Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Revenue and Taxation Committee

January 26, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·1:16:53
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (14)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1162 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1162 C. Fite TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX, SA…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1028 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1031 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1037 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1037 Wardlaw TO REGULATE THE SALE OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY; AN…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1153 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS"…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1203 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1203 Holcomb TO PROVIDE FOR A RECOVERY FEE ON THE RENTAL OF HEAV…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1221 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1225 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSUR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1227 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES;…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1252 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1253 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PR…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1263 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB114 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB114 Hester TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR PUBLISHING NOTICE OF D…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB115 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB115 J. Hendren TO CREATE THE TAX REFORM AND RELIEF ACT OF 2017;…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
I'm going to, I'm going to, yeah. Thank you. Thank you. This meeting is in order. Members, today we're going to listen to House Bill 1162, starting it, and Representative Feit, are you ready to present your bill, ma'am? I am. Please proceed to the end of the table, and you recognize yourself and you're free to proceed, ma'am. Excuse me, ma'am, before you start. Members in the audience, staff has a sign in sheet to speak for or against the bill. If anybody wants to speak for and against the bill, please sign in. Governor Griffin, you don't have to do that, sir. You're recognized to be the first person to speak for the bill. He has a prior commitment, so we're going to forward him that opportunity. So please sign in to speak for or against the bills. Thank you. Representative Fayette,
▶ Play
you're free to proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, members of the committee. In almost every meeting I attend here in the Capitol, and this is my third term, I have heard that we want to attract more jobs to Arkansas. We want to make Arkansas a good jobs magnet. is a term that I hear frequently. We also say, to attract jobs, we need a skilled workforce. Ladies and gentlemen, we have a skilled workforce. Unfortunately, they are leaving our state, and they are going to Tennessee, Missouri, Oklahoma, Texas, Missouri, Alaska, Maine. They are not staying here in Arkansas. Who is this skilled, highly trained workforce? Who is this workforce that is ready to go to work, has experience, have already been proven to be drug free, have skills that we need in our state? They are our experienced, retired military. These retirees are typically aged 38 to 44. Why are they leaving? How can we retain them? That's what we're here to talk about today. I have with me Lieutenant Governor Tim Griffin. I also have somewhere Senator Jake Files, who will be coming to help me present this bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative. Thank you, Chairman, Committee. I have a much higher view of you now, Chairman. I know you were in the Air Force. That's right. I'd have laid off of you over all the years if I'd have known you'd been in the Air Force the whole time. You know, I'm in the Army. Not all of us can be in the Air Force. Yeah, me and Colonel Jim Hendry got something in common. Yeah, well, let's just say I appreciate your service. Thanks for letting me testify about this. I want to take a little different, bring a little different perspective, I think, on this, because we've all seen the talking points, and there's a lot of great information in there. And Representative Fayette has made a lot of good points about keeping the talent here. All you got to do is look at not only neighboring states, but states across this country have tax laws, to be frank, that are a lot better than ours. Our tax code's a mess from top to bottom, in my view, but on this particular point, they're beating us. Now, why are they making changes? Why are they doing things like this? Well, yeah, they want to show they care for veterans. But they also know that there's an advantage in keeping military retirees in the state. So much so that the state of Iowa launched a whole campaign, website, the whole deal, basically saying, hey, y'all come here. They don't say y'all up there, but they say, you come here. This is where we want you to settle because we understand the value that you bring to the state. States are going out of their way to do this because it benefits the state, and it doesn't cost a ton of money to do it. I would argue that the upside is much greater than any cost. So we know other states are doing it. and we've heard stories, I've heard stories, a lot of the folks in this room can tell you stories of people that were living here and left because of the tax code, plain and simple. That's the reason a lot of military have residences in Florida and Texas. Now, whether they're actually in Florida and Texas doesn't really matter because when you're in the military and you're moving around as part of your career, You can basically pick anywhere you want. I challenge you to survey military members who are moving around the world and ask how many picked Arkansas as their own record tax address. Not many. Right? Well, we shouldn't be offended by that. We should be moved to action. Right? We ought to try to fix that. But so I think the idea of an exemption for military pay, I think the value of it and all the different positives, I've mentioned some of them. A lot of people here have talked about it. MOA and a lot of the different groups, AUSA and American Legion, Various Foreign Wars, Purple Heart, a bunch of these groups. And I'm a member of most of them. They've made a great case for this. But I want to bring a little different approach here at the end because there seems to be some confusion about what is a retiree in the military. Because if you talk to a lot of folks who have not been in the military or who are not familiar with the military rules, they're different. And a lot of folks may not know what that is Because in a lot of government, you can work a few years, and you may not get the full deal, but you get some kind of retirement, right? You can work for the federal government. I think you invest in five years, right? And you work here, and you can invest in five years. And you don't have to work 20, for example. Well, that's not the military, okay? So military retirees, by definition, are people who have spent 20 years. 20 years, okay? Why is that important? Because someone could spend a few years, get some good training, move on to another career, and not be invested in it the way you are when you spend 20 years. When you spend 20 years doing logistics, security, avionics, whatever, medicine, when you spend 20 years, you're not just doing that at one of five or six jobs throughout your life. You have put an enormous amount of time and energy in your education, in your training, and what you're doing. That's what we're talking about. And here's the beauty, folks. The federal government's paid for it. We don't have to train these people. They're already trained. How do I know? I'm getting a master's degree in the Army from the Army War College right now. And I'm not paying for it. The Army is. I've been going on 21 years. If I would have gotten out at 19 years, you know how much retirement I get? Zero. Zero. Zero. So we are talking about people who have been in a significant chunk of their lives, have put enormous amount of effort into training and education. They are being served up to the states on a silver platter. This is a ready-made worker, economic development engine, job creator, and participatory citizen. These are people that vote, that are involved in their community. If you've been in 20 years, you're not an E1, an E2, an E3, right, a private. If you've been in 20 years, you've accumulated some rank, you've reached some rank, either as an NCO or as an officer, as a warrant officer or whatever. And so that's the sort of people we're talking about. 