Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee

January 31, 2017 ·Committee Room 130 ·2:05:24
Video Transcript

Bills discussed (20)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1267 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1267 L. Fite TO CREATE THE USED TIRE RECYCLING AND ACCOUNTABILIT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1021 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1034 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1034 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DIS…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1040 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONC…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1160 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN E…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1180 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1180 Bentley TO AUTHORIZE ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1181 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1182 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1183 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1183 Dotson TO PROVIDE CONSISTENCY AND EFFICIENCY OF CHIROPRACTI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1186 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AS APPLICABLE TO…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1204 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBST…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1205 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1215 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE TH…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1228 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED P…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1237 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1250 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO AMEND…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1254 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTI…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1264 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1264 Pilkington TO PROVIDE FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERV…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1280 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1280 Magie TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF TANNING EQUIPMENT BY MINORS; A…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1300 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIOR…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 14, 2026
If the members would grab your seat, we'll go ahead and get started. We're not doing a picture today? Yeah. We've got the photographer ready. If you guys would, come on up here. We'll go ahead and get our picture taken and then we'll go ahead and get started with the committee.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 0:30
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
▶ Play
Speaker 5 2:00
Now that we got that out of the way, I'm going to let Representative Vaught, if you would
▶ Play
I'm going to let you get your resolution out of the way
▶ Play
Speaker 37 2:39
first Thank you, Mr. Chair Today I'm bringing a resolution in honor of Zaden Davis who is battling NF and we want to honor him for his bravery during this big trial that he's going through so I would appreciate a good vote. Representative Bentley, you're recognized for a question. I have a motion at
▶ Play
the appropriate time. All right. Seeing no questions or anyone in the audience speak for or against the resolution. Seeing none, Representative Bentley, you're recognized for your motion. Motion do pass, Chairman. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, congratulations. Your resolution has passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. All right, guys, we're going to stay with our same agenda. Today we have AEDQ coming to the end of the table. And if I could, if I could find Ms. Becky Kehoe and I think Mike Pickens is coming with her. If you guys would introduce yourself to the committee
▶ Play
Speaker 37 3:54
and then you're recognized. Good morning. My name is Becky Keill. I am the director of the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality, and I have with me Mike Pickens, who is our general counsel and working with us on legislative committees, and particularly we'll be spending a lot of time with your committee as we go through the session as well as follow-up rulemakings that come before you. many of our is that we also are handing out some books that have been designed for you and I'll talk a little bit about that so I'll kind of walk you through it so if if just to give you a little bit of more insight so of what we're trying to present to you and we're happy to follow up with each of you on a one on what I call a one-on-one discussion about your district and how the agency he provides services in your district. I did want to ask if the chairman agrees to also bring forward Julie Chapman, our senior associate director. I'll have her sit here also in case she wants to help respond to questions.
▶ Play
Speaker 20 5:00
So Julie Chapman is also here with me.
▶ Play
Speaker 37 5:14
Just briefly, we wanted to give you a little glimpse of the Department of Environmental Quality, some of our activities and services that we provide as an agency, our responsibilities under law, as well as the opportunities that the agency has to affect positive outcomes for the state. And I wanted to start with just describing a journey I've been on for the last roughly two years. Last, I guess, two years ago now, almost at the end of February, it'll be two years, Governor Asa Hutchinson called me and asked me if I would be interested in serving as his director of the Arkansas Department of Environmental Equality. And I was pleased to accept that privileged role, but understood that it came with a lot of responsibility based on the fact that I had spent time with the department previously in an associate director role approximately a decade ago. Since that time, I had been out in private sector working on environmental responsibilities on behalf of various industries and communities, not only in Arkansas, but across the country. So with that commitment to the governor, I came into the agency, I guess perhaps in the middle of what was the last legislative assembly, and began work to look at the agency. And I set out to change the culture of the agency that was there to reflect the governor's priorities but also to respond to negative feedback relating to ADQ that he had encountered on the campaign trail and that we had received as a result of input from not only this committee but others across the legislature. In a nutshell, I think our agency was perceived and perhaps fairly sane of having a gotcha mentality at that time, and we began to approach that in a different form. One of the first requests or directives, I guess I should say, I made of the agency staff was to begin our interactions with all our citizens of Arkansas with a statement that was simply, how can they help you? And I know that's a trial as a government agency, but many times, our conversations can get very difficult, challenging, as a regulatory body. And we wanted to open conversations initially to understand where the other person was coming from and what their needs were, so that we could better result in a positive outcome for us, but also result in an outcome that met their individual challenges. We began that pathway. We also, as an agency, were broken apart in what I'd call silos within our organization, where we had divisions that operated and functioned almost as independent agencies themselves. So we began to deal with that, as well as we wanted to put a face on the agency. Many people don't understand our agency mission. So the mission of our agency is to protect, enhance, and restore the natural environment for the well-being of all Arkansans. As we began to look at that mission and our organization, we found that it was important to drive efficiency, streamlining across our organization, but also that effort could result in better environmental outcomes and hopefully address a vision that we put forth. And that vision was not only to focus on protecting our air quality, our land resources, and our water quality, but also to create an atmosphere and a culture that promotes environmentally responsible economic development. And that's something we focused on as we consider every rule and every action that I take as a director. The vision is not simply a statement in a book that you see before you, it's actually a functioning effort that we test each decision against. So I've likened, as a counterpart of mine in another state has likened our function and our organization not differently than the private sector which I stepped out of. I make my decisions, obviously, with input from our governor, and we consider him our CEO. We consider the public our shareholders, the legislature here, and this body before you, our board of directors, and the regulated community often as our customers. And with that approach, I think we look and we inform our decisions in a different role. And as my counterpart said, why would we not embrace a private sector mentality when the stakes are so much higher in what our product is, which is the environment of Arkansas? So we want to work with you as legislators to make sure we progress efficient government, streamlining government, simplification of regulatory requirements, but also, at the end of the day, better outcomes for the environment, which is so critical not only to just the economic attraction of businesses to the state, but also our tourism industry and our agriculture industry, which we know we rely on heavily as a state. So while we looked to lead in the protection of quality of air, weather, and land, we began to move our staff into those three offices. So what you'll see on page, I want to take you into the book for a minute, to some pictures on page four. We built an executive team. Now, I mentioned silos before. When I walked in and I organized my first leadership team, I had 20 managers sitting around a table like this. and not to, not out of this respect to the chairman at the top part of the room, but it's very difficult to run an agency and lead 20 different divisions with accountability to a single director. We began to look at how could I more effectively hold these directors accountable for the performance of what the agency was about, but also allow my input to how the philosophies and policies should be established. So therefore, we began to create these offices. We also created an office led by Julie Chapman, which is our Office of Law and Policy, as well as an operational office to meet our administrative and facilities. And some of you had the opportunity to come out to our facility. But we have a fantastic state facility that sits in North of Rock down at Crystal Hill Exit. But it's a big investment for the state in terms of the facility that was designed and built as an example of how environmental principles, energy efficiency principles can be built into a building, and yet the building can be designed and operated effectively. This building operates as a six-story building housing over 350 employees, but is an energy-story building, which is phenomenal in today's world. So we keep our operating costs managed and low and it's monitored, so it's a great model. But that facility, we want to open up and make it. It is not the agency's facility, but we believe it's, in fact, the state's facility, and we're opening that up to allow more citizens and agencies to come into our facility to see and get ideas to take back to their own work. So with that, we have Operation Officer, and these individuals are pictured here. Now, the last role we've added recently, I've asked Tim Cain to step in he is running that we have established as a compliance and continuous improvement office and this again speaks back to that commitment of mine to and the governors to streamline simplify and increase the productivity of our government if you look back a page on page three we set forth some commitments as I mentioned we are looking for efficiencies through our practices of our programs in permitting. In fact, we began a focused effort on permitting backlog, which is important to industrial siting in the state, and we took what was perhaps one of the worst permitting backlogs in the country, and now we have been recognized for having one of the lowest permitting backlogs in the country in less than about a 15-month process. And that is to the credit of my staff and my leadership that works with me to make this happen. It's also, we took 700 days of backlog on average out of our aeroporting program. So our aeroportments are now some of the most expedited permitting efforts that can be accomplished in the country, but also these permits not only come out as expedited, they come out as defensible, which if you talk to a major industry or a major company, when they come in to receive a permit, they understand that that is a key cornerstone to their license to operate. And it's very important to industry to know that when we issue a permit, that it's protective. It's protecting the environment, but it's also protecting their investment. And that when we write the permit, Their commitment to Arkansas is protected through any legal challenge that might be encountered when they receive a permit. So we want those permits not only to come out fast, but we want them to be basically without challenge with respect to meeting the law. And we work closely with industry and other entities, including our communities, to do so. So we have that continuing. We also achieve that through a commitment to technology. We've implemented what we call our e-permitting program, which makes permitting easier for our regular community, but also facilitates the review process within our agency. It makes it transparent. If someone submits a permit, they can now see where the permit sits within the permitting process for the first time ever. They can evaluate the progress that permitting application is going through. They can also make changes. We had a specific entity that came in and received a permit. they said in the past it took them a week to modify a permit, now it takes two hours to modify a permit. So amazing economic relief to not only our agency, but also to the regulated community. We also have made a commitment to fiscal responsibility. In driving my reduction from 20 offices to five, I ask each associate director to bring me a plan to reduce their costs by a minimum of 5%. And that successful result in a savings of over $700,000, as you see, in the last fiscal year. We have reflected that in our appropriation, of course. We are reducing appropriations in some of our travel budgets across the line, across some of our other spending budgets, recognizing that we also are looking at federal spending decreases that are available to us. So we're balancing the fact that while we may have reduced federal funds available to us, we want to be able to take our state dollars, our federal dollars, and our fee dollars that we collect and use them more effectively to demonstrate the effect of the agency. And I think there's a reflection of that budget in a minute, and I'll let Julie speak to that. But lastly, as I mentioned, we have this Office of Continuous Improvement. So we've developed what we call our mission management system, which means our actions will daily speak to that. So we're creating not a flash of my management style, but hopefully a continuous process that