but they're willing to be a host family. Maybe they can't, because in foster care, sometimes you're committing six months to a year or more with the foster child to keep that child in a stable home. And as he said, 30 days is their average, And there are parents that, you know, can do 30 days or maybe two months at a time to help these children out. So, you know, that's another great point that you brought out. Thank you, Representative Watson.
Speaker 84
58:39
Representative Barker. Thank you, Madam Chair. Just a clarification on the temporary. You said 30 days is an average. Is there a limit? Is it very clear what is temporary or what is not? I mean, would you possibly be, you're thinking temporary, but now it's been?
Speaker 47
58:58
very long time right so that's why when we work with the families we work very closely with them and all the volunteers that surround them and like a wrap around support type function but naturally built into the power of
attorney there's a statutory limitation to that and so that's that's a natural cutoff but the reality is we're working very closely with these families so that they don't get to the point where they're just abusing the system I mean that we don't want our families to be that way as well you know to be abused and so we're working together on that process. Okay let's remember I see a
few more hands but let's remember we have a couple of more audience members who have asked to speak. Representative Gray. Thank you Madam Chair. Representative Meeks
Speaker 30
59:46
personally I want to say move for immediate consideration. It's not a commentary on your bill just simply to move on so I want to make that clear with you so I'm absolutely respectful of you presenting this bill my question goes to one last time I can only imagine as a parent I can only imagine how desperate a situation would be to need to find a home and it's for your kids whether it be for two days or two months or whatever and unfortunately it happens
all too often as we're all aware. So I can imagine being a desperate parent, a desperate situation in a community or area where my parents or my siblings weren't available to me to take care of those children and I would be looking for some reputable organization that could help me out in that situation. But what I would also want or need the assurance of is that it wasn't just well enough that
somebody was standing behind this organization to say, no, they absolutely are what they say they are. The people that, the families that you don't know that you'll get to meet have been vetted the way they say they've been vetted. So my question to organization and do you represent Meeks, would you consider, two parts of that. One, would you consider as you look at this legislation, some way to create a licensing or oversight from the state that would be oversight of, I respect your desire not to
have the families go through the training and levels that the foster family may have, some level of oversight over the organizations themselves so appearing in such a desperate situation would at least know that someone is holding the organization accountable. And to you guys, would that be something, I mean, if licensing came into power, are you guys gone? I mean, Governor Hutchinson, to represent Meeks' point, has made a great effort to include
faith-based organizations in helping alleviate some of this problem, would you guys be willing to some kind of cursory oversight by the state just to make sure to Representative Tucker and Representative Wings but we don't have other fly-by-night, frankly, organizations attempting to do the same thing? Well,
Speaker 47
1:02:17
I would again just say I respectfully question the necessity of that because this is a relationship between two parents. All we're doing is filling that screening vetting role.
And in the 30-plus other states that are doing it, it's not a requirement. It's a relationship between
Speaker 30
1:02:36
two adults. But would you be willing to entertain some method of that? Not at
this point. Thank you, sir. Madam Chair, if I could add. Yes. Again, I'm open to a lot of different things, but for me to come and say that the state has to give permission or whatever the case may be, you know, that is something that I can't see happening.
I don't want to just say never because my mom taught me never to say never. But, again, even with foster care, I don't get a license per se. All I do is I get a piece of paper just saying, you know, I've met the requirements and that my home is open. And Bethany does something similar, but the only difference is there's not a piece of paper from the state saying that, okay, you're there. So the state is already taxed enough as far as our resources are concerned. I mean, our caseworkers and anybody else
who might be involved in doing that, they are already over slammed with capacity. There's no way that we would be able to do this from really a state standpoint with the resources that we currently have. And as he said, I don't think that it's needed because, again, it's just a relationship between two individuals. They're bringing two consenting adults together to make the best decision available for that particular
child. Thank you very much. We have Mr. Paul Kelly signed up to speak against the bill.