90% of this room probably knows all that because there's a lot of veterans in here. But there are a lot of people I've talked with, is that fair, that don't know that. I think that's fair. And you know what? They'd have no reason to know it unless they're in this system. I knew it because if I got out a year early, no retirement, right? Wasn't going to happen. So those are the type of people we're talking about. And I want to give you one specific example of the type of people, and there's tons of people we want to keep here. But I'm going to mention this because I had a lieutenant colonel write an email. He's trying to get, this is a separate issue, school choice. He was right and made, he wanted his kid to go to a particular school. Can't do it because of the rules. But he wrote me about this because he's coming to Arkansas. it's his next stop at the air base. And I'm not going to get into too many specifics. I don't want to embarrass him. But I'm getting enough specifics. This is a lieutenant colonel who is being moved here. And at the bottom of his email was this. Ph.D. candidate, security studies, Princeton, U.S. Air Force. The United States Air Force is paying for this gentleman to get his Ph.D. in security studies from Princeton. When this guy's done, I want him and his family to stay here. And if they move away, I want them to come back. Because this guy's got something. He's got leadership skills, I'm sure, and he's got something to contribute. And so it seems to me, not only are we competing for jobs with other states, we're competing for human talent. And the laws we make, the policies we have, have a big impact on that. And that's why I think giving military retirees an additional reason, In addition to having the best people in the world, and I was having dinner with some folks last night who said, we moved from Michigan, I tell you what, people of Arkansas, no better anywhere. In addition to having natural beauty, in addition to being a great place to live, all that stuff, let's give them another reason to make Arkansas their home and show appreciation for their 20 years plus of service to our country and exempt their income tax. Thank you all. Thank you, Lieutenant Governor.
▶ Play
Will you take questions, sir? Sure. The second, Representative Hendren, I've got one right out of the gate. First of all, I commend you for your military service, and I know there's a lot of veterans in this room. I know Colonel Don Barry is here and Ken Griffin, Mr. Heater. and to all the other veterans in this room, I certainly appreciate your service. I'm a retired, my dad's a retired military vet and lived all over the world, and I'm Air Force also, so I understand what you guys are asking for, and I'm going to support this. But my question always comes down to, at the end of the day, is the money part. Do you support, sir, how we are paying for this?
▶ Play
That's a good question. I'm glad you asked it. No, you're not. Yes, I am. I learned in Congress that there's a lot of bills. In fact, I learned in Congress that pretty much every bill has a good side and a side that you don't think is as good. I voted for a lot of things that had stinkers in it because the overall good was better than the overall bad. I'm not the governor. I'm not a legislator. I have my preferences. Most people know that I might do things a little differently. But I'm not here to try to replace your judgment or the governor's judgment with mine. uh i'm happy to tell you in private how i do things maybe a little differently but uh ultimately i think the good of this bill regardless of what pay for you choose within reason um i think the positive way far outweighs the negative uh there's a there's uh Most bills that you have to vote for in the legislature have a stinky side to them, meaning it's not your ideal deal, not your ideal bill. But I'm here because I believe the good outweighs the bad, and particularly as it relates to this Vets deal. Now, let me say this, if I can, since you asked, and I appreciate the question. I really do appreciate the question, because I think transparency and honesty is a good thing. I am encouraged by the willingness that I've heard from some folks to look at the entire tax code. I have long been an advocate, sometimes loud, sometimes quiet, for starting over with a blank sheet of paper on the tax code. I do not mean the income tax. I mean the entire code. Our code is indefensible. Our code is too complex. Our code hurts job growth. Our code is not competitive. Our code, in some rankings, is a joke. That's just a fact. And our code, this was acknowledged in a way by President, then Governor Clinton in 1979, if I have my dates right. Now, our code is so bad that we have to give one of our border towns an exemption from it. Am I right? Yeah, I think we know about this, don't we? Texarkana? And let me say for the record, I fully support the relief they get. I think they ought to keep it. If they were up to me, we'd give a bunch more people relief. If I were a border town, I'd say, why not me? And then I'd say, well, this is 2016. It's not like if you're 30 miles from the border, you don't compete with Texas. I mean, come on. The whole state competes with Texas. The fact that folks in 1979, if I have my date right, gave an exemption to one of our towns because the code was so bad that people were moving across the border. The fact that we didn't fix the code, we didn't take the miners out of the coal mine, we just put a respirator on the canary, that tells you all you need to know. You don't listen to Tim Griffin. Listen to the folks that did that back then. So the fact that there's a willingness to look at the whole deal encourages me And it's part of the reason why, in the intermediate to short term, I am more understanding of some of the pay-fors that are floating around this side. So that's a long answer to a short question. Thank you, sir. And also,
▶ Play
I'm in agreement with just about everything you said. And I would commend your record serving in Congress. You served with a distinction, and I certainly appreciate that. So you certainly understand the position that we are in here today. Thank you, sir. I'd like to ask one more pointed question. Yes, sir. If you will. In my district, I have approximately 28,000 folks in my district, and I have probably around 2,000, best I can tell from the last of the consensus from the United States, of 2,000 folks. So basically, out of the 28,000 folks in my district not getting a tax cut, if you were still serving in my capacity or your capacity as a United States congressman and this happened, how could you go back to those other 28,000 folks saying we're not going to give them some type of tax relief and we're giving
▶ Play
the veterans a tax relief? Well, if I were in charge, we'd be given a whole bunch more tax relief than you can. Well, I'd give them all tax relief. But let me say this. But let me say this. I want to give, I think, as part of tax reform, I think the whole tax code, the whole tax code can be reformed. Corporate, business, franchise, income, property, a property tax system. Talk to the people that oversee the consistency across the different counties. A lot of it, they don't even understand some of what's going on. So I think there's the first thing I'd say to them, there's an opportunity to give everybody relief. But the other thing I would say is we do a lot of things for veterans that's unique, okay? That's not a new thing. We give, not everybody can go to a commissary. We have certain discounts that people get because of their service. Why do we do that? because we as a society, including your 28,000, I would say a high percentage of them, if not all of them, recognize that when veterans serve, particularly 20 years, they're making a sacrifice on behalf of the country. And I would say that most citizens in your district or anywhere else, if you tell them that you're showing more appreciation and you're trying to recruit more military people here, most of them have no problem, no problem. doing that for veterans. No problem. I have never found anyone say, I've never heard anyone say to me, you're always taking care of veterans, you're not taking care of, I've never heard anyone say that. Americans don't, by and large, do not feel that way. So I would say that, but number two, I would say, I'm for relief for everybody. And I also understand the pay for thing, and that's why I've said repeatedly, the only way we're ever going to have enough money to play with to get to comprehensive bold tax reform is if we walk through a door, and that door is called massive, bold, innovative government reform, top to bottom, blank sheet of paper. That's the only way you're ever going to find the savings to do the kind of bold tax reform that I think needs to be done. I know you didn't ask me that, but I think a complete picture here is important, and I really appreciate you letting me talk. Thank you, Thank you, Chairman. Thank you for
▶ Play
your service. God bless all y'all. Appreciate it. Do you have time for one more question? Yes, I
▶ Play