will last beyond this management structure to affect improvement in what we do on a daily basis. If you want to also flip over to page, the next page after, I guess it was the photo page, which is page five here, I have put together an advisory team. This advisory team, which is supporting our executives across our agency, will also be available to you on various entities. And we've given you a description of how they can advise and what their expertise is. And we'll see a couple of those members today. But one of those came around us here in the room put together this enterprise services book, because we've made the statement that there is no way 350 individuals will accomplish the mission effectively of protecting, enhancing, and restoring our environment. In fact, it's truly an enterprise relationship and partnership across the state. So we want to provide resources to all our citizens to be part of that mission that we take. And while we provide leadership and resources and regulatory action that are necessary to create fair playing for for those that do perform well we want to incentivize good action so that's kind of what i wanted to present today i believe there's also some presentation material in the back that speaks specifically to how we support your individual districts we provide our resources that are available to you at the local level at the very back of the thing the book i believe on page 13 we reflect our revenue sources are distributed so you understand how we operate on a daily basis some of our funds are what we call reserve funds or trust funds so monies that come into this agency has a requirement not only to operate the agency but we also happen to be trustee of three trust funds that provide financial integrity and assurance to the state for any long-term liabilities being associated to landfall operations, emergency response, or hazardous substance reactions, as well as our petroleum storage program, which is a program that benefits not only the marketing industry for petroleum products, but also benefits the state in providing funds available to address any kind of releases from those sites in a timely fashion and also protect third parties that might be impacted adversely from that. So I'm going to cut off at that. I wanted you to know that we have a number of proactive programs in the program and in the back we have tried to identify where your district is taking advantage of those grants and assistance programs and we've perhaps shown you in a few areas where perhaps you're not taking advantage of those assistance and we'd like to work with your district to provide you more education about those programs and how they can help your district in the future. Now I went a little bit long, I hope that was helpful to you, but I just wanted to see if there was any questions or if there's any additional support that we can provide. Before I do that, I'll turn it over to Julie if she wanted to add anything to my comments. Mr. Chairman, just one point of order for today's meeting. We have some maps that I think will be useful. They're personalized for you all that will show every regulated facility in your district. So they're district-specific. This is what the maps look like. Phil, I think, is holding one up. If you all would like, we'll hold on to those, and you can get them as you exit the room so you don't have to keep up with them. We'll also hand-deliver them to your office. But I think that will help in the dialogue. The phone numbers are in the back of the book for you to reach anyone within our agency. And the only thing I would add to Director Keogh's comments, Director Keogh is the president-elect of ECOS, the Environmental Council of the States. They're the voice, the unified voice of the states as far as interacting with the EPA. Many of our programs are delegated programs, so they start with the EPA and we implement them. The great thing about the position Director Keogh has now is we have a front row seat to what's happening in Washington, D.C. We've been working very closely with Senator Bozeman, who sits on the Public Health and Works Committee from the small, developing the questions for Scott Pruitt's confirmation hearing. We helped make sure some of those were Arkansas-centered questions, but we've had great success working with D.C., getting Arkansas concerns heard, one, because of Senator Bozeman, two, because of Director Keough's role in that national level. So as you all encounter things in your district that we may hit some roadblocks at the state level, know that we are working in developing those contacts, resources, and relationships in D.C. We're very optimistic of some changes that we're seeing in the EPA. What we're hearing during these transition times talks is that we're going to have a lot of state control. That's, I guess, in a nutshell what we're hearing from D.C. We need to know what you all need in order for us to voice that at the national level. So find me. I work on the D.C. side of this quite a bit, but I'll be glad to make sure that those hit the ECOS agenda. If there are any other questions for the committee, we'd be glad to answer them. Otherwise, come find us, and we'll drill down deeper in some of these materials with you at that point.
▶ Play
Representative Bentley, you had a question? Thank you all very much for coming today. and I found this very helpful listing out the different things. I did have one question. I've had some farmers very concerned about wanting to put down liquid waste and the concerns that we've had with the Buffalo River. They've been finding their permits taking up to a year. They would just like to know one way or another any time or matter so that they need to make adjustments they can. If I could just get
▶ Play
Speaker 37 23:39
your response to that, to their concerns. We're happy to address that specifically with any farmer. Two years is extremely long, I would say, especially in today's permitting regime that I've established. So we want to address that. I think that's probably, I hope that's an exception. We are trying to make it timeliness more visible. I know the water permitting, or in this case, as you talk about land application permits, are becoming part of our e-permitting program as we move forward. This has been a phased-in approach, so we addressed our air permitting, which was our initial focus. so I think you'll see some progress across the board but we continue to work on land application as a viable practice for our farmers to use as nutrient needs on their property and we want to make sure they do it in a way that's going to be accepted in their community as a practice that also protects the environment so that's that's the process we're going through but I'll be happy to follow up with your own specifics if you have a specific Farmer you'd like me to follow up on? Seeing no further
▶ Play
questions, I just want to tell you guys how much we appreciate you and appreciate the work you guys are doing. I want to tell you guys I have spent hours with these guys the last two weeks, and I had a unique problem happen to me the other day. I called for the – my mind went blank, but her sister came to my office, and they're identical twins. and I said I didn't call ADQ and then she had to remind me that that was her twin sister so I don't want that to happen to y'all so I'm letting you know
▶ Play
Speaker 37 25:19
yes yes Barbara Webb is my twin I we don't know if we're identical or not but I think people would argue we are identical twin sister and she serves as the operating officer for a workers compensation so if you start asking me questions about worker compensation I'll probably get a glazed over looking if you ask her questions about environment she will probably direct you to me. So anyway, she's a little more direct on that. So we do have, I think we have in your booklets, I hope, a summary of our proposed legislation that we believe are necessary. And I will tell you, we tailored that legislation and trimmed it down to the bare bones on what we thought was effective. There are several bills, one which will be discussed, I know, on this agenda today, and I'll leave that for the chairman to lead. but I wanted to make sure that you're aware we wanted to give you some insight to those bills as they may be coming forward. Two of the six major pieces of legislation, if you want to call it major, are part of the governor's package, and that includes the merger of the Energy Office to the Department of Environmental Quality. That bill has been introduced now, and I believe Missy Urban, Central Urban will be sponsoring that bill. So the waste tire or used tire bill you'll hear more about this morning, I believe, from the sponsor sitting here at the table. And then we have some additional bills related to wastewater services in the state, specifically in our rural areas and the non-municipal wastewater services. So with that, I'm not going to go into the others in any detail. I just wanted you to be aware that we are working closely with you as well as stakeholders to make sure these bills result in those efficient government services, increased services, simplified approaches, but fair and positive outcomes for the state. So thank you very much. Thank you guys
▶ Play
once again. So with that, we'll go right into House Bill 1267 with Representative Fite. And I think we have a friendly amendment to discuss first. And it's on the tablet. It's listed as KLC 148. Thank you, Mr. Chair and
▶ Play
Speaker 37 27:44
the committee. I appreciate you hearing this bill this morning. I have an amendment that I'd like to put to my bill this
▶ Play
morning. Yes, sir. If you don't mind, I want to explain to the committee a little bit behind this amendment. Yesterday, last week, I represented parts of six different counties. All six of those judges called me in opposition to this bill. So I got with Representative Fite, I got with AEDQ, and we set up a meeting for yesterday. Originally, we were only going to meet with those six judges. We had a lot of support for getting other people involved in that meeting, So we scheduled this room, and for four hours yesterday, we tore this bill from one page to page 33 into pieces. This amendment was an agreement out of that meeting. There was multiple other amendments asked for, but this was the one that most of the folks in the room said that if it happened, they would be for the bill. So I just wanted to give you all a little insight. When I said a while ago we spent hours with these folks, we've really spent hours. We were in here for right at four hours yesterday going through this. So Representative Fayette, I just wanted to give them a little bit of
▶ Play
Speaker 37 29:04
insight of how we got to this point. All right, and I appreciate that. Let me start off by saying about two years ago, we started reviewing solid waste in the tire districts. Let's get the amendment out of the way first. Okay, I'm sorry. Yes, sir. I got
▶ Play
a motion for to do pass on the amendment. Can you explain why he's pulling that out? Why
▶ Play
Speaker 44 29:30
he's pulling? Yeah, I mean, can you explain the amendment? Yes. Explain
▶ Play
Speaker 37 29:33
what the amendment does, Representative Frank. Okay, just a second. You gave my bill to him. Page 29.
▶ Play
Speaker 3 29:42
Yeah. I don't have my bill in it. It's fine.
▶ Play
Speaker 37 29:48
It is on page 27, and starting with line 29, going to 31, it says the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality shall not directly operate or be directly responsible for operation of a used tire program, and that has been struck. You're recognized for a question, Representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chair. this may kind of dovetail into the bill but by you striking that what you're telling me is that the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality can operate or be directly responsible for the operation of the used tire program and so if you could explain I mean it seems to be a pretty huge change without really being able to discuss the bill so if you have to discuss the bill in order to explain that you know I'm all for it but I would like to know why that that change was made and I'll be honest with you they wanted that struck from there I'll be honest with you I believe that state of Arkansas there's a mechanism in the in the waste solid waste legislation and it's about to happen in North Arkansas if they fail to operate and they collapse then it will they have the ability to put a fee on the solid waste district to offset the cost of this. And, again, the state is not involved in it anyway. It's the local district that is responsible, the taxpayers in that district. Go ahead and follow up. You know, again, I guess I'm concerned, and I hope you can allay my fears as to why you think it's a good idea. Because what you're saying here and this right here is that the state can come in and operate a used tire program. I mean, is that something that we need to do? Like if the used program tire fails, that the state can come in and maybe operate it temporarily? So, again, I'm trying to understand in what instances may be used and how can we keep it from being abused by the state. Ms. Keough, if
▶ Play
you would introduce yourself for the committee, and then you're recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 37 32:14
to answer a question. Becky Keough, Director of the Department of Environmental Quality. With respect to your specific question, Representative, the program is implemented at the local level, and it is the state's position and the governor's position to keep this program operated at a local level. And the law, as the bill was drafted, as I understand it, that condition was placed in to make it very clear that, in fact, the state would not step in and operate districts. I believe the district's concern was there may be a time where they needed support from the state, and they didn't want law to prevent that support from the state. So at this point, we don't think it changes anything. The amendment actually takes us back to where we sit today in law, and we leave that up to the courts and the districts to make those decisions. So we don't believe by removing it enables the state any more power than we currently have, nor does, and in fact, that amendment will protect areas that may need support should the legislature act to send a support in. Thank you.
▶ Play
Seeing no further questions will take up. Representative Love, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, Ms. Keogh, before the amendment was, or we adopted, if we do adopt the amendment, what would the state's position be then? What would the state be doing that it's not currently
▶ Play
Speaker 37 33:50