Speaker 30
1:04:11
Please identify yourself with the remaining. Good morning. My name is Paul Kelly. I'm the Senior Policy Analyst at Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families. Advocates really supports the overall intent of providing this help to parents in situations that do not rise to the level of neglect. But we do want to make sure that the kids are safe. We believe that since an agency is helping coordinated full-time care of children who
not remain in their homes that the agency should be licensed by the state. My understanding is that if such a license were pursued in this case it would likely be under the Division of Child Care and Early Childhood Education not the DCFS. In being a license that will help ensure their children's safety it It assures that a home study and other checks are done before the child is placed in the
home of someone without a license. An exempt agency is not required to do those things. And even though many reputable providers would do those things, it creates the abilities for others who do not. A child would have to be home before the state would know about the bad practices of an agency. In fact, license would allow the Child Welfare Review Board to shut down an agency as needed.
Without a license, the exempt agencies can continue to operate despite those practices. So I know there's been a lot of discussion. I don't want to be prolonging this, but I just want to say again that Arkansas Advocates believes that if we're going to call this Safe Families, that we need to issue some license to make sure that that is what happens. Thank you.
I see one question. Representative Flowers. I'll
just make a statement, and I know that there's a little bit of information that I haven't gotten. We
need a question, Representative Flowers. Then I'll reserve my comment to the sponsor. Thank you, Madam Chair. All right, thank you. Any other questions by the committee? We have Ray Williams signed up to speak for the bill.
Speaker 30
1:07:11
I need to push this. Madam Chair and Representative Meeks and members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to speak for this bill. My name is Ray Williams. I serve as a local outreach pastor of a church here in Little Rock Fellowship Bible Church, and also serve with a network of churches called the Nehemiah Network.
And so while I'm not here speaking officially for all of those churches, I think I know many of them well enough to represent in general at least many of the churches of our community. And I think many know that the churches all across Arkansas have played a very significant role in helping to provide foster care. And in that same spirit, there is a similar desire to help in this area as well. As has been mentioned, this represents a different place in the continuum of care for children.
This is before a situation has transpired where the state moves in. And so I wanted to just give two examples that aren't hypotheticals but are real that I see all of the time. One is that as a pastor, I'll hear about a family in our church who is a very qualified family, a very caring family, who's taken someone into their home in a temporary care situation.
And normally they do a great job. I can't think of a time when they've not. But one of the things that I think excites church leaders is that what safe families can offer is they offer training and support that would help those families who are doing what they already are permitted to do, safe families would help them do that better. and so from a church leader standpoint that would be a tremendous resource to
help us help our people do what they're already doing and so that's one example another example which is a lot closer to home is that our church operates an after-school program in one of the urban parts of our community that's very economically challenged and one of the single moms in that program had to have surgery and the surgery was such that she was dismissed from the hospital was still a long recovery and literally was incapable physically of providing the
kind of care that she needed to provide for her children there was a member of her family who tried to help but unfortunately that that member of the family wasn't fully prepared and and couldn't do all that they needed to do so over time things begin to deteriorate in the family child begins to act out and eventually unfortunately DHS had to step in and take those children and when I think about that situation I often think what if what if a family in our
church could have could have helped that mom for a few days or a few weeks until she got back on her feet and could have cared for her children and said, I'm not sure that we served those children well in what happened. So I would urge consideration for this bill because it would help us do better what we're already doing, and I think it would reduce significantly the number of children who are actually going into foster care. So thank you for the opportunity to speak.
Thank you. Are there questions from the committee? Thank you. Representative Meeks, you had mentioned possibly pulling your bill down for today. What is your wish? Yeah, I'm going to go ahead and
pull it down, because I was going to try to do it on the Senate end, but I will go ahead and amend the bill with that particular thing. I'm going to get with Representative Tucker and also Representative Gray and see if I can address maybe some of their concerns as well, and then I'll be glad to bring the bill back before the committee.
Okay. Thank you, Representative Meeks. We will move to House Bill 1060, and I believe Representative Birch is presenting this bill today.