do. Representative Hendren, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I would just respectfully ask that the Chair and Governor Griffin give me a little bit of time, like you all have taken, to present your question and your answers, if that's possible. Sure. Let me begin by framing it this way. I am not a veteran. I attempted to be that at the University of Arkansas in Fayetteville. I took two years of basic ROTC in the Air Force, by the way. Passed all the tests to become a pilot, went to Oklahoma City, and they said, you can't do it because you're going to be a pup. No, they didn't say that. They said, you can't do it because you're colorblind, as about half of the men are. And then I said, well, if I can't drive, I'll just wait and take my chances. This was in 1958, and I just married a lady, and so we came back to Arkansas, And I didn't go into advanced ROTC at the U of A in Fayetteville and then graduated in 60. In the meantime, this woman I married started having kids. And as you know, back then, you can get deferment if you have kids. So I've never served in the active military. And that makes me every time I go to Branson or anywhere else and sit in a theater and they recognize veterans, I feel embarrassed and I feel sorry that I did not serve. That's a personal idea. And I respect those who do. And as most of you know, I have a son now that I'm very proud and a grandson who is actively flying F-15 Strike Eagles right now. So I think Mary Lee and I can take some credit for being involved in that, as I'm sure most veterans give other families that don't actively serve. And I talked to a gentleman last night that served in Vietnam. And some of us back in those ages remember that and some of the abuse those people talk. So let me just preface that, Mr. Chairman and Governor, with saying that I'm not anti-veteran. But I am for responsibility. And so getting back specific to this bill now, Governor, you talked about your background in Congress down here. And I'd say my Congress and my background in 20 out of the 40 last years down here, and then a lifetime in business and manufacturing and education and what have you, that's where I'll frame my question I'm going to ask. Number one, I am for this bill, period. But I am not sitting at this table and saying I'm for everything and let's pass everything and then I can get re-elected when I go back for re-election. You can't be for everything and then not decide how to pay for it. And my question is this. We just passed a bill two days ago in the Arkansas House of Representatives that cost $50 million to give a so-called tax cut to the people under $21,000. We passed another. The next bill failed, that cost $40 million, that actually gave more of a tax cut to the people under $21,000 than that one did. So that's what bothers me. Now, we all say we're for this. As I read this bill, what this does, this raises taxes on soft drinks. Because of lobbyists and lobbyists down here, it changed from increased tax on manufacturing housing to now that some of the constituents have told me it's an additional tax on students at the University of Arkansas and others many a time that their parents and family are having a hard time. I'm talking about digital stuff. And as you go down and look through this, and I've got a bunch of other notes that I'm going to say here, we talk about we're for all this. How are we going to pay for the foster kids' care in this state? How are we going to pay for prisons? How are we going to take care of highways and say, I'm for all this. Let's just pass it all. No, we don't do it. We come through with a bill today that's been amended to now taxing some of our students that are having the hardest time getting through education. And so, Governor, my question to you and to the chairman as well, how are we going to pay for this? And we're for it, but how are we going to pay for it? I'm for it if we can pay for it, but I'm not in for it to tell somebody to let somebody else pay for it. So, Governor Griffin, how would you pay for this? Period. Let me be real clear. First of all, you have no reason to be embarrassed that you had a a medical issue. You've served in other ways. You and I have become buddies, and I appreciate your service, and you shouldn't spend your money in Missouri. If you're up in Branson, then that's part of the problem. And I'm not even sure because you can spend your money out of state whether I need to answer the rest of the question, but I will. I was for this bill. I sat in I don't know, this room looks a lot nicer than it was two years ago. Was something happening here? Yeah. Golly, if we make this a little longer, we might have to spend smoke signals. So I was here in this chair up there somewhere two years ago for this bill. And for, not for this bill, but for the general concept of what this bill represents. You know, the pay-fors are changing. That's, you know. And I don't know who you're talking about, but you're not talking about me if you're talking about being for everything. You clearly, maybe we haven't gotten to know each other well enough if you think I'm for everything. That's just false. As far as education downloads, I think they're exempted, but here's the deal. I am here to testify to the value of this exemption. I, as I said every bill that we pass whether it be here or some other body usually has a part you like and a part you don't like there are very few where you go I like everything in this bill but you still vote for them because you think the positive outweighs the negative now I know there's some people in this room who'd like me to be a cheerleader for every line in this bill that ain't going to happen because most people wouldn't buy what I was saying anyway I'd have no credibility. I'm for the bill because I'm for the veterans exemption. I have my own preferences on pay for, but that's not why I'm here. And I'm not the governor. Don't pretend to be. And I'm leaving that to the governor and the people that make the laws, the legislature. I've got my ideas. Happy to share them with you. Not why this nice lady here that I've known for a long time, not why she invited me here to get into the details of her bill. She can answer those. But I can tell you, without getting into any more specifics, there are a myriad of ways, there are a myriad of ways to pay for the amount that's in this tax relief. Regardless of how that ends up, and I'll certainly have an opinion on that, In deference to the governor and to the chairman and the legislators, I'm going to not get into that. But regardless, the exemption itself is needed by the state. It is important. And I think we'll be in better shape if we pass it. So out of deference to the governor and the lawmakers, I'm not going to get into a debate about the pay-fors. just suffice it to say I've got my own opinion on that thank you thank you Governor I know you have a prior commitment Senate may be out by now well they probably went home by now I'll go check on them thank you all thank you sir
▶ Play
appreciate your testimony Mr. Chair may I call to the table with me Senator Jake Files yes ma'am you may
▶ Play
Speaker 8 28:59
is he in the room no he probably went home with the rest of the
▶ Play
Senators you may sit him down Please, he was supposed to be here. Maybe somebody from DFA wants to go down to the end of the table. I think we're fixing to hit that part of how we're paying for this. I think we probably pretty much, I think everybody knows where they are on the veterans issue. Now we're down to the nuts and bolts, the money part of it. Representative Gray, you going to have a question? Hold that just for a second. Let's see if we can find
▶ Play
Speaker 22 29:36
Senator Jake Files. Is Senator Files not in the room,
▶ Play
ma'am? Okay, I'll move down. Okay, we're going to proceed. Members, let's proceed until we get Senator Files in the room. He's helped on some of the amendments, and also the amendment has been engrossed into Representative Fayette's bill. So, Representative Gray, are you good to proceed with
▶ Play
Speaker 49 29:57
her, sir? Yes, sir, my question doesn't have to do with the digital download part at all. You're good to go, buddy. Thank you. Representative Fite, I know that this bill, the portion that we've been discussing that the governor was discussing was also in a previous bill that you pulled down. because the tax increases to pay for the exemption that we're speaking of had to be added in. But I'm a little confused. I understand that we've got to figure out how to pay for it, to represent a hindrance point. And the tax increases that have been put in this bill to do that. But my real confusion is there's another tax cut in this bill. And so while, once again, we may all have different opinions on how we pay for the veterans' exemption, I don't think there's much dissent that the veterans' exemption is something we should be pursuing. But can you explain why, in this bill, there's another tax cut? I mean, how does that fit with the veterans' exemption? I'm just really confused. Well,
▶ Play
first of all, this is not a veterans' exemption.
▶ Play
Speaker 49 31:08
I mean, excuse me, military retiree's benefits.
▶ Play
This is military retiree pay exemption. We need to be very clear about that. This bill is revenue neutral, and I have sent you all a statement from DFA explaining how this is revenue neutral. I'm not sure what you're referring to, can you tell me exactly where the bill it is, in the bill it is?
▶ Play
Speaker 49 31:27
Yeah, well, I'm looking at the fiscal impact, Representative Phype from DF&A that it absolutely is revenue neutral. And forgive me for using the wrong terminology on the military retiree benefits. My question would go to the last bulleted item in the fiscal impact where it would amend the special excise tax levied on soft drink and simple syrups and under the current law, so on and so forth, and it reduces those amounts, which is an issue I've been aware of for a few years. I just didn't realize it was tied to the military retiree benefits package. So I'm just interested in why that is in this bill.
▶ Play
Well, I will leave some of those finer details to the gentleman from DF&A. But we were very committed to showing how this will be paid for. We believe, and we have studies to back up, that this will pay for itself after a number of years, after perhaps four to five years. But we wanted to show immediately how this will be paid for. So therefore, we looked at a lot of different areas, And these were the ones that were suggested that would show exactly how, from the very beginning in 2018, this will become revenue neutral. And I will leave some of the questions for
▶ Play
Speaker 49 32:50