doing now? I think the amendment takes us back to what we do today, which basically we rely on the districts. We provide the revenue sources that are collected statewide to the districts to implement the programs. Those districts implement the programs, and the states have various regulatory roles around the management of used tires. This would not change that in any way. The only way the state has been engaged with tire clean ops have been with respect to our abatement grant monies or our support grants to the district. why would we be able to continue this? I believe that the card that was added in the proposed bill, which you haven't taken up yet, in that proposed bill there was a statement wanting to assure the districts that the state, in adjusting the program, had no interest in coming in and telling the districts or taking over a district program. And I think it wouldn't be the most effective way to do it if we went in and hand-picked and took over one district at a time. I don't think we could cost-effectively implement the program that way as a state. So this was really to correct perhaps the misconception. I think it was just declaring the state does not have that responsibility nor interest in doing so is what the bill was suggesting. I guess the district saw that as a negative, that they wanted to have that fallback. You know, that would be determined, you know, in the future should a need arise, whether the state could step in or not based on the legal structure with the Solid Waste Management Act. Representative Miller, do you have a question on the amendment? You're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ma'am, right now, you were alluding to this just a minute ago that the state or ADEQ does send money to the various districts to implement these programs. I know that right now, if a tire dealer sells a new tire, they send, I think it's $2 to the state. You know, y'all don't want to call that a tax. Is this on the amendment, Representative? Yes, sir. So is that $2 what you're talking about being the money that y'all send? There's a
▶ Play
Speaker 37 36:16
fee assessed, and the bill is looking at how we do that, but there's a fee assessed on certain tires currently in the state, and it's the services of managing that tire to its ultimate destination through processing or through disposal. That fee comes through DF&A and is distributed by a legislated formula to the district. So all the department is is a pass-through on that fee. We do receive some funding to administer and enforce the laws related to tire programs as a result of some of those fees, as well as hold a fund to support districts that don't have sufficient funding to operate an effective program. So we do some special grants at this point out of those same monies, but I guess the simple answer is yes. That's
▶ Play
the money we're talking about. Follow-up real quick. And so this amendment basically takes us back to where we are currently and leaves all that in place as it has been. I know the bill is going to change some things, but the funding infrastructure, that process would stay the same by this amendment.
▶ Play
Speaker 37 37:32
This amendment does not affect the ability for the districts to receive the things that are collected at this point or in the future.
▶ Play
Thank you. Thank you. Representative Love, you still have that motion? We have a motion on the floor to accept the amendment to the bill. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed? Your bill has been amended. Representative Fight, if you would, present the bill as
▶ Play
Speaker 37 38:01
amended. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. And I'm sure there's not anybody around this table who hasn't been contacted about this bill. and I hope to be able to explain it to you to your satisfaction today. As I say, I began about a year and a half, two years ago, looking at the solid waste and also the tire program. And it was very obvious that the tire program was in financial trouble. You could see that early on, or it was heading in that direction. So at that point, we started looking, and it was very obvious that it needed some accountability in it. There were 11 tire districts, and they all did something different. No one was the same. The further you looked at it, we had a used tire problem in the state. We have one district that they sold 186,000 tires one year, but they processed 190,000 other tires that were, they claimed that were, came down from Missouri. There's no way that we can determine that without coming up with a system that can track these tires. If they're coming down from Missouri, we want to stop them. And the only way you can stop them is track them with the used tire tax. What happens, a dealer sells you a new set of tires. There may be some used tires in there that they go, oh, I can resell these. Or the guy who's hauling them to the process plant, he may take some of them off. And then the processor himself may find some tires, and he takes them off. so what you end up your manifest that left the dealer by the time it gets to the operator could be 20% low and what was actually kind of and you don't know where these tires went to and this is one of the things this bill addresses and we're going to do it at e-manifest and it will be that dealer and may I say this when that dealer when it gets to the processor if that manifest is low that dealer is responsible for those two dollars on each tire under this he will not be because whatever he sends when it gets there if someone has taken it off they will be charged that will be the hauler or the processor I tell you there's I think there's some confusion about the bill I've had several County judges who have approached me we've satisfied some of them in our questioning but our purpose in this bill is to bring a responsible bill to you that that's accountable that they can understand it there's nobody that understands the financing out there I promise you to give you a great example of the of the of the the financial end of it on what each district receives it goes from $1.11 a tire to $2.97 a tire and that was in 2015 we had eight of the tire districts that were over reporting what was sold in their district they were processing more tires so again that brings up that used tire I believe there are used tires coming into our community I talked to one dealer who told us about a friend of his who's a tire dealer who would buy like 1,500 at a time from another state and so we have 1,500 tires at some point that we have to process that we are not funded and then we have internet tires got to researching that we don't have anything local here that we can determine but looking nationally they talk anywhere from 20 to 29 percent of the tires today are sold on the internet and they negotiate with tire dealers all over the state in which to put these on well there's no money collected on those so we're losing money there and when you take the used tires internet tires alone we're losing money under this bill we will be anything it's gonna be a rim fee so if it's a tractor tire comes off it'll be three dollars if it's a car tire be three dollars this truck tire be three dollars there's no confusion in the fees right now you have two five and ten and there's confusion everywhere but we're going to broaden you know the scope of collection which we should have done years ago we're losing money all these people are having to process these hires but they get nothing for them at this time at this point I would like to invite Michael group a appeared if he would come up here mr. chair if you don't mind that's fine one of the other things that that we saw as a problem and some of y'all may experience uh you know i had a man at church sunday said a guy dumped 29 tires on my property or somebody did well under the present law you can take four of them to the collection center for free but the other uh 25 you're gonna have to pay two dollars apiece for uh under this bill we it'll be where that uh you'll be able to take all 29 there uh had another man i spoke to yesterday he said his farm, and it goes back to his grandfather, he's inherited the farm, has about 200 tires on it. Well, in this, we have where you can mitigate that and not cost you. Our purpose is to get the used tires in the facilities and process. Michael has worked with me on this bill, and I would let Michael at this point explain a little bit about the mechanics
▶ Play
of it if you don't mind. Mr. Chair. Yeah if you would introduce
▶ Play
yourself for the committee please and then you're recognized. My name is Michael. I'm with the Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality from the Office of the Director and I have been working with Representative Fight previous in my previous position as the director of the Saline County Regional Solid Waste management district and then as of November I was an employee of ADQ. The bill in a very basic form it changes the waste tire collection when you buy new tires to a rim fee so when you pop that tire off that allows us to collect the internet tires without having to address taxes for the internet. We also have special tires in there like lawnmower tires ATV tires golf cart tires but we made it a flat fee of three dollars so it doesn't matter what type of tire you have it's just three dollars per tire so it simplified the accounting process then it protects the car dealers or the tire dealers from having to pay for tires that typically they have been receiving today like internet tires that actually It comes out of their pocket when they get ready to process it. So this protects them. Then we have the e-manifest system that we have developed in-house that will allow us, with registration through the dealer, the hauler, and the processor, to track the tires from cradle to grave. And those tires that are what we call culled, that is pulled out for resale, will also be tracked so that we can get a true number of how many times we're actually dealing with and where they're coming from. We have in this program today there's only three districts that are actually breaking even or making a little bit of money on the program. The rest of them are losing money every year and they're having to supplement that with recycled money, e-waste money and landfill fee monies or assessment monies. This bill is to help them get out of that program so that they can be financially stable. And the way this bill is intended is that over the next year and a half, there will be a transition period where the districts will work with AEDC, ADQ, and any other government agency they can provide value at, and they will put together a business plan and so there's two steps to that the first is tell me currently how much is it costing you to do the program you have today and and we will help them establish what that number is today because most of them don't know how much it costs to operate today and they've been doing this for over 20 years and they haven't got a clue about how much actually is it per tire cost so we're going to help you establish what that true cost is today. And the reason why we're going to do that is because it's a learning process and it will teach them, hey, we need to figure out what our mileage is to get that tire from Bradley County all the way up to Pine Bluff. We've got to have gas for that. We've got to have labor for that. And we've got to have insurance. And we should have some maintenance costs involved in that. So that's what the business plan will address. And then once that business plan goes through the process and then it's presented, it's approved by the boards, the local boards, it's approved with ADC, and then it comes to the director, and she blesses it as well, whatever that fee is, they will get paid for for each tire. So if you have a recycling program and you determine that this is going to be the fee based on the business plan and the e-manifest system, that's your reimbursement rate. So they will provide each district with ample money to operate without having to supplement with other funds that take away from our other recycling programs or their operational programs in the landfill. And then we have money set aside in this bill for abatement to take care of the tires that are found by local county road departments. They load them up and they bring them to them. Typically, somebody's got to pay for those. There's labor involved in that. So we won't have abatement money to allow for those tires to be taken care of as well. We don't believe that in our philosophy, once those tires come off the rim, they belong to the state. And it's the state's responsibility to pay for those tires and so we don't believe that we should be forcing districts to pay for those tires any kind of treatment in them so that's what this bill addresses and then we also have money there for to provide some funding for IDCOs that will actually go out and do investigations into used tire as well as legal dump sites and then finally we have earmarked support for marketing to work with these districts both on a statewide program as well as individual tailored programs of helping them get their product to market any questions I've got a
▶ Play
couple representative Peyton you're recognized her first question thank you
▶ Play
mr. chair I'd like to draw your attention to page 13 line 24 okay I just like to ask is it constitutional for us to create an import fee last time the import taxes and import fees were unconstitutional When
▶ Play
the truck full of tires comes into our district and the guy buying those tires, used tires yeah it's my understanding we can it's it's go ahead that
▶ Play
Speaker 37 50:59
provision was established by previous law and is currently codified in Arkansas law so that's not something made of this proposed bill if I could
▶ Play
Speaker 81 51:11
follow-up one follow-up for
▶ Play
around 30 years there was a tax on used automobiles that came into the state of Arkansas from out of state and until it was challenged in court it existed but once it's challenged in court it loses and there's many other instances of interstate commerce cannot be taxed as an import fee or a tax so I would ask that you get some legal staff to review that but absolutely
▶ Play
Speaker 37 51:42
we're happy to look at anything that would question constitutionality on that's something we're focusing on and make sure our programs align with state and federal constitutional practices let me take a moment to describe this is a fee it's for management of the tire it's a service related fee it's not intended to be a tax it's applied on the tire as it's removed from a vehicle not because we have tires come in on various entities when you buy automobiles and stuff that are not assessed this fee but the thing when the tire is taken off this this fee is assessed to provide the funding to manage that tire to hold it to service it so I would caution whether it's coming off of it's not we need to think about it differently than using the word tax because i don't believe it qualifies any of the constitutional definition of a tax if that makes sense so maybe that helps the representative's concern on that too but we want to make sure that and the purpose as i understand this was added years ago was the concern that other states would bring tires in to get rid of in Arkansas and help the individuals that would buy tires or the districts receiving tires from the dealers would all of a sudden have to deal with this influx of tires without a fee. So it was basically putting a parody on out-of-state tires with in-state tire fees, if that makes sense. I appreciate it. I think
▶ Play
I understood the purpose, but the way this is worded, you really need to check into constitutionality. And I'll have more questions
▶ Play
when you get back around to me. Thank you. Ms. Kehoe, I think I'll ask a question, follow-up behind Mr. Payton. This import fee here would be no different than any person living in the state of Arkansas would pay the same fee also, correct? That's true. And possibly on your used cars, Arkansas, Arkansas was not paying that same tax, which would cause that issue. Oh, Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Speaker 37 54:03