And Representative Birch, you are recognized. Thank you, Madam Chair. This is going to sound very familiar to everybody in the room because this was actually presented or at least initiated last week. And there was a question that was presented by Representative Walker with regard to a particular word in the statute. It wasn't one that's being changed. It wasn't one that was affected by the change being brought with this bill. It was one that was actually already in the statute. and that word was menacing, and I see that he's not here today,
but now, Chair, with your permission, I'd like to provide the definition that Colonel Wood provided out of a 1988 military justice case. Yes, please. Bear with me, because it's really interesting language. It's in U.S. v. Burnett, which is 27 military justice, 99 case, 1988 case again, and it defines the term from a military justice perspective. It says, the employment of the single descriptive term menacing has the effect of excluding from the cognizance of the court the use in its presence of improper words which yet do not express or involve a threat or defiance.
Thus language, however disrespectful, if it be not of a monotious character cannot, unless actually amounting to or creating a disorder, be made the occasion of summary proceedings and punishment as for a contempt. What that basically could be translated in is if it's not really egregious, you're not going to be able to use that.
Again, I propose that this definition and the change in this proposed statute with regard to military justice punishment for contempt has nothing to do. It's not being changed. It was just in response to the question by Representative Walker, basically, if I'm in front of a court-martial, in front of a judge, and he thinks I'm being menacing, or she thinks I'm being menacing, what might happen? And again, with regard to this particular bill, that was a great aside, and I'd love to provide that
to anybody that wants to try to read it and further define it for their own self. But the provision in the bill that's before us today, Madam Chair, is with regard to changing the punishment such that it doesn't exceed confinement for 30 days or a fine of $500, as opposed to the original proposed fine or the original statutory language of the fine, which
was $100. Thank you, and we do recall hearing House Bill 1060 by Representative House last time our committee met.
Are there any questions by members of the committee? Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for or against this bill? Would you like to close for the bill, Representative Birch? I would, Madam Chair. Thank you. You're closed for the bill? I am closed. Oh, okay. Excuse me. I misunderstood that. My apologies. All right. What are the wishes of the committee? Okay.
We have a motion do pass for House Bill 1060. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Against, no. Congratulations, Representative Birch. Representative House, you have passed your bill. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, ma'am. Thank you. Is Representative Davis here to present his bill? Excuse me?
Okay. All right. I have not heard from him, so I'm assuming he will not be here today. All right. I see no further business before the committee, so with that, we are adjourned.
Agenda
REGULAR AGENDA Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1048 D. Meeks TO PERMIT VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; TO CREATE A LICENSE EXEMPTION CONCERNING VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1060 House CONCERNING THE MILITARY JUSTICE PUNISHMENT FOR CONTEMPT.
HR1004 Boyd URGING STATE AGENCIES IN ARKANSAS TO COOPERATE IN IMPROVING LITTER CLEAN-UP STATEWIDE.
HB1184 D. Meeks TO REQUIRE STATE BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS TO PROMULGATE RULES FOR TEMPORARY LICENSURE, CERTIFICATION, OR PERMITTING OF SPOUSES OF ACTIVE DUTY SERVICE MEMBERS.
HR1012 D. Meeks CONGRATULATING THE UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL ARKANSAS SUGAR BEARS WOMEN'S BASKETBALL TEAM ON AN HISTORIC SEASON.
HCR1006 Watson CONGRATULATING THE PRESCOTT HIGH SCHOOL CURLEY WOLVES FOOTBALL TEAM ON WINNING THE STATE 3A CHAMPIONSHIP.
HB1261 Davis TO AMEND THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE COMMITTEE RESPONSIBLE FOR RECOMMENDING A PERSON TO BE APPOINTED AS POET LAUREATE BY THE GOVERNOR; AND TO AMEND THE TERM LENGTH OF A POET LAUREATE.
DEFERRED Subtitle Sponsor Number
HB1059 House TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE OFFENSE OF VIOLATION OF AN ORDER OF PROTECTION; AND TO CRIMINALIZE THE VIOLATION OF A MILITARY ORDER OF PROTECTION.
Documents
No documents posted.
Speakers
Representative Charlene Fite Chair
Unverified
Representative Justin Boyd
Unverified
Debbie Doss
Unverified
Speaker 30
Representative Danny Watson
Unverified
Representative Carlton Wing
Unverified
Speaker 47
Representative Charles Blake
Unverified
Representative LeAnne Burch
Unverified
Speaker 63
Representative Frances Cavenaugh
Unverified
Speaker 78
Speaker 84
Representative Vivian Flowers
Unverified