DF&A. Yes, I appreciate that. And I don't mean to belabor the point, so please accept my apology if I seem to be. I feel as you do that we will see over time that this policy change will more than pay for itself in the human capital to the point that Governor Griffin made that the laws we pass and the policies we make affect the people we get here in Arkansas. So I couldn't agree more with you, and I also respect that to make things revenue neutral, sometimes we're not all going to agree on what increases have to be in place. My question is more so with the other tax cut that's in this bill, not with the tax increases, because I think they're an unfortunate necessity in this bill. My question is with the other tax
▶ Play
Speaker 59 33:45
cut in this bill. Good morning, my name is Paul Gehring. I'm the Assistant Commissioner for Policy and Legal with the Department of Finance and Administration. The portion of the veteran's retirement pay that caused the revenue reduction needed to be offset. And in order for the governor's tax plan, in order to be revenue neutral, we had to combine several elements of taxes. And one of those was to make the candy and soft drinks be subject to the full state sales tax rate. However, there was also a decision that was made in putting together this tax plan that the responsibility for collection of the tax to move that when soft drinks are involved, you move them from the tax that's collected at the wholesale level instead and have that collected at the retail level. Excuse me just a second, Senator Jake Files is going to go
▶ Play
down. I think he might be able to answer your question, Representative Gray. Senator Files, you get to the end of the table, recognize yourself, sir. And then, Representative Gray, if you please repeat your question to Senator Jake Files.
▶ Play
Speaker 66 34:52
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Senator Jake Files, Chair
▶ Play
Speaker 49 34:56
of Revenue and Tax and Senate. Senator Files, good morning, thank you. My question was, there's been plenty of debate and lobby over the increases that we have to put in this bill to pay for the military retirement benefit exemption, and I'm not here to re-debate that with you. My question was more so to the other tax cut that's in this bill on the, which is the last bulleted item in the fiscal impact, which is amending the excise tax levied on simple syrups and soft drinks. And so that was the question we were at, not so much the offsets that are being associated with the benefits. Okay, and the question was specifically- How that relates or why it would be included in the equation to the military retirements retiree benefits exemption. The revenue neutral portion I understand, but it seems like this is another tax cut that's riding the coattails. Forgive the expression of the military retiree benefits.
▶ Play
Speaker 66 35:59
Sure, sure, and it's a good question, and I think it's a fair question. This thing was formulated probably without a lot of our, not necessarily input, but there were a lot of different factors that went into putting these things together. And had it been in an ideal situation, I don't think these things would be joined like this, but they are. And I think it starts at the top with the military side and the impetus and the will for most, I think, most of us to do that. And in getting to that point, all the other things, which include the ones you're talking about, get there. And so would I have done it this way? Probably not, but it is this way. And so I don't disagree that it seems like it's right in the coattails. This is something that has been talked about in the past of doing. So I think this was a way to achieve probably two goals at one time and make it revenue neutral at the same time. So I don't know that that specifically answers your question. But that's the best I think I can do with what it is and where we are.
▶ Play
Speaker 49 37:06
Thank you, Senator. Mr. Chairman, to DF&A, since they addressed it one quick and I'll let the point go. Thank you, Senator, I appreciate that. Sir, you said that in explaining this that we are shifting because of the increase in the sales tax to the consumer. We are, to neutralize that, we are lowering the cost of the tax to the corporate interest and raising the tax on the consumer, is that a correct analysis of your explanation?
▶ Play
Speaker 59 37:37
That's a fair assessment. Currently, you have, in this bill discussed, there are two components that affect soft drinks. You have a tax that is leveled at the wholesale level, and that's the soft drink tax or the soda tax. And you also have, currently in Arkansas law, you have both candy and soft drinks that are purchased at the retail level. They are taxed at the reduced rate for tax for groceries. So under this bill, what you would have is that the tax would primarily, well, the component of the taxes in this bill is going to be the $13.8 million that will be collected additionally at the retail level, and there will be a less tax collected at the
▶ Play
Speaker 49 38:21
wholesale level. Mr. Chairman, thank you for your indulgence, and thank you all for your answers. Representative Fyde, thank
▶ Play
you for bringing this bill. Thank you, Representative Gray. Representative Les Eves,
▶ Play
you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, I want to go on record and say I absolutely support the main function of this bill being the exemption of military retired pay. I think we're doing some good work there. I understand all the points. I don't like how we're getting there, and I don't like the bad parts that are in this bill. I don't like how we're paying for it, to be honest with you. I know manufacturing homes were in it at one point, and now we're adding in digital items, I guess. So, going record saying that, my real question is this, and I'm not really sure what all these digital downloads are going to be all about. Are there going to be students downloading digital books at college? Are those exempt? We all are pretty much aware that Amazon doesn't collect sales tax and remit it to Arkansas. You can download books, videos, music on Amazon. Will they at some point, are going to be required to collect the sales tax on that because we're now adding in this bill. So I don't really understand how we're going to get there, and I don't really understand how we ended up putting digital products in the bill that on its face value is such an honorable thing, I think, and the right thing to do. And I don't have any preference on who answers that question, if you can. anyone down on the end
▶ Play
Speaker 66 40:00
of the table. I'll start it. It's a good question. And, you know, I think the alternative, I agree with the premise of your question where you start. And the alternative would have been to find spending cuts to offset this. And I think that would be preferred. At this point, there hasn't been any offered up. And so to maintain the sensitivity of the budget and the balanced budget as we move forward, there has to be something in that line. Otherwise, we just We lop everything off except the veteran's cut to do the, quote, honorable thing, and then we find it at revenue stabilization. We did that two years ago, and that's when the libraries got cut and all of us heard about it, although not all of us were involved in that cut-making process. So I think with where we are, this is really the best-case scenario at this current time. Having said that, I would prefer to do it a different way, like I said a while ago. So moving on to your specific question, we will have a bill later that I filed to deal with the Amazon side of things. But it is clear in here about which digital products are being taxed. And in looking at that, we're going to run our bill in the Senate on Monday. Between now and then, if something pops up that somebody finds something, there's lawyers all over the state and probably the country looking at this to make sure that they're not incorrectly assessed or taxed. And so if we find something between now and then, I can assure you that we'll amend it and make sure that it's right on our end and then bring this one back as well. But that's about all the assurance I can give you in terms of that, just trying to make it revenue neutral. But I do agree with your premise, but the realities are where we are.
▶ Play
Let me follow up on that also, Senator Files. Members, what will happen is if it gets amended down on the Senate end or he brings his down, then it's also got to get concurred back here in this committee. So this deal is probably not over yet. Representative Collins, do you have a?
▶ Play
May I give a clarification about the other part of that question about educational products?
▶ Play
Speaker 8 42:06
Yes, ma'am, you may. Would you
▶ Play
Speaker 59 42:10
speak to that, please? Mr. Chair, currently in Arkansas law, textbooks and educational instructional materials that are purchased by a public school, They are exempt from gross receipts tax and use tax. So under this bill, if those public schools ought to purchase those books electronically, they will continue to be exempt under Arkansas law. Now, I know that there's been also some questions about, I think that Senator, I'm sorry, Representative Hendren mentioned about the textbooks that are purchased by college students. Those are subject to tax currently in Arkansas, and they would be subject to tax under this bill. Do you have a follow-up, sir? Yeah. Thanks
▶ Play
for that clarification. Do you know, you mentioned public universities. Will that also apply to private universities? It was public schools, public K through 12. All right, thanks for the clarification, thank you. And thank you to all the veterans and military personnel in the room. I appreciate your service. I just want to do