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And first of all, I'll say that I did get e-mail, but the e-mail was asking me to hold off on this bill, voting on this bill, because apparently there's still some concerns that folks want to be addressed. And so I'm just throwing that out there as far as receiving an e-mail on that. but just looking at this bill I'm concerned with all of the fees and so if you could help to lay some of the concerns because I went through the checker and the word fee is mentioned 81 times in this bill and I know in some cases it is you know you're striking some of the old language and you know you're going from one fee and you're calling it now a rim removal fee but the fiscal impact does say that it's going to generate 1.5 million dollars in additional revenue and so if you could go over specifically are there any fees that are going to be increased are you getting rid of and what other fees that you may be getting rid of and replacing so if you could kind of just summarize the whole 81 times that this is fees are mentioned in the bill if we have that summary. I'll begin and I believe Michael can add to this because he can speak to the specific questions you had at the end. One of the primary purposes of this bill, I mean, and I didn't really speak to this, and the reason the governor has included this bill in his package is about fairness. And so I want to take the fee situation very seriously with you in this way because right now this tiered fee structure we have is on passenger tires, truck tires, and also larger tires, plus giving the district the ability to charge fees on the super-sized tires, if you will, that cannot be processed at normal cost. Michael can speak to how that changes. But this was to bring the fee down, because at this point, when you as a consumer go buy tires and have tires taken off your car, we have received a number of anecdotal stories from other employees, but they've purchased tires and have been assessed fees up to $5 per tire because of this tiered fee structure for those passenger tires, but a more appropriate fee for those dealers to charge is $2 by law. So the $5 fee they're currently being charged because the law does not prevent that. They're being charged basically what the dealer says up to $5. And they also often load the tires in the trunk for the individual to take them home and deal with, which is not the intent of the program. So what we wanted to do was because of the confusion on the consumer and the opportunity for dealers to change the fee based on their business practice, we wanted to establish a flat fee. That does result in those that were being charged $2 now to be paying $3. However, there's a large number of tires that were being charged at $5 per hour. We'll now come down to $3. Also, the large truck tires, the larger fleets in this state will see a reduction because most of them are truck fleets. They're going to see a reduction from $5 to $3. So we believe this is consumer protection in terms of simplifying the fee structure so that everyone knows exactly what fee will be paid. And only under certain exceptions can the district separate out a different costing structure. And the bill doesn't offer that. When we have an industry such as Cooper Tire or someone that wants to take care of several truckloads of tires that the fees are not managed on, they can negotiate an appropriate cost with the processing facility for management of those tires. It doesn't preempt specific programs like that where we have a group to come in. But in terms of actual tires and as far as a public service of taking that tire as it comes off the road and making sure it gets into hopefully a recycled market where it can be used as a post-consumer product rather than placed in a landfill. But the last place we want it, and the last place the governor wants to see it, is illegally dumped, stockpiled in your community, creating both a health hazard when we have mosquito-borne viruses, which tires are known to be havens for, as well as fire threats that we've seen just as recently as this week when I pulled emergency crews out to the Port Road site here in Central Arkansas again for the second or third time where we had 20,000 tires on fire. And so we wanna make sure that we reduce the likelihood of these tire fires and we also wanna reduce the public health threat that's being generated by these tires being left on the side or accumulated in stockpiles and not affecting the public. So those are fundamentally principles the governor is supporting is a public health bill, it's a consumer protection bill, it's an equity bill in terms of bringing all the tires that we manage as a state under the fee structure. Currently there's a lot of tires coming in that are not being assessed to fee at all, so yes, those people will have to pay a fee that did not pay a fee before, but those tires have had to be banished, so basically others have been buying the cost of that fee. So we want to make an equitable, simplified fee structure that everyone can understand. They can understand when they buy the tires, what their obligations are, and when they take their tires. The good news is if an individual has tires, is on an individual, they can bring their tires to the district free of charge. So if you somehow end up with, you know, you pop them off the rim and you can put tires on, better you than I. If you can, you know, if you've got the equipment to put your tires in, your arms, you can take your tires in and get those managed by the district. So it's not crowding their fee, and the fee is to assess the collection, the proper storage of those tires, and there's actually incentives now in the bill that allows the funds to go to districts to help them pay for the more expensive processing and market development. The governor also sees this as an economic development bill that, in fact, we'll be looking to create motorcycle markets very closely with the district on how to build Arkansas-based businesses to reutilize this current labor in a more effective way. So I think there's a lot of wins in this bill, but there are some costs. So specific to your fee question, Michael, do you want to answer about the actual
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:01:17
fee changes? There's a $3 fee for all tires. There is a $1 used tire or cold tire fee for those tires that replace used tires. The primary difference is $3 for the replacement of a new tire, $1 for the replacement of a used tire. And that's it on the fee side. And we're continuing with the permitting of tire generators, tire haulers, and tire processors. And those have already been established in previous legislation. I guess a follow-up, if I could. So I think Ms.
▶ Play
Speaker 37 1:02:02
Keogh touched on it just a little bit, But the extra 1.5 million dollars that this is the fiscal impact says this is going to generate Where is that money going? I'm not and I don't need a detailed breakdown But obviously that money is going to be going somewhere to be spent somehow. I Don't want it just piling up, you know, so if you could just kind of in law on what money can go to a district and some districts can't afford honestly to process tires they can afford the landfill and that's about it so what that's built and some of them can't afford to that i said i often feel like the parents who had a college student that went to college on allowance and they're calling me monthly saying my bank my bank accounts in the world mom give me some more money and you know and honestly sometimes i don't have the money to give them anymore with this system so I think to your question as we're collecting more fees because there's actually a potential to double the fee revenue collection with this because of the broadness that this picks up so many tiers that are currently not being addressed in the system that come under the management process. Well if money's go though is as now there's we're going to take the same amount of money that we received in the past administrative program, all the monies will go out to the districts based on these business plans, and they will work out the districts to mirror all the districts toward having the system either collaborating with any districts or whatever the most cost-effective way is to get these towers into processing and to markets, as opposed to roundfills or roundfills where those are not, they're not disallowing that practice, and they're going to, you know, we work with districts that that seems to be the most cost-effective approach due to transportation, but at the end of the day, we want to make sure tires are not going to be a legacy problem for future generations, and so we want to make sure all the tires can get into the marketplace because we know clean bubble is available marketable material and can replace fuel, it can help build roads, it can be a lot of good things for our country as a whole as we consider the future of our state so I think that the extra money is getting out to the districts we don't expect to accumulate money there will be money set aside for abatements so we're now having we have not had enough money left earlier to do abatements in the state because the districts have been asking for support grants ahead of those abatement grants because they just don't they run out of money right now so we've done some limited abatement work but not to the level that we could do before as a state so that gives us some money to do that and those would be implemented to the districts again we don't see these being state abatements we see these district-led abatement projects so um we also feel like that i think that speaks to all the money that we expect to come in but with your questions so that's the plan And Representative Meeks, again, as I said earlier, about eight of the 11 are in financial distress right now, and they're supplementing their tire fund from the recycle fund, their e-waste fund, doing things like this to stay in the abatement fund. It's been years since we abated anything, and this would be going to that for abatements. I promise you that once this abatement fund starts, your community and every community around will make application for, there's not many large dumps, but there's several in the state, but there's a lot of small dumps, I would say 2,000 tires and down, you know. And so that's what that money would be used for. It will not get out of the fund
▶ Play
is what I'm saying. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Representative Hammer, are you recognized
▶ Play
Speaker 37 1:06:13
for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Representative Feitbeck, you've sat through some of those meetings back during the interim where we had the folks coming in and some of the issues going on. And I just want to make sure my perception of what the intent of your bill is geared toward doing. It seems like we all agree we've got a tire problem, but it seems like the way the rules are set right now and the way the table is set right now that there are some who are not doing what they're supposed to be doing, whereas there are others who are supposed to be doing what they're supposed to be doing. But the problem is those that aren't doing what they're supposed to be doing are costing everybody else. What I see your bill doing is just aligning the process so that everybody carries their fair share of the weight equally. And because we know that the way it's been going, we've got some problems in the state. Is that a fair 100,000-foot view of what this bill is intended to do? I wish I'd said that, yes. So follow-up, Mr. Chair? So as far as the issue of charging individuals that this bill will allow to be charged and kind of tagging on what Representative Payton said about the unconstitutional issue, does this does this put the point of responsibility at the place where the
▶ Play
Speaker 92 1:07:42
tire journey begins to the dump excuse me would you
▶ Play
Speaker 37 1:07:48
repeat that again please as far as the where the money ought to be assessed where the fee ought to be assessed because I remember sitting one mean one day and it's really kind of the honor system and some people are taking advantage of that honor system my opinion and they they kind of fudge the numbers a little bit because there's not tied enough controls this is going to bring the controls but it's also going to put the cost associated with that tire being disposed of properly at the right place in the journey of that tire going from from receiving down to the dump or wherever it ends up correct is that correct that is correct thank you and what's any hammer uh what the bill is designed to do the governor this is part of the governor's package right here and the and what the bill is designed to do is bring efficiency to the program now there's a lot of a lot of them that districts don't know what a a tire cost to dispose of and what we're going to do it'll give them that ability see what it is the perfect thing is to recycle it but it's not going to be possible at times this program will have an 18-month period in which you make this transition from the old program to the new program so it's just not overnight that we drop the new program on them and again it's trying to be more effective in processing and not put a financial burden on them in doing that that is not our purpose at all uh question of the chair representative hammer
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:09:21
What the new tar bill will do is, as far as the honesty of our tire dealers or tire generators are concerned, they used to have to pay for a lot of tires that were not covered under the program. There's no reason for them to lie anymore because the tires will be, all the tires they have will be covered. And so it gives them an incentive to be honest because then they get credit to get rid of those tires without any burden to themselves.
▶ Play
Speaker 37 1:09:52
Representative Hammer, you had a question to the chair. The chair stated you had a four-hour meeting yesterday, and I'm not sure I caught who was in that meeting, but I'm just curious. I don't remember you saying the results of the perception people came into that meeting with and the perception they left that meeting with, and so I was
▶ Play
wondering if you'd elaborate on that a little bit, please. A meeting consisted of county judges from basically all over the state, some tire shredder operators, I guess would be what you'd call them, tire district managers, I guess would be a better description. Questions led to what if you change this, what if you change that. Representative Fight and myself discussed, and we had Carrie Lockhart come over and address some of those issues. It was about 6.30, 7 p.m. She finally sent us an e-mail back with some of those answers. I got back with some of those tire managers and judges and let them know what those would do to the effects of the bill. The amendment that was presented this morning by Representative Fite was one of the results of that meeting. They went through all the fees. They went through how to assess those fees. and it was a very long meeting, but it was very productive. It did not feel like a four-hour meeting because it was so productive. Does that answer your question, Representative Hammer? It does, but I'd like to
▶ Play
Speaker 37 1:11:18
go to the bottom of the hopper for
▶ Play
another question, please. We got you there. Representative Miller, we automatically put you there every time.
▶ Play
Representative Miller, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Fyde, I appreciate you all being here and the folks from ADEQ is making it a little bit clearer. Now, the question I've got is probably going to seem kind of stupid, but let's say that I have a tire dealership, and Representative Payton over here goes down the road to another dealership and buys a couple of tires because we're not that close of friends, and he wouldn't do business with me. But he just buys them, takes them home. Where did you buy your van? That doesn't matter. uh anyway he takes them home puts them in the garage for a month or so and then he says hey you know what i'm i'm gonna go get these mounted now he takes the stickers off of them and rolls them around out in the driveway and gets them dirty brings them into my shop asked me to mount them is that a new tire or a used
▶ Play
Speaker 37 1:12:28
tire and that and that sounds like representing payton's I'll be honest with you, I don't know the answer to that question. It's a new tire.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:12:44
But if you can't prove it's a new tire, you'd accept it as a
▶ Play
used tire. Thank you. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? um so what kind of what kind of burden would y'all say that we are putting on the tire dealers the folks who have the the shops where the the mounting and balancing of the tires is going to go what kind of additional burden are we putting on them with having to keep track of all this um as opposed to what they have been dealing with in the past where when they sold a tire
▶ Play
Speaker 104 1:13:25
you know they sent two dollars into
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:13:28
ADEQ. I don't believe we're putting any additional burden on them. We're actually trying to streamline the reporting process that they're doing now. They currently keep track of automobile tires and they keep track of truck tires as they change them in their shop. They do not keep track of all of the specialty tires as they change and then have to pay the processor for it we're going to include that as part of the program so that the burden of disposal is not falling on the tire dealer so the streamlined system it should be easier for you to manage and you don't have
▶ Play
Speaker 37 1:14:05
the liability of those tires and the dealer keeps 10% by the way so that helps offset any cost that they might have a net record keeping. The letter then goes to DF&A, where it's held. DF&A has a certain management fee on all the funds that come to them of 3%. So only after those cuts does it actually find its way over to our agency, and then it's distributed by check. But again, at this point, as we've said, it's a pass-through grant with no reporting obligation or minimum, I guess quarterly reporting at this point, but no strings attached. Committee, I want to get
▶ Play
full discussion on this bill, so don't take anything I'm supposed to say wrong, but we are at 11.17, and we need to try to be out of here by noon. We will take up the vote on this bill on Thursday, and we do have a full page of folks to speak for and against. We have about an equal number for and against. So if there's any of your questions that you may want to hold after some of this testimony, we can go ahead and get some of that started. I'm asking for y'all's input in this. So I've got Representative Bentley, Representative Payton, and Representative Hammer in the queue. So if you guys can hold your questions and let some of the testimony happen, we'll come back to them, and we'll have some more discussion on Thursday as well. So how do y'all feel, committee? I'm looking for y'all's input. Yes. Yeah. Yes, most definitely. All right. Representative Fyde, without objection from you, I'm going to get the lady from SLC up first. Yes, thank you. Ms. Ann Roberts Brody, if we could, and let her testify for the bill. If you could make sure your green light's
▶ Play
Speaker 111 1:16:12
on, please, ma'am. There we go. Never had
▶ Play
trouble being heard before. If you would introduce yourself
▶ Play
Speaker 113 1:16:19
to the committee, then you're recognized for your testimony. Absolutely. My name is Ann Roberts Brody, and I am a policy analyst for the Southern Legislative Conference, or as many of you in the room and around the table know us simply as SLC. And those of you who do know us know that we are a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization, and we exist primarily to provide research support to state legislatures in 15 southern states. And many of you may remember our annual meeting that was hosted just about a mile down the road here in Little Rock in 2014. And I'd like to thank Representative Feit for inviting me to be here today. I started looking into state legislation and regulations on used and waste tires back in about 2014. In 2015, I authored a white paper on state laws and regulations in the southern region as they pertain to used tire management programs. And I also have a forthcoming article in the 49th edition of the Book of the States on this issue. So as you can tell from those qualifications, I've spent a lot of time looking at used tire regulations, probably more than any sane person should. In 2009, an illegal waste tire dump was discovered in Calhoun County, South Carolina, that spanned, let's see, 50 acres and was visible from outer space. Now, that illegal dump took more than five years to clean up, and the expense fell primarily on the state. So that gives you sort of a sense of worst-case scenario what a poorly managed tire program can result in. And as has already been discussed, used tires can serve as a vector for disease. They're an excellent breeding ground for mosquitoes, And as we all recall, the warmer months of 2016, as we grew increasingly concerned about the threat of the Zika virus, managing and eliminating these breeding grounds feels even more crucial today than ever. As also has been mentioned, illegal tire dumps can pose a serious fire hazard. That thick black smoke is a threat to public health, and also the contaminants from the fire can run off into surface and groundwater sources, causing serious pollution. But cleanup of these waste tire piles is not enough to solve the problem. States need to have comprehensive management programs in place. And having looked at the management programs in place across the southern region, I can tell you that the legislation before you today really does create the most comprehensive program that currently exists in the southern region. And, of course, we all want to know what that state next door to us is up to and how they're managing certain things and how we stack up. I can tell you the legislation in front of you stacks up pretty darn well. I'm primarily here today to give you an overview of what I see as some of the merits of the legislation and also to put those within a regional context. The legislation under consideration does have many merits and those include a reform of the current tiered fee system as we've already discussed in depth and it shifts the focus from a fee imposed on the sale of new tire to a rim fee. It also includes the introduction of a uniform e-manifest system which will increase accountability and transparency and can help the state track where the used tires are going, how they're being used, and as Michael mentioned, it really helps you all see where these are going from cradle to grave, and that's a feature of a strong tire management program. There's also a requirement for biennial reports. That's another layer of accountability that's built in. And there are also funding levels and prioritized that encourage and incentivize responsible end use. Finally, there are incentives here for program consolidation, which has been shown to improve program management. Now, waste waste tire stockpiles do not have an inherent net value, positive net value, particularly in sectors where end use markets are underdeveloped. And because of this, in many states, illegal stockpiles become a public liability that require mitigation funding. And so to protect themselves against this, states often establish funding mechanisms as has been done here within the enabling legislation that authorize their waste tire programs. Overwhelmingly, that funding mechanism is what we're looking at here today, which is a tire fee. Now, the difference is in most states, they impose that fee on the sale of new tires. As we've talked about quite a bit today, the state of Arkansas under this legislation would be shifting that focus from a fee placed on new tires sold to a rim fee. As we all know when a tire is no longer suitable for use, not everyone replaces that old tire with a brand new tire. Many people do choose to go the route of purchasing used pre-owned tires. And so under the current structure and in many states, those used tires are not part of the funding stream, but they are part of the problem. And so by shifting the focus From a fee imposed on the purchase of new tires to a rim fee, Arkansas can better capture all tires by collecting fees for any tire that comes off a rim at a dealer, whether that's a new or a used dealer. And that's a significant improvement over what takes place in other states because it creates a more comprehensive, stable, and reliable funding stream. The legislation establishes a $3 fee for all tires removed from rims. and as we've already discussed, currently the state has a tiered fee system that ranges from $2 to $10. Simplifying this fee structure makes it easier for dealers to impose and collect the fees, enhancing the likelihood of compliance. If a rule is clear to understand and easy to follow, it's pretty likely that we're going to follow that rule. But if we don't understand the rules that are set out for us, then sometimes we can accidentally break a rule without even meaning to. So this simplified structure really clarifies things for the tire dealers. And, of course, there is an exception to this fee, which we've discussed, and that's when cold-used tires replace a tire that is being discarded. And in that case, a $1 fee is imposed. And based on evidence from neighboring states across the region, these fees are well within the standard current range and should be sufficient to ensure stable funding streams. Again, I want to stress that the shift in focus from a new tire fee to a rim fee is a creative solution to an often unaddressed issue, the replacement of a used tire, one being removed from a rim, with another used tire that's been called for resale. Of course, these fees are remitted monthly to the director of the DF&A and must be accompanied by a return detailing the total fees collected during the previous calendar month, and these monthly returns represent one of the many layers of accountability built into this legislation. Finally, the legislation allows generators, use tire dealers, to retain a specified percentage of fees to cover the cost of administering this portion of the program, and this is well within the average range permitted by other states in the region. Another key feature of this legislation is the introduction of a uniform electronic manifest system. Without the ability to track the movement and processing of waste or use tires, states are unable to fully monitor the disposal of tires and prevent the formation of new illegal stockpiles. A state's ability to track the life of a tire from its point of generation to the point of end use or disposal can enhance compliance and reduce the number of new illegal stockpiles. To that end, the E-Manifest is crucial. ADEQ's current system will be enhanced to create the electronic uniform used tire management system, which will be used to accurately report all information related to the collection, transportation, distribution, and disposal of recyclable waste tires and used tires that are called for resale. And the actors who provide this information throughout the life cycle of a tire include used tire programs, tire retailers, tire transporters, tire collection centers, and any person who removes the tire from the used tire program after it's collected. And this represents the full range of actors who are involved in the life cycle of a used or waste tire. And again, it's another level of accountability built in to ensure the proper management and ultimately the responsible end use of a tire. And by creating an electronic uniform manifest, the state is going to be able to better evaluate the used tire management program. The provision of biennial reporting within this legislation further enhances compliance and accountability. These biennial reports, which will be evaluated based on important indicators, can be further checked against information within the manifest system and monthly records provided by tire dealers, creating an additional tool for identifying potential bad actors within the program. The indicators outlined in the legislation provide a thorough reporting and evaluation process, and these biennial reports will allow the state to track the overall effectiveness and progress of use tire management programs the funding levels and priorities outlined here encourage responsible end use reimbursement funding levels 1 through 3 are ranked in descending order beginning with the most responsible end use for used or waste tires recycling further the structure of funding priorities which ensures that reimbursement funding for level one is fully met before each subsequent level is met ensures that the most responsible end uses receive the most funding and also first priority in terms of reimbursement funding. I'd also like to take a moment and highlight funding level five, which provides funding assistance reimbursement for an illegal dumps control officer position, which is commendable. Finally, the legislation provides two mechanisms by which reimbursement rates may be increased, tying it to the consumer price index, or if used tire programs have established an increase in operational costs, however, an increase may not exceed 10 percent per year. Regional and national trends indicate that used tire programs serving larger populations and greater geographical areas collect and process a large number of tires, are more sustainable, and optimize the use of economies of scale. As has already been mentioned today, as of December 31, 2016, there were 11 waste tire districts in the state. Larger inter-district programs can operate more efficiently and sustainably, which is in the best interest of the state. To encourage this, the legislation offers eligible inter-district use tire programs up to $25,000 a year to assist with funding an illegal dumps control officer position, which is a win-win. Larger programs are more efficient and sustainable, and receiving funding assistance for this control officer position will help the program better identify and remediate illegal dumps, which, as we've already established, poses a risk to human health and public safety. Based on the factors I've discussed, I'd like to reiterate that in my opinion, this legislation creates the most comprehensive used tire accountability program in the region. And I know that many of you have questions both for myself and for the other folks who are scheduled to testify today. So in the interest of time, I will conclude my comments. I want to thank you all for your time and attention, and I will be happy to answer any questions to the
▶ Play
best of my ability. We have a few. Oh,
▶ Play
boy. Representative Payton, you're recognized for the first one. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ma'am, it does seem that you're very well-versed on this, so maybe I could start by telling you my concern and then a question that I have. As you know, most people buy a set of new tires. They probably don't wear those tires completely out, and when they come off, there's a set of tires that have life left in them that can be used by the next purchaser and possibly, you know, even a third level or a fourth level in some cases. The number of tires manufactured directly correlates with the number of tires that will ultimately be disposed of. So it's in our best interest to make sure that these tires are wore out before we dispose of them because if we start disposing of tires that have life left in them, then that's just going to mean the manufacturer of more tires and we're not getting efficient use. So my concern is that as we address this problem, that we would discourage the resale and the use of those tires downstream where we get a lot more miles in usage out of them before they become a waste product. So with that in mind, how many fees would we collect during the life of that tire if it goes through two or three or four owners? Is there a fee