▶ Play
a little bit of housekeeping. I was told this and I never tell the members this. Members, anytime that you turn your microphones on and you pull your microphone to you, Somebody sitting upstairs with headphones on, you're probably bursting their drum. So just be aware of that. I've been chewed on that for like five times, and I've yet to tell you guys that. So from this moment on, let your conscience be your guide. So President
▶ Play
Collins, you're recognized, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Senator Fowles, appreciate you coming over to our end and gracing us with your presence over here. And I know that you've been working hard to solve the problem for another tax exemption reversal. so you have not had nearly as much time to square that circle as the previous exemption had. So I recognize we're running fast and appreciate your willingness to amend. I just want to make sure in the process of trying to achieve multiple objectives, one objective is an idea of revenue neutrality. Another one is the objective of fair tax collection, fair taxation, when we make a change. So, you know, if the answer is we're going to tax, you know, all milk, then it needs to be all milk. It can't be skim milk is exempt. So I just, as we're squaring that circle, I just want to make sure we're thinking about all of those elements so that we don't wind up with, if you deliver Internet services one way, it's taxed, but if you deliver them another way, it's not. So that company A has to collect or is taxed, but company B is not. So I know you're thinking about all those things. I know some people are talking to you about it. And I appreciate all the work that you're stuck doing over the next 72 hours.
▶ Play
Thank you, sir. Thank you. Representative Flowers, you're recognized, ma'am. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess my question would be to everybody at the end of the table who could ever answer it best, or maybe everyone has a different answer. But the concept of revenue neutrality clearly is a good one in terms of how everything comes out in the wash and is important when we're trying to make sure that we are able to and that we do pay for initiatives like this, for bills like this. And I'll say, too, that I was ready to vote on this bill two years ago, so there's no question about my support for the meat of this bill and what it would do, and no question about my respect for and support of our military veterans in general, and especially those who would retire and stay in the state. As a matter of fact, there are some, I have to give a shout out to Jefferson County and Pine Bluff who are here representing as citizens who are concerned about this. So that said, we also are here as legislators and making these kinds of decisions. And I appreciate this conversation and that we're able to flesh out publicly and these details in front of the folks who would be most affected in terms of the meat of the bill. One of the things I remember a couple of years ago when I was being lobbied about this is that this is something that would ultimately pay for itself. And we've talked about the economic benefit. We know the human capital, right? We've talked about the economic benefit and what would happen when people who are retiring here would stay in Arkansas and spend that money here, save that money here, invest that money here in a home, invest that money here in a business. And so recognizing that that's sort of one of the biggest benefits to this as opposed to other retirees and that in time we've seen in other states that this exemption for military retirees pays for itself, then my question would be for the tax increases, and that's what they are. At the end of the wash, it's a revenue neutral proposal, but incorporated in it, we have tax increases. So if we know that over time, the exemption for our military retirees would pay for itself, why wouldn't there be some sort of sunset on the tax increases that are incorporated in here to pay for this to make it truly revenue neutral? Is it really revenue neutral if we're going to continue to reap the benefits of the tax increases while the exemption will pay for itself over time?
▶ Play
Thank you for that question. I appreciate your support on this. As you know, we're going to be looking at our entire tax code system. We're going to be looking at everything. There are not going to be any sacred cows at that point. What we often do down here at the Capitol is come back in two years and do a tweak, a small change, sometimes a large change, to something that we have already passed. Certainly, we can do that. As this begins to pay for itself, we can come back and change things and change how we're showing it's going to be paid for right now from the very beginning. Mr. Chairman,
▶ Play
Speaker 66 48:59
if I may, Representative Flowers, that's a great point, and I think it's very true. I agree with you that all the things we've seen, this pays for itself. What we don't have the luxury of doing is taking that from the outset. And so looking at this five years down the road, it's my hope that we have greatly increased revenues and we can look at this population and say, look what we did five years ago and look at the benefits of the states deriving now on multiple levers. I think this is a great economic development tool for our state, and it's a jobs bill. So there's a lot of different facets of it, but I would hope that we would come back in two years and four years at whatever point and look at those increased revenues and take that opportunity to cut taxes again at that point by that measure. And some of the things that are in here, the digital downloads, I think some of that stuff is parity, and like Representative Collins was saying, And as we look across at milk's milk, books are books, CDs, music's music, some of this stuff, I hesitate to use the words need to be taxed. But if it's taxed in one place, in fairness, it ought to be taxed somewhere else just because of method of delivery. And so using those as a paradigm, I think our paradigms have shifted to where we're looking at capturing revenue and taking that captured revenue and immediately moving over and making things beneficial for all of our state and all of our citizens. So a great point. I
▶ Play
hope we do that. Follow-up? Yes, ma'am. I want to make a point in that when we look at, for example, the unemployment, the tax on unemployment benefits. That's a question. And, you know, the statement has been made that that is something that would affect all Arkansans all over the state. And while that's true, it wouldn't affect. I was about to pull this closer, and I just remembered
▶ Play
Speaker 94 50:52
you said it. They're cheering on you
▶ Play
from here on out. But while that's true, how something like that affects people, and I'll say in southeast Arkansas. So we heard at the top of the session when the governor made remarks, you know, the litany of cities and areas where we have seen job growth and jobs come to Arkansas. Nowhere in that list that the governor provided for us was a city in southeast Arkansas. And we're all aware of what unemployment looks like throughout that region of our state. And so taking into consideration that the last session, we, well, many of my colleagues voted to pass a bill to lower the amount of unemployment as well as lessen the time period in which Arkansans who've lost their jobs can collect that benefit that they, by the way, pay into as being working Arkansans, it doesn't have the same effect. And so it really does. While I'm very supportive of this bill and I'm trying to raise the point that we have to be very careful when we apply the concept and the rhetoric of revenue neutrality to something like this. People in Southeast Arkansas who are not yet seeing any benefits of job increase and job growth are going to be affected by something like this when you talk about attacks. And for many of us who may encounter, many of our people who may encounter a situation where they find themselves unemployed, 40% of, you know, $100,000, $80,000 is different than 40% of $20,000. And so I just want to leave that with you. And as we move into a situation where we're not expressing or outlining over time when this benefit would turn into a situation that it's not revenue neutral, I would first ask for someone from DF&A to maybe provide us, especially since this is something that could come back, more clarity on how the exemption might over time pay for itself so that we can have further discussion. And I guess the question is, wouldn't you agree? Thank you, because I was going to fix and
▶ Play
ask you if there was a question and there's some place.
▶ Play
We have an answer to that question.
▶ Play
Just a moment, please. And members, along those lines, just make sure we got a question in there. And Representative Flowers, a very good point brought up. So I kind of let it go, but make sure we got questions coming here because there's a period for debate. And this is just a question and answer session of
▶ Play
Speaker 59 54:10