▶ Play
Speaker 113 1:31:09
collected every time? Yes, there is a fee collected each time, but that fee is $1 as opposed to
▶ Play
the $3 fee that is imposed on new tires. Right, and so if I could have a little follow-up there? One follow-up. So I understand the fee is perceptually minimal, but the management of that fee and the bookkeeping and the accounting and the logs that are being created here for those downstream suppliers that may not have the big fancy retail storefront, but they serve a very useful purpose in picking up tires from metropolitan areas, taking them out to the rural parts of the state where the income levels are lower, and selling these tires to individuals that can wear them out when they only have 20 or 30 percent of their life left. I mean, my fear is that we would discourage that through the regulation and the paperwork that's going to be demanded and what is a low-profit margin segment of the business, if you could speak to that. Well,
▶ Play
Speaker 113 1:32:22
and I certainly hear your concerns. I would counter that by reminding the committee that in terms of paperwork, this legislation really does streamline things with the E-manifest. It's going to be quicker. It's going to be more transparent. And if it does seem that there is a discouragement in used tires, that should be able to be identified through the many levels of reporting and accountability. Again, a $1 fee is significantly smaller, and so I hope that that addresses your concerns. Sufficiently, thanks. If you have a follow-up, Representative Payton, I have
▶ Play
no one behind you. I will recognize you. for follow-up well I already took my notes away for
▶ Play
Thursday but I'll be happy to drag them out here I didn't know if I
▶ Play
went that far page 11 line 12
▶ Play
through 16 basically says that I have to hire for disposal a transport company that has been certified and regulated by the state so if that doesn't discourage And the activity I was just speaking of, I don't know what would, but in other words, I own a Chevrolet dealership, and we're not really in the tire business, but we do sell some tires, and we do put them on vehicles, and we don't generate a lot of waste tires because many of what we deal with are resellable. But those 25 or 30 or maybe 50 or 60 that pile up over a two-month period, I have my employee haul them to the disposal site, and this is going to outlaw that. This is going to say that I have to – so we're creating a monopolized business where I think that will discourage the distribution of these
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:34:25
used tires. Representative Payton, the bill is created. In your case, you would just register your pickup or your trailer as a hauler. You can haul as many tires as you want to to the recycle center or to your other disposal site. It doesn't – what we want to do is we want to – Mr. Payton, can you explain
▶ Play
to Representative Payton that's due to the manifest? would that not be correct it
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:34:57
would be correct yes you would simply because you're registered as a hauler as well as a tire generator you would simply put your number down for as a generator your number down as a hauler and then you would print the manifest system print your copy for DOT records and then go to the processing center it's going
▶ Play
to be much easier for me to I mean it says that I must use a tire transporter that's permitted it's going to be much easier for me to just say those tires don't have enough value for me to worry about I'll just send them on to the recycler even though they have 20 or 30 percent of their life left and we're going to be wasting some usable tires because people don't want to deal with that regulation Well, the intent of the bill was
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:35:49
to prevent the bootleggers who come and take the tires from you, and they call the ones that they believe are 20 or 30 percent good, and then they take the rest of them and they dump them in your creek. So we wanted to register them so that they were accountable so that when they picked up those tires from you or you took them yourself and you brought them to the processor, A, you get full credit for them, and then B, they all went to where they were supposed to go. And I believe the fee, we're talking about a fee of $25 yearly for a hauler, I believe is a minimum amount, which would be your cost to haul those tires. I would love to visit with y'all, but I don't think
▶ Play
we want to take up the committee's time
▶ Play
on all that. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 37 1:36:44
you. Representative Hammer, are you recognized for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. The one thing I guess trying to get my mind wrapped around is the idea that this bill is going to drive up the cost, either whether you call it a tax increase, fee increase, or whatever you call it, it's going to drive up the cost. Can you kind of drill down a little bit about how it does or does not do that, especially if we're just addressing the problem over here, we're going to realign the way we address it, and now we're going to address it like this over here. Can you just give some comfort level about how this doesn't create a
▶ Play
Speaker 113 1:37:19
tax increase, or if it does, just call it what it is? Absolutely. So as I mentioned and as several of the other speakers have mentioned today, currently there's a tiered fee system in the state, $2, $5, and $10. And what this does is this streamlines that fee system so that whether you were paying $2, $5, or $10, you now would be paying $3. So, yeah, for those who were paying $2, there is a $1 fee increase now. But for those who were paying $5 or $10, there is a fee decrease.
▶ Play
Speaker 83 1:37:58
You're recognized for a follow-up. So
▶ Play
Speaker 37 1:38:01
the perception that's been given is that this is going to create extra surplus funding that wasn't being created under the old system, and how is it that the realignment of the fees is going to generate more money than what it was doing under the old
▶ Play
Speaker 113 1:38:21
system? Well, it does that in a couple of ways. Firstly, as we've mentioned, there is the new $1 fee on used tires. That is previously a problem that did not have a solution. So used tires are part of the full life cycle of tires, ultimately end up in stockpiles, too. But there were no fees paid on used tires. Now there is that $1 fee. Additionally, because there was confusion in the fee structure, it was not always being collected appropriately and in a uniform fashion. And furthermore, because the tracking and accountability mechanisms were not uniform, there was no way to ensure that fees always were being paid appropriately at all. So by creating accountability and also by introducing used tires into this accountability system, it ensures that there's adequate and sustainable funding, both for the used tire management programs and also for abatement of stockpiles. all right thank you and thank you
▶ Play
for uh flying in today to to give us that testimony uh you got a question for okay you recognize representative gonzalez for one last question for uh miss brody thank you mr chair so
▶ Play
how would you address people have concerns that say we're uh subsidizing the trucking industry by reducing their fee and uh and increasing the fee on on
▶ Play
Speaker 113 1:39:54
common auto tires? Well, I don't see it as subsidizing the trucking industry because, as Michael mentioned a moment ago, if you are a mom-and-pop tire dealer, you're not required to use a large truck. Oh, I'm sorry. You weren't talking about transporters, were you? You were talking about fleets who use these tires. Okay. Thank you. You stumped me.
▶ Play
Michael? Michael, can you address that,
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:40:30
please? I can. We're trying to find an equitable way to make everybody come to the table. $3 today would encompass any type of tire. Today, the Farm Bureau or the farmer doesn't have the ability to bring in a tire because no one wants to pay for the disposal of it. We have truck tires that we process about 250,000 truck tires a year. We process 2.5 million car tires a year. So we figured that in order if we could adjust that range somewhere in the middle and say $3 for a flat fee, we can include everybody into this program and generate enough money to address all of the tires for the state of Arkansas. Because at the end of the day, it doesn't matter where they came from, We're going to have to process them. So $3 was the number that we picked because it was in the middle, and it generated the income that we needed to address the districts that are in distress and provide the money that they are going to need to operate, and then provide money set aside for abatement marketing programs. So it didn't matter where the tariffs came from in our mind. It's a state problem, and if we don't do something, will have a big dump sometime in the near future, and we're all going to have to pay for it. The state will pay for it to remediate it. The pit property over here in southwest Little Rock, that's not an insignificant cleanup that needs to take place, but we're all going to pay for it because it's going to come out of the state program. I don't know if I answered your question or not as far as subsidies are concerned, but we just picked a middle number that allowed us to increase some, decrease some, and then capture all the tires in the program. Thank you, Ms. Brody,
▶ Play
and thanks for coming in today. Thank you. I am going
▶ Play
Speaker 113 1:42:33
to be scooting out of here to make another meeting. I'm going to be here all day today and half the day tomorrow, so if any of you want to just grab me by the elbow and ask questions as I'm traipsing about,
▶ Play
please feel free to do so. Thank you. Judge Griffin from Independence County I recognize you to speak against the bill Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 37 1:43:01
you Mr. Chairman, committee I think saying I'm against the bill is a misnomer Number one, there's been a Herculean effort given by Mr. Grappe and Representative Thyat who's a very, very good friend to counties the problem is in the details to the extent that as a board member for the White River District we would be better to be able to opt out because the program we're currently doing is storing tires in a in a pit they're going to cut the funding in half this bill literally would bankrupt us immediately on its inception and the truth is the problem exists the problem is with funding but But this bill has three components that I'm not sure that any of the committee agrees with all of. One is it increases funding, that's a tax increase. That part is more than likely very necessary. Being a mathematician by education, you don't do a distribution table pulling a number out of midair. You let the numbers settle to themselves and it's ridiculous to take a big truck tire, I also have farms and say this is equitable to charge less to me to dispose of a tire we're currently picking tires up at some farms and charging $80 a ton for their disposal but first the revenue is a taxation the second it is burdensome and onerous with regulations this bill increases regulations and considerably so when the problem right now is only finance Thirdly, it takes away local control by ceding the power in the state's central government. And up to the amendment, which I'm very grateful for, it did not allow for the potential that they take it over. From our district, if we could just opt out, we would be satisfied not to oppose the bill. But I want to give you one component that I think each of you can identify with. tier four level four or five if we simply wanted to haul the tire it has a gracious 25 cents per mile and how much do you get per dem as a state employee that is a ridiculous low amount to expect and if it fails at that part it fails in other parts as well that's not a quarter per tire mile it says a quarter per mile and state employees I think get 43 cents I believe so we know there's a problem. We want to be partners, but we don't want the increased tax, increased regulations, and centralized control instead of local control, and I'd accept questions for any
▶ Play
specifics. Representative Gonzalez, you recognize for a question. I
▶ Play
was under the impression that that quarter of a mile was a minimum, and that if it costs you more to transport those tires, that you could include that in your report and be reimbursed for that. Is that correct? That
▶ Play
Speaker 37 1:46:09
is a hypothetical that is promised. It's kind of like the funding. The funding is by DFA, and I've researched your own archives, a million and a half, but then the programs are allowed to maybe generate four and a half million. But there's no determinant. And as said by the previous testimony, the tier one, level one, is for recycling. If you can't meet that goal, then you're going to be left out in the cold if it takes $5 a tire to recycle, it may eclipse every other effort and put a problem in individual districts. Each district is different. Each district has its own challenges. Each district may be more rural, may be more mountainous. You may have to, in Polk County, drive from one mountaintop and go 10 miles to get to the next one that's not a half mile across. Every solution is not the same for every district. This is trying to have a one-solution-fits-all, as long as the program is approved by the state back to giving state control over a local problem. Seeing
▶ Play
no further questions, Judge, thank you for your testimony. Thank you. I'm going to recognize Stacey Ford from the Waste Tide Program to speak for the bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 149 1:47:30
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to all the members who are still here with us. And I wanted to also congratulate and commend Representative Fite and Michael Grape and the team at ADEQ for the work they've done on this. It is a Herculean task. And these problems are long-lasting, and they're comprehensive, and they affect all of us, and it's not easy to grapple with them. I'm going to start by saying that out there in Arkansas and probably every state, there's what I call the waist-tire underbelly. there's a whole dark world out there of people who make money on these things in crazy ways that I haven't thought of yet and I can't figure out so keeping that in mind there are a lot of people out there who will find ways to circumvent this and so I'm not um you said I was for the bill and I am speaking for the bill because it does address a lot of things it addresses accountability which I'm for. It addresses more uniform fund collection, which I'm for. It addresses better oversight for the used tire dealers, which I'm absolutely definitely for. But I'm concerned about some holes in it that we may need to look at. So as I speak for it, it may sound like I'm speaking against it, but please hear me out and I'll say I'm for it where I'm not against it. So let me start by just mentioning a few things that came to light in my own study of the bill, and if I'm incorrect on any point, I would invite Michael or one of you to correct me as I go forward in what I've come up with from my study of it. My first concern jumped out to me right away in my reading of it as to how this bill will de-incentivize the illegal dumping issue that we have. It's currently incentivized, as someone mentioned before. There's an honor system if you sell used tires especially, and if that's all you sell especially, you're in that category where you're incentivized to dump or to do the right thing. You have to come up with out of your pocket the fee to dispose of those tires, and so I'm all about taking care of that so that that has better oversight and so that that incentive is not there for them. However, I have concerns about the electronic manifest system requirement and the burden that it will place on the smaller used tire dealers primarily, some of whom English is not their first language, so it may be cumbersome that way, some of whom don't have access to a computer or any other electronic means to file a manifest or participate in that system, some of which will choose simply not to because of the complexity of it and they feel that they're not capable of it. My concern with that is to ensure that these smaller tire dealers particularly are provided with what they need to participate, that they have some oversight as far as compliance with this and that that gap is closed in that way, and that they have the training that they need in order to do this because I think that's going to be a challenge. And you would almost need a bilingual person who spent their days going from store to store and talking with these people and getting them on board with this in order to even make a start at getting this to work. So I want to make sure that the small tire dealers are not incentivized to continue even further by saying this is too cumbersome, this is too complicated, I don't know how to participate in this, so I'm going to try to fly under the radar as long as I can, and that may actually increase our dumping issue. That's one concern. the next concern I'd like to mention is who exactly will run the quote used tire programs that we're discussing I've heard a lot of talk today about districts and that's currently how it's run solid waste management districts operate a waste tire program under the direction of the solid waste management district boards who are tasked by the legislature to do that and so the Waste hire programs currently are a subdivision of the solid waste management districts, and the waste hire programs currently are not their own legal entity, but the payments are made to the solid waste management boards and then to the districts. My question about this or my concern with it is that the way it's written, it seems to me that on page 4, line 7, where the qualified entity is defined, which can run a waste tire or a used tire program under this bill, there are a lot of different entities that could fit that definition. And then again on page 15, line 12, where it discusses what that entity shall do to receive payment and reimbursement from the state, it uses the word if, if this entity is a government entity or a public entity. So that to me speaks to the fact that this bill leaves it open for complete privatization of the waste tire or use tire program in Arkansas. And if the public entity is running it, of course they are subject to all the things on page 15 that are listed as far as fiscal processes, as far as county purchasing procedures, accounting procedures, all of those things that government entities are required to comply with. However, if it's a private entity, there's not going to be that underlying structure that is guiding the expenses that are made and the usage of those funds. So I'm concerned that there would not be sufficient oversight if a private entity were to run the use tire program in any district or any area or for the state. So just to make sure that that's clear. again if someone would correct me on that if that's not left wide open for that I would appreciate it but that was my reading of it my next concern oh go ahead go ahead Michael if that's if you would Michael you can
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:53:44
address that concern yes thank you the intent is that the solid waste districts will be responsible for the program through their tire districts and Pulaski is an excellent example of that where you have five solid waste districts yes sir you have five solid waste districts in your tire district and each and your board of your tire district is made up of a chairman from each one of the solid waste districts and then all the money that comes to you currently is through a formula it's not enough exactly so the The intent is to make sure that you have full control over the program that has been approved through the business plan and your solid waste boards and your tire board. And then that establishes the base that you operate under. As far as the manifesting concerns, issues or concerns, currently DF&A acquires, they run their program both electronically and paper wise if you will we will we will have to start that program off that way as well for the e-manifest system because as we have found out over several weeks that there's a lot of people who don't have computers still and they don't have smartphones and so And they may not speak English, but when we get ready to roll this program out, we have the ability to reach out and teach anybody that wants to learn how to use this eManifest system, get their license. So we have a mechanism in there to teach on site in areas that eManifest program. Michael, this may be something you guys can get
▶ Play
together on after a committee. I've got one more witness that drove a long ways that I want to get their intake before we adjourn for lunch, and then I've got Representative Love with a question. Well, I have
▶ Play
a piece I want to try to clarify. Hey, Michael, Michael, I have something I want to clarify. Because, Ms. Ford, you were talking about public entities versus the private entities and the oversight, And you continuously say the intent, and I'm not really concerned about the intent of the bill. I'm concerned with what actually will happen. So can you address not the intent but what will actually happen as the public versus private in the oversight?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:56:27
The bill is written so that the solid waste districts manage the tire program.
▶ Play
That's the bottom line. Okay, so what happens
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:56:40
with the private entity then? Well, in Pulaski County's place, they actually hire a private company to manage their entire program. So then the private entity has to adhere to? Yeah. Today, through our legislative process, we give our monies to the district and the districts manage the entire program. We're not changing that process. and then there are some districts who manage their tires from cradle to grave there are some districts who hire a private company and then there's to manage the tires locally and then there's some that hire a company to take them out of state to be to be processed we don't plan on changing any of that that's up to the district how they want to manage these tires miss
▶ Play
for since I'm in Pulaski County and you're over my entire district, does this address the issue?
▶ Play
Speaker 149 1:57:35
Yes and no. My concern with that is that the basic fundamental structure of the waste tower program as it is today is changing so that it's no longer a subdivision of the solid waste management districts, but it appears to be its own separate legal entity, which totally changes the way that that functions. But granted, if the intent of the bill is to leave that program I'm in the hands of the salt waste management districts. Personally, I would like to see some clarity of that in the bill so that that is clearly the intent. Because the way it's written now, it appears that almost we would be competing with separate business plans written maybe by private companies and other government entities and with us trying to compete for who can give you the best price, almost like a bid process, and then that would be selected. So things can't have long-term continuity and goals can't be met long-term if that's the case. That's my concern. representative love i would say get with a bill sponsor
▶ Play
and see what you can get worked out all right thank you miss ford if if that's all you had for us today okay i had two technicalities
▶ Play
Speaker 149 1:58:43
i'll discuss with the sponsor that i would like to see too um and i would also like to just officially request that instead of this being rushed through that we have more time to understand because it sounds like there's a lot of confusion out there not only on the part of the solid waste districts but maybe the county judges and others as well that's the reason we're not voting today thank you judge
▶ Play
Speaker 144 1:59:06
willis if you would you want to speak
▶ Play
against the bill you're recognized if you introduce yourself for the committee and then receive your testimony
▶ Play
my name is woody willis i'm county judge in crittenden county and deborah ferguson our state representative she lives in the district or the county that I represent first of all mr. chairman and committee members thank you for allowing me to be here today and I'll be very brief because I know time is of essence we've heard a lot today about accountability and that's one of the issues that our district has been concerned with also is accountability and when you look at when you look at the mechanisms that are in place here my concern and I've talked to mr. group a about this last Friday my concern with accountability is that all the districts do something different you come up with the e manifest system you may be using the same piece of paper but you're still counting your tires totally different in these districts some count them hand hand by every tire by hand some of them actually take them and weigh them and use a formula to determine how many tires they've got on that truck so with that being said and you're doing it that way you're still potentially leaving the door open for accountability there not to happen and that's my concern is that we need to make sure without a doubt that we are all on the same page doing the same thing on the accountability part of it. And I don't believe that's going to happen because when I talked to Mr. Grupe, I just basically said basically what we're doing today is we're all on our honor system. And even if this bill passes, we're still going to be on our honor system. And he agreed that we would still be on our honor system. So that doesn't really, that really doesn't address accountability in my opinion. Another thing that we have to look at is when they make the remark that the districts don't know how much that they are actually uh being charged to process a tire we know without a doubt it's a dollar 91 cents in our district we know what it's costing us to process it we have a very streamlined process that we we use and yes we're still losing money even at a dollar 91 and so we do know what it's costing us to be able to process our tires we're very engaged the county judges are engaged in what's going on so we want to make sure that everybody is on the same page, and when you talk about the funding mechanisms, it sounds good, what we've heard Mr. Group A say, it sounds very good, but this legislation does not state what he's actually saying, so when you sit here and you say you're going to fill out a business plan and take care of that business plan, and they're going to fund you once they've approved that business plan, what if every one of the districts turn in a business plan, they've approved it, and you don't have enough money to fund all these business plans, what do you do then? Where does
▶ Play
that money come from? That's it. Thank you for allowing me to be here. I got one question, Judge. You made a statement that $1.91 was your cost, but you also said that you were still losing money at $1.91. So if that's your cost, how can you be losing money at $1.91? That's what it's costing us to
▶ Play
process it, but the revenue that we're getting to take care of that is less than what it's costing us to process. each tire. I'm sorry. I just wanted to make sure you elaborate. We're losing money, but that's what it's costing us to process each tire, but our revenue is less than that. We have a reserve, and we're dipping into that reserve every month. Thank you. I thought that's what you meant, but I wanted to clarify. Thank you.
▶ Play
Vice Chair Ferguson has got a
▶ Play
question. Sure. I know every district is struggling, but you might sort of just explain to them how our specific district, I know that we're headed for insolvency, and the only thing I understand is keeping us afloat is because we sold some equipment. That's correct. And we're not the only district, but you might walk through how the tire program is really unsustainable with the present revenue. I agree.
▶ Play
Four years ago when I was elected as county judge, the way our district operated the tire program is that we had multiple trailers throughout the county. We didn't have enough money coming in to be able to pay to have those trailers hauled back and forth. So we knew we were going to have to streamline our process in order to be able to come close to making ends meet. So several years back, what we did was we brought all those trailers in. We sold all of our equipment off. We bid out the tire program, and I believe West River Valley was the one that got the low bid. And what we did was in the counties, we put 18-wheeler trailers in those counties, and everybody was required to bring those tires to those 18-wheelers to be disposed of. Our county shop currently has two trailers there, and the tires are brought to the county shop. They are counted, put on the trailer, and then they're hauled away. Currently, our tires are being hauled away by Liberty Tide, I believe, and are being hauled away to Tupelo, Mississippi, as we speak. But we've had to streamline and cut back the amount of trailers that we had in our county to be able to get that within or close to the amount of money that we're actually getting to be able to fund this tire program. So we have really cut way back compared to what we
▶ Play
were doing several years ago. And I understand that's the only thing that's keeping us solvent
▶ Play
Speaker 162 2:04:25
is the sale of the trailers. That's correct. That's
▶ Play
money you're spending down. That's correct, because we're losing money every month.
▶ Play
And so how much is Liberty charging compared to what West River was? I believe we were just a little under $100 a ton with Liberty Tire, and we're paying about $155, $157 a ton using Liberty. I might have said West River, but West River was 90-something, and Liberty is 150-something. Thank you. Big
▶ Play
difference. Yes, sir. Appreciate you driving in here and giving us your concerns today. Committee, I've got a couple housekeeping things before we adjourn. Thursday's committee meeting will start off with the Office of Medicaid Inspector General giving us oversight of their office. I want to congratulate Representative Womack for leading the House in the Capital Go Challenge and how high he has set the bar for the whole Capitol. So without further ado, we stand adjourned. Thank you, Phil.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONCLINICAL SETTING.