this right now. So thank you, ma'am. Representative Flowers, I'm not sure if this addresses all of the questions or issues that you raised in your question, but we spoke with our income tax section. And they prepared a spreadsheet on the unemployment compensation issue impact. And we have some data based upon the Internal Revenue Service as well as Arkansas returns that were filed. Income tax has broken down the $3.2 million in increased general revenue from taxing unemployment benefits into five categories. Less than 25,000, 25,000 to 50,000, 50,000 to 75,000, 75,000 to 100, and over $100,000. There are, for the category of less than $25,000 of taxpayers with that income, under this, there would be no taxes collected from that group under this plan. Now from 25,000 to 50,000, we are projecting that 1.5 million would be collected. from $50,000 to $75,000, $808,000, $75,000 to $100,000, $454,000. And then over $100,000, the tax that we project to be collected would be $441,000. So it looks like the burden would not start until you received an income over $25,000. And then, of course, the two groups that would have the most impact, it's probably because there are more taxpayers that are in those groups, are the 25 to 50 and the 50 to 75. Thank you. Representative Scott
▶ Play
Balz. Hold that thought and we'll come back and recognize you, sir. Representative Gray. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Speaker 49 56:06
Question for the F&A, I think, Mr. Chairman, I'm looking at the revenue impact and specifically to fiscal year 2019 and help me out with my math here. But basically, in round numbers, $13 million hit to general revenue for the military retirement income tax exemption that would be paid for by the increase of the state sales tax on candy and soft drink products. Those basically, that is the offset for that tax exemption. Is
▶ Play
Speaker 59 56:45
that correct? That would offset, but there would be an additional $400,000 that would be applied to the other reduction. Okay,
▶ Play
Speaker 49 56:55
so my question would be, once again, and I don't mean to belabor the point, but we are all, I would feel like if in unanimous feeling that the tax exemption for military retiree benefits is a good and just cause that we're all here to pass. My question goes, once again, to this other tax cut. And so let's make sure the light is shined at whatever is said in the dark. It should be hard on the light. Let's make sure the light is shined on the rest of this bill. So my question is the increase of taxes on the digital downloads, while I think the debate on parity is a fair debate, and I think we should have it, But the increase on unemployment benefits and the increase on now digital downloads that was in a previous version, mobile homes, those are simply there to cover the, to make the other tax cut revenue neutral. Or they, they're there to make the other tax cut revenue neutral. So my question is, if the other tax cut, the corporate tax break, wasn't riding the coattails of the veterans or the military retirees exemption, would these other tax increases be
▶ Play
Speaker 59 58:14
necessary? Well, I believe that we, that's very similar to the question that you'd asked previously, that Senator files. I'm not sure that DFA would have any further explanation or analysis other than. Would we
▶ Play
Speaker 49 58:28
need those offsets to offset the hit to general revenue if it was simply the exemption for retiree benefits and the increase to the state sales tax that would cover that? Would we need the other exemptions? Well, as I
▶ Play
Speaker 59 58:44
just explained, the $13.8 for the Canyon Soft Drinks to be taxed at the full state sales tax rate would, in fact, offset the $13.4 with an additional $400,000. So those would not match up equally in order to make the bill general revenue neutral. So certainly in order to make a GR revenue neutral bill, there had to be other impacts to taxes that would affect GR. So there would be
▶ Play
Speaker 49 59:16
a $400,000 surplus. There'd be a GR gain, correct? Right. So my question would be there wouldn't be revenue negative. So the other tax cut being included in this bill is what That necessitates the need to add more offsets, if you will, into the bill. I think that may be
▶ Play
Speaker 59 59:37
a proper consideration when this policy was being drafted. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Sabin, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. And my question actually is about the fiscal impact, and it's for DF&A. But I feel obligated, like everybody else, to preface my question by saying that I do commend Representative Fyfe for bringing this proposal. I think everybody's very supportive of extending the tax exemption to military retirees for all of the reasons that you and the Lieutenant Governor articulated very well. So, again, my question really goes to the fiscal impact. And I wanted to bring up, you know, about 30 years ago, the legislature passed an income tax exemption on the first $6,000 in retirement income for Arkansas teachers and state employees. And there was actually a lawsuit that took place after that exemption was passed by federal retirees. And they sued and challenged that, you know, really the government couldn't limit that tax exemption just to the teachers and to the state employees. And they actually won that lawsuit. And it was a federal lawsuit. And the court held that the state income tax discriminated against retirees of the governments of other states and military retirees based upon the source of the payment. And therefore, the tax violated United States Code 4111 and the doctrine of intergovernmental tax immunity. And for the lawyers in the room, that case was in 1991. It's Pledger versus Bosnick. And so basically, as the law exists today, that first $6,000 of retirement income is actually exempt from income tax for all retirees, regardless of your career. And so when you're calculating the fiscal impact of this proposal, are you anticipating that basically a similar challenge could take place? And not just military retirees, but basically anybody who is receiving retirement income would then be exempt from our state income tax.
▶ Play
Speaker 59 1:01:45
Representative, we certainly try to anticipate any type of issues that a bill might present for possible litigation. Certainly, we'd be happy to take a closer look at the Bosnick case that she cited to see if that would be implicated. But when we look at the tax proposal, we're always mindful of challenges that may occur. but may not be actually based on a meritorious legal argument. But I'm not aware of any conclusion that we have made that this would violate any prior Supreme Court precedent in Arkansas.
▶ Play
Speaker 103 1:02:16
Representative Collins. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
I have a question for you. I'm wondering if we could make this a kumbaya moment, since it seems like we're all supply-siders now. Art Laffer would be quite happy. And I would submit in the spirit of that kumbaya moment that not only will cutting taxes for people that have to do with the military help grow the economy, but I feel just as strongly about the taxes that our nurses are paying, the taxes that our school teachers are paying, the taxes that our restaurant workers are paying, the taxes that our small business owners and farmers and all the other groups in Arkansas saw and that they too would generate the same kind of dynamic analysis and dynamic impact that we're doing here. So I went to the Naval Academy myself, my two sons are in the National Guard. My daughter's in the Navy Reserve, my other daughter works for the Department of the Air Force. My brother graduated from the Air Force Academy. My sister got an ROTC scholarship in the Air Force, my last brother also in the Air Force. So I love the military, but I also love our nurses and school teachers and all the others. So, Mr. Chair, could we have a
▶ Play
kumbaya moment? May I respond to that?
▶ Play
Is it a question? A kumbaya moment where we all just feel good together.
▶ Play
Well, I know what a kumbaya moment is, and I can even sing the song, but I wasn't sure about how to answer that other than to say we all have great respect for our nurses and for our teachers and some of the other groups that you mentioned. However, we don't have large groups of nurses ages 38 to 44 who are looking to come to Arkansas as compared to our border states and perhaps retiring here at age 38 to 44, beginning a second career, starting a business, buying a home, putting children in college, contributing to the Arkansas economy. If they were, then I think we would look at something similar for one of those groups.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Feight. Members, we're going to try to speed this up. We're kind of beating a
▶ Play
dead horse here now. Representative Neves. Thank you. All right, so if our goal here is to exempt a military retired income from income tax in the state of Arkansas, and the 6.5% state sales tax on candy and soft drinks takes care of that, I would like some clarification on why the other things are in there. If our goal is to exempt military retired pay, and we've got one line item here on state sacks on candy and soft drinks, why is it necessary to have all these other things, these
▶ Play
Speaker 59 1:05:13
other three things in there? Thank you, Representative. DFA, when we are tasked to do a fiscal impact, we are tasked to look at the bill, what it does, if it causes any administrative problems for the department. and we also are tasked to provide the fiscal impact. In terms of the policy questions on why things are done a certain way, I certainly would always defer to the governor's staff or to the sponsors of the bill. So certainly I think that in that respect, DFA wouldn't have any additional information other than what we've responded to in the questions in the community today. Anyone else at the end
▶ Play
of the table might could offer some insights to help me understand that. Representative Ease,