HB1264 Pilkington TO PROVIDE FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERVICES PERFORMED BY A WALK-IN CLINIC OR EMERGENT CARE CLINIC WHEN THE PATIENT DOES NOT HAVE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER ASSIGNED.

HB1267 L. Fite TO CREATE THE USED TIRE RECYCLING AND ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAM.

27:37 - 2:05:23 266 segments 20 speakers

HB1280 Magie TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF TANNING EQUIPMENT BY MINORS; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "TANNING EQUIPMENT".

HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIORITIZE SPENDING WITH THE DEPARTMENT AND THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO FULLY FUND HOME- AND COMMUNITY-BASED SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES

Scope of Practice Bills Will be Considered in Committee During the Week of February 13, 2017 - February 17, 2017

Subtitle Number Sponsor

HB1034 C. Fite TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING HEARING INSTRUMENT DISPENSERS.

HB1180 Bentley TO AUTHORIZE ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES TO HAVE SIGNATURE AUTHORITY.

HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ACT; AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.

HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLOW AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO BE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.

HB1183 Dotson TO PROVIDE CONSISTENCY AND EFFICIENCY OF CHIROPRACTIC COVERAGE IN THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM; AND TO ALLOW MEDICAID RECIPIENTS DIRECT ACCESS TO A CHIROPRACTIC PHYSICIAN WITHOUT REFERRAL FROM A PRIMARY CARE PHYSICIAN.

HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AS APPLICABLE TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES; AND TO CLARIFY THE PROCESS NECESSARY FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO QUALIFY FOR PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY.

HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBSTITUTIONS.

HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT.

HB1215 Love TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF MASSAGE THERAPY TO INCLUDE THE PRACTICE OF CUPPING.

HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSE.

HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; AND TO ESTABLISH THE REGISTRATION OF SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS.

HB1250 M. Gray TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS DENTAL PRACTICE ACT; TO AMEND THE DENTAL HYGIENIST COLLABORATIVE CARE PROGRAM; TO MODIFY THE APPOINTMENTS TO THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF DENTAL EXAMINERS; AND TO MODIFY DENTISTRY SPECIALTY LICENSES.

HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES FROM THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD.

HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS CONCERNING PROHIBITED CONDUCT AND REMEDIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS.

HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN ELECTRICIAN".

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Jeff Wardlaw Chair Unverified
49 segments
Speaker 5
1 segment
Speaker 37
130 segments
Speaker 20
1 segment
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 44
1 segment
Speaker 3
1 segment
Representative Fredrick J. Love Chair Unverified
5 segments
Representative Josh Miller Chair Unverified
7 segments
Chair Unverified
36 segments
Representative John Payton Unverified
18 segments
Speaker 81
1 segment
Speaker 92
1 segment
Speaker 104
1 segment
Speaker 111
1 segment
Speaker 113
36 segments
Speaker 83
1 segment
Representative Justin Gonzales Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 149
14 segments
Speaker 144
1 segment
Woody Willis Unverified
11 segments
Representative Deborah Ferguson Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 162
1 segment