▶ Play
Speaker 66 1:05:50
I'll just go back to what I said earlier. This is the bill that was brought, and this is the package of items that come together to make it happen. I think all of us would have supported a veterans bill that didn't have anything else in it, but somebody's got to figure out how to pay for that to maintain the governor's balanced budget and us to walk out of here without making cuts to other things. So in light of that, I think that's where we are, and we sit with the bill in front of us and move forward. It's not perfect, but it's part of the process. And I can feel your pain in looking at the different items and going, I don't like this. And I told one of my constituents last week, I wish there was a yes, no, I'd change something to make this a better bill box, but there's not. So it's just up or down. So thank
▶ Play
you. Thank you, members. Let's do this. No more questions we have on queued up. Let's go back to the audience, people speaking for or against the bill. Representative Fyte, you good with that, ma'am? Yes, thank you. Okay. Members, is there anybody in the audience that want to speak against the bill? Here's what we're going to do, people in the audience. We're not, when we start chasing a rabbit, we're going to let everybody try to speak. But when we start hearing kind of the same thing over and over, then we're going to kind of put a stop to the process. We've been at this for about an hour and a half now. So is there anybody in the audience want to speak against this bill? Anybody in the audience want to speak for the bill? Yes, sir. Can you go down at the end of the the
▶ Play
table and recognize yourself can you can you push your microphone I'm sorry about that my name is Gary Fletcher I'm the mayor of city of Jacksonville I have the privilege of being the home of Little Rock Air Force Base and get to live among America's heroes there. I just want to say that without repeating a lot of stuff and being respectful of your time, just to put some testimony to a test that was posed here, about seven or eight weeks ago, Amy Madison, who's from our Jacksonville Chamber of Commerce, and I had the privilege of going to New Hampshire to Sig Sire, a company that a year ago the governor announced would bring 50 jobs to Arkansas, specifically to Jacksonville. While we was there, that number's been raised to 125. And I want to say that, and Amy can testify to this as well, is the fact that they were very excited about the military there because they understand the caliber of workmanship and the training and the type of individuals these are. And so while sometimes we look at what something costs on the front end, and I respect you having to do that. I had to do that in the city budget. As you know, it's difficult with Internet sales, and even the lotteries are hurting seats, quite honestly, as well. But, you know, it's easy to see the cost from the front end, but there's also a cost always associated with doing nothing as well. And I think if we're going to be competitive in this global economy, we at least need to be competitive with the states around us as well. So I appreciate anything you can do, and I just want to say I'm out there every two weeks, and I get to address the newcomers every two weeks out there, and I always talk about the great things about Arkansas. And I'll tell you something, some of the greatest talented people, I think it's one half of one percent of the men and women wear that uniform. And I've been in that tarmac at 2 o'clock in the morning when I've seen an hour before that those 200 soldiers were saying goodbye to their families in a hangar. And I was thinking at that time that my wife and that night, my two granddaughters went to sleep in a safe world, expect to wake up in a safe country. And that just don't happen because we're America. It's because of the men and women that make that sacrifice, but also their spouses and their children pay a price too. So I appreciate anything you can
▶ Play
do to help our military. Thank you, sir. Anybody? Yes, sir. Please go to
▶ Play
Speaker 112 1:09:43
the end of the table and recognize yourself. Thank you, Chair. I'm Nathaniel Todd, retired military, retired three years ago. The Army sent me to get a master's in health care administration. I've been able to use that, coming back to our state, to provide health care for our veterans. In that, I've lived in Oklahoma, a station in Oklahoma, and in Texas. And coming to Arkansas was something that I wanted to do. I share with coming home to Arkansas, I am from Jefferson County, I share with you that military retirees make this decision every day. And for us that were born and raised in Arkansas to come home, I just purchased a house. I think the taxes on that is going to be about $3,600. In addition to that, I paid tuition in five Oklahoma schools. Well, if I can get some of my grandkids to come back and go to school in Arkansas, I'll pay that tuition in Arkansas. So I think that this, as Representative Flowers has said, I think that this bill will help our economy in bringing a workforce and those that will buy homes and hopefully their grandchildren will come back to our estate. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, sir. Members,
▶ Play
anybody else in the audience want to speak for or against the bill? If not, Representative Flatt, you want to close
▶ Play
for your bill, ma'am? Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, in closing, I ask a question to someone I trust very much, my son-in-law, Brian. Now, Brian will not benefit from this bill if we pass it. However, Brian is in constant contact with many military men who are ready to retire. And Brian told me they talk about this constantly, and they say, why would I retire in Arkansas? I could retire anywhere. I could go to Tennessee, I could go to Missouri, I could go to any number of states in the United States and not immediately take a hit on my retirement pay. Arkansas is the only southern state from New Mexico to the Atlantic Ocean to fully tax military retirement pay. Why do we think they would come to Arkansas if we do not compete with the states around us for these wonderful citizens that we would like to bring to our state? Right now, we have 6,000 Arkansans on active duty. I say it's time to bring them home to this state, let them use their skills and their talents here in Arkansas. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am. Representative Boss, do
▶ Play
you have a motion to make, sir? Representative Balts has a motion to do pass. Any debate on the motion, members? I hear no debate. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed, no? Congratulations, ma'am. Your bill has passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. You're welcome, ma'am. We're going to give, if anybody wants to leave, we're going to give people in the audience just about one minute, and then we're going to take up our Senate Bill 115. That's the mirror bill of the governor's $50 million tax cut proposal. And that will be the last bill we hear today. So if anybody else is waiting for another bill other than Senate Bill 115, we will not take that up today. Senator Jake Files,
▶ Play
Speaker 115 1:13:11
I appreciate you
▶ Play
Speaker 118 1:13:13
coming down, helping out.
▶ Play
Speaker 119 1:13:18
Thank you. opposite direction of
▶ Play
Speaker 121 1:13:30
everybody hey reginald
▶ Play
Speaker 94 1:13:42
Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 118 1:14:12
Wake up, man. I had to say hi to Wesley when I was up here. I don't get to see him that night. Let's see you, buddy. Let's see you, teacher. Let's see you.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 1:14:42
Members, we start kind of getting gathered up. Reps to the pitch, you ready, sir? Members, this is Senate Bill 115.
▶ Play
We litigated this in this committee for about an hour, litigated on the House floor for about an hour. I think we're probably all pretty much aware of what's going to be talked about. And let's see if we can't do this thing in expedient fashion, if we can. Representative Douglas, you've got 15 seconds, sir. Proceed. I'll be very
▶ Play
Speaker 136 1:15:47
quick, Mr. Chairman. First, I feel like there should be almost a comment about how fast I can empty a room, but I don't know. That may be inappropriate. What you have in front of To you, it's Senate Bill, companion bill to what you voted on, HB 1159 in the House. This is Senator Hendren's bill. He's asked me to present it, available for any questions. Same bill, no amendments, no anything different than what you voted last Thursday. Is anybody in the audience, you got a question, Representative Saban? No, I was just going to say motion at the proper time. Thank you,
▶ Play
sir. Anybody in the audience want to speak against the bill or for the bill? Representative Pitchy, close for your bill. I am closed, Mr. Chairman. Representative Sabin, can I hear your motion, please, sir? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I move due pass. Representative Henry wants to make a co-motion. You good? Okay. We have a motion on the table for due pass from Representative Sabin. Any debate on the motion? All in favor, say aye. Any opposed, say no. Congratulations, sir. You did it in 45 seconds. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and committee. We will come back.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1162 C. Fite TO AMEND ARKANSAS TAX LAW CONCERNING INCOME TAX, SALES AND USE TAXES, AND THE SOFT DRINK TAX;AND TO SUPPLEMENT MEDICAID PROGRAM TRUST FUND TO OFFSET DECREASED DEPOSITS FROM TAX REVENUES.

0:13 - 1:16:02 202 segments 22 speakers

HB1203 Holcomb TO PROVIDE FOR A RECOVERY FEE ON THE RENTAL OF HEAVY EQUIPMENT PROPERTY; AND TO REQUIRE THAT MONEYS COLLECTED AS A RECOVERY FEE BE USED TO PAY AD VALOREM TAXES ON TANGIBLE PERSONAL PROPERTY.

HB1037 Wardlaw TO REGULATE THE SALE OF TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY; AND TO PROHIBIT OWNERS TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY FROM BIDDING ON OR PURCHASING TAX-DELINQUENT PROPERTY.

HB1253 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE REQUIREMENT THAT CERTAIN RETAILERS PREPAY SALES TAXES.

SB115 J. Hendren TO CREATE THE TAX REFORM AND RELIEF ACT OF 2017; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

1:16:02 - 1:16:55 2 segments 1 speaker

SB114 Hester TO AMEND THE REQUIREMENTS FOR PUBLISHING NOTICE OF DELINQUENT TAXES ON MINERAL INTERESTS.

HB1028 Lemons TO EXEMPT CERTAIN BUSES, COACHES, AND OTHER MOTOR VEHICLES FROM SALES AND USE TAXES.

HB1031 Bentley TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX EXEMPTION FOR INCENTIVES RECEIVED UNDER THE COMMUNITY MATCH RURAL PHYSICIAN RECRUITMENT PROGRAM.

HB1153 Boyd TO CLARIFY THE MEANING OF "ACTUAL AND OBVIOUS ERRORS" ON THE PART OF A COUNTY ASSESSOR IN THE ASSESSMENT OF REAL AND PERSONAL PROPERTY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1221 Sabin TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR SALES BY A CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION.

HB1225 Magie TO REPEAL THE EXEMPTION FOR AND REQUIRE THE DISCLOSURE OF CERTAIN ADVERTISING RECORDS AND UNDER TAX PROMOTION FREEDOM OF THEINFORMATION ACT OF 1967

HB1252 Rye TO AMEND THE INCOME TAX DEDUCTION ALLOWED FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES; AND TO REMOVE THE THRESHOLD FOR CLAIMING AN INCOME TAX DEDUCTION FOR MEDICAL AND DENTAL EXPENSES.

HB1263 Jett TO CREATE A SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR PARTS FOR AND REPAIR OF AGRICULTURAL EQUIPMENT AND MACHINERY.

HB1227 Farrer TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO REDUCE INCOME TAX RATES BASED ON THE GROWTH OF INCOME TAX COLLECTIONS.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Joe Jett Unverified
33 segments
Representative Charlene Fite Unverified
18 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Chair Unverified
47 segments
Speaker 8
2 segments
Speaker 22
1 segment
Speaker 49
21 segments
Speaker 59
19 segments
Speaker 66
12 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
8 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
7 segments
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 94
2 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 103
1 segment
Gary Fletcher Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 112
3 segments
Speaker 115
1 segment
Speaker 118
2 segments
Speaker 119
1 segment
Speaker 121
1 segment
Speaker 136
2 